header advert
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 88-B, Issue SUPP_II May 2006

EH Garling BL Kaptein ER Valstar R.G.H.H. Nelissen

Outcome measures must be valid, reliable and responsive to change criteria. The most common clinical outcome measures are Knee Society Scores, SF-36 quality of life scores, HAQ and DAS scores. However, performance based measures of functioning may not be dependent on patient report or observer judgment.

Examples of objective pre- and post-operative performance outcome measures are surface Electromyography (EMG) of muscles, kinematics and kinetics (gait analysis). For the evaluation of implant survival after joint arthroplasty, Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis (RSA) is the golden standard to assess micro-motion of the implants.

Surface EMG can be used to asses the stability of joints before and after intervention. Calibrating of raw EMG data is necessary to compare the data between subjects. It was shown that calibration of EMG data by means of isokinetic contractions on a dynamometer during flexion and extension was more reliable and repeatable than using a Maximum Voluntary Contraction in patients after total knee arthroplasty. After total knee arthroplasty RA patients have a lower net knee joint moment and a higher co-contraction than controls, indicating avoidance of net joint load and an active stabilization of the knee joint.

Fluoroscopy can be used to assess the kinematics of joints. In the pre-operative situation the use of CT models of the involved bones can be matched to the assessed fluoroscopic images. In the post-operative situation CAD models of the implants can be used for this purpose. In this way accurate 3D kinematics of joints can be assessed. During a step-up task of RA patients, the rotating platform of a mobile bearing knee showed no- or far less longitudinal rotation than the femur. Therefore, some of the theoretical advantages of this specific rotating platform knee prosthesis can be questioned. Fluoroscopy has also been used to assess soft tissue artifacts that occur in gait analysis i.e. displacements of skin-mounted markers relative to the underlying bone. The large soft tissue artefacts observed (displacements up to 17 mm and 12 degrees) question the usefulness of parameters found with external movement registration.

In order to assess the micromotion of implants after joint arthroplasty a measurement technique with a much higher accuracy than fluoroscopy is needed. RSA uses tantalum markers as landmarks bony structures and as landmarks on the implant. Recently a new RSA technique has been developed that does not rely on the attachment of artificial markers on the implant but uses CAD models of the implant instead. As an example of RSA as outcome measure, results showed that a calciumphosphate coating improves fixation of tibial components in RA patients, thus preventing mechanical loosening and subsequent long-term revision. In another clinical RSA study, it was found that mobile bearing knees are more predictable and forgiving with respect to micromotion compared to posterior stabilized tibial components in RA patients.

The results obtained by the above described performance outcome measures can be valued since the accuracy and precision of the used outcome measures are all published.


ER. Bogoch

Orthopedic surgeons treat numerous patients in whom osteoporosis (OP) is an important factor: inflammatory arthritides (rheumatoid arthritis); sports medicine (the anorexic, amenorrhoeic female athlete); in consultation to renal, transplant and cardiac units; patients on corticosteroids, as well as others. Orthopedic procedures in patients who have osteoporotic bone require special techniques and precautions. A common example is hip replacement, where, through endosteal resorption, the medullary canal is large, cortices are thin, and the risk of femoral fracture and a poor outcome is higher.

The commonest interface of orthopedic surgery with OP is in the management of fractures. In North America, most orthopedic surgeons manage fractures in hospital and in the fracture clinic, where typically 3%–8% of patient visits are for classic fragility fractures. Traumatic fractures also commonly occur in osteoporotic bone. The yield of screening for OP in orthopedic wards and clinics, targeting fragility fracture patients, is much higher than screening in a general population. Published guidelines based on Level I evidence indicate that fragility fracture patients are at highest risk of future hip fractures, which often occur within one year of index fragility fracture, and that preventive treatment is economical and safe.

Treatment prevents 30–50% of hip fractures in high risk groups. Unfortunately, less than 20% of fragility fracture patients generally receive appropriate OP care, in multiple studies in developed countries. There is a growing international focus on developing care delivery systems that will promote consistent OP investigation and treatment in the inpatient and outpatient orthopedic environment.

In Ontario, Canada, an Osteoporosis Exemplary Care Program was initiated in 2003 to identify, educate, evaluate, refer, and treat female (> 40 years) and male (> 50 years) fragility fracture patients for OP. In the first year of the program, over 95% of inpatients and outpatients were appropriately diagnosed, treated, or referred for OP care. Success resulted from the presence of a dedicated coordinator and cooperation by orthopedic surgeons and residents, technologists, allied health professionals and administrative staff.

Regional, national and international orthopedic associations have developed initiatives designed to improve processes of care for OP in the orthopedic environment.


A. Aeschlimann

A better understanding of the pathophysiology of rheumatoid arthritis has led to important and innovative approaches to its treatment In the case of confirmed diagnosis the recommended gold standard is to give methotrexat, possibly in combination with corticosteroids. If disease activity cannot be controlled, other basic therapies, possibly in combination with or as biologic DMARDs (Diseases modifying drugs) are prescribed. The main emphasis here is placed on TNF-Alpha blocker and drugs that inhibit Interleukin-1. New drugs such as anti-CTLA4-Ig and anti-CD20 (Rituximab) aim to influence the activation of T- and B-cells. Management is supplemented by educating the patient, physiotherapy and ergotherapy as well as specific surgical intervention, as required.


JK Stanley

Rheumatoid arthritis is a whole body, lifetime incurable disease. The problems engendered by the disease process itself are highly individual, given that each set of problems that a patient has, the assessment and planning of surgery is a crucial aspect of the appropriate management of patients with polyarthritis.

The presence of deformity does not necessarily indicate a problem of function, but one has to accept that certain deformities cause more problems than others and I draw your attention to swan neck deformity being relatively function-impairing and Boutonnière deformities less so. There is always a balance between the risk of surgery and the benefits to be obtained.

The assessment is functional, anatomical, radiological, psychological, medical, financial and, finally, surgical. The functional assessment is intended to identify the problems a patient has in the activities of daily living, the anatomical assessment identifies the structures damaged which need to be prepared or replaced, the x-rays define the bone loss and, therefore, determine the limits of bony surgery, the psychological aspect identifies the patient’s capacity and willingness to be involved in often quite complex therapy programmes over a significant period of time. The medical problems of vasculitis and active disease are less frequent now but are contra-indications to surgery in the acute phases.

The financial aspects are often under-rated. The costs of maintaining someone with significant disabilities is really quite great and, therefore, although surgery may only give some small improvement in function, it often has quite a significant impact on the degree of care and help an individual needs.

Finally, the surgical assessment is to identify which structures and in which order.

In terms of planning, the surgical priorities, described by Nalebuff, are:

1 Nerves 2 Flexor tendons 3 Wrist 4 Thumb 5 MCP joints 6 Extensors 7 PIP joints 8 Distal Interphalangeal joints

Prolonged nerve compressions do not recover well; ruptures of flexor tendons are very difficult to treat; if the wrist is painful and unstable it inhibits any function that the hand might have; the thumb is 50% of hand function; metacarpophalangeal joints need to be stable and to flex approximately to 60° in order to be functional; extensor tendons need to glide and to be able to lift fingers away from the palm; the interphalangeal joints contribute greatly to the closing of grasp.

The role of the therapist is pre-operatively to assess the patient appropriately for surgery, assessing all the aspects defined above and to ensure that the patient is compliant with the treatment post-operatively. The aphorism that 20% of the effort comes from the surgeon, 50% from the therapist and 20% from the patient is probably a fairly accurate representation of the importance of therapy post-operatively. Therapy must be planned, purposeful and progressive.


Full Access
F Angst J. Goldhahn

Background Critical reflection in clinical routine and research raises the question of how we measure outcome. The classical etiopathogenetic way of thinking has led to biophysical, investigator-based, ‘objective’ parameters. However, new concepts of holistic health assessment based on the WHO’s International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health (ICF) emphasize the patient’s (subjective) perception.

Methods We present different approaches to health and health-related quality of life assessment by applying assessment tools to specific examples and providing an overview of some of the existing instruments with an analysis of their properties.

Results Self-assessments reflect the patient’s needs more closely than biophysical parameters. Reliability and validity of the self-assessments are high and population surveys provide valid norms for comparisons. Generic instruments offer a comprehensive range of measurements, and condition-specific self-assessment tools differ in their pattern of health dimensions and their sensitivity to change (responsiveness) as expressed by specific scales. A specific set of instruments has to be compiled appropriate to the focus of interest.

Conclusions Self-assessments are an important complement to clinical signs as indicators of the patient’s condition and fulfill the requirements of the modern salutogenetic, holistic view of the patient as set out in the ICF concept. As a valid representation of the patient’s needs they help in the optimization of disease management and medical-economic planning.


Dieter Grob

Introduction Rheumatoid arthritis also affects the spine and creates conditions that need surgical treatment. As in other parts of the body, the maintenance of function and reduction of pain are primary goals of surgical treatment, however the additional threat to the neurological structures create an additional dimension in the surgical treatment of the spine.

Destructive processes of osteoligamentous structures and severe osteoporosis may be blamed as the principle cause for pain, deformity and subsequent neurological deficit in the rheumatoid patient’s spine. Cervical spine Atlantoaxial instability is the most frequently encountered pathology in the cervical spine of the rheumatoid patient. In order to avoid late appearance of myelopathy, the timing of surgery in the presence of significant atlantoaxial instability (ADD < 5mm) has to be carefully evaluated. The tendency is towards early surgical stabilization since no spontaneous improvement is to be expected in cases with aggressive rheumatoid arthritis. Late surgery not only carries the risk of causing myelopathy by repeated micro-trauma of the myelon, but also the need for extensive surgery including the occiput and the lower cervical spine in case of advanced destructive processes.

The subaxial cervical spine has a tendency to disintegrate in the presence of aggressive course of rheumatoid arthritis. The extent of instability and site of compression has to be carefully analyzed, using MRI and neurophysiological examinations. Due to weak bone structures anterior and posterior interventions are often necessary. Lumbar spine The rheumatoid pathology in the lumbar spine is mainly influenced by the degree of osteoporosis. Typical osteoporotic fractures, often on several levels, represent the most frequent pathology, which needs surgical help. In case of persistent pain the relatively new technique of vertebroplasty offers an elegant way to reduce pain. If severe deformities occur, the osteoporotic structure of bone limits the surgical possibility of correction of the deformity.

Conclusion “Wait and see”-policy in rheumatoid patients with spinal pathology is often not appropriate (as in other joints of the body) if function and neurology should be preserved and maintained. Early surgery represents usually minor intervention and is better tolerated than extensive corrections. Osteoporosis is the main limitation for surgical treatment in the rheumatoid spine.


Full Access
Yoshitaka Minamikawa

Development of newer finger implant in Japan started with hinged Ceramic implant in early 1980’ and was abandoned its use in early stage (Doi 1984 and Minami 1988). Although silicone finger implant has been most popular, breakage of the implant, particle induced inflammation and implant subsidence continued to be the problems of the silicone implant. In turning to new century, there was another enthusiasm of developing new finger implant in Japan. Surface replacement was chosen for the PIP joints, however, most of design for the MP joint had constrained mechanism, including ball and socket joint with stem allows piston motion and semi-hinged joint with much freedom. Currently available finger implants in Japan will be discussed briefly.

The author developed cement-less surface finger implants (Self Locking Finger Joint, SLFJ) for the MP (including thumb) and PIP. Characteristics of the implant include,(1) the joints anchor(stem) has tapered screw with two long legs which spread intramedullary allows fixation without cement and thus change the position during the operation for optimum collateral tension, (2) joint design that preserve collateral ligament and surface contour, (3) simultaneous replacements of both MP and PIP are possible. Over 500 joins in 200 patients have been operated during last seven years. Of 50 cases operated by author with minimum of 4 years follow up, 34 cases were available for evaluation. There were 98 joints: 72 MP, 12 PIP and 14 MP of the thumbs. Average follow up was 5 years and 5 months (4 years ~ 6 years and 6 months). Fixation of the joints anchor were stable, only three joints showed marked loosening. Breakage of the joint anchors was found in 7 MP and 2 PIP; 5 out of 9 breakage of the legs were occurred during the operation. In x-ray evaluation, about half of the joint anchors were found securely fixed to the bone within 2 years. Dislocations of the joints were found in 4 MP joints in 3 cases (3 were early dislocation and were found to be technical failure and one late dislocation) and 2 PIP joints (one early and one late dislocation). Five MP implants were removed because of progressive flexion contracture and 3 MP and 2 PIP were re-operated. Range of motion of ext/flex averaged −25/70 in MP and −20/65 in PIP.


M Huber P. Rippstein

For many decades ankle fusion has been the only option for treatment of symptomatic osteoarthritis of the ankle joint. From the late 60’s on the crusade of joint replacement for hip and knee led to successful functional restoration for severe destruction of these joints. Because of a lack of understanding the biomechanical principals of the ankle a similar approach in reconstructing the ankle arthritis was doomed to fail. On the other side very good functional outcome after fusion of the ankle seemed to make needless further development. Although first encouraging results with non-constrained designs and cementless fixation were obtained in mid-late 70’s a wider acceptance within the orthopaedic society was found only almost 20 years later whereas today many surgeons wouldn’t give up the ankle arthroplasty for several indications. Despite good and very good midterm results we still need to understand limits and further develop operative techniques especially soft-tissue balancing.

In our institution we have been using TAR since 1995 on a regular basis and by now overlook a total of almost 400 TAR’s. The experience with different designs (Agility, S.T.A.R. and Buechel-Pappas) led to the development of the Mobility-TAR in collaboration with two surgeons from England and the U.S. It is a 3-component TAR, non-constrained. As a unique feature the instrumentation allows an accurate centring of the implants both in the frontal and the saggital plane. In a prospective trial in Wrightington and Zurich we clinically and radiographically evaluate the outcome. The first 42 cases in Zurich with a follow-up of more than 1 year showed a significant pain reduction from av. 8.1 on a visual analogue scale to av. 1.4 after one year. The ROM assessed radiographically could be improved from 26° preoperatively to 33° after one year. We have seen 4 fractures/osteotomies of the medial malleolus and one neuropathy of the tibial nerve as intraoperative complications. Postoperative complications included two superficial wound healing problems, one deep infection and finally two stress fractures of the medial malleolus. One case had to be revised because of aseptic loosening after 6 months. All but one of the first 42 patients would undergo the same procedure again.

The first results are encouraging because of good overall results with significant pain reduction and good ROM combined with only few complications.


H.J.L van der Heide B Schutte J.W.K Louwerens H.A van Heereveld F.H.J van den Hoogen M.C. de Waal Malefijt

Introduction: Total ankle prostheses (TAP’s) are implanted for end stage cartilage damage especially in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) or post-traumatic arthritis. Little is known about the long term survival of these prostheses in patients with RA and JIA. In this study we examined the outcome of TAP in these patients.

Patients and methods: Between 1994 and 2004 85 TAP’s were implanted in 58 cases (10 males and 48 females) with RA (n=53) or juvenile chronic arthritis (n=5). The records of all patients were reviewed. Every patient was invited for a visit to our outpatient clinic for a history taking, a physical examination and a Kofoed ankle score (a clinical score for ankle function ranging from 0 to 100) was obtained.

Results: The record of every patient was available for review. Two patients had died (cause of death was unrelated to the surgery), and 56 patients could be reexamined. A perioperative fracture (8 medial 3 lateral and 2 tibial) occurred in 13 cases. The fractures were fixed in the same operation and healed without complications; none of these prostheses needed a reintervention. After a mean follow up of 2.7 years (range 1 to 9 years) two patients died with the prosthesis in situ, one patient underwent an above knee amputation for infected arthroplasties of ankle and knee and four prostheses were removed because of loosening or malfunctioning of the prosthesis and arthrodeses were performed. The other 51 cases were analysed and showed a mean Kofoed ankle score of 72.8 (SD=15.8). This score is similar to scores obtained from patients receiving ankle arthroplasties for non-rheumatic indications.

Conclusions: Placement of total ankle prostheses in patients with RA shows good medium term results. The intra-operative fracture rate is high, but does not affect the outcome; none of the failed arthroplasties was due to a preoperative fracture.


A Röser F.-W Hagena R.M. Christ

With the increasing number of implantation of total ankle arthroplasty a higher rate of pitfalls and failures has to be expected.

Intra- and postoperative complications in total ankle arthroplasty, their sources of failure and revision options are demonstrated.

In the time of 7/97 until 1/06 269 S.T.A.R. total ankle prostheses have been implanted at our hospital.

Intraoperative complications occurred in 7 cases (4 fractures of the malleolus medialis, 2 fractures of distal fibula, 1 fissure of talus).

We observed early complications in form of delayed wound healing (n=31) and 4 deep infections. A higher incidence of secondary wound healing is shown in rheumatoid arthritis patients in comparison to patients with OA.

Late complications included persisting intraarticular synovitis, especially in rheumatoid arthritis, an impingement (11 cases) and osteolysis (4 cases).

Revision surgery was performed in 45 cases (16.7%) 1.5 years after primary implantation (14 operations with problems in secondary wound healing, 9 lengthenings of the Achilles tendon with a dorsal capsulotomy (2 rheumatoid arthritis patients), 11 revisions of the PE gliding core with resection of periarticular hypertrophic bone formation, 4 revisions of singular components, 2 complete revisions of the prosthesis, 4 ankle fusions, 1 amputation. Only in 18 cases (6.7%) these complications and the following surgical procedures influenced the satisfaction of the patients.

Despite the demonstrated complications, total ankle arthroplasty is more than an alternative to open ankle arthrodesis in the progressive phases of arthritic joint destruction, also in RA at a LDE stage ≥ III.


Full Access
P Bijlsma H.J.L van der Heide F.H.J van den Hoogen J.W.K. Louwerens

Introduction: The standard procedure when operating the rheumatoid forefoot is resection arthroplasty of the metatarsophalangeal joints of the lesser rays. Correction of the hallux is mostly achieved by arthrodesis of the first metatarsophalangeal joint. Good clinical results (with a follow-up of over ten years) have been reported when a combination of these two techniques is used. Another technique is repositioning of the metatarsophalangeal subluxation or dislocation of the lesser rays, thereby preserving the metatarsophalangeal joints, thus leaving the function of the aponeurosis plantaris intact. As a result of this it can be expected that unrolling of the forefoot is unaffected and therefore a better function of the forefoot remains.

Aim: To assess the results of forefoot reconstruction using the repositioning technique performed in 54 feet (39 patients) by one surgeon using this technique.

Methods: Fifty-four feet (39 RA patients) were treated with the technique of repositioning the metatarsophalangeal subluxation or dislocation. All surgery was performed by one orthopaedic surgeon. In case of severe deformity of the metatarsophalangeal joint of the hallux, an arthrodesis was performed. All patients were reviewed after a mean follow up of 40 months (range 12–72 months) and an AOFAS [American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society] foot score, and FFI [Foot Function Index] were obtained.

Results: At a mean of 40 months (SD=15.6 months) postoperatively, the mean AOFAS forefoot score was 69.80 (SD=11.8) if, in addition of repositioning the metatarsophalangeal joints, an arthrodesis of the hallux was performed. In patients with no operation on the hallux, the AOFAS score was 42.2 (SD=18.8) (P=0,001). The postoperative FFI-scores were 74.0 (SD=17.5) and 57.6 (SD=14.6) respectively (P=0,026)

Conclusions: Reconstruction of the rheumatoid forefoot by repositioning the metatarsophalangeal joints of the lesser rays, thereby preserving the joints, can be considered a procedure that provides improvement in the clinical outcome. Best results were seen in patients in whom, in addition of reconstruction of the lesser rays, an arthrodesis of the hallux was performed.


M.H. Makoto Hirao J.H. Jun Hashimoto H.T. Hideki Tsuboi K.S. Kazuomi Sugamoto A.M. Akira Myoui H.Y. Hideki Yoshikawa

Background: Heel valgus and flattening of arch are common in rheumatoid arthritis (RA). The progression of hindfoot valgus deformity results in pain and debilitating disability, and causes the excessive stress on the ankle joint. Subtalar arthrodesis is often indicated in these cases to reduce the pain and to correct the talocalcaneal alignment. However, accurate correction is not easy without bone grafting, because bone defect often appears after correction. Bone grafting is necessary for accurate correction in these cases, but we have avoided it because of following reasons; donor site problem like insufficiency fractures of pelvis, supply limitation of autograft for possible multiple operations during long term disease progression of RA and the lack of bone graft substitutes, which possesses enough osteoconductivity. Now we have developed the interconnected porous calcium hydroxyapatite (IP-CHA) which possesses good osteoconductivity and achieves major incorporation with host bone much more rapid than the other porous calcium hydroxyapatite. So, we evaluated the usefulness of the packing with the newly developed IP-CHA in bone defect after correction of pes planovalgus deformity of RA patients.

Methods: The best possible correction of talonavivular alignment and fixation is performed using one cubic hydroxyapatite block (1x1x1cm), staple and Kirschner wire. Then granular IP-CHA is implanted in bone defect existing mainly in talar body, gap of talonavicular joint and sinus tarsi. Six planovalgus feet were treated with subtalar arthrodesis in 4 female RA patients (3; triple arthrodesis, 3; subtalar and talonavicular arthrodesis). The average age was 56.8 years. Angle of internal arch (IA), tibiocalcaneal (TC) angle in modified Cobey’s method, talocalcaneal height (TCH) in standing position were assessed on the basis of the radiographies at just before operation and final follow-up (average 17.5 months, range 7 to 25 months).

Results: Mean IA angle was 138.9 degrees pre-operatively and 132.4 at the last follow-up. Mean TC angle was 14.9 degrees pre-operatively and 7.2 at the last follow-up. No collapse or deformity of hydroxyapatite implanted in the bone defect was observed.

Conclusion: Our original technique using IP-CHA was shown to prevent from initial sinking or loss of correction. This technique could make it quit easy to correct the malalignment of talocalcaneal joint with regaining of TCH in painful planovalgus deformity of RA patients.


H.C Doets E.R. Valstar

Introduction Mobile-bearing total ankle arthroplasty has gained more interest in recent years. Clinical results show favourable but varying results, with survival rates between 70% and 90% at 10-year follow-up. Design-specific differences in early migration patterns might explain differences in result and possible modes of failure.

Methods Prospective study of a cementless mobile-bearing total ankle arthroplasty by radiostereometric analysis (RSA). Fifteen total ankle arthroplasties were performed in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society ankle score and radiostereometric radiographs were evaluated at regular intervals throughout the follow-up period: immediately postoperatively, 6 weeks postoperatively, 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months postoperatively and yearly thereafter.

Results The postoperative clinical results improved. We observed increased migration of the tibial component during the first 3 months, but this stabilized by the 6-months followup. The mean lateral-medial migration was 0.8 mm, distal-proximal migration was 0.9 mm, and posteroanterior migration was −0.5 mm. The latter implicated that the total resultant migration was in anterior and valgus tilting of this tibial component. This resulted in a main mode of migration proximal, anterior and valgus tilting of the tibial component.

Discussion This pilot study showed initial migration of this mobile-bearing ankle prosthesis into upward anterior and valgus tilting. However, migration stabilized at 6 months postoperatively. We think the surgical technique (anterior cortical window for placement) and the method of tibial fixation likely explain this migration.


K. Tillmann

The ankle joint offers adverse conditions to any prosthetic replacement: high loads on small surfaces, only vague landmarks for the insertion, complex and individually very different functional anatomy.

Despite these obstacles many excellent short- and some long-term results have been published, giving little way to a learning curve. This contrasts with our own experiences over at all 29 years now: 24 % failures of cemented two-component EP’s after 14,6 (6,1–21,2) years (n=67) and 8,7 % failures of uncemented tri-component EP’s after 3,7 (0,6–7,6) years (n=92).

We analyze and explain special problems and typical failures by a brief historical review of ankle joint replacement: as a logical sequence of various concepts, each of them basing on the knowledge of preceding insufficiencies. The general concern of the functionally useful, but limited mobility after the implantation will be discussed, also on the basis of own early and medium-term results: ROM ranging on average from 26° for TPR-(n=35) and 29° for New Jersey LCS-(n=30) up to 35° for S. T. A. R.-prostheses (n=12). Possible solutions of problems will be considered, respecting assumed causalities.

Basing on the literature and own earlier investigations, especially the long-term results will be compared critically.

The incertitude of an exact implantation has been partly compensated by the actual „meniscal“ concept of tricomponent prostheses. It should be favourable for their fixation to the bone and moreover reduce polyethylene-wear. But – as before – the discrepancy of high loads on a small area threatens the durability of ankle joint prostheses.

Prosthetic replacement has become indispensable in the treatment of painfully destructed ankle joints, but it demands a careful and critical indication.


U Müller L Staub C Röder O Tamcan

Introduction: Randomized Controlled Trials (RCT) are the golden standard in nowadays evidence based outcome assessment. Nevertheless, RCTs in surgery are associated with several concerns. The major concern focuses on ethical issues when randomization is done.

Method: We conducted an indebt analysis on advantages and disadvantages of three types of data acquisition (Case Control Study (CCS), RCT, and Registries) where scientific impact, ability to assess changes over time, cost efficiency, time consumption, ability to provide bench marks and other variables are compared.

Results: RCTs are best regarding the scientific impact. Registers are superior in detecting changes over time (post market surveillance, early warning system), cost efficiency, time consumption, ability to provide benchmarks, local/national/international comparability and ability to let private practitioners participate. CCSs are of minor value in respect to all the assessed variables.

Conclusion: In Surgery, registries are an excellent alternative to RCTs if a great majority of the treating physicians (in respect to a therapy) participate and if all the treated patients (per physician) are included. The register increases its scientific impact if alternative therapies are included (control). In this case, the scientific impact of a register is getting nearly equivalent to RCTs.

Take home message: If ethical aspects allow an RCT, than the RCT is the study set up of choice when a new technique/implant has to be introduced in the market. Once the implant has proved its evidence, the following post market surveillance should be accompanied by registries (introduction of an implant in each country). If an RCT is not indicated (ethical or other contra indications), than registries should be used to prove evidence for an indicated therapy. CCSs are not recommended.


L.J Jung P.M Maldyk E.S Sommer B.W Wojciechowska J.C.W Chorostowska-Wynimko J.B Bany E.S.R Skopinska-Rozewska

Angiogenesis, the growth of new blood vessels from pre-existing vasculature has an obvious and essential role in soft and hard tissue repair. During the wound healing many potential angiogenic factors are released and may be found in circulating blood. The most important are basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF).

Experimental data confirm the important role of VEGF and bFGF in wounds and bone healing. It was proved that heparin and its low-molecular derivatives may interfere with various steps of angiogenesis process. Enoxaparine (En) is frequently used as anticoagulant for prophylaxis of thromboembolic complications. The aim of this study was to evaluate in vivo angiogenic potency and VEGF and bFGF content of sera collected from 7 patients after hip surgery, treated for 14 days with 40 mg of En (Clexane, Aventis) daily. Evaluation of angiogenic activity was performed twice before surgery (before and 1 day after one En dose) and 14 days after surgery. Sera were injected intra-dermally to anaesthetized Bal/c mice and 72 hours later the number of newly-formed blood vessels was counted in dissecting microscope (SIA test). Cytokines concentration was estimated by ELISA. Results: Sera obtained after one En dose presented increase of angiogenic activity (57,3+/− 2,4, n=112, p< 0.01)in comparison to the value before En (44.6 +/− 2.5, n=113 of newly-formed blood vessels. After 14 En doses, further increase was observed (72 +/− 4.9 blood vessels, n= 112).

BFGF levels increased after the first En dose, VEGF concentration was significantly higher after 14 injections as compare to the results obtained before or after one injection of En.

Conclusion: Beneficial effect of 14-days prophylaxis with enoxaparine on healing process might be expected in patients after hip surgery.


C Kolling J Goldhahn B. Simmen

Since the successful introduction of National arthroplasty registers by the Scandinavian countries, requirements in arthroplasty research have changed from pure implant survival rates to functional results and quality of life aspects. More patient data are required to address these areas. The goal of our international arthroplasty register survey was to determine key factors for an effective database as source for these scientific analyses.

In the first step, we identified and analysed all available arthroplasty registers via extensive literature and web searches. The preliminary data were validated by sending out a standardized questionnaire with questions regarding goals, organization, funding, documentation, data handling and output of the register. The responses were checked and, if necessary, further information requested via phone.

So far we received detailed information from nine arthroplasty registers worldwide. Only two registers collect data from clinical scores or questionnaires in addition to data for the survival rate. The majority of registers are maintained by the national orthopaedic associations, others like Finland by governmental organizations. The legal boundary conditions vary considerably, e.g. in Finland participation is mandatory, while patient tracking via Social security numbers is not possible in all countries. The rate of participating hospitals ranges up to 100%: 510 surgeons in Canada (72%) – 43 hospitals in Denmark (100%). The preferred locations are hip and knee, the preferred documentation method is paper-based, several registers offer online access or other types of electronic data transfer. In return, surgeons receive a regular feedback from the registers, mostly in form of annual reports. Only a few registers allow the surgeons to have online access to their data in the database. Funding is still of major concern. Although the definition of annual total costs varies, they stay far below 500,000 dollars. Examples of funding sources are the government, National Orthopaedic Associations, grants, a levy placed on the sale of implants, and others.

For the completeness of the collected data, a high rate of participating hospitals as well as a high follow-up-rate is crucial. This can only be guaranteed with substantial funding, governmental support for setting up an adequate framework and the compliance of the participating hospitals. New ways of data collection and processing might help to increase patient and hospital compliance.


Full Access
U. Böhling

Summary: The tribological development in the metal-metal partners brought out a new surface texture for the femoral cup. A reduction of the coefficient of friction and a reduction of the metallic abrasion on almost half are secured in lab tests. First clinical applications took place in our hospital.

Question: Total hip surface replacement in metal-metal partners have, although in small quantity, metallic abrasion, which leads to clear increases of the serum concentration of the serological level. The long-term effect on the organism is not so far clarified. A reduction of the abrasion quantity is however worthwhile. Is a structural change of the surface of the femoral cup suitable to cause such a reduction of the metallic abrasion?

Methodology: Derived from bionic systems in nature the surface of total hip surface replacement was changed by dimple like surface, so that in presence of liquid an accumulation of liquid between both sliding partners takes place and takes place thus on this liquid film the articulation. Laboratory tests on a simulator were accomplished, in order to examine whether the desired reduction of the abrasion is obtained. This surface is called Biosurf-surface.

Results: Simulator wear tests of the standard total hip surface replacement in the metal-metal partner have been compared with the Biosurf-surface. The simulator attempts showed that after 5 million motion cycles the Biosurf –system the abrasion quantity in milligram reduces to more than a half. By this clear reduction of particles the concentration of the metal ions which can be expected in the serum is clearly smaller, so that thereby a contribution is made to reduce the possibly damaging influence of metallic ions in the organism.


S Egner-Höbarth W Goessler R Krassnig R Jeserschek R. Windhager

Introduction: Chronic infection after total joint arthroplasty is a complication of major concern to orthopaedic surgeons, especially if patients suffer from any type of immunodeficiency. But for extensive surgical and systemic treatment recurrence rates are high.

Silver is a long known local antimicrobial agent. The use of silver coated prostheses is a valuable option in some cases.

Yet there are patients for whom the permanent implantation of large amounts of silver does not seem to be the perfect solution.

Methods: From 02/2004 to 12/2005 nine patients with severe deep infections after multiple revisions following total joint replacement underwent two-stage revision and implantation of silver coated megaendoprostheses (MUTARS®).

From 04/2004 to 01/2006 seventeen patients of slightly less impaired disposition were treated by a comparable two-stage procedure using silver-augmented cemented spacer prostheses or cement fills.

Patients are closely observed regarding toxic side effects.

Concentration of silver in blood and puncture samples are measured using an argon plasma mass spectrometer.

Results: To date eight of nine patients with silver coated megaendoprostheses are free of infection. One patient with known cellular and humoral immunodeficiency recently developed a fistula, puncture showing superinfection by coag. neg. staphylococci.

In the second group one patient of seventeen actually shows a persisting infection, but cannot be matched properly as he primarily suffered from a long-term infected knee arthrodesis.

Silver concentrations ranged from a maximum of 1010 to 243 μg/kg (ppb) to a minimum of 84 to 304 μg/kg (ppb) with silver coating, and a maximum of 380 to 22,9 μg/kg (ppb) to a minimum of 76 to 5,02 μg/kg (ppb) with silver spacers.

There are large individual differences in both groups.

We found no signs of argyrosis or recently developed neurological deficits.

Discussion: The use of silver in the treatment of severely infected joint prostheses is a promising approach, but it is not without risks and throwbacks. Strict indication and surveillance are needed to keep possible side effects under control. It ought not to be used out of specialized centres.


J Goldhahn S Drerup F Angst B.R. Simmen

Introduction: Patient self-assessment plays a significant rule in the monitoring of patients within clinical studies as well as a separate quality indicator. The self-assessment of function, disease activity and quality of life is known to have a predictive value in the disease progression of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and other orthopaedic diseases. However, all questionnaires challenge the clinical infrastructure. The questionnaire administration and their processing require still considerable manpower and is a potential source for errors. We analysed the in-house processes, identified the essential requirements and explored possible electronic solution with the aim to reduce necessary manpower and failure sources.

Materials and methods: In a first step we defined a set of questionnaires we want to administer on a regular base. We then evaluated candidate systems with respect to data handling and to further statistic processing. Two years later we re-evaluated the system and possible alternatives. We then paid special attention to scanning features and data export options. Finally we performed reliability and handling tests and a first clinical trial.

Results: The standardized set for shoulder patients comprises 144 items per patients. The set was designed as a four-color print for automatic processing with Qualicare. Four large studies with a total of more than 300 evaluations were performed using Qualicare. Our reevaluation of the system revealed major problems with the line scanner, the data processing in the system and the data export into statistics programs. After intensive search we installed a new scanning system based on an OMR reader that detects regions of interests on the questionnaire (Remark Office). This system allows simple form generation with the PC, the use of bar-code and faster processing. Reliability was more than 0.95 and handling revealed no major problems. Since first trials were successful the new system became the standard for all questionnaires in our department. Discussion: The high amount of variables in patient self-assessment requires automated processing to save manpower and to avoid failures during manual processing. During a three-year period we identified scanning and export options as the key factors for long-term success. The new system (Remark Office) accomplishes both requirements and might serve as the base for large studies or regular quality control.


K Kuriyama J Hashimoto M Fujii T Murase H Tsuboi A Myoui H. Yoshikawa

Background: Juxta-articular intraosseous cystic lesions (JAICL) are common lesion in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and could cause spontaneous pathological fractures and extensive joint destruction. Although surgical treatment is well indicated for benign bone tumour such as solitary bone cyst, RA induced JAICL have been rarely treated surgically because of following reasons. The first is the possible re-absorption of grafted bone due to disease progression. The second is donor site problem of iliac bone autografting. The third is limitation of autograft for possible operations in the future. The fourth is the lack of bone graft substitutes with good osteoconductivity. We have developed the interconnected porous calcium hydroxyapatite ceramic (IP-CHA) with excellent osteoconductivity. The IP-CHA achieved major incorporation with host bone much more rapid than the other porous calcium hydroxyapatite ceramics. We evaluated the feasibility and effectiveness of curettage and packing with the IP-CHA for the treatment of JAICL in RA patients.

Methods: Nine JAICL in 7 RA patients were treated by curettage and packing with IP-CHA. Eight lesions were impending pathological fractures. Two were male and five were female, the average age of operation was 57.8 years (range, forty-nine to seventy-two years). Follow-up assessment was based on final radiography at an average of 10.9 months after surgery (range, five to seventeen months). The expansion of the cystic lesions around the implanted IP-CHA and the re-absorption of the IP-CHA itself, which means erosion or increasing porosity of implanted IP-CHA, were assessed on the basis of the radiographies at just after operation and final follow up.

Results: The locations were as follows: distal radius, 6 lesions; distal ulna, 1; proximal tibia, 1; distal fibula, 1. No lesions showed the re-absorption of implanted IP-CHA itself. One of 9 lesions showed out-expansion of radiolucent area around the implanted IP-CHA without re-absoption of IP-CHA itself at the final follow-up. There were no postoperative fractures as complication.

Conclusions: These results suggested that surgical intervention with the IP-CHA could be useful for prevention of pathological fractures due to arthritis related JAICL. The efficacies of this technique might be augmented by amelioration of disease activity with concomitant drug therapy including biologics, since there was one case with out-expansion of cystic lesions in RA patients.


K.F. Kazuo Fujiwara K.A. Koji Asaumi H.E. Hirosuke Endo V.A. Nobuhiro Abe K.N. Keiichiro Nishida S.M. Shigeru Mitani T.O. Toshifumi Ozaki H.I. Hajime Inoue

Purpose: We use a minimally invasive surgical technique (MIS) when performing cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA). Because, it is difficult to put the implant correctly through the small incision, we have used a computed tomography (CT)-based navigation system navigation system since 2005. The current study is a preliminary report of the results.

Materials and Methods : We performed MIS-THA with an antero-lateral approach, in treating 10 osteoarthritis (OA) cases by navigated MIS-THA (Navi group) and compared them with the 10 OA cases treated without navigation (non-Navi group). Follow-up periods ranged from 6–9 months. All of the implants were AMS HA cup with a PerFix stem. The patient’s preoperative CT data in DICOM format was used in the work station for preoperative planning. Appropriate angle and the positions of cup and stem were decided preoperatively on the 3D model of pelvis and femur. The factors evaluated were operation time, blood loss, the inclination and the cup anteversion angle on post operative radiographs and CT images.

Results: The mean operation time and mean amount of blood loss were 110 minutes versus 80 minutes, and 417 ml versus 260 ml in the Navi and the non-Navi groups, respectively. The differences were significant. The differences between the planned and postoperative angles were lower in the Navi group than in the non-Navi group. However, the differences between the groups were not significant. There were no major complications, nerve palsy, or fracture in either group.

Conclusion: Our findings were similar to previous reports. The increase of operation time and the amount of blood loss were caused by lengthy registration and adjustments to the system. Although the navigation system increased implantation accuracy, improvements are necessary to reduce blood loss and operation time.


H. Osnes Ringen T Uhlig T.K Kvien

Background: The overall goal in the treatment of RA is to minimize the loss of function and preserve the quality of life. In addition to drug therapy orthopaedic surgery may offer an opportunity to improve functioning in varies parts of the skeletal system.

Objective: To examine the overall magnitude of change in quality of life over a ten years period, with special focus on the changes in physical functioning in different joint areas.

Methods: Data from the Oslo RA register with 1600 living patients were used as basis for the study. Self-reported questionnaires were sent to the patients in 1994, 1996, 2001 and 2004, including the SF36, the AIMS2, the MHAQ, and three 100 mm visual analogue scales (pain, fatigue and patient global). 310 patients (mean (SD) age 56.4 (13.0) years, and disease duration 12.0 (9.9) years, 85.5% women) who completed questionnaires at baseline and after 10 years were eligible for the current analyses. Changes in health status were adjusted for age, sex and duration of disease. Magnitude of change was analysed by standardized response mean (SRM), i.e. the change divided by the standard deviation. AIMS2 comprises physical scales for different parts of the body and was used to examine changes in physical functioning in different areas of the musculoskeletal system.

Results: The overall physical functioning was deteriorated with MHAQ SRM 0.25 and AIMS2 physical SRM 0.11. Larger average deterioration in physical functioning was seen in mobility and walking and bending, than for upper extremity function (arm and hand finger scales). These results were supported by adjusted SRMs for the individual items of MHAQ: Dressing 0.26, Get out of car 0.24, Walk outdoor 0.22, Bending 0.22, Get in and out of bed 0.16, Lift to mouth 0.13, Turning faucets −0.02.

Conclusion: Physical functioning and quality of life deteriorated over 10 years in patients with RA. The largest loss of functioning was seen in the lower limb physical activity (mobility, walking and bending). This finding may give a clue to priorities of resources to surgical procedures in patients with RA.


N Abe K Fujiwara T Yoshitaka Y Nasu H Date Y Sakoma T Ozaki H. Inoue

Purpose: Minimally invasive surgery (MIS) total knee arthroplasty (TKA) makes faster rehabilitation in many cases, but it was sometimes difficult to performed the precise osteotomy and place the implants correctly due to loss of view or orientation for its small exposure. The computer-assisted navigation TKA system (CAS) was reported to achieve the optimal alignment and placement. However, it had disadvantages of longer operation time and wider exposure to acquire the reference points than these of the conventional method. Now MIS technique needs the accuracy of implant placement, on the other hand, CAS needs less-invasive methods. Among CAS methods, CT-based navigation system would have the potential for MIS because it would be referred to preoperative CT images. This study examined the accuracy of the registration with CT-based navigation system and the possibility of its application for MIS.

Material and Methods: CT data were obtained from the femur and tibia of “Sawbone” (synthetic bone, Pacific Research Laboratories, Vashon, WA, USA) with a slice thickness of 1 mm. These data were transferred to Vector Vision Knee 1.5 (BrainLab Inc, Heimstettenm, Germany) and reconstructed to three-dimensional model. Two registrations were performed by a surface-matching algorithm. One is the conventional method as Vector Vision protocol; another is MIS approach which was allowed the limited area around the femoral notch and joint surface of tibia for registration. The accuracy of registration with these two methods was evaluated by Vector Vision Knee. And these registration points of these different methods were measured using a coordinate measuring machine, 3D surface scanner (Mitsutoyo, JAPAN) and were analyzed and calculated the distribution of points.

Results and Discussion: There was a high degree of reproducibility of the MIS approach compared with the conventional method in the femur. However, the reference points in the distal tibia were deviated 1.5 cm to medial and thus 2.39 degree in varus would be happened at the proximal tibia in both methods. Now this software should be improving to be more accurate.


U Rydholm Q. Li U. Kesteris

Different resurfacing implants offer different kinds of positioning instruments. As it is of outmost importance to position the components within rather narrow limits to diminish the risk of femoral notching or impingement we decided to measure the position achieved in 72 hips resurfaced with the Durom® resurfacing hip and instruments.

There were 38 males and 27 females with 72 hips (7 bilateral). The indication was OA in 51 cases, RA in 12 and ON in 2. We compared 2 groups, 26 hips operated with an antero-lateral approach (A) and 46 with a postero-lateral approach (B).

The acetabular cup anteversion angle was 22±11° in group A and 15±9° in group B. The abduction angle was 38±9 ° in group A and 44±7° in group B. The acetabular gap was 2±1 mm, resp. 2±2 mm. The stem-shaft angle was 140±5° resp. 141±6°. Retroverted cups averaged 7±4°.

The difference between pre- and postoperative acetabular size was 3 mm in group A (mostly RA patients) and 5 mm in group B (mostly OA patients).

Conclusions: We have obtained a fairly good implant position. The only significant differences between the two groups were decreased acetabular cup abduction angle compared to the preoperative angle in the antero-lateral group, but increased angle in the postero-lateral group, and that less acetabular bone was removed in the antero-lateral group (patients with RA included) compared to the postero-lateral group.


A Kitamura K Nishida Y Nasu T Ozaki H. Inoue

Introduction Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) commonly affects the forefoot, and pain caused by the deformity of forefoot impairs the walking ability. We have performed resection arthroplasty for all metatarsal heads using modified Lelièvre procedure in affected feet. The aim of the current retrospective study was to investigate the long term results and problems of this procedure.

Patients and methods We investigated 45 feet treated by modified Lelièvre procedure in 29 women from 1985 to 2003 at our institute. Their average age at operation was 54.8 years (range 39 – 76 years). They were followed-up more than two years (26 – 203 months). Resection of all five metatarsal heads was performed for the RA forefoot which had severe deformity and persistent pain, using medial approach for first metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint and plantar approach for lesser MTP joint. The results were evaluated by the rating scale of the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS), Foot Function Index (FFI), physical examination, radiographic evaluation, as well as subjective assessment using questionnaire for mental and physical disability.

Results Pain and walking ability were improved in all but 2 feet; one of which underwent additional surgical treatment. Eight out of 45 feet had recurrence of MTP joint dislocation of thumb at the final follow-up. Re-formation of callosities was seen in 69% of the patients, 50% of which were developed within 3 years after operation, and 78% within 5 years. No superficial infection or delayed wound-healing was noted in any case. Satisfactory surgical outcome was maintained for at least 2 years after operation in all cases, and deteriorated later. At an average of 96 months postoperatively, the average AOFAS forefoot score was 67.9 points. Seven cases were judged to have excellent (25%), 13 cases good (46%), 7 cases (25%) fair, and 1 case poor (4%) results. The average radio graphic hallux valgus angle was 31.3 degrees. Eventually, 70% of patients underwent total hip or knee arthroplasty.

Conclusion Resection arthroplasty of all five metatarsal heads using modified Lelièvre procedure in RA patients with pain and deformity of forefoot seemed to be an effective procedure over a long postoperative period, providing reasonable relief of symptoms. Because RA affects multiple joints including hip and knee joints, the forefoot reconstruction alone cannot sustain the improved walking ability.


H. Thabe

The management of a bacterial periprosthetic infection by two-stage re-implantation should be presented using an implanted application spacer for antibiotics to maintain mobility and soft tissue balance and ensure simultaneous local delivery of antibiotics. Indication is an acute periprosthetic infection, acute and chronic course of the infection with unknown spectrum of organism, hardly to treat and with a probable loss of mobility due to protracted immobilization after implant removal. Acute infections with a known spectrum of organisms that can be controlled by synovectomy and antibiotic treatment or by one-stage re-implantation are contraindications for this treatment. Spacers are available for hip and knee replacements including surface replacements of the knee. First a complete synovectomy is performed; the implant bed is then prepared for implantation of the application spacer for antibiotics. Silicone catheters are advanced through two separate drill holes into the intramedullary canal and then inserted into the perforated implant stems. Daily parenteral doses of antibiotics in parenteral doses are delivered through the percutaneous silicone catheters directly into the intramedullary canal. The application spacer for antibiotics allows daily physiotherapy and even mobilization on a CPM device. Partial weight bearing may even be allowed, if there is sufficient stability. Once the CRP values have decreased to normal levels, the definitive implant is placed using antibiotic-impregnated cement according to current resistance studies. 36 patients have been treated with this method since 1993. Two-stage re-implantation of a total knee was performed in 20 cases, and re-implantation of a total hip in 16 cases. The longest postoperative follow-up period is now 10 years. Till now, no revision surgery has been required on a joint treated in this manner, and no periprosthetic re-infections have been observed. In the knee, a range of motion of 0/0 /106 degrees was achieved after an average follow-up period of 6.1 years. In the hip, values of 10/0/110 degrees were achieved after an average of 6.3 years. Revision surgery for infection included cases of fungal and tubercular infection. A postoperative Hospital for Special Surgery rating of 79.5 was achieved in the knee and a rating of 81.3 in the Harris hip score.


D Hirokazu A Nobuhiro Y Teruhito S Yoshimasa O Toshifumi I. Hajime

The precise implantation of the prosthesis is quite important to have the good long term outcomes. One of the important methods for the implantation is the preoperative templating to determine the selection of implant size, position and alignment. But the preoperative template system sometimes could not give us the reproducibility of the actual size of prostheses which were assessed intra-operatively. One reason for the inaccuracy of the radiograph based templating system is caused by the magnification of the view due to the fixed knee deformity and another is by the rotation view of the prostheses due to tilt shooting radiograph. We are now performing the preoperative CT based 3 dimensional templating system or intra-operative molding template system with virtual bone model, in the addition to the traditional preoperative radiographic templating system. Our aim is to assess the reliability of these templating systems which are traditional radiograph template (2D-template), CT-based template (3D-template) and intra-operative molding template (Free-template), for the selection of correct prosthetic size during operation. We randomly selected 51 patients with 19 osteoarthritis, 30 rheumatoid arthritis, 1 juvenile rheumatoid arthritis and 1 systemic lupus erythematosus, and performed PFC sigma total knee arthroplasty (DePuy). In all 51 knees, the sizes of implants were estimated on the traditional radiograph to get the 2D-template data. The 3D template data were obtained from 25 knees preoperatively by the CT-based navigation system (BrainLab) and Free-template data were collected intra-operatively from 27 knees with the CT-free navigation system (BrainLab). These template data were compared with the actual implanted size of the femur and tibia without any information. The statistical analyses were performed to evaluate the reliability of these templating systems. The precision of 3D-template was not significantly different from that of 2D-template. On the other hand, the reproducibility of Free-template data was significantly higher than the other templating system. In our conclusion, the precise selection of the prostheses could not be achieved with either 2D-template or 3D-template, due to the disappearance of joint space and severe osteophytes. CT-free system could be precisely acquire in-situ bone information of femur and tibia even in the severe deformity knees, and at the same time, CT-free system, which has the kinematics based navigation system, can determine the placement and alignment. Thus CT-free navigation system would be the best assistance during pre- and intra-operation to achieve the long-term good results.


K.S. Kaichiro Saigo J.R. Junnosuke Ryu S.S. Shu Saito T.I. Takao Ishii

Introduction: We reviewed clinical results of the performance of FNK-type total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) for treatment of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) knees.

Materials and Methods: Materials we had studied were 372 knee joints in 202 cases (21.1%) with RA (36 joints in 22 male patients, and 336 joints in 180 female) out of 1762 knee joints in 1032 cases who had undergone TKA using FNK type prostheses between May 1995 and December 2003. A mean age of patients at index procedures was 62.4 years (24 – 74 years), with a mean follow-up period of 6.7 years (1 – 9.4 years). With these cases, we discussed clinical evaluation on the basis of JOC rating scores, postoperative range of motion, complications, and others.

Results: 288 knee joints (77.4%) in 144 patients were involved in bilateral simultaneous TKA. The range of motion (ROM) had shown a significant improvement from a preoperative average of 15.2 – 110.2° to 2.3 – 125.0° at the last follow-up. There have been no cases of revision surgery at all, with excellent postoperative results.


J.M Wilkinson P Haslam J Williams D.J Moore C.J.M. Getty

We compared the long-term clinical outcome scores of the Stanmore total hip arthroplasty (THA) in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA, n=26 subjects) versus osteoarthritis (OA, n=35 subjects) at a mean of 12 years after THA. Patients with RA were a mean of 11 years younger at review (66 years, P< 0.001) than those with OA. A greater proportion of RA patients had bilateral THA (19/26 versus 12/35, p=0.03), and were of Charnley grade C (23/26 versus 2/35, p< 0.001). The proportion of male versus female subjects and body mass index were similar between groups (p> 0.05 all comparisons). The overall SF-12 score and SF-12 physical component score were 8% and 15% poorer, respectively, in subjects with RA versus those with OA (P< 0.05). The hip-specific Oxford and Harris hip scores, however, were similar between groups (p> 0.05). Within the individual domains of the Harris hip score, patients with RA had poorer scores for walking distance, stair climbing, putting on of socks/shoes, and ability to enter public transport (p< 0.05 all comparisons). The other domains of pain, limp, use of walking aids, sitting, deformity and range of movement were similar between groups (p> 0.05). The observed differences in outcome scores between RA and OA groups were independent of age and whether the patient had bilateral THA (ANOVA, p> 0.05). Clinical outcome scores in the long term after THA are poorer in RA subjects versus OA. The principal differences occur in the ability to walk long distances, and the use of stairs and public transport.


A.M Thomas C McBryde P.B. Pynsent

Metal on metal hip resurfacing was introduced in 1992 by Derek McMinn initially using an all cementless device and then an all cemented device. A hybrid resurfacing with a cemented femoral component and a cementless acetabular component was introduced in 1994. The manufacturer of the hybrid hip resurfacing was changed in 1996. Since 1997 the Birmingham hip resurfacing has been in continuous use.

The device is approved by NICE (National Institute for Clinical Excellence) for use within the NHS in patients with Osteoarthritis of the hip. The device is not yet approved for use in patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis and other types of inflammatory arthritis. There are concerns regarding bone quality in rheumatoid patients, which may result in a high incidence of component loosening or femoral neck fracture. Conventional total hip replacement is a successful procedure in inflammatory arthritis however with modern treatments producing increased activity levels there are concerns about polyethylene wear.

The author has performed metal on metal hip resurfacing in patients with inflammatory arthritis over the past 12 years. A total of 170 patients have been operated on with 198 resurfacings. 33% of patients have a diagnosis of some type of inflammatory arthritis. The outcomes have been assessed using Oxford hip scores and long term clinical and radiological review. Our results indicate that there is a minimal risk of femoral neck fracture and a minimal risk of component loosening when the device is used with this approach in patients with inflammatory arthritis.


K Masuda T Mori T Juji R Marutani T. Hirose

Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate the safety and efficacy of sequential bilateral total knee arthroplasty (TKA) for patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), in comparison with staged bilateral and unilateral TKA.

Patients and Methods: Between July 2000 and June 2005, 340 TKA were performed in our department. We investigated retrospectively the clinical data of each patient, including the peri-operative data such as the surgical time, the amount of haemorrhage and postoperative adverse events. We also examined the clinical outcome before and after bilateral TKA by using the Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) evaluation chart of knee joint function (JOA score).

Results: We have done sequential bilateral TKA for 60 knees of 30 patients (group A), staged bilateral TKA for 26 knees of 13 patients (group B) and unilateral TKA for 254 knees (group C). Before TKA, the mean JOA score were 44.9, 40.1, 46.4 points, and the mean range of motion of affected knees were 14.6–113.6°, 27.9–89.6°, 14.1–116.9° in group A, B and C, respectively, indicating that group B included more severe cases. Whereas the mean surgical time were 136.4, 158.4, 154.3 minutes, the mean amount of peri-operative haemorrhage were 414.6, 273.4, 277.7 ml in group A, B and C, respectively. Although we experienced 1 case with symptomatic pulmonary embolism in group A, which was successfully treated, there was none of cases with death within 1 month of surgery or early-phase infection. The JOA score at final follow-up (the mean follow-up period was 1 year and 8 months) were 91.1 and 86.9 points in group A and B, respectively, showing good results in both groups.

Conclusion: In short-term data, sequential bilateral TKA was successfully performed and beneficial approach to patients with RA. The intensive pre- and post-operative management could be essential for good clinical outcome. Further improvement should be needed to perform this procedure more safely and prevent complications, especially serious cardiopulmonary events.


U Rydholm T Andersson L Linder P Maxander J Besjakov F Montgomery A. Carlsson

25 RA patients with their ankles fused with an intramedullary nail were compared to 35 RA patients with their ankles fused with compression screws.

24/25 nailed patients showed radiographic healing at follow-up after 3 (1–8) years, and 26/35 ankles in the compression screw group examined after 6 (1–14) years healed after the first attempt and another 5 after repeat surgery.

In the nailed group 23 patients were satisfied and 2 somewhat satisfied. In the compression screw group 20 were satisfied, 12 somewhat satisfied and 3 dissatisfied.

There were 4 deep infections (3 healed after nail extraction and antibiotics, one unhealed) in the nail group and 1 deep infection (healed after antibiotics) in the compression screw group.

Six patients in the nailed group also had a permanent plantar sensory loss.

Conclusion: Ankle fusion with retrograde intramedullary nailing seems to result in a high rate of healing and satisfied patients, but cares a substantial risk of deep infection compared to fusion with compression screws, which has a lower fusion rate fewer satisfied patients, but less complications.

RA patients with a normal subtalar joint are of course only managed by compression screws.


K.I. Kazuhiko Inoue

Purpose: Synovium proliferation of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a key role in development of destruction in articular joints. Arthroscopic synovectomy is quite useful for resection synovium less invasively for RA patients. However there are few papers about shoulder joint synovectomy of rheumatoid arthritis. Ho-YAG laser is also effective to decrease synovium proliferation. The advantage of using Ho-YAG laser is effective to pannus even in deep zone of bone erosion. In this paper, we treated 13 shoulders of 11 patients of RA by using Ho-YAG laser to assess whether Ho-YAGH laser is effective in shoulder arthroscopic synovectomy of RA

Materials and Methods: We treated 13 shoulders in 11 patients of RA, including 8 in stage II, 4 in stage III, 1 in stage IV. The duration of RA is an average of 4, 6 years. The follow-up period is an average of 14 months. We compared CRP, DAS28 and MRI findings before and after surgery. Those patients were taking DMARDs such as MTX in 8 patients, steroid in 3 patients infliximab in 1 patient and etanercept in 1 patient. We used 4.0 mm arthroscope, VAPR and shaver for synovectomy. Ho-YAG laser set to 10W to bone erosion area to reach deep zone of pannus and to resect synovium.

Results: We found villous synovium proliferation with vascularity in rotator interval and supraspinatus tendon in shoulder joint. In subacromial bursa, yellow fat tissue and white fibrous soft tissue was detected almost all shoulders. After synovectomy by using Ho-YAG laser, CRP was decreased from an average of 3.6 to 0.8 and DAS28 was also decreased an average of 5.4 to 3.7 at 14 month after surgery. MRI showed decreased pannus with synovium and joint destruction was not preceding after 14 month.

Discussion: Ho-YAG laser is effective for using shoulder arthroscopic synovectomy especially to treat pannus in bone erosion. The amount of energy of Ho-YAG laser for synovectomy is not clear so far. We used 10W for 5 second in each area that could be effective to decrease pannus formation. We would further investigate in the basic experimental levels to confirm Ho-YAG laser efficacy.


K Arai T Murai J Fujisawa N Kondo T. Hanyu

Our approach to reconstructing forefoot deformities in patients with rheumatoid arthritis was as follows. In the lateral toes with mild or moderate joint destruction, shortening oblique osteotomy of the metatarsals is performed. With severe joint destruction, metatarsal head is resected. Arthrodesis of the first MTP joint is performed as a rule with resection arthroplasty in the lateral toes. When shortening oblique osteotomy in the lateral toes is indicated, the great toe is managed as follows: in young patients with mild joint destruction in the great toe (Larsen grades I and II) and who are able to ambulate well, Mitchell’s osteotomy is done. In older patients, or in patients with moderate or severe joint destruction (Larsen grades III to V), flexible hinge toe prosthesis is implanted.

Between 1987 and 2000, Mitchell’s osteotomy was performed on 47 feet in 31 patients, whose mean age was 53 years, Larsen grade was 2.5 and hallux valgus angle (HVA) was 35.0 (SD11.9). Arthroplasty with flexible hinge toe prosthesis was performed on 31 feet in 23 patients, 58 years, Larsen grade was 3.7 and HVA was 45.3 (SD12.9). After 1995, grommets were used in 17 feet. In 2002, we studied clinical results of them. 40 feet of Mitchell’s osteotomy had no pain and 7 feet had some pain. 26 feet of arthroplasty with flexible hinge toe prosthesis had no pain and 5 feet had some pain. Radiologically, HVA was 17.2 (SD10.3) in Mitchell’s osteotomy and 12.1 (SD6.3) in arthroplasty with flexible hinge toe prosthesis. Maintenance of correction by arthroplasty with flexible hinge toe prosthesis was better than Mitchell’s osteotomy significantly, especially more than 30 degrees of HVA. Without grommets, grade 0 was 8 feet, grade I was 3, and grade II was 3 feet judged by Granberry’s grade. But no revision surgery was performed by silicone synovitis or fracture of implant. With grommets, there were no fractures.

We added degree of HVA to management of operation after 2002. More than 40 degrees of HVA was considered flexible hinge toe prosthesis. After 2002, Mitchell’s osteotomy was performed on 7 feet in 6 patients, 53.7 years, Larsen grade was 2.4 and HVA was 32.3 (SD6.8). Arthroplasty with flexible hinge toe prosthesis was performed on 14 feet in 10 patients, 60.7 years, Larsen grade was 3.9 and HVA was 42.5 (SD7.5). Radiological result in these patients at 2005, HVA was 14.6 (SD4.9) in Mitchell’s osteotomy and 14.9 (SD2.5) in arthroplasty with flexible hinge toe prosthesis.


A. Lluch

Introduction and aim: In the rheumatoid hand, a radial inclination of the wrist is commonly observed in the presence of an ulnar drift of the fingers. The question that remains is: Which came first? To find an answer to this question, we have studied the radiographs of 122 hand affected by rheumatoid arthritis.

Material and methods: In group I (44 hands), the disease was restricted to the wrist joint, which presented an average ulnar inclination of 15°, ranging from neutral to 43° of ulnar inclination.

In group II (13 hands), the disease was limited to the MP joints, with an average of 30° of ulnar inclination of the fingers, ranging from 10° to 70°. A compensatory radial inclination of 12° was observed at the wrist, ranging from 2° to 26°.

In group III (28 hands), both the wrist and MP joints were affected by the disease. The fingers presented an average ulnar inclination of 17°, ranging from 7° to 40°. The wrist presented an average radial inclination of 4°.

In group IV (34 hands) and V (3 hands), measurements were done before and after the finger deformity was corrected from an average of 45° to 7°, while the wrist corrected itself, without wrist balancing procedures, on an average from 30° to 2° of radial inclination.

Results: When only the wrist is involved, the metacarpals are always inclined towards the ulnar side. We have observed a radial inclination of the wrist only in the hands presenting an ulnar inclination of the fingers. When the ulnar drift of the fingers is surgically corrected, the radial inclination of the wrist will tend to correct itself.

Conclusion: It has been generally accepted that radial inclination of the metacarpals is one of the causes of the ulnar drift of the fingers, but from our studies the radial inclination of the metacarpals should not be considered the cause but rather a consequence of the ulnar drift of the fingers.


A. Hilker

Background The AscensionTM MCP-implant acc. to Beckenbaugh is an unconstrained endoprosthesis consisting of a graphite core with a pyrocarbon coating. Long term results published by the Mayo Clinic gave rise to the hope of good ingrowth properties and a long durability due to the optimum wear resistance of the material. Purpose of this study was the evaluation of the early results of this implant applied on the patients of a rheumatoid arthritis surgery department.

Methods In a prospective manner we evaluated the data of 18 patients with 19 involved hands in which we implanted a total of 29 Ascension endoprostheses between July, 2000 and Oktober, 2002. The mean follow up time was 39.7 months. We assessed hand function (SODA-score), mobility, radiographic appearance and the subjective parameters pain, functionality, power, cosmetic appearance and global satisfaction.

Results The SODA score increased from 82.8 preoperatively to 92.9 (maximum 108) at follow up. With 50.9 and 51.3 deg. respectively the range of motion remained almost unchanged. On a visual analogue scale from 0 – 10 the subjective results were: pain 2.1 (−5.2), functionality 6.5 (+3.0), power 5.3 (+2.3), cosmetic appearance 8.0 (+3.4), global satisfaction 8.1.

Radiographically we observed suspicious radiolucent lines around 17 of 58 implanted components (29%), three of them progressive. Around the tips of three stems an osteolytic area with minimal progression was found. Three stems showed a slight migration. The following intraoperative complications were observed: Two bone fissures and three lacerations of a collateral ligament, which all healed uneventfully. Five endoprostheses were converted into a flexible hinge silicone implant for persistent pain and loosening between 12 and 48 months p.o. One more implant had to be revised due to a late haematogenous infection 4 years p.o.

Conclusion With the AscensionTM MCP implant a good pain relief can be obtained in almost every case but only rarely an improvement in the range of motion can be seen. The subjective results were predominantly good. But the apparently inconstant bony ingrowth resulted in a rate of revisions for aseptic loosening as high as 17% at a mean follow up of 3 ½ years. A modification of the implant leading to a better bony fixation would be required before a wider clinical use of this implant can be recommended.


H Ishikawa A Murasawa K Nakazono I Toyohara A Abe S. Kashiwagi

Objective: The objective of this study was to clarify the clinical outcome of upper-extremity surgeries for the rheumatoid patients using the Japanese version of the DASH Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand questionnaire and to investigate whether the outcome was affected by the activity of the disease.

Materials and methods: One hundred and twenty seven surgical procedures in 103 rheumatoid patients (male: 26, female: 77) were included in this study. Surgeries were performed in 4 shoulders (HHR: 4), 35 elbows (TEA: 28, synovectomy: 6 etc.), 60 wrists (Kapandji: 6, radiolunate arthrodesis: 28, total arthrodesis: 7, extensor tendon reconstruction: 19 etc), and 28 hands (MP Swanson: 13, PIP fusion: 7, thumb IP fusion: 4 etc.). The patients’ average age at the surgery was 61 years and an average duration of the disease was 11 years. The DASH (function/symptoms) score and DAS (Disease Activity Score) 28-CRP(4) were taken just before the surgery and an average of 1 year and 3 months after the surgery. According to the EULAR’s improvement criteria, disease activity and response to the medical treatment was determined.

Results: The preoperative DASH score decreased in 96 surgical procedures (76%) postoperatively and the average score decreased from 50 to 38 (n=127, p< 0.01). Change in the score was −17 in shoulder surgeries (n=4, p=0.17), −12 in elbow surgeries (n=35, p< 0.01), −12 in wrist surgeries (n=60, p< 0.01) and −10 in hand surgeries (n=28, p< 0.05). The DASH score in the patients with preoperative HDA (high disease activity: n=16, from 70 to 57, p< 0.01) remained high compared to those with preoperative LDA (low disease activity: n=23, from 45 to 32, p< 0.01) and MDA (moderate disease activity: n=88, from 47 to 36, p< 0.01). Decrease in the score was more prominent in the patients with good response to the medical treatment (n=34, −22, p< 0.01) than those with moderate response (n=38, −11, p< 0.01) or no response (n=55, −6, p< 0.05). There was no significant decrease in the postoperative score in the patients with increased DAS28-CRP (4) (n=26, −1, p=0.822).

Conclusions: The clinical outcome of upper-extremity surgeries for the rheumatoid patients was good. Control of the disease activity by the medical treatment proved to be one of the important factors to produce a favourable outcome of surgical treatment.


J.W Sperling R.H Cofield C.M Schleck W.S. Harmsen

Between January 1, 1976 and December 31, 1991, 195 total shoulder arthroplasties and 108 hemiarthroplasties were performed by the senior author in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. One hundred eighty-seven total shoulder arthroplasties and 95 hemiarthroplasties with complete preoperative evaluation, operative records, and minimum 2-year follow-up (mean 11.6 years) or follow-up until revision were included in the clinical analysis. Twenty patients died and one was lost to follow-up. All 303 shoulders were included in the survival analysis.

There was significant long term pain relief (P< .0001), improvement in active abduction (P< .0001), and external rotation (P< .0001) with both, hemiarthroplasty and total shoulder arthroplasty. There was not a significant difference in improvement in pain and motion comparing hemiarthroplasty and total shoulder arthroplasty for patients with a thin or torn rotator cuff. However, among patients with an intact rotator cuff, improvement in pain and abduction were significantly greater with total shoulder arthroplasty. Additionally, among patients with an intact rotator cuff, the risk for revision was significantly lower for total shoulder arthroplasty (p=0.04).

Radiographs were available for 152 total shoulder arthroplasties and 63 hemiarthroplasties with a minimum 2 year follow-up. Glenoid erosion was present in 62 of 63 hemiarthroplasties (98%). Glenoid periprosthetic lucency was present in 110 of 152 total shoulder arthroplasties (72%).

The data from this study indicate there is marked long term pain relief and improvement in motion with shoulder arthroplasty. Among patients with an intact rotator cuff, total shoulder arthroplasty appears to be the preferred procedure for pain relief, improvement in abduction, and lower risk of revision surgery.


J.R. Junnosuke Ryu T.I. Takao Ishii M.N. Masahiro Nagaoka

The recent advance of drug therapy for RA tends to replace preventive surgery, for example synovectomy. A rupture of a dorsal extensor tendon of the hand is an absolute indication for surgery, however. Such tendon ruptures are usually treated by tendon reconstruction and synovectomy of wrist joint. At our department, reconstructive surgery was administered with synovectomy for extensor tendon ruptures of the hand in 97 hands for 86 patients until June 2005. Recently, however, we occasionally encounter ruptures of extensor tendons not associated with severe synovitis. To treat such tendon ruptures, we usually administer tendon transfers in combination with tenosynovectomy through a small skin incision. Because this surgical procedure has achieved excellent results, we report our experience.

This study included 15 patients who received tenosynovectomy in combination with tendon transfers in 14 hands since February 2001. This surgical procedure is indicated for tendon ruptures associated with mild synovitis (swelling) without instability on the ulnar distal end. As a rule, a 2–3 cm transverse skin incision was made on the dorsum of the hand under maxillary nerve block. After exposure of the distal ruptured end of the tendon, tenosynovectomy was administered through the incision. Then, the distal end was transferred to the adjacent normal tendon and fixed to it with sutures. Postoperatively, the repair was immobilized with bandage. The patient was allowed actively to extend and bend the hand on the next day. As a rule, this operation is administered on an outpatient basis. The postoperative course was uneventful, without rupture of the repair. The preoperative ranges of motion of the MP and PIP joints were retained postoperatively without difficulty in ADL.


L.J. Jung

According to authors investigating problems with the hand in rheumatoid arthritis (RA), up to 95 % of patients suffer due to wrist involvement after 8–12 years from the onset of the disease. In a high activity and a progressive pattern of RA, wrist damage occurs earlier. The question is what to do when pain and instability are dominant factors and at the same time the x-rays show only a mild or moderate degree of destruction of the joint. Trying to find an alternative procedure to a more radical surgery, in 1995 I started surgical stabilization using a pedicled flap of the joint capsule and the extensor retinaculum.

Material and methods: 44 wrists in 36 patients were treated with this method. The patients were 34 women and 2 men at the ages from 24 to 73 (49 on average). The follow-up was from 2 to 9 years (average > 6). The operation was done through a dorsal approach. After synovectomy of the wrist, the capsular pedicled flap was prepared, in a case of subluxation, the carpal bones were repositioned and two mattress strong stitches were put on through the capsule flap and proximal and distal row of carpal bones. The joint was closed with single stitches. Depending on the pathology, hemi- or total- resection of the ulnar head was combined with the procedure. In some cases, a repair of the ruptured extensor tendons was necessary. Immobilisation in the palmar splint for 6 weeks was recommended, and then a rehabilitation program started.

Results: 25 wrists (63 %) at the latest follow-up were free from pain and stable, 8 (20 %) were stable but mildly and occasionally painful, 4 were moderately painful, and 3 needed arthrodesis because of the marked bone destruction and pain. The power of the combined grip was significantly improved in 31 wrists (77 %); moderate improvement was in 6 cases (15%).

Conclusion: Stabilisation of the painful and unstable wrist with the use of the method described above gives good results and seems to be a valuable procedure even in selected cases qualified as arthrodesis.


F. Hagena B. Mayer

Background: In 80% of patients with rheumatoid arthritis the metacarpophalangeal (MP) joints are involved with increasing destruction and loss of function. Silicone arhtroplasties of the MP joints produce a limited range of motion, increasing osteolysis and fractures of the implants. The cementless, unconstrained design of the ElogenicsTM prosthesis is a new concept for treating the MP joints of rheumatoid patients.

Methods: In a prospective study 72 ElogenicsTM prosthesis were implanted, 62 in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, osteoarthritis (n=4), polyarthritis (n=5) and 1 after revision of a silicone implant. The patients were reexamined after an average follow up of 21 months (12–51 months) clinically and radiologically.

Results: The average active range of motion for extension to flexion increased from 0/18/65° before surgery to 0/14/71° after surgery. The remaining ulnar drift was 12° (preoperative 18°!). Pain in the visual analogue scale improved from 2.3 to 1.7 postoperatively. Eight palmar luxations of the implants were recognized. They were revised and are stable during the follow-up. No infection occurred. Two prostheses were changed because of loosening. The X-rays showed osteointegration in the metacarpal components. Radiolucent zones were found in progress at the basis on the palangeal components.

Conclusion: The short- and midterm results after implantation of the cementless, unconstrained ElogenicsTM prosthesis show an improved hand function and pain relief. The design of the implant may solve the accepted postoperative problem of instability of the MP joints.


D.S Della Santa A.C. Chamay

Twenty five years ago, the 1 st paper concerning radiolunate arthrodesis was published by us (Med Hyg 38 1980). Ten years ago a 5 year follow-up radiological evolution of 26 operated rheumatoid wrists by radiolunate arthrodesis compaired with 20 non operated wrists was reported (JHS 20B 1995).

Six critera were retained for XR analysis :

- Evolutive stage classification (Alnot)

- Polyarthritis type classification (Simmen)

- Frontal desaxation (Thirupathi)

- Carpal collapse (Mc Murtry)

- Ulnar translation (Chamay)

- Carpal instability (Tubiana)

Our results showed that although radiolunate arthrodesis induced a lasting functional improvement, correction of the desaxation and collapse was only temporary.

Details of the radiological analysis will be presented and compaired with the litterature data.


E.H Garling D.B Herren R.G.H.H. Nelissen

Various radiological classification systems exist for rheumatoid wrist progression but few have been evaluated for reliability and clinical application. In order to research these three sets of wrist radiographs of 35 rheumatoid patients, with an average duration of disease of 11 years, were classified according to four different classification systems (Larsen, Simmen, Wrightington and Modified Wrightington). The inter- and intraobserver reliability of each was calculated. The reliability of the Larsen and both Wrightington systems were good but the Simmen system had poor interobserver and intraobserver reproducibility. None of the classification systems satisfactorily assessed the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) and the Modified Wrightington system could not classify DRUJ disease in 6 of the 35 wrists.


H.J.L van der Heide M.J de Vos J.M Brinkman D Eygendaal F.H.J van den Hoogen M.C. de Waal Malefijt

Introduction: The Kudo total elbow prosthesis (TEP) is a well established implant, with good mid-term results. In the last decades this implant underwent several modifications. The last modification (type 5) has overcome the problems of stem breakage of the humeral component by modifications of the stem. The ulnar component can be placed with or without cement; the humeral component is always placed without cement.

Aims of this study: To examine the mid-term results of the Kudo type 5 TEP and to compare the results of the uncemented Kudo total elbow prosthesis (TEP), with the hybrid Kudo TEP (uncemented humeral component and cemented ulnar component).

Material and methods: Between 1994 and 2004 89 Kudo type 5 TEPs were placed for joint destruction due to rheumatoid arthritis (RA). The mean age of the patients was 55 years (range 21–84 years). Twenty-two prostheses were placed in males, 66 in females. Forty-nine TEPs (group 1) were fully uncemented and 40 TEPs (group 2) were hybrid (humeral component uncemented, ulnar component cemented). The groups were comparable as related to age, sex and indication for surgery. After implantation of the prosthesis a radiograph was made every two years or sooner when indicated.

Evaluation took place after an average of 5.3 years of follow up (range 1.7–10.6 years) and consisted of a questionnaire, elbow function assessment and anteroposterior and lateral radiographs in a standard way. Pre- and postoperative range of motion was analysed with the paired T-test. Pain scores and EFAS scores postoperatively were analysed using the independent sample T-test. The survival of the prosthesis was calculated from the time of implant to the time of revision or occurrence of radiolucencies.

Results: In group 1, seven ulnar components had to be revised due to aseptic loosening after a mean follow-up of 4 years (range 1.5–6.3 years). Three of these ulnar components were short-stemmed, four were long stemmed uncemented.

In group 2 five patients died of an unrelated course and no revisions have taken place, one TEP is loose on X-ray (after two years) with a suspicion of septic loosening The EFAS scores (87 in group 1 and 91 in group 2) and range of motion (84 degrees in group 1 and 90 degrees in group 2) were the same in both groups.

Conclusion: In this group of patients with RA the survival of the Kudo type 5 TEP with cemented ulnar component is better as compared to the uncemented ulnar component.


A Abe H Ishikawa A Murasawa K Nakazono I Toyohara S. Kashiwagi

Background: Total wrist arthrodesis is a reliable procedure for severely deteriorated and unstable rheumatoid wrist. In 1999, we developed a new wrist fusion rod (WFR), a cannulated titanium rod could be buried into the third metacarpal with proximal fins and a transverse pin to prevent the rod migration and rotation in the medullary canal. After bone preparation, the 4 mm diameter rod was inserted through a guide pin in ante-grade fashion from the carpus to the neck of the third metacarpal to prevent metacarpal fracture. Then the rod was inserted in retrograde fashion into the radius with an introducer, and countersunk until the distal end of the reached the metacarpal isthmus. After burying the rod, it was bent to the desired angle using a special bender.

Materials and Methods: Total wrist arthrodesis was performed using this rod on 39 wrists in 33 patients with rheumatoid arthritis (6 males and 27 females). Their radiographic change was Larsen grade IV or V with subluxation at the radiocarpal joint. The mean age at the operation was 60 yrs. old (28 to 75), and the mean duration of the disease was 12 yrs. (3 to 40). The mean follow-up period was 39 mos. (5 to 75). Supplemental fixation with staples was incorporated in this intramedullary fixation. Iliac bone was grafted on 8 mutilated wrists in 8 patients. Postoperative immobilization using a short arm cast or a wrist brace was continued for 8 weeks.

Results: Preoperative pain and swelling disappeared in all operated wrists, and grip strength increased in 31 wrists (79%). The mean preoperative grip strength increased from 97 mmHg to 124 mmHg postoperatively. Subluxated wrist was reduced and fused in slight extension and slight ulnar deviation. The rod did not migrate distally or proximally in the medullary canal. Bony fusion was obtained in 36 wrists (92%). Four rods (10%) were broken due to an overuse or a fall before completion of fusion; however, they did not cause any pain. There were no major complications.

Conclusion: Using this WFR, rigid fixation at the desired angle was obtained in the total wrist arthrodesis on rheumatoid wrist. It is technically simple, safe and fast to use.


T Parkkila E Belt M Hakala H Kautiainen J. Leppilahti

Since the 1970s Swanson implant arthroplasty has become a treatment of choice in metacarpohalangeal (MCP) joint arthroplasty in destructed MCP joints of rheumatoid patients. Sutter (Avanta) implant is also composed of silicone but the centre of rotation is more anatomical, and volar to improve extension moment. Clinical results about these implants have been similar but fracture rates of Sutter implant have been reported to be high. Reason for osteolysis is inflammation reaction to silicone particles released from prostheses due to movement of prosthesis in bone or implant fractures. Reports about osteolysis around Swanson implants present variable result.

There is not grading of osteolysis in the literature before and we created a new radiographic grading for osteolysis around silicone MCP implants. Grading is based on involvement of cortical bone: Grade I: Osteolysis varying from a single clear line adjacent to the stem of the prosthesis to a larger, clear area which did not involve the bone cortex; Grade II: Osteolysis affecting the bone cortex to a maximum of one half of the thickness of the cortex; Grade III: Osteolysis affecting the cortex to more than one half of its thickness but not perforating the cortex; Grade IV: Osteolysis perforating the cortex.

In this study we compare the incidence of radiographic osteolysis following insertion of 89 Swanson and 126 Sutter MCP implants in rheumatoid arthritis patients. Before surgery hands were randomised one by one to Swanson and Sutter implant groups. The mean follow-up time in the two groups of patients was 57 (40–80) and 55 (36–79) months, respectively.

A total of 45 (60%) metacarpal and 40 (53%) proximal phalangeal bones showed no osteolytic changes in the Swanson group. In the Sutter group numbers were 20 (21%) and 26 (27%). In the Swanson group, there was less cortical osteolysis and there were 4 (5%) perforations of a metacarpal and no perforations of a proximal phalanx. In the Sutter group, there were 9 (9%) perforations in a metacarpal and 5 (5%) in a proximal phalanx. (p< 0.001). To create a single independent observation of osteolysis for a hand, the worst osteolysis of a metacarpal or proximal phalanx was recorded. There was only one (5%) perforation in the Swanson group, while there were 8 (30%) perforations in the Sutter group (p=0.011). In all grades of our classification, osteolysis was more frequent in the Sutter than in the Swanson group.


K.N. Keiichiro Nishida K.F. Kazuo Fujiwara K.H. Kenzo Hashizume Y.N. Yoshihisa Nasu A.K. Ai Kitamura H.I. Hajime Inoue

Objective: To investigate the long-term follow-up results of total elbow arthroplasty (TEA) with a non-constrained elbow prosthesis with a solid ceramic trochlea (Stemmed Kyocera type I, SKC-I) on patients who have rheumatoid arthritis (RA).

Materials and Methods: Between May 1988 and February 1999, 84 patients of RA underwent TEA with cement fixation (108 elbows). Fourteen patients (14 elbows) were lost due to change of address. One patient (1 elbow) required revision surgery due to aseptic loosening, and 2 elbow implants in 2 individuals were removed due to deep infection, and 18 patients (24 elbows) have died within 5 years after the surgery due to causes unrelated to TEA. Of the remaining 52 patients (70 elbows), 38 patients (53 elbows, 75.7%) were available for the over-5-year detailed clinical and radiographic review at a mean period of 9.2 years (range, 5–17 years). The clinical condition of each elbow before and after operation was assessed according to the Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) elbow scoring system (up to 100 points).

Results: The average postoperative JOA score improved from 45.1 to 83.3 points with marked pain relief in all but 2 cases. The mean range of motion (ROM) of extension / flexion before the surgery was −35.6 / 117.1 and at last follow-up was −17.6 / 136.9 degrees. The mean ROM of pronation / supination improved from 49.6 / 55.8 to 80.0 / 82.1 degrees. Revision surgery was required in 2 patients (2 elbows) due to humeral fracture and ulnar component fracture, respectively. One elbow implant was removed due to deep infection. An ulnar component was removed from one patient with olecranon fracture. During the follow-up, 3 elbow joints had dislocated in 3 patients, and loosening was seen in 5 elbows in 5 patients. Of the 53 elbows, 45 elbows (84.9 %) were judged to have excellent (90–100) or good (75–89) results, and 2 elbows to have poor (< 60) results (0.04%). With loosening and revision or removal of the implant defined as the end point, the likelihood of survival of the prosthesis was 92.2 and 88.3%, respectively, for as long as 10 years by Kaplan-Meier analysis.

Conclusion: The results of the current study showed a high reliability over a long period of the SKC-I when implanted with cement. However, good results in the use of non-constrained devices are limited by the amount of bone and by the need for the ligamentous stability, which can be problematic in RA cases.


S.F Schindele A Steinbach D Herren B.R. Simmen

Introduction: Silicon-implant-arthroplasty in cases of severe destruction of the radiocarpal joint was a routinely used procedure in rheumatoid arthritis to restore mobility and function. However in many cases an implant failure with a fracture rate of up to 50% with massive synovitis and a severe carpal collaps must be documented. Main problem is the extensive bone loss which makes further procedures difficult. Revision-wrist-arthrodesis with bone grafting (iliac bone, allograft or free fibula-graft) is the commonly used procedure. Therefore non-union in these cases is documented in up to 40%.

Material and Methods: Between 1999 and 2003 we performed in 2 cases of severe seropositive rheumatoid arthritis and in one case of psoriatic wrist joint destruction with extensive bone loss only a revision arthroplasty with debridement and insertion of a new Swanson silicon implant. At the time of revision mean age was 61 years and primary silicon arthroplasty was done 11 years ago. In one case a decompression of the median nerve in the carpal canal was necessary. In one case a transposition of the ECU to ECRB was performed to neutralize the ulnar drift of the remaining carpus.

Results: In all patients a good mobility in the wrist with pain free function could be achieved. All patients were satisfied with this procedure. Clinical, subjective and radiological results are presented.

Conclusion: Revision after silicon-wrist arthroplasty with severe bone loss without or only minimal carpal bone stock and a thin trumpet-like distal radius is difficult. Revision arthrodesis often ends in a non-union despite substantial bone-grafts. Debridement and revision with a new silicon implant is easy to perform and respectable function and a pain free situation might be achieved.


W.A Souter L.S Lockerbie A.C Nicol R.J. Prescott

Aim of Prospective Study To assess the long-term survival of Souter-Strathclyde replacements and determine the causes of failure.

Materials and Methods: Between 1977–97, 445 Souter-Strathclyde replacements were undertaken by the presenting author in 321 patients, ranging in age from 25–81 years (mean 59). The Larsen X-ray grading at the time of surgery was Gd III-2%, Gd IV-43%, Gd V-55%. The standard humeral component was used in 76% and the long-stemmed model in 24% of cases, the standard ulna in 91%, and the long-stemmed in 9%.

Clinical and radiological assessments were carried out before surgery and at 6 months and one year after surgery and annually thereafter until the death of the patient or the revision of one or both components, the mean follow-up being 8.9 years (S.D. 5.6).

The survival statistics are based on Kaplan-Meier survival curves and Cox regression analysis applied to 3 Groups with differing end-points: 1) Revision of one or both components of the prosthesis 2) Ditto or the development of a complication, seriously threatening the survival of the arthroplasty and 3) As in (2) or definite evidence of progressive radiological loosening.

Results Very satisfactory pain relief was achieved in 90% of cases. Mean flexion improved from 129° to 144°, pronation from 42° to 59°, and supination from 43° to 62°. Once achieved, these results were well maintained. Mean extension was slightly reduced after surgery (47° to 52°)

For Group 1: the survivorship at 5, 10, 15 & 20 years was 95, 89, 82, & 81% respectively; for Group 2: 93, 87, 76 & 69%; and for Group 3: 91, 84, 72, & 68%. In Group 1, indications for revision or removal of one or both components were persistent dislocation (5), fracture (5), aseptic loosening complicated in some cases by fracture (20) and infection (14). In Group 2 the threatening complications included instability (2), un-united fracture of the ulna (4), infection (7), and clinical loosening (2)

Conclusions This method of elbow replacement offers very successful and durable pain relief and restoration of function in the adult rheumatoid patient. Survivorship in the first decade after surgery is very acceptable. Later, due to increasing disability and reliance on crutches, resulting from multi-joint involvement, more problems are likely to arise from aseptic loosening, fracture and infection.


A Hallett L Lockerbie W.A. Souter

Aim of study To determine the radiographic changes which can be regarded as indicative of probable eventual aseptic clinical loosening.

Methods 150 TERs performed in 121 adult rheumatoid patients (95 female) with a mean age of 59 years (34–81) were followed up for a mean of 8 years. All X-rays until the final review or revision of each TER were independently reviewed by the principal author. The cement/bone interface around each component was divided into Zones and any radiolucencies were graded within each Zone. This data was then analysed to determine in which zones and at which grading of severity, radiolucencies are of importance in predicting aseptic loosening.

Results Humeral Components Radiolucencies occurred quite frequently in Zones 1& 5. Where they became active and progressive, the usual pattern was for them to extend into Zones 2 and 4 and eventually into Zone 3. The incidence of lucencies of all grades of severity in Zones 1& 5 with standard humeral components was 55 and 53% respectively, in Zones 2& 4 29 and 33%, and Zone 3 18%. The significance of the radiolucencies also varied markedly in the different Zones. In Zones 1& 5, only 22% went on eventually to complete lines > Grade 3 severity in all Zones, 14% eventually requiring revision, while in Zones 2& 4, the corresponding figures were 36% with 22% requiring revision, and in Zone 3 60%, with 22% revision.

The results with the long-stemmed implants showed a very similar trend, the important Zones being 2B, 4B, and 3.

Ulnar Components Lucencies in Zones 1& 2 and in 3& 8 occurred in 90 & 73% of elbows respectively but are probably of little significance as only 15& 10% were later associated with the development of complete lines in other zones. The Zones of significance appear to be 5& 7, and especially Zone 6. Although lucencies were found in these Zones in only 35, 43 and 28% respectively, 49, 40 and 51% of these went on to form complete lucencies in all Zones, the eventual revision rate being 51, 21, and 32%.

Conclusions Many TERs demonstrate areas of lucency on follow-up radiographs but we would argue that it is only of importance in specific locations (humeral zone 3 for the standard implant and humeral Zones 2B, 4B and 3 for the long-stemmed implant and ulnar Zones 5& 7 and especially 6) and when it is of Grade 3 severity or more. Such cases require to be monitored very regularly and carefully so as to carry out revision at the optimal time should this eventually be required.


F.J Giesen R.G.H.H Nelissen P.M Rozing J.H Arendzen Z de Jong T.P.M. Vliet Vlieland

Objective: Complex hand function problems in patients with rheumatic diseases may require the expertise of physicians and health professionals from multiple disciplines. The aim of the present study was to describe the characteristics, management strategies and outcomes of patients with rheumatic diseases who were referred to a multidisciplinary hand clinic.

Methods: All consecutive patients with complex hand function problems who were referred to a multidisciplinary hand clinic including a rheumatologist, an orthopaedic surgeon, a rehabilitation specialist, an occupational therapist and a physical therapist were included. Of all patients, sociodemographic characteristics, general disease characteristics, the most troubling impairments and limitations regarding hand function and deformities were recorded at baseline. The following measures of hand function were assessed at baseline and 3 months after treatment: the Sequential Occupational Dexterity Assessment (SODA), the Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire (MHQ), the hand/finger function subscale of the Arthritis Impact Measurement Scales (AIMS), grip strength (Jamar dynamometer) and pain (visual analogue scale, VAS, 0–10 cm).

Results: Over a period of 28 months 69 patients were included. Basic characteristics, characteristics of hand function, impairments and limitations that were most frequently mentioned as well as the advised management strategies were recorded. In 38/54 patients (70%) the advised treatment was executed and 33 of them completed the follow-up assessment.

Conclusion: The most frequently mentioned impairments and limitations of patients with rheumatic diseases and hand function problems pertain to grip ability and grip strength, pain and shaking hands. Management advices, including conservative and surgical treatment, are followed by two-thirds of the patients. On average, patients who are treated improve significantly with respect to grip strength and overall hand function as measured by a questionnaire.


W Koithan P Magosch L. Staub

Introduction In view of the legal claim for quality assurance in Germany, complete documentation and a professional evaluation of shoulder arthroplasty procedures are indispensable.

Under the auspices of German AO International (DAOI), the German Society of Orthopeadics and Orthopeadic Surgery (DGOOC), the German Society of Trauma Surgery (DGU) and the German Society of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery (DVSE), and in collaboration with the MEM Institute for Evaluative Research in Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Bern, the nationwide online Shoulder Arthroplasty Register was implemented.

Register setup The German Shoulder Arthroplasty Register consists of three online questionnaires, covering surgery for primary shoulder arthroplasty, follow-up examination, and revision surgery. Registered surgeons can access the questionnaires via Internet. For easier administration in clinics, paper copies of the questionnaires are also available. Online validation procedures check all entered data for completeness and plausibility. After passing these checks, data are sent to the central database. The centralization of the data collection is crucial for data unification and validity.

Advantages Participating surgeons benefit from descriptive real-time statistics of their patients, and constant benchmarking of their performance in comparison with the whole register is possible. With the documentation of complications, implant failures and revision surgery, quality assurance reports can be easily produced. Furthermore, X-ray images of special cases can be uploaded.

Perspective The German Shoulder Arthroplasty Register was launched in January 2006 and documentation is ongoing. First scientific results will be available in 2007.


N Nakagawa Y Saegusa S. Abe H. Ishikawa

Purpose: Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) frequently affects the finger joints. Persistent synovitis is believed to cause not only bone destruction but also various deformities of the hands. For this reason, synovectomy of the finger joints is attempted when chronic swelling of the synovium of finger joints does not respond to any conservative treatment. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of surgical synovectomy of finger joints in RA patients.

Method: Forty-six finger joints (MP 24; Steinbrocker Stage II: 8, Stage III: 16) (PIP 22; Stage I: 5, Stage II: 9, Stage III: 8) of 20 patients with rheumatoid arthritis who had synovectomy were examined at an average of 20 months follow-up (range 14–43 months). The active motion exercises of the operated fingers started as early as 2 or 3 days after surgery. The results of synovectomy in these patients were evaluated by pain, range of motion, and radiograph.

Results: Pain was relieved (Visual analogue scale MP: 6.5→1.4, PIP: 6.2→0.7), swelling was diminished in all and only a little loss of motion was observed (arc of motion MP: 59.8→53.4, PIP: 75.5→69.6) after surgery. Radiological bone changes progressed in 4 (17%) MP and 3 (14%) PIP joints. Deformities (ulnar drift or subluxation) after surgery developed in 3 (12%) MP-joints.

Conclusion: Synovectomy performed on finger joints of RA patients were evaluated. From the results of this clinical study we recommend synovectomy of finger joints in RA patients before bone changes, when chronic synovitis of finger joints does not respond to any conservative treatment.


F Angst J Goldhahn A Aeschlimann B.R. Simmen

Background The new concepts of health assessment based on the WHO’s International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health (ICF) require the increased use of patient self-rated outcome measurement. There is an extensive body of literature to support the concept that self-rating is far more valid than ‘objective’ parameters such as x-ray findings, range of motion etc. While the value of joint-specific assessment is obvious in rheumatoid arthritis (RA), the need for comprehensive outcome parameters may seem to be less important. We present an exemplary study which compares generic, comprehensive assessment with condition-specific assessment.

Methods In a cross-sectional catamnesis study, the outcomes of patients with RA and posttraumatic (PT) elbows were compared 11 years after total elbow arthroplasty using generic and specific self-rating instruments.

Results Compared to the scores recorded for the 20 PT patients, the 59 RA patients achieved mean scores of 105.6% on the Short Form 36 (SF-36) Mental Component Summary, 82.5% on the Patient Related Elbow Evaluation (PREE) function, 69.5% on the Disability of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) function, and 60.2% on the SF-36 physical functioning (a higher score means better health).

Conclusions The elbow-specific PREE revealed little functional deficits for RA compared with PT, the arm-specific DASH showed moderate, and the generic, comprehensive SF-36 demonstrated large functional deficits, whereas psychosocial health was comparable for RA and PT. Post-interventional outcomes may be similar when focusing on a specific condition or joint. Functional deficits and holistic health can only be captured by comprehensive measurement when dealing with systemic polyarticular affection like RA.


J Goldhahn H.-.K Schwyzer S Drerup B.R. Simmen

Introduction: The restoration of the anatomical centre of rotation can be achieved in total shouder arthroplasty (TSA) using newly developed modular shoulder prosthesis (Promos), anchored with rectangled, non-cemented shaft. Especially patients with complex pathological destructions due to rheumatoid arthritis (RA) should benefit from this feature. So far it was not clear, whether the concept works in their poor bone stock too. The aim of this prospective study was to assess outcome and complication rate of patients with RA and Omarthrosis (OA) after TSA with Promos prosthesis.

Materials and Methods: All patients that received a TSA either due to OA or due to RA were prospectively recorded and evaluated 6 and 12 month after surgery. Functional outcome and quality of life was charged with a standardized scores set (DASH, Constant-Murley score, SPADI, ASES and SF-36, all normalized from 0=worst to 100=best) and compared with normative data as well as with data from a retrospective control, operated with an Aequalis prosthesis. Number and types of complications were recorded and the radiological findings evaluated from an independent observer.

Results: Although RA patients (n=8) did not reach the same functional results than OA patients (n=53) operated with Promos“ prostheses (DASH 78 in OA vs. 67.4 in RA, CS 74.3 in OA vs. 67.6 in RA) the difference between both indication groups was significantly smaller than for the Aequalis prosthesis (p< 0.001). Whereas RA patients after Promos“ prosthesis revealed functional deficits ranging from −6.7 in the Constant score, −10.6 in the DASH to −11.1 in the SPADI, this difference was larger in the Aequalis group with −16.4 in the Constant score, −25.2 in the DASH and −19.6 in the SPADI. Radiological findings and complication rate did not differ significantly.

Discussion: The newly developed modular design of the Promos prosthesis seems to offer better features to restore the complex anatomy, especially in RA patients. The required cementless shaft anchorage is not associated with a higher complication risk. Methodological issues limit the comparison of the two studies and the differences have to be proven in a prospective, comparative study therefore.


G. Meyer zu Reckendorf J.L Roux Y. Allieu

Reconstruction of deficient bone stock during total elbow arthroplasty in rheumatoid arthritis represents a challenge for the surgeon. Fracture and osteolysis of the olecranon process is a very rare condition in rheumatoid arthritis. The consequence of a deficient olecranon is an instable and painful elbow. We report a case of successful olecranon reconstruction with bone graft associated to total elbow arthroplasty with a 8 years follow up and discuss surgical aspects.

This case concerns a 44 years old woman with a very severe rheumatoid arthritis. She complains of pain and instability of her right elbow. X-rays show fracture and major osteolysis of the olecranon process with only some persistent bone at the insertion of the triceps tendon. The humeral condyles were subluxated posteriorly.

We performed a total elbow replacement with a GSB3 implant and reconstruction of the olecranon with two cancellous iliac bone strut fixed by 2.7 diameter screws to the proximal ulna. The triceps tendon with remnant olecranon bone chips was secured to the bone graft by tension band wiring. Postoperatively, the elbow was immobilized for 3 weeks.

With a follow up of more than 8 years the elbow is pain free with excellent function. The active range of motion of flexion – extension is 140° / −20°. The elbow is stable and triceps function is very satisfying authorizing the use of crutches. X-rays show good bony integration of the reconstructed olecranon process and no signs of loosening of the GSB3 implant.

The literature concerning olecranon reconstruction during total elbow arthroplasty in rheumatoid patients is very poor. Kamineni and Morrey reported on one case of olecranon reconstruction with strut allograft in revision total elbow arthroplasty with an unsatisfying result. Their fixation technique was different. We prefer an autograft whenever it is possible and we recommend our fixation technique using screws and tension band wiring.


M.A. Murtaza Adeeb N.R. Naeem Raza M.T. Michael Thomas

Background: To date there has been only one published series of elbow arthroplasty in patients with Juvenile Idiopathic arthritis. These patients pose particular problems because of the size and variable shape of the humerus and ulna together with the soft tissue contractures and bony erosion which can sometimes be severe. We have reviewed the results of elbow arthroplasty using the unlinked Kudo 5 and the linked Coonrad-Morrey implants which in our practice have different indications dependent upon bone stock and stability.

Methods: 19 total elbow replacements in 13 patients with juvenile idiopathic arthritis were performed by 1 specialist elbow surgeon, the senior author. 13 of these are Kudo 5 and 6 are Coonrad-Morrey implants. The mean age at operation was 39 years.

6 of the elbow replacements had undergone previous surgery, 4 had an interposition arthroplasty and 2 a synovectomy and radial head excision.

No patients were lost to follow up. All were evaluated at a mean follow up of 49 months [6–84 months] using the Mayo Clinic Performance Index. Postoperative radiographs were also reviewed for loosening using standard anteroposterior and lateral films.

Results: Preoperatively 7 had moderate pain and 12 had severe pain. Postoperatively the pain was rated as none by 13 and mild by 6. The average Mayo Elbow Score improved from 26 preoperatively to 81 postoperatively. The mean arc of flexion/extension improved from 85 to 108 degrees.12 elbow replacements had intra and postoperative complications. 2 elbows have been revised, 1 for malalignment resulting in instability and 1 for aseptic loosening of the ulna component. 1 customised extra small implant has radiographic loosening of both components with minimal pain and a further aseptic loose implant awaits revision at 7 years.

Conclusions: The medium-term results of Total Elbow Replacements in patients with Juvenile Chronic Arthritis are acceptable and comparable to the only other published series which also records a high complication rate similar to that reported by ourselves.


M Adeeb I Mersich L Neumann M. Thomas

Background: Total elbow prostheses are broadly classified into linked and the unlinked categories. We have looked at long-term results of unlinked Kudo 5 total elbow replacement used in the treatment of patients with rheumatoid arthritis in 2 hospitals.

Methods: 87 Kudo 5 Total elbow replacements in 70 patients with adult rheumatoid arthritis were performed at Wexham Park Hospital, Slough and City Hospital, Nottingham by 2 specialist elbow surgeons, the senior authors.

16 patients had died and 8 patients were lost to follow up. 62 elbow replacements in 46 patients were evaluated at a mean follow up of 79 months [29–137 months] using the Mayo Clinic Performance Index. Postoperative radiographs were also reviewed for loosening using standard anteroposterior and lateral films.

Results: Preoperatively 6 had moderate pain and 56 had severe pain. Postoperatively the pain was rated as none or mild by 58 and moderate by 4. The average Mayo Elbow Score improved from 37 preoperatively to 86 postoperatively. The mean arc of flexion/extension improved from 60 to 99 degrees. There were 14 complications including ulnar neuropraxia, fracture, dislocation, triceps rupture and loosening. 4 cases were revised, 2 for aseptic and 2 for septic loosening. Postoperative radiographs showed 5 cases with loosening around the ulna component.

Conclusions: The long-term results using the Kudo 5 elbow prosthesis in patients with rheumatoid arthritis are acceptable and comparable to other series reported of this implant. To date this is the largest series reported with the longest follow up using this implant.


K.K. Katsuaki Kanbe

Purpose: In order to investigate if arthroscopic synovectomy is effective for non-responder by infliximab, anti-TNF-α antibody, for rheumatoid arthritis (RA), we assessed 7 patients including 10 arthroscopic synovectomy including in knee joint, in shoulder joint and in ankle joints respectively.

Materials and Methods: We performed arthroscopic synovectomy in 10 joints of 7 patients to compare CRP and DAS28 before and after surgery at 6 and 50 weeks. Those patients include 1 male and 6 female from 49 to 68 years old with average of 62 years old. 3 patients was underwent arthroscopic synovectomy after 4 times of infliximab, 2 patients were after 5 times and 2 patient was 6 times. All patients were initially responder to infliximab and MTX but gradually the effect decreased, the average of CRP was 3.45±0.4 (2.7–5.6) mg/dl at the surgery. The indication of operation was that after treatment infliximab CRP was more than 2.5 mg/dl and the numbers of arthritis joints were limited to within five joints of relatively large joints such as knee, shoulder including ankles and wrists. After arthroscopic synovectomy we continued infliximab treatment with MTX in routine manner.

Results: We detected synovium proliferation with vascular increase in patella femoral (PF) joint and around the meniscus and femoral and tibial side of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) in the knee joints. We also found synovial proliferation in rotator interval (RI) in the glenohumeral joint and fatty changing in subacromial bursa (SAB) in shoulder. In ankle joint we found synovial proliferation with white meniscoid between tibiofibular joint to develop impingement. Serum CRP was improved from 3.45±0.4 to 1.12±0.2 at 6 weeks, 1.22±0.4 at 50 weeks after arthroscopic synovectomy. There is no severe side effects by arthroscopic synovectomy during infliximab treatment, however 1 patient had slight rash that was improved. DAS28 was improved from 5.58±0.23, to 3.87±0.47 at 6 weeks, improved to 2.58±1.49 at 50 weeks after arthroscopic synovectomy.

Conclusion: It is possible that arthroscopic synovectomy can be one of the effective method to continue infliximab treatment when its efficacy decreased or in non-respond of infliximab for RA patients.


H.U.G. Hoffmeyer

Introduction Shoulder arthroplasty is a difficult procedure which, for success, is dependant on many factors as correct retroversion of the humeral implant.

An experimental set up was therefore devised, using a model to determine the actual accuracy of the retroversion obtained under ideal in vitro conditions in two different situations, one in which the proximal humerus was intact such as that encountered in osteoarthritis or P.A.R. and the other where most usual landmarks were missing such as that seen in the four-part fracture situation.

Materials and methods 106 prostheses were inserted into 106 arms (plastic bone). 54 bones were cut at the level of the surgical collar as in complex fractures and 54 were untouched as in omarthrosis. The first series was done without any guide (52 implants). Every operator has to put 3 prostheses with 30 degree retroversion according to his particular chosen method of mark, either the bicondylar line, or according to the position of the forearm. The second one was done with a jig (Neer 3) indicating 25 degrees of retroversion (54 implants).

The degree of retroversion of prostheses put is measured according to the angle between the axis passing by the previous face of the condyles of the ulna and the axis passing by the mark taken on the prosthesis (perpendicularly in the axis of the humerus).

The humeral axis, the condylar axis, the prosthesis plane and the cutting plane were determined. 3 barycentres of humeral sections determined the humeral axis. The condylar axis is determined from the 2 barycentres of the digitalized points on the anterior articular condylar surfaces. These 2 axes determine the frontal plane on which a reference mark R(x, y, z) is attached with Z lined up with the humeral shaft and X lined up on the condyles.

Discussion and results All these results show that with or without guide, the prosthesis is not inserted in the right way. Only one third of the P.T.E. ( 33 on 106) were put with a correct angle of retroversion, or between 20 and 40 °, with a maximum of 67,7 ° and a minimum of 4,4 ° (standard deviation 12, 8 !). Shoulder prosthesis, a difficult technique, may need computer help for the positioning especially for the retroversion angle.


Dang Lei Douglas Wardlaw David W.L. Hukins

Introduction This abstract describes the development of an effective procedure for removing as much nucleus as possible from an intervertebral disc with minimal disruption to the annulus. The procedure was developed on cadaveric sheep discs which are well established as a model for human discs in studies of this kind. The purpose of the study was to develop a method for removing the nucleus as part of a laboratory study of nucleus replacement; however, it is also intended to guide the development of procedures for the removal of residual nucleus when indicated in surgical procedures that involve replacing the nucleus with synthetic materials.

Methods All procedures were performed via a 3 mm trocar. Four procedures were compared: (I) unilateral approach using rongeurs alone, (II) unilateral approach using rongeurs followed by chymopapain, (III) bilateral approach using rongeurs alone and (IV) bilateral approach using rongeurs followed by chymopapain. Chymopapain was administered as a solution (30 units in 0.1 cm3 de-ionised water) to a disc at 37°C. For each procedure (I–IV) 14 discs were used.

Results The percentages of nucleus removed were: (I) 34 ± 2%, (II) 41 ± 2%, (III) 52 ± 3% and (IV) 75 ± 8%; ANOVA showed a significant differences between the four sets of results (P < 0.05).

Conclusions Significantly more nucleus is removed using a bilateral than a unilateral approach; significantly more nucleus is removed if chymopapain is used in addition to rongeurs. A brush is useful in removing strands of nucleus loosened by chymopapain. For the purpose of these experiments a bottle brush with nylon bristles was trimmed to an overall diameter of about 10 mm, so that it could be inserted into the nuclear cavity via the trocar. Design of a surgical instrument for this purpose would be guided by a preliminary risk analysis.


M.J.H. McCarthy M.P. Grevit

Introduction: The NDI is a simple 10-item questionnaire used to assess patients with neck pain. The original validation was performed on 52 patients with neck pain and the test-retest on 17 whiplash patients with a 2-day interval. The SF36 measures functional ability, wellbeing and the overall health of patients. It is used in health economics to assess the health utility, gain and economic impact of medical interventions.

Objectives: (1) Independently validate the NDI in patients with neck pain. (2) Draw comparison of the NDI and SF36.

Subjects: 100 patients with neck pain attending the spinal clinic completed self-assessment questionnaires. A second questionnaire was completed in 30 patients after a period of 1–2 weeks.

Statistics: The internal consistency of the NDI and SF36 was calculated using Cronbach alpha. The test-retest reliability and the concurrent validity between the two questionnaire scores were assessed using Pearson correlation. Individual scores for each of the ten items of the NDI were correlated to the total disability score categories.

Results: Both questionnaires showed robust internal consistency – alpha for NDI = 0.85 (95% CI = 0.8–0.89) and SF36 = 0.84 (95% CI = 0.79–0.88). The NDI had significant correlation to all eight domains of the SF36 (p< 0.001). The individual scores for each of the ten items had significant correlation with the total disability score (p< 0.001). The test-retest reliability of the NDI was acceptable.

Conclusions: We have shown irrefutably that the NDI has good reliability and validity and that it stands up well to the SF36.


Jitendra Mangwani Claire Giles Mark Mullins M.A Colin Natali

Study design: Prospective cohort study.

Objective: To investigate association between recovery from low back pain (LBP) and body mass index (BMI) in patients with LBP undergoing physiotherapy.

Introduction: The relationship between obesity and LBP has long been debated. There are no published studies examining the influence of BMI on recovery from LBP.

Methods: One hundred and forty patients with chronic LBP and no neurological deficit underwent a back-specific physiotherapy programme. BMI and recovery parameters such as pain intensity (visual analogue scale scores), and self-experienced impairment and disability scores were measured. The range of motion of the lumber spine was also recorded. These variables were compared pre and post treatment. Statistical analysis was performed using paired t tests, Spearman’s rank correlation coefficients and ANCOVA.

Results: Mean age was 38 years (range 18–67) with 62% males and 38% females. The treatment resulted in significant improvements in all the recovery parameters (P < 0.005, paired t test). No significant association was detected between the BMI of subjects and % changes in pain intensity, self-experienced impairment and disability, and range of motion of the lumbar spine. A comparative analysis of the after treatment recovery parameter scores in normal (BMI ≤24.9), overweight (BMI 25–29.9) and obese (BMI ≥ 30) revealed no significant differences in the mean pain intensity and mean self-experienced impairment and disability scores.

Conclusion: Although a BMI within normal range is desirable for prevention of many health conditions including LBP, it does not influence the overall recovery from low back pain in patients undergoing physiotherapy treatment.


R. Kamath P. Chandran S. Malek A.M.M.A Mohsen

Introduction and Aims Back pain patients usually demand more time in clinic. A significant proportion of this time is spent in performing clinical examination. It has been recognised that detailed history of symptoms is the backbone in reaching the diagnosis and deciding the management plan for patients with lower back pain and/or radiculopathy. The aim of the study was to look at 1) Contributions from History and Examination. 2) Does Clinical Examination add any further information not identified from history?

Method A prospective, blinded study was carried out to determine the usefulness of history and clinical examination, individually to reach the diagnosis and plan the management. 75 consecutive lower back pain and/or radiculopathy patients were included in the study. Two orthopaedic registrars saw all the patients. One took detailed history and the other registrar performed clinical examination. Both registrars based on their information arrived at a provisional diagnosis. A consultant also took history and examined these patients. MRI scan was done as per clinical indication.

Results The data was analysed using standard statistics software. In all patients history suggested the possible diagnosis. Clinical examination did not add any further information to alter the course of management, which was planned for the patient. Clinical examination did not show any further information that was not identified in the MRI scan.

Conclusion Clinical examination does not add to the body of information available from history. Clinical examination does not add any further information not available on the scan. Clinical examination should be performed for patients considered for surgery to document the findings; here both subjective and objective assessment should be performed. Examination is not a useful screening tool.


P Lakshmanan S Ahuja PR Davies J Howes

Introduction Local steroid injection is commonly performed as a treatment for facet joint arthritis in the lumbosacral spine. The injection is performed under image guidance for which some surgeons utilise antero-posterior (A-P) imaging only while others prefer oblique imaging.

Purpose The aim of this study is to find out the difference in the functional outcome in patients who received the facet joint steroid injection by A-P imaging and those who had the injection by oblique imaging.

Material and Methods A prospective randomised controlled trial was performed by randomly allocating the 20 patients who were diagnosed to have facet joint arthritis clinically and by magnetic reasonance image scans, and who were then placed in the list for facet joint injections. Ten patients in Group I received the facet joint injections with A-P imaging while 10 patients in Group II received the facet joint injections with oblique imaging using image intensifier. All the patients received 40mg of methylprednisolone acetate with 1mL of 1% lignocaine and 1mL of 0.5% bupivacaine to each joint. The duration of the entire procedure was noted. Short Form-36 (SF-36) questionnaire was used before the procedure and at six weeks after the procedure to assess the functional outcome.

Results All the patients were followed up for a period of six weeks. The mean age was 51.3 yrs in Group I and 48.3 yrs in Group II. The male to female ratio was 3:7 in Group I and 2:5 in Group II. One patient in Group I had the facet injections at only one level while it was in two patients in Group II (L4/5 or L5/S1). Further one patient in Group I and one in Group two had unilateral facet joint injections at two levels. All the other patients had bilateral facet joint injections at two levels (L4/5 and L5/S1). One patient was excluded from the study as the A-P image obtained was very poor and that an oblique image had to be performed to visualise the facet joint because of obesity. The mean duration of the procedure was 18.33 min (10–25 min) in Group I and 22 min (10–35 min) in Group II (p=0.14, 95%CI −8.5 to +1.4). The patient function score improved from a mean of 20.0% to 32.5% after the injection in Group I, and from 30.0% to 41.0% in Group II. The pain score improved from a mean of 33.3% to 47.2% in Group I, and from 35.6% to 44.4% in Group II. The difference in physical function score (p=0.85, 95% C.I. −15.29 to +18.29), and pain score(p=0.71, 95% C.I. −24.21 to +34.22) between the two groups were not statistically significant.

Conclusions There is no difference in the functional outcome of patients treated by facet joint injections using A-P or oblique imaging. There is no significant difference in the duration of the procedure as well between the two techniques. However, with experience we found that it may be difficult to visualise the facet joint clearly by A-P imaging alone in obese individuals.


T. Coltman P. Chapman-Sheath A. Riddell E. McNally J. Wilson-MacDonald

Study design: A prospective comparison of MRI findings with surgical findings in patients presenting to our spinal triage service with a prospective diagnosis of a lumbar disc herniation.

Objective: To investigate consistency between radiologists interpretation of MRI scans, and comparison between MRI and surgical findings, in an attempt to identify those patients suitable for percutaneous treatment.

Background: MRI has assumed a preeminent position in the diagnosis of lumbar disc prolapse.

Methods: 87 consecutive patients presenting with signs and symptoms suggestive of a lumbar disc prolapse that underwent an MRI and based on that a discectomy.

Results: Reliability tests show only fair agreement (k=0.36) between the radiologists and at best only moderate agreement (k=0.41) between the radiologists and surgical findings.

Conclusions: MRI is an excellent tool for diagnosis of a disc prolapse but does not appear to help in classifying discs suitable for percutaneous treatment.


M.J.H. McCarthy A.T. Brodie D. Annesley-Williams C.E.W. Aylott A. Jones M.P. Grevitt

Introduction: (1) Determine whether initial MRI findings correlate with clinical outcome.(2) Study the reproducibility of MRI measurements of large disc prolapses.(3) Estimate the ability to predict CES based on MRI alone.(4) Does CES only occur in degenerate discs?

Method: 31 patients with CES were identified and invited to attend clinic. 19 patients who underwent discectomy were identified. Digital photographs of all 50 MRIs were obtained. Observers: 1 Radiologist, 2 Spinal Surgeons and 1 Trainee did not know the number of patients in each group. Observers estimated the percentage spinal canal compromise on each view (0–100%), indicated whether they thought the scan findings could produce CES and commented on disc degeneration. Measurements were repeated after 2 weeks.

Results: 26 patients attended clinic – mean follow up 51 months (range 25–97). 12 of the 26 patients with CES had, on average, > 75% canal compromise. No significant correlations were found between MRI canal compromise and clinical outcome. Kappa values for intra-observer reproducibility of measurements ranged from 0.4–0.85 and inter-observer 0.63–5. Based on MRI, the correct identification of CES has sensitivity 68%, specificity 78%, positive predictive value 84% and negative predictive value 58%. Over 80% of the CES causing discs were degenerate.

Discussion: Canal compromise does not appear to predict clinical outcome. MRI measurement reproducibility has substantial agreement. CES is a clinical diagnosis supported by an MRI scan. In less clear cases the presence of a large disc on an MRI scan supports a diagnosis of CES (PPV 84%). CES occurs in degenerate discs.


J H H Chan G Heilpern G Marsh

Objective A prospective longitudinal study with a mean 22 month follow up (range 6–36 months) to assess the outcome of patients with chronic discogenic lumbar back pain who underwent intradiscal electrothermal therapy (IDET).

Method Patients with a discogenic origin of their back pain confirmed by diagnostic imaging and discography and who underwent IDET were included in the study. Discographic reproduction of symptoms with subsequent abolition with local anaesthetic led to inclusion in the study regardless of discogram volume. Outcome was assessed using VAS pain scores, Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) scores, employment status, subjective outcome and pain diagrams.

Results 68 patients were treated with IDET. 51 patients were successfully followed up for a minimum of one year, of whom 31 had at least 2 year follow up. These patients were divided into two groups. Group 1 consisted of 29 patients aged less than 40 with single level disease, no facet joint arthritis, a low volume positive discogram and an organic pain diagram. Their mean VAS scores decreased from 7.52 to 3.84 (p< 0.001). 70% reported a good or excellent outcome with only 30% fair or poor. Group 2 included the remaining 22 patients. Their mean VAS decreased from 7.41 to 6.13 and only 32% reported a good or excellent outcome with 68% fair or poor.

Conclusion We conclude that with very strict selection criteria, IDET can have a successful outcome.


J. Mangwani C. Natali C. Giles R. Sarvanan R. Francis

Study Design: Prospective study with a 2-year follow-up.

Background: Intradiscal electrothermal therapy (IDET) was developed as an intermediate stage between conservative measures (analgesia, physiotherapy and injections) and radical surgery (fusion and disc replacement) for the treatment of internal disc disruption (IDD). Recent reports have questioned the efficacy and safety of this treatment.

Objective: To assess the long-term outcome of patients with discogenic low back pain (≥ 6 months duration) treated with IDET who had previously failed to improve with nonoperative treatment

Methods: Forty patients with IDD determined by pre-operative provocative discography and MRI were treated with IDET. VAS pain scores, SF-36 scores, analgesic usage and sitting tolerance (mins) were collected pre-treatment and at 12 and 24 months. Subsequent treatments were recorded. The differences in the outcome scores were tested by Wilcoxon signed rank tests.

Results: Average age was 46 years (range 25–62 years) with 44% males and 56% females. No significant improvement was seen in pain intensity as measured by VAS and bodily pain SF-36 scores pre treatment and at 12 and 24 months post IDET. There were no significant differences in the remaining SF-36 subscales. Only 11% used less pain medication. Sitting tolerance improved between pre and 1-year post IDET, the difference was not significant. Eight (20%) patients underwent further surgery; 5 disc replacement and 3 fusions at 1-year post treatment.

Conclusion: The patients with IDD did not show any improvement at 1-year or 2-year post IDET. A significant proportion of patients required further surgery. We believe that the efficacy of IDET is doubtful.


S Apsingi PL Sanderson

Introduction: Sciatica is the classical indication for decompression of the lumbar nerve roots. However there is a small group of patients who have atypical proximal pain i.e. pain in the groin, buttock and thigh pain without radiation below the knee, and have nerve root compression on the MRI scans. We investigated these patients with nerve root injection (NRI).

Methodology: We retrospectively studied 125-diagnostic NRIs, of these there were 12 patients (7 female & 5 male) with pain in the groin(5), thigh (4), buttock(6) & lower back(9) but no radiating pain below the knee. The MRI scans were reported independently as nerve root compression (11 L5 & 1 S1) by the radiologist. All these 12 patients were offered nerve root injection. The nerve root injection was carried out as described by Herron, under the guidance of image intensifier with bupivacaine and methylprednisolone.

Results: Of these 5 (42%) of them had temporary relief of the symptoms with nerve root injection; all of them underwent flavectomy & facetectomy of the affected nerve root. They were followed for an average duration of 39 months. Three patients were delighted with the result, 1 patient had a pain free period for 3 years then the symptoms recurred and the last patient did not benefit with the surgery.

Conclusion: We conclude that nerve root injection can be an important diagnostic tool in making a surgical decision regarding patients with such atypical symptoms.


Manal Siddiqui Malcolm Nicol Efthimios Karadimas Kay Mutch Frank Smith Malcolm Pope Douglas Wardlaw

Introduction Symptoms of neurogenic intermittent claudication in spinal stenosis are explained by the narrowing of the spinal canal in the extended (upright) position and widening in the sitting (flexed) position. The XStop inter-spinous process distraction device is a new product that is designed to hold the affected segments in a flexed posture. This prospective study looks at the changes in the lumbar spine in a variety of postures from pre- to post insertion.

Methods Using a positional magnetic resonance imaging (pMRI) scanner, patients were scanned before and six months after the insertion of the device. Images were taken in sitting flexed and extended, and standing positions. The change in the total range of movement of the lumbar spine and in the individual operated segments was measured along with changes in the surface areas of the exit foramen, the dural sac, and the disc height.

Results 12 patients with 17 levels distracted have been scanned and measured. The cross sectional area of the dural sac at the level of the stenosis has increased from a mean of 77.8 mm2 to 93.4 mm2 in the standing position (p=0.006) and from 84.56mm2 to 107.35mm2 on extension (p=0.008). There were no statistically significant changes in the range of movement of the whole lumbar spine, or at levels adjacent to the device.

Discussion This study demonstrates that the X Stop device increases the cross sectional surface area of the spinal canal at the stenosed level, without causing extensive changes in the posture of the lumbar spine.


E. Karadimas M Siddiqui M. Nicol W. Bashir T. Muthukumar M. Pope F. Smith D Wardlaw

Introduction The Dynesys device uses transpedicular screws linked by a cord and spacers. It is claimed that the advantage is that it allows some motion, in all directions, in the operative levels. In vitro laboratory biomechanical studies show that the movement permitted is similar to rigid fusions.

This study measures the changes in the lumbar spine in different postures, pre- and after insertion of the device.

Material-method In our study 20 patients with dominant low back pain, with or without leg pain, were treated with Dynesys system. Stress discography was made to evaluate the symptomatic level

All had a positional MRI preoperatively and nine months post-operatively in flexion-extension-lateral bending.

The patients were divided in to two groups:

Group(A) with 8 patients in which Dynesys was used with fusion (disc-height< 40 %)

Group(B) with 12 patients was the Dynesys-only group (disc-height=40–90%).

Results The operated levels were 42, 10 of those were fused levels. The results showed that there was a statistically significant difference in flexion-extension range of movement of the whole lumbar spine (mean= −13.45)(p< 0.005), but it wasn’t significant in the level above (mean=0.056)(p=0.972) and at a single instrumented segment was (mean=−4.06°)(p< 0.05)

The changes in the anterior disc height was (mean= −1.18)(p< 0.05) and to the posterior (mean=0.37)(p=0.134). In bending were (mean=−0.87°)(p=0.18) for left and (mean=−0.24°)(p=0.75) for the right

Discussion This study shows that in the Dynesys stabilizing system allows small range of movement at the instrumented levels, with no significant increased mobility in the adjacent levels. Also the device acted to compress the anterior annulus


JS Butler MJ Shelly M Timlin JM O’Byrne

Introduction: Haematogenous pyogenic spinal infection encompasses spondylodiskitis, septic discitis, vertebral osteomyelitis and epidural abscess. Management of pyogenic spinal infection can involve conservative methods and surgical intervention. We carried out a retrospective review of 48 cases of pyogenic vertebral osteomyelitis presenting over a twelve-year period to the National Spinal Injuries Unit of the Republic Of Ireland. Our objective was to analyze the presentation, aetiology, management and outcome of 48 cases of non-tuberculous pyogenic spinal infection.

Methods: Both the Hospital Inpatient Enquiry (HIPE) System and the National Spinal Injuries Unit Database were used to identify our study cohort. The medical records, blood results, radiologic imaging and bacteriology results of all patients identified were reviewed.

Results: The average age of presentation was 59 years with an almost even distribution between males and females. Most patients took between three and six weeks to present to hospital. Diagnosis was confirmed by serological testing of inflammatory markers and radiological imaging. The most frequently isolated pathogen was Staph. aureus (75% of cases). 94% of cases were managed by conservative measures alone, including antibiotic therapy and spinal bracing. However, in 6% of cases surgical intervention was required due to neurological compromise or mechanical instability.

Conclusions: With this large cohort of non-tuberculous, pyogenic spinal infections from the NSIU, we conclude that Staph. aureus is the predominent pathogen. In the vast majority, conservative management with antibiotic therapy and spinal bracing is very successful. However in 6% of cases surgical intervention is warranted and referral to a specialist centre is appropriate.


H* Sharma SA Mehdi E MacDuff M Jane A Reece R Reid

Between 1944 to 2003, eighty nine cases were registered with a diagnosis of Paget’s sarcoma in the Scottish Bone and Soft Tissue Tumour Registry. We found thirteen cases of sarcomatous degeneration of the spine (0.26% of the total bone tumour registry case) which were analysed in this study elaborating clinical, radiological and histopathological features. The mean age was 66.9 years (range 56 to 79 years). There were ten males and three females. There were seven cases involving sacral spine (63.6%), three cases involving lumbar vertebrae and two affecting dorsal spine. One case had diffuse dorso-lumbar involvement from D11 to L3 vertebrae. The mode of presentation was increasing low back pain (in all 13), unilateral sciatica (6, left sided-5, right sided-1), bilateral sciatica (2), lower limb weakness (8) and autonomic dysfunction (4, presented as chronic cauda equina syndrome). The majority of the cases (69.23%) were osteosarcomas. Out of these osteosarcomas, two showed giant cell rich matrix and one revealed predominant telengiectatic areas. Rest of the histological types was shared by chondrosarcoma, fibrosarcoma and malignant fibrous histiocytoma. Decompression laminectomy was performed in three cases. Eight patients had received radiotherapy. The mean survival was 3.93 months (range, 1 week to 7 months), nearly half to the whole Scottish Paget’s sarcoma series with a mean survival of 7.5 months. We found a constellation of symptomatology due to radiculo-medullary compression with a fatal evolution, predominantly lumbosacral involvement, predominantly osteosarcomatous histopathology with a poorest prognosis of all Paget’s sarcoma. Although, decompression laminectomy and adjuvant radiotherapy provided reasonable pain relief and palliation; however, there was no significant influence on the overall prognosis of the patients with Paget’s sarcoma of spine in the last six decades.


MJ Shelly M Timlin M Walsh A Poynton JM O’Byrne

Aims: Rugby is a popular sport in Ireland, with over 100,000 players registered with the Irish Rugby Football Union (IRFU) at all levels. We report a 10 year series of spinal injuries presenting to the National Spinal Injuries Unit (NSIU) at the Mater Misericordiae University Hospital.

Methods: A large series of spinal injuries in rugby players was isolated utilizing the NSIU database, HIPE and data from the IRFU. An extensive chart review and telephone interview was performed in all cases to determine age, mechanism of injury, possible aetiological factors, anatomic location of injury, American Spinal Injuries Association (ASIA) scores, current level of activity and response to rehabilitation.

Results: From 1994 to 2004, 22 rugby players with spinal injuries necessitated admission to the NSIU. Twelve patients (54%) presented with neurology. The average age at time of injury was 21.1 years (range 14 – 44 years) and all patients were male. The average length of hospital stay was 10.1 days (range 1 – 45 days). Twenty patients had cervical spine injuries. The most common mechanism of injury was hyperflexion of the cervical spine, with C5/C6 most commonly injured. Fifteen injuries occurred at adult level, the remainder at schoolboy level. Seventeen (77%) players were injured whilst playing First Team rugby. Eleven (50%) players were injured in the Backs, the remainder in the Forwards. 68% of injuries occurred in the tackle situation and 32% in the scrums, rucks and mauls. Winger, Full Back and Hooker were the playing positions at greatest risk.

Nine (41%) patients underwent surgery and 11 (50%) required rehabilitation in the National Rehabilitation Centre, Dun Laoghaire, with an average length of inpatient stay of 9.22 months (range 5 – 14 months). Eight (36%) patients felt that their injury was preventable. Of those patients without neurology, 60% have returned to playing rugby.

Conclusion: Rugby as a sporting pastime is not without risk. During the ten year period under review, 8 players suffered permanent disability as a direct result of participation in competitive rugby. Serious spinal injuries continue to occur and recent rule changes have had little effect in reducing their incidence.


P Lakshmanan A Jones K Lyons J Howes

Background: Type II odontoid fractures are the commonest upper cervical spine injury in the elderly, following minor falls. Structural heterogeneity within the axis with deficiency of bone mass in the base of the odontoid process has been attributed for these fractures.

Aims: To analyse whether osteoporosis at the dens-body junction is directly related to the occurrence of odontoid fractures in the elderly.

Material and Methods: We studied the reformatted CT scan images of 36 patients over the age of 70 years who had cervical spine injuries following minor trauma. In all these patients the severity of osteoporosis at the dens-body junction, and in the peg and body of axis were evaluated. The osteoporosis was graded into none, mild, moderate and severe. Statistical analysis was performed using Pearson’s Chi-square test to find the significance of osteoporosis at the dens-body junction in producing Type II odontoid fractures in the elderly.

Results: Type II odontoid fractures was seen in 21 patients. Eleven of the 21 patients with Type II fractures and eight of the 15 patients with no Type II odontoid fractures had significant osteoporosis at the dens-body junction. Five patients with Type II fracture and eight patients with no Type II fractures had significant osteoporosis at the dens and body of axis. Statistical analysis showed that the osteoporosis at the dens-body junction was not significant in patients with Type II odontoid fracture compared to those with no Type II odontoid fracture (χ2 = 1.1; df = 3, p = 0.78).

Conclusions: Eventhough osteoporosis is one of the factors that increase the incidence of Type II fractures of the odontoid process in the elderly, it is not a direct aetiological factor.


M.J.H. McCarthy C.E.W. Aylott M.P. Grevit M.C. Bishop

Introduction: To determine the factors which influence outcome after surgery for cauda equina syndrome.

Method: 56 patients with evidence of sphincteric disturbance who underwent urgent surgery between 1994 and 2002 were identified and invited to follow up. Outcomes consisted of history and examination, and several validated questionnaires.

Results: 42 patients attended with a mean follow up of 60 months (range 25–114). Mean age at onset was 41 years (range 24–67) with 23 males and 19 females. 26 patients were operated on within 48 hours of onset. Urinary disturbance at presentation did not affect the outcomes. Bowel disturbance at presentation was associated with sexual problems (< 0.005) and abnormal rectal tone (p< 0.05) at follow up. There was a weak association between delay to operation and bowel disturbance (p< 0.05) at follow up. Eight patients had faecal soiling and faecal incontinence at follow up and this was associated with sudden onset of symptoms, initial abnormal rectal tone and time to operation (p< 0.05). The 12 patients who failed their postoperative trial without catheter had worse outcomes. The SF36 scores at follow up were reduced compared to age matched norms in the population. The mean ODI was 29, LBOS 42 and VAS 4.5.

Discussion: In our series the duration of symptoms and speed of onset prior to surgery appears to influence bowel but not bladder outcome two years after surgery. Based on the SF36, LBOS and ODI scores, patients who have had CES do not return to a normal status.


R Kotnis A Jariwala N Henderson

Method: We reviewed the hospital notes of 45 patients who underwent a lumbar discectomy over a 30month period. The care pathway was divided into three components: Pre-Hospital Wait (time from GP referral to first outpatient appointment), Hospital Wait (first out-patient appointment to being listed for surgery) and the Waiting List period.

The patients were divided into three groups: those following a standard pathway (group I), patients referred with an MRI scan (group II) and emergency admissions to hospital (group III).

Results: The groups I, II and III comprised of 18, 12 and 7 patients respectively. The mean Pre-Hospital Wait in weeks was 16 (group I) and 14 (group II). The Hospital Wait was 12 (group I), 3 (group II) and 1 (group III). The Waiting List period was 26 (group I), 18 (group II) and 1 (group III). The difference in The Hospital Wait between groups I and II reached significance.

Discussion: The Waiting List Period is often blamed as the causa principale for a delay in treatment. This review shows that a considerable time is spent in the Hospital Wait period and draws attention to a recognised delay in the care pathway, which requires a multidisciplinary approach to reduce its effect.


J A Corner R Marshall

Bilateral decompression of spinal stenosis may induce instability which compromises outcome. In an attempt to overcome this problem, bilateral decompression can be carried out through a unilateral approach. The ipsilateral side is decompressed by hemi-laminectomy with undercutting partial facetectomy and the contra-lateral side is treated by careful excavation beneath the spinous processes and laminae with preservation of the laminae, posterior ligament complexes and paraspinal muscles. This is achieved with the aid of an operating microscope or loupe and headlight. Previous reports contain little information about outcome and complications.

We reviewed 30 patients with bilateral spinal stenosis, but without significant spondylolisthesis who were decompressed bilaterally from a unilateral approach by a single surgeon during a calendar year. They represented a third of our annual operations for spinal stenosis. Thirty patients had 45 levels decompressed. Female to male ratio was 2:1 and average age was 66 years. The average duration of preoperative symptoms was 1.6 years. The mean follow up period was 30 weeks (12 weeks to one year).

Assessment was carried out using the Oswestry Disability Index, pre- and post-operative visual analogue pain scores for leg pain and back pain, walking distance and MacNab criteria of patient outcome.

Results: improvement in Oswestry Disability Index, pain scores for sciatica and back pain and improved walking distance. All but one case had good or excellent outcome.

Complications: one dural tear and two cases with temporary dermatomal sensory change.

Whilst the technique is safe, and effective, a longer randomised controlled study is needed to demonstrate any real advantage over traditional approaches.


S Tafazal P Sell

Introduction: Lumbar spinal stenosis commonly affects elderly patients with multiple co-morbidities. They are at increased risk of complications following surgical interventions. Non-operative strategies for treating them are desirable and previous studies have shown some benefit of subcutaneous salmon calcitonin for the treatment of spinal stenosis.

Objectives: To assess the effectiveness of nasal salmon calcitonin for the treatment of lumbar spinal stenosis in a cohort of patients.

Study design: Prospective cohort study

Methods: 34 patients with MRI proven lumbar spinal stenosis were enrolled into the trial. They received salmon calcitonin in the form of a nasal spray for 6 weeks. All the patients had multiple co-morbidities making them high risk for any surgical intervention. They were followed up at 6 weeks and at 12 weeks. The main outcome measures were oswestry disability index (ODI), low back outcome score (LBOS) and visual analogue scale (VAS). The patient’s were also subjectively asked to rate the treatment excellent, good, fair or poor.

Results: The mean age was 73.5 years (range 51–92 years). The mean duration of symptoms was 32.6 months (range 3–120 months) The mean ODI pre-treatment was 50 and after 6 weeks of treatment decreased to 47 (p=0.14). The mean LBOS was 18 pre-treatment and increased to 21 (p=0.02) after 6 weeks of treatment. The mean VAS for leg pain was 76mm pre-treatment and decreased to 64mm (p=0.001) after treatment and the mean VAS for back pain only decreased from 64mm to 61mm (p=0.5). 11 patients (32%) had a minimum 20mm change in VAS scores after treatment and 7 patients (21%) improved their ODI score by a minimum of 10 points. All results remained stable at 12 weeks follow-up, suggesting a longer effect than the duration of treatment. With regards to patient’s subjective outcome 9 patients (27%) rated the treatment as fair, 3 rated it as good (9%) and 17 reported no change (50%).

Conclusion: Our results suggest the benefits of nasal salmon calcitonin treatment are marginal, with a minimal improvement in symptoms of patients with lumbar spinal stenosis.


Mr. A.S. Raman Mr. A. Rai Dr. T. Marshall Mr. R.J. Crawford

There are numerous surgical techniques described for cervical decompression for multilevel cervical stenosis. Cervical skip laminectomy is a new technique described by Japanese surgeons in 2000. The advantage of this procedure over the other conventional techniques is it addresses multilevel problem in a least traumatic way without need for instrumentation. It is also described to have lesser incidence of post operative axial symptoms, range of motion and loss of cervical lordosis.

We are presenting our prospective case series of 23 patients who had this procedure in our institution between 2002 and 2004. Of these 16 patients are at least 6 months from their operation. We performed clinical outcome measurements using SF12 questionnaires, pre and postoperative clinical assessment performed by independent surgeon and a specialist spinal physiotherapist. We also routinely performed pre and postoperative MRI scans to assess the adequacy of decompression (Done by our musculoskeletal radiologist).

Our study showed a good clinical and radiological outcome with this relatively simple new procedure. This has become our standard operation for our patients with multilevel cervical stenosis with cervical myelopathy.


P J McKenna B J C Freeman R C Mulholland M P Grevitt J K Webb S H Mehdian

Introduction We report the two-year clinical outcome of a prospective randomised trial comparing Femoral Ring Allograft (FRA) to a Titanium Cage (TC) in circumferential lumbar spinal fusion.

Methods 83 patients recruited to the study fulfilled strict entry requirements (> 6 months chronic discogenic low back pain, failure of conservative treatment, one or two-level discographically proven discogenic pain source). 38 patients were randomised to receive FRA, 45 patients were randomised to receive TC. Posterior stabilisation was achieved with translaminar or pedicle screws. Patients completed questionnaires including Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and the Short-Form 36 (SF-36) pre-operatively and 6, 12 and 24 months post-operatively.

Results Results were available for all 83 patients with a mean follow-up of 26.5 months (range 24–75 months). Baseline demographic data (age, sex, smoking history, number of operated levels, pre-operative outcome measures) showed no statistical difference between groups (p< 0.05). For patients receiving the FRA, mean VAS (back pain) improved 2.0 points (p=0.01), mean ODI improved 14 points (p=< 0.01), and mean SF-36 scores improved by > 11 points in all domains (p< 0.03) except general health and emotional role. For patients receiving the TC, mean VAS improved 1.2 points (p=0.002), mean ODI improved 5 points (p=0.02); SF-36 improved significantly in only one of eight domains (bodily pain).

Discussion Clinical outcome following circumferential lumbar fusion with FRA readily achieves the accepted mean clinically important differences (MCID). Fusion with TC does not achieve the MCID. The use of TC for circumferential lumbar fusion appears not to be justified.


Andrew Clarke Michael O’Malley James Hegarty Brian JC Freeman

Introduction Surgeons request cross-match based on habit not evidence. The spinal unit requested 686 units of blood during 2002–2003 and transfused only 42 for elective lumbar spine surgery. This wastes money, time and blood.

Aim Optimise the transfusion requests in elective lumbar spinal surgery by creating evidence based guidelines.

Methods The data on elective operations performed on the lumbar spine during the period June 2002 to June 2003 was collected from the spinal unit database and cross-referenced with the records of blood transfusion. Cross-match: Transfusion ratios (C:T Ratio) and Transfusion Index (TI) for common procedures were calculated. Based on these results, a Maximum Surgical Blood Ordering Schedule (MSBOS) was created and prospectively audited for six months.

Conclusion Eighty units were cross-matched during the prospective audit. Therefore, in one year one hundred and sixty units would be requested. This represents a reduction of over five hundred units.


A O’Brien C Southgate M Oliver A Tavakkolizadeh G Selmon J.A.N. Shepperd

We report a consecutive series of 352 patients with back pain treated by Dynesys flexible stabilisation between July 2000 and November 2004, to include perceived indications, surgical techniques and complications. A detailed analysis of the first 120 cases with minimum follow up of 2 years is included. Our unit has undertaken 352 operations to date, and this communication reports all cases. Follow up is to 48 months.

All patients were profiled prospectively using the Oswestry Disability Index, Euroquol, SF36, Pain analogue scale, Pain chart and modified Zung. The same measuring instruments were used at review for which follow up was 100%

The procedure involves paired bilateral pedicle screw instrumentation above and below the level of perceived pathology, with each screw pair connected by load relieving carbopolyurethane flexible spacers, in conjunction with a tension band polyethylene cord passed through the spacer. This construct is then held under tension with screws in the main pedicle screws.

All patients are profiled at entry to the hospital service using a proforma which includes the measures outlined above. Conservative treatment is arranged by the centre, and includes physiotherapy to the point of failure. All our cases have failed conservative treatment before enrolling for surgery.

There was significant improvement in symptoms for most of the patients in the series. However clear patterns emerged as to those cases in which Dynesys is contra-indicated.

This is the largest series of cases reviewed so far in the literature.


S Tafazal P Sell

Objectives: To assess the outcome of patients undergoing anterior lumbar interbody fusion with the Hartshill Horseshoe cage device.

Study Design: Prospective cohort of patients from a single centre in the UK

Methods: 20 patients underwent anterior lumbar inter-body fusion from September 1994 to November 2002. All patients underwent primary anterior fusion alone. The diagnosis was back pain alone in 10 patients, instability and back pain post discectomy in 9 patients and pseudoarthrosis in the remaining patient. The main outcome measures were oswestry disability index, low back outcome score, visual analogue scale for back and leg pain, modified somatic perception and modified zung depression score.

Results: Follow-up data was available for 17 patients at two years (85%). There were 11 females and 9 males and there average age at operation was 39 years (range 30–50 years). The mean ODI pre-op was 56 and this improved to 30 post-op (p=0.004). The mean LBOS pre-op was 21 and this improved to 41 post-op (p=0.005). The VAS pre-op was 83mm and improved to 48mm postop (p=0.01). Overall 13 of the patients (76%) improved their ODI by a minimum of 10 points. When comparing the groups according to diagnosis, the patients with back pain alone had a 17 point improvement in ODI whereas the patients with back pain post discectomy had a 29 point improvement in ODI (p=0.33). The main complication of surgery was common iliac vein tear occurring in two patients which was repaired intra-operatively.

Conclusion: Anterior lumbar interbody fusion using the Hartshill horseshoe cage device is a safe and effective method of achieving spine stabilisation in patients with back pain. It seems to be particularly effective for those patients who have instability and back pain post-discectomy.


M. Khatri H Norris ERS Ross

Introduction: Disc Replacement has been described as 21st Century revolution in spinal surgery that preserves mobility and prevents adjacent segment degeneration. Numerous short-term studies are available on clinical outcome but to date there are no published long term clinical, radiological and survival data on disc replacement.

Aim: To analyse clinical, radiological & survival results of Charite III Disc Replacement.

Study Design: Ethical committee approved retrospective study.

Methodology: 160 patients (Av. Age 46yrs; Std.Dev 8.06; 62 Males & 98 Females) underwent disc replacement surgery between Jan1990 and Dec2000. An independent observer reviewed case notes, radiographs and administered a questionnaire that included Oswestry Disability Index, and Pain Score.

Results: Clinical: At an average follow up of 79 (range 31 to 161) months, mean improvement in ODI and pain score were 18.01(p< 0.001) and 1.69(p< 0.001) respectively.

Radiological: average movement at replaced disc, defined as greater than 4 degrees on flexion-extension lateral view was 1.5 degrees for L3L4, 4.01 degrees for L4L5 and 4.8 degrees for L5S1 disc replacement.

Survival: A mean survival time of 147(95% C.I. 140 to 154) months was observed with cumulative survival of 55% with implant removal as an endpoint. A mean survival time of 124(95% C.I. 116 to 133) months with cumulative survival of 35% was observed with all radiological failures as an endpoint.

Complications: were post-operative incisional hernia seen in 17(10.6%), wound infection 9(5.6%) and retrograde ejaculation in 5(3.1%) patients.

Conclusion: Charite III Disc Replacement results in clinically significant (> 15, p< 0.001) improvement in ODI, but does not result in clinical significant (> 2 points) improvement in back pain. Motion is preserved at L4L5 and L5S1 level. It has low survival rate and does not seem to prevent onset of facet arthritis. This study does not support the use of this device for management of back pain.


J H H Chan G Heilpern I Packham G Marsh A Knibb

Objective To assess the effectiveness of intrathecal fentanyl in the relief of post operative pain in patients undergoing lumbar decompression or fusion.

Method 60 patients undergoing lumbar spinal surgery were prospectively recruited. All patients received our standard analgesic regime with PCA via a syringe driver. They were also randomised to receive either 15 micrograms of fentanyl intrathecally, or nothing. The fentanyl was administered by the operating surgeon (GM) under direct vision one or two levels above the site of the operation at the end of the procedure. VAS pain scores were taken at 2, 4, 24 and 48 hours post operatively independently. The total dose of morphine required was recorded.

Results The patients randomised to receive fentanyl showed a decrease in their mean VAS scores as well as a 40% reduction in the total morphine dose delivered. There was no increased incidence of side effects in the group receiving fentanyl. No patients suffered respiratory compromise requiring treatment. All patients left recovery after 2 hours to be nursed on an open ward.

Conclusion Intrathecal fentanyl is effective at reducing mean pain VAS scores and morphine use via a PCA after lumbar spinal surgery. We would support its use over intrathecal morphine because of the reduced incidence of respiratory complications and the ability to nurse patients on the open ward.


S. Molloy P. Jayakumar R. Kaila F. Gow A. Saifuddin

Background: There is conflicting evidence of correlation between clinical outcome and severity of thoracolumbar spine fractures in neurologically intact patients1. Kalyan et al2 presented the results of their prospective study of thoracolumbar spinal fractures and concluded that the clinical outcome was consistently better predicted by the severity of disc injury than that of the bony fracture. They suggested that if severe disc injury was present, treatment of the disc injury may result in a better short term clinical outcome. The aim of this study was to detail the incidence and type of disc injury in patients with thoracolumbar spinal fractures with intact neurology.

Methods: Retrospective analysis of a prospectively collected spinal injury database at a regional spinal injuries unit. Only patients with a thoracolumbar spinal fracture and intact neurology were included. Retrospective analysis of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings. One hundred and thirty nine neurologically intact patients (89M:50F, mean age 36 years, range 15 – 77yrs) with a thoracolumbar (T11 –L5) spinal fracture were admitted to our spinal unit over the last 11 years (1994 – 2004). Patient data was collected prospectively onto a spinal injuries database. All of these patients had an MRI scan on admission. All types of thoracolumbar fracture were included in this study and the presence or absence of an associated disc injury was recorded retrospectively from the MRI study. The type of disc injury was also recorded.

Results: The incidence of severe disc injury adjacent to a thoracolumbar spinal fracture in our cohort of patients was 43% (60 patients). Disc prolapse or extradural herniation was seen in 16 patients (11%). Intraosseous disc herniation into an adjacent vertebral body was seen in 20 patients (14%). Internal disc disruption was seen in 24 patients (17%). Disc injury was found at more than one level in 21 patients (15%).

Conclusion: The incidence of severe disc injury in our study of neurologically intact patients with a thoracolumbar fracture was considerable (43%). Kalyan et al2 suggested that treatment directed at addressing the disc injury in these patients may promote earlier pain relief and also earlier return to pre-morbid activities. If this is the case, then the decision making regarding operative versus non-operative management, in a patient with a thoracolumbar fracture and intact neurology, should be based on the severity of the disc injury as well as the bony injury.


S. Molloy R. Kaila R. Green A. Saifuddin

Background: It is very difficult to ascertain how much of the degeneration seen in a post-traumatic spine was due to pre-existing disease and how much was due to the trauma. The aim of the current study was to determine the prevalence of pre-existing disc degeneration on MRI in a region of the spine injured by spinal trauma.

Methods: Prospective whole spine MRI study in 118 patients with spinal trauma. One hundred and eighteen consecutive patients (79M:39F, mean age 36years, range 13 – 90 yrs) admitted to our spinal unit for treatment of their acute spinal trauma were investigated with whole spine magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Whole spine MRI was already the standard protocol for all patients admitted with spinal trauma to rule out co-existing pathology and multiple spinal fractures1. Patient data, including age, sex, and mechanism of injury was recorded prospectively onto a spinal injury database. We divided the spine into cervical (C1–C7), thoracic (T1–T12), and lumbosacral (L1–S1) regions. For the purpose of this study we documented the presence or absence of pre-existing degenerative disc disease in all regions of the spine. Of particular interest was any pre-existing degenerative disc disease in the region affected by the spinal trauma. The number of spinal levels affected by pre-existing disc disease within each region was also detailed.

Results: The two most common mechanisms of injury were flexion-compression (68 patients) and flexion-distraction (24 patients). Seventy-one of the patients sustained burst fractures and the vast majority of these were in the thoracolumbar region. Thirty-seven patients (31%) had degenerative disc disease in the same region of the spine that was injured in the spinal trauma. Seven patients had pre-existing cervical degeneration in the presence of cervical spine trauma and thirty had pre-existing lumbosacral degeneration in patients that had lumbosacral trauma. Twenty four patients (20%) had more than one level of degenerative change within the same region as their spinal trauma. Eighteen patients (15%) had degeneration in a different region of the spine to the one that was injured.

Conclusion: Thirty one percent of the patients in our study had pre-existing degenerative disc disease in the same region as their spinal trauma despite the average age of our patients being only 36yrs. This has important medicolegal implications because it means that a large % of patients who sustain spinal trauma have pre-existing degenerative changes which are not the result of their injury.


J Bernard S Molloy S Somayaji A Saifuddin

Background: It has been reported that there is poor correlation between neurological injury and degree of bony retropulsion in thoracolumbar burst fractures1. Wilcox et al2 showed biomechanically that there was poor concordance between the extent of post impact spinal canal occlusion and the maximum amount of occlusion that occurred at the moment of impact. In the current study we examined the possibility that variation in the termination of the conus medullaris may offer protection from neurological injury in a proportion of these fractures.

Methods: A retrospective study was made of 39 patients (26M:13M, mean age 35.9 years, range 15 – 75 years) presenting with a single level thoracolumbar burst fracture (T12–L2) between 1998 and 2001. A whole spine MRI scan was performed on all patients and the level of the conus noted. Age, sex, injury severity score (ISS), neurological status (ASIA motor score) and the transverse spinal canal area (TSCA) of the vertebral levels either side of the fractured vertebra was measured. A predicted TSCA for the injured level was then calculated from the mean of the TSCA’s of the adjacent levels. The actual TSCA of the injured level was calculated and this enabled a percentage decrease of the TSCA to be worked out from the predicted value. Analysis was made of the presence or absence of neurological injury in relation to canal compromise and involvement of the conus.

Results: Eighteen patients with neurological compromise and 21 with intact neurology (the age and sex distribution in the two groups were similar). The mean ± SD ASIA motor score of the patients studied was 90.4 ± 23. Mean ISS was 20.2 in the neurologically injured and 10.5 in the intact (p=0.0005). Mean TSCA of the canal was 218mm2 in the intact and 150mm2 in the injured groups (p=0.006) and mean %TSCA was 70 and 49 respectively (p=0.007). The conus lay between T12 and L2 in all patients. When the conus lay cranial to the fracture (n=13), 38% were neurologically intact. When the conus lay at the level of the fracture (n=26), 62% were intact (NS). Neurological deficit did not occur in the absence of neurological compression on MRI.

Conclusion: Our study showed that the risk of neurological injury from a thoracolumbar burst fracture was not decreased when the conus lay outside the fracture zone. However, there was a statistically significant difference in percentage of canal compromise when the patients with neurological impairment were compared with those that were neurologically intact.


RR Verma JB Williamson D Patel

Background: To assess the safety and efficacy of intrathecal diamorphine for the postoperative pain relief in patients having lumbar decompressive surgery.

Methods: Retrospective study of case records of 39 consecutive patients who underwent lumbar decompression surgery, carried out by the same surgeon. There were 39 (24 males & 15 females, age range 19–75 years) healthy patients (23 ASA 1, 13 ASA 2 and 3 ASA 3). All patients having lumbar microdiscetomy or decompression for spinal stenosis were treated by a single intrathecal injection of diamrphine, performed by the surgeon prior to wound closure. All were prescribed regular paracetamol, and a NSAID if there were no contraindications. Oral opiates were prescribed for “rescue” analgesia. Retrospective analysis of the case notes of these patients was carried out and visual analogue pain scores, sedation scores and side effects/complications were evaluated.

Results: Five patients required rescue analgesia in the first six hours after surgery. None was required subsequenty. Nausea occurred in 2 patients, 1 patient had vomiting and one pruritus requiring piriton. Respiratory depression and sedation were not found in any of the patients. None of the patients had neurological complications.

Conclusion: Intrathecal diamorphine proved to be safe, effective and eliminated the need for opioid infusions following lumbar decompression surgery.


N. R. Boeree

Background: To asses the safety and efficacy of the Wallis Stabilization System in degenerative disorders of the lumbar spine.

Methods: A prospective international multicentre clinical and radiological outcome assessment study. The study is ongoing. The study group comprises 260 consecutive patients meeting inclusion and exclusion criteria with respect to diagnosis (and levels affected), age, medical conditions and prior surgery. 61% were male, 39% female and the mean age was 44 years. The principal diagnosis was massive disc herniation in 37%, degenerative disc disease (with Modic type I change) in 27%, canal stenosis in 13%, recurrent disc herniation in 9% and disc herniation above a transitional segment in 5%. L4/5 was the operated level in 88%. Clinical assessment has been performed using a p atient completed questionnaire incorporating SF-36, JOA (Japanese Orthopaedic Association score), VAS (lumbar pain Visual Analogue Score, 0–100), ODI (Oswestry Disability Index) and Odem’s Criteria. Any adverse or serious adverse events were documented. Pre-operative static and dynamic radiographs and MRI scans have been undertaken, and the radiographs are then repeated at 3 and 6 months post-operatively and yearly thereafter. Post-operative MRI scans are obtained on a yearly basis up to 5 years post-surgery.

Results: Mean operating time has been 74 minutes overall, with mean implantation time of 19 minutes. Blood loss averaged 180 mls. The pre-operative mean VAS of 71 improved to 21 at 3 months (p< 0.01) with further improvement at 6 months (VAS 18) and 1 year (VAS 11). SF-36 scores improved in every category from 3 months onwards, this improvement being statistically significant in all categories except general health. At 1 year SF-36 scores were not distinguishable from an age and sex matched general population. JOA scores improved significantly from 6.1 (15 point scale) pre-operatively to 12.5 at 3 months and 13.7 at 12 months (p< 0.01). Odem’s criteria provide additional evidence of efficacy, with 80% of subjects categorized as ‘good’ or ‘excellent’ at 3 months, this proportion improving to 89% at 1 year. Of those graded as ‘fair’ at 3 months, half had improved to ‘good’ or ‘excellent’ by 1 year.

From the series of 260 cases there were only 3 implant related complications (1.2%).

Conclusion: Previous biomechanical and finite element analysis studies have shown that the Wallis stabilization system off-loads the intervertebral disc and improves the biomechanical characteristics of the degenerative lumbar motion segment. The surgical procedure is simple, minimally invasive and non destructive, preserving surgical options for the future.

This study provides preliminary evidence with respect to the safety and efficacy of the Wallis Stabilization System.


M. Emran M. A. El Masry A. Al-Shawi W. J. Farrington C.R. Weatherley

Background: To determine whether the operation of LSD destabilizes the lumbar spine and leads to an increase in any pre-existing scoliosis or spondylolisthesis. Lumbar spondylosis, which commonly includes a degenerative listhesis and a scoliosis, is the commonest cause for stenosis in the lumbar spine. The standard operation for spinal stenosis remains a laminectomy with fixation and fusion in the presence of possible instability. The laminectomy, however, destabilises the spine and the instrumented fusion makes it a much bigger operation in patients often not best placed to cope with it. The more limited operation of LSD, which has previously been reported to this society, avoids a simultaneous fusion or instrumentation and has been shown to give long term symptomatic relief (1) Its possible effect on the stability of the spine has not previously been reviewed.

Methods: A retrospective clinical and radiological review of consecutive patients operated on for degenerative spinal canal stenosis with either a pre-existing scoliosis or degenerative listhesis or both. Sixty-one patients (44 female and 17 male) with a mean age at operation of 72.8ys (range: 54–85). Pre-operatively 35patients (57%) had a degenerative listhesis, 14 patients (23%) a lumbar scoliosis and 12 (20%) had both. The mean postoperative follow-up was three years (range from one to fourteen years).

Results: None of the 47 patients with a preoperative degenerative spondylolisthesis had any change in grade of the listhesis. Also no patient developed a new spondylolisthesis.

Of the 26 patients with a preoperative scoliosis, 10 progressed by a mean of 4.9° (range 2°–15°)

Conclusion: The results show that the operation of LSD was not associated with the development of a spondylolisthesis or a further progression of a pre-existing listhesis, and no patient developed a scoliosis. In those who had a scoliosis pre-operatively, 38% progressed and this only to a degree which we believe falls within the natural progression to be expected in such a group of patients. We believe these results support the view that the operation of Limited Segmental Decompression for spinal stenosis does not significantly destabilize the spine, even in a group that would appear most vulnerable, and as such there is no indication in such cases to consider a simultaneous instrumentation and fusion.


A Jackowski I Pitman

Background: To assess the clinical and radiological results of motion-segment sparing anterior cervical partial discectomy and foraminotomy surgery in patients with at least 1 year of follow-up.

Methods: The study is a prospective, non-randomized, observational study. The patients all had symptoms of intrusive nerve root irritation with or without motor symptoms, refractory to conservative management for greater than 6 weeks duration. Patients were asked to complete questionnaires capturing) VAS (visual analogue) pain scores, NDI (neck disability index) and European myelopathy scores, patient satisfaction, and return to work details. Radiographic assessments were collected preoperatively, at 4 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, 1 and 2 years postoperatively.

Results: 58 patients have been assessed with at least 1year follow-up. The mean duration of symptoms prior to surgery was 24 weeks (6–20 weeks). 55 patients had single level surgeries (C5/C6-15, C6/C7-38, C7-T1-2), 3 patients had two level surgeries (C4/C5& C5/C6-1, C5/C6& C6/C7-2). In 34 patients sugery was for soft disc prolapse, in 12 patients surgery was for hard osteophytes and in 12 patients both pathologies contributed equally. Operation time ranged from 50–85 minutes. Average in patient stay was 2.6 days. There were no complications apart from 1 patient who had to return early to theatre for evacuation of haematoma and then made a full recovery. All patients reported pain intensity reductions. Pain decreased from 6.7 to 1.4 for arm pain on a 10-point scale. NDI scores improved from a preop mean of 42 to 16 on a 100 point score at 6 months post-surgery. All patients returned to their usual occupations with the exception of 2 patients who are involved in litigation against an employer or third party. No patient required repeat surgeries. Radiographic analysis at 1 year shows preservation of segmental motion in 75% patients, preservation of interbody height in 60% patients, spontaneous fusion in 12% patients.

Conclusion: A clinical success rate of 90% was achieved (clinical success being defined as a patient rating of very satisfied or satisfied on a 5-point patient self-scoring outcome scale). 56 out of 58 patients would undergo the same procedure again and recommend it to friend.


D.S. O’Donoghue M. de Matas K. Kopitzki Z. Abidin J. Hickey R. Pillay

Background: To assess the accuracy of pedicle instrumentation placement using an image guidance system ( Medi Vision) in a pig cadaveric model.

Methods: A 4mm diameter (10cm long) screw was inserted transversely into the spinous process of a pig cadaver percutaneously using fluoroscopic guidance. The dynamic reference base (DRB) of the image guidance system was then attached to the screw. Using the navigation system both pedicles at each level were identified and 3.2mm guide wires inserted percutaneously. This process was performed for each level from D7 to L4. Actual wire placement was recorded using standard anteroposterior and lateral fluoroscopic images. Virtual trajectories generated by the image guidance system were recorded on the guidance system database. Accuracy of wire placement was then evaluated in an automated way by linear correlation between corresponding images.

Results: 20 pedicles were instrumented at 10 levels from D7 to L4. Mean estimate of accuracy for dorsal levels AP and lateral (mm). Mean = 1.452mm, standard deviation 1.57mm. Mean for lumber levels= 1.047mm, standard deviation 1.187mm

Conclusion: Lumbar pedicle instrumentation showed more accuracy when compared to dorsal pedicle instrumentation. The error of navigation that was accommodated by the image guidance system was 2mm.

There was correlation between fluoroscopic copies and virtual trajectories.

This image guidance system may not only aid in the placement of pedicle instrumentation but also assist the senior surgeon in trainee supervision.


D. Flynn A. van Wersch P. van Schaik K. Ryan V. Ferguson S. Papastefanou

Background: Despite people with idiopathic scoliosis (PwIS) experiencing pain (typically radicular that is often unrelated to clinical factors) of significantly greater frequency and severity to matched controls and the general population1, a paucity of attention has been devoted to elucidating psychosocial correlates of pain in this population. Therefore, the aim of this study was to investigate the predictive value of clinical and psychosocial factors for the pain experiences of PwIS in the UK.

Methods: A questionnaire-based design was used to examine associations between pain experiences, sociodemographic, medical, treatment and psychosocial factors (stressors, coping styles, coping functions, perceived body image [PBI], acceptance of scoliosis [AoS], health-related quality of life [HRQoL] and Health Locus of Control [HLoC]). A sample of 126 PwIS (88% female) with a mean age 39.0 years. Mean age at onset, Cobb angle before and treatment was 16.6 years, 57.9°, and 36.4° respectively. The number with thoracic, thoracolumbar, double major and lumbar curves was 26 (41.3%), 16 (25.4%), 16 (25.4%) and 5 (7.9%) respectively. Sixty one (48.4%) had undergone some form of surgery. Pain experiences (presence [yes, no], intensity, description and location/distribution of pain) were assessed with the McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ). Medication use and factors reported by PwIS to increase and reduce their pain were assessed with open-ended questions.

Results: The majority (85%) of PwIS reported pain and 56% reported using medication for pain due to scoliosis. Logistic regression revealed that medication use was associated with undergoing surgery, increased sleep disturbances and reporting that medication decreased their pain. Presence of pain was correlated with education stressors, coping functions (emotional regulation and avoidance), AoS and HRQoL. Predictors of MPQ measures were predominately psychosocial factors. Pain intensity was predicted by pre-treatment Cobb angle, PBI, HRQoL, absence of stress due to inadequate hospital services and reporting abdominal pain. Total pain on the MPQ was associated with absence of bereavement stressors, increased satisfaction with appearance before adolescence, HRQoL, not taking medication and reporting abdominal pain.

Conclusion: The findings indicate that psychosocial interventions have the potential to impact positively on the prevalence of pain, analgesic usage and satisfaction with healthcare in PwIS. The findings also highlight a need to develop clinical guidelines for the multidisciplinary management of scoliosis that adequately address the medical and psychological aspects of this condition.


D.R. Cohen P. Tran S. Duckett T. Hall C.E. Bruce J C Dorgan

Background: In times of blood shortage, the department of health plan to cancel elective surgery requiring more than 2 units of blood cross matching preoperatively. We assessed the use of blood products in scoliosis surgery and identified factors increasing the need for post operative blood transfusion.

Methods: Prospective data collection. Forty four patients underwent corrective spinal surgery between January 2003 and June 2004. Numbers of units of blood cross matched pre operatively and transfused post operatively were calculated. Subtype of scoliosis and surgical approach were also identified.

Results: All patients were cross matched 6 units of blood pre operatively, total of 264 units. Only 133 units were actually transfused, giving an overall 50.4 % product use rate. All syndromic patients were transfused blood irrespective of surgical approach. Idiopathic patients who had a one stage anterior approach did not require transfusion. Idiopathic patients were transfused a mean of 2.4 units and 2.9 units for one stage posterior and 2 stage approaches respectively. Syndromic patients were transfused a mean of 2.5 units, 5.8 units and 4.2 units for one stage anterior, one stage posterior and 2 stage procedures respectively.

Conclusion: The department of health published a paper on contingency planning for the shortage of blood products (1). In times of shortage, those surgeries requiring preoperative cross matching of more than 2 units will be cancelled first. Therefore, not only is it important to reduce the waste of blood products from a cost perspective, but also to cross match appropriately to avoid unnecessary cancellation if blood shortages occur. Surgical approach and underlying diagnosis need to be identified when cross matching patients for corrective scoliosis surgery. Idiopathic scoliosis patients only require 2 units of blood cross matching preoperatively. Patients with syndromes require 2–6 units depending on the surgical approach. A prospective validation trial has been implemented to validate our retrospective findings.


D. Flynn A. van Wersch P. van Schaik K. Ryan V. Ferguson S. Papastefanou

Background: Instruments for the psychological assessment of people with idiopathic scoliosis (PwIS) are required to design and plan interventions and services for this population. The few instruments available such as the Scoliosis Research Society Outcome Instrument1 rely on single item measures, omit important domains such as coping, and are not validated for use by the UK population. Therefore, the aim of this study was to assess the psychometric properties of a battery of existing instruments to measure the psychosocial functioning of PwIS in the UK.

Methods: A non-experimental design was used to examine the psychometric properties of the following scales: Functional Dimensions of Coping (FDC); Iowa Body Image (IBI); Acceptance of Scoliosis (AoS); Quality of Life Profile for Spine Deformities (QoLPSD); Multidimensional Health Locus of Control (MHLoC); and the McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ). A sample of 126 PwIS (88% female) with a mean age 39.0 years. The number with thoracic, thoraculumbar, double major and lumbar curves was 26 (41.3%), 16 (25.4%), 16 (25.4%) and 5 (7.9%) respectively. Sixty one (48.4%) had undergone some form of surgery. The instruments were assessed in terms of factor structure (factor analysis); internal reliability (Cronbach’s alpha); discriminant validity (examining significant correlations with > 5% overlap in variance, i.e. r > 0.022); construct validity (correlations between one construct such as HRQoL and another construct that is expected to covary such as pain); and sensitivity (correlations between scores on the instruments and patient factors such as Cobb angle).

Results: The instruments had clearly defined factor structures that confirmed previous research and the sub-scales were universally reliable (Cronbach’s alpha ≥ 0.7; range 0.7 – 0.95). Except for MHLoC the instruments possessed adequate discriminant validity. Construct validity was demonstrated by 70% overlap in variance between AoS and HRQoL – Psychosocial Functioning subscale and significant correlations between HRQoL – Sleep Disturbances and HRQoL – Back Pain with all the MPQ subscales. Subscales on all the instruments (except MHLoC) were sensitive to differences in patient variables (e.g. age and Cobb angle).

Conclusion: Given the excellent psychometric properties of the instruments used, we propose a new outcome measure ‘The Scoliosis Psychosocial and Pain Profile Inventory’ (SPPPI), that consists of the following instruments: FDC, IBI, AoS, QoLPSD, and MPQ. Further research is needed investigate the test re-test reliability and responsiveness of the SPPPI after the delivery of medical, surgical and psychosocial interventions.


A. Mirza E. Aldlyami C. Bhimarasetty J. Spilsbury D. Marks

Background: Anterior scoliosis surgery is associated with potentially significant intra-operative blood loss, requiring homologous transfusion either intra- or postoperatively. Blood loss in this type of surgery correlates with surgical & anaesthetic techniques. In our centre the development of specific anaesthetic techniques as well as the routine use of Cell Salvage has dramatically reduced the rates of homologous blood transfusion. Currently, specific indications for the use of the Cell Saver in Anterior Scoliosis Surgery have not been proven. Previous studies have commented on the beneficial aspects of autologous transfusion for Orthopaedic patients in general; However, others have shown a negligible advantage specifically in anterior thoracolumbar fusion surgery. The aim of our study was to assess and quantify the use of homologous blood, as well as the effects on haematological indices.

Methods: We carried out a retrospective study of 144 consecutive patients, all of whom underwent instrumented anterior scoliosis correction between April 2001 and October 2004. A cell saver was used in all the cases, and hospital data (including haematological indices and number of levels fused) was collected.

Results: The median age of the study cohort was 15.0 years (range 8 – 46), and there were 31 males and 113 females. The mean preoperative haemoglobin in patients was 13.5g/dl and the mean postoperative haemoglobin was 10.6g/dl. Haematocrit values followed a similar pattern, the mean pre-op value being 0.41, mean post-op value was 0.29. The range of volume of intra-operatively salvaged cells was 200 to 1100mls. 25 of 144 patients required transfusion. In these patients, the average number of units given was 2.3, although the total homologous transfusion rate was 0.4 units per patient. Results show that homologous transfusion was not required in 82.6% of patients. This is better than previously published rates of transfusion in this procedure. There was no correlation between the number of levels instrumented and the number of units transfused (Pearson Correlation Coefficient 0.19), and no correlation between the number of levels instrumented and postoperative haematocrit values (Pearson Correlation Coefficient 0.16). None of the patients required intra-operative homologous transfusion.

Conclusion: Our experience shows that along with meticulous surgical haemostasis, and hypotensive anaesthesia the use of Salvaged Autologous Blood Transfusion in anterior scoliosis surgery has an important role in reducing the incidence of postoperative anaemia and homologous transfusion requirements.


D. Flynn A. van Wersch P. van Schaik K. Ryan V. Ferguson S. Papastefanou

Background: Despite the benefits of quality information material, there is a dearth of research on the information needs of people with scoliosis (PwS). The aim of this study was to identify the information needs of PwS including preferences for the presentation of benefit/ risk information, in order to inform the design of written information for this population.

Methods: A questionnaire-based design was used to identify the importance attached to characteristics of information material, scoliosis-related knowledge, preferred treatment decision-making role, preferences for presentation of risk information and current information needs. A sample of 73 PwS (86% female, mean age 41.9 years). The majority (74%) had at least an A’ level standard of education and 60% had undergone some type of surgery. The importance of 13 characteristics of information material was assessed using criteria described by previous research1. PwS were asked to rate their level of knowledge on 20 scoliosis-related topics. The Control Preference Scale was used to assess treatment decision-making role. Preferences for the presentation of risk information was assessed in terms of (a) absolute versus relative risk, (b) loss versus gain information, and (c) perceived clarity of different methods for presenting benefit/risk information. An open-ended question requested PwS to state their current information needs.

Results: Characteristics of information material assigned the highest importance were: information on benefits/ risks of treatment; coverage of all relevant treatments; and clear information on probability of benefits/risks of treatments. Scoliosis-related knowledge was rated below average for 14 of the 20 topics. The majority (88%) expressed a preference for an active or collaborative role in treatment decisions. The majority also preferred to be presented with information on benefits/ risks in both absolute and relative terms, and informed of both loss and gain information. Bar graphs and pie charts were assigned the highest clarity ratings for the presentation of benefit/risk information. Content analysis revealed 27 mutually exclusive categories of current information needs and the rank order of the top 3 were: psychological services and psychosocial support; surgery; and aftercare and self-management.

Conclusion: PwS lack knowledge about their condition, desire both psychological and medical information and wish to be involved in treatment decisions. Based on the results, written information will be designed to address the salient information needs of PwS. It is anticipated, following further evaluation that these materials could be used to impact positively upon clinical outcomes such as psychosocial functioning, patient satisfaction and participation in shared decision-making.


Full Access
H V Dabke A Jones S Ahuja J Howes P R Davies

Background: Long waiting lists in the NHS are a cause for public concern especially with regards to progressive conditions like scoliosis. We reviewed records to 61 patients to ascertain whether waiting time had any detrimental influence on their surgical management.

Methods: Retrospective review. Assessment of clinical records and radiographs of 61 patients who had scoliosis surgery over past two years was done by two independent investigators. Patient demographics, waiting times between referral and outpatient review and waiting time for surgery were collected.

Results: There were 41 females and 20 males with mean age of 11.8 years (range, 1– 22 years). Thirty-four patients had thoracic curves (28- right sided), 21 had thoracolumbar curves (19- right sided) and 6 patients had right sided lumbar curves. Mean Cobb angle at presentation was 58° (range,17°–90°) which increased to 71°(range, 30°–120°) at surgery. Average waiting time to be seen in the clinic was 16 months. Average waiting time for surgery was 10 months. Rapid curve progression was seen in twelve patients (20%), of which 10 required more extensive surgery than originally planned. Their mean Cobb angle at presentation was 48° (range, 45°– 80°), which increased to a mean of 59° at surgery (range, 50°–92°). At presentation their Risser grades were: 5 – grade 0, 3- grade 2, 2- grade 4. These 10 patients had waited averagely 7.8 months to be seen in the clinic and for 11 months to have the surgery.

Conclusion: Significant curve progression occurred in 20 % of patients waiting to have scoliosis surgery. Ten of those required much more extensive surgery than originally planned. Long waiting times therefore have a detrimental effect on the surgical management of scoliosis patients.


Full Access
E Palayiwa Z Jana-Mohyadin

Background: To review the results of spinal cord monitoring over a five year period and determine whether the generally accepted criterion used for warning the surgeon is appropriate and whether this criterion could be modified without compromising patient safety.

Methods: This was a retrospective study of patients monitored at the John Radcliffe hospital between October 1999 and June 2004. Monitoring is carried out by stimulating the peroneal nerve behind the knee and monitoring using an epidural electrode above the surgical site. Results are recorded throughout the surgery using a Synergy mobile system. Exponential averaging is used and the surgeon is warned of possible damage if the amplitude of the signal drops by more than 50% from the reference value which is set as soon as the surgical site has been exposed1. Two hundred and twenty two patients were studied all of whom had spinal surgery with instrumentation. The age range was from 4 to 80 years old. Patient notes were assessed to determine whether there was any neurological damage and if so what the nature and duration of this was. These results were compared with the results of monitoring, both the absolute value of amplitude change and also the time course of any variations in amplitude.

Results: Of the 223 cases studied 78 exhibited a 50% drop of amplitude of the signal on one or both sides at some stage during the surgery. In 30 of these the deficit remained on at least one side at the end of surgery, 6 having a deficit on both sides. There were no cases of neurological damage in the patients where the signal amplitude was greater then 50% at the end of surgery. In the 30 cases where the signal amplitude was less than 50% at the end of surgery only one had any lasting neurological damage and one showed a transient neurological deficit. The time course of the change of amplitude appeared to be different in the cases of neurological damage than in those without damage.

Conclusion: In this study all patients suffering neurological damage were identified by the spinal cord monitoring. However, there was a significant number of “false positives” which could possibly be reduced by developing new criteria for warning the surgeon. It is also possible that the exact methodology used in monitoring may affect the number of false positives. Both the stimulus method and recording method may contribute to this2. Development of evidence based criteria for warning the surgeon and optimizing methods of monitoring would need co-operation between many centres. We would propose that a multicentre study should be set up with this objective.


Marianne McMaster A J Lee R G Burwell

Background: To our knowledge, there are no publications that have evaluated physical activities in relation to the etiology of AIS other than sport scoliosis (1,2) so we undertook a study to assess the physical activities of patients with progressive AIS from their first year to early teens and compared these with those of a control group.

Methods: All 156 children in this study had to adhere to the following 6 criteria:- born full term, fed well as infants, achieved their milestones, no hospital visits except for sports injuries, no family history of a scoliosis and no back pain (prior to diagnosis in the patient group). We compared 79 consecutive patients (girls 66, boys 13) diagnosed as progressive AIS (62 of whom subsequently had a spinal fusion) with a control group of 77 subjects (girls 66, boys 11) of similar age, gender, race and socioeconomic status. A structured history was obtained from the mother and child of each group average time taken to obtain the history was 47 minutes. Each child was examined for toe touching and vertical symmetry of spinous processes whilst standing. The findings suggest a relation between physical activities or the lack of them and the development of progressive AIS.

Results: There is a significantly increased odds of AIS in those who were introduced to a swimming pool within the first year of life (p=0.001), did not attend gymnastics/ karate classes (p=0.005), did not attend dance classes (girls only, p=0.045), did not have horse riding classes (p=0.003), did not go skating (< 0.001), and who could touch their toes (p=0.011). No association is found with playing football/hockey or regular swimming at the age of 10 years.

Conclusion: Progressive AIS is positively associated with an early introduction to swimming and ability to toe touch. Spinal asymmetry was noted in the controls. AIS is negatively associated with participation in dance, skating, gymnastics/karate and horse riding classes. Is it possible that children who develop AIS have a longstanding proprioception defect which makes them less likely to participate in sporting activities? If so, by encouraging children to participate in sport might we increase their proprioception abilities and make those at risk less likely to develop spinal asymmetry which may progress to a scoliosis requiring surgical correction?


J. Andrews J. Clamp M. Grevitt

Background: It is often useful to gauge the flexibility of curves while assessing patients with scoliosis. Our aim was to discover if there were any reliable x-ray predictors of stiffness.

Methods: Previously the flexibility index has been shown to be an accurate measure of curve stiffness. A random selection of fifty x-ray sets was analyzed for parameters that might predict flexibility. These were then compared to the flexibility index generated from bending films. We recorded age; Cobb angle; bending film Cobb angle; Perdriolle rotation assessment; percentage wedging of the apical vertebrae and translation of the apex of the curve from a central sacral/cervical line. We then calculated the flexibility index. All measurements were taken from immediately pre operative standing AP x-rays and fulcrum bending films (1). The group was then assessed as a whole and subgroups were analyzed. Large curves (> 50 degrees) were compared to small (< 50 degrees) curves and thoracic curves were compared with thoracolumbar curves. Correlation between the flexibility index and the other parameters was then studied. We used Pearson correlation coefficient for parametric data and the Spearman rank correlation coefficient to study the non parametric data. P values were then assigned using a statistics software package.

Results: Age and apical translation were not related to curve stiffness. The Cobb angle was the only strong predictor of flexibility (p-0.002) looking at all curve types together. The Cobb angle was, however, more useful in larger curves and did not reach statistical significance in the small curve subgroup. In small curves Perdriolle rotational assessment was a more useful measurement (p-0.02). In the thoracic curve subgroup the percentage wedge of the apical vertebrae was a strong predictor (p-0.007).

Conclusion: Our sample had a strong bias toward an adolescent age group (5–61) mean age 17 and probably did not have enough of a spread to demonstrate the previous relationship between age and stiffness (2). The study re enforces the value of the Cobb angle in predicting curve stiffness but suggests caution using it in smaller curves. It also suggests a role for Perdriolle measurement in small curves and percentage apical wedge in thoracic curves.


J. R. Andrews C. V. J. Morgan-Hough B. J. C. Freeman M. P. Grevitt J. K. Webb

Background: Anterior scoliosis correctional surgery can result in screw pull out or pedicular fracture. This is more common in stiff curves where the instrumentation extends to the smaller, higher, thoracic levels. The fracture/intra-operative pull out usually occurs during the reduction maneuver. In all of our cases the curve was reduced in the standard cranial to caudal direction using a cantilever maneuver. We describe a salvage technique using circlage wires that can be used for this problem. We present seven cases and the final outcome.

Methods: The technique involves placing a longer screw into the damaged vertebrae so it protrudes 5mm proud. A 1.25mm circlage wire is then cut to length and passed around the tip of the screw. It is then looped in a figure of eight passed under the rod and tightened around the respective pedicle screw head. A case record and x- ray review of seven procedures performed was then carried out. The age of the patients was between 14 and 41 years (mean 20) at surgery. The pre-operative Cobb was between 72 and 43 (mean 58). One curve was flexible with a flexibility index of 70% but the remainder was stiffer (range 34%–40%). There was one thoracolumbar curve with a T11 fracture. All other curves were thoracic and the fracture levels were T5, T7, T7, T6+7, T6+7+8, and T6+7+8 respectively. Four out of seven were braced post operatively for three months. The Cobb angle over the instrumented levels immediately post surgery and at final follow up was measured. The technique was deemed to be successful if no significant loss of correction occurred.

Results: The technique held position in six out of seven of the subjects. The average loss of position in these patients was two degrees (range 0–4). In one subject the curve went from 28 degrees immediately post operatively to 38 degrees over 2 years. The four month post operative x ray showed no loss of position suggesting that this loss of position may not be due to the fracture. This patient remained pleased with his cosmetic result and went from 72 degrees pre operatively to 38 degrees at 2 year follow up.

Conclusion: Care should be taken in patients with stiff proximal curves. The use of larger 8mm screws may decrease pull out and consideration may be given to caudal to cranial reduction in some cases. Circlage wire rescue is a useful salvage procedure for inter-operative fracture or screw pull out during anterior scoliosis correction.


MJ Hutchinson IW Nelson

Background: To describe – Forced traction radiographs under GA for operative planning; The use of segmental orthogonal image-intensification for screw insertion in thoracic & lumbar pedicles; An audit of X-ray exposure during these procedures; The use of multiple Chevron osteotomies as an alternative to anterior release; The correction of scoliosis with convex cantilever, Cotrel-Debousset manoeuvre, segmental translation, segmental rotation,” lumbar-levelling”.

Methods: We present our operative technique in addressing deformity. This represents an eclectic evolution, which we feel is sufficiently dissimilar to current standards to merit presentation. Pedicle screws are inserted at multiple levels with no recourse to hook or wires. Five reduction techniques are used and repeated.

Results: The complications of 1500 thoracic pedicle screws; the predictive value of forced traction films under GA; the Fulcrum Bending Correction Index and operative parameters of our series are submitted separately.

Conclusion: We commend consideration of some or all of our techniques to the society.


OA Gabbar MJ Hutchinson IW Nelson

Background: To assess reliability of traction views under GA in predicting curve flexibility when performing posterior correction of scoliosis deformity with pedicular screws.

Methods: Compare reliability of preoperative fulcrum bending film with intraoperative traction films in predicting and influencing the correction of scoliosis deformity using posterior pedicular screws. Twenty patients undergoing corrective surgery for scoliosis deformity the average age was 19 years old. The Lenke classification was used to classify the curves using pre-operative fulcrum bending views, the student’s t test was used to assess the reliability of x-ray views in predicting the end results.

Results: The mean preoperative major structural Cobb angle was 80 degrees and mean minor structural Cobb angle was 27, the mean major structural Cobb angle on fulcrum bending views was 49 degrees, the mean major structural Cobb angle on the traction views was 33.6, the minor structural Cobb angle was 9 degrees thus changing the lenke classification of the curve reducing the numbers of levels for fixation by at least one level either end of the curve. Posterior pedicular screws were used in all the patients. The number of patient at risk of combined anterior release and posterior instrumentation was reduced from 13 to 2. The P value for the difference between fulcrum bending views and traction views was P< 0.0001, for traction and end result P=0.18

Conclusion: The traction views under GA were superior in predicting curve flexibility when performing only posterior scoliosis correction with interpedicular screws reducing the number of levels required to incorporate and the number of procedures required to achieve adequate correction.


OA Gabbar MJ Hutchinson IW Nelson

Background: To assess the correction of curves using the Fulcrum bending correction index FBCI with pedicular screws in posterior scoliosis surgery.

Methods: Compare preoperative upright and fulcrum bending views, intraoperative traction films with postoperative views to assess the correction of scoliosis deformity using posterior USS II interpedicular screws. Peri-operative complications are reviewed. Twenty patients undergoing corrective surgery for scoliosis deformity were reviewed the average age was 19 years old 4 males and 16 females, 17 were idiopathic adolescent scoliosis, 3 were neuromuscular scoliosis. The Lenke classification was used to classify the curves, the Fulcrum bending correction index (FBCI) as a percentage for assessing postoperative correction.

Results: The mean preoperative major structural Cobb angle was 80 degrees and mean minor structural Cobb angle was 27 degrees, the mean major structural Cobb angle on fulcrum bending views was 49 degrees, the mean major structural Cobb angle on the traction views was 37 degrees. Pedicular screws were used in all the patients for posterior correction; only two patients required combined anterior release. The average inter-operative blood loss was 2200 ml, the initial results suggest an of FBCI of 181% compared to Luk et al results 100.2% to 109.1% 4 different methods of posterior stabilisation.

Conclusion: Pedicular screws provided excellent segmental correction and stabilisation for posterior scoliosis correction.


A Rafee D Mittal RB. Smith

Background: To assess the cosmetic advantage of costotomy at the angle of the ribs on the convexity of a curve in the management of Adolescent Idiopathic scoliosis. Whilst modem segmental correction produces gratifying improvement in Cobb-angle and, to some extent rotation, rib asymmetry often remains as a concern for patients. Performing costotomy at the angle of the rib at the same time as corrective surgery can improve the cosmetic appearance significantly. It avoids any further scars or surgery, and is associated with minimal complications, the main one being pneumothorax and the requirement of a chest drain.

Methods: Retrospective review of 50 patients. This has been a standard practice and this presentation reports on 50 patients treated in Preston with a variety of corrective devices; we have assessed results radiologically, with cosmetic acceptability by the patient and surface topographical analysis.

Results: Significant improvement occurs at the time of costotomy as the ribs drop from their arched position after the coronal deformity has been improved

Conclusion: The addition of costotomy at the time of primary surgery for Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis leads to minimal complications. Significant improvement occurs at the time of costotomy as the ribs drop from their arched position after the coronal deformity has been improved. This is maintained in the post-operative period by moulding of the brace.


CVJ Morgan-Hough Andrews BJ Freeman MP Grevitt JK Webb

Background: To assess the treatment of Lenke Type 1 Curves with anterior USS Instrumentation.

Methods: A retrospective radiographic review of 29 cases. Twenty nine patients with Lenke type 1 curves were treated with anterior USS instrumentation. The average age was 14.8 years (range 12–25 years) with an average of 17.4 month follow up (range 6–61 months). 27 were right sided curves, with 2 left sided. Standard AP and Lateral Standing X-rays were taken preoperatively (together with bending films), post-operatively and at follow-up. Measurements recorded at each assessment were the mean Cobb angle, sagittal and coronal balance, kyphosis and lordisis. Complications we associated with the instrumentation were also recorded.

Results: 12 patients had double minithoracotomies, the rest (17), single thoracotomies, the average blood loss at operation was 1055mls, with no significant difference between the two groups. The mean number ofleve1s instrumented was 6 (range 4–8). The mean pre-operative Cobb angle of the major thoracic curve was 53° (range 37–74). This value corrected to 24° on fulcrum bending films. The compensatory lumbar curve averaged 36° bending down to 6.°. The mean correction of these two curves post-operatively and then at most recent follow-up was 21 and 26 degrees for the thoracic curve, and 21 and 20 degrees for the lumbar curve. The mean pre-operative kyphosis was 25 increasing to 34 post-operatively and 39 at follow-up. The mean lumbar lordosis readings were 46, 46 and 45 respectively. Sagittal balance, gradually improved from a mean of 12mm to 11 then 10 at follow -up. Coronal balance did not show the same trend and was 3mm pre-operatively then 7 and 7 at final follow up. Instrumentation complications in total occurred in 9 cases, which included 4 cases of vertebral body fracture requiring circlage wiring and 5 cases of partial screw pulling out of the vertebral body. Fractures requiring wiring occurred at T5, T7, one case of three levels T6,7,8 and one case of two levels T6,7, this complication always occurred at the highest level instrumented. Partial screw pull-out always occurred at T5, with two cases occurring at two levels i.e T5,6.

Conclusion: Good correction was obtained with an mean of 6 instrumented levels. There was however a significant instrumentation complication (31 %). Despite this the intra-operative fractures caused no significant complications and good correction was still achieved in these cases. There are some concerns over mild deterioration in the curves over long term follow up but this deterioration is not clinically significant.


CJ Goldberg DP Moore EE Fogarty FE Dowling

Background: In adolescents at or near skeletal maturity, correction of severe scoliosis may be facilitated by first mobilising the spine anteriorly before the definitive posterior fusion and instrumentation. There is no dispute that this is effective, but it is significantly more invasive, and carries greater risks. The benefits have been measured in greater reduction in the Cobb angle, but the patient’s real concern is with cosmesis. Surface topography can measure this aspect.

Methods: Retrospective comparison of topographic parameters (before surgery and at 7 days, 6 months, and 2 years after, and at latest review, if more than two years) after one-stage (Group 5, N=10) and two stage (Group 3, N=39) with normal adolescents (Group 1, N=63). Patients operated for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis by one surgeon (FED) were compared with girls referred and then judged normal from the screening programme. Topographic parameters (spinal angle, saggittal profile, asymmetry and trunk balance) and Cobb angles were compared by t-test.

Results: Prior to surgery, both treatment groups differed significantly from the index group on all parameters except saggittal profile; from each other, they differed only in mean Cobb (Group 3: 73.6°, Group 5: 59°) and spinal angles and Suzuki hump sum. After surgery, both groups showed significant mean reduction in most parameters and in final Cobb angle (Group 3: 32.7° (−40.9°), Group 5: 29° (−30°) postoperatively) excepting rib hump, and were not statistically distinguishable. Over two years, there was continued improvement in trunk balance and re-establishment of lumbar lordosis in both groups. Group 5 (single stage) showed a slight recurrence of some asymmetry parameters that was statistically (but perhaps not clinically) significant. All patients had a solid fusion post-operatively.

Conclusion: Ideally, this study would be done prospectively, on a controlled, double-blind, randomised basis, but the numbers required and time involved make this impractical. These two surgical groups were pre-selected on the basis of curve severity, and these results may show that the anterior procedure is necessary to bring Group 3 to the same end-point as Group 5. Alternatively, while the anterior procedure improves the reduction of the Cobb angle, it might be the posterior fusion that rearranges the shape of the back and hence brings about the cosmetic improvement. In conclusion reducing the Cobb angle has been the standard of surgical assessment, but the cosmetic result does not necessarily correlate with this. The possibility that less invasive surgery may give as good a cosmetic outcome is worth discussing, as the savings in time, money and risk would be enormous.


LM Breakwell DS Marks AG Thompson RR Betz L D’Andrea LG Lenke

Background: To present the experience of three centres in the surgical management of scoliosis in patients with Prader-Willi syndrome1, and to describe the associated complications. A retrospective case series reviewing treatment type, surgical outcomes and complications with a review of the literature

Methods: There were 15 patients treated surgically in the three centres over an eleven year period. The average age at initial surgery was 9.6 (5 to 16+8) yrs. Minimum follow-up from index procedure was 28 months. 5 underwent posterior spinal fusion, 2 had anterior fusion alone and 2 had combined anterior/ posterior fusions as their index procedure. 6 patients were initially managed with growing rod constructs. Outcome measures included fusion rate, curve progression and complication rate.

Results: 11 patients achieved a solid fusion. 2 patients were still undergoing the lengthening process and were thus unfused. 1 patient had broken instrumentation with pseudarthrosis, and one patient not fit for final fusion remained without implants. No curve progression was seen in the 11 fused spines. Progressive kyphosis and scoliosis were noted in the two ongoing lengthening patients. There were 17 revision procedures not including planned lengthenings, with a total of 59 surgical procedures. 5 rod breakages occurred in the growing-rod patients. There were 11 infections (4 deep) in 7 patients. There were 6 respiratory complications, 3 requiring ventilatory support. One patient had post-operative neurological deterioration requiring re-exploration and who had grade 3 paraparesis at final follow-up. In total there were 36 complications (240%)

Conclusion: The outcome of surgical management of scoliosis in Prader-Willi syndrome is adversely affected by the obesity and respiratory difficulties of the patients and complications abound2. The use of growing constructs, whilst enabling the management of the growing child, greatly increases the risk of implant failures. Their use in Prader-Willi requires careful consideration.


S. Molloy G. Edge J. Lehovsky

Background: The long term survival of patients with type II and III spinal muscular atrophy differs considerably from patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Despite this, treatment of scoliosis in both groups is often reported together1. There are only sporadic reports, all with small numbers, of combined anterior and posterior (two stage) scoliosis surgery in patients with spinal muscular atrophy (SMA)1. The aim of the current study was to document the peri-operative morbidity, length of stay and correction of deformity in patients with SMA that had two stage surgery and compare them with the patients that had single stage surgery.

Methods: A retrospective analysis of data on our consecutive series of patients with SMA.

We analysed the data of 31 patients with SMA (16M:15F) who underwent scoliosis surgery between 1996 and 2004. The data collected included SMA type, age at surgery, percentage predicted forced vital capacity(%PFVC), blood loss, duration of surgery, complications, type of surgery undertaken, pre-operative mean Cobb angle ± SD(including bending film Cobb angle ± SD), post-operative Cobb angle ± SD and length of hospital stay. The decision to do single or two stage surgery was based on the history of recurrent chest infection, %PFVC and the stiffness of the curve. Percentage correction of Cobb angle in patients that had two stage surgery compared with those that had single stage posterior surgery. Comparison of post-operative respiratory complications, estimated blood loss, total hours in theatre and mean length of stay between the two groups.

Results: There were 27 SMA type II and 4 SMA type III’s with a mean age at surgery of12.5 years (range 7.8 – 17.4). The mean pre-operative Cobb angle of all 31 patients was 89.7° ± 19.7°, the mean bending preoperative Cobb angle was 54° ± 13.3° and the mean post-operative Cobb angle was 33.7° ± 17.3°. Eighteen patients had single stage surgery and 13 had two stage surgery. Twelve out of the thirteen two stage operations had either a thoracotomy or a thoracoabdominal approach. In the patients that had single stage posterior surgery, the mean bending preoperative Cobb angle was 54° ± 13.3° and the mean post-operative Cobb angle was 38.7° ± 19.2°. In the patients that had two stage surgery the mean pre-operative bending Cobb angle was 53.6° ± 11.6° and the post-operative Cobb angle was 25.5° ± 10.8°. The %PFVC in the patients that had single stage and two stage surgery was 39.2 ± 12.8 and 69.2 ± 12.2 respectively. There were 3 respiratory complications in the single stage group and 4 in the two stage group. The average total estimated blood loss (EBL) in the single stage and two stage groups (first and second stage EBL’s combined) were 2433ml and 1902ml respectively. The length of stay for the patients with single stage surgery and two stage surgery was 14.1 ± 4.1 and 18.5 ± 7.4 days respectively. The total surgical hours for the patients with single and two stage surgery were 2.9 ± .6 hrs and 4.8 ± 1.2 hrs respectively.

Conclusion: The results of our series would suggest that in a selected group of SMA patients (no history of recurrent chest infection and an acceptable %PFVC) a better immediate deformity correction can be attained with two stage surgery. This has to be weighed up with a greater total EBL and mean length of stay for the patients that had two stage surgery.


T Ember H Noordeen

Background: To stimulate a debate as to whether neurological compromise as a result of spinal instrumentation is the result of direct or indirect cord injury of more the result of cord ischaemia due to the highly abnormal vascular anatomy encountered in these patients.

Methods: Review of three cases of neuromuscular scoliosis who underwent angiograms under general anaesthetic. Graphical comparisons with normal patterns spinal vascular anatomy

Results: Vascular anatomy was found to be so abnormal in these patients that the series was discontinued due to the perceived risk of paraplegia as a result of the angiogram procedure itself.

Conclusion: We plan to perform CT angiograms in patients with neuromuscular scoliosis to further elucidate the vascular anatomy in these patients


M Assous C Lawson DL Douglas AA Cole

Background: To assess the potential for Quantec imaging to save radiographs in the follow-up of patients with early onset scoliosis. This is a group of patients who often have many radiographs due their age at diagnosis.

Methods: This is a prospective cohort study. Twenty-four children with early onset scoliosis are identified. They all have a minimum of three simultaneous radiographs and Quantec scans as part of routine follow up for their scoliosis curves. There are 15 males and 9 females (22 thoracic, 1 thoracolumbar, 1 lumbar). Mean age at diagnosis is 3 years (range 1–4.8 years). The Cobb angle of the major curve is measured from each radiograph and compared with the Q-angle using Bland-Altman plots and linear regression analysis.

Results: The mean Cobb angle was 30° and the mean Q-angle 19°. The correlation coefficient was 0.68 (p< 0.05). In curves with Cobb angle < 30°, The Bland-Altman plots show a close scatter with a mean difference of 3.4°. It was calculated that this could have safely saved 18 radiographs in 14 patients. In curves > 30°, there was a large scatter and a mean difference between Cobb angle and Q-angle of 20.1°.

Conclusion: In early onset scoliosis, curves with Cobb angle less than 30° can be safely followed clinically and with the Q-scan reducing the number of radiographs required. Curves with Cobb angle greater than 30° cannot be reliably observed with Quantec scans alone.


CJ Goldberg EE Fogarty FE Dowling A. O’Meara

Background: A sharp, localised, thoracolumbar gibbus is pathognomonic of the mucopolysaccharidosis (MPS) group of disorders, the most common of which is Hurlers syndrome (MPS I). Untreated patients with this disease run an inevitable course of neurological and physical degeneration until death within the first decade. Haemopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) has resulted in considerable improvement in survival with amelioration of many of the symptoms and signs which characterise this disease. Data, however, is disappointing in relation to the impact of HSCT on skeletal dysplasia. This study reviews the natural history of spinal deformity in Hurler’s syndrome after HSCT in infancy.

Methods: Twenty three patients (12 male and 11 female), transplanted at a mean age of 0.9 years ± 0.47, (range 0.27 – 1.8yrs) were investigated, of whom 19 were at least two years post-HSCT and were included. HLA identical donor sources included unaffected or heterozygote family members, unrelated adults or cord blood. Mean age at review was 9.4 years ± 4.57, (range 2.5 – 18.4yrs). Serial measurements of the thoracolumbar spines incorporated clinical records, radiographs and surface topography. The thoracolumbar gibbus was measured on lateral spinal radiograph using the standard adaptation of the Cobb method. Two segments of the spine were documented: the gibbus itself and the thoracic profile above it. Clinical assessment and surface topography were contrasted with this.

Results: At presentation, all showed the characteristic gibbus at the thoracolumbar junction, with a flat and stiff thoracic spine above. Three patients underwent surgery to correct or maintain the gibbus, which was unsuccessful in two; the third is stable, but still young. Two patients have developed scoliosis: one in the juvenile period and one in infancy. Three female patients are now post-menarchal and have shown no progression of their gibbus. One male patient, now aged 19 years, had significant progression of his gibbus at puberty, but is now stable, untreated and cosmetically acceptable. The remainder are still pre-pubertal but their deformities are not currently progressive.

Conclusion: The fate of the spinal deformity in untreated MPS-I has been poorly documented, as the condition was invariably fatal from cardiorespiratory failure during the first decade. These interim results suggest that, while the deformity persists and may become more pronounced during growth and adolescence, it does not significantly impact on quality of life. The considerations which usually dictate intervention in other spinal deformities of childhood may not necessarily apply and should be approached with caution. The more recent availability of recombinant human -L- iduronidase adds further interest to the management of these patients and warrants cautious expectation , in the context of experience gained in these groups of patients. In conclusion atients with MPS I have complex multisystem disorders, independent of their orthopaedic status. While monitoring their spinal deformity is indicated, over-intrusive investigation and treatment may be counterproductive.


P.M. Whittingham-Jones S. Molloy G. Edge J. Lehovsky

Background: There are conflicting reports regarding the effect of scoliosis surgery on respiratory function in Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD)1,2. Galasko et al2 found that the Percentage Predicted Forced Vital Capacity (%PFVC), remained static for thirty six months following surgery, in patients with DMD that underwent spinal stabilisation for scoliosis. The aim of the current study was to support or refute the above finding in a large series of patients with DMD.

Methods: A retrospective analysis of data on 55 consecutive patients with DMD that underwent single stage posterior surgical correction for scoliosis. We analysed the data of 55 boys with DMD who underwent scoliosis surgery between 1990 and 2002. Age at surgery, pre-operative Cobb angles, pre-operative %PFVC, and post-operative %PFVC at 6 months, 12-18 months and 2–3 years were collected. We documented the pre-operative Cobb angle ± SD to assess the difficulty level of our surgical cases. Percentage PFVC was used as our outcome measure to assess respiratory function. The mean pre-operative %PFVC was compared to the post –operative mean %PFVC at three different time intervals; at 6 months, 12 to 18 months and at 2 to 3 years.

Results: The mean age was 14.6 years (range 11.2–18yrs). The mean pre-operative Cobb angle was 65.4 degrees ± 14.8. The mean %PFVC pre-operatively was 33.9 ± 10.4. The mean post-operative %PFVC’s were: 6 months (29.1 ± 10.4), 12 to 18 months (27.6 ± 12.1) and 2 to 3 years (25.4 ± 8.7). Therefore the mean % PFVC following surgery at 6 months, 12 to 18 months and 2 to 3 years decreased from the mean pre-operative % PFVC by 4.8%, 6.3% and 8.5% respectively.

Conclusion: The natural history of patients with DMD is a gradual decline in respiratory function. In the current study the mean post –operative %PFVC was less than the mean pre-operative %PFVC at 6 months, 12 to 18 months and at 2 to 3 years post surgery. Our series would suggest that respiratory function declines post-operatively, even in the short term, in patients with DMD that undergo spinal stabilisation. The decline in respiratory function in our study was progressive over the 3 year follow up period.


T Ember H Noordeen

Background: To assess whether modern instrumentation systems are biomechanically strong enough to allow instrumented fusion to pelvis on the concavity of the major curve only and if this confers a significant advantage with respect to complications rates and disadvantages with respect to correction achieved and fusion rates.

Methods: A retrospective review from the notes and radiographs of blood loss, operation time, complication rates, degree of correction and fusion rates. Comparisons drawn with neuromuscular curves of similar aetiology treated by same surgeon using more traditional two rod fusion techniques. Subjects were high risk children with progressive neuromuscular scoliosis of varying aetiology requiring stabilisation. (7 cases to date) We compared operation times, blood loss, complication rates, degree of correction and fusion rates with standard segmental fusion techniques in a similar cohort of children. Basic statistical analysis only required to compare the two groups (Analysis of Variance (ANOV A) and Chi squared tests)

Results: Mean operation times, blood loss and complication rates of this small cohort were lower than the control group. No implant failure to date with longest follow-up now approaching two years.

Conclusion: We hope to open a debate as to whether there is a place for this more limited fusion technique in an effort to minimise the complication rates in these highly challenging children


H V Dabke A Jones S Ahuja J Howes P R Davies

Background: Campbell et al from Texas have pioneered the use of Vertical Expandable Prosthetic Titanium Rib (VEPTR) in congenital scoliosis. Our centre is the first in the UK to use it and we report our experience of 5 cases done in the past 2 years. VEPTR works on the principle of expansion thoracoplasty and thoracic spinal growth of upto 0.8 cms/year has been reported by the developers of this device.

Methods: This case series includes one child who had the index surgery in America and is undergoing sequential expansion in Cardiff. All surgeries were done using a standard technique with monitoring of somatosensory evoked potentials. After appropriate soft tissue and bony releases, VEPTR was inserted and expanded by 0.5 cms to maintain tissue tension. Subsequent expansions were done as day case surgeries at 4–6 month intervals through a small incision over the VEPTR. We assessed clinical and radiographic assessment, which included – hemithorax height ratio, Cobb angle, interpedicular line ratio, space available for the lung.

Results: There were 3 males and 2 females with mean age of 6.3 years (range 0.9 to 9 years) at the time of index operation. Average follow up is 2 years (0.4 to 5 years). Average hospital stay for the index surgery was 5 days (4–7 days). All patients had mean of 3 expansions (range: 0–6). Mean improvement in the Cobb angle was seen from 48° to 36° at last followup. Space available for lung improved from a mean of 72 % to 86 %. Mean improvement in hemithorax height ratio was from 72.5% to 86%. One child had mild pain due to prominent metalwork; 2 children had transient brachial plexus neurapraxia, one of whom had progression of a secondary cervical curve and is awaiting further surgery for the same.

Conclusion: Our early results show good improvement of clinical and radiographic parameters. Transient nerve palsies have been well reported on the concave side and occur due to traction on the nerves as a result of increased height of the thoracic cage. This occurred in one initial case and has not been seen later. These results are encouraging but do indicate a learning curve.


T Ember H Noordeen S Tucker

Background: To assess the use of subcutaneous rodding with sequential lengthening procedures to control progressive early onset curves not responding to conservative treatment modalities.

Methods: A retrospective study reviewing the notes and plain radiographs of all children with early onset scoliosis treated by growth rod insertion over a seven year period (two paediatric spinal surgeons using similar techniques at two major centres). Subjects were children with early onset scoliosis unresponsive to conservative management. Outcome measures – curves at time of instrumentation, curve progression, number of lengthenings, curve magnitude and age at time of definitive fusion, spinal growth achieved and complications encountered.

Results: Majority of children treated uneventfully with satisfactory control of curvature until age at which definitive fusion acceptable. However our results do suggest a number of cases and circumstances where simple growth rod instrumentation is not sufficient and augmentation with anterior apical fusion is required (will discuss these on an individual basis).

Conclusion: The management of early onset progressive scoliosis by means of growth rod instrumentation and sequential lengthenings is safe and effective.


RG Burwell RK Aujla AA Cole PH Dangerfield BJC Freeman AS Kirby RK Pratt JK Webb A Moulton

Background: In preoperative thoracic (TC) and thoracolumbar (TLC) AIS curves to evaluate periapical rib-vertebra angle asymmetry [1] and rib-spinal angle asymmetry in relation to the spinal deformity and the 4th column support of the spine [2].

Methods: Consecutive preoperative AIS patients having spinal instrumentation and fusion were assessed using radiographs and ultrasonographs. Twenty-eight preoperative patients with AIS were studied (TC 19, apex T8-9 in 15, TLC 9, apex T12 in 2, L1 in 7, mean Cobb angle 51 degrees). In AP radiographs the following were measured by one observer (RGB): Cobb angle (CA), apical vertebral rotation (AVR) and apical vertebral translation (AVT) from the T1-S1 line; in TC at 6 levels about the apical vertebra (3 above, at and 2 below) for each of 1) rib-vertebral angles (RVAs) and difference (RVAD=concave minus convex RVA), 2) rib-spinal angles (RSAs) to the T1-S1 line and difference (RSAD), and 3) vertebral tilt; and in TLC the RVAs, RVADs, RSAs and RSADs of ribs 11 & 12. The ultrasound apical spine-rib rotation difference (SRRD) was obtained as a measure of transverse plane rib deformity. With the subject in a prone position and head supported, readings of laminal rotation (LR) and rib rotation (RR) were made on the back at 12 levels by one of two observers (RKA, ASK) using an Aloka SSD 500 portable ultrasound machine with a veterinary long (172mm) 3.5 MHz linear array transducer. The maximal difference between LR and RR about the curve apex was calculated as the apical spine-minus-rib rotation difference (SRRD).

Results: Thoracic curves. The RVADs (but not the RVAs, RSAs or RSADs) only at 2 & 3 levels above the apex correlate significantly with each of CA (p=0.054), AVR (p=0.047), AVT (p=0.014, after controlling for CA p=0.131) and vertebral tilt (p=0.032) but not SRRD (all two levels above apex). Thoracolumbar curves. The 11th RSAD (but not RVAD or RSAs) correlates significantly with each of AVR (r= −0.776, p=0.014, after controlling for CA p=0.022) and SRRD (r= −0.890, p=0.001, after controlling for CA p=0.003) that together correlate significantly (r=0.672, p=0.048).

Conclusion: In TC supra-apical rib asymmetry (RVAD) in sternally-stabilized [2] and longest levers of the sternal-rib complex is associated with spinal deformity; in TLC supra-apical rib asymmetry (11th RSAD) is associated with transverse plane deformity of each of the apical vertebra (mainly L1) and 12th ribs. These rib associations, probably secondary to the spinal deformity, may involve a primary rib component in the 4th spinal column. The prognostic value of supra-apical RVAD and RSAD for progressive AIS needs to be evaluated.


CJ Goldberg DP Moore EE Fogarty FE Dowling

Background: Scoliosis occurring during the growing years of childhood, while less common, has a greater potential for severe deformity than that with adolescent onset. Treatment is therefore more urgent, and the untreated natural history more difficult to determine. Orthotic treatment and the more recently improved surgical techniques may halt or even reverse the natural history, but the length of time needed for adequate follow-up makes this hard to verify. This report examines the outcome for a historical group of these patients, treated and not, to establish a bench-mark against which results can be measured.

Methods: Retrospective analysis of records derived from the scoliosis database. Subjects were patients presenting with non-congenital scoliosis before the age of ten years and who were at least ten years old when last reviewed. Outcome measures were treatment protocols, the age and incidence of surgery, and the radiological and cosmetic outcome.

Results: 243 children were included, being 38 infantile idiopathic scoliosis (IIS: 20 male, 18 female); 86 juvenile idiopathic scoliosis (JIS: 19 male, 67 female); 119 symdromic scoliosis (Syn:46 male, 71 female) Depending on age, perceived progression potential and individual factors, treatment was either jacket and brace, or observation unless surgery was deemed advisable. In all, 81 children were braced and 162 were not; 129 have had surgery (25 IIS, 48 JIS; 56 Syn.). The individual groups showed no statistical advantage to non-operative treatment in preventing surgery, but in the whole group it appears that a significantly greater proportion (Z=2.7269, p< 0.01) of those braced were subsequently operated. Mean age at surgery was 7.3 years for IIS, 12.97 for JIS and 8.3 for Syn. Recurrence of deformity post-operatively was always observed in those operated before puberty, regardless of the surgical technique.

Conclusion: Ten years of age was taken as the minimum for inclusion, although it is significantly earlier than skeletal maturity, because it has been practice to offer surgery well before this age, and some short term effects may already be apparent by the tenth birthday. This was not a trial of treatment between similar groups, so the appearance of increased surgery in the braced children suggests that, while the clinicians were well able to identify those with a worse prognosis, orthotic treatment was not effective in altering this prognosis. A recently published study1 demonstrated the failure of past surgical techniques to prevent progressive deformity and respiratory compromise in infantile-onset scoliosis. Here it was found that the older the patient at corrective surgery, the better the result, that methods supposed to prevent post-operative recurrence in skeletally immature children failed to do so, and, while non-operative treatment may be effective at least in postponing surgery, even preventing it in some cases, this was not demonstrated statistically. Treatment of spinal deformity in pre-adolescent children warrants debate as a separate subject, and is a more serious problem than that occurring in adolescence.


T Ember H Noordeen

Background: To quantify the distraction forces required to lengthen a standard subcutaneous domino linked two rod construct. This was a seminal piece of work as part of a project to design a magnetic coil driven micro electromechanical internal device that would mitigate the need for surgical lengthenings of these growth rod constructs.

Methods: A distraction tool with strain gauge was designed and built in the RNOH Department of Biomechanics and following calibration and testing was used to perform five distraction procedures. Subjects were five patients with early onset progressive scoliosis unresponsive to conservative treatment modalities who have previously had a subcutaneous rodding procedure and are hence having regular lengthenings. Forces were transduced and collected on a laptop computer in theatre running a piece of software specifically written for the experiment.

Results: Forces will be displayed in graphical format with correlation with pre- and post-lengthening radiographs.

Conclusion: The magnitude of force required to achieve distraction is compatible with that achievable via a magnetic coil driven internal micro electromechanical device that we are currently in the design phase of producing.


H Al-Hussainy N Chiverton DL Douglas AA Cole

Background: It is generally accepted that surgical correction in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) is largely for cosmesis. Scoliometer measurements of back surface asymmetry and rasterstereographic methods are used to attempt to quantify the surface deformity, These methods are also used to determine the ‘success’ of surgery. This study objectively evaluates trunk cosmesis from pre-operative photographs.

Methods: This is a prospective cohort study. Twelve pre-operative girls with thoracic AIS had standard photographs taken in the standing and forward bending positions. The mean Cobb angle is 74°, mean age 13.7 years. Twenty observers were selected by their profession (3 Spinal Consultants, 4 Orthopaedic Specialist Registrars, 4 nurses, 4 medical illustrators and 5 lay-people). Each patient’s photographs were arranged on a single sheet and the observer was asked to arrange the patients in order of cosmesis and having done this to give a score between 0 (best) and 100 (worst) for overall cosmesis.

Results: There was no good agreement either in the ranking or the scoring for any of the groups of observers. Some observers agreed quite well whilst others ranked and scored much differently to the ‘mean’.

Conclusion: Cosmesis is a spectrum and is most definitely in the eye of the beholder with wide disagreement between individuals both for ranking and scoring cosmesis. We must identify the components of trunk cosmesis (for the majority of observers) so that we can quantify these and produce a score to reflect what we are trying to treat. Only then will we be able to assess the results of our treatments.


RG Burwell RK Aujla PH Dangerfield BJC Freeman AS Kirby JK Webb A Moulton

Background: In lumbar scoliosis curves of school screening referrals were evaluated (1) for the possible relation of pathomechanisms to standard and non-standard vertebral rotation (NSVR) [1], and (2) the relation between apical lumbar axial vertebral rotation and the frontal plane spinal offset angle (FPTA) [2].

Methods: Consecutive patients referred to hospital during routine school screening using the Scoliometer were examined in 1996–9. None had surgery for their scoliosis. There are 40 subjects with either pelvic tilt scoliosis (11), idiopathic lumbar scoliosis (19), or double curves (10)(girls 31, postmenarcheal 25, boys 9, mean age 15.3 years). One observer (RGB) measured: 1) in AP spinal radiographs Cobb angles (CAs), apical vertebral rotations (Perdriolle AVRs), and trigonometrically sacral alar tilt angle (SATA), and FPTA as the tilt of the T1–S1 line to the vertical; and 2) total leg lengths (tape).

Results: Excluding the double curves there are 16 left and 14 right lumbar curves mean CA 11 degrees (range 4–24 degrees), mean AVR 9 degrees (concordant to CA in 18/30, discordant in 7/30), SATA 2.8 degrees (range 0.2–7.7 degrees associated with CA side and severity, p=0.0003), and leg-length inequality 0.7 cm (significantly shorter on left, p< 0.0001 and associated with SATA (p=0.02) but not CA). Neither CA nor AVR in each of the laterality concordant and discordant lumbar or thoracic curves is significantly different. Twenty-six subjects have thoracic curves (16 right) 22 with AVR (mean CA 11 degrees, range 4–17 degrees, AVR 9 degrees, n=22) the CA being associated with each of lumbar CA and SATA (respectively p< 0.0001, p=0.003, n=26). Thoracic curve laterality of CA and AVR is concordant in 12/26 curves and discordant in 10/26 and for concordance/discordance neither is significantly different; thoracic AVR sides with laterality of lumbar curve AVR shown by thoracic AVR (but not CA) being greater in lumbar discordant than in lumbar concordant curves (14 & 7 degrees respectively, p=0.03, n=18 & 7). Both for lumbar curves alone and for lumbar with double curves, AVR by side is significantly associated with FPTA by side (r= −0.568, p=0.001, n=30; r=−0.560, p=0.0002, n=40).

Conclusion: (1) It is hypothesized that different pathomechanisms may separately affect the frontal (CA) and transverse (AVR) planes: in discordant curves these mechanisms may neutralize each other and limit curve progression; concordant curves require these biplanar mechanisms to summate and facilitate curve progression. (2) The association of frontal plane spinal tilt angle and lumbar AVR may result from balance mechanisms affecting trunk muscles – mechanisms that may underlie the complication of post-operative frontal plane spinal imbalance or decompensation [2].


AA Cole RG Burwell JK Webb

Background: The study evaluates the inter-relationships between Cobb angle (CA), apical vertebral rotation (AVR), apical vertebral translation (AVT) and maximal angle of trunk inclination (max ATI). The effects of sex, curve laterality, curve type and apical levels will be studied

Methods: This is a study of consecutive pre-operative AIS patients. There are 122 pre-operative AIS patients (106 thoracic, 16 thoracolumbar), with a mean age of 15.6 years. From the pre-operative AP radiograph, CA, AVR (Perdriolle) and AVT are measured. The max ATI is measured using the Scoliometer with the patient in a standing forward bending position. Ratios between the measurements are calculated to allow comparison between different curve types and curves at different apical levels.

Results: For a given Cobb angle, each of AVR, AVT and max ATI are largest in King type IV curves, less in King type III curves and smallest in King type II curves (p=0.001 to 0.015). For curves without a significant compensatory curve, for a given AVR, the max ATI reduces significantly as the curve apex passes caudally (p=0.002 to 0.019). Sex and curve laterality are not significant factors.

Conclusion: It is suggested that as a curve develops, the interaction between the measurements in different planes may be responsible for determining the curve type (presence or absence of a compensatory curve). The smaller surface hump as the curve apex passes caudally is probably due to the transition from fixed ribs to floating ribs to no ribs. These finding also have implications for surgery. In King type IV and III curves, the emphasis should be on correcting translation and derotation perhaps with a primary costoplasty whilst in King type II curves, the emphasis should be on the correct selection of fusion levels and achieving a balanced spine.


P H Dangerfield R.C. Davey N Chockalingam T Cochrane J C Dorgan

Background: To compare height-adjusted fat and fat-free mass components of body composition in girls with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis to young adolescents with eating disorders. Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) has been linked with low bone densities. Animal and human studies have shown that bone densities are influenced by a wide variety of inter-related factors that includes body fat, oestrogen levels, nutritional status and energy balance. Anthropometric studies have reported girls with AIS as being taller and more slender than their age-matched peers and that they also exhibit complex patterns of body asymmetry, particularly in the upper limb. There are also some studies report eating disorders in this population.

Methods: Height-adjusted fat and fat-free mass components of body composition were examined. Fat mass index (FMI) and fat-free mass index (FFMI) were calculated and normalised for height and were superimposed onto UK 1990 growth reference data. The data for left and right limb length was also compared. A sample of 325 girls with AIS referred to the specialist spinal unit in Liverpool during the period 1970–1990.

Results: The fat mass index and fat-free mass index were reduced in this sample of AIS subjects compared with normal reference children, but were similar to those diagnosed with eating disorders (anorexia nervosa). The cohort also exhibited significant upper limb asymmetry.

Conclusion: The findings suggest that this population has significantly low fat mass compared to normal, healthy reference values. Since fat mass reflects energy balance, nutritional status (possibly eating disorders) and is closely linked to endocrine function, the implications of reduced fat mass on growth, bone mass accretion and the aetiology of AIS merit further investigation.


S.C. Daivajna C.I. Adams S.M.H. Mehdian

Background: To analyse the effects of surgery on sagittal alignment1 in patients with severe Scheuermann’s kyphosis. To assess the ability of two surgical techniques to prevent loss of correction in the thoracic kyphosis. To assess factors of patient’s Body Mass Index (BMI) and instrumentation level on the risk of adjacent level kyphosis or pullout.

Methods: A retrospective study of 13 consecutive cases of rigid Scheuermann’s kyphosis. Group A: 6 patients with anterior interbody cages. GroupB: 7 patients with interbody autogenous rib graft. All patients were instrumented posteriorly from T2 to L2. Radiographs from initial presentation, pre-operatively, post-operatively and at final follow –up were assessed. The thoracic kyphosis, lumbar lordosis, sagittal balance2 and sacral inclination were measured.

Results: There were 7 males and 6 females with a mean age of 22 years (range 15 to 38yrs). The mean follow-up was 26 months (range 7 to 53 mths). In Group A: the mean preoperative kyphosis was 87° (range 82° to 92° ) and postoperative kyphosis was 45° (range 38° to 60°). The mean loss of correction was 0.3° (range 0° to2°). In Group B: the mean preoperative kyphosis was 83° (range 70° to 100°) while the postoperative kyphosis was 43° (range 30° to 60°). The mean loss of correction was 1.1° (range 0°to 2°) at final follow-up. The mean lumbar lordosis pre-operatively for all patients was 66° (range 62° to 84°) reducing to 48° (range 34° to 82°) following surgery. The mean sacral inclination pre-operatively was 41° (range 18° to 80°) reducing to 32 °(range 14°to 40°) following surgery. The mean sagittal balance preoperatively was −1.1 cm (range +0.1 to −3.5). It reduced postoperatively to −2.2 cm (range +1.5 to −4 cm) and was −1.6cm (range +0.2 to – 3.5cm) at final follow- up. Three patients with BMI greater than 25 had an increased lumbar lordosis at final follow up, with one case of implant failure and 2 cases with lower junctional kyphosis. No patient had an upper thoracic junctional kyphosis. There was no evidence of neurological compromise.

Conclusion: Patients had a mean thoracic kyphosis correction of 41° (49%). This was maintained during follow-up with no significant difference between autograft and cages. Cranially, all patients had instrumentation to T2 and there was no junctional kyphosis. Caudally, three obese patients (BMI > 25) suffered screw pullout (1 patient) or junctional kyphosis (2 patients). Instrumentation to L3 may avoid this complication in this patient group. The lumbar lordosis and sacral inclination reduced immediately postoperatively, with further correction at final follow –up.


J. Bernard S. Molloy P. Hamilton A. Saifuddin

Background: The incidence of neurological symptoms due to spinal stenosis in patients with achondroplasia is reported to be as great as 38%1. These symptoms most commonly occur in the 4th decade and myelography and CT myelography are most commonly described in evaluation of the stenosis. Difficulty arises in localisation of stenosis in patients presenting with neurological deficit2. The value of MRI of the cervicomedullary junction has been reported in achondroplasia but it has not yet been evaluated in the investigation of spinal stenotic symptoms. The aim of this study was to review our experience of whole spine imaging in patients with achondroplasia that presented with symptoms and signs of neurological deficit.

Methods: We retrospectively reviewed the clinical notes and radiological imaging of 10 consecutive achondroplastic patients (3F:7M, mean age 31.7 years, range 13 to 60yrs) that presented to our unit with neurological compromise between 1998 and 2003. All patients had whole spine MRI at the time of presentation. Recorded from the notes were age and sex, and whether symptom pattern was radiculopathy, claudication or paresis. All radiological levels of stenosis on MRI were documented.

Results: Four patients presented with spinal paresis, four with neurogenic claudication, and two with radiculopathy. MRI confirmed that each patient had at least one region (cervical, thoracic or lumbar) of significant spinal stenosis. In six of the patients an additional region of significant stenosis was identified. All ten patients had lumbar stenosis but this was only the primary site in six of the ten. In the other four patients two had the dominant stenosis in the thoracic spine, one in the cervical spine and one at the foramen magnum – the clinical symptoms correlated with the dominant site in each of these four cases.

Conclusion: MRI was a useful tool for assessment of neurological compromise in the patients with achondroplasia in our study. All ten patients had classical lumbar stenosis on MRI but this was only the dominant site of stenosis in six of the ten cases. The MRI and clinical findings need to be evaluated together to ensure correct surgical treatment.


A.I. Tsirikos M.J. McMaster

Background: Congenital anomalies of the chest wall and Sprengel’s shoulder are often associated with congenital deformities of the spine. It has been suggested that extensive rib fusions on the concavity of a congenital scoliosis may adversely affect progression of the spine deformity, thoracic function and growth of the lungs, which can lead to a thoracic insufficiency syndrome.

Methods: This is a retrospective study of the medical records and spine radiographs of 620 consecutive patients with congenital spine deformities. The rib anomalies were classified into simple and complex and the presence of a Sprengel’s shoulder was recorded.

Subjects: There were 497 patients (80%) with scoliosis, 88 patients (14%) with kyphoscoliosis, and 35 patients with kyphosis (6%). The mean rate of scoliosis deterioration without treatment, age and curve size at surgery was compared for the different types of vertebral abnormalities in patients with and without rib anomalies.

Results: Rib anomalies occurred in 124 patients. The rib anomalies were simple in 97 patients (78%) and complex in 27 (22%). The most common simple rib anomaly (70 patients; 72%) was a fusion of two or three ribs. The most common complex rib anomaly (20 patients; 74%) was a fusion of multiple ribs associated with a large chest wall defect. Rib anomalies were most commonly associated with a congenital scoliosis (116 patients; 93.6%), and much less frequently with a congenital kyphoscoliosis or kyphosis (8 patients). In those patients with a scoliosis, the rib anomalies were simple in 91 patients (78.5%) and complex in 25 patients (21.5%). Eighty-eight of the 124 patients (76%) with rib abnormalities had a scoliosis due to a unilateral unsegmented bar with or without contra-lateral hemivertebrae at the same level, and 8 patients had mixed unclassifiable vertebral anomalies. In contrast, only 17 patients with a scoliosis and rib anomalies had hemivertebrae alone. The rib anomalies were most frequently associated with a thoracic or thoracolumbar scoliosis (107 patients; 92.2%) and occurred on the concavity in 81 patients (70%), convexity in 27 patients (23%), and were bilateral in 8 patients. Sprengel’s deformity occurred in 45 patients; 43 patients with congenital scoliosis (8.6%), and 2 with kyphoscoliosis or kyphosis. A Sprengel’s shoulder occurred most frequently in association with a thoracic scoliosis due to a unilateral failure of vertebral segmentation (28 patients). The elevated shoulder was on the concavity of scoliosis in 26 patients and on the convexity in 16 patients. We compared the mean rate of curve progression without treatment, the age and curve size at spine surgery for the different types of spine deformities in patients with and without rib anomalies either simple or complex and found no significant difference (p> 0.05); the only statistical difference was that the mean age at surgery was higher for patients with a unilateral unsegmented bar without rib anomalies (p=0.005).

Conclusion: Congenital rib anomalies and Sprengel’s shoulder occur most commonly on the concavity of a thoracic or thoracolumbar congenital scoliosis due to a unilateral failure of vertebral segmentation. However, these anomalies do not have an adverse effect on curve size or rate of progression.


A Ohlin

Background: Patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) exceeding fifty degrees or more at maturity are at risk for continuous progression. For curves in the thoracolumbar or lumbar region vertebral olisthesis, with severe low back pain with or without radicular pain, may result. Conventional techniques with anterior, posterior or combined approaches often fail to achieve a good alignment. The technique described by Bradford employing a shortening osteotomy at the apical segments can be used in very stiff curves with translations.

Methods: Three women with AIS and successive curve deterioration were treated by means of shortening osteotomy at our institution. The mean age was 40 (48–35) years and the follow up was 26 (60–8) months. The resected vertebrae were L1 in two cases and L2 in one. The operations were staged, initially anterior discectomies were performed. A flap of the vertebral wall was then raised and a total resection of the vertebral body and the convex pedicle was undertaken. After protection of the dual sac with a Spongostan film, the harvested bone was impacted into the defect. One week later, the remnants of the vertebra were removed posteriorly following temporary stabilization. Correction was achieved by compression.

Results: Two osteotomies united and the patients are pain free, in good balance and back at work. The other case had a temporary partial drop foot on one side, however radiographically is progressing well and she remains in rehabilitation. There have been no implant related complications.

Conclusion: Shortening osteotomy appears to be a good technique when treating adult patients with late rigid, painful scoliotic deformities of the thoracolumbar region.


M Al-Maiyah J Mehta D Fender M J Gibson

Background: To evaluate bone mineral density in patients with scoliosis of different causes and compare it to the expected values for the age, gender and body mass.

Methods: A Prospective, observational case series. From October 2003 to December 2004, Bone Mineral Density (BMD) of patients with different types of Scoliosis was recorded. Patients listed for corrective spinal surgery in our institute were included in the study (Total of 68 patients). BMD on lumbar spine and whole body was measured by DXA scan and recorded in form of Z-scores. Z-scores = number of Standard Deviations (SD) above or below age matched norms; it is age and gender specific standard deviation scores. Data collected using the same DXA scan equipment and software.

There were 29 patients with Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis and 7 patients with congenital or infantile scoliosis. Z-scores from patients with neuromuscular scoliosis also included, 10 patients with cerebral palsy and 11 with muscular dystrophies (mainly Duchenne MD). There were also 3 patients with Neurofbromatosis and 8 patients with other conditions (miscellaneous). Outcome measures were bone mineral density in patients with different types of scoliosis in form of Z-scores.

Results: Bone mineral density was significantly lower than normal for the age, gender and body mass in all patients with neuromuscular scoliosis; whole body z-score in group with cerebral palsy was −1.00 and −1.30 in muscular dystrophies group. Lumbar spine BMD was even lower in lumbar spine, mean z-score, – 4.51 in cerebral palsy and −2.36 in muscular dystrophies (mainly Duchenne MD). In idiopathic Scoliosis group mean BMD was markedly lower than normal for the age, gender and body mass, mean z-score = – 1.87, however whole body BMD was within the normal range, mean z-score = +0.124. Similar results were found in congenital and infantile scoliosis group, mean lumber z-score= – 1.36 and whole body z-score, – 0.30. In patients with neurofibromatosis, there were low BMD on spine, mean z-score was −1.19 while whole body z-score was + 0.19. In group of patients with other miscellaneous causes of scoliosis or syndromic scoliosis lumbar mean z-score= −2.22 and whole body mean z-score was −1.67.

Conclusion: This study showed that BMD on spine was lower than normal for the age, gender and body mass in all patients with scoliosis and the condition was even worse in neuromuscular and sydromic scoliosis. There was no correlation between spine BMD and whole body BMD. Spine BMD was lower than normal in almost all patients even when whole body BMD was within normal range. Thus we believe that DXA scan is a useful adjunct in the preoperative assessment of scoliotic patients prior to spinal surgery.


D Chan

Background: We report on the surgical treatment of a case spinal neuroarthropathy, where surgical fusion of the pathological level was achieved by a shortening osteotomy and apposition of the adjacent vertebral bodies. Neuropathic (Charcot) arthropathy of the spine is relatively an uncommon problem. Spinal neuroarthropathy has been described to occur after traumatic paralysis as well as other causes of neuropathic arthropathy. Surgery has been recommended for the treatment of painful or unstable neuropathic joints of the spine. From the few cases that have been reported in the literature, surgical management included extensive debridement, bridging of the defect with autogenous graft as well as instrumentation to achieve an anterior and posterior fusion. To the knowledge of the authors, the technique of spine shortening and vertebral apposition was reported only once in the literature, however the patient had to be kept recumbent in a cast for six months. (1)

Methods: Literature review and a case of spinal neuroarthropathy successfully treated by a shortening osteotomy and instrumented arthrodesis is presented.

Results: Patient was allowed to mobilize in his wheelchair by the second week post operation with a support of a TLSO, which was used for five months. Roentgenograms and CT scan done at thirteen months showed good position of the spine and evidence of solid bone arthrodesis. This matched marked clinical improvement in the preoperative symptoms.

Conclusion: Treatment of a Charcot affection of the spine should be directed toward vertebral stabilization to eliminate the pathological effects and complications secondary to instability. Sound arthrodesis in our case could be achieved with resection of the affected level(s), shortening of the spine and good apposition of fresh bleeding bone surfaces. Careful attention to the demanding surgical technique is required. Yet, any fusion procedure poses additional stresses to the adjacent levels. So long term monitoring of the rehabilitation is mandatory to detect the possibility of developing secondary levels of Charcot joints below a previously successful fusion.


S.C. Daivajna A. Jones S.M.H. Mehdian

Background: A 9- year-old child with osteogenesis imperfecta and severe cervical kyphosis associated with wedged vertebrae and progressive neurological deterioration is presented. There is no report of upper cervical kyphosis associated with wedged vertebrae in osteogenesis imperfecta in the literature. We discuss the methods and difficulties in the surgical management of this condition and to highlight the appropriate surgical approach.

Methods: Methods:A 9-year-old girl presented with progressive cervical kyphosis and quadriparesis. At the age of 3 years she underwent posterior cervical fusion (C1–C6) for instability and deformity. Radiological and laboratory investigations confirmed the diagnosis of osteogenesis imperfecta. Radiographs of the cervical spine revealed a kyphotic deformity of 120° Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) and Computerised Tomography (CT) scans showed anterior cord compression due to wedged vertebrae at C3 and C4. MRI-Angiography was performed pre-operatively to identify the anatomical position of the vertebral arteries. A modified anterolateral approach to the upper cervical spine was performed. Anterior C3 and C4 corpectomies with interbody fusion with cage and plate fixation was carried out.

Results: Postoperatively the patient made a full neurological recovery and significant correction of the deformity was achieved and correction was maintained at final follow-up.

Conclusion: Cervical kyphotic deformity in Osteogenesis Imperfecta is uncommon. Association of this condition with wedged vertebrae is rare. Surgical decompression of the upper cervical spine with severe kyphosis is a challenging problem. Which surgical approach should be used is controversial? There are difficulties exposing wedged vertebrae by a standard anterior or chin split approach to perform vertebrectomy. Costo-transversectomy has been used successfully in patients with Gibbous deformity in the thoracic spine but due the presence of vertebral artery in the cervical spine posterolateral approach is impossible. We have used a modified anterolateral approach to overcome this problem. Spinal stabilisation in children with Osteogenesis Imperfecta and poor bone quality is another challenge. We have used a small diameter MOSS cage with maxillofacial plate and screws to achieve stabilisation and fusion. The purpose of this report is to highlight the importance of diagnosis of progressive cervical kyphotic deformity in children with osteogenesis imperfecta and also to describe the difficulties encountered with surgical management of this condition.


A Jackowski

Background: A novel, elastomeric total cervical disc replacement is currently undergoing clinical evaluation in an MHRA approved Multicentre European study. At the time of abstract submission seven patients have been implanted with the device. The device is a two component one consisting of an inner core of medical grade silastic enveloped in an outer jacket of embroidered polyester that replicates the annulus, posterior and anterior longitudinal ligaments.

Methods: The pre-clinical testing of the device included biomechanical, biocompatibility and mechanical fatigue testing have previously been reported at the 2002 Spine Arthroplasty Society meeting in Montpellier. At the time of abstract submission seven patients have been implanted with the device. The clinical trial is a prospective, non-randomized observational study. Patients are followed for a period of two years. VAS pain scores, SF36, NDI and European myelopathy scores, patient satisfaction and detailed radiographic assessments are collected preoperatively, at 4 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, 1 and 2 years postoperatively.

Results: Seven patients (2 female, 5 male) have been implanted at the time of abstract submission. All cases were single level surgeries (C3/C4-1, C5/C6-2, C6/C7-4). Operation time ranged from 55-104 minutes. Blood loss averaged less than 15mls. The NeoDisc implant is very straightforward to implant with no special instrumentation. The lack of any metal components has allowed postoperative MRI and CT scanning to be performed with virtually no artefact present and excellent visualisation of cord and root detail. All patients reported pain intensity reductions. Pain decreased from 4.6 to 1.4 for neck pain and from 6.5 to 0.9 for arm pain on a 10-point scale.

Conclusion: A clinical success rate of 83% was achieved (clinical success being defined as a patient rating of excellent or very good on a 6-point patient self-scoring outcome scale).


J Chitnis H V Dabke DAS Jones S Ahuja J Howes P R Davies

Background: Although either anterior or posterior corrective scoliosis surgery has been reported in Jehovah’s Witnesses, we did not find any reports of single stage combined anterior and posterior scoliosis surgery being done in these patients. We report our experience in one such case.

Methods: This is a case report of a 14 year old female Jehovah’s Witness who had cerebral palsy with total body involvement presented with right sided thoracolumbar scoliosis. She was wheel chair bound and was being treated in a spinal brace. She had a partially correctible thoracolumbar curve from T5 to L2 measuring 94°, which reduced to 74° in brace. Her parents were counselled regarding scoliosis surgery. They consented for the surgery and also signed a special consent form for Jehovah’s witnesses specifying that they would prefer their child not to have transfusion of blood or blood products under any circumstances. They were explained that in case of excessive bleeding, further surgery may need to be deferred.

Results: Although her pre-op Haemoglobin was 14.3 g/dl, she was given oral ferrous sulphate because of low serum ferritin level (34 mcg/L). After induction of anaesthesia, intra operative hemodilution was performed using 900 ml of crystalloid. During surgery aprotinin infusion was used with controlled hypotension and cell salvage. Anterior release was performed followed by posterior instrumentation. The operation lasted for 8 hours. Central venous pressure and arterial oxygen saturation remained stable throughout the operation. She recovered well following surgery, with post-operative haemoglobin of 9.8 g/dl and was discharged on the7th post-operative day. Oral iron supplementation has been continued after surgery.

Conclusion: Due to religious reasons, Jehovah’s Witnesses do not accept transfusion of blood and blood products, which makes major surgery like scoliosis correction difficult as it involves a significant amount of blood loss. Such patients benefit from pre-operative iron supplementation, pre-operative haemodilution, intraoperative hemodilution, cell salvage, use of Factor 7, aprotinin and erythropoietin. These modalities have made it possible to perform major operations like scoliosis surgery in this group of patients.


Full Access
D Williams L Lougher A Mukherji S Ahuja

Background: There has been an exponential rise in Internet use over recent years with over 11 million homes in the United Kingdom currently having access to the Internet. Previous studies have shown that up to 50% of orthopaedic outpatients have researched their condition on the Internet and that this percentage is dependent upon the condition from which they are suffering. The aim of our study was therefore to assess the prevalence of Internet usage among three groups of orthopaedic outpatients and to further determine how the patients felt their Internet research compared to the information received at consultation.

Methods: Data was collected from 150 patients / parents attending three outpatient clinics; 50 consecutive patients attending scoliosis clinic; 50 patients attending paediatric orthopaedic clinic; 50 patients attending back pain clinic.

Results: 58% of scoliosis, 22% of general paediatric and 30% of back pain patients had researched their condition on the Internet. 83% of scoliosis, 64% of paediatric and 80% of back pain patients found this information useful. Nearly all patients, however, would trust their doctor more than the Internet.

Conclusion: We believe therefore that clinicians need to keep up to date with information available on the Inter-net and provide recommended websites to patients wishing to consolidate their knowledge of their condition.


T. Williams D. Williams S. Ahuja A. Jones J. Howes P. Davies

Background: More patients are turning to the Internet for health-related information. Studies indicate that this information is being used to make decisions about their management. The aim of this study was to assess the information available specific to scoliosis on the Web using four common search engines.

Methods: Four search engines (Google, Yahoo, Hotmail and Ask Jeeves) were used in scanning the Web for the following key word- “Scoliosis”. Both U.K. only and World Wide sites were accessed. Four Spinal Surgery Consultants independently graded each site for layout, content, relevance to patients as opposed to medical professionals, ease of use and links to other sites. Each point was marked on a scale of 0–2 and a total of 10 points available. Web sites were assessed via U.K. search engines and forty via World Wide search engines. Good was awarded to a site with a score of 7–10; an average awarded for a score of 4–7 and poor was given to a site with a score of 0–4.

Results: For the U.K. search engines, twenty sites were evaluated and five common sites identified (spineuniverse.com, S.A.U.K.org, orthoteers.co.uk, B.O.A.ac. uk and scoilosis.info). From these sites only two were given a rating of good. For the World Wide Web search engines eighteen sites evaluated and seven common sites identified (SRS, spineuniverse.com, scoliosis.org, orthinfo.aaos.org, iscoliosis.com, scoliosisrx.com and scoliosis-world.com). From these sites four were given a rating of good. It was evident that the Scoliosis Association of United Kingdom did not appear in three of the search engines but only in Hotmail.

Conclusion: These results suggest that there are good sites available for patients to access information with regards to their condition and treatment options but there are also very poor sites available where incorrect information is available. Commonly, unfamiliar users of the Web will not search U.K. sites specifically and could easily miss the S.A.U.K. site, which is an excellent site and was one of the two sites via the U.K. search engine awarded a good score. Obviously, there were more good sites via the World Wide Web due to the American healthcare system. We recommend that leaflets should be available to parents and patients with scoliosis with information from the BSS of the condition and available Web sites with good ratings. Also we recommend that these sites be linked to the Royal College of General Practitioners Web site to provide reference on good practice.


S. Molloy J. Langdon R. Harrison B. A. Taylor

Background: Sacral tumours are commonly diagnosed late and therefore are often large and at an advanced stage before treatment is instituted. The late presentation means that curative surgical excision is technically demanding1. Total en-bloc sacrectomy is fraught with potential complications: deep infection, substantial blood loss, large bone and soft tissue defects, bladder, bowel and sexual dysfunction, spinal-pelvic non-union, and gait disturbance2. The aim of the current study was two-fold: firstly to detail the technique used by the senior author and chronicle how this has evolved; and secondly to present the complications and outcome of nine total en bloc sacrectomies.

Methods: We retrospectively analysed of total en-bloc sacrectomies between 1991 and 2004. Nine patients (2M, 7F, mean age at surgery 39 years, range 21 – 64yrs) with a diagnosis of primary sacral tumour underwent total en-bloc sacrectomy under the care of the senior author. The mean follow-up was 50.2 months (range: 3.5 – 161 mths). Patients’ functional outcome was evaluated using the Functional Independence Measure (FIM) instrument and the SF-36. Intra-operative and postoperative complications (including disease progression) were documented.

Results: Surgical technique has evolved from single stage surgery without and with colostomy to two stage surgery with colostomy. Currently, the first stage includes an anterior lumbar interbody fusion at L4/L5 retaining the L5 nerve roots. In the second stage an L4 to pelvic fusion is performed posteriorally. The dura is tied and divided just below the L5 roots. The mean total operating time was 13.3 hrs (range: 8 – 20.1hrs); the mean total blood loss 14.1 ltrs (range: 4.2 – 33 ltrs). There were two revision L4 to pelvic fusions for pseudoarthroses. The mean length of hospital stay was 8.9mths (range: 2 – 36mths). One patient had a recurrence and died 2 years after her surgery. Of the surviving 8 patients the results from the functional outcome scores were variable. Three patients are able to walk independently; the remaining 5 are all mobile but require differing degrees of assistance to walk.

Conclusion: Total en bloc sacrectomy is a major surgical undertaking but our series has shown that it is probably justified in view of the fact that 8 out of 9 patients have had no tumour recurrence and all are able to walk.


J Yu

Background: The intervertebral disc has a highly organised collagen network (1) which has an important role in regulating the mechanical properties of the tissue. A recent study of bovine discs has also revealed an abundant and organised elastic fibre network (2) indicating that elastic fibres could play an important mechanical role. The aim of this study was to describe changes in organisation of the collagen and elastin fibre networks in scoliotic relative to normal discs.

Methods: Intact wedges of intervertebral disc were obtained from patients undergoing routine spinal surgery where the disc was removed by an anterior approach. Frozen sections were cut and examined as described in detail elsewhere (2). Briefly, they were digested with hyaluronidase to remove glycosaminoglycans. Micrographs of the sections were examined by polarised light to visualise collagen organisation. The elastic fibre network was visualised by histochemical staining with orcein or immunohistochemically. We examined 9 discs from 6 scoliotic patients (12–22y), ranging in level from T1 0/11 to L4/L5; three had adolescent idiopathic scoliosis and three neuromuscular scoliosis. We also examined 4 discs from a 12 year old female patient with a spinal tumour not affecting the discs, and 2 discs from a 17 year female patient who had discs removed as the result of trauma.

Results: The ‘control’ discs showed a highly organised collagen network arranged in regular lamellae as described previously (1). A highly organised elastic fibre network, similar to that described in bovine discs (2) was also revealed in the ‘control’ human discs. Dense elastic fibres were located between adjacent lamellae of the annulus. Elastic fibres appeared to be long (> 100μm) and straight in outer annulus and were at angle of approximately 600 or 1200 to those in adjacent lamellae in the inner annulus. Elastic fibre bridges crossing the lamellae perpendicularly or obliquely were observed. In scoliotic discs however, the organisation of the collagen network was grossly disturbed with marked loss of lamellar structure. Elastic fibres were very sparse and the elastic fibre networks were highly disorganised in all regions. Cell clusters, typical of disc degeneration, were seen in scoliotic but not in age-matched ‘control’ discs.

Conclusion: Our results reveal an abundant and organised network of elastic fibres in the young (12–17yr) human intervertebral disc. The localisation of these fibres in the inter-lamellar space suggests that the elastic fibre network plays a significant biomechanical role. This network is sparse and disrupted in scoliotic discs; loss of network integrity could affect disc biomechanical function adversely and could be involved in the progression of the spinal deformity.


P Katrana JR Crawford S Vowler A Lilikakis RN Villar

Aims: Resurfacing arthroplasty of the hip is increasing in popularity. Recently concerns have been raised about resorbtion of the femoral neck after hip resurfacing, which may increase the risk of femoral neck fracture. We conducted a study to assess the degree of femoral neck resorbtion after using a cemented femoral component at hip resurfacing arthroplasty and to compare this with an uncemented femoral component.

Patients and Methods: We included 130 patients who had undergone a hip resurfacing arthroplasty in our study. Our uncemented group included 70 consecutive patients who had received an uncemented Cormet hip resurfacing arthroplasty (Corin, Cirencester, UK). Our cemented group included 60 patients who had received a cemented Birmingham hip resurfacing arthroplasty (Smith and Nephew, Cambridge, UK). All patients were regularly followed up for a minimum of two years. Clinical outcome was assessed using Harris hip scores. Femoral neck resorbtion was assessed by measuring the cup-neck ratio on post-operative radiographs by two independent observers.

Results: The mean age of the patients was 50.7 years for the cemented resurfacing group and 51.5 years for the uncemented resurfacing group. No difference was found in Harris hip scores between the two groups at any of the follow-up periods. The overall survival rate at two years was 100% for the cemented group and 98.6% for the uncemented group. There was however, a significant increase in femoral neck resorbtion for the cemented resurfacing group compared to the uncemented resurfacing group (median cup-neck ratio 1.11 vs. 1.04), p< 0.0001

Conclusion: We found a significant increase in femoral neck resorbtion with the use of a cemented femoral component at hip resurfacing arthroplasty compared with an uncemented femoral component. This may increase the risk of femoral neck fracture and could affect the long-term outcome if a cemented femoral component is used.


MHA Malik BM Wroblewski PR Kay

Introduction: We describe the association between postoperative femoral stem radiological appearances and aseptic failure of THA (total hip arthroplasty).

Methods: A retrospective review of records and radiographs of all patients attending for follow-up between August 2002 and August 2003 who had a cemented Charnley femoral stem and either a cemented polyethylene acetabular cup inserted. Femoral stem aseptic loosening was defined either by findings at revision surgery, the definite radiographic loosening criteria of Harris or progressive endosteal cavitation across zones as described by Gruen. Well-fixed control THA’s were defined as those that demonstrated none of the radiographic features of aseptic loosening or ‘at risk’ signs as described by Wroblewski. Parameters measured were: Alignment, Barrack grade of cementation, cement mantle width of the cement mantle and the presence and width of any radiolucent lines

Results: 63 hips were entered into the aseptic failure group and 138 into the control group. The alignment of the femoral stem was not associated with failure (p=0.283). Thickness of the cement mantle was statistically associated with failure in Gruen zones 6 (p=0.040) and Gruen zone 7 (p=0.003). A significant association for the presence of radiolucent lines was found for Gruen zones 3 (p=0.0001) and 5 (p=0.0001). The grade of cementation as measured by the Barrack grade was strongly associated with failure for grades C (p=0.001) and D (p=0.001).

Discussion and conclusion: This study has demonstrated that easily applied radiological criteria can be used to identify ‘at risk’ Charnley THA’s from the immediate post-operative AP radiograph.


Professor BM Wroblewski PD Siney PA Fleming

We report the results of our continued review of 11 hip arthroplasties using 22.225mm alumina ceramic femoral heads (CCH) on a Charnley flanged stem articulating with a chemically cross-linked polyethylene (XLPE) cup. The initial bedding-in of up to 0.41mm, which was reached within about 2 years, has not progressed further with a follow up to 18.1 years. The mean total penetration of the XLPE cup for this group of patients is 0.31mm (0 – 0.41) and a penetration rate of 0.019 mm/year (mean 0 – 0.026). One patient with CCH/XLPE arthroplasty on the left side and a conventional metal on ultra high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) on the right side, has a ten fold difference in total penetration: 0.41mm compared with 4.1mm and a year shorter follow-up.

The mean age of the 9 patients (11 hips) attending was 47.2 years (26–58) at the operation and is now 64 years (42–73). Clinical results remain excellent with freedom from pain and normal activity level appropriate to their age and gender.

Radiographically none of the cups or stems show evidence of loosening or osteolysis and there have been no problems that could have been attributed to the materials or the design used.


Professor BM Wroblewski PD Siney PA Fleming

Triple-tapered cemented polished C-Stem has evolved from the study of long-term results of the Charnley low-frictional torque arthroplasty when the first fractured stem and then proximal strain shielding of the femur and stem loosening were identified as the continuation of the same process: lack or loss of proximal stem support.

The C-Stem, by the concept, design and the surgical technique, caters for a limited slip of the stem within the cement mantle transferring the load more proximally. With a follow-up past 10 years and 3299 primary procedures there have been no revisions for aseptic stem loosening and no stem is radiologically loose.

Four hundred and forty eight patients had 500 LFAs using the C-Stem with the longest follow-up: 256 women and 192 men; 52 patients had bilateral LFAs. The patients’ mean age at surgery was 55.5 years (range 17–89 years) and at a mean follow-up of 5.2 years.

There was an overall improvement in the clinical outcome graded according to d’Aubigne and Postel for pain, function and movement from 3.1, 2.9 and 2.8 to 5.9, 5.7 and 5.5 respectively.

A good quality proximal femur had been maintained in 56.8% and improved in 21.8%.

The results are encouraging and support the concept but place a demand on the understanding of the technique and its execution at surgery.


SM Hussain K Barnett DF Finlayson

Total hip replacement using components from different manufactures is common and has been known as cross-breed arthroplasty. The implant industry clearly advises against it for primary arthroplasty, even though this has been the accepted practice in revision hip surgery. The response of the Medicine and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency is to agree with the manufacturers. Thus this advice has been implemented in National Institute of Clinical Excellence guidelines without any supportive clinical data.

A consecutive series of 206 crossbreed total hip arthroplasties were performed in 192 patients by a single surgeon between 1990 and 1993. These were observed for an average 11.5 years (range, 10–13years). There were 126 women and 80 men with an average age of 69 (range, 41–89) at the time of surgery. There were 9 failures defined as reoperation. Of these, 5 were for aseptic loosening of cup, 2 for deep infection, 1 for recurrent dislocation and 1 for revision of stem for Periprosthetic fracture following a fall. There was no aseptic loosening of stem. With survivorship to date of 94% these data suggest that it is safe to continue using at least one of the common combinations in primary hip arthroplasty.


Mr A Rafee Mr G J Mclauchlan Dr R Gilbert Mr D Herlekar

Background Elevated plasma levels of D-dimer have been found to be a useful screening tool in the diagnosis of deep venous thrombosis (DVT) in the general population. In the postoperative setting however their role is less clear.

In approximately 73% of NHS trusts D-dimer is a prerequisite test prior to radiological imaging to diagnose DVT.

This study evaluates the effectiveness of D-dimer as a screening tool for DVT in the postoperative period following total hip and knee arthroplasty.

Method Plasma D-dimer levels were measured pre operatively and on post-operative days 1, 3, 5, and 7 in 78 patients undergoing primary total hip or knee arthroplasty. On day 7 patients underwent bilateral duplex ultrasound scanning in order to confirm the absence of DVT.

All patients wore pneumatic foot pumps for DVT prophylaxis. Chemical thromboprophylaxis was not used. All patients were under the care of one surgeon with the same postoperative regimen.

Results D-dimer levels in the post-operative period were characterized by a double peak, on days 1 and 7. Mean day 1 value 3.63 (sd=2.72, range 0.60–14.34), mean day 7 value 2.83 (sd=1.58, range 1.10–10.30). Mean values on days 3 and 5 were 2.52 (sd=2.26, range 0.50–11.85) and 2.45 (sd=1.41, range 0.91–5.05)

Comparing D-dimer levels between hip and knee arthroplasty we found that both groups displayed the same trend in post-operative D-dimer levels (i.e. peaks at days 1 and 7); however levels were significantly higher following knee replacement (At day 7 p< 0.005)

We compared D-dimer levels of these patients with a second group of 43 patients who had a confirmed DVT following hip or knee arthroplasty. The mean D-dimer level in this group was 2.20 (sd=0.98 or range 0.80 – 4.46). This group was subdivided into two groups, those with D-dimer samples before (and including) day 7 and those after. We found a significant difference between the groups (p=0.01). Mean ≤ day 7 = 2.70. Mean > day 7 = 1.97.

The group of patients with Confirmed DVT on or before day 7 were compared with those free of clot. There was no significant difference found between the D-dimer levels of the two groups. (p=0.37)

Conclusion The D-dimer level is never normal (< 0.4mg/l), in the week following total hip or knee replacement and so cannot exclude a DVT. The level it rises to is indistinguishable form that seen in the population with a DVT and so cannot identify those patients in whom further investigation is warranted. Requesting a D-dimer test in this population wastes time and resources and is of no benefit.


NA Siddiqui P Mohandas SK Muirhead-Allwood

Here we present the results of functional outcome of 531 patients (aged from 27.6 to 88.7, mean 62.6) who have had the Trilogy (Zimmer; Warsaw IN, USA) acetabular shell implanted for 5 years or longer. All patients operated at our unit between 20/1/1992 and 31/3/2004 were included, looking at both Primary (431) and Revision (100) hip arthroplasties. All surgery was performed by the senior surgeon using the Trilogy shell and liners. The Trilogy acetabular shell was used with either an ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene liner or ceramic liner, along with a wide variety of femoral stems, mainly: Harris Pre-coat stem (183 patients, Zimmer), Versys cemented stem (102 pts, Zimmer), CADCAM (140 pts, Stanmore), and HAC Furlong (96 pts, JRI). There were a variety of other stems, including Exeter and Pro-femur. 48 patients had revision of socket only.

Functional outcome was assessed by three questionnaires: the Oxford Hip Questionnaire (12 best function-60 worst), the Harris Hip Score (100 best to 0 worst), and the WOMAC Hip Score (0 best-96 worst).

Patients filled in these questionnaires at every postoperative follow-up clinic. These were compared with the pre-operative scores obtained from questionnaires which the patients completed retrospectively. Mean follow up questionnaire times were 76.5 months postoperatively for primary arthroplasties, and 70.6 months for the revision arthroplasties.

For primary arthroplasty mean scores improved from 40.8 pre-operatively to 16.4 post-operatively (Oxford), 43.9 to 92.9 (Harris), and 51.8 to 9.4 (WOMAC) (all p< 0.05). For revision arthroplasty mean scores improved from 39.1, 41.7, and 49.3 pre-operatively to 19.6, 88.0, and 12.5 (all p< 0.05).

No patients required re-operation for loosening, one patient dislocated at day 5.

We can conclude that the Trilogy acetabular component is a versatile acetabular implant which can be used with a wide range of femoral components, both in primary and revision Total Hip Arthroplasty, with successful functional outcome scores greater than 5 years after implantation.


Mr RJK Khan Mr D Fick Dr P Khoo Dr F Yao Prof B Nivbrant Prof D Wood

Introduction We believe minimally invasive surgery should be defined by the extent of soft tissue dissection rather than incision length. We describe a new technique that is truly soft-tissue sparing and report our early results.

The surgical approach The landmarks for the incision are identified and an incision is made over the posterior aspect of the greater trochanter. Piriformis is preserved. A capsular repair is performed through drill holes into bone. There are no restrictions to mobility. No specialised instruments are required.

Method The standard posterior approach (group 1) was compared with the PSMI approach (group 2) in a prospective cohort study of 200 consecutive patients over 60 years of age. Patients were scored pre-operatively and followed up prospectively, by a blinded observer.

Results Mean operation time was about 1 hour in both groups. Mean incision length was 21.5 cm in group 1 and 8.4cm in group 2. Mean blood loss in group 1 was significantly higher than group 2 (P< 0.0001). Mean inpatient stay was significantly higher in group 2 (P< 0.0001).

Minimum follow-up was 3 years in group 1 and 1.5 years in group 2. There were 3 dislocations in group 1, and none in group 2. There were 2 re-operations in both groups. The relative improvement in WOMAC scores was significantly greater in group 2 at 3 months and 1 year (P< 0.05).

Conclusion: This is the first study to suggest the benefits of minimally invasive surgery may be prolonged. Cosmesis is a by-product rather than primary objective.


Piers Yates Nasir Qurashi Eric Swarts Alan Kop Don Howie Clare Marx

Relatively high rates of fracture of the femoral stem of total hip replacements were seen with early designs manufactured with stainless steel. Improvements in metallurgy, alloy chemistry, materials and stem design have led to a reduction in the incidence of this complication and the occurrence of fracture with modern femoral stems is a now a rare event. However, the implantation of modern stems into heavy patients and the use of higher offset stems leads to considerable testing of the mechanical capabilities of some stem designs.

We present ten cases of fracture of modern stainless steel polished tapered stems. The fractures occur either in the neck, or in the distal half of the stem. Our clinical data suggests that heavy patients with small stems and high offsets are at risk of breaking their implants. Varus positioning of the stem in a number of cases further increases the bending moment of the stems, and the sacrifice of cement mantle thickness for implant size within narrow medullary canals may lead to the loss of proximal support. Failure analysis of the retrieved high nitrogen stainless stems also suggests there may be metallurgical factors that contribute to their failure.

On the basis of our findings, careful consideration is required when using high offset stainless steel stems in large patients.


D A Hoad-Reddick I Stockley

Aims and Objectives Hybrid hip replacement became popular in some centres for younger patients with expected lower rates of acetabular loosening and subsequent revision. We have previously reported our 5 year results and now have further follow-up data on the same cohort of patients.

Materials and Methods 86 uncemented acetabular components of the same design were implanted into 68 patients between 1992 and 1997 who were prospectively followed with respect to clinical outcome, polyethylene wear and intention to revise as a definition of failure.

Results Data is available on 73 acetabular cups with a mean follow-up of 9.5 years. The failure rate is 22%. 9 patients have been revised and 7 further patients await revision for polyethylene wear and osteolysis which in some cases has been very aggressive. Further patients have advanced wear and early lysis which is under close observation.

Conclusion The prosthesis studied has a high failure rate. Patients often report few symptoms until advanced osteolysis has occurred. We recommend that all patients with this type of prosthesis be recalled for frequent radiological review and report on an implant which seems to be failing unacceptably early.


D. Campbell L. Cochrane D.I. Rowley

As part of a user group of a collarless polished tapered stem a database was established in 1993 recording all significant data pre-operatively, intra-operatively and at 1,3,5 and 7 years.

All were primary hip replacements and the study included 38 different surgeons who were free to use the head size, approach and cup of their choosing. All hips had a collarless polished tapered prosthesis (Zimmer inc.).

Data on 2,250 hips were available for analysis and stratification of risk factors for dislocation. Correlation of head size and surgical approach was performed and tested for significance. The patient demographics were standard for a typical arthroplasty study group. Of the surgical approaches used, 13.1% were anterolateral, 27.55% lateral, 23.88% posterior and 35.47% Hardinge. There were no trochanter osteotomies or anterior approaches.

94 (100%) of the hips had a first dislocation occurring in the first two years: 38 during acute stay (40.43%), 45 from acute stay to the first year (47.88%) and 11 during the second year (11.7%). The 22mm head was associated with the greatest risk of dislocation (5.93%, P < 0.001). The risks with the 28mm head (3.05%) and the 26mm head (2.5%) were not significantly different. The lowest risk of dislocation occurred with the lateral approach (2.11%) and the highest with the posterior approach (5.99%). Dislocation rates for the anterolateral and Hardinge approaches (4.1% and 3.28% respectively) were not significantly different. Unfortunately data pertaining to frequency of capsular repair combined with the posterior approach was not available.

The combination of lateral approach and 28mm head was associated with the lowest dislocation risk of 1.56%, while the risk with the posterior approach and 22mm head was the highest at 10.09%.


A Gordon E Kiss-Toth I Stockley A Hamer R Eastell JM Wilkinson

Cytokine mediated activation of osteoclasts can lead to peri-implant osteolysis and aseptic loosening. The aim of this study was to determine the IL-1β and TNFα mRNA cytokine expression profile of human macrophages when stimulated with polyethylene particles using relative quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (rqRT-PCR).

Human peripheral blood monocytes or human monocytes from the cell line THP-1 were used in this study. rqRT-PCR conditions were optimized by stimulating human macrophages with 200ng/ml lipopolysaccharide (LPS). The median CV% value for duplicate measures was 12.6 (range 4.5–54). Stimulation assays were performed using unfractionated endotoxin-free commercial polyethylene particles (median size 7μm); or fractionated particles (size range 0.1–1.2μm). Human macrophages were stimulated with high dose unfractionated polyethylene particles at 0, 3500 or 10500 mm3/cell or with fractionated polyethylene particles at 0 and 100mm3/cell at time points 0 and 3 hours. Low dose unfractionated polyethylene stimulation was performed on THP-1 cells at 0, 50, 100, 1000 and 10000 mm3/cell. In all experiments LPS stimulation was used as a positive control. RNA was extracted and rqRT-PCR was performed using standard techniques

High dose unfractionated polyethylene stimulation did not result in a significant difference in cytokine mRNA levels between groups. Using fractionated polyethylene, a small increase in IL-1β mRNA was identified (21% versus maximal stimulation using LPS). Low dose unfractionated polyethylene stimulation of THP-1 cells demonstrated dose dependent decreases in TNFα and IL-1β mRNA expression that was not due to inhibition of RNA extraction or a decrease of cell viability.

Endotoxin-free polyethylene particles do not appear to be a major stimulus for IL-1β and TNFα mRNA production as measured by rqRT-PCR. We did observe a small positive effect on IL-1β mRNA expression using a fractionated polyethylene stimulus. However it remains unclear whether this effect is due to fractionation of particles into the submicron range or is due to introduction of endotoxin during the filtration process.


J. Page A. Jennings T. Fawcett

The use of sub-lethal doses of cell wall active antibiotics to induce cell wall deficiency in S aureus has been described. Cell Wall Deficient S aureus show an increased in-vitro ability to form biofilm. Cephalosporins(cell wall active antibiotics.) are commonly used at time of arthroplasty surgery as antimicrobial prophylaxis. Adherence is fundamental step in biofilm formation.

The adherence of cell wall deficient S aureus versus ‘wild type’ S aureus to glass was investigated. Slides comparing the two types of organisms were analysed using fluoroscopy and J-image software. The ability to adhere to plastic was investigated using a micro-titre based absorption test. In a third investigation a centrifugal force was used to quantify the adherence ability of the cell wall deficient organisms to the glass slides.

The cell wall deficient organisms demonstrated an increased ability to adhere to glass compared to the ‘wild type’. After exposure, there was on average twenty times more cell wall deficient organisms per unit area compared to the ‘wild-type’. The micro-titre plates were similar. After incubation, the absorption of each well was measured. Compared to the ‘wild type’ there was a significantly increased absorption in wells containing the cell wall deficient organisms. Showing an increased ability to adhere to plastic. The third technique quantified the ability to adhere using a centrifugal force. The slides were exposed to ‘wild type’ and cell wall deficient organisms, however before staining they were placed in a centrifuge. On analysis there were five cell wall deficient S aureus per field of view, compared to 0.5 ‘wild-type’.

An increased ability of cell wall deficient S aureus to adhere to surfaces has been shown. Adherence is fundamental to biofilm formation. The significance to orthopaedics is that the inadequate use of Cephalosporins at time of operation may be facilitating chronic infections.


Mr. Y. Michla Dr. M. Holliday Dr. K. Gould Mr. D.J. Weir Prof. A.W. McCaskie

Introduction Infection is a disastrous complication of arthroplasty surgery, requiring multidisciplinary treatment and debilitating revision surgery. As between 80–90% of bacterial wound contaminants originate from colony forming units (CFU’s) present in operating room air tending to originate from bacteria shed by personnel present within the operating environment, any steps that can reduce this bacterial shedding should reduce the chances of wound contamination. These steps have included the use of unidirectional downward laminar airflow theatre systems, and the introduction of theatre attire modelled on this principle (e.g. total body exhaust suits). Our unit has introduced the use of the Stryker Sterishield Personal Protection System helmet in conjunction with laminar flow theatre systems. This study compares an enclosed helmet system used with standard gowns, with standard hood & mask attire.

Method 12 simulated hip arthroplasty operations were performed, six using disposable sterile impermeable gown, hood and mask, with a further 6 using a Sterishield helmet & hood. Each 20 minute operation consisted of a series of arm and head movements simulating movements performed during surgery. Air was sampled at wound level on a sterile draped operating table using a Casella slit sampler, sampling at 700l/minute. Samples were incubated on Blood agar for 48 hours at 37°c & the CFU’s grown were counted.

Results The mean number of CFU’s for the helmet was 9.33 with hood and mask attire having 49.16 CFU’s (S.Ds 6.34 & 26.17; p value 0.0126). In all cases, the organism isolated was a coagulase negative staphylococcus

Conclusion Although the sample size was small, we demonstrated a fivefold increase in the number of CFU’s shed when using hood and mask attire compared to personal helmet and sterile hood. We conclude that the helmet system is superior to non-sterile hood & mask at reducing bacterial shedding by theatre personnel.


1Alison L. Galvin 1Eileen Ingham 2Martin H. Stone 1John Fisher

Introduction Zero wear of highly crosslinked UHMWPE has been reported in hip simulators (1). In contrast clinical studies have reported finite wear rates (2). The aim of this study was to compare the wear rates produced by UHMWPE with different levels of crosslinking in a hip joint simulator and compare them to clinical wear rates.

Materials and Methods Studies were carried out using 28mm diameter cobalt chrome femoral heads. These were articulated against UHMWPE in the Leeds ProSim hip joint simulator. The acetabular cups were manufactured from UHMWPE GUR 1050. The PE was highly crosslinked with 10MRad or 7.5MRad of gamma irradiation in nitrogen followed by re-melting at a temperature above 150°C. Slightly crosslinked (gamma irradiated with 2.5MRad in air) and non-crosslinked PE were also tested. Wear measurements were taken every million cycles using a coordinate measuring machine. At each million cycles a 3D measurement was taken of the contact region of the acetabular cups.

Results and Discussion The wear rates decreased as crosslinking levels increased. The non-crosslinked material had an overall average wear rate (mm3/million cycles) of 45.6±1.35, the 2.5MRad material 46.9±9.4, the 7.5MRad 15.04±4.28 and the 10MRad 8.7±3.11. All four polyethylenes showed greater volume change in the first million cycles and this was associated with initial creep deformation. The results of the surface topography showed that the highly crosslinked materials became smoother than the other materials. This would benefit the crosslinked materials in aiding lubrication and could have contributed to the lower wear rate seen with these materials.

Conclusion Finite wear rates have been recorded for the first time in simulator studies with highly crosslinked polyethylene. The wear rates and wear surfaces compare with those found in clinical studies.


Constant A Busch Robert B Bourne Cecil H Rorabeck Steven J MacDonald Richard W McCalden Dr John M Martell Christopher M Haydon

Background: Reduced implant survivorship due to aseptic loosening has prompted research into alternative bearing materials. Simulator testing is useful, but clinical studies are the gold standard to evaluate the wear characteristics of new bearing materials. Net compression molded polyethylene has clinically reported improved wear characteristics over traditionally used RAM extruded UHMWPE 1,4,17,22. Machining of the compression molded acetabular component however may be detrimental to its wear properties 29. We report a 23–29% increase in 2D and 3D linear and volumetric wear in a cohort of patients in which machined compression molded acetabular components were used.

Methods: Ninety-two patients matched for gender, body mass index, primary pathology, Charnley grade, and length of follow up underwent uncemented total hip replacement using an identical acetabular and femoral implant. Group 1 (52 patients) had a RAM extruded polyethylene liner (GUR 4150 HP) and Group 2 (40 patients) had a machined compression molded polyethylene liner (Montell H 1900). UHMWPE sterilisation regimes were identical. Antero-posterior and lateral radiographs were analysed for acetabular wear using the Martell technique at a minimum follow up of five years and a maximum mean follow up of 87.4 months for group 1 (SD=8.7) and 84.9 months for group 2 (SD 7.7).

Results: Both 2D and 3D linear and volumetric wear rates in patients with a RAM extruded polyethylene acetabular component were 23–29% less compared to patients that received a machined compression molded acetabular liner. There was a statistical difference in age between to the two groups (P=0.007). Looking at acetabular wear in patients over 55 years, machined compression poly was still 16–31 % worse then RAM extruded polyethylene although statistical difference could not be reached for 3D linear and volumetric wear. The incidence of acetabular osteolysis on review of radiographs at maximum follow up was similar in both groups (group 1 =16.3% versus group 2 =15%).

Conclusions: Despite favourable reports of improved wear characteristics of net compression molded UHMWPE, this study shows a 23– 29% increase in 2D and 3D linear and volumetric wear in machined compression molded acetabular components. It appears that machining of compression molded polyethylene bar stock, to obtain the final component, is detrimental to the wear properties of the acetabular liner.


FCNK Kwong RA. Power

The longevity of cemented femoral components has been shown to be related to the cement used. The reason for this difference between the available commercial preparations is unclear. One mode of failure of the stem is thought to be cracking within the cement mantle. This may be secondary to residual stress resulting from shrinkage of the cement on curing. It was hypothesised that there was a difference in shrinkage on curing between the different polymethylmethacrylate cements used commonly in hip arthroplasty.

Under standardised conditions, a fixed volume of Palacos-R, Palacos-LV, Simplex, CMW1 Radio-opaque, CMW2 and CMW Endurance was mixed under vacuum and allowed to cure in a measuring cylinder of fixed volume. The cylinder was then split open 24 hours later and the block of cement removed. The final volume of cement was then determined by measuring the volume it occupied in a container filled with water using Archimedes principle.

Our results indicate that, under standardised conditions, the degree of shrinkage for each commercial preparation was Palacos-R 6.9%, CMW1 5.2%, CMW2 5.4%, CMW Endurance 5.3%, Simplex 5.8% and Palacos-LV 7.2%.

There is a difference in the amount of shrinkage on curing between the different types of bone cements in use commercially and this may account for their differences in long term outcome.


S Williams Z M Jin M H Stone E Ingham J Fisher

There is currently much interest in the wear of metal-on-metal THRs and potential concerns about elevated metal ion levels. Generally, wear of metal-on-metal THR’s has been low in simulator studies. Slightly higher and more variable wear has been found clinically. Variations in surgical approach, technique and fixation method may influence the level of force applied across the prosthesis during gait. It is hypothesised that increased joint tensioning may increase loading of THR’s during the swing-phase; leading to elevated wear and friction due to depleted fluid film lubrication. This study aimed to assess the effect of swing-phase load on the friction, lubrication and wear of metal-on-metal THR’s.

Cobalt-chrome 28mm metal-on-metal THR’s were tested in a physiological hip simulator, loading was modified to provide; (1) ISO swing-phase load (280N, as per ISO 14242-1) and (2) low swing-phase load (< 100N). Friction testing was conducted using a pendulum friction simulator, with 280N and 100N swing-phase loads. Theoretical lubrication modelling was carried out using elastohydrodynamic lubrication theory.

The overall mean volumetric wear rates was 10-times greater in THR’s tested with an ISO swing-phase load in comparison to THR’s tested with low swing-phase loads (0.58±0.49 compared to 0.06±0.039mm3/million cycles). The friction factors were 0.129 and 0.173 respectively under low and ISO swing-phase conditions. A decrease in the predicted lubricant film thickness when the swing-phase load was increased was observed; at the start of stance phase this was 0.12microns and 0.07microns under low and ISO swing-phase conditions respectively.

The results demonstrate that the performance of metal-on-metal THR’s is highly dependent on swing-phase load conditions. It is postulated that fixation method and surgical technique can affect the swing-phase load. This study has demonstrated that over-tensioning of the tissues may also accelerate wear. These observations may explain some of the variations reported clinically.


A P Sprowson A W McCaskie M A Birch

Background A biomaterial serves to support, organize and directly influence the behaviour of growing cells. Chitosan has the capability to be a very useful biomaterial in the speciality of orthopaedics, due to its excellent biocompatibility, and physical properties that allow topographical modification. Chitosan films have potential to be used to coat implant surfaces, regulating bone cells at the implant interface. Enhanced integration may therefore help towards solving problems such as aseptic loosening.

Method 85% deacylated chitosan (Sigma) was dissolved in 2% acetic overnight. The viscous chitosan was then sterilized by autoclaving for 10 minutes. PDMS patterned stamps produced from a silicon mould were added to the viscous chitosan and as the chitosan film forms the topographic impression is left on the surface. The gel was then dried for 36 hours in a sterile system. The pH is neutralized with NaOH1M for 24 hours. The gel was washed in sterile hanks balanced salt solution until the pH was 7.4. Osteoblasts were then grown on these surfaces in a cell culture system and analysed by light microscopy and image analysis.

Results We have successfully designed a protocol for the production of sterile topographically modified chitosan, with surface features that can be produced in the range of 1–100um. We have shown that cells on un-modified chitosan differentiate and form bone at a much slower rate than on chitosan with a modified surface. Findings supported by in-situ alkaline phosphatase levels. Control can be exerted on cell shape and inter-cellular interactions based upon shape and surface area between shapes; with a smaller surface area making adhesion more difficult.

Conclusion. Our data shows that osteoblasts can be controlled by altering chitosans surface topography. Being able to influence biology by changing biomaterial surface features will enhance interaction at the bone implant interface, allowing greater implant integration.


Mr C. N. Peck Miss A. Foster Mr G. J. Mclauchlan

It has been suggested that minimal incision surgery for hip arthroplasty allows earlier mobilisation and reduces hospital stay. Intensive post-op physiotherapy may also have the same effect. This study aimed to assess which was the more important factor.

The study compared 45 patients (26 NHS and 19 private) undergoing primary total hip arthroplasty using a standard posterior approach to 51 patients (29 NHS and 22 private) with a minimal incision of 10cm or less. Physiotherapy involved once daily weekday sessions with the NHS patients (five sessions per week) versus twice daily with the private patients (14 per week). We compared demographics, incision length, post-operative stay, complication rates and Oxford Hip Scores between the four groups.

Results showed no significant difference in age, sex and BMI between the groups. There was a significant difference (p = 0.0002) in mean scar length between the mini and standard incision groups (15.3 vs. 8.3 cm). There was no significant difference in post-op stay between the mini and standard incision NHS patients or the mini and standard incision private patients. There was a significant difference (p = 0.003) in stay between NHS and private patients (11.4 vs. 7.9 days) regardless of the incision used. There were four (4%) early dislocations, three in the mini incision group. Eleven patients received prophylactic antibiotics compared to five in the standard groups for prolonged wound ooze (> 5 days); only one patient had a proven superficial infection. There was no significant difference in the change in the Oxford Hip Scores between any of the groups.

This study suggests that intensive physiotherapy can significantly reduce in-patient stay but minimal incision surgery itself does not. The higher dislocation rate in the mini incision group demonstrates the learning curve for this technique.


Fares Haddad Rahul Patel Nada Al-Hadithy Michelle Odumenya Mike Grocott Monty Mythen

Aim: To identify the incidence of post-operative morbidity in elective total hip replacement patients as a cause for prolonged admission using the POMS. To assess the utility of POMS as a measure of short term orthopaedic outcome and a tool to influence decision making for appropriate discharge time.

Background: The currently available methods for assessing overall surgical outcome (as opposed to quality of life or joint specific outcome) are generally unreliable, unvalidated, unresponsive and almost always inconsistent. Mortality is usually infrequent and length of hospital of stay is likely to be affected by non-medical factors and monitoring of complications is subject to variations in both definition and intensity of surveillance.

The POMS is the only published method for prospectively describing complications associated with major surgery. It comprises a 9-point survey and provides a generic measure of short term post-operative outcome. Data is simple and quick to collect and easily learnt. No additional tests are required for data collection.

Method: Patients undergoing elective primary and revision hip arthroplasty were recruited. Research assistants collected POMS data prospectively on postoperative days 1, 3, 5, 8 and 15 (if the patients were still in hospital).

Results: 182 patients were recruited and followed-up. Median length of stay was 11 days (range 2–58). Of the patients remaining in hospital on post-operative days 1, 3, 5, 8 and 15, 0% (n=182), 34% (n=61), 30% (n=51), 29% (n=39) and 63% (n=22), respectively, had no evidence of medical morbidity as defined by the POMS.

Conclusions: The POMS is a generic post-operative screening survey, designed to monitor morbidity in all main organ systems. This study suggests that a significant proportion of orthopaedic patients remain in hospital despite having no evidence of medical morbidity as defined by the POMS. Length of hospital stay is influenced by a number of other factors, further investigation is warranted to identify the factors responsible for their post-operative length of stay. We also hypothesize that POMS may be very useful in areas were managed care / insurance companies dictate the length of hospital stays.


R Nagai I Ines AJ Fox V Edwards-Jones M Upton PR Kay

Purpose Coagulase negative staphylococci (CNS) have been one of the major pathogens responsible for prosthetic joint infections, and are showing increasing multiple-antibiotics resistance. Intact cell mass spectrometry (ICMS), based on the analysis of bacterial surface proteins, has been recognised as a new technique for identification of micro-organisms. The aim of this study was to evaluate the ability of ICMS for species level identification of clinical CNS isolates.

Method A total of 50 CNS strains from revision joint replacement operations were studied. ICMS and commercial identification kits were used for identification of those CNS. The commercial kits were used following the manufacturer’s recommendations. For ICMS, single colonies were smeared onto five spots on a sample slide. After drying, a 1 μl of aliquot of matrix solution was added to each spot. Analysis of strains was performed using a Kompact MALDI 2 linear, time of flight mass spectrometer and 3-ns pulse width nitrogen laser light. Combined spectra were constructed from 100 shots at each spot on the sample slide.

Results In this study, the commercial kit did not require any special equipment, but required overnight incubation and could not identify at least seven strains. On the other hand, the ICMS method was rapid, accurate and highly reproducible. The mass: charge spectra produced by ICMS contained potential biomarker peaks that could be used for species level identification.

Conclusions ICMS has the potential as a powerful tool for species level identification of clinical CNS isolates in terms of rapidity, accuracy and cost effectiveness. This study suggested that ICMS is a possible new method of identifying causative organism in infected joint replacements.


P Gaston CR Howie R Burnett RW Nutton IH Annan D Salter AHRW Simpson

If an arthroplasty patient presents with wound breakdown, sinus formation or a hot, red joint the diagnosis of infection is straightforward. However, most total joint replacement (TJR) infections are difficult to distinguish from aseptic loosening. It is imperative to know if a painful TJR is infected to plan appropriate management.

In this prospective study of 204 patients we analysed the diagnostic accuracy of various tests for infection: Inflammatory Markers (CRP/ESR); Aspiration Microbiology; and the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) – a novel technique in this situation. We used international criteria as the gold standard for infection, applied at the time of revision surgery. Any of – a sinus; frank pus in the wound; positive intra-operative microbiology; positive histology – classified the patient as infected. The sensitivity (Sens), specificity (Spec), positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) of each test were calculated.

52 patients with an original diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis were excluded, as histology may be inaccurate. The results for the remaining 152 patients are: CRP > 20mg/l: Sens 77%; Spec 76%; PPV 49%; NPV 92%. ESR > 30 mm/hr: Sens 61%; Spec 86%; PPV 57%; NPV 87%. Aspiration Microbiology: Sens 80%; Spec 83%; PPV 71%; NPV 88%. PCR: Sens 71%; Spec 78%; PPV 43%; NPV 89%.

Few patients with negative CRP/ESR were found to be infected; if positive, there was a 50/50 chance that the joint was infected. Positive aspiration microbiology was associated with underlying infection 3 times out of every 4, and negative results were correct 9 times out of 10. PCR was no more accurate than existing tests.

All patients with painful TJR’s should have inflammatory markers checked – if negative the clinician can be relatively reassured that the implant is not infected. If positive or suspicion remains, further investigation should be undertaken. Joint aspiration for microbiology is currently the best available second line investigation.


VE Hannah JV Smith M Riggio J Bagg DB Allan

Infection is one of the major reasons leading to early revision of total hip joint replacements. Traditionally, samples have been taken for microscopy, culture and sensitivity at the time of surgery. However, this doesn’t always reveal a causative organism. Molecular techniques have now been refined to improve sensitivity in bacterial detection.

In this study, samples were taken from acetabular and femoral components at the time of revision hip surgery for suspected infection. These underwent conventional culturing and also PCR and DNA sequencing. The white cell count, CRP and ESR were also recorded.

Results are available for 6 cases. All of these patients had an elevated CRP level (17–169). Microscopy at the time of surgery showed scanty white cells and no organisms on at least 1 sample from 2 cases. Subsequent culture was negative. When sonication techniques were used to remove bacterial DNA, followed by PCR and sequencing, one of these cases yielded Stenomophonas sp. A further 4 cases were positive for Stenophomonas using molecular techniques despite conventional culture being negative.

Stenophomonas sp is a gram negative bacillus. Its ability to adhere to plastic and to produce a bacteraemia are of significance in its proposed role in hip arthroplasty infection. It is also known to be resistant to most commonly used broad spectrum antibiotics.

This study demonstrated that we may be under-diagnosing infection in hip revision patients. These new techniques could prove invaluable in detecting low yet significant levels of bacteria which may lead to a change in current antibiotic policy for joint replacements and subsequently a reduction in the number of revisions required for loosening due to infection.


N.R Shetty A.J Hamer I. Stockley R. Eastell J.M. Wilkinson

Peri-prosthetic bone loss may contribute to aseptic loosening after THA. The aims of this randomised controlled trial extension study were to study the effect of pamidronate therapy on Peri-prosthetic bone mineral density (BMD) and Peri-prosthetic osteolysis over 5 years after primary THA.

50 patients were enrolled in the study in 1998. All received a hybrid THA (Ultima-TPS stem, Plasmacup) for osteoarthritis. Subjects were randomised to receive either 90mg of pamidronate or placebo by intravenous infusion on the 5th post-operative day. At 5 years 36 patients (41 Hips: placebo n=21, pamidronate n=20) returned for measurement of BMD and clinical and plain radiographic assessment. Five patients had died and nine had withdrawn from the study.

The effect of pamidronate in maintaining femoral bone mass in the region of the calcar previously reported at 2 years was maintained at 5 years (Gruen zone 6 pamidronate versus placebo ANOVA P=0.038; Gruen zone 7 ANOVA P=0.048). No differences in pelvic BMD were found between treatment groups at 5 years. Harris hip scores used to evaluate clinical outcome did not show any significant difference between the 2 groups over the 5-year period. (Mann Whitney p> 0.05). Isolated expansile osteolytic lesions were identified on AP radiographs of the hip at 5 years in 4 patients (2 placebo, 2 pamidronate; P> 0.05). One patient had a 5x9mm lytic lesion in the region of the femoral calcar, and 3 patients had pelvic lytic lesions in the region of the acetabular dome (largest measuring 20x10mm).

Single-dose peri-operative pamidronate therapy preserves femoral calcar bone mass over a 5 year period after THA. However, although the number of subjects with osteolysis is small, we have seen no difference in the rate of osteolytic lesions between treatment groups. Long term study of this patient group is required to examine the rate of aseptic loosening between the treatment groups.


A Dramis DJ Dunlop RJ Grimer E Aldlyami N O’Connell TS Elliot

Background The exclusion of infection at the site of a painful or failed prosthetic joint replacement is important for pre-operative planning and counselling. A variety of investigations can be used to assist in the diagnosis or exclusion of infection.

An ESR and CRP are widely used as the initial screening investigation to differentiate between aseptic and septic loosening of prosthetic joint replacements1. Propionobacteria are organisms of low virulence, although they do cause deep peri-prosthetic infections2. We believe that Propionobacteria do not always cause a significant rise in ESR and CRP.

Methods Between May 2001 and May 2004, we identified 78 patients with prosthetic joint replacements colonised with Propionobacteria. There were 48 hip joint replacements, 27 knee joint replacements, 2 endoprosthetic replacements of the femur and 1 shoulder joint replacement. There were 48 males and 30 females. The preoperative values of ESR and CRP were recorded. For the purposes of this study, an ESR rate of 30mm/hr or higher and a CRP level of 10mg/lt or higher were considered to be suggestive of infection and were deemed a positive result.

Results All of the 78 patients had both ESR and CRP measured preoperatively. In only 17 patients (22%) both ESR and CRP were higher than 30mm/hr and 10mg/l respectively. In 33 patients (42%) with prosthetic joint replacements colonised with Propionobacteria, the preoperative values of both ESR and CRP were normal.

Conclusion In our study we have shown that 33 out of 78 patients (42%) with prosthetic joint replacements colonised with Propionobacteria had normal preoperative of both ESR and CRP values. This is to suggest that normal preoperative values of ESR and CRP in suspected failed prosthetic joint replacements might not exclude infection, if the causative organism is of low virulence such as Propionobacteria.


Full Access
Nikhil Shah Farokh Wadia Matthew Frayne Kate Pendry Martyn Porter

Aim We have prospectively investigated the effect of tranexamic acid in reducing blood loss and transfusion requirements in primary and revision total hip arthroplasty in a comparative study.

Patients and Methods In the study group, tranexamic acid was given half an hour before the skin incision. (10 mg/kg as an intravenous bolus, followed by 10 mg/kg as intravenous infusion over 6 hours). We recorded the haemoglobin level preoperatively and prior to discharge, and number of units of blood transfused. The total peri-operative blood loss and the fall in haemoglobin after surgery was calculated in consultation with our haematologist. There were 9 primary and 17 revision hip replacements in the study group. We compared the results with a control group of 10 primary and 20 revisions performed during a similar period, without tranexamic acid, recording identical parameters. Thrombo-embolic and wound complications were recorded.

Results Patients receiving tranexamic acid had a mean fall in haemoglobin level of 3.1 g/dl and mean blood loss of 4.1 litres. The control group operated without tranexamic acid had a mean fall in the level of haemoglobin of 3.7 g/dl, and the mean blood loss 5.4 litres. The average number of units of blood transfusion required was 0.77 per patient in the study group compared to 2.03 per patient in the control group. The differences were significant (p value of 0.05). There was no increase in the incidence of complications such as deep vein thrombosis, pulmonary embolism, or wound problems in the study group.

Conclusion Tranexamic acid given prior to surgery reduces blood loss and need for blood transfusion, not only in primary but also in revision hip arthroplasty, without any increase in the rate of thrombo-embolic complications.


R Jenabzadeh N Wardle F Haddad

Treatment Centres (TCs) specialise in common elective operations with long waiting lists. One of the concerns that has arisen with this enforced new healthcare model is the potential for suboptimal outcomes after joint arthroplasty. In order to decrease this risk we set in place a number of measures and have evaluated the outcome of the fist 100 total hip and total knee replacements undertaken at our TC and compared these to 100 consecutive controls undertaken concurrently by out hip and knee service. •Cases were only to be performed by consultant orthopaedic surgeons appointed to our trust – to the exclusion of visiting / sessional arrangements. •Same implants and care pathways as used within the rest of our department. •Weekly team arthroplasty rounds and planning sessions.

There was no significant difference in baseline demographics with both groups showing a slight female preponderance, and similar age ranges (35–88 av. 62; 42–86 av. 64). The treatment centres patients were heavier (78Kg range 48–111Kg; 72Kg range 43–101Kg). The TC group averaged 2.9 comorbidities per patient compared to 2.2. The average time to discharge was similar at 7.6 days . There was no significant difference in the improvement in Harris Hip or Knee Society Scores at a minimum 6 months follow-up. There were 2 infections in the TC group and one in the control group. There were 3 thromboembolic complications in each group and there was one unrelated death in each group. There was one dislocation and one fracture in the TC group and two fractures in the control group. Radiographic criteria including implant size, position, slope, offset, cementing and alignment were comparable in the two groups.

TC patients are not “fitter more predictable” patients and may have greater comorbidity. Our insistence on a local consultant led service and on identical standards to those of our non TC department have generated similar short term outcomes to those of non TC patients.


P McGraw S Hossain JP Hodgkinson

Background: With the foreseeable increase in demand for revision hip surgery, it is likely that orthopaedic surgeons working in district general orthopaedic units will undertake an increasing number of secondary procedures. This article set out to determine whether a single orthopaedic surgeon, working in a district general hospital, could achieve results comparable to those obtained by surgeons working in specialised tertiary referral centres.

Patients and methods: Complete records and serial radiographs of 72 patients (76 hips) having revision total hip arthroplasty by a single surgeon and follow-up of at least 1 year, were reviewed by an independent observer.

Results: The mean follow-up period was 4 years. Indications for revision were aseptic loosening (N=51), sepsis (N=16), fracture (N=3), dislocation (N=2), and other (N=4). Complete cement removal was achieved in 97% of acetabular components revised and 88% of femoral components revised. There were no documented complications in 68% of revised hip prostheses. The complications of the remaining cases comprised trochanteric bursitis (9%), dislocation (10%), thromboembolism (5%), periprosthetic fracture (1%) and infection of the revised prosthesis (1%). None of the cases studied died as a direct result of surgery. All radiographic parameters measured were improved by revision of the prostheses.

Conclusions: Orthopaedic surgeons working in district general hospitals performing 5 to 10 revision hip arthroplasties per year can achieve results comparable to those of surgeons working in specialised units.


RJK Khan D Fick M Lee R Alakeson AG Bowers DJ Wood B Nivbrant

Introduction Primary and revision total hip surgery in the face of poor neuromuscular function, cognitive impairment or recurrent dislocation are fraught with complications. A useful option for such cases is the constrained acetabular component, or “captive cup”. We present the largest series reported to date, and use radiostereometric analysis (RSA) to assess cup migration.

Method Between February 1999 and September 2003 133 patients (141 hips) were identified as high risk of dislocation and were treated with a constrained acetabular component. One hundred and twenty cases were revision arthroplasties and 21 were primary replacements. Patients were assessed pre-operatively (WOMAC, Harris Hip Scores and SF-36). Defects were reconstructed with allograft (massive, morsellised or strut) where required. Most components were inserted into uncemented metal cups. Radiostereometric beads were inserted. Post-operatively patients were followed up regularly and clinical scores repeated. Radiostereometric analysis (RSA) was performed at 6 months, and then annually to assess prosthesis migration.

Results Mean follow-up was 3.1 years (range 1 – 5.6 years). At last review 26 patients had died, and 7 were lost to follow-up. There were 8 revisions for cup loosening. There were 5 dislocations and 2 dissociations in 6 patients. There was a statistically significant improvement in WOMAC and Harris Hip scores. RSA confirmed cup migration was greater than for non-captive cups, but was nevertheless minimal. Interestingly there was no statistically significant difference at 6, 12 and 24 months suggesting most migration occurs early on.

Conclusion Our results suggest the “captive cup” is an effective and safe option for the treatment of primary and revision arthroplasty in those at high risk of dislocation.


Fares Haddad

The management of infected total hip replacements remains controversial. The standard of care is two stage revision with antibiotic load ed cement during the interval period and parental antibiotic therapy for six weeks. Single stage revision may have economic and functional advantages however.

Fifty consecutive patients with infected total hip replacements were treated according to a Standard Protocol. Patients were selected for single or two stage revision based on their general characteristics, the infecting organisms and type of reconstruction to be used. If a single sensitive organism was identified and antibiotics were available to use antibiotic loaded cement on the femoral side then a single stage revision was undertaken.

Eleven patients underwent a single stage revision and 39 two stage revision. All 11 patients who underwent single stage revision had femoral components inserted using antibiotic loaded cement. Six had uncemented acetabular components. All the patients were reviewed at a minimum of 2 years post surgery. There was evidence of re-infection in two cases who were treated w ith two stage exchange and in none of the one stage revisions. The average Harris hip score in the patients treated with one stage exchange improved from 42 to 85. In the patients treated with two stages the scores improved from 36 to 73. Patients with one stage exchange were significantly more satisfied than those undergoing two stage exchange.

Single stage exchange arthroplasty can be performed in selected patients with excellent success rates. We have not seen any detrimental effects of using uncemented acetabular components in these cases although we continue to use cement on the femoral side to provide a high local antibiotic load. At a minimum of 2 years of follow up of single stage revision appears to offer some advantages in specific patients over two stage exchange.


W W Duncan M J W Hubble A J Timperley G A Gie

Retention of well fixed bone cement at the time of a revision THA is an attractive proposition, as its removal can be difficult, time consuming and may result in extensive bone stock loss or fracture. Previously reported poor results of cemented revision THA, however, have tended to discourage Surgeons from performing ‘cement in cement’ revisions, and this technique is not in widespread use.

Since 1989 in Exeter, we have performed a ‘cement within cement’ femoral stem revision on 354 occasions. An Exeter polished tapered stem has been cemented into the existing cement mantle on each occasion.

Clinical and radiological follow up of 5 years or longer is available for 156 cases. On no occasion has a cement in cement femoral stem had to be re-revised during this time for subsequent aseptic loosening.

This has encouraged the refinement of this technique, including the development of a new short stem designed specifically for cement within cement revisions. This stem is designed to fit into an existing well fixed cement mantle of most designs of cemented femoral components or hemi-arthroplasties, with only limited preparation of the proximal mantle required. The new stem greatly simplifies cement in cement revision and minimises the risk of distal shaft perforation or fracture, which is otherwise a potential hazard when reaming out distal cement to accommodate a longer prosthesis.


A.T.M. Phillips K.W. Taylor F.P. May C.R. Howie P. Pankaj A.J. McLean A.S. Usmani

Morsellised bone graft is used extensively in revision arthroplasty surgery. The impaction technique at the time of surgery has a significant effect on the subsequent elastic and inelastic properties of the bone graft bed. Differences in values reported in the literature for the mechanical properties of morsellised cortico-cancellous bone (MCB) can be attributed to the different loading histories used during testing. We performed serial confined compaction tests to assess the optimum compaction strategy. Compaction of the samples was carried out using repeated standardised loading cycles. Optimal preparation of MCB is dependant on the force and frequency of compaction. The maximum compactive pressure the samples were subjected to was 3 N/mm2 based on the clinical experience of Ullmark & Nilsson1 in MCB preparation at the time of surgery. This paper presents the Young’s Modulus, E, vs. number of compaction cycles and inelastic strain, ie, vs. number of compaction cycles curves for MCB. Qualitative and quantitative descriptions of the material behaviour of MCB are developed. The importance of frequent percussive episodes prior to implant insertion is illustrated.

MCB was also found to exhibit significant visco-elastic response, with stress relaxation under displacement controlled loading continuing for several hours following initial load application. Bone graft substitutes do not at present exhibit a similar beneficial shock absorbing visco-elastic response.

Our experiments indicate that the material properties of MCB are dependent on the force of impaction and the number of impactions applied with a hammer at the time of surgery. A minimum of 10 to 20 compaction episodes, or hammer blows are required for MCB to achieve 60 to 70% of its long term predicted stiffness.


P Bobak B M Wroblewski P R Kay B Purbach H Nagai P Siney C Platt P Fleming

Factors influencing the results of revised cemented sockets with bone grafting have been studied in 249 cases.

Freeze-dried allografts in 77 and fresh frozen in 172 cases have been used. The average follow-up was 8 years 11 months for the freeze-dried group and 2 years 11 months for the fresh frozen cases. There were 13 postoperative dislocations, 20 TNU, 4 thromboembolic complications, 4 delayed wound healing and 2 intraoperative fractures of the acetabulum. There have been 11 re-revisions: 8 for aseptic loosening, 2 for dislocation and 1 for infection. Radiographic evidence of loosening was seen in another 38 cases.

The acetabular bone stock at the time of revision and initial stability of socket fixation had a significant influence on the outcome. Direction of socket migration before surgery appeared to predict risk of failure. The primary pathology, type of bone graft and grafting technique also had an effect.


F Wadia N Shah N Pradhan M Porter

Aim: To review the results and complications of revision of the socket in total hip arthroplasty using rim mesh and impaction allograft for reconstruction of segmental and complex defects

Patients & Methods: 43 patients who underwent a revision of the socket in 47 total hip replacements were retrospectively reviewed over a 3 ½ year period. All the patients had segmental or complex bone loss around the acetabulum which was reconstructed using Stryker Howmedica rim mesh, impaction bone grafting and a cemented cup through the posterior approach. Final analysis included clinical review at latest follow-up, radiological evaluation to assess graft incorporation and socket migration and any other complications.

Results: All patients were followed up for a mean period of 14.2 months (range: 2 months-33 months). The mean age at surgery was 58.2 yrs. There were 14 males and 29 females. This was a re-revision in 5 patients. The most common indication for revision was aseptic socket loosening with migration in 39 patients. One patient had a two stage revision for infection, one had socket fracture, and two patients had collapse of bulk graft and socket migration. Superior segmental defect of varying sizes were present in all patients, in addition to which there were central deficiencies, anterior and/or posterior column deficiencies and complex defects. 4 patients had post-operative dislocation, 1 had significant limb length discrepancy, 1 had infection and 1 had transient sciatic nerve palsy. At the latest follow-up all patients had good graft incorporation and no socket migration.

Conclusion: Rim mesh helps in containing a segmental defect of acetabulum provides good immediate support for impacted graft and socket and has produced good early results. However, long term follow-up is necessary to determine the outcome of this construct.


NA Munro MR Downing JR Meakin RA Duthie JD Hutchison RM Aspden GP Ashcroft

Synthetic graft expanders have recently been developed for use in impaction grafting revision hip arthroplasty, but their true role has yet to be determined.

We performed a series of experiments to investigate the properties of one such porous hydroxyapatite material (IG-Pore, ApaTech Ltd). IG-Pore was mixed with fresh-frozen human allograft chips and impacted into composite femoral models with a similar biomechanical profile to human bone (Sawbones Europe). Exeter hip prostheses (Stryker Howmedica Ltd) were implanted with cement and each model was axially loaded for 18000 cycles at physiological levels using an Instron servohydraulic materials testing machine. Four test groups with 0%, 50%, 70% and 90% IG-Pore were used, and there were eight femora in each group.

Pre- and post-loading radiostereometric analysis was performed to characterise migration of the prosthesis. Total subsidence was measured and was separated into that occurring at the prosthesis-cement and cement-femur interfaces. Cyclical compression and expansion of the graft-containing models was measured using the Instron.

Median values (interquartile range) for total subsidence were 0.43 mm (0.28 to 0.55) for the pure allograft group, 0.31 mm (0.20 to 0.55) for the 50% IG-Pore group, 0.23 mm (0.07 to 0.34) for the 70% allograft group and 0.13 mm (0.06 to 0.18) for the 90% IG-Pore group. These differences were statistically significant (p=0.034, Kruskal-Wallis). Subsidence at the prosthesis-cement interface was also lower for IG-Pore containing models (p=0.019, Kruskal-Wallis), although there was no significant difference at the cement-femur interface. Specimens with a higher proportion of IG-Pore showed smaller cyclical movements on loading (p=0.005, ANOVA).

Higher proportions of IG-Pore do appear to reduce subsidence in a mechanical model of impaction grafting. A randomised clinical trial using RSA to compare a 50% IG-Pore/allograft mix with pure allograft is in progress to investigate the use of this material as a bone graft expander in the clinical setting.


HK Shanker NA Shah ER Gardner DB Allan

Substantial bone loss and bone defects are the most challenging problems faced by the surgeon performing revision surgery. Of the many techniques available, impaction bone grafting aims to achieve stability of an implant with the use of compacted, morselized bone graft and subsequently allows restoration of bone stock by bone ingrowth. This technique was proposed with a highly polished double tapered stem. This technique has also been subsequently used with stems of varying surface finish and shape. We report here our experience with impaction grafting using Charnley stem and variants with 8–10 year results assessing the radiological appearance and subsequent behaviour of the impacted allograft.

A prospective radiological study of revision hip arthroplasty done for aseptic loosening with femoral bone loss is presented. Pre operative bone loss was assessed using the Endo Klinik grading system. Impaction grafting with fresh frozen femoral head allograft and the flanged 40 size Charnley stem was used in 17 cases and extra heavey flanged 40 size was used in 9 casaes. Post operative and annual review radiographs were examined for graft distribution, graft consolidation, cortical repair and subsidence of the stem.

Twenty six revisions performed in 25 patients between May 1994 and November 1996 were followed up for 8–10 years. Mean age was 66 years(range 26–83 years). There were eighteen male and 7 female patients. One patient died 2 years and 9 months after the operation. Pre operatively Endo Klinik grade 2 bone loss was seen in 7 cases and grade 3 bone loss was seen in 19 cases. Post operative radiographs showed even graft distribution in twenty cases, five patients had poor filling in Gruen zone 3 and one patient had poor filling in zone 2. All cases demonstrated evidence of graft consolidation by one year. Twenty two cases showed no further changes after 8–10 years. Two cases of subsidence have been revised and one patient is awaiting revision ( 8 years after revision). Two of these were extra heavy flanged 40 stems. Three cases showed subsidence > 5mm and were associated with graft deficiency in zone 2 or 3. Out of these three one had an extra heavy flanged 40 stem inserted. There were no medical complications or deep infection following surgery in these patients. One patient had dislocation.

In conclusion, femoral revision using impaction grafting with the Charnley stem produces satisfactory radiological results in the medium to long term. Good graft distribution on a postoperative radiograph is associated with graft consolidation, cortical repair and minimal stem subsidence. Extra heavy flanged 40 stems perform less satisfactorily compared to the flanged 40 stems. Inadequate graft filling is associated with stem subsidence and revision. These findings highlight the importance of meticulous surgical technique to ensure even graft distribution. This study supports the taper of the Charnley stem and suggests that a vaquasheen finish is not contraindicated.


Sameh El-kawy Douglas Hay Khalid Drabu

Introduction: We conducted a retrospective study at our institution to see what effect, if any, the use of impacted morsellised bone allograft technique had on the incidence of early and late infection in revision hip arthroplasty where contemporary measures were taken.

Patients and Methods: This study included 120 patients.

Patients were 36 male and 84 females with the mean age at the time of revision surgery was 71.4 years (range 42 – 89 SD 9.7).

In all the patients their indication for revision surgery was aseptic loosening.

All the patients had impacted morsellised bone allograft as part of the reconstruction used with cemented prostheses.

Clinical and radiological assessments of all patients were conducted for average of four years follow up.

Results: At mean follow up period of 4 years the early infection rate was 0.8% and late infection rate was 0%.

Conclusion: In our study the use of morsellised bone allograft does not appear to have added risk effect on the incidence of early or late hip joint infection provided contemporary measures are taken.


Mr S Karthikeyan Dr A Leyendecker Mr S J Krikler

Revision hip arthroplasty for severe acetabular deficiency is a technically challenging operation. Many different methods have been described for the management of acetabular deficiency. These include augmentation with bone cement, structural allografts, impaction grafting, support rings with graft and reconstruction with a high centre of rotation. The long term results of many of these methods were variable.

We reviewed the outcome of a stemmed acetabular cup (McMinn cup, Link UK) used with morsellised bone graft for revision hip arthroplasty with severe acetabular deficiency. The implant was used only in the most severe cases of acetabular deficiency where it was impossible to achieve stable fixation using simpler methods. This device was used in only 13 out of 265 revision arthroplasties performed by the senior author.

Between 1995 and 2002 13 acetabulae were reconstructed using a stemmed acetabular cup and non-structural morsellised bone graft. All were revision procedures with the number of previous operations on the same hip ranging between 1 and 4. 2 patients died from causes not related to surgery. 1 hip was revised for persistent discharge although no organisms were identified on repeated cultures. The mean follow-up of the remaining 10 hips was 72 months (range 46 – 108 months)

All patients were satisfied with the results and their function improved significantly post-operatively. 8 of the 10 people report no pain from the hip and 2 reported slight or occasional pain which did not interfere with their activities at last follow-up. The mean Harris Hip Score was 84.6 (range 70 to 99.8). Radiological assessment showed regeneration of acetabular bone stock. Some X-Rays showed proximal migration of the cup but with no evidence of loosening at last follow-up.

Acetabular reconstruction using the McMinn stemmed acetabular cup is a useful technique in revision hip arthroplasty with severe acetabular deficiency.


P Bobak B M Wroblewski P R Kay B Purbach P Siney C Platt P Fleming

We previously reported the result of 45 Charnley LFA’s with femoral head autograft for Developmental Dysplasia of the hip with a minimum follow-up of ten years.

After an average follow-up of eleven years there was no revision. One socket migrated and four sockets were fully demarcated.

To assess our long-term results we reviewed the clinical and radiological findings in the same group of patients that had been studied previously.

To date 5 patients died from causes unrelated to the hip replacement and were excluded from the final radiological analysis. 40 Charnley LFA’s have been followed-up regularly.

The average follow-up is now 17 years 1 month / range: 15–21 years/. Three sockets have been revised: two for aseptic loosening and one for infection. Radiographic assessment showed that three sockets migrated and four had full demarcation.

Demarcation at the cement-bone interface of the socket was rare in zone one but was common in zone two.

We concluded that sound fixation of the autograft and orientations of the acetabular component are essential. We recommend that solid bone graft should be combined with impaction bone grafting in dysplastic cases. We also observed that bone grafting at primary surgery gives better chances for component fixation at the time of revision.


HK Shanker AJR Gray P Grigoris

Femoral revision total hip arthroplasty is a technically demanding procedure, especially when there is extensive proximal femoral bone loss. Secure fixation maynot be possible to achieve if the implant relies solely on proximal metaphyseal fit. The use of a long tapered cementless stem having a microporous surface offers a strong anchorage distal to the damaged bony segment. By bypassing the compramised proximal femur, initial implant stability is achieved and a high rate of osseointegration can be expected.

We present our experience with Link MP reconstruction stem which utilises distal fixation and has a modular proximal end.. The prosthesis is made of Tilastan( Ti6AI4V Eli Titanium Alloy) with microporous texture of about 70 microns pore diameter. The distally tapered stem is angled about 3 degrees proximally to enable easy insertion of the stem. In our series there were 53 stem revisions done in 51 patients. Twenty three were males and 28 were female patients. The average age of the male patient was 66 years and that of the female was 74 years. The mean followup was 37 months( range 12–76 months.) Indications for revision were aseptic loosening in 35 cases, infected hip replacements in 8 patients and periprosthetic fracture in ten cases. Revision for infected primary arthroplasty was done in two stages with the Link MP stem inserted at the second stage.

All the proximal femoral defects were classified radiographically as described by Gustillo and Pasternak. There were 29 type 2 defects and 14 type 3 defects. The periprosthetic fractures were classified as per the Vancouver system and all the cases were type b fractures. Clinical scoring as described by d’Aubigne and Postel was used . The mean preoperative score was 3.5 while average score at the time of follow-up was 9.8. The subsidence ranged from none to 6mm. Good radiological evidence of proximal femoral restoration was seen in 44% of the cases in our series. Complications included greater trochanter fracture in 4 cases, perforation of the anterior cortex during reaming using the rasp in 2 cases and dislocation in one patient. In one case there was unacceptable penetration of the implant medially and this was subsequently treated by re-revision with a Huckstep stem. There were two intraoperative fractures which were treated with circlage wire fixation and they went on to union. None of the patients required a re-revision till date.

In conclusion , our experience with Link MP reconstruction stem has been encouraging as shown by the improved d’Aubigne & Postel scores and low rate of complications. We also observed proximal femoral restoration and high implant survivorship in our series.


FS Haddad R. Bourne J. Sprague S. Tsai R. Lambert D. Kelman A. Salehi

Introduction: Bone loss, lack of ingrowth, and use of extended trochanteric osteotomies (ETO) all contribute to loss of proximal support in revision hip arthroplasty, leading to increased stem stresses. Clinical observations of fractured, distally fixed, proximally unsupported stems necessitates methods to mitigate proximal femoral bone loss. This study evaluated various cabling and strut techniques to reduce stem stresses seen with bone loss and ETO.

Methods: Finite element analysis (FEA) was performed on a clinical case of a fractured revision stem after an ETO. Stem stresses were determined and multiple treatment options were evaluated.

An instrumented extensively porous coated stem was implanted in composite femur models (n=3) and mechanically tested. The stem stresses resulting from proximal overbroaching, ETO, cable grips, and various cable and strut constructs were determined.

Results: Stem stresses increased 62 percent with a strut cabled above the distal portion of the ETO using FEA methods. This increase was reduced to as little as 10 percent when a third cable was added distal to the ETO.

Stem stresses increased 98 when a proximally loose stem was combined with an ETO using laboratory tests. This stress was decreased by up to 37 percent when a long trochanteric plate was utilized.

Discussion and conclusion: This study demonstrates the importance of proximal femoral support to the stresses imparted upon a cementless revision hip prosthesis. In the presence of proximal bone loss, an ETO dramatically increases these stresses, which can be reduced by cabling and strut techniques.


S Sadiq S Zaki B Purbach

We evaluated thirty six patients who underwent revision total hip arthroplasty for Vancouver type B periprosthetic femoral fractures. The implant used was a modular proximal femoral replacement stem cemented distally. All the patients were treated at Wrightington Hospital and included 15 males and 21 females. The primary diagnosis was OA in 28, RA in 2, AVN following femoral neck fractures in 3 and hip dysplasia in 3. The average age of patients was 75 years.

The fractures and bone loss were classified according to the Vancouver classification and included 23 B2 and 13 B2 fractures. The mechanism of injury was minor fall in 24 patients, spontaneous in 8 and intraoperative injury in 4.

Using a trans-trochanteric approach the existing prosthesis was removed and a long stem modular femoral stem was inserted bypassing the area of proximal femoral fracture/bone loss. Patients were typically mobilised within the first post-operative week. The patients were clinically and radiologically followed up at regular intervals. Fracture healing with significant improvement in bone stock was noted in 17 patients under 6 months, 13 patients at 12 months and 6 patients at 18 months.

Our series show that use of distally cemented long stem proximal femoral replacement prosthesis allows restoration of proximal bone stock and fracture healing in patients where conventional prostheses cannot be used because of massive bone loss in the proximal femur. This special modular prosthesis bypasses the area of bone loss/periprosthetic fracture, thus avoiding the need for bone allograft or other major reconstructive surgery in elderly patients.


F Muir E Williams A. Khaleel

Analysis of the different phases of the gait cycle has been shown to demonstrate differences in pathological osteoarthritic gait. These differences can be quantified and their improvement following total hip arthroplasty has been shown, allowing use of gait analysis as a tool in evaluating function after total hip replacements.

The purpose of this study was to determine the degree of improvement in gait attained after resurfacing hip arthroplasty.

Ten patients with monoarthritic hips were evaluated using gait analysis preoperatively and 1 year postoperatively.

The results indicate that there is a significant improvement in the patients gait during the first postoperative year following resurfacing arthroplasty.

There is a 30% increase in the Harris Hip score, 100% increase in the velocity of walking. 51% increase in stride length, 30% improvement in the ground reaction force and 33% improvement in cadence at 1 year.

These improvements in gait mirror those shown previously following Total hip arthroplasty and show that following resurfacing procedures gait parameters are comparable to able-bodied controls.

We have concluded that resurfacing hip arthroplasty can greatly improve the gait characteristics of patients with unilateral degenerative hip arthritis.


Mr U Prakash Mr V V Killampalli

Aim: To present the results of trochanteric reduction osteotomy for treatment of resistant trochanteric bursitis.

Methods: Trochanteric reduction osteotomy was performed on ten patients. All patients had been conservatively managed for at least one year with analgesics, anti-inflammatory medications and local steroid injections. All these measures however failed to relieve patients symptoms. The senior author performed trochanteric reduction osteotomy and the osteotomy site was fixed using screws. Patients were assessed pre and postoperatively with a minimum follow-up of six months using oxford hip and modified UCLA scores.

Results and Conclusions: Patient demography, patient selection, surgical technique and results will be presented. All patients were followed-up for a minimum period of six months at regular intervals before being discharged. Early results are very encouraging. Trochanteric reduction osteotomy is a good treatment option in the management of resistant GT bursitis who do not respond to conservative treatment as most of the patients were disabled before operation.


S.P. Krishnan R.W.J Carrington R.M Jeffery G. Thevendran N. Garlick

Functional evaluations using the Harris hip scoring system and the delayed Trendelenberg test were performed on fifty randomly selected patients who had undergone cemented primary CPT total hip replacements (Zimmer UK) at least 12 months previously using Hardinge approach. The prosthesis used increases offset with femoral stem diameter but did not allow separate correction of neck offset.

Patients were grouped according to whether hip offset had been accurately reconstructed, increased or decreased. Their functional outcomes were compared. There was no significant difference (p value 0.57) in the final functional outcome between the three groups. Reconstruction of the hip using a standard cemented CPT prosthesis produced considerable variation in the reconstructed hip arthroplasty offset. This resulted in no functionally significant effect.

Accurate reconstruction of the hip joint offset in total hip arthroplasty may therefore not be as important in the early functional outcome as recently advocated.


Shatrughna Ram Amit Rosha

Thirty patients with old displaced femoral neck fractures have been treated by accurate reduction, two Asnis-type cannulated screws and whole free fibular graft fixation. Patients were of the age group 18yrs–50yrs, presented to our centre 3–6 months post injury and included Garden’s grade III/IV fractures with varying degrees of neck reabsorption, but no avascular necrosis. No plaster was applied, and early return to function encouraged. Bony union was achieved in 27 (90%) of the cases with a mean time of 19.5 weeks, varying from 16wks–24wks. Good function was seen in all patients with union in subsequent follow up of up to 10years.

Our procedure allows early return of function in a young active population disabled by femoral neck fractures and compounded by neglect of early treatment.


S Hook G.C. Bannister E. Moulder

Introduction: Between 1988 and 1993 we performed 154 primary hip arthroplasties with the Exeter Universal femoral stem and a variety of acetabular components and describe our experience after a minimum follow up of 10.5 years (mean 12.6 years).

65 hips were assessed clinically and radiologically.

Our aim was to establish whether results from the inventing centre for the Exeter Universal stem were reproducible and to identify the features of cementing technique associated with survival of this prosthesis.

Results: At follow up the mean Oxford hip score was 24. Our stem revision rate was 1.7% and cup revision 13%. The majority of the cup failures occurred between 8 and 15 years and were the non flanged cemented metal backed Exeters which tended to both wear and migrate. We intend to revise 11 hips in 10 patients. 10 of these are for migration and or wear of the metal backed Exeter cup and one for distal stem-cement dissociation of the stem in a patient with thigh pain. Radiologically this stem showed migration and lucent lines at the cement-stem interface. 6% of stems had cement mantle defects, which were associated with endosteal lysis. Stem subsidence was related to Barrack’s grading for cementing technique. The worse the Barrack grade the more the prosthesis subsided within the cement mantle.

Conclusion: A complete cement mantle rather than 3rd generation cement compression is important for long term fixation of the femoral component. The Exeter universal stem is relatively forgiving of surgical technique. The cemented, collarless polished tapered device is suitable for general use and represents the reference standard for cemented femoral components.


Mr U Prakash Mr V V Killampalli

Aim: To evaluate the results of hip resurfacing done using the Ganz trochanteric flip osteotomy.

Introduction: Long term survivorship of hip resurfacing depends on preservation of blood supply to the head of the femur. The most important artery supplying the head of femur is the deep branch of the medial circum-flex artery. Posterior approaches to the hip can damage the deep branch. The Ganz trochanteric flip osteotomy preserves this branch by sparing the external rotators of the hip. The trochanteric osteotomy is stable as the pull of the gluteus medius on the osteotomy is counteracted by the vastus lateralis.

Methods: Over a period of 12 months, the senior author performed hip resurfacing in fifty patients using this approach. The post-operative regime consisted of early mobilisation with touch weight bearing for 6 weeks followed by full weight bearing. The surgical technique and potential pitfalls will be presented.

Results and Conclusions: There were 26 males and 24 females with an average age of 57 years (24–71 years). Minimum follow-up period was 12 months. There was one infection, one early failure of osteotomy. In three patients, one or more screws came loose and had to be removed but the osteotomy had healed. Pre and postoperative Oxford hip and modified UCLA activity scores will be presented.

There was a definite learning curve with this approach. We find it gives an excellent exposure of the hip with minimal trauma to surrounding tissues. The early results are encouraging. It remains to be seen if this approach results in a better survivorship of hip resurfacing in the long term.


A.R. McAndrew A. Khaleel M.D. Bloomfield A. Aweid

Introduction Hip resurfacing is a method of treating the degenerative hip joint in higher demand patients. In this study we present the results of the first four years of using this technique in a typical District General Hospital.

Materials and Methods This is a review of the outcome of 303 consecutive hip resurfacing procedures performed at Ashford and St. Peter’s Hospitals NHS Trust. All the operations were carried out through a posterior approach to the hip joint, followed by standard resurfacing using metal on metal components. The patients were evaluated radiographically and clinically pre-operatively and post-operatively. All patients had regular follow up.

Results The mean age was 56 years old with a range from 24 to 75 years. There was a statistically significant improvement between the pre-operative Harris Hip Score and the score at the latest follow up. All patients achieved a full range movement in the hip within twelve weeks following surgery. There were four fractures of the femoral neck, one was intra-operative and was converted to a traditional total joint arthroplasty. Three fractures occurred later, two were revised to a hybrid standard hip arthroplasty with a cemented stem and uncemented cup and one was treated conservatively. Two patients had transient femoral nerve palsies. There were no cases of dislocation or deep infection. All the prostheses remain well fixed with no signs of osteolysis.

Three procedures were performed because of avascular necrosis of the femoral head; none of these show signs of further collapse.

Conclusions The short and medium term results that have been achieved in a District General Hospital are comparable to those that have been achieved in the originator’s institution.


A Mehra MV Hemmady JP Hodgkinson

Introduction: Trans-trochanteric approach to the hip joint has become less popular in recent years mainly due to problems associated with trochanteric non-union. Although reported incidence of dislocation is low when the trochanter unites following the trans-trochanteric approach, the radiographic appearance of an ununited high flying trochanter with broken wires is distressing for patient and surgeon.

Aim & objective: The aim of our study was to determine if trochanteric non-union was associated with a higher incidence of revision for mechanical failure.

Method: The case notes and radiographs of 371 patients operated between 1979 and 1989 by two senior surgeons were reviewed. The mean follow-up was 16.7 years (Range 15–25 years).

Results: 19.6% (66/336) patients with the trochanter united and 20% (7/35) with trochanteric non-union had been revised at the latest follow up. The difference was not found to be statistically significant (p value > 0.1, Odds Ratio 1.02).

Conclusion: This study showed that trochanteric non-union following primary total hip replacement did not increase the incidence of revision surgery over a period of 25 years.


Mr. M.K. Sayana Mr. P. Lakshmanan Mr. C. Wynn-Jones Prof. N. Maffulli

Background: Fracture neck of the femur (NOF) is one of the indications for Total Hip Replacement (THR). However, the practice is not the same throughout the world.

Aim: We compared the use of THR in the management of the fracture NOF using the annual reports of the National Joint Registries from various countries.

Material and Methods: We used the latest available on line annual report of seven national arthroplasty registries to ascertain the rate of use of THR for fractures of the neck of the femur. The registries from Australia, Canada, Norway, Sweden, and the UK gave a detailed breakup of the indications for THR in their reports.

Results: 11.9% of the all the THRs performed in Norway since 1987 were for NOFs. · 11.39% of all the THRs performed in Sweden since 1992 were for NOFs.

6.0% of the THRs performed in Canada in 2002–2003 were for NOFs.

2.9% of THRs performed in Australia since 1999 were for NOFs.

1.9% of the THRs performed in the UK in the period April – December 2003 were for NOFs.

The registries from Finland and New Zealand had no detailed information on their websites regarding the indications for THA surgery.

Discussion: In the Scandinavian countries, THR is performed for the management of a NOF 6 times more often than in the UK, and 4 times more often than in Australia. It is unlikely that the prevalence of patients with previous osteoarthritis of hip who sustain a NOF is higher in the Scandinavian countries than in the UK. Women in Sweden have a higher lifetime risk of hip fracture and live longer, so a procedure providing a good long term results would be beneficial. Provision of health care may also influence surgical management options. The long waiting lists for elective THR in the UK may explain the low number of THRs performed for NOFs.


Full Access
A Kadakia M Utting RF Spencer

Introduction Resurfacing hip arthroplasty is becoming an increasingly popular option in the management of hip arthritis in younger individuals. Large series from units pioneering the technique have yielded encouraging results, but smaller units have reported alarming complication rates in recent years. We report a single-surgeon series performed from within the ambit of a multicentre trial.

Method Data on 49 cases in 46 patients (28 males, 18 females, age 34–68, mean 50.6) were collected. Harris Hip scores were obtained preoperatively and at follow-up (6, 12, 24, 36 and 48 months, mean 16.2). Radiological assessment included evaluation of component position and possible migration. Technical difficulties with implant insertion were recorded.

Results Postoperative hip scores improved dramatically in 47 cases. 3 patients have thigh pain. In one case rotational displacement of the cup occurred over 3 months. This is asymptomatic. In 2 cases there was minor femoral neck notching during surgery, without complications. One femoral component was inserted in slight varus. There was incomplete seating of the acetabulum in 4 cases, without complications. Lateral guide pin protrusion occurred into the tissues during surgery in 2 cases, and this pin is no longer used. Painless clicking, possibly due to impingement, has been noted in 4 cases. There was 1 death, due to total mesenteric infarction. There have been no femoral neck fractures and no revisions in these cases, all performed via the anterolateral approach.

Discussion Resurfacing arthroplasty is more technically demanding than total hip replacement. All cases in this series were entered in a multicentre analysis, the benefits have including regular contact with other surgeons. The procedure is conservative on the femoral side at least, and conversion to hip replacement in the event of future femoral component loosening or neck fracture should be easy, although the results of articulation between a new stemmed device and an old (worn) cup are not known. The results of this single-surgeon series from a DGH, performed within the ambit of a large multi-centre analysis, have been encouraging.


Mr Sanjeev Sharma Mr Paul Kingsley Mr M S Bhamra

Introduction The aim of the study was to review the results of total hip arthroplasty (THA) in relatively fit and mobile patients with Garden 3 and 4 fractures of the neck of femur.

Materials and methods 42 patients with displaced hip fractures who underwent THA ≥ 3years ago were reviewed. One was lost to follow-up.

Results Average age was 67.17 years (SD-9.4, range 37–80 years) with Male:Female ratio 6:35. Average follow-up was 5.8 years (3–9.6 years). Average Modified Barthel index before the fracture was 18.63 (SD-2.08, range 13–20). Majority were ASA grade II (22 patients). 33 hips were cemented, 1 uncemented and 7 hybrids. Canulated CF-30 femoral stem was most commonly used (33 patients) and acetabular component was Weber cup in most cases (34 patients). 35 hips had metal-on-metal bearing surface and the rest had metal-on-polyethylene. Average hospital stay was 12.5 days (SD-7.84, range 6–43); majority (36) of the patients were discharged home and the rest needed additional rehabilitation. Average post-operative drop in Hb was 2.78 (SD-1.34) and 15 (36.5%) patients needed blood transfusion. Average transfusion was 0.85 units per patient. Complications included: minor wound dehiscence (1), DVT (3), pulmonary embolism (1), dislocation (1), per-operative femur fracture (1), peri-prosthetic fracture (2) and stem loosening (1). 3 hips (7.3%) were revised (loosening 1, peri-prosthetic fractures 2). Average harris hip score at follow-up was 91 (66–100). At final follow-up 24 patients were independently mobile without support, 12 used 1 stick, one used 2 sticks, 3 used a frame and 1 patient was wheelchair bound due to stroke.

Conclusion In relatively fit and mobile patients, we recommend total hip replacement as the primary treatment since it promises better function and pain relief and avoid the drawbacks of internal fixation and hemiarthroplasty.


S Kumar R Penematsa S Parekh

Aim: To evaluate the benefits of suction drainage following primary total joint arthroplasty.

Materials and Methods: A two year retrospective study was conducted on 126 consecutively selected patients who had primary total hip & knee replacements in a district general hospital. There were 63 patients (mean age 69 years) each in drain and non-drain groups. Sex distribution and anticoagulants use in both groups were similar. All patients underwent same operative technique and method of closure. Primary hip replacements were carried out by Hardinge approach and knee replacements by medial parapatellar approach.

Results: Mean postoperative fall in haemoglobin was 3.2 and 3.3 gm/dl in the drain and nondrain groups respectively. Blood transfusion was required in 34 patients with drains and 28 patients without drains. Mean blood transfusion requirements in both the groups were between 2–3 units. There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups in postoperative complications such as hypotension and wound infections (all negative for microbiology culture). The average rehabilitation time in both the groups was 8–9 days. Statistical analysis showed no difference in postoperative fall of haemoglobin, blood transfusion and rehabilitation time between the two groups (p> 0.05).

Conclusion: We concluded that the routine use of suction drain is unnecessary after an uncomplicated total joint arthroplasty.


Mr Sanjeev Sharma Mr M S Bhamra

Introduction We conducted a prospective study to compare the early post-operative recovery following the two different incisions.

Materials and Methods 40 patients with BMI ≤ 30 were prospectively randomised (20 patients in each group) by use of envelopes. Conventional incision was 12 cm postero-lateral in all cases and minimal incision was diameter of the femoral head plus 2 cm. The patients, and assessors (physiotherapists and nurses on ward) were unaware of the treatment group.

Results Average age was 66.95 years for MI group and 68.55 for conventional group (p-0.51). Average BMI for MI and conventional group was 26.5 & 24.4 respectively (p-0.029). Average pre-operative Oxford hip score was 41.75 for conventional group and 42.15 for MI group (p-0.87). There was no statistically significant difference as regards the operating times (p-0.207); post-operative day the patients were mobilised with zimmer frame (p-0.71); drop in hemoglobin (p-0.197) and hematocrit (p-0.208) or the need for blood transfusion (p-0.56). However there was a statistically significant difference in the two groups as regards post-operative pain (on a 10 point visual analogue scale) and the number of postoperative days the patient was fit for discharge. Average pain score on day 1 was 4.05 for MI group and 6.25 for conventional group (p-0.0089) with similar difference on day 2 and the day of discharge. Patients in MI group were fit for discharge on an average 1.65 days earlier than those in conventional group (p-0.042). There was no superficial or deep wound infection, dislocation or per-operative fracture in either group. Transient sciatic nerve neuropraxia occurred in one patient in the minimal incision group which recovered within 6 weeks.

Conclusion Minimal incision posterior approach for total hip replacement may be useful in decreasing the post-operative pain and duration of hospital stay. However the incidence of complications is an area of concern and needs to be studied on a larger study group.


Lankester RF Spencer MB Lee CW Curwen M Blom T Ottesen ID Learmonth

Introduction The CPS-Plus stem (Endoplus UK) is a polished double-taper with rectangular cross section maintained throughout for rotational stability. There are 5 stem sizes with proportionate offset, and 5 neck length options. A unique proximal stem centraliser has been shown to increase proximal cement pressurisation during insertion in-vitro, also assists with alignment of the stem and helps create an even cement mantle. RSA analysis has demonstrated linear subsidence in a vertical plane, without posterior head migration and valgus tilt.

We report a multi-centre prospective clinical trial. 231 hips in 223 patients have been entered into the study. 151 of these have reached 3 years follow-up.

Method Patients were recruited by surgeons working at three centres in the UK, and two in Norway. Merle d Aubigne and Postel, Harris, and Oxford hip scores were recorded pre-operatively and at follow-up (3, 6, 12, 24, 36, 60 months). Radiographic assessment included evaluation of subsidence and the presence of any radiolucencies.

Results Hip scores have been very satisfactory. Radiological subsidence is less than 1.5mm in over 95% of cases and only one stem has subsided more than 3mm. There has been one revision for deep sepsis, 7 dislocations and one femoral fracture, but none of these complications were related to the choice of femoral component. There have been no revisions for aseptic loosening. Kaplan Meier survivorship analysis at 36 months for aseptic stem loosening is 0.997 (95% CI 0.977 – 1) and for all-cause revision is 0.981 (95% CI 0.958 – 1). 53 hips had reached 5-year follow-up at 30/9/04.

Discussion The tradition of polished tapered stems arose from serendipity and most results have been excellent. The CPS-Plus stem represents an attempt to re-examine the issues relating to rotational stability, subsidence, cement pressurisation and offset. Earlier laboratory studies have now been supplemented by this clinical evaluation, performed in a number of different centres by several surgeons, and the evidence is encouraging.

In particular, the RSA subsidence characteristics, cement pressurisation and rotational stability already associated with this implant in-vitro have been supported by excellent survivorship analysis, and the authors believe that increasing familiarity with the concepts raised by this implant will result in clinical benefits in relation to polished taper cemented stem longevity.


Mr WJ Hart Mr A Mehra Mr JP Hodgkinson

Background: Infection in total joint replacement remains one of the most devastating post operative complications. The majority of these infections are still caused by organisms normally found on the skin. The use of adhesive wound drapes has become commonplace in orthopaedic surgery but frequently these are detached from the wound edges at the end of surgery allowing contamination of the wound.

Aim: To develop a technique to improve the adherence of wound drapes.

Methods: The first part of this study was to experiment with a number of techniques to prepare the skin preoperatively. We were able to identify that a combination of initial Betadine in alcohol preparation, followed by re-preparation of the operative site with Chlorhexidine in alcohol produced the best combination of drape adherence. In a consecutive series of 100 patients we have used our original technique of preparing the wound for 50 patients followed by a further 50 patients prepared with the new technique.

Results: In the initial patient group all of the adhesive drapes were detached enough to expose the skin edges in at least one part of the wound by the end of the surgical procedure. With the new technique we have had no detachments of the adhesive drape.

There have been no complications or skin reactions related to this method of skin preparation. There has been no significant difference in the incidence of early post operative wound infection.

Conclusion: This technique of operation site preparation provides an excellent means of preventing detachment of adhesive wound drapes. We have found it reliable, safe and effective to date and it adds little to the overall procedure time. We recommend this technique as a way of ensuring that the skin edges remain covered throughout primary and revision procedures.


MR Utting BJ Lankester L Smith RF Spencer

Background Prescriptive guidelines for selection of implants for hip arthroplasty are likely to become increasingly established, on grounds of safety, cost and effectiveness. Such guidelines were introduced in the UK by the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE) in 2000. Most departments were non-compliant in one or more respects, and knowledge of the recommendations was limited among clinicians. Concern exists that the recommendations may replace the Bolam Test in cases of clinical negligence in future.

Materials and Methods The recommendations of NICE, from the initial documentation to the present, were scrutinised alongside experience of other nationally-funded or managed healthcare systems in Europe and North America. The evolution of guidance from 1999 onwards, together with the areas of potential difficulty were identified.

Results Potential difficulties were encountered in relation to a number of implants in widespread use in the UK, particularly in relation to the choice of acetabular component (cup), despite the fact that cup loosening accounts for a third of revisions. The use of cup and stem from different manufacturers was also identified as a cause of concern.

Discussion Departments face a choice of adopting the recommendations of NICE in their entirety or continuing with established practice, with the attendant risk of future litigation should certain implants prove to be unacceptable as clinical results become available through the National Registry. Continuation with established practice may be acceptable, even in respect of implants not recommended by NICE, provided data collection activity is maintained. We propose an algorithm through which individual departments may maintain compliance with NICE without altering departmental practice.


Mr.M. Carmont Mr.M.K. Sayana Mr. C. Wynn-Jones

It is well appreciated that thigh pain following recent arthroplasty surgery is likely to be due to prosthetic loosening or infection. Both these sequelae can lead to periprosthetic fracture presenting complex challenges to even experienced surgeons.

Revision arthroplasty patients are prone to both fatigue and insufficiency fractures as they may have reduced bone stock after previous surgery and reduced bone density secondary to medical and immobility reasons. The post operative painfree condition will frequently permit early load bearing leading to a relatively rapid increase in activity and load bearing.

Fatigue fractures occur in bone of normal quality subject to abnormal cyclical overloading, leading to resorption and eventual failure, before adequate time has passed to permit adaptive remodelling. Insufficiency fractures occur when normal physiological loads are applied to bone of abnormal quality.

Surprisingly few periprosthetic stress fractures are reported in the literature but a series notes lateral tensile stress fractures associated with varus prosthetic alignment. These all occurred near the tip of the prosthesis.

The case of an unusual Gruen Zone 2, Vancouver B1 stress fracture, 9 months following revision arthroplasty is reported. Initially loosening was suspected due to the development of load bearing thigh pain. Plain radiography revealed the development of a dreaded black line, consistent with a stress fracture. Bone scintigraphy revealed the typical appearance of a stress fracture in the absence of loosening or infection.

The unusual location of this stress fracture allowed consideration of conservative non weight bearing management which lead to the alleviation of symptoms rather than further revision surgery.

This report illustrates this unusual stress fracture and highlights the importance of careful loading practises to permit adequate remodelling following complex revision surgery.


Mr A Mehra Mr WJ Hart Mr N Pradhan

Aim: To develop a device to improve the preparation of morcellised bone graft for use in revision arthroplasty surgery.

Background: Washing morcellised graft prior to impaction has been shown to improve the stability of the graft after impaction. By removing the cellular debris the chance of contamination is potentially reduced.

Methods: A readily available domestic appliance was identified which met the requirements of being able to contain the graft whilst allowing free drainage of the pulsed lavage solution. This hand held potato masher has an all metal construction with few moving parts and is therefore easily cleaned and sterilised between cases. The numerous perforations in the receiver of the masher ensure that the lavage solution rarely backs up and also that all of the cellular debris is washed through effectively.

Results: This device has been in regular use in this institution over the last two years. It allows a no touch technique for the preparation of morcellised graft in complex cases that require replacement of the bone stock.

This poster will demonstrate pictorially the technique for graft preparation and the quality of the prepared graft that can be obtained.


Eric Yeung Andrew Rahman Johan Witt

Pelvic and acetabular surgery may be associated with significant blood loss because of the vascularity and anatomy of the pelvis. Concerns continue in relation to blood transfusion because of the potential for disease transmission and because of the increasing cost of providing safe blood products. The purpose of this study was to examine in a retrospective fashion the blood transfusion requirements in a consecutive series of patients undergoing peri-acetabular osteotomy for hip dysplasia.

Surgery was performed under general anaesthesia with an epidural in place in the majority of cases. A cell saver was not used and no pre operative autologous blood donation was performed. In seven cases one unit of blood was drawn off immediately prior to the operation in the anaesthetic room and re-infused towards the end of the operation. This practice was discontinued when one of these units clotted and could not be re-infused. A post-operative transfusion policy was adopted where an haemoglobin (Hb) concentration of < 7.5 g/dl was an indication for transfusion.

There were 19 females and 2 males. The average age was 26.6 (range 14 – 40). The average duration of surgery was 233mins (range 180 – 285min). Pre-operatively the average Hb concentration was 13.68 g/dl (range 12.3 – 16.2 g/dl). Overall 16 patients did not require any cross-matched transfusion. Two patients received one unit of blood and three received two units. If the transfusion policy had been correctly followed, 4 of these patients would not have received cross-matched blood. The average post-op Hb in those not receiving transfusion was 8.6 g/dl (range 7.3 – 9.9 g/dl).

This study shows that it is possible to safely perform peri-acetabular osteotomies in most cases without blood transfusion which is important in this group of patients who are generally young and female.


D. M Wright A Alonso D. H Sochart M Rathinam

This is a prospective study looking at 116 consecutive total hip replacements in 110 patients using the C-Stem total hip replacement system (Depuy International, Leeds, UK) between March 2000 and October 2002. This is the first documented study of results of the C-Stem outside Wrightington Hospital where it was developed.

There were 69 females and 41 male patients. Average age was 66 years (Range 32 – 89 years). 64 patients had a right hip replacement, 52 patients had a left hip replacement and 6 were bilateral. The duration of follow up was from 24 to 55 months, with an average of 38.75 months.

All patients had a cemented C-stem via a posterior approach. 107 with a metal head and 9 with a ceramic head. Cemented, all polyethylene cups were used. 82 hips had an Opera cup inserted and 34 had an Ogee cup inserted. Palacos R with Gentamicin was used for the cement.

103 femoral stems were neutral.12 stems were in varus (5–10 degrees) and 1 stem was in valgus (5–10degrees). No stems were greater than 10 degrees in either direction. There were no lucencies in any of the zones described by Gruen. The average amount of subsidence of the stem was 0.86mm (range 0–4mm).

The average cup angle was 44.29 degrees (SD = +/− 4.85). 8 acetabular components had a 0.5mm lucent area in zone 1 and 2 acetabular components had 1mm lucent area in zone 1. All of these lucencies were present on the immediate postoperative x-ray and none were progressive.

There were no lucencies in the other zones. There have been no incidences of deep infection, fatal P.E, dislocation or revision.

We conclude that the C-Stem has produced excellent results in the short term in keeping with the criteria of the NICE guidelines.


Mr AH Mehra Mr WJ Hart Mr JP Hodgkinson

We present the case of an elderly lady who was treated surgically as an infant for osteomyelitis of the left distal femur. Throughout the whole of her adult life she describes episodes where the thigh has become more painful and warm followed by a watery discharge from a sinus on the upper medial aspect of the thigh. This sinus has discharged at least weekly up until the present day. No further surgery has been performed on the proximal femur since childhood.

Almost 10 years ago the patient presented with symptoms of osteoarthritis in the left hip. A total hip replacement was performed at that time without any further active measures aimed at eradication of the osteomyelitis.

Despite obvious concerns of the possibility of exacerbating the osteomyelitis and developing pan femoral disease this has not been the case. The hip replacement is symptom free, stable and there are no signs of infection clinically or radiologically.

Conclusions: Whilst we would not immediately recommend this course of action; the surgical treatment of long bone osteomyelitis if an arduous procedure for both patient and surgeon with high recurrence rates. This case demonstrates that in low demand elderly patients it may be possible to implant a hip replacement.


Mr WJ Hart Mr A Mehra Dr C Sutton

Aim: To review the study size and requirements of studies looking at factors affecting outcome following total hip arthroplasty.

Background: The orthopaedic literature is full of claims that new products out-perform older ones, cemented and un-cemented components are equal, cementing grades and mantles are all important and that component orientation is vital to longevity. We are also aware of patients who have performed well despite having numerous adverse features to their joint replacements.

We have searched the available literature for factors that have been implicated in the survival of hip replacements. We have used these to determine the likely study sizes required to provide meaningful data.

Method: We identified over 50 variables that have been implicated in the survival of hip replacements. Assuming all of them to be of equal relevance the study size required for multivariate analysis to be possible would be in excess of 50000. Some of these variables are less likely to be of great significance and this number could potentially be reduced to 25–30000.

Discussion: Because total hip replacement has a greater than 90% success rate at 10 years in nearly all series this makes the numbers required for multivariate analysis much larger. Individual factors affecting survival will be difficult to identify unless large series are considered.

Conclusion: The only way to reduce the numbers required for meaningful studies is to increase the matching of as many variables as possible to ensure that investigators conclusions are valid in the majority of small series orthopaedic studies.

The use of Joint Registers is likely to be the only way of obtaining the volume of data required to detect individual factors affecting survival. Care will still need to be taken interpreting this data as there are still numerous variables which are not accounted for in the Joint Register.


Mr WJ Hart Mr JP Hodgkinson

We present the case of a patient with Rheumatoid Arthritis who underwent a right total hip replacement as a young adult. At the time of surgery there was an intra-operative femoral fracture and the prosthesis and cement breached the cortex of the proximal femur postero-medially.

The fracture was detected on the post-operative film and the patient was treated non-operatively until the fracture consolidated. Despite having rheumatoid arthritis our patient went on to an active adult life having a family and she worked full time with this hip replacement. She subsequently required a socket revision at 15 years post index surgery and at the time the femoral component was well fixed, not scratched and left in situ.

Currently, the revision socket remains satisfactory, the stem still appears well fixed and clinically the patient is well.

Discussion: This case highlights the fact that not all intra-operative fractures require surgical intervention. They are low energy events with minimal soft tissue disruption and may heal satisfactorily. This case demonstrates that it should not be assumed that loosening and failure are inevitable.


Mr. D M Wright Mr. A Alonso Dr. E Lekka Mr. D H Sochart

Fractures of the femoral stem component in total hip Arthroplasty have been a well documented complication. The incidence over recent years has decreased due to improvements in both surgical technique and implant design and manufacture.

We report two cases of femoral stem fracture. Both occurred in CDH stems from the C-stem system (Depuy International, Leeds, UK). Both patients were women weighing 83kgs and 89kgs at the time of fracture. The fractures occurred at 46 and 24 months respectively.

The design of the CDH stem is fundamentally different from the rest of the primary stems with absence of the medial strut. In addition to this factor, both stems fractured through the insertion hole, which acted as a stress raiser. Also of note was the fact that both patients BMI’s were above 25. No weight restrictions have been imposed by the company on this implant.

We conclude that if at all possible, a primary C-stem should be inserted but if a CDH stem is used attention to patients’ weight is paramount.


Mr WJ Hart Mr A Mehra Mr ML Porter

Aim: A radiological review to assess component orientation in a consecutive series of primary total hip replacements performed by a high volume hip surgeon through either a standard or reduced size incision.

Background: Using a posterior approach and standard instrumentation the senior author has reduced his incision size in selected patients over the last 2 years. There is no fixed definition of incision size in this series, incision sizes fall between 10 and 15cm in most cases. The implication is that deliberate efforts were made to limit the incision length compared to a routine exposure at the start of surgery.

Method: From the operative records kept for the senior author a series of 48 patients was identified, with equal numbers having reduced or standard incisions. A radiological review was performed looking at the cementation, leg length and component orientation in both the AP and lateral planes.

Results: In the AP plane there was no significant difference in the alignment of the components. In the reduced incision group an increased number of stems were directed from anterior to posterior on the lateral x-rays.

The quality of the femoral cement mantles was significantly better in the standard incision group (75% Barrack A vs. 50% Barrack A)

On the acetabular side the components were better positioned and orientated in the small incision group but cementation was again improved in the standard incision group.

Conclusions: Reducing incision size does have an influence on cementation and the positioning of components during hip arthroplasty.

The orientation and cementation of components in both study groups would be considered acceptable in the majority of cases.

The authors recommend small audit studies of this nature as a way of providing ongoing feedback on the quality of their surgery thereby allowing improvements to be made to their surgical technique.


S. P. White A. Blom M. Lee E. J. Smith

Dissociation of the polyethylene liner of modular acetabular components is a rare occurrence, and previous reports have commented on the difficulty in diagnosis from plain radiographs. The radiograph is often incorrectly reported by radiologists as showing advanced polyethylene wear, causing delay in referral and increasing the complexity of treatment required.

We report 9 cases of late polyethylene liner dissociation of the cementless Harris-Galante II porous-coated acetabular component (Zimmer Inc, Warsaw, IN) which occurred without trauma or injury. This is the largest reported series to date.

In all cases, there was a common pattern of clinical symptoms and signs which is described.

Radiographs showed a distinct appearance with a radiolucency medial to the femoral neck in association with an eccentrically placed femoral head lying in contact with the acetabular metal shell. We have termed this the ‘crescent sign’.

We believe that the diagnosis can be made from a single antero-posterior pelvic radiograph without the need for previous films for comparison, or the need for arthrography. Clinicians should look specifically for the crescent sign when an eccentrically placed femoral head has been noted, in order to differentiate the more unusual diagnosis of dissociation from that of polyethylene wear. Early diagnosis and prompt referral prevents further damage to the femoral head and metal acetabular shell, thus reducing the complexity of revision surgery.


S. P. White E. J. Smith

There is a strong drive from industry, patients and the media to offer minimal access hip surgery (MAS) for joint arthroplasty. There is a plethora of definitions, implants, specialist instrumentation and techniques available. Confusion reigns as to the definition, who should offer it, which approach should be used, and what training should be undertaken.

Method : All Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeons in the United Kingdom were sent a simple questionnaire asking for MAS training undertaken, evidence of specialisation, volume of minimal access cases performed, availability of specialist instrumentation, approach used and definition of mimimal access surgery.

Results : 23% of those performing hip arthroplasty had performed MAS. The majority performed between 1–5 cases last year. 41% had observed MAS.

Of those with a specialist interest in hip arthroplasty, 37% had performed MAS.

Of those performing MAS, 83% had observed another surgeon and 60% had attended a course. 29% of consultants intend to perform MAS in the future. The mean and mode quoted length of a regular total hip arthroplasty scar was 15.4 and 15cm respectively. The mean and mode quoted length of a MAS scar was 9.7 and 10 cm respectively.

75% used the miniposterior approach.

Relationships with specialisation, British Hip Society membership and volume breakdown are discussed.

Conclusion: MAS is a popular technique although currently small case numbers are being performed. Given the level of interest in the technique, the definition and training required need to be clarified, and the clinical outcome requires close monitoring to ensure that standards of implantation are not jeopardised.


Graham S J Chuter David J Cloke Sarah M Green Paul F Partington

Introduction The ABG I acetabular insert is an ultra high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) component used in primary hip arthroplasty. Studies have shown early osteolysis and aseptic loosening of the ABG I uncemented cup compared with other implants. Theories advocate that loosening is initiated by the biological response to insert wear debris; wear volume and the distribution of particle size are considered to be important parameters. This study analysed explanted plastic inserts to identify any mechanical properties that may have contributed to early failure.

Materials and Methods 21 ABG I acetabular components were revised due to aseptic loosening over a 16 month period. Silicone casts of the insert sockets were made and volumetric analysis performed using a shadowgraphing technique and a coordinate measuring machine (CMM). The UHMWPE inserts were divided into uniform pieces with a diamond-tipped microsaw and analysed for hardness, wear, stress and strain properties using a microhardness tool, pin-on-plate analysis and small punch testing. We performed identical tests on explanted inserts from other manufacturers.

Results We present the findings of the above tests and provide suggestions as to why these particular implants are more prone to early failure when compared with other common implants. We also discuss the results of volumetric analysis by shadowgraphing compared with CMM.


Simon Jameson Daniel Howcroft Prof. Andrew McCaskie Mr. Craig Gerrand

Introduction Smaller skin incisions during a minimally invasive approach to total hip arthroplasty may accelerate rehabilitation and reduce inpatient stay. Cutaneous nerve injury from a standard 20cm lateral approach was compared with a new, oblique minimally invasive 10cm incision.

Method The two surgical approaches were defined on fifteen cadaveric thighs. Cutaneous nerves lying deep to the incisions were dissected out. Projected nerve injury resulting from each approach was recorded.

Results The mean number of nerves divided by a standard approach was 5.0 compared with 4.1 in the minimally invasive approach (mean difference 0.87, 95% confidence interval 0.03 to 1.7, P=0.043). However, the mean number of nerves per cm divided by the standard approach was 0.25 compared with 0.41 by the minimally invasive (mean difference −0.163, 95% confidence interval −0.09 to −0.24, P< 0.001).

Discussion The oblique incision ran perpendicular to the underlying cutaneous nerves; therefore, more cutaneous nerves were divided per cm than a standard approach. A 10cm oblique incision divides as many nerves as a 16cm standard approach.


Mr Carl Meyer Mr Marcus Head Mr Ian McMurtry

Introduction The effect of hip rotation on the measurement of femoral offset is determined firstly using artificial bones in an anatomical study and then in a patient population. Its effect on the choice of femoral component in total hip arthroplasty is discussed

Methods X-rays were taken of a series of saw bone models rotated through a range of angles. The resultant offset was then measured

Standardised and Control (unstandardised) x-rays of the pelvis were taken of patients presenting to orthopaedic outpatients. Femoral offset was measured from each x-ray

Results In the anatomical study angles of rotation differed significantly with respect to measurement of offset (p< 0.0001 Friedman 2-way analysis of variance by ranks). The greatest measurement of offset was at 15 degrees internal rotation. Offset decreased with external rotation.

The clinical study had power of 80%. Femoral offset was increased in all the standardised x-rays compared with their controls (n=64, mean=8.68, SD=5.56, 95% CI (7.34,10.01) A one-sample t-test was performed to see if the standardised and control films were greater than 5mm different (t=12.94 (63df), p< 0.01).

Conclusions The clinical study confirmed the findings of the anatomical study. A standardised AP x-ray of the pelvis improves the measurement of femoral offset.

For surgeons using the Exeter hip system failure to account for offset could lead to the selection of a stem two sizes too small with regards to offset. Lesser degrees of rotation, not readily identified by looking at the x-ray, could still lead to the selection of an incorrectly sized stem.

Offset has been shown to increase the range of movement, abductor strength and stability of the hip joint whilst decreasing the rate of wear. It therefore benefits patients to account for offset, ensuring a correctly sized hip replacement.


Miss Samantha Z. Tross Mr. K. Min-Yeoh Mr. Len Walter

Patients with Neuromuscular disorders who have an arthritic hip joint present unique challenges. Due to inadequate bone stock, bony deformity and muscle imbalance there is a potentially increased risk of dislocation. These patients who have undergone conventional total hip replacement in the past, have been immobilised post-operatively in a hip spica to prevent post-op dislocation. Large heads are inherently more stable and adequately treat these patients, without the need for post-operative immobilisation.

We present our experience with large head replacement in this group of patients. Eight patients, five with cerebral palsy, two with Down’s Syndrome and one with Cornelia de large Syndrome, who underwent total hip replacement with a large head prosthesis were reviewed. Their average age was 44.5 years and patients were followed up for maximum 51 months. Patients were assessed with respect to pre- and post-op pain, mobility and function. Hip scores have not been found to be useful in assessing these patients.

Two Birmingham Surface replacements were used and six large heads on conventional stems, with large uncemented cups. In all patients there was improvement in pain and function. Four patients had improvement in their ambulatory status. In none did this worsen. Despite no post-operative immobilisation, there was only on dislocation. This was due to error in cup positioning, an error in the early learning curve.

Despite the small numbers and short follow up, we feel that large head replacement is a viable alternative to conventional hip replacement in these difficult cases.


Mr Sanjeev Sharma Dr Gopalkrishna Verma Mr Kingsley P Draviraj Mr M S Bhamra

Introduction Hip arthritis in the young has been a problem area in orthopaedics and thrust plate prosthesis (TPP) was developed as an option. TPP is an implant with fixation in proximal femur metaphysis transmitting hip forces to the resected neck. In young patients undergoing a hip replacement such prosthesis preserves proximal femoral bone stock, which is vital for a revision procedure.

The purpose of the study was to evaluate the results of the Thrust Plate Prosthesis as a treatment option for osteoarthritis of the hip in young patients.

Patients & Methods Of the fifty patients (63 hips) reviewed, 31 (62%) were males and 19 (38%) females. Pre-operative diagnosis included primary osteoarthritis (23), developmental dysplasia (8), avascular necrosis (7), Perthes (4), post-traumatic arthritis (3), rheumatoid arthritis (2), ankylosing spondylitis (1), psoriatic arthropathy (1) and slipped upper femoral epiphysis (1). All components were implanted uncemented with metal-on-metal articulation. The average follow-up was 4.04 years (range 12 months–8.5 years).

Results The mean age of the patients was 42.3 years (range 21–57 years). The mean pre-operative Harris Hip Score was 41.9 (range 12–89) and at final follow-up 89.91 (range 41–100). In 25 hips with ≥ 5yr follow-up, the average HHS at final follow-up was 84.5 (range 50–100). Complications included dislocation (2), transient sciatic nerve palsy (1), discomfort from lateral strap (2), implantation of wrong femoral head (1), revision 3 (4.76%) and implant loosening (4) (6.35%).

Conclusion The thrust plate prosthesis is a useful alternative in young patients with hip arthritis and the results are comparable with other uncemented hip replacements. The added advantage is preservation of the proximal femoral bone stock, which can prove useful in future revisions.


F Kwong M Elahi J Swanevelder L Spaine

Objective: Elderly patients with femoral neck fracture have varying degrees of cognitive capabilities when admitted to hospital. Following hemiarthroplasty, these patients are given standard precautionary advice in order to prevent dislocation of their prostheses. We aim to determine the relationship between mental state on admission and the ability to recollect these precautions postoperatively.

Design: Over a one-month period, 26 patients, aged 70 years and above admitted with hip fracture, were recruited prospectively for this audit study. Mini-mental test score on admission was used to classify non aphasic subjects into three groups: normal, mildly impaired and severely impaired. On the 2nd post-operative day (POD) the patients were given verbal instructions aimed at preventing dislocation of their hemiarthroplasty. Recollection of these precautions was then tested using a specially designed questionnaire (score: 1–10) on POD-6 and at 6 weeks.

Results: One patient died (3.8%). Of the remainder, 21 (84%) were female and 4 (16%) were male. The mean age was 80.4. There were 10 patients in Group-I (normal; 40%), 7 in Group-II (mildly impaired; 28%) and 8 in Group-III (severely impaired; 32%). The resulting score to the questionnaire in Group-I was 6.2 and 3.2; Group-II was 3.3 and 1.2; and Group-III was 0.3 and 0.3 on POD-6 and 6 weeks respectively.

Conclusion: 6 days following surgery, the best recollection of advice is only 2 thirds of what the patient had been told and 6 weeks following surgery, the best recollection of advice is only 1 third of the advice given. The recollection of advice in both mentally impaired groups was very poor throughout the study period. We recommend either not giving hip precautions advice to these patients or changing the way the advice is given to try to improve their recollection.


CM Robinson S Houshian LAK Khan

The purpose of this study was to prospectively audit the functional outcome and peri-operative complications associated with the use of a trochantericentry cephalomedullary nail to treat all low-energy subtrochanteric fractures.

Methods: Over a 95 month period, we used the Long Gamma Nail (LGN) to treat a consecutive series of 302 locally-resident patients who sustained subtrochanteric fractures during low-energy trauma. We prospectively assessed the mortality, prevalence of complications and functional outcome during the first year post-injury. We used survivorship methodology to assess the rate of re-operations and implant revision during the first year after surgery.

Results: By one year, 74 patients had died, 10 were untraceable and 7 refused to participate in follow-up. The remaining 211 patients had evaluation of their functional outcome and post-operative complications during the first year post-injury.

The prognosis following an operatively-treated subtrochanteric fracture was similar to other proximal femoral fractures, with a one-year mortality of 24.5%, and an increased level of social dependence, increased use of walking aids and reduction in mobility amongst survivors.

Re-operation was required in 27 patients (8.9%), although only 18 patients required nail revision. On survivorship analysis, 96.8% of fractures had healed by six months post-injury, and only five patients had confirmed non-unions, which were successfully treated with autogenous bone grafting. Lag-screw mechanical failure and fractures distal to the nail were seen in twelve (4%) and five (1.7%) patients respectively; all of these fractures subsequently healed after further treatment. Deep sepsis occurred in only five (1.7%) patients.

Conclusions: Subtrochanteric fractures caused by low-energy trauma have similar prognosis to other proximal femoral fractures. Trochanteric-entry cephalomedullary nails are a versatile treatment option for these injuries, and are associated with an acceptable rate of peri-operative complications and favourable functional outcome.


MHA Malik J Gray PR Kay

Introduction: Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) are inhibitors of cyclooxygenase activity and are potential therapeutic agents in the prevention of aseptic loosening. Cigarette smoking is a risk factor for decreased proximal femur bone density. We investigated whether the clinical variables of NSAID usage and cigarette smoking are possibly linked to aseptic loosening around total hip arthroplasty (THA).

Methods: Retrospective review of records and radiographs of all patients attending for follow-up between August 2002 and 2003 who had undergone THA. Age, gender, primary and revision surgery details, radiographic parameters as detailed above, smoking history and NSAID usage history were recorded. Logistic regression analysis was used to determine the presence of associations.

Results: 224 patients were recruited to the study: 143 to the control group with a mean time of THR survival of 14.6 years and 81 to the aseptic group with a mean time to THR failure of 5.1 years. 130 patients had never smoked, 69 were ex-smokers and 25 were smokers (average of 15.5 cigarettes/day). 13.6% of patients in the study group were smokers and 10.5% in the control group. The average duration of NSAID usage pre-operatively was 3.4 years and post-operatively was 4.4 years. Using the logistic regression model, amount of cigarettes smoked, years as a non-smoker and length of usage of NSAID were not found to be associated with aseptic loosening

Discussion and conclusions: We found no such statistically significant relationship with regards to smoking habit or NSAID usage as either protective or risk factors.


Mr. A. Shetty Dr. M. J. Jackson Mr. M. S. Siddique

Aim To determine the variability of magnification with digital radiographs and thereby improve the accuracy of templating

Materials and methods We have previously described a method of taping a ten pence coin in the region of the greater trochanter, on the basis that it is cheap, easily available and of constant diameter and radio-opacity. The magnification may then be deduced by dividing the coin’s maximal projected diameter by its actual diameter of 24.5 millimetres, as per the Royal Mint’s specifications. The perceived maximal diameter of the coin’s projected image was measured, to the nearest 0.5mm on each illuminated hard film using a standard 30 centimetre ruler with millimetres scale. Coin diameters were subsequently measured to the nearest hundredth millimetres on the digital radiographs.

Results 20 AP digital pelvic radiographs (hard copies and digital images) were analysed. The ranges were as follows: 27.17 to 29.40 mms actual, equating to magnification range 10.9 to 20.00 per cent

Conclusions This study has demonstrated that magnification on digital radiographs is not as constant as previously assumed. Prior to this study a magnification factor of 10% was assumed to be standard on all pelvic X-rays and was the basis of templating.

We now recommend using a set magnification of 15% in our department, or to be more accurate using radio-opaque markers for templating.


MHA Malik E Staniford E Handford AK Gambhir PR Kay

Previous attempts to assess the comfort and protection afforded by surgical gowns have been extremely simplistic and limited in their nature relying on a single and subjective linear scoring system. We have performed a comfort assessment comparison between the Charnley exhaust suit, disposable gown plus visor and the Stryker Steri-Shield system using a newly developed objective multi-dimensional validated ergonomic tool.

A prospective, comparative study was conducted using a modification of the Comfort Rating Scales (CRS) designed to measure wearable comfort of computer devices during physical activity across 6 dimensions. These dimensions are emotion, attachment, harm, perceived change, movement and anxiety.

10 theatre staff were recruited to the study and completed modified CRS scores on three separate occasions after having worn a disposable surgical gown plus mask with visor, a Charnley exhaust suit and a Stryker Steri-Shield system. The total mean CRS for a disposable gown plus visor was 16.1 with a mean dimensional score of 2.7 (range: 0.2 – 8.4), for the Charnley system the values were 51.4 and 8.6 (range: 5.9 – 12.8) respectively and for the Stryker Steri-Shield 15.4 and 2.6 (range: 0.8–5.6).

Although disposable, impermeable gown plus visor or the Steri-Shield system provide a similar level of comfort, the modified CRS has demonstrated that over 6 dimensions of measurable comfort the Steri-Shield system provides the least variation in comfort and as such may offer the best combination of comfort, protective qualities and form or style of personal protection systems for lower limb arthroplasty operations.


A Gordon E Kiss-Toth I Stockley A Hamer R Eastell JM Wilkinson

Phagocytosis of wear particles by perimplant macrophages results in cytokine release and osteoclast activation and osteolysis. Some investigators have proposed that this response may be mediated by adherent endotoxin. The aim of this study was to determine the role of endotoxin in modulating pro-inflammatory cytokine mRNA expression of macrophages when stimulated with titanium particles using relative quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (rqRT-PCR)

Human peripheral blood mononuclear cells were isolated from healthy subjects and plated in chamber slides. Three types of titanium particles were prepared; commercially pure titanium particles (cpTi), endotoxin stripped particles and endotoxin stripped particles with endotoxin (LPS) added back. Endotoxin levels of 450, 0 and 140 Eu/ml respectively were confirmed by high sensitivity Limulus Amebocyte Lysate assay. Macrophages were stimulated with particle concentrations of 0, 8.3, 83 and 830 particles per cell at time points 0 and 3 hours. LPS (200ng/ml) was used as a positive control. rqRT-PCR was performed using standard techniques.

Stimulation of human macrophages with cpTi demonstrated a significant dose dependent increase in TNFα, IL-1A, IL-1B and, IL-6. (Kruskal-Wallis p=0.01, p=0.017, p=0.001 and p=0.013 respectively). IL-18 mRNA levels were not increased (P> 0.05). The expression of mRNA following stimulation with the highest dose of titanium particles was similar to that following LPS stimulation. Endotoxin-free cpTi particles did not elicit any increase in mRNA expression above base line levels (P > 0.05, all cytokines). This lack of response was rescued in endotoxin-stripped particles with LPS added back. Particle dose dependent increases in cytokine mRNA levels were observed for TNFα, IL-1A, IL-1B and, IL-6 mRNA but not IL-18 (p=0.01, p=0.01, p=0.01, p=0.05 and p=0.> 0.05 respectively).

Our results show that adherent endotoxin plays a role in modulating particle induced pro-inflammatory cytokine mRNA expression in-vitro. Further study is required in evaluating the role of adherent endotoxin in vivo


D Barlow V Hill P Hopgood JG Andrew

This paper describes the surgical indications and technique for lateral femoral cutaneous neurectomy in the hip following formation of a neuroma post surgery.

We would like to present a single surgeon series of the treatment of localised trochanteric pain post total hip replacement. It is believed that in certain cases localised pain in the line of the scar is attributable to formation of a neuroma of the posterior branch of the lateral femoral cutaneous nerve of the thigh.

Method We have reviewed a consecutive series of 5 patients who underwent this procedure for unremitting pain following THR. Of the 5 patients 4 underwent unilateral neurectomy and one underwent a bilateral neurectomy. All had persistent pain before the operation with a positive Tinnel’s test.

Results Of all the patients, 4 said that their pain was improved after the operation and would undergo the operation again. One had no improvement at all. None were worse after the operation.

Conclusion We believe selective neurectomy to be a good procedure in this often, difficult clinical situation.

Several case reports will highlight the findings on history and examination and the technique used.


Mr G Shah Mr G Singer

Femoral neck fracture is a recognised complication of Birmingham Hip Resurfacing. But stress fracture is uncommon. Femoral neck stress fractures are one of the most difficult problems to diagnose. The pain associated with a femoral neck stress fracture often is localized poorly and may be referred to the thigh or back.

We present a young fit gentleman who underwent Birmingham Hip resurfacing for Osteoarthritis Hip.

He underwent Birmingham Hip Resurfacing Right side with satisfactory post-operative x-rays and progress. He presented for the Left side Birmingham Hip Resurfacing. X-rays revealed a stress fracture through the femoral neck. Patient was asymptomatic and refused any surgical intervention. Patient successfully underwent Birmingham Hip Resurfacing Left side.

The Right stress fracture neck of femur healed in varus without any further complications.

The patient is asymptomatic after 30 months of diagnosis.

We conclude that expectant treatment has role in asymptomatic stress fracture following Birmingham Hip resurfacing.


N.R Shetty RM Hamer A.J Kerry I. Stockley R. Eastell J.M. Wilkinson

The pattern and magnitude of pelvic periprosthetic bone loss around cementless metal-backed acetabular implants have previously been described. The pattern of periprosthetic BMD change around cemented all-polyethylene acetabular implants is unreported. The aims of this study were to determine the precision of pelvic BMD measurements around the Charnley cup and to examine the longitudinal pattern of BMD change over the first 2 years after surgery.

19 subjects who had previously received a Charnley cup for osteoarthritis underwent duplicate measurements of pelvic BMD after repositioning using an Hologic QDR 4500A densitometer. Scan analysis was carried out using a 4-region of interest model according to a protocol previously described. In-vivo precision was expressed as coefficient of variation (CV%) for each region of interest. The precision of pelvic periprosthetic BMD measurements were 7.7%, 9.8%, 10.8%, and 9.9% for regions 1 to 4, respectively.

Longitudinal BMD changes were measured over a 2 year period in 32 patients (mean age 74 years; 22 women) undergoing cemented THA for unilateral osteoarthritis (17 right-sided). Transient decreases in BMD were observed in regions 2 and 3 (behind the dome of the implant) at 3 months (−9.0% and −13.2%, respectively; P< 0.05) and at 1 year (−8.1% and −9.3%; P< 0.05). By 2 years there had been some recovery in bone mass (BMD−6.9% and −2.6% respectively). No significant changes in BMD for regions 1 and 4 (located at the rim of the implant) were found.

The precision of pelvic periprosthetic BMD measurements for the cemented Charnley cup are poorer than those we have previously reported for cementless cups and may be due, in part, to cement artifact. The pattern of BMD change observed for the Charnley implant suggests that load transfer between the implant and the pelvis occurs principally at the implant rim. The magnitude of bone loss is similar to that we have previously reported for cementless metal-backed acetabular implants.


NR Shetty AJ Hamer RM Kerry I Stockley JM Wilkinson

The Exeter (Howmedica Ltd) and Ultima-TPS (Depuy Ltd) implants are both collarless, polished, double-tapered, cemented femoral implants. The Exeter is manufactured in stainless steel and has an excellent long-term survivorship. The Ultima-TPS is manufactured in cobalt-chrome and has been recently introduced. The aim of this study was to compare the early performance of these implants in a 2-year randomised clinical trial.

65 patients with unilateral hip osteoarthritis were randomised to receive either the Exeter or TPS stem. All received a Charnley Cup. Outcome measures included the Oxford Hip Questionnaire, proximal femoral bone mineral density (BMD) measured by dual energy x-ray absorptiometry, and implant subsidence measured using EBRA. At 2 years 43 patients (66%) were reviewed. 22 patients (mean age 70 years, 16 female, BMI 27.9Kg/m2) received the TPS implant, and 21 patients (mean age 70 years, 15 female, BMI 28.9Kg/m2) received the Exeter implant. 19 patients withdrew for reasons unrelated to the study, 2 died, and 1 was withdrawn after deep wound infection.

Complete Oxford hip scores were available pre-operatively and at 2 years in 37 patients (n=20 TPS). Median (IQR) pre-operative hip scores were 51 (43 to 54) and 48 (36 to 53) for the TPS and Exeter implants, respectively. At 2 years the hip scores improved to 24 (18 to 31) and 22 (16 to 31), respectively. There were no differences in scores between groups at each time-point. There were no differences in BMD between groups at pre-operative baseline, 3 months, 1 and 2 years (Gruen zones 1–7, all time-points; n=19 TPS, n=13 Exeter implants: P> 0.05). Maximum bone loss was seen in Gruen zone 7 at 2 years for bone implants (TPS-11%, Exeter -14%, P> 0.05). Measurement of subsidence over 2 years using EBRA was possible in 20 patients (n=7 TPS, n=13 Exeter). Mean subsidence at 2 years was 1.62mm for the TPS implant and 1.60mm for the Exeter implant (P> 0.05). There was no plain radiographic evidence of osteolysis in either group.

These data suggest that the early performance of the two implants studied is similar. However, long-term survivorship data is required to confirm their equivalency.


S. Kamath D.J. Pegg

Background A further two changes to the technique of primary Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) have recently been advocated, computer assisted surgery and access by mini incision(s). These add to the potential different ways the surgeon can perform THA and are still in an early evolutionary stage. However, they add further fuel to the question, what is the best technique for THA ?

Method We considered the procedure of THA and broke it down into the main component stages. We then assessed the various possible different options for each different stage from the literature and a survey of 14 Orthopaedic Surgeons (6 consultants, 2 associate specialists and 6 trainees).

Results We calculate that THA can be performed by at least 1.08 x 1011 different unique techniques. We were unable to find any consensus on the best technique for THA.

Conclusions This massive diversity causes problems with informed consent, research and training. NICE and NJR have issues regarding choice of implant but we believe the choice of surgical technique for THA can play an even more important role in outcome.


BD Coupe M See SA Fletcher ST Donell JK Tucker

There is an increasing body of evidence that allogenic blood transfusion is harmful and blood itself is a valuable resource not to be dispensed lightly. Therefore, a review was undertaken into the need for allogenic blood transfusion following primary unilateral hip arthroplasty in our unit. An initial audit was performed retrospectively on 191 consecutive patients, revealing that 73 of the 191 (38%) received allogenic blood either intra-operatively or postoperatively. Guidelines were drawn up, then implemented, with the assisistance of the anaesthetic and haematology departments. The threshold for transfusion was a post-operative haemoglobin of less than 8g/dL. A trial period of 2 months was used to study the impact of these guidelines. No patients were excluded at the outset due to age or co-morbidity. During this period 96 patients were identified for inclusion in the study, of which only 19 (20%) required blood transfusion. In order to ensure these guidelines were not unsafe we compared the length of hospital stay following surgery in both groups of patients as a surrogate measure of postoperative complications. There was no significant difference between the lengths of stay in each groups. The conclusion was drawn that these new guidelines are not detrimental to the patient, and roughly halve the need for allogenic blood transfusion.


JR Crawford P Katrana RN Villar

Aims: Leg length discrepancy is a well-recognised complication after total hip arthroplasty. However, the effect of using a cemented or uncemented femoral component on leg length has not been previously investigated. The aim of our study was to assess leg length discrepancy following total hip arthroplasty using a cemented femoral component and to compare this with an uncemented femoral component.

Patients and method: We included 140 patients who had undergone a primary total hip arthroplasty in our study. All patients received an uncemented Duraloc acetabular cup (Depuy, Leeds, UK). Our uncemented group consisted of 70 consecutive patients who had received an uncemented Accolade femoral prosthesis (Depuy, Leeds, UK). Our cemented group included 70 patients who had received a cemented Ultima femoral prosthesis (Depuy, Leeds, UK). Leg lengths were measured from radiographs by two independent observers using a validated assessment method, pre-operatively and at six months post-operatively. Clinical outcome was assessed using Harris hip scores.

Results: The mean age of the patients was 68 years for the uncemented group and 56 years for the cemented group. The overall leg length discrepancy was mean 5.7mm (range 0 to 26mm). The uncemented group had an increase in leg length discrepancy post-operatively compared to the cemented group (6.4mm vs 4.2mm), p< 0.05. There was no significant difference in Harris hip scores between the uncemented and cemented groups either pre-operatively (37.4 vs 38.7) or at 6 months postoperatively (77.9 vs 78.7 respectively).

Conclusion: We found a significant increase in leg length discrepancy after total hip arthroplasty using an uncemented femoral prosthesis compared with a cemented femoral prosthesis. This was detectable radiologically but did not affect clinical outcome. Patients should be informed about the risk of leg length discrepancy before total hip arthroplasty particularly if an uncemented femoral prosthesis is used.


JR Crawford I Syed M Babatope GS Keene

Aims: Post-operative check radiographs after primary total hip replacement are routine practice in many orthopaedic units. However they can be uncomfortable for patients and are often of poor quality. We conducted a prospective study to assess the quality of post-operative check radiographs after total hip replacement and to establish whether they alter the management of the patient.

Patients and method: We included 50 consecutive patients that underwent a primary total hip replacement in our study. During the post-operative period A-P and lateral check radiographs of the hip were performed. For each patient, any change in management and the time to discharge were recorded. The quality of each set of radiographs was assessed using a standard proforma (0–10) and scored by two independent observers.

Results: The mean age of the patients was 68 years (range 39 to 83 years). The median time to x-ray was 4.0 days from operation and the median length of stay was 7.0 days. Overall 7 (14%) patients had their discharge delayed by a mean time of 2.0 (±0.89) days waiting for post-operative radiographs. The mean score for quality of radiographs was 8.12 (±1.32) with good inter-observer and intra-observer agreement. In total, 15 (30%) sets of radiographs were of inferior quality (a score of 7 or less). None of the patients had their management altered by the post-operative radiographs.

Conclusion: We conclude that initial post-operative radiographs are of inferior quality and do not alter the management of the patient. Consideration should be given to performing check radiographs at the first out-patient clinic follow-up as an alternative.


DO CENTRALISER’S WORK? Pages 249 - 249
Full Access
AM Thomas G. Bedi CHM Curwen

Inadequate cementation remains a prime cause of aseptic loosening in Hip Arthroplasties. While good progress has been made in preparation of femoral canal and cement, with newer techniques there are problems with ensuring adequate cement mantle. A distal centraliser available with some prosthesis does aid in better alignment and distal centralisation, but proximal centralisation remains a problem especially with some approaches.

We have recently used a new prosthesis CPS (Endoplus) which has a smooth polished double tapered design and also comes with a proximal and distal centraliser. We undertook a study to evaluate the effect of these on cement mantle, stem alignment, centralisation and supero-medial cement thickness. We defined adequate mantle as a thickness of at least 2mm. 75 consecutive cases were included in the study. All cases were done either by or under direct supervision of the senior author using the antero-lateral approach.

We found 88% of stem’s aligned within 2 deg. of anatomical axis of the femur. Distal tip of the prosthesis was within 2mm of centre of the medullary canal in 92% in the lateral view and in 95% in AP view. Deficiencies in cement mantle were noted in very few cases, zones 6 & 13 had the highest incidence but even here only 9% of cases had inadequate cementation.

We find the centralisers a useful adjunct in cemented hip arthroplasty.


A Gordon L Southam J Loughlin I Stockley A Hamer D Macdonald R Eastell M Wilkinson

In-vitro evidence suggests that wear debris can alter osteoblast function resulting in decreased bone matrix production and negative remodelling balance. FRZB encodes for Secreted Frizzled-Related Protein 3 which may play a role in bone formation and osteoarthritis. This study was undertaken to investigate whether the recently described single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) at positions [+6] and [+109] of the FRZB gene are associated with osteolysis after THA.

Genomic DNA was extracted from 481 North European Caucasians at a mean of 12 years following cemented THA for idiopathic osteoarthritis. The control group consisted of 267 subjects and the osteolysis group 214 subjects. The [+6] and [+109] FRZB SNPs were genotyped using standard techniques.

For the FRZB [+6] SNP, the rare T allele was significantly over-represented in control versus the osteolysis group (χ2 test for trend, p=0.02,). The odds ratio for osteolysis associated with carriage of the [+6] T-allele versus the [+6] C-allele was 0.58 (95%CI 0.36 to 0.94), p=0.03. The odds ratio for osteolysis associated with carriage of the [+109] G-allele versus the [+109] C-allele was 0.66 (0.38 to 1.12), p=0.15. A number of covariates have previously been described in this cohort and after adjustment for the effects of these covariates, the odds ratio for osteolysis with carriage of the [+6] T-allele was 0.69 (0.42–1.16).

We found that the FRZB [+6] T-allele is less common in subjects with osteolysis after THA versus controls, suggesting that allelic variants of genes associated with bone formation pathways may have a role in modulating the risk of osteolysis. However its loss of significance after correction for other factors suggests an interaction between this allele and other risk factors in osteolysis.


P Lakshmanan RGN Hansford DJ Woodnutt

Background The magnitude of the medial offset and the limb length discrepancy after a total hip replacement (THR) significantly alters the biomechanics of the hip. If both these components are not properly restored, the rate of dislocation may increase. Further decreased offset may result in impingement at the extremes of movement, and also results in soft-tissue laxity, while increased offset increases stress within the stem that may lead to stem fracture or loosening. In addition to affecting the clinical outcome, limb length discrepancy may also cause legal problems.

Aim To find out whether intraoperative assessment and restoration of desired offset, and correction of limb length discrepancy actually corrects these two components as assessed by postoperative radiographs.

Material and Methods We evaluated 39 consecutive THRs in 37 patients who had the surgery performed via the posterior approach. Intraoperatively the medial offset was measured using a ruler from the tubercle in the trochanteric fossa to the centre of rotation of the head, and then check again after the seating of the femoral prosthesis. The size of the head was then accordingly altered. The limb length was measured using the ruler parallel from the lesser trochanter, and taking it upto the tip of the greater trochanter. The preoperative and the postoperative radiographs were evaluated for the medial offset and limb length discrepancy. The medial offset was calculated as a ratio in reference to the opposite side.

Results The median medial offset was 93.9 (85–100) preoperatively and 94.2 (85–110) postoperatively. The median limb length discrepancy was improved from a preoperative −4.84mm (0 to −30mm) to a postoperative −0.06mm (−9 to +16mm).

Discussion Preoperative templating may be a way of obtaining the correct medial offset and limb length in THRs. However, varus or valgus placement, and sinking or protrusion of the prosthesis may alter both these components significantly. Hence, intraoperative measurement and thus changing the components and the position of the stem accordingly may be the best method in addition to preoperative templating, in achieving the required offset and minimising limb length discrepancy in THRs.


A R Guha U K Debnath S Karlakki J R Wootton

Introduction The Zweymuller tapered cementless titanium femoral stem has been in widespread use since 1986.1 Stress shielding of the proximal femur has been a concern with pressfit cementless femoral stems. Radiolucent lines (RLLs) are signs of stress shielding and possibly over time, may lead to aseptic loosening.2

Aim To evaluate the longterm radiographic bone response in the femur following Zweimuller total hip replacements.

Study Design Consecutive case study (serial radiographic analysis)

Material and Methods 49 Total Hip Replacements in 42 patients (M:F=25:17) with a mean age of 59 years (range 49–70 years), were included in the study. All patients were operated on by the senior surgeon (JRW). 28 Alloclassic and 21 Endoplus stems were implanted. AP and Lateral radiographs were assessed. A gap of 1mm or more at the bone prosthesis interface was recorded as positive for RLLs in the Gruen zones. The mean duration of follow-up was 46 months (range 24–140 months). 17 patients had follow up of more than 5 years. Other measurements included subsidence, bone remodelling and heterotropic ossification.

Results After 2 years there were distinct radiological changes (RLLs), mainly in Gruen zones 1 and 7, in 18/49(36%) femora. Though there was evidence of RLLs in zones 2 and 6, the numbers were insignificant. Subsidence of more than 3mm was noted in 16 stems (33%). Heterotropic ossification was found in 4 patients (8%), one of whom required excision. Persistent pain due to trochanteric bursitis was noted in 10 patients. 4 patients needed revision due to reasons other than aseptic loosening. There were two dislocations, which needed revision of the acetabular component.

RLLs were more common in the Endoplus group (10/21) compared to the Alloclassic group (8/28). There was no clinical compromise (all had pain free mobility) in these patients and no progression of RLLs was noted.

Conclusion Proximal femoral stress shielding following Zweimuller femoral stem implantation is observed in significant number of patients. The RLLs do not correlate with symptoms and patient satisfaction.


NA Munro M Nicol S Selvaraj DF Finlayson

Cement pressurisation is recognised as critical to achieving optimal results in cemented arthroplasty of the hip, but relatively little data exists on the pressures generated by different cement introduction systems. An in vitro experiment was consequently undertaken to measure the mean pressures developed by three such systems: the Howmedica Mark 1 and DePuy Cemvac retrograde cementation systems, and a novel antegrade system consisting of a simple 60ml catheter-tipped syringe and a Miller proximal femoral seal (Zimmer Ltd).

Plastic femoral models (Sawbones Europe) were prepared as for hip arthroplasty, and had a series of three transducers attached to their medial wall. Pressure was recorded continuously during cement introduction and pressurisation, before implanting a hip prosthesis and allowing the cement to cure. The experiment was repeated on ten models for each of the three systems. After cement curing, the femora were split in the coronal plane and examined for air-bubble defects in 7 zones analogous to Gruen’s radiographic zones.

Mean pressure was significantly higher for the syringe system (161.45 ± 28.9 kPa) than the Mark 1 (103.51 ± 22.0 kPa) or Cemvac (92.65 ± 30.7 kPa) systems (p=0.0001, ANOVA). The antegrade syringe system also generated a statistically different distribution of pressure in comparison to the two retrograde systems, with particularly high proximal pressurisation in the former. The median number of zones with defects was 1 (interquartile range 1,2) using the syringe system, 3 (IQR 2,4) with the Mark 1 system, and 3 (IQR1,3) using the Cemvac system. These differences were also statistically significant (p=0.0256, Kruskal-Wallis).

These results have relevance for clinical practice and cement system design, and the various design features of the different systems are discussed.


EP Jesudason M Jeyem

Introduction Intertrochanteric fractures are common and represent a major source of morbidity and mortality. As with all orthopaedic implants a DHS can fail. One of the most important predictors of failure has been shown to be the Tip-Apex Distance (TAD). An audit was carried to assess the following:

What was our rate of cut out and implant failure?

Where we achieving an acceptable screw position and TAD?

Was there any difference between TAD and grade of surgeon?

Methods An audit of the case notes and x-rays of 54 consecutive patients with hip fractures, treated with DHS, within a twelve-month period were reviewed. Demographic data, grade of surgeon, fracture stability, DHS position, mortality and implant failure were assessed.

Findings Our rate of failure was 2 out of 54 patients, 3.7%. Both of the patients that failed had a TAD of greater than 20mm, and none of the patients with a TAD below 20mm required further surgery. There was no statistical correlation between TAD and grade of operating surgeon.

Recommendations It is paramount importance to ensure that the basic principles of DHS position are well taught to surgical trainees in order to reduce the risk of failure. Following DHS fixation, patients should be followed up for a minimum of 3 months until evidence of radiographic union is evident. DHS failure rates and screw positions should be constantly audited to ensure that failure rates are minimised.


AC Gray J Christie C Howie L Torrens A Shetty CM Robinson

Study Purpose To assess clinical cognitive function and measure cerebral embolic load following primary cemented hip arthroplasty.

Methods 34 primary cemented hip arthroplasty patients (mean age 69.9 (SD 11.0)0 and no history of cerebrovascular disease, underwent cognitive assessment before and after (day 4) surgery. Testing included: Verbal fluency and speed (Control Oral Word Association Test); Working memory to assess immediate and delayed recall (Weschler Memory Scale III); Attention and mental processing speeds (Colour Trails 1& 2). A one sample Wilcoxon signed rank test compared median differences before and after surgery. A sub-group of 20 patients had intra-operative transcranial Doppler ultrasound monitoring of the middle cerebral artery for embolic signals. A marker of neuronal injury (S-100B protein) was measured pre-operatively and at 0, 24 and 48 hours following surgery.

Results A significant difference was noted in Colour Trails tests 1& 2 following hip arthroplasty with P values (C.I.) of 0.002 (−21, −4) and 0.023 (−15.5, −1.0) respectively.

Using established emboli criteria 10 (50%) patients had true cerebral emboli with a range from 1 to 550 signals (median 2.5 interquartile range (IQ) 2 to 12.5). S-100B levels increased from a pre-operative median (IQ) of 0.15 microg/L (0.12 to 0.20) to a peak immediately following surgery of 1.88(1.36 to 4.24) returning to 0.26(0.18 to 0.37) by 48 hours (normal range: 0.03–0.15). Plotted scatter charts indicated no correlation between embolic load and cognitive dysfunction or with S-100B levels following surgery.

Conclusion Cognitive testing indicates deterioration in early measured attention, visual searching and mental processing speed shortly following hip arthroplasty. No direct correlation was found between cognitive dysfunction and cerebral embolic load.


R Bhattacharya V Kumar AC Hui

Purpose of the study: To determine usefulness of skyline x-ray in diagnosis of patellofemoral osteoarthritis.

Materials and Methods: 50 patients scheduled to undergo knee surgery, had standard antero-posterior, lateral and skyline x-rays of their affected knee. At operation, their patellofemoral joints were graded into two groups according to presence or absence of osteoarthritis. Their lateral and skyline x-rays were also graded into the same two groups, according to presence or absence of patellofemoral osteoarthritis. The two x-ray views were then compared individually against operative findings.

Results: The skyline view had sensitivity of 79% (95% confidence intervals (C.I.) 66% to 93%) and specificity of 80% (95% C.I. 62% to 98%). The lateral view had sensitivity of 82% (95% C.I. 69% to 95%) and specificity of 65% (95% C.I. 44% to 86%).

Conclusion: There was no statistically significant difference between the two x-ray views in terms of sensitivity and specificity in the diagnosis of patellofemoral osteoarthritis of the knee joint. Hence, we cannot recommend the skyline view as a routine radiological investigation in all cases of suspected patellofemoral osteoarthritis.


JH Newman M Hendrix

Introduction: This study assesses the prevalence of trochlear dysplasia as a cause of patello-femoral arthritis (PFOA), though for many years the condition was scarcely recognised and not recorded.

Method: Since 1989 385 primary isolated patello-femoral replacements have been performed in Bristol for patello-femoral arthritis.

The diagnoses recorded were:

Lateral facet PFOA 227

Symmetrical PFOA 95

Medial facet PFOA 24

Dislocation 15

Subluxation 33

Post traumatic 6

Trochlear dysplasia was noted either retrospectively or as “other diagnosis” in only 10 cases between 1989 and 2003, however in the last year, the condition became recognised locally, and has been recorded in 11 of the 48 cases performed.

A recent review of 40 cases aged under 55 showed evidence of causative trochlear dysplasia in more than 50%.

This was based on:

Trochlear dysplasia recorded on operative note 8

A positive crossing sign on a true lateral xray 19

A sulcus angle > 144° 20

Conclusion: Trochlear dysplasia frequently leads to severe symptomatic patello-femoral arthritis, often at an early age, and can be helped by isolated patello-femoral replacement. Since only 38 of the 385 cases had undergone re-alignment procedures it seems likely that the condition initially presents in a variety of ways.


SG Nicol MB Howard JH Newman

Introduction: Progressive symptomatic tibiofemoral arthritis following PFJR is an important cause of failure. This study is designed to quantify radiologically the degree of tibiofemoral disease progression in patients who have undergone PFJR in our institution.

Patients and Methods: A prospective series of 102 consecutive Avon PFJRs in 78 patients with a minimum follow-up of five years was analysed.

Available AP weight bearing radiographs of the knee taken at 8 months and 5 years postoperatively were examined in a random order twice by each of two surgeons who were blinded to the patient details and length of follow up. The severity of arthritis was graded using the classifications of Ahlback and Altman, giving a measure of arthritis progression.

Results and Discussion: Arthritis was seen to progress in 8.5–17% of medial and 11–17% of lateral compartments after PFJR. Statistically significant progression was demonstrated using the Altman but not the less sensitive Ahlback scoring system, suggesting that the former should be used in scoring the tibiofemoral joint prior to PFJR. Of those patients who had a preoperative tibiofemoral Altman score of zero, 87% showed no radiological evidence of disease progression at minimum 5 year follow up, suggesting that these are the ideal candidates for PFJR.


DO Molloy J McConway NW Thompson DE Beverland

Isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis has been reported to occur in approximately 5% of patients with gon-arthrosis of the knee. A number of options are available for the surgical management of these individuals. We reported the short-term outcomes on thirty three patients (33 knees) with isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis who underwent LCS total knee arthroplasty (TKA) without resurfacing who had been operated on between 1996 – 19991.

Barrack et al2 in 2001 reported on the incidence of anterior knee pain in two groups of TKA patients, one with patella resurfacing and one without. They reported an increase incidence of anterior knee pain in both groups.

We now report the longer-term outcomes with an average follow-up of 80.2months (range 54–94 months). At latest review, 9 patients experienced night time pain, all describing it as improved from their preoperative level. Twelve patients walked with the use of a walking aid, compared with 21 preoperatively. Disease specific scores at latest review showed improved outcome measures at latest review.

We also report our outcomes in an additional fifty-five patients (59 knees) with isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis who were treated between 1999–2004 receiving an LCS total knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing. Our preliminary findings suggest that this technique continues to be an option in the management of the older patient with isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis.


M R G Hendrix C E Ackroyd

Aims: determine functional outcome of revision Avon patellofemoral replacements (PFR), converted from primary Lubinus PFR.

Materials and Methods:

Prospective review of 11 knees (8 patients, 6 female).

Average age at primary PFR – 64 years

Indication – isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis (11), patellofemoral instability (3)

9 knees (7 patients) temporarily improved.

Revision Avon PFR at average 83 months after primary procedure.

Indication – polyethylene wear

polyethylene synovitis

femoral component malposition

At review:

average 61 months after revision

age – 70 years 10 months.

fixed flexion contracture 1.7°

maximum flexion 111°.

Bristol knee score improved from average of 54.5 to 77.2. Pain score component averaged 25, functional component averaged 16.9. No malalignment or instability.

Average American Knee Society Score 132.8

Bartlett patellar score 19.8

Three patients (4 knees) had medical problems contributing to their functional incapacity.

No radiological complications except minor polyethylene wear on lateral facet of one patella. Progression to tibiofemoral osteoarthritis (Ahlburgh grade 1) in 3 knees.

Discussion: Primary Lubinus PFR temporarily improved 82% of knees. Maltracking/polyethylene wear was usual cause for failure. Revision to Avon PFR resulted in substantial improvement of pain and function.

Conclusion: revision Avon PFR can provide a suitable alternative to revision to total knee replacement.


R Roach R Banim D Rees S Roberts S White

Background: Unfortunately ACL injuries are not uncommon in the young: the majority however occurring after skeletal maturity.

Aim: To perform an internal audit of the demand, methods and results of ACL reconstruction in young patients at a tertiary referral centre.

Methods: Patients were identified through electronic patient records, and all operation notes and follow up records were scrutinised.

Results: 84 cases under 20 years of age (range 14–19) were reviewed from 2000–2004 with a minimum follow-up of 6 months. Over 10% had undergone previous surgery or had documented articular injury. 42 cases required further meniscal surgery at the time of reconstruction: 12% repairs (20/168 menisci), 18% partial menisectomy (30/168). The median time to reconstruction from injury was 9 months (range 1–72). No case was delayed for growth plate maturation. Reconstruction methods were partly surgeon dependent, following adult themes. Occasionally tibial fixation was away from the growth plate with low profile screws and washers. We are only aware of 1 failure during this short follow-up.

Conclusion: We believe that the use of techniques similar to those used on adults is appropriate for adolescents. However the high comorbidity is of some concern, demonstrating that this age range is as challenging as their older counterparts.


S. Thomas M. Pullugura E. Robinson A. Cohen

Aim: This retrospective study was undertaken to establish the accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in diagnosing medial meniscal, lateral meniscal and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears.

Materials and methods: Sixty patients who had arthroscopic knee surgery following MRI scans were included in the study. MRI findings were then compared with the pathologies noted at subsequent arthroscopy.

Results: In this study, the sensitivity of MRI in diagnosing tears was 67% (ACL), 100% (medial meniscus) and 57% (lateral meniscus) whereas the specificity was 91%(ACL), 46 %(medial meniscus) and 77 % (lateral meniscus).The positive predictive values were 29% (ACL), 68% (medial meniscus) and 57% (lateral meniscus). The negative predictive values were 98% (ACL), 100% (medial meniscus) and 76% (lateral meniscus).

Conclusion: In contrast to some studies, these findings indicate a lower accuracy for MRI scanning in detecting tears of, in particular of the ACL and lateral meniscus. We suggest that where symptoms and clinical findings support one of these diagnoses and arthroscopic therapeutic intervention is contemplated, that MRI scanning is not beneficial. The additional expense and delay in management seems inappropriate given the findings we have demonstrated.


N J Bottomley A Williams R Birch A Noorani A Lewis J Lavelle

Purpose: The relationship of pattern of injury to this region of the knee to the intraoperative finding of abnormal common peroneal nerve position and associated nerve palsy was studied.

Methods: 54 consecutive patients with posterolateral corner disruption requiring surgery were assessed prospectively by MRI, arthroscopic examination, and by operative display. The pattern of disruption, the status of the biceps tendon and any displacement of the common peroneal nerve were recorded.

Results: Of the 54 cases, there were 9 with CPN palsy, 18 were seen to have distal injuries (13 suffering a fibular head avulsion fracture and 5 biceps tendon avulsion with no fracture). There was a strong relationship (p< 0.001) between such distal posterolateral corner injury and abnormal position of the common peroneal nerve, as 16 of the 18 (90%) patients were seen to have abnormal nerve position. No proximal injury resulted in abnormal nerve position and only 1 was associated with CPN palsy. 7 of the 13 cases of fibular head fracture had CPN palsy, and 1 of the 5 distal soft tissue avulsions.

Conclusion: There is a strong association of distal soft tissue avulsion and fibular head fracture and CPN palsy in these injuries. Whenever such a distal injury is suspected, the surgeon operating in this region should expect an abnormal position of the common peroneal nerve and appreciate the increased risk of iatrogenic damage. Presumably since the CPN is intimately bound to the biceps tendon by deep fascia, proximal retraction of the biceps tendon results in displacement of the CPN to an abnormal position and accounts for the high incidence of nerve palsy.


J R Robinson A M J Bull A A Amis

Introduction: By characterising ACL strain behaviour in intact and posteromedial deficient knees under a variety of external loading conditions the aim of this work was to demonstrate whether posteromedial corner insufficiency could increase strain in an ACL reconstruction graft.

Materials and Methods: 15 fresh cadaveric knees were mounted on a materials testing machine. A miniature extensometer was implanted onto the anteromedial bundle (AMB) of the ACL. The knees were loaded in: Anterior draw (150N), varus/valgus rotation (5Nm) and internal/external rotation (5Nm) at 0°, 15°, 30°, 60° & 90° flexion. The posteromedial corner structures – posteromedial capsule, superficial MCL and deep MCL – were cut sequentially and the effect AMB strain measured.

Results: Strain data for analysis was available for 11 intact knees: Tibial internal rotation produced increased strain in the AMB at all angles of knee flexion (p< 0.05). Tibial external rotation reduced ACL strain at 0° to 30° (p< 0.05) and 60° to 90° knee flexion (p> 0.05).

Anterior loading of the tibia increased AMB strain. With the tibia free to rotate, strain was highest at 90 degrees knee flexion (5.3%) and lowest at 0 degrees (1.6%). Fixed internal and external tibial rotation reduced AMB strain produced by a 150 N anterior drawer force at all knee flexion angles.

Strain data for analysis was available for 6 Posteromedial Corner deficient knees:

With the tibia free to rotate or when locked in internal rotation, cutting the posteromedial structures had no effect on AMB strain with a 150 N anterior drawer force applied to the tibia. However, with the tibia locked in external rotation, cutting the posteromedial structures increased AMB strain at 60 and 90 degrees flexion. This difference however did not reach statistical significance.

Conclusions: The findings that division of the posteromedial structures may cause increased AMB strain and that there is significant load sharing by the peripheral ligamentous structures, suggests that valgus and rotational stresses to the knee in a patient with posteromedial corner insufficiency could lead to increased strain in the ACL graft, that would otherwise have been restrained by the posteromedial corner complex. It would also therefore seem to be appropriate to recommend the use of a collateral ligament brace in the post-operative period when combining a repair of the posteromedial structures and the ACL, to again prevent excessive graft strains.


R Siebold K Webster AG Sutherland J Elliot JA Feller

Introduction: Some authors have suggested that the results of ACL reconstruction in females using hamstring tendon (HS) autograft are inferior to those using patellar tendon (PT) autograft. The purpose of this study was to compare our results of ACL reconstruction in females using both graft types.

Material and methods: 80 females who had undergone primary ACL reconstruction using either HS (n=48) or PT (n=32) were evaluated at mean 3.7 year follow-up (2.4 – 5.7). The same surgeon carried out all the reconstructions, using Endobutton femoral fixation and interference screw tibial fixation, and the same rapid rehabilitation protocol was followed by all patients. Independent assessment included IKDC 2000, SF-36, and Cincinnati Sports Activity Score (CSAS) and measurements of anterior knee pain (AKP), kneeling pain and anterior knee laxity (KT-1000).

Results: One patient in the PT group sustained a traumatic graft rupture. For the remaining patients there were no significant differences between the two graft types in terms of objective IKDC 2000 or KT-1000. In terms of subjective IKDC the HS group scored significantly higher (PT: 85 pts., HS: 90pts, p< 0.05), as well as for the CSAS (PT:72.8 vs. HS: 82.1, p< 0.01) and for the SF-36 on the Physical Functioning (PT:90 vs. HS:95, p< 0.01) and General Health subscales (PT:79 vs. HS 86, p< 0.05). Although there was no significant difference in AKP between the two groups, there was a significantly greater mean kneeling pain in the PT group (PT:4.1 vs. HS: 2.5, p=0.001).

Conclusions: Both PT and HS primary ACL reconstructions appear to provide comparable good objective results in females, but ACL reconstruction with HS showed significantly better subjective results. This finding seems to be related to less donor site problems compared with PT. Our results indicate that a quadruple hamstring autograft is an adequate alternative to a patellar tendon autograft for ACL reconstruction in female patients.


MA Bhutta CD Thomas DS Johnson

Purpose: The aim of this survey was to assess the practice of obtaining informed consent for Total Knee Replacement Surgery in the United Kingdom.

Method: A postal questionnaire was distributed to consultant members of the British Orthopaedic Association. They were questioned regarding their practice for obtaining informed consent for Total Knee Replacement Surgery.

Results: Of the 1571 consultant members contacted 34% (526) replied. From these 76% (400) performed total knee replacements. Informed consent was obtained in a pre-operative assessment clinic in 64%, on admission in 32.5% and during the first clinic visit in 3.5% of cases. Consent was routinely obtained by Consultants in 76%, Senior House Officers in 38%, Pre-Registration House Officers in 4% and Specialist Nurses in 5% of cases. Consultants warned of the following complications: Infection 99.2%, Stiffness 70.5%, Aseptic loosening 81.6%, neurovascular damage 56.9%, DVT 96.5%, PE 88.5%, Wear 61.2% and Mortality 67.4%. Patient information leaflets were provided by 71.5% of consultants for Total Knee Replacement.

Conclusions: This survey has identified inconsistencies in the complications described to patients. Junior practitioners are continuing to obtain informed consent. Informed consent should be obtained by a suitably experienced practitioner. Patient information leaflets should be provided to patients at the time of listing. We recommend national guidelines relating to obtaining consent for Total Knee Replacement should be published by the BASK. These could be incorporated into their best practice document regarding Total Knee Replacement Surgery.


R Raman N Kandiyil W White A Chapman G Chakrabarty

Aim: To report the intermediate clinical and radiological results of a consecutive series of knee arthroplasies using PFC Sigma endoprosthesis.

Methods: 525 total knee replacements (469 patients) were performed from Aug 97 to Jun 01 using the PFC Sigma components. Cruciate retaining femoral component was used in 219 knees. All patients were prospectively followed up at 6 weeks, 3 months and yearly. Pre operative HSS knee scores and Oxford knee scores were compared with annual scores. Quality of life was assessed using SF12 questionnaire. Knee Society scores were used to assess the radiographs. The average follow up was 61 months (36–84). 11 patients lost to follow up.

Results: Of the 469 patients, 64% were females. Mean age was 74.2 yrs (59–90). Pre operative valgus deformity of at least 10 deg was present in 87 (16.5%). Patella resurfacing was performed in 80.5%. A lateral release was performed in 20 patients. Post operative mobilisation was standardised in all patients. 34 patients developed radiologically proven DVT. 24 patients died from unrelated causes. 16 (3%) patients developed superficial and 6 developed deep infection. 4 patients underwent revision surgery (3 for infection, 1- catastrophic failure). The HSS scores improved from 29(16–65) to 86(59–97) at final follow up (p=0.004). Pre operative Oxford knee scores improved from 10(6–31) to 43(37–48) at last follow up (p=0.008). Radiological knee society score for the femur were less than 5 in 477/478 patients and 7 in 1 patient. The scores for the tibia were less than 5 in 475/478 patients and 6 in 3 patients. Average femoral flexion was 1–9.2 deg (3.9), knee valgus angle 0.5–7.4 (3.5) degrees and the tibial slope was 3.1 deg (0–7.1). SF 12 health scores revealed a good functional outcome of both the physical and mental components. With failure defined as repeat revision because of aseptic loosening, the rate of survival at 5 years months was 99.1% and overall survival at 5 years with removal or repeat revision of any component for any reason as the end point was 97.5%.

Conclusion: Our prospective study of patients with primary knee arthroplasties supports the use of PFC sigma total knee endoproshesis. Our results show excellent clinical outcome comparable with other prosthesis. A longer follow up is needed to establish the durability and longevity of this prosthesis given its excellent intermediate term results


K P Iyengar B Tauro

Aim: A prospective cohort study on the role of flowtron intermittent compression garment (Flowtron) in improving fixed flexion deformity (FFD) in patients coming in for Total Knee Replacement (TKR).

Methods: A total of 36 patients with FFD of the knee averaging 26 deg. (range: 22 to 38 deg.) were included. There were 22 men & 14 women, with a mean age of 66 yrs (58 to 78). The diagnosis was osteoarthritis in 26 knees and rheumatoid arthritis in 10. The right knee was involved in 24 patients and the left in 12.There were 26 varus knees and 10 valgus. Patients with peripheral vascular disease and congestive cardiac failure were excluded from the study.

Results: Use of flowtrons for one week at home resulted in 80% mean improvement in fixed flexion deformity from an average 26 to 6 degrees (p< 0.001). The residual correction was obtained on the table without excessive posterior release or bone resection. The correction was found to be maintained at 6 months and 1year follow-up. There were no complications with Flowtron treatment. We also noticed that the improvement was better in Osteoarthritis group (26 to 5 degrees) as compared to Rheumatoid arthritis (31 to 9 degrees).

Conclusions: Conventional TKR in patients with moderate to severe FFD requires extensive posterior soft tissue release and bone resection. This prolongs surgical time, increases blood loss and has potential soft tissue complications. Flowtron has been used in the past to improve FFD with good early correction but the deformity gradually recurred. We have overcome this problem by doing definitive surgical procedure in the form of TKR. In summary, flowtron is safe and effective in reducing FFD, helping the surgeon to perform TKR without extensive posterior soft tissue release or bone resection with its attendant complications. The correction is maintained with no complications with its use. We recommend that flowtron be used in patients with moderate to severe FFD.


S Bridgman P Richards G Walley D Clement G MacKenzie Y Al-tawarah N Maffulli D Griffiths

Statement of Purpose: We tested the null hypothesis of no significant difference in arthroscopy rates for patients on a waiting list for arthroscopy in patients in which surgeons had a knee magnetic resonance imaging scan report prior to surgery, compared to those who did not have a report.

Methods and Results: This is a single-centre randomised controlled trial. 252 eligible patients consented and randomised. The two groups were similar with respect to a range of baseline factors. Very few arthroscopies were not performed −4.8% in the intervention arm and 5.5% in the control arm (χ2=0.06, df=1, p> 0.05). A longitudinal analysis of the secondary outcomes showed that there were no significant differences between the intervention and the control arms of the study.

Conclusion: Magnetic resonance imaging, prior to knee arthroscopy, does not lead to a reduction in the number of arthroscopies undertaken in the intervention group nor improve patient outcome in a range of secondary measures.


RAE Clayton A Amin M Gaston IJ Brenkel

Introduction: The Depuy Pressed Fit Condylar (PFC) total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is well established with reported 10-year survival rates of 93–97%. The PFC was modified, leading to the introduction of the Sigma TKA in 1997. The theoretical advantages of the Sigma system include increased contact area between the femoral component and the tibial insert. We report the first 5-year clinical and radiographic follow-up data for the Sigma TKA.

Methods: Over a ten-month period, 211 Sigma TKAs were performed in 179 patients. Patients were seen at a specialist nurse-led clinic at admission and at 6 months, 18 months, 3 years and 5 years after surgery. Data were recorded prospectively at each visit. Radiographs were obtained at the 5-year follow-up appointment.

Results: Of 211 knees, 187 (150 patients) were alive at 5 years. 5 were lost to follow up. 5 knees (2.4%) were revised: 4 for infection and 1 underwent change of polyethylene insert at 4.9 years. 5-year survival with an endpoint of revision for any reason was 97.4%; with an endpoint of revision for aseptic loosening it was 99.5%. The median American Knee Society score was 93/100 at 5 years compared with 25/100 at admission. Of 145 radiographs, 17 (11.7%) showed radiolucent lines. None showed radiographic loosening of either component. 28 (19.3%) had alignment outside the range of 7±3° valgus.

Discussion: These results suggest that the Sigma TKA gives excellent clinical results after five years. Further follow-up studies are required to see if this performance is maintained in the long term.


H Thakral A Butler-Manuel H Apthorp

The 98 % 10-year survivorship of cemented AGC TKR is regarded as gold standard.(1) The authors attributed their excellent results to the flat-on-flat design and compression-moulded polyethylene.

The aim of this trial is to determine if the type of fixation also influences outcome.

Participants were randomly allocated to either a cemented or cementless hydroxyapatite-coated AGC prosthesis. All patients were assessed with the Hospital for Special Surgery Score (HSS) and radiographs pre- and post-operatively at six weeks, six months and annually.

223 knees were studied with a mean follow-up of 53.4 months (max.10 years).

There were no significant differences between the two groups in post-operative HSS scores or in improvement of HSS scores. There has been no observable migration in either group. There has been 1 case requiring revision from the HAC group and 2 patellar buttons were revised following traumatic separation.

The early results are equally good for both groups with no significant difference in outcome or complication rate between cemented and HA coated fixation.


RS Ahluwalia PR Allen

Introduction: An accepted treatment of lateral compartment osteoarthritis with valgus deformity is to correct the malalignment, and unload the affected compartment. Previous techniques have used large fixation plates to secure complete osteotomy sites. We present a prospective study using a novel incomplete opening wedge osteotomy, in treating lateral compartment osteoarthritis in active patients younger than 65.

Methods: We assessed all patients (n=26) who underwent opening wedge femoral osteotomy with Puddu plate fixation over a 5 – year period by one surgeon (PRA). All patients had long leg X rays and arthroscopic evaluation; revealing either grade 3 and 4 osteoarthritis within the lateral compartment; 11 secondary to lateral menisectomy, 4 to complex trauma to the lateral tibial plateau, the others were diagnosed with primary osteoarthritis. Pre operative and post-operative Knee Society and Oxford Knee scores and long leg X rays were used to monitor subjective and functional improvement.

Results: Patients had a mean age of 48, (mode 56); ASA of 1 (range 1–2); and BMI of 24 (range 20–26). Mean follow up time was 46.8 months (6–62 months). Results in table 1 show early benefits in post-operative pain and improved function scores, which were maintained to 42 months. All patients had radiological union by 3 months (2–8months). Plates were removed as a minor procedure in some patients at 8 months (6–18 months), and did not lead to loss of correction or conversion to total knee replacement within the study.

Subjective and functional progress was observed by using the Oxford Knee Score and the Knee Society Score, early results showed an improvement from in the Oxford Knee score from 54.4 (+/−5.7) to 27.2 (+/−4.7)*, and the improvement was maintained at 12**, 30**, and 62** months (*P< 0.002; **P< 0.005). The same pattern was repeated with the knee society score where a pre opetrative score of 53.9 (+/−4.8) improved to 87.6 (+/−6.2) at 6 months and was 82.4(+/−8.7) at 62 months.

No infections were recorded, or differences in pre and post-operative flexion were observed at 36 months (P< 0.005) in all patients. However, 3 patients required further manipulation to overcome post-operative stiffness. Plates were removed only for local discomfort, and follow up showed there was no loss of corrective angulation.

Conclusion: These results suggest using the puddu plate is an alternative to unicompartmental or total knee arthroplasty in young active patients with lateral compartment osteoarthritis, without significant morbidity.


S Derrett E Stokes M James W Bartlett G Bentley

Purpose: To assess costs and health status outcomes following ACI and mosaicplasty used to treat chondral knee defects (1).

Methods: Patients received ACI or mosaicplasty at the Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital between 1997 and 2001, or, were on a waiting list for ACI. Resource use per patient was collected to two years post-operatively. A postal questionnaire collected sociodemographic characteristics, knee-related (Modified Cincinnati Knee Rating System) and general health status (EQ-5D).

Results: 53 ACI, 20 mosaicplasty and 22 patients waiting for ACI participated in this study. The average cost per patient was higher for ACI (£10,600: 95%CI £10,036-£11,214) than for mosaicplasty (£7,948: 95%CI £6,957-£9,243). Estimated average EQ-5D social tariff improvements for QALYs (quality adjusted life years) were 0.23 for ACI and 0.06 for mosaicplasty. Average costs per QALY were: £23,043 for ACI and £66,233 for mosaicplasty. The ICER (incremental cost effectiveness ratio) for providing ACI over mosaicplasty was £16,349. Post-operatively, ACI and mosaicplasty patients (combined) experienced better health status than patients waiting for ACI. ACI patients tended to have better health status outcomes than mosaicplasty patients, although this was not statistically significant.

Conclusions: Average costs were higher for ACI than for mosaicplasty. However, both the estimated cost per QALY and ICER fell beneath an implicit English funding threshold of £30,000 per QALY. To our knowledge this is the first study to compare the costs and utility of ACI with alternative ‘best’ treatments for people with chondral knee problems. Prospective studies are required to confirm these results.


W Bartlett C Lee RWJ Carrington AT Cohen JA Skinner

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to use the thromboelastogram to determine whether autologous blood transfusion following primary total knee replacement surgery results in an alteration to systemic coagulation.

Methods: 44 patients were randomised to receive either Hartmann’s solution alone postoperatively (control group), or Hartmann’s solution and autologous blood at six hours (ABT group). Thromboelastogram measurements of systemic blood clotting were performed pre-operatively, and post operatively at 6h just prior to the commencement of the ABT, 6h 30mins, and 8h.

Results: At 8h post operation (2h post ABT), the ABT group when compared with the control group showed an earlier onset of coagulation (3.83 minutes versus 4.49 minutes, p=0.003) and the formation of a stronger clot as assessed by the TEG maximum amplitude (maximum clot strength 83.9mm versus 75.9mm, p< 0.001).

Conclusion: The transfusion of drained autologous blood following total knee replacement may lead to an exaggerated hypercoagulable postoperative state. Further investigation of this potentially serious consequence of autologous blood transfusion is required.


N Raby S E Chalmers W J Leach

Aim: Assessment of the effect of arthrography on the accuracy of MRI studies in the diagnosis of recurrent meniscal tears.

Materials and Methods: A prospective, double blind study was undertaken of 21 patients with a history and clinical examination suggestive of a recurrent meniscal tear. Patients deemed symptomatic enough to justify repeat arthroscopy were also assessed with conventional and contrast enhanced MR imaging. An arthroscopy was performed in order to identify, and where appropriate surgically manage, recurrent meniscal tears. The radiologist performing and reporting the investigations and the surgeons undertaking the arthroscopies were blinded to the results.

Results: 14 patients underwent both the MR scans and the arthroscopies during the period of investigation. An accurate diagnosis of a recurrent meniscal tear was diagnosed in 8 patients on the basis of the conventional MRI, and 7 using MR arthrography. The sensitivity of MRI and MR arthrography in the diagnosis of recurrent meniscal tears was 33%; the specificity of MRI and MR arthrography was 75% and 63% respectively.

Conclusion: Arthrography does not improve the diagnostic accuracy of MRI in assessment for recurrent meniscal tears.


D Kumar A Alvand J P Beacon

Method: The diagnosis of Hoffa’s disease with acute or chronic impingement of the fat pad was made by clinical signs and confirmed by arthroscopic examination in 180 patients. One hundred and forty two patients had one or more associated lesions. Thirty eight patients with isolated Hoffa’s lesion were treated by arthroscopic resection of the affected part of the fat pad and were assessed using the Lysholm knee and Tegner activity level scales. Their average age was 39 years (range, 19–65 years). Thirty five patients performed regular sporting activities. A history of acute onset following injury was present in only 23 patients (56 %). The average duration of symptoms prior to surgery was 10 months (range, 1–26 months). Fourteen patients had one or more previous failed arthroscopies at other centres.

Results: There was a significant improvement in the symptoms, function of the knees and level of activity after the surgery at an average follow-up of 68 months. The average improvement in Lysholm scores were 47 and 58 at 3 months and 1 year respectively. This improvement was maintained through to the latest follow-up (4 to 8 years after surgery) in all but three patients. On Tegner activity level all but 5 returned to their pre-injury status. Three had minimal symptoms and two chose to step down the level of activity due to non-physical reasons. Natural history of the disease was observed both with and without surgery as many persevered with symptoms while they were treated by analgesics, physiotherapy and arthroscopic surgery without resection of the impinging fat pad. Statistically significant negative correlation was found between duration of symptoms and gain in Lysholm score after surgery (Pearson r = − 0.58). Two distinct etio-pathogenesis and three stages of the disease were identified. Chondromalacia of the articular cartilage especially of the patella was a common association. Special surgical technique is important to avoid the pitfalls.


D Molloy L Ogonda D Beverland

Objective: To examine the impact of aspirin and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) on preoperative haemoglobin levels and perioperative transfusion rates in patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty (TKA).

Methods: We examined the pre-operative haemoglobin (Hb) and haematocrit (Hct) of a consecutive series of 81 patients, looking at the relationship between the pre-operative use of Aspirin/NSAIDs on preoperative Hb, postoperative Hb deficit and the perioperative transfusion rate. A single surgeon performed all procedures using an LCS TKR (Depuy, Leeds UK). A standardised transfusion protocol was used.

Results: The patients were grouped according to their pre-operative use of aspirin or a NSAID, singly or in combination. The patient groups are as shown in the table below. All groups were comparable for age, BMI and ASA grade.

Results show a significantly higher transfusion rate (p=0.048) in the group of patients who received a combination of aspirin and a NSAID compared to the other groups. The patients on aspirin or a NSAID alone also had an increased transfusion rate but the increase was not statistically significant (p=0.12 and p=0.07 respectively).

Conclusion: The use of both aspirin and an NSAID in combination leads to a lower preoperative Hb and an increased post-operative transfusion requirement following total knee arthroplasty.


JRM Hutchinson EN Parish MJ Cross

Introduction: Stiffness following Total Knee Arthroplasty is a serious and debilitating complication. There are many different patient and surgical factors implicated in it cause. Previous studies have suggested that it will occur in approximately 1% of TKR patients. Arthrofibrosis is an uncommon but potentially debilitating cause in an otherwise well positioned implant. The cause of this abnormal scar formation is as yet unknown. The treatment of this condition remains difficult and controversial. Revision of the TKR has been suggested as the gold standard treatment as other operative strategies have had limited success. Our approach to this problem has been to conserve the prosthesis and try to release the scar tissue.

Aim: The aim of this study is to assess the results of open arthrolysis in the treatment of established arthrofibrosis.

Method: 1522 patients undergoing primary uncemented TKR have been prospectively followed up (2022 TKR’s) using the International Knee Society Scores. 13 patients underwent open Arthrolysis for stiffness post-op (Incidence 0.64%). The average age was 65 (range 50–78). 6 cases were simultaneous bilateral procedures (Incidence 1.2% of simultaneous bilateral procedures). The average time between TKR and arthrolysis was 14 months. Our average follow-op was 7.2 years (range 2 – 10 years)

Results: The average ROM just prior to Arthrolysis was 58°. The average ROM six months after surgery had improved to 91° (p< 0.05). The average ROM at last follow-up was 95° (p< 0.05) with an average Knee Society score of 155 (pain 83, function 72).

No patients have required revision of their components.

Conclusions: We have found open arthrolysis a successful approach to post-op arthrofibrosis. Although a large procedure it has been well tolerated by our patients. They have had an improvement in range of movement by six months which has been maintained up to 10 years.


R Mohil N Shah P Hopgood B Ng G Shepard W Ryan A Banks

Aim: To review results and complications of revision knee replacements.

Materials and Methods: We retrospectively reviewed 41 cases of cemented revision knee arthroplasty in 39 patients (15 male, 24 female) performed between 1993 and 2003. Data regarding clinical and functional outcomes and complications was recorded.

Results: Mean age at index (revision) operation was 67.8 years (32 to 86) and mean follow-up was 6.8 years (1.5 to 12). Average time to revision was 80 months (9 months to 23 years).

The indication for revision was aseptic loosening in 16 cases, and deep sepsis in 13 cases, (12 were done in 2 stages). Others included polyethylene wear in 4 knees, instability in 2, and 1 each of peri-prosthetic fracture, implant breakage and pain of undetermined origin. 3 revisions were performed for failed Link Lubinus patello-femoral replacement. Mean interval between staged procedures for sepsis was 2 months.

Reconstruction was performed using the Kinemax Revision system with the use of augments and stems. The modular rotating hinge was used in 4 cases. Surgical exposure included additional lateral release in 7 cases, tibial tubercle osteotomy in 4 and quadriceps snip in one.

Complications: Included 1 post-operative death due to haematemesis and 2 non-fatal cardiac complications. 1 patient was re-revised for aseptic loosening at 3.5 years, 1 needed an above knee amputation for intractable sepsis after multiple failed reconstructions and 1 is awaiting patellar revision.

At latest review, 7 patients had died due to unrelated causes with a pain free functioning knee prosthesis. Of the remaining 31, 26 patients had none or minimal pain. 21 were independently mobile with a satisfactory range of motion.10 patients needed a walking stick.

Conclusion: Revision total knee replacement can give satisfactory results in the short to medium term, although the complication rate can be significant. The procedure should be performed in specialist units. Revision in 2 stages for sepsis resulted in satisfactory control of infection in our study.


S. Kandikatu S. El-kawy S. Ansara D. Dubash S. Geeranavar

Introduction: The Royal College of anaesthetists in 2000 issued its recommendations about raising the standard in postoperative pain management.

It recommended that 100% patients should be satisfied with the management of their pain and any side effects of analgesic treatment.

We conducted this prospective study to compare effectiveness of combining local nerve blocks with PCA (patient controlled analgesia) morphine to PCA morphine only in controlling acute post operative pain among total knee arthroplasty patients.

Patients and Methods: Prospective study from January 2002 till November 2003.

It involves 50 Patients underwent total knee replacement.

Average patient age 71y (range 53–83y)

Patients divided into two groups: (A) – PCA (patient controlled analgesia) Morphine only and (B) – PCA

Morphine + local nerve Blocks

Data collected:

Pain score at 1,3,6,12,24 hrs after operation, Morphine used, Supplementary analgesia, Side effects (vomiting score), Patients satisfaction, Patients’ knee joint early range of movement and Patients average period of hospital stay.

Results: Optimum pain control was 94% in group B compared with 78% in group A

Side effects was seen in 30% in group B compared to 45% in group A

There was no difference in the knee joint early range of movement

There was no difference in the patients’ average period of hospital stay.

Conclusion: This study concludes that the pain relief, morphine usage, side effects and patient satisfaction are much better with PCA when combined with local nerve blocks than with PCA alone.

We recommend that more total knee arthroplasty patients should be offered local nerve blocks in addition to their standard anaesthesia.


N Pradhan K Iyengar A Gambhir P Kay M Porter

Aim: To undertake clinical and radiological assessment of the TCIII prosthesis for Revision total knee arthroplasty with survivorship analysis.

Methods: We reviewed the clinical and radiological outcome of 57 Total Condylar III (TCIII) prostheses used for revision knee arthroplasty performed between December1995 and December1997 at Wrightington hospital. Twelve patients (12 knees) had died. At a mean follow-up of 6.75 years (range, 5–8years) 45 knees in 43 patients were available for review. None were lost to follow-up. There were 23 women and 20 men, with a mean age of 73 years. Radiographs were analysed for component position, alignment and bone-cement radio-lucencies.

Results: The reason for revision was instability in 38 knees, infection in 4 knees, pain in 2 knees and stiffness in one knee. The mean preoperative Hospital for Special Surgery HSS score was 36, improving to 70 after revision at latest review(p=< 0.001). The mean postoperative range of movement was 95 degrees. 2 prostheses were revised, one for infection and another for instability, Survival analysis using the Kaplan Meier method provided a cumulative survival rate of 95.56 % at 8 years.

Conclusion: The clinical and radiological results of our study support the continued use of the TCIII prostheses in revision total knee arthroplasty with satisfactory outcome in the medium term.


SM Hussain D Robinson WA Hadden

Background: To our knowledge, a prospective randomised study comparing blood loss in cemented and uncemented total knee replacement has not been performed.

Method: From 1994 to 2004, 205 consecutive patients (78 men and 128 women) undergoing total knee replacement were randomised to one of the two groups, one using a cemented Kinnimax prosthesis and the other an uncemented LCS knee prosthesis. In 96.1% of the patients the procedures were performed for osteoarthritis whilst 3.9 % for RA. All patients had their haemoglobin and heamatocrit recorded preoperatively and postoperatively. The patient’s height, weight and body mass index were recorded preoperatively. The red blood cell (RBC) volume loss were measured by an indirect method which involved calculations using height, weight and pre op and post op heamatocrit.

Results: The mean red cell volume loss in uncemented knees (0.46lts) was significantly greater than the loss in cemented knees (0.39lts) p = 0.015. There was no statistically significant difference in relation to preoperative deformity, approach or ASA grade.

Conclusion: Our study concludes that the uncemented knees loose more blood compared to cemented knees. There have been smaller studies looking at this, but we believe this to be the largest and most comprehensive to date.


BJ Mockford NW Thompson P Humphreys DE Beverland

Objective: To determine if a standard course of outpatient physiotherapy improves the range of knee motion following primary total knee arthroplasty.

Design: One hundred and fifty patients undergoing primary total knee arthroplasty were recruited and randomly assigned into two groups. Group 1 received a course of physiotherapy with a standard protocol over a six week period within 4 weeks of hospital discharge. Group 2 received no outpatient physiotherapy. All patients received inpatient physiotherapy for the length of their hospital stay. Range of knee motion was measured using a goniometer by members of the outcome team blinded to the randomisation. Validated knee scores (Oxford knee and Bartlet patellar) were collected. An SF12 health questionnaire was used as a generic outcome measure.

Results: Both groups were equally matched by age and sex. Although patients in Group 1 achieved greater range of knee motion than those in Group 2 this was not statistically significant. No difference was also noted in any of the outcome measures used.

Conclusion: We conclude that in patients undergoing primary total knee arthroplasty, inpatient physiotherapy with good instructions and a well-structured home exercise regime can dispense with the need for outpatient physiotherapy.


J L Pozo R K Kankate A Khurana

The aim of this study is to assess the extent of osteolysis around a TKR which would then help in effective planning of revision surgery.

Osteolysis around a TKR can be difficult to identify in plain radiographs because this typically occurs in low radiodensity cancellous bone of distal femur and proximal tibia. These can often look innocuous and benign allowing the surgeon to fall into a false sense of security.

We discuss the use of 3 dimensional CT scan in 7 cases with pre revision initially unsuspected massive osteolysis and its usefulness in planning appropriate implant and/or bone grafting technique in revision surgery.

6/7 knees had a primary cruciate retaining knee implant and the mean time to revision surgery was 11 years and 8 months

Based on our pre operative CT assessment we were able to plan and effectively undertake 3 custom built prosthesis and 4 stemmed revision implants along with the use of adjunct bone additives including allograft.

On the basis of this experience we would recommend the routine use of a 3D CT scan in preoperatively assessing a revision TKR and would caution the appearance particularly of the ‘posterior femoral bubble’ as it often belies a large osteolytic cavity.


S Datir C Wynn-Jones I Dos-remedios G Walley N Maffulli

Aim: To investigate and compare the effects of two types of LCS total knee arthroplasty AP glide {(posterior cruciate is retained and the mobile bearing allows anteroposterior and well as rotational movement) and RP (in which posterior cruciate is sacrificed and the mobile bearing allows only rotational movement)} on joint proprioception and range of motion.

Methods: 30 patients scheduled to undergo mobile bearing total knee arthroplasty were randomised to receive either a LCS AP glide or Rotating platform prosthesis. Clinical scores (Oxford knee score, American knee society score (AKSS), EuroQol), range of motion and proprioception were assessed prior to and at three and six months after the operation. Proprioception was assessed in terms of absolute error angle (mean difference between the target angle and the response angle). Student’s t-test was used to compare the mean of two groups (with a level of significance of p < 0.05).

Results: Both groups were comparable in terms of pre-operative range of motion, oxford knee score, American knee society score, EuroQol score and proprioception. At 6 months there was significant improvement in the Oxford knee score, AKSS and EuroQol score in both groups (p< 0.001), but no difference was noted between the two groups with respect to these parameters. There was improvement in the proprioception (reduction in absolute error angle) in both groups though this was not significant statistically (p> 0.05). The mean active non-weight-bearing range of motion improved in both groups {AP glide group, (p< 0.05) and RP group, (p> 0.05)}

Conclusions: We did not find significant difference between AP glide and RP LCS knee arthroplasty in terms of improvement in proprioception and range of motion.


M A Hassaballa S Mehendale A J Porteous J H Newman

Aim: To assess the results of aseptic and aseptic cases using the PFC/TC3 system, and to correlate this with the restoration of joint line height.

Method: 148 patients underwent revision TKR using the PFC/TC3 system. No re-revision cases were included in this series. Data was prospectively collected (using the Bristol Knee Score) pre-operatively and at a mean of 4.2 years post-revision. 31 revisions were for infection and 53 revisions were for aseptic loosening. Revision for infection was done as a two-stage procedure and aseptic as a single operation. Measurements of the joint line height were made pre and post-operatively using Figgie’s method. The cases were divided into 3 groups on the basis of joint line restoration:

Lowered by more than 5 mm

Restored

Elevated more than 5 mm

Results: The mean pre-op total score for the infection group was 35/100 and 40/100 for the aseptic loosening group. The total score post-operatively was 67 for the infection group and 73 for the aseptic loosening group. The joint line was restored in 50% of infected cases and in 60% of aseptic loosening cases.

Conclusion: although the overall results were slightly less satisfactory for the infected revision group, there was no significant difference between the two groups either in total BKS scores or in reproduction of the joint line. The average outcome was much less good than for primary TKR.


Full Access
M. Hassaballa A Weal A Porteous JH Newman

Purpose: This study was carried out to compare the alteration in skin sensation following midline, medial and short medial incisions for knee replacement.

Method: 88 patients with 102 replaced knees were examined for altered skin sensation over the front of the knee, all were at least 18 months from their knee replacement. Twenty-one knees had a medial incision, 38 a midline incision and 43 a short medial incision for UKR.

A scale of −2 to +2 was used to measure different degrees of skin hypo or hyperaesthia. A purpose-designed grid, designed to fit different knee sizes, was used to record sensations. A computer programme was created to record all patients’ data including the length and shape of the incision in relation to anatomical landmarks.

A parallel histological study was carried out on 18 skin specimens taken from the 2 standard incisions. The specimens were prepared and stained for nerve endings. The number of nerve endings in each incision was calculated.

Results Histologically, less cutaneous nerve endings were seen in specimens from midline incisions than medial incisions.

Discussion: Altered skin sensation is unpleasant to many patients at least initially and may affect function especially kneeling. The midline line incision seems to produce less dermal parasthesia than the medial incision, this probably relates to both the wound position and the density of nerve endings. As expected, the length of incision correlated with the area of numbness when comparing short and long medial incisions.


D A Hoad-Reddick C R Evans P Norman I Stockley

The use of prolonged courses of parenteral or oral antibiotic therapy in the management of two stage revision of infected total knee arthroplasty is reported by all major series.

We present a series of 59 consecutive patients, all with microbiologically proven deep infection managed at our unit where a prolonged course of antibiotic therapy has not been routinely used. The mean follow-up is 56.4 months (range 24–114 months). Of the 38 patients undergoing a staged exchange, infection was successfully eradicated in 34 patients (89%) with recurrent or persistent infection in 4 (11%). The infection cure rate in our series is similar that reported elsewhere.

A prolonged course of antibiotic therapy does not seem to alter the incidence of recurrent or persistent infection. The costs of antibiotic administration are high, both to the patient and care facility. It may be unnecessary.


A Sambatakakis D J Johnstone T Briggs L Unitt

Soft tissue balance is known to be an important factor for the success of Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA). Traditional surgical techniques involve soft tissue releases and bony cuts to achieve the correct balance. Evaluation of balance is currently based on subjective intraoperative clinical assessment, or the “feel” of the knee. More recently, an instrument to objectively measure soft tissue balance following bony cuts has been developed. Soft tissues releases using this instrument may be extensive.

Hypothesis. The hypothesis is that patients who undergo more extensive releases will have poorer short-term outcome and increased complication rates compared to those who undergo less extensive releases.

Method: 506 patients aged 40–90 years underwent 526 Kinemax TKAs, performed by seven surgeons in five centres between October 1999 and December 2002. Five surgeons used traditional methods for soft tissue balancing and two were guided by the balancer instrument taking measurements pre- and post-releases. Patients were assessed by an independent observer using the Oxford Knee Score, the American Knee Society Score and radiographic evaluation, with a minimum follow-up of 12 months.

Results: Extensive soft tissue releasing procedures showed no significant difference in outcome in comparison with minimal releases. For the 2 surgeons using the ‘balancer’ technique, a significant difference was seen with the change in knee scores. The knees left imbalanced had substantially lower change scores and the imbalanced – balanced group showed the most improvement. There was no significant difference between surgical technique or range-of-movement with outcome. Complication rates were low, clinically representative and showed no significant difference between the groups.

Conclusions: Extensive soft tissue releases do not result in an increase in complication rate or a poorer short-term outcome. When comparing traditional and ‘balancer’ guided techniques there is no difference in outcomes. Balancing an imbalanced knee significantly improves knee outcome.


P Gallie TJW Spalding A Siddiqui D Dunne

Purpose: X-Ray analysis of a subset of TKR’s performed using the mini-incision technique has been undertaken to assess the accuracy of alignment, as TKR through limited exposure lends itself to a potential risk of mal-positioning of the components.

Methods and Results: The limited exposure afforded by the small skin incision and mid-vastus approach in the new technique of Mini Incision TKR, has a potential for increasing the risk of mal positioning components without the use of navigation systems. 128 mini-incision TKR’s have to date of submission, been undertaken in 125 patients (67F: 58M: mean age 72: mean BMI 29). A prospective assessment of these patients has been ongoing since its introduction in November 2003. The mean hospital stay is 5.5 days and mean range of flexion at six weeks is 106°. Two patients have required manipulation under anaesthetic for poor flexion at six weeks and blood transfusion has only been required in 4%. In patients with a minimum 6 months follow up, long leg alignment X-rays have shown the mechanical axis to be within 3° of normal in 4/5.

Conclusion: We believe that Mini Incision TKR is a safe reliable and reproducible technique offering substantial savings to the patient and health service without compromising accuracy.


M A Hassaballa A Revill B Penny J H Newman I D Learmonth

Introduction: Correct prosthesis alignment and joint line reproduction in total knee replacement (TKR) is vital for a successful clinical outcome. It is acknowledged that the ideal coronal alignment of the knee following TKR should be between 4–10 degrees of valgus. A neutral or varus knee is associated with a higher failure rate. Previous studies have shown that ideal alignment is achieved in only around two-thirds of cases.

Joint line elevation > 8mm has been associated with inferior clinical outcome, and depression associated with retropatellar pain and increased risk of patella subluxation.

Recently, modifications have been made to the Kine-max-Plus Total Knee System instrumentation, theoretically providing better internal fixation to prevent a varus cut and a 12 mm measured resection from the “normal” tibial plateau. This study aims to examine whether these changes result in an improvement in alignment, and a more reliable restoration of joint line.

Materials and Methods: Two consecutive series, each of 75 patients who had undergone TKR using either the old (Group A) or the new (Group B) instrumentation were included in the study. Antero-posterior and lateral preoperative and postoperative knee radiographs were assessed using the American knee society radiographic analysis for prosthesis postionoing by 2 independent observers. The Tibial and Femoral Component Angles in the coronal plane (cTCA and cFCA) and in the sagittal plane (sTCA and sFCA) were measured, as was the change in joint line height.

Conclusion: Our results suggest that use of the new instrumentation is associated with better restoration of joint line, and is more effective in preventing implantation of the tibial component in varus. These figures relating to a modern instrumentation system provide a yardstick against which computer assisted and robotic surgery can be judged. Long-term follow-up will be required to assess the clinical significance of these results.


A R Guha U K Debnath N M Graham

Introduction: Early non progressive horizontal RLLs (< 2mm) under the tibial component following cemented TKR have been noted to be due to poor cement injection into cancellous bone. They may facilitate the entry of joint fluid and wear debris into the interface, which may proceed to ballooning osteolysis. At present, there is no consensus on the preferred cementing technique (single mix versus dual mix cementation) in TKR.

Purposes of the study: To assess RLLs in immediate postoperative radiographs in cemented TKRs at the cement-bone and cement-implant interface.

To compare the RLLs following single mix and dual mix cementation techniques.

Study Design: Prospective, consecutive radiographic analysis.

Material and Methods: 53 consecutive cemented TKRs in 39 patients (12: 27, F: M) with mean age of 72.5 years (range 50–90 y) who were operated on between 2001 to 2004 by the senior author (NMG). 27 had single mix and 26 had double mix cementation. Immediate postoperative radiographic assessment (AP and LAT standing view) was blinded for single mix versus dual mix cementation. All the radiographs were independently assessed by two of the authors for the presence of RLLs using the zonal pattern of the Knee Society scoring system. We have evaluated the RLLs in the cement-implant interface in a similar manner as described for the bone-cement interface.

Results: Most common TKR used was the Maxim (31) followed by the PFC (9). 29(54.7%) TKRs had RLLs (11in single mix : 18 in dual mix). There were more RLLs at the Cement-implant interface (29), than the bone-cement interface (10). In AP view, Zones 1(medial) and 4 (lateral) were the common sites for RLLs in both groups (< 2mm). In Lateral view, Zone 1 (Anterior) followed by Zone 2 (Posterior) were the common sites of RLLs (< 2mm). In AP view, there was no significant difference in the number of RLLs (Zone 4) between the two groups. The total number of RLLs in all zones (Zone 1–4) was significantly low in the single mix group (p< 0.05). There was no difference between the two groups in the lateral view.

Conclusions: Single mix cementation technique reduces the incidence of RLLs in the immediate postoperative radiographs following cemented TKRs.


N S Wardle J K L Lee F S Haddad G W Blunn

Background And Aims: Total knee replacements provide a cost effective treatment for painful joint conditions such as osteoarthritis. Their long term performance is governed by ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) wear which produces wear debris and leads to osteolysis and aseptic loosening of the implant. Using a new material which is more scratch resistant than cobalt chrome it is hoped to reduce wear of UHMWPE and its subsequent complications.

Methods: Two total knee replacements made from cobalt chrome and two of oxidised zirconium were wear tested in a knee simulator. Surface roughness data from the femoral components was collected. Gravimetric and volumetric wear of the polyethylene inserts was measured. SEM analysis of the surfaces was also performed.

Results: Oxidised zirconium is significantly more scratch resistant than CoCr; Ra (mean average roughness) of 0.7μm compared to 0.43μm (p< < 0.01) at end of test, and confirmed by SEM analysis. This was accompanied by a 4 fold reduction in wear of UHMWPE 49.60mg to 12.48mg (p=0.02). Barium sulphate particles were found to be embedded in the surface of the CoCr implants.

Summary And Conclusions: Oxidised zirconium leads to a reduction in wear of UHMWPE due to its increased resistance to third body wear. It has the potential to increase the longevity of total knee replacements by reducing UHMWPE related complications.


RJ Minns A Yates YF Ahmad

Meniscal knee designs are unlike conventional surface replacement designs as they have two moving surfaces between the polyethylene and the metal tibial tray. This means the sliding distance is shared over two surfaces. This study was performed to assess the damage to both surfaces and whether the concept of wear sharing exists in knee prostheses of these designs.

Although 22 meniscal bearings from both the designs of knee prosthesis of the Minns design were collected, 4 pairs of bearings (2 from each design of the Minns knee) were examined in detail as it was felt they represented the range of damage features seen in the explanted samples. These samples were examined for wear and damage on both the upper and lower polyethylene surfaces. In both designs of bearings, the wear was significantly less extensive on all the lower surfaces examined. The roughness of the burnished areas on the upper surface was always less than any of the lower surfaces of the same bearing. Even the specimens with gross wear and delamination damage on the upper surface has no corresponding damage on the lower surface. Only one specimen had wear on the lower surface of the dovetail retention bar, usually no wear was seen on this surface indicating the main weight-bearing area is the lower flat surface of both designs of bearings, and that the sliding distance is shared during use thus reducing the wear factor for both surfaces in use.


HK Shanker CR Dreghorn CC Mainds DB Allan

Low Contact Stress(LCS) total knee arthroplasty was developed to reduce contact stress on the bearing surface and to minimise stresses at the interface between the host bone and the implant surface leading to long term implant survival. The rotating platform was introduced as the bearing interface when both cruciates are sacrificed. It has a central cone which engages into a matching cone in the tibial tray. This allows unconstrained axial rotation of the bearing surface. However, this potentially leaves the platform susceptible to subluxation/dislocation. The reported rate of this complication varies from 0.5% to 4.65%.

In this study from a single center we report the incidence and highlight the associated causative factors found in our series. There were 1053 Low Contact Stress total knee arthroplasties performed between 1994 and 2003. We reviewed 10 knees in 9 patients who had dislocation of the polyethylene rotating platform. This amounts to 0.95% in our series. All the patients with dislocation were women. Average age was 72 years(range 62–84). Osteoarthritis was the primary diagnosis in 8 patients. One patient was suffering from rheumatoid arthritis was on long term steroid therapy and had bilateral dislocations. One patient with Osteoarthritis with Parkinson’s disease went onto have 2 recurrent dislocations. Pre-operative deformity was varus in 9 knees(range 4–10 degrees) and valgus of 15 degrees was noted in one. Time from index operation to dislocation ranged from as early as 10 days to 10 months. There was history of trauma and acute presentation only in one patient. In one patient the knee dislocated while she twisted her knee in bed and in another while climbing up the stairs. In the remaining seven patients the presentation was subacute with symptoms such as pain, decreased range of motion, swelling and a clunking sensation while walking.

Although manipulation under anaesthesia was successful in 3 patients, all of them had recurrent dislocations and two patients had revision to a deepdish platform. Failed closed reduction led to open reduction in two patients with replacement of the rotating platform to deepdish (12.5 mm) type in one. Following both procedures knee was immobilised in a cast for 6 weeks. Five patients were directly revised without attempting closed reduction to a deepdish rotating platform. At revision in all cases the platform was found to be rotated medialy and posteriorly. Soft tissue imbalance and laxity were seen in all but one. At an average followup of 48.5 months (range 11–84 months) no patient had recurrent instability.

Increasing age, questionable soft tissue integrity and varus deformity were significantly associated with rotating platform dislocation. Closed reduction may be possible but invariably leads to recurrence of dislocation and open reduction with revision of the rotating platform gives reliable results. Replacing the rotating platform with a thicker deepdish bearing provides satisfactory stability at revision surgery. Meticulous surgical technique with accurate soft tissue balancing are important in reducing the incidence of dislocations.


R Vadivelu C N Esler S P Godsiff M L Harding

Aim: To analyze early clinical outcome and patients satisfaction following Oxford phase 3 Unicompartmental Knee arthroplasty at a mean follow up of 30 months from a single centre in the Trent arthroplasty register.

Methods: Between 1999 and 2002, 180 Oxford phase 3-unicompartmental knees were implanted in 173 patients. Average age at operation was 66 years. All patients were assessed pre and post-operatively using Oxford Knee questionnaire. At a mean follow up of 30 months (range 12–48 months); ninety knees in 83 patients were assessed using Oxford and EuroQol health questionnaire. Subjective patient’s satisfaction was also assessed.

Results: Seven knees out of 180 were revised early in the series giving a failure rate of 4%. Three patients had died due to unrelated causes. 90 knees were assessed at recent follow-up. The mean Oxford knee score improved from 48 preoperatively to 28 post-operatively. Subjectively 76% of the patients felt that the operation was successful and 74% were able to resume their leisure activities with out any pain.

Conclusion: This study shows that the short-term results following minimally invasive Oxford phase 3-unicompartmental knee implantation technique can yield satisfactory clinical and functional results. Using stringent selection criteria, Oxford phase 3-unicompartmental knee offers a good alternative to total knee arthroplasty.


PJ Boscainos H Pandit J Seward D Beard CAF Dodd DW Murray CLMH Gibbons

Aims: The purpose of this study is to determine the causes of failed medial Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) and assess the outcome after revision surgery.

Materials And Methods: From 1993 to 2003, sixty-nine Oxford UKA (58 patients) were revised to a total knee replacements (TKR) at this centre. The type of implant used at revision surgery, pre- and post-revision American Knee Society (AKS) and Tegner scores were analyzed retrospectively.

Results: The patient’s mean age at the time of UKA was 64.5 years (range: 50–79). The average pre-revision scores were as follows: AKS-Objective score was 41.2 (± 10.4), the AKS-functional score was 56.8 (±10.0) and the average Tegner score was 1.5 (±0.6). The mean follow-up period was 38.3 (range: 12–107) months. The common causes of failure were: lateral compartment osteoarthritis (34.0%), component loosening (30.4%) and early or late infection requiring two-stage revision surgery (14.3%). The majority were revised using a standard primary TKR implant and only six (9%) requiring augmentation stems. Patellar resurfacing was performed in 25% of cases. The mean polyethylene liner width of the revision TKR was 13.4mm (±3.7). The average post-revision scores were: AKS-Objective score 77.4 (±13.1), the AKS-functional AKS score 70 (±21.1) and the average Tegner score of 2.2 (±0.8). Three knees needed rerevision for infection of the revised implant.

Conclusions: Lateral compartment osteoarthritis was the commonest indication for revision surgery for a failed medial Oxford UKA. Revision of a UKA is technically easier and the results are superior to the published results of revision of a primary TKR. In more than 90% cases, no augmentation or stemmed implants were necessary.


S Kamath E Shaari P McGill A C Campbell

Few studies suggest that the use of a cemented stem reduces proximal stresses and may result in proximal bone resorption. Aim of our study: Does bone cement affect peri prosthetic bone density? The study was approved by the local ethics committee.

Patient and methods: 30 patients were included in each group based on power analysis. All 60 patients had the same type of knee replacement (Rotaglide rotating platform). Both groups, cemented and uncemented respectively were matched for the variables like mean age (67.2 & 67.33 years), gender (13: 17 males: females), body mass index (30.95, 29.90), average time following surgery (4 and 3.25 years), activity level (UCLA scoring: 6 & 4) and mean T score (osteoporosis index: −0.51 & −0.62). Periprosthetic bone density was measured in five regions of interest in the distal femur and five regions of interest in the proximal tibia. This was performed with Prodigy scanner (Lunar) using ‘orthopedic’ software to eliminate metal related artifacts. The same area was measured on the opposite unoperated knee. The values thus obtained were compared between the cemented and uncemented groups.

Results: There was no statistically significant difference in bone density around proximal tibia, patella and bone density proximal to femoral flange. However, there was some difference between the groups for bone density behind the flange of the femoral component measured in the lateral view, although not strictly significant at the 5% level. In this region of interest, the bone density in the cemented group appears to be less than in the uncemented group (p=0.059).

Conclusion: Use of bone cement do not seem to alter the peri prosthetic bone density contrary to suggestions in a few other studies. While reduction in periprosthetic bone density is noted in both groups, use of bone cement did not affect the results significantly.


A J Langdown H Pandit A J Price C A F Dodd D W Murray U C G Svärd C L M H Gibbons

Introduction: This study assesses the outcome of medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) using the Oxford prosthesis for end-stage focal spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee (SONK, Ahlback grades III & IV).

Methods: A total of 29 knees (27 patients) with SONK were assessed using the Oxford Knee Score. Twenty-six had osteonecrosis of the medial femoral condyle; 3 had osteonecrosis of the medial tibial plateau. This group was compared to a similar group who had undergone Oxford Medial UKA for primary osteoarthritis. Patients were matched for age, sex and time since operation.

Results: Mean length of follow-up was 5.2 years (range 1–13 years). There were no implant failures in either group, but there was one death 9 months post-arthroplasty from unrelated causes in the group with osteonecrosis. The mean Oxford Knee Score in the group with osteonecrosis was 37.8 (± 7.6) and 40.0 (± 6.6) in the group with osteoarthritis. There was no significant difference between the two groups using Student’s t-test (p=0.31).

Interpretation: Use of the Oxford Medial UKA for focal spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee is reliable in the short to medium term, and gives similar results to when used for patients with primary osteoarthritis.


E Pearse A Khwaja A Richards A Khaleel

We report the outcome of 58 knees with anteromedial osteoarthritis in which the Oxford unicompartmental arthroplasty was inserted. These were performed in a district general hospital by three surgeons.

All the knees had only anteromedial disease, an intact anterior cruciate ligament and correctable varus. The indication for replacement in all cases was pain. The mean follow up was 24.5 months (6–48). Outcome was assessed by patient satisfaction and the Oxford knee score. Complications, revisions, time to mobility and time to return to work were also noted.

The average age of the 26 women and 23 men at time of operation was 65 years. 31 of the patients were very happy with the outcome, 12 were happy, 5 were unhappy, and one was very unhappy. Mean pre-operative Oxford knee score was 43 (27–53) this improved post-operatively to 18 (12–45) a significant improvement (p< 0.005, paired t-test). Time taken to mobility was an average of 36 hours (24–72), 24 of the patients were in full or part time employment at the time of operation, all returned to their former posts at an average of 6 weeks (2–24).

Three patients have ongoing pain and are booked for revision to TKR. One patient had a dislocated femoral component and required this to be revised twice with a meniscus change at the same time; this patient is now happy. 2 further patients had revision of the meniscus to a larger size for meniscal dislocation. One patient had an infection treated with debridement and antibiotics; infection settled. Our results show that there is a learning curve; all of the insert revision occurred early in the series. Patient selection is important, those with disease in other compartments have continuing pain. Appropriate selection of patients and good surgical technique are the key to obtaining a good outcome.


R Carey Smith B Ainsworth M Varnier A Cooper C Darrah M Glasgow

Aim: To demonstrate that a multidisciplinary protocol reduces both in-patient stay and the need for out-patient physiotherapy following minimally invasive (MIS) uni-condylar knee replacements (UKR).

Methods: The data for hospital stay was collated for a consecutive group of primary UKR at our institution during 2002. We then compared this with a consecutive group of patients seen in a dedicated physiotherapist run clinic, with the provision of brochures and a “patient experience video”, with input from nurses, physiotherapists, anaesthetists, and surgeons, as well as time of expected discharge. The data was compared between informed (dedicated pre-operative assessment and patient video) and uninformed patients (standard pre-operative care).

Results: Total of 57 patients were initially assessed and compared with 81 patients after introduction of specific pre-op care pathway. Average hospital stay was reduced from 3.7 days to 2.1 days, with 60% going home within 24 hours.

Discussion: By changing the preconception of long hospital stays after arthroplasty ingrained in patients and staff we have reduced hospital stay significantly. Major factors contributing to this include the team approach, patient and ward staff education, perceptions of discharge and the inclusion of specific local anaesthetic techniques, and a minimally invasive approach. Delays in discharge include the geography of the region.


H Pandit D Hollinghurst D Beard C Jenkins CAF Dodd DW Murray

Introduction: The indications for medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) remain controversial; in particular, those relating to the state of the patello-femoral joint (PFJ). Some authorities consider the presence of anterior knee pain (AKP) and/or full thickness cartilage loss (FTCL) to be a contraindication. The aim of this study was to determine the influence of patello-femoral problems on the outcome of medial UKA.

Materials and Methods: This prospective study involved one hundred knees with cemented medial Oxford UKA (phase 3), via a minimally invasive approach. Pre-operatively presence or absence of AKP was noted. The cartilage status of medial and lateral patello-femoral joint was grade and recorded intra-operatively. Outcome was evaluated at one-year with the Knee Society Score and the Oxford Knee Score (OKS).

Results: 54% of patients had pre-operative AKP. The clinical outcome at one year was not dependent on the presence or absence of pre-operative AKP [OKS: 40.2 (± 8.2) for patients without pre-op. AKP and OKS: 40.8 ((± 6.8) for patients with pre-operative AKP]. 35% of patients had FTCL seen at operation in the PFJ. The outcome at one year was independent of the state of the medial and/or lateral PFJ [OKS = 40.7 (± 7) with normal or partial thickness cartilage loss and OKS = 39.8 (± 7) with full thickness cartilage loss in PFJ]

Conclusions: These short-term results suggest that for the Oxford UKA the presence of anterior knee pain or full thickness cartilage damage in patello-femoral joint should not be considered to be a contraindication.


H Davies O H Khan A E Weale J H Newman

Purpose of study: To examine the fate of the non operated on compartment of the knee, following unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR), by radiological assessment 10 years after operation.

Summary of methods and results: A total of 50 UKRs were performed on 45 carefully selected patients between 1989 and 1992. Fifteen patients died, two patients were lost to follow-up and two knees were revised. The radiographs of the remaining 30 knees were reviewed three times by blind and randomised assessment using Ahlback and Altman scoring systems to measure the progression of osteoarthritis within the joints. Standard long-leg weight-bearing anteroposterior views of the knee and skyline views of the patello-femoral joint were taken before, at eight months and ten years after operation. Two knees showed evidence of progression of osteoarthritis within the patello-femoral joint and three knees showed some progression of the opposite tibio-femoral compartment.

Statement of conclusion: Our study provides evidence that after ten years progressive OA within the retained compartments following UKR is rare and usually minor.


J. Kitson G. Booth R. Day

The aim of this study was to determine the biomechanical behavior of two different implants used in the fixation of proximal humerus fractures. The two implants in this study are specifically designed for the fixation of proximal humerus fractures and both utilize the concept of fixed angle locking screws. Bone densitometry was performed prior to fracture production and fixation. A reproducible three-part fracture was created in paired human cadaveric bone and then fixed using the locking screw implants. Stress/strain curves for the bone-implant construct were created for loads applied in cantilever bending and torsion to determine the relative stiffness below the yield point. Following this each construct was tested to failure with a valgus bending load.

The locking nail implant provided a significantly stiffer construct in torsion, valgus, extension and flexion at loads below failure threshold. The valgus load to failure was significantly higher for the nail. The mode of failure was different between implants.


W. Matthee J McKenzie S.J. Pope

The results of three years of treatment of children’s forearm fractures with flexible titanium nails was compared with the results from three original papers (Lascombes 1998, Richter 1998, Cullen 1998).

37 cases were identified using our trauma database and the main theatre database. 25 sets of case notes and x-rays were reviewed (age 4-16). The indication for fixation was fracture instability, either primarily or after initial conservative management. 6 cases were compound fractures. The fractures were reduced under general anaesthetic and then fixed using the ‘AO titanium elastic nail instrument and implant set’ (Synthes). 9 out of the 19 closed fractures needed to be opened for satisfactory reduction. Average theatre time was 104 minutes (25–165).

Average hospital stay was two days (1–4). 22 of the patients were immobilised in plaster of Paris for an average of 5 weeks. Nails were removed on average 4 months after insertion (1–10 months). 16% had minor complications which included transient nerve impairment, superficial infection and refracture. All patients were considered to be fully recovered when discharged.

Use of flexible nails in our district general hospital is comparable to previously published series in terms of case mix and complication rates.


S.M. Blake P.J.A. Cox

It is difficult to predict the outcome or likely treatment that will be required for an individual child with a rigid clubfoot deformity at an early stage.

32 Dimeglio grade II, III or IV CTEV feet in 24 infants were treated with weekly serial casts according to Ponseti method. Graphical plots of the improvement obtained in Dimeglio scores during serial cast treatment of CTEV were subsequently analysed to identify characteristic features that would help predict the likely success of casting or the need and extent of surgical release. The rate of change in global Dimeglio score, hindfoot (equinus / heel varus) and midfoot (adduction / derotation) components were specifically studied.

During casting the rate of change over 4 weeks and a “plateauing” of the global Dimeglio score after 4–6 weeks of casting separated those feet that responded to casting alone from those that required additional surgery. Those with “plateauing” and minimal midfoot deformity by 4 weeks (adduction /derotation score < =2) required a posterior release. Failure to correct the mid-foot deformity by 4 weeks (adduction /derotation score > = 3) predicted the need for a combined plantar medial and posterolateral release. These parameters were clearly demonstrated by graphical plots that can be easily obtained in a busy clinic setting.

Graphical representation of the rate of change in Dimeglio parameters can predict the likely treatment needed for children with CTEV. A graphical algorithm has been developed that can be used during the first 6 weeks of treatment to guide Ponseti method casting and early surgical intervention.


A.K. Al-Shawi T.D. Bunker

Ultrasound has become an essential adjunct to clinical examination when assessing a patient with suspected rotator cuff pathology. This prospective study was conducted to examine the accuracy of the scans performed by a surgeon over a period of four years.

Out of 276 scanned patients we selected 143 who ultimately received an operation and we compared the findings with the ultrasound reports.

The surgical findings included 77 full thickness tears, 24 partial thickness tears and 42 normal cuffs. Two small tears were missed and one partial thickness tear was reported as full thickness. This presents a 98.6% sensitivity and 99.3% specificity for full thickness tears. Three partial thickness tears were reported normal on ultrasound and eight normal cuffs as partial thickness tears. This presents a 97.9% sensitivity and 94.4% specificity for partial thickness tears. The size estimation of full thickness tears was more accurate for large/massive tears (96%) than moderate (82%) and small/pinhole tears (75%). The tear sizes were more often underestimated which may partly reflect disease progression during the unavoidable time lag between scan and surgery.

We conclude that shoulder ultrasound performed by a sufficiently trained orthopaedic surgeon is a safe and reliable practice to identify rotator cuff tears.


Full Access
R. Badge D. Chan

Posterior lumbar interbody fusion is a well established method of treatment in spinal disorders. It is particularly useful in situations in which neural decompression and simultaneous interbody fusion is indicated. The interbody fusion is generally done using various cage designs which are often sizeable and difficult to insert into the limited space available in the spinal canal. The B twin device is inserted collapsed and expands in the disc space to provide interbody support.

We present our experience with the use of this device and present our clinical and radiological results.


A. Shepherd C. Mills

In order to prevent fatal pulmonary embolism TED stockings, foot pumps and early mobilisation on the second post-operative day are used at our centre. Only patients deemed to be high risk (previous DVT/PE or obese) are given Clexane as an inpatient and Warfarin for six weeks post op. 1137 primary hips and 1017 primary knees were identified using the hospital database and the figures confirmed with the theatre implant order books. Those patients now deceased on the database had their death certificates obtained from the coroner. No patients had died from pulmonary embolism within three months post operation. 34 patients had been discharged on Warfarin according to the pharmacy records. We would therefore not recommend the routine use of chemical thromboprophylaxis following joint replacement.


D. Deakin G. Bannister

Background: Rates of around only 40% graft incorporation have been reported when irradiated bone allograft is used during revision hip arthroplasty. In this series we washed fat from irradiated allograft and added 40% by volume of autologous marrow from the iliac crest before impaction grafting. The aim of this study was to determine the rate of graft incorporation in a consecutive series of patients who underwent this modified technique of impaction bone grafting.

Methods: 85 consecutive patients, including 51 acetabular and 59 femoral revisions were reviewed. Evidence of graft cortication and or trabeculation was recorded by zone over the period of radiographic follow up.

Results: Using washed irradiated allograft with autologous marrow, 96% (49/51) of acetabular and 90% (53/59) of femoral grafts showed incorporation in the majority or all zones. Most of these changes were apparent within 6 months of surgery. The average subsidence of the stem at mean follow up of 45 months was 1.28 mm. Of the 8 patients whose graft failed to incorporate, 2 had grafts removed for post operative infection and 3 had early reoperation for intraoperative fractures. Only 3 out of 85 patients failed to demonstrate bone incorporation in the majority of zones with out an obvious reason why.

Conclusions: The addition of autologous marrow to irradiated bone allograft during impaction grafting is a cheap and effective way of increasing the rate of bone incorporation. This series demonstrates over 90% bone incorporation, usually occurring within 6 months after surgery.


Full Access
A. Baco G. Bentley H. Alyawer

Ninety knees were treated in the same centre between1995 and 1999 each had Low Contact Stress (LCS) knee prosthesis with patelloplasty; none of the patients had resurfacing of the patella. The average follow-up period was seven years (ranging from five to nine years). There were no exclusion criteria, almost all the patients included in this study were available for follow-up, the mean age was 75 years, and the majority of the patients were affected by osteoarthritis. All the operations were done by the same surgeon or under his supervision according to the protocol.

Evaluation was performed with using The Knee Society Clinical Rating System and new Patellar Scoring System. The final scoring was done by an independent Senior Physiotherapist. The Knee Society’s radiological evaluation system was used to assess the pre and post-operative alignment of the knee and the prosthesis. Image Tool (IT accessories UTHSCSA) software used to for measurements of patellar tracking and alignments on the digitalised radiographs.

Pre-operatively, the mean Knee Society score on a scale ranging from 0-200 points was 81.50 points (range 25 to 124 points); postoperatively this score improved to a mean of 150.76 points (range 46 to 195 points). Statistical analysis using paired-comparison t-tests showed the score differences were statistically significant at p-values < 0.0001.

None of the patients required resurfacing during the follow-up. There were no reported cases of significant anterior knee pain, dislocation, maltracking or fractured patella.


V. Budnar S. Geduzzi G.C. Bannister

Poor proximal femoral pressures obtained during a cemented, primary hip replacement may lead to poor fixation of the stem to the cement and cement to bone, contributing to early aseptic loosening of the prosthesis. Occlusion of the proximal femoral area during stem insertion, especially in the region of the calcar, may help in achieving a uniform and sustained rise distally and proximally.

An In-vitro analysis of femoral pressures was performed. Dental plaster was used to prepare femoral moulds in aluminium cylinders and the stem insertion phase of a cemented hip replacement was simulated with a number 3 Exeter stem, with no proximal occlusion, with thumb occlusion over the calcar and with the Exeter Horse collar. Pressure transducers were attached to the moulds. 54 experiments were performed. Of these 18 experiments were done with Palacos R cement, with the stem inserted at the recommended time of insertion and 18 with a delayed time of insertion. The last 18 experiments were performed with low viscosity Simplex P cement.

Good distal pressures were obtained in all cases. However, digital occlusion helped achieve sustained, high proximal pressures as well as early, high distal pressures. The Horse collar did achieve high pressures, but only towards the end of the stem insertion phase. This was much more appreciable with low viscosity cement, where peak pressures obtained with the collar were higher than with digital occlusion.

Our results show that occluding the medial cal car area is an effective way of achieving and sustaining high-pressures in the proximal and distal femur, during a hip replacement. The Exeter Horse collar is an effective means of increasing the pressure, towards the end of stem insertion, especially with low viscosity cement. Animal or cadaveric bone studies are required to show the actual penetration of cement in bone, achieved with these high pressures.


D. Buchanan J Field

Introduction: Osteoarthritis of the thumb is the second most common site of arthritis in humans. There are numerous operations for the condition, but perhaps the commonest is trapeziectomy, which can be supplemented with a suspension procedure generally using FCR.

It was the aim of this study to determine whether there is an advantage of one procedure over the other.

Materials and methods: 60 patients with either Eaton and Littler grade III or IV arthritis of the CMCJ of their thumbs were randomised into either having a traditional trapeziectomy (with no wiring), or a trapeziectomy with FCR suspension. The surgery was performed by the senior surgeon. All patients were assessed pre- and post operatively (at 3,6 and 12 months) by a physiotherapist measuring pain on visual analogue scores doing various activities, range of movement and grip and pinch strength. X-rays were taken at the same intervals.

Results: Patient satisfaction from both operations was similar. There was no significant difference between visual analogue scores. Measurement of the gap left by the trapeziectomy was less when trapeziectomy alone was performed.

Discussion: There is no obvious difference in the results of these two surgical techniques for treating OA of thumb CMCJ. It is not necessary to perform the FCR suspension.


R. Cove M. Podmore

We present a series of 6 cases of femoral hip arthroplasty using the 3rd generation Thrust-Plate femoral hip prosthesis. The rational and outcomes of using this implant in selected patients is discussed. A brief overview of the Thrust-Plate as a device is presented along with a review of the current literature.

In our series of 6 we report no major complications. The average age of these patients is 53 years old. All implants remain fully functional at a mean follow-up of 41 weeks.


M. Abdullah P. Van der Walt C. Mills

Locking of the MCP joint of the finger, except with stenosing tenosynovitis, is relatively rare. The middle finger is most frequently involved. We treated 7 patients who had locking of the MCP joint of the middle finger because of osteophyte of the metacarpal head. The locking of the MCP joint usually occurred in the older patient as a result of significant osteophyte around the metacarpal head. Unlocking of the MCP joint was done by closed manipulation under local anaesthesia.

Locking of the MCP joint of the finger because of other causes than tenosynovitis has been reported infrequently.

Locking of the MCP joint caused by osteophyte of the head of the metacarpal is characterised by painful loss of extension of the MCP joint without loss of flexion.

We have treated 7 patients who had locking of the MCP joint occurring in the middle finger with an obvious osteophyte of the metacarpal head. Seven patients, 4 women and 3 men, were treated in our Department. None of the patients had a history of trauma to their hands, and in all of them it was the dominant hand which was affected and usually due to powerful full flexion movement of the fingers. The average age was 73.8 years (65 – 81). The duration of locking was from 3 hours to 14 days. All the patients were treated within 30–60 minutes after reporting to our Clinic. The presentation of the patients was extremely similar. In all cases active and passive extension was blocked and they had pain around the finger. Full flexion was possible. The MCP joint was tender around the palmar aspect with slight diffuse swelling around the dorsal aspect.

Radiographs of the MCP showed degenerative changes in all the patients and oblique views demonstrated an osteophyte either on the ulnar or the radial side of the head

Local anaesthetic Lignocaine 1% 5ml was injected in the MCP and around the joint and after 5–10 minutes manipulation was performed, unlocking achieved and the patients straightaway extended and flexed the finger fully. No-one underwent surgical release. Follow-up from 3 to 8 months, average 6 months. No recurrence of the locking.

Akio Minami reported 4 cases of MCP joint locking of the middle finger, treated surgically. Williams classified the locking of the MCP joint in 3 groups. Langenskiold reported 2 cases of intrinsic locking of the MCP due to catching of the collateral ligament on the lateral bony projection of the metacarpal head.

It is very difficult to explain why the middle finger is most likely affected. Kessler noted that the MCP joint seldom participates in a generalised degenerative OA.


A. Blom L. Astle J. Loveridge I. Learmonth

Polyethylene liners of modular acetabular components wear and sometimes need to be replaced, despite the metal shell being well fixed. Replacing the liner is a relatively simple procedure, but very little is known of the outcome of liner revision. We prospectively followed up 1126 Harris-Gallante 1 metal backed, uncemented cups for between 9 and 19 years. 38 (3.4%) liners out of 1126 acetabular components wore and required revision. These revisions were then followed up for a mean of 4.8 years. The rate of dislocation was 28.9%. Nine of the dislocations were single dislocations and 2 were recurrent.

The overall re-revision rate was 3 out of 38 total hip replacements (7.9%) at a mean follow up of 4.8 years. This gives a 92.1% survivorship at just under 5 years. In isolated liner revision we had a complication rate of 23%. In liner revision combined with stem revision we had a complication rate of 48%. Possible reasons for high dislocation rates are discussed.

Leaving the well fixed acetabular shell in-situ leads to an increased risk of instability. However, this needs to be balanced against the otherwise low complication rate for liner revision. Patients should be consented accordingly


N C L Giles

The strength of bone cement interface is determined by the depth of penetration of cement into bone. The strength of the bone cement interface is an important factor in the long term survival of cemented arthroplasty. Aseptic loosening is relatively rare in cemented total knee arthroplasty but when it occurs it usually affects the tibia.

We analysed the quality of cementation in fifty consecutive total knee arthroplasties performed by two surgeons (N C L Giles and A J Timperley) using different cementing techniques.

The depth of penetration of cement into the proximal tibia was measured by an independent observer. The cement penetration was significantly greater using a suction technique when compared to a cement gun injection technique.


A. W. Blom M. Rogers A. H. Taylor G Pattison S. Whitehouse G. C. Bannister

The aim of this study was to determine the outcome of total hip arthroplasty, with regard to dislocation, at our unit.

1727 primary total joint arthroplasties and 305 revision total hip arthroplasties were performed between 1993 and 1996 at our unit. We followed up 1567 of the primary hip arthroplasties and 284 of the revision hip arthroplasties at 8 to 11 years post surgery. Patients were traced by postal questionnaire, telephone interview or examination of case notes of the deceased.

The dislocation rates by approach were: 23 out of 555 (4.1%) for the posterior approach, 0 out of 120 (0%) for the Omega approach and 30 out of 892 (3.4%) for the modified Hardinge approach.

58.5% of dislocations after primary total hip arthroplasty were recurrent. The mean number of dislocations per patient was 2.81.

8.1% of revision total hip arthroplasties suffered dislocation. 70% of these became recurrent. The mean number of dislocations per patient was 2.87. The vast majority of dislocations occur within 3 months of surgery.

To our knowledge this is the largest multisurgeon audit of dislocation after total hip arthroplasty published in the United Kingdom. The follow-up of 8 to 11 years is longer than most comparable studies.


D Hinsley W Tam D. Evison

Objectives: Behind armour blunt trauma (BABT) to the thorax results from motion of the body wall arising from the defeat of high-energy projectiles by body armour. NATO predicts that BABT will increase in future conflicts. This study aims to define biomechanical tolerance levels for BABT to the lateral thorax.

Methods: Terminally anaesthetised pigs (n=19) were subjected to 4 levels of severity of BABT (Table). Two types of armour plates were used. Group 1 were subjected to a 7.62 mm round (INIBA armour) whilst group 2 was subjected to a 12.7 mm round (EBA armour) the latter group being further subdivided by the presence or absence of two thicknesses of trauma attenuating backing (TAB). Accelerometers were attached to the pleural aspect of ribs 7, 8 and 9 mid-way between the spine and the sternum.

Results: Outcome was assessed by classifying severity of injury, in terms of mortality, into 3 groups – survivors (animals surviving to 6 h post-impact), early (0–30 min) and late deaths (> 30 min–6 h). The peak acceleration values were obtained from the accelerometer closest to the point of impact. Mean peak acceleration was significantly higher in the early death group (1070 km/s2) compared to survivors (591 km/s2) (p< 0.05).

There were 6 early deaths, 5 late deaths and 8 survivors. In terms of outcome Group 1 represented the lowest threat with 5 survivors and 1 late death. The animals in Group 2 with no TAB fared worst with 2 early deaths, one late death and no survivors. Deaths were due to respiratory failure/apnoea (n=4), pneumothorax (n=2), haemothorax (n=1), respiratory failure/pulmonary contusion (n=3) and ventricular fibrillation (n=1).

Conclusions: Peak acceleration of the body wall may be used to rank the outcome following BABT. There is a significant difference in peak acceleration at the extremes of the injury scale.


WGP Eardley G Pathak M Stewart

Introduction A prospective study of consecutive hand injuries treated at a British Field Hospital revealed a distinctive pattern of injury. This is a unique review of hand injuries in a recent military deployment.

Method Patients presenting to the field hospital with hand injuries over a two-month period were entered into a database.

The parameters studied included mechanism of injury, timing and nature of treatment and ultimate disposal. An anatomical comparison of pattern of injury with six months retrospective data and a literature search was performed.

Results Of nine hundred and thirty one patients attending the hospital in this period, fifty-three had injuries to the hand.

Only seven cases resulted from battle injuries. Of the remainder, thirty-three were work related and the 13 were due to sport.

Twenty-eight of the patients required a surgical procedure; the mean time to surgery was 1.7 hours.

Twelve patients were subsequently aero medically evacuated.

Conclusion Wounds of conflict account for a small proportion of hand injuries seen in the operational environment. The injury pattern seen reflects Daily Non-Battle Injury (DNBI) – the hazards encountered by deployed troops on a daily basis


D Hinsley S Phillips J Clasper

Background: Ballistic fractures produce a significant burden on medical facilities in war. Workload from the recent conflict was documented in order to guide future medical needs.

Method: All data on ballistic fractures was collected prospectively. Wounds were scored using the Red Cross Wound Classification and the Red Cross Fracture Classification.

Results: During the first two weeks of the conflict, 202 Field Hospital was the sole British hospital in the region. Thereafter, until the end of the conflict, it became the tertiary referral hospital for cases requiring orthopaedic and plastic surgery opinions. Thirty-nine patients, with 50 ballistic fractures, had their initial surgery performed by British military surgeons. Fifty-two percent (26/50) were caused by bullets. Seventeen upper limb fractures and 33 lower limb fractures were sustained. Four children sustained five fractures. Thirty per cent of wounds became infected. Thirteen limbs were amputated; seven were traumatic amputations. The relationship between those fractures with adverse outcomes and their fracture and wound scores will be discussed.

Conclusion: War is changing; modern conflicts appear likely to be fought in urban or remote environments, producing different wounding patterns and placing civilians in the line of fire. Military medical skills training and available resources must reflect these fundamental changes in order to properly prepare for future conflicts.


Capt Anna Crawford Lt Col Prakesh

Introduction The Role 4 facilities available for those troops serving in Iraq, as well as Civilians contracted by the Ministry of Defence, to support the Iraqi Security Forces, are distributed into four quadrants. The 120 bed Field Hospital at Shaibah Log Base receives patients through A& E, a Primary Health Care facility and direct referrals to the SHO from the Role 1 & 2 facilities within the South East quadrant.

This study was a retrospective evaluation of the orthopaedic attendances via A& E, as well as direct referrals (but did not include PHC attendances) during a three month period; January through March of this year.

Aim The aim of this study was to assess the percentage of orthopaedic attendances, and of these:

- the number admitted

- the (average) length of inpatient stay

- the management of each condition (surgical/conservative/active rehabilitation)

- the outcome ie. Repatriation (via Aeromedical Evacuation) or Return to Unit

Conclusions The deductions drawn from this (short) study are aimed to explain the rationale behind the Repatriation process for prognostic purposes, to introduce the logical reasoning of requiring internal fixation capability in Operational Theatre, to introduce a concept of need for a Rehabilitation Facility/Inpatient Rehabilitation Ward and to discuss the unsuitability and inappropriateness of referring chronic orthopaedic conditions to the Orthopaedic Team within Theatre.


WGP Eardley G. Pathak

Introduction A retrospective analysis of aeromedical evacuation of casualties from OP TELIC contrasting the demand for evacuation and nature of injury during both war fighting and peace enforcement missions. The study was performed to address a perception of clinicians working within the operational theatre that service personnel outside of times of conflict were being evacuated with increasingly trivial or chronic injuries compared with those evacuated when war fighting was occurring.

Methods A comprehensive record of patients evacuated was retrospectively studied. Consecutive cases were classified by diagnosis. The period of study was 1st March 2003 to 30th June 2004.

Results In the sixteen month period a total of one thousand nine hundred and twenty four patients were evacuated by air to the United Kingdom. In the first three months (immediately before, during and post conflict) eight hundred and thirty patients were evacuated, an average of 280 per month. Of these, 2.8% were as a result of battle. During the conflict phase, an average of 60 patients a month were evacuated due to a chronic orthopaedic condition. This is in contrast to an average of 10 a month in the post conflict phase. In the three months following the conflict (incorporating the Iraqi summer) four hundred and seventy one troops were evacuated - an average of 157 per month. Of these, heat illness accounted for 28%. In the following ten months 621 troops were evacuated, averaging 62 per month. During the post conflict period, Battle injuries accounted for 5.6% of those evacuated, which is double that seen during conflict. Chronic general surgery maintained a similar percentage of total sent home throughout both phases. Other specialities were more sporadic with no particular pattern other than a decrease in raw figures compared to the war fighting phase.

Conclusion This pattern of aeromedical evacuation in a modern major deployment illustrates the paucity of battle injury at the time of fighting in relation to non battle injury. It also highlights the impact of chronic injury on a deployed force, especially injury related to back pain. The study has shown that contrary to perception by the clinicians in theatre, there was no obvious increase in evacuation of troops as a result of chronic or minor injuries in the post conflict period. Heat illness clearly places an important predictable strain on this method of evacuation.


Surg Lt Cdr T Coltman Lt Col D Prakash

The drive in contemporary medicine is improved utilisation of scarce resources and a faster turn around of patients, with patients seeking faster recovery from surgery. Delaying factors in discharge from hospital following total knee replacement surgery include the time taken to get active extension and a straight leg raise following surgery. A retrospective case matched study of 20 patients shows that reducing the length of incision into the quadriceps tendon, therefore sparing the quadriceps mechanism speeds the post operative recovery significantly. Reducing the average time to discharge from 9.6 days in the control group to 3.2 days in the quadriceps-sparing group. All but one patient had an ASA grade of 2 with no significant co-morbidity in either group. No patient in either group suffered a post-operative medical event precipitating a delayed discharge. The criteria for discharge were the same in both groups.


R.J. Pickard D. Higgs N. Ward

Increasingly hospitals are moving away from hard copy xrays to digital films. These offer advantages in terms of cost, film availability and decreased radiation dosage but concerns have been raised about the accuracy of these images for preoperative templating.

We reviewed the pre and post operative films in 20 patients with subcapital fractured necks of femur. Each film was reviewed by 3 different observers on 3 separate occasions. The sizes of the femoral head and the hemi-arthroplasty were measured using the PACS digital system. These were then compared with the known size of the implant.

A total of 360 measurements were taken. Intra and inter observer errors were low with intra class correlations of in excess of 0.98 and 0.99 respectively. The average magnification on the pre-op film was 117.6% (t=18.96, p< 0.0001) and on the post-op film 121.5% (t=22.18, p< 0.0001) with a range of 109.3% to 128.2%. The overall magnification was 119.6%.

We conclude that measurements made on PACS have a high repeatability and reproducibility but that PACS has a significant and wide variation in magnification errors. PACS should therefore not be used for templating until a way of standardising magnification has been found.


J Rollo C Taylor A Ievins A Pimpalnerkar

This is a report of 30 patients who underwent arthroscopic, Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) reconstruction without the use of a tourniquet, but using saline and epinephrine, pump regulated, irrigation. Each case was performed as a day case by the same surgeon for the period May 2003 to December 2004. 5 patients had their tendons reconstructed with the use of patellar tendon grafts, the remainder, 25 patients, had hamstring tendon grafts. The study included 4 women and 26 men. This prospective study assessed cost effectiveness, clinical efficacy by measuring post-operative pain and post-operative results and finally whether this procedure remained the “patient choice”. The mean age was 30.6 years, (range 17 – 46). In addition to assessing level of immediate post operative pain the patients were also assessed at two weeks and six weeks for pain, range of movement, swelling and for the occurrence of any early post-operative complications. We were able to show that there was a significant cost benefit, approximately one third to a half in comparison to other local surgeons; that the study was clinically effective and that there were no reported early complications; and that all 30 patients would choose to have the surgery again as a day case procedure with this technique. We would like to present day case ACL reconstruction as a safe option for the carefully selected patient and as a procedure that could perhaps be included in the orthopaedic basket for day case surgery in the UK.


M McErlain O Khan A Ward T Chesser

The Stoppa approach was originally conceived to deal with difficult abdominal hernia surgery. Its use has been modified to deal with Acetabular and Pelvic surgery. We report on our use of the Stoppa approach in 26 cases from 1998–2003 to fix Pelvic, Acetabular, and combined Pelvic/Acetabular fractures.

The Stoppa approach was used in combination with other approaches to afford the best access for fixation. 11 of the cases were Acetabular fractures with no pelvic ring disruption (42.3%), 4 cases (15.3%) were pelvic ring disruptions without an Acetabular component. The other 11 cases (42.3%) were combined Pelvic and Ace-tabular fractures where this approach came into its own. In particular it is to be noted that the Corona Mortis was easily identifiable in 5 (19.2%) of the cases to allow its safe ligation.

The anatomy of the approach and the access afforded are considered, along with the plating techniques that can be achieved because of its use.

Patients were followed up for an average of 17.39 months with one lost to follow up. Clinical results were excellent in 20 cases, good in 2, fair in 2, and poor in 1.

Complications were lateral femoral cutaneous nerve palsy in 11 patients, 1 bladder rupture, 2 superficial wound infections, one lateral incisional hernia related to an ilioinguinal approach, and 1 deep vein thrombosis. Heterotopic Ossification occurred in 3 patients in whom the Kocher-Langenbeck approach was used. One revision for screw proximity to the joint was undertaken.

The Stoppa approach allows safe access and ease of reduction and fixation in these complex fractures, in combination with other approaches, particularly in combined pelvic and Acetabular fractures. We outline our recommendations for its use in this paper and outline a series of fracture patterns where it is most helpful.


J Kendrew K Gurusuamy M. J Parker

The admission radiographs for 404 patients with a displaced intracapsular hip fracture treated by reduction and internal fixation were classified using five different variables. These were the Garden grade, a modified Garden grading, a ratio of fracture displacement, direct measurement of fracture shortening and trochanteric shortening. Inter-observer reliability of the various classifications was also studied.

Only trochanteric shortening had an acceptable degree of inter-observer variation. For the Garden grading equal numbers of grade III and IV fracture healed. For the modified Garden grading 36% of Grade III fractures developed non-union against 48% of grade IV fractures (p value =0.02). The ratio method and fracture shortening were related to fracture healing complications, but trochanteric shortening was predictive of fracture healing (15.2 mms versus 11.0 mm), although the usefulness of this measure in clinical practice has to be questioned.


Full Access
Major Michael McErlain

Intra-capsular fracture neck of femur in a young patient is a surgical emergency. Results of internal fixation with cannulated screws to date show high rates of non-union and of avascular necrosis. This leading to a high rate of re-operation with cannulated screws. A tendency therefore is to lean toward total arthroplasty of the hip in the instance of displaced fracture of the neck of femur.

We discuss both the biomechanical and biological reasons for failure of internal fixation of displaced fractures of the neck of femur with cannulated screws, and criteria required to provide adequate fixation of these fractures to allow union and avoid osteonecrosis.

We consider other methods of fixation of displaced intracapsular fractures and analyse illustrative cases demonstrating these methods.

In view of the precarious biological milieu of displaced intracapsular fractures of the neck of femur, we feel that the use of cannulated screws is a poor fixation method. Therefore the option of internal fixation should not be abandoned in favour of arthroplasty because of poor results from this one biologically and biomechanically inadequate operation.


Mr Kamran Saeed Lt Col Paul Parker

Satisfactory military orthopaedic service provision in the UK suffers significantly from a lack of basic resources, notably overall consultant numbers and host trust support. The waiting time to see an appropriate consultant (uniformed or contracted) can be as long as nine months. Many of these referrals from the primary care sector do not, in fact, need to see a consultant. Appropriately trained individuals such as; GP’s with special interests, Nurse Practitioners and Extended Scope Practitioners may all have a role to play in patient management. Military Physiotherapists are uniquely qualified to deal with these referrals. They can provide military input, advice on grading, order appropriate investigations (including MRI scans and X-rays) and give guidance on further management and arrange follow-on treatment. Although popular in spinal assessment clinics, we are unaware of this facility being formally used in a general military orthopaedic setting. We have now reviewed the results of our first 100 patients. The average waiting time to first appointment was 2 weeks. 75 patients were dealt with solely by the screening clinic. 21 MRI scans, were ordered. Only 25 patients required review by the orthopaedic team. 7 patients required surgery. Our conclusion is that such clinics represent a clinically beneficial and cost-effective screening tool at the primary/secondary care interface. A high patient satisfaction at the short waiting times and outcomes was also noted.


Surg.Lt. C Arthur Lt.Col. DM Standley J Kilbey P Buxton

The Defence Medical Services (DMS) Telemedicine Unit won awards for innovation from the British Computer Society in 1998 and the current version of the software went live on 7th April 2003. We present a review of the referrals made to the Unit from April 2003 to March 2005. Over this two-year period the Unit received 110 referrals from areas such as Falkland Islands, Bosnia, Ghana, HMS Ocean and Belize. We consider the referral patterns; reporting times; ease of use; and clinical consequences of the system.


J Heywood

Background Changes in professional boundaries have allowed many of the tasks traditionally undertaken by doctors to be delegated to Nurses and Allied Health professionals. The employment of an appropriately experienced specialist physiotherapist in orthopaedic clinics in the NHS to triage patients is well established. This paper examines the background, establishment and outcomes of the use of a Physiotherapist Extended Scope Practitioner (ESP) in the Orthopaedic Department at the Royal Hospital Haslar, Gosport.

Method The post at RH Haslar has evolved in the five years since its implementation. All military patients referred to RH Haslar Orthopaedic Department with spinal, predominantly low back, pain are assessed in the Military Spinal Triage Clinic. The Physiotherapist ESP case-manages patients with access to radiological and haematological investigations and onward referral to other specialities as appropriate.

Results In eighteen months 235 new patients have been assessed. Only 25 patients required review by the consultant spinal surgeon, while 5 were referred to non-spinal orthopaedic consultants with shoulder/hip pathology. A total of 18 patients were referred to Pain Clinic and 3 patients to rheumatology.

The results indicate that nearly 90% (n=210) of patients who would previously been reviewed by a consultant spinal surgeon could be managed by a Physiotherapist ESP. The waiting time to spinal surgery has reduced from approximately 8 months to between 6 and 16 weeks.

Conclusions It is concluded that an appropriately trained specialist physiotherapist is clinically and economically appropriate to manage patients in an Orthopaedic Department. This has important implications for optimising patient management and additionally supports the wider clinical employment of senior military physiotherapists.


T Coltman P Chapman-Sheath A Riddell McNally J Wilson-MacDonald

Study design: A prospective comparison of MRI findings with surgical findings in patients presenting to our spinal triage service with a prospective diagnosis of a lumbar disc herniation.

Objective: To investigate consistency between Radiologists’ interpretation of MRI scans, and comparison between MRI and surgical findings, in an attempt to identify those patients suitable for percutaneous treatment.

Background: MRI has assumed a pre-eminent position in the diagnosis of lumbar disc prolapse.

Methods: 87 consecutive patients presenting with signs and symptoms suggestive of a lumbar disc prolapse that underwent an MRI and based on that a discectomy.

Results Reliability tests show only fair agreement (k=0.36) between the Radiologists and at best only moderate agreement (=0.41) between the Radiologists and surgical findings.

Conclusion: MRI is an excellent tool for diagnosis of a disc prolapse. MRI is poor at defining the character of a disc prolapse, and does not appear to help in classifying discs suitable for percutaneous treatment.


CJ* Taylor R** Bansal A*** Pimpalnerkar

Introduction. Acute distal biceps rupture can be a devastating injury and surgical repair offers the only real chance of full recovery. We report on a new surgical technique in which the use of suture anchors and a modified de-tensioning suture was employed to protect the repair in the early post operative recovery period and aid early rehabilitation and return to full pre-injury activity.

Materials & Methods. Using the standard anterior incision the distal biceps tendon was approximated to the radial tuberosity using two Mitek sutures and a sliding stitch. Using 2-0 Vicryl, de-tensioning sutures were used to attach the medial and lateral sides of the tendon to the underlying brachialis muscle. Post-operative recovery encouraged isometric contractions as early as 24 hours and after 2 weeks allowed flexion and extension with gravity eliminated. Six weeks onwards full active movement commenced with gradual increase in stretching and strengthening exercise.

Results. 14 patients underwent this procedure and all returned to pre-injury activity levels within 9 months. Follow up (6–14 months) demonstrated all had regained pre-injury levels of strength in flexion and supination.

Discussion. Using two suture anchors, it is suggested that load bearing strength is greater than the trans-osseous method, providing even tension is applied to both anchors. This can be achieved using a sliding stitch. De-tensioning sutures restore the isometric pull on biceps in the early phase and protects the repair.

Conclusion. All cases operated on in this way have made excellent recoveries and have returned to full pre-injury levels of activity. We therefore recommend this technique as a way of enhancing rehabilitation in what can be a devastating injury for the active sporting individual


TK Rowlands G Pathak

Background Scaphoid non-union remains a difficult problem to treat effectively. Screw fixation and standard bone grafting techniques are good options with union reported in approximately 90% of cases. Studies of the vascular supply to the distal radius have revealed a consistent vascular bone graft source from the dorsal radius. This allows for a pedicled vascularised bone graft to be fashioned, further enhancing the local blood supply to the fracture site.

Methods 14 male patients with a mean age of 30 years (21 to 51 years) and a mean duration of injury of 57 months (15 – 348 months) underwent vascularised bone grafting of established non–union of the scaphoid. The graft was vascularised with a pedicle based on the 1, 2 intercompartmental supraretinacular branch of the radial artery. In addition the long standing deformity resulting from the non-union was corrected by a tri-cortical iliac crest bone graft. (The results were assessed with regard to evidence of union at the fracture site and resolution of pain with return of function). Some of the cases had previous operations with conventional bone graft and failed.

Results Fracture healing was demonstrated radiologically in 9 of 14 cases (64%). 12 of 14 cases (86 %) showed resolution of pain and improvement in function.

Conclusion This technique shows promising results for treating established non-union of the scaphoid, even after long intervals between initial injury and the grafting procedure.


REB Anakwe DM Standley

It has been shown that extremity injuries form a large proportion of the operative surgical workload in conflict situations. Injuries to the hands are an important subgroup and hand surgery has a long association with military surgery. While most hand injuries do not require surgical intervention, those that do, require that military surgeons should be well versed in the principles of hand surgery. The concepts of staging and/or damage control surgery are well applied to this region.

The nature of military medical support necessarily changes in the transition from war fighting to a post-conflict phase. We examine the activity in the sole British Military Hospital serving a multi-national divisional area in Iraq over 2004. During this post conflict phase, the spectrum of hand trauma is characterised.

The overwhelming majority of hand trauma resulted in soft tissue injury. There was a clear predisposition to hand trauma for males, manual workers, combat soldiers and engineers/mechanics. X-ray imaging is heavily used in this environment. Even where soldiers are returned to duty they are often restricted in the duties that they can perform.

The results of this study reinforce the relevance of basic principles of hand trauma management, particularly in challenging environments. These knowledge and skill requirements should be emphasised for the war surgeon and the emergency physician. Hand surgery is an evolving speciality that continues to find clear and direct applications for the military surgeon.


RJ Kampa CR McLean J Clasper

Introduction SLAP (superior labrum anterior and posterior) lesions are a recognised cause of shoulder pain and instability. They can occur following a direct blow, (biceps) traction and compression injuries, and are commonly seen in overhead athletes. Military personnel are physically active and often subjected to trauma. We assessed the incidence of SLAP lesions within a military population presenting with shoulder symptoms.

Methods A retrospective review, of all shoulder arthroscopies performed by a single surgeon between June 2003 and December 2004 at a district general hospital serving both a military and civilian population, was undertaken. The presentation and incidence of SLAP lesions were recorded for both military and civilian patients.

Results 178 arthroscopies were performed on 70 (39.3%) military and 108 (60.7%) civilian patients. The average age was 42.3 (range 17–75), 50 females and 128 males were included. Indications for arthroscopy included pain (75.3%), instability (15.7%), pain and instability (7.9%), or “other symptoms” (1.1%). 39 SLAP lesions (22%) were found and grouped according to the Snyder classification – 20.5% type 1, 69.3% type 2, 5.1% type 3, 5.1% type 4. Patients with a history of trauma or symptoms of instability were more likely to have a SLAP lesion (p< 0.05). The incidence of SLAP lesions in the military patients was 38.6% compared to 11.1% in civilian patients (p< 0.05). After allowing for the increased incidence of trauma and instability in the military, SLAP lesions were still more common in the military patients (p< 0.05).

Conclusions There is a higher than average incidence of SLAP lesions in military patients compared to civilian patients. They tend to present with a history of trauma, as well as symptoms of pain and instability. Given the high incidence in military personnel, this diagnosis should be considered in military patients presenting with shoulder symptoms, and there should be a low threshold for shoulder arthroscopy.


Mr M. D. Brinsden Mr. J. L. Rees Prof. A. J. Carr

We present a single-surgeon series of surgical release of post-traumatic flexion contracture of the elbow performed via a limited lateral approach.

We undertook a retrospective review of patients having surgery for established post-traumatic flexion deformity of the elbow. All patients underwent anterior capsulectomy via a limited lateral approach. Patients with an intrinsic contracture also had the intra-articular lesion addressed at the time of surgery. Short-term follow-up was available from clinical review until discharge. Medium-to-long term follow-up was conducted by telephone interview supplemented by clinical review in selected cases.

Between 1998 and 2004, 23 patients were treated surgically for established flexion contracture of the elbow. There were 15 males and 8 females with a median age of 35 yrs (range 16–52 yrs). In sixteen patients the contracture was not associated with damage to the joint surface (extrinsic) and in seven it was (intrinsic). The mean pre-operative deformity was 55 degrees (95%CI 49 – 61) which was corrected at the time of surgery to 18 degrees (95%CI 12 – 23). The mean residual deformity was 25 degrees (95%CI 20 – 31). The difference between the pre-operative and discharge deformities was significant (Wilcoxson test p< 0.001). In the extrinsic group the mean deformity at discharge was 21 degrees (95%CI 17 – 25) compared to 34 degrees (95%CI 19 – 49) in the intrinsic group – this difference was significant (Mann-Whitney U test p< 0.01). In those patients with an extrinsic contracture all elbows had a return of functional extension. One patient suffered a post-operative complication with transient dysaesthesia in the distribution of the ulnar nerve which resolved after six weeks.

Surgical release of post-traumatic flexion contracture of the elbow via a limited lateral approach is a safe, reliable technique with the best results achieved in patients with an isolated extrinsic contracture.


P Motkur M. Firth G. Pathak

Scientific Background The Coracoid process of scapula is a principal landmark in shoulder surgery. Brachial plexus is at risk of injury during surgery around the coracoid, e.g. Weaver-Dunn procedure. Magnetic resonance imaging is the method of choice for evaluating the anatomy and pathology of the brachial plexus and has good resolution compared to Computed tomography or Ultrasound (Ref: 1).

Aim The aim was to study the proximity of brachial plexus to coracoid process in various Shoulder positions. The objective was to define the position of safety for operating around the coracoid.

Methods With Ethics Committee approval, twelve healthy volunteers (men with average age of thirtyfive years) were recruited. Exclusion criteria included previous shoulder injury or operations, known contra-indication for MRI examination and children. An open Magnetic Resonance Scanner (1.5 Teslar) was used to facilitate shoulder positioning. Consent was obtained prior to scanning after information was given to subjects. They were placed under the scanner and images were obtained in axial, coronal and sagittal plane with shoulder in neutral, 45 degrees and 90 degrees of abduction. The images taken are T1, T2 axial spin-echo sequences with 2-mm cuts and coronal echo of a T1-3D gradient with 2 mm cuts, together with a T1 coronal spin-echo, with cuts 2 mm in width. Distance from coracoid process to the Brachial plexus bundle is measured in millimetre on the PACS system which has software to eliminate magnification.

Results The brachial plexus consistently moved away medially from the coracoid in all the subjects at 45 degrees abduction of the shoulder. It returned to the closer position to coracoid in 90Degree abduction. The statistical analysis showed that on an average the distance the brachial plexus moved away towards medial side by 4.37 mm with Standard deviation 3.57 (p= 0.014).

Conclusion The brachial plexus move medially away from coracoid process at 45 degrees shoulder abduction. This position reduces the risk of injury to the brachial plexus during surgery around the coracoid process.


J Fountain A Anderson M Bell

Introduction: This study examined the cohort of patients selectively screened over a 5 year period with ultrasonography according to our risk factors (positive Ortolani or Barlow manoeuvre, breech presentation, first degree affected relative and talipes equinovarus) for developmental hip dysplasia (DDH). The aims were to evaluate the success of those managed in a Pavlik harness and identify predictive factors for those that failed treatment.

Methods: 728 patients were selectively screened between 1999 and 2004. Of those, 128 patients (189 hips) were identified as having hip instability. Failure was defined as inability to achieve or maintain hip reduction in a Pavlik harness. A proforma was designed to document patients’ risk factors and ultrasound findings at time of initial dynamic ultrasound scan where the senior radiographer and treating consultant were present. Each hip was classified according to Graf type. Acetabular indices were recorded prior to discharge.

Results: All 128 patients with hip instability were managed in a Pavlik harness. This was abandoned for surgical treatment in 9 patients (10 hips) giving a failure rate of 5.3 %. All those successfully managed had an acetabular index of less than 30 degrees at follow up (6 – 48 months). 7 hips in the series were classified as Graf type IV, of these, 6 went on to fail management in a Pavlik harness. 67% of those that failed were also breech presentation compared to 22% of those managed successfully. There were no complications associated with management in a Pavlik harness.

Discussion: Our overall rate of selective screening is 14 per 1,000 with a subsequent treatment rate of 2.3 per 1,000, which is comparable with other centres. Our rate of failure for DDH in a Pavlik harness (5.3 %) is extremely encouraging. Graf type IV hips and breech presentation correlated with a high likelihood of treatment failure.


M Dodds P O’Connor J Lee J Fitzpatrick D McCormack

Introduction: The use of a trans-physeal, trans-articular suture anchor across a joint as a means of internal stabilisation has not previously been described. This study assesses the damage caused by the procedure to the immature porcine hip.

Methods: Six twelve week old pigs underwent unilateral hip surgery. Anteroposterior pelvic radiographs were taken preoperatively and six weeks post-operatively. The acetabular index and diameter of the femoral head ossific nucleus of both hips were measured and compared. Specimens were analysed macroscopically for femoral head diameter, acetabular dimensions and for evidence of gross chondrolysis. Histological analysis was performed to assess the presence of articular chondrolysis and proximal femoral physeal arrest.

Results: In four out of six specimens the rate of change of the acetabular index slowed as compared to the unoperated side, though none worsened. The diameter of the femoral ossific nucleus continued to increase in size at a similar rate to the unoperated side on radiological examination. Similar findings were seen with the macroscopic analysis. Gross and histological analysis of the articular cartilage showed only local areas of chondrolysis, related to the drilling. Metaphyseal growth at the proximal femoral physis was unaffected by the procedure.

Discussion: The use of a trans-articular suture-anchor across the hip appears to cause marginal retardation of acetabular development in the normal hip. The trans-physeal approach to the hip does not appear to affect proximal femoral physeal or epiphyseal growth in the short-term, and the presence of a bioabsorbable suture within the joint did not result in chondrolysis.


J Forder S Mathew M Cornell

Introduction: Ideally any screening system should use a simple reliable test with good intraobserver reproducibility. This is important in DDH as once there is an established abnormality surgical intervention is frequently required. The aim of early detection (within six weeks) is to increase the number of children that may be treated nonoperatively. We have evaluated the effectiveness of our selective screening program by determining the late presentation rate of DDH in our region.

Methods: Between January 2001 and December 2003 we looked retrospectively at all patients presenting with DDH in our region. We recorded their age at scan and presentation, the Graf classification if recorded, their management, the presence of risk factors for DDH, referral source and presence of a positive clinical examination. All these were entered into a database and analyzed specifically with regard to patients presenting late.

Results: In the period between January 2001 and June 2002 prior to selective ultrasound screening (Group 1) there were 9441 live births and 26 cases of DDH (incidence of 2.75). There were 11 late presenters with an incidence of 1.12 per 1000 per year. Between July 2002 and December 2003 (Group 2) there were 9428 live births and 20 cases of DDH (incidence of 2.12). There were 3 late presenters with an incidence of 0.3 per 1000 per year.

Discussion: We have shown that a program of selective ultrasound screening in our region has decreased the number of children presenting late with DDH. It must be remembered however, that in the absence of any risk factors, clinical examination remains critical in identifying those with DDH in a selective screening program.


J Maclean A Hawkins D Campbell M Taylor

Introduction: The Pavlik harness is widely used in the management of developmental dysplasia of the hip and its efficacy in the treatment of instability and acetabular dysplasia is well established. There are some hips which although reducible consistently fail to stabilise in a harness irrespective of the age of application. We report three cases in which through altering the method of application of the harness, stability and subsequent normal development was achieved.

Method: Three patients age one week, six weeks and twelve weeks failed to stabilise in a harness applied in the conventional fashion. By rerouting the posterior “abduction strap” in front of the anterior “flexion” strap and attaching it as usual distally we observed improved abduction and more restriction of movement such that the unstable hip was held reduced. Reduction was confirmed by anterior ultrasound. The harness was converted back to the conventional application at four weeks by which time all of the hips had stabilised clinically. It was retained for a further eight weeks.

Results: Significant dysplasia was evident in all three hips at presentation ( alpha angles 32, 48 and 34). At average follow up of 23 months all hips were concentrically reduced with no significant persisting dysplasia nor evidence of avascular necrosis.

Discussion: Early reduction and stabilisation of the femoral head in DDH is important if subsequent intervention is to be minimised and it has been suggested that the more rigid Von Rosen splint is more effective than the Pavlik in achieving this. Our early experience with this simple modification has been successful in treating three unstable hips which would otherwise have failed splintage in our hands. We recommend it as an option to consider in the unstable hip, in conjunction with anterior ultrasound to confirm that reduction has been achieved from the outset.


A Gaffey R Wellings

Pre-operative planning for limb deformity correction involves detailed imaging of the lower limb to define the level, magnitude and direction of deformity. This is then used to plan the correction by defining the centre of rotational alignment (CORA). The method as described by Paley and Hertzenberg involves the use of orthogonal radiographs of the lower limbs using long cassettes (130 cm) taken from a distance of 305 cm to minimize magnification. This method requires special equipment, trained radiographers and multiple doses of radiation even when each radiograph was perfectly positioned first time every time.

We present a work in progress replacing the radiographs with a “virtual 3D” CT dataset of the lower limb which we hope will improve the ability to pre-operatively plan deformity correction, but at a lower cost in terms of skill, equipment and dose. Whole limb CT is too costly in terms of time and radiation dose for this to be suitable. New multislice CT systems allow a single coherent study to include segments of unscanned data. Thus it is possible to run a single series through a lower limb to include the articular surfaces, but excluding the diaphyseal segments (gaps). This reduces the radiation exposure to the patient. Such data when entered into suitable DICOM image manipulation software allows the Radiologist or Surgeon to measure and assess the deformity with great precision. Such software is available on the diagnostic radiology workstations but is also available for personal computers, allowing the Surgeon to perform preoperative planning in a numerical modeling setting. Allowing the elements of length, rotation, translation and angulation of the deformity to be measured and corrective surgery tested on the mathematical model.

We have compared the measurements taken from a deformity model using this new CT approach and compared it to standard radiographs and found that the above method is no less accurate. Rotational deformities are easier to estimate. However the advantage of our method is that the dataset can be manipulated to determine other technical aspects of deformity correction such as calculating the mounting parameters of the Talyor Spatial Frame.

We present worked examples of the methodology showing how this technique improves deformity appraisal.


G Ayana R Thomas A Ray D Sinclair H Read

Introduction: The aim was to evaluate the outcome of orthopaedic intervention in children who sustained peripheral ischaemia from meningococcal septicaemia and assess the benefit of fasciotomies within this group.

Methods: From 1994–2004 there were 190 admissions to paediatric intensive care unit (PICU) with meningococcal septicaemia. 12 had significant Orthopaedic/Plastic Surgical input. Case notes were examined to establish admission patterns, limb progress, operative intervention and outcomes.

All presented with viral symptoms and developed rapidly spreading purpuric rashes within 24hours. 8 were admitted from A& E, 4 transferred from other hospitals. All received antibiotics, fluid resuscitation, ventilation and inotropic support. One child died within 14 hours of PICU admission. Haemofiltration was used in 11 children (mean 14.8 days, range 2–60 days).

We were able to follow up 8 of the survivors clinically.

Results: All children had surgical treatment. 9 children had one or more amputations. Two children did not require amputations. Seven of the 12 children had fasciotomies performed (mean 34 hours after admission, range 2–96 hours). The child who died had multiple fasciotomies at 9 hours post admission. The remaining children had varying amputations. The other five children did not have fasciotomies. Of these one child did not require any amputations, three children had partial amputation of a single limb and one child had partial amputations of two limbs.. All five within this group required additional split-skin grafts.

8 children were followed clinically. 7 were mobile with walking aids with a mean of 1.3 prosthetic lower limbs (range 0–2).

Conclusion: There is no evidence from our study that early fasciotomies are detrimental to survival, limb function or subsequent wound healing after definitive amputation. In other published series fasciotomy has been advocated within 24hours.

In 2 of 7 patient, after fasciotomy the demarcation level receded distally leading to more distal amputation levels.


M Murphy D McCormack F McManus

Introduction: Despite early screening, infants continue to present late ( > 4 months) with DDH. The impact of late diagnosis is significant. Established DDH causes significant morbidity and may have major medicolegal implications.

Aim: To review the incidence of late presenting DDH nationally for a single year and assess the patterns of referral. To identify the reasons for the late presentation of DDH in the presence of early clinical screening.

Methods: In a retrospective study all cases of late DDH presenting in 2004 were identified using inpatient database. Patient records were retrieved and data collected.

Results: Fifty nine cases of DDH were diagnosed at greater than 4 months. There was an additional 26 cases of isolated acetabular dysplasia treated at greater than four months.

The mean age of diagnosis was 14.6 months (range 4–72). Many of the late referrals had risk factors for DDH.

Conclusion: Despite routine clinical screening at birth and six weeks, children continue to present with late DDH. This represents a significant workload for our tertiary unit.


J Clegg A Gaffey J Patankar

Introduction: The UMEX system of external skeletal fixation has been widely used on the Indian subcontinent since its development by Dr. B.B. Joshi of Mumbai. The system employs a method of gradual distraction with manual correction of deformity. It has applications to both the upper and lower limbs, both in Orthopaedic and Traumatic conditions.

This paper aims to introduce the system to members of B.S.C.O.S. as an alternative method of correction of the relapsed clubfoot. It has a use in other Paediatric and Adult foot deformities.

The system is light and easy to apply, and unlike some other methods of external fixation is cheap and well tolerated by patients and their parents.

Results: This paper will describe the use of the device in the first 3 patients with club foot and with 2 others, one with deformity secondary to neurological abnormality, one patient with congenital abnormality of the forefoot.

The assessment of deformity in club foot is controversial and difficult to apply to many cases. The goal of treatment is a plantigrade and supple foot, that functions well in locomotion. To date, admittedly in a small number of cases, this has been achieved following relapse from earlier surgery.

Discussion: The management of relapsed club foot and other complex foot deformities is often far from easy, and results in a stiff foot, with some residual deformity evident after repeated surgery. The UMEX system, by combining distraction with gentle manual correction, has, in our hands, been effective in restoring shape and function to the foot without the need for invasive surgery.


R Gul P Jeer M Murphy M Stephens

Introduction: A retrospective evaluation of early results of arthroereisis.

Material and Methods: Eight feet in five patients with pathological flexible planovalgus deformity that had failed non-operative management were treated with subtalar arthroereisis using the Kalix prosthesis. Diagnosis include oblique talus (2), vertical talus (1), diplegia secondary to head injury (1) and type I neurofibromatosis (1). The average age of patients was 6.4 years (range 4–12), and average follow-up was 9.9 months(range 4–20). Outcome was assessed using clinical assessment of the foot axis and functional improvement and radiographic measurements of change in the talocalcaneal angle and talonavicular sag.

Results: Arthroereisis was never performed in isolation, additional procedure included achilles tendon lengthening (2), gastrocnemius recession (6), talonavivular and spring ligament plication (5) and split tibialis anterior tendon transfer (1). All patients had improvement of foot function and restoration of foot axis to a position parallel to the axis of progression. Restoration and maintenance of the talocalcaneal angle was excellent in all cases with preoperative average of 42 degrees (range 20–70), improved to a postoperative average of 23 (range, 0 – 40). Talonavicular sag improved from preoperative average of 16.5 degrees (range 0–32), to post operative average of 26 degrees (range 18–35). Complications include persistent first ray extension which required a Lapidus procedure (1), Ongoing minor discomfort (1). No patients or parents were dissatisfied.

Discussion: The preliminary report supports the use of this technique in selected cases. Sizing of the implant and intraoperative assessment of correction of deformity and balanced surgery are critical to success. It is a simple and rapid procedure with advantages over alternatives such as Osteotomy and fusion. Long term results need further evaluation.


Z Sadiq T Syed J Travlos

Introduction: Supracondylar fracture of the humerus is a common upper limb fracture in children. Treatment is controversial and often technically difficult; complications are common. Cubitus varus is the most common problem with a mean incidence of 30%. A variety of methods of treatment for displaced fractures have been recommended.

Materials & Method: We reviewed 20 cases of severely displaced grade III supracondylar fractures of the humerus in children. There was marked swelling and distorted local anatomy in all these cases. These fractures were managed conservatively with straight – arm lateral traction. The patients were treated in skin traction for 2 weeks. They commenced physiotherapy after that. The traction was applied with arm in 90 degrees of abduction and forearm in supination.

Results: None of the patients developed any complication. All had full range of movements. None had cubitus varus deformity and none of these patients required resurgery. There was a complete patient and parent satisfaction.

Discussion: Open or closed reduction with internal fixation is the most common method of treating these injuries. In some cases this can be very difficult and dangerous. The local anatomy and swelling may not permit this; hence non-operative measures have to be adopted.

Conclusion: We conclude that straight – arm lateral traction is a safe and effective method of treating these fractures especially when the local anatomy is disturbed and the swelling is making operative intervention more risky and difficult. Moreover this method is also appropriate in areas where access to specialised centres in treating these injuries is either difficult or delaying.


R Gul D Farah M Murphy J Lunn D McCormack

Introduction: Duchenne’s Muscular Dystrophy (DMD) is a progressive sex linked recessive disease, predominantly involving skeletal muscle. Scoliosis is almost universal in patients with DMD. Surgical stabilization carries a significant risks and complications with peroperative mortality of < 6%. Cardiopulmonary complications along with severe intraoperative blood loss requiring massive blood transfusion are the major cause of morbidity

Aim: To evaluate the efficacy of single rod fusion technique in reducing the peroperative and post operative complications especially blood loss, duration of surgery and progression of curve

Material & Methods: Retrospective review – 14 patients with scoliosis secondary to DMD with an average age of 14.5 years (range, 11–17) underwent single rod fusion technique using Isola rod system and pelvic was not included in fixation. Blood loss was measured directly from the peroperative suction and post operative drainage, indirectly by weighing the swabs. Vapour free hypotensive anesthesia was used in all case. Progression of curve was monitored over a period of five years.

Results: The mean operative time was 110 min (range, 80 – 180). The average blood loss was 1.6L (range, 0.7 – 5). The mean follow up was 32 months (range, 4 – 60). There was no progression noticed in the curve on follow up. Two patients develop complications, one had loosening & migration of the rod, required revision and superficial wound infection treated with intravenous antibiotics.

Conclusion: In our experience, single rod stabilization is a safe and quick method of stabilizing the spine in DMD with less blood loss and complications compared to traditional methods.


Full Access
M Sibinski S Sharma D Sherlock

Introduction: The aim of this paper was to present a profile of Legg-Calve-Perthes’ (LCP) disease and test the hypothesis of an association between LCP disease and poverty.

Methods: We examined demographic data on a group of 240 children (263 hips) presenting with LCP disease in Greater Glasgow, where the mean deprivation scores are substantially greater than in the rest of Scotland, to see if this association applies or whether other clues to the aetiology of LCP could be divined.

Results: There were 197 males and 43 females. The majority presented in the sclerosis phase with much smaller numbers in the other phases. 70 % (184 cases of LCP) were Catterall grades 3 or 4. 16.25% had a family history of LCP. Bone age in our series is heavily skewed towards the lower centiles. The number of siblings in the family averaged 1.9, with 13 % being an only child. The maternal age at birth of the index child showed no preponderance to older age. Maternal smoking during and after pregnancy was noted in 55 %, which compares with 52% reported in the population of Greater Glasgow in general. Bone age in our series was heavily skewed towards the lower centiles. Birth weight showed a definite shift to the left, height a weaker shift to the left. 25 % of the children in our series are in social class IV and V, although this accounts for more than 50 % of the population of the Greater Glasgow.

Discussion: There is no significant evidence of a preponderance of LCP disease in the most deprived groups (p=0.9). The aetiology of LCP disease is likely to be multifactorial and may include a genetic or deprivation influence causing low bone age, hyperactivity and a high pain threshold.


T Azzopardi S Sharma G Bennet

Introduction: Slipped Upper Femoral Epiphysis (SUFE) is very rare in children less than 10 years of age but may be more common with increasing obesity in children. There are concerns with the presentation of SUFE in this age group regarding bilateral slips and prophylactic pinning, fixation with multiple pins to preserve growth, and complications.

Methods: We identified 12 cases of SUFE in 8 patients who presented aged less than 10 years to our institution between 1997 and 2004. Case note and radiographic review were carried out.

Results: There were 5 boys and 3 girls in this group, with an average follow-up of 48 months (6 – 90 months). Bilateral SUFE was present in 4 patients (50%). Only 3 slips were unstable. One child was found to be hypothyroid and another had oculocutaneous albinism. The remaining children had normal genetic and endocrine profiles. Six children were above the 90th centile for weight. The severity of slip was mild in 9 hips and moderate in 3 hips.

Multiple threaded pins were used in 10 hips and a cannulated screw in 2 hips.

Complications include revision surgery due to loss of fixation in 3 hips and a superficial wound infection. There were no cases of avascular necrosis and chondrolysis.

Discussion: Gross obesity is the commonest predisposing factor. The high incidence of bilateral involvement is an indication for prophylactic pinning. Multiple threaded pins may need to be revised if the fixation is lost as the child grows. These should be left proud of the lateral femoral cortex to facilitate removal, although at the risk of producing a windscreen wiper effect.


R Freihaut M Stephens

Introduction: Many surgeons recommend surgical resection of symptomatic tarsal coalition. The success of this procedure in reducing symptoms has been well described in the literature, but long term results remain scarce. In 1967 Mitchell et al described a series of 41 resections of calcaneonavicular coalition with an average 6 year follow up. In 1990 Gonzalez et al described two groups who underwent a total of 75 resections of calcaneonavicular coalition by multiple surgeons. We describe the largest combined series of calcaneonavicular and talocalcaneal coalition resection with a minimum follow up of 3 years and a maximum of 12 years (average 9.5 years).

Methods: We retrospectively studied the clinical results of a consecutive series of 79 primary resections for tarsal coalition in 63 patients carried out by the senior author over a 12 year period. A standard resection procedure was performed in each case. Duration of symptoms, side of maximal symptoms, activity level, family history, peroneal spasm, and patient weight preoperatively was recorded retrospectively using medical records. Visual analogue pain scores, analgesia requirement, activity level, time to return to maximum activity, occupation, patient and parent satisfaction level, peroneal spasm, range of motion, AOFAS ankle-hindfoot score, and patient body mass index was recorded at follow up.

Results: At follow up the majority of patients had mild or no pain and did not require regular analgesia, had some limitation of recreational activities but not of daily activities, and had some stiffness. The majority of patients and parents were satisfied with the outcome.

Discussion: Resection of tarsal coalition is recommended when symptomatic but also is recommended bilaterally when present regardless of symptomatology of the lesser affected foot.


J MacLean S Reddy

Introduction: The consequences of the complications associated with the management of slipped upper femoral epiphysis are a major source of disability in young adults. Whilst the management of chondrolysis, avascular necrosis or malunion of the femoral neck is usually undertaken by paediatric orthopaedic surgeons the initial management of SUFE in many regions is as part of an adult trauma service. This retrospective audit assessed the outcome of the management of SUFE in one such health region in which treatment occurred at three sites by a number of surgeons of varying experience. The aim was to compare our outcomes with those published and to identify any local issues.

Method: Review of case notes and xrays of all patients treated over a ten year period as recorded in theatre records. Fixation in all cases was by a single cannulated screw.

Results: Of the 64 cases that presented during this period adequate records for 60 patients were retrieved. 75 slips were recorded, 15 of which were bilateral. In 17 patients prophylactic pinning was performed in the remaining 43 patients nine presented with subsequent slips. Of these, eight were unstable of which two had slip angles greater than 60°, in one of these avascular necrosis developed. Three other cases of avascular necrosis occurred (incidence 5%) all in unstable slips. Chondrolysis occurred in one patient with persistent pin penetration. In the remaining 91 cannulated screws that were inserted no complications were observed.

Discussion: The complication rates observed in this series are within those accepted in the literature. The high incidence of subsequent slips and the attendant severity of these when compared with the relative safety of contemporary cannulated screw fixation has lead us to recommend prophylactic pinning in our region.


S Shewale S Sharma M Sibinski D Sherlock

Introduction: The aim of this paper was to test the hypothesis that for hips affected with Legg-Calve-Perthes’ (LCP) disease under the age of 8 years, surgery does not affect the outcome.

Methods: We performed a retrospective paired study of patients, who were diagnosed with LCP disease before the age of 8 years, to compare the radiological results after treatment between conservatively and surgicallytreated groups. One patient was selected from each group to create the pairs for this study. Each pair was strictly matched for gender, body mass index, age at onset, and stage at the first visit, Catterall and Herring grading and radiological at-risk signs. Each pair was assessed by comparing the values of five radiological measurements.

Results: From a cohort of 345 hips diagnosed with LCP disease 14 pairs (28 hips) fitted the criteria. The radiological measurements, which showed a statistically better result in the surgical groups, were Mose’s method (p = 0.019), the Acetabular-Head Index (p = 0.034). There were no statistical differences in the Slope of the Acetabular Roof (p = 0.37), Articulotrochanteric distance (p = 0.17) and Stulberg grading (p = 0.2). 5 pairs had a better Stulberg result in the operative group. Three of these 5 pairs were less than 6.5 years at the time of their surgical procedure. Three pairs had a better Stulberg result in the conservative group. Six pairs had no difference between the groups.

Discussion: We conclude that surgical treatment can improve the sphericity of the femoral head and provide greater acetabular cover than conservative treatment in hips of patients less than 8 years at the onset of LCP disease. However, the Stulberg grading was not affected. Our study supports the hypothesis that for hips affected with LCP disease under the age of 8 years, surgery does not affect the outcome.


D Campbell G Bennet

We report a case of Perthes like changes in the rare disorder of Geleophysic dysplasia and add it to the world literature (24 cases). We found an increased incidence of Perthes at 12% (3/25). Geleophysic dysplasia is characterised by short stature with short limbs distally, normal intelligence, joint stiffness, hepatomegaly and happy facial characteristics. The disease has the clinical and histological appearance of a mucopolysaccharidosis. Perthes changes were seen at the age of 4 years and treated conservatively, with poor clinical results despite the early onset and reasonable radiological improvement. MRI scans of the affected hip did not show any unusual features that differentiate it from normal Perthes disease. The patient also developed carpal tunnel syndrome, which has been seen in with increasing frequency in mucopolysaccharidoses such as Hurlers syndrome, but has not been associated with Geleophysic dysplasia before.


S Blake P Cox

The management of hip instability in the non-ambulant paediatric cerebral palsy (CP) patient is complex. Subluxations and dislocations arise secondary to muscle imbalance caused by strong hip flexors and adductors overpowering weaker hip abductors and extensors. These conditions give rise to sitting problems and can cause debilitating pain making care difficult. Treatment methods include physiotherapy, abduction bracing, muscle releases and transfers, proximal femoral and pelvic osteotomies, proximal femoral excision +/- interpositional arthroplasty, arthrodesis and total hip arthroplasty (THA). THA in the adult CP patient is not uncommon, however dislocation has remained a concern. THA is rarely used in the paediatric patient and to our knowledge the use of a constrained liner, which should prevent dislocation, has never been described. We present the case of a non-ambulant paediatric CP patient with normal intelligence whom by the age 16 had been successfully managed with staged bilateral uncemented THAs using constrained liner technology.


T Azzopardi S Sharma D Sherlock

Stickler’s syndrome, also called Hereditary Progressive Arthro-Ophthalmopathy, is an autosomal dominant connective tissue disorder with strong expressivity, characterised by ocular, orofacial, skeletal, cardiac, and auditory features.

We describe a case of valgus slipped capital femoral epiphysis in a 13 year-old boy with Stickler’s syndrome. He presented at routine rheumatology clinic follow-up with a 1-month history of progressively worsening right hip pain, which radiated to the knee. He underwent insitu cannulated screw fixation of the right slipped capital femoral epiphysis.

Joint pains are a common manifestation in Stickler’s syndrome and this might delay the diagnosis of slipped capital femoral epiphysis. Valgus slipped capital femoral epiphysis is a rare entity. Obesity and the increased femoral anteversion are predisposing factors. Insitu fixation with a single cannulated screw is the treatment of choice.


M Bhattacharyya H Win S Sinha R Isibor S Sakka

Introduction: Sliding screws has been described to use in hip fractures since 1950s. Failure of fixation varies from 16 – 23%. We aim to assess the effect of audit and re auditing the failure rate after introduction of the Tip apex distance concept since January 2000 to December 2004.

Methodology: We measured the tip apex distance in 161 (93 in the audit group and the rest re audit patients, 140 available for analysis. Their mean age at diagnosis 82.2 years [range 56.2–100.6 years] and male and female ratio was 1:6. Average time to Operation 1.7 days form the day of admission. The average Hospital Stay was 15.8 days

Result & discussion: We found that Patients had recorded Lag screw length 92.6mm [75–115], Side plate: 4 hole:6 hole = 4:1, Measured TAD 27.6 mm [6.3–66.4] in 140 patients,

The mean radiation time was 38.27 sec (7–71) and the dosage 0.68 Cgycm2 (0.93–2.06),

The mean Tip Apex Distance in the failed fixation group of 16 patients with cut out screw (13 in the audit group and 3 in the re audit group) is 43.05 [27.2–65.8]

Conclusion: We found the auditing and re auditing could potentially improve the surgical outcome. Although the Risk of cut out depends on many variable such as increasing age, Unstable fracture, poor reduction, high angle side plate 150deg, TAD is the stronger predictor than any other variable. This variable can be controlled by regular audit of the surgical practice.


DS Damany D Morgan D Griffin S Drew

Aims: The re-dislocation rates in adults (< 30 years) in the initial 12 months after FAT (first,anterior,traumatic) shoulder dislocations treated non-operatively vary from 25% to 95%. Some surgeons advocate early arthroscopic surgery following such dislocations as this appears to reduce recurrent instability. The purpose of this study was to establish if arthroscopic surgery reduces the incidence of recurrent instability after such dislocations when compared to non-operative treatment.

Material and Methods: Specific search terms were used to retrieve relevant studies from MEDLINE, EMBASE, and CINAHL extending from 1966 to October 2003. Guidelines for reporting of meta-analysis, adapted from QUOROM statement were followed. Adults under 30 years of age, with clinical and radiological confirmation of anterior dislocation following trauma with a minimum follow-up of 12 months were included. Patients with previous shoulder problems, generalised joint laxity, neurological injury, impingement and a history of substance abuse were excluded.

Results: 13 studies involving 433 shoulders were reviewed.

Group A included 84 shoulders treated by arthroscopic lavage without stabilisation. There were no subluxations. The re-dislocation rate was 14.3% (12/84).

Group B had 179 shoulders treated by arthroscopic stabilisation. The incidence of subluxation was 5.02% (9/179) and dislocation was 6.14% (11/179).

Recurrent instability (subluxation /dislocation) following arthroscopic lavage (12/84 – 14.3%) was significantly higher than after arthroscopic stabilisation (20/179 – 11.2%). [p= 0.04, Relative risk = 2.32, 95% CI: 1.07 to 5.05]

Group C involved 170 shoulders treated non-operatively. The incidence of subluxation was 8% (12/150) and dislocation was 62% (93/150). The overall incidence of recurrent instability was 70% (119/170).

Recurrent instability following arthroscopic intervention (32/263 – 12.2%) was significantly lower than following non-operative treatment (119/170 – 70%) [p< 0.0001, Relative risk = 0.17, 95% CI: 0.12 to 0.24].

Conclusion: Early arthroscopic surgery reduces recurrent instability during the initial 12 months after FAT shoulder dislocation in young adults (< 30 years) when compared to non-operative treatment. Arthroscopic treatment should be offered to young, athletic patients especially those involved in contact sports or defence personnel, who are at a high risk of recurrent instability after initial shoulder dislocation. Further randomised control trials reporting on a larger number of patients with a minimum follow-up of 5 years are required before one can draw firm conclusions on the ability of arthroscopic intervention to influence the natural history of FAT shoulder dislocation.


N Abhishetty A Zarugh Z Khan N Shaath

Introduction: We present a modification of surgical technique of Mitchell’s Osteotomy for hallux Valgus and the follow-up results in a consecutive series of patients operated by a single surgeon using this technique.

The modification involves: 1/not using any form of fixation of the osteotomy – neither a bone suture nor any k wires or pins. 2/a capsulodesis was preformed to correct the Hallux Valgus deformity by suturing the capsule to the distal metatarsal shaft using vicryl through 2mm drill hole.

Patients and Methods: Ninety nine patients operated on, 54 patients were seen in the clinics, 26 answered telephone questionnaire and 19 patients were unable to attend. The 54 patients who attended the clinics were examined and roentgenograms of the feet were taken. AOFAS forefoot score was used to assess the outcome.

Results: Of the 54 patients seen, 29 patients scored > 90 (AOFAS), 17 patients scored between 80 to 90 points in AOFAS and 8 patients scored < 80 points. Of the patients who answered the questionnaire, 22 patients were satisfied with the surgery and four had minor discomfort during activity. Three patients had secondary surgery for transfer metatarsalgia /hammer toes. On statistical analysis, there was no correlation between the outcome and factors such as age, degree of deformity and the post operative shortening of the first ray.

Discussion: Our surgical technique did not result in any acute instability of the osteotomy. There was no evidence of any symptomatic stiffness of the metatarsophalangeal joint because of capsulodesis.


Q Choudry I Siddique G Eastwood R Mohan

Introduction: Blood conservation has rapidly moved into political and medical agendas. The ongoing shortage of blood in blood banks and the discovery of vCJD pose a threat to UK blood supply with ever rising costs. The use of blood conservation techniques is increasingly being used in surgery to help reduce the need for homologous blood.

We studied the use of Autologous blood transfusion drains (Bellovac ABT) in lower limb arthroplasty compared with standard closed suction drains. We studied 123 lower limb arthroplasty (61 TKR & 62 THR) to see if there was a significant reduction in the need for homologous blood transfusion when using re-transfusion drains and its cost effectiveness.

Methods: Retrospective analysis of 123 patients undergone lower limb arthroplasty from March 2002 to Dec 2004 under one surgeon using the same technique for TKR and THR. 61 TKR (30 ABT drains v 31 standard drain) and 62 THR (30 ABT drains v 32 standard drain). Data was collected on sex, age, pre & post op Hb, volumes drained, volumes re-transfused and the number of homologous blood transfusions.

Results: 30 THR with ABT drains: 14 male, 16 female, mean age 68.7, mean pre op Hb 13.67, mean post op Hb 10.55,mean volume re-transfused 324ml, mean volume drained 466ml. 7 patients(23%) required additional homologous blood transfusion.

32 THR with standard drains: 14 male, 18 female, mean age 68.4, mean pre op Hb 12.96, mean post op Hb 9.36, mean volume drained 579.5ml. 24 patients (75%) required homologous blood transfusion.

30 TKR with ABT drains: 14 male, 16 female, mean age 69.8, mean pre-op Hb13.4, mean post-op Hb 11.03, mean volume re-transfused 415ml, mean volume drained 580ml. 4 patients (13%) required additional homologous blood transfusion.

31 TKR with Standard drains: 13 male, 18 female. Mean age72.1, mean pre-op Hb13.33, mean post-op Hb10.4, mean volume drained 711.5ml. 14 patients (45%) required homologous blood transfusion.

No re-transfusion complications occurred in the ABT group. 2 patients requiring homologous blood had increasing pyrexia and transfusion hence stopped.

Discussion: 11 out of 60 patients (18%) using ABT drains required additional homologous blood compared with 38 out of 63 patients (60%) requiring homologous blood using standard drains. Pvalue< 0.001. We show a stastically significant reduction in the need for homologous blood transfusion using an autologous blood re-transfusion drain. One unit of blood costs approximately £120 the ABT drain less than half of this amount, there is a significant cost saving in using autologous blood re-transfusion drains. We conclude that using Autologous blood Re-transfusion drains is safe, cost effective and reduces the need for homologous blood transfusion. If drains are to be used then Re-transfusion drains should be used.


W Salah Badawy D Chan

Objectives: Is to present the short term outcome of lumbar Artificial Disc Replacement in the Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital, UK.

Design: Review of literature and the short term outcome.

Summary of background data: The mainstay of surgical treatment for discogenic low back pain has been spinal fusion for many decades. The outcome of fusion procedures has been somewhat unpredictable and is linked with some limitation in the activities related to spinal motion.

Recently and in the last few years a relatively new procedure was introduced to spinal surgery practice which is the artificial disc replacement, the potential benefit of which is to relief back pain as well as keeping the spinal motion.

In this study, we are reporting our early experience in the results and short term outcome of lumbar artificial disc replacement done on 26 patients in The Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital

Methods: The 26 cases were operated upon in the duration between 1996 and 2003. We used artificial disc replacement.

Results: Our results based on ODSS and the VAS were good to excellent with patient satisfaction of about 87%

Conclusion: The Artificial disc replacement procedure in the lumbar and lumbosacral region is promising in short term outcome , however the long term results should be carefully evaluated.


A Khan Barton N Hanson

Purpose: To evaluate the clinical results after meniscal repair using Bionx arrows.

Methods: The study reports the clinical results of 50 patients who had meniscal repair.

The meniscal repairs were carried out by a single surgeon over a period of 4 years.

30 patients ( 1st set) had isolated meniscal repairs. 9 patients ( 2nd set) had meniscal repairs and ACL reconstruction at the same time. 11 patients (3rd set) had meniscal repair followed by ACL reconstruction few months later. The patients were seen in the clinic at 2, 6, 24 weeks post surgery and then kept under surveillance.

Results: In the 1st set , there were only 2 failures who needed partial menisectomy at 7 months and 2 years respectively after the initial repair. So, the failure rate is only 6.6%.

There was only 1 failure in the 2nd set who needed partial menisectomy 19 months post repair. This gives it a failure rate of 11.1%. In the 3rd set, there were 2 failures out of whom one needed partial menisectomy and other needed re-repair using the arrows at 3 and 7 months respectively post repair at the time of ACL reconstruction, a failure rate of 18.8%.


A M S Aweid

The purpose of this study is to show our experience with Birmingham Hip Resurfacing which we think it is a procedure that will play a big role in hip replacement surgery, especially for young people.

Methods:

Operative Records from the Theatre Registrar Book, Implant register Book and the theatre computer records.

Other similar studies from other Hospitals

Birmingham Hip Resurfacing – Ashford and St. Peter’s Hospitals Experience for the period March 2000 to January 2004.

The total number of cases done for the period: 290

The number of patients: 277

Male: 160

Female: 130

Right Hip: 145

Left Hip: 120

Side not recorded: 25

Both sides done: 13

Primary cases: 286

Revisions: 4

The youngest male done aged: 25 years

The youngest female done aged: 33 years

The oldest male done aged: 75 years

The oldest female done aged: 72 years

Mean age: 56.5 years

Conclusion: Birmingham Metal on Metal Resurfacing started by Mr. Derek McMinn at about 13 years ago.

Our results and results world-wide are encouraging. The failure rate of THR in young patients is very high, and the revision is difficult and requires a major reconstructive operation. Therefore BHR is a good alternative in our opinion.


P Heaton-Adegbile J G Hussell J Tong

Objective: To develop in-vitro experiments that measure the strain distributions at the bone-implant and bone-cement interface of the acetabular region under physiological loading conditions for cemented and cementless sockets.

Experimental model: Four hemi-pelvic specimens of saw bones were used. Following careful placement of six protected precision strain gauges, two specimens were prepared to receive a cemented polyethylene cup (Depuy Charnley Elite 53/28). Another two specimens were prepared and implanted with un-cemented Duraloc 58/28 cups. Press-fit technique was validated by torque measurements.

Background: Symptoms associated with prosthetic migration result from osteoclast induced bone resorption at the interface adjacent to bone. We aim to develop a new and more accurate method of measuring strains at this critical interface.

Methods: To simulate quasi-static loading, selected variables of hip joint force relative to the cup during normal walking was used for quasi-static tests on an Instron 1603 testing machine. The magnitude and orientation of the principal strains (maximum and minimum) were calculated based on the readings of strains from a 32 channel digital acquisition system.

Results: The magnitude and distribution of acetabular trabecular bone strains are dependent on the type of cup material (un-cemented/cemented) implanted.

At the position of maximum load, the maximum principal strain in the un-cemented specimens was 14.4 times higher than that for the cemented specimens (T-value = −96.40, P-value = 0.007). The highest recorded tensile strains in these specimens were localised to the acetabular rim of the posterior-superior quadrant.

For the cemented specimens, the maximum principal strains are highest in the dorsal acetabulum, at a location that approximates to the centre of rotation of the replaced hip joint.

Shear strains in the posterior-superior quadrant of both cementless and cemented acetabuli surpass the maximum principal strains.

Conclusion: In both cemented and un-cemented specimens, the maximum shear and principal strains magnitude show similar spatial and statistical distribution. As indicators of local failure prospect within the acetabulum, these strains suggest that the posterior-superior quadrant is the most likely site for load-induced micro-fractures, in both cemented and cementless acetabuli.


P Mestha S R Koka S Thiagaraj S McNally

Aim: To assess the long-term treatment outcome following conservative treatment of wrist ganglions by aspiration and steroid injections.

Materials and Methods: Between December 2001 and November 2003, 49 patients with wrist ganglions were seen and treated by one surgeon*. There were 20 males and 29 females with an average age of 37 years (range 13 to 70 years). Anatomically we had 41 dorsal wrist, 5 volar wrist and 3 digital ganglions. Diagnosis was made on clinical examination, explained to patients about the condition and given three options of treatment.

Reassurance,

Aspiration and steroid injection and

Surgery with its associated complications.

39% (14) were satisfied with reassurance alone, 69%(34) had aspiration and steroid injection and one opted for surgery.

Those who opted for aspiration and steroid injection are included in the study.

The aspiration was carried out under sterile technique, area infiltrated with 1% lignocaine, followed by aspiration of ganglion content using 16 G needle and injection of Methyl-prednisolone Acetate BP 40 mg/ml. The patients were advised to carry out their normal activities and followed up at 6 weeks, 3 months and 6 months.

Follow up period range between 6 weeks to 6 months (average of 3.8 months).

Results: 34 ganglia treated with aspiration and steroid injection had a cure rate of 47%(16), 31%(10) and 12%(4) respectively after 1,2 and 3 treatments with a cumulative success rate of 88%(30 of 34). We had recurrence rate of 12% (4 of 34) after 3 injections and two patients with skin discoloration.

Conclusion: Treatment options should be given to patients with wrist and digital ganglions. Conservative treatment is quite successful, which will avoid surgery and associated complications. Even though our sample size is too small to make any statistical significance, cumulative success rate of 88% following multiple treatments of aspiration and steroid injections are in comparable with other studies.


P Shah

The purpose of the study was to assess the accuracy of clinical examination to diagnose meniscal injury.

Internal Derangement of Knee is one of the most common conditions encountered in routine orthopaedic practice. The ultimate outcome depends upon timely management based on correct diagnosis. There are various tools available to diagnose this condition, mainly clinical examination, MRI & Arthroscopy. The individual method needs to be evaluated on the basis of merits and demerits depending upon the cost, time spent waiting for results and the degree of accuracy it provides.

The study was carried out retrospectively by looking at case notes of 98 patients, who had arthroscopy of the knees with or without MRI. An attempt was made to establish the correlation between the arthroscopic diagnosis and the clinical signs looked for to diagnose meniscal injury.

The result of the study showed that although the accuracy to diagnose the internal derangement prior to arthroscopy was fairly high, poor documentation of clinical examination findings, defeated the purpose of the assessment of accuracy. From patient’s management point of view, it appears that Arthroscopy & MRI have become indispensable tools in the evaluation of the injured knee. They can provide the physician and patient pre treatment prognosis. However they must be utilized as a complimentary to (not instead of) clinical evaluation and judgment. They become less cost-effective if used in a less responsible manner without the appropriate first-line investigations i.e. accurate clinical examination.


M Bhattacharyya B Gerber

Early mobilisation following Anterior Cruciate Ligament(ACL) reconstruction surgery is indicated for optimum results for accelerated rehabilitation. However, the graft used in reconstruction is at it’s weakest during the early post-operative period and can be prone to slipping.

Aim: This study compared two types of graft, bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) and soft tissue tendon, with the hypothesis that BPTB grafts would lead to less slippage under cyclical loading conditi ons.

Materials & Method: A comparative biomechanical study was carried out using sixteen proximal tibiae of calves, aged 20–26 weeks and carrying out ACL reconstruction, 8 constructs with human Cadaveric BPTB and another 8 with calves’ extensor tendons. An interference screw measured 9 x 25mm was used to fix graft tissue in the transosseous tunnel. The specimens were tested in material-testing machine using Merlin software.

The constructs were subjected to cyclical loading. A load cycle of 0-150-0N was applied at a crosshead speed of 100mm/min, approximately 80 load cycles per minute simulating the forces applied in post-operative mobilisation. The crosshead position was noted at peak load at 1, 100, 300, and 1000 cycles.

Results: The value of the graft slippage found in the soft tissue tendon model was 1.83 ± 0.54 and that of bone tissue (BPTB) model was 0.76 ±0.29. Creep value showed no statistical significance. There was significantly less slippage when using BPTB-to-bone fixation than with soft tissue tendon-to bone fixation (p< 0.005).

Clinical relevance: BPTB grafts are more likely to resist the return of anterior-posterior laxity in the immediate post-operative period, prior to graft fixation by tissue healing. BPTB grafts should be used when accelerated rehabilitation is required.


N Shaath A Zarugh I Whiteman

Introduction: We present the results of a prospective randomized trial of Zadik’s procedure V. chemical ablation by sodium hydroxide for the treatment of ingrowing toenails.

Materials and Methods: Thirty eight patients had Zadik’s procedure, 45 patients had chemical ablation by sodium hydroxide. Mean average follow-up was 12.45 months for Zadik’s group and 11.69 months for the chemical group.

Results: We have studied 5 end points: 1/return to normal shoe wear. In Zadik’s group, the average return to normal shoe wear was 2.13 weeks and 3.73 weeks in the chemical group. 2/average return to normal activity was 2.18 weeks for Zadik’s group and 3.89 for the chemical group. 3/the median numbers of dressings were 3 and 8 for Zadik’s and chemical ablation patients respectively. 4/the pain score, using the visual analogue, were not statistically significant between the two groups. 5/the recurrence rate, 23 recurrences in Zadik’s group (60.5%) and seven recurrences in chemical ablation group (15.6%). However, only 13 patients had symptomatic recurrence (34.2%) in the Zadik group and two patients had recurrence in the chemical ablation group (4.4%). 6/economic implications are considerable if we to compare the surgical ablation against the much cheaper chemical ablation.

Conclusion: The use of chemical ablation by sodium hydroxide in the treatment of ingrowing toenails shows statistically significant reduction in the recurrence rate of ingrowing toenails compared to Zadik’s procedure (P< 0.05).


A.K Choudhary C Bangalore M Bijoor A G Kasis

Aim: To evaluate the effect of Warfarin, the prevalence of acceptable level of INR by the anaesthetist, leading to delay of surgery in patients with fracture neck of femur and the outcome of such treatment.

Material and Methods: We retrospectively reviewed all patients admitted with fracture neck of femur who were on Warfarin in the year 2002. In total 9 out of 135 pt were on Warfarin.

Their entire medical records were scrutinised.

A control group of similar age, sex and pre- morbid conditions was identified.

A telephone survey was then conducted

In warfarin group average delay in surgery was 4 days (1 to 7) , needed 76% more blood test, total morphine 40mg and Codeine 960mg, 60% longer stay and after all 78% had General anaesthesia.

The six hospital survey showed the estimated number of such patients averaged 2 (1 to 4) per year, delay in surgery of 2 to 5 days and acceptable INR between 1.5 to under 3.

Conclusion: We found that we under estimate the number of patients on Warfarin. These patient had a significant delay in surgery requiring more analgesic both oral and parental, no significant post- op complications but a much longer hospital stay causing significant increase in morbidity, bed block and expenditure. We were surprised that there is no consistently acceptable level of INR to perform the surgery and type of anaesthesia.


A Khan

Aim of study: To establish whether there was a correlation between the degree of bony spinal canal encroachment and initial neurological deficit and subsequent neurological recovery.

Methodology and Results: Twenty-six Patients with Thoraco-lumbar Burst fractures presenting with Frankel Grades C, D and E were studied retrospectively. All the Patients were admitted to the spinal injury centre within seven days of injury and were managed conservatively with bed rest for six weeks (mean) followed by brace or a POP jacket for a further period of approximately six weeks. Neurological progress was assessed by Frankel Grade and American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) motor score.

The degree of spinal canal encroachment was determined from coronal sections of the CT scan by measuring the antero- posterior diameter (APD) and the surface area (Area). (APD 18.84% – 80.62%, Area 9.5% – 81.29%).

Average period of follow up was 24.8 months. All Frankel Group C improved to Frankel D and six out of the 13 Frankel D patients improved to Frankel E. The other seven Frankel D patients out of the 13 patients also had improvement in motor scores but did not change Frankel grade.

Conclusion: There appeared to be no statistically significant correlation between the degree of canal encroachment, the degree of initialneurological impairment or the degree of neurological recovery in patients who had motor sparing within one week of injury.


F Kwong M Elahi J Swanevelder L Spaine

Introduction: Elderly patients with neck of femur fracture have a wide range of cognition when admitted to hospital. Following hemiarthroplasty, these patients are usually given a standard set of precautionary advice in order to prevent dislocation of their prostheses. This may constitute a loss of time and resources as patients may not recall all the advice given.

Aim: We aim to determine the relationship between mental state on admission and the ability to recollect these precautions postoperatively.

Setting: Leicester Royal Infirmary, a busy teaching hospital

Method: Over a one-month period, 26 patients, aged 70 years and above admitted with hip fracture, were recruited prospectively for this audit study. The patients’ mini-mental test score on admission was used to classify nonaphasic subjects into three groups: normal, mildly impaired and severely impaired cognition. On the 2nd post-operative day (POD) the patients were given verbal instructions aimed at preventing dislocation of their hemiarthroplasty. Recollection of these precautions was then tested using a specially designed questionnaire (score: 1–10) on POD-6 and at 6 weeks.

Results: One patient died (3.8%). Of the remainder, 21 (84%) were female and 4 (16%) were male. The mean age was 80.4. There were 10 patients in Group-I (normal; 40%), 7 in Group-II (mildly impaired; 28%) and 8 in Group-III (severely impaired; 32%). The resulting score to the questionnaire in Group-I was 6.2 and 3.2; Group-II was 3.3 and 1.2; and Group-III was 0.3 and 0.3 on POD-6 and 6 weeks respectively.

Conclusion: 6 days following surgery, the best recollection of advice is only 2 thirds of what the patient had been told. 6 weeks following surgery, the best recollection of advice is only 1 third of the advice given. The recollection of advice in both mentally impaired groups was very poor throughout the study period. We recommend either not giving hip precautions advice to these patients or changing the way the advice is given to try to improve their recollection.


V Kumar A C Hui

Aim: This study compares the MRI scan with clinical diagnosis, and looks at the reliability of both these against the gold standard of arthroscopic diagnosis, in disorders of the knee.

Materials and methods: The patients were from the knee specialist unit of a tertiary referral centre seen and operated by the senior author , over a two year period. This is a retrospective study. The total number of patients in this study was 58(n=58) , with ages ranging from 18–63 years. The results were obtained using statistical formulae, which calculated the sensitivity , Specificity , accuracy and the positive and negative predictive values of the MRI scan and that of clinical diagnosis .

Results: The MRI scan was found to be significantly sensitive in diagnosis of medial meniscal lesions, 96% (95% Confidence interval 89–100), it was also found to be significantly specific in diagnosis of lateral meniscal, 90% ( 95% CI, 81–98) and ACL lesions 94% (95% CI,87–100). The MRI scan had poor sensitivity and specificity for articular cartilage lesions.

The sensitivity of clinical diagnosis for medial and lateral meniscus and ACL lesions was found to be less than 90%. Clinical impression was found to be significantly specific for lesions of ACL and the articular cartilage.

The negative predictive value of the MRI scan was found to be significantly high (> 95%), for lesions of the medial and lateral meniscus and the ACL.

Conclusion: The MRI had a poor diagnostic value in diagnosing and quantifying articular cartilage (chondral) lesions. Clinical diagnosis had a lower sensitivity as compared to MRI in diagnosis of medial meniscal lesions but was more specific in diagnosing cruciate and articular cartilage pathology. The reliability of a high negative predictive value for the MRI scan in ruling out medial meniscus, lateral meniscus and ACL lesion was demonstrated. Therefore, a ‘normal’ scan can be used to exclude lesions. thus sparing patients from expensive and unnecessary surgery and also freeing up valuable theatre time.


DS Damany MJ Parker A Chojnowski

Aim: Intracapsular hip fractures in young adults have a significant risk of fracture healing complications. Consequently, some authors advocate urgent and/or open fracture reduction. Our aim was to analyse outcomes following such fractures with reference to influence of fracture displacement, timing of surgery and method of reduction (open/closed) on the incidence of non-union (NU) and avascular necrosis (AVN).

Methods: Specific search terms were used to retrieve relevant published studies from 1966 to May 2003.

Results: Eighteen studies involving 564 fractures were analysed. The overall incidence of NU was 50/564 (8.9%) and AVN was 130/564 (23.0%). There was a higher incidence of NU and AVN following displaced than undisplaced fractures. NU occurred more frequently after open reduction than closed reduction (10/89 [11.2%] versus 13/275 [4.7%])

There was an increased incidence of AVN after closed than open reduction but this became not statistically significant when one study with a markedly higher reported incidence of AVN was excluded.

The difference in the incidence of NU and AVN following early (< 12 hours) or late (> 12 hours) surgery was not significant for either NU or AVN.

Conclusion: Early or open reduction of these fractures may not reduce the risk of NU or AVN. There is a suggestion of a higher incidence of NU following open reduction than closed reduction. Randomised studies with two year follow-up are required to report on a larger number of patients before definite conclusions on treatment can be made.


P Mestha M Catchpole SE James RPD Cooke

Aim: To determine the surgical site infection (SSI) rates for prosthetic hip and knee replacement surgery.

Materials and Methods: Between April 2002 and March 2003 the Infection Control team in conjunction with the Orthopaedic Department had participated in national surveillance project to determine the surgical site infection rates for prosthetic hip and knee replacement surgery. Information was collected relating to surgeon specific data and patient risk index. Each surgeon was given a unique confidential code and patients intrinsic risk of infection calculated based on ASA grade, wound class and the duration of surgery.

Results: During the first year of surveillance 455 prosthetic hip replacements were undertaken (i.e. hemiarthroplasty, primary and revision surgery). A total of 12 patients were identified with an SSI giving an average of 2.6% compared with national figure of 3.0%. Out of this 25% (3) superficial and 75%(9) deep-seated infection with Methicillin Sensitive Staphylococcus Aureus (MSSA) and MRSA being the commonest organisms.

234 prosthetic knee replacements (Primary and Revisions) were carried out over the same period of time with 7 cases identified with SSI, an average incidence of 3% compared with national average of 1.6%. Three were superficial and four with deep infection with MRSA, MSSA and coagulase negative staphylococci being the commonest organisms.

MRSA containment policy was introduced in November 2002 with pre operative screening,” ring fencing” orthopaedic patients and improved awareness of cross infection. Since then over the last 4 months of this study the incidence of SSI has fallen from 3.3% to 1.9% in prosthetic hip surgery and 5.8% to 0.7% in prosthetic knee surgery in comparison to previous quarter.

Conclusion: Significant cost and morbidity are associated with infection of the prosthetic joint. With simple measures like improved awareness of cross infection among the staff and relatives, ”ring fencing” orthopaedic patients and pre operative screening surgical site infection rate can be reduced.


M Siddiqui M Nicol E Karadimas F W Smith D Wardlaw

Purpose: To measure the effect of the X-Stop interspinous distraction device on spinal canal, exit foramina, and disc height dimensions at the operated level; and adjacent segment endplate angle, and lumbar spine movement in patients with symptomatic lumbar spinal stenosis using upright MRI.

Methods /Results: 14 patients (9 M;5 F) were scanned before and six months after operation. Age ranged from 57 to 88 years. All had symptomatic lumbar spinal stenosis- single level- 9 (L2/3-1; L3/4-1; L4/5-7); double level 5 (L3/4, L4/5).

Images were taken in sitting flexed, extended, neutral, and standing. The total range of motion of the lumbar spine and of the individual segments were measured, along with changes in disc height, areas of the exit foramina, and dural sac.

The mean area of the dural sac at the operated levels increased from 62.46mm2 to 77.69mm2 (p=0.004) in the standing posture and from 70.85mm2 to 94.62mm2 (p=0.019) in extension postoperatively. The area of the exit foramina in extension increased from 83.57mm2 to 107.88mm2 (p=0.002) on the left side and from 83.77mm2 to 108.69mm2 (p=0.012) on the right. The overall changes in the range of movement of the individual segments or of the lumbar spine were statistically insignificant.

Conclusions: This is the first study carried out using an upright MRI scanner in patients with lumbar spinal stenosis. The X-Stop device increases the cross-sectional area of the spinal canal and exit foramina by distracting the spinous processes of the operated level without significantly affecting overall posture of the lumbar spine.


S Ansara S El-Kawy S Geeranavar B Youssef M Omar

Introduction: Tennis Elbow affects 2% of the general population. 90% respond well to conservative management. Different surgical options are available for the treatment of recalcitrant Tennis Elbow. One of the most simple is percutaneous lateral release.

Methods: Prospective analysis of 31 patients, who failed a trial of conservative treatment, and underwent a lateral release of the common extensor origin under local anaesthetic as a day case. The symptoms had been present for an average of 21 months. Patients were scored for pain, activity and satisfaction.

Results: Pain relief was achieved in 90.3%, patient satisfaction in 90.3% and a return to full activity in 93.5%. The results were good in 28, fair in 2 and poor in 1. Return to work was on average after 4 weeks.

Conclusion: It is a simple, safe and effective procedure. It should be offered at an earlier stage, in those who failed conservative treatment. If all other procedures are equally effective, it is logical to choose the simplest.


K Rajasekar AA Faraj P Gholve

The factors affecting patient satisfaction with the outcome following treatment of Tendo-Achilles rupture were assessed. 35 patients were reviewed. 14 were treated non-operatively and 21 by open surgical repair. Mean follow up was 2 years (range 9 months– 4 years). Evaluation consisted of questionnaire and information from medical records. Mechanism of injury, type and time of injury, co-morbidity and follow-up were noted from the medical records. From the questionnaire, pre-injury activities, occupation, post-injury activities and overall satisfaction with their function were collected. The overall satisfaction level was quoted by the patients themselves by grading 10 for excellent recovery and 1 for the poor recovery.

Seventy percent were very satisfied with the outcome of treatment with a mean visual analogue score of 8.4 (7–10). The age, gender and occupation did not have any significant influence on the satisfaction level. The main determinant in the unsatisfied group was reduced post injury leisure activities. This was statistically significant between the two groups at p=0.003. Delay in initiation of treatment had a significant influence, with the group that presented late for treatment being less satisfied with p=0.015. Regression analysis showed that physiotherapy following treatment increased post injury activity and the level of satisfaction with p=0.034.

Reduced post injury leisure activity, delay in initiation of treatment and post treatment physiotherapy had a significant influence on patient satisfaction with outcome. There was no significant difference in the overall outcome between the operative and non-operative group.


K Rajasekar A A Faraj

There are good evidence that the distal canal restrictor improves pressurisation. Bone block and Hardinge restrictors are among the commonly used restrictors in UK.

During the introduction of cement, the restrictors tend to migrate. The effect may cause significant change in the size and thickness of the cement mantle. One of the determinants of early dramatic failure is the size of the cement mantle.

In our study, we compared the cement mantle thickness and amount of migration with Bone block restrictor and with Hardinge restrictor. The measurements were done in the standard AP x-ray of the hip taken in the post operative period. All cases were operated by one surgeon. The position of the either of the restrictor were maintained in all cases to 1.5 cm below the tip of the stem. Measurements were made for the cement mantle thickness, the distance between the tip of the stem and restrictor and canal diameter.

One observer who was not involved in the operative procedure evaluated 69 x-rays. Twenty seven cases of bone block restrictor and 42 cases of Hardinge restrictors were used.

At the end of our study, we conclude that both restrictors migrate with pressurisation. The amount of migration with Hardinge restrictor is more than bone block restrictor (21.5mm Vs 14.4mm) which is significant (p-0.007). The amount of migration had not affected the zone-4 cement mantle thickness (p-0.450). With the use of either restrictors, migration was influenced by the canal diameter (p-0.00). Canal diameter did not affect the cement mantle thickness ( p-0.368). We conclude that bone block restrictor is superior in withstanding pressurisation


A Arya G Kakarala J Sinha

Proximal humeral non-unions are uncommon, but when they occur they are disabling and often present a surgical challenge.

We have treated 55 cases of proximal humeral fractures by internal fixation from March 2002 to March 2004. Of these, 18 were non-unions out of which 16 were treated using AO Cannulated blade plate and bone grafting. Results of these patients are presented in this report.

14 out of 16 were available for follow up, which ranged from 18–30 months. Patients were regularly reviewed clinically and radiologically and had constant and DASH scoring at final follow up. Average Constant score was 64 and DASH score was 35.3. Range of movement recovered to 50% or more in every patient but only 3 had full range of movements. Maximum recovery in the strength of shoulder muscles measured with myometer was about 75% as compared to other side. Although X-rays showed sound bony healing in all but one case, none of the patients was completely symptom free at final review. However, they were all satisfied with the outcome of their operation.

Stable internal fixation is the key to success of surgical treatment of non-unions. We are satisfied with the usefulness of AO cannulated blade plate in providing a rigid fixation in our cases. However, it is difficult to achieve perfect results in terms of pain relief and recovery of normal function due to various reasons, which would be highlighted in our presentation. The report would also discuss the technical difficulties encountered in using this implant.


V Vallamshetla P Inaparthy S Deo

Aim: To quantify changes in epidemiology, in-patient treatment and outcome of hip fracture patients over seven-year period.

Subjects and methodology: Retrospective randomised analysis of in-patient charts of patients with hip fractures admitted to a large 650-bed Acute District General Hospital in 1996 compared with 2003. The following data is gathered: Epidemiological data, baseline test data for anaemia and renal function, time to surgery from admission, post-operative complications, time to discharge from ward and functional outcome.

Results: In 1996, the total number of admissions over 6 months was 144 compared to 160 in 2003 for the same time period. The mean age has increased from 83 years compared to 85 years in 2003. Median mental test score declined from 9 in 1996 to 6 in 2003. The mean co-morbidities rose from 1.7 in 1996 to 2.8 in 2003. 11% of patients were medically unfit for surgery in 1996 compared to 30% in 2003 resulting in delay in time to theatre. 33% of patients were admitted from nursing homes in 2003 compared to 22% in 1996. The mortality rate was 12% in 1996 compared to 18% in 2003.

Conclusion: This study demonstrates that deteriorating pre-operative status in terms of age, ASA, mental test score and co-morbidities seems to have negated any of the system changes we introduced to improve our service. As patients with neck of femur fractures are often already suffering from other significant co-morbidities, the improvements in the overall health care system may not have an impact on the outcome of the patients concerned.


M A Diab G N Fernandez

Purpose Of The Study: To compare the Coblation technology Vs standard diathermy regarding surgical time & cost in arthroscopic subacromial decompression.

Methods & Results: This prospective randomized comparative study between Coblation technology Vs standard monopolar diathermy in ASD. 40 patients with chronic impingement syndrome prospectively randomized 20 patients in each group. Procedure time & cost per case were accurately calculated. Results show that the Coblation group had an average 8 minutes shorter procedure time per case P value: 0.0001. The cost saving as a result was about £64 per case P value: 0.01

Conclusion: Use of Coblation technology for soft tissue debridement & resection in ASD reduces procedure time by 38% and the cost by an average of 18% per case (£64) compared with the use of a shaver and diathermy probe.


M Bhattacharyya H Bradley S Holder B Gerber

Inappropriate use of surgical dressing cause blisters around the surgical wound and increase the incidence of peri-operative wound infection and patients dissatisfaction which influence the outcome of the surgery. It is more so when patients are being treated as a day case procedure. We have not found any study correlating with patient’s satisfaction and surgical dressing.

Objective: To evaluate patient’s preference of surgical dressing and analyse which type of dressing is associated with significant morbidity

Design: Prospective, Non randomised, Clinical study.

Materials and Methods: Two different dressings Opsite post op or Mepore were applied by a single surgeon on 100 patients (50 each group) undergoing same arthroscopic procedure of the knee under general anesthetic were included in this study. They were followed up to 10 days. An independent nurse practitioner evaluated the complication related to the dressing and assessed the satisfaction with the 5 item short questionnaires at outpatients clinic.

Results: Blisters developed in 6% of patients with Mepore dressing (p=0.24) and none with Opsite Post op. 14% Patients with Mepore dressing developed superficial inflammation and this is significantly greater (p< 0.001) than opsite. 86% patients with opsite dressing on were able to take bath and thereby reduce the chance of contamination from the skin flora. 90% patients with opsite rated the dressing as excellent compared to mepore 26%, (p< 0.001)

Conclusion: Patients preferred Opsite post op as the dressing of their choice. It is not associated with dressing related morbidity, may improve better post operative wound healing. It may help to prevent superficial wound infection by contamination. After this study, we have changed our policy.


V Kumar F Attar A Adedapo

Objective: Our aim was the record variation in foot pressures through parts of the foot, in normal subjects and compare with foot pressure distribution in patients with conditions of the foot such as symptomatic hallux rigidus and metatarsalgia.

Methodology: This was an observational study. We assessed the foot pressure distributions in 30 normal subjects, using the foot pressure pedobarograph system. The foot pressures were measured through the Hallux, 1st Metatarsal head, 2,3,4th metatarsal heads, 5 metatarsal head, midfoot and hindfoot. Foot pressure in patients with hallux rigidus and metatarsalgia were compared with the pressures in normal subjects, using statistical analysis.

Results: The foot pressures were measured in Kilopascals(Kpa). Independent T test was used to compare pressures. In patients with hallux rigidus, the mean pressures through the hallux 314 (t= −3.62, p< 0.01) and midfoot 140 (t=−5.11, p< 0.01), were significantly higher, as compared to pressures in normal subjects. In patients with metatarsalgia, the mean pressures through the 5th metatarsal head 217 (t=−2.32, p< 0.05) and midfoot 94 (t=−3.17, p< 0.01), was significantly higher when compared to pressures in normal subjects.

Conclusion: The foot pressures through the hallux and midfoot were higher in patients with hallux rigidus (compared to normal). Thus any foot orthosis or surgery should aim to relieve the pressure through these regions. Whereas, foot pressures through 5th metatarsal head and midfoot were higher in patients with metatarsalgia (compared to normal). This reflects the adaptation the foot develops to avoid the painful region and thus any orthosis or surgery should try to spread the foot pressures evenly across the foot.


V R P Vallamshetla E Bache

Aim: To propose new guidelines in the management of supracondylar fractures treated by percutaneous Kirschner wires.

Subjects and Method: We audited 62 children with displaced, unstable supracondylar fractures of the humerus, which were fixed with Kirschner wire over a period of 2 years. The fractures were classified according to the Wilkins modification of the Gartland system. 10% were type II and 90% type III. The protocol followed was that all unstable fractures that required closed or open reduction must be stabilised with Kirschner wires of adequate thickness used in a crossed configuration and supplemented with back slab. They were then followed up mostly weekly, often with multiple check X-rays until 3 weeks, and for wire removal at 3 weeks. The parameters studied are level of surgeon, adequacy of intra operative reduction, re operation rate, adequacy of intra operative X-rays, out of hour operations, number of post operative X-rays, number of follow ups and any complications.

Results:

Two patients had re operation because of poor intra operative reduction which were performed by junior grade surgeon without supervision during out of hours.

No fracture had displaced at follow up when compared with the intra operative X-ray when properly reduced and wired.

One child had ulnar neuropraxia post operatively

One child had superficial infection, which settled with oral antibiotics.

Conclusions: Unnecessary radiation can be avoided by obtaining adequate intra operative X-rays and avoiding check X-ray as no fracture had displaced at follow up. New guidelines proposed: 1. Patients with no N-V complications can wait till the morning trauma list. 2. All intraoperative X-rays to be reviewed by consultants before discharging home. 3. 3 weeks appointment for wire removal can be set at one week clinic follow up with out X-ray.


E J Karadimas M Siddiqui M Nicol W Bashir T Muthukumar F W Smith D Wardlaw

Purpose Of The Study: This study measures the changes in the lumbar spine in different postures, pre- and after insertion of the device.

Material-Method-Results: All the 25 patients, with chronic back pain, had discography preoperatively a positional MRI scans pre-op and nine months postoperatively in different postures.

The patients were divided into two groups. The Group-A with 14 patients in which only Dynesys was used and Group-B with 11 patients in which Dynesys was combined with fused levels.

The operated levels were 51, 13 of which were fused. The results showed that the mean range of movement of the lumbosacral angle reduced by 10.28° (Preop=39.21°, Postop=28.93°) (p=0.016) in group-A. In group-B it reduced by 13.73° (Preop=36.18°, Postop=22.45°) (p=0.02).

The range of movement of the end plate angle at the instrumented segments in group-A reduced by 2.96° (Preop=5.56°, Postop=2.60°) (p=0.016) while in group-Bit reduced by 4.23° (Preop=6.69°, Postop=2.46°)(p=0.008).

The mean range of movement of the end plate angle at adjacent level in group-A reduced by 1.58° (Preop=8.7°, Postop=7.21°)(p=0.427) while in group-B it increased by 1.73° (Preop=6.91°, Postop=8.64°) (p=0.149)

The mean anterior disc height in group-A reduced by 1.18mm (Preop=10.05mm, Postop=8.87mm) (p< 0.005), and the posterior one was increased by 0.6mm (Preop=6.51mm, Postop=8.87mm) (p=0.013). In group-B, the anterior disc height was reduced by 1.11mm (Preop= 10.44mm, Postop=9.33mm) (p=0.049) and the posterior one by 0.16mm (Preop=6.98mm Postop=6.82mm) (p=0.714)

Conclusion: Dynesys stabilizing system allows movement at the instrumented levels, with no significant increased mobility in the adjacent levels. Also the device acted to compress the more the anterior annulus than to distract the posterior.


S Gella R Ponnuru G Wells N Tulwa

Purpose Of Study: To evaluate the results and functional outcome of use of three lateral K wires in supracondylar fracture fixation in children.

Methods And Results: It is a prospective study of 25 cases of supracondylar fractures over a period of three years from 2001, in children between 2 to 9 years, comprising of closed manipulation and percutaneous fixation with 3 lateral K wires, all done by the same surgeon.

Patients were immobilised for 3 weeks and K wires removed at that time. They were followed up till they regained full range of movements in the elbow.

Of the 25 cases, 2 were previously fixed with crossed K wires and were revised because of displacement . One patient had a delayed fixation because of gross swelling and was initially managed with traction.

Pin tract infection was noted in one case and responded to antibiotic therapy.

All the patients regained full range of movements and no angulatory deformity or loss of fixation was noted at the end of follow up.

Conclusion: Fixation with three lateral K wires is an excellent technique in treating displaced supracondylar fractures in children.


DA Stewart D Macdonald WJ Leach

We performed a prospective audit to assess radiological and clinical sequelae of using injectable calcium sulphate in the management of distal radial fractures.

All patients in a 4-month period who were treated with injectable calcium sulphate for distal radial fracture were included in the audit. Initial data was collected on demographics; AO classification and degree of deformity; method of fixation and surgical complications. Follow up consisted of clinical and radiological assessment of fracture healing at standard fracture clinic intervals with a final assessment of subjective functional recovery. 16 patients were included in the audit, all of whom were followed up for a minimum of 8 weeks. We observed a low incidence of secondary displacement, and did not observe the problem of increased pain and erythema that has been observed with other bone graft substitutes.

We conclude that injectable calcium sulphate is a useful adjunct to conventional management of these fractures that is safe, helps maintain fracture reduction and is not associated with product specific complications.


V Kumar F Attar P Savvidis J Anderson

Aim: Assessing Polyethylene wear is very important in following up patients after Total hip replacement (THR) and Livermore method (using callipers) is routinely used by clinicians in calculating this wear. Our aim was to assess if ‘Imagika’, a new computer software programme can accurately assess polyethylene wear(PE-wear). We also compared the computer software with the Livermore method in calculating wear.

Method: We used 15 different THR X rays of patients who had an ABG total hip replacement done. X rays that were included for the calculations were taken at different time intervals following the operation. Wear was calculated on each X ray by 3 clinicians using both the methods, on 3 separate occasions. We compared the Livermore method and the computer software for consistency of measurements and also calculated the inter and intra observer variability for both.

Results: There was a statistically significant difference (at the 5% level) between the measurements taken by the Imagika software and the Livermore method. F(1,88) = 5.38, p< 0.05. There was a statistically significant difference in the inter-observer measurements using the Livermore method. F(2,42) = 4.18, p< 0.05, but there was no significant inter-observer variation using the Imagika computer software. There was no statistically significant difference (at the 5%level) in the intra-observer variability of both groups.

Conclusion: The Imagika computer software proved to be better than the Livermore method in calculating wear with regards to inter-observer bias. There was also a significant difference between measurements taken using both methods. We conclude that the computer software may be a more accurate tool in the assessment of PE-wear in the future.


B Komarasamy M C Forster V Leninbabu

The mortality following surgery in patients with a recent MI is high. Standard advice is to wait for a minimum of 6 months. In urgent situations, this may not be possible. From Jan 2003 to Aug 2004, 10 patients were admitted with fracture neck of femur and a recent MI proven by ECG changes or raised troponin. There were 7 females. The mean age was 79.5 yrs (59–95yrs). The premorbid mobility and co-morbidities were noted. Echocardiography was done in all patients preoperatively to assess the cardiac function. All patients were seen by physicians and anaesthetist pre-operatively. The mean time from infarction to operation was 11.5 days (3–23 days). The patients underwent either Thompsons hemiarthroplasty or DHS. The anaesthetic was performed by a consultant. Most patients received spinal anaesthesia (7/9). The anaesthetic records could not be found for 1 patient. 6 patients died within a month and 1 patient died within 6 month of operation. Despite thorough preoperative work-up and consultant anaesthesia, the mortality following surgery for proximal femur fractures in patients with recent myocardial infarction is 70% at 6 months. To our knowledge, there are no published mortality figures for this situation. This is much higher than the reported mortality following proximal femur fracture.


I. Rafiq

Objective: We set out to identify if the quality of femoral cementing as assessed on the first postoperative AP radiograph was significantly different when operations performed by trainees were compared with those done by consultant staff.

The Barrack scoring system was used as a tool to evaluating cementation quality in all cases.

Material and Method: 70 patients with primary hip replacement were included. 41 cases performed by consultant while 29 by training surgeons.1st post-operative hip x-rays were taken between 3–5 days postoperatively. The x-rays were numbered randomly and their digital images were graded using Barrack grades by one observer (I.R) who was blinded to the seniority of surgeon who had carried out the case.

Results: Of the total cohort of 70 patients, 35(50%) were grade A, 28(40%) grade B and 7(10%) grade C. In the consultant cases 18(44%) were grade A, 19(46%) grade B and 4(10%) were grade C. The results in for training grade surgeons were 17(58%) grade A, 9 (31%) grade B and 3(11%) grade C. There were no grade D cases in either group.

Conclusion: The quality of femoral cementing was not significantly different when the operations carried out by consultants were compared to those where a trainee was the primary surgeon (p< 0.01). These results would suggest that learning curve (Figure) from trainees to consultants was quite satisfactory. Patients undergoing operation undertaken by an adequately experienced and supervised trainee are not at increased risk for implant failure compared to the individuals where the Consultant is the primary surgeon.


S Ansara S El-Kawy S Geeranavar B Youssef M Omar

Introduction: Diagnosis of rotator cuff tears by clinical examination and MRI is not always accurate. If the extent of the tear could be predicted pre-operatively, both the patient and the surgeon would be better equipped for the subsequent operation and rehabilitation.

Aim: To assess the accuracy of clinical examination and MRI in detecting the presence of rotator cuff tears.

Method and Results: Retrospective analysis of 86 patients with symptoms and signs of rotator cuff disease. All underwent clinical examination of the shoulder followed by an MRI scan. The diagnosis was confirmed intra-operatively.

Sensitivity of clinical examination for all tears was 69%, with a specificity of 64% and a positive predictive value of 80%. Individual sensitivities were as follows: grade I 50%, II 76%, III 100%. MRI had a sensitivity of 82.8% for all tears, specificity of 57% and a positive predictive value of 80%. Individual sensitivities: I 69%, II 90%, III 100%.

Conclusion: In some patients clinical examination remains uncertain, MRI is helpful but the diagnosis is not always reliable.


A M Yousef P J Livesley

Our study is to evaluate a new scheme designed to treat at home patients with Prolonged Leakage from wounds after lower limb arthroplasty

A prospective study of a 258 patients with leaking wounds after lower limb arthroplasty was conducted between August 2002 and February 2005. Each patient assessed, if meet the criteria entered the discharge scheme. A trained nurse visited each patient daily to provide wound care. The scheme could accommodate a maximum of 5 patients at any time. If the wound showed signs of infection the treating team was contacted and patient reviewed and treated if appropriate. For each patient Clinical data was collected including personal details, referral details, medical history and their progress. A satisfaction questionnaire was given at the completion of treatment.

Of the 324 patients referred to the scheme, 258 were accepted. 66 refused because the service was full (17), the wound was dry on assessment (6), failed the criteria (16), and patients declined the scheme (27). The average age was 67 years (16–93), 19 (8%)of patient readmitted to hospital, 14(6%) related to wound problems non required further surgery. The average number of home visits were 6, 5% of the patients called for advice. The number of bed days saved assessed as from the day of discharge from hospital to the date wound dry was 232 days. The response rate to questioners was 98%; all patients describe the service as excellent or good.

We concluded that the majority of leaking wounds after lower limb arthroplasty are self-limiting problems. The service provided an excellent way of treating patients at home and resulted in a major increase of available beds for little cost.


R Trehan TD Tennent

The image intensifier is an essential part of orthopaedic trauma surgery. The Image Intensifier can move in a number of planes and has to be positioned accurately. Frustration arises in the surgeon, the radiographer and the rest of the theatre staff when the image intensifier is moved in the wrong direction and there are also increased radiation hazards to all involved if unnecessary x-rays are taken due to incorrect positioning. Communication between the surgeon and the radiographer lies at the heart of safe practice. A questionnaire was designed and circulated to all the radiographers using the image intensifier and to orthopaedic surgeons including consultants, SpRs in London southwest deanery and SHOs of St George’s Hospital, London. They were then asked to write descriptors on a diagram illustrating the major movements of the image intensifier (Vertically up/down, to the patients left/right and head/feet). The questionnaires were completed by 32 radiographers and 48 surgeons (8 consultants, 33 registrars and 7 SHOs). There was very little consensus either within or between the groups as to what command should be used for which direction. A set of directions was agreed upon and put on image intensifier machine. When used these produced a significant reduction in misunderstood commands Confusion abounds when directing the Image Intensifier. When a set of directions can be agreed upon stress reduces and satisfaction improves although it is difficult to measure the reduction in radiation exposure.


HD Bhansali RS Page SR Murali

Purpose: The objective of the study was to determine the changes in the driving pattern – especially the capacity to use the steering wheel after carpal tunnel surgery so that recommendation for suitability to return back to driving can be made.

Methods Used: A computerised driving simulator normally used for driving assessment of drivers with disability at the regional mobility centre at the Wrightington Hospital was used to assess the patient’s driving. Static and dynamic steering torque was measured before and at 2 & 6 weeks after carpal tunnel release in 25 patients using the static assessment rig. Driving reaction time was also studied in these patients.

Results: There was decrease from preoperative static steering torque to that at 2 weeks postoperatively but the dynamic steering torque did not differ in most cases. By 6 to 8 weeks postoperatively, the mean torque values for static and dynamic steering capacity had significantly improved. The driving reaction times at preoperative assessment did not differ significantly from the post operative ones at all times.

Conclusion: Although at 2 weeks postoperatively the ability to use the operated hand for static steering had not returned in most patients, their overall steering capacity was not affected as suggested by their unaffected dynamic steering time and the reaction time.


A Abbassian G Giddins

Introduction: Impingement syndrome has been reported to occur in a proportion of patients (9%) following whiplash injuries to the neck. In this study we aim to examine this finding to establish the association and incidence of subacromial impingement following whiplash injuries to the cervical spine.

Method and results: We examined 219 patients who had presented to a single surgeon for a medico-legal report, at an average of 13.8 months (range 1–52) following a whiplash injury to the neck. All patients were assessed for clinical evidence of subacromial impingement. The patients were asked if the symptoms had developed following their neck injury and those with past history of shoulder pain were identified and excluded. 56 patients (26%) had shoulder pain following the injury; of these, 11 (5%) had clinical evidence of impingement syndrome, however in the majority other clinicians had overlooked this. The seatbelt shoulder (driver’s right and front passenger’s left) was involved in 9 (82%) of the cases (p< 0.001). The average age was 38.2 years compared with 57.8 years in those with subacromial impingement (p< 0.05). Impingement is therefore likely to be due to direct trauma from the seatbelt in the older age group with an already compromised subacromial space.

Conclusion: It is now established that subacromial impingement occurs following whiplash injuries to the neck. This is however, frequently overlooked and shoulder pain is attributed to pain radiating from the neck. It is important that this is appreciated and patients are specifically examined for signs of impingement so that appropriate treatment can be instigated. Direct trauma from the seatbelt is one likely explanation for this association.


S Ansara S El-Kawy S Geeranavar B Youssef H El-Shafei

Introduction: Locked posterior dislocations of the shoulder, with humeral head defects are rare injuries. It constitutes less than 2% of all posterior dislocations of the shoulder and 60% are misdiagnosed. There have only been a few articles describing the treatment of such injuries either by bone graft or Mc Laughlin’s procedure.

Patients: The first patient is a 23 year-old who presented as a missed diagnosis three weeks after a seizure. The second is a 35 year-old male referred four weeks after a traumatic dislocation. The third is a 55 year-old, known epileptic, who was diagnosed on admission. CT scan revealed a locked humeral head against the posterior glenoid rim, with defects of 30%, 20% and 30% respectively.

Treatment: All underwent reconstruction of the defect. The first using freeze-dried allograft, the second and third using iliac autograft.

Results: Each patient was assessed using the Constant and Murley score. The first patient scored 76 points at 30 months, the second patient scored 95 at 12 months and the third scored 97 after 12 months post-operatively.

Conclusion: Early diagnosis is important in management and prognosis of such injuries. Using bone graft in the reconstruction of the humeral head defect restores the normal anatomy, rather than distorting it by using McLaughlin’s procedure.


A Sharma P Lakshmanan HG David

Purpose Of The Study: Avulsion fractures of the anterior tibial spine are uncommon injury and we have evaluated the results in-patients who have undergone arthrotomy and fixation of the fracture.

Material & Method: Twenty five patients were followed up between 21–108 months (mean 44 months) after the operation. They were evaluated clinically, radiologically and the residual ACL laxity was measured with KT 1000. Lysholm scoring scale has been used to assess the outcome.

Eight fractures were fixed with a single AO screw; 5 with Herbert screws; 4 with a steel wire loop and 8 with absorbable stitch.

Results: Significant residual anterior laxity despite adequate fracture union was a common finding. The ACL laxity was maximum in adults in whom absorbable stitch had been used to fix the fracture and they had a corresponding lower Lysholm score.

In 2 out of the 5 patients where Herbert screws had been used there was significant migration of the screws.

Additional articular damage was observed in 3 patients who were pedestrians hit by a car. All 3 ended up with restricted knee movements and poor results. Three individuals who had their knee immobilised in 250–500 of flexion developed flexion deformities, which took 12–18 months to recover.

Conclusions: We recommend that use of absorbable stitches as a method of fixation be avoided in adults. Herbert screws in this situation have a tendency to migrate. AO screws or a non-absorbable loop should be used were possible. Immobilisation of the knee in excessive flexion leads to prolonged flexion deformity and we recommend immobilising the knee in no more than 100 of flexion.


A M Shahin

Many patients with proximal tibial, distal femur aggressive benign or malignant bone tumors had been treated with wide resection and reconstruction of the knee joint with a tumor prosthesis or an allograft. Reconstruction of the extensor apparatus, infection, non-union, fracture, high cost and mechanical failure is still a problem. If the patient’s own knee can be preserved while allowing a safe tumor excision, better functional results can be obtained for a long time.

We describe a series of 9 patients with juxta-articular giant cell tumor around the knee treated by extended intra-lesional curettage and chemical cauterization . Articular surface was preserved and subchondral bone was reconstructed with autogenous bone graft. Full function of the limb was preserved in all except one patient with a mean follow up of 3 years.


A Yousef N Al-Jafari T. Horton

Introduction: To compare soft cast (SC) with plaster of paris (POP) in treatment of greenstick fractures in children.

A prospective randomised study analysing and comparing the two types of treatment in terms of patient and medical staff satisfaction, duration of treatment, pain during treatment. Wrist movement after removal of plaster, and the cast quality . An approval to conduct the study obtained from trust ethic committee

Material and method: We identified 87 children (46 females and 41 males) referred to our clinic between September 1999 and June 2000 with forearm greenstick fractures. Patient and parents approached to participate and given written information about the trail if agreed consente obtained and patients randomised in to two groups using sealed envelopes. Those treated with a traditional hard cast (POP), and those treated with 3M soft cast tape (SC). A clinical details and progress form completed for each patient a questionnaire was completed by patients designed to score their overall satisfaction with treatment. Another questionnaire for clinicians score their satisfaction with cast quality and handling.

Results: A total of 61 patients completed the trail. 26 patients either declined the study after consent or lost during follow up. 29 patients had (SC) and 32 had (POP). The mean age was 8.88years for (SC) group and 8.34 years for (POP) group. The average treatment period was 22.7days for (SC) group and 23.1 for (POP) group. The average patient score for pain and satisfaction was 8.88 for (SC) group and 8.13 for the (POP) group with P value of 0.632. . [0 for Poor and 10 for excellent]. The average clinician satisfaction score was 8.7 for (sc) group and 8.03 for the (pop) group. With p value of 0.22. [0 for Poor and 10 for excellent]. 92% of the (SC) group achieved excellent wrist range of movement compared with 88% of the (POP) group.

Conclusion: We concluded that although each type of cast has its own advantages and disadvantage however when used in treatment of greenstick forearm fractures in children they produce comparable results. with on statistical differences.


A. Zarugh N Shaath P Bryant Z Khan

Introduction: We report a prospective study of the effect of body mass index and the length of the tourniquet time on the blood loss in total knee replacement in 70 consecutive patients.

Methods and materials: The patients’ weight and height were recorded to establish the body mass index (BMI). The patients were classified into four groups according to their BMI. The blood loss both intra-operative and post-operative was recorded. In addition, the tourniquet time was recorded.

Results: No significant increase in blood loss was demonstrated in patients with a high BMI, and there was no significant increase in the blood loss with longer tourniquet times.

Conclusion: Obesity does not increase the overall bleeding in total knee replacement.


T McCarthy B Lenehan J Street J McCabe

Introduction: Bone Morphogenic Proteins (BMP’s) are a family of bone-matrix polypeptides isolated from a variety of mammalian species. Implantation of osteogenic proteins induces a sequence of cellular events that leads to the formation of new bone.

Recombinant human osteogenic protein-1 (rhOP1 or BMP-7) has now been produced and is commercially available.

Rationale: OP.1 has been used in our centre since early 2003 and we now report on our experience with its use in the treatment of fracture non unions in a general orthopaedic trauma setting.

Methodology/Results: OP1 has been used in 19 fracture non unions, the commonest site being the tibia but also in the humerus and forearm. Five of these cases had previous autologous bone grafting. There was one case of deep MRSA infection in a proximal humerus fracture. There were no complications associated with the use of OP1 and specifically there were no instances of symptomatic heterotopic bone formation. Eighteen fractures went on to clinical and radiological union.

Conclusions: Autogenous bone is the current standard in the management of fracture non union because of its high osteogenic potential and biocompatibility. Donor site morbidity and quantity remain drawbacks. The use of OP.1 in the treatment of tibial non unions is well documented in the literature but there is little written about its use in other sites.

We are encouraged by our early experiences with the use of OP1 in numerous anatomical sites and apart from issues of cost would see great potential for further use.


OPINIONS ON OSTEOPOROSIS Pages 279 - 279
Full Access
NT O’Malley S Morris JP McElwain

Introduction: With a worldwide aging population, and an expected doubling in numbers of people older than 65 between 1990 and 2020, we are in the midst of a predicted increase in osteoporosis and resultant fractures. The International Osteoporosis Foundation recently surveyed consultant orthopaedic surgeons in mainland Europe and New Zealand to determine how patients with osteoporotic fractures were managed. Their conclusion was that treatment patterns were varied, and the findings supported the need to improve fragility fracture services to reduce the risk of recurrent fractures.

Aim: The aim of our study was to see how Irish practices and opinions related to the IOF survey, in anticipation of a formal protocol being established in our unit.

Methods: A modification of the International Osteoporosis Foundation survey used in 2002 was sent to 85 Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeons listed in the Irish Medical Directory. The questionnaire evaluated the surgeon’s education and knowledge of osteoporosis management, as well as estimated numbers of patients being treated with osteoporosis and the investigations available to their service. Treatment and referral patterns were also established. All responses were anonymous.

Results: The Irish response rate to the survey of nearly 50% was higher than that of our European colleagues, and showed that only 25% of surgeons felt they received sufficient training in the area of osteoporosis, but only a minority were not confident managing the disease. One-quarter of those surveyed would treat a patient with a fragility fracture for osteoporosis themselves, while over half would refer the patient on to a General Practitioner for further management. 50% of Irish Consultants would first order bone mineral densitometry, and nearly three-quarters believe the General Practitioner is the most appropriate professional to follow up these patients. Significantly, 15% of Orthopaedic surgeons did not have any access to densitometry. The most popular treatment modality is a combination of calcium and vitamin D supplementation in conjunction with Alendronate.

Conclusion: There is currently a lack of standarisation in the management and follow up of patients with osteoporosis. While the disease and its treatment is an internationally important topical issue, our study showed that at a national level there is a lack of consistency between the need for specialised services and implementation of treatment algorithms, due in part to lack of investigative facilities and organised management teams.


O Flannery A Walsh M Naughton N Awan

Aim: To compare the outcome of open reduction and internal fixation with MUA and k-wire stabilisation of dorsally displaced distal radial fractures

Methods: A review of patients that had ORIF or MUA and k-wire stabilisation for dorsally displaced distal radial fractures was carried out and patients with a follow period of more than 6 months were selected for this study. The patient history and the management of the injury were obtained and the wrist examined. Each patient completed a patient-rated wrist evaluation form and the range of movement and strength of the wrist was determined by the senior occupational therapist. Standard radiographs were obtained and volar tilt, radial inclination and radial length were measured.

Results: This study provides results on 24 patients, which were grouped according to the two different surgical procedures; ORIF and MUA and k-wire stabilisation. The procedure undertaken depended on consultant preferences and in the majority of cases patients were treated with MUA and k-wire stabilisation. Patients of both groups were of similar age and all sustained either a low or medium energy injury. All patients from each group received physiotherapy post operatively.

There was no significant difference between both groups for range of movement and grip strength. There was also no difference between the patient’s perception of pain and function which was assessed using the patient rated wrist evaluation (PRWE). Radiologically, the k-wire stabilisation group averaged better volar tilt compared with the ORIF group. For radial height and inclination the outcome was similar.

Conclusion: MUA and k-wire stabilisation has been the most popular surgical management for unstable dorsally displaced fractures of the distal radius. More recently ORIF with the locking compression plate has been used with good results. This study showed that the outcome of ORIF and MUA and k-wire stabilisation were similar and therefore either surgical management can be used with good results.


S Bahari S Morris P Nicholson J Sparkes J Rice J Mc Elwain

Introduction: The incidence of osteoporosis is increasing as the population ages. Amongst the recommended treatment modalities for osteoporosis is the use of bisphosphonates. The National Osteoporosis Foundation (U.S.A.) recommends DEXA scanning prior to commencing treatment with bisphosphonate therapy. However, in the Irish setting the availability of DEXA scanning is often limited. We hypothesised that a high percentage of elderly women presenting with fragility fractures of the distal radius (following a simple fall from standing height) had underlying osteoporosis. As such, the initiation of treatment with bisphosphonates prior to obtaining a DEXA scan may be warranted in this patient cohort.

Aim: To assess the incidence of osteoporosis in a continuous cohort of women over 60 years of age presenting with fractures of the distal radius.

Patients and Methods: All female patients aged > 60 years old presenting to the fracture service over a five month period with distal radial fragility fractures were evaluated. Exclusion criteria included:

non-English speakers

non-resident in Ireland

previous diagnosis of osteoporosis or commenced on treatment for osteoporosis

not fit to attend for DEXA scan

not willing to participate in the study

100 consecutive patients presenting to the fracture service with distal radial fragility fractures were prospectively identified. Data was collected, including body mass index (BMI), risk factors for osteoporosis, and the OST risk index calculated. A DEXA scan was then performed on the patient’s hips and lumbar spine.

Results: The mean patient age was 74.3 (95%CI + 10.6) years. Mean BMI was 17.3 kg/m2. The mean Osteoporosis Self-assessment Tool (OST) index score was 0.65 correlating with a moderate risk for osteoporosis. The mean T score for the patients’ hips was −2.0 while that for the lumbar spine was −1.7. 64% of patients were osteoporotic with a T score of less than −2.5.

Conclusions A significant incidence of osteoporosis was noted in the study cohort. It is imperative that orthopaedic surgeons recognise the high incidence of osteoporosis in the elderly female population presenting with fragility fractures. The high morbidity and mortality associated with hip and vertebral fractures in this population may be prevented by early treatment of underlying osteoporosis.


R Thakral PE McHugh W Brennan S Lalor K Kaar

A study on cadaver ankles was performed; two methods of ‘Danis-Weber type B’ lateral malleolar fracture fixation were compared.

Materials and Method: Ten ankles from five female cadavers were used. The distal fibulae were osteotomised at the level of the syndesmosis with a saw and the fracture fixations were divided into two groups. In Group I, the fractures were fixed with traditional anteroposterior cortical screws and in Group II, the contra lateral fractures from the same cadaver were fixed with postero-anterior cortical screws. The distal fibulae in both groups were subjected to biomechanical compression and torsion forces and the force at which the fixation gave way was recorded.

Results: In the former group the breaking force was significantly lower than that required in the latter group by a mean of 0.4 kN.

In conclusion, the fixation done in Group II was found to be better.


M Ashraf M Hussain R Thakral J Corrigan K Kaar A McGuiness M Dolan

Aims: Treatment options for proximal humeral fractures are not very clear, specially in osteoporotic bones. Non operative treatment if on one hand leads to unpredicted and poor outcomes, the operative treatment on the other hand leads to devascularization of fractured fragments and implant failure leading to unacceptable results. Newer interlocking plates, which are applied with minimum soft tissue stripping of fractured fragments and better fixation abilities seems a promising alternative. We present our experience with such plates.

Patients and Methods: Over a period of two years 2002 and 2003, we used 50 plates to treat Neer’s two and three parts and surgical neck of humerus fractures. We reviewed our clinical results with PHILOS plates, which is in interlocking plate. Average age was 34 (24–82). 21 Male and 29 Females. We followed them clinically and radiologically for healing. The shoulder function was assesses with DASH scoring system. The DASH system questionnaire was filled by patients before the fracture and after healing of the fractures. We used a regimen of progressive rehabilitation of shoulder from immediate post operative period. All the complications including union issues, shoulder function, wound problems, nerve injuries, infection and implant failure were noted. Two different techniques were used to fix the fracture with the plate.

Statistical analysis was performed on the data collected through DASH questionnaires along with multivariate and univariate analysis and t-tests.

Results: We were able to follow all the patients who filled the pre fracture and post healing DASH system questioner. X-rays and clinical findings were available for all the patients in the study. All the patients united with average length of 6 weeks (5–12 weeks). All the fractures united. There were no deep infections; however, two patients had to have a week of oral antibiotics for superficial wound infection. There were no permanent nerve injuries. Eight patients had transient axillary nerve paresis, which resolved after 10–15 days. Patient satisfaction with the procedure was high.

48 % of patients showed a rise in DASH scores after the fracture healing, indicating decrease shoulder function. This was statistically analysed and failed to reach any significance p=0.867. There was no difference between the two techniques in terms of complications and union rates.

Conclusions: PHILOS interlocking plates in our study showed 100% union rate with no or minimal complications and preservation of shoulder function. They are technically not difficult to apply and allow immediate post operative mobilization. Hence we recommend their use in primary fixation of proximal humerus fractures.


G Colgan S Morris J Sparkes P Nicholson JJ Rice JP McElwain

Introduction: Proximal humeral fractures are common in the elderly osteoporotic population. Surgical management of such fractures with traditional internal fixation techniques is often challenging due to poor bone quality. Fixation with intramedullary devices theoretically offers better fixation, but with increased risk of shoulder pain and decreased range of motion. We undertook a study to compare outcome following fixation of such fractures with either an intramedullary nail (Polarus), standard Clover Leaf plate (AO), or Philos Locking plate (AO).

Method: All patients admitted for surgical management of a proximal humeral fracture were entered into the study. 10 patients were treated using a Philos plate (Group 1), 5 with a Clover Leaf plate (Group 2), and 10 with a Polarus nail (Group 3). Post-operative assessment included radiological evaluation, clinical assessment of range of motion compared to the non-injured arm, assessment of pain severity (visual analogue scale), and functional assessment (DASH score). Non-parametric statistical techniques were used to analyse results.

Results: There was no significant difference in age or sex distribution between the three groups. (Mean ages: Group 1: 54.6 yrs, Group 2: 45.2 yrs, Group 3: 59.7 yrs) Mean patient follow-up was 22 months (range 5–52 months).

All patients in Group 1 and 2 went on to satisfactory radiological and clinical union. A higher complication rate was noted in the Polarus nail group, with 3 patients requiring removal of metal due to soft tissue or subacromial impingement. In addition one patient developed a non-union and required Philos plate fixation.

All groups demonstrated a significant decrease in shoulder range of motion following injury, however this was less marked in Group 1 (Philos plate). In addition, patients in group 1 (Philos plate) demonstrated a more rapid recovery in terms of severity of pain, functional impairment and range of motion in the early postoperative phase. However, no significant long-term difference was noted in terms of post-operative pain or functional deficit between group 1 and 2. The poor outcome in group 3 was associated with a high incidence of shoulder pain and secondary procedures.

Conclusion: Intramedullary fixation of proximal humeral fractures resulted in a high level of complications requiring secondary procedures in many cases. Our study supports the safety and efficacy of plate fixation techniques in the operative management of proximal humeral fractures.


M Vioreanu D O’Briain S Dudeney B Hurson K O’Rourke E Kelly W Quinlan

Background: The aim of operative treatment for ankle fractures is to allow early movement after internal fixation. The hypothesis of this study was that early mobilisation facilitated by a removable cast after internal fixation of ankle fractures would improve functional recovery of patients compared with that after conventional immobilisation in a cast.

Material and Methods: Sixty two patients between the age of seventeen and sixty five with ankle fractures that required operative treatment were randomly allocated to two groups : immobilisation in a non weight bearing below knee cast for six weeks or early movement in a removable cast ( at two weeks after removal of sutures ) for the following four weeks. The follow up examinations which consisted of subjective (clinical, Olerud-Molander score, AOFAS score, SF 36 ) and objective ( swelling measurement, x-ray ) evaluations were performed at two, six, nine, twelve and twenty four weeks postoperatively. Time of return to work was recorded.

Results: There were no postoperative complications in the group treated with immobilisation in cast. There was one superficial wound infection treated with oral antibiotics in a patient with a previous dermatological condition around the fractured ankle in the group treated with early movement in a removable cast. Patients in group two ( early movement ) had higher functional scores at nine and twelve weeks follow up but not of statistical significance. They also return to work earlier ( 55.5 days ) compared with the ones treated in cast ( 98.7 days ). Patients treated in removable cast had higher mean SF-36 scores, but this difference was significant only for two of the eight aspects investigated.

Conclusions: Early movement with the use of removable cast after removal of sutures in operated ankle fractures decrease swelling, prevent calf muscle wasting, improve functional outcome and facilitate early return to work of patients. Our findings support the use of a removable cast and early exercises in selected, compliant patients after surgery of the ankle.


A Johnston J Wong-Chung

Percutaneous fluoroscopically asseisted iliosacral screw insertion has become one of the most popular methods of stabilisation of the posterior aspect of the vertically unstable pelvis. Screw malpositioning rates range from 0 to 10%. Screw misplacement can cause injury to the iliac and gluteal vessels, L4 to s1 nerve roots and sympathetic chain.

We performed two radiographic studies on dry human bones to seek safe radiographic landmarks for insertion of iliosacral screws.

Part 1: Two parallel linear densities are always present on lateral plain radiographs of the lumbosacral spine and pelvis. Using wire markers on pelvic bones, we accurtely define the origins of these “pelvic lines”. Steel wires of different lengths were placed along the iliopectineal and arcuate lines of the pelvis. The shorter wire stopped at the anterior limit of the sacroiliac joint. The longer wire extended further along the entire course of the medial border of the ilium to the iliac crest posteriorly. We demonstrate that each “pelvic line” represents the sharp bony ridge that forms the anterosuperior limit for insertion of the iliosacral screws.

Part 2: In a second experiment on dry pelvis, we inserted balloons filled with radio-opaque contrast medium into the spinal canal of the sacrum and exiting through the anterior and posterior sacral foramina on either side. Plain lateral radiographs and CT scan with reformatted images were obtained. We present a previously undescribed radiological sign on plain lateral radiographs of the lumbosacral spine. The inferior and posterior boundaries of the “acorn sign” are delineated. Together, the “pelvic lines” and “acorn sign” provide accurate landmarks for the safe insertion of iliosacral screws. Iliosacral screws should be contained within this “acorn sign” to avoid injury to the nerve roots and below the “pelvic lines” to safeguard the iliac vessels and lumbosacral trunk.


A. Glynn P. Connolly D. McCormack J. O’Byrne

Introduction: Total hip arthroplasty for osteoarthritis secondary to developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) is technically difficult due to the abnormal anatomy involved. The use of a modular hip replacement system is advantageous in that its versatility allows for intra-operative adjustment to accommodate for final acetabular position and version.

Aim: The aim of this study was to assess our early results with the S-ROM hip (DePuy), a cementless modular femoral implant.

Methods and materials: We performed 22 total hip replacements on 20 patients with DDH over a three and a half year period. Nineteen patients were female and one was male. Ages ranged from 30 to 59 years (average 38.3 years). Ten patients had had previous osteotomies performed, including two of whom had Ganz periace-tabular osteotomies performed in our centre.

Nine patients had additional acetabular bone grafting with autologous femoral head, two patients had subtrochanteric osteotomy, and another patient had an adductor tenotomy performed at the time of their surgery. Follow-up ranged from 6 to 44 (mean 19.6) months.

Results: Harris hip scores improved from an average of 42 points pre-operatively to 90 points post-operatively. No radiographic evidence of osteolysis was seen around the femoral implant. Two patients required revision of their acetabular components. Both had satisfactory outcomes.

Conclusion: Our early results with the S-ROM femoral prosthesis correlate well with those from other studies involving arthroplasty for DDH. There were no complications related to the use of uncemented prostheses. Modularity makes this implant extremely versatile and easy to use in this complex patient population.


P Archbold M Slomczykowski DE Beverland

Background: The positioning of the acetabular component is of critical importance in total hip arthroplasty. Due to the orientation of the acetabulum and limitations of observation imposed at the operative site mal-positioning is common. We believe that by utilising the transverse acetabular ligament (TAL) and acetabular labrum, we are able to anatomically position our cup. In this study, we evaluate the correlation between placement of the acetabular component by reference to the TAL and the acetabular labrum with the taught safe zones for cup placement.

Method: 7 embalmed hips were studied. Following disarticulation the labrum and TAL were digitised and their plane was calculated. Orientation of cup placement in this plane was calculated from a pre-dissection pelvic CT.

Results: The plane of the labrum/TAL varied between 5–26° of anteversion and 32–59° of inclination. Interob-server differences in acetabular cup placement based on the TAL/labral plane indicate reasonable coherence. Almost all components were inside the documented “safe zone” 0–40° of anteversion and 30–55° of inclination of placement.

Conclusion: The acetabular labrum and TAL form a plane that reflects the documented “safe zones” for acetabular component placement. We feel that this plane allows a surgeon to determine optimal patient specific acetabular component placement, irrespective of patient position.


P Brady G O’Toole K O’Rourke

A review of the first two hundred and ten patients undergoing Birmingham hip re-surfacing between January 2003 and June 2005 was performed. All surgeries were performed by a single consultant orthopaedic surgeon. All resurfacings were carried out utilising the antero-lateral approach to the hip.

Mean review post-operatively was at six weeks. The following clinical parameters were evaluated: length of in-hospital patient stay, intra-operative blood loss and post-operative range of joint movement. In addition, the following radiological measurements were made: the acetabular inclination angle, the head-shaft angle and evidence of leg-length discrepancy.

One patient experienced fracture of the femoral neck and two other patients underwent revision surgery. Our results demonstrate that the anterolateral approach represents an alternative approach, with short-term results comaprible to the posterior approach for hip resurfacing.


M. Vioreanu S. Brophy S. Kearns E. Kelly B. Hurson S.K. O’Rourke W. Quinlan

Introduction: The optimal management of ankle fractures in the elderly is controversial, with wide variation in the complication rates reported in the literature. Achieving a satisfactory outcome is essential as reduced mobility exacerbates pre-existing morbidity and diminishes the likelihood of independent living. However, in elderly patients surgery carries increased risks due to osteoporosis, poor skin condition and decreased vascularity.

Methods: We performed a retrospective review of outcome and complications in patients over 70 years of age with ankle fractures. Patients were admitted for manipulation under anaesthetic and application of cast (MUA) or open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF). Data were retrieved from medical and nursing notes relating to pre-operative functioning, type of injury, operative procedure and outcome. All X-rays were also reviewed to confirm fracture grade and union.

Results: A total of 134 patients over the age of 70 were admitted for management of ankle fractures during January 1995 and December 2003 and 117 of these were included in the study. 84 were operatively treated for ankle fractures and a further 27 patients underwent MUA. The mean age in both groups was 76 and there was a female predominance in both groups (89% in MUA, 79% in ORIF). 14.8% of the conservatively managed group were nursing home residents compared to 2.4% of the operatively treated group. The groups were similar with respect to ASA grade and co-morbidities. The median length of stay was shorter for the conservatively managed group (4 vs. 6 days). 7.5% of the MUA group required a second intervention compared to 4.5% of the operatively managed group. There were two below knee amputations in the operatively managed group, both related to open fractures, and one arthrodesis in each group. There were three wound complications in the operatively managed group. The rate of postoperative medical complications was the same in both cohorts. 7.4% of patients treated with MUA and 1.1% of patients treated operatively had reduced mobility at final follow-up.

Conclusion: The decision-making process for treatment of ankle fractures in the geriatric population is challenging. We observed significantly better functional results in the ORIF group than the MUA group. These results indicate that open reduction and internal fixation of ankle fractures in geriatric patients is efficacious and safe in selected patients


A Madhavan A Thomas P Moroney O Brady

Introduction: Dislocation following total hip arthroplasty is a recognised complication and is attributable to several factors. The posterior approach to the hip is associated with higher dislocation rates than anterior or lateral approaches. We retrospectively reviewed the incidence of dislocation following total hip arthroplasty, in our institution, over a period of 5 years (from January 2000 to December 2004).

Results: We found 97 instances (in 49 patients) of dislocation following total hip arthroplasty. Of the 49 patients, 35 had the total hip arthroplasty done through the posterior approach. The Stacathro approach was performed on one patient, antero-lateral approach in 7 patients, and the transtrochanteric approach on 6 patients. Eleven patients had undergone revision arthroplasty prior to sustaining a dislocation and 16 had undergone primary arthroplasty. 16 patients had multiple dislocations. 8 of the 16 with multiple dislocations had a primary arthroplasty and rest had revision procedures done. A number of authors have reported decreased dislocation rates after using various techniques for enhancing the closure of the posterior soft tissues following total hip arthroplasties using the posterior approach. We reviewed 256 patient records that had undergone total hip arthroplasty in this period by the senior author through the posterior approach. The Savory technique was used to repair the posterior soft tissue layer. 160 patients had undergone primary arthroplasty and 96 had revision surgery. There were 3 cases of dislocation among the primary arthroplasty cases and 7 among the revision group.

Conclusion: This review showed that posterior approach to the hip continues to be associated with higher dislocation rates than other approaches. Using the Savory technique can reduce the dislocation rate following total hip arthroplasty.


P Archbold M Mohammed S O’Brien D Molloy DE Beverland

Current methods for restoring or preserving limb length following total hip arthroplasty are anatomically inaccurate, as they do not consider acetabular and femoral height independently. In order to address this, we present and evaluate a technique that uses the transverse acetabular ligament to control the vertical height of the acetabular component and a caliper that controls the vertical placement of the femoral component within the femoral canal. Limb lengths were measured in 200 patients who had undergone primary total hip arthroplasty using this technique. Using this method, 94% had a post-operative limb length inequality that was 6 mm or less when compared to the normal side (average +0.38 mm). The maximum measured limb length inequality was ± 8 mm.


R MacNiocaill R Britton J Prendergast P Kenny

Aims Cemented acetabular components remain the standard for many surgeons around the world, however the main draw back of this technology is that of aseptic loosening. It has been suggested that loosening is initiated when mechanical failure occurs at the cement/bone interface. Successive generations of cementation techniques have evolved over the years in order to address this problem by improving the mechanical integrity of the cement bone construct. Negative pressure intrusion cementation techniques (NPI) represent a more recent phase of this evolution. These techniques involve the introduction of vacuum into the peri-acetabular bone immediately prior to cement application with the aims of decreasing the deleterious effects of the systemic bleeding pressure, removing fat and debris from the path of the advancing cement and causing deeper cement ingress through the direct effects of negative pressure. There exists in the literature very little scientific information relating to this technique; therefore our aim is to assess the quality of the cement bone interface in constructs created using a specially constructed rig.

Methods: Samples of screened, fresh frozen, human femoral head are machined to create a cylindrical core of cancellous bone measuring 24 x 40 mm. These samples are carefully stratified for porosity using a method of combing DEXA scan bone mineral density findings with microCT (Scanco 40, Bassendorf, Switzerland) histomorphological parameters. These cores are then introduced into the vacuum chamber of the rig and are subjected to a negative pressure of −30 kPa using a clinical suction machine (Cherion, Czech Rep). Simplex P (Stryker, Mahwah, US) polymethylmethacrylate cement is applied to the exposed cancellous bone within the rig and subjected to a constant positive external pressure via the vertical actuator of a servohydraulic materials testing machine (Instron 8873, Mass. US). The cement is allowed to set and the constructs are removed en bloc and frozen. The constructs produced are cylindrical and consist of three distinct zones; cement, bone and that of the cement bone interface. The quality of the cement bone interface is assessed in two distinct ways:

MicroCT is used to produce both quantitative and qualitative data relating to the cement bone interface. This data is processed using the 3D reconstruction software (Scanco, Bassendorf, Switzerland) to give values for intrusion depth and the integrity of cement bone interlock indicated using a previously published method of recording incidence and size of vacuolation within the cement bone interface.

The mechanical integrity of the cement bone interface is tested in shear, torsion and tension. Control is provided by repeating the identical procedure in porosity controlled bone in the absence of vacuum.

Results: Early results indicate a tendency toward deeper and ‘tighter’ cement interdigitation within the cement bone interface in the samples created using the NPI method. These samples also tend to be mechanically stronger than controls.

Discussion This series of in-vitro experiments provides important information about this accepted but poorly understood technique. The model accurately mimics the operative technique and the use of microCT in this way is a novel application, allowi ng the digital assessment of cement intrusion depth and quality without having to physically section the constructs. It also attempts to relate these properties to mechanical strength.


RV Kalyan A Hamilton P Nolan E Cooke N Eames M Crone D Marsh

Background context: Stable thoracolumbar spinal fracture is a common injury, yet there remains a relative lack of evidence that would allow reliable prediction of outcome. Variation in outcome in stable thoracolumbar spine fracture without neurological deficit could not be explained by the assessment made from x-rays and CT imaging alone, which measures mainly the bony injury severity. So far, no good classification system has been developed to assess the severity of soft tissue injury (disc).

Objectives: To measure short-term outcome of stable thoracolumbar fracture and analyse aspects of injury severity for their ability to predict outcome. To develop a new disc injury severity grading system in thoracolumbar spine fractures.

Study design: Prospective observational.

Patient sample: 44 patients with stable fractures between T11 and L5 vertebra with no neurological deficit and treated conservatively were selected.

Methods: All had plain x-rays, CT and MRI scans post-injury and at one year post-injury (except CT). Bony injury severity was scored on a seven-point ordinal scale based on (a) communication, (b) apposition and (c) kyphosis. Disc injury severity was scored by the newly developed six-point ordinal scale (none to severe) based on the following variables: (a) Herniation of the disc, (b) Indentation of the end plate, (c) Change in height and (d) Change in signal. Outcome was assessed at one to two years from injury. The following outcome measures were collected: (A) Five domains of pain symptoms – intensity, duration, bothersome, interference and satisfaction. (B) Five domains of function – Physical Component Summary (PSC) measure, Mental Component Summary (MSC) measure, Oswestry disability score, return to pre-injury level of overall activities and return to employment. Non-parametric correlation coefficients were calculated between outcome variables and other variables to look for the predictors of outcome. Stepwise linear regression analysis was performed to compare the predictive values and to look at what proportion of outcome is predicted by different predictors.

Results: According to AO classification, the fractures were A1, A2, A3 and B1. The Spearman correlation coefficients between outcome and injury severity were consistently higher with disc injury severity than bony. For the outcome of pain intensity, the correlation coefficients for disc and bone injury severity respectively were:.63 (p < .0001) and.28 (NS-not significant). Similarly for SF36 PSC were: .41 (p < .01) and.25 (NS). The predictive value of pain at F < .01 was 29% for disc injury severity and all other variable were not significant and excluded. At F < .05, the predictive value of disc injury severity (29%) increased further by 9%, 8% and 6% by addition of variable “Patient’s pre-injury SF36 MSC”, “Legal and Compensation issues pending” and “Physical demand of job” respectively. The predictive value of function at F < .01 was 16% for disc injury severity and it increased to 31% by the addition of “physical demand of the job” variable. At F < 0.05 the predictive value further increased by 5% by addition of variable “Legal and Compensation issues pending”. All other variables were not significant.

Conclusions: A new grading system of disc injury severity was developed and it showed good predictive value for pain and functional outcome. Disc injury severity has a better predictive value for short term outcome than bony injury severity in stable thoracolumbar fractures. In the spectrum of injuries studies, the AO classification and the degree of kyphosis provided no prediction of outcome.


P Brady D FitzPatrick J Fitzpatrick D McCormack

The aim of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of the application of vibration, during the femoral cementation, as a cementing technique.

It has been demonstrated that when vibration of a constant frequency was utilised, flow of low viscosity cement increased with vibration of increasing amplitude up to a particular acceleration. Above this acceleration there was little additional benefit. It has also been shown that when constant amplitude was used the flow increase was uniform over a wide frequency range, eventually falling off over a particular frequency. These results prove that the flow of orthopaedic bone cement is significantly affected by mechanical vibration of the receiving structure. It is our hypothesis that vibration promotes the ingress of bone cement into cancellous bone.

The effect of mechanical vibration in the frequency range 0–500 Hz on the cadaveric human femur has been assessed in the past. It was found that when the bone was fixed at both ends, its resonant frequency was markedly affected by end loading and damping. If the conditions of the experiment were designed to simulate the condition of the femur when prepared for a total hip replacement, it was found that the bone did not resonate but behaved in a mass-like mode. The significance of this observation is that in the event of vibration being applied to enhance the penetration of orthopaedic bone cement, the movement induced in the bone will be proportional to the force applied regardless of frequency.


N Hogan BJ Dower E Sheehan P Cartan E Walker T O’Sullivan

Heterotopic ossification (HO) is a common complication following total hip replacement with a number of papers reporting an incidence of greater than 40%. In an effort to reduce the degree of contamination of the abductor muscle bed with osteoprogenitor cells, we used a plastic protective shield during the preparation and reaming of the femoral head in the hope that this would result in a decreased incidence of HO.

One hundred and forty consecutive metal-on-metal resurfacing procedures (mean age 52.3 years) utilizing the Birmingham hip prosthesis were performed between March 1999 and May 2002. Pre-operative diagnosis included osteoarthritis (105), Dysplasia (19), AVN (8), Inflammatory arthropathy (8). In the first 70 cases wet swabs packed around the femoral head were used in an attempt to reduce bone contamination. For all subsequent cases, bone contamination was controlled by the use of the plastic shield. Patients were reviewed clinically and radiologically at a mean of 36.1 (range 24–62) months post operatively. Pre-operative and follow up radiographs were assessed for presence of HO according to the Brooker classification. Harris hip and UCLA activity scores were recorded pre- and post-operatively on all patients. Three patients were lost to follow up.

Eighteen patients (12.9%) were noted to have HO on follow up radiographs. Sixteen patients in the initial group when no shield was used developed HO (Brooker I [10], II [2] & III [1]). Only two patients developed HO (Brooker I) following introduction of the protective shield. This modification in surgical technique was statistically significant in decreasing incidence of HO. All patients with radiological abnormalities were asymptomatic. We propose that this protective shield should be used during resurfacing hip arthroplasty as prophylaxis against ectopic new bone formation.


AR Memon M. Nellign E. Walker T O Sullivan

Introduction: There is a general conception in the orthopaedic community that blood loss/transfusion rate in hip resurfacing procedures is greater than that conventional Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA). The theoretical basis is that uncemented procedures leave large bleeding bone surfaces and that resurfacing arthroplasty needs larger incisions, greater exposure and more extensive soft tissue releases. Although this theory has gained informal

Acceptance in orthopaedic practice, there is little evidence in the literature to support this.

Background The purpose of this study was to determine the actual blood loss and transfusion rate (including hidden blood loss) in a consecutive cohort of patients undergoing hip re-surfacing by a single surgeon using the Articular Surface Replacement (ASR – DePuy).

Materials and Methods: The cohort consisted of 58 patients who were followed prospectively. All patients underwent a standardized surgical procedure performed by one senior surgeon. Hypotensive anaesthesia was used in all cases and surgery was via a standard posterior approach. Drains were not routinely placed, but if used, were removed within 24 hours. Low Molecular Weight Heparin was given 24 hours post procedure until discharge. Surgical blood loss was calculated in a standard fashion (suction volume plus swab weight). Drain volume (if used) was added after removal at 24 hours. Unseen loss of blood in soft tissues, joint space, as well as loss due to haemolysis, is calculated by the modified formula of Kallos1:

\batchmode \documentclass[fleqn,10pt,legalpaper]{article} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amsmath} \pagestyle{empty} \begin{document} \[MABL=\ EBV\ x\ (\underline{Hct\ pt\ -\ Hct\ min})\] \end{document}

Hct pt, Where is

MABL = Maximum allowable blood loss

EBV =Estimated blood volume, 70 ml/kg

Hct pt= Pre operative haematocrit of patient

Hct min=Minimum allowable haematocrit

This was modified to

\batchmode \documentclass[fleqn,10pt,legalpaper]{article} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amsmath} \pagestyle{empty} \begin{document} \(ABL=\ EBV\ {\times}\ \frac{(Hct\ pre\ op\ {-}\ Hct\ post\ opD2)}{Hct\ pre\ op}\) \end{document} where is

ABL= Actual blood loss, Unseen loss = ABL – Visible loss (Loss in OT + Drain)

Results: 58 Patients undergoing ASR, the aeitology was Osteoarthritis in 50 Patients, Dysplasia in 3, Inflammatory Arthritis in 1 and in 1 patient the aetiology was arthrosis secondary to trauma. The average blood loss during the procedure was 221 mls. After 24 hours this had risen to 377 ml, Mean Unseen blood loss was 787.6 ml, Mean Total actual blood loss was 1385.6 ml. There was a mean drop in haemoglobin of 3.6 g/dl and mean drop of Hematocrit was 10.33%. Only 3 patients required blood transfusion.

Conclusion: The mean blood loss in this study was 598 ml and actual blood loss was 1385.60. This is considerably lower than expected for resurfacing arthroplasty and results in a low transfusion rate of only 5% patients undergoing the procedure. Meticulous haemostasis combined with hypotensive anaesthesia reduced the perioperative blood loss and transfusion rate


M Dodds P O’Connor D Fitzpatrick D McCormack

Purpose: The use of a bioabsorbable suture anchor across a joint as a means of internal stabilization has not previously been described. This study assesses the iatrogenic damage caused by such a procedure in the normal immature porcine hip.

Materials and Methods: Six twelve week old pigs underwent unilateral transarticular suture anchorage of the hip using a Panalok® RC Quick Anchor® Plus with Panacryl® suture. (Mitek® Products Johnson and Johnson). Anteroposterior pelvic radiographs were taken pre-operatively and six weeks post-operatively. Acetabular index, diameter of the femoral head ossific nucleus of both hips on both occasions were measured and compared. Pigs were sacrificed six weeks post-operatively. Specimens were analysed macroscopically for femoral head diameter, acetabular dimensions, and presence of gross chondrolysis. Histological analysis was performed to assess the presence of articular chondrolysis, and proximal femoral physeal arrest.

Results: In four out of six hips the rate of change of the acetabular index slowed as compared to the unoperated side though none worsened. The diameter of the femoral ossific nucleus on the operated side continued to increase in size at a similar rate as the unoperated side, despite the surgical procedure according to radiographic comparison. Similar findings were made in the macroscopic analysis of the hip geometry. Gross and histological analysis of the articular cartilage show only local areas of chondrolysis related to the drill holes, and in one hip where a second hole was drilled, cartilage regeneration was noted. Metaphyseal growth at the proximal femoral physis was unaffected by the procedure.

Conclusions: The use of a trans-articular suture anchor across the hip appears to cause marginal retardation of acetabular development in the normal hip. The procedure does not appear to affect proximal femoral physeal or epiphyseal growth and the presence of a bioabsorbable suture within the joint did not result in chondrolysis.


A. Glynn S. O’Donnell1 J. O’Gara D. Molony E. Sheehan D. McCormack

Introduction: Staphylococcal bacteria, especially the coagulase negative Staphylococci, are responsible for the majority of orthopaedic device related infection. These infections are sub acute, and may not present for months or years following surgery. The virulence of these bacteria is related to their ability to form biofilm, a protective slime which allows them to survive the effects of the host immune system and antimicrobial therapy. Treatment of biofilm based infection almost always necessitates removal of the implant.

Recent work has identified environmental stimuli which induce biofilm formation in Staphylococci. These include stressors such as high temperature, high osmolarity, anaerobiosis, nutrient depletion, salt, ethanol and subinhibitory concentrations of certain antimicrobial drugs. Given the ability of these bacteria to survive the “respiratory burst” from the cells of the mononuclear-macrophage system, we hypothesised that oxidative stress may be one such promoter of biofilm formation by Staphylococci.

Methods and Materials: Staphylococcus epidermidis CSF41498 and Staphylococcus aureus RN422O were selected for study as these are known biofilm forming organisms. Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) was used as an oxidizing agent.

Bacteria were incubated for 24 hours at 37°C in Brain-Heart Infusion (BHI, Oxoid) containing progressively weaker concentrations of H2O2 to determine a Minimal Inhibitory Concentration (M.I.C.) for the representative strains. Bacterial viability was assessed by measuring the optical density of the incubated culture using a cell density meter (Ultraspec 10, Amersham Biosciences).

The bacteria were then grown as a biofilm on a 96 well microtitre plate (Nunc) in the presence of subinhibitory concentrations of H2O2, using pure BHI as a control. Semiquantative determination of biofilm formation was performed by washing the plates, staining the adherent cells with crystal violet, and measuring the light absorbance of the adherent stained cells at 492 nm using a Multiskan plate reader (Flow Laboratories).

Results: The M.I.C. of H2O2 was 18 mM for both Staphylococcus epidermidis CSF41498 and Staphylococcus aureus RN422O. Concentrations of H2O2 of 16 mM and below had no normal bacterial growth and replication.

There was no difference in biofilm formation by Staphylococcus epidermidis csf41498 in the presence of 15 mM H2O2 when compared to that of the control. However, H2O2 had a significant inhibitory effect on biofilm formation by Staphylococcus aureus RN422O, even at a concentration well below the M.I.C.

Conclusion: We conclude that oxidative stress may have an antibiofilm action on certain Staphylococcal species, which is independent from its bactericidal effect, and which is manifest at a concentration below the M.I.C. for that species.


M Donnell M Nelligan C Condron P Murray D Bouchier-Hayes

Phenytoin has previously been shown to accelerate wound healing through upregulation of angiogenesis and promotion of collagen deposition. These reported effects led us to hypothesise that phenytoin could be used locally at the tendon repair site to increase the rate and strength of healing. Systemic treatment with phenytoin has also been shown to increase the thickness and density of calvarial and maxillary bones in humans, and promote fracture healing in rabbits, rats and mice. Based on these and similar studies we hypothesised that local percutaneous injection of phenytoin solution into a fracture site would result in improved fracture healing without the risk of the side effects of systemic administration of the drug.

Methods: For the tendon repair study, a previously validated rabbit tendo-achilles tenotomy model was chosen. Animals underwent a transverse tenotomy of the FDL and TA tendons. These were immediately repaired using 3/0 ethibond sutures using the modified Kessler technique, prior to local application of either a phenytoin or buffer gel formulation. At 21 days post-op, the animals were euthanased and the TA harvested for tensiometry testing and collagen content estimation, and the FDL was harvested for histological analysis.

For the fracture study, a rat femur fracture model was utilised. Adult male Sprague-Dawley rats were anaesthetised. Following a medial parapatellar approach, the femur was cannulated using an 18 gauge cannula. The cannula was cut flush with the distal femur and countersunk. The skin and retinaculum were closed with 5.0 monocryl. The nailed femur was then fractured using a 3 point bending technique. The femurs were xrayed to ensure each fracture was mid-diaphyseal and transverse. At 6 hours post op animals underwent either 1) Fracture site percutaneous injection with 100 μmol phenytoin solution 2) Fracture site percutaneous injection with phosphate buffer solution (PBS) 3) No percutaneous injection. This procedure was once again repeated at 72 hours. At 2 and 4 weeks post op 6 animals from each group were euthanased, their femurs were harvested for biomechanical analysis of stiffness and strength.

Results: There was no difference in tendon diameter, gross adhesion formation, ultimate tensile strength or collagen content between the groups. Histologically, however, there were a significantly greater number of inflammatory cells (p< 0.05) and blood vessels (p< 0.05) in the phenytoin treated tendons compared to controls.

At both 2 and 4 weeks there was no statistical difference in stiffness or strength of the phenytoin treated fractures compared to controls.

Conclusions: The study phenytoin formulations whilst apparently promoting neovascularisation in the healing tendon, did not augment healing strength in either tissue suggesting that at these doses and dosing schedules the role of phenytoin is limited in these tissues.


S Boran P Duffy D Fitzpatrick D McCormack

Slipped upper femoral epiphysis (SUFE) is a condition, which affects the immature hip joint. Many theories have been postulated as to its underlying aetiology however; its exact cause is, as yet unknown. The final common pathway appears to be failure of the of the growth plate to resist shearing forces, giving rise to displacement of the femoral head. We hypothesized that the lubricating ability of the synovial fluid in hip joints of children with SUFE was defective, thereby allowing increasing shear forces on the physis to occur, so that when the joint is loaded it will fail at its weakest point, namely the capital epiphysis.

Aim: The aim of this study was to establish a biomechanical porcine cadaveric model to study SUFE and use this model to determine how defective joint lubrication may increase the probability of SUFE.

Methods: Using immature porcine femurs and a custom-made rig, a torsional load was applied about an axis perpendicular to the growth plate in order to cause the femur to fail along the growth plate. The Hounsefield testing machine applied a tensile load and recorded the associated elongation. From these figures the torque applied to the femoral head and the associated angular rotation could be computed. Using Weibel analysis we were able to determine the probability of SUFE occurring for a range of synovial fluid coefficients of friction, a range of joint reaction forces and neck-shaft angles.

Results: We found that it is possible to induce a SUFE in an immature porcine loaded hip joint and that there was an increased probability of slip with increased coefficient of friction of synovial fluid, increased percentage body weight and increased neck-shaft angle.

Conclusion: Defective lubrication may be a key underlying aetiological factor responsible for SUFE.


S. Saravanan P. Moroney P.A. O’Connor O. Barry

The incidence of DDH Varies depending on genetic and ethnic varieties but in Ireland on an average in 3 per 1,000 live births. Current treatment is focused on early diagnosis and congruent reduction of the hip joint. With conservative measures, principally skilful use of the Pavlik harness, the majority of (85%) of dislocated or subluxated hips will be successfully treated. Late diagnosis impacts on the mode of treatment and on the subsequent outcome.

An audit of annual incidence of DDH in North Eastern health board, in Ireland showed a dramatic increase in late diagnosis (> 4 month). There were 4668 live births in 2004 with 17 cases of DDH presenting between the ages of 4 – 36 months during this period. The mean age of presentation was 10 months. Two cases were bilateral. The male: female ratio was 4.6:1. Risk factor analysis showed, only 50% fell in to the high risk group, majority of them had positive family history. Three fourth of them were frank dislocations and all of them required operative intervention. As opposed to early presenters, only 10% needed operative intervention. 30% of the late presenters needed major osteotomies.

We examined the reasons for this extreme high rate of late presenters and argue for the introduction of routine ultrasound screening in this region based on historical high incidence of DDH and the dramatic incidence of delayed diagnosis.


E Conroy P Connolly D McCormack

First described in 1910, Legg Calve Perthes disease is considered to be a complication of osteonecrosis of the femoral head-affecting children between the ages of 2 and 12. Treatment has centred on containment, surgical and non-surgical in the hope that keeping the femoral head covered by acetabulum that it will remodel and maintain congruency with the acetabulum. We know from previous studies that deformities of the femoral head increase the risk of development of arthritis in later life and that the shape of the femoral head is the only alterable parameter in the development of this early onset arthritis.

During the natural history of the disease, once the central part of the femoral head collapses the integrity of the femoral head is reliant on the support of the lateral and medial columns. These columns then collapse altering the shape of the femoral head. We induced LCPD in the femoral heads of twenty skeletally immature rabbits and buttressed the central column of the femoral head in twelve. These treated rabbits had cement, bone graft or bone paste inserted through a drill hole that extended into the centre of the femoral head. The rabbits were then recovered and x-rayed at six weeks. All the rabbits had evidence of varying degrees of head collapse radiologically. Once the rabbits reach skeletal maturity in March, they will be euthanised and their femoral heads examined histologically and radiologically to determine the effects of central column enhancement by each of the three substances.


MOBILITY IN HURLER SYNDROME Pages 284 - 284
Full Access
CC Taylor P Brady M Walsh A O’Meara DP Moore FE Dowling EE Fogarty

Introduction: Therapeutic bone marrow transplantation has increased survival in Hurler syndrome, but the effects on musculoskeletal development remain unclear. Long term reports on mobility are poor, with many patients gradually losing walking ability in later childhood secondary to hip subluxation and joint contractures. As previous cohorts are small, data is limited.

Methods: We detail the follow up of twenty patients over a mean of 94 months (range 1 – 17.4 years). Radiographs were assessed for hip dysplasia using acetabular angle of Sharp, centre edge angle of Wiberg and tibiofemoral shaft angle. Clinical examination was performed at an annual multidisciplinary assessment by one clinician and compared against age matched controls. 3D gait analysis was performed on eight older children, and deviance in kinematic variables was plotted against controls with Mann-Whitney U test for statistical analysis.

Results: All patients demonstrated characteristic ace-tabular dysplasia. Fourteen patients have undergone containment surgery at a mean of 4.4 years. Innominate osteotomy is an essential part of this. Mean preoperative acetabular angle was reduced from 34 ± 4° to 22 ± 3°. Femoral head containment is maintained, with mean centre edge angle in older patients 39 ± 7°. Genu valgum is observed early, and five patients underwent medial epiphyseal stapling at a mean of 7.8 years, decreasing tibiofemoral angle by a mean of 8.0°. All patients are currently independently mobile, with restriction of internal hip rotation being the only significant clinical finding (P< 0.001). Joint contractures were not noted. Walking speed and stride length were comparable to controls, but endurance is reduced by about one quarter. Gait analysis demonstrates a characteristic pattern, with anterior pelvic tilt secondary to thoracolumbar gibbus, relative hip flexion throughout the gait cycle, valgus knees and compensatory pronated feet; all measured deviations were significant (P< 0.001).

Conclusions This large group maintained successful hip containment and good mobility throughout childhood. Innominate osteotomy alone has been used recently. Despite plain film appearance, genu valgum is a functional problem in gait, and we would anticipate greater use of corrective stapling in the future. This is the first report of gait analysis in Hurler syndrome, and features specific to the condition are described.


L Wilson D Gibson AP Cosgrove

Aims and Objectives Lateral condyle fractures can be difficult diagnose and the treatment still remains controversial. It is well known that these fractures are prone to a number of complications, both early and late. The aim of this paper was to review the treatment practice of lateral condyle fractures presenting to a children’s hospital fracture unit over the past 5 years to identify any consistency in the management of these fractures. We also aimed to try and determine if a particular treatment method was more favourable than others in terms of complications and the need for further surgery with a view to developing a treatment protocol.

Methods: We conducted a chart and x-ray review of all lateral condyle fractures treated operatively from December 1998 to August 2004. We recorded patients’ age, sex, side of injury and month of injury. The fractures were classified according to the Milch classification. We also measured the preoperative and postoperative fracture displacement. We recorded the nature of surgery (Examination Under Anaesthetic (EUA) and casting, Manipulation Under Anaesthetic (MUA) and wiring and Open Reduction and wiring). We documented whether the wires were percutaneous or buried. Length of time in cast and length of time to wire removal were also noted. Finally any complications and the need for further surgery were documented.

Results: 90 patients were identified. 72% were male and 28% female, with an average age of 5.6. 28% of injuries were right sided, 72% were left sided. 21 (23%) patients were Milch Type 1 fractures and 66 (73%) were Type II fractures. Preoperative fracture classification was unavailable for 3 patients. In 78 patients we were able to determine the initial fracture displacement. 8 (9%) patients were displaced < 2 mm, 18 (20%) were displaced 2–4 mm and 52 (58%) were displaced > 4 mm. 7 patients (10%) had associated elbow dislocations – all of these were Milch type II fractures. 5 patients had EUA and casting, 19 had MUA and K wiring and 63 had open reduction and wiring. In the 19 patients who had MUA and K wiring, 13 were percutaneous and 6 were buried. In the open reduction and wiring group 59 patients had their wires buried and 6 were percutaneous. 1 patient did not have that information recorded.

The average time in cast was 41 days. In those with buried wires average length of time to wire removal was 63 days. Average percutaneous wire removal was at 42 days. For the 5 patients undergoing EUA and casting residual displacement was < 2 mm in all. 2 of these patients (40%) had complications of lateral spur formation and delayed union. For the 19 having MUA and k wiring, 14 had a post op displacement of< 2 mm and 5 had 2–4 mm displacement. 3 of the 14(21%) had the complications of spur formation, pin site infection and wire prominence. 2/5 (40%) of those with residual displacement of 2–4 mm developed complications, 1 patient had ulceration of wires through the skin and another had loss of position requiring further surgery.

In the patients treated with open reduction and wiring 51 had a residual displacement of < 2 mm, 14 had 2–4 mm residual displacement and 1 remained displaced > 4 mm. 11/51 (22%) in the first category developed complications. 6 were problems with the wires, 1 lost position requiring re-operation, 1 lateral spur development. 2 malunions and 1 delay in ossification of the lateral condyle. In the 2–4 mm group 8/14 (57%) developed complications. – 2 wire ulcerations, 2 wound infections, 1 non-union and 3 malunions. Finally the 1 patient with residual displacement > 4 mm developed a malunion requiring further operative intervention.

In total 5 patients had further surgery - 1 patient for wire prominence 2 for loss of position and 2 patients required corrective surgery for malunion.

Conclusion: This study highlights the variety in treatment methods for these fractures. Complications occurred in all treatment groups. The short term complications such as wire problems and initial loss of position had no long term sequelae. All malunions occurred in the open reduction and wiring group, despite 2 patients having post operative fracture displacement of < 2 mm. The patient with a non union was a late referral but underwent open reduction and wiring at our unit and subsequently healed. We recommend that displaced fractures should be reduced either closed or open and all fractures should be secured with k wires to prevent loss of position. These should be bent and buried allowing them to remain insitu for 3 months. Postoperative casting should be for 6 weeks. These fractures need to be followed closely at fracture clinic for the short and long term problems they can develop.


MJ Shelly M Timlin JS Butler M Walsh AR Poynton JM O’Byrne

Aims: Rugby is a popular sport in Ireland, with over 90,000 players registered with the Irish Rugby Football Union (IRFU) at all levels. We report a 10 year series of spinal injuries presenting to the National Spinal Injuries Unit (NSIU) at the Mater Misericordiae University Hospital.

Methods: A large series of spinal injuries in rugby players was isolated utilizing the NSIU database, HIPE and data from the IRFU. An extensive chart review and telephone interview was performed in all cases to determine age, mechanism of injury, possible aetiological factors, anatomic location of injury, American Spinal Injuries Association (ASIA) scores, current level of activity and response to rehabilitation.

Results: From 1994 to 2004, 22 rugby players with spinal injuries necessitated admission to the NSIU. Twelve patients (54%) presented with neurology. The average age at time of injury was 21.1 years (range 14 – 44 years) and all patients were male. The average length of hospital stay was 10.1 days (range 1 – 45 days). Twenty patients had cervical spine injuries. The most common mechanism of injury was hyperflexion of the cervical spine, with C5/C6 most commonly injured. Fifteen injuries occurred at adult level, the remainder at schoolboy level. Seventeen (77%) players were injured whilst playing First Team rugby. Eleven (50%) players were injured in the Backs, the remainder in the Forwards. 68% of injuries occurred in the tackle situation and 32% in the scrums, rucks and mauls. Winger, Full Back and Hooker were the playing positions at greatest risk.

Nine (41%) patients underwent surgery and 11 (50%) required rehabilitation in the National Rehabilitation Centre, Dun Laoghaire, with an average length of inpatient stay of 9.22 months (range 5 – 14 months). Eight (36%) patients felt that their injury was preventable. Of those patients without neurology, 60% have returned to playing rugby.

Conclusion: Rugby as a sporting pastime is not without risk. During the ten year period under review, 8 players suffered permanent disability as a direct result of participation in competitive rugby. Serious spinal injuries continue to occur and recent rule changes have had little effect in reducing their incidence.


J. Walsh JF. Quinlan K. Butt M. Towers A. Devitt

Introduction: The position of the L4/5 disc inter-space is commonly believed to be represented by a line drawn between the two highest points of the iliac crests. This line is used frequently as a pre-operative guide for incision placement, in patients undergoing spinal surgery.

Aim: To investigate whether a line drawn between the two highest points on the iliac crests corresponds to the L4/5 disc inter-space, in varying patient age groups.

Patients and Methods: We reviewed 450 AP and lateral lumbar spine radiographs in patients ranging in age from 20 – 90 years. Patients with an obvious deformity or previous spinal surgery were excluded from the study. In the AP films, a line was drawn between the two highest points on the iliac crests. From this line, the distance to the midpoint of the L4/5 disc was measured. This was achieved in the lateral films, by finding the midpoint between the two iliac crests and again measuring the distance from this point to the midpoint of the L4-5 disc.

Results: In all age groups measured, the true L4-5 disc inter-space lay below the line between the iliac crests. In the patient group a 20–30 yrs, the inter-iliac crest line lay on average 1.86 mm above the true l4–5 disc space. In the patients aged 30–40 yrs the line was on average 2.49 mm above the disc space. Patients aged 40–50 yrs the line was 6.05 mm above the disc space. In patients aged 50–60 yrs and 60–70 yrs, the line was 3.17 mm above the disc space. In the 70–80 yrs age group, the line was 4.5 mm above the true disc space. In the oldest group of patients studied (80–90 yrs), the line was positioned 9.06 mm above the true disc space. The results were analysed using the ANOVA system to assess their statistical significance. Comparison of the patients aged 20–30 yrs versus patients aged 80–90 yrs yielded a p value of p=0.0045. Patients aged 60–70 yrs versus patients aged 80–90 yrs, p=0.0049. Patients aged 50–60 yrs versus patients aged 80–90 yrs, p=0.0023. Patients aged 30–40 yrs versus patients aged 80–90 yrs, p=0.0004. Patients aged 70–80 yrs versus patients aged 80–90 yrs, p=0.03. Comparison of other patient groups, were of low statistical significance

Conclusions These results show that, while the L4/5 disc inter-space does broadly correspond to a line drawn between the iliac crests, there is a significant variation between different age groups and within individual age groupings. Therefore, it is advisable to perform a pre-operative AP and lateral radiograph of the lumbar spine, to enable accurate incision placement when performing spinal surgery in this area.


JF Quinlan M Ryan S Eustace

Bertolotti’s syndrome, first described in 1917, is characterised by the presence of an anomaly of unilateral or bilateral enlargement of the transverse process of the most caudal vertebra that may articulate or fuse with the sacrum or ilium. This gives rise to low back pain. Although described, relevant literature is sparse and in particular, no evidence exists as to its incidence specifically in young people.

This study analysed all MRI scans of the lumbosacral spine performed on patients between July 2003 and November 2004 inclusive. MRI scans for all indications were included in the study.

Out of a total of 818 MRI scans of the lumbosacral spine, 627 showed disc disease. Of these, 35 had radiological signs of Bertolotti’s syndrome (7 bilateral, 28 unilateral). There were 22 males and 17 females in this group. The average age of the Bertolotti group was 31.8+/−12.0 years (range: 15–60). This was less than those with multiple disc disease whose average age was 44.0+/−15.6 years (p< 0.0002, ANOVA), those with isolated disc disease (41.1+/−16.0 years, p=0.013, ANOVA) and those with isolated disc disease at the L4/5 level (46.0+/−11.3 years, p=0.003, ANOVA). The overall incidence of Bertolotti’s syndrome in this study was 5.6%. However, 18 of the patients in the Bertolotti group were under 30 years of age giving an overall incidence in this age group of 8.9%.

Bertolotti’s syndrome is a frequently occurring pathology in the lumbosacral spine. It occurs in significantly younger patients than either multi-level disc disease or isolated disc disease including at the L4/5 level. In the under 30 group its incidence of 8.9% mandates that it must form part of a differential list in the investigation of low back pain in young people.


CC Taylor P Curtin E Sheehan DP Moore FE Dowling EE Fogarty

Introduction: There is little epidemiological data on childhood injury in Ireland, despite large numbers of referrals to fracture clinics particularly in the summer months. Information is difficult to obtain retrospectively, and our aim was to quantify paediatric injury referrals to our clinics and analyse trends in injury patterns.

Methods: A prospective injury surveillance system was initiated in our department. Parents were asked to record demographic information and a brief description of the injury at fracture clinics or admission to the ward. Diagnosis and treatment was completed by the attending doctor. Details were transferred to a customised database for analysis.

Results: Overall compliance was excellent. Of 397 recorded referrals, 66% had confirmed fractures, and 20% of these were admitted for operative management. There was an equal sex distribution, and mean age at presentation was 9.1 years. The peak hour of injury was 7 – 8 pm, with fairly even distribution throughout the week. 62% of injuries were due to falls. 39% of injuries occured in or about the home, including 61% of all falls greater than 1 metre, most often from walls and slides. Other common locations for injury were school (16%) and sportsfields (14%). Gaelic football and soccer were the predominant sports causing injury. Fractures occuring during unsupervised sport were more likely to need surgery. Road traffic accidents were an uncommon cause of injury. Home ‘bouncy castles’ and trampolines were a notable cause of injury, causing 6% of all fractures, particularly of the upper limb. Predictably, 41% of all fractures involved the radius. Fractures of the distal humerus, diaphyses of radius, ulna and tibia were most likely to need operative management.

Discussion Analysis yielded a timely insight into the local epidemiology of childhood injuries. In comparison with other studies, sports related injuries were frequent and road accidents were unusually few in our group. Many injuries occurring late in the evening needed early reduction, with almost two thirds of surgical procedures performed out of hours with significant implications on theatre and radiology staffing. A large proportion of higher energy trauma occured in or about the home, representing a potential area for injury prevention stratgies.


M Murphy R Gul C Fitzpatrick G Byrne D Fitzpatrick D McCormack

Many pedicle screw instrumentation systems are currently available to the spine surgeon. Each system has its unique characteristics. It is important for the surgeon to understand the differences in these pedicle screw systems1

Following the introduction of a new spinal instrumentation set to our clinical practice we encountered two cases of pedicle screw breakage. We thus decided to investigate the mechanism of this screw failure (screw A) in these particular cases and to compare the biomechanical properties, through independent analysis, of a variety of pedicle screws from different manufacturers.

Samples of the broken pedicle screws were retrieved at surgery. Surface analysis of the fracture area using the electron microscope, demonstrated features consistent with fatigue fracture.

Pedicle screws of comparable size from a variety of manufacturers were gathered for independent analysis. Shadowgraph analysis was performed of each screw allowing multiple measurements to be taken of the screw’s geometry. Using this data stress concentration factors were determined demonstrating screw A to have larger values than all the other screws ranging from 2 – 3.6 times the nominal stress. The smaller teeth of screw A, spaced further apart than in the other screws, means that the large proportion of the load which would be carried by the threads is distributed over a smaller area resulting in higher stresses in the threads. The sharp corner at the root of the thread, acting as a stress concentrator, would become the focal point of these high stresses, and magnify them by 2 to 3.6 times.

These increased stresses most likely account for an increased susceptibility to fatigue fracture seen in screw A.

In conclusion it is important to be careful with the introduction and use of new pedicle screw materials and designs, that all the standard biomechanical testing has been performed to a satisfactory standard.

Knowing the physical characteristics of the available pedicle screw instrumentation systems may allow the choice of pedicle screw best suited for a given clinical situation.


N Hogan T O’Donnell M Solan M Stephens

This study reviewed the subjective, clinical, and radiological outcome of 24 patients (31 feet) treated by basal metatarsal osteotomy with a modified McBride procedure for severe (intermetatarsal angle > 150) hallux valgus, carried out at our institution with an average follow-up time of 29 months.

At the time of follow-up, 40% of the patients were very satisfied, 45% were satisfied, and 15% were not satisfied. The mean Hallux – Metatarsophalangeal – Interphalangeal scale score raised significantly from 39 points (17 – 64) pre-operatively, to 82 (39 – 96) points at follow-up (p < 0.001). The Lesser - Metatarsophalangeal – Interphalangeal scale score raised significantly from 46 points (26 – 69) pre-operatively, to 84 (33 – 97) points at follow-up (p < 0.001). The radiological angles, including M1-M2, M1-P1, M1-M5, and DMAA improved significantly (p < 0.001). 12 of these cases had a M1-M2 angle post correction > 15°. Among the 9 complications recorded, 7 were minor and 2 required an additional procedure.

The basal metatarsal osteotomy coupled with a modified McBride procedure resulted in an overall high satisfaction rate, as well as significant clinical and radiological improvements in our series. Nevertheless, the range of motion of the first MTP joint remained low: 30 – 75° in 67% and < 30° in 6%. Furthermore, the failure to correct the M1-M2 angle to < 15° in 12 cases was probably due to the severe nature of the M1-M2 angle in these patients pre-operatively (21–33°).

Basal metatarsal osteotomy with a modified McBride procedure remains a safe procedure with excellent results, both subjectively and objectively, in patients with severe hallux valgus


AJ Butt D Borton

Recurrent dislocation of peroneal tendons is an uncommon presentation following ankle injuries. It usually follows an inversion injury to the ankle, most commonly seen in skiing, however it has also been described in many other sporting activities. X rays appear normal, and patients usually get treated as ankle sprain. The diagnosis, usually delayed is a clinical one, patients usually describe ankle instability and sudden painful snapping or popping of the subluxating peroneal tendons. This makes it difficult for them to participate in any sporting activities and is a source of continous discomfort while walking. Examination may show tender peroneal tendons and demonstration of subluxing tendons is facilitated by eversion against resistance or manually by thumb pressure. The common pathology is tear of the peroneal retinaculum and striping of periosteum from the anterior attachment to the lateral maleolus.

We describe 11 cases of recurrent dislocation of peroneal tendons from February 1999 to October 2004. They all suffered trauma related dislocation of peroneal tendons, causing recurrent peroneal tendon dislocation. All procedures were performed by a single consultant. Procedure involves soft tissue anatomic reconstruction of the peroneal retinaculum. There were 9 males and 2 females, mean age was 30.1 years (range 15 to 58 years). All patients were treated initially with rest followed by period of physiotherapy to no benefit. All complained of ankle instability with pain associated with tendon dislocation even while walking. The mean duration from time of injury to surgery was 10 months (range 2 to 45 months). We performed clinical assessment, ankle scoring, SF 36 version2 scoring and assessed patient satisfaction with the procedure.

At the latest follow up of 6 months to 6 years all patients were extremely satisfied with the procedure. There was no recurrence of dislocation. All patients were back to their normal daily activities and sports within 6 months of surgery. One patient complained of occasional mild pain over the tendon. One patient reported mild paraesthesiae in distribution of sural nerve, which recovered over 3 months. On clinical assessment the tendon was stable in all patients with full ROM and strength in the affected ankle when compared to normal side. The mean ankle score increased from 62 pre-op (range 22 to 89) to 96 post-operative (range 90 to 100). Mean SF 36 scores increased from PCS of 41 and MCS of 53 pre-op to a PCS of 57 and MCS of 60 post-op.

In the past procedures have been described for treatment of recurrent dislocation of peroneal tendons. We report the results of a procedure previously described and published by the senior author ( ‘The Foot’: 2003 ). This is an anatomic procedure for repair of torn peroneal retinaculum and double breasting of redundant periosteum. Our latest follow up of 6 months to 6 years shows excellent results with no recurrence and no limitation of ankle movement or sporting activities.


F Khan J Harty C Healy R Stack P Hession L D’Souza

Purpose of study: Study and prove the benefits and efficacy of the use of extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT)for the treatment of planter fasciitis.

Introduction: Planter fasciitis is the second most common cause of heel pain. Conservative treatment modalities for the treatment of planter fasciitis includes NSAIDS, heel cushions, ultrasound, physiotherapy, injections, etc and these often do not offer satisfactory results. We present the results of the use of ESWT in the treatment of planter fasciitis with good results.

Methodology: 129 patients, 77 males and 52 females with a 152 heels were treated with ESWT from July 2002 until August 2004 and were included in the study. The average age was 53.2 years (Range 28 to 83 years). All patients had previously undergone other conservative forms of treatment with poor results. Inclusion criteria included age greater than 18 years, male or female, no previous history of surgery on the heel or foot, visual analogue score of over 5 for pain. Treatment was done on an outpatients basis. Each patient received between minimum of one and maximum of three sessions of ESWT at two weeks interval.

Results: 116 patients, 69 males and 47 females with 136 heels were reviewed with 13 patients with 16 heels lost to followup. 52 patients (44.8%) with 60 heels (44.1%) had excellent results. 45 patients (38.8%) with 53 heels (38.0%) had good results. 13 patients (11.2%) with 16 heels (11.8%) had fair results. 6 patients (5.2%) with 7 heels (5.1%) had poor results. Overall 104 patients (89.7%) with a 121 heels (89.0%) considered the outcome to be successful.

Conclusion: Based on our results, we recommend ESWT fot the treatment of planter fasciitis especially in patients with failed other forms of conservative treatment and as an alternative to surgery with good results.


JP Dillon AJ Laing M Hussain AC Macey

Introduction: Carpal tunnel decompression is the most commonly performed procedure in hand surgery. This study was done to assess the effectiveness and acceptability by patients of open carpal tunnel release under local anaesthetic and compare our results with previous published work from our department following alterations to our operative techniques.

Methods: 92 carpal tunnel releases were performed on 80 patients over a four year period, 2001 to 2004. 55 were females and 25 were males. A patient satisfaction survey was done by a postal questionnaire which addressed opinion regarding preference for LA over GA, pain due to LA infiltration, effectiveness of LA, patient comfort during surgery, outcome of surgery and overall satisfaction with the procedure. In this cohort of patients we did not use a tourniquet which caused severe pain in 29% of cases in the previous study. We also administered LA with adrenaline using a dental syringe to reduce pain which was previously reported as severe in 20% of cases.

Results: 62 patients replied to the questionnaire, a response rate of 77.5%. Preference for LA over GA was 90% as compared to 70% in the previous study. Pain due to tourniquet use was previously reported as severe in 29% of cases but this did not apply in this subset of patients. Pain due to infiltration of LA with a dental syringe was severe in 9% of cases compared to 20% with a 25G needle. Effectiveness of LA, outcome of surgery and overall satisfaction with the procedure remained unchanged.

Conclusion: Carpal tunnel decompression is a quick, convenient, inexpensive and safe method of treatment. We have demonstrated that injecting LA with adrenaline using a dental syringe obviates the need for tourniquet and improves patients’ acceptability and tolerance of this procedure.


Full Access
NT O’Malley PM Kelly DP Moore

Introduction: Historically, arthrodesis of the knee was accepted as a primary procedure in patients with extensive joint destruction, usually in the elderly arthritic population. Since the significant advances in arthroplasty, knee arthrodesis has mainly become an uncommon salvage procedure for failed and infected arthroplasty. However, when all other surgical options in reconstruction post-trauma have failed, arthrodesis remains an alternative to amputation.

Patients and Methods: Six patients who had unilateral knee arthrodesis with the Ilizarov frame for traumatic destruction of their knee were assessed by physical examination, radiology review and clinical questionnaires.

The Lower Extremity Functional Scale (LEFS) and the AMA Criteria for Impairment Associated with Station and Gait Disorders were used to evaluate their functional levels of impairment. The Short-Form-36 (SF-36) Health Survey was also used as a general survey of their health.

Results: The patient group ranged from 24 – 47 years of age (mean 32.5 years), and are between 1 – 10 years after unilateral knee arthrodesis. All were satisfied with the outcome of their procedure, and half are able to work full time. 80% of those who drive report actually driving while being treated with the Ilizarov frame. Those who score lowest on the SF-36 also had significant other post-trauma injuries (e.g. upper limb amputation). Significantly, while the average level of whole person impairment was 10–19%, patients perceived their ability to walk on the flat as normal, and only have mild difficulty in rising to stand.

Conclusion: Knee arthrodesis is a realistic and acceptable alternative to amputation, and is therefore an option which should be offered to patients in the non-acute setting. It has successfully enabled salvage of otherwise “unsalvageable” limbs in our young patient group.


S Bahari S Morris C Taylor D Broe J Sparkes P Nicholson J Rice J Mc Elwain

Introduction: The increasing popularity of minimal access surgery in orthopaedic surgery has resulted in increasing use of intra-operative fluoroscopy. The radiation dose received by the surgeon varies from procedure to procedure depending on several factors such as duration of procedure, direct exposure to radiation beam and distance from the radiation source. In particular hand and wrist injuries often involve direct fluoroscopic exposure to the hands of the surgeon and assistant during the procedure.

Aim: We undertook a prospective study to directly evaluate the exposure of the surgeon’s and assistant’s hands and thyroid glands during K-wiring procedures of the hand and wrist. In addition we evaluated the efficacy of a lead thyroid shield in limiting the radiation dose to the thyroid gland. In addition we undertook a questionnaire of orthopaedic surgeons and trainees in Ireland to assess the availability of thyroid shields and current practice in wearing them.

Method A total of 30 cases were evaluated. Dosimeter film badges (TLD) were obtained from the Radiological Protection Institute of Ireland (RPI). Two dosimeters were worn by each of the surgical team: one on the dorsum of the dominant hand and a second worn on the neck during the procedure. The number of fluoroscopic exposures, number of times that hands were caught in the image field, the total dosage of radiation for the procedure and the length of time of exposure were recorded. In 20 cases the surgical team undertook standard precautions of a lead jacket. In a random selection of 10 cases the surgical team also wore a thyroid shield.

Results. The mean dose to the surgical teams’ hands was 1.8 cGy (95% CI + 0.6). The mean dose to the thyroid gland was 0.6 cGy in unprotected cases. Notably the dose to the assistants’ hands was higher though this did not reach statistical approval. In cases in which a thyroid shield was worn a significant decrease in dose was noted (p< 0.05). 35% of surgeons had completed a radiation protection course with junior trainees being less likely to have completed such a course.

Conclusion: Significant cumulative radiation dose to the hands and thyroid gland occurs following K-wiring of extremities. The dose to the thyroid gland can be effectively decreased by the use of a thyroid collar. Junior trainees whose operative times and hence radiation exposure are higher, have limited radiation protection training. The mandatory use of thyroid shields and early introduction of radiation protection training may help minimise further radiation exposure.


I Hanif E Masterson S O’Dwyer

We have developed a comprehensive system of assessment of patients undergoing total hip and total knee replacement. This new unified scoring system provides a single instrument to measure the disability of patients suffering from primary osteoarthritis of either hip or knee. This instrument will be used to prioritize these patients for a single waiting list and it will be used as an outcome measure to assess their progress after their hip or knee replacement surgery. The scoring system is comprised of two parts carrying equal point value. The subjective part is an assessment tool completed by the patients themselves. It is comprised of 12 Items covering every aspect of the disability associated with hip and knee arthritis. The objective part is an assessment tool completed by the treating physician or a trained joint arthroplasty nurse.

The first stage of this project comprised of formulation of a preliminary questionnaire after a thorough assessment of 50 patients suffering from hip or knee arthritis. We then organised multiple clinical sessions with focus groups to critically appraise the content of our new questionnaire. The focus group patients were invited to give their comments about any issues not discussed previously. This preliminary questionnaire was then converted into a set of closed questions and was divided into a subjective and an objective part.

The second stage of this project involved assignment of scales and scale grading for different components of the objective part. This involved the process of magnitude estimation. 75 patients, 25 consultants and 5 nurses were involved in this process.

The third stage of this project involved a comprehensive assessment of this new scoring system in terms of internal consistency, internal consistency reliability, inter-observer reliability, test-retest reliability, face validity, content validity and construct validity. The process of validation involved comparison of our scoring system with the relevant parts of SF36, Oxford knee score, WOMAC and AIMS. It has also been tested on the first subset of post operative patients to measure its responsiveness. Cronbach’s alpha was used for internal consistency and Pearson’s correlation coefficients were used for different correlation studies.

Our new scoring system has shown a very satisfactory internal consistency. The inter-rater agreement and the test-retest reliability data on the first set of 100 patients are very promising as well. The instrument has shown a significant effect size in the first set of post-op patients 4 months after their surgery.

Our new scoring system will provide an easy to apply and comprehensive instrument for a need based waiting list for patients undergoing either THR or TKR. It will also be a reliable and sensitive outcome measure to monitor these patients’ progress in the post-operative period.


A R Memon P. A. O’Connor I Kelly

Object: To assess the benefit of prescribed Iron supplementation on the recovery of patient’s Haemoglobin level after elective joint replacement.

Design: A Prospective, Randomised Trial was undertaken. All patients undergoing elective arthroplasty (Hip, Knee, and Revision Hip) at our unit were considered. Qualifying parameters included: a normal store of Iron (Fe) prior to surgery (based on the serum Ferrittin level) and normal markers of inflammation (serum C - reactive protein [CRP] and erythrocyte sedimentation rate [ESR]). Elevated CRP and ESR are known to be factors affecting the serum Ferrittin level.

Method: 318 patients undergo joint replacement from May 2004 to Oct 2004 were considered for the study. 208 patients were excluded for the following reasons: 52 patients had low serum Ferrittin level or elevated ESR and CRP levels pre-operatively. 156 patients was normal post operative Haemoglobin (> 11 mg %). This left 110 patients with normal pre-operative inflammatory markers and Iron stores. This cohort formed the basis of the study and was randomised to either receiving prescribed Iron Supplementation (Oral Ferrous Sulphate) twice a day for 8 week or no supplementation. Randomisation was performed based on the month of surgery. Even numbered months received the intervention, odd numbered did not. Post-operatively all patients had serum Haemoglobin checked at intervals 2nd–7th day and 8 weeks

Results: There was no significant different in mean Haemoglobin level between treatment group i.e. 12.72 mg% (10.8–15.4) and controlled group 12.71 mg% (11–15.3) at 8 weeks follow up.

Conclusion: The prescription of oral Iron in healthy postoperative joint replacement patients did not hasten the recovery of Haemoglobin level provided adequate tissue Iron stores were present. The use of Fe supplementation provides no benefit in these patients and our study confirms this. Iron supplementation therapy should be reserved for patients identified pre-operatively with either low Iron stores or elevated serum inflammatory markers.


AM Byrne SF Morris P Gargan T McCarthy J O’Byrne W Quinlan

Introduction: Despite exhaustive prophylactic measures, intra-operative contamination still occurs following cemented arthroplasty. We undertook a prospective study to identify the incidence of intra-operative deep wound contamination in cemented joint arthroplasty. Furthermore, we assessed the medium term incidence (at 4 years) of wound contamination in this patient cohort.

Materials & Methods: A total of 82 consecutive patients admitted for elective cemented arthroplasty were enrolled in the study over a 6 month period. Standard medical and dental work up was performed prior to admission to assess fitness for surgery. Pre-operative wound site preparation included Hibitane showers and painting and draping of the operative site in both the anaesthetic room and theatre. All cases were undertaken in an ultra-clean laminar airflow theatre and the surgical team wore isolation suits in all cases. Standard swabs from skin incision and deep in the wound were sent in addition to the blades and suction tip used. Cultures were typed by morphology and identified by standard techniques. A control swab was sent from all cases to exclude contamination occurring in the laboratory setting.

Results: A total of 82 patients were included in the study. Mean patient age was 67.4 years (36–85 years). Of the 82 procedures performed, 59 were total hip replacements and 23 total knee replacements. Five procedures were performed for revision arthroplasty (1 knee and 4 hips). 19 of the 82 cases (23%) examined grew contamination organisms with S. epidermidis being the commonest organism (16). In 16 cases a single specimen demonstrated contamination. 2 patients had 2 contaminated specimens and 1 had 3 contaminated specimens. No significant correlation between the duration of the case, number of personnel in theatre, or the seniority of the operating surgeon was demonstrated. On medium term follow up (mean 49.6 months, 95% CI 3.2 months) no patient had developed clinical evidence of infection.

Conclusion: We noted a high incidence of intra-operative contamination of cemented arthroplasties despite standard prophylaxis. However, this was not reflected by a similar rate of post-operative infection. This may be due to a small bacterial innoculum in each case or possibly may be due to the therapeutic effect of peri-operative intra-venous antibiotic prophylaxis.


P Brady R Khan D Hynes

This was a double-blind randomised controlled study. The objective of this study was to determine the cause of post-injection pain after peri-articular steroid injection. Approval for this study was granted by the hospital’s Ethics Committee. Selection criteria included all patients undergoing a peri-articular injection under the care of the senior author. Patients who elected to be in this study gave their consent following a detailed explanation of the study and provision of a patient information leaflet. The enrolled patients were randomised into one of two groups. Group A received a standard triamcinolone acetonide injection mixed with bupivicaine. Group B patients received triamcinolone acetonide without the preservative part of the drug and bupivicaine. Both the patient and the surgeon were unaware which group the patient was selected to be in. Patients’ scores were recorded using visual analogue scales and pain severity scores prior to injection and 4 days following injection. Inflammatory signs were also recorded at 4 days post-procedure. A total of 52 patients were enrolled. Pain scores reduced by 46% in group A and 43% in group B. Inflammatory signs occurred in 26% less cases when group B was compared with group A, however this was not statistically significant.


JJ Cronin FJ Shannon E Bale W Quinlan

Introduction: Urinary retention is a significant complication following hip and knee arthroplasty. Published literature has shown that the insertion of a catheter post-op is associated with an increased incidence of deep joint sepsis, however, pre-operative catheterisation has not.

The International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS) is an internationally validated scoring system used by Urologists to assess the severity of obstructive urinary symptoms and response to treatment.

The purpose of this study was to quantify the incidence of urinary retention following major joint arthroplasty in an elective orthopaedic unit and to investigate whether a patient’s pre-operative IPSS score could be used to predict the likelihood of post-operative urinary retention.

Patients and Methods: Over a 9 month period, 118 patients were enrolled prospectively into this study. 28 patients were admitted for knee replacement(TKR) and 90 patients for hip replacement (THR). All patients were asked to fill out an IPSS questionnaire form on admission. Demographics including age, mode of anaesthetic, intra-operative blood loss and operative time were recorded. Results: In our study group of 118 patients, 43(36.4%) developed urinary retention postoperatively. 29(32.2%) patients following THR developed urinary retention, whereas 14(50%) of the men who had a TKR developed urinary retention post-op. Of the 25 patients with a pre-operative IPSS score > /=10, 14(56%) went into retention. The mean pre-operative IPSS score was 7.74 for those who went into retention, compared to 5.0 for the other patients (p < 0.05). Type of anaesthesia, blood loss and operative time were non-contributory.

Conclusion: This study shows a high rate of post-operative urinary catheterisation in our patient group. Despite the mean IPSS score being higher in patients requiring catheterisation, our results did not show any conclusive evidence that this scoring system could be used to predict the development of post-operatively urinary retention in patients presenting for hip or knee arthroplasty.


A Foster C Green D Montgomery M Laverick

Introduction: An extensive review of the literature has found no evidence supporting the routine use of antibiotic prophylaxis in patients with prosthetic joints undergoing dental treatment. A working party of the British Society for Antimicrobial Chemotherapy have stated that “patients with prosthetic joint implants (including total hip replacement) do not require antibiotic prophylaxis for dental treatment” and that “it is unacceptable to expose patients to the adverse effects of antibiotics when there is no evidence that such prophylaxis is of any benefit”.

Method: A postal questionnaire containing both open and closed questions regarding prescribing habits and protocols with respect to antibiotic prophylaxis in patients with prosthetic joints undergoing dental treatment was sent to all General Dental Practitioners and all Consultant Surgeons in Northern Ireland. Response rates of 72% and 97.5% were obtained from the two groups.

Results: The majority of Dentists (82–96%) routinely prescribe antibiotic cover in patients with structural heart defects but not in those who have had a joint replacement (24%) with Penicillin being the most frequently used antibiotic. 43% of Dentists have however, been asked by an Orthopaedic Surgeon to give cover with 216 of these 242 having given it. Responding Orthopaedic Surgeons indicated that the majority (63%) prefer their patients to have cover during dental extractions. A Cephalosporin is the most commonly suggested antibiotic(25%). Only one of the Surgeons given advice to his patients to ask for antibiotic cover during dental procedures.

Conclusion: We conclude that current practice, particularly amongst Orthopaedic Surgeons with regard to antibiotic prophylaxis in patients undergoing dental extraction following joint replacement does not adhere to national recommendations and that dissemination of the guidelines is essential.


A Glynn E Bale V McMahon P Keogh W Quinlan J O’Byrne P Kenny

Introduction: An arthroplasty database, such as the Swedish Hip Registry, provides a crude means of quality control over the sizable number of prosthetic implants available on the market today. It provides relatively rapid feedback on the performance of orthopaedic devices and surgical techniques, allowing inferior devices and methods to be discontinued. The maintenance of an arthroplasty register is inexpensive and of enormous benefit to the patient. At present, there is no nationwide arthroplasty register in operation in the Republic of Ireland.

Aim: To develop an arthroplasty register which prospectively captures all clinical, radiographic and medical outcome data on patients undergoing surgery in our unit

Materials and methods We are using an existing computer software programme (Bluespier Patient Manager) to capture our information, although our database is stored independently of this.

Data recorded includes medical outcome scores (WOMAC and MOS SF-36), patient data, operative details (including type of prostheses used and operative technique employed), inpatient course, and any postoperative events. For revision procedures, additional data such as location of bony defects (Gruen zones) and acetabular bone loss (Paprosky classification) are also recorded. Follow up in a special Joint Register Clinic is at six months, two years and every five years thereafter for primary procedures. This is reduced to every two years in the case of revision procedures.

To date, a pilot study involving four surgeons has prospectively captured data on 82 patients undergoing both primary and revision procedures in our unit. We aim to enrol all our patients in the register from July 2005, increasing the amount of data collected, which we hope will subsequently benefit patients undergoing hip and knee arthroplasty in the future.


S. Sherif E. Sheehan A. Wahab I.P. Kelly

MRSA wound infection following Total joint arthroplasty is catastrophic with disastrous consequences. Our aim was to determine the prevalence and risk factors for MRSA colonization in patients presenting for orthopaedic surgery in our unit. All patients admitted to the hospital for elective arthroplasty over a four year period were included in the study. At the time of admission, a detailed questionnaire was completed by each patient. Routine nasal, throat, axilla, perineum swabs and from any pre-existing wound sites were sent for culture.

Among 2900 patients studied, 42 patients (1.4%) were positive for MRSA on admission. The prevalence of MRSA colonization in patients who were admitted directly from Nursing homes or from own home was 36.7% and 1.3% respectively. All MRSA positive patients who were admitted directly from home had at least one documented hospital admission in the preceding year and/or antibiotic administration within three months prior to admission. The risk factors identified for MRSA colonization were in risk order : Nursing home residency(p< 0.05), previous hospital admission(p< 0.05), antibiotic administration in previous three months(p< 0.05), and female gender(p< 0.01 )Statistical analysis with Chi squared test for independence p< 0.05 considered significant.

Present MRSA screening focuses on all patients being admitted for surgery, this contrasts to North American policies of screening only patients with risk factors. We would question the validity and economical reasoning of general rather than targeted screening procedures.


AJ Laing JP Dillon JT Street JH Wang HP Redmond A McGuinness

Background: Aseptic loosening remains the most common cause of failure of total hip arthroplasty. Its pathogenesis is based upon the generation of wear debris particles which trigger synovial macrophage activation.

Statins, inhibitors of 3-hydroxy-3 methylglutaryl coenzyme A (HMG-Co-A) reductase, have revolutionised the treatment of hypercholesterolaemia. More recently statins have been shown to have potent anti inflammatory effects. We investigated the effects of cerivastatin in attenuating the activation of human macrophages by polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) particles.

Methods: Polymethylmethacrylate-particle-stimulated human macrophages were cultured in vitro with cerivastatin at 75 and 150... mols/litre. TNF-α (tumour necrosis factor alpha) and MCP-1 (monocyte chemotactic protein) expression were determined using ELISA. An ERK1/2 inhibitor, UO126 was utilised to identify the mitogen activated protein kinase (MAP-Kinase) pathway involved and western blotting was used to demonstrate the effect of Cerivastatin on this pathway.

Results PMMA-stimulated TNF-α and MCP-1 expression was consistently attenuated by cerivastatin therapy.

PMMA activation was attenuated by the ERK1/2 inhibitor, UO126.

Western blotting confirmed ERK downregulation by cerivastatin, establishing a mechanism for its anti-inflammatory effects.

Conclusion: We have demonstrated the beneficial effects of statins in suppressing particle mediated activation of macrophages and the potential to prevent or treat periprosthetic osteolysis.


G Weekes GC O’Toole JF Quinlan JM O’Byrne

Urinary retention following total hip and knee arthroplasty is a common problem frequently requiring catheterisation in the immediate post-operative period. The direct relationship between urinary tract instrumentation and deep sepsis in total hip replacements is well documented.

Method: This prospective study analysed 164 male patients who underwent primary arthroplasty between September 2004 and March 2005 inclusive. Patients who had previous urological intervention for obstructive symptoms were excluded from the study. Upon admission and prior to surgery, all patients answered an 8-point urinary symptom questionnaire and were tested on their ability to micturate while supine.

Result: 34 patients required urinary catheterisation – 130 did not. The average age of the catheterised group was 69.5+/−10.7 years (range 45–90) and the non catheterised group was 65.2+/−10.5 years (range 33–85). There was no difference between these groups (p=0.134, ANOVA). Similarly, there was not difference (p=0.919, ANOVA) between the blood loss in the 2 groups, 880.6+/−455.5 mls and 895+/−533.7 mls respectively. With regards to the symptom questionnaire, the average score in the catheter group was 3.1+/−2.4 and the non-catheter group was 2.0+/−1.8 (p=0.034, ANOVA). The ability to micturate in a supine position was of no predictive value with 22 patients in the catheter group able to do so.

Conclusion: These results show the value of a urinary symptom questionnaire used pre-operatively in predicting those who may require post-operative urinary catheterisation. By appropriate use of this tool, patients with potential for post-operative retention may be identified before surgery. Consequently, this group should be catheterised pre-operatively thus reducing their risk of infection.


A. Glynn T. McCarthy M. McCarroll P. Murray

Introduction: The use of allogeneic blood is associated with many complications. A baseline audit performed in our institution in 2000 showed that 11% of patients undergoing primary total knee arthroplasty required post-operative transfusion. Following this audit, patients undergoing primary knee arthroplasty were no longer routinely cross matched, a Haemovigilance Nurse was employed in compliance with the National Blood Users Group guidelines, and post-operative cell salvage was introduced for patients with a pre-operative haemoglobin level of less than 12 g/dL.

Aim: To assess the impact of these changes on our transfusion practice

Methods and materials A prospective audit was performed over a nine month period, from 1st January to 30th September 2003. Data was collected on 233 patients who had primary total knee arthroplasty performed during this period. Patients were transfused if their blood loss exceeded a pre-calculated maximal allowable loss, or based on a 48 hour post-operative haemoglobin level.

Results: Seventeen of the 233 patients (7%) received allogeneic blood. The average amount received was two units. Pre-operative anaemia and advanced patient age were predictive for increased risk of transfusion. Thirty six per cent of patients who were given a cell saver did not collect sufficient blood for re-transfusion. Ten per cent of this group required further transfusion with allogeneic blood.

Conclusion: There was no statistically significant difference in either the percentage of patients transfused or the volume of blood given to each patient between the two periods of audit. We did not find post-operative cell salvage to be an effective method of reducing allogeneic blood use.


FJ Shannon J Cronin S Eustace J O’Byrne

Introduction: Total knee replacement (TKR) is an established and successful treatment option for symptomatic osteoarthritis of the knee. Arthroplasty surgeons, however, continue to debate the merits of posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) preservation or resection. Published literature on this subject has not demonstrated a significant clinical difference in outcome in matched subjects. Deliberate PCL resection during non-posterior stabilised TKR has also been shown to have similar outcomes.

The aims of this study were to map the tibial PCL footplate using MRI in patients undergoing TKR and more importantly, to document the percentage disruption of this footplate as a result of the tibial cut.

Patients and Methods: Patients awaiting TKR were prospectively enrolled into this study. Plain radiographs and an MRI scan of the knee were performed. Using coronal and sagittal images and the available software, the cross sectional area of the tibial PCL footplate was determined along with its location relative to the tip of the fibular head. Plain x-rays of the knee were performed postoperatively. Using a number of pre-determined markers we estimated the impact of the operative tibial cut on the PCL footplate.

Results: Twenty-five patients were enrolled into this study. There were 7 male and 18 female patients, mean age: 69 years. The vast majority of implants were AMK (80%), with a mean posterior slope cut of 3.6 degrees (range 0–7) and mean spacer height 11.4 mm (range 8–16).

From MRI analysis, the tibial PCL footplate had a mean surface area of 83 mm2 (range: 49 – 142), and there was a significant difference between male and female patients [Male: 104 mm2versus Females: 75 mm2; t-test, p < 0.005]. The inferior most aspect of the PCL footplate was located on average 1 mm above the superior most aspect of the fibular head (range: 10 mm below to 7 mm above).

Analysis of post-operative radiographs showed that the average tibial cut extended to 4 mm above the tip of the fibular head (range 2 mm below to 14 mm above). Over one third of patients had tibial cuts extending below the inferior most aspect of their PCL footplate (complete removal) and a further one third had cuts which extended into their PCL footplate (partial removal).

Conclusions We have found a wide variation in the size and location of the tibial PCL footplate when referenced against the fibular head.

Proximal tibial cuts using conventional jigs resulted in the removal of a significant portion if not all of the PCL footplate in the majority of patients.

Our findings suggest that when performing PCL retaining TKR’s, we commonly do not actually preserve the PCL.


Full Access
M Cleary F Shannon D Borton

Introduction: The goals of TKR are restoration of the mechanical axis, joint line and Q –angle. Reproduction of the offset of the extensor mechanism during arthroplasty is less well understood. The lever arm of the extensor mechanism is primarily affected by femoral component position, patella tracking and overall patellar thickness. Changing this lever arm alters quadriceps muscle and patellofemoral joint reaction force. Some TKR designs purposefully aim to increase this offset in order to reduce PFJ contact pressures. Overstuffing the PFJ will however adversely affect outcome.

The aims of this study were to measure and compare the pre and postoperative quadriceps lever arm and its effect on function in a consecutive series of patients undergoing TKR.

Methods: Fifty consecutive patients who had an LCS TKR without patellar resurfacing by a single surgeon were reviewed. Patient demographics were recorded. We measured the pre and post-operative quadriceps lever arm using comparable lateral radiographs and digital imaging software. Functional outcome in these patients was determined using the American Knee Society Score pre and 6-months post-operatively. Patients were specifically questioned regarding the presence or absence of anterior knee pain

Results: Quadriceps lever arm was on average 6 mm greater post-operatively than pre-op but this difference was not significant [t-test]. The functional outcome in these patients was independent of any change in quadriceps lever arm.

Conclusions Reproduction of normal biomechanics is essential in order to optimise outcome from TKR.

Using the LCS system, there is a small but insignificant increase in the quadriceps moment arm. We have not found that this has any bearing on functional outcome in these patients.


A Pillai R Shenoy R Ried P Tansey

Background: The late effect of ionizing radiation on the development of sarcomas within the field of radiation is referred to as Post Irradiation Sarcoma (PRS).

Methods: A retrospective study from the Scottish Bone Tumor Registry (1940–2000) of PRS of the upper limb. The diagnostic criterion of Cahan was strictly followed and all patients followed up for 5 years.

Results: 11 female patients with previous history of radiotherapy (XRT) for carcinoma breast were identified as having PRS. The mean age at diagnosis was 68.7 years (51–80y). The latent period between irradiation and diagnosis ranged from 8 to 36 years (mean 15.6 y). All lesions occurred on the same side as breast malignancy. 6 lesions involved the proximal humerus and 5 the scapula. Histologically there were 7 osteosarcomas (65%), 1 chondrosarcoma, 1 spindlecell sarcoma and 2 dedifferentiated sarcomas. 2 humeral lesions underwent forequarter amputation, 2 excisions and endoprosthesis and 2 chemotherapy. Cumulative 5 year survival for humeral lesions was 33%. Survival was better with patients who achieved complete surgical margins. Majority of scapular lesions presented with either pulmonary/chest wall secondaries and were unresectable. Cumulative survival was poor ranging from 1 to 12 months (mean 6.2 months). De-differentiated lesions had the worst prognosis. Both orthovoltage and megavoltage XRT were implicated. It was not possible to analyze the relationship between total irradiation dose, individual fraction dose and incidence of PRS.

Discussion: PRS is an uncommon tumor with an incidence less than 1%, for patients who survive 5 years after XRT. Delay in diagnosis, aggressive nature, truncal location making extirpative surgery difficult and elderly patients all make the prognosis worse than that of primary sarcomas. As treatment of carcinoma of the breast evolves towards greater breast conservation it will be important to monitor the frequency of this complication more closely.


KN Srikanth M Revell A Abudu SR Carter RM Tillmann RJ Grimer

Purpose: The aim of this study was to understand the effect of endoprosthetic reconstruction in treatment of solitary bone plasmacytoma threatening structural integrity of bone.

Materials and methods: We retrospectively studied 11 patients who underwent endoprosthetic reconstruction for solitary bone plasmacytoma between 1988 and 2003 with more than 1 year follow up. Most had radiotherapy and those who sustained structural damage to a joint or thought to be salvageable were treated with endoprosthetic replacement.

Results: There were 7 males and 4 females, with M: F ratio of 1.75:1, the median age at diagnosis was 53.61years (35–74). Average duration of symptoms prior to presentation at oncology unit was 7.27 months. We had 4 proximal femoral, 2 pelvic, 4 humeral and one tibial Plasmacytomas that were treated with endoprosthetic replacements.8/11 had preoperative radiotherapy for at least 4weeks and 3 did not. Two had postoperative radiotherapy and one adjuvant chemotherapy. Average follow up is 5.45 years (range 1–16years). We had one death due to unrelated causes, one progression to Myeloma treated with adjuvant chemotherapy, two revisions and one dislocation which was reduced by open method. The cumulative overall survival for all patients was 91% at 5 years. The cumulative risk of failure of reconstruction including; infection, dislocation, local recurrence/progression to Myeloma was 27% at 5 years.

Conclusion: Literature review shows that nearly 53% of SBP progress despite radiotherapy to Myeloma at a median time of 1.8 years (2–4 years). But despite average follow up of 5.45 years, progression to Myeloma after endoprosthetic replacement at our unit is 9.09%. We concluded that the use of endoprostheses for reconstruction after excision of solitary bone plasmacytomas threatening structural integrity of bone combined with radiotherapy decreases the disease progression to Myeloma than radiotherapy alone and offers a reasonable but not absolute chance of cure.


Full Access
Henk Giele Gael MacLean

Aim: To review a series of 30 tumours affecting the Brachial plexus for the purposes of analysing the presentation, pathology, indication, surgical approach and outcome of these tumours. We describe a modification of an approach to such tumours.

Method: A personal series of 30 cases of tumours affecting the Brachial Plexus were identified, and their notes reviewed. 30 patients with a slight predominance of females, and an average age of 43 were reviewed. The presenting complaints (in order of decreasing frequency) were mass, pain, motor dysfunction, sensory dysfunction and Horner’s syndrome. Previous operation was common. There was significant past history of neurofibromatosis, radiotherapy and other malignancy.

The supra-clavicular approach was most commonly used, however infra-clavicular, trans-clavicular, trans-manubrial, trans-thoracic, axillary and combined approaches were all used when necessary. A modification of the trans-manubrial approach is described preserving the continuity of the clavicle.

The histology of the tumours was extremely varied, with half being benign and half malignant. The incidence of marginal and incomplete excision was higher then other tumour sites, due presumably to the proximity of vital structures.

Post-operatively there was good resolution of pain and recovery of motor dysfunction, but poor recovery of sensory loss and Horner’s syndrome. At follow up most were alive, 5 had lung metastases, 3 local recurrence, 4 metastases else where and 5 dead of their disease.

Conclusion: Tumours affecting the Brachial plexus are rare. Only 3 previous series have been published. The adjacent structures and the morbidity complicate tumour clearance, however, outcomes suggest that excision is worthwhile.


YS Lau A Sabokbar H Giele V Cerundolo NA Athanasou

Introduction: Osseous metastases from melanoma are relatively common (7% of cases), and occur most often in the axial skeleton. Bone destruction in skeletal metastases of solid tumours is due to stimulation of osteoclast formation and bone resorption. Osteoclasts are formed by the fusion of marrow-derived mononuclear phagocyte precursors which express RANK (receptor activator of nuclear factor κB) which interacts with RANKL expressed by osteoblasts/bone stromal cells in the presence of macrophage colony-stimulating factor (M-CSF). Osteoclast formation by a RANKL-independent, tumour necrosis factor α (TNFα)-induced mechanism has also been reported. Tumour-associated macrophages (TAMs) are present in both primary and secondary tumours and TAMs are known to be capable of osteoclast differentiation. Our aim in this study was to determine the role of TAMs and the humoral mechanisms of osteolysis associated with melanoma metastases.

Materials and Method: In this study we isolated TAMs from extraskeletal primary melanomas and lymph node metastases. TAMs were cultured for up to 21 days in the presence and absence of M-CSF and RANKL or TNF. In a separate experiment, conditioned medium was extracted from the melanoma cell line, SK-Mel-29, and cultured with human peripheral blood mononuclear cells in the presence of M-CSF.

Results: TAM-osteoclast differentiation, as evidenced by the expression of tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase, vitronectin receptor and lacunar resorption pit formation, occurred by both RANKL-dependent and RANKL-independent mechanisms. Osteoclast formation induced by RANKL-independent mechanism was not abolished by the addition of osteoprotegerin or RANK:Fc, decoy receptors for RANK. Conditioned medium from SK-Mel-29 could support osteoclast differentiation in the absence of RANKL. This effect was not abolished by antibodies to RANKL, TNFα, TGFβ, IL-8 or gp130.

Discussion: These results indicate that melanoma TAMs are capable of differentiation into osteoclasts and that both RANKL-dependent and RANKL-independent (TNFα) mechanisms are involved. Melanoma tumour cells also secrete a soluble factor that supports osteoclastogenesis.

Conclusion: Inhibitors of osteoclast formation targeting TAM-osteoclast differentiation and osteoclast activity and identification of the osteoclastogenic factor produced by melanoma cells may have a therapeutic potential in controlling tumour osteolysis.


Ross Barker Paul Cool David Williams Bernhard Tinns Victor Pullicino

Purpose: Chondroblastomas are a lesion of immature cartilage found in a typically epiphyseal location. The peak incidence is in teenagers. Current surgical treatment is a balance between complete excision, with potential for physeal and articular cartilage damage, and local recurrence. A minimally invasive technique with a low complication rate providing effective treatment may be provided by radiofrequency (RF) thermocoagulation. Already the treatment of choice for Osteoid Osteoma – another lesion that can occur in the epiphysis.1,2,3 Literature to date on clinical use of RF thermocoagulation in chondroblastoma is scarce.4 The high water content of chondroblastoma should ensure its sensitivity to RF ablation. Our units experience in osteoid osteoma has been extended to RF thermocoagulation of chondroblastoma.

Patients: Four patients were treated with RF thermocoagulation for a chondroblastoma. Minimum follow up one year.

Methods: A RITA Starburst probe thermocoagulates the lesion for at least 5 minutes at 90 degrees centigrade. Overnight stay and outpatient follow up until skeletal mature, or two years following treatment.

Results: Two chondroblastomas were in the proximal tibia, one in the distal femur and one in the proximal humerus. One patient had surgery previously and one patient presented with collapse of the proximal tibial plateau. All patients were treated successfully and are pain free. All patients, accepting the one with pre-existing collapse, have a full range of movement. There has been no local recurrence at one year.

Conclusion & Discussion: Our experience suggests that radiofrequency thermocoagulation is a safe and effective treatment method for patients with chondroblastoma.


RK Trehan K Daly

Treatment of unicameral bone cysts ranges from injections of corticosteroids, bone marrow with allogenic demineralised bone matrix to open bone grafting procedure. These procedures have their own disadvantages in form of infection, fracture, long-term morbidity, repeat procedure and high recurrence rate.

We describe here a new, technically simple and safe technique with minimal morbidity and short hospital stay. We treated 2 young children with active bone cyst (that did not heal with pathological fractures in past 18 months) by this technique and in both the cases bone cyst healed without any complications.

In patient with active bone cyst at the proximal end of humerus, under image intensifier control distal humerus perforated with 3.5 mm drill and a pre bent 2.5 mm, flexible, intramedullary nail passed into the medullary canal and then to proximal end of bone cyst. Nail now rotated sequentially at 5 mm intervals to destroy the architecture of the cyst completely until no resistance is felt. Wound closed with skin sutures and steristrips. Post operatively both children were comfortable and discharged home next day. In both cases cyst healed uneventfully.

Though we have small experience but technique looks very promising.


SC Talwalkar H Bhansali JH Stilwell L Cutler

Purpose: We present a 12 year follow up of a patient who presented with a multiple plexiform schwannoma of the median nerve with multiple recurrences, where it was possible to salvage the limb.

Patients and Methods: Multiple plexiform Schwannomas are rare nerve sheath tumours. In this case the tumour presented as a soft non-tender swelling in the palm of a child. On exploration the lesion was found to involve the median nerve from the digital nerves to the antecubital fossa. Histology confirmed a plexiform schwannoma.

The tumour was locally very aggressive with multiple recurrences initially in the median nerve and ulnar nerves and later in the nerve grafts used following excision of the primary tumour.

We present a pictorial review of the mode of presentation of the tumour; discuss different modalities used for limb salvage and the differential diagnosis of this rare tumour.

Conclusion: There are very few reports of PS involving main nerve trunks and none describe the long term follow-up. We report a twelve year follow up of a PS involving the main nerve trunks of the upper limb with salvage despite multiple recurrences. The clinical course of the tumour is presented up to the age of sixteen where the growth tumour appears to have regressed.


Full Access
A W Davidson N Chhaya

Aim: To determine if bonewax will act as a suitable barrier during cementation of bone cavities after curettage of bone tumours.

Method: One mix of methylmethacrylate cement was placed on top of a standard piece of bonewax. A steel thermometer probe was used to measure the temperature of the surface of the cement. The temperature was measured above and below the bonewax.

Results: The surface temperature of the cement was found to be 57°C both above and below the bonewax. The exothermic reaction occurred after the end of the cement working time, thus the bonewax acted as a physical barrier to protrusion of cement before melting away.

Discussion: Bone tumours such as GCT may cause cortical destruction. Standard treatment for many such benign tumours is curettage and cementation1. This is simplest when there is no cortical defect, other than the cortical window which is created by the surgeon who then curettes the tumour and performs any adjuvant therapy that is indicated. The cavity is then filled with cement, which is applied while still workable and runny to allow complete fill of the cavity. Pressurisation is the norm to interdigitate cement into bone to produce thermal necrosis of residual tumour cells. Problems occur when a cortical defect exists as this will allow the escape of cement into the joint or soft tissues with a detrimental thermal effect on cartilage or soft tissues2,3. The surface temperature found in this study is consistent with others4. A cortical defect will deny effective pressurisation, interdigitation and thermal necrosis of tumour cells. We have used bonewax in such surgery and found it is an effective barrier to cement protrusion during cementation of an incomplete cavity and allows effective pressurisation and interdigitation of cement whilst preventing potentially harmful escape of cement and direct contact with cartilage or soft tissues and thus reduces the risk of immediate thermal necrosis and of later third body joint wear1, or soft tissue irritation. Furthermore the bonewax disappears and is non-toxic.


H Sharma P Vashishtha V Paode MJ Jane R Reid

This study aimed to analyse clinical, radiological and histological features of 29 cases of pathological fractures of the long bones either presented as or occurred during the course of sarcomatous degeneration in Paget’s disease of bone utilising Scottish Bone Tumour Registry between 1950 to 2000. The mean age was 67.2 (range, 53–81) years with 16 males and 13 females. The commonest bone affected was the femur (n=13) followed by humeral (n=8), tibial (n=5), ilium (n=2) and os calcis (n=1) fracture. The mean duration of symptoms prior to presentation was two months. Fourteen patients presented with pain associated with a pathological fracture. One patient presented with painless lump and eleven with painful swelling followed by a pathological fracture. In the remaining three, the patients reported with a delayed or non-union of the pathological fracture. Nine patients presented acutely as pathological fracture being their main presenting symptom. The typical radiological appearance was a lytic (n=22). Histology showed predominantly osteosarcoma (n=17) followed by malignant fibrous histiocytoma (n=7) and pleomorphic sarcoma (n=5). Amputation was carried out in 16, internal fixation in 5 and replacement arthroplasty in two (1-cemented bipolar and 1-Charnley’s total hip arthroplasty). In addition, adjuvant radiotherapy in 13, adjuvant chemotherapy in 3 and combined radiotherapy-chemotherapy in 2 patients was instituted. The mean survival was 19.3 months (humeral=4.6, pelvifemoral=30, tibiocalcaneal=23.3 months). In conclusion, the majority of the pathological fractures in Paget’s sarcoma behave differently from their counterparts (non-Pagetic pathological fractures) with regard to their limb ablation treatment rather than stabilisation operation. The actual occurrence of a pathological fracture did not show to significantly affect the overall survivorship.


D J M Macdonald G Holt K Vass M Jane C S Kumar

Introduction: Lumps of the foot present relatively infrequently to the orthopaedic service. There have been very few published studies looking at the differential diagnosis of such lesions and there is no clear evidence for the prevalence of malignant lesions in patients presenting with foot lumps.

Aim: To assess the prevalence of malignant lesions identified in patients presenting with a lump on the foot.

Methods: All patients presenting to a regional centre with a foot lump who required surgical excision of their lesion were identified over a 3 year period. All case notes were retrospectively reviewed. Data recorded included patient demographics, presenting characteristics, pre-operative diagnosis and histological diagnosis The centre includes a tumour service and serves a population of 550,000 patients. Tertiary referrals from out-with the direct catchment area of the centre were excluded.

Results: 101 cases presenting during this study period underwent surgery. Average age was 47.3 years (range 14–79) and there was a significant female preponderance with 73 females and 28 males. There was only one malignant tumour although 32 different histological diagnoses were identified. Only 58 out of the 101 lumps were correctly diagnosed prior to surgery.

Conclusions: We have shown that the prevalence of malignant lesion presenting as foot lumps is low but there are a wide variety of potential diagnoses which have to be considered. Pre-operative diagnosis is often inaccurate, therefore surgical excision and histological diagnosis should still be sought if there is any uncertainty.


MBS Brewster DM Power SR Carter A Abudu R Grimer R Tillman

Aims: Soft tissue sarcomas (STS) of the foot and ankle are rare tumours. The aims of this study were to examine the presenting features and highlight those associated with a delay in diagnosis.

Methods: Patients presenting during a 10-year period were identified using a computerised database within the Orthopaedic Oncology Unit at the Royal Orthopaedic Hospital, Birmingham, UK. Additional information was obtained from a systematic case note review.

Results: 1519 patients were treated for STS of which 87 (8.2%) had tumours sited in the foot and ankle. Of these, 75 (86.2%) had presented with a discrete lump (42 (56%) of them having an inadvertent “whoops” excision biopsy), 3 (3.4%) with ulceration and the remaining 9 (10.3%) with symptoms more commonly associated with other benign foot and ankle pathology. Within the group of 9 patients they had previously been treated as plantar fasciitis (3), tarsal tunnel syndrome (2), Morton’s neuroma (1) and none specific hind foot pain (3). Median delay from onset of symptoms to diagnosis as STS was 26 months for this group (mean 50; range 6–180 months) compared to 12 months (mean 32; range 3–240) for the “whoops” biopsy group and 10 months (mean 16; range 2–60 months) for the unbiopsied discrete lump group.

Conclusion: Soft tissue sarcoma in the foot and ankle may present insidiously and with symptoms of other benign pathologies. Failure to respond to initial treatment of suspected common benign pathology should be promptly investigated with further imaging e.g. MRI scan or high resolution ultrasound, or with specialist consultation.


Full Access
T Theologis S Ostlere C L M Gibbons N A Athanasou

Aim: To describe the clinical, radiological and pathological features of this rare subtype of osteoblastoma diagnosed pre-operatively and treated by excision.

Conclusion: Toxic osteoblastoma is a benign bone forming tumour that presents with systemic symptoms of fever, anorexia and weight loss.

It has a characteristic radiographic appearance with marked periostitis in the involved bone mimicking osteosarcoma and associated focal abnormality in juxtaposed skeletal sites.

With the help of two previously reported cases from the literature of aggressive bone forming tumours in children who presented with marked anorexia and cachexia diagnosed as osteomyelitis and osteosarcoma and treated by ablative surgery this tumour was correctly diagnosed with planned subtotal scapulectomy and reconstruction enabling a good functional result. The systemic symptoms fully resolved following surgery with return of appetite and weight gain.


CH Gerrand C Billingham P Woll RJ Grimer

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine how patients with soft tissue sarcoma are followed up in the United Kingdom to inform the development of a prospective clinical trial.

Methods: A list of clinicians (surgeons and oncologists) treating patients with soft tissue sarcomas in the United Kingdom was compiled and a postal survey performed. Reminders were sent to non-responders. The survey included questions about the specialty of the clinician, the grade, membership of specialist societies, perceptions about risk factors for recurrence and the value of follow up and asked specifically about three clinical scenarios.

Results: Of 192 clinicians who were sent the questionnaire, responses were obtained from 155 (81%). 128 of these met the criteria for analysis. In the given clinical scenarios, length of follow up varied from 1 year to lifelong. The total number of clinic visits in 5 years varied from 5 to 30, of chest radiographs from 0 to 24, of chest CT scans from 0 to 10, and of local site imaging from 0 to 13. 88 (84%) agreed that follow up is of benefit. 57 (59%) agreed that it would be reasonable to follow up selected patients in the community. 96 (93%) agreed that a study of follow up protocols would be of value.

Discussion: There is significant variation in follow-up protocols amongst clinicians in the United Kingdom. A prospective study of follow-up protocols is likely to be supported.


Henk Giele Paul Critchley Max Gibbons Nick Athanasou Adrian Jones

Aim: To review our series of mid foot sarcomas with regard to excision of tumour, tolerance of radiotherapy and preservation of function.

Methods and results: We identified 6 patients with mid foot sarcomas treated in our unit. Synovial sarcoma was the commonest diagnosis. All the patients had stage 1 disease with no evidence of pulmonary metastases at presentation. Patients judged to have resectable tumour but preserving sufficient foot to be functional were spared amputation. They had excision of the sarcoma and immediate reconstruction using fascio-cutaneous free flaps. Complete excision was achieved in all cases. One flap was lost and repeated. In all patients, subsequent radiotherapy was well tolerated without significant complications. All patients remain disease free. All patients have returned to pre-operative functioning including walking and jogging. All except one have returned to work.

Conclusion: Patients and feet treated by wide local excision of mid foot sarcomas and reconstructed by free fascio-cutaneous flaps tolerate post-operative radio-therapy well, and return to near normal function.


A. Pillai R Shenoy R Ried P Tansey

Introduction: Frozen shoulder is a general term denoting all causes of motion loss in the shoulder. As the syndrome is very common, many patients do not undergo detailed imaging studies before treatment. Some patients are managed by their GPs for long periods before being referred to a hospital.

Objectives: A series of 15 patients with primary neoplasms of the shoulder girdle mimicking frozen shoulder syndrome is presented.

Methods: A retrospective review of the Scottish bone tumor registry.

Results: There were 6 male and 9 female patients. The common presentation was pain and stiffness of the shoulder joint. Mean age at diagnosis was 46.63Yrs (range 23 – 71 Yrs). 73% were less than 50 Yrs of age. Only 2 gave history of trauma. Most received local steroids and physiotherapy before diagnosis. There were 10(66.6%) proximal humeral lesions and 5(33.3%) scapular lesions. Humeral lesions included chondrosarcoma (2), Ewing’s (2), lymphoma (2), chondroma (2) and osteoblastoma (1). Scapular lesions included chondrosarcoma (3), lymphoma (1) and fibromatosis (1).Scapular tumors involved older individuals. The mean delay in diagnosis after onset of symptoms was 15.8 mts (range 2 weeks- 48 months). All patients had X rays and CT/MRI. Treatment included a combination of surgery, chemotherapy and radiation. 3 patients with humeral lesions died at a mean of 20.6 mts, and 3 patients with scapular lesions died at a mean of 4.3 mts after diagnosis. The common cause of death was pulmonary metastasis.

Discussion: Many so called frozen shoulders are joints inhibited by pain rather than by true contracture. The commonest lesion to mimic a frozen shoulder is a slow growing low/middle grade chondrosarcoma. Young patients presenting with persistent pain or night pain must be examined for this possibility. Consideration should be given for further investigation before instituting treatment. Delay in diagnosis adversely affects survival. Surgeons are reminded that although rare, a tumor should be suspected when clinical presentations are unusual.


PM Whittingham-Jones AP Sanghrajka TWR Briggs SR Cannon

Introduction: Chondrosarcoma is the second most common malignant solid tumour of bone. The management of extra-axial low grade chondrosarcomas remains a controversial issue. Many groups advocate wide excision, necessitating substantial reconstructive surgery, often requiring massive endoprostheses or allografts. Our unit favours intralesional curettage, as it is less invasive and results in smaller defects affecting only the medulla, which can be reconstructed using simpler methods. The purpose of this study was to assess the oncological and functional outcomes of this treatment strategy.

Methods: Using our database, we identified patients with long bone chondrosarcoma that had undergone intralesional curettage between 1999 and 2001. The resultant defects had been filled with PMMA cement in 22 cases and bone graft in 2 cases. A review of all notes and radiographs was performed, with functional assessment of all available patients using the Musculoskeletal Tumour Society Scoring (MSTS).

Results: 24 consecutive cases were identified; 11 cases affecting the distal femur, 8 in the proximal humerus, 3 in the tibia and 1 each of the scapula and radius. Average age was 47 years, (range 22–75). Tumour grade was: grade 1 – 22 cases and grade 2 in 2 cases. Mean follow-up was 52 months, (range 38–73 months). There was a single case of local recurrence in a patient that had a grade 2 lesion; there were no incidences of metastases. Functional outcome was assessed in 20 of the 23 remaining cases, scoring a mean 93.7% (range 53–100) on the MSTS.

Conclusion: This study suggests intralesional curettage is an effective treatment strategy for extra-axial low grade chondrosarcoma with excellent oncological and functional results. Careful case selection, with stringent clinical and radiographic follow-up is recommended.


G. Johnson G Smith A Dramis R Grimer

To establish whether Patients or Medical Professionals are the main source of delay for patients referred to a Specialist Centre for Soft Tissue Sarcoma.

Methods: Patients were recruited from both outpatient clinics and from the surgical ward. A semi-structured interview was used to take a detailed history of the patients’ treatment pathway, before arriving at the Specialist Centre. Results: The average time for patient to present to a SC from the onset of symptoms was 110 weeks, (min 3 days, max 1089 weeks), with a median of 40 weeks. Average delay to presentation to a medical professional (patient delay) was 24.5 weeks (min 0, max 530), median 2 weeks. Average delay in referral to a SC (service delay) was 84 weeks (min 0 max 1083), median 25weeks.

Discussion: Medical professionals rather than patients contribute the greatest source of delay in patients reaching a Specialist Centre for treatment of Soft Tissue Sarcoma. Adherence to previously published guidelines could decrease this delay. Medical professional awareness of these guidelines and their contents needs to be increased.


L Tiessen RJ Grimer AM Davies SR Carter A Abudu RM Tillman

Purpose: To identify the risk of metastases at the time of diagnosis in patients with soft tissue sarcomas and to estimate the cost effectiveness of identifying these.

Methods: A retrospective database review was used to identify all new soft tissue sarcoma patients referred to our unit and to find those identified to have metastases at diagnosis. Data of tumour size, depth, grade, age, type of tumours, Chest x-ray (CXR)/CT chest results were available in all patients. We estimated the efficacy of CXR in identifying metastases and the costs of various staging strategies.

Patients: 1170 with newly diagnosed STS in 7.5 years (1996–2004) were included.

Results: The incidence of metastases at diagnosis was 10% (116 patients), 8.25% (96 patients) had lung metastases and 20 had metastases elsewhere. The risk of having lung metastases at diagnosis was 11.8% in high grade tumours, 6.95% in intermediate grade and 1.2% in low grade tumours. The risk increased almost linearly with size at presentation and was higher in deep tumours and older patients. CXR alone detected 2/3 of all lung metastases. The positive predictive value of the CXR was 93.7%, the negative predictive value was 96.7%, the sensitivity 62.5% and the specificity 99.6%.

The accuracy was 96.9%. CT overestimated metastases in 4%.

Discussion: We recommend that all patients with a newly diagnosed STS should have a CXR and only those with an abnormality or who have large, deep high grade tumours should have a CT chest. This strategy will save £7500 per 100 new patients with STS and will detect 93% of all chest metastases, missing 1 patient with metastases per 166 patients.


S E Gwilym D J Whitwell H Giele A Jones N Athanasou C L M Gibbons

Purpose: To quantify the functional outcome of patients who were known to have sciatic nerve involvement pre-operatively and went on to have nerve preserving surgery utilising a planned marginal excision with epineurectomy.

Materials and Methods: Ten patients with large volume posterior thigh soft tissue sarcoma with known sciatic nerve involvement were reviewed between 1997 and 2004. Nine underwent surgery with extended epineurectomy of the sciatic nerve and planned marginal excision.

All patients underwent staging and follow up at Sarcoma Clinic with functional assessment and TESS evaluation.

Results: There were seven low and two high grade posterior thigh tumours of which nine were liposarcoma and 1 haemangiopericytoma. Two were recurrent and eight primary. There were five men and five women with a mean age of 77.

Nine patients underwent planned marginal excision. Sciatic nerve involvement was 13–30cm in eight cases and in one case the sciatic nerve was abutting the tumour throughout its length. There was soft tissue reconstruction in three cases using fascial adductor or gracilis graft for sciatic nerve cover and one with superficial femoral nerve and vein resection requiring ipsilateral saphenous reconstruction. The remainder underwent direct primary reconstruction.

Four patients underwent radiotherapy 46–60 Gy.

There was no local recurrence of disease within 14 – 96m follow-up. There was one patient with post radiation wound breakdown that resolved.

Three patients have died of unrelated causes. To date there has been no evidence of local recurrence of disease at FU.

Conclusion: Planned marginal excision of low grade large volume posterior thigh sarcomas with extensive sciatic nerve involvement can be successfully treated with preservation of the sciatic nerve without significant morbidity and resultant good limb function.


D J Whitwell I C Dickinson

The aim of this study was to assess the significance of the extent and adequacy of the surgical margin on three outcome variables; survival, metastasis and local recurrence. We statistically analysed (Cox proportional hazards regression modelling) 279 consecutive patients who presented with soft tissue sarcoma without meta-static disease. They were treated by a single surgeon to a standard protocol in two centres. In terms of overall survival, the failure to achieve a wide surgical margin by contaminating the resection, led to an elevenfold increase in the relative death rate (p=0.04). However, where the margin was not contaminated (even if the margin was closer than 1 mm) then the overall survival rate was similar across all groups of patients with a clear margin up to 20 mm. A large margin greater than 20mm afforded the lowest risk to overall survival. The extent of the surgical margin was not statistically significant in the development of metastatic disease. The presence of a contaminated surgical margin and a narrow margin less than 1mm led to a significantly higher rate of local recurrence (p=0.02) A margin greater than 1 mm allowed a satisfactory outcome in terms of a low local recurrence rate and the extent of the margin up to 20mm was not statistically important. Patients who had radical resections did poorly and generally represent a group where palliative surgery was performed, and there was a very high relative metastasis and death rate. Our study provides statistically significant evidence that increasing width of resection improves local control and overall survival. However a narrow margin due to anatomical constraints such as bone or neurovascular structures does not significantly compromise patient outcome and this provides guidance for surgical decision making in limb salvage surgery.


Full Access
L Babu F Adeyamo K Baskaran P Kumar A Paul

Purpose of Study – The unusual presentation of this case posed a diagnostic dilemma between a chronic haematoma and soft tissue sarcoma even after full investigation and biopsy. Salient points to differentiate between the two are discussed along with literature review.

Case Report – A 61 year old gentleman presented with sudden increase in size of an already existing swelling over the mid third of right leg associated with throbbing pain & foot drop of 4 months duration. There was no recent history of trauma or bleeding abnormalities but there was a vague history of injury to his leg during his late teens. Clinical signs showed features suggestive of malignancy with engorged veins and diffuse margins with complete foot drop (Fig 1 & 2). X-rays showed calcifications within the substance of the swelling along with proximal tibiofibular synostosis (Fig 3). MRI scan revealed a well encapsulated mass between the peroneal muscles mechanically compressing the common peroneal nerve (Fig 4). Trucut biopsy showed cholesterol clefts and areas of dystrophic calcification characteristic of chronic haematoma (Fig 5). Patient successfully underwent enucleation of the swelling along with cutaneofascial suture to obliterate the dead space leading to complete recovery of foot drop. Biopsy confirmed a Chronic Haematoma.

Discussion – Reid et al first used the term chronic expanding haematoma for haematomas that persisted and increased in size more than a month after the initiating haemorrhage. The cause of initial haemorrhage is most commonly trauma which results in displacement of skin and subcutaneous fatty tissue from more deeply located fixed fascia with formation of blood filled cysts surrounded by dense fibrous tissue. Factors in the blood-clotting cascade are said to be associated with an inflammatory reaction leading to additional bleeding from fragile capillaries and thus to additional inflammation, hence setting up a self-perpetuating process.

Although the MRI & biopsy results in this case were reassuring, the clinical scenario of sudden foot drop with increase in pain point more towards a malignant process rather than a benign condition. Some salient points to differentiate the two include that sarcoma have no history of trauma and the duration of symptoms is longer in haematoma than sarcoma. Also, sarcomas usually involve deeper structures while haematoma occur in superficial layers. It should also be noted that several soft tissue sarcoma themselves commonly reveal haemorrhagic or cystic changes. Other differential diagnosis includes myositis ossificans and tumoral calcinosis.

Conclusion – It is difficult to differentiate between chronic haematoma and soft tissue sarcoma based on clinical findings alone. X-ray and biochemical tests are always essential to rule out any fracture or bony mass but MRI is the gold standard and biopsy is the only way to rule out a malignant tumour. Surgical excision of the swelling including the fibrous pseudocapsule along with cutaneofascial suture to obliterate the dead space is the treatment of choice for chronic haematoma because aspiration of the fluid or incomplete excision could lead to recurrence, continued growth or a chronic draining sinus with or without infection.


E Dunstan P Whittingham-Jones SR Cannon

To reduce the disability after hip disarticulation customised endoprostheses have been used in our unit to preserve a proximal femoral above knee amputation stump. This procedure involves preservation of a musculocutaneous flap and insertion of a customised stump prosthesis that articulates with the acetabulum. This procedure has been performed not only for primary malignancy but also in the reconstructive setting. Six patients have undergone the above procedure with a good functional outcome-allowing mobilisation with an appropriate orthosis. We will discuss the complications of such a procedure that includes disassociation of the femoral head from the customised prosthesis.

We present the technique as a useful adjunct not only in the treatment of large proximal femoral tumours but also in the end stage reconstructive setting.


V Gowda K Rao A Lahiri F C Peart

We evaluated the effectiveness of local and free flap cover done at revision surgery for infected endoprosthetic replacement (EPR) in achieving ultimate control of infection.

Methods: Ten patients needed plastic surgical input in the form of flap cover at the time of revision surgery for infective endoprosthetic failure between March 1999 and March 2005. The revision of EPR itself was undertaken in 2 stages. The 1st stage involved removal of the endoprosthesis, insertion of antibiotic spacer and flap cover. After achieving adequate control of infection, 2nd stage revision was carried out, in which the spacer was exchanged for an endoprosthesis.

Results: Average age at time of flap surgery was 29 years (range 14 – 58 years). Average follow up was 23 months (3 to 72 months) for patients who remained free of infection and 19 months (5 to 52 months) for those who underwent amputation. 9 out of 10 patients underwent some form of muscle flap (6 free LD flaps, 2 gastrocnemius flaps and 1 pedicled LD flap). Infection was adequately controlled in 5 out of 6 patients in free flap group. Out of 4 patients who underwent local flaps, 2 ended up having amputation.

Conclusion: Reconstructive surgery in the form of flap cover has an important role in limb salvage in patients with endoprosthetic failure due to infection. The aim of such surgery should be to provide as much new vascularized tissue over the dependent portions with sinuses and areas of radiotherapy with scarring. Results of cover by a broad flat musculocutaneous flaps seem to be better in comparison to local flaps.


L Tiessen A Abudu RJ Grimer RM Tillman SR Carter

Limb preserving surgery following segmental resection of the distal end of the radius and its articular surface presents a major challenge. We have studied 11 consecutive patients with aggressive tumours located in the distal radius that required segmental resection of the distal radius and its articular surface to evaluate the clinical and functional outcome of reconstruction of such defects.

The mean age at the time of diagnosis was 33 years (7–60). Follow up ranged from 12 to 306 months (median 56). Histological diagnosis was osteosarcoma in 4 patients, chondrosarcoma in 2, giant cell tumour in 5 and meta-static carcinoma in 1 patient. Four patients received chemotherapy. The length of excised bone ranged from 6 to 14cm. Reconstruction was performed with non-vascularised proximal fibula strut graft in 6 patients, ulna transposition in 3 and custom made endoprosthesis in 2 patients. The wrist joint was arthrodesed in 5 patients.

At the time of review 2 patients had died of disease, one was alive with disease and 8 were alive and free of disease. Non-union of the graft occurred in one patient, reflex sympathetic dystrophy in 2 and prosthetic dislocation in one. One patient had local recurrence. Four patients required further surgery including one patient who needed an amputation for severe reflex sympathetic dystrophy, one graft revision for non-union, one secondary wrist arthrodesis and one closed reduction of dislocated endoprosthesis. Patients without arthrodesis often had clinical and radiological signs of wrist instability. The majority of the patients achieved satisfactory function with little or no discomfort and ability to perform activities of daily living.

We conclude that limb salvage surgery is worthwhile in patients with resectable tumours of the distal radius.


AW Davidson A Hong SW McCarthy PD Stalley

Aim: To clinically and radiologically review our first 50 cases of treatment of malignant bone tumours by extra-corporeal irradiation (ECI) and re-implantation and review the world literature’s other 100 such cases.

Methods: We have treated 50 patients with bony malignancy by en bloc resection, ECI with 50Gy and reimplantation of the bone segment as a method of limb salvage. Mean survivor follow-up is 38 months (12–92).

Results: 42 patients remain alive without disease. 4 recurrences occurred. Functional results were generally good: Mankin grades 17 excellent, 13 good, 9 fair, 3 failures; MSTS mean 77 (20–100); TESS mean 81 (40–100). Solid bony union was the norm, however bone resorption was seen in some cases.

Discussion: The dose of radiation is theoretically lethal to all cells and produces a dead autogenous bone graft of perfect fit. ECI is a useful technique of limb salvage where there is a reasonable residual bone stock. It allows effective re-attachment of muscle tendons, and produces a lasting biological reconstruction. The risk from the re-implanted bone of both local recurrence and of late radiotherapy induced malignancy should be nil.


E.H.C Wright C.L.M.H Gibbons S Gwilym H Giele P Critchley

Aim: To assess the functional outcomes for patients treated by limb salvage surgery for sarcomas of the upper limb and shoulder girdle.

Materials and methods: Patients who had undergone limb salvage surgery for upper limb sarcoma between 1997 and 2004 were entered into the study. The operation notes were used to obtain details of the surgery. Pathology reports were consulted to identify the type, grade and margins of the tumour. The Toronto Extremity Salvage Score (TESS) questionnaire was used to assess post-operative function, in a postal survey.

Results: A total of 62 patients were identified. Liposarcoma was most common histological diagnosis, and “low” the most common grade (27). Histologically clear margins were achieved in 28 (44%) cases, marginal in 2 (3%), incomplete in 13 (21%) and indeterminate in 20 (32%). 30% had received adjuvant radiotherapy with or without chemotherapy as indicated. A total of 48 (76%) had been treated with excision and primary closure, 7 (11%) with local flaps, and 4 (6%) with endoprostheses. 10 patients had died, and 1 was untraceable. 29 completed TESS questionnaires were returned; with an average follow-up of 33 months post-resection (range 4 to 83). 11 female (38%), 18 male (62%), with an average age at surgery of 55. The average TESS score was 77 +/−10 with a range of 18–100. For the different regions, forearm sarcomas had an average TESS of 81 +/−17, upper arm 76 +/−19 and shoulder 81 +/−14.

Discussion: Surgical excision of soft tissue tumours with limb salvage aims to balance morbidity and mortality. Upper limb amputation has greater morbidity than lower limb and thus the argument for limb salvage should be stronger. A limb-salvage procedure should be considered preferable to amputation provided oncological outcomes are not compromised, and the resulting functional outcome is worth the oncological risk. In this cohort, patients had good functional outcomes, as described by the TESS functional assessment score, with no evidence of compromised oncological outcome during the follow up period.


Full Access
PJ Boscainos S Ostlere J Rainsbury E Velzeboer CLMH Gibbons

Aim: To describe the radiographic findings of soft tissue sarcoma.

Materials and Method: The retrospective review of 100 consecutive patients with a histological diagnosis of primary soft tissues sarcoma of the extremities.

Results: Fifty five patients had plain radiographs at initial presentation. This was mainly due to the fact that most patients were tertiary referrals or had other initial imaging. Histological diagnosis in these patients was: liposarcoma in 24 patients, leiomyosarcoma in 8, undifferentiated spindle cell sarcoma in 5, malignant schwannoma in 4, synovial sarcoma in 4, MFH in 2, fibrosarcoma in 2, haemangiopericytoma, epithelioid sarcoma, malignant GCT, melanoma and spindle cell histiocytoma in one. The upper limb was involved in 18 patients and the lower limb was involved in 37. Thirty-five (63.6%) patients had a visible soft tissue mass on plain film. Eleven had mineralisation within the soft tissue mass and seven had either bone involvement or periosteal response. Those with a distinct soft tissue mass and evidence of fat content on plain film were noted to be diagnosis of liposarcoma in 86.7% of the cases. Mineralization was noted in synovial sarcoma (2), liposarcoma (3), leiomyosarcoma (1), MFH (2) and poorly differentiated sarcomas (2).

Conclusion: The plain radiograph is useful in assessing soft tissue tumour and abnormality is seen in 2/3 of cases reviewed. Mineralization as a radiographic finding features in malignant sarcoma notably liposarcoma. With tumours demonstrating fat on plain film this can correlate with MRI and facilitate surgical treatment avoiding biopsy.


Full Access
M. Abou-Shameh R.U. Ashford J.L. Cruickshank A Rao

Primary bone tumours in the elderly population are relatively rare.

We reviewed the Leeds regional bone tumour registry between 1990–1999 and found them to constitute only 43 of the 341 (12%) bone tumour cases.

Malignant tumours (65%) were more common than benign tumours with primary tumours accounting 92 % and metastatic tumours only 8 % of all the malignancies. Females were more affected than males (55% versus 45 %).

Chondrosarcoma was the most frequent tumour, constituting 24% of primary malignant tumours and 18 % of all bone tumours.

Chondroma was the most common benign tumour accounting for 50% of all benign tumours, and 11% of all tumours.

Survival rate was relatively poor in elderly population with primary malignant tumours.

The majority of malignant tumours were in the lower limb (femur 25%, tibia 14 %).The upper limb accounted for 14% and the axial skeleton 5%.

Bone tumour registries provide a valuable source of cumulative information about both common and uncommon tumours. Such information could not easily be gathered by personal experience. It is also a very good source of information for research education and service.


Full Access
N J Little B A Rogers J Pringle S R Cannon

Adamantinoma is a rare low-grade malignant epithelial bone tumour.

We report a case of an expansile, osteolytic mid-diaphyseal tibial lesion found in a 12 year-old girl. An initial histological diagnosis of basaloid-type adamantinoma was made. Following excision, further histology demonstrated basaloid cells and acellular matrix focally surrounded by osteoclast giant cells with calcium deposits, features consistent with pilomatrixoma. Several histological variants of adamantinoma have been documented; this case details a previously unreported histological adamantinoma variant – pilomatrixoma-adaminatinoma.


M K Sayana D Edwards C Wynn-Jones

Aim: To present and highlight a remote complication following deep x-ray radiotherapy to Ilium.

Background: Radiotherapy is one the options to treat malignancy. Surrounding normal tissue can be affected by super-imposed infection, radiation-induced tumors, and other complications of radiation therapy. Timing of radiation changes varies in the different organs. Acute radiation pneumonitis is generally seen approximately 2 months after completion of radiotherapy, but radiation pericarditis not until 6–9 months after therapy. Radiation-induced sarcomas do not develop on average until 10–15 years after radiation therapy.

Case report: A 39-year old presented to an oral surgeon 29 years ago with a submandibular swelling that was gradually increasing in size. Excision biopsy revealed Follicular, Large cell, Non-Hogdkin’s Lymphoma. Lymphogram showed positive nodes in pelvic and para-aoric regions. She was treated with chemotherapy initially. She developed left SI joint pain 2 years later and was treated with radiotherapy. The lymphoma later became chemotherapy resistant and the patient was treated with whole body irradiation. She was in remission since 26 years. She started having discomfort in the left hip region far past 5 years and was reviewed. A recent MRI scan revealed avascular necrosis of the femoral head with little collapse. Changes in the ilium and muscle wasting around the left iliac wing were noted, which were consistent with post radiation osteonecrosis.

This lady noticed a recent change in the gait and examination revealed positive trendelenberg test and a lurching gait. Latest radiographs have shown a fracture of the left iliac crest. The patient did not request any surgical intervention and was reassured with explanation.

Conclusion: Post radiation osteonecrosis can cause complications as late as 26 years following deep x-ray radiotherapy.


H Sharma P Vashishtha V Paode MJ Jane R Reid

Between 1944 to 2003, ninety cases of Paget’s sarcoma from the Scottish Bone and Soft Tissue Tumour Registry were reviewed. The mean age of patients was 72.3 years (range, 30 to 85 years). There were 59 males and 30 females. The most frequent sites were the femur (26), pelvis (19), humerus (13), tibia (11), and thoraco-lumbosacral spine (9). Biopsy was done in 69 cases. In the remainder 20 cases, the histological diagnosis was confirmed either from examining amputated limb or at autopsy. The most common type was osteosarcoma. Local excision was performed in seven cases. Resection in two cases and prosthetic replacement in two cases was carried out. Twenty nine patients underwent amputation surgery. Chemotherapy was administered to 15 patients (including 2 preop chemotherapy). Fifty one patients received radiotherapy (preoperatively in eight patients). All the patients died within one year from the date of biopsy with an average survival time of 7.5 months. Patients with Paget’s sarcoma tend to have a very poor prognosis inspite of improvements in therapy strategies including surgery, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy. We emphasise the need for more research by a combined oncosurgical, oncological, radiological and histological approach in the management of Paget sarcoma to improve the prognosis.


R Williams R Wragg T Briggs S Cannon A Flannagan

Introduction: Mazabraud syndrome is a rare disorder characterised by fibrous dysplasia and intramuscular myxomas. We present six new cases.

Method: A reterospective review was performed on six patients from our institution. This is a consecutive series over 48 months.

Results: The patient group consisted of three females and three males. The six patients were referred to our bone tumour unit from other hospitals (four by orthopaedic teams and two by general surgeons). The referring hospitals had been unable to exclude a malignant process. Imaging was tailored to each individual case. Three of our six patients demonstrated polyostotic fibrous dysplasia. The commonest site of the osseous leision was the proximal femur (n=4). The majority of the patients had solitary myxomas (n=4) with only two being multiple myxomas. The average size of the myxomas was 3.7 cm. All soft tissue leisions were ipsilateral to the osseous leisions.

Five of the six patients were treated with surgical excision.

Discussion: In contrast to the existing literature the majority(n=4) of the six patients had solitary myxomas and the male to female distribution was equal. One of the cases was also unique to the current literature with the syndrome present in the right elbow.

The number of cases that we have seen in a short time may also be an indication that this syndrome is not as rare as scarcity of the published cases would imply.


S. Mitchell E. Lingard B. Dallol P. Kesteven A.W. McCaskie C.H. Gerrand

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine the rate of clinically detected deep venous thrombosis and pulmonary embolism in patients with trunk or extremity bone or soft tissue sarcomas.

Patients and methods: The clinical records of patients with a confirmed diagnosis of primary bone or soft tissue sarcoma presenting between 1998 and 2003 were reviewed. Data relating to clinical features, risk factors for thromboembolism and clinical thromboembolic events were retrieved.

Results: 252 patients were identified. 94 had a diagnosis of primary bone sarcoma and 158 a diagnosis of primary soft tissue sarcoma. The mean age was 53 (range 15 to 94); 137 (54%) were male.

37 patients were suspected clinically of having a deep venous thrombosis, 10 of which were confirmed radiologically, giving a rate of 4%. Nine patients had a suspected pulmonary embolism, 2 of which were confirmed radiologically and one of whom died of pulmonary embolism, giving an overall rate of fatal pulmonary embolism of 0.4%. All patients with thromboembolic events had lower extremity tumours and all were surgical patients. However, the majority of thromboembolic events (6 of 10 deep venous thromboses and 2 of 3 pulmonary embolisms) occurred prior to surgery.

Discussion: The risk of a clinically apparent thromboembolic event in patients with bone or soft tissue sarcomas is comparable to that in other orthopaedic patients. Risk factors for venous thromboembolism include lower extremity sarcomas and mechanical obstruction of the venous system. Consideration should be given to excluding deep venous thrombosis before surgery.


M Ramakrishnan N J Shaw

Aim: To report the technique of reverse femoral LISS [Limited Invasive stabilisation system] plate fixation of pathological fractures of proximal femora with pre-existing deformity due to multiple fractures in a patient known to suffer with Osteopetrosis

Design: Osteopetrosis, a rare heterogeneous condition, is a result of failure of the bone remodelling. The orthopaedic presentations of which include, back pain, deformity of long bones and multiple fractures. Historically, most fractures in patients with Osteopetrosis were treated nonsurgically with good results, but at the expense of malunion. Operative treatment is indicated, to avoid disabling deformity or to treat nonunion of the fractures. The conventional onlay or inlay devices for fracture stabilisation are difficult to use due to malunion and obliteration of medullary canal, caused by previous fractures and hardness of the bone. The new LISS is an extramedullary, internal fixation system and its main features are an atraumatic insertion technique, minimal bone contact, and a locked, fixed-angle construction. The LISS plate can be used to stabilize the whole length of a femur with multiple deformities.

Subject: A 46-year – old lady who is a known case of autosomal dominant Osteopetrosis sustained 5 left femoral and 4 right femoral pathological fractures, over a period of 25 years. They were treated nonoperatively and the fractures were healed with some malunion. During the recent clinical presentation, her bilateral proximal femoral fractures failed to unite by conservative methods and operative treatment was indicated. We used a bilateral reverse femoral LISS plate as the proximal fragments were short and needed axial and rotational control.

Conclusion: The reverse LISS is a useful implant for treatment of femoral fractures, especially when the femur is deformed and the medullary cavity is obliterated as in cases of Osteopetrosis.


Full Access
SC Talwalkar M Kimani MJ Hayton R Page JH Stilwell

Purpose: We report a locally invasive tenosynovial haemangioma infiltrating the flexor digitorum sublimis of the non dominant little finger in a sixteen year old student which was excised with part of the sublimis tendon and the A2 pulley.

Patients and Methods: Haemangiomata developing in the hand in relation to tendon and the tenosynovium (tendon sheath) are very rare. To our knowledge only three cases have been described arising in relation to the tenosynovium of the tendons of the hand only one of which showed infiltration of the underlying tendon. We report the case of a sixteen year old right hand dominant student who presented to her family doctor with a swelling on her left little finger. A magnetic resonance scan was arranged which confirmed a soft tissue lesion between the flexor tendons and the proximal phalanx of the left little finger with appearance similar to giant cell tumour of the tendon sheath. Surgical exploration demonstrated a dark red fleshy tumour that appeared to infiltrate the flexor digitorum ublimes tendon, and extend around either side of the proximal phalanx. For complete excision of the lesion the infiltrated sublimis tendon and a part of the A2 pulley were sacrificed. There was no resultant bowstringing of the profundus tendon.

Histologically the tenosynovium was expanded by a vascular lesion consisting of dilated, thin-walled vascular channels within fibrous tissue The appearances were those of a synovial haemangioma of the tenosynovium of the flexor tendons

Conclusion: Our case illustrates the pitfalls in diagnosis and the invasive potential of a synovial haemangioma which in our case had infiltrated the flexor sublimis tendon and the area around the A2 pulley. A complete surgical excision is critical to prevent recurrence.


A Hussain D Basu A Irwin

Introduction: Osteoid Osteomas are not uncommon, benign bone tumours which have well-defined clinical, radiological and pathological characteristics. These tumours can potentially affect any bone in the body, but show a predilection for long tubular bones. The clinical presentation can easily be confusing, if the site in question is rare and the presentation atypical. Lesions occurring in the foot often pose particular problems in diagnosis, often leading to delays in treatment. Although there have been accounts of the post traumatic presentations of osteoid osteomas, no direct link has been established between trauma and its incidence.

Case Report: A 38 year old gentleman was referred by his GP with an eighteen month history of right midfoot pain after a football injury which forced his right foot into hyperextension and abduction. Initial radiographs after the injury were normal. The pain did not respond to non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) and there were no nocturnal exacerbations. Examination at presentation showed an antalgic gait with medial mid-foot tenderness centred over the first tarso-metatarsal joint (TMTJ). Repeat radiographs showed mild degenerative changes in the first TMTJ. A bone scan showed a hot spot over the right cuneiform bones. Subsequent computed tomography (CT) showed an osteoid osteoma, with a characteristic central calcific nucleus within the nidus, of the medial border of the lateral cuneiform bone. The osteoma was treated with en-bloc excision and the diagnosis was confirmed by histology.

Conclusion: Despite the advances in its treatment, osteoid osteoma of the foot can pose a difficult diagnostic puzzle. This condition should always be kept in mind when faced with persistent, post-traumatic foot pain, even in the absence of roentgenographic findings. In such cases a high index of suspicion and a low threshold for appropriate imaging can lead to the timely diagnosis and treatment of this tumour.


AD Gorva R Mohil MS Srinivasan

Aggressive digital papillary adenocarcinoma (ADPACa) is a rare skin adnexal tumour, which has a predilection for the digits. We report a case with this tumour in a 51 year old insulin dependent diabetic man, who presented as a paronychia of right index finger. After histopathological confirmation as an ADPACa partial amputation was performed. This case emphasizes the presentation of this tumour as a simple nail bed infection occasionally.


MBS Brewster I Pitman A Abudu

Aim: The pelvis is a rare location for osteochondromas and differentiation from chondrosarcomas can be difficult. We aim to aid this differentiation using tends and demographics of treated cases.

Methods and Results: Patients referred to a supra-regional bone tumour centre with pelvic tumours, consequently diagnosed as osteochondromas were studied to determine the clinico-pathological features that differentiate them from chondrosarcoma. Treatment outcome was also reviewed.

30 patients were studied with a mean follow-up of 32 months. The mean age at diagnosis was 34yrs (range 19–79). The male to female ratio was 1:1. The most common location was the ilium (19 patients), with the pubis and ischium accounting for a third of patients. Only 1 patient had an acetabular osteochondroma. Median duration of symptoms prior to referral was 6 months (1–79). Pain without a lump was the main presenting symptom (16 patients), followed by lump with pain (6), and lump alone (6). Two patients presented with obstructive labour requiring emergency procedures. The lesions were solitary in 24 and associated with hereditary multiple exostosis (HME) in 6 patients. 1 patient had a radiation induced lesion.

The lesions showed increased uptake on bone scans and the cartilage cap was less than 10mm in all but 2 patients. Treatment was surgical excision in 21 patients and observation with serial radiographs in 9. Histological examination confirmed osteochondroma in all patients, however 1 patient with HME had areas of Grade I malignancy. Significant surgical complications occurred in 1 patient who developed pulmonary embolism.

Conclusion: We conclude that symptoms from osteochondromas of the pelvis are similar to those with chondrosarcomas and increased uptake on bone scans is seen in both. However, a tumour with a cartilage cap larger than 10mm or arising from the acetabulum is unlikely to be an osteochondroma.


D J Whitwell P C Steadman

The aim of this study was to retrospectively assess the long term results of the surgical excision of a series of proximal tibio-fibula joint ganglions. They are uncommon tumours in this position (prevalence < 1%) and mimic more sinister pathology creating diagnostic difficulty. From the Queensland Orthopaedic Oncology Database, twelve patients were identified who had presented with proximal tibio-fibular joint cysts between 1991 and 2004 and proceeded to surgery. There were four males and eight females with an average age of 44 years (18–75). One patient had bilateral cysts but elected to only have one side resected. The side distribution was equal. All patients presented with a swelling and ten with pain. Two patients presented with a common peroneal nerve palsy. All patients obtained a marginal excision and histology confirmed a ganglion cyst. Patients were seen at clinic or contacted by phone to assess continued symptoms or recurrence. At mean long term follow up of 49 months (8–168), eight patients had had no recurrence. One patient postoperatively had a transient common peroneal nerve palsy. Of the four patients who had had a recurrence, one patient’s surgery is planned and another patient at 5 months post surgery is symptom free following further resection. The two remaining patients have required re-resection but have presented with further recurrence within 1 year. The common peroneal nerve palsies resolved between 6–12 weeks post surgery. A number of case reports record neurological involvement by direct epineurial involvement but this behaviour was not observed in our series. Review of the literature shows no larger series than ours. We conclude that cysts arising in this region commonly present with pain, swelling and neurology. Recurrence rate is high (33%) and further marginal resection is unlikely to lead to cure. More aggressive surgery such as joint excision or arthrodesis may then be necessary.


MBS Brewster DM Power SR Carter A Abudu R Grimer R Tillman

Aims: To establish the frequency and demographics of soft tissue sarcomas (STS) presenting in the lower limb.

Methods: Patients presenting to a tertiary referral orthopaedic oncology unit over a 10-year period were prospectively entered into a computerised database. The site of primary STS and demographic details were also recorded.

Results: 1519 STS in all body regions were treated. 1067 (70.2%) within the lower limb. 57.0% thigh, 13.0% calf, 8.2% foot and ankle, 7.7% buttock, 5.7% knee, 4.6% pelvis and 3.8% in the groin. There was a male predominance (56.2%). M:F ratio was 2.5:1 for the groin and 1.3:1 for the thigh with the other body regions approximately equal.

Conclusion: The majority of STS are found in the lower limb. In this large series there was a male predominance most marked in groin presentations.


L Foster R Reid D E Porter

Purpose: The aim of the study was to document the trends in survival from childhood osteosarcoma in Scotland using clinical data held in the Scottish Bone Tumor Registry from 1933 onwards.

Methods and Results: From 217 osteosarcoma patients identified in Scotland aged 18 and under with case notes in the BTR, 184 with non-metastatic appendicular disease were included in the analysis. Kaplan Meier curves were constructed and log rank statistics calculated for univariate analysis. Multivariate analysis was performed using the Cox regression proportional hazards model.

Epidemiological figures reflect those of other studies. The male: female ratio was 1.4: 1, most common age at diagnosis was 16 – 18 and the most common site of tumor was the distal femur, 71% of tumors occurred at the knee. 5 year and median survival were 30% and 26 months for the entire period. 5 year survival was found to have improved from 21% between 1933–1959 to 62% in 1990 – 1999. On univariate analysis the most significant factor influencing outcome was use of chemotherapy in treatment (p< 0.00005). On multivariate analysis, date of diagnosis had most influence on the hazard ratio, the greatest difference being found between diagnoses pre and post – 1980. Site of tumor was also found to be a significant factor (p=0.044). The survival from Osteosarcoma in Scotland in recent years was found to be no worse than the rest of the UK as had previously been suggested.

Conclusion: Survival from childhood osteosarcoma in Scotland has improved significantly from the 1930s to the present day. This is largely due to the introduction of effective chemotherapy protocols into the treatment regimen. These improvements reflect those seen in other countries over the same period.


R Shenoy A Pillai R Ried P Tansey

Background: Tumors and tumor-like lesions of the clavicle are uncommon and often present with a diagnostic problem. Although almost every type of tumor has been reported from this location the true incidence of primary tumors is 0.5–1%.

Materials and Methods: A retrospective review of the Scottish Bone Tumor Registry (1940–2000). All histologically confirmed lesions with minimum 5 year follow-up are included.

Results: 32 lesions were identified from the registry. The age at presentation varied from 4 years to 84 years. There were 7 myelomas, 10 lymphomas, 2 Ewing sarcomas,1 osteosarcoma, 1 chondrosarcoma, 1 Giant Cell tumor, 1 Aneurismal bone cyst, 1 chondroma, 1 unicameral bone cysts, 1 non-ossifying fibroma, and 6 eosinophilic granulomas. 3 cases presented with pathological fractures. Majority lesions involved the medial third. Malignant lesion underwent excision and adjuvant chemo-radiotherapy. The cumulative 5 year survival was 80% when adequate surgical margins were achieved. Death was usually due to soft tissue and skeletal metastasis. Benign lesions were treated with curettage and bone grafting or by partial excision of the clavicle. 3 cases of eosinophilic granulomas and the solitary chondroma required no further treatment after biopsy.

Discussion: Metastatic tumors are more common than primary tumors in this region. Among primary lesions, malignant tumors are more common than benign. All ages can be affected. The subcutaneous location of the clavicle usually aids in early diagnosis. Anatomically, the medial third was the commonest site involved. Prognosis is good if adequate surgical margins can be achieved and if there is no distal spread. Partial or total claviclectomy usually results in good functional outcomes.


A. Pillai R Shenoy R Ried P Tansey

Background: Bizarre parosteal osteochondromatous proliferation [Nora’s lesion] is a rare tumourous lesion with aggressive growth that affects primarily the small tubular bones of extremities and often recurs after excision. It is often confused with chondrosarcomas, parosteal osteosarcomas and florid reactive periostitis.

Materials and Methods: The clinical and pathological findings in eight cases of Nora’s lesion from the Scottish bone tumour registry are presented.

Results: There were eight lesions reported in the registry. (5 female & 3 male). Anatomically there was 1 metacarpal lesion, 2 proximal phalanx lesions, 3 middle phalanx lesions and 2 distal phalanx lesions. Age at presentation ranged from 25 – 65 years (mean 41y). The common mode of presentation was pain and swelling for a period of 6 months to 2 years. There was no history of trauma. Two patients were initially misdiagnosed, one as synovial chondromatosis and the other as an osteochondroma. Treatment was in the form of an excision biopsy. The recurrence rate after excision was 62.5%. 60 % of recurrences occurred within 12 mts of excision. One phalangeal lesion recurred twice after excision. There was no distal metastasis.

Discussion: Bizarre parosteal osteochondromatous proliferation is histologically composed of bony, chondroid and fibrous proliferation, with a high cellular density and bizarre chondrocytes but is devoid of cellular atypia or necrosis. It is a rare pseudotumorous lesion, with typical clinical, radiographic and histopathology findings similar to those of other benign and malignant tumours. The rarity of this lesion and the high local recurrence rate necessitate an accurate histological diagnosis and complete excision.


A. Pillai R Shenoy R Ried P Tansey

Background: Osteoid Osteomas were first described by Bergstrand (1930), and were later elaborated by Jaffe (1935). They account for 12% of all benign bone tumors. Approximately 6–8% of lesions occur in the hand, and can be extremely difficult to diagnose.

Aims: A retrospective review of osteoid osteomas from the Scottish Bone Tumor Registry is presented focusing on the unusual clinical features of lesions of the carpus and hand.

Results: 19 patients (8 male, 11 female) were identified from the registry. The mean age at presentation was 27.5 Yrs (10–56 Yrs). 78% of lesions occurred within 2nd–3rd decade of life. Pain over the involved area most noticeably at night, was the usual presentation. 21% gave history of associated trauma. Phalangeal lesions accounted for 68.4% tumors with the proximal phalanx predominating.4 lesions involved the distal phalanx. There were 3 metacarpal and 3 carpal lesions. Carpal bones involved included the Capitate (2), and the Trapezium (1). Clubbing was noticed in distal phalanx lesions. The mean time from presentation to diagnosis was 5.6 months. 9 patients were initially misdiagnosed as having either a traumatic or infective condition.3 patients required a bone scan for diagnosis. All patients underwent surgical excision, with 2 requiring bone grafting. Follow up ranged from 1–9 Yrs (mean 3Yrs). There were no instances of recurrence or spontaneous regression.

Discussion: Osteoid Osteoma is an infrequent tumor of the hand. Absence of typical pain pattern, unobtrusive radiographic features (absence of reactive bone, inapparent nidus), and variations in the histological picture make diagnosis in this region difficult. Lesions are easily misdiagnosed and successful treatment often delayed. Isotope bone scan is diagnostic and CT accurately visualizes the nidus. Awareness of these characteristics may aid early diagnosis. Surgical excision is usually curative and has excellent prognosis.


A. Pillai R Shenoy R Ried P Tansey

Introduction Ewing’s sarcoma family of tumors was first described by James Ewing in 1921. It is a rare tumor and no one center can hope to accrue sufficient numbers over a reasonable period of time to accurately review them.

Objectives A retrospective analysis of all Ewing’s sarcomas of the upper limb from the Scottish Bone Tumor registry (1940–2000), is presented. Attempts have been made to elaborate on prognostic factors, and to document improvements in survival with trends in local therapy over the study period.

Results The registry included 23 patients with Ewing’s sarcoma of the upper limb bones. Age at diagnosis ranged from 7–58 Yrs (mean −21.6 Yrs). 48% of lesions occurred in the second decade and 26 % in the third decade. Male: Female ratio was 2.8: 1. The commonest site involved was the proximal humerus (30%), followed by scapula (21%), radius (17%) and hand bones (13%).Resectable lesions underwent excision and adjuvant radio/chemo therapy. Cumulative 5 year survival for the series was 52%. Forearm and hand lesions which achieved complete excision had best results (75% five year survival). Proximal humeral lesions had 57 % survival. Scapular lesions had the worst prognosis (20% survival). Death was usually due to metastatic disease (diagnosed mean 12mts after initial presentation). Lesions presenting with pathological fractures, or having metastasis at diagnosis had extremely poor survival. There was an increasing use of surgery, and changes to chemotherapy (Euro-Ewing protocol) during the latter part of the study period. There were no toxic deaths reported.

Discussion Ewing’s sarcoma is a rare lesion. Any of the upper limb bones can be involved. Majority of lesions occur within the first 3 decades of life (87%). Survival is highly dependent on initial presentation. The key prognostic factor is the presence of detectable metastasis at diagnosis. Increased use of surgery and newer chemotherapeutic agents have decreased the local relapse rate over the period of study.


R Shenoy A Pillai R Ried P Tansey

Background Osteosarcoma is the most common bone sarcoma, and the 3rd most common malignancy in children and adolescents. It accounts for 20% of primary malignant bone tumors.

Methods A retrospective review of osteosarcomas from the Scottish National Bone Tumor Registry (1940–2000) involving the upperlimb bones is presented. Patient demography, type and location of lesions, treatment options, recurrence and survival rates, and metastasis have been analysed.

Results 75 cases were identified from the registry. Sex incidence showed a slight male preponderance with male: female ratio 1.14: 1.Age at presentation ranged from 4–88 Yrs (mean 28.44 Yrs). 46.7% sarcomas occurred in the second decade (11–20 Yrs). The humerus was the bone most frequently involved (78.6% of lesions), and the proximal humerus the commonest site (60%). The scapula was involved in 9.3% and the forearm in 8%.A rare solitary lesion of the clavicle was encountered.17% presented with pathological fractures at diagnosis. Patients typically present with dull aching pain of weeks to months. All patients underwent radiological studies and diagnostic biopsy. Treatment modalities included amputation, limb-sparing surgery, adjuvant/neoadjuvant chemotherapy and radiotherapy. The cumulative 5 year survival for the series was 32%.Death was usually due to pulmonary and skeletal metastasis, and the mean survival in such patients was 21.5 mts. Patients presenting with metastatic pulmonary disease had poor prognosis. Limb-sparing surgery with wide margins does not compromise survival. Results with custom endoprosthesis are encouraging.

Discussion Osteosarcomas require a multidisciplinary approach to diagnosis and treatment to optimise survival. During the first half of the study period amputation was the mainstay of treatment with high incidence of mortality due to metastatic disease. Recent advances in neoadjuvant/adjuvant chemotherapy have improved the ability to perform limb –sparing resections, and disease free and overall survival rates have improved. Regular, long follow-up is indicated in these patients.


SE Gwilym DJ Whitwell HP Giele CLMN Gibbons

Purpose: To assess the functional outcome of patients who pre-operatively, were known to have sciatic nerve tumour involvement and proceeded to have nerve-preserving planned marginal excision with epineurectomy.

Methods: We identified patients who had surgery between 1997 and 2004, for soft tissue sarcomas in the posterior thigh with known sciatic nerve involvement. During this period it was the practice of the senior authors (MG & HG) to apply a nerve-preserving epineurectomy approach as part of their planned marginal excision of these tumours.

The identified patients had their notes reviewed, and were contacted by post to complete a Toronto Extremity Severity Score (TESS) questionnaire to assess lower limb function in day-to-day life. Details of their presenting features, oncological work-up, surgical intervention and adjuvant therapy was established and correlated to the TESS score.

Conclusion: This study demonstrates that a careful epineurectomy can preserve sciatic nerve function and allow tumour excision with no increase in local recurrence rate. With good soft tissue cover it appears nerve function can be maintained, even in cases where adjuvant radiotherapy is indicated.


Full Access
R Shenoy A Pillai R Ried P Tansey

Background: Chondrosarcoma is the second most frequent primary malignant tumor of bone. The biologic evolution of these tumors is slow, requiring long follow up for meaningful survival analysis.

Methods: The clinicopathologic profiles of 84 (41 male, 45 female/M: F, 1:1.09) chondrosarcomas of the upper limb from the Scottish Bone Tumor Registry (1940–2000) are presented.

Results: The mean age at presentation was 54.8Yrs (range 12–85yrs).The proximal humerus was the most frequent anatomical site (30.2%).21% lesions involved the scapula, and 34% small bones of the hand. Local pain was the most frequently reported initial symptom. All patients were followed up for a minimum 60 mts. Radiographically; chondrosarcomas had a characteristic appearance of bone expansion and cortical thickening. The cumulative 5 year survival was 82.5%. Local recurrence developed in19.7 % (mean 40 mts after initial presentation), and distal metastasis in 16.2%.Hand tumors rarely had metastasis. Tumor breach at time of surgery increased risk of local recurrence. Histological grade was an important factor in predictor of local recurrence and metastasis.

Discussion: Chondrosarcomas are highly diverse tumors ranging from slow growing non- metastasizing lesions to highly aggressive metastasizing sarcomas. With adequate initial surgical intervention, chondrosarcoma is primarily a local disease with a low metastatic rate. Hand lesions have best prognosis.


A. Pillai R Shenoy R Ried P Tansey

Introduction: Types of cancer occurring in children are very different from those occurring in adults. Reliable data on incidence and mortality of childhood cancers is sparse.

Methods: A review of all primary malignant bone tumors in children (0–14 Yrs) from the Scottish National Bone Tumor Registry (1940–2000) is presented. Epidemiology, clinical presentation, pathology, radiological characteristics, treatment options, recurrence rates, geographic distribution and incidence are discussed.

Results: Excluding myelomas and lymphomas, 154 patients were identified. 122 (80.2%) lesions were benign, and 30 (19.7%) malignant. There were 20 osteosarcomas (66%), 8 Ewing’s sarcomas (26%), 1 chondrosarcoma and 1 fibrosarcoma.

Osteosarcoma – Age at presentation ranged from 4–14 Yrs (mean 10.3Yrs). 70 % involved 10–14 Yrs. Male: Female incidence was 1.5:1. 75% of lesions involved the proximal humerus.15 % presented with pathological fractures. The mean cumulative 5 year survival was 20%. Death was usually due to pulmonary metastasis.65% had pulmonary metastasis at a mean 6.3 mts after diagnosis. Mean survival in these patients was 14mts. Survival was superior with adjuvant chemotherapy and wide excision.

Ewing’s Sarcomas- Age at presentation ranged from 7–14 (mean 11.2Yrs).71.4% involved 10–14Yrs. Male: Female was 1.6:1. 62.5% lesions involved the humerus and 25 % the radius and 12.5% the scapula. The mean cumulative 5 year survival was 37.5%.Death was due to pulmonary or skeletal metastasis (mean 21.5mts). All patients had radiotherapy and chemotherapy.

Chondrosarcoma- A rare low-grade chondrosarcoma of the proximal humerus was encountered. Excision and grafting yielded good results.

Discussion: Majority of bone lesions in this age group are benign. Osteosarcomas and Ewing’s sarcomas predominate among the malignant (93%).The peak incidence occurs with adolescent growth spurt. Mean age is lower for osteosarcomas, and the sex incidence for both show male preponderance. Survival rates for Ewing’s was higher than for osteosarcomas. Pulmonary involvement at presentation had worst prognosis.


R Shenoy A Pillai R Ried P Tansey

Introduction: Musculoskeletal tumours and lesions resembling tumours present exceptionally difficult diagnostic and treatment problems in children. Presenting symptoms are usually a poor guide to diagnosis, and are often misleading.

Methods: A review of benign bone lesions of the upper limb in the peadiatric age group (0–14 yrs) from the Scottish Bone Tumour Registry is presented.

Results: Excluding myelomas and lymphomas, the registry included 154 lesions. 122 (80.2%) were benign including, 25 unicameral bone cysts, 22 aneurysmal bone cysts, 31 chondromas, 15 osteochondromas, 12 diaphyseal aclasis, 7 osteoidosteomas, 2 chondroblastomas, 2 nonossifying fibromas, and 1 each of giant cell tumour, eosinophilic granuloma and chondromyxoid fibroma.

Unicameral cysts- Age at presentation ranged from 3–14 yrs (mean 9.4).Male: Female incidence was 7.3:1. 92% involved the proximal humerus. 88 % presented with fracture. Recurrence rate after curettage was 20% at a mean of 10.8 mts.

Aneurysmal cysts – Age at presentation ranged from 5–14 yrs (mean 9.3). 55% involved the proximal humerus, and 20% hand bones. 45% presented with fracture. Recurrance rate after curettage was 31.8% at a mean of 15.1mts.

Chondromas- Age at presentation ranged from 3–14 yrs (mean 10.4).20 lesions were solitary and 11 multiple. Among solitary lesions, 16 were central (75% hand) and 4 parosteal.

Osteochondromas- Age at presentation ranged from 1–14 yrs (mean 10.1).Male: female ratio was 2.75:1. 53.3% involved the proximal humerus.

Osteoid Osteoma- Age at presentation ranged from 5–13 yrs (mean 10.14). Male: female ratio was 1:6. 42% involved the hand.

Discussion: Benign tumours compose majority of bone neoplasms in this age group. Unicameral and aneurysmal cysts, along with enchondromas were most frequent. Although the age at presentation shows variations with tumour type, the incidence seems to peak at 9–10 Yrs. Careful analysis of the clinical presentation, radiological characteristics and histology are required to distinguish them from malignant lesions.


E Sibly VP Sumathi RJ Grimer SR Carter RM Tillman A Abudu

Myxoid liposarcoma (MLS) is an unusual type of soft tissue sarcoma as it tends to metastasize frequently to sites other than the lungs. This study was aimed to investigate the natural history of patients with MLS to try and identify prognostic factors which could help predict outcome and aid earlier detection of metastases.

Data was prospectively collected from patient notes and analysed retrospectively. Prognostic factors and metastatic pattern were examined using Kaplan-Meier curves. There were 124 patients with MLS, aged between 28 and 93, the median size of the tumours was 12cm and the most common site was the thigh. Following treatment with excision and radiotherapy the 5yr survival was 65%. Survival was related to younger age (p=0.010) and proximal site (p=0.003) and was also related to the % round cell component of the tumour but was not related to either size or depth of the tumour. Site and margins of excision were significant prognostic factors for local recurrence of disease. 32% of patients developed metastases, of whom 18 cases (46.2%) developed pulmonary metastases and 21 (53.8%) developed extra pulmonary metastases. The sites of these varied hugely and was not significantly related to the site or size of the primary tumour. There was no difference in time to develop metastases or in overall survival between the two groups. Median survival following metastases was 24 months.

Although MLS has an unusual pattern of metastases the site of metastases does not predict a better or worse outcome. Intensive follow up for extraskeletal metastases is probably not justified until they become symptomatic.


J Dhaliwal RJ Grimer SR Carter RM Tillman A Abudu

Aim: To identify prognostic for patients who develop local recurrence after initial attempted curative treatment for a soft tissue sarcoma (STS).

Method: All patients who developed a local recurrence (LR) after initial primary treatment of a STS were identified from a prospective database. Their management and outcome were analysed to find prognostic factors.

Results: 178 patients were identified. They had a median age at original diagnosis of 53 and 102 of the patients had high grade tumours, 50 intermediate grade and 23 low grade. The median time to LR was 14 months but extended up to 11.5 years. 47 of the patients developed metastases either before or synchronously with the LR. In these patients the median survival was 20 months with only 4% surviving to 5 years. In the 131 patients who did not have identifiable metastases at the time of diagnosis, 74 subsequently developed metastases at a median time of 12 months following the development of LR.

The median survival for patients without metastases at the time of LR was 3 years with a 31% survival at 10 years. The most important prognostic factor in this group was grade with low grade tumours having a much better outlook (70% survival at 10 years) than intermediate or high grade tumours (24% at 10 years). Complete control of the first local recurrence could not be shown to be a prognostic factor.

Conclusion: Local recurrence has a poor prognosis but this is because it frequently arises in patients who have other bad prognostic factors. Whilst obtaining local control is important, overall survival is poor, but not as bad for those patients who develop metastases.


Full Access
A K Singh S A Murray

Background: Paget’s disease of the sacrum is rare. A monostotic lesion in the sacrum is reported. A case with an unusual presentation is discussed.

Introduction: A 53 years old man was referred to our unit with a 5–6 months history of abdomen discomfort and tenesmus.

He had a history of low back pain and was noted to have an area of increasing numbness over the left buttock. A prominence of the left sacroiliac region was noticed and on rectal examination a bony hard mass was palpable posteriorly.

A plain x-ray of the pelvis showed a gross expansion and enlargement of the sacrum with lucent area and widespread new bone formation.

Biochemical test revealed a raised alkaline phosphatase level.

A MRI scan reported a large tumour arising from the sacrum. with a differential of chordoma, paget’s sarcoma or an osteochondroma.

In addition a bone scan reported raised uptake in the pelvis.

An open incision biopsy was performed and the histology report was consistent with appearance of paget’s disease with no evidence of sarcoma.

Interestingly the patient symptoms improved after the biopsy. He was commenced on biphosphonates. A surveillance scan is to be performed in due course.

Conclusion: This case was unusual in terms of clinical presentation and location.

Furthermore even the most sophisticated imaging modalities may fail to establish the diagnosis and biopsy is then necessary. This should always be performed in specialized centers, in order to minimise complications.


M Abou-Shameh R U Ashford J L Cruickshank A Rao

Bone tumours are not common in the bones of the feet. We reviewed 10 years of referrals to the Leeds regional bone tumour registry between 1990 and 1999 which revealed twenty such tumours accounting for 5% of the total number of 341 bone tumours.

The mean age of the patients was 32 years (range 2 yrs to 80 yrs).

Men were affected more commonly than women (60% versus 40%).

40% affected the tarsal bones, 25% affected the hind foot, and 35 % affected the small tubular bones of the foot.

80% of tumours were benign. Malignant tumours accounted for only 20 % of all foot tumours and of these, 95% were primary tumours and only 5 % were metastases. Malignant tumours were found more frequently in the older population mean age (50 years).

Bone tumour registries offer a reliable source of data to study rare neoplasms in a large population group.


Full Access
G S Nandhara L Babu A B Y Ng A S Paul

Purpose: Case to highlight the difficulties and delays in diagnosing pelvic soft tissue tumours.

Introduction: A 32 year old female presented with long standing lower back pain. She had a history of a road traffic accident four years prior which lead to a splenectomy. Over the next few years she had intermittent episodes of increasing pain in the lower back, groin and right leg. These symptoms were attributed to the RTA and she was given a course of physiotherapy.

There were no focal neurological signs and lumbar spine movements were normal. However, she did have some pain inhibition in her proximal muscles and difficulty weight bearing in her leg.

Lumbar spine x-rays showed grade II spondylolytic spondylolisthesis at L5/S1. MR scan of the lumbar spine confirmed this with some facet joint degeneration. She was sent back for more physiotherapy.

Six months later she presented with increasing pain in the right hip and a lump in the right groin. Subsequent MR scan showed a large 20cm x 15cm x 10cm lobulated soft tissue mass within the right obturator space extending through the foramen to lie in the adductor space with infiltration into right hip joint. She had a radical resection but later developed lung metastases.

Conclusion: This case highlights the difficulties in diagnosing pelvic soft tissue tumours especially with lower back pain. We should have a high index of suspicion in all young patients who present with intermittent flare up of groin/pelvic pain and no sign of inflammatory pathology. Once cutaneous signs appear it is often too late.


S Bandi M K Sayana E Ahmed

Objective: To report a case of non-obstructive urinary retention secondary to cord compression due to metastases from undiagnosed carcinoma of prostate in a middle aged patient. This is the first case to be reported of its kind.

Case Report: A 58-year old brick layer, presented with urinary retention with overflow incontinence was referred by GP to A& E. No obstruction was felt during catheterisation and residual urine of 1.2 litres was drained. He also had dull low back pain since 5–6 weeks that was relieved by simple analgesia and he was able to work normally. He had no other symptoms or significant past medical history. Clinical examination including digital rectal examination (DRE) was normal. Laboratory investigations were normal except a rise in Alkaline phosphatase(194U/L) and ESR (43 mm/hr). X-rays of his spine were normal. MRI scan of the spine showed multiple metastatic lesions, bilateral end plate fractures and loss of vertebral body height of D12 with bulging of posterior vertebral body wall causing extradural compression of the conus.

An urgent D12 decompression and biopsy of D12 was done with D10-L2 instrumentation. PSA levels were > 500ng/ml.Histopathology showed moderately to poorly differentiated adenocarcinoma with a cribriform pattern. Immunohistochemistry showed a strong staining for PSA consistent with metastatic adenocarcinoma of the prostate. Post-operatively, he regained bladder control and was referred to oncologists for further management.

Conclusion: Urinary retention may be the only presenting symptom of spinal cord compression due to metastasis from prostate cancer. High index of suspicion of prostate cancer in middle-aged and elderly male patients with urinary retention, especially when associated with back pain of any severity, even though prostate is normal on DRE is needed. PSA in patients complaining of low back pain who are at high risk for prostate cancer is recommended, even though DRE is normal.


L Tiessen U Da-Silva A Abudu RJ Grimer RM Tillman SR Carter

Large benign lytic lesions of the proximal femur present a significant risk of pathological fractures. We report our experience of treating 9 consecutive patients with such defects treated with curettage and fibula strut grafting without supplementary osteosynthesis to evaluate the outcome of this type of reconstruction..

The mean age at the time of diagnosis was 13 years (8–21). Follow up ranged from 2 to 215 months (median 15). Histological diagnosis was fibrous dysplasia in 10 patients and unicameral cyst in 2. All the patients were at risk of pathological fracture. None of the patients developed pathological fracture after surgery and the lesions consolidated fully within one year. Local recurrence occurred in one patient (8%). Minor donor site complications occurred four patients.

All the patients were able to fully weight usually within 3 months of surgery.

At the time of review all but one patient were completely asymptomatic and fully weight bearing. The only symptomatic patient was the patient with local recurrence which has recently been treated.

We conclude that fibula strut graft is a good method of reconstruction of cystic defects in the proximal femut. It prevents pathological fracture, allows mechanical reinforcement of the lesion and delivers biological tissue allowing early consolidation of the defect.


G S Nandhara L Babu A B Y Ng A S Paul

Purpose: Many cases of Alveolar Soft Part Sarcoma have been reported on the trunk or head and neck region; we present two cases of the tumour in the soft tissues of the extremities.

Case Series: Alveolar Soft Part Sarcoma is a very rare tumour representing only 0.2–1 percent of soft tissue sarcomas. Patients commonly present with distant metastases both at the time of diagnosis and late in the course of disease. Many of the reported cases involve the trunk or head and neck region, especially around the orbit.

We present cases of Alveolar Soft Part Sarcoma, one in the upper limb the other in the lower limb, in two young females. Both were treated in the same centre by the same consultant.

The first is the case of a 33 year old female with a swelling in the right triceps present for 7 months before presentation to our centre. The time between diagnosis of possible tumour and biopsy was less than a month. Biopsy revealed a trojani grade 2 tumour and there were no metastases prior to wide excision. She received radiotherapy and has no metastases on follow up. Post therapy she is left with neurological pain and a rash on her face after radiotherapy.

The second case is that of a 25 year old female presenting, with a swelling in the right thigh, after 12 months including a 6 month history of shortness of breath. She had a family history of pancreatic cancer. Biopsy revealed a trojani grade 3 tumour and imaging revealed lung metastases. She went on to have chemotherapy. She later developed bone metastases.

Conclusion: Alveolar Soft Part Sarcoma must be suspected in all tumours and there aggressive nature must be realised.


L Babu G Nandhara K Baskaran F Adeyemo R Suneja A Paul

Background – Limb salvage surgeries for soft tissue sarcomas (STS) leads to significant amount of morbidity and fear psychosis among the affected individual. We looked into the potential complications and its implications.

Patients & Methods – Retrospective review of 96 patients over a period of 5 years from 1999 to 2004 with a minimum follow up of 8 months. Complete data of every patient was reviewed with particular emphasis on post op complications.

Results – 72 patients had STS in their lower limbs while the rest had in the upper limbs. 53 tumours were either at the level of knee or above the knee while 19 were found below the knee. The anterior compartment of the thigh was the most common site (13) with Vastus Lateralis being the commonly involved muscle. Liposarcoma was the commonest tumour (22) followed by Leiomyosarcoma (19), Fibro sarcoma (14), Synovial Sarcoma (12), Rhabdomyosarcoma (10), Histiocytoma (9) and other rare sarcomas. 61 patients had wide local excision, 17 had radical excision and 12 had marginal excision. 6 patients had palliative treatment only due to extensive metastasis (mets). 38 patients had post op radiotherapy. The average interval between presentation and definitive treatment was 28 days. 22 of the 71 patients (31 %) with no mets pre op. developed mets during follow up. The commonest problem in the post op period is inadequate skin cover which required skin grafting in 17 cases and flap cover in 3. Three of the skin grafts got necrosed due to radiotherapy. Local recurrence was the next most common complication (12 patients) along with equal number of patients with lymphaedema. Seroma/Haematoma was noted in 8 patients but none required drainage. There were 7 cases of superficial infection and one deep infection. Fixed Flexion Deformity at knee of > 10 0 was noted in 5 cases. Intractable neurological pain was noted in 3 cases involving the upper limb and one involving the lower limb. 3 developed skin rashes after radiotherapy. 2 had ulnar nerve palsy and one had foot drop. DVT occurred in 3 patients. Stump neuroma created problems in 2 cases and 2 patients ended up with below knee amputation. Another notable feature was the fear psychosis among the patients about benign swellings that were present in other parts of their body either before or after surgery which resulted in 11 surgeries but none proved to be malignant. As on 31-3-2005, 39 were dead and the rest were alive. The average life span of the patients who died from the time of confirmed diagnosis was 23 months.

Discussion – There is a plethora of complications that can occur following extensive resection of huge tumours in the extremities. This may involve sacrificing neuro-vascular structures to achieve adequate clearance. In spite of this, there is evidence of frequent local recurrences and distant metastatic spread. There is still some lack of awareness among the public about innocuous looking swellings and they present late with distant metastasis when the prognosis becomes poor.

Conclusion –

Significant complications can occur after sarcoma surgeries.

Patient should be adequately informed and educated about the complications

Surgeon should properly plan his surgery liaising with other specialities

Radical excision offers no significant advantage over wide local excision followed by radiotherapy.


RK Trehan I Packham P Mehrotra G Marsh

Malignant change in existing benign enchondroma of phalanx of hand to chondrosarcoma of hand is extremely rare. Books suggest that chondrosarcoma does not arise in small bones of hands and feet although in literature few cases have been reported but not described comprehensively.

We report a rare case of chondrosarcoma in distal phalanx of ring finger in a 75- year old healthy female who had cystic lesion for past 25 years with recurrent fractures. Patient came to us with severe pain and tender, hard swelling of distal phalanx of left ring finger. X ray showed pronounced expansion of the terminal phalanx surrounded partially by a shell of bone, with focal spotty calcification with in the lesion. Because of sudden increase in size and pain of swelling, an amputation was performed at distal inter phalangeal joint. Histopathology showed grade II myxoid chondrosarcoma with pre-existing enchondroma. Wound healed nicely. Extensive investigation in form of CT chest and bone scan did not show any metastasis. Five year follow up did not show any local recurrence or distant metastasis.

Clinical suspicion should be aroused in an older individual with a previously relatively quiescent lesion that becomes larger and painful. Usually course of the tumour is slow and metastasis to lungs is late. Treatment of choice is disarticulation a joint proximal to lesion. Prognosis is good if metastasis has not occurred. Once diagnosis is made, patient should be investigated to look for any possible metastasis and must be regularly followed up. A literature review and discussion of salient diagnostic and treatment issues is included.


S Bandi JS Narreddy CR Birudavolu P Ravishankar VSK Reddy SV Sagar

Objective: To report the use of a pedicled patellar transplant (d’ Aubigne procedure) in the reconstruction of femoral condyle for unicondylar giant cell tumours, in developing countries where facilities for custom made prostheses are not widely available.

Case Report: A 28 year old male presented with 5 month history of left knee joint swelling and pain and 1 month history of inability to walk. X-ray showed eccentric, expansile lytic lesion of the lateral femoral condyle associated with a pathological fracture of the subchondral bone. A diagnosis of Enniking’s stage-III Giant cell tumour was made based on the x-ray and histopathology findings. Due to the associated subchondral fracture, joint reconstruction using custom made prosthesis was considered as an ideal option. But, as this prosthesis was not available, d’ Aubigne procedure was considered as an alternative, in order to preserve the joint. Femoral condyle was removed “en bloc” with the tumour. Patella was prepared with intact vastus lateralis and fixed in continuity and in level with the medial condyle. Gap between the patella and femoral shaft was filled by combined cancellous and cortical grafts from iliac crest and tibia. Post operative course was uneventful. After a follow up of 2 years there was no recurrence and the range of flexion was 90° without any instability and pain.

Conclusion: In patients with unicondylar giant cell tumours with subchondral fractures, arthrodesis can be avoided and the joint can be preserved using pedicled patellar transfer, when arthroplasty can not be carried out.


L Babu G Nandhara K Baskaran P Kumar A Ng A Paul

Background: To look into the incidence of lymphatic spread in Soft Tissue Sarcomas (STS) of the extremities and its relevance to the patient’s prognosis.

Patients & Methods: Retrospective review of 96 patients over a period of 5 years from 1999 to 2004 with a minimum follow up of 8 months. Complete data of every patient was reviewed with particular emphasis on lymph node and distant metastasis. All the patients were seen by one consultant and the histology reports were given by one Pathologist. 2 consultant radiologists were also involved in giving reports.

Results: There were 39 males and 57 females with an average age of 51 years. The average duration of swelling at presentation was 6 months. There was a strong family history of cancer in first degree relatives in 23 patients (24%). Liposarcoma was the commonest tumour (22) followed by Leiomyosarcoma (19), Fibro sarcoma (14), Synovial Sarcoma (12), Rhabdomyosarcoma (10), Histiocytoma (9) and other rare sarcomas. The Trojani grade of the tumours was Grade 1 = 36, Grade 2 = 39 & Grade 3 = 21. No metastasis (mets) were found during pre op. screening in 71 patients (74%) while 11 (12%) had lung mets, 9 (10 %) had lymph node involvement and 5 had liver involvement (4 %). 4 had multiple organ involvement on presentation. All except 6 patients had either wide local or radical excision of the tumour. The average interval between presentation and definitive treatment was 28 days. 9 of the patients with lymph node mets underwent nodal clearance during primary surgery. 2 turned out to be reactive hyperplasia while 7 proved to be malignant. 22 of the 71 patients (31 %) with no mets pre op. developed mets during follow up at an average duration of 11 months (11 to lungs, 8 to regional lymph nodes, 2 to liver and one to bone. 4 patients had multiple mets) In addition to this, there was local recurrence in 12 patients of whom 9 had incomplete excision during primary surgery. Of the total 15 patients who had proven lymph node mets, 5 came from Rhabdomyosarcoma, 4 from Leiomyosarcoma, 3 each from Lipo & Synovial sarcoma. The average life span in patients with lymph node involvement was 13 months in total when compared to 31 months for others. As on 31-3-2005, 39 were dead and the rest were alive. The average life span of the patients who died from the time of confirmed diagnosis was 23 months. The average life span for Rhabdomyosarcoma was 8 months, Histiocytoma was 12 months, Liposarcoma was 19 months, Leiomyosarcoma was 28 months and Synovial sarcoma was 36 months. Patients with Trojani grade 3 STS died at an average of 9 months when compared to 38 months for grade 1.

Discussion: There is a 16% spread to regional lymph nodes. It appears that lymph node involvement is indicative of micrometastatic disease elsewhere. Excision of the lymph nodes during primary surgery did not improve the life expectancy.

Conclusion:

Lymph node involvement is a poor prognostic sign

While removal of clinically suspicious lymph nodes is reasonable, there appears to be little justification for treating clinically uninvolved draining regional lymph nodes

Therapeutic lymph node dissection might be indicated as part of the palliative management

The presence of regional lymph node metastasis at any time should be interpreted as an expression of systemic tumour spread and treated palliatively only.


RK Trehan JHH Chan G Marsh

Giant cell tumour of tendon sheath is usually benign in nature but their tendency to recur is well known, this cause problems for surgeons and there is always a puzzle in determining the appropriate therapy. This study was done to highlight characteristics, differential diagnosis and current options of treatment for giant cell tumour of tendon sheath.

We report two cases treated at our hospital. Both are females, one of 24 years while other was 65 years at the time of diagnosis. First patient had incidental associated benign teratoma of ovary as well. One tumour was of thumb in non dominant hand while in older patient it was at distal interphalangeal joint of ring finger in dominant hand. Both presented with history of slowly growing painful swelling, they were treated with local excision but in both patients there was an aggressive local recurrence. Revision surgery was performed with wider local excision. There was no recurrence this time.

Giant cell tumour of tendon sheath is mostly benign condition but need to be differentiated from serious conditions like clear cell sarcoma. Therapy of choice is local excision. Wider excision after surgery should be reconsidered where microscopic examination reveals a lesion with characteristics suggestive of potential aggressive behaviour. A literature review and discussion of salient diagnostic and treatment issues is included.


PJ Boscainos HP Giele MA McNally CLMH Gibbons NA Athanasou

We are presenting the outcome of a young adult with extensive epithelioid hemangioendothelioma of the femur treated with wide excision and vascularised fibular graft.

An 18-year-old builder was referred with an aggressive primary bone tumor of the right femur. Initial staging showed no evidence of distant disease but tumor confined to a 26.5cm diaphyseal segment of the femoral shaft. The patient’s pre-operative Oxford knee score was 28 and the AKSS scores were 74 (observational) and 65 (functional). True cut open biopsy confirmed low grade angiosarcoma. The patient underwent a wide excision of the lesion through a lateral approach leaving a generous cuff of bone and muscle tissue around the tumor. Clear resection margins were assessed intraoperatively. Histologically, the tumor was found to be epithelioid hemangioendothelioma. The 29.5cm defect was filled with a vascularised bone graft of the ipsilateral fibula. The graft was secured with a 22-hole DCS bridging plate and screws at both ends. Intraoperative knee range of motion was from 0 to 125 degrees without recurvatum and graft movement.

The patient had an unremarkable recovery. At the latest follow-up, one year after his operation, the patient had made an excellent functional recovery with non-symptomatic full weight bearing and had also returned to his work as a builder. He demonstrated a knee range of motion of 0 to 115 with a slight genu varum. The patient’s post-operative Oxford knee score was 40 and the AKSS scores were 70 (observational) and 90 (functional). Radiographs showed excellent union at the distal aspect of the graft and a healing stress fracture of the fibula graft at the proximal aspect.

Vascularized fibular graft with plating is a safe reconstruction limb salvage option for defects of long bones after tumor resection.


V Gowda S Godey A P Thomas A Abudu

Metachronous multifocal osteosarcoma (MFOS) is a rare form of osteosarcoma manifested by one or more new tumors developing after the initial treatment of primary osteosarcoma. We present a 61 year old Asian male who was referred with 10 week history of pain and discomfort around his left shoulder and low back pain. In 1968, he received radiotherapy followed by disarticulation of left hip for an osteosarcoma of lower end of left femur complicated with pathological fracture. He did not show any clinical features suggestive of recurrence of disease since then until he presented again in February 2005. CT scan of left scapula has revealed extensive osteosarcoma of lower part of scapula, involving subscapularis and infraspinatus muscles. An MRI scan of whole spine has shown evidence of multiple lesions in sacrum, ilium and acetabulum. A core biopsy from scapula has confirmed the histological diagnosis as high grade osteoblastic osteosarcoma. Slides from 1968 were reviewed in the context of recent recurrence and were consistent with features of intermediate grade fibroblastic osteosarcoma. He is currently undergoing chemotherapy prior to planning definitive treatment as there is evidence in the literature that MFOS is a potentially curable condition.


B Komarasamy J Braybrook V Lenin babu

Objective: We report an unusual presentation of telangiectatic osteosarcoma of distal femur in a preadolescent boy.

Methods: A 9 year old boy fell down heavily while he was on holiday and fractured his distal femur. He was given above knee plaster locally and then transferred him to hospital where he lives normally. He developed increasing pain over next two weeks over fracture site (4 weeks after injury) and was reviewed in clinic. X ray of his femur showed permeative pattern of bone destruction with new bone formation. Subsequent biopsy of his lesion confirmed telangiectatic osteosarcoma. His subsequent MRI scan of thigh and CT scan of his chest showed pulmonary metastasis and dissemination of tumour to proximal femur. He never noticed any pain, discomfort or swelling before fracture and until four weeks after fracture apart from symptoms of fracture. Retrospective review of his x ray which was taken at the time of fracture demonstrated not very obvious osteolytic lesion in distal femur.

Conclusion: Telangiectatic osteosarcoma is a rare subtype of osteosarcoma and represents nearly 2% of all osteosarcomas. The incidence peaks in early to mid-adolescence and is not commonly encountered in very young and preadolescent patients.

Osteosarcoma usually presents with pain at night and precedes tumour by weeks or months. Some times there may be only a history of a tired feeling, a slight limp or a history of trauma.

Our case did not have any symptoms at all until two weeks before the presentation. The fracture made the tumour extra compartmental and led to metastasis and poor prognosis. We should always aware of this possibility of rare presentation when we see a preadolescent patient with increasing pain following fracture.


P Vashishtha H Sharma V Paode MJ Jane R Reid

We describe a 65 year old gentleman presented with a three month history of painful lump in the right forearm which was subsequently confirmed to be osteosarcomatous degeneration in the Paget’s disease of the radius.

A 65 year old gentleman presented with a three month history of painful lump in the right forearm with overlying redness thought by the patient to be the result of recent sun exposure. On physical examination, there was an 8 x 10 cm sized mass over the radial aspect of the right forearm. The mass was soft to firm, mildly tender to palpation, fixed to bone and deep-seated. There was erythema with increased warmth over the area of the mass. There was significant restriction of forearm supination and pronation. Neurovascular examination was normal. Chest x-ray was normal. Plain x-ray of the affected forearm revealed a mixed pattern (both sclerotic and lytic appearance) affecting the entire diaphyseal portion of the radius with soft tissue extension in the mid-shaft. There were alterations in the trabecular pattern of the bone, thickened cortices, encroachment of the medullary space and an increase in the size and deformity of the entire length of the radius with cortical destruction sparing the ulna. Bone scan showed multiple hot foci with an increase uptake in the sacrum, left hemipelvis, L3 vertebra and intensely increased uptake over the right radius. On the 10th day of presentation, an open incisional biopsy was done. Microscopy showed a high grade sarcomatous tumour with areas of osteoid formation. There was evidence of vascular invasion. The presence of preexisting Paget’s disease of bone was confirmed in the specimen. An above elbow amputation was done 4 weeks from the date of biopsy and after full staging. The patient died 16 months with multiple metastases from the date of diagnosis.

Any patient with Paget’s disease who develops new pain in a previously pain-free area of Paget’s disease, or worsening of pain, or a painful progressive mass or a lytic area in sclerotic Paget’s bone should be evaluated for possible sarcomatous degeneration.


H Sharma P Vashishtha V Paode MJ Jane R Reid

Fourteen cases of pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS) of the foot and ankle (between January 1957 and December 1999) accrued from Scottish bone tumor registry are presented with an average follow-up of 4.6 years aimed to analyse the clinical, radiological and histopathological features in order to investigate the clinical behaviour of PVNS in the foot and ankle, and to determine the factors influencing recurrence. The mean age was 26.4 years (range, 8 to 52 years). There were eight females and six males. The mean delay in presentation was 10.3 months. The anatomical sites were foot phalanges (n=2), tarso-metatarsal area (n=3) and hindfoot (n=9). Hindfoot cases comprised of 6 extra-articular soft tissue swelling around the ankle, two affecting the ankle joint and one involving the subtalar joint. There were eight (57.1%) cases presented with painless lump, five (35.7%) patients with painful lumps and one case with a lump associated with toe deformity. The clinical suspicion were ganglion, gout, soft tissue swelling (? tumour) and exostosis. Peri-articular tissue invasion and cortical infiltration was found in one third on plain films. CT scan showed multiple lytic lesions and MRI scan findings were consistent with extensive low signal soft tissue hypertrophy and bone erosion, two of which were suspected with synovial sarcoma. Excision of the lump was done in 4 cases with a complete recovery. Foot phalangeal PVNS were treated with toe amputation through metatarsophalangeal joint and no cases had recurrence of the lesion. There were two recurrences affecting the ankle and the subtalar joint. Recurrent ankle PVNS was treated with re-exploration, open synovectomy, curettage of talar cyst and autogenous bone grafting. The second recurrent case involving subtalar joint was treated with re-excision and curettage. Both recurred cases were primarily treated with intralesional excision for their diffuse variety. There were no recurrences in the nodular variety. Complete recovery was achieved in 85.7% case (12/14). A high index of suspicion for PVNS should be observed for cases presenting with a painless or painful mass in the foot and ankle region. Complete recovery can be achieved in the majority by complete excision. Toe amputation may be considered for foot phalangeal PVNS.


Full Access
H Sharma P Vashishtha V Paode MJ Jane R Reid

Ten cases of histologically proven chondromyxoid fibroma (CMF) of the Foot and Ankle with a mean follow-up of 6.1 years were reviewed. The mean age was 19 years (12.8 for skeletally immature and 25.2 for remaining skeletally mature patients). There were 6 males and 4 females. There were 5 phalangeal (3-proximal, 1-middle and 1-terminal phalanx), 3 metatarsal, 1 tarsal affecting body of os calcis and one case of distal tibial involvement. The mean delay in presentation was 16.7 months. The common modes of presentation were pain only (n=4), painful lump (n=4) and painless lump (n=2). Typical x-ray finding was an expansile, lobulated, cystic metaphyeal lesion. Cortical erosion was documented in 50% patients. Histology confirmed by several pathologists due to difficulty in diagnosis. There were two atypical CMF. In four cases, curettage alone was carried out, while 5 underwent curettage along with autogenous bone grafting. One case of distal phalangeal CMF had primary toe amputation. Postoperatively, calcaneal CMF had infection (treated with wound debridement and re-curettage). Two cases observed recurrences after 9 and 16 months from their initial operation. Both of them were male, had preliminary proximal phalangeal CMF, showed to have cortical erosion and were treated with curettage only. Re-curettage was done for one, while toe amputation through the metatarsal neck was performed for another recurrence. Foot phalangeal CMF which were initially treated with curettage only should be kept under close follow-up as we observed 20% recurrence rate within two year period. Cases with cortical erosion should be supplemented with autogenous bone grafting.


V Paode P Vashishtha H Sharma MJ Jane R Reid

A 68 year old lady presented with one year history of painful right heel. She noticed slowly growing swelling resulting in broadening of the heel and difficulty in putting on her shoe-wear for a period of two months. On physical examination, there was a diffuse swelling over the posterior aspect of the right heel. The mass was firm to hard, mildly tender on palpation, fixed to bone and deep-seated. There was no erythema with increased warmth over the area of the mass. Plain x-ray of the affected heel revealed a pathological avulsion fracture of the posterosuperior corner of the calcaneus with typical Pagetoid features in the form of diffuse cortical thickening, coarsened trabeculae, loss of corticotrabecular differentiation and poorly demarcated osteolytic destruction. The lateral radiograph of the left heel showed normal radiological appearance of the os calcis. Chest x-ray was normal. The histological examination showed malignant fibrous histiocytoma characterised by the abundance of pleomorphic cells, spindle cells, lipid containing macrophages and touton type giant cells. The microvascular invasion and amount of mitosis declared the tumour as a high grade anaplastic, pleomorphic tumour. A below knee amputation was done approximately 3 weeks from the date of biopsy and after full staging. The patient died after surviving for a period of 6 years and 8 months from the date of biopsy. It is important to recognise the fact that an avulsion fracture can be pathological in nature and secondary to Paget’s sarcoma in patients with Paget’s disease. This case highlights that a high index of suspicion should be observed in patients presenting with a chronic heel pain who are shown to have pre-existing Paget’s disease on radiological grounds and who may have an avulsion fracture or other localising signs of underlying sarcomatous degeneration.


F Adeyemo L. Babu R. Suneja D. Ellis

Introduction: Pathological fracture of the clavicle is not such a rare condition. By definition the fracture occurs either without or with minimal trauma. We present a case of pathological fracture where there was a definite history of trauma; clouding the true malignant diagnosis.

Case Report: A 73 year old man first presented to the Accident & Emergency Dept. of our hospital with a history of having fallen on to his left shoulder after throwing a piece of concrete, and to have developed swelling and pain around the shoulder immediately following the fall. On examination the main findings were swelling and bony tenderness over the proximal clavicle and inability to use his left shoulder due to pain. X-ray showed a fracture at the junction between the proximal 1/3 and distal 2/3 of the left clavicle, and he was given a broad arm sling for support and a one week appointment for review in the fracture clinic.

Two clinic appointments later he was still complaining of pain. X-rays taken at that time showed what appeared to be some evidence of callus formation at the fracture site. Six weeks later he had clinical and radiological signs of what appeared to be “huge callus formation”. He was given a 3 month appointment for what was expected to be a final review.

Before his next fracture clinic appointment, however, he became jaundiced and complained about this to his GP who felt it was obstructive jaundice and referred him to the physicians who admitted him to the hospital, and began to investigate him as to the cause of the jaundice. These investigations included an Ultrasound Scan of the abdomen which showed a bulky head of pancreas with biliary and pancreatic ductal dilatation; and a CT scan of the upper abdomen which showed the presence of a cystic mass within the caudate lobe of the liver. Soft tissue vascular encasement around the portal vein and hepatic artery were reported as in keeping with malignant infiltration. Extensive tumour was present within the retroperitoneum involving local vascular structures.

He came down to the fracture clinic for his next clinic appointment from the ward. At this point he was very ill, deeply jaundiced and frail. The swelling of the clavicle was the size of a large orange, firm to touch with dilated veins. X-ray at this point showed complete radiological destruction of the medial 1/3 of the left clavicle. At this point palliative care was the mainstay of his management.

A week later the chest x-ray report came back as showing collapse of the left upper lobe with whiteout appearance and bulky hilum indicating an underlying bronchogenic carcinoma.

Three days later, almost 5 months after initial presentation following a fall, this patient finally succumbed to his disease.

Conclusion: This patient presented with a simple fracture and was given the standard treatment for the condition. However because his treatment was compartmentalized, i.e., orthopaedics treating the orthopaedic condition, radiology doing x-rays, and physicians managing the jaundice; it took some months before the different pieces of the jig-saw puzzle were put together and the malignant diagnosis arrived at.


S. Wertz N. Franchimont M. Malaise V. Gangji H. Van Cauwenberge J.Ph. Hauzeur

Introduction: Abnormalities of mesenchymal stem cells and osteoblastic cells (Obs) might play a role in producing bone collapse due to insufficient repair of the necrotic area in osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ON). Osteoblast and osteocyte apoptosis should be increased at the osteonecrotic site.

Materials and Methods: We compared the TRAIL (TNF-related apoptosis-inducing ligand) cytotoxicity in primary Obs isolated from femoral heads from patients with ON or osteoarthritis (OA) and on two human osteosarcoma cell lines, MG-63 and SaOS2.

Results and Discussion: We showed that ON but also OA Obs were sensitive to TRAIL. We also observed TRAIL cytotoxicity on MG-63 but not SaOS2 cells. Moreover, we saw that TRAIL negatively regulated Akt and ERK survival pathways in MG-63 cells. We also investigated the IL-6 influences on apoptotic response of Obs to TRAIL. Even though decreased IL-6 and sIL-6R levels were observed at peripheral sites of the ON in regard to the levels produced in the iliac crest, IL-6 had no protective effects on TRAIL-induced apoptosis in ON Obs and only a weak protective effect in MG-63 cells. However, TRAIL stimulated IL-6 production in MG-63 cells and, cells and OA Obs, suggesting to a lesser extend, in SaOS2 other roles of TRAIL in the bone environment.


Y. Kaneshiro Y. Oda K. Iwakiri T. Masada H. Iwaki Y. Hirota K. Takaoka

Introduction: Osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ONFH) has a close association with corticosteroid therapy. As corticosteroids are accepted to be metabolized mainly by CYP3A4 in the liver, low constitutive levels of the enzyme might lead to an excessive response to corticosteroids and lead to adverse events including bone necrosis. This clinical study was designed to elucidate this hypothesis and to present potential modalities to avoid corticosteroid-associated ONFH by tailoring the steroid dose according to individual metabolic capacities of corticosteroid.

Materials and Methods: Twenty-two steroid-associated ONFH patients, 27 alcohol-related ONFH patients, and 65 general population controls were enrolled in this study. To estimate functional level of hepatic CYP3A4 level, a midazolam (MDZ) clearance test was carried out in respective subjects. The results from the tests were compared between those groups.

Results: The distribution profile of the MDZ clearance in steroid-associated ONFH patients were shifted to the left, indicating lower hepatic CYP3A4 activity in those patients when compared with the general population. By using an unconditional logistic regression model, patients with low (< 9.7) MDZ clearance due to low hepatic CYP3A4 activity were at 9.5 times greater risk for corticosteroid-induced ONFH compared with those with high (9.7+) MDZ clearance (OR 9.5 [95% CI 2.79–32.2], p< 0.001). The hepatic CYP3A4 activity was not associated with prevalence of alcohol-associated ONFH.

Discussion: A significantly low constitutive hepatic CYP3A4 function in corticosteroid-associated ONFH patients was found. The corticosteroid-associated ONFH might result from excessive responsiveness to corticosteroids in those patients due to prolonged exposure of bone to high levels of corticosteroids because of low functional level of the steroid metabolizing enzymes. The steroid-associated ONFH might be avoided by tailoring the corticosteroid dose in accordance with the functional level of hepatic CYP3A4.


M.A. Mont P.S. Ragland G.A. Marulanda R. Delanois N.B. Flowers T. Seyler

Introduction: Osteonecrosis of the knee occurs with approximately 10% of the incidence of osteonecrosis of the hip. Core decompression is a minimally invasive technique which can potentially forestall bony collapse and thus avoid the need for joint arthroplasty. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of a new minimally invasive approach using a small diameter Steinman pin to perform core decompression of the knee.

Materials and Methods: Between September 5, 2000 and May 30, 2003, the senior author performed 55 core decompressions of the knee in 39 patients with symptomatic osteonecrosis of the knee. All procedures were performed using the small-bit drilling technique. There were 32 women and 7 men who had a mean age of 43 years (range, 18 to 52 years). Radiographic and clinical outcomes were assessed during post-operative clinical visits, with persistent pain, loss of joint space, or progression to total knee replacement considered failures.

Results: There were excellent or good outcomes in 45 knees (82%) at a mean three year follow-up (range, 2 to 5 years). Four patients had symptomatic knees that led to total knee arthroplasty. There were no complications from the procedures which were all performed as out-patient surgery.

Discussion: The percutaneous drilling technique appears to be a low-morbidity method of relieving symptoms in patients with symptomatic knees from osteonecrosis. These short-term results are encouraging for this difficult to treat disease.


Q. Cui Y. Wang K. Mulhall K. Saleh G.-J. Wang G. Balian

Introduction: Alcohol can induce osteoporosis and osteonecrosis. Studies have demonstrated that alcohol contributed to abnormal lipid metabolism in cells in bone marrow but the mechanisms have not been defined. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of alcohol on the differentiation of pluripotential cells cloned from bone marrow.

Materials and Methods: The cells were maintained in culture and treated with either increasing concentrations of ethanol (0.09, 0.15, and 0.21 mol/L) or without alcohol to serve as controls. Morphologic features of the cells were monitored using a phase-contrast microscope. Alkaline phosphatase activity was determined using a colorimetric assay. Gene expression of adipogenesis [422 (aP2), PPAR y] and osteogenesis (osteocalcin) was evaluated using the Northern blot technique and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). ANOVA was used for statistical analysis.

Results: The cells treated with ethanol started to accumulate triglyceride vesicles at Day 7; the number of adipocytes and the percentage of the area that contained the cells with fat vesicles increased significantly; and the level of alkaline phosphatase activity diminished with longer durations of exposure and with higher concentrations of ethanol. Analysis of gene expression showed diminished expression of osteocalcin without a significant increase in the expression of the fat cell specific gene, 422 (aP2), and PPAR y, in cells treated with ethanol. This suggested that adipogenesis may occur at a point downstream in the fatty acid metabolism pathway.

Discussion: Alcohol induces bone marrow fatty changes in patients and in animal models contributing to osteoporosis and osteonecrosis. This study demonstrated that alcohol treatment decreased osteogenesis while enhancing adipogenesis by bone marrow stromal cells, which may be one of the mechanisms leading to osteoporosis and osteonecrosis. Inhibition of adipogenesis may lead to the prevention of the disease.

Clinical relevance: This is a novel finding that alcohol induces adipogenesis in a cloned bone marrow stromal cell. The results explain the clinical observation that there is increased adipogenesis in alcohol-induced osteoporosis and osteonecrosis.


W.H.C. Rijnen B.W. Schreurs J.W.M. Gardeniers

Introduction: Osteonecrosis of the distal femur produces a segment of dead bone in the weight-bearing portion of the femoral condyle, frequently associated with subchondral fracture and collapse, and eventually resulting in secondary osteoarthritis.

Materials and Methods: We developed a new surgical technique; the osteonecrotic lesion was removed and impacted bone grafts were used to regain sphericity and prevent collapse. In this prospective one surgeon study, we included 9 consecutive knees (6 patients) with extensive steroid-associated osteonecrotic lesions of the femoral condyles. A new staging system was developed that includes location and quantification of the osteonecrotic lesion.

Results: Six knees showed a preoperative collapse. The mean age of the patients was 31 years (range, 16–47 years). At a mean follow up of 51 months (range, 29–93 months), no conversion to total knee arthroplasty was performed. The objective Knee Society Score improved from 63 to 89 points. The functional Knee Society Score improved from 19 to 81 points. At follow up, there was no progression of collapse observed and only 3 knees showed slight signs of osteoarthritis. The clinical success rate was 75%, and 78% were radiologically successful.

Discussion: This method is attractive as a salvage procedure, is relatively simple and quick and does not interfere with an eventual future total knee arthroplasty.


K.-H. Lee Y.-S. Kim D.-S. Im H.-M. Kim

Introduction: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of free vascularized fibular grafting (VFG) for the treatment of osteonecrosis of the femoral head.

Materials and Methods: We reviewed the results in a consecutive series of 115 hips (88 patients) who had undergone free VFG between July 1991 and February 1999. Among them, 46 hips (32 patients, 28 males and 4 females) were available with periodic follow-up of at least 5 years. The mean follow up period was 7.1 years (range, 5 to 13 years). An average age of patients was 37.6 years at the time of VFG. We performed survival analysis by the Kaplan-Meier method according to the stage, etiology, age of patients, size of involvement, and degree of collapse of the femoral head. We used the Harris hip score for clinical evaluation, and used plain radiographs and MRIs for radiological evaluation.

Results: The survival rates were 85% in Ficat stage 2a, 34.7% in stage 2b, and 76.2% in stage 3. Eleven hips were evaluated as failures of VFG of which 7 hips were converted to a prosthetic joint. Harris Hip Scores were 67.8 points preoperatively, and increased to 80.4 points postoperatively. Good or excellent results were found in 69.5% of hips clinically and 56.5% of the hips radiologically. Age and size of necrosis affected the postoperative Harris Hip Score significantly, but other factors did not.

Discussion: Free VFG for the early osteonecrosis of femoral head revealed satisfactory results with good survival of the joint and improvements in Harris Hip Scores.


R.T. Steffen S.R. Smith H.S. Gill D.J. Beard J.P.G. Urban D.W. Murray

Introduction: The incidence of femoral neck fracture is approximately 2% after resurfacing hip replacement. Avascular necrosis is thought to be a contributory factor. The aim of this study was to investigate oxygen concentration in the femoral head during metal-on-metal hip resurfacing (MMHR).

Materials and Methods: In ten patients, following division of the fascia lata, a calibrated gas-measuring electrode was inserted into the supero-lateral quadrant of the femoral head via the femoral neck. Xsrays confirmed placement of the electrode 2-3 cms below the femoral head surface. Baseline oxygen concentration levels were recorded immediately upon electrode insertion and used as a reference for all intra-operative measures. Oxygen levels were monitored continuously throughout the operation.

Results: Oxygen concentration was reduced during the surgical approach and average oxygen concentration following dislocation and circumferential capsulotomy dropped significantly (p< 0.005) to 38% of baseline (SD=26%). Insertion of implants resulted in a further significant drop in oxygen concentration (p< 0.04) to 21% of baseline (SD=28%). Oxygen concentration rose slightly, but not significantly after relocation of the resurfaced joint and reconstruction of posterior soft tissues, reaching 22% of initial baseline oxygen levels. Considerable variation between subjects was observed.

Discussion: Intra-operative measurement of oxygen concentration in blood perfusing the femoral head is possible. During MMHR there is a dramatic decrease in femoral head oxygenation during surgical approach and implant fixation. This may increase the risk of avascular necrosis and subsequent femoral neck fracture. Future experiments will determine if a different surgical approach can protect the blood supply to the femoral head and neck. Measurements of femoral head oxygenation during metal-on-metal hip resurfacing demonstrated a significant concentration decrease during surgical approach and implant fixation.


P. Bonnutti M. Mont M. McMahon

Introduction: Avascular necrosis of the knee has recently been described to occur after various arthroscopic procedures around the knee. In this report, we described 19 cases that were treated with either a uni- or tri-compartmental knee arthroplasty.

Materials and Methods: In this study, we characterized nineteen patients (19 knees) that were treated with a diagnosis of avascular necrosis that occurred after a knee arthroscopy. All of the knees had magnetic resonance imaging prior to the arthroscopy that was negative for avascular necrosis. Knees in the study had positive MRI findings and severe symptomatology requiring further treatment. Operative procedures performed included unicondylar (n=3) and total knee arthroplasties (n=16).

Results: Six patients had an arthroscopy with laser treatment, 7 had radiofrequency assistance, while 6 others had no special adjuncts. There were 5 men and 14 women with a mean age of 69 years (range, 42–86). All knees were doing well clinically (mean Knee Society Score of 95 points, range 91–100), at a mean follow-up of 4 years (range, 2 to 7 years). Minimally invasive approaches were utilized for all knees.

Discussion: Avascular necrosis of the knee after arthroscopy is an uncommon and not well-characterized disorder. It can be successfully treated with minimally invasive uni or tri-compartmental knee arthroplasty,


P. Bonutti M.A. Mont M.B. Naughton

Introduction: The results of total hip arthroplasty in patients with avascular necrosis of the hip have been variable. This study analyzed the clinical and radiographic outcome of young patients treated with Four different cementless systems, three with alumina-on-alumina bearings in comparison to a control metal-on-poly couple in young patients with avascular necrosis of the femoral head.

Materials and Methods: This was a US IDE multicenter prospective randomized clinical trial begun in 1996 to evaluate safety and effectiveness of alumina-alumina bearings in young patients. Four cementless systems were compared in 95 patients (105 hips), three alumina-on-alumina bearing systems: ABC System I, porous coated cup; ABC System II, hydroxyapatite coated cup; Trident system, hydroxyapatite coated cup with metal sleeve backing on ceramic cup liner. The control group was the ABC System III, porous coated cup with polyethylene and cobalt chromium bearing system. All patients received a cementless Omnifit HA femoral stem. Patients were randomized to receive ABC System I, II, or III. Trident patients (Study arm begun in 1999) were not randomized. Examinations were performed at 7 weeks, 6 months, 1 year, and yearly thereafter including x-rays, clinical exam and modified Harris Hip Scores (HHS).

Results: For the alumina-alumina hips patients had a mean age of 45 years (21–67) with 18 women (23%) and 61 men (77%) at a mean follow up of 4.2 years (range, 2–7). The mean HHS at latest evaluation was 96 points. There were three revisions: one revision of all components for hip pain (sepsis suspected but not confirmed); one stem and head for traumatic postoperative periprosthetic femoral fracture; and one insert and head for subluxation in a patient implanted with the Trident insert and head. For the metal-poly hips, there were similar demographics, follow-up, and clinical scores. There were two revisions; one stem and head for traumatic postoperative periprosthetic femoral fracture, and one insert only 2 days after index surgery for dislocation.

Discussion: Both bearing couples (alumina-alumina and metal-poly) did well in theses cementless hip arthroplasties performed in young patients with avascular necrosis of the femoral head. The low revision rate is encouraging for these previously difficult to treat patients.


T. Kabata T. Matsumoto A. Kaneuji T. Sugimori T. Ichiseki H. Ebara T. Maeda D. Sakagoshi K. Tomita

Introduction: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical results of Sugioka’s transtrochanteric rotational osteotomy (TRO) for osteonecrosis of the femoral head.

Materials and Methods: We reviewed 54 hips in 49 patients who underwent TRO between 1986 and 1998 (follow-up rate was 90%). The mean age of patients was thirty-six years. The average duration of follow-up was 116 months (range, 60 to 201 months). Risk factors for osteonecrosis was steroids in 23 patients, idiopathic in 15 patients, alcohol in 13 patients, and others in three patients. Using the staging system of The Japanese Investigation Committee of the Ministry of Health and Welfare, 16 hips were in Stage 2, 23 hips in Stage 3A, 13 hips in Stage 3B, and two hips in Stage 4. Clinical assessments were made according to the Japanese Orthopaedics Association hip scoring system (JOA score).

Results: The overall results were excellent (JOA score of 90 to 100 points) in 22 hips (40.7%), good (80 to 89 points) in 16 hips (29.6%), fair (65 to 79 points) in 3 hips (5.5%), and poor (fewer than 64 points) in 13 hips (24.1%). The result was influenced by post-operative complications, the ratio of transposed intact femoral articular surface to the acetabular weight-bearing area after TRO, and the pre-operative stage. All hips with a ratio less than 40% showed progressive collapse. All Stage 2 hips with the ratio more than 40% showed excellent or good results. Conversely, 19% and 25% of the hips were fair or poor in Stage 3A and 3B hips even though the ratio was more than 40%. All Stage 4 hips had poor results.

Discussion: We conclude that satisfactory results can be achieved using TRO by maintaining exact surgical technique and by limiting the surgical indications. The hips in early or intermediate stages with sufficient intact area are good candidates for TRO.


T. Atsumi Y. Hiranuma S. Tamaoki Y. Asakura T. Kajiwara K. Yamano Y. Takemura

Introduction: Posterior rotational osteotomy has been used in young patients to treat apparent collapse and extensive osteonecrosis of the femoral head. We have reviewed a series of our patients with greater than 3 year follow-up.

Materials and Methods: Forty-three hips in 32 young patients with non-traumatic femoral head osteonecrosis were treated by posterior rotational osteotomy. All heads were apparently collapsed (Greater than 3mm), and 12 hips showed joint narrowing. Extensive lesions were noted on measurements of the area below the acetabular roof on preoperative AP radiographs. The age of the patients at the time of surgery ranged from 15 to 48 years with a mean of 34 years. There were 13 women and 19 men. Nineteen patients received steroid administration, 9 had alcoholic abuse, 6 had no apparent risk factor. Posterior rotational angle was 60–150 degrees with a mean of 124 degrees. We reviewed radiographically at 3 to 17 years follow-up (mean; 7.6 years).

Results: Re-collapse were prevented in 39 hips (91%) on final follow-up AP radiographs. Progressive joint narrowing was found in 6 hips (14%). Of the remodeling, we observed a collapsed area on the medial portion of 19 hips after posterior rotation. Re-spherical contour was noted on 18 hips. In 12 hips with joint narrowing preoperatively, atrophy of acetabular subchondral bone was seen on 12 hips 6 months postoperatively. A newly formed acetabular bony roof was noted in 11 hips at 2 years postoperatively.

Discussion: These results suggest that this operation is effective for young patients with advanced stage osteonecrosis.


Y. Shenava S. Rajaratnam S. Phillips G. Groom D. Goss

Introduction: It is unknown what effect distraction osteogenesis has on bone blood flow to the affected limb. Our study analyzed in vivo measurement of tibial blood flow during distraction osteogenesis using Doppler ultrasonography.

Materials and Methods: Blood flow was measured in the femoral artery, with Doppler ultrasonography in five people treated with bi-focal tibial distraction osteogenesis. The normal leg was used as the control to correct for differences in cardiac output. Measurements for each leg were taken and means recorded preoperatively, at 1 week postoperatively, and at subsequent intervals up to 6 months.

Results: Preoperative blood flow varied from 0.5 – 2.25. All treated legs demonstrated increases in flow from 2.25 – 5.75, with peaks in the first weeks following osteotomy. Significant increases in blood flow during treatment with distraction osteogenesis, confirming previous experimental studies.

Discussion: Blood flow plays a significant role in the successful outcome of this treatment. Compression of the non-union at the time of peak blood flow gives more reliable union than bone transport methods, where docking takes place when blood flow has returned towards the control limb.


S. Espahbodi K.N. Humphries C.J. Doré I.D. McCarthy N.J. Standfield D.O. Cosgrove S.P.F. Hughes

Introduction: Duplex ultrasound has recently been used to demonstrate inflammatory hyperaemia in arteries supplying inflamed joints in RA, bursitis, and tendonitis. The technique has yet to be applied to examine blood flow in lumbar arteries in LBP patients, though we have previously shown its feasibility in healthy subjects. Our aim was to determine if there are differences in the flow characteristics of lumbar arteries in patients with LBP that may be reflective of pathology.

Materials and Methods: Sixty four patients with LBP (21–82 years) and 30 volunteers with no history of LBP (19–82 years) were studied. Sacral and lumbar arteries at L5 to L1 were identified and hemodynamic data was obtained using Duplex ultrasound. Angle corrected measurements of blood flow peak systolic velocity (PSV) were obtained at all lumbar levels and the aorta.

Results: Mean lumbar artery PSV was normalized with mean aorta PSV for patient and control groups. Reference range (mean ± 1.96SD) for normal lumbar artery PSV was defined from the control data and the proportion of patients with abnormally high PSV determined.

Discussion: Blood flow velocity in lumbar arteries of LBP patients is significantly higher compared with asymptomatic controls (p< 0.01). Approximately 40% of the LBP group have abnormally high lumbar artery flow velocity and the proportion of abnormal values increases at lower levels. Abnormally high velocity flow suggests the presence of an inflammatory component in the lumbar spinal structures. This technique has important applications in improving diagnostic specificity and assessing outcome of treatment in patients with LBP.


R.S. Khakha Z. Bloomer D. Bain G. Nicholson A. Gall M. Ferguson-Pell

Introduction: Studies have shown Near Infrared Spectroscopy (NIRS) as being an effective tool in measuring oxygenation non-invasively in tissues. More recently it has been used in clinical settings to assess circulatory and metabolic abnormalities, however, clinical studies in bone are lacking.

Materials and Methods: Ten able-bodied (AB) (5 men and 5 women; age, 23-40 years) and ten spinal cord injured (SCI) (complete cord transection above T10, 5 men and 5 women; age 19–38) participants were matched by age, gender, skin pigmentation and studied.

A spectrometer measured between 498-1000nm, at 0.2Hz , using glass optodes (2mm diameter). Five minutes of resting readings, followed by 3 minutes of below knee arterial occlusion and then 6 minutes post-occlusion were made. The second study, started with 5 minutes of resting readings, vibration loading for 3 minutes at 30 Hz with acceleration of 3g and 6 minutes post-vibration was then conducted.

Results: NIRS showed changes in blood parameters during the hyperemic response (avg. 97% increase in Hb from baseline, p< 0.0001). Able-bodied subjects had significantly quicker (p=0.01) capacity for Hb to return to baseline. There was a significant difference (p=0.001) in the time to peak for Hb following arterial occlusion in the SCI group, 16.6 seconds (sd 4.3), and 10.1 seconds (sd 1.7) in the able bodied.

Conclusion: Our findings suggest that there is a reduction in the bone’s ability to restore oxygenated blood in SCI participants compared to the AB participants. Future studies looking at changes in bone following a range of vibration amplitudes and frequencies in the SCI group should be considered using NIRS in order to optimize potential clinical benefits.


L.C. Jones D.S. Hungerford H. Khanuja P. Pietryak M.W. Hungerford

Introduction: In a previous study (ARCO, 2002), we reported that the clinical results of revision total hip arthroplasty for osteonecrosis patients were less satisfactory than those found for a matched group of osteoarthritis patients. The aim of this study was to evaluate the potential factors that may have contributed to these findings.

Materials and Methods: This study included 34 hips in 30 osteonecrosis patients who had undergone revision of a femoral total hip arthroplasty component. There were 19 men (22 hips) and 11 women (12 hips) who had a mean age of 46.1 years (range, 28 to 69 years). The surgeries were performed between March 1984 and January 2001. Most femoral stems (91%) were implanted without cement. Prostheses were of different stem lengths, but most (97%) were proximally porous-coated. The mean follow-up was 8.2 years [range, 0.1 (a re-revision) to 19.8 years]. A physical examination as well as patient and physician outcome forms were collected at each visit. Preoperative x-rays were categorized according to the technique of Della Valle and Paprosky. A Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was performed (PEPI statistical software package).

Results: Risk factors for osteonecrosis included 15 corticosteroid, 8 alcohol, 7 trauma, and 4 unknown. This was the first revision in 27 cases, second revision in 5 cases, and third revision in 2 cases. Preoperatively, the defects included 4 Type I, 9 Type II, 15 Type IIIA, 2 Type IIIB, 1 Type IV, and 3 unknown types. Of the 34 hips, the femoral component was re-revised in 12 cases. One of the failures was the only fully porous coated stem that was implanted. One of the 3 cemented implants failed, as compared to 11 of the 31 implanted without cement. Survival rates were 90.9% (74.4%–97.1%) at 5 years, 54.8% (24.9%–81.6%) at 10 years, 54.8% (19.9%–85.6%) at 15 years, and 27.4% (1.7%–88.9%) at 20 years. There was no relationship between frequency of re-revision and defect category, risk factors, or age.

Discussion: Although there was a high failure rate (12/34; 34%) in this patient cohort, over 50% survived at least 10–15 years. The lack of a relationship between the patient age or the extent of defect and re-revision suggest that other factors concerning this disease need to be examined.


C Caulkins-Pennell H Winet

Introduction: Insufficiency of poroelastic bone bending as the sole mechanism driving bone interstitial fluid flow (BIFF) to account for the shear stress required to activate mechanoreceptors on osteocytes and osteoblasts, has stimulated a search for alternative or complementary mechanisms in the quest for a comprehensive bone remodeling model. Some investigators, noting that a substantial amount of interstitial fluid is exchanged with blood and lymphatic capillaries, have suggested that this exchange may play a substantial role in both microtransport through the collagen matrix and lacunar-canalicular transport. In order to accept the vascular system as a significant source of transport driving BIFF, it must first be demonstrated that capillary filtration, the proc ess by which fluid is transported from blood vasculature, is sufficiently convective to drive interstitial percolation. We have proposed that while, as shown by Otter et al., resting transmural vascular pressures are sufficient to generate streaming potentials across cortical bone, it is likely that these forces must be complemented by muscle pump contractions during exercise to generate convective percolation flows which will develop the required mechanotransducer shear stress activation threshold. To determine a minimal baseline for a muscle pump driven BIFF (MPD-BIFF) model, we have investigated the role of repetitive skeletal muscle contractions, uncoupled from gravitational loading, on blood flow and capillary filtration in cortical bone of the rabbit tibia. We tested the hypothesis that these effects increased when the muscle pump was activated.

Materials & Methods: The experimental model combined non-invasive, low magnitude transcutaneous neuromuscular stimulation (TENS), with real-time measurements from intravital microscopy (IVM) of optical bone chamber implants. Sling suspension of rabbits was utilized to eliminate gravitational reaction forces throughout TENS and data collection. TENS-induced muscle contraction forces were measured in situ, resultant bone strains were calculated, and systemic circulatory parameters were monitored, in order to eliminate these factors as contributors to blood flow changes. Blood flow rates and capillary filtration were measured by video-image analysis of 1 μm fluorescent microspheres and dextran-conjugated fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) and rhodamine (ITC) injected intravascularly during IVM. Bone formation, angiogenesis, and mineral apposition rates (tetracycline labelling) were analyzed from weekly microscopy pictures. Changes in bone mineral content and density were determined with CT scans obtained at implantation and termination.

Results: Mechanical loading and baseline systemic circulation did not significantly contribute to the findings. Rhythmic muscle contractions were shown to increase cortical blood flow, rate of capillary filtration, rate of bone apposition, and angiogenesis.

Discussion: The hypothesis was supported by the data. However, since no measurements were made on single capillaries, we could not confirm previous reports by this laboratory of convective extravasation.


J.T.K. Melton N.M.P. Clarke H.I. Roach

Introduction: Chondro-epiphyseal cartilage is generally resistant to vascular invasion. At the time of formation of the secondary ossification center in skeletal ‘long’ bones, the anti-angiogenic nature of cartilage is altered in favor of angiogenesis and vascular invasion takes place. We studied the control of this angiogenic ‘switch’ by experimentally investigating two factors which might influence vascular invasion. MMP 9 is a 92Kda gelatinase which degrades collagen types IV, V and X and gelatin (denatured collagen). It has been implicated in the control of endochondral ossification at the growth plate and has been shown to modulate endothelial cell morphogenesis. Basic Fibro-blast Growth Factor (b-FGF) is a cytokine with well established angiogenic capability and has also been implicated in the development of the growth plate. We investigated whether MMP-9 caused an effect on the development of the vasculature of the chondro-epiphysis of neo-natal rabbits and compared this to the effects of b-FGF.

Materials and Methods: The CAM Culture consists of placing a small tissue explant onto the the chorioallantoic membrane of 10 day-old chick embryos and continuing culture for a further 10 days. CAM derived vessels will invade the tissue, unless anti-angiogenic factors are present. Hence, CAM culture is used as an assay system for angiogenesis and factors that will influence it. We utilized the CAM culture model to investigate vascular in-growth into explants of femoral and humeral heads from 4 day old postnatal rabbits to test the influence of MMP-9 and b-FGF. A small nylon membrane, pre-soaked in a solution containing the factor, was placed on to a tangential cut across the perichondrium. The explant was then cultured on the CAM for 3–10 days.

Results: In control epiphyses, the in-growth of CAM derived blood vessels was rare and invasion of cartilage canals through the perichondrium seldom occurred, thus confirming the anti-angiogenic nature of epiphyseal cartilage. The initial presence of MMP 9 caused a tremendous increase in the de novo vascular invasion. MMP 9 treated epiphyses contained numerous large cartilage canals. In b-FGF treated epiphyses, a greater level of vascular in-growth was seen compared with controls, but this was not as marked as with MMP 9.

Our findings indicate that b-FGF and perhaps, more interestingly, MMP-9 are implicated in the activation of the angiogenic ‘switch’ at the chondroepiphysis leading to vascular invasion. The fact that MMP-9 can act as a stimulator to angiogenesis is a novel finding. The mechanism of action remains unclear although it is possible that it is involved in the deactivation of inhibitors of vasculogenesis or the activation of angiogenic factors, or both.


Q. Cui N.M. Azer K.J. Saleh G.J. Wang G. Balian

Introduction: Treatment of osteonecrosis continues to be a challenging problem in orthopedic practice. Arthroplasty is generally successful but long-term results are inferior especially in young adults. Alternative treatments such as core decompression and trap-door procedures provide only temporary benefits and need much improvement. The replacement of necrotic bone to promote osteogenesis and angiogenesis and healing subchondral bone are future approaches. Autogenous cancellous bone is the preferred graft material but its supply is limited. Allografts are useful but not as desirable as autografts. Substitutes for bone grafts have been actively researched but few are available currently. In this study, we have attempted to use genetically engineered bone marrow stem cells in order to enhance the healing of a bone defect in a mouse model.

Materials and Methods: A bone marrow stem cell was cloned from Balb/c mice and transfected with LacZ and neomycin resistance genes. The cells were cultured for 7 to 10 days and both the osteoblastic and angiogenic properties of the cells were examined using Northern blots to detect osteocalcin and VEGF gene expression. The cells were also analyzed for alkaline phosphatase activity to demonstrate the osteoblastic phenotype of the cells. A suspension containing 2 x 107 cells/ml phosphate buffered solution was prepared for cell transplantation. A total of forty-eight, 8-week old Balb/c mice were used in this study. A 1.2 mm defect was created bilaterally with an electric drill in the femurs of 24 mice to mimic the core decompression and trap-door procedures. 2 x 106 cells were transplanted into each defect of the right femur while the left femur served as a control trap-door defect which was injected with PBS but without cells. An equal number of cells were injected either at subcutaneous sites, in the hindquarter muscles, or into the renal capsule (8 mice in each site) to evaluate ossification at ectopic sites. Animals were sacrificed at 2, 4, 6 and 8 weeks. Defect repair was evaluated radiographically and the contribution to osteogenesis by transplanted cells was studied histomorphometrically using tissue sections stained with X-gal as well as biochemically on DNA extracts using primers for the neomycin resistance gene.

Results: Radiopaque tissue appeared two weeks after the cells were transplanted into bone defects, muscle, subcutaneous sites, and the renal capsule. Histological analysis demonstrated that these tissues consist of newly formed bone from transplanted cells that stained positively with X-gal and contained neo DNA. The repair tissue did not contain cartilaginous areas indicating that ossification surrounding the D1-BAG cells was not through the endochondral process. At four weeks, 4 of 6 femora showed a defect that was filled with new bone. At 6 weeks, all of the defects (6 of 6) contained fully restored bone. However, in the control side that was injected with PBS (no cells) only 2 of 6 at 4 weeks, 3 of 6 at 6 weeks, and 5 of 6 at 8 weeks showed complete repair. All histological sections of bone defects (n = 24) were examined histomorphometrically using a computerized image analysis system. Transplantation of marrow stem cells into bone defects produced more bone at an earlier time point than controls and, the process of enhanced ossification continued throughout the healing process.

Discussion: The cloned bone marrow stem cell can directly form bone after transplantation into bone defects and into ectopic sites, indicating that the in vitro expanded bone marrow stem cells can serve as a grafting material to enhance healing of bone defects and the treatment of osteonecrosis. In addition, this study demonstrates that genetic labelling is a useful tool in studies of cell differentiation in vivo and that bone marrow stem cells may be useful as a carrier of genetically-engineered factors in the treatment of skeletal diseases.


C. Ruggero M. Leo S. Stefania

Introduction: The biological basis of biophysical stimulation with pulsed electro-magnetic fields (PEMFs) induced in the bone tissue for treatment of AVN are becoming increasingly clear and was investigated.

Materials and Methods: In this study, 66 patients were treated with PEMFs. Mean duration of treatment was 5 ± 2 months. The patients were periodically checked after therapy had ended with a mean follow-up of 28 months.

Results: At final follow-up, progression of the AVN required surgery in 15 patients (20%). In the majority of the patients at 30 to 60 days from the beginning of stimulation, a considerable improvement was observed in the pain symptoms (pain was absent in 54% of cases, moderate in 26%, still intense in 20%). Hip joint function was normal in 46% of cases, sufficient in 39%, and insufficient in 15%. We observed that the earlier lesions respond well to treatment with PEMFs which are capable of preventing the progression of the disease in Ficat II. Ficat stage III does not constitute a real indication for this treatment.

Discussion: The treatment with PEMFs represents a therapy of choice in the first stages of AVN. The immediate use of stimulation represents a new and important therapeutic opportunity that can resolve this disease.


W. Drescher J. Lohse T.R. Lieb1 A. Helfenstein T. Herdegen J. Hassenpflug

Introduction: The aim of this study was to investigate if steroids enhance the vasoconstrictive effect of endothe-lin-1 (ET-1) on femoral arteries.

Materials and Methods: Ten female Wistar rats 59 to 88 days of age and 238 to 310 g of body weight, were used. Forty femoral artery segments were harvested. These arterial segments were mounted as ring preparations on a small vessel myograph. Two vessels from each animal were randomized to incubation with methylprednisolone 5 μg/ml [1] while the other 2 vessels were incubated with placebo. The arteries were stimulated cumulatively with endothelin-1. Isometric wall tension was quantified by the EC50; the vasoconstrictor concentration resulting in half maximal contraction.

Results: Thirty-eight arteries could be harvested in total; 20 were randomized to steroid treatment while 18 served as controls. The endothelin-1 dose-response curve displayed a stronger contraction for the steroid group in relation to the controls with increasing doses of ET-1. The EC50 of 4.4*10−8 M ± 1.8*10−8 M for the steroid vessels was lower compared to 5.9*10−8 M ± 3.4*10−8 M for the controls (mean ±SD; n.s.).

Discussion: Endothelin-1 is a potent vasoconstrictor. This study showed that incubation with methylprednisolone enhanced ET-1 mediated contraction of femoral arteries which can diminish blood flow within the vascular bed supplying the femoral head. This may be a relevant cofactor in the early pathogenesis of steroid-associated femoral head necrosis.


W. Drescher J. Lohse A. Helfenstein T.R. Liebs T. Herdegen J. Hassenpflug

Introduction: The aim of this study was to investigate if steroids enhance the vasoconstrictive effect of nor-adrenaline on femoral arteries, which may result in femoral head blood flow reduction.

Materials and Methods: Ten male Wistar rats 62 to 88 days of age, 254 to 318 g of body weight, were used. Twenty femoral artery segments were harvested. These arterial segments were mounted as ring preparations on a small vessel myograph for isometric force measurements. The arteries were stimulated cumulatively with noradrenaline before and after incubation with methylprednisolone (5 μg/ml). Isometric wall tension was plotted and quantified by the EC50, the vasoconstrictor concentration resulting in halfmaximal contraction.

Results: The noradrenaline dose-response curve displayed a shift to the left for the steroid group in relation to the controls. This was reflected by a significantly lower EC50 of 9.5*10−7 M ± 5.1*10−7 M for the steroid vessels compared to 2.5*10−6 M ± 1.1*10−6 M for the control vessels (mean ± SD; p< 0.005).

Discussion: This study showed that incubation with methylprednisolone enhanced noradrenaline-mediated contraction of femoral arteries. Enhanced contraction of femoral arteries can diminish blood flow within the vascular bed supplying the femoral head. This may be a relevant cofactor in the early pathogenesis of steroid-associated femoral head necrosis.


W. R. Drescher H. Li A. Lundgaard C.E. Bünger E.S. Hansen

Introduction: In the pathogenesis of steroid-associated femoral head necrosis only intra- and extravascular factors have been discussed. This study investigated the effect of long term glucocorticoid treatment on contraction of intraosseous femoral head arteries in a porcine model.

Materials and Methods: From 24 immature female Danish Landrace pigs from 12 litters, 12 animals received 100 mg methylprednisolone daily for 3 months. Their 12 sister pigs served as controls and received no steroids. Resistance arteries (diameter approximately 250 μm) were isolated from the femoral head epiphyseal cancellous bone and mounted as ring preparations on a small vessel myograph for measurement of isometric force development.

Results: Increasing doses of endothelin-1 evoked significantly stronger vasoconstriction after 3 months of methylprednisolone treatment. The vasocontractory response to increasing doses of noradrenaline was not altered by the previous methylprednisolone treatment. After submaximal precontraction by noradrenaline, vasorelaxation by bradykinin was not altered by methylprednisolone treatment.

Discussion: The vasocontractory response of isolated intraosseous femoral head epiphyseal arteries to endothelin-1 after long term glucocorticoid treatment in the pig was enhanced. Enhanced contraction of FH lateral epiphyseal arteries can diminish femoral head blood flow as vessel diameter decreases. This may be a relevant cofactor in the early pathogenesis of steroid-associated femoral head necrosis.


J. Lienau H. Schell D.R. Epari N. Schütze F. Jakob H.J. Bail G.N. Duda

Introduction: The formation of new blood vessels is a prerequisite for bone healing. CYR61 (CCN1), an extracellular matrix-associated signaling protein, is a potent stimulator of angiogenesis and mesenchymal stem cell expansion and differentiation. A recent study showed that CYR61 is expressed during fracture healing and suggested that CYR61 plays a significant role in cartilage and bone formation. The hypothesis of the present study was that decreased fixation stability, which leads to a delay in healing, would lead to reduced CYR61 protein expression in fracture callus. The aim of the study was to quantitatively analyze CYR61 protein expression, vascularization, and tissue differentiation in the osteotomy gap and relate this to the mechanical fixation stability during the course of healing.

Materials and Methods: A mid-shaft osteotomy of the tibia was performed in two groups of sheep and stabilized with either a rigid or semirigid external fixator, each allowing different amounts of interfragmentary movement. The sheep were sacrificed at 2, 3, 6, and 9 weeks postoperatively. The tibiae were tested biomechanically and histological sections from the callus were analyzed immunohistochemically with regard to CYR61 protein expression and vascularization.

Results: Expression of CYR61 protein was upregulated at the early phase of fracture healing (2 weeks) and decreased over the healing time. Decreased fixation stability was associated with a reduced upregulation of the CYR61 protein expression and a reduced vascularization at 2 weeks leading to slower healing. The maximum cartilage callus fraction in both groups was reached at 3 weeks. However, the semirigid fixator group showed a significantly lower CYR61 immunoreactivity in cartilage than the rigid fixator group at this time point.

Discussion: The fraction of cartilage in the semirigid fixator group was not replaced by bone as quickly as in the rigid fixator group leading to an inferior histological and mechanical callus quality at 6 weeks and therefore to slower healing. The results supply further evidence that CYR61 may serve as an important regulator of bone healing.


M. Murnaghan G. Li D. Marsh

Introduction: Ten percent of fractures end in delayed or non-union. NSAIDs have been linked to an inhibitory action on fracture repair for three decades yet the mechanism of action remains to be elucidated. Cancer research has identified that NSAIDs impede cell proliferation by inhibiting angiogenesis. It is proposed that a similar mechanism occurs in the induction of NSAID induced non-unions. We have investigated this hypothesis in a randomized placebo control trial of the NSAID rofecoxib using a murine femoral fracture model.

Material and Methods: All animals had an open femoral fracture treated using an external fixator. Outcomes measures included x-ray, histology, and biomechanical testing, with laser Doppler used to assess blood flow across the fracture gap.

Results: Radiology showed similar healing patterns in both groups, however at the later stages (day 32) the NSAID group had significantly poorer healing. Histological analysis showed that controls healed quicker (days 24 and 32), with more callus (day 8) and less fibrous tissue (day 32). Biomechanical testing showed that controls were stronger at day 32. Both groups exhibited a similar pattern of blood flow; however NSAIDs exhibited a lower median flow from day 4 onwards (significant at days 4, 16 and 24).

Discussion: Positive correlations were demonstrated between both histological and radiographic assessments of healing, with increasing blood flow. NSAID animals exhibited lower flows, and poorer healing by all outcomes. Regression analysis demonstrates however that the negative effect of NSAIDs on fracture repair is independent of its inhibitory action on blood flow. In conclusion, COX-2 inhibitors are marketed as having cleaner side effect profiles and are widely used in trauma patients. Following development of a novel method of analyzing functional vascularity across a fracture gap, we have demonstrated that the COX-2 inhibitor rofecoxib has a significant negative effect on blood flow at the fracture gap as well as inhibiting fracture repair.


Full Access
Q. Cui X. Li K.J. Saleh

Introduction: Osteonecrosis continues to be a challenging problem in orthopaedic practice. Etiology is multi-factorial but steroid- and alcohol-associated osteonecrosis contributed to more than two thirds of all the cases. While the pathogenesis of the disease is still unknown, many new insights have emerged from research in the last decade. Studies have demonstrated that both steroids and alcohol promote adipogenesis and inhibit osteogenesis, in vitro and in vivo, leading to osteonecrosis and osteoporosis. It has been found that Dexamethasone can turn on adipogenic transcription factor PPARy2 but suppress osteogenic transcription factor Cbfa1/Runx2. Steroids also decrease VEGF production resulting in inhibition of angiogenesis by osteoprogenitor cells. However, alcohol produces adipogenesis through a different mechanism at a point downstream in the fatty acid metabolism pathway, but it does inhibit osteogenesis by decreasing osteocalcin gene expression. Increased adipogenesis and osteoporosis, together with decreased osteogenesis and angiogenesis, will eventually lead to the final pathway of osteonecrosis.


M.A. Mont P.S. Ragland J. Khaled Saleh L.C. Jones D.S. Hungerford

Introduction: Multiple classification systems for avascular necrosis of the hip have been developed to assist physicians in the diagnosis and treatment of this potentially debilitating disorder. However, this lack of consistency makes clinical decision making difficult when comparing publications. The purpose of this study was to quantify the classification systems reported since 1985 (post-MRI) and identify consistent factors which would allow cross-publication comparisons to be made.

Materials and Methods: The authors performed a PubMed search for reports of outcome studies concerning treatment methods of hip avascular necrosis that were the initial basis for analysis. All studies reported since 1985 were included in the analysis if outcomes of greater than 10 patients treated for this disease were reported. Classification systems utilizing at least one factor were also identified. Tabulation of how frequently these classification systems were used in terms of the number of studies reporting results was performed.

Results: Fifteen major classification systems utilizing more than one radiographic factor were identified with 9 having one to three modifications reported throughout the literature. Additionally, 14 systems utilized either MRI or anatomic factors. Cross-publication analysis revealed five major classification systems which were utilized in greater than 80% of the reported studies.

Discussion: This analysis of the reported classification systems for avascular necrosis of the femoral head revealed several similarities between systems. A cross system analysis can be made if data is collected according to patient symptoms, magnetic resonance imaging findings, and x-ray findings which would allow for the use of any staging system.


L.C. Jones M.W. Hungerford H. Khanuja D.S. Hungerford

Introduction: Evidence-based medicine is a form of practice in which the physician accesses relevant, state-of-the-art research findings to guide the care of the individual patient (Gordon and Cameron, 2000). Therefore, evidence-based medicine should influence the decision making process when developing a treatment algorithm for early stage osteonecrosis. It was the purpose of this project to explore the literature concerning surgical options that are used currently to treat early stage osteonecrosis.

Materials and Methods: Literature searches were conducted using PubMed (National Library of Medicine, USA) to identify journal articles pertaining to the treatment of pre-arthrosis osteonecrosis during the past decade. The articles were screened to include only those with greater than 5 patients and greater than two year follow-up.

Results: Published reports in medical journals included: core decompression with and without nonvascular grafting (18); core decompression augmented with BMP or bone marrow cells (2); bone cement (1); vascularized graft – fibular or iliac (10); osteotomy (26); osteotomy and vascularized grafts (3); trap-door procedure (2); and hemiarthroplasty/resurfacing arthroplasty (9). There was one review of nonoperative treatment, but no clinical studies. There were only a few case reports concerning osteochondral graft/osteochondroplasty; which did not meet the inclusion criteria. Several classification systems were used: Ficat and Arlet (55%); University of Pennsylvania / Steinberg (21%); Japanese Investigational Committee (13%); Marcus (2%); Myers (3%); ARCO (5%), and other (1%). A majority of reports included follow-up of 5 years or greater (91%). Most studies (91%) were not randomized, control-matched, or prospective.

Discussion: Several surgical options are available for the treatment of pre-arthrosis osteonecrosis. However, it is not possible to apply evidence-based medicine practices to the research relating to the treatment of osteonecrosis as most of the research is not controlled and not comparative. This represents a substantial void in our knowledge base concerning osteonecrosis which remains to be filled.


K.-H. Koo Y.-C Ha J.-R. Kim N.H. Seong H.J. Kim

Introduction: A hypothesis that combined necrotic angle measurement using MRI scans predicts the subsequent risk of collapse of femoral head osteonecrosis was tested.

Materials and Methods: Thirty-seven hips with early-stage osteonecrosis in 33 consecutive patients were investigated. The arc of the necrosis was measured by the method of Kerboul et al. using mid-coronal and mid-sagittal MRI scans of the femoral head instead of anteroposterior and lateral radiographs, and the two angles were added. Hips were classified into four categories based on the magnitude of the added angle; grade 1 (< 200), grade 2 (200–249), grade 3 (250–299), and grade 4 (≥300). After the initial evaluations, the hips were randomly assigned to a core-decompression group or a non-operatively-treated group. Patients underwent regular follow-up until femoral head collapse or for a minimum of five years.

Results: Seven hips in grade 4 and 16 hips in grade 3 developed femoral head collapse in 36 months; six out of nine hips in grade 2, and none of five hips in grade 1 developed collapse (log rank test, p< 0.01). In a retrospective analysis, none of four hips with combined necrotic angle < 190 (low risk group) collapsed, and all 25 hips with combined necrotic angle > 240 (high risk group) collapsed, and four (50%) of eight hips with combined necrotic angle between 190 and 240 (moderate risk group) collapsed during the study.

Discussion: The Kerboul combined necrotic angle ascertained by MRI scans instead of radiographs is a major predictor of future femoral head collapse.


T.G. Myers K.J. Saleh M.A. Mont Q. Cui M. Kuskowski

Introduction: The authors systematically reviewed the available literature in order to define the outcomes for avascular necrosis (AVN) and spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee (SPONK) after unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) or total knee arthroplasty (TKA).

Materials and Methods: A literature review yielded seven reports with Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) or Knee Society Score (KSS) outcomes for arthroplasty secondary to either AVN or SPONK. The mean pre-operative, post-operative, and difference in KSS or HSS scores plus the mean revision rates for the arthroplasties for each underlying disease (AVN and. SPONK) were tabulated and reported in this order. The reported means were weighted by the number of knees in each study.

Results: A total of 63 TKAs were performed for AVN and 85 TKAs were performed for SPONK. Additionally, 74 UKAs were performed for SPONK. TKAs performed secondary to AVN had mean KSS scores of 50.6, 90.2, and 39.4 points. The revision rate was 12.5% (SD=10.45). TKAs performed for SPONK had mean HSS scores of 55.6, 82.5, and 27 points. The revision rate was 5.9% (SD=2.79). UKAs performed for SPONK had mean HSS scores of 54, 83.1, and 29.1 points with a revision rate was 9.7% (SD=5.9).

Discussion: Although the KSS for TKAs performed for AVN match the KSS performed in osteoarthritic patient populations receiving TKAs, the revision rate is higher in the AVN group. The HSS scores for patients with SPONK receiving TKAs or UKAs are similar although the revision rate is higher for UKAs.


Y. Takemura T. Atsumi T. Kajiwara Y. Hiranuma S. Tamaoki Y. Asakura

Introduction: We performed rotational open wedge osteotomy ( ROWO ) for Perthes’ disease with an extensive lesion. With this technique, the femoral head was rotated anteriorly, the postero-lateral viable segment was moved below the lateral acetabular roof consequently with the intertrochanteric osteotomy. We reviewed the results of this procedure radiographically.

Materials and Methods: Twenty two cases over 2 years follow up were investigated. Nineteen hips (19 patients) were boys and 3 hips (3 patients) were girls. The patients’ mean age at the time of the operation was 7 years and 9 months and the mean follow-up was 6.5 years. There were 15 hips in fragmentation stage and 7 hips in healing stage. In Catterall Grouping, 19 hips were in Group III and 3 hips were in Group IV. The mean rotation angle was 36 degrees, and the mean varus angle was 21 degrees. We analyzed Stulberg classification and Mose’ rating at the final X-ray.

Results By the Stulberg classification on final X-ray, 3 hips were in class I, 17 hips were in class II, 2 hips were in class III, and class IV and V were not seen. In Mose’ rating, all cases had good or fair results.

Discussion: We conclude that rotational open wedge osteotomy is a beneficial procedure for Perthes’ disease with extensive lesions.


Y. Asakura T. Atsumi Y. Hiranuma K. Yamano T. Kajiwara Y. Takemura S. Tamaoki E. Kato M. Watanabe

Introduction: We investigated the necrotic area and its shrinkage on stage 1 femoral head necrosis with band pattern low intensity on MRI.

Materials and Methods: Eleven femoral heads (6 patients) with a history of steroid treatment were studied. In heads, band pattern was detected by MRI. The mean age was 40 years.

The location of the lesion shown by the band pattern low intensity was determined by Japanese investigation committee as follows. Type A lesion occupies the medial one-third or less; Type B occupies the medial two-thirds or less; Type C-1 occupies more than the medial two-thirds; and Type C-2 extends laterally to the acetabular edge at the neutral position. Types were observed on initial and final MRIs. The mean follow up was 4 years and 3 months. For the repair patterns, the direction was observed in the anterior and posterior slices of MRIs.

Results: Initial MRIs showed types were Types A, B, C-1, and C-2 in 3, 3, 3, and 2 femoral heads, respectively. At the final observation, no band pattern was noted on the weight-bearing surface in 3 Type-A femoral heads. The femoral head surface was repaired, and the lesion was present only in the non-weight-bearing region. In all of the 3 Type-B femoral heads and 5 Type-C1 and -C-2 femoral heads, the lesion shrank to Type A. The articular surface was covered with normal intensity area from the posterior direction in all femoral heads

Discussion: We believe that the repair occurred during the disease process in stage 1 necrosis.


L.C. Jones B. Yeoumans D.S. Hungerford C.G. Frondoza

Introduction: The response of osteoblasts to dexamethasone is dose-dependent. While low doses are used to stimulate osteoblasts to maintain their phenotype, high doses are cytotoxic. The purpose of this study was to test the hypothesis that mechanical stimulation alters the response of osteoblast-like cells to dexamethasone.

Materials & Methods: MG-63 cells were propagated on 6-well Flexcell plates (flexible silicone membranes) under standard culture conditions. One half of the plates were subjected to biaxial strain at a frequency of 0.5 Hz through an imposed vacuum pressure of -7kPa (~1% stretch; 0.01 strain) for 42 hours using the Flexercell Apparatus. Replicate samples were maintained under static conditions. Simultaneously, the cells were exposed to either 0, .001, .01, or .1 nM of dexamethasone. The wells were then spiked with tritiated thymidine for 6 hours. The results were normalized to the control values. Triplicate wells were included for each experimental condition; and the experiment was repeated four times. Data were analyzed by JMP statistical package (SAS).

Results: Increasing doses of dexamethasone resulted in decreasing cellular proliferation. For the unflexed cells, we noted the following reduction in proliferative capacity: 0.86% ± 0.09 (.001nM), 0.50% ± 0.07 (.01nM), and 0.39% ± 0.07 (.1nM). Similar results were observed for the cells exposed to cyclic loading: 0.89% ± 0.12 (.001nM), 0.52% ± 0.08 (.01nM), and 0.47% ± 0.07 (.1nM).

Discussion: Our results confirmed the work of others that there is a decrease in the proliferation of osteoblasts (incubated under static conditions) when exposed to high levels of dexamethasone. Although cyclic loading had no effect on the proliferative response of osteoblasts to dexamethasone, it may still have had an effect on cellular metabolism or function, which remains to be evaluated.


Y. Hiranuma T. Atsumi K. Yamano Y. Takemura S. Tamaoki Y. Asakura E. Kato M. Watanabe

Introduction: We evaluated antero-posterior instability of the hip with osteonecrosis immediately after anterior rotational osteotomy using Dynamic CT and investigated the relationship between the instability and the developing marginal osteophyte of the femoral head postoperatively.

Materials and Methods Twenty-three hips in 21 patients with non-traumatic osteonecrosis undergoing anterior rotational osteotomy were studied. There were 19 men and 2 women with a mean age of 39 years at operation. All patients were followed up for more than 2 years (mean: 4). The etiologic factors were steroid administration in 10, alcoholic abuse in 12, and both in 1. According to the staging system by the Japanese Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare, there were 11 hips in stage 3a (collapse less than 3 mm), 9 in 3b (collapse 3 mm or greater), and 3 in stage 4. Dynamic CT, taken in both neutral and 45 degrees flexion positions, studied the antero-posterior shift of the femoral head. In addition, we analyzed marginal osteophytes with more than 2 mm in size on follow-up A-P radiographs.

Results: Seven hips (30%) with 5 hips in stage 3b and 2 hips in stage 4 showed instability. Marginal osteophytes were shown in 8 hips including all of 7 hips with the instability. However, these hips had no joint narrowing.

Conclusions: From these results, hip instability immediately after anterior rotational osteotomy occurs in cases with an extensive necrotic lesion and marked collapse preoperatively. Developing marginal osteophytes may prevent the instability.


S. Tamaoki T. Atsumi Y. Hiranuma K. Yamano T. Kajiwara K. Nakamura Y. Asakura E. Kato M. Watanabe

Introduction: In cases of small and middle size osteonecrosis on conventional antero-posterior (AP) radiographs, we studied the extent of the lesion on AP radiographs at the 45 degrees flexion position for lesions of the anterior area of the femoral head.

Materials and Methods: Classification of Japanese organizing committee was applied for the extent of the lesion on joint surface. Type A lesions occupy the medial one-third or less; Type B, the medial two-thirds or less; Type C-1 occupies more than the medial two-thirds; and Type C-2 extends laterally to the acetabular edge at the neutral position on conventional AP radiographs. Thirty-three hips (25 patients) with small or middle size lesions (Type A;11, Type B;22) were studied. On AP radiographs taken at the 45 degrees flexion position, the extent of the lesion was studied in 33 hips.

Results: Seven of 11 hips of Type A on neutral position showed Type A lesions. For the remaining 4 hips, 2 were Type B, 2 were on Type C-1 at 45 degrees flexion position. For 22 hips with Type B on neutral position, 6 were Type B, 12 were Type C-1, 4 were Type C-2 found at the 45 degrees flexion position.

Discussion: AP radiographs at the 45 degrees flexion position revealed more extensive necrotic area in cases of small and middle size lesions comparing with the neutral position. This finding may be related to progression of the disease.


K. Narayanasetty M. Mueller J. Fonseca R.S. Ahluwalia

Introduction: We present the use of Orthopaedic POSSUM Score and Surgical Risk Score (SRS) in femoral neck fracture surgery. The objective of this study was to identify the physiological status at admission and at operation and identify differences in predictive and actual patient operative outcomes.

Material and Methods: All 338 consecutive, hip fractures from December to July 2005 at three hospitals were assessed prospectively. Collection of demographic, admission, and operative POSSUM, and SRS scores, fracture pathology, physiological status, and outcomes were analyzed.

Results: In total, 306 (90.5%) patients had surgery. The median age was 73 years (range 55–95). The majority had co-morbidities (77.5%; n=237), as suggested by average ASA scores of 3.2. POSSUM predicted mortality was 13.6% (n=25) at 30 days, whereas the SRS predicted 11.4% (n=21), but mortality was 7.1% (n=13) if operated before 48 hours. Differences between admission and operative physiological Possum score increased with operative delay. Physiological scores over 30 had a 67.8% risk of 30-day mortality. Eighty-six patients had an increase in physiological score from admission to operation, resulting in higher analgesic requirements and reduced mobility scores (P< 0.005).

Discussion: Possum and SRS had a tendency to predict prior than actual operative mortality. Nevertheless, comparison of admission and operative physiological POSSUM scores indicate room for improvement in pre-operative care if surgery is delayed.


P.S. Ragland M.A. Mont G.A. Marulanda R. Delanois N.B. Flowers T. Seyler

Introduction: The results of total hip arthroplasty in patients with avascular necrosis of the hip have been variable. This study analyzed the clinical and radiographic outcome of young patients (mean age of 39 years) treated with a proximally hydroxyapatite-coated tapered stem.

Materials and Methods: Sixty-seven patients (84 hips) treated with late-stage avascular necrosis of the hip with a proximally hydroxyapatite-coated tapered stem as part of their total hip arthroplasty was studied. There were 41 men and 26 women who had a mean age of 39 years (range, 18 to 80 years). Patients were followed both clinically and radiographically for a minimum of two years (mean of 3 years).

Results: Overall, there were good and excellent clinical outcomes in 78 hips (93%). Fair results were found in five patients with persistent pain. There was only one stem loosening (obese patient with SLE). Radiographic zonal analysis revealed no evidence of impending failure or progressive radiolucencies.

Discussion: Excellent short-term results were found with total hip arthroplasty in this difficult patient population. The proximally hydroxyapatite-coated tapered stem utilized in this study was useful in patients with avascular necrosis of the hip.


P.S. Ragland M.A. Mont G.A. Marulanda R. Delanois T. Seyler

Introduction: Metal-on-metal resurfacing is a type of total hip arthroplasty that is conservative on the femoral side. It is controversial whether this procedure should be used in patients with avascular necrosis where the femoral resurfacing component is cemented on dead bone. This study analyzed the clinical and radiographic outcome of patients with avascular necrosis treated with metal-on-metal total hip resurfacing arthroplasty.

Materials and Methods: Thirty-seven patients (41 hips) treated with late-stage avascular necrosis of the hip with a metal-on-metal resurfacing hip arthroplasty were studied. There were 27 men and 10 women who had a mean age of 40 years (range, 16 to 62 years). Patients were followed both clinically and radiographically for a minimum of two years (mean of 3 years).

Results: Overall, there were good and excellent clinical outcomes in 38 hips (93%). Fair results were found in three patients who had excessive heterotopic bone (2 hips) and persistent groin pain (1 hip). There were no cases of component loosening. Radiographic zonal analysis revealed no evidence of impending failure or progressive radiolucencies.

Discussion: Excellent short-term results were found with metal-on-metal total hip resurfacing in this difficult patient population. The authors await long-term results to see if these early excellent results are maintained.


JC. Theis A. Panting R. Naden A. Barber

The aim of this study was to evaluate a new joint arthroplasty clinical priority scoring tool.

A new arthroplasty scoring tool based on pain, function, social limitation, potential of benefit from surgery and consequence of more than 6 months delay was developed and evaluated using 16 patient scenarios (vignettes) related to hip and knee osteoarthritis. Sixteen orthopaedic surgeons were asked to score the vignettes using clinical ranking, ISS tool and the new tool.

Significant variation in ranks allocated by surgeons was recorded for all three tools. Vignettes at either end of the scale ie. those who are severely or minimally disabled had less variability compared to a large group in the middle range. Comparing the three tools there did not appear to by any advantage of one over the other. Most of the variations occurred in the interpretation of benefit from the operation and consequence of delay.

Scoring tools rely heavily on judgement based decisions. More work is required to understand judgement processes used by surgeons and audit/feedback mechanisms may help in reducing the variations in priority assignment.


G. Hooper D. Darley D. Patton A. Perry R. Skelton

The purpose of this paper is to review the first six months experience of using the ‘Time Out’ procedure to avoid wrong site/side surgery and to evaluate the usefulness of this procedure in the routine preoperative check.

Over a period of 18 months all elective surgical hospitals in Christchurch (both private and public) have coordinated to develop a pre-operative ‘Time Out’ check list to ensure that the correct surgical procedure is performed on the correct site. This procedure involves a final check of patient details, including surgical procedure and site, immediately prior to surgical preparation of the operative site.

All forms during this six month period were prospectively collected and evaluated, specifically looking for system errors, which could proceed to wrong site surgery.

There were a total of 10,330 procedures performed during this period within the three hospitals of which 9,098 (87.2%) completed time out forms were returned.

There were no wrong side or wrong site surgeries performed during this six month period. However, there were three ‘near miss’ situations which were captured by the time out procedure.

Analysis of the time out forms also revealed numerous consent issues, incorrect documentation and systems errors which could potentially have lead to serious errors in management and which will be discussed in detail.

During this period there were 109 objections (1.2%) to the time out procedure.

The time out procedure has been shown to be a useful tool for avoiding wrong site/side surgery and has gained acceptance amongst both medical and nursing staff as being a valuable check prior to surgery. It has accentuated the collective team responsibility for determining the correct site and side of surgery and as such is recommended for use in all centres to eliminate system errors resulting in incorrect site/side surgery.


S. Amarasekera R.O. Lander

To explore whether the fundamental concepts of informed consent and patient autonomy are acceptable and practical from a surgeon’s point of view.

One hundred and fifty three questionnaires distributed to Orthopaedic Surgeons in NZ were analysed statistically.

Seventy six percent of the surgeons guided their patients towards a particular procedure. Fifty five percent spent between 10% and 25% of their consultation time on obtaining informed consent. Forty eight percent of the surgeons felt that the patient did not have sufficient autonomy to choose to undergo a particular procedure, while 76% felt that it was impractical to offer all necessary information needed for that patient to choose the procedure.

Although the length of time that a surgeon had been in practice did not influence the practice of obtaining consent or his/her opinion of the patient’s self autonomy, the degree of his/her specialisation did (P< 0.05). There was no correlation between the time spent on obtaining consent and the degree of specialisation. There was a very strong correlation between the surgeon’s belief in patient autonomy, the practicality of offering all the necessary information and the method of obtaining consent (P< 0.0001).

The majority of Orthopaedic Surgeons in NZ do not believe it was practical to offer all the necessary information to a patient and to expect that patient to be fully autonomous in choosing to undergo a particular procedure. This indicates that it is time for re-evaluation of the practice of modern day informed consent based on its original concept.


H. Love T. Lamberton

The aim of this study was to

Report the clinical scores of patients placed on the waiting list for joint arthroplasty in Tauranga (CPAC, Oxford hip and knees scores, WOMAC and SF-12)

Compare the scores for this cohort to those of patients reaching threshold for joint arthroplasty published internationally.

Compare scores obtained between the scoring tools and establish accuracy of correlation in this population

In this prospective study all patients complete Oxford hip or knee scores, SF-12, and WOMAC scores. An initial subset of patients (457) who had been entered onto the waiting list prior to May 2005 also completed CPAC scores. A literature search for published studies using Oxford, WOMAC, SF-12 and SF-36 scoring tools was performed using Medline and PubMed databases.

Four hundred and fifty seven waiting list patients completed all 4 scores. Results, including correlation between scoring systems and comparisons with international data are reported.

We found significant variation between internationally accepted scores and the CPAC scoring system. Current waiting list Oxford scores for Tauranga patients are significantly worse than those published in the literature although when including the entire group the difference is small. 2.04 (1.34–2.74 95% CI). After rescoring, patients reaching the certainty threshold, (cTT), and active review threshold, (aTT), have scores that are much worse than those in the published literature.


J. Taylor A. Vincent

This paper presents the experience of a tertiary referral centre for pelvic and acetabular trauma.

From August 1999 a tertiary referral centre was established in Christchurch to provide management for pelvic and acetabular trauma for the South Island. The experience of unit was reviewed.

One hundred and twenty four unstable pelvic and acetabular fractures were treated between August 1999 and March 2005. Ninety two percent of fractures were treated by one or both of two fellowship trained trauma surgeons. While the rate of complications was low, there were 6 significant infections, 3 nerve injuries, and 2 non-unions. The experience of the unit is presented.

A tertiary referral centre for pelvic and acetabular trauma has been able to provide a successful service to the South Island with satisfactory results.


B. Donaldson G. Inglis E. Shipton D. Rivett C. Frampton

Lumbar discectomy is now the operation of choice for lumbosacral radicular syndrome. Few studies of high quality have been performed on the post surgical management of these cases. The studies that have been reported compared one exercise regime to another. This study compares an exercise group with a true control group involving no exercise or formal rehabilitation. This is a randomized controlled trial comparing post surgical lumbar discectomy management regimes.

Ninety three lumbar discectomy patients were randomized to two groups. Group A; the control group followed usual surgical advice which was to resume normal activity as soon as pain allowed. Group B; undertook a six month supervised non aggravating gym rehab programme. Both groups were followed for a one year period using validated outcome measures and a questionnaire. The results are based on an intention-to-treat analysis.

Patients in both groups improved during the one year follow up period (P=0.001). However there was no statistical difference between groups at the clinical end point (Roland Morris P=0.83, Oswestry Low back index P=0.90). Group B patients returned to work seven days earlier than group A patients and had fewer days off work in the one year follow up period but this difference was not statistically significant.

There was no statistical advantage gained by the patients who performed the gym rehabilitation programme after one year follow up. These are the preliminary one year results of a three year follow up study.


Full Access
S. Faraj G.J. Coldham A. Doyle P. Baber

Cervical Cord Neuropraxia (CCN) and incomplete cord injuries such as Central Cord Syndrome (CCS) are more prevalent in patients with congenitally narrow spinal canals. The aim of this study was to identify if racial groups were over represented in patients with incomplete cord injuries, and if there was an ethnic variation in mid sagittal cervical spine diameter in the general population.

CT scan was used to measure the mid sagittal diameter of the C3 to C7 cervical vertebrae in a group of 166 sequential trauma patients who had CT scans of the cervical spine at Middlemore Hospital. Patient’s race was that declared by the patient. Four different observers used computer digitisation to measure the mid sagittal diameters and mean sagittal diameter for each level. Measurements were compared between races.

Maori cervical spine canals were found to be 1mm smaller than Europeans (P values less than 0.005) whilst Polynesians had on average a 2mm smaller mid sagittal diameter compared to Europeans (all P values less than 0.001).

This study has demonstrated that Polynesians were over represented in the group of patients who experienced CCS or Transient Cervical Neuropraxia. CT scan assessment demonstrated that both Maoris and Polynesians had significantly narrower canals than their European counterparts. The implications of this study are that Maori and Polynesians involve in high impact activities such as rugby may be at increased risk of incomplete or complete spinal cord injuries. There is however no reliable screening tool available for congenital spinal canal stenosis.


P. Devane G. Horne

In the past measurement of deformity correction in spinal surgery has been done using measurements made directly from radiographs using a pencil, ruler and goniometer The aim of this paper is to describe a reproducible, accurate and partially automated system that has been developed for measuring x-rays of patients with spinal disorders.

Computer assisted measurement of polyethylene wear in patients with THJR is now well established. Many of the image processing algorithms have been modified to allow identification of the outline of both thoracic and lumbar vertebral bodies on digital images of radiographs made from patients with spinal disorders. The Genetic Algorithm (GA), a branch of Artificial Intelligence, has been adapted to allow the modelling of a four sided figure to each vertebral body, with minimal user input.

The accurate identification of each vertebral body within a spinal radiograph allows measurement of multiple parameters, including Cobb angles, vertebral width, vertebral height and cross sectional area, as well as measurement of average disc height and cross sectional area. The method is 100% reproducible for each digital image. An attempt to measure accuracy has not been made because these are two dimensional measurements of a three-dimensional structure.

Comparison of these measurements between pre and post-operative radiographs for a patient allows accurate and reproducible measurement of reconstructive surgery for scoliosis and other spinal disorders. It may aid in development of a classification system for scoliosis.


J. Dunbar R. Craig

We describe a previously unreported technique of Z-lengthening for the treatment of refractory trochanteric bursitis and review the long-term outcomes for this procedure.

Fifteen patients (17 hips) were diagnosed with trochanteric bursitis based on clinical criteria. These patients were found to be unresponsive to conservative treatment including multiple corticosteroids injections. “Snapping Hips” were excluded. All went on to have bursectomy and Z- lengthening of the iliotibial band.

Harris Hip Scores were evaluated for before and after their operation as well as a standardised baseline questionnaire and examination.

At mean follow up of 47 months following Z-lengthening, eight patients reported excellent results with complete resolution of symptoms, eight had good results with symptoms improved and one had a poor result. One patient required secondary repair of a tear in the tendon of gluteus minimus with a subsequent excellent result. The mean Harris Hip Score improved from 46 to 82 (p< 0.05).

Bursectomy and Z-lengthening has been shown to be an effective and long-term operative solution for the treatment of refractory trochanteric bursitis when conservative measures have failed. Although the majority of patients had a successful outcome, not all respond well to this procedure and careful patient selection is recommended as well as a pre-operative MRI to rule out concomitant pathology such as a tear in the Gluteus medius or Gluteus minimus.


V. Pai B. Hodgson

This is a retrospective study of patient out-come after spondylolytic repair using a Scott¦s or a Van Dam Procedure (tension band repair). We also looked at the use of plain static radiographs, and a reverse gantry computed tomography scanning in the assessment of healing of the spondylolytic defect.

Tension band repair of spondylolysis has proved to be a useful procedure for refractory spondylolysis. However, there is no universally accepted method or determining fusion of the spondylolysis, and the definitive criteria for diagnosing a successful fusion remains controversial.

The Oswestry Disability Index was measured in 2000 and in 2004. Plain static radiographs and computed tomography scans were performed on 14 patients one year after fixation of the spondylolysis. A radiologist and an independent orthopaedic surgeon assessed the presence of bridging trabecular bone in the scan and X rays.

Results in 14 patients were rated as excellent and in 4 as good in year 2000 and results remained excellent to good in 16 of 17 patients followed up in year 2004. The fusion rate was 90%[18/20] on the plain radiographs. Fusion on the computed tomography scans was observed in 50% [7/14]

A high rate of good-excellent clinical results can be obtained following a Scott or Van Dam Procedure. Radiological fusion rate was higher than assessment with thin-section computed tomography scans. CT tomography studies clearly demonstrated the presence or absence of bridging bone, a property not easy to see in plain static radiographs. However, clinical significance of CT non-union is not clear.


Full Access
H. Crawford

The purpose of this study is to audit the early clinical outcomes of a consecutive series of hip arthroscopies performed by one surgeon.

Pre-operative WOMAC and Non Arthritic Hip scores were performed on the patients. All patients had MRI arthrograms. These were correlated with the clinical findings at the time of surgery. Postoperatively all complications were recorded and at one year post surgery the pre-operative scores were repeated.

There are 37 consecutive cases. 15 males and 22 females. Average age 39 years. 76% of cases were accident related. The average length of symptoms pre-operatively was 21 months. There were 2 false negative MRI arthrograms and one false positive. The surgical treatment included debridement of 18 labral tears and 10 labral tears associated with an articular cartilage defect. The average traction time was 39 minutes. The complications were minor and all have resolved.

There are many indications for hip arthroscopy however the outcomes of labral debridement are not clearly defined. This paper attempts to measure the success of arthroscopic labral debridement in a consecutive series of patients. The clinical symptoms and MRI arthrograms seem to have a good correlation with the arthroscopic findings. The short term results of this treatment are encouraging as is the low morbidity associated with the surgery itself.


S. Hadlow J. Donovan

Cortisone injection for radicular leg pain may be useful in treating patients with lumbar foraminal pathology based on accurate CT/MRI diagnosis and operator-controlled biplanar fluoroscopy in an angiography suite.

Patient details were collected from operative records and angiography suite records. Demographic data, diagnosis and level of injection were recorded. Low Back Outcome Scores (LBOS) were collected prospectively for most patients. Patients were then posted a questionnaire, including the LBOS. Patients were excluded from further analysis if further injection or surgery was required.

Fifty eight patients, all with CT or MRI diagnosis, underwent lumbar foraminal steroid injection. Thirty-seven had disc protrusion (64%) and twenty-one had stenosis (36%). Eighteen (31%) patients required further intervention, eleven with stenosis (52%) and seven with disc protrusion (19%). Thirty-two patients (80%) completed follow up questionnaires, one patient had died, one was lost to follow up, and six patients declined to complete the questionnaires. The average LBOS for the thirty-two patients who completed the questionnaires was 41.8+/−17.5. Twenty-three patients with pre-treatment LBOS improved on average from 25.1+/−13.5 to 45.9+/−16.1 following injection (p=0.050). Of this group, the eight patients with stenosis improved from 28.8+/−12.3 to 41.6+/−15.9 (average 12.9). The fifteen patients with disc protrusion improved from 23.2+/−14.1 to 48.1+16.3 (average 24.9). This difference in improvement between the two groups was significant (p=0.016).

This study reports 81% of patients with disc protrusions not requiring further treatment, with improvement of the average LBOS to 48.1=/−16.3. However the results in patients with foraminal stenosis was less satisfactory.


S. Mukherjee

Closed manipulation of long bone fractures is often a difficult problem. Muscles and soft tissues along with gravity, acting along the fracture fragments, can cause complex displacement and deformity at the fracture site. At the same time surgeons have to rely on human assistants to manipulate and realign these fractures. This depends a lot on their individual skills and furthermore human assistants are prone to fatigue and are liable to imprecise movements. A robotic device has precision, accuracy, and steadiness along with the ability to be programmed. The purpose of this study is to conceptualize a device, which can aid orthopaedic surgeons to manipulate long bone fractures.

Extensive literature search was done using the Internet and conventional resources, to find recent developments in the use of robotics in trauma and fracture surgery. Different models of robots were considered and finally a parallel robot of the Stewart platform type was considered to be of the design that will be more compatible with an orthopaedic operating environment.

Computer aided design and graphics modelling of the robot was done and range of motion and force it can generate was calculated. The prototype that was built had six degrees of freedom and enough force and range of motion to reduce and manipulate long bone fractures. The actual controlling interface of the robot through a PC was established.

It is possible to build a robot for manipulating long bone fractures. Further research is being done to focus on the integration of the robot to fluoroscopic images and designing the correct attachment tools for the extremities.


W.B. Leigh J. Draffin P. Taylor JC. Theis M. Walton

Percutaneous vertebroplasty (PVP), where vertebral bodies are injected with polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) cement, is used to treat various spinal lesions. Although the complication rate for PVP is low, thermal damage caused by the exothermic curing of PMMA has been implicated.

This study was to measure the temperatures reached during PVP as PMMA cures as well as assessing the cement volume effect and inter cement differences. Validating spinal cord monitoring during PVP was also undertaken.

In the in vivo experiment each of the lumbar vertebral bodies of 10 sheep were injected with one of two cements and one of two volumes. Thermocouple monitoring was undertaken at the bone cement interface. While undertaking the in vivo experimental studies 6 sheep underwent epidural monitoring using Motor Evoked Potentials (MEPs).

The mean peak temperature at the bone-cement interface was 49.5 C (3.0ml Simplex); 61.47 C (6.0ml Simplex); 42.1 C (DePuy 3ml) and 47.2 (DePuy 6ml). Spinal cord monitoring showed that when cement was injected into the correct location within the trabeculae of the vertebral body no change in amplitude monitoring was noted. When leakage occurred, deliberate or unintended, amplitude changes were noted.

Using cement volumes similar to those used in human clinical practice in a sheep model we were able to monitor temperature changes. The temperature of the bone cement interface reached temperatures that are known to cause tissue necrosis. Using epidural monitoring we were able to detect leakage of cement during injection.


A. Cockfield V. Bell G. Hooper

Recent studies have assessed operative skill in surgical trainees “objectively” based on patient outcomes by attempting to statistically separate many contributory variables. Compression hip screw fixation (CHS) for neck of femur fracture (#NOF) is a standard operation commonly performed by orthopaedic trainees of varying experience. Our aim was to determine if trainees could be assessed objectively on their efficiency and aptitude in performance of this operation. A secondary aim was to evaluate the predictors of fixation failure for CHS described in the literature.

Records and radiographs for all CHS performed by trainees of all levels for acute adult #NOF were examined retrospectively for 2 calendar years. Preoperative patient and fracture variables were scored. Outcome measures included operative time, scores of accuracy of fracture reduction and fixation, blood loss and complications. Failure of fixation was compared to the scores given to radiographs. Multivariate analysis was used to apportion variance between multiple contributing factors.

Three hundred and eight two eligible operations were performed by 26 trainees. Operative time was effected by fracture complexity, trainee level and trainee operator (all p< 0.05). “Tip apex distance”, a measure of depth and centrality of screw placement in the femoral head, known to predict screw cut out was associated with trainee operator. Other outcome scores of fixation on radiographs were not correlated with fracture, patient or operator variables. Blood loss and complications were not associated with operator. The rate of failure of fixation was low and associated with scores of reduction quality only (p< 0.05).

Trainees of variable experience perform CHS with a low overall complication rate and the most noticeable performance difference seems to be in speed of surgery.


F. Phillips P. Devane G. Horne

This study examined the effect of completely disregarding dislocation precautions on the incidence of dislocation, as well as the speed of patient rehabilitation after THJR

Since 1st March 2005, all uncomplicated primary THJR’s performed by one of the senior authors for OA have been told by their physiotherapist to do what they like, when they like, during the post-operative period. All patients were operated on through a modified direct lateral approach A representative sample of 30 patients were administered a questionnaire at their 6 week postoperative visit.

There were no dislocations. Of those patients in full-time employment, the majority had returned to work by 6 weeks. Most were able to drive between 3 and 4 weeks. Nearly all had regained their pre-operative range of movement and could put on their own shoes and socks. All claimed that being told to disregard dislocation precautions gave them more confidence in their THJR and helped with their achieving a speedy recovery from surgery.

Patients who are judged at the time of surgery to have a stable THJR articulation, benefit form being told to disregard the usual dislocation precautions, and are able to return to work and driving in a more timely manner.


W.P. Yau A. Leung K.Y. Chiu W.M. Tang T.P. Ng

This study investigated the intra-observer errors in obtaining visually selected anatomic landmarks that were used in registration process in a non-image based computer assisted TKR system.

The landmarks studied were centre of distal femur, medial and lateral femoral epicondyle, centre of proximal tibia, medial malleolus and lateral malleolus. Repeated registration in the above sequence was done for one hundred times by one single surgeon.

The maximum combined errors in the mechanical axis of the lower limb were only 1.32 degrees (varus/valgus) in the coronal plane and 4.17 degrees (flexion/extension) in the sagittal plane. The maximum error in transepicondylar axis was 8.2 degrees.

The errors using the visual selection of anatomic landmarks for the registration technique of bony landmarks in non-image based navigated TKR did not introduce significant error in the mechanical axis of the lower limb in the coronal plane. However, the error in the transepicondylar axis was significant in the “worst case scenario”.


Full Access
R. Pitto

Hip impingement is a diagnosis that has been increasingly recognized among young patients with hip pain.

Two different types of impingement have been described. Over coverage impingement, or a “pincer” effect, occurs between the anterior wall or labrum of the acetabulum and the femoral head. This is typically due to a decrease in anteversion of the acetabulum or over-coverage of the femoral head (coxa profunda or protrusio). A so-called cam-effect impingement occurs when the femoral head-neck junction has an abnormally large radius resulting in insufficient offset. Widening of the femoral neck reduces its concavity, creating an impingement over the acetabular rim. Thus, the anterolateral junction is forced under the acetabular rim, resulting in labral injury and deterioration of the cartilage.

Options for treatment of impingement include non-operative management, arthroscopic débridement, trimming of the anterior aspect of the acetabular rim after surgical dislocation of the hip, periacetabular osteotomy when impingement is secondary to an acetabular torsion abnormality, and surgical resection of a femoral neck bump and/or part of the anterolateral aspect of the neck when the primary anatomic abnormality is secondary to insufficient head-neck offset. Resection of a portion of the anterolateral aspect of the femoral head-neck junction improves the femoral head-neck ratio, increasing the range of motion before impingement occurs.

Recently, surgical dislocation has been used for achieving full access to the femoral head and the acetabulum. Surgical dislocation and resection osteochondroplasty were performed in 22 hips from January 2001 to Decem-ber 2004 because of anterior impingement resulting from an idiopathic nonspherical femoral head, mild slipped capital femoral epiphysis, or poor offset at the head-neck junction. Osteonecrosis was not observed in the hips treated with this method. Pain and function markedly improved after the index operation. Two patients required hardware removal. Treatment goals in young patients with hip impingement should be pain relief and, prevention of further damage to the cartilage and subsequent osteoarthritis. Surgeons using this technique need to know the amount of bone that can be removed safely before catastrophic weakening of the femoral neck occurs.


I. Elkinson H. Crawford M. Barnes P. Boxch J. Ferguson

The aim was to evaluate the Intraobserver and Interobserver reliability of Pelvic Incidence as a fundamental parameter of sagittal spino-pelvic balance in patients with spondylolisthesis compared to controls with Idiopathic Adolescent Scoliosis.

A blinded test retest study including multi-surgeon assessment of Pelvic Incidence in patients with spondylolisthesis and Idiopathic Adolescent Scoliosis was carried out. We assessed the agreement between the pelvic incidence measurements using the Bland and Altman method and mean differences (95% confidence interval) are reported.

Forty patients seen at Starship Children’s Hospital between 1992 – 2003 by two spinal surgeons were retrospectively identified. The main group had 20 patients with spondylolisthesis (Isthmic and/or Dysplastic types) and the control group consisted of 20 patients with Idiopathic Adolescent Scoliosis. Five observers with different levels of experience included the two orthopaedic surgeons, one fellow, one senior trainee and one non-trainee registrar. Prior to the initial test phase, a consensus-building session was carried out. All five observers arrived at a standardised method for measuring the Pelvic Incidence. In the test phase randomly ordered lateral lumbosacral radiographs were independently evaluated by the five observers and pelvic incidence was measured. Assessment of the Pelvic Incidence was repeated one week later in the re-test phase. The radiographs were presented in a randomly pre-assigned order. Bland and Altman plots were constructed and mean differences (95% confidence interval) reported to evaluate the agreement between the Pelvic Incidence measurements among the five independent observers. All analysis was performed on the statistical software package SAS. P-value of 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

The spondylolisthesis group had 11 (55%) males and 9 (45%) females with an average age of 14 ± 4.2. 2 patients had high-grade (Meyerding Class III, IV, V) and 16 had low-grade (Meyerding Class I, II) spondylolisthesis. 2 patients were post-reduction of spondylolisthesis. In the Scoliosis group there were 2 (10%) males and 18 (90%) females with an average age of 15 ± 2.9. There was no significant difference between male and females pelvic incidence measurement (60° ± 18.7° vs. 57° ± 14.6°, p=0.540) or age (15 ± 2.9 vs. 14 ± 3.8, p=0.181). There was no difference in pelvic incidence across the Meyerding groups, p=0.257. There was a significant difference between spondylolisthesis and scoliosis pelvic incidence measurements 65° ± 15.6° vs. 51° ± 12.8°, p=0.003. In the Spondylolisthesis Group the interobserver reliability between five clinicians, expressed as the mean difference in pelvic incidence measurement was 0.6° (95%CI −0.81, 1.91) and was not significantly different from zero p=0.423. The agreement limits were from −12.8° to 13.9°. The intraobserver reliability of pelvic incidence showed the mean difference ranging from −2.1° to 1.4° (p=0.129 and 0.333 with 95% CI). One had marginal evidence of a significant difference of 3.3° (95% CI 0.05° to 6.55°, p=0.047). In the Scoliosis Group the interobserver reliability was 0.3° (95% CI −0.81, 1.49) and was not significantly different from zero p=0.726. The agreement limits were from −11.0° to 11.6°. The intraobserver reliability among four observers ranged from −1.7° to 0.5° (p=0.178 and 0.661). One had a significant difference in readings of 4.1° (95% CI of 0.70° to 7.40°, p= 0.020).

Scoliosis patients had a significantly smaller pelvic incidence than spondylolisthesis patients. The interobserver reliability of the pelvic incidence measurement was excellent across both groups. The intraobserver reliability was good with only one observer in each group demonstrating a marginally significant difference. Pelvic incidence is therefore a reliable measurement which can be used as a predictor in progression of spondylolisthesis.


D.P. Gwynne Jones A.G.S. Vane G Coulter P. Herbison J.D. Dunbar

The aim of this study was to determine the inter and intra observer reliability of ultrasound measurements in treated unstable neonatal hips and whether ultrasound measurements correlate with radiological outcome at 6 months.

Sixty-four babies treated from birth with a Pavlik harness for neonatal hip instability were scanned at 2 and 6 weeks. The α and β angles of Graf, the combined (H) angle of Hosny and the femoral head coverage (FHC) were measured by 3 observers and inter-observer and intra-observer repeatability co-efficients calculated using 95% confidence limits. Hips were categorized as normal, abnormal or borderline for each parameter and Kappa values calculated. A stepwise linear regression analysis was performed to assess any relationship between ultrasound measurements at 2 or 6 weeks and outcome as determined by acetabular index at 6 months.

Seven hundred and ninety two sets of measurements were made from 248 scans. The α angle had the smallest interobserver range (17°), the H angle range was 21°and the β angle 28°. Kappa values showed good agreement for FHC and β angle. The mean acetabular index of all hips at 6 months was 26° (sd 4.9). The acetabular index was 30° or greater in 24 hips (18 babies) despite prolonged splintage in 9 hips (6 babies). The FHC at 6 weeks was predictive of acetabular index at 6 months (regression coefficient −0.27, 95% CI −0.42 to −0.12, p< 0.001)

We recommend the FHC as being reproducible, useful and predictive of outcome in neonatal hips treated for instability.


A.H. Mackey N.S Stott S.E Walt F. Miller M.C Waugh

The aim of this study was to investigate upper limb botulinum toxin A (BTX-A) injections in children with spastic hemiplegia.

Ten children with hemiplegia, aged 10–17 years, received upper limb BTX-A injections and 6 weeks therapy. BTX-A was injected using EMG guidance into elbow and wrist flexors, and forearm pronators (dose 1–2 units/kg body wt (Botox®) per muscle). Follow-up assessments continued to 24 weeks post BTX-A. Outcome measures included three-dimensional (3-D) upper limb analysis of functional tasks, Melbourne Assessment; passive range of motion (PROM), and muscle tone.

There were no serious adverse effects. Elbow flexor muscle tone was reduced to 12 weeks post BTX-A (p < 0.05). Mean passive elbow supination increased by 19 degrees (not significant, p= 0.3). Pre-injection 3-D analysis showed that, compared to controls, children with hemiplegia were slower at performing upper limb reaching tasks, using less elbow extension and supination, and utilising increased compensatory trunk forward flexion. Post BTX-A, the time to complete upper limb tasks did not change (p> 0.15). However, at least six subjects had increased elbow extension (average 17 degrees) and decreased trunk forward flexion (average 16 degrees) during upper limb reaching tasks. Five subjects improved their Melbourne Assessment score by 5% or greater.

Decreased tone and individual improvements in upper limb functional tasks were seen post BTX-A and therapy. However deficits in timing of upper limb movements did not change post BTX-A.


C. Fougere S. E. Walt R.O. Nicol S.J. Walsh N.S. Stott

We studied the results of multi-level surgical intervention for children with cerebral palsy.

Thirty patients, aged 7–16 years, with spastic diplegia (n=20), or spastic hemiplegia (n=10) were studied prospectively by gait analysis. Multilevel surgery included a combination of psoas lengthening, medial hamstring lengthening, rectus femoris transfer and gastrocnemius lengthening +/− foot surgery or femoral derotation osteotomies. Gait analyses were carried out pre-op and at 6 and 24 months post-op.

Children with spastic diplegia increased their walking velocity by an average of 20% at two years (p< 0.05). Mean stride length increased from 89cm pre-op to 102cm at two years (p< 0.05) with similar improvements in both groups of children. Maximum knee extension in stance improved from an average 17.5 degrees flexion pre-operatively to an average 5 degrees flexion postoperatively (p< 0.05). Peak knee flexion in swing was maintained and the timing improved. Peak ankle dorsiflexion in stance was unchanged following surgery but the timing of peak ankle dorsiflexion was normalised to late stance (from 24% of cycle pre-operatively to 48% of cycle post-operatively (norm = 48%). Average maximum hip extension in stance did not change. The mean anterior pelvic tilt did not change post-operatively. However, a number of children with spastic diplegia had increased anterior pelvic tilt post-operatively.

These results are similar to those reported internationally, with most improvement seen distally at the knee and ankle and less improvement at the hip. Increased anterior pelvic tilt was seen as a consequence of hamstring lengthening in some more involved patients.


S. Faraj B. Hodgson

The patients were reviewed with the aim of determining whether extending the fusion to the sacrum was needed or would affect the pelvic obliquity over the long term.

Twenty-four patients with quadriplegic cerebral palsy, (non-ambulators) aged between 5–23 who underwent corrective surgery for their scoliosis were included in the study

Twelve patients were stabilized to the sacrum (LUQUE-Galveston technique) and 12 to L4 or L5 in the lumbar spine using pedicle screws. The patients were divided into two groups. Group 1 Pelvic obliquity less than 20° – no stabilisation to the pelvis. Group 2 Pelvic obliquity more than 20° – stabilisation to the pelvis.

Group 1 – Patients with pre-operative pelvic obliquity less than 20° maintained their pre-operative pelvic obliquity without significant deterioration (less than 6° change). Group 2 – Patients with pelvic obliquity of 20° or more stabilised to the sacrum maintained or improved their correction until fusion. One patient had a draining sinus six months after the index operation for which removal of metalware (after fusion) was needed. No patient had a non union of the fusion mass.

We believe that patients with a pelvic obliquity of less than 20 degrees at the time of surgery don’t need stabilization to the pelvis. Lumbar pedicle screws give sufficient stability to the distal construct and preserve mobility at the lumbosacral junction. Operative times and blood loss were reduced in those patients not fixed to the pelvis. There appears to be no significant loss of correction of the pelvis obliquity over time.


H. Crawford G. Haaft C. Walker

Non-operative treatment methods of idiopathic clubfoot have become increasingly accepted worldwide as the initial standard of care. The Ponseti method has become particularly popular due to published short and long term success rates in North America. The purpose of the current study was to examine the early rate of relapse in a New Zealand population and analyze patient characteristics for factors predictive of relapse.

Fifty-one consecutive babies with seventy-eight club-feet treated by the Ponseti technique were followed prospectively for a minimum of two years from the start of treatment. Recurrence, defined as the need for any operative intervention, was analyzed with respect to severity at presentation, timing of presentation, the number of casts needed to obtain correction, family history of clubfoot, ethnicity, and compliance with abduction bracing. Recurrence was subdivided into minor recurrences, defined as a tendon transfer or Achilles lengthening, and major recurrences, defined as a full posterior or posteromedial release.

Twenty patients (39%) had a recurrence. Eleven patients (22%) had a major recurrence and nine patients (17%) had a minor recurrence. Only three of twenty-five patients (12%) who were compliant with bracing had a major recurrence. Twenty-five of fifty-one patients (49%) were compliant with bracing. The greatest risk factor for recurrence was non compliance with abduction bracing, with an odds ration of 5 (p = 0.009). Although not quite statistically significant (p = .07), ethnicity was also related to recurrence, with Polynesian patients being three times less likely than white Europeans to recur. No statistically significant relationships were found between recurrence and severity at presentation, timing of presentation, the number of casts needed to obtain correction, or family history of clubfoot.

Compliance with abduction bracing is crucial to avoiding recurrence of clubfoot. The Polynesian club-foot seems more amenable to Ponseti technique and less likely to recur than the white European clubfoot. In those patients who are compliant, the Ponseti method is very effective at maintaining a correction, with minimal need for major surgery. However, even among the compliant patients, minor recurrences are common, and among the noncompliant patients, many major and minor recurrences should be expected.


K. Mohammed A. Broksbank A. Gooding M. Coates

The aim was to define the operative and MRI arthrogram findings in recurrent post stabilization instability, to establish the accuracy of MRI findings compared to surgical findings, and to define the role of MRI in evaluation and planning for these patients.

The operative findings in 25 consecutive patients undergoing revision shoulder stabilization procedures were reviewed. 18 of these patients had MRI arthrograms prior to their revision procedure. All revision procedures were performed by the same surgeon, and all MRI scans reviewed by 2 musculoskeletal radiologists.

Primary and contributing factors for instability were identified for each patient. Primary factors for failure included; new injury at a different site to the index repair (6 patients), laxity of the inferior glenohumeral ligament (5 patients), failure of the index repair (7 patients) and failure to address the pathology at the index procedure (7 patients).

MRI arthrography had 85% sensitivity, 100% specificity and 89% accuracy.

MRI arthrography is accurate in assessment of the labrum in recurrent post stabilization instability. Recurrent instability is complex and multifactorial, but a primary factor can often be identified. In some cases new trauma results in injury at a different site to the initial repair. MRI arthrogram may assist in surgical planning. If a labral injury is present without laxity or a glenoid bony defect, arthroscopic revision may be undertaken. If significant capsular laxity or bone deficiency is present, then an open procedure with capsular shift and rotator interval closure may be appropriate.


A. Puri J. Calder

Rotator cuff tears are an increasingly recognizable and common problem amongst the elderly. We undertook this review to assess outcome from open surgical rotator cuff repair and acromioplasty in patients over the age of 70 years.

A retrospective review of 61 patients with 64 full thickness rotator cuff tears treated with open repair and decompression acromioplasty between 1/1/92 and 30/6/04.To evaluate the current functional state and satisfaction (mean time from surgery 46.3 months) 50 patients were contacted and invited to attend for clinical evaluation using Constant and Murley’s functional score and/or answer a modified subjective 12 point Simple Shoulder Test. Eleven patients were not contactable despite attempts through post and phone.

All grades of tears were reparable with 48 being good tendon to bone. All the patients underwent a six week supervised physiotherapy programme. Complications included 6 frozen shoulder and seven cases of re- rupture .One patient each developed pulmonary embolism and reflex sympathetic dystrophy. Based on the definitive scoring of Constant and Murley’s 31 were rated as excellent (80–100 points) 9 good (65–79), 2 fair (50–64) and 2 poor (less than 50). Out of the total 43 patients (44 shoulders) examined and scored 90% showed excellent and good results.

Symptomatic rotator cuff tears in the elderly, active and healthy patients treated by a surgical repair results in good and early functional return, lasting pain relief and excellent patient satisfaction and should be actively considered as a definitive mode of treatment in this age group.


S. Dempsey J. Manson J. van Dalen

To investigate the significance of a cluster of cases of glenohumeral chondrolysis occuring following the intra-articular injection of methylene blue to assess rotator cuff integrity during open anterior acromioplasty.

All cases of acromioplasty during the period 1999 to 2004 were reviewed to determine the incidence of chondrolysis with and without methylene blue injection.

There was a significantly higher incidence of chondrolysis following intra-articular injection of methylene blue.

The association of intra-articular methylene blue with chondrolysis has not been previously described in the literature. We conclude that methylene blue should not be used for intra-articular injection.


A. Durrant H. Crawford M. Barnes

The aim was to compare the efficacy and outcomes of reduction of closed forearm fractures in a paediatric population using Ketamine in the Emergency Department (ED) setting versus reduction under general anaesthesia (GA) in the operating theatre (OT).

A prospective audit of children presenting to our institution with closed fractures of the radius and/or ulna was conducted. Patients presenting to ED were offered manipulation under GA or Ketamine, and then grouped accordingly. Children were followed up until full range of motion had recovered. Outcomes measured at follow up were 1) need for remanipulation, 2) position at union, 3) total hospital stay and 4) functional outcome.

Forearm fractures account for 22% of acute paediatric orthopaedic admissions to our institution. 70% require manipulation and splintage. 221 forearm fractures required manipulation during the study period. 90 patients (41%) were manipulated under Ketamine in the ED, 131 patients (59%) were manipulated in the OT. There was no significant difference in mean angulation of fractures treated by either method (p=0.20). There was no significant difference between the two methods with respect to rates of remanipulation (p=0.73) or poor position at union (p=0.55). There was a significantly shorter hospital stay for those treated in the ED.

Treatment of paediatric forearm fractures in the ED under Ketamine sedation offers an effective alternative for selected fractures. It also offers considerable financial savings and is less of a drain on valuable theatre and staff resources.


S. Amarasekera K.J. Davey

To determine the outcome of Clavicle Hook Plate fixation in terms of level of function achieved, healing of the fracture and the need for removal of the hook plate.

Review of patient records and radiographs of all the fractured clavicles and acromioclavicular dislocations that were surgically treated with a Clavicle Hook Plate. The study population was identified using the operating theatre data.

A total of 24 patients (19 lateral third-Neer type II-fractures and 5 type III acromioclavicular dislocations) were treated from January 1998 to December 2003. Eighteen of the 24 plates (75%) had been removed at the time of the study. In 72% restriction of the range of movement and pain due to plate impingement were the main causes for removal of the plate. Two of the plates (11%) were removed due to ‘mechanical failure’; the plate being levered off the bone or eroding the acromion. Mechanical failure of the plate was significantly associated with an older age group (P=0.01).

At the time of discharge from the clinic 57% had more than 50% of their shoulder movements, while 55.5% had minimal or no pain.

We suggest that Clavicle Hook Plates should be routinely removed as they cause impingement symptoms and they be used with caution (if at all) in the older age group given the tendency for the plate to lever off the bone.


T. Woodfield S. Miot I. Martin J. Riesle C.A. van Blitterswijk

Tissue engineering techniques, combining autologous chondrocytes with biodegradable biomaterials, may offer significant advantages over current articular cartilage repair strategies. We present a series of experiments investigating the effect of 3D scaffold architecture and biomaterial composition on cartilage tissue formation in vitro and in vivo.

Porous polymer (PEGT/PBT) scaffolds with low (300/55/45) or high (1000/70/30) PEG molecular weight (MW) compositions were produced using novel solid free-form fabrication (3DF) techniques, allowing precise control over pore architecture, and conventional compression moulding (CM) foam techniques. Scaffolds were seeded with expanded human nasal chondrocytes, and cultured in vitro or implanted subcutaneously in vivo in nude mice for 4 weeks and cartilage tissue formation accessed.

3DF scaffolds contained highly accessible networks of large interconnecting pores (Ø525 μm) compared to CM scaffolds, containing complex networks of small interconnecting pores (Ø182 μm). 3DF scaffold architectures enhanced cell re-differentiation (GAG/DNA) and cartilaginous matrix accumulation compared to CM scaffolds, but only if 1000/70/30 compositions were used. Collagen type-II mRNA was significantly increased in 3DF architectures irrespective of scaffold composition. These effects were likely mediated by preferential protein adsorption to 1000/70/30 materials, promoting a spherical chondrocyte-like morphology, as well as efficient nutrient/waste exchange throughout interconnecting pores within 3DF architectures.

We observed synergistic effects of both composition and 3D scaffold architecture on human chondrocyte re-differentiation capacity, however, our data suggests that scaffold composition has a more significant influence than architecture alone. Such design criteria could be included in future scaffold architectures for repairing articular cartilage defects.


H. Curry G. Horne

The aim was to review the data and survival of patients with osteosarcoma in New Zealand from 1994 to 1999 and compare this to data retrieved from a similar review of the data and survival of patients from 1981 to1987.

Data was obtained from the New Zealand cancer registry from 1994–1999 and the raw data was retrieved from the 1981–1987 study.

There were 98 cases in the 1981–1987 cohort and 85 cases in the 1994–1999 cohort. Overall 5 year survival from osteosarcoma improved from 31.6% to 43.5% between the cohorts. The 5 year survival in patients less than 40 years with non metastatic tumours improved from 54.2% to 69.7%. When patients were stratified by age and stage there was a statistically significant improvement in survival between the 2 cohorts

The survival in patients with osteosarcoma in New Zealand has improved over the study period and is similar to that seen in the overseas literature.


A. Rothwell K. Cragg L. O’Neill

The aim was to compare the medium term results of metacarpophalangeal joint (MCPJ) arthroplasty using three different types of silicone hinged implants.

All rheumatoid arthritis patients undergoing four finger MCPJ arthroplasty at Burwood Hospital have had standardised pre and post operative assessments for up to four years consisting of: measurement of MCPJ active arc of motion (AOM); finger ulnar drift (UD) and the Baltimore upper extremity function test (UEFT). All surgery was undertaken or directly supervised by one surgeon using a standardised technique followed by a dynamic and static splintage programme supervised by the same hand therapists.

Implants – Swanson; 25 hands, 100 joints, 1989 to 1995 – Avanta; 27 hands, 108 joints, 1995 to 2000 – Neuflex; 11 hands, 44 joints, 1999 to 2003

Swanson – at two years the AOM changed from 46 – 80° to 15 – 51°; UD reduced from 33 to 4°and 66% had improved from partial and poor to functional UE categories.

Avanta – the AOM changed from 51 – 79 to 15– 60; UD from 31 to 7° and 67% had improved to functional.

Neuflex – the AOM changed from 42 – 68 to 17 – 63°; UD from 32 to 11 and 45% had improved to functional classification.

From two to four years the UEFT for the Swanson and Avanta had significantly deteriorated.

The medium term outcomes for the three implants were very similar. Neuflex use was discontinued in 2003 because of early recurrence of ulnar drift. The significant deterioration of hand function from two to four years is likely to be the effect of progressive rheumatoid disease as the AOM and UD remained unchanged.


Full Access
P. O’Grady RWG Watson J. O’Bryne T. O’Brien J. Fitzpatrick

Aseptic loosening is the single most important long-term complication of total joint arthroplasty. Wear debris induced inflammation stimulates osteoclastic resorption of bone. Cellular mechanisms involved in osteoblast viability in PWD induced inflammation is poorly understood.

Wear induced inflammation increases osteoblast necrosis and susceptibility to death by apoptosis. PMMA cement has a detrimental effect on osteoblast resistance to apoptosis, and that this is via an receptor mediated pathway. Osteoblast cell cultures (Human and MG63) were grown with and without PMMA cement and assessed for apoptosis and necrosis. TNF-α or Fas antibody simulated inflammation. Viability and apoptosis with PI exclusion, flow cytometry and western blotting assessed response.

Cement induced osteoblast necrosis up to 1 hour. This effect was negated after 24 hours. Culture of osteob1asts on cement had no direct effect on spontaneous apoptosis but susceptibility to inflammation was increased.

Polymerised cement has no direct effect on osteoblast cell death. Effects are mediated by inhibiting expression of anti-apoptotic protein (Bcl-2), and increasing susceptibility to inflammatory. Osteoblast resistance to death may represent a novel and important factor in aseptic loosening. The role of gene therapy is explored.


M. Fairhurst J. Donovan L. Hansen

Twenty four patients who had a Proximal Row Carpectomy (PRC) were reviewed 9 months to 9 years post surgery (average 5 yrs). The initial cohort of 14 patients was previously reported to the society in a review encompassing 12 months to five years follow-up post surgery. No patients were lost to follow-up. Primary pathology involved wrists with scapholunate advanced collapse, long-standing scaphoid non-unions and fragmented Kienbock’s disease. All patients had painful wrists limiting function preoperatively.

Twenty wrists continue to function well with their PRC. They are comfortable and strong. Mass power grip was 77% of the non-injured side. A functional flexion/extension arc of 65 % of the non-injured side was obtained. No patients with functioning PRCs have had to change their work or recreational activities primarily because of their wrist. Rapid return to work and sport was achieved in the twenty patients with a well functioning PRC. Four wrists (from the first cohort) were converted to wrist fusion for unresolved pain all around a year post PRC. Three patients developed major reflex sympathy dystrophy requiring intensive therapy. Three patients developed carpal tunnel syndrome requiring decompression.

PRC is appealing in its surgical simplicity as a motion preserving procedure for the painful wrist. In the majority of circumstances it is both reliable and durable providing a comfortable strong wrist with a functional range of movement. Rehabilitation is uncomplicated and function is rapidly recovered. Patients with ongoing pain can be salvaged with a wrist fusion.


A. Rothwell

The aim was to study the outcome of the vein wrap technique in the treatment of post carpal tunnel causalgia (CRPS type II).

Five patients with a diagnosis of post carpal tunnel release causalgia were treated with the vein wrap technique. This involves performing an extended carpal tunnel release gently freeing all nerve adhesions and then wrapping the endothelial surface of a longitudinally split segment of the cephalic vein around the median nerve from proximal to the carpal tunnel to the commencement of the distal divisions. The wrap is secured with 6.0 Novafil sutures. Post surgery the wrist and hand are supported in a volar slab and bandage for two weeks followed by patient managed mobilising exercises. There were three females and two males with follow-up ranging from six months to three years. Time from onset of causalgia to surgery ranged from 6 months to 13 years. In three patients there was immediate and profound relief of causalgic symptoms; in one, symptoms completely resolved over six weeks and in one, in which the nerve had been severely crushed prior to initial surgery, the causalgic symptoms markedly improved but the post injury numbness has persisted. In none has there been recurrence or deterioration.

Post carpal tunnel release causalgia is a devastating and disabling complication. It is often resistant to a range of treatment modalities but the vein wrap is a simple procedure which in the author’s experience can be dramatically effective even in patients with very long standing causalgia.


M. Clatworthy S. Young H. Deverall T. Harper

Microfracture is a stem cell stimulation technique to promote the healing of full thickness articulate cartilage defects

Sixty-six patients have undergone microfracture for full thickness articulate cartilage defects over a five year period. All procedures were performed by one surgeon following the technique of Steadman. All patients were under 46, had an isolated chondral lesion, had a stable well aligned knee and were a minimum of one year post surgery.

Patients were evaluated with a preoperative and follow up IKDC score, WOMAC score, KOOS Score, Tegner activity level and SF 36, VAS pain scores and overall knee function score. Failure was determined by the need for a secondary chondral procedure.

Nine patients failed. Thus the overall success rate was 86%. The failure rate was higher with larger lesions.

There was a significant improvement in IKDC score, WOMAC score, KOOS Score, Tegner activity level and SF 36, VAS pain scores and overall knee function score.

Microfracture has a good success rate in the short to medium term with isolated full thickness articular cartilage lesions in the stable well aligned knee.


R. Tregonning

The aim was to identify frequency and pattern of early UKR failure in New Zealand.

We analysed data from the New Zealand National Joint Register in a 44 month period of 2000–2003.

Thirty-five percent of the 1790 registered UKRs were performed in the last 8 months [ie. in 18% of the total time period]. The ratio of UKRs to TKRs performed was 1:6.25. Fifty two revisions meant a failure rate of 2.9% for UKR (n=1790) compared with 1.6% for TKR (n=11243). The most commonly used implants were the Oxford P3 (68% of total with 2.2% revision rate), MG uni (14.6% with 4.6% revision rate) and Preservation (7% with 5.6 revision rate). The most common reasons for revision (n=52) were aseptic loosening (28%), bearing dislocation or impingement (19%), and unexplained pain (13%). The deep sepsis rate for UKR was 0.33% compared to 0.43% for TKR.

UKR usage is rapidly increasing in NZ. The revision rate for UKR was 1.8 x that for TKR. The revision rate for deep sepsis was 77% that for TKR. Unexplained pain in apparently technically normal UKR was the 3rd most common reason for revision. Bearing impingement was as common as bearing dislocation as a cause for failure in the Oxford P3 UKR. Early polythene wear was the reason for revision only in the 8mm MG prosthesis.


J. Rollo C. Taylor A. Ievins A. Pimpalnerkar

The aim was to demonstrate that day case Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) reconstruction, without the use of a tourniquet, is clinically effective, cost effective, safe and “patient choice” procedure.

Fifty patients who underwent day case, arthroscopic, ACL reconstruction without the use of a tourniquet, but using saline and epinephrine, pump regulated, irrigation. The same surgeon performed each case for the period May 2003 to April 2005. Seven patients had their tendons reconstructed with the use of patellar tendon grafts, the remainder, 43 patients, had hamstring tendon grafts. The study included 6 women and 44 men. This prospective study assessed cost effectiveness, clinical efficacy by measuring post-operative pain and postoperative results and finally whether this procedure remained the “patient choice”. The mean age was 30.6 years, (range 16 – 46). In addition to assessing level of immediate post operative pain the patients were also assessed at two weeks and six weeks for pain, range of movement, swelling and for the occurrence of any early post-operative complications.

We were able to show that there was a significant cost benefit, approximately one third to a half in comparison to other local surgeons; that the study was clinically effective and that there were no reported early complications; and that all 50 patients would choose to have the surgery again as a day case procedure with this technique.

We would like to present day case ACL reconstruction without the use of a tourniquet, as a safe option for the carefully selected patient.


T. Sharpe E. Yee T.G. Lynskey

The aim was to determine the longterm results of the Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement implanted by a single surgeon in a community hospital setting.

The results of the first 97 cases performed by a single surgeon between Feb 1991 Feb 1999 were retrospectively reviewed. Demographic and operative data were recorded and patients were assessed with Knee Society knee score and x-ray.

Ninety seven operations were performed on 83 patients. Antero-medial osteoarthritis was the predominant preoperative diagnosis present in 96, gout was present in 2 and avascular necrosis in one. The average age was 70, follow-up 104.3 months with maximum 170 months. Kaplan-Meier analysis was performed and survival was 88% at 124 months. 20 patients (21 knees) had died and 10 (9 patients) had required revision leaving 65 knees available for review. No cases were lost to follow-up. Of the 10 revisions 7 had been revised to a total knee, 4 for lateral wear or pain, one for femoral loosening, 1 for tibial subsidence and 1 for infection. Four of these patients had a previous high tibial osteotomy. The remaining 3 revisions included 2 1iner exchanges for fracture and wear in one patient with varus knees at 11 years and 1 liner exchange for dislocation.

The Oxford UKA gives satisfactory longterm results in antero-medial osteoarthritis. We would caution against using this prosthesis where a previous high tibial osteotomy has been performed.


D.P. Gwynne Jones J. Draffin A.G.S. Vane R. Craig S.F. McMahon

The aim was to compare the initial pull out strengths of various interference screw devices used for tibial fixation of hamstring grafts and the effect of concentric or eccentric screw position.

Quadrupled tendon grafts were harvested from freshly killed sheep. The grafts were then prepared and fixed in the distal femur using various devices (Intrafix, RCI screw, Wedge screw +/− transfix pin, screw and post) in both concentric and eccentric positions. A single load to failure test was then performed.

The highest pull out strength was with the Intrafix device inserted concentrically (mean 941N). This was significantly higher than the wedge screw inserted concentrically (737N) (p=0.015). This in turn had significantly greater initial pull out strength than the wedge eccentric with post or pin (p=0.03) and the RCI screw (464N) (p=0.00036).

In this sheep model the Intrafix device inserted concentrically had a significantly greater initial pull-out strength than the other interference screws tested. Concentric positioning of an interference screw gave significantly greater initial pullout strength of a quadruple hamstring graft than eccentric positioning. Addition of a cross pin or post made no difference to initial pullout strength.


M. Clatworthy T. Harper R. Maddison

The purpose of this study was initially to examine the effect of tibial slope on anterior tibial translation in the ACL deficient knee measured objectively using the KT 1000 arthrometer. Patients were then evaluated one year post ACL reconstruction to determine the effect of tibial slope on the outcome of ACL reconstruction.

One-hundred patients (male = 70, female 30) aged between 14 and 49 years (Mean = 28.70, SD 8.80) with a diagnosis of isolated anterior cruciate ligament rupture were prospectively recruited. All participants had intact ACLs of the contralateral limb. The following information was recorded for all patients preoperatively and one year post surgery; time from injury to surgery, IKDC objective and subjective assessment and KT 1000 arthrometer readings. Tibial slope was assessed from long tibial lateral x-rays as described by Dejour and Bonnin. Finally, assessment of the menisci occurred intra-operatively. Tibial slope was correlated with KT 1000, meniscal integrity and IKDC assessments. Patients underwent an arthroscopic hamstring ACL reconstruction using Endobutton and Intrafix fixation. All procedures were performed by one surgeon

Pre Reconstruction – Bivariate correlations showed a significant correlation between tibial slope and KT 1000 (r= .29, p < .001). This relation was strengthened when the integrity of the menisci were controlled for (r = .32, p < . 001). When time to surgery was controlled for, correlations between tibial slope and KT 1000 were unaffected. There was also a negative correlation between medial meniscal integrity and time to surgery (r = −.41, p < . 001). No relationships between time to surgery and KT 1000 were evident

Post Reconstruction – Eighty patients were evaluated at a one year post surgery. One patient had a rerupture. The mean KT 1000 difference was 1mm. KT 1000 was > 2mm in 9% and > 5mm in the re rupture only. The mean subjective IKDC score was 89. Using objective IKDC 89% were classified as normal, 10% as nearly normal and 1% as severely abnormal (the rerupture). Bivariate correlations showed no significant correlation between tibial slope and post operative KT 1000 (r= .178, p = .0.115).

This study demonstrates a significant relationship between increasing tibial slope and anterior tibial translation of the ACL deficient knee. The relationship did not exist in the post ACL reconstructed knee. However this needs to be investigated further with greater numbers and in the ACL revision group.


J. Mckie

Opening wedge proximal tibial osteotomy has become more popular in recent years, particularly in the management of medial compartment osteoarthritis. Unfortunately, fixation failures and/or non-unions of this osteotomy still occur.

The aim of this study is to review two cases of failed opening wedge osteotomies salvaged with the Taylor Spatial frame.

Both cases were reviewed clinically and radiographically and an analysis of their deformity was carried out. If required, metalware was removed and the Spatial frame applied and the deformity gradually corrected with either repeat osteotomy (case 1) or distraction of the non-union (case 2) until ideal alignment had been achieved. When the osteotomy regenerate had satisfactorily hardened, the frame was removed, and the patients were initially protected in a range of motion brace.

Both patients achieved the desired correction of their deformities and union of their osteotomies, and had the frames removed at an average of 124 days following application.

The Taylor Spatial frame is a very powerful tool for correcting complex multi-apical deformities in the juxta-articular region of the proximal tibia through minimally invasive techniques.


N.I. Hartnett R.J.A. Tregonning A. Rothwell T. Hobbs

To identify frequency and patterns of Oxford Phase 3 UKA failure in New Zealand through analysis of national primary and revision data.

Retrospective audit examining all revision Oxford Phase 3 UKAs recorded in the New Zealand National Joint Register from January 2000 to October 2003 were analysed along with surgeons’ clinical notes and patient x-rays.

Seventy-three Orthopædic Surgeons performed 1216 Oxford UKAs. The average age was 66.4 years (range 35–94). Osteoarthritis was the primary diagnosis for 1163 (96%) patients. Mean time to revision was 437 days (14.4 months). The early revision rate was 2.2% (n=27). The most common reasons for revision were aseptic loosening (n=7, 26%), bearing dislocation (n=5, 19%) and pain (n=4, 15%). The deep infection rate was 0.16% (2/1216). Eighteen surgeons (high use > 8 UKAs/year) performed 787 (64%) operations, with a revision rate of 1.5%. Twenty-two surgeons (low use ≤ 1 UKA/year) performed 38 (3%) operations, with a revision rate of 8%. This was statistically significant, p= 0.03 (odds ratio 5.7).

The early revision rate for the Oxford UKA is 1.4 times greater than TKA. High use surgeons revision rate is lower than TKA. An inverse relationship between failure and surgeon experience exists. This confirms Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register findings.


JC. Theis S. Gambhir

We analysed the clinical outcome of infected hip and knee replacements treated in Dunedin over a 10 year period.

Using the departmental audit data base all infected arthroplasties treated between 1990 and 2000 and the clinical notes reviewed.

Fifty-three hips and 20 knees were identified. 69% of patients had debridement and antibiotics as the primary treatment. In terms of prosthesis retention 41% of patients had retained the original prosthesis, 30% had implants in place following revision and 29% had a resection arthroplasty or arthrodesis. Retention of the original prosthesis was significantly higher in early as compared to late infections and knees did better than hips. The most common organisms identified were staphylococci (47%) and streptococci (29%). We did not see any difference in outcome of streptococcal infections.

The treatment of infected arthroplasties remains controversial. We propose management guidelines based on outcomes of a series of 73 cases.


G. Hooper N. Hooper T. Hobbs A. Rothwell

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of simultaneous bilateral total hip and total knee arthroplasty performed in New Zealand during the first five years of the New Zealand National Joint Register and to determine whether this was an acceptable practice.

All total knee and total hip arthroplasties collected on the National Joint Register between 1999 and 2003 were divided into three groups – unilateral joint arthroplasty, staged bilateral joint arthroplasty and simultaneous joint arthroplasty. The Oxford 12 questionnaire results at six months were assessed as well as the patients self reported complications. All deaths that occurred within 6 months of the surgery were also recorded.

Analysis between the three groups was then performed using ANOVA tables comparing age, the Oxford scores and complications.

There was generally a significant difference (p< .001) in age between unilateral hip and knee replacement and staged or simultaneous bilateral replacement, with patients undergoing bilateral simultaneous replacement being younger.

There was a significant difference (p< .001) in the Oxford 12 scores between unilateral hip and knee replacement and both staged and simultaneous bilateral hip and knee replacement, with the bilateral simultaneous replacements scoring the best.

The death rate within the first 6 months was low in all groups with only 1 patient dying within 3 months of the surgery from an unrelated cause. The complication rate was low in all groups, in particular the DVT and pulmonary embolus rate, as reported by the patients, was not increased in either the sequential staged group or the simultaneous bilateral group.

The New Zealand National Joint Register has proven to be a valuable tool in gaining early information regarding the outcome following bilateral and staged lower limb total joint arthroplasty. The results clearly show that in the appropriate clinical situation performing simultaneous bilateral total knee or total hip arthroplasty is a safe and effective procedure.


N. Lash G. Horne P. Devane K. Adams

The aim was to review patients that had single stage bilateral total hip joint replacements (SSBTHJR) of two surgeons in the Wellington area, to assess symptomatic relief and overall quality of life before and after surgery. To also review xrays of this population to assess acetabular component orientation.

Fifty patients from two hospitals, with minimum follow up of two years, who had SSBTHJR, were reviewed for duration of stay, time to mobilisation, and complications (eg. wound infections, venous thrombus and embolism (VTE), gastrointestinal ileus, and cardiac events). Patient opinions on hip joint function (Oxford Hip Score) and overall quality of life (EQ-5D Score) were performed (37/50 patients could participate). Patient’s postoperative radiographs were analysed with Polyware Auto Version 6.00 to measure acetabular cup orientation for both sides.

Oxford Hip Score mean was 20.5 (range 12 – 56), compared to the national mean 19.3. The median score was 14. Most patients (65%) had no symptoms of pain, difficulty in mobilising, or performing activities of daily living (ADL). 19% of patients had mild to moderate symptoms/difficulty, and 16% had significant pain/difficulty On average, using a visual analogue scale, patients felt their health was 42% better after having their surgery. Complication rates were minimal, and were primarily superficial wound infections. Hip acetabular cup positioning analysis was performed (statistical analysis pending).

Patients undergoing SSBTHJR have comparable results for Oxford Hip Scores compared to unilateral THJR patients, improved lifestyle, but not increased complications.


G. Horne P. Devane W. Allanach

The aim was to evaluate the polyethylene wear in an uncemented all polyethylene titanium coated acetabular cup a minimium of ten years post-operatively, and to determine the effect of supine “stress” radiographs on 3-dimensional polyethylene wear, compared with “non-stress” radiographs.

Twenty seven hips in twenty five patients were examined, and standard and stress radiographs were performed. All radiographs were analysed using Polywear 5 auto, to measure 2d, 3d, and volumetric wear. Wear measurements were performed three times to minimise error. Radiographs were analysed for osteolysis.

There were 12 males and 13 females. Eighteen patients had a diagnosis of osteoarthritis.20 patients had a ceramic head and 7 a metal head. There was no association between wear rates and age, weight, diagnosis, Harris hip score or femoral head type. There was no acetabular osteolysis. The average linear wear was 0.11 +/− 0.08 mm/yr. The stress radiographs did not influence the 2D or 3D wear measurements.

This sudy shows a similar wear rate to most published series. The stress radiographs did not influence the wear measurements. The absence of osteolysis is of interest as other uncemented cups have significant osteolysis at ten years.


I.A. Spika M.L. Walker W.J. Farrington

The study was conducted to investigate differences between simultaneous and sequential cementing of the tibial and femoral components in total knee joint replacements. Our hypothesis was that cementing the components sequentially increases accuracy of the final position.

This was a prospective and randomized study, performed using a computer navigation system as the evaluation technique to determine the accuracy of implant positioning. All knee replacements (Scorpio, Stryker) were implanted using navigation technique.

The patients were divided in two groups. The first group had implants cemented simultaneously where the tibial and femoral components were implanted with a single mix of cement and then pressurized by extending the leg.

The second group of patients had the tibial component inserted with the first mix of cement and then impacted. The cement was allowed to set before proceeding with insertion of the femoral component using a second mix of cement.

The computer navigation system was utilized for bone cuts. It was then used to measure 3 sets of angles. The first set was varus/valgus cut of the femur, varus/valgus cut of the tibia and posterior slope of the tibia. The second set of measurements were the same angles, this time of the position of the prosthetic components before cementing, and the third set after cementing.

Our interim results show just a small difference between the two techniques.

It does not appear there is substantial difference in positioning of the implants between these two different techniques.


G. Horne P. Devane A. Davidson G. Purdie K. Adams

The aim was to investigate whether or not the pre-operative injection of cortico-steroids into the knee influences the infection rate of a subsequent total knee replacement.

This was a case controlled study, in which it was calculated that 152 controls and 38 infected cases would give sufficient power to the study. The infection group had to have had a delay in wound healing or have had a revision for infection.

A total of 32.8% had had an injection at some time pre-operatively. The average number of injections was 2.23, with a range of 1–15. 37% were performed by a G.P., 35% by an orthopaedic surgeon, and 22% by a rheumatologist.79% had the injection within 12 months of surgery. The rate of injection was the same in the two groups. There was no significant difference in the infection rate between the two groups (OR 1.38; 95%CI 0.55–3.31)

Despite recent literature indicating that there is a 10% increase in infection in patients having steroid injections into the hip prior to THR this study does not confirm this risk in patients undergoing TKR.


D. Gwynne Jones

The aim was to audit the numbers of non-residents requiring orthopaedic admission to our hospital and determine the effect of increasing tourist numbers and changes in Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) regulations on health care resources.

Details of non-resident orthopaedic admissions for fiscal years 1997/8 to 2003/4 were analysed with respect to country of residence, mechanism of injury, case weights consumed and actual costs.

There has been no change in numbers of admissions or cost averaging 32 cases (50 case weights) per year over the 7 year period. Most patients came from Asia (59 cases, 26%), then Australia (52 cases, 23%) and UK (40 cases 18%). Snowsports accounted for 40% of admissions, Motor vehicle accidents (MVA)17% and falls 29%.

Non-resident, non-MVA admissions have averaged 21 CW per year since the changes in ACC regulations in 1999.

Despite increasing tourist numbers there has been no increase in numbers or CW of non-residents requiring orthopaedic admission. Although representing only a small proportion of the orthopaedic budget they generate many hidden costs. The 50 CW annually equates to approximately 13 major joint replacements per year. The increase in CWs consumed due to the ACC changes have had no corresponding increase in contracted orthopaedic volumes.


Full Access
P O’Grady R.W.G. Watson H.P. Redmond D. Bouchier-Hayes

The mechanism by which cells die is important in an immune response and its resolution. The role of apoptosis in sepsis and trauma, and its regulation by cytokines is unclear. During the systemic inflammatory response, rates of human neutrophil apoptosis are decreased. Peritoneal macrophage apoptosis has been induced by nitric oxide and Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in vitro but this has not as yet been demonstrated in vivo.

We examined the induction and effects of macrophage apoptosis in a model of trauma and sepsis.

One hundred female CD-I mice were randomised into four groups: Control, Septic model, challenged with intraperitoneal LPS (1.Img/200ul/mouse), Traumatic model, received hind limb amputation (HLA) and a Combined trauma/septic model. After 24 hrs mice were sacrificed and peritoneal macrophages were assessed for apoptosis by morphology and DNA fragmentation by flow cytometry and DNA gel electrophoresis

Peritoneal lavage from septic models had a decreased percentage of macrophages in comparison to control and trauma groups. The septic model also had a significantly increased incidence of apoptosis in comparison to control and trauma levels. There was no significant difference between control and traumatic groups.

These findings demonstrate that in a murine model of sepsis, lipopolysaccharide induces macrophages apoptosis. Modulation of this immune response may have important roles in the management of trauma patients.


Full Access
P. O’Grady A Moore N. Currams E. Masterson

Waste disposal is an issue that affects us all. The amount and toxicity of medical waste has increased in line with increasing medical facilities and diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. Demand for landfill sites and increasing household and hospital waste loads, have made the current situation untenable. New thinking and new strategies must be employed

To investigate waste production in the operating department during a primary total hip arthroplasty.

A prospective observational study, waste from packaging and non-clinical materials in fifty consecutive total hip replacements. Weight, volume, cost of disposal and percentage of recycled items were recorded. Inappropriate segregation of waste was recorded and the hazards involved are discussed.

Domestic waste is compressed and buried at a cost of €222($383)/tonne. This extrapolates into a cost of about €1,500($2,589) yearly in the region and over €10,000($17,000) in Ireland. Cost to the environment, 2.6 tonnes locally, and 18.9 tonnes of surgical waste/year. Biological waste buried at €880 ($1,518)/tonne.

Reduce, Reuse and Recycle are the cornerstones of waste management. Medical staff need to understand how best to segregate waste and take advantage of opportunities for reuse and recycling. We must revisit the packaging of implants, the use of recycled paper.


O.D. Williamson B. J. Gabbe D.M. Urquhart P.A. Cameron

The aim of this study was to determine predictors of persisting moderate/severe pain post orthopaedic injury.

Data were obtained from patients presenting to the two adult level 1 trauma centres in Victoria, Australia between August 2003 and August 2004. The maximum self reported pain levels at discharge and at 6 months post injury were determined using 11-point visual analogue scales (VAS). Moderate/severe pain was defined as a VAS score of 5 or greater. Associations between categorical variables were determined using chi-square tests and adjusted using multivariate logistic regression to determine possible predictors of persistent pain.

Data were obtained from 742 patients (age 15–100 years, 60.7% male). 37.1% had moderate/severe pain 6 months post injury. Moderate/severe pain at discharge was associated with an increased risk (OR 2.46 (95%CI 1.72–3.52), p< 0.0001) and isolated upper extremity injuries were associated with a reduced risk (OR 0.43 (95%CI 0.24–0.75), p=0.003) of moderate/severe pain 6 months post injury. Age (p=0.98), gender (p=0.37) and the presence of multiple orthopaedic (p=0.76) or non-orthopaedic injuries (p=0.58) were not predictors of moderate/severe pain 6 months post injury.

The severity of pain at discharge was the main predictor of moderate/severe pain 6 months following orthopaedic trauma. Further studies are needed to determine if improving pain control prior to discharge can reduce the incidence of persistent pain following orthopaedic injury.


O. D. Williamson

The aim was to investigate the outcomes of patients admitted with orthopaedic injuries to adult Level 1 trauma centres.

All patients admitted to the two Level 1 adult trauma centres in Victoria, Australia were registered by the Victorian Orthopaedic Trauma Outcome Registry (VOTOR). Baseline data collected included age, gender and injury cause, diagnosis and management. Patients were contacted 6 months after their trauma. Pain, disability, health related quality of life and work status were determined using visual analogues scales, global disability scales, SF12 and the work subscale of the Sickness Impact Profile. Patients were categorized into 3 groups: isolated orthopaedic injury alone, multiple orthopaedic injuries alone and orthopaedic injuries and other injuries. Non-parametric tests were used to compare outcomes across these groups.

Six month outcomes were determined in 75.6% of 1181 eligible patients. The patients lost to follow-up were more likely to be male, younger and have isolated injuries than those who were available for follow-up. Patients reported ongoing pain (moderate-severe pain 37.2%), disability (79.5%) and inability to return to work (35.2%). Poorer outcomes were evident in those who had other injuries than those with isolated or multiple orthopaedic injuries alone.

A large proportion of patients presenting to adult Level 1 trauma centres have ongoing pain and disability and a reduced capacity to work 6 months after orthopaedic injuries. Further research into the long-term outcomes of these patients is required to identify patient sub-groups and specific injuries and treatments that result in high morbidity.


A. Puri R. Kusel B. Krause

The aim was to determine the knowledge patients have about Total Hip Joint Replacement, their expectations from it and to evaluate the degree of disability from their hip and co-morbidities.

A total of eighty questionnaires were posted to two groups of patients. The survey consisted of open ended questions. They were also requested to complete Hospital for Special Surgery Hip Replacement Expectation Survey. Patients awaiting a Total Hip Joint replacement were assessed using Harris Hip Score and Index for Coexistent Disease.

Response rate was 81%. Average Harris hip score of 44.96 for the group on the waiting list for THJR.16 of 29 patients fell between mild to severe ICED. Questions to ascertain patient’s knowledge of THJR its risks and complications were open ended. 32–67% either expressed being unaware or answered incorrectly to these questions. Analysis of the Expectation survey revealed that over 75%of patients in both groups rated 15 of the 18 items as being an important expectation. The three items rated low/not applicable in expectation were related to employment, sexual activity and use of support for mobilizing.

This survey reveals a population waiting for a THJR possessing inadequate and unacceptable levels of knowledge about it while having high expectations of improvement in their quality of life. Unmet expectations can form grounds for complaints and even recourse to medico legal action. The expectations of the patients waiting for a THJR should be discussed and realistic goals set.


K. Adams C. Allanach G. Horne P. Devane T. Blackmore

The aim was to determine how periprosthetic hip and knee infection and subsequent revision impact on patient lifestyle and function. While the literature abounds with studies of outcomes of revision surgery for prosthetic infection, few studies address functional outcome and patient-based outcome measures.

This retrospective study examined a consecutive series of revision total knee and hip arthroplasties performed for infection between 1996 and 2002 by surgeons at Wellington Hospital. Eight knees and ten hips were treated with a two-stage exchange using antibiotic spacer and IV antibiotics. Two knee and seven hip patients underwent direct exchange procedures.

In 90% of knees and 65% of hips Infection was successfully eradicated after one revision. One (10%) knee and eight (47%) hips required further intervention of either surgery or antibiotic therapy. Mean Oxford Scores for knees and hips were 29.6 and 29.5 respectively. Oxford scores following revision for infection were slightly higher compared with scores following the primary procedure, indicating poorer functional outcome. EuroQol-5D responses indicated a lower level of function than that of a general population sample, with problems in the areas of mobility, usual activities, and pain/discomfort, most apparent.

While functional outcome is intrinsically related to both the amount of destruction caused by infection and the eradication of infection, absence of re-revision in itself cannot be equated with functional success. Although TKA/THA revision is a technically challenging orthopaedic procedure, patients do attain favourable results. Surgical revision of a prosthetic joint implant for infection can be associated with reasonable function and satisfaction scores.


G. Horne P. Devane K. Adams

To review the results of revision THR performed with a modular titanium tapered uncemented stem in two cohorts of patients to assess whether subsidence of this type of stem is avoidable through improved surgical technique.

The first 70 patients undergoing revision THR with this type of stem were compared with 38 patients who had their revision in the last 24 months and had a minium follow up of 12 months., with particular reference to stem subsidence. All patients were also assessed with the Oxford Hip Score. All radiographs were reviewed to measure subsidence. Identical post-operative management was used in both groups.

The mean subsidence in the first group was 11.7 mm and in the most recent group 4mm. The Oxford Hip Score in both groups was similar (20.9) which compares very favourably with the OHS score from the National joint Register for revision arthroplasty (24.3).

This comparison shows that changes in surgical technique can limit the subsidence seen with tapered stems used in revision total hip replacement. No bone grafts were used in either series, only small changes in bone preparation, and prosthesis selection were used .The outcome as determined by the OHS was similar in both groups.


N. Musa R. Bohm

We undertook this study to determine the types and frequency of injuries sustained in luge riding in Rotorua. Before this study, no data was available in the medical literature on (road) luge riding.

We conducted a retrospective study for all injuries related to luge riding seen in Rotorua Hospital for five years (July/1999 to July/2004). Data obtained from the Hospital records was studied with regards to patient demographics. Two hundred and fifteen luge riding related injuries were recorded. One hundred and thirty two cases were trivial injuries mostly bruises and contusions. Eighty three cases were injuries needing admission or follow up after discharge from A& E. The majority were male (85%) with a mean age of 28 years (range 14 to 82 years, peak 20–27 years). No patient had multiple injuries.

Significant lower limb injuries (54%) included: ankle fractures, 20; knee injuries, 13 (predominantly males; age group, 21–30 years); fracture tibia, 5; fracture shaft of femur, 2; foot fractures, 4; and one pertrochanteric fracture. Upper limb injuries were (35%): shoulder dislocation +/− fracture, 11(mainly males; age group, 14–20 years); hand injuries 11; fracture clavicle, 3; one each of fracture head of radius, fracture ulna, fracture shaft of humerus and AC joint dislocation. Other injuries (11%): stable fractures of the spine, 3; mild abdominal injuries, 2 and mild head injuries, 4 (mainly young females). During the same period, and according to the ACC statistics, there were 60 claims for luge riding in New Zealand with an estimated cost of $246,000 NZD.

Significant injury can occur as a consequence of luge riding. Upper limb injuries tent to occur in younger age groups than lower limb injuries.


R. Peterson G. Horne P. Devane K. Adams G. Purdie

To assess if highly cross-linked polyethylene is associated with less linear wear than ultra high molecular weight polyethylene in vivo.

To assess whether alteration in biomechanical characteristics of the reconstructed hip influence’s wear patterns.

A randomised prospective trial comparing conventional polyethylene with highly cross-linked polyethylene in an acetabular component was designed. Identical cemented stems were used in all cases, with a metal head. The polyethylene thickness was controlled. The trial design required 124 cases to be entered to give the study sufficient power to determine any difference in wear rates. Polyware Auto was used to assess 2D wear rate and volume.

This paper presents the preliminary results of the early patients entered into the study and looks at both 2D wear or creep at 18 months post operatively, and seeks to establish any relationships between 2D movement and biomechanical characteristics of the reconstructed hip.

There was no significant difference in the 2D wear (or creep) between the two types of polyethylene at 18 months. There was no correlation between femoral offset, cup offset, or centre of rotation offset and 2D wear (or creep).

This preliminary data shows no difference in the early wear rate of the two types of polyethylene. This is in contrast to an in vitro wear simulator study that has shown more creep in highly cross-linked polyethylene. The significance of this observation is unclear. We hope to demonstrate that as the trial progresses any difference in the performance of the two types of polyethylene should be evident.


P. Blyth N. S. Stott I. Anderson

There is increasing pressure to develop virtual reality surgical simulation that can be used in surgical training. However, little is known of the attitudes of the surgical community towards such simulation, and which aspects of simulation are most important.

A postal survey on attitudes to surgical simulation was sent to all New Zealand orthopaedic surgeons and advanced trainees. This comprised 44 questions in ten sections, using either a visual analogue scale (0 to 10) or free text box replies. Results were analysed for two sub-groups; surgeons qualified before 1990 and those qualified in or after 1990 or still in training.

Of 208 possible responses, 142 were received, a response rate of 68%. Only 4 respondents had tried a surgical based simulator. Earlier qualified surgeons were more likely to agree that simulation was an effective way to practice surgical procedures, median score 7.7 versus 5.6 (p=0.03). Both groups thought the most important task for simulation was practicing angulation/spatial orientation (median score 8.4/10), while a realistic view of the operation was the most important requirement (median score 9/10). Both groups were unconvinced that simulation would impact on their practice in the next five years, with this statement being scored lower by later qualified surgeons, median score 2.4 versus 4.1 (p=0.04).

Orthopaedic surgeons in New Zealand are supportive of surgical simulation but do not expect simulation to have an impact in the near future. Intriguingly, later qualified surgeons and trainees are more sceptical than their earlier qualified colleagues.


K. Adams G. Horne P. Devane

We analysed factors affecting the rate of recovery from ankle fractures. Delays in return to normal functioning may relate to poorer quality and duration of sleep during recovery.

This prospective study investigates the relationship between the rate of recovery from ankle fracture and sleep disturbance, comparing ankle fractures classified using AO-Danis-Weber Classification – types A, B & C treated at Wellington Hospital, aged between 18 and 55 years. From June 2003 to October 2004 participants completed an ankle fracture questionnaire, and a general health profile at three, six and twelve months post-injury. A randomly selected subgroup was interviewed to identify specific recovery issues.

Six percent were Weber A, 56% B and 39%, C. Mean (and standard deviation) for return to normal functioning was; 5 (2); 8 (3) and 8 (7) weeks respectively, overall range – 2 to 24 weeks. Those who returned in 2 weeks had sedentary jobs, worked from home or were students, all with a high level of support by ACC. Physically demanding occupations delayed return to work. After one year, (93%) scored 85 – 90% satisfaction with their ankle performance. 97% scored highly on the SF 36, indicating positive life attitudes. 98% reported no change from their pre-fracture sleep patterns.

Rate of recovery is less predictable and sometimes more prolonged for Weber C than for A and B ankle fractures. Earlier return to work is a function of practical support in the workplace and positive health attitudes including balanced sleep patterns. Work planning and workplace assessment are significant factors.


R.S. Dhillon J. Krebs JC. Theis N. Aebli

Cementless implants have gained popularity in modern orthopaedic practice. The type implants and surface characteristics on fixation has been extensively investigated, however there is insufficient data on the effect of the host bone bed status on implant fixation. This study aims to determine if there is a correlation between the fixation strength of cementless press-fit implants and bone mineral density (BMD) of the host bone bed.

Implants coated with pure titanium, Hydroxyapatite (HA) with or without Hyaluronic Acid (HY) and implants coated with bone growth factors – Bone Morphogenetic Protein 2 (BMP-2) were inserted into tibiae and femora of 32 skeletally mature ewes (109 implants) for a period of 1, 2 and 4 weeks. Mechanical pull-out testing was performed after each time interval to evaluate the ultimate load of failure (Nmm−2). The BMD (gcm−3) surrounding the implant site was measured using a CT scanner.

The mean BMD (S.D.) was 1.515gcm−3 (0.147gcm−3). The mean (S.D.) mechanical pull-out strength at 1, 2 and 4 weeks was 0.37 (0.31), 3.14 (0.17) and 9.74 (2.31) Nmm−2 respectively. The overall correlation co-efficient between BMD and pull out strength is 0.31.

Early fixation strength of implants is independent of BMD, however, the strength of fixation increases with time in a ‘normal’ sheep population. This suggests that the fixation of implants is dependent on the type of implant and surface coating used rather than the density of the host bone bed.


Full Access
P. O’Grady Y. Lodhi D. Bennett P. Keogh

Total hip arthroplasty has improved the quality of life for many patients with osteoarthritis. Infection is a serious complication, difficult to treat and often requires removal of the prosthesis to eradicate the infection.

An analysis of the surgical management, risk factors, complications and outcome of infected total hip replacements. Thirty one consecutive patients underwent revision hip arthroplasty for infection between 1997 and 2003. Risk factors, co-morbidity, clinical presentation, biochemical profiles, microbiology, management and radiology were recorded. Outcome and complications following surgery are reviewed. Classification of infection after total hip arthroplasty was based on their clinical presentation—early postoperative, late chronic, or acute hematogenous infection, and positive intraoperative cultures.

All patients underwent resection arthroplasty, 26 had a two-stage revision, 1 had a three stage, 4 did not have a re-implantation. Staph Aureus was the most common organism identified. 16 patients were classified as late chronic insidious, 8 early post operative infection, 6 acute haematogenous and 1 occult intraoperative. Average total blood loss was 5 litres, average replacement was 7 units. 1 patient had a persistent infection. 3 underwent further surgery for dislocation, stem perforation or fracture. 5 patients had a persistent limp.

In infected revisions the bone stock is usually adequate, the soft tissues are very poor. Bivalving the femur allows for optimal cement removal. Blood loss can be significant with average replacement of 7 units. Meticulous removal of infected components, cement and tissue is essential for good long-term results.


A. Vane T. Lamberton A. Heath

We present two cases of Ogilvie’s syndrome and to raise awareness of this rare but serious complication.

Methodology: Analysis of two recent cases at our institution. Subsequent 5 year retrospective audit of all joint replacement in Tauranga Hospital and analysis of patient records with a recorded gastrointestinal complication.

We report on two recent cases of Ogilvie’s Syndrome (acute colonic pseudo-obstruction) with subsequent caecal perforation after THJR. Case 1: A 49 year old woman underwent THJR for osteoarthritis. Postoperatively developed abdominal pain and distension. Underwent laparotomy for a perforated caecum 10 days following THJR. Died 24 hours later. Case 2: A 73 year old man underwent a revision THJR. Postoperatively developed a distended abdomen. Underwent laparotomy and caecostomy 10 days after THJR. Discharged 29 days after admission. Both cases had GA and spinal anaesthetics with intrathecal Morphine. Both failed to settle with conservative treatment. There was no mechanical obstruction in either case. Audit figures showed 21 other cases of non-mechanical bowel obstruction after hip or knee arthroplasty.

Ogilvie’s Syndrome is a rare “malignant” form of postoperative pseudo-obstruction characterised by massive dilatation of the large bowel which, if untreated, results in caecal perforation. It is rare following joint arthroplasty but if occurs has a high morbidity and mortality. Prompt recognition of the presenting features by orthopaedic surgeons with expedient general surgical intervention is necessary to avoid potentially fatal consequences.


T. McTighe L. Keppler H. Cameron

Concern was expressed that the use of a modular stem might produce fretting leading to osteolysis, and component failure. The goal of this study was to document the variability of this design by looking at the long-term i.e. 5–17 year follow-up of the use of a Proximal Modular Stem in primary cases.

A cohort of 955 (S-Rom) primary cases have been followed prospectively and rated clinically using the Harris Hip Score and radiologically after the fashion of Gruen. The mean age was 53. Follow-up was 5–17 years (mean 8.5).

Aseptic loosening requiring revision occurred in three cases (0.3%). One a non-union of a subtrochanteric osteotomy. Two others, one for fracture at the stem tip and one for fracture of the proximal part of a subtrochanteric osteotomy. Harris rating was 78.2% excellent, 16.4% good, 2.3% fair and 3.1% poor. Gruen rating, no lucency in 98.8%, low grade in 1.1% and high grade in 0.1%. Distal osteolysis occurred in two cases. Six patients had persistent thigh pain (type C bone) that was treated by onlay-strut graphs.

There have been no cases of device failures. Other than in the two loose cases distal osteolysis has not been seen. It would appear therefore that the sleeve does act as an adequate seal. There have been no cases of late aseptic loosening and limited thigh pain in type C bone. The authors concluded that this modular device is safe, effective and continue to recommend its use in primary THA.


R. Tregonning

The aim was to compare anterior knee pain (AKP) felt before, and after hamstrings (HS, n = 65) and bone-patellar tendon- bone [B-PT-B, n = 94] ACL reconstructions.

The same questionnaire (modified from Shelbourne et al 1997) was answered by patients before, and at least 12 months after surgery. Questions covered five main categories of pain ie. during prolonged sitting, stair climbing, kneeling, sport or vigorous activity, and ADL.

There was no statistical difference in the two groups in overall AKP scores before surgery. After surgery, there were improvements in this overall score in both groups, but the improvement was statistically greater in the HS group (p = 0.02). Analysis of the five different pain categories showed no significant difference in the improvements in sitting, sport or ADL. In both climbing stairs (p = 0.009), and kneeling (p = 0.02) there were significantly greater improvements in the HS group.

The majority of patients had AKP before surgery. Surgery improved pain levels in both HS and B-PT-B groups, but there was statistically significant greater improvements in overall AKP scores, and the scores for climbing stairs and kneeling in the HS group.


Full Access
T. McTighe W. Low T. Tkach G.B. Cipolleti

Dislocation continues to be a significant problem in THA. Instability due to improper reconstruction of the abductors can be a contributing factor.

Eight hundred primary THA’s were performed over the past four years utilizing a proximal “Dual Press™” cementless porous coated modular stem. This design allows for a large selection of proximal bodies that enable the restoration of proper soft tissue tension and joint biomechanics after the stem is inserted.

Data on stem, neck and head centers were available for 600 of these cases. Head center locations were tabulated and compared to data from the literature.

The head center location data clearly showed that a wide variety of offsets and lengths are required to properly balance the soft tissues. Further, when the data were sorted by distal stem diameter, there is little correlation between head center location and stem size. All were performed utilizing the posterior approach and used without bone cement. 3 fractured stems, 2 dislocations, 14 intra-op fractures, no significant leg length inequalities (+/− 5mm), and 10% indexed to a position other than neutral.

Restoration of joint mechanics was possible using this proximal modular “Dual Press” stem due to the intra-operative versatility offered in regards to head center location when compared to monoblock stems. The data suggest that hip reconstruction benefits from the availability of many head centers for every stem size. The authors conclude that this proximal modular design provides for a more intra-operative accurate approach for reconstructing the biomechanics of the hip.


S. Andrews S. Bentall D. Atkinson

To measure for evidence of early subsidence of Accolade tapered uncemented femoral stems. To quantify any subsidence and to identify factors which may predispose to this.

A retrospective audit of patients who have received Accolade stem total hip joint replacement in Hawkes Bay Hospital from October 2003 to October 2004. Post operative and follow up x rays (within one year of surgery) were reviewed and position of femoral component in the femur was measured and adjusted for magnification and angulation.

Thirty-eight patients were identified. Patients age averaged 66 years old (44 – 82yo). Results show an mean subsidence of 2.8mm with a range of 0 – 13mm.

There is evidence of early subsidence of Accolade femoral stems. In cases of large subsidence under sizing of the femoral component was identified as the most significant contributing factor.


Full Access
T. McTighe H Del Schutte H. A Demos N.C. Romero

Traditionally the most commonly used femoral implants in revision hip arthroplasty are distally fixed monoblock designs. Ability to adjust length version and offset is limited once the stem is inserted. Revision using this type of stem has been associated with high incidence of complications including dislocation. Modular distally fixed femoral implants have been developed in order to decrease the complication rate by restoring normal hip mechanics. The goal of this study is to evaluate the performance of these type stems as it relates to fixation and instability.

Seventy three revisions were done using three modular stem designs. All stems were common in design featuring a proximal cone shape body attached by a taper to a fluted distal stem. Revisions were performed for loosening, periprosthetic fractures and infections. Most revisions were in patients with severe bone loss. Follow-up range from 6 to 72 months with an average of 30 months. Parameters evaluated included fixation and instability.

In this series we obtained excellent bony fixation as well as an acceptable dislocation rate in revision of severely compromised femurs. There were no stem fractures at the modular junction at early follow-up. Dislocation was readily managed by revision of the proximal portion of the stem without compromising distal fixation. This study demonstrates that modular approaches can be used successfully.


A. Cornett C. Hoffman

The aim of this study was to determine if job availability at initial assessment altered the return to work (RTW) recommendations and six month outcomes for ACC claimants undergoing an activity based rehabilitation program (ABP).

Sixty five cases who underwent an ABP at The Back Institute, Wellington were enrolled (28 female, 37 male). Patients were categorized as: Working (IN WORK; n= 21), Not Working/Job Available (OFF WORK; n=20), and Not Working/Job Not Available (NO JOB; n = 24). All patients underwent a similar treatment program. Recommendations on completion of the program and work status at six months follow-up were recorded.

All patients in the IN WORK group, 90% in the OFF WORK group, and 83% in NO JOB group were recommended to RTW at completion of the ABP. At six months a follow-up work status was obtained – all patients in the IN WORK group, 70% in the OFF WORK group, and 29% in the NO JOB group were working (p< 0.05).

Patients that present for rehab without a job (NO JOB) yield similar RTW recommendations at discharge but poorer RTW outcomes at six months when compared to those in work (IN WORK) or off work with a job (OFF WORK). This highlights the importance of job availability in achieving robust return to work outcomes. It is recommended that patients without immediate work available undergo a concurrent Pre-Employment Programme which identifies immediate return to work options.


M. Foster D.P. Gwynne Jones P. Taylor

The aim of this study was to prospectively audit the results of carpal tunnel decompression using a subjective patient derived outcome score (modified Boston Symptom Severity Score) and to examine the relationship between symptom severity scores and nerve conduction studies.

Prospective cohort study of all patients undergoing open carpal tunnel decompression at Dunedin Hospital over a 13-month period from December 2003 – January 2005. Demographic details collected included age, sex, duration of symptoms, diabetes, occupation and ACC status. Pre-operative investigations consisted of nerve conduction studies and a modified version of the Boston Symptom Severity Score developed for this study. Symptom severity scores were reassessed six months post-operatively.

One hundred and ten patients participated in the study. Mean pre-operative Boston Symptom Severity Score was 3.35 (1= normal, 5=severe). Post-operatively this improved to mean 1.66, median 1.45. Ninety three percent of patients were “very satisfied” or “satisfied” with their results. Age and duration of symptoms were not significant predictors of poor outcome.

The majority of patients undergoing carpal tunnel decompression were satisfied with the outcome and had excellent or good outcomes as determined by symptom severity score. The use of preoperative nerve conduction studies help in diagnosis and prognosis.


Full Access
S. N. Rao S. Andrews F. Horrocks

An independent audit of Lumbar Spinal surgery performed by a single surgeon over a 4 year period is presented. The three groups evaluated included Lumbar fusion, decompression and discectomy.

Patients were assessed using the Oswestry Disability Questionairre and five other questions related to overall outcome and patient satisfaction. The minimum follow-up was 6 months. Patient response rate was 74%.

The overall outcome was 81% Excellent/Good vs 19% Fair/Poor. The best outcomes were in the discectomy group. The decompression group showed a variable and unpredictable outcome. Complications encountered in the three subgroups are discussed.

Lumbar spinal surgery offers lasting and predictable outcomes to a large majority of well selected patients. Independent surgical audits form an important part of evaluating one’s surgical practice.


A. G Rothwell T. F. Hobbs

We recorded the preoperative posterior deltoid (PD) and postoperative elbow extensor torque (EET) to determine if it is possible to predict the likely EET following PD transfer.

A custom built device (Troidometer) was used to measure the preoperative torque generated by the PD under maximum isometric contraction with the shoulder at 90° of abduction and the coronal plane and the elbow flexed at 90°. At a minimum of 3 months post surgery the maximum isometric EET was measured again with the Troidometer.

In a total of 17 arms in 9 patients the average preoperative PD was 9.5 Nm and the average post operative EET was 5.4 Nm or 57% of the PD preoperative torque. A paired sample test demonstrated a highly significant decrease (P = 0.001) and a correlation coefficient of 0.8 between the pre and post operative data. If a poor result from a revised transfer is excluded then the average EET is 60% of preoperative torque.

Based on this data it can be predicted that approximately 60% of the pre operative PD torque will postoperatively be converted to EET.


S. Ryan M.S. Costic P. U. Brucker P. J. Smolinski

Higher re-tear rates after arthroscopic single row rotator cuff repairs have been linked with the inability to restore the native footprint. The objective in our study was to evaluate the biomechanical properties and anatomic footprint restoration after both single and double row repairs.

Human cadaveric shoulders (n=22) were tested using a materials testing machine. Cyclic loading was performed on intact, injured (3cm tear), and arthroscopically repaired rotator cuff. Repairs tested: 1) single row A (Lateral Simple, n=6); 2) single row B (Lateral Mattress, n=5); 3) double row A (Medial Mattress/Lateral Simple, n=6); and 4) double row B (Transosseus Simple, n=5). Percentage of footprint restoration was calculated for each repair followed by a load-to-failure protocol. Biomechanical properties were determined from the load-displacement curves.

Single and double row repairs restored an average of 40% and 90% of the native footprint (p< 0.05) with small amounts of cyclic creep and permanent elongation. No differences were detected between any of the repairs for the ultimate load (724±344N, 879±247N, 741±339N and 896±229N) and stiffness (100±43N/mm, 106±31N/mm, 89±34N/mm and 100±14N/mm), respectively.

Double row repairs have comparable initial strength and increased footprint restoration compared to single row repairs. These similarities can be attributed to the inclusion of surrounding soft tissue structures during testing; however, the increased restoration of the anatomic footprint may lead to increased tendon-to-bone healing with the possibility of improved biomechanical properties and should be examined in the future.

The characteristic U-shaped tear confirms clinically observed scenarios which may be caused by overuse after a RC injury has been sustained. The small amount of cyclic creep and permanent deformation in all arthroscopic repairs suggest that initial rehabilitation could be prescribed after surgery without compromising the initial stability of the repair; however, surgeons should carefully select a RC repair based on the state of the surrounding tissue.


G. Malham D. Varma R. Jones O. D. Williamson

To investigate the diagnostic properties of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans in detecting surgically verified disruptions of the cervical intervertebral disc and anterior (ALL) and posterior longitudinal (PLL) ligaments.

Data were extracted from the reports of cervical spine MRI scans of patients who subsequently underwent surgical stabilization for presumed instability following disco-ligamentous injuries of the cervical spine. The level and severity of disc, ALL and PLL disruption was compared with surgical findings. Unweighted kappa statistics were used to assess agreement. The sensitivity, specificity, positive (PPV) and negative (NPV) predictive values were calculated after findings where dichotomised into complete rupture, yes/no. Sensitivity analyses were performed to account for missing data.

The MRI and surgical findings were compared on 31 consecutive patients. The kappa values for intervertebral disc disruption, ALL and PLL disruption were 0.22, 0.25 and 0.31 respectively, indicating fair agreement. Sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV are shown in Table 1. The false negative rates for diagnosing complete disruption of the disc, ALL and PLL were 0.18, 0.40 and 0.14 respectively.

The ability of cervical MRI scans to detect surgically verified disruptions of the intervertebral disc, ALL and PLL varied depending on the structure examined. In this series, the cervical MRI scan reliably detected disruption of the intervertebral disc disruption and ALL. The false negative rates are of concern and indicate the need for additional investigations to exclude instability in the absence of negative MRI findings.


S. Mukherjee T. Love

Non contiguous fractures in spinal trauma are not infrequent occurrences. Incidences in the literature have been cited as 3.2 to 16.7%. Of these the combination of cervical and lumber spine injuries are very uncommon (less than 0.5%). Isolated traumatic lumbosacral spondylolisthesis is a very uncommon occurrence and English language literature search reveals less than twenty cases reported.

We present a case which is a combination of an unstable C2 body fracture with a traumatic spondylolisthesis of L5 on S1. This is an unusual injury pattern and has never been reported before.

The case of a 17 year old man who had non contiguous cervical and lumber spine injuries was described and treatment modalities and rationale explained. Literature review and discussion on the subject of non contiguous spine injury is presented in the paper.

The outcome of treatment with internal fixation for the bifacetal fracture dislocation of the lumbosacral spine was discussed along with conservative management of the cervical spine injury. He had no residual limb weakness but had persistent bladder dysfunction since this injury.

Non contiguous spine injury is a commonly missed injury and the case we describe is a highly unusual but probable pattern of injury that has to be kept in mind in dealing with these kinds of injuries.


S Faraj JC. Theis

Locking compression plate is part of a new plate generation requiring an adapted surgical technique and new thinking about commonly used concepts of internal fixation using plates.

They offer a number of advantages in fracture fixation combining angular stability through the use of locking screws with traditional fixation techniques. This makes the implant suitable for poor bone stock and for fractures in metaphyseal areas.

However the system is complex and cases of plate loosening and plate breakage reported by many authors recently, many of these authors believe it is attributed to the choice of inappropriate plate and/or fixation technique rather than to the features of locking compression plate system.

We are reporting 2 cases of plate breakage after using it to fix diaphyseal femoral shaft fractures; in each case we discuss the pitfalls in the fixation method.

The locking plate manual did not highlight the important pitfalls, which was published later on in the literature as guidelines for their clinical application. Careful and detailed attention to the biomechanical principles of locking compression is crucial to the success of implant in fixing fractures in diaphyseal areas.


O.D. Williamson I. Millar Cate Venturoni

To investigate the efficacy of hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) in improving outcomes following open tibial fractures.

A prospective randomized controlled trial was conducted on patients presenting to an adult level 1 trauma centre with severe open tibial fractures (Gustillo 3B,3C). The primary outcome measure was soft tissue healing without secondary necrosis. Based on previously reported complication rates, 36 patients had to be randomized into each group in order to have ≥ 80% chance of detecting an improvement in necrosis free soft tissue healing rates from 70% to 95%. Secondary outcome measures included amputation, non-union, osteomyelitis and chronic pain rates, lower limb function and health related quality of life. The Alfred Hospital Human Research Ethics Committee approved conduct of the trial.

The trial was abandoned after 17 patients were randomised because the number of severe open tibial fractures presenting and complication rates were significantly lower than previously observed and because some surgeons declined to enrol patients in the belief that HBO was efficacious. Randomised patients were followed as per protocol but there were insufficient patients enrolled to observe any positive or negative differences in outcome. The logistics of treating major trauma patients with HBO proved readily manageable in the Alfred Hospital setting.

The efficacy of HBO in improving outcomes following open tibial fractures remains unknown. An international collaboration has been formed with the aim of commencing a multi-centre prospective randomized controlled trial of HBO in the near future.


Full Access
H. Crawford

Scoliosis is a common problem in cerebral palsy typified by rapid progression that often leads to large curve magnitudes even after skeletal maturity. The purpose of this study was to determine the relationship between curve progression and disease severity in cerebral palsy according to the Gross Motor Function Classification (GMFCS).

This retrospective study reviewed 34 children with a known diagnosis of cerebral palsy who were scheduled for or have already had surgical stabilization for scoliosis. Two patients (6%) were classified as GMFCS level III, 13 (38%) as GMFCS level IV, and 19 (56%) as GMFCS level V. There were no patients in GMFCS levels I or II.

Between the more severely involved children in GMFCS levels IV and V, there were no significant differences in curve magnitude at first presentation (means, 41.4 and 45.3 degrees, respectively; p=O.72), peak curve progression (28.2 degrees – interval 1.5 years, 31.4 degrees – interval 1. 75 years, respectively; p=O.35), or age at onset of peak curve progression (12.2 and 11.2 years, respectively). When adjusted for age at presentation, however, there was some indication of a difference in initial curve magnitude between GMFCS levels IV and V (least squares means, 35.7 and 49.2 degrees, respectively; p=O.10). The small number of patients in GMFCS level III precluded statistical analysis.

In this study, the nature of scoliosis in cerebral palsy was found to be related to functional level. Once scoliosis has been diagnosed, children in the higher GMFCS levels have an increased risk of rapid and unpredictable curve progression.


H. Rawlinson B. Twaddle

To assess the efficacy of percutaneous K wiring in the treatment of distal radius fractures.

A retrospective audit was performed of patients with distal radius fractures treated with the combination of manipulation under anaesthetic, K wiring and cast application at Auckland Hospital. Patients were identified by using the Orthopaedic Trauma Database. Charts were reviewed for patient demographics, preoperative delay and complications. X-rays were reviewed recording Frykman Grade and radial tilt, radial inclination and ulnar variance preoperatively, immediately postoperatively and at 6 weeks postoperatively.

Seventy five consecutive cases were identified over an 18 month period between May 2002 and October 2003 with 4 excluded because of inadequate notes or x-rays. The majority of patients were female with an average age of 55 years. Most operations were performed by Advanced Trainees using 3 wires with at least one trans styloid wire. 55% of fractures were intra articular. Radial tilt was restored to within 10 degrees of normal in all but 3 patients immediately postoperatively but at 6 weeks 12 patients had more than 10 degrees dorsal tilt. All patients had less than 2mm positive ulnar variance immediately postoperatively but at 6 weeks postoperatively 11 patients had more than 2mm positive ulnar variance. 9 patients (13%) experienced local complications related to the wires.

Manipulation under anaesthetic, K wiring and cast application offers a useful treatment option for distal radius fractures which are reducible but unstable. Care is required with patient selection and surgical technique to minimise complications.


H. Crawford

This study was conducted to quantify the incidence of gastrointestinal morbidity and identify risk factors for developing gastrointestinal morbidity following spinal surgery in children.

A retrospective review was conducted on 253 surgical spinal procedures performed over a 5 year period at Starship Children’s Hospital. Multivariate logistic regression analysis was used to identify significant risk factors.

Seventy eight (77.9%) percent of the study population developed gastrointestinal morbidity and this significantly prolonged the median post-operative hospital stay (8 days vs. 4 days; p< 0.0001). Emesis (50.6%), paralytic ileus (42.3%) and constipation (22.5%) were the most frequent gastrointestinal morbidities. Significant risk factors for developing gastrointestinal morbidity were fusion surgery, co-morbidities and duration of post-operative opioid use.

The high incidence of gastrointestinal morbidity after paediatric spinal surgery and consequent prolonged hospital stay has clinical implications to both the patient and the institution. Awareness of those with significant risk factors identified by this study could assist in the timely implementation of appropriate treatment.


J Burgos MA Castrillo-Amores E Hevia I Sanpera G Piza J Lopez-Mondejar S Amaya

Introduction and purpose: We present the results of our surgical method involving nerve decompression, reduction and circumferential spinal fusion via posterior approach for severe spondylolisthesis.

Materials and methods: We studied 14 patients with spondylolisthesis and slippage greater than 50%; mean age 24. Mean slip angle 37° and mean preoperative slip 74%.

Procedure: Via a posterior approach we performed neural decompression and placed pedicle screws in L5-S1 (in one case we instrumented L4 for associated L4-L5 spondylolisthesis) and iliac screws (except in three cases). We removed the annulus fibrosus, the L5-S1 disc and the rounded proximal edge of the sacrum. Following distraction of L5-S1 we inserted bone graft cages (from 3 to 5). We adjusted the bars with spanners to reduce slippage and achieve final curvature of the spine.

The cases were monitored with evoked potentials and epidural catheter.

We studied preoperative, postoperative and final check X-rays. The clinical histories were also reviewed.

Results: One rupture of the dura. Two patients with anterior slippage of a cage. One posterior slippage of L5 screws, without revision surgery. One postoperative infection resolved by surgical cleaning and antibiotic therapy.

After mean follow-up of 32 months the radiographic study showed no pseudoarthrosis. Final mean slippage was 15% and slip angle 5°. Ten patients had no pain or physical limitations. Two presented mild lumbar discomfort and occasional limitation.

Conclusions: The procedure we used was shown to be effective in correcting the deformity with excellent clinical results.


J Font Segura JL Doreste X Mir-Bullò

Purpose: Objective, prospective study of professional athletes with chronic forearm compartment syndrome and treatment.

Materials and methods: We studied 18 cases of chronic compartment syndrome in 12 patients. The sample consisted of 12 men in an age range of 17 to 33. Both forearms were involved in six cases. Sixteen patients were motorcyclists and two were windsurfers. The clinical picture was compatible with chronic compartment syndrome. For confirmation the compartment pressure was measured after simulating each person’s activity. The test was considered positive when the pressure measured 15′ after exercise was > 15 mmHg.

Results: The 12 patients presented clinical pictures and compartment pressure test results compatible with severe chronic compartment syndrome of the forearm with loss of sensitivity and proprioception. We found compartment pressures of 15–20 mmHg 15′ after exercise in two cases, 20–30 mmHg in six cases and > 30 mmHg in ten. The flexor and extensor compartments of the forearm were released by minimally invasive surgery.

Conclusions: We can conclude that fasciotomy was followed by clinical improvement with no evidence of loss of strength, and the athlete was able to play again within a short time.


R García E Manrique A Frances E Moro

Introduction: The incidence of postoperative periprosthetic femoral fractures ranges from 0.1% in primary arthroplasty to 2.1% in revision surgery, and is often a challenge for the surgeon.

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective clinical study of periprosthetic femoral fractures found among the primary arthroplasties and revision hip replacements performed at San Carlos University Hospital between 1991 and 2003. We found 82 patients with postoperative periprosthetic femoral fractures. The fractures were classified according to the Vancouver classification, and we analysed the associated risk factors, treatments used, complications and results.

Results: The mean age of the patients was 72 (SD 12). There were 57 women (69.5%) and 25 men (30.5%). Of the 82 cases, 22 (26.8%) were type B1 fractures, 33 type B2 (40.2%), 20 type B3 (24.4%) and 7 type C (8.5%). The most common surgical treatment was the combination of a long stem held in place with cerclage wires in 27 cases (33%), followed by treatments using allografts in different combinations in 22 cases (26.8%).

Conclusions: Femoral bone stock is a factor that influences the occurrence of periprosthetic fractures.

The use of allografts has little effect on the fracture consolidation time, although it involves an increase of femoral bone stock, which makes allografts advisable even in Vancouver type B2 fractures.


V Sánchez-Ramos T Bas M Duart-Clemente C Maroñas-Abuelo JC Peñalver JL Padilla E Blasco C Jordá

Introduction and purpose: The anterior approach to the spinal column has revolutionised this field of surgery. The purpose of this retrospective study is to assess the use of this route and its complications throughout three decades in our unit.

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective study of 608 patients who underwent surgery via the anterior spinal approach between 1972 and 2002. The mean age was 22.60 ±12.65 [2–74] with a sex distribution of 274/334 male/female (ratio 1.2). Both variables (mean age and gender) can be explained in that most of the operations were for scoliosis (58%). Different surgical approaches were used. Among the most common were thoracophrenolumbotomy (52.6%) and thoracotomy (36.5%), with predominance of the left side (63.8%). The most commonly used surgical procedure was discectomy with non-instrumented spinal fusion (53%) and with instrumentation (32%).

Results: A total of 13.8% presented complications associated with the anterior approach. The most common were thoracic: pleural effusion and atelectasis. The most severe complications were large vessel lesions, splenectomy, nephrectomy, Claude-Bernard-Horner syndrome and transient paraplegia. Only three patients required revision surgery. Six patients died (0.98%) and perioperative morbidity was 16.28%.

Discussion: The anterior approach has been consolidated as a valid, effective alternative in surgical treatment of the spinal column. Complications are not uncommon but usually not serious. We recommend the use of this technique to provide a wide range of therapeutic options in the field of spinal surgery.


Full Access
P Villanueva A García N Fernandez-Baillo FS Perez-Grueso

Introduction: Congenital kyphosis is an uncommon deformity caused by failure of the vertebral bodies to form and/or segment. It is treated surgically. Our purpose is to confirm whether the treatment protocols established years ago are still valid and to assess the benefits of improved implants.

Materials and methods: Between 1985 and 2003, 24 patients underwent surgery in La Paz Hospital. They were classified into three groups: < 5 years (8 p), 6–12 (6 p) and > 13 (10 p). The minimum follow-up was 2 years (2–14). The procedures were posterior or circumferential spinal fusion, with or without instrumentation, and corrective osteotomy. Complications were evaluated radiographically.

Results: In the first group posterior spinal fusion was performed in six patients and circumferential in two, with a correction rate of 55%. In the second group instrumented circumferential spinal fusion was performed in three cases and instrumented posterior in three (30% correction). In the third group eight of the ten patients underwent instrumented anteroposterior spinal fusion (osteotomy in five) and the correction rate was 45%. Complications: 3 pseudoarthrosis, 1 DVT, 2 infections and 3 failed implants.

Conclusions: Congenital kyphosis can be controlled at any age, although early surgery is best. Gradual correction occurs after poster spinal fusion in children and instrumentation prevents revision of the fusion and prolonged immobilisation. Persons over the age of 5 with type I kyphosis usually require circumferential spinal fusion.


E Martínez-Arribas V Sánchez-Ramos C Maroñas-Abuelo R Diaz-Fernandez T Bas P Bas

Purpose: To review the sagittal lumbar and clinical profile of the two surgical procedures: TLIF (transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion and ALIF (anterior lumbar interbody fusion).

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective study of 46 patients who underwent circumferential fusion in 2000–2001. TLIF was used in the first group (21) and ALIF in the second (25). The posterior approach with pedicle instrumentation was used in all patients. Lateral radiographs of the lumbar spine in neutral position and bipedestation were used for evaluation before and after surgery and during follow-up. The results were compared statistically using the Wilcoxon matched pairs test.

Results: Lumbar lordosis was achieved with both techniques: TLIF+PF(posterior fusion) −33° (preoperative), −46° (postoperative) and ALIF+ PF −49° (preoperative), −54° (postoperative). However the height of the disc improved significantly with the anterior approach: TLIF+ PF 0.62 (preoperative), 1.35 (postoperative) and ALIF+PF 1 (preoperative), 4.65 (postoperative).

The duration of surgery, blood loss and hospital stay were greater with ALIF+PF than with TLIF+PF.

Conclusions: TLIF+PF has clinical and economic advantages over ALIF+PF. Lumbar lordosis and the area of instrumented lordosis was achieved with both circumferential fusion procedures and the only radiographic difference was the restoration of the disc height with ALIF.


R Lòpez R Goterris A Pascual A Silvestre A Teruel C Arbona F Gomar

Introduction and purpose: Methods are needed to store blood for scheduled surgery with high transfusion requirements. We evaluated the transfusion requirements in patients undergoing surgery for total hip replacement (THR) and the results of the autotransfusion programme.

Materials and methods: We assessed 211 patients who underwent primary or secondary THR between November 1999 and November 2004 and were included in the blood-storing programme. The variables analysed were: sex, age, operation, start of weight bearing, hospital stay, units extracted and transfused, basal hemoglobin and follow-up and use of allogeneic blood.

Results: 177 patients entered the programme, 14 on EPO and 13 with no blood-storing procedure. The mean age was 61.8. The male/female ratio was 1.5, and 109 patients (52%) were transfused. We found differences (p< 0.01) between non-transfused and transfused patients in relation to their basal Hb (14.4 vs 13.7), start of weight bearing (4.6 vs 9.6 days) and hospital stay (9.1 vs 10.3 days). Of the patients in the autotransfusion programme, 58% (103) required transfusion and used 54% of the units extracted. Seven percent (13) required allogeneic blood. Of 138 patients with primary THR, 80 were transfused – 83% women and 36% men (p< 0.001). Of the 39 revision THRs, 23 patients were transfused with no differences between the sexes. Overall, 31 units of allogeneic red cell concentrate were used, 192 autologous. 87 patients required 2 units, 15 patients 1 unit and one patient 3 units.

Conclusions: The autotransfusion programme for THR patients is adequate for storing allogeneic blood. Nevertheless, it should be included in this protocol via an individualised interdisciplinary programme.


S Sastre JM Segur JA Carbonell S Suso

Introduction and purpose: The purpose of this study was to obtain environmental scanning electron microscope images of the joint surface of fresh osteochondral grafts cryopreserved in RPMI and modified Krebs-Henseleit medium (K-H) and evaluate and compare them using a validated classification system.

Materials and methods: We extracted the femoral condyles from 6-month-old female New Zealand rabbits weighing 3.5 kg and cryopreserved them using two methods (RPMI and K-H). After thawing the samples we took 20 photographs of each one (total of 100 images per group, 3 study groups) using an environmental scanning electron microscope.

Results: We assessed and compared each of the study parameters using the Chi-Square test:

- smooth surface, protuberances and peaks

- presence of grooves

- presence of valleys

Conclusions: On the basis of morphological studies, we can conclude that the K-H method provides a higher degree of chondrocyte viability than other cryopreservation methods in use up to the present.


C Maroñas C Gutiérrez T Bas E Hernandez-Ayuso

Introduction: Most hospitals that treat patients with Pectus Excavatum use the pectus bar designed by D. Nuss. In essence, chest elevation is achieved by using a previously moulded steel bar.

It is relatively safe since the introduction of thoracoscopy, although there is a risk of injury to the heart.

Our group has attempted to diminish this risk by means of sternal traction using a clamp specially designed for use with a thorascope anchored in the cancellous tissue of the sternum.

Materials and methods: We used a tailored clamp in three consecutive patients aged 8, 12 and 15 with Pectus Excavatum Haller index > 7.

Procedure: Thorascopy was performed for a good assessment of the rib cage. Under direct vision, we inserted one arm of the clamp underneath the sternum at the deepest point of the defect about 5 cm to the right of the midline. With the other arm of the clamp we grasped the anterior side of the sternum percutaneously. When the clamp was closed, we could raise the sternum to increase the mediastinal space.

Results: The sternal elevation was satisfactory. Using thorascopy during the procedure enhanced safety and the additional time was a few minutes.

Conclusions: Correction of pectus excavatum is indicated for aesthetic purposes in many patients and the absence of severe complications is a goal. The sternal elevation described here (although it is only a preliminary study) is fast, economical and appears to make the Nuss procedure safer.


L Moraleda A Moreno EC Rodríguez-Merchán

Purpose: To understand the epidemiology and risk factors of an osteoporotic hip fracture in a non-elderly patient.

Methods: Retrospective study covering the period 1999–2004, assessing individual and family history, fracture type, hospital stay, time until surgery, type of treatment and possible study or treatment of bone fragility.

Results: 38 cases. 23 patients (60.5%) presented some risk factor related to osteoporosis: enolism 7, liver pathology 3, neuromuscular disease 13, steroid treatment 4 and anticonvulsant 3. Seven patients (18.4%) presented some type of psychiatric disorder. Mean hospitalisation time: 13 days. Time until surgery: 3 days. Fracture type: 20 (52.6%) pertrochanteric and 16 (42.10%) subcapital. Treatment: cannulated screws in 11 cases (29%), screw and plate in 21 (55.2%). We found no diagnosis of osteoporosis or related indications in the admission reports except in one patient. Patients over 50: hip fracture incidence 161.21/100,000 inhabitants, pertrochanteric in 54.9% and subcapital in 45.1%*.

A Torrijos, C Ojeda. Area 5 hip study group, La Paz Hospital

Conclusions:

Hip fractures resulting from low-energy trauma are uncommon in the population under the age of 50.

There are factors predisposing to bone fragility in 60.5%.

The type of fracture is similar to those found in the elderly.

Treatment with cannulated screws is more common in non-elderly patients (20% vs 7%*)

There is not adequate consideration of the problem of osteoporosis in these patients.


J Elorriaga-Vaquero J Sánchez-Sotelo AD Hanssen ME Cabanela

Introduction and purpose: Two-stage reimplantation of a hip replacement is the treatment of choice for deep periprosthetic infections. The purpose of this study is to analyse the survival of the femoral component in two-stage hip replacement reimplantations and compare the results of cemented and cementless components.

Materials and methods: Between 1988 and 1998 our hospital carried out 169 two-stage reimplantations for treatment of first episodes of deep infection. The femoral component was cemented in 121 cases and cementless in 48. All patients were followed up clinically and radiologically for at least five years.

Results: The two-stage revision was associated with a significant clinical improvement. The reinfection rate was 9% (16/169), of which 11 patients underwent revision surgery and five received chronic suppressive antibiotic treatment. Eight patients required revision due to aseptic loosening and two for periprosthetic fracture. With the numbers available, fixation with or without cement showed no significant differences.

Conclusions: The two-stage revision of an infected hip prosthesis resolved the infection in 91% of the cases. An additional 5% required revision due to aseptic loosening. The surgical outcomes seem to be independent of the femoral component fixation (cemented or cementless).


T Balci C Josten G Lob M Mella

Introduction and purpose: Primary instability and subsidence of hip implants is a very common problem. What is the load on a locking screw?

Materials and methods: Helios® modular prosthesis (IQL / Biomet España) with distal holes (static/dynamic). Fifty patients (46%) with locking, total n=109 (26 of 67 with FX of proximal femur, 14 of 25 aseptic loosening cases and 13 of 17 with periprosthetic fractures). Experimental study: stress on the distal locking screws. Loads applied in 9 cadavers with 3 types of simulated fractures: group I, femoral neck; group II, intertro-chanteric; and group III, subtrochanteric. Imitating slow, normal and fast walking, sitting down and standing up, going up an down stairs (Zwick Z010 and screw capacity meter).

Results: Follow-up 6–18 months. 50 with distal locking (20% dynamic, 80% static): 13 screws removed between 6 and 12 weeks (7 in revisions, 3 in FX, 3 others).

Subsidence: 80% 1–2 mm, 14% 3–5 mm, 6% 6 mm or more.

Experimental study: Weight-bearing: group I, 40.89% (max. 78.61%); group II, 43.15% (max 90.84%); group III, 64.49% (max. 136.74%). No torsional stress. Maximum stress when walking fast and climbing stairs.

Conclusions: When bone consolidation occurs in 6 to 12 weeks, distal locking ensures sufficient reinforcement and prevents movements of over 30 μm. If more time is needed for proximal bone integration, shaft fixation is preferable. The Helios® system provides both solutions satisfactorily.


E Melendo C Torrens J Cebamanos E Cáceres

Introduction: Study of the influence of anatomical restoration on the outcome of the surgical treatment of proximal humerus fractures treated by sutures and Ender nails.

Materials and methods: 44 fractures. Mean age 64.45. 12 men and 32 women. Mean follow-up 55.83 months (12.83-97). 14 2p fractures, 27 3p and 3 4p. Functional study using the Constant Scale. Quality of life measured with EuroQol-5D. Imaging done one year after surgery: AP X-Ray, full bilateral humerus with external measurement and control CT.

Results: Mean Constant score for series: 78.98. Mean EuroQol-5D rating for the series: 0.7681. Constant scores for total humerus length: Diminished length: difference < 1 cm, 84.71; difference ≥1 cm, 56. Increased length: difference < 1 cm, 79.2; difference ≥ 1 cm, 78.67. Constant score according to distance between head and trochlea: difference +: 77,94; difference −: 82.92. Differences by age groups: < 70 years, 84.12; ≥70 years, 73.5.

Conclusions: No significant involvement of function with differences of less than 2 cm in total humerus length. No significant involvement of function for differences of less than 1 cm in head-trochlea distance. Functional differences by age groups. Best result < 70 years of age.


JF Zanui S Bellés MC Sánchez

Introduction and purpose: Rhizarthrosis of the thumb is the most common form of osteoarthritis of the hand. In some cases it courses with intense pain and severe functional limitation of the thumb or the entire hand.

The purpose of this study is to compare the results of treating rhizarthrosis with a total ARPE trapezio-metacarpal prosthesis and trapezectomy, whether or not associated with tendon interposition and ligament repair.

Materials and methods: A retrospective comparative study in which we reviewed cases of rhizarthrosis treated surgically in our hospital between 1994 and 2004. We found 75 cases, of which 28 were treated with resection arthroplasty (group A), 32 with ARPE prosthesis (group B) and 15 with bone fusion (not included in this study). The mean age was 58.85 for group A and 63.16 for group B. Mean follow-up time was 39.5 months.

We used the DASH questionnaire for the subjective clinical examination and the Jamar dynamometer for the objective examination. For radiological assessment we used the Eaton classification and Walch radiological criteria.

Results: We analysed the results using SPSS statistical software and found no significant differences between the two groups, although the subjective assessment showed better results in terms of mobility and pain remission in group B and strength in group A.

Conclusions: The aim of surgical treatment of rhizarthrosis is to achieve a stable, pain-free thumb. Several procedures are available, the success of which depends on correct indication and meticulous surgical technique.


A Silvestre F Argüelles E Arana JM García-Gomez

Introduction and purpose: We present a new decision-making method to assist orthopaedists and radiologists in diagnosing soft-tissue tumours. It can distinguish between benign and malignant characteristics in these lesions and classify them histologically with satisfactory efficiency. The pre-surgical diagnosis of the nature of the tumour and whether it is benign or malignant is crucial to planning surgical procedures.

Materials and methods: We reviewed our cases of soft-tissue tumours (47) studied by MRI over the past year and a half. They are part of a multicentre study involving several European hospitals (430 patients).

We analysed the clinical and MRI data: age, clinical presentation, size, shape, location, edges, image signal, calcification, intratumour fat, dependency, fibrosis, relation to fascias, bone and vessel disorders.

Results: With this method we detected 62% benign tumours and 38% malignant. The system sensitivity and specificity are 86% and 95%, respectively.

Conclusions: It is easy to distinguish between vascular, nerve and cystic lesions. The diagnosis of fibrous, synovial and fatty lesions is complex in all cases.

The method can help orthopaedists make a diagnosis before surgery, which will facilitate planning of surgical procedures.


D Roca I Maled R Lòpez VL Caja

Purpose: We set four objectives: compare compression plate with locking screw, assess bone graft usefulness, assess utility of resection and compression of fracture site, and determine prognostic factors.

Materials and methods: A multicentre study was carried out including Sant Pau, Valle de Hebròn and IMAS hospitals in Barcelona. 54 surgical cases treated from 1994 to 2003 were included for retrospective study. Three groups of factors were analysed: familial, factors associated with the initial trauma and those associated with the surgical procedure. We studied the statistical relation to consolidation, consolidation time and postoperative complications.

Results: The following factors significantly enhanced consolidation (p< 0.05): treatment with nail in atrophic pseudoarthrosis and plate in hypertrophic. Consolidation time was significantly shortened (p< 0.05) if fractures were initially simple (type A) and for those initially treated conservatively. Postoperative complications were reduced (p< 0.05) in fractures that were initially simple (type A).

Conclusions: There were no differences between the two implants studied in terms of consolidation, consolidation time and complications. However, cases of atrophic pseudoarthrosis had a better outcome with nails and the hypertrophic cases with plates. Bone grafts did not improve results. Compression of the fracture site was a determining factor in achieving consolidation; therefore, open intramedullary nailing should be performed to this end. Simple fractures and fractures initially receiving conservative treatment were good prognostic factors following pseudoarthrosis surgery.


D Roca I Proubasta D Lacroix JA Planell

Purpose: We carried out a biomechanical study by finite element analysis to compare treatment with a plate and treatment with a nail in pseudoarthrosis of the humeral shaft.

Materials and methods: We used a cadaver humerus and the two fixation devices to generate the geometry with design software (CATIA® v4.2). We then modelled the shapes with finite element analysis software (MSC.Patran®) and created three experimental models: healthy humerus, humerus with shaft pseudoarthrosis stabilised with AO plate and humerus with shaft pseudoarthrosis stabilised with locking nail. Both implants were titanium. The three models were subjected to nine different load conditions and the results compared.

Results: The nail model is stiffer than the plate in compression (3002.80 vs 789.68 N/mm), traction (6576.73 vs 1559.90 N/mm) and torsion (4.67 vs 2.73 N/mm). However, the plate model is biomechanically superior to the nail under other load conditions (mediolateral flexion, anteroposterior flexion, anteroposterior shear and mediolateral shear).

Conclusions: Although we can understand and compare the stability of the plate model with the nail, joint clinical and biomechanical studies are needed to determine the minimum stiffness required so that it will not interfere with the process of union under different load conditions.


P González-Herranz C de la Fuente M Castro Torre

Introduction and purpose: Femoral osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) is a process of unpredictable clinical course and uncertain aetiology (vascular, post-traumatic or microtraumatic). Its prognosis is based on diagnostic imaging (MRI and scintillation scanning) and age (Multicentre EPOS OCD Study). In our study we analysed the influence of the alignment of the lower limbs in femoral OCD.

Materials and methods: From 2000–2004 we studied 22 cases in 19 patients with femoral OCD. We carried out a tele-radiographic study of the lower limbs with weight-bearing, recording the location of the OCD according to Cahill, the femorotibial angle (n=87.5° ±2°) and the mechanical axis of the limb, which was considered normal when it went through the two tibial spines (Cahill zone 3).

Results: The mean age was 13.4 years (r: 10–28). The OCD was located in the medial condyle in 16 cases and the lateral in 6. We found changes in the femorotibial angle in 12/22 (55%) and of the mechanical axis in 18/22 (82%). In the cases with worst prognosis and loose bodies (7 cases), 100% showed changes in the mechanical axis.

Conclusions: There is a strong relation between OCD and changes in the lower limb alignment. The most sensitive radiological measurement is the mechanical or weight-bearing axis. This finding confirms the good prognosis of the lesion in children, since they undergo physiological changes in the femorotibial angle and constant changes of the mechanical axis until growth is complete.


P Garcia_Parra FJ Serrano Escalante JJ Gil Álvarez E Lòpez-Vidriero

Introduction and purpose: Calcaneal fractures are relatively common. The severity of this condition is due to the residual functional limitation. There are several therapeutic alternatives.

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective study of 70 patients with calcaneal fractures, divided into two groups. The first group of 35 patients was treated with bone synthesis using pins and the second group of 35 with bone synthesis with a low-profile plate and screws. We analysed epidemiological data, injury mechanism, type of fracture and complications. We calculated the reduction of Böhler’s angle and return to work. The clinical and functional results were analysed using the AOFAS scale.

Results: The mean age and injury mechanism were very similar in both groups. In the pin group, the fracture type was mainly grade 2 according to the Sanders classification, while in the plate group it was grade 3.

The reduction of Böhler’s angle was greater in the plate group. There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups with regard to return to work. However the final AOFAS score was 82.7 in the plate and 69.8 in the pin group.

Conclusions: A fracture of the calcaneus is a complex pathology, especially because of the functional limitation it leaves behind.

There were fewer complications in the plate group, except for skin problems.


TJ Sanchez-Lorente PJ Delgado-Serrano JJ Asenjo-Siguero F Lòpez-Oliva

Introduction and purpose: When treating for loss of mobility in the elbow, after at least six months of conservative treatment following an injury we should consider surgery. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the improvement in range of motion after surgery.

Materials and methods: We reviewed the cases of elbow arthrolysis carried out in our hospital from 1999 to 2004, analysing the following variables: personal data (sex, age, type of work) and information on the injury (type, location, associated lesions and degree of stiffness). The main variables were degree of mobility in flexion/extension (F-E) and pronation/supination (P-S) before and after surgery, in addition to functional and occupational results.

Statistical analysis: Percentage estimate and by 95% confidence intervals, and analysis of increased mobility after surgery in F-E and P-S using Student’s t-test of repeated measures.

Results: 52 patients who underwent arthrolysis (86% males, mean age 37.2 years) whose jobs required average exercise and with grade II stiffness in 46.2% of the cases. The average preoperative ranges of motion for F-E and P-S were 74.52 (SD 32.3) and 120.10 (SD 66.6) degrees, respectively. The postoperative estimates for both parameters were 96.5 (SD 29.5) for F-E and 158.9 (SD 39.8) for P-S. The increases were statistically significant (p< 0.00001). The increased motion in P-S was slightly better than for F-E (p=0.054).

Conclusions: After our study, we can confirm that arthrolysis is an effective surgical procedure to improve mobility in stiff elbows. It is indicated when the joint interline is preserved. The lateral approach is the most common because it enables access to the anterior and posterior aspects of the capsule. Good functional and occupational outcome in a high percentage of cases.


JJ Martínez J Ríos F Martínez A Martínez-Almagro

Introduction and purpose: Our aim was to determine a morphometric relation between the long head of the brachial biceps and the bicipital groove with respect to the subscapular tendon, and its repercussion on functional imbalance of the shoulder.

Materials and methods: For this analytical observational crossover study we took a sample of 30 right-handed, sedentary, duly informed male subjects. The morphometric study was carried out with ultrasonography using a cross-section of the long head of the brachial biceps.

Results: In the dominant limb: 1. Bicipital groove (depth 2.6 mm, width 13.4 mm, internal angle 149.8°); 2. Long head of the brachial biceps (area 1.35 mm, internal angle 152.53°, echogenicity 97.95); 3. Subscapular thickness 4.53 mm. In the non-dominant limb: 1. Bicipital groove (depth 2.9 mm, width 12.5 mm, internal angle 145.73°); 2. Long head of the brachial biceps (area 1.07 mm, internal angle 141.32°, echogenicity 112.72); 3. Subscapular thickness 4.12 mm.

Conclusions: The greater the thickness of the subscapular tendon: 1. Bicipital groove (greater width and internal angle, less echogenicity and depth); 2. Long head of the brachial biceps (greater area and internal angle, less echogenicity). Therefore, there is a greater risk of dislocation of the long head of the brachial biceps and functional instability of the shoulder.


M Corrales C Torrens G Gonzalez E Cáceres

Introduction: Analysis of location of central peg and the fours screws of the glenoid component in inverted shoulder prostheses.

Materials and methods: 34 inverted prostheses. Mean age 74.10. 33 women, 1 man. Preoperative CT: glenoid version, presence and size of bone spurs. Postoperative CT: location of central peg and 4 screws.

Results: 27 retroverted glenoids (mean 6.5°), 7 anteverted glenoids (mean 5.3°); anterior bone spur in 17 cases, posterior in 12. In 52% of the cases the central peg was inside the glenoid; in 33% the anterior part was outside and in 14% the posterior part. If the anterior part of the central peg was outside, 85% was due to retroverted glenoids (mean 8.33°). If the posterior part was outside, 66% of these were due to anteverted glenoids (mean 9.5°). Lower inside screw in the scapula in 38% of cases, 3/4 inside in 19%, 2/4 in 23% and 1/4 in 19%. Upper screw: 47%, 23% 19% and 9%, respectively. Anterior screw: 66%, 23% and 9%, respectively. Posterior screw: 38%, 42%, 14% and 4%, respectively.

Conclusions:

- Lower screw completely within the lateral part of the scapula with less coverage by upper screw.

- Anterior extrusion of the central peg correlated with more retroverted glenoids and posterior extrusion with very anteverted glenoids.

- No correlation between presence of anterior and posterior bone spurs and the position of the peg or the screws.


D Cachero Bernárdez JC Roa-Montero N Cachero-Rodríguez S Pérez-Rodríguez

Introduction and purpose: The purpose of the study is to look at the progress of fixed implants with osteolysis and bone defects treated and to set ground rules for treatment guidelines.

Materials and methods: We reviewed 204 hips between March 1996 and March 2003, in 40 of which femoral osteolysis was treated with fixed prostheses.

The reasons for the revisions were 20 aseptic cup loosenings and 20 cases of worn polyethylene, with presence of femoral osteolysis. Thirty of the stems were biological, nine mini-madreporic and one cemented.

The mean follow-up was 5 years and 2 months.

We used morsellised impacted bone graft held in place with cement, metal laminas or bone stock.

Results: Clinically the outcome was excellent or good in 92.5% of the cases, with no migration or revision of the stem.

All the grafts took. There was very limited partial resorption in 20% of the cases and radiolucent lines in 20.6%.

Among the complications were two new cases of wear with osteolysis and a fractured femur caused by a fall, with no infection or dislocation.

Conclusions: Femoral osteolysis must be watched and treated surgically if it progresses, even though the implant is fixed.

Impacted morsellised bone grafts in the femoral canal with a fixed stem, even with extensive, unchecked osteolysis, held in place with metal cages are a reliable means of recovering bone stock and holding the femoral component firmly in place for the long term, with good clinical and radiological outcome, minimal risk and shorter surgery.


G Fernández A Jiménez B García JL Carrasco

Introduction and purpose: There has been a great increase in prosthetic surgery. The demand for homologous blood is higher than the supply in blood banks. We must bear in mind the adverse effects of homologous blood transfusion: incompatibility reactions, metabolic disorders, risk of disease transmission. There are alternatives to homologous blood: autotransfusion methods.

Materials and methods: Knee prostheses were implanted in 60 patients between 2002 and 2003 using the CBCII Constavac Blood Conservation System and reinfusion of the harvested blood. We analysed epidemiological data, ASA, harvested blood volume, haematology values, need for homologous blood transfusion and complications.

Results: 60 prostheses. Mean duration of surgery 121 minutes, mean hospital stay 8 days. 83.3% women, mean age 66.2 years. Harvested volume 677.5 ml (±221.3). Homologous transfusion was required in 9 cases. Haematocrit and haemoglobin tests were performed prior to surgery and at 24, 48 and 72 hours with the following results, respectively: 40.87, 13.4; 31.39, 10.4; 30.06, 10.05; 30.75, 10.2. Complications: fever (7), nausea (3).

Conclusions: Autotransfusion reduces the need for homologous blood. Harvested blood is an excellent source of erythrocytes and platelets. There are few adverse effects if reinfusion takes place within 6 hours and the volume is not over 1,000 ml. The association of different autotransfusion techniques and other more recent ones such as EPO and intravenous iron could make transfusion of homologous blood unnecessary in over 90% of patients.


P Alvarez G Steinbacher G Samitier* R Cugat

Introduction and purpose: The treatment of PCL injuries has undergone many changes in recent decades and the number of stabilisations has increased. The improvement of arthroscopic techniques makes it possible to stabilise the PCL safely and gives good results.

The purpose of this paper is to present a retrospective study of arthroscopic PCL stabilisations carried out in our hospital from 1997 to 2003.

Materials and methods: Between 1998 and 2003 we performed 25 PCL reconstructions, associated with posterolateral angle stabilisations in four cases. The mean age was 21.4. The mean follow-up was 36.5 (18–74). We used autologous BTB graft in 18 cases and Achilles tendon allograft in 7. In all cases a single-bundle arthroscopic reconstruction was performed. Gravitational X-rays were taken of all patients before and after surgery to assess the posterior drawer. We used IKDC for postoperative evaluation.

Results: The mean posterior drawer in preoperative neutral rotation was 7.51 mm (6.5–15), and 2.37 mm postoperative. Postoperative IKDC evaluation was as follows: 6 cases (24%) A, 16 (64%) B, 3 cases (12%) C. In 88% of the cases the athletes returned to normal sports activity.

Among the complications was one case of infection of the surgical wound in a reconstruction of the posterolateral angle.

Conclusions: Our retrospective study suggests that the single-bundle reconstruction procedure we used gives good functional results, and most of the patients returned to their previous sports activity.


A Sánchez-Granado M Rodriguez R Narros D Sicilia

Introduction and purpose: Large defects of diverse aetiology (traumatic, oncological, etc.) in long bones pose a number of difficulties for reconstruction because of their dual condition: structural and functional.

The free fibular flap can be a useful method for reconstructing large defects in bones such as the tibia or humerus.

We present our experience with 15 patients in whom this bone flap was used to reconstruct defects of different pathological origins.

Materials and methods: Retrospective analysis of 15 patients between the ages of 6 and 55 in whom a vascularised fibular flap was used to reconstruct bone defects in the following locations and pathologies: Tibia: 7 cases of congenital pseudoarthrosis, 1 case of posttraumatic pseudoarthrosis, 1 case of firearm wound, 1 case of chronic osteomyelitis, 2 cases of Ewing’s sarcoma in the distal third of the tibia; Humerus: 2 cases of Ewing’s sarcoma; Radius: 1 case of osteosarcoma. Of the 15 cases 14 fibulae were used with a single bar, with different attachment methods, and one with a double bar.

Results: The viability rate of the flaps was 100%, and adequate function was achieved in all cases except one case of posttraumatic pseudoarthrosis that required further procedures.

Conclusions: The vascularised fibular flap is the best option for treating congenital pseudoarthrosis of the tibia and a good option for reconstruction after oncological bone surgery.


L Ruiz JA Hernández JL Agullò JJ Morales-de-Cano

Purpose: To compare the results of reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) using autologous patellar bone-tendon-bone (BTB) graft with four semitendinous-medial rectus bundles (STMR). Our technique involved a double incision and attachment with an interference screw.

Materials and methods: Non-randomised prospective study of 296 athletes operated on between 1988 and 2001: 202 BTB and 94 STMR. The mean ages were 22.8 and 21.6, males 52.9% and 58.5%, right knee involved in 54.46% and 54.3% of cases and mean follow-up of 13.7 and 12.4 months in the BTB and STMR groups, respectively.

The evaluation of the results was based on the IKDC protocol and pre- and post-surgical anterior tibial displacement was evaluated with the radiological Lachman test and Telos® arthrometer.

Results: The final IKDC evaluation was excellent or good in 86% and 89%, post-surgery Lachman tests showed less than 3 mm in 58.6 and 50.6%, from 4 to 8 mm in 33.3% and 31.6%, the athlete dropping sports activity in 9.3 and 3.4%, infection in 3 and 2 cases, stiffness in 2 and 2 cases and discomfort on kneeling in 8.7 and 2.2% of athletes in the BTB and STMR groups, respectively.

Conclusions: We found no clinical differences between the two procedures. Anteroposterior stability was better in the BTB group. There was less discomfort on kneeling and fewer athletes dropped sports in the STMR group.


F Pérez JF Moscoso J Oran JJ Fernández

Introduction and purpose: There still remain controversies with regard to knee replacements, such as the preservation or replacement of the patellar surface. Although numerous studies have compared the clinical results of the two procedures, there have been few long-term radiological follow-up studies of the non-resurfaced patella. Our purpose is to assess this follow-up and determine the relation to clinical pain pictures of patellar origin.

Materials and methods: We carried out a clinical and radiological study of 74 PFC modular arthroplasties without patellar resurfacing with a mean follow-up of 10 years (range: 9–12 years). We measured the size and height of the patella, Wiberg classification, degree of patellar sclerosis, patellar excursion and presence and size of bone spurs. We carried out an exhaustive examination of the extensor apparatus. We related the radiological data to the clinical picture of the patella.

Results: We observed a tendency toward reduced titlting, increased height and width and diminished patellar thickness. None of these variations was statistically related to the onset of patellar pain or sustained pain.

Conclusions: Radiological variations of the non-resurfaced patella in total knee arthroplasty do not result in patellar clinical pictures.


Á Solís-Gòmez I Fernández-Bances V Asensi-Álvarez J Paz-Jiménez

Introduction: For the health-care system and for society in general, fractures of the femoral neck are epidemic among the elderly. With increased life expectancy, this type of pathology will continue increasing in the future. The study of possible biological causes of this phenomenon will provide better understanding of the pathology and help us prevent such fractures. Different genes involved in the synthesis of nitric oxide and interleukins are related to the occurrence of fractures of the femoral neck.

Materials and methods: We studied 111 patients with fractures of the femoral neck between 2002 and 2004 and a control group of 127 patients operated on for total hip or knee replacement in the same period. In both groups we looked at different genetic polymorphisms of IL-1 alpha, IL-1 beta, IL-1 RA, NOS2 and NOS3. We also measured the levels of IL-1 beta, IL-6 and TNF alpha in patient sera.

Results: We found a significant difference for certain genetic polymorphisms related to IL-1 beta and NOS3 and patients with fractures of the femoral neck.

Conclusions: There are different genes related to inflammatory reactants which are significantly related to the presence of fractures of the femoral neck.


J Fernández-Lombardía F García-Arias D Hernández-Vaquero

Purpose: We assess the advantages of helical computerised tomography as compared to conventional radiological methods in the diagnosis of this problem in the acetabulum.

Materials and methods: We studied 51 patients with 63 porous hemispheric acetabular implants coated with hydroxyapatite who were part of a planned radiological follow-up. After 10 years they were examined with helical computerised tomography according to a protocol designed to minimise metal artefacts. We compared the diagnosis of acetabular osteolysis by the two imaging techniques, taking the presence of delimited areas of absent trabeculation as a criterion.

Results: With computerised tomography we detected 23 osteolytic lesions in 19 hips, of which 5 had been diagnosed by conventional radiology. Only 3 patients presented symptoms in the form of mild-moderate pain. The mean volume of the lesions was 1.61 cc (SD: 1.41) with a minimum of 0.3 and maximum of 5.5 cc.

Conclusions: Computerised tomography can be a useful tool in the diagnosis and follow-up of acetabular osteolysis in total hip replacement. More studies are needed to complete its diagnostic possibilities and specify its indications.


C Ojeda-Thies C Bohorquez-Heras O Macho-Pérez A Torrijos-Eslava

Introduction and purpose: Osteoporotic hip fractures are a major cause of hospital morbidity and mortality in geriatric patients. Our purpose was to study hospital mortality due to osteoporotic hip fractures in persons over 50 in our hospital and evaluate the prognostic factors for mortality.

Materials and methods: We carried out a prospective evaluation of all patients with osteoporotic hip fractures admitted to our hospital between March and September 2004. We emphasised the possible predictive factors for hospital mortality, such as individual background, clinical situation, cognitive aspects, functional and social situation, treatment used and complications. We excluded patients with high-energy or pathological fractures and those who did not want to sign the informed consent form for inclusion in the study. The data were analysed with SPSS statistical software v11.0.

Results: In the six-month period mentioned above, 357 patients were admitted for osteoporotic hip fracture. The female/male ratio was 2.9:1. 37.6% were over 85 and 28.1% had been institutionalised prior to admission. 27 patients died while in hospital (7.6%), with a similar distribution between preoperative and postoperative mortality. The most common causes of death were related to decompensation of the patient’s baseline pathology, mainly of cardiorespiratory origin. Multivariate analysis showed significant prognostic factors independent of hospital mortality (p< 0.05): male sex (RR=4.3), age over 80 (RR=2.9), prior institutionalisation in a care home, the presence of confusional syndrome, low haemoglobin on admission and anaesthetic risk above III.

Conclusions: Hospital mortality was found to be high in cases of hip fracture. This was similar to previous studies carried out in our hospital and others. The prognostic factors for mortality were, above all, those that could not be changed (age, sex, anaesthetic risk, institutionalisation). Patients over 85, men, those coming from a care home and those with high anaesthetic risk have a greater risk of dying while in hospital. We should also be attentive to haemoglobin on admission and the presence of acute confusional syndrome.


J del Río JR Valentí A Valentí J Duart

Purpose: The purpose of this review is to present our experience in prosthetic reconstruction after resection arthroplasty, its outcome and possible complications.

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective study of 23 hips reconstructed after an average of 2.2 years. Inclusion criteria were: having had a resection arthroplasty, a reconstruction with joint prosthesis and a minimum follow-up of one year. For evaluation we used the Merle d’Aubigne score for pain, walking and range of motion.

Results: The operated limb was lengthened 2.9 cm (1.2–4.8). The average for pain was 4.6, for range of motion 4.3 and walking 5.2. The overall outcome, 14.1 points, was considered acceptable. 47% had good or very good outcomes. All the patients improved their ability to walk. Four patients presented dislocation of the prosthesis after reconstruction and only one patient had a reinfection.

Conclusions: Prosthetic reconstruction after resection arthroplasty is technically difficult. This is due mainly to wear in the soft tissues and changes in the amount and quality of bone stock as a result of prior surgery. The biggest gain is seen in the ability to walk while there is less improvement in pain and range of motion. Candidates for reconstruction must be carefully selected to prevent complications and/or false expectations of always achieving excellent results.


O Marin-Peña C Gebhard K Velev M Ribas-Fernandez MA Plasencia-Arriba

Purpose: To determine the incidence of anterior femoroacetabular impingement (AFAI) as a cause of idiopathic coxarthrosis in young adults.

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective study of 196 patients with total hip replacement (THR), selecting patients under 55 (51 cases, 26.02%). We recorded epidemiological, clinical and radiological data prior to the implantation of the THR. In all cases we used cementless stems and cups. The statistical analysis was done with SPSS software v10.0.

Results: The mean age was 50.7 (29–55). There was a predominance of men (31 cases, 61%) over women (20 cases, 39%). The mean BMI was 30.1 kg/m2 (20–42). The mean time with pain before hip arthroplasty was 8 years (2–20 years). Among the possible causes of the origin of coxarthrosis we found sequelae of acetabular fractures, hip growth dysplasias, rheumatoid arthritis, sequelae of Perthes disease and AFAI. 70.6% presented a “hump” in the head-neck junction on the axial projection, which appeared at the onset of symptoms; 10% presented frank deformity of the femoral head and 8% had protrusion of the head toward the acetabulum. The patients with AFAI presented less mean flexion (78.5°) and internal rotation (2.9°) (p< 0.05), and the predominant type of pain was inguinal irradiating to the thigh or greater trochanter (p< 0.05). The mean time from onset of symptoms to implantation of THR was less in this group (7.4 years) as compared to the rest (10.4 years) (p< 0.05).

Discussion: Murray (Br. J. Radiol 38:810–24, 1965) and Harris (CORR 213:20.23, 1986) had already mentioned AFAI as a predisposing factor in the degeneration of the coxofemoral joint. In recent years its importance has increased as the resection of the femoral hump in the initial degenerative stages has became more widespread (Tönnis 0 and I). This osteoplasty can be performed by hip arthroscopy (small humps), with dislocation of the femoral head (as described by R. Ganz) or by a very small anterior approach without dislocation of the femoral head as proposed by Ribas-Vilarubias (2004). Leunig (2005) speaks of an AFAI incidence of 15% in the general population and Tanzer (CORR 429:170-77, 2004) discovered “humps” in the femoral head-neck junction in 68–100% of patients with THR. Our study gives similar results, placing the incidence at 70.6% in patients under the age of 55 who have had a THR.

Conclusions: We think the incidence of femoroacetabular impingement is high and that this syndrome plays an important role in the onset of degeneration of the coxofemoral joint in young adults. These findings suggest the advisability of early surgery to attempt to delay the rapid progression toward primary arthroplasty at an early age.


A Ginés P Hinarejos M Tey JC Monllau

Introduction and purpose: To present the clinical, radiological and MRI results of a series of collagen meniscus implants (CMI) with 4–7 years follow-up.

Materials and methods: We implanted 25 CMI from 1997 to 2000 in 20 men and 5 women between the ages of 18 and 48. Five cases were operated on for postmeniscectomy syndrome, 19 for degenerative ruptures and one for acute rupture. We reconstructed the ACL at the same time in 17 cases (68%).

Results: The Lysholm score went from a preoperative mean of 59.9±15.8 to 89.6±6.3 at 2 years (p< 0.003), while the visual analogue pain score went from a preoperative mean of 7.0±1.8 to 2.0±1.6 (p< 0.001).

Conventional radiology showed no deterioration of the joint line. With MRI we saw a certain degree of meniscal regeneration in 68% of the cases. However, the implant tended to become smaller and it was common to see extrusion in frontal sections.

Three cases had persistent pain on the medial side of the knee. In one we removed the CMI and performed an allogeneic meniscus transplantation (AMT). The second case was treated by valgus osteotomy of the tibia and then AMT in the stage. The last case was not treated.

Conclusions: After 4 to 7 years of BMI follow-up, we found no adverse effects for the knee. Clinically the outcome was good in most of the cases (22/25). Regeneration appeared to occur in over one-third of the cases, although the size was smaller than expected.


A Peirò-Ibáñez J Sarasquete-Reiriz

Introduction and purpose: Cortical strut autografts provide primary stability to resolve fractures or pseudoarthrosis associated with major bone loss, or fractures close to joint prostheses.

Materials and methods: We present 8 cases in which strut autografts were used: one pseudoarthrosis of the humerus, three periprosthetic fractures in TKR and four fractures associated with hip prosthesis surgery.

We resolved the humeral pseudoarthrosis with struts and a PCL plate plus cancellous tissue graft. For the periprosthetic fractures of the knee and hip we used revision prostheses with extension stems plus struts, held in place with cerclage wires or compression bands, with or without plates.

In all cases functional rehabilitation started early. The mean non-weight-bearing period for lower limbs was 10 weeks (8–12 months).

Results: Primary stability made it possible to begin rehabilitation early in all cases. Total consolidation of the grafts in a mean time of 5 months (4–7 months), with complete recovery of bone stock. Excellent functional outcome with full return to daily activity as before surgery.

Conclusions: The use of strut autografts associated with osteosynthesis and/or revision prosthesis implantation makes it possible to resolve cases that require a large amount of bone graft and provides sufficient primary stability for fast rehabilitation. The proper final consolidation of the grafts and complete recovery of bone stock provides stability with full guarantee of long-term success.


D Obrero MJ Gòmez G Meseguer JA Raya AD Delgado B Campos

Purpose: To determine the degree of burnout among resident physicians in orthopaedic surgery and traumatology departments in Spanish hospitals and the influence of various factors.

Materials and methods: Descriptive crossover study. The study population included all the resident physicians in orthopaedic surgery and traumatology departments in Spain. We sent an anonymous self-administered questionnaire, the Maslach Burnout Inventory, which assesses emotional exhaustion, depersonalisation and personal accomplishment, in addition to a number of sociodemographic, occupational and personal variables by means of a questionnaire.

Results: Replies were received from 63 orthopaedic surgery and traumatology resident physicians (8%). 47.6% of the participants presented a high degree of emotional exhaustion, 66.6% a high degree of depersonalisation and 38.1% a low degree of personal accomplishment. Among the variables studied we found a high degree of burnout related, among others, to female sex, poor department organisation, little appreciation of the resident’s work and little free time for family. 32.8% of the respondents would choose the same medical specialisation but in a different hospital, as compared to 62.3% who would choose the same specialisation and the same hospital.

Conclusions: The levels of burnout among resident physicians in orthopaedic surgery and traumatology departments in Spain are higher than among associate physicians in the same departments in Spain and than those found in two earlier studies among primary care physicians in Spain and among several medical specialisations internationally. Training activities are needed to alleviate this problem.


J Solana M Pons C Guinot R Viladot

Introduction and purpose: Numerous surgical procedures have been developed for the treatment of chronic ankle instability, which can be broken down into two: tenodesis of the peroneus brevis and ligament capsuloplasty. We assess the indications for these procedures, discuss their advantages and disadvantages based on a comparative review, and describe an algorithm in the treatment of this pathology.

Materials and methods: We reviewed 21 patients who underwent surgery from 1997 to 2001. In 10 of the patients the operation consisted of a Castaing II procedure with tenodesis of the peroneus brevis, and in 11 a Larsson procedure was performed as a ligament capsuloplasty. The ankle was evaluated using the AOFAS scale.

Results: The age difference between the two groups, which was 40 for those undergoing the Castaing II procedure and 28 for the Larsson technique. The mean AOFAS score was 80% (min. 70%, max. 95%) for the Castaing II procedure and 86% (min. 71%, max. 97%) for the Larsson technique.

Conclusions: The use of tenodesis with the peroneus brevis is indicated for severe ankle instability, failed anatomical repairs and in patients with connective tissue pathology. A capsuloplasty that attempts to reconstruct the lateral ligaments of the ankle as anatomically as possible is indicated for mild-to-moderate chronic instability in young patients.


S García-Mata S Gozzi E Ibarlucea A Hidalgo

Introduction: Calcaneal lengthening osteotomy as a treatment for severe flat foot was described by Evans (1975) and his indications were expanded by Mosca (1995).

Materials and methods: We reviewed 28 feet operated on in 21 patients with neuromuscular processes (17) and with flat foot-valgus associated with congenital short Achilles tendon (11). The mean age was 12.2 (6–18) and mean follow-up was 7.3 years (4–11). In all cases the associated Achilles tendon was lengthened. We evaluated the subjective and objective clinical results (Kitaoka, 1994) and the radiological parameters.

Results: Subjective clinical: excellent and good 89.28% (100% in neuromuscular, 72.7 in short Achilles tendon). Objective clinical: (preop 64.25, postop 90.06 at 3 years, 86.13 at 7 years). The worsening of outcomes was due to three fair or poor results in the short Achilles tendon group (one required triple bone fusion).

All but one presented complete subtalar mobility. Normal alignment in all but one, with slight valgus; none in varus.

Conclusions: This surgical procedure gave excellent long-term results: subjective, nearly 90% excellent; objective: radiological anatomical correction, subtalar and tarsal mobility maintained. Its outcome was comparatively worse in the short Achilles tendon group than in the neuromuscular cases.


P Sáez L Amigo J Alarcòn

Introduction: Fracture of the osteoporotic hip is more common in people over the age of 74.

Purpose: To describe the co-operation between traumatologists and geriatric physicians in treating hip fractures among the elderly.

Materials and methods: Prospective study covering the number of referrals from Traumatology to Geriatrics in one year. We obtained data on age, sex, type of fracture and surgery, geriatric assessment and repercussion of this activity on the hospital.

Results: Over a period of 7 months in 2004, 120 patients were referred to Geriatrics, with a predominance of women and most with hip fractures. The intervention of the Geriatric Department consisted of detecting and compensating prior pathologies, adjusting medication, studying the fall, assessing the surgical risk and preparation for surgery, pain treatment, management of post-surgical complications (anaemia, malnutrition, pressure ulcers, infections, heart failure, etc.), early weight-bearing, detecting social risk and planning release from hospital. The repercussion of this work on the hospital translated into greater satisfaction among traumatologists, nursing staff and patients, more conditions diagnosed and treated and more complete release reports, thus improving ongoing care and shortening hospital stays.

Conclusions: Collaboration between the Traumatology and Geriatric Departments in treating geriatric patients admitted to Traumatology is cost-effective because it prevents complications, rationalises treatment, improves the patients’ functional status and shortens hospitalisation stays.


AG de la Torre M Vicente CF Catalan J Paz-Jimenez

Purpose: Vascular complications in lumbar disc surgery are rare, difficult to diagnose and may have serious consequences. We review our experience in eight cases treated in the past 30 years.

Methods: Between 1976 and 2005 we operated on 16,391 cases of vascular pathology, eight for vascular complications after lumbar discectomy (herniated disc), six men and two women aged 36 to 70 (mean 52 years). The symptoms were abdominal pain in four, ischial irradiation in one, episodes of heart failure in one, limb oedema in two, acute haemorrhage in three, abdominal murmur in two. The diagnosis was made during surgery in two cases and immediately postoperative in the third due to severe hypovolemia. The others were diagnosed because of abdominal murmur, limb oedema and suspected abdominal aneurism. Abdominal CT scans and arteriography were performed in five cases. Treatment was surgical, with direct closure in seven cases and interposition of a Dacron aortoiliac prosthesis in the other. No sequelae were seen during follow-up, which lasted a maximum of fifteen years. All the patients returned to normal life and there was no mortality.

Conclusions: Because of the severity and rareness of this complication, few cases have been described in the literature, and its real incidence is therefore unknown. We should think of it whenever there is any unexplained, sustained haemodynamic disorder during lumbar disc surgery or immediately postoperative. Treatment should be immediate.


R Fernandez N Fiz E Crespo S Pérez-Tierno

Introduction: Fractures of the proximal third of the femur are a major health problem in Western countries, where there has been a high increase in their incidence due to factors such as ageing of the population, which in itself does not explain the rise in this pathology.

Fractures of this type are one of the main causes of mortality and morbidity in the elderly, the main risk group.

In the context of the above, it is useful to know the different variables that influence aetiopathogenesis, prevention and treatment while in hospital and after release.

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective study of 250 fractures in patients admitted to this hospital between 2001 and 2003, with a one-year follow-up, and designed a data-collection form. We divided the patients into two groups, those who had died and those alive after one year, and compared the different variables using SPSS statistical software.

Results: The one-year mortality rate in hip-fracture patients in our hospital is 25%, within the limits found in the literature. Age, ASA surgical risk and dementia are factors that have a significant influence on one-year mortality in hip-fracture patients.

Conclusions: The main factors that significantly influence one-year mortality are those inherent to the patient, such as age, ASA surgical risk and dementia.


P Guillén I Guillén M Guillén M Leyes

Introduction: Recent clinical, morphological and MRI studies have evidenced a potential for regeneration of the tendons of the semitendinous and medial rectus muscles. This is the first article in the world literature describing how these two tendons have been obtained for the second time and have been used for reconstruction of the ACL.

Materials and methods: The study included two men aged 30 and 38 in whom the ACL had been reconstructed (6 and 9 years before, respectively) using the semitendinous (ST) and medial rectus (MR) tendons. The full length and width of the tendons were harvested using a tenotome. The ACL reconstruction was subsequently broken in both patients in a sporting accident. Preoperative MRI was performed in both patients and confirmed the rupture of the ACL and regeneration of the ST and MR. Both tendons were harvested, the macroscopic findings were noted and samples of the tendons were taken for histological study. The regenerated tendons were used to reconstruct the ACL, maintaining their distal attachment and fixing them proximally with a staple.

Results: Macroscopically the regenerated tendons looked nearly normal. Both had regenerated to their normal thickness and length (the diameter of the tunnels in the ACL revision surgery was the same as in the primary surgery).

The histological study showed normal tendinous tissue with a few areas of disorganised collagen bundles, increased proliferation of fibroblasts and formation of capillaries.

After a follow-up of 14 and 17 months, both patients recovered their prior level of sports activity and their knees were stable.

Conclusions: Harvesting the tendons of the semitendinous and medial rectus muscles leads to regeneration of both tendons. Although the biomechanical properties of this regenerated tissue are unknown, clinically it appears to be an appropriate tissue for ACL reconstruction.


M Fakkas Fernández A Pascual Carra J Hernández-Elena MA Alonso Aguirre

Introduction: The anatomical complexity of the acetabulum and the difficulty of classifying fractures mean that treatment plans change continuously.

The decision to treat surgically involves evaluating the type of fracture, individual factors, the hospital’s possibilities and the surgeon’s experience.

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective review of 81 patients treated surgically for acetabular fractures between January 1994 and December 2003 with minimum follow-up of one year. 49 patients were followed up for more than 3 years. The patients’ ages were between 19 and 74. We reviewed the type of fracture, presence of dislocation, injury mechanism, associated sciatic injury, surgical approach and time to weight-bearing. We evaluated clinical (Merle d’Aubigne) and radiological results at one and three years.

Results: One patient required total hip replacement after a year and four at three years. According to the Merle d’Aubigne scale, there were 63 excellent results, 14 good and 4 fair at one year (81 cases), and 41 good and excellent, 6 fair and 2 poor at three years (49 cases).

There was one case of intraarticular screw, another with an incarcerated bone fragment and another of sub-capital fracture.

Conclusions: In treatment, careful classification is essential to choose the appropriate surgical approach and achieve better reduction.

Good reduction improves the functional prognosis. The worst outcomes were in elderly patients. In young patients the outcome was related to the damage to joint cartilage.


JM Rojo Manaute R Barco Laakso JM González Lòpez F Lopez-Barea

Introduction and purpose: Benign giant cell tumours (GCT) are locally aggressive and may transform into primary sarcomatous tumours (1–3%) following recurrence (10–15%) and lung metastases (1–6%) even with benign histology. However, survival in these cases is high (96–100% of transformations and 15–50% of metastases). Recurrences after en-block resection are less common (0–5%), but curettage together with bone graft and/or adjuvant therapy achieves acceptable recurrence rates (0–34%) with lower morbidity.

The purpose of this study is to analyse our results after en-block resection and curettage.

Materials and methods: Retrospective series of 19 patients with GCT operated on between 1988 and 2002 with en-block resection and local reconstruction or curettage and allograft or cement. Location: proximal tibia (3), distal femur (4), hip (3), proximal humerus (2) and distal radius (6).

We describe the recurrences, metastases, deaths and complications according to treatment.

Results: There were no recurrences in 9 cases of en-block resection and we performed local reconstruction with a prosthesis (3), allograft (5) or VFG (1). The rest (10) underwent curettage with cement (2) or allograft (8). We had one recurrence treated with en-block resection and prosthesis. There were no metastases, deaths or other complications.

Conclusions: Although there were no recurrences with the en-block resection, curettage resulted in acceptable control of the disease with less morbidity. As a general rule, we tried to preserve the joint even with lesions in advanced stages.


Full Access
A del Arco L Trullols A Ruiz

Introduction and purpose: The purpose of our study is to make a critical review of our experience and find a method of systematised, objective therapeutic strategy in the treatment of vertebral metastases.

Materials and methods: We reviewed 38 cases of vertebral metastasis (1995–2004) from primary tumours: lung 21%, breast 21%, prostate 12%, renal 12%, ovary 8%, tongue 4%, cavum 4%, melanoma 4%, unknown primary tumour 17%.

24 cases were treated surgically in terms of the clinical criterion agreed between oncologist and traumatologist.

We reviewed the follow-up of the cases (treatment, complications, mortality) and the subsequent application of the Tokuhashi prognostic index and the Tomita therapy protocol with two objectives: to evaluate our results and assess these two methods as working tools.

Results: 74% of the patients had preoperative radiotherapy. The surgical treatment was corporectomy and dorsal decompression (17%), partial corporectomy and dorsal decompression (29%), decompression and dorsal instrumentation (37%) and non-instrumented decompression laminectomy (17%).

The mean survival was 17 months. The surgical treatment controlled pain in 87%; there was neurological improvement in 21%, control in 54% and progression in 25%.

Conclusions: Our results were not as good as those found in the literature, in which the usefulness of postoperative radiotherapy is emphasised.

Preoperative radiotherapy may have made tumour excision more difficult which, together with the delayed decision-making, influenced the loss of efficacy in our cases.

We need more prospective studies to validate the Tokuhashi index and the Tomita protocol, which we think are very useful in taking therapy decisions.


I Cabanes A Murcia J González-del-Pino

Introduction and purpose: The ulnar carpal impaction syndrome (UCIS) is a common cause of pain in the ulnar aspect of the wrist. It has numerous causes, although most cases are due to rupture of the triangular fibrocartilaginous complex (TFC), either traumatic or degenerative.

Materials and methods: We carried out a prospective study of the results of ulnar shortening osteotomy in 41 wrists. The osteotomy (transverse) was performed in the middle third of the ulnar and the shortening ranged from 3 to 10 mm. For stabilisation we used a 3.5-mm AO LC-DCP and LCP plate. Minimum follow-up was 6 months and maxim was 8 years.

Results: The mean age was 37; there were 28 women and 12 men. The ulnar variance ranged from 5 mm positive to 2 mm negative. All the wrists had Tolat type I or II distal radioulnar morphology. Pain and pain frequency were reduced to levels below surgical indication in 89% of cases within 2 and 4 months after the operation. All the ulnae consolidated satisfactorily between 12 and 14 weeks, except for one case of pseudoarthrosis, which was treated with an iliac crest graft and further bone synthesis.

Conclusions: The results obtained in this series reveal adequate progression of wrist pain and function in patients treated for UCIS by ulnar shortening. There were very few complications and revisions.


O Pablos P Lopez-Osornio C Tramunt J Casañas

Introduction: The metacarpophalangeal joint of the thumb is prone to frequent injury in the capsule and collateral ligaments, especially the ulnar collateral ligament. Delayed diagnosis, inappropriate treatment or progressive laxity of the ligament complex can lead to chronic instability of the MCP joint of the thumb. Various surgical repair procedures have been described.

We present the surgical procedure consisting of a bone-retinaculum-bone autograft taken from the second tunnel of the flexor retinaculum of the carpus.

Purpose: Our purpose is to present the experience of seven cases in which chronic instability of the thumb was treated using a bone-retinaculum-bone autograft.

Materials and methods:

Type of study: Descriptive

Period: 2003–2004

Number of cases: 7 (4 women and 3 men) aged 23 to 65

Injury-to-surgery time more than one year

Results:

- We achieved stability of the MCP joint in all cases.

- The metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joint balance was not diminished.

- The grasp force was sustained at over 80% of that of the healthy side.

- Two elderly women were not employed; the other five returned to their previous jobs.

Conclusions: Given the results obtained, we think this is an excellent method for deferred reconstruction of thumb instability and, although it involves considerable technical difficulty, we feel it is an option to bear in mind for this type of injury.


G de Cabo-Tejerina J Valle-Cruz A Francés-Borrego L Lopez-Durán

Introduction and purpose: To assess the validity of determining polymorphonuclear leukocytes in frozen intraoperative samples for diagnosing infections in hip and knee prosthetic revision surgery.

Materials and methods: We reviewed the 146 revisions (83 hips and 63 knees) carried out between 1996 and 2002. We analysed the polymorphonuclear leukocytes per high-magnification field in frozen intraoperative sections (diagnostic test) and periprosthetic tissue culture (gold standard). We evaluated sensitivity (S), specificity (Sp), positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), Youden index, positive likelihood ratio (PLR) and negative likelihood ratio (NLR). We compared the intraoperative results with the analysis of the same samples embedded in paraffin in the knee group.

Results: In the knee group we found S=66.7% (CI 95%); Sp=89.7% (CI 95%); PPV=81% (CI 95%); NPV=81.4% (CI 95%); Youden index=0.56; PLR=6,5 (CI 95%); and NLR=0.4 (CI 95%). In the analysis of the same samples in paraffin (postoperative) we found S=91% (CI 95%); Sp=87% (CI 95%); PPV=81% (CI 95%); NPV=94% (CI 95%); PLR=7 (CI 95%); NLR=8.7 (CI 95%) (significant differences between the two analyses with p< 0.05). In the hip group we found S=50%; Sp=100% (CI 95%); PPV=100%% (CI 95%); NPV=94.9% (CI 95%); Youden index=0.5; and NLR=0.5 (CI 95%).

Conclusions: The analysis of the validity of the test showed that the presence of polymorphonuclear leukocytes is related to infection, but negative results of the test do not rule out infection. It is a quick, low-cost test that we recommend for inclusion in the diagnostic protocol for hip revision surgery.


S Martínez X Pelfort M Tey JC Monllau

Introduction and purpose: Fractures of the tibial plateau account for 1% of the total. Among them, 55–70% involve the lateral plateau with differences in separation and subsidence. Minimally invasive osteosynthesis under arthroscopic control increases the indications in these cases. Our purpose is to assess the long-term clinical and radiological outcomes.

Materials and methods: We carried out a retrospective analysis of the medium-term results of closed fractures of the tibial plateau treated with arthroscopic reduction and percutaneous fixation with cannulated screws. A series of 32 patients with displaced fractures of the tibial plateau underwent surgery between 1993 and 2004. We used the AO classification. We analysed the clinical, functional and radiological results.

Results: The mean follow-up was 6 years. We treated 12 type 41B1, 7 type 41B21, 5 type 41B22, 7 type 41B31 and 1 type 41B12. All the fractures were consolidated and 79.1% had anatomical reduction. External meniscal injuries that could be sutured were present In 11 cases (34.3%). Joint balance was complete in 24 knees. According to the Lysholm scale 23 had an excellent outcome and 9 good. One case presented infection of the surgical wound, which was resolved by surgical debridement and antibiotic therapy.

Conclusions: The results suggest that this is a good method for treating selected fractures of the tibial plateau.


E Melendo P Hinarejos F Montserrat L Puig M Marín E Cáceres

Introduction: Defects in rotational alignment of the femoral component in total knee replacements (TKR) may cause poor alignment of the extensor apparatus. There are numerous references concerning the correct alignment of the femoral component of a prosthesis: transepicondylar axis, anteroposterior axis, and posterior condylar axis.

Materials and methods: Computer-assisted measurement of the relative differences between the transepicondylar axis, anteroposterior axis and posterior condylar axis in 38 TKR patients, excluding those with varus or valgus deformity greater than 15 degrees.

Results: The difference between the anteroposterior axis and the transepicondylar axis was 3.13 degrees of external rotation in the former.

Between the posterior condylar axis and the transepicondylar axis it was 1.18 degrees of internal rotation in the former.

Between the anteroposterior axis and the posterior condylar axis it was 5.51 degrees of external rotation of the former.

Conclusions: Probably the transepicondylar axis is the best landmark to enable reproducing the biomechanics of the knee in a patient bearing a prosthesis, although it is often difficult to reproduce it precisely. Several studies have noted errors among observers that are too great to make us feel certain that we are doing the best thing.

Although it is accepted that the perpendicular to the anteroposterior axis is reliable and corresponds to 4° of external rotation in relation to the posterior condylar axis, we have observed significant differences from one patient to another.

It would seem preferable to use a combination of the different axes, which we can do with a surgical browser.


M. Hernandez G. Rivkin ED Leibner M. Shiloach O. Elishoov M. Liebergall

Introduction Musculoskeletal injuries, especially fractures, cause reduced limb mobilization. The diminished limb activity promotes muscular atrophy, leading to a slower return to function. Attempts to prevent this atrophy using electrical stimulation have been described after knee reconstruction.

The Myospare percutaneous electrical stimulator has been developed to prevent immobilization related atrophy. We undertook this pilot study to assess feasibility, safety, and efficacy of applying electrical stimulation under a cast after ankle fractures.

Patients and Methods Between May and December 2004, patients who sustained closed ankle fractures requiring surgery, were recruited to participate in this study. 24 patients took part in the study, sixteen male and eight female. Age range was 18 to 62 years (average 40). All patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation using standard AO technique. A short walking cast was applied after surgery. Patients were randomized into a treatment and a control group. The experimental device was applied in the treatment group for 6 weeks. Patients were examined at 2, 6 and 12 weeks.

Evaluation included measurement of calf and ankle circumference, dorsiflexion and plantiflexion, and calculation of the ratio between the injured and uninjured side. At each visit pain intensity was assessed using a visual analog score, and patients filled out a function assessment questionnaire. Analysis was performed using chi square, t-test and repeated measures analysis.

Results All patients tolerated the stimulator well. No adverse effects were encountered. There is a trend toward improvement in calf diameter, dorsiflexion and plantarflexion. However, with the small number of patients in this study, no significant difference was apparent. Functional recovery and VAS scores were borderline higher in the treatment group at 12 weeks (p=0.043 and p=.049) when compared to baseline.

Discussion The use of the Myospare device under a cast in patients after surgical fixation of ankle fractures has been demonstrated as feasible and safe. In this pilot study a trend toward enhanced recovery was apparent in the treatment group.


U. Givon N. Dreiengel A. Schindler A. Blankstein A. Ganel

Objective: To assess the efficacy of split Tibialis Posterior tendon transfers for the treatment of spastic equino-varus feet.

Materials and Methods: Fourteen patients with 14 spastic equino-varus feet underwent split Tibialis Posterior tendon transfers. The spasticity was due to cerebral palsy, ataxia telangiectasia and traumatic brain injury. All the patients had Ashworth 1–3 spasticity, and the forefoot was correctible in equinus. Evaluation of the results was by grading of the shape of the feet, ambulation, pain and brace tolerance.

Results: One patient was lost to follow-up after an excellent primary result. Twelve patients had good or excellent results, and one patient had a fair result due to partial recurrence of the deformity. No complications were encountered.

Conclusions: Split Tibialis Posterior tendon transfer is a safe and efficacious procedure for the treatment of spastic equino-varus feet. Good alignment of the treated feet allows comfortable brace and shoe wear. Patient selection is important in order to avoid over-correction or recurrence of the deformity.


K. Romas R. Stalnikowicz M. Brezis L. Kandel

Introduction: Ankle and midfoot injuries are one of the most common orthopaedic complaints, both in the general medicine and the orthopedic practice. The percentage of fractures among these is small, however many of them will undergo an x-ray. Ottawa ankle rules are clinical guidelines developed for the use of radiography in these cases. This aim of this prospective study was to examine these rules’ implementation in the Israeli emergency medicine department and our ability both to predict a fracture and to reduce the amount of unnecessary x-rays.

Materials and Methods: Ninty-two consecutive patients with ankle injuries attending our emergency medicine department were divided in two groups. Study group included 32 patients who arrived during the morning shift and were examined by an internal medicine specialist according to the Ottawa ankle rules. Patients discharged without an x-ray were followed in the clinic or by telephone communication. Control group included 60 patients who were examined during the evening and night shifts by orthopedic residents unaware of the study.

The mean age in the study group was 24 years and in the control group – 26 years. There was good acceptance of the study in patients of the study group. Only 2 of them insisted on the xrays and were excluded from the study. Rest 30 patients were followed as described.

Results: Nine patients (30%) in the study group underwent an x-ray as opposed to 55 patients (92%) in the control group (p< 0.001). There was one fracture diagnosed in each group. In the study group, no fractures were found later in patients discharged without an x-ray. The mean time spent in the emergency department was 58 minutes in the study group and 98 minutes in the control group (p< 0.002).

Discussion: The Ottawa ankle rules were developed as a simple “yes/no” decision tool as to whether to x-ray the ankle. In our emergency department, these rules were proved both accurate and safe. They can be effectively used by professionals not trained in trauma. It can save radiation and patient waiting time without jeopardizing the treatment.


N. Simanovsky E. Leibner N. Hiller N. Simanovsky

Introduction: Pediatric ankle trauma is common, and mostly a self limiting condition, with most children recovering within a few days to one week. However, some children seem to be affected more than others and to recover more slowly, despite normal radiographs. We set out to determine the occurrence of radiographically occult fractures, using high-resolution ultrasound.

Material and Methods: Twenty consecutive, skeletally immature patients, aged from 5 to 13 years with acute ankle injury, and normal radiographs were referred for high resolution ultrasound during the first week after the injury. A follow-up radiograph, obtained 2–3 weeks after the injury, was assessed for periosteal reaction / callus formation.

Results: In 13 patients there was no ultrasonographic evidence of fracture, nor was a periosteal reaction / callus formation. Six patients had ultrasonographic evidence of small fractures of the lateral malleolus, and periosteal reaction / callus formation on the follow-up film. In one patient a subcortical compression was evident on ultrasound. In this patient, although no periosteal reaction was observed on the follow up X-ray, a small fracture line became evident.

Discussion: Small lateral malleolar fractures may be missed on standard ankle radiographs. In patients with a clinical presentation consistent with a fracture, high resolution ultra-sound is a highly sensitive and specific diagnostic tool.


E. Sacagiu N. Loberant J. Stolero A. Gorski G. Volpin

Introduction: Penetrating injuries of the foot are very common. Although apparently straightforward, inappropriate approach and treatment can lead to complications and unsatisfactory results. We present our diagnostic and therapeutic approach using an outcomes approach, clinical results and complication rate.

Patients & Methods: Between 2001 and 2003, 63 patients (57 M and 6 F; mean age- 38, range 8 to 63; follow-up: mean 2.5Y range of follow-up 2–4 years) were treated for penetrating foot injury. Each patient had a routine x-ray and foot sonography. The most common injuries were those that penetrated shoes (45/63 pts) – nails (39/45) and wood pieces (6/45), – or bare feet (18/63 Pts) – nails (10/18), glass (5/18), wood pieces (2/18) and even seashells (1/18). The medical files of all these patients were searched for the relevant parameters.

Results: The presence of a foreign body inside the foot tissues was detected in 58/63 Pts (92%) and they were operated upon by meticulous debridement and removal of FB. In the remaining 5 Pts we could not trace any FB and they were treated initially by IV antibiotics. In these 53 Pts (91%) penetrating foreign bodies were detected by sonography, most of them on arrival. Only 5% of the cases could be diagnosed initially by x-ray. The false negative rate of sonography was 19% (11/58 pts). In 6 of these 11 pts, the presence of FB was detected only by a second sonography. In the remaining 5 pts, foreign bodies were not detected even in the second sonography, but found only during surgery. Complete healing was observed in 62/63 (98%) of patients, although 6 /63 (9%) underwent secondary debridement. One patient (diabetic) developed chronic osteomyelitis of the second metatarsal bone and needed repeated surgical interventions.

Conclusions: In order to avoid complications and poor clinical outcome, penetrating injuries of the foot must be approached in an orderly and appropriate manner. The main purpose is to confirm the presence of a foreign body. Plain x-rays and sonography should be used in order to identify or rule out the presence of FB. Sonography is a good diagnostic technique, but it is operator dependent; thus a high index of suspicion must be maintained when the imaging study is negative and there is no clinical improvement despite appropriate systemic and local treatment. In our experience, repeated sonography and sometimes surgical exploration in such circumstances are likely to reveal the presence of a FB. It should be emphasized that injury through a shoe rather than a bare foot may result in local infection secondary to the penetrating object and also complications related to the additional presence of fiber, rubber or leather foreign body. Excellent results are observed following meticulous debride-ment combined with systemic antibiotics.


E. Heller Z. Feldbrin D. Zin A. Lipkin D. Hendel

Proximal Metatarsal osteotomies are used for larger deformities, generally those with an intermetatarsal angle greater than 15°. These osteotomies usually are combined with a Distal Soft Tissue Release, which is necessary to correct metatarsophalangeal (MTP) sub-luxation with a Hallux Valgus Angle greater than 35°. Many types of osteotomies have been described. These include a medial opening wedge, a lateral closing wedge, proximal chevron, and a crescentic. Additional osteotomies include the Scarf, Ludloff, and Mao osteotomies. Presently, the proximal chevon and crescentic osteotomies are widely used.

In our study we used the proximal chevon osteotomy combined with Distal Soft Tissue Release and approximation of the 1st and 2nd metatarsus using a string to further decrease the intermetatarsal angle.

From January 2000 to June 2005 the basal chevon osteotomy was selected in 44 patients (37 female and seven male patients, ages 14 to 80, mean: 54.97 years) total of 49 feet with moderate metatarsus primus varus (IMA 13 to 20 degrees) and hallux valgus deformities (less than 50 degrees). The AOFAS Hallux Metatarsopha-langeal-Interphalangeal Scale and patient satisfaction were monitored prior to surgery, and postoperatively. Changes in the IMA and HV angle were measured in the conventional method and documented. All patients were treated in a Darco Post operative splint.

Results: Multiple complications were encountered. The most common is transfer metatarsalgia. This occurred in 10 patients (20%). Other complications include delayed union (4%), increase in the height of the first metatarsus (10%), floating toe (6%), superficial infection (15%), local parenthesis and early recurrence of deformity in 3%. 38 patients were available for follow-up. The hallux valgus angle improved significantly more than 20 degrees on average postoperatively. The intermeta-tarsal angle also improved significantly (more than 10 degrees on average) postoperatively. The position of the sesamoids was realigned to beneath the first metatarsal head and the metatarsal length remained essentially unchanged. The AOFAS score preoperatively was a mean of 75.64 with respect to pain, deformity, motion, disability, and cosmetic. The AOFAS score postoperatively was a mean of 94.55. The mean improvement was 18.91. About 95.45 percent (42/44) were satisfied and would recommend the surgery to a friend.

Conclusions: The basal chevron osteotomy combined with Distal Soft Tissue Release and realignment using a string is a technically demanding procedure and has multiple potential complications but provdes a reliable method with respect to stability, technical ease and satisfactory surgical outcome for correction of moderate and severe bunion deformity, both as a primary and revision procedure.


Full Access
J. Hakim F. Elkish D. Ghattas E. Calif

Purpose: Nail punctures of the foot initially appear deceptively mild. Most reported series relate to injuries in children mostly complicated by pseudomonas infection. The study aimed at reviewing our experience of managing plantar puncture injuries.

Methods and Patients: The medical charts of 350 patients treated and followed between 1995 and 2000 were reviewed. Data collected included wound classification according to Alson, wound location, management, isolated pathogens, and complications.

Results: 151 patients had superficial wounds (Alson I) treated with oral antibiotics. Of the 199 patients who were admitted (Alson II– IV), 74% were construction workers, average age was 24.5 years, 35% presented within 24 hours after injury, 68% of wounds were located at forefoot (23% and 21% at first and second MTPJs areas respectively), 21% were in midfoot, and 11% in hindfoot. 44% were treated with intravenous antibiotics, 30% had plantar incision and drainage, 14% had plantar and dorsal incision and drainage, and in 12% arthrotomy or bone debridement were also needed. Different pathogens were isolated mainly staphylococcus (36%). Retained foreign bodies were identified in 14 cases. Septic arthritis and osteomyelitis developed in 11% and 4% of cases respectively.

Conclusions: Adult and children puncture injuries seem to behave differently, including risk for complications, and bacteriology. Clinical vigilance and early treatment are crucial. Forefoot injuries occur at the heel-off stage of the stance phase, and the nail is pushed with a high ground reaction force. The injury is therefore deeper, usually involving an MTPJ space and consequently more liable to complications.


A. Rosenstein B. Veazey D. Shephard Ke XU

Total knee replacement has proven to be a very successful procedure. However, problems have been encountered in fitting standard femoral implants to distal femurs using various popular total knee replacement systems.

Authors observed that difficulties matching femoral components with distal femurs most frequently occurred in female patients. In practice, as far as femoral sizing is concerned, women are just treated as small men.

Despite an extensive English literature search, only a limited number of studies addressing the gender differences in distal femurs proportions were identified.

In view of our experiences, we hypothesize that 1) Anterior-posterior (AP) dimensions do not increase in the same proportion to medial-lateral (ML) dimensions in men and women. 2) The AP/ML ratio is different in males and females. 3) Femoral implants AP/ ML ratios are more inline with men ratios then with women

Materials and Methods: In order to test the hypothesis, 50 male and 50 female patients consecutive knee MRI scans of the knee were studied. The patients were referred to UMC MRI Center with a variety of diagnoses. The knees involved with conditions distorting bony anatomy were excluded. The age distribution of the patients ranged from 17 to 77 years for the males and 17 to 85 years for the females.

Evaluation was focused on axial views of the distal femur. A cut with the maximum medial lateral dimensions of a studied femur was selected. The ML measurement was made along the epicondylar axis. The maximum AP dimension was obtained perpendicular to the epicondylar axis on the same cut. The ratios were then obtained. AP data for males and females was plotted against ML data. The data was found to approximate linear relation, permitting linear regression.

Inside AP and ML dimensions of eight popular TKR systems produced by six manufactures were obtained. The AP vs. ML plots were made as well as ratios were calculated for each system. The implants data were compared with male and female data.

A t-test was performed to demonstrate whether the AP/ML ratio was significantly different between males and females. In addition, ordinary least squares analyses were performed to establish whether the AP/ML ratios varied across different AP and ML sizes for both genders.

Conclusions: Our study demonstrated a significant difference in distal femur proportions between males and females. The variation in dimensions did not appear to be well covered by femoral implant sizes from studied seven commonly used TKA systems.

Dimensions propagation of femoral components for TKR fallowed significantly closer to males’ distal femur dimensions variation than to females’.


E. Melamed Z. Keidar D. Militianu R. Bar-Shalom O. Israel C. Zinman

Background: The occurrence of osteomyelitis in diabetic foot often dictates different treatment approach. The diagnosis of osteomyelitis, though, is sometimes difficult. When X rays are not diagnostic or equivocal, a nuclear medicine studies are often performed. In common practice bone scan with Tc99m-MDP combined with In111 labeled leucocytes scintigraphy are used. Although highly sensitive, these procedures may be hampered by coexisting pathological processes such as neuroarthropathy, trauma, or cellulites. In addition, poor resolution of the In111 images, complicates the interpretation weather the observed uptake (e.g. infection) is in the soft tissue or within the bone. Positron emission tomography (PET) using 2-Deoxy-2-[18F]-Fluoro-D-Glucose (FDG) is a useful clinical tool for the assessment of malignancies. FDG, a nonspecific tracer of increased intracellular glucose metabolism, accumulates in sites of infection and inflammation as well. PET is highly sensitive but may lack the ability to define the anatomic location of a focus of increased FDG accumulation. The hybrid PET/CT technology, providing precise registration of metabolic and structural imaging data, obtained in one session on a single device, may improve diagnosis and localization of infection.

Goals: The present study assesses the role of PET/CT imaging using FDG for the diagnosis of diabetic foot osteomyelitis.

Methods: Fourteen diabetic patients (M=10, F=4; age range 29–70 years) with 18 clinically suspected sites of infection underwent PET/CT following the injection of 185–370 MBq FDG for suspected osteomyelitis complicating diabetic foot. PET, CT and hybrid images were independently evaluated for the diagnosis and localization of an infectious process. Additional data provided by PET/CT for localization of infection in the bone or soft tissues was recorded. The final diagnosis was based on histopathological findings and bacteriological assays obtained at surgery or clinical and imaging follow up.

Results: PET detected 14 foci of increased FDG uptake suspected as infection in 10 patients. PET/CT correctly localized 8 foci in 4 patients to bone, indicating osteomyelitis. PET/CT correctly excluded osteomyelitis in 5 foci in 5 patients, with the abnormal FDG uptake limited to infected soft tissues only. One site of mildly increased focal FDG uptake was localized by PET/CT to diabetic osteoarthropathy changes demonstrated on CT. Four patients showed no abnormal increased FDG uptake, and no further evidence for an infectious process in the foot on clinical and imaging follow up.

Conclusion: FDG-PET can be used for diagnosis of diabetes-related infection. The precise anatomic localization of increased FDG uptake provided by PET/CT enables accurate differentiation between osteomyelitis and soft tissue infection.


V. Bilenko A. Bunin D. Atar D. Lebel V. Benkovich

Purpose of the Study: The outcome after revision knee arthroplasty with structural distal femoral allograft augmentation for major bone loss has been rarely reported in the literature. The aim of this study was to assess the outcome for patients managed with such a procedure in our hospital.

Materials and Methods: Since 2001, ten revision knee arthroplasties requiring structural distal femoral allograft for major bone loss were performed in nine patients who underwent surgery at mean age of 68.1±9.8 years and prospectively followed. All patients were operated by the same surgical team. The first assessment was completed for the patients during August 2005 for radiographic and clinical evaluation. The mean follow up time was 22.2±15.1 months.

Results: On radiographic analysis none of the allografts had resorbtion. Implant position

Was preserved in all patients. Two patients had postoperative complications: one had superficial wound infection without need of surgical revision, another patient needed angioplasty because of pseudoaneurisma of popliteal artery and temporary using of knee brace for mild medial instability. Clinical evaluation revealed that mean “Hospital for Special Surgery Score” had improved from 39.8 to 84.1 points and mean range of motions improved from 75.0±42.0 to 103.5±12.5 (p=0.05, paired t-test). Before the surgery all patients used a walker or a crutch, while only one of them used a cane and the remaining patients walked without any support after the operation.

Conclusions: Our preliminary results demonstrate that structural femoral allografts used in revision knee replacement improve clinical and functional outcomes. Further follow-up is planned.


G. Volpin R. Shachar H. Shtarker A. Gorski A. Kaushanski M. Daniel

Introduction: The optimal treatment of osteoarthritis of the medial compartment of the knee joint is still controversial. Optional procedures include arthroscopic knee debriedement, high tibial osteotomy, and total knee arthroplasty. In the last decade the use of unicompart-mental knee arthroplasty (UKA) for localized knee arthritis has become more and more common. This study reviews our experience with unicondylar meniscal bearing knee arthroplasty in patients with localized osteoarthritis of the medial compartment of the knee joint.

Material & Methods: Between 2001–2004, 26 Pts. (17F, 9M; 52–74 year old, mean 63Y) underwent surgery using the Medial Oxford Unicompartmental Knee. Four of them had since been operated on their other knee, usually 1–2 years after the first UKA. The mean age at surgery was 63 years (52–74). There were 17 women and 9 males. All patients had a stable knee and their preoperative ROM was between −10 degrees to full extension and between 100 to 120 degrees of flexion. Patients were followed for 1.5 – 4 years (mean 2.5Y), and evaluated by the Knee Society Score and radiographs.

Results: 24/26 (92%) patients, including the four patients who had staged bilateral procedures of both knees, had satisfactory results, of them 16/26 (61%) had excellent results and 8/26 (31%) had good results. They were almost free of pain, and most of them had marked improvement in knee function. Similar results were observed in each of both knees of the patients who had staged bilateral unicondylar knee arthroplasty. The remaining 2 patients (8%) had fair results. A second look arthroscopy of these patients revealed a progressive development of degenerative changes of the lateral compartment in one patient, and development of degenerative changes of the patella and patellar groove in the second patient.

Conclusions: Based on this study it seems that unicondylar knee arthroplasty is a favourable procedure in patients with localised arthritis of the medial compartment. This procedure allows replacement of only the affected joint compartment with less bone loss, and therefore enables preservation of healthy tissue and bone. Recovery following surgery is fast, rehabilitation is quick and ambulation is early. The ideal patient for UKA is a relatively young patient with localized degenerative changes, who has a stable knee, a flexion contracture less than 15 degrees and a mechanical axis of less than 10 degrees from neutral for a varus knee, or less than 5 degrees for a valgus knee.


G. Morag S. Hanna AE Gross D. Backstein

Introduction: Distal femoral varus osteotomy (DFVO) has been advocated as the treatment of choice for lateral compartment osteoarthritis associated with a valgus knee in the young population in order to delay the need for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term results of DFVO for the valgus osteoarthritic knee.

Methods: A retrospective analysis was performed on 38consecutive patients (40 knees) who underwent a DFVO between 1984 and 2001. Two patients (2 knees) were lost to follow-up. Mean follow up was 123 months (range 39 to 245 months). Peri-operative documentation was evaluated for etiology, pre-operative functional and subjective impairment, intra-operative technical difficulties or complications, early and late post-operative complications and post-operative functional and subjective outcomes.

Results: At the time of the most recent follow-up, 24 knees had good or excellent result, 3 knees had a fair result and 3 had poor results. The remaining 8 knees were converted to a total knee arthroplasty. The mean Knee Society objective score improved from 18 (range, 0–74) to 87.2 (range, 50–100) and the mean Knee Society function score improved from 54 (range, 0–100) to 85.6 (range, 40–100). The ten-year survival rate of DFVO was 82% (95% confidence interval, 75%–89%) and the fifteen-year survival rate was 45% (95% confidence interval, 33%–57%).

Discussion: With proper patient selection, DFVO is a reliable procedure for the treatment of the valgus osteoarthritic knee. This procedure delays the need for further surgical procedures, such as TKA, with good results.


T. Pritch A. Haim N. Snir S. Dekel

Medial transfer of the tibial Tuberosity remains the treatment of choice for skeletally mature patients with patellar malalignment (recurrent dislocation, subluxation with or without patellar tilt). As many patients with patellar malalignment have patellar articular cartilage lesion or patella alta, anteriorisation and distalisation of the tibial tuberosity is advised.

Material and Methods: Tibial tuberosity transfer was performed in our center on 80 knees in 66 patients (40 females, 26 males) during the past 13 years (mean age 23 range 15 – 52). One surgeon supervised all the operations. The average follows-up was 6.2 years (one to thirteen years). All patients were examined clinically for the purpose of this study. The Lisholm and Karlsson scoring system were used to evaluate the results. Radiographs of both knees were also taken. Fifteen knees had no dislocation of the patella prior to the operation, seventeen knees had 1 to 10 eleven knees had 10 to 50, ten knees 50 to 100, and twenty-seven knees had more than hundred dislocations of the patella prior to surgery. Ten of these knees had daily dislocations of the patella.

All operations were done either by selective epidural anesthesia (only sensory and not motor) or general anesthesia without muscle relaxant using quadriceps muscle stimulation. The mean tibial tuberosity medialisation, anteriorisation and distalisation was 1.4 cm (0–2.5 cm) 0.4cm (0–1.1cm) and 0.87cm (0–1.2cm) respectively.

Results: When interviewed by an independent examiner 87% of the patients reported improvement and only 4.3% (3 patients) reported worsening of their condition after the operation.

84% of the patients stated they would have the operation again. All patients had full active range of motion on both knees without extension lag.

At the final evaluation visit the Lisholm and Karlsson scores were good and excellent in 72% and 72.5%, 18.8% and 23.5% had fair results and only 8.7% and 4.4% had poor results respectively. The poor results correlated well with the degree of the patella cartilage damage found during surgery, poor selection of patients and extreme ligamentous laxity. There were two complications: one non-union of the tibial tuberosity treated successfully with bone grafting and one non displaced fracture bellow the osteotomy, treated conservatively. Both had excellent results.

Conclusion: We conclude that distal patella re-alignment done by tibial tuberosity transfer is a reliable technique for the treatment of patello femoral pain secondary to mal-alignment.


N. Attias

Purpose: To assess the treatment results of long segmental bone defects using cylindrical titanium mesh cages.

Methods: A case series of six patients who sustained open Gustilo Anderson Type IIIB Tibia, Femur, and Humerus fractures, associated with extensive segmental bone and soft tissue loss. The patients were initially treated with serial wound irrigations, debridements, and external fixation. After the soft tissue envelope was successfully reconstructed by the Plastic Surgery Service, the large segmental bone defects were reconstructed with cylindrical titanium mesh cages packed with a composite of cancellous allograft and demineralized bone matrix putty, and stabilized with statically locked intra-medullary nails, or plates.

Results: The mean segmental bone loss was 9.2 cm (range: 7–13), and all patients had a minimum of one year follow-up. At one year post reconstruction, radiographs demonstrated stable, well aligned, and healed constructs, and computed tomography images confirmed the presence of bony in-growth through out the cages. All patients were able to full weight-bear ambulate, and all achieved good range of motion of the affected extremity, except for two patient that suffered drop foot, as a result of the index injury.

Conclusion: This technique appears to be a reasonable alternative in the treatment of large segmental bone defects of the Tibia.


A. Kaushanski G. Volpin L. Lichtenstein B. Grimberg J. Chezar H. Shtarker

Introduction: Meniscal tears are common in young athletes, usually result from a twisting injury during sport and may occur in the anterior or posterior horns. Injured menisci may be treated arthroscopically by excision of the torn fragments. However, in patients with peripheral meniscal detachment, located at the “vascular zone”, operative repair is feasible and usually successful. Meniscal repair may be done by open direct suture of peripheral tears or by arthroscopic techniques as “Outside-In”, “Inside-Out” or “All-Inside”. We present our experience with arthroscopic suture of completely detached menisci.

Patients & Methods: This study consisted of 33 male patients (14-48Y; mean 25Y; Follow-up: 2-6Y; mean 3.5Y). Inside-Out technique was used in 31 patients and Outside-In technique in two patients. 16/33 patients had detachment of the peripheral half of the meniscus (14-medial; 2-lateral); 13/33 patients had peripheral detachment of almost two thirds of meniscus (10-medial; 3-lateral) and 4/33 patients had detachment of one third of the meniscus (3-lateral; 1-medial injuries; all combined with fractures of the tibial plateau). 15 patients with medial meniscus detachment had complete (5 Pts) or partial (10 Pts) tear of ACL. Two other patients with medial meniscus detachment had associated small radial tears of the affected meniscus. Two of the patients with complete ACL tear had later been operated upon for reconstruction of ACL. Results were assessed by the Knee Society Knee score and by Lysholm Scoring Scale.

Results: 25/33 patients (76%) had good and excellent results. Four of them developed re-tear and detachment of medial meniscus during other later additional sport injuries, usually between 1–2 years following initial treatment. Four other patients had a “second” arthroscopic look 1–2 years later following another sport twisting injury and in all of them a stable peripheral attachment of the sutured menisci was observed. Results were better in patients who had ACL reconstruction a few months following meniscal repair. 5 patients had fair results (15%) and 3 patients had poor results (9%).

Conclusions: Based on this study it is suggested that meniscal suturing for peripheral tears is a satisfactory procedure. Meniscal tears suitable for repairs are those within the vascular zones (the outer third of the menis-cus), unstable on probing, are longer than 7mm and without major surgical damaging. Tears of posterior segments are the most difficult to suture and often require open arthrotomy. ACL reconstruction combined with meniscal repair appears to increase the healing rate of the meniscus. There are also adjuvant techniques for meniscal repair such as: fibrin clot or laser (both are weaker than suture alone) and adhesives. However, there is still not enough data.


R. Karpf M. Topaz R. Sevi

Our experience using a skin stretching device applying KW and rib retractors for the approximation of extensive skin loss in the treatment of complex injuries involving massive loss of soft tissue is presented. Major soft tissue injury inflicted by the detonation of explosives in close proximity requires a unique approach for the closing of massive gaping wounds. This method has been applied in multiple situations at our medical center since 1995.

The technique involved insertion of the KW into the deep dermal layer along the longitudinal edges on both sides of the wound, and the application of rib retractors to approximate the skin edges. Lately we have been combining this method with vacuum-assisted skin closure (VAC).

This method enabled closure of massive soft tissue losses of limbs, trunks, and abdominal wall. Approximation of wound edges necessitated in some cases minor skin grafting of the residual gap. Application of the VAC system reduced edema, infection rate and skin necrosis, and also enabled early skin grafting. We will describe the novel use of VAC in extensive soft tissue trauma.

The KW stretching device is inexpensive and is readily available in any OR setup. It enables setting of a vector traction on wound edges in a more homogenous manner. The VAC system may be combined for optimizing treatment.


S. Karkabi

Purpose: To evaluate and compare the effect of arthroscopic depridement and lavage versus arthroscopic lavage only as a treatment in osteoarthritis of the knee.

Type of Study: A prospective study.

Material and Methods: 500 patients ( mean age 58 years ) were available for 6 years follow-up after arthroscopy of the knee as a treatment of osteoarthritis refractory to conservative treatment. 250 patients were treated with debridement and lavage and 250 patients were treated with lavage only.

Osteoarthritis of the knee is a common cause of knee pain. The pain from osteoarthritis is due to synovitis, capsular and ligamentous inflammation, and subchondral bone pain because cartilage has no nerves.

Degenerative arthritis is usually the end result of mechanical stress inflicted on the articular cartilage, either through a suddenly applied single load or through the cumulative effect of multiple or repetitive loads leads to breakdown of the articular cartilage.

The treatment of knee pain due to osteoarthritis of the knee includes conservative treatment such as rest, weight loss, physical therapy, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, Cox-II inhibitors, nutritional supplements, steroid injections, Viscosupplementation, and surgical treatment such as arthroscopy, osteotomy or arthroplasty. With failure of conservative treatment, arthroscopic debridement and lavage is the treatment of choice for such patients.

Results: Arthroscopic debridement and lavage performed in earlier stages of osteoarthritis of the knee resulted in significant reduction of pain for long period of time. In advanced stages of osteoarthritis, patients experienced less pain relief for shorter period of time. Debridement and lavage was superior to lavage only at 6 years in reduction of pain.

In my group 93.8% (91.2% of the lavage group and 96.4% of the debridement group) were satisfied at 6 months and felt better than before their surgery, at 3 years 45.6% (35.6% of the lavage group and 55.6% of the debridement group) felt better, and at 6 years 30.2% (22.8% of the lavage group and 37.6% of the debridement group) felt better after the arthroscopic procedure.

Conclusions: Arthroscopic debridement and lavage of painful osteoarthritic knees has a better outcome than lavage only for the same treatment, however patients must be made aware that the procedure is not curative and that it is quite possible that they will need further surgery in the future. Arthroscopic surgery (debridement and lavage or even lavage only) is reasonably successful temporizing and palliative procedure. However, the patient must be informed about the prospects of success, the benefits, the alternative and the risks of that procedure.


S. Hofmann

Minimal Invasive Surgery (MIS) in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) has gained much attention in the scientific community and the public in the last few years. There still exists confusion in the related terminology and different surgical techniques are recommended. Cost effectiveness and risk/benefit analysis are not available at the moment. There still remains controversy whether these new techniques represent only a modern trend or the future of TKA.

MIS Unicondylar replacement has shown significant faster rehabilitation but the same reproducible radiographic and clinical results compared with the conventional open technique. In Oct 2003 we have started using MIS TKA in our hospital. After a significant learning curve the decision was made to do only MIS TKA from Nov. 2004 up to now. More than 300 cases were performed. Only few definite data are available at this stage. In 20% of the patients we performed the so called quad sparing (QS) technique. This offers a less invasive but very demanding and time consuming approach, where most of the surgery has to be performed from the side using complete new side cutting instruments. In the majority of our patients (80%) we performed a modified mini midvastus (MMI) approach, using standard 4 in 1 front cutting instruments. Electromagnetic navigation (EM) might be a helpful tool for MIS surgery in TKA. We have limited experience with this new EM navigation system in combination with the new MIS TKA surgical techniques.

In a pilot study with two groups of patients the direct comparison between QS and MMI was evaluated. Clinical evaluation was performed by two scores (KSS and WOMAC) and five additional functional tests including straight leg raising, active motion, raising a chair, stair climbing and functional gait analysis. Testing was performed pre-op and at 1, 6 and 12 weeks post-op. Patients and investigators were blinded to the surgical technique (either QS or MMI).

The average OR time was 92 min (70 to 130) for MMI and 110 (85 to 165) for QS respectively. There were no complications in the MMI and 1 (wound healing) in the QS group. There were no differences in the different scores and in the functional tests between the groups at any time.

There is still controversy in the benefit-risk analysis for the different minimal invasive techniques. In our hospital the MIS future for TKA has already started. Patients’ satisfaction and significant earlier rehabilitation are the key advantages of these new surgical techniques. The much easier MMI technique is now the standard. Only in selected cases the more demanding QS technique is performed. According to the learning curve these new MIS techniques are for specialized surgeons only and require additional training programmes. Despite these facts, we do believe that MIS is the future of TKA surgery.


I. Ilsar Y. Weil R. Mosheiff L. Joskowicz A. Peyser M. Liebergall

Introduction: To enable navigated-assisted orthopedic surgery, a reference frame must be rigidly fixed to a stable bony structure. This may create technical obstacles and wound complications. Instead, we propose to attach the reference frame to the fracture table.

Methods: The study population consisted of 10 patients who underwent fixation of subcapital femoral neck fracture with three cannulated screws, using fluoroscopy-based navigation. Step 1 – the patient was positioned on a fracture table and the reference frame was attached to the iliac crest. Three guide wires were inserted under fluoroscopy-based navigation. 2 – New fluoroscopic images were acquired. 3 – Navigated drill guide placed over each guide wire to record final navigated drill guide position – these images include actual guide wire positions and the trajectories of the navigated drill guide. Navigation accuracy was validated, measuring translational and angular deviations of the virtual trajectory from the implant on the same fluoroscopic image in anteroposterior and lateral views. 4 – The reference frame was removed from the iliac crest and attached to the fracture table. Step 3 was then repeated.

Results: The translational deviation of the virtual trajectory from the inserted guide wire when the reference frame was attached to the iliac crest was not statistically significant from the deviation when it was attached to the fracture table. Angular differences were also not statistically significant.

Conclusions: In our experience, attaching the reference frame to the fracture table instead of to the iliac crest allows for similar accuracy of the navigation process with the possible benefit of reducing patient morbidity.


Y. Weil M. Liebergall A. Khoury R. Mosheiff D. Segal

Introduction: Non union of the humerus in the ostoeportic bone is a great challenge for the orthopedic surgeon. The non weight bearing nature of this bone together with extreme osteoporosis seen in the elderly had rendered a high degree of failure in different modes of internal fixation of established humeral non union. Tantalum is a trabecullar metal with biomechanical properties similar to bone with a high modulus of elasticity and low rigidity. It is proved both in vitro and in vivo to induce excellent bone and vascular in growth and have been used successfully treating other application in orthopedics. We have introduced the tantalum rod for the treatment of humeral non union in the elderly.

Patients and Methods: Six patients with humeral non-union were selected for tantalum rod implantations. All were above 60 years old. All patients had established non and 4 had failures after previous osteosynthesis. The surgical technique was exploration of the fracture site via a posterior or an anterolateral approach, debridement of the fracture site and intramedullary insertion of a 100 mm x 10 mm tantalum rod. No bone grafting was used. Ancillary fixation included a 4.5 broad DCP plate with screws drilled into both bone and rod or screws alone drilled into the bone and tantalum construct. Follow up period was up to one year.

Results: All fractures united clinically and radiographicaly up to 3 months. All patients achieved satisfactory shoulder and elbow range of motion and regained functional activity. No infection or foreign body reaction was noted.

Conclusion: Intramedullary tantalum rodding is a viable treatment option for the cases in both primary and secondary non union of the humeral shaft in osteoporotic bone.


D. Lebel Y. Gortzak E. Rath D. Atar A. Korngreen

Background: Displaced proximal humeral fractures (PHF) remain a challenge to the orthopedic surgeon. Conservative treatment yield poor results in the majority of these fractures. Surgical treatment, although preferable, lacks the proper exposure and fixation technique.

The locking compression plate (LCP), which is inserted in a minimal invasive technique, utilizing an anterolateral approach to the proximal humerus, allows adequate reduction and fixation, while minimizing the risk for complications derived from extensive exposure and poor fixation.

Methods: All patients admitted to our department with a complicated PHF between Jan 2004 and May 2005 were included. After obtaining informed consent, open reduction and internal fixation was performed through an anterolateral minimal invasive approach. After exposure and reduction with or without acromioplasty and rotator cuff repair, the fracture was fixated with a LCP 3.5mm. Patients were encouraged to perform pendular movements on the first post-operative day.

The patients were followed closely beginning 2 weeks post-operatively and afterwards on a bi-monthly basis. Immediate complications, radiographic and functional outcome were noted.

Results: 22 patients have been treated according to the treatment protocol during the study period. Minimal follow up of three months is available. A single complication was noted (deep wound infection which necessitated hardware removal). No nerve injury or hardware failures were noted.

Functional outcome was good, patients regained 120°±25 of flexion, 112°±27 of abduction and 17°±8 of external rotation.

Conclusions: The anterolateral approach to the shoulder and fixation with a LCP plate is a safe technique in our hospital. Rigid stabilization allows for early shoulder activation which results in a good range of motion and functional outcome on short-term follow up. Further study and long-term follow up are needed to validate this technique in treating complex proximal humerus fractures.


J. Saveski

Pelvicring disruption (PRD) requires considerable forces and usually occurs in polytraumatized patients(pt).

The purpose of this study is to analyze radiologic results and functional outcome of PRD in polytraumatized pt.

Material and Methods: Of 226 pt with PRD, 78% (176) were polytraumatized, and they are the subject of this study. Mean age was 38.8 years (11.4–85.8). There were 102 men and 74 women. The cause of injury in 69% was traffic accident; fall from a great height in 16.4%; accident at work in 8.6% and miscellaneous in 6%. The incidence of involvement of other systems was: musculosceletal-78%; respiratory-58%; CNS-51%, intestinal-32%, urinary-14%; cardiovascular-8%. The average ISS was 34; 56 pt (32%) were haemodynamically unstable. According to M. Tile’s classification, 101 were found type B (B1-48; B2-30; B3-23) and 75 type C (C1-49; C2-18; C3-8). Perioperative mortality was 6% in B-type and 15% in C-type fractures.

Immediate resuscitation started at admission and was followed by staged treatment. Life-saving surgery and provisional stabilization of pelvis were performed as a top priority (first stage). Management of associated lesions (second priority) was the next stage. The last stage was open reduction and internal fixation of PRD in 102 pt, external fixation in 46 pt and combined fixation in 28 pt.

Results: X-ray follow-up results were excellent in 66%, good in 16%, fair in 10% and poor in 8%.

The best X-rays results were in type B1-94%; B2/B3-76% and C-63%.

Functional results were excellent in 48%, good in 32%, fair in 12% and poor in 8%. The best functional results were in type B2/B3 -90%; B1-73% and C-70%.

Conclusion:

Determination of priorities of surgery is essential in the management in polytraumatized patients with PRD especially in the early period.

Reconstruction of PRD requires a staged approach.

These findings are not only related to the stability and symmetry of pelvic ring, but also depend on the severity of soft tissue injury around the pelvis.


G. Volpin G. Kirshner V. Kamiloki V. Slobodan J. Saveski

Introduction: Fractures of the scapula are rare injuries. When they do occur, they are usually caused by high-energy trauma and some of the patients may have significant associated injuries. Most fractures are minimally displaced and amenable to nonsurgical treatment. Open reduction and internal fixation of intra-articular fractures are considered if there is a glenohumeral sub-luxation secondary to fracture or if there is an intra-articular displacement greater than 5 mm.

Patients and Methods: This study consisted of 33 Pts from Israel and Macedonia (28 M, 5F, 18–74 year old, mean 43.5Y) followed for 2–5 years (mean 3.5Y). Fractures were classified according to Idelberg following analysis of plain radiographs and computerized radiographs. 26 patients had undisplaced or minimally displaced fractures of the glenoid and were treated conservatively by collar and cuff for three weeks, then followed by physiotherapy. The remaining seven patients had comminuted fractures with marked displacement of the glenoid and some degree of shoulder subluxation and were treated surgically. Six patients were treated by open reduction and osteosynthesis by rigid plates (3) or by screws alone (3). The 7th patient who was treated surgically, a 73-year-old female, had a displaced fracture of the glenoid associated with comminuted fracture of the proximal humerus. She was treated by internal fixation of the fractured glenoid by 2 screws, followed by hemi-arthroplasty of the shoulder. All patients were evaluated by the Constant’s Shoulder Score and by radiographs.

Results: Overall results were excellent and good in 27/33 Pts (82%). They were almost free of pain and most of them had almost complete ROM of the affected shoulder. In the group of the patients treated conservatively for undisplaced or minimal displaced fractures of the glenoid 22/26 (85%) had satisfactory results. Five of the patients treated surgically (71%) had excellent and good results, with some better results in less comminuted fractures. The remaining 2/7 Pts treated surgically had fair results. One of them had a comminuted fracture of the glenoid and the other patient had an associated compound fracture of the proximal humerus and a shoulder hemiarthroplasty.

Conclusions: Based on this study it seems that most fractures of the glenoid – undisplaced or minimally displaced – can be treated conservatively. However, for patients with displaced glenoid fractures, best results can be obtained with open reduction and internal fixation by screws or by plates. This should be followed by intensive physiotherapy.


K. Atesok A. Kallur E. Peleg Y. Weil M. Liebergall R. Mosheiff

Background: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the applicability and advantages of the intraoperative use of a mobile isocentric C-arm with 3-dimensional imaging (SIREMOBIL ISO-C-3D) in trauma surgery.

Patients & Methods: Between November, 2004 and September, 2005, the ISO-C-3D was used at our institution for intraoperative CT-quality visualization of 33 trauma cases with the fractures of calcaneus (13), tibial plateau (7), tibial plafond (6), acetabulum (4), distal radius (2) and talus (1). The mean patient age was 42 and male to female ratio 25 to 8. In 30 cases ISO-C-3D was used during the surgery after the reduction and fixation of the fracture to assess the accuracy of reduction and implant position prior to wound closure and in 3 cases the device was used before starting the operation to obtain real-time CT images which were transferred to a navigation system to perform computer navigated procedures.

Results: This novel technique was highly beneficial from 4 aspects; intraoperative diagnosis, proper reduction, correct implant placement and feasibility in combining the CT images to computer navigation. In 40% of the cases (13/33) who had no regular CT scan before the surgery, intraoperative three dimensional imaging with ISO-C-3D has been a superior modality in diagnosis. In one case the reduction and implant position was corrected during the surgery after the ISO-C-3D scan. In all the procedures with ISO-C-3D navigation, satisfactory reconstruction of the articular surfaces with precise fixation was achieved.

Conclusion: Intraoperative 3-dimensional visualization with ISO-C-3D provides useful information in trauma surgery which enables the surgeon to re-evaluate the injury diagnostically and to judge the reduction and implant position before wound closure. Combining the ISO-C-3D images with computer navigation makes the reduction and implant placement highly accurate.


D. Dabby N. Blumberg N. Shasha I. Jakim A. Menachem

In the last years there has been a new enthusiasm for the use of resurfacing THA. With the experience gained we have learned that there are some absolute and relative contraindications (i.e. inflammatory arthritis, AVN, poor bone stock, sever distortion of thehip anatomy, varus neck, small head). In order to over come those contraindications and in the light of the fact that reliable long-term effectiveness of hip replacement in young active patients remains problematic we have started to use metaphyseal prosthesis. The metaphyseal implant minimizes bone resection, violets less the native bone of the proximal femur, has favorable remodeling characteristics and facilitate revision once needed. Due to its small size and the varus orientation limited or minimal approach is easy and safe.

Material and methods: The Mayo Conservative hip was used in 65 patients during the years 2000–2005. 3 patients were lost to follow-up and were not included. Avrage age was average 44.6. The basic etiology was osteoarthritis (38), AVN (12), RA (4), DDH (4), distorted proximal femur (2) and revision after failed resurfacing THA (2). Follow-up was 6–58 months (average 45.2). XR were taken each time and clinical examination was done, gait pattern was noted as well as ROM and muscle strength Patient satisfaction was noted based on their function ability, using of waking aids and the amount of pain.

Results: We had 2 cases of intraoperative proximal femur crack that were treated with tension wire; no other intraoperative complication was noted. None of the patients developed infection and no one had dislocation. Pain was reduced from sever in all patients to mild or none in 90% (56/62), moderate in 8% (5/62) and sever in one patient (2%). Pre operative ROM was reduced and painful. Painless, near normal ROM was achieved in all patients and only 5 needed walking stick (all of them between 6–12 month post operative). Follow-up XR showed no sign of bone subsidence or loosening

Conclusions: Metaphyseal prosthesis can be a good alternative to resurfacing arthroplasty. Our experience show that the procedure is safe and medium term results are good to excellent.


R. Debi Y. Bar-Ziv S. Efrati N. Cohen R. Kardosh N. Halperin D. Segal

Introduction: Total hip arthroplasty preformed with the use of minimal incision surgery has received tremendous attention recently. Various surgical approaches have been introduced to minimize surgical trauma to the soft tissues. The mini invasive Modified Watson-Jones approach have been selected to decrease the perioperative complications associated with other mini invasive approaches that has been described.

The anterolateral mini incision is a new innovative approach using the intramuscular plan between the gluteus medius and the tensor fascia lata. This intermuscular interval through a small incision provides good exposure and preserves muscle integrity. Moreover, preserving the muscle integrity provides a very stable joint after implantation such that no restrictions is giving to the patient during the rehabilitation period.

Materials and Methods: Between July 2004 to September 2005, we used this approach on 60 sequential patients. Fifty patients were enrolled in this prospective study. Patients were evaluated preoperatively, immediately postoperatively, and at 3-month and 6 month follow-up according to operating time, intraoperative blood loss, subcutaneous drains blood loss, post op pain control drugs requirements, short form 36 patient questionnaire (SF-36) scores and the Harris Hip Score (HHS). 4 patients had previous THA on the contralteral side.

Results: The average operation time was 137min (range 90–200min), there were no dislocations, the mean post operation blood transfusion requirements was 1.64, the mean subcutaneous drains blood loss was 241.9ml (range 20–620ml), there was significant improvement in function, pain, SF-36 and Harris Hip Score (HHS) at the 3-month and 6-month follow-up examination. The average length of the incision was under 12cm. We had one reoperation due to deep infection. All four patients with bilateral THA preferred their last operation due to lack of post operative restrictions and due to shorter recovery of muscle strength.

Conclusion: We think that using mini invasive Modified Watson-Jones approach in total hip replacement surgeries is a preferable option. There are several advantages of using this approach compared with the more traditional techniques. Such a technique should help reduce morbidity and complication rates for those patients undergoing a total hip replacement.


AI. Spitzer P. Goodmanson K. Evensen B. Habelow Kathleen Suthers

Purpose: Double-tapered polished cemented femoral stems have demonstrated excellent long-term clinical results, but subsidence with cement mantle fracture, distal stress transfer and proximal stress shielding persist as problems. Adding a third taper from broad lateral to narrow medial purportedly reduces subsidence and improves proximal bone loading and preservation. We report our independent experience with a triple-tapered collarless polished cemented stem.

Methods: Between May 1999 and July 2001, 66 C-Stems (DePuy, Warsaw, IN, USA) were implanted in 45 females and 15 males, with a mean age of 67 years (R 35–86) and mean weight of 77 Kg (R 42–117). Diagnoses were OA in 62, RA in 1, AVN in 2 and fracture in 1. Average follow-up was 58 months (R 45–71).

Results: Harris hip scores improved from a mean of 43 (R17–100) to 84 (R 10–100). SF36 and WOMAC scores improved similarly. Six hips dislocated, but there were no reoperations. Subsidence was less than 1 mm in all cases. There was no radiographic stress shielding. Bone quality was maintained, especially in the critical medial calcar region, with positive bone remodeling along radial stress lines and improvement over time of some bone-cement interfaces.

Conclusions: The C-Stem, a triple-tapered collarless polished cemented stem, engages the surrounding cement mantle in an axially stable manner, minimizing subsidence to within the creep tolerances of cement. The radial stresses so generated favorably load the proximal bone, stimulating positive bone remodeling and eliminating stress-shielding. The clinical results at short to mid-term follow-up in this non-designer series are outstanding.


I. Ilsar Y. Weil R. Mosheiff A. Peyser M. Liebergall

Introduction: Fluoroscopy-based navigation systems enables surgeons to place implants with a simultaneous multi-planar monitoring. Percutaneous fixation of femoral neck fractures is an example of the growing usage of these systems in orthopedic trauma surgery. Growing evidence suggests that the accuracy of screw placement might affect the fracture outcome.

Methods: Between 2/2001 and 8/2005, 80 patients underwent internal fixation of femoral neck fractures using computerized navigation system. Three cannulated screws were implanted in an inverted triangle formation. The average patient’s age was 62±20 years (range 11–88), and 12 patients were under the age of 40 years. 53 patients were female, 27 male. 68 patients sustained the fracture due to a simple fall, 4 fell from high ground, 3-bicycle injuries, 2 due to motor vehicle accidents, and 3 patients suffered from insufficiency fractures with no trauma. The data includes results for both undisplaced fractures and fully displaced fractures which underwent closed reduction.

Results: The average length of hospital stay was 6.3±4 days (range 1–19). The average operating room time was 82±22 minutes (range 30–135), this including the preparation of the patient and instrumentation. Complications included one case of infection which necessitated long term antibiotic treatment, four patients requiring hip arthroplasty due to avascular necrosis of the femoral head, and one patient who underwent hip arthroplasty due to osteoarthritis. The total failure rate is 6%.

Conclusions: Computerized navigation for the internal fixation of subcapital femoral neck fractures allows improved screw positioning, which may reduce fracture complications, and provides reduced radiation to both the surgeon and the patient.


T. Ben-Galim P. Ben-Galim N. Rand Y. Floman S. Dekel

Study Design: The effect of Total Hip Replacement surgery (THR) upon spinal sagittal alignment and low back pain was assessed in patients with severe hip osteoarthritis.

Summary of Background Data: Osteoarthritis in the hip joint is associated with abnormal posture and gait due to hip flexion contracture and hip pain. This in turn may cause abnormal spinal sagittal alignment and secondarily induce low back and leg pain. However, there have been no reports regarding the corrective effect of Total Hip Replacement surgery upon spinal sagittal alignment in patients with osteoarthritis of the hip.

Methods: This study prospectively analyzed the results of 25 patients (15 females and 10 males, average age 67.4 years (32–84)) undergoing THR for severe osteoarthritis of the hip. Pre and post-surgical assessment included; sagittal measurement of Sacral Inclination (SI) and total Lumbar Lordosis (L1-S1) on standing lateral radiographs. Functional clinical outcomes for hip as well as low back were also evaluated using the Oswestry back Questionnaire, the Modified Harris Hip Score and Visual Analog Scale for lower back pain and hip pain accordingly.

All the radiographic and clinical evaluations were completed both before THR surgery and 3 months following the surgery during routine follow up.

Results: Mean Lumbar Lordosis before the surgery and in the follow up was 50.36 and 50.32 respectively. Mean sacral inclination before and after surgery were 39.06 and 38.16 respectively. Mean Functional outcomes as assessed by the HHS score before and after the surgery were 45.74 and 81.8 respectively. Mean Oswestry Questionnaire scores before and after the surgery were 36.72 and 24.08 respectively. Mean VAS scores for hip pain before and after the surgery were 7.08 and 2.52 respectively. Mean VAS scores for lower back pain before and after the surgery were 5.04 and 3.68 respectively.

Discussion: No Significant difference was found between the sagittal alignment of the spine before THR and 3 months following it. Interestingly, total hip replacement surgery significantly improved spinal functional outcome as well as relieved low back and hip pain.


G. Morag P. Zalzal B. Liberman O. Safir M. Flint A.E. Gross

Background: Revision total hip replacement in patients with a previous diagnosis of developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) can be a challenging and technically demanding procedure. Two of the major concerns are deficient acetabular bone stock and the position of the acetabular implant, particularly if the hip centre was not restored during the primary procedure. The purpose of this study was to determine if cup height, lateralization or abduction angle are correlated with functional outcome or survivorship in revision total hip replacement (THR) in patients with a previous diagnosis of DDH.

Methods: A retrospective investigation of 51 sequential patients (63 hips) previously diagnosed with DDH who underwent revision THR at our center between 1984 and 2000 was performed. The mean duration of follow up was 119 months (range 36 to 238 months). Forty-one patients (52 hips) were available for functional outcome and survivorship analysis. The remaining ten patients (11 hips) were available only for survivorship analysis. Three independent variables identified apriori as possible correlates were cup height, lateralization and angle as measured on the AP radiographs. Functional outcome measurement consisted of the Harris Hip, SF36 and WOMAC questionnaires. Linear regression analysis and Kaplan-Meier curves were used to determine if any of the variables correlated with functional outcome or survivorship.

Results: Cup height was found to have a statistically significant (p< 0.05) correlation with Harris Hip, SF36, and WOMAC functional scores. High hip centers correlated with worse scores. In addition, patients with hip centers less than 3.5 cm above the radiographic tear drop had a statistically significant improvement in cup survivorship compared to those with higher hip centers.

Conclusion: Restoration of hip center height to as close to the radiographic teardrop as possible improves functional outcome and cup survivorship.


P. Goodmanson K. Evensen AI. Sptzer B. Habelow Kathleen Suthers

Purpose: Proximal femur fracture occurring at the time of femoral canal preparation or insertion of the femoral component is a recognized complication of primary total hip arthroplasty.

Methods: Two hundred seventy three consecutive primary THAs were reviewed retrospectively for occurrence of intraoperative fracture. 146 cemented femoral components and 127 cementless femoral components were implanted. Intraoperative management of non- or minimally-displaced proximal femur fractures involved placement of either one or two cerclage cables, with postoperative weightbearing to tolerance using an assistive device for approximately six weeks.

Results: Eight (2.9%) hips sustained an intraoperative non- or minimally-displaced fracture of the proximal femur: six (75%) occurred using cementless stems and two (25%) occurred using cemented stems. At an average follow-up of 57 months (R 26–90 months), all patients in the fractured cohort have remained radiographically stable, with well-fixed femoral components showing no evidence of subsidence. All of the patients in this fractured group have achieved good or excellent functional results.

Conclusions: Midterm follow-up results suggest that non- or minimally-displaced proximal femur fractures occurring at the time of primary THA can safely and effectively be managed by placement of single or multiple cerclage cables, and without significant modification of standard postoperative rehabilitation protocols. No compromise in functional outcome has been observed with this treatment method.


D. Lakstein A. Edelman D. Hendel

Objective: The purpose of this study was to survey and to evaluate our early results with the cementless ZMR hip prosthesis.

Methods and Patients: This modular system is designed to address the challenges and design goals of hip revision with off-the-shelf flexibility, proximal-distal extensive fixation and restoration of hip kinematics (offset, lengths and anteversion). The Taper femoral component is designed for distal fixation using a distal stem that is tapered to help obtain secure, consistent seating in the femoral canal, and splints that engage bone to provide rotational stability. The porous stem is designed to provide proximal or extensive (both proximal and distal) fixation. The geometry of the modular proximal body is designed to help preserve bone. The taper junction between the proximal body and distal stem allows for control of version of the implant. Eighteen ZMR taper hip prostheses were implanted between January 2004 and August 2005. The mean age of the 18 patients (13 females, 5 males) was 72 and the mean follow-up period was 10 months.

Results: Out of these 18 patients, 4 interventions were primary (DDH or pathological fractures) and 14 were revision procedures. In most (16) cases a taper stem was used. In 14 cases a total hip revision was performed, in 2 cases only the femoral stem was revised and in 2 cases a bipolar Hemiarthroplasty was done. Operative time averaged 187±33 minutes.

The stem displayed an excellent distal fixation, clinically and radiologically. Much less complications were noted, compared to earlier series. Three patients had postoperative infections – one case was after a 2 stage revision of an infected implant, one case was associated with a large hematoma due to excessive anticoagulation and another case was a superficial infection that resolved. Other complications included 2 (11%) early dislocations and one femoral nerve palsy. There were no intraoperative fractures of perforations and none of these complications necessitated implant removal.

Conclusion: The excellent distal fixation, simplicity of the operative technique and modularity of stem length and diameter, body size and offset, and anteversion, makes this system an attractive solutions for a wide variety of difficult femoral revisions. The high rate (11%) of early dislocations is still lower than other series with this system.


S. Shabat Y. Folman T. Gefen Y. Leitner R. David I. Pikarsky Y. Pevsner R. Gepstein

Background: The prevalence and incidence of low back pain in general society is high. Workers whose job involves walking long distances have even a higher tendency to suffer from low back pain.

Purpose: Our goal was to examine the effect of insoles on low back pain among workers whose job involves long-distance walking.

Methods: In this double blind prospective study we examined the effectiveness of insoles constructed in a computerized method to placebo insoles in 58 employees whose work entailed extensive walking and who suffered from low back pain. The evaluation was performed by the MILLION questionnaire.

Results: 81% of the employees preferred the real insoles in comparison to 19% of the users of the placebo insoles (p < 0.05). A substantial improvement in the LBP after the use of the true insoles was noted.. The average pain intensity before the use of the insoles was 5.46. However, after the use of the real insoles and the placebo insoles the average pain intensity decreased to 3.96 and 5.11 respectively. The difference of the average pain intensity at the start of the study and after the use of the real insoles was significant: −1.49 (p=0.0001), whereas this difference after the use of the placebo insoles was not significant: −0.31 (p=0.1189). A level 5 pain and above was reported by 77% of the subjects at the start of the study. After the use of the real insoles 37.9% of the subjects reported a similar degree of pain severity, and 50% of the subjects did so after the use of the placebo (p< 0.05).

Conclusions: LBP decreased significantly after the use of real insoles compared to placebo ones.


I. Caspi M. Levinkopf H. Arzi A. Friedlander J. Nerubay

Background: Complex Thoraco-Lumbar Spine fractures and fracture-dislocations are not common injuries and pose a great challenge for the surgeon. No method had been accepted as a gold standard for the treatment of such injuries. We describe our experience with the use of the Socon reduction system, which was originally designed for reduction of lumbar spondylolisthesis, for the treatment of complex Thoraco-lumbar injuries.

Materials and Methods: During the years 2000–2005 6 patients with AO type C Thoraco-lumbar injuries were operated using the Socon reduction system. 5 of them had complete paraplegia at the level of injury and one was neurologically intact. Reduction was achieved using the socon reduction system, and once in reduced position the fracture was stabilized using another posterior pedicular screws and rods system.

Results: Good sagittal and coronal alignment has been achieved in all 6 cases and stable fixation was achieved using posterior instrumentation. The Patient who didn’t have neurological deficits remained intact throughout the procedure. No major complication has been noted and reduction and fixation was stable during the follow up period with no case of hardware failure despite early mobilization.

Conclusions: The Socon reduction system provides an elegant and reliable mean for the reduction of complex Thoraco-lumbar spinal injuries. The system enables the reduction to be carried out only in a posterior approach thus minimizing the risks for further neurological insult and avoiding further damage to the facet joints. The use of posterior instrumentation proved safe and stable in this group of patients.


R. Hod-Feins I. Abu-kishk Y. Barr G. Eshel Y. Mirovsky Y. Ankstein

Background: Few studies addressed the immediate post operative complications after pediatric scoliosis surgery.

Objectives: The objective of this study was to evaluate the influence of pre, intra and post-operative parameters on immediate post-operative course.

Methods: A retrospective review of 109 pediatric patients’ records who underwent spinal fusion & instrumentation for scoliosis in one medical center between 1998–2005. The following data were collected: age and gender; curve type, etiology and degree; pulmonary function tests; surgical approach and the addition of thoracoplasty, operation time; blood products and morphine administration; blood test results at arrival to the intensive care unit (ICU). We evaluated the latter data influence on: 1. Prolonged post-operative ventilatory support. 2. Prolonged duration of ICU hospitalization 3. Presence of serious and non-serious post operative complications. Statistical analysis was done with T-test, Chi-square and Pearson correlations.

Results: Statistically significant correlations were found between neuromuscular etiology and prolonged ICU hospitalization, need for prolonged ventilatory support and the presence of major complications (P< 0.006). Anterior and combined anterior & posterior approaches were found to correlate with higher rate of pulmonary complications(P=0.015). All other parameters were not found to significantly and independently influence the post-operative course.

Conclusions: Anterior and combined approaches as well as neuromuscular etiology were found as risk factors for less favorable early post operative course while the addition of thoracoplasty and use of blood products were not.


O. Keynan CG Fisher F. Miyanji MF Dvorak

Introduction: Reported standardized functional outcome assessment of flexion distraction injuries of the thoracolumbar spinal column seems to be lacking in the literature. The primary focus of this study was the long term functional outcome in this patient population in view of the management employed in a tertiary spine referral center. In an attempt to overcome the lack of pre-injury Health Related Quality of Life (HRQOL) data, patient recall of the pre-injury state was used.

Secondary outcomes included the long-term disease-specific HRQOL in these patients, the correlation between radiographic alignment and functional outcome, comparison of HRQOL between operative and non-operative care, and identifying potential prognostic factors influencing functional HRQOL.

Method: A database generated retrospective cohort study with a cross-sectional outcome analysis was carried out for patients with a thoracolumbar (T11-L2) flexion-distraction injury treated at a tertiary care referral center between 1995 and 2000.

Inclusion criteria were age over sixteen, and referral to our center for a traumatic thoracolumbar flexion-distraction injury within two weeks of the injury. Exclusion criteria were an associated spinal cord injury, a previous spine injury or a multi-level spine injury, a significant associated other system injury with an ISS > 50, or patient refusal or inability to complete the outcome questionnaires. Patients were followed for a minimum of two years. Injury classification, healing, and alignment were determined by radiographic analysis. Standing lateral x-rays at final follow-up were used to determine the amount of residual kyphosis by two independent observers.

Results: A total of 87 patients were identified by the research database, of which 83 met inclusion and exclusion criteria. Twenty-eight patients were lost to follow-up, leaving 55 eligible patients. Eight refused to participate. Of the 47 remaining patients, 40 completed questionnaires representing a response rate of 85%.

There were 26 males and 14 females with a mean age of 27.4 years (range 16–48). Average follow-up was 3.3 years (range 2.5–7). Twenty-five patients (64.9%) were treated operatively and fifteen patients (35.1%) underwent non-operative management. Complications in the surgical group included one non-union, three cases of painful instrumentation, and one infection. In the non-surgical group, two patients developed non-unions requiring surgical intervention.

Comparing the follow-up mean SF-36 PCS and MCS scores to the recalled baseline SF-36 pre-injury scores, demonstrated the patients did not return to baseline physical component and mental component scores (p < 0.001).

The mental component (MCS) and NASS pain scores showed significant statistical difference between the two groups with a trend of non-surgical patients scoring higher.

There was no statistically significant difference in the SF-36 PCS between the two groups.

Linear and multiple regression models identified “associated other system injuries” as the only useful predictor of outcome influencing the SF-36 PCS. Patients with associated injuries are likely to have a poorer prognosis with lower scores.

Radiographically, there was no association between degree of kyphosis at last follow-up and outcome.

Discussion: Long term functional outcome assessment in this patient population and comparison between the surgical and non-surgical groups, revealed a trend in the non-surgical group towards reporting higher scores on both the generic and disease-specific questionnaires. There were also a higher number of complications associated with the surgical group, as well as potential residual back pain related to instrumentation.

Limitations of the study were the retrospective nature of the study, as well as the inherent absence of real time pre-injury quality of life assessment. The study is, however, strengthened by a homogeneous cohort and the use of validated outcome measures. It also involves a cross-sectional analysis and so has a prospective component

Conclusion: The health related quality of life in patients treated for flexion-distraction injuries without spinal cord injury is favorable overall, but does not return to normal after an average of two years following injury, with a trend in the non-surgical group towards reporting higher scores on both the generic and disease-specific questionnaires. Radiographically, no association was found between degrees of focal kyphosis at last follow-up and functional outcome.


J. Finkelstein A. Yee N. Adjei

Purpose: Purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of elective lumbar spinal surgery as it relates to patient expectations for outcome and outcome as quantified by patient derived generic and disease specific measures.

Methods: Prospectively collected patient derived generic health status (SF-36) and disease specific outcome measures (Oswestry) were quantified in all patients prior to surgery, and at serial postoperative clinical follow-ups. Patient expectations for their surgery were also measured; (pain relief, sleep, recreational and daily activities of living, return to work). Postoperatively, patients completed a questionnaire regarding the results of their spinal surgery as it related to meeting their expectations. Multivariate analysis of variance was used to evaluate for factors that influenced the results of surgery relating to patient expectations.

Results: Between 1998 and 2002 one hundred and forty three consecutive patients were evaluated. Average age was 52 (range 18–84). Diagnosis was disc herniation 43%, spondylitic spondylolisthesis 10%, degenerative spondylolisthesis 30%, spondylosis 6%, other 11%. The mean preoperative SF-36 mental component and physical component scores were 42.1 and 22.3 respectively (1.2 and 3.4 standard deviations below age and gender matched norms). Postoperative SF-36 scores were 48.1 and 38.6. The mean Oswestry disability scores were 48.7% preoperatively vs. 23.1% postoperatively. 81% (116/143) had their expectations met. Of the 19% (27 patients) who did not meet their expectations, they reported lower preoperative SF-36 general health and vitality domain scores. Patients were also less likely to have their expectations met if they had prior lumbar surgery, were involved in worker compensation or litigation. Patients who reported either back or back > leg symptoms were less satisfied than patients who presented with predominantly leg symptoms.

Conclusions: Patient factors inclusive of mental, (as measured by general health perception and vitality), physical (predominance of leg vs back pain), and social (presence of compensation, litigation), all contribute to patient satisfaction and outcomes following lumbar spinal surgery for degenerative conditions.


A. Hasharoni T. Azoulay Y. Zilberman M. Liebergall D. Gazit

Introduction: Spinal fusion has become a popular surgical technique. Problems of fusion failure or pseudo-arthrosis as well as bone graft donor site complications are common. Ex vivo gene therapy using mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) genes can provide a local supply of precursor cells and a supra-physiological dose of osteoinductive molecules that may promote bone formation and lead to spinal fusion.

Methods: Thirty 6–7 weeks old C3H/HeN immune-competent female mice received an injection of 2x106 genetically engineered MSCs to the para-vertebral muscle of the lumbar spine (L2-L6) under manual palpation. Ten animals served as negative control group and 20 animals constituted the experimental group.

Bone formation in the para spinal region of the injected animals was evaluated by histology staining. Quantitative analysis of the fusion mass was monitored by micro computerized tomography (μCT).

Results: At 1, 2, 4 and 8 weeks post injection. Bone formation was extensive, as soon as the 1st week post injection, in the area adjacent to and adhering to the posterior elements of the spine in all the study animals. None of the control animals, in which hBMP-2 was inhibited, showed any new bone formation.

Discussion: Exogenously regulated expression of the hBMP-2 enabled us to regulate bone formation in vivo, using genetically engineered MSC system. The effect of hBMP-2 in inducing bone formation was monitored in real time, non-invasive and quantitative system that enabled us to better understand the biological process during bone regeneration and repair. Our data demonstrate a regulated and monitored system for inducing bone for spinal fusion. We conclude that controlled gene therapy for spinal fusion can be achieved using Tet-regulated hBMP-2 gene and MCSs.


L. Kaplan Y. Barzilay R. Rivkin Y. Bronstein A. Hasharoni JA Finkelstein

Purpose: To describe the role of osteotomies in rigid spinal deformities

Patients and Methods: One hundred fifty six patients with spinal deformities undergoing surgery between March 1998 and August 2005 were identified from our spine registry. Our study cohort included 23 cases where osteotomies were performed for correction.

Corrective osteotomies were one of: 1) wedge osteotomy convex based; 2) wedge osteotomy dorsally based; 3) complex wedge or eggshell osteotomy for combined frontal and sagittal plane deformity. Patient’s demographics, type of deformity, underlying conditions, operative results, complications, and need for secondary procedures were documented.

Results: Twenty three patients (15%) with rigid curves underwent osteotomies as part of their corrective surgery. Mean age in this cohort was 11.3 years (2–26), 35% were males, 65% females. In 17 of the patients the main deformity was scoliosis, in 5 – kyphosis and in – 1 lordosis. MMC was the leading underlying condition in 4 cases, followed by VACTER syndrome (2), congenital myopathy (2), arthrogryposis and pterygium (2), Neuro-blastoma (1) and other congenital conditions. Operative results were satisfactory in terms of cosmetics, alignment and function. In 3 cases (13%) complications were encountered, with 2 infections requiring debridement, (one requiring hardware removal) and 1 Neurofibromatosis patient undergoing her 8th surgical procedure, developing an intraoperative partial neurological injury with nearly full recovery.

Conclusions: Osteotomies are an important part of surgery in rigid spinal deformities. These deformities occur frequently in syndromatic children making peri-operative treatment more complex. Osteotomies facilitate better outcome in terms of correction, sagittal and coronal balance and cosmetics. These procedures are highly demanding technically. However, it is our opinion that adequate correction of rigid deformity with the benefit of spinal column shortening by way of osteotomy, is protective from significant neurological traction injuries that otherwise may occur.


O. Keynan CG Fisher MF Dvorak M. Boyd

Introduction: There is clear evidence that violating the margins of a sarcoma or other malignancy during surgical resection will risk local recurrence and diminish overall survival. Previous publications have retrospectively demonstrated this oncologically sound approach to spine tumor management to be internally valid. The external validity or limited generalizability has not been assessed.

Methods: A prospective cohort study design. Included were all patients who underwent enbloc surgical resection of a primary tumor of the spine between January 1994 and November 2003, at the authors’ institution. Tumors were classified using the Ennking and WBB staging systems. All specimens were submitted to a single experienced musculoskeletal pathologist. Surgery was performed by the authors. Surgical approach, specimen margins, complications, adjuvant therapy, neurological status, local recurrence and survival were prospectively collected.

Results: Twenty-six patients (12 males and 14 females) were eligible for the study. Average age was 42 (range 16 to 70). There were 19 malignant tumors and 7 benign. Review by the pathologist revealed that 13 resections were wide, 5 marginal (at dura) and 7 intralesional (2 planned wide, 1 planned marginal). Except in benign lesions intral-esional or marginal margins occurred at dura.

There are 20 surviving patients with an average follow up of 41.5 months (range 6 to 111 months), 15 of who had malignant tumors. None of these patients have evidence of local recurrence and one has evidence of systemic disease.

The health related quality of life, using the SF-36, shows acceptable morbidity of these procedures (PCS=37.73 ± 11.52, MCS=51.69 ± 9.54).

Conclusions: Principles of wide surgical resection, commonly applied in appendicular oncology, can and should be used for the treatment of primary bone tumors of the spine with anticipated acceptable morbidity and satisfactory survival.


A. Khoury H. Kreder T. Skrinskas M. Hardisty M. Tile CM Whyne

Introduction: Lateral compression (LC) is the most common type of pelvic fracture, however there are no clear clinical or radiologic indications to direct conservative versus operative treatment of this pattern of injury. This study aims to determine if improved characterization of LC fracture patterns is possible through 3D radiological analysis.

Methods: CT scans of 61 patients with unilateral LC pelvic fractures were identified. The scans were segmented to generate a 3D model of the pelvis (Amira, MCS Inc). To quantify displacement of the fractured hemipelvis, the spatial orientation of three distinct anatomical landmarks (anteriof superior iliac, posterior superior iliac and ischial spines) on each side of the 3D hemipelvis were identified. Translational and rotational differences between the intact and fractured sides were compared to determine patterns of displacement with respect to a generated mid-sacral sagittal plane.

Results: 36.6% of the LC fractures were classified as non-displaced, 36.6% had an isolated single axis rotation, in another 13.3% had a pure translation with no rotation. 10% demonstrated pure rotational involvement in extension and the remaining patients, 3.3% had dual axis rotation.

Conclusion and Significance: Using 3D geometric analysis we were able to quantify patterns of LC fracture displacements not previously described. We characterized 5 subgroups of displacement patterns in LC fractures of the pelvis. Our 3D findings demonstrated a spectrum of translation and rotation motivating comparison with clinical outcome.


J. Saveski G. Kondov V. Filipce S. Pejkova N. Trajkovska

Anterior spinal pathology of the upper thoracic (T2–T4) segment is rare. The surgical approach is still controversial. Anterior week approach with partial osteotomy of the sternum or high latero-posterior thoracotomy are insufficient to approach this segment.

The purpose of this study is to present our experience with sternotomy as a approach in the surgical treatment of anterior spinal pathology to the upper thoracic (T2–T4) segment.

Material and methods: Between 2000–2004 nine patients with anterior spinal pathology in the upper thoracic segment were surgically treated. From all patients 5 were male and 4 female. The age ranged from 52 to 62 years. The anterior spinal pathology localisation was in 5 patients in T2; in 2 pt. in T2 and 2 pt. in both T2 and T3. The diagnosis in all patients was done by protocol wich included: careful neurological examination; standard radiographic films (AP and lateral view); CT; MRI; bone scan and other routine investigations. Neurologic status (deficit) was evaluated by modified Frankel Scale (M.F.S.). There were one patient grade A2; 4 patients with grade B; 3 pt. as a grade 3 and one grade D1. Sternotomy as a approach was used in all patients to expose the upper thoracic (T2–T4) segment. Corpectomy, extirpation of the local tumors mass; decompression of the spinal canal and neural elements was done.

The defect between T1-T3-4 was bridged with three-cortical iliac crest bone graft. In 7 cases fixation with anterior plate was done. Histologically in 2 pt. was found metastasis of carcinoma of thyroid grand foliculocellulare type; in 4 pt. solitary plasmocytoma; in two pt. giant cell tumor and in one patient invasive chondroma. All patients after surgery were transferred to the Oncology Center for other aditional treatment. Neurological recovery was registered in all patients expect one who died 2 months after surgery. The patient with grade A2 and one of grade B recovered to grade D1; one patient of grade B recovered to grade C and two of grade B and patients of grade C and D recovered to grade E. The solid fusion happened in all patient expect one who died.

Conclusion:

Sternotomy is a safe approach to the upper thoracic T2–T4 segment with possibility of direct visualisation of pathologic process and radical extirpation of the tumorous mass.

Early decompression of the spinal canal and neural elements by corpectomy and manolatory for neurologic recovery.


E. Peled D. Norman J. Bejar JH Boss D. Levin H. Ben-Noon C. Zinman

Introduction: In avascular necrosis [AVN] of the femoral head the dead bone undergoes osteoclastic osteolysis and is replaced by newly synthesized, immature, weak bone, which cannot withstand the daily loads. The articular surface might caves in because of these changes, and osteoarthritic joint changes can develop. Alendronate interferes with the osteoclastic activities, it can slow-down the bone turnover of the necrotic bone and can differ these changes.

The aim of this study is to delay the speedy renewal of living epiphyses by alendronate medication in order to describe the effects of it on the fate of the necrotic femoral heads in rats.

Methods: Sixty female sprague-dawley rats, 6-month old weighing about 400–500 grams, underwent surgical AVN of the right femoral heads. Forty-four rats, the treated group, were treated with alendronate 200 μgm/kg/day. Sixteen rats, the control group, were treated with saline. Both groups were daily injected subcutaneously for six weeks and sacrificed. Both femoral heads were harvested and were evaluated microscopically and stained by H& E.

Results: The necrotic femoral heads of the control group, which were not treated by alendronate, were severely distorted with osteoarthrosis features as; collapse of the epiphysis, pannus formation, filling of spaces by chronically and mildly inflamed densely textured fibrous tissue which was polluted by numerous tiny particles of necrotic bone. Additionally, large chunks of necrotic articular cartilage were haphazardly scattered in the fibrous tissue. All hematopoietic and fat cells of the intertrabecular spaces of the epiphysis were replaced by fibrous tissue. More often than not, the cartilage of the physis was focally or entirely absent such that osseous trabeculae of the epiphysis and metaphysis linked with each other, forming so-called epiphyseal-metaphyseal bridges. The above described alterations were encountered in all animals, yet their severity varied.

The decisive difference between the necrotic femoral heads of otherwise untreated in opposition to the alendronate-medicated rats was the preservation of a hemispherical configuration of the femoral heads. There was no distortion of the femoral heads in the alendronate-treated animals and the femoral heads preserved their roundness.

All femoral heads of the non-operated left hips were microscopically normal.

Discussion: It has become clear that the degree of architectural distortion of the femoral epiphyses depends on the extent of bone turnover leading to resorption of all debris and its replacement by living osseous and soft tissues. The more rapidly and more extensively the reconstruction of living epiphyses progresses, the smaller is the prospect of reshaping a hemispherical or near-hemispherical femoral head. The recently rebuilt epiphyses cannot carry daily transarticular loads without caving in. The revascularization-related reconstitution of weak bony trabeculae is blamed for the collapse of the femoral heads. If this indeed is the case, the remodeling of the necrotic femoral heads should be delayed, rather than sped-up. Alendronate interferes with the osteoclastic activities and hence, slowing-down the bone turnover.

The osteoclastic activity is detrimental for the conservation of a hemispherical femoral head because of the rapidly occurring replacement of the necrotic bone by living tissues. Halting the activities of the osteoclasts by a biphosphonate would stop the hasty osteoneogenesis, which is responsible for the early femoral capital disfigurement and might delay the regeneration of osteo-arthiritic changes of the joint later on.


N. Rosenberg O. Rosenberg S. Leschiner S. Weizman M. Soudry M. Gavish

Introduction Efficient control of osteoblast metabolism is crucial for the development of methods for enhancement of bone fracture repair and in the treatment of osteoporosis. If extracellular matrix elaboration by osteoblast could be controlled on the cellular level, new theurapeutical means might be developed. The current methods for osteoblast metabolic manipulation include mechanical, electromagnetic, hormonal and biochemical, i.e. growth factors and cytokines, means. All this methods have different degrees of therapeutic success. Finding of additional pathways of metabolic stimulation of osteoblast will provide an important insight for the understanding of human bone mass maintenance. The recent report of the existence of peripheral ben-zodiazepine receptor(PBR) in mammalian fibroblast arises the possibility of the existence of an unknown cellular pathway for mesenchymal cells metabolic regulation through this receptor. The PBR is a part of the mitochondrial permeability transition complex with important role in cell proliferation, differentiation, steroidogenesis, immunity and apoptosis, i.e. this complex is involved in most of the cellular metabolic activities. The PBR was identified in various organs, especially with enhanced steroidogenetic activity, but never has been investigated in bone. Therefore PBR’s identification in the human osteoblast may reveal a new cellular pathway of its metabolism.

Methods Cultures of confluent layers of osteoblast-like cells originated from human cancellous bone from distal femur. The samples were taken during osteoarthritic knee replacements. Chips of cancellous bone, 2 – 3 grams in total, were incubated in DMEM with heat-inactivated fetal calf serum (10%), 20mM HEPES buffer, 2mM L-glutamine, 100 μ M ascorbate-2-phosphate, 10nM dexam-etasone, 50 U ml-ml penicillin, 150μml-ml streptomicin at 37°C in humidified atmospheric environment of 95% air with 5% CO2 ( v:v ) for 30 days. Human osteoblast-like cells grew out from the chips as adherent to the plastic culture plates until confluency. The human bone cell cultures obtained by this method have been shown previously to express osteoblast-like characteristics.

The PBR in the homogenized osteblast-like cells was identified by using its selective ligand PK11195. The affinity and density of the PBR was estimated by the scatchard analysis.

Results We found that binding of the ligand [3H]PK11195 to the human osteoblast PBR is saturable with a single population of binding sites (r=0.92 – 0.95). The equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) equaled 9.15-9.34 nM and density of receptors (Bmax) was 7,672–7,691 fmol/mg protein.

Discussion The PBR receptor was identified in the human osteoblast with affinity to the PK11195 in the same magnitude as previously found in other tissues. The density of the PBR in the osteoblast appeared higher comparing to uterus, kidney, brain and placenta from different mammalian origin. PBR’s density in osteoblast is comparable only to the adrenal tissue, that is known to have its highest values. PBR density in the human osteoblast is also higher than in the rat’s skeletal fibroblast, and although this may suggest a higher differrention of the osteoblast, the interspecies comparison might be misleading. These data suggest that the human osteoblast is one of the important sites rich with PBR. The exact role of the PBR in the human osteoblast metabolism is not known yet and will be further investigated.


A. Khoury CM Whyne MJ Daly DJ Moseley G. Bootsma T. Skrinskas JH Siewerdsen DA Jaffray

Introduction: Malrotations following Several complications have been reported in femoral nailing, among them. The aim of this study is to develop an intraoperative method based on cone beam CT (CBCT) to assess comminuted fracture periaxial rotation. We hypothesize that bone surface matching using CBCT image data can precisely predict malrotation in the fractured femur even with severe comminution.

Methods: A mid-shaft osteotomy in a fresh frozen cadaveric femur was performed and a rotational axis was formed. The proximal part of the femur was fixed and the distal part was optically racked for periaxial rotation. At each rotation a CBCT was aquired. The images were segmented at bone threshold. The center of the bone in each axial slice was calculated and the distance from that center to the inner and outer bone surfaces was sampled at 1o intervals (360x). The resulting plot was an unwrapped virtual bone surface consisting of a pattern of ridges and valleys. Fracture gaps were simulated by removing CT slices adjacent to the osteotomy. The fracture gap was reconstituted using an extrapolation algorithm to the midline of the fracture. The two bone surfaces were then continuously shifted relative to one another in order to match the geometric bony features. Calculated malalignments were compared to the measured at each of the 16 rotations with each of the 9 simulated fracture gaps. Three rotational malrotations were tested twice to assess repeatability.

Results: Femoral malrotation was strongly predicted as compared to the rotation measured by optical tracking. The performance was not impacted by gap size up to 100 mm.

Discussion: The high quality of intraoperative CBCT imaging data enables surface matching algorithms to be utilized. The results ratify this novel method for assessing fracture rotation.


C. Nguyen D. Singh M. Harrison G. Blunn I. Dudkiewicz

Introduction: Many mini compression screws are now available for fixation in procedures such as metatarsal osteotomies or arthrodeses of the foot.

The aim of the current study is to compare the compression forces achieved by the relatively new commercial mini compression screws on cortical and cancellous bone models.

Material and Methods: The screws that were tested are listed in the table below. All screws apart from the AO screws are headless and cannulated; and all screws apart from the AO cortical screw are self-tapping. The compression forces were tested by inserting a pressures load measurement cell between longitudinally-split sheep tibia as a cortical bone model and longitudinally split retrieved femoral heads as a cancellous bone model. The screws were inserted across the 2 halves with gradual compression after allowing the reading of the cell to settle.

Results: The Headed AO 3.5 mm cortical screw gave the best compression force, both in cortical and cancellous bone and the Bold was the weakest both in cortical and cancellous bone. The relative compression forces of the other tested screws were different between cortical and cancellous bone. Compression with the headless screws was lost as soon as the screw penetrated through the cortex in the cortrical bone model.

Conclusions: The indications for using headless self-tapping screws should be reserved for fixation of cancellous bone or of metatarsal or Akin osteotomies where compression is not required for union. When compression is important, such as in MPJ, tarso-metatarsal or talo-navicular arthrodeses, Headed AO 3.5 mm or 2.7 mm cortical or 4 mm cancellous screws, which give better compression, should be used.


Full Access
James W. Brodsky

Forefoot reconstructive surgery can be complex and intricate, and even though performed by orthopaedic surgeons, it can be delicate, too. Despite the most ingenious techniques, patients routinely walk (stomp) all over this work, and the resulting forces applied to the foot have been extensively studied in gait analysis laboratories.

But the everyday clinical challenge is how to employ durable reconstructive techniques, and how to salvage these case when they fail?

Hallux valgus surgery is replete with complications of malunion, non-union, over-correction and recurrence. Salvage often requires a revision of the patient’s expectations in addition to another surgery. First metatarso-phalangeal joint (MTP) arthrodesis, which has been demonstrated to have excellent functional outcomes, including return to sports activities, is an excellent salvage technique.

Failed first MTP arthroplasty leaves a large bone defect, both in the metatarsal and phalanx. Salvage by arthrodesis requires bone grafting, rigid internal fixation, and long healing times. Tricortical iliac graft can be used to enhance restoration of length. Associated meta-tarsalgia may persist due to shortening of the first ray.

Lesser metatarsal salvage sometimes can be accomplished with distal metaphyseal osteotomy. Some cases previously treated with a pan-metatarsal head resection can now be successfully salvaged by using these osteotomies to shorten multiple metatarsals. Meticulous technique is an advantage.

First MTP arthrodesis itself can be complicated. One uncommonly recognized problem is the painful pressure under the residual sesamoid bone following an otherwise successful fusion. This is caused by arthritic enlargement of the sesamoid, and should be anticipate, and prevented by sesamoidectomy. Surgical technique for obtaining ideal position of the hallux will be presented.

The distinction between true recurrence of interdigital (Morton’s) neuroma, and metatarsalgia can be subtle. The cause of failed neuroma surgery is as frequently an error in patient selection as it is failure of surgical technique.

Case presentations will be employed to illustrate forefoot salvage principles.


M. Itzchaki

In 1882, as a French medical student, Philippe Charles Ernest Gaucher, described a 32 year old female with an enlarged spleen that he thought was an epithelioma.

Gaucher disease, the most prevalent lysosomal storage disorder, is a result of a genetic defect in the enzyme β-glucocerebrosidase (EC3.2.1.45), and the consequent accumulation of a glycolipid, glucocerebroside, in the cells of the monocyte-macrophage system, the “Gaucher cells”.

Of more than 200 mutations identified, most are private or rare mutations; those with some prevalence have been loosely categorized as a mild, severe, or lethal mutations on the basis of residual enzyme and clinical phenotype.

The most common presentation includes hepato-splenomegaly, anemia, and thrombocytopenia. Bone involvement is perhaps the most variable of all the findings attributed to Gaucher disease: ranging from asymptomatic disease, with or without radiological signs, to symptomatic disease, including avascular necrosis of bone adjacent to the large joints and pathological fractures (including compressed fractures of the spine). Episodic “crises” of bone pain in children and young adults, are common manifestations, which can be severe and engender considerable pain and disability.

One feature of Gaucher disease is the failure of correlation of bone with visceral or hematological disease. Symptomatic bone disease, may occur in any patient regardless of the extent of the visceral manifestations, and may be present or relatively absent in patients with severe splenomegaly or bone marrow depression.

With the advent of enzyme replacement therapy (ERT), which has proven to be safe and effective in improving the hematological parameters and reducing the organomegaly, it was hoped that the bone disease would be equally amenable to replacement therapy. But, the general experience has been that the skeletal response is considerably slower. However, it does seem that bone crises are much less frequent among ERT-treated patients. The greatest advantage of ERT to the skeleton is prevention before irreversible damage occurs, and that severe skeletal complications are usually prevented if ERT is begun at an early age in patients at risk. In addition, because of cost considerations, many national health budgets are unable to acquire ERT for affected patients and these individuals continue to suffer from the consequences of the natural history of their disease. Thus, the need for orthopaedic consultations and interventions are as critical today as in the era prior to global marketing of ERT.

This lecture outlines findings from the large referral clinic (> 500 patients) in the decade since the advent of specific enzyme replacement therapy. Although there have been some theories suggested to explain aspects of the pathological behavior of Gaucher bone, no one model is completely adequate: much is poorly understood. We face a relatively young and intelligent patient population whose expectations of quality of life are high and most patients do not want to be restricted in their daily activities. On the other hand, there arises the question whether conventional orthopaedic solutions, such as osteotomies, joint replacements or arthrodesis will be as successful as in patients with normal bones, this was the goal of our investigations.


I. Ilsar A. Hareven I. Leichter O. Safran AJ Foldes Y. Mattan M. Liebergall

Introduction: Several factors render plain X-ray radiographs of the hip unsuitable for bone mineral density measurements, mainly variability in X-ray exposure levels and soft tissue surrounding the bone. We present modification of proximal femur digital radiographs to compensate for these interfering factors.

Methods: The study population consisted of 99 women, in three groups: 1 – elderly, sustaining a fracture of the neck of the femur. 2 – elderly, without a fracture. 3 – young. Each patient’s hip was radiographed with a brass step-wedge for standard reference. Dual-Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DEXA) of the same hip was performed. On each radiograph, Regions Of Interest (ROIs) of the proximal femur were determined in concordance with ROI of the DEXA, together with three soft tissue regions surrounding the bone. Mean gray level was measured for each ROI.

Results: The difference in gray level of the ROI within the proximal femur was not statistically significant between the groups. Correction of bone gray level to exposure level by dividing the gray level of the ROI to that of the step wedge, resulted in statistically significant difference between group 1 and either group 2 or group 3. Similar results were obtained by correction of bone gray level to soft tissue gray level. Using this method, multiple R2 of 0.62 was found predicting the DEXA value from the gray level of each ROI.

Conclusions: After correction to the exposure level and to the soft tissue surrounding the bone, a plain digital radiograph of the pelvis can provide valuable information concerning the bone mineral content of the proximal femur. These preliminary results warrant further research aimed at exploring the potential value of this fast, accessible and relatively inexpensive technique to diagnose osteoporosis and the prediction of future fractures.


G. Maor G. Nierenberg

Purpose: Hyaline cartilage lesion in a large weight bearing joint can lead, if not treated, to damage of the subchondral bone. Since cartilage tissue does not heal spontaneously, nor can it regenerate, joint functional restitution is based on temporary biological solutions. The only promising approach for recovering damaged joint and avoid its eventual deterioration is to restore the genuine surfacing of hyaline cartilage.

Methods: We have developed a novel primary chondrocytes culture based on a unique source of cartilage cells whereby a gradual collagenase separation yield a homogenous chondrocyte population, which unlike other cartilage source-derived cells preserve the capability of spontaneous differentiation into cartilage forming cells.

Results: Following a short period of intensive proliferation, the cells start to differentiate into polygonal shaped cells, expressing Cbfa1-the skeletal tissues specific transcription factor, type II collagen and cartilage proteoglycan; thus producing a genuine hyaline cartilage. The cultured chondrocytes also preserve their responsiveness toward local and systemic factors such as growth hormone, insulin, PTH and IGF1. Since, cartilage is an immuno-privileged tissue; non- autologous cartilage sources may also be successfully transplanted. We have shown that mourine and porcine-derived cells injected into rats afflicted (AIA) joints replenish the articular lesion with no signs of WBC infiltration. Since, prior to differentiation, these cells undergo an intensive proliferation phase they can also be transfected. We have also shown that osteoprotegerin (OPG)-firstly known for its activity as RANK ligand decoy receptor, has direct ameliorative effects on cartilage development. We have shown that OPG transfected chondrocytes preserve their typical morphological and functional features.

Conclusions: This model of primary chondrocyte culture, develop authentic resemblance to hyaline (surfacing) cartilage with similar physical and mechanical properties of the original tissue. These cells can be successfully transplanted into damaged joint of a foreign host. Hence, we propose that these primary spontaneously-differentiating chondrocytes, from non autologous source- can be suitable for replenishment of articular lesions as well as vehicle for local application of beneficial cytokines like OPG.


E. Adar A. Gam N. Halperin V. Rzetelny D. Hendel

Background: The embryology of the cruciate ligaments of the knee had received scant attention in the orthopaedic and embryologic literature. Understanding the embryonic development of the blood supply to criciate ligaments (CL) may help to comprehend the mechanisms of pathology leading to failure of these structures and of the revascularization process after reconstruction injured of cruciate ligaments or implantation of grafts.

Aim: To describe the anatomy and spatial relationships of the cruciate ligaments and their blood supply in the developing fetus.

Method: Knees from one leg of 48 normal human embryos from abortion material were examined, gestational age varying from early as the 8th week and up to the 20th week. Microscopic semi serial consequent sections of the knees were examined under light microscope and spatial changes within the cruciate ligaments were noted. The contra-lateral knees of some of the embryos were dissected to confirm the three dimensional picture. This gave us the possibility to follow the developmental changes of the spatial orientation of the cruciate ligaments and the blood vessels within them.

Results: The anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments are formed from a single mass of cells, divided by a sinovial septum. Folds within the septum partially divide the ligaments into bundles and carry within them the vasculature needed to sustain the ligaments. We show that the blood supply of the growing CL arises from the middle genicular artery and enters the ligaments from the poster-superiolateral corner (P.S.L.C.) of the inter-condylar notch, passes between the ACL and PCL and descends along he posterior aspect of the ACL.

These findings can explain why injury involving the P.S.L.C. in the adult has a worse prognosis for rehabilitation.


A. Yayon E. Neria S. Blumenstein B. Stern H. Barkai R. Zak Y. Yaniv

Introduction: Articular cartilage injuries cause pain and disability and lead to early osteoarthritis. Autologous chondrocytes implantation (ACI) demonstrated long-term clinical benefit. However, clinical application of ACI is laborious requiring arthrotomy of the knee, harvest of a periosteal flap from a secondary surgery site and suturing over the cartilage lesion. Use of the periosteal flap often leads to tissue hypertrophy requiring an arthroscopic intervention. BioCart™II is a new matrix-assisted autologous chondrtocytes implant. The autologous cells, propagated with a unique growth factor variant, are delivered within a biocompatible and biodegradable scaffold made of human fibrin and hyaluronic acid. BioCart™II eliminates the need for a periosteal flap and enables implantation by a minimally invasive procedure thus significantly simplifying surgery and reducing rehabilitation time.

Methods: Chondrocytes were obtained from cartilage tissue using enzymatic digestion. The cells were then expanded in medium supplemented with a fibroblast growth factor (FGF) variant. Chondrogenic potential of the cultured chondrocytes was determined by in vitro high density pellet culture. The pellet cultures were analyzed for expression of cartilage specific markers by PCR and histology. Distribution of the cells within the fibrin-hyaluronic acid scaffold was studied by histology using H& E staining, presence of proteoglycans and collagen types I and II (Col-I, II) was determined by specific stains and immunohistochemistry (IHC).

Results: Cells cultured in the presence of the FGF variant exhibit a dramatic increase in proliferation rate compared with untreated cells. The chondrogenic potential of cells cultured for 4, 7, and 10 days in the presence of the growth factor were tested by pellet culture. Cells cultured for 4 days did not form a hyaline-like pellet, while cells cultured for 7 and 10 days form pellets with hyaline like structure which express proteoglycans and collagen type II. Col-II expression determined by real time PCR was significantly increased compared with Col-I in the pellets indicating the regeneration of hyaline cartilage phenotype. Pellet culture of chondrocytes cultured in the presence of the growth factor formed a much larger pellet and expressed more proteoglycans than pellet of cells cultured without the growth factor. Histological analysis of implants immediately post seeding demonstrate the chondrocytes are distributed throughout the fibrin-hyalronic acid scaffold. Expression of Col-II but not Col-I was observed within the scaffold by IHC.

Discussion: We present a new articular cartilage repair implant composed of autologous cells embedded within a fibrin and hyaluronic acid scaffold. Fibrin which is the natural scaffold for wound healing is used as the implant building material thereby mimicking the body’s natural healing process. The porous open channel structure of the scaffold allows for an immediate three-dimensional distribution of the cells within the scaffold to promote full thickness repair Use of the FGF variant allows implantation of BioCart™II within two to three weeks from the cartilage biopsy and increases the regenerative potential of the implant. BioCart™II is currently in clinical studies for the treatment of knee cartilage injuries.


S. Norman V. Rzepakosky T. Brosh M. Salai

Background: To date, conventional freezing and cryopreservation of articular cartilage has had limited success due to the mechanical injury of cells resulting from uncontrolled ice crystal propagation. Frozen then thawed grafts show a total lack of viable articular cartilage cells and weakened matrix. Directional freezing using a precise velocity offers a new approach to the process of freezing, enabling cryopreservation of articular cartilage for long term storage and implantation.

Hypothesis: Cryopreservation of articular cartilage using directional freezing maintains significant chondrocyte viability and extra cellular matrix quality.

Study Design: Controlled Laboratory Study.

Methods: Articular Cartilage, collected from 20 porcine hind legs harvested immediately after slaughter, was transferred to the processing laboratory for cryopreservation and analysis. Cryopreservation was performed using a directional freezing system (MTG 1315). During preparation for freezing cryoprotectants were injected into the matrix using an array of 20 micron needles. Thirty 15mm cylindrical grafts were examined for cell viability and cell density using fluorescent and confocal microscopy and proteoglycan synthesis via 35SO4 uptake. Biomechanical assessment was performed on a second set of 9 grafts to determine the matrix instantaneous dynamic modulus of elasticity.

Results: Chondrocyte viability (53%±9%), viable cell density (18900 ± 4100 cell/mm3, 68%±5.7% viability) and 35SO4 uptake (59% compared to fresh control) were achieved. Biomechanical measures were mildly impaired (62%±5.2%) compared to fresh control due to the injection of cryoprotectants. In addition, chondrocyte viability in the cryopreserved allograft was preferentially maintained in the superficial zone. Similar results were obtained in human in-vitro studies.

Conclusion: Cryopreservation using directional freezing enables the preservation of viable cells within the collagen matrix. These cells are embedded in the supporting hyaline cartilage matrix with good mechanical stability. The behavior of cryopreserved cartilage after transplantation as indicated in sheep transplantations favors the generation of new, healthy hyaline cartilage during one year follow-up. The high percentage of viable cartilage cells, the quality of the matrix following freezing and thawing, and the ability to store these grafts in a hospital facility, are encouraging to meet the growing demand of such allografts in human cartilage repair procedures.


G. Mozes E. Maman N. Parnes

Introduction: In many cases of massive rotator cuff tears, especially in cases of revision repairs the shoulder surgeon is facing a technical and biological challenge. The loss of collagenous material in the tendon, coupled with poor quality of the remaining rotator cuff, makes obtaining a mechanically strong repair difficult. Primary closure of such defects may result in excessive tissue tension, which may further increase the chance of failure.

Purpose: The objective of this study is to determine the feasibility of using xenogeneic small intestine submucosa (SIS) as a biomaterial to reinforce repair of massive rotator cuff tears.

Clinical Material and Methods: Nine patients ranging in age from 52 to 74 with massive rotator cuff tears were selected for the study. Selection of these patients was based upon the quality of remaining rotator cuff tendon tissue at the time of the repair. Seven cases after failed repair of massive rotator cuff tear and two cases of long standing neglected rotator cuff tears in patients with weight bearing shoulders (bilateral below the knees amputation and incomplete paraplegia after anterior poliomyelitis) were selected for this study.

In all patients first the tear was repaired by well-known techniques: tendon to tendon, tendon to bone through bone tunnels or using suture anchors. After the repair was accomplished, the poor quality tissue obtained was reinforced by a patch of Restore Orthobiologic Soft Tissue Implant (DePuy, Johnson & Johnson). The Restore Implant is a xenograft obtained of ten layers of porcine small intestine submucosa, it is biocompatible, infection resistant, possess predictable mechanical properties, and, perhaps most significantly, induce a host connective and epithelial tissue response that results in regeneration of specialized connective tissues.

Results: Follow-up ranging between 6 to 22 month excellent and good results were observed in eight cases (88%), whereas in the patient aged 74, the cuff repair failed again (after two previous failures). In the eight successful cases an almost normal painfree active range of movements was observed three month after surgery.

Conclusions: The results confirm the usefulness of the SIS graft material in the patients having questionable quality cuff tissue remaining after repair. Use of the Restore soft tissue implant could possibly be utilized to strengthen the repair, as well as the inside ingrowth of the tendon, leading to a successful repair of the rotator cuff.


S. Beyth Y. Weil E. Galun M. Shiloach Z. Gazit M. Liebergall

Introduction: Cell-based strategies for regeneration and reconstitution of musculoskeletal tissues are gaining interest. The difficulty in obtaining the required amount of mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) stems from their scarcity and the time needed to grow them in culture. We developed a rapid and efficient method to isolate MSC from bone marrow aspirate based on their surface markers, as a platform for future cell based therapy.

Methods: Bone marrow was aspirated from the iliac crest of fifteen adult subjects undergoing surgeries involving this bone. 15 ml samples were obtained, fractionated for mononuclear cells and then subjected to immunomagnetic isolation using microbeads of directly conjugated mouse anti–human CD105 antibodies. Recovered cell fraction was analyzed for phenotype and functional parameters.

Results: The samples yielded an average of 14.6±2.5x106 mononuclear cells per ml. Of these, fraction of CD105 positive cells consisted of 2.3±0.45%, which accounts for 0.25±0.06x106 cells per ml. Post isolation analysis shows that 79±3.2% were positively stained for CD105 and 36±5.8% stained positive for CD45. These cells generated 6.3±1.4 Colony Forming Units (CFU) per 105 cells. MSC concentration is higher in males and lower in smokers. Processing time is approximately 3 hours.

Discussion and Conclusion: Regeneration of mesenchymal tissues using progenitor cells with appropriate matrix and signals was shown feasible, however large numbers of these rare cells are needed. An effective and safe method for purification of autologous MSC enables us to avoid the risks and the time span associated with culture expansion. We conclude that this method is both effective and rapid.


S. Karkabi

Purpose: To review the results of simple arthroscopic subacromial decompression in patiens with impingement syndrome and rotator cuff tears without repairing the tears.

Type of Study: prospective study.

Material and Methods: From 1998 to 2003, 160 patients (168 shoulders) had arthroscopic subacromial decompression for impingement syndrome with a torn rotator cuff without repairing the tear of the cuff (120 males and 40 females). The average patient age was 64 years and the average follow up was 24 months.

With increasing use of arthroscopy in the treatment of shoulder disorders, tears of the rotator cuff have been well described. Management of rotator cuff tears should include consideration of tear size, patient age and activity level, and tear etiology.

Operative treatment of impingement syndrome in elderly less active lower demand patients with small and moderate tears involves decompression with and without repairing the cuff.

We evaluated the clinical outcome of arthroscopic subacromial decompression and debridement in 160 patients ( 168 shoulders ) with impingement syndrome with small and moderate tears of the rotator cuff without repairing the cuff.

Rotator cuff tears are graded arthroscopically as small (< 1 cm), moderate (> 1 cm < 3 cm ), large (> 3 cm < 5 cm ), and massive rotator cuff tears (> 5 cm ).

Results: At follow up 96 patients (60%) were rated excellent or good , 56 patients (35%) were rated fair and 8 patients (5%) were rated poor. The average “Constant” score was 62 preoperative compared with 82 postoperative in the improved group (152 patients) . The 8 patients who showed no improvement had average postoperative “Constant” score of 64.

Conclusions: Arthroscopic subacromial decompression without suture of the cuff in elderly less active lower demand patients with impingement syndrome with small and moderate tears of the cuff is a legitimate method of treatment for their shoulder pain and limitation of function.

The main advantages were: immediate physiotherapy and return of function since there is no need for immobilization.


M. Pritsch (Perry) R. Behar A. Oran D. Lieberman

The presented study investigated the difference of positioning sense of the shoulder before and after surgery (capsular shift or Arthroscopic Bankart repair) for shoulder instability.

For this purpose a sample of patients with recurrent dislocations of the shoulder that underwent surgery and patients with instability before surgery volunteered to participate in a set of experiments. Their results were compared to the results obtained from a matching sample of healthy subjects.

All subjects completed all movement’s conditions that included the performance of hand movements towards memorized visual target in A-horizontal plane condition and B-Three dimensional movement condition.

The mixed design (3 groups x 3 2D levels x 3 3D levels) with repeated measures allowed the comparison among the groups in terms of final accuracy measures (Absolute and Variable Errors) and variability around mean tangential velocities and end-point paths.

The results showed that operative shoulder stabilization improves the ability to accurately position the arm on a target at the end of the movement and in addition the kinematic profile, which is disturbed before stabilization, improves as well.

These measures may be used as an objective tool to asses the success of conservative as well as operative treatment for shoulder instability.


O. Levy B. Venkateswaran AS Montgomery T. Zaman T. Even S. Copeland

Arthroscopic Rotator cuff repair is gaining popularity in recent years; however, the results of arthroscopic repairs are yet to be reported. Between November 2001 to May 2003, 115 consecutive patients were operated (73 males and 42 females) with arthroscopic repair. 13 patients were lost to follow up, leaving 102 patients available for follow up.

The mean follow up time was 23.8 months (range 12–61). There were 107 patients (95.5%) with full thickness tears and 5 (4.5%) had partial thickness tears. Of the full thickness tears, 8 (7.6%) were massive in size, 36 (34%) large, 44 (41.5%) medium and 18(17%) small.

Mean age was 57.3 years (range 23–78). 47% had a history of trauma.

Mainly Supraspinatus (SSP) tear was recorded in 83.5% and isolated subscapularis tear in 7%. A combination of SSP tear with infraspinatus and teres minor minor (posterior tear) was found in 9.6%.

86% had Acromioplasty (ASD) with or without an AC joint excision arthroplasty. Two patients had Bankart repairs in addition at the time of cuff repair.

Patients were evaluated using the Constant score, satisfaction levels and ultrasound scan to evaluate cuff integrity. Failures were defined as dissatisfied patients and those who had had a re-operation. Re-tear rate was recorded.

The mean pre op Constant score was 40.9 points (95% CI 37.3 to 44.5), which had improved to 84.8 (CI 82.2 to 86.9) at last follow-up. 78% returned to same work and 82% returned to pre injury leisure activity. There were 20 ultrasound demonstrated re-tears (19.6%). However, the majority of patients with radiological re-tears had good function, pain relief and were satisfied. Eight of the 102 patients were not satisfied. Five of these patients had revision operation.

Arthroscopic cuff repair shows high satisfaction rate (92%) and good functional results while offering all the advantages of arthroscopic surgery.


N. Parnes E. Maman G. Mozes

Introduction: Latarjete operation for anterior shoulder instability, first described by Latarjete in 1954 consists of transfer of the coracoid process through the sub-scapularis tendon to the neck of the scapula. Many modifications were described in the English literature as described by Mc Murray in 1958, by Bonin in 1969 or May in 1970. In 1985, Braly and Tullos emphasized that the Bankart lesion, when present, should be corrected.

Rockwood transplants the entire coracoid process onto the neck by “laying it flat” onto the neck of the scapula using two screws instead of one, which gives a larger base for the coracoid transplant.

The disadvantages of this procedure, as described in the English literature, are relative shortening of the sub-scapularis tendon, thereby decreasing internal rotation power, limited external rotation and the possibility to damage the musculocutaneous nerve.

Purpose of the Study: To demonstrate that transplantation of the coracoid process with its tendon attachments through a split in the subscapularis muscle and tendon without shifting the capsula gives better results then transplant of the coracoid process with capsule-labral repair. The goal of this report is to review the result of our series.

Patients and Methods: Between January 2000 and June 2005, 26 Latarjete operations (Rockwood modification) were performed by the senior author. The indication for surgery was failed artroscopic Bankart repair or anterior shoulder instability associated with anterior inferior glenoid deficiencies (“inverted pear” deformity). Five cases were excluded having less than 6 months follow-up. In the first 5 cases in addition to the coracoid process transfer, labral repair with capsular shift was performed whereas in the next 21 cases only coracoid process transplant with excision of the damaged labrum/scar tissue and no capsular shift was performed. The postoperative rehabilitation program was the same for both groups. The patients age and sex was very close in both groups.

The parameters for comparison between the two groups were: range of motion, stability after 6 months, return to work and sport activity, satisfaction, and complication rate.

Results: 6 months after surgery all patients of both groups returned to full work and sport activity including contact sports. No recurrent dislocation was encountered during this short period of follow up. All patients who underwent this procedure, with or without capsule-labral repair, were satisfied with the procedure.

In the small group that included capsulo-labral repair an average of 10 degrees decrease of external rotation was encountered compared to the opposite shoulder. In the second group no decrease in range of motion was found.

Conclusion: Transfer of the coracoid process through the subscapularis tendon alone has better results then Latarjete operation complemented with capsulo-labral repair in regard of range of motion. The procedure is simple and of short duration giving the best solution for failed artroscopic procedures or for cases of shoulder instability having anterior inferior glenoid deficiencies.

The authors are aware that longer follow up is mandatory.


O. Levy D. Raj SA Copeland

Copeland Surface replacement arthroplasty provides a good outcome in cases of arthritis. However, the limitation of use of this prosthesis is severe bone loss of the humeral head.

We describe the use of Copeland Surface Replacement Shoulder Arthroplasty in cases of severe humeral head destruction extending more than 50% of the humeral head. The bone deficiency was reconstructed with the autograft from the reaming and reshaping of the humeral head and a synthetic bone graft substitute (Tricalcium phosphate granules (Biosorb)) mixed with the patient’s blood.

We report preliminary results in 8 cases. 3 males and 4 females (One patient bilateral). The average age was 48 years ( 22–76 years). 5 cases had Posttraumatic avascular necrosis of humeral head, two patients had locked posterior fracture dislocation with loss of more than 50% of the humeral head and one patient with severe juvenile rheumatoid arthritis.

In this series the remaining bone of humeral head was less than 50% ranging between 30–50% (average 38%).

The patients were followed clinically and radiographically. The average follow–up was 10.6 months (range: 5 to 15 months).

All patients had substantial improvement in there shoulder function and pain. All the patients were very satisfied. Average pre-op constant score was 9.3 points (range: 9–14). At the latest follow-up the average constant score was 59 (range: 36–74). Age and sex adjusted constant score was 68.6 (range: 37– 87).

Radiographically we observed good incorporation of the Bone graft substitute with no signs of loosening or any lucencies under the prosthesis.

These are early and encouraging results in this group of young patients with severe destruction of the humeral head. It seems like it may provide a good bone preserving solution in these cases and extend the frontiers for the surface replacement of the shoulder.


YS Brin V. Barchilon B. Kish S. Greenberg-Dotan G. Mozes N. Parnes M. Nyska

The Purpose: To compare clinical results of proximal humerus fractures following internal fixation with proximal humeral locked plate versus conservative treatment.

Materials and Methods: 25 patients sustained 3-part fractures of the proximal humerus. 8 were internally fixed and 17 were treated conservatively in two different centers.

Mean age: 65.4±12.7 Gender: 22 females, 3 males. Age and gender were similar in both groups. Follow up was longer in the conservative group (23.8 m ±7.5) compared to the operated one (11.1 m ±8.3).

All the patients were evaluated clinically using Constant’s score.

Statistical analysis was performed using Fisher’s exact test (examination rates differences), Mann-Whitney test (examination means difference) and Spearman’s test (evaluation of the correlation coefficient between two continuous variables).

Results: Constant’s score in the operated group was 57.1±19.3 and 58±21.5 in the conservative group. Union was noticed in all the operated patients, and there was one case of nonunion in the conservative group. There were no cases of AVN in any group.

Statistical Analysis: No significant difference between the two groups was found for total Constant’s score. ROM was similar in both groups except for the rotations, which tended to be better in the operated group: IR 7.6±2.6 versus 5.4±3.3 (p=0.103) respectively, ER 7.7±3.1 versus 6±2.6 (p=0.169) respectively.

Conclusions: Clinical results are similar for operative and conservative treatments in 3 part fractures of the proximal humerus. There are better results for rotations in the operated group. Strength in abduction is superior in the conservative group.

The difference could be influenced by the shorter follow–up period in the operated group.


D. Dabby H. Patisch N. Blumberg I. Cohen I. Jakim

The proper management of radial head fractures is difficult and controversial. The radial head is intra-articular, part of the forearm ring and participates in both flexion and extension as well as in pronosupination. Our main goal in treating those fractures is anatomic restoration of the joint surface and early mobilization. Excision of the radial head, a well described procedure, may result in elbow instability and proximal migration of the radius. In this work we tried to avoid those complications by either conserving the head (ORIF) or by using a Radial head prosthesis.

Material and Methods: 20 Patients were enrolled into the study between 2003–2004. They were divided into 2 groups. 10 patients had ORIF and in patients the Corin Radial head prosthesis was used. Post-op all patients started immediate CPM. All patients were followed-up for 12–28 months (average 18.6). XR were taken each time and clinical examination was done, ROM was noted as well as muscle strength. Elbow stability was tested only on the 2nd month post op. Patient satisfaction was noted based of their function ability, and the amount of pain. Pain was rated on a scale of 1–10.

Results: Both groups passed the surgery uneventfully. No neurovascular damage nor infection were noted. In clinical examination the elbow was found to be stable in both groups. Decreased ROM in compare with the other elbow was found in both groups, but was more prominent in he ORIF group. One patient in the ORIF group in which biodegradable rod was used developed moderate synovitis that passed without intervention after 9 weeks. XR reveled that one patient in the ORIF group developed Heterotopic ossification, no dislocation or subluxation of the prosthesis was seen. Regarding to pain, in the ORIF group the patients rated their pain as milder in compare to those in the prosthetic group.

Conclusions: Both methods result in stable elbow but the ORIF group showed tendency to experience less pains and the prosthesis group showed tendency to better ROM.


WB Lehman DM Scher JHP van Bosse DS Feldman DA Sala

Purpose: A retrospective study to determine the causes of failure of the Ponseti technique and treatment for those failed feet.

Materials and Methods: Eighty-nine patients with 136 clubfeet were treated by the Ponseti technique and evaluated on the Dimeglio/Bensahel and Catterall/ Pirani scoring systems. Six patients with 9 clubfeet were not corrected and therefore did not enter the dynamic ankle-foot orthosis stage. These 6 patients started treatment after the age of 8 months, except for one patient who was 9 weeks old at the start of treatment. Of these 9 feet, 8 underwent open Achilles tendon releases combined with posterior releases. Three of these feet had percutaneous Achilles tenotomies prior to their failure and 1 foot underwent complete soft tissue clubfoot releases. Eighty-three patients (127 clubfeet) completed the Ponseti technique. Eighteen patients with 28 club-feet were lost to 2-year follow-up (Group A), and 65 patients with 99 clubfeet (78.3%) had a greater than 2-year follow-up (Group B).

Results: Nine out of a total of 136 clubfeet failed the Ponseti technique. At 2-year follow-up, one-third (29/99) required additional procedure(s). At application of the dynamic ankle-foot orthosis in Group B, patients’ rating scores were similar. However, after 2-year follow-up, the noncompliant group’s scores (no orthosis) changed significantly for the worse when compared to the compliant group’s scores who used the orthosis for 2 years. After 2-year follow-up, Group B patients in the orthosis-compliant group had better scores than the 2-year failures (29 feet) who underwent further surgery and the initial 9 feet who failed the Pon-seti technique.


M. Haddad N. Rozen M. Soudry

Introduction: There is a controversy regarding the treatment of the intra articular fracture of the distal radius. Plating for anatomical reduction vs the minimally invasive method by mini external device and K wires. We report our experience with the minimal invasive technique.

Materials and Methods: Between January 2003 and march 2005, 43 patients with intra articular fracture of distal radius were treated. 22 females, 16 males were followed. Age range 23–81 (mean 55 years). All cases were uni lateral. 38 patients were followed out of 43 fractures. Causes: 23 fall, 9 RTA, 6 sport accidents. The fractures were classified according the Frykman classification: 5 F3, 6 F4, 6 F5, 9 F6, 5 F7 and 7 F8. Follow up was 6 weeks after treatment and 6 months later. A Lateral and PA views were performed and the angles were measured. The V.A.S. was used to quantify the painful level. The Lidstrom criteria scale was used to evaluate the functional outcome. The surgical procedure was performed on the same day or one day later. In all cases the mini external device of AO (2 threaded rods in the second metacarpal and another 2 rods in the radius) was used. In 20 cases, 1 or 2 K wires were inserted in addition from the radial styloid to stabilize the fracture. The mini external was removed 6 weeks later.

Results: According to Lidstorm criteria, 12 patients (31%) had excellent results, 23 (61%) good, 2 (5.5%) fair and 1 (2.5%) poor outcome. The results of the VAS were good: 33 had less than 3, 4 patients less than 5 and one patient chose the number 9 to quantify his pain. At the follow up, 35 patients restored a very good range of motion (ROM) of the wrist, while 3 patients had markedly reduced ROM. The best outcome is shown in the younger population, except one case, a young man 33 years old, who was unable to return to work 6 months later. Four patients (1%) had a pin tract infection treated by PO antibiotics.

Conclusion: In our hands, the minimally invasive technique seems to be a satisfactory procedure. In the young population, the restoration of the range of motion was very good. The loose of few degrees in the arc of motion in the elderly population didn’t disturb there functional performance. We think that the mini-invasive method is excellent tool for treating intra-articular fractures of the distal radius; the procedure is shorter and there is less chance of infection and less damage to the surrounding tissues.


Y. Beer Y. Mirovsky D. Weigl A. Oron R. Shitrit L. Copeliovitch G. Agar N. Halperin

Aim: To evaluate the long term effect of Distal transfer of the greater trochanter in Perthes’ disease.

Patients and methods: Twelve patients (thirteen hip joints, 10 males and 2 females) who suffered from Perthes’ Disease were treated by distal transfer of the greater trochanter (DTT). The operation was performed because of progressive shortening of the articulo-trochanteric distance accompanied by signs of insufficiency of the hip abductors. Total or near total femoral head involvement was found in all the patients except for one of them. Follow up period was 28 years (21–35). Mean age at diagnosis of Perthes’ was 7 years (4–11). Patient were studied in 1992 and reviewed again 13 years later, using the Harris hip score, short form 36 (SF36), physical examination and A-P X-rays.

Results: Not one of the patients underwent a total hip arthroplasty. Mean Harris hip score is 80 (range 54–100, 4 patients under 70 score). Mean SF36 score was 71 (range 30–94) and was correlated to the Harris score. Three of the patients were working in a physically demanding profession. The rest were office workers. Two of them chose non strenuous type of work due to the hip condition. Limb length discrepancy was 1.7 cm short on the operated side (range 0–3) and correlated with Trendelenburg sign (4 patients with positive sign). Femoral head sphericity according to Stulberg classification was good in 5 patients (grades 1–2), fair in 3 patients (grade 3) and poor in 4 patients (grade 4–5). Head sphericity was not correlated to age at diagnosis, Harris score, SF36 score or level of hip pain.

Conclusions: Long term outcome are surprisingly good in those patients, considering the degree of head involvement, advanced age at diagnosis and severity of disease which necessitated high degree of varus osteotomy and hence trochanter transfer.


AD Grant D. Atar

Severely involved patients with spastic diplegia or mild quadriplegia have increasing difficulty remaining ambulatory as they progress to adolescence and young adulthood, often becoming wheelchair bound. This presentation addresses effort to prevent or reverse this progressive state, allowing continued ambulation in a select group of patients. They must be highly motivated to keep walking, have a willingness to undergo extensive rehabilitation and have good psycholsocial support.

The program consists of multiple surgeries to the spine, pelvis/hip, knee, foot and ankle followed by a spika or long casts, leg braces (HKAFO to final GRO), 12–18 months of intense physical therapy and permanent use of crutches.

Seventeen patients, 16 adilescents and young adults, one adult over 50 adult, who were within 6 months of permanent wheelchair existence qualified and underwent this program. They were followed for a minimum of 10 years post surgery. All patients but one have remained supported community ambulators. The extent of the surgery, complications and problems are described.

An additional group of wheelchair bound patients with quandriplegia and severe diplegia were treated with extensive global surgery (described). The purpose was stabile symmetric seating with no pain and allowing the use of the hands and upper extremities for other than support in seating. The ability to achieve these goals has required addressing the controversy associated with extensive surgey in the non-ambulatory patient.


Full Access
J. Hakim E. Calif M. Hakim D. Gattas

Purpose: The injury occurs when a child passenger sits behind or in front of the rider; his leg gets caught in the rotating wheel’s spokes, and crushed against the frame. The study aimed at reviewing our experience in managing this common injury.

Patients and Methods: Between 2000–2005, 43 children were treated following bicycle spoke injury. All cases were thoroughly reviewed.

Results: Mean age was 5.1 years (range 1–15). Twenty-seven were up to 5 years. Thirty-seven were males, and 7 were females. The right leg was injured in 30 children, and the left in 13. Twenty one were seated behind the rider, and 6 in front of him. Most children were injured in the afternoon and between April and September. Twenty six injured the antero-medial aspect of the ankle and lateral calcaneal region. Twenty nine children had deep abrasions, 11 had abrasion with skin defect, and 3 had laceration. All children had edema and ecchymosis. Eighteen children had fractures. Greenstick fracture of the distal and fibula with anterior and varus angulation was observed in 6 cases. Hospital stay ranged 2–12 days. All fractures were treated non-operatively and healed uneventfully. Soft tissue injuries healed well largely by secondary intention within up to 9 weeks.

Conclusions: Bicycle spoke injury may lead to considerable morbidity and prolonged healing time. The mechanism of injury and management are discussed. The injury may be initially underestimated due to deceptively mild appearance. The prognosis is determined mainly by soft-tissue damage. Preventive measures include ergonomic changes like installing special carriers and spoke-guards.


T. Amichai Z. Dvir H. Patish L. Copeliovitch S. Bar-Haim M. Koren N. Harries

Background: Only a few studies have investigated the change in energy cost and functional ability after lower limb bone surgeries in children with cerebral palsy (CP).

Research Objectives: To examine the effect of intervention (surgery) in the operated group over time on: Energy cost values, Walking functions, and on Functional mobility.

Setting: Motion analysis laboratory and the child development and rehabilitation center at Assaf Harofeh Medical Center.

Methods: Participants in the study consisted of 41 children with CP. The study consisted of two groups: one that had undergone surgery (the operated group) and a control group. The operated group consisted of 20 children with CP who were candidates for Femoral Derotation Osteotomy (FDO) or Tibial Derotation Osteotomy (TDO), or both. They were examined three times: the first was one day prior to surgery; the second was six months after surgery; and the third was about a year after surgery. Each examination included: anthropometric measurements, energy cost measurement using the Heart beat cost index (HBCI) in the stair climbing test, assessment of function during walking using the Functional assessement questionnaire (FAQ) and assessment of motor function using the Gross motor functional classification system (GMFCS). Control group consisted of 21 children with CP in ages compatible to the operated group, who had not been operated during the passing year. The control group was examined two times, the second a year after the first. The examination was the same as in the operated group.

Main Results: In the operated group, a significant change (p< 0.0076) was observed in energy cost values over time following surgical intervention. The change was indicated in decreasing energy cost values from measurement to measurement (from value of 0.91 to value of 0.48). Significant decrease was found in the third measurement, as compared to the first measurement (p=0.0026). In the control group, a decrease, although not significant (p=0.062) was observed in energy cost values. Angles values measured in both hip and tibia a year after surgery were changed significantly (p< 0.004). Angles values after surgery were measured within normal range.

Conclusions: This study indicates that the FDO and TRO have effected over time on the energy cost values in the operated group.


G. Bialik M. Sussman

The iliopsoas is considered a major deforming force causing hip flexion deformity in children with cerebral palsy. Although iliopsoas release at the lesser trochanter is thought by many clinicians to cause excessive hip flexor weakness, we believe that it does not produce iatrogenic hip flexion weakness. We were unable to find a study in the literature that objectively studied this issue. Included in the study were 25 patients, all ambulators with cerebral palsy (any type). They underwent iliopsoas release at the lesser trochanter and multiple surgeries (soft tissue with or without bony procedures). Mean age at surgery was 11.4 years.

Motion analysis was performed to all patients prior to surgery and one year post-op. Hip and knee range of motion was improved with out significant decrease in hip flexion power. Maximum hip extension improved, no change in maximum and total flexion power generation was found. As expected, hip range of motion was improved significantly. We proved that when releasing the iliopsoas at the lesser trochanter, the change in power generation is statistically insignificant, as shown by maximum and total hip power generation in swing phase.


U. Givon N. Sher-Lurie Am Schindler

Objective: To review our results with hip joint reconstruction in severe spastic hip disease.

Design: Descriptive case series.

Setting: A tertiary referral medical center.

Subjects: All the patients who underwent a hip reconstruction procedure because of SHD were retrospectively evaluated. Twenty-five patients with 32 involved femoral necks were treated between 1997 and 2003. All of the patients had a migration index greater than 40% with 8 of them having a migration index of over 65%. 15 patients had total involvement type CP and 10 patients had diplegic type CP.

Intervention: Hip joint reconstruction comprised of varus derotation osteotomy and a periacetabular osteotomy such as the Dega osteotomy, and when necessary an open reposition of the hip joint was performed.

Results: Good coverage of the femoral head was achieved in 23 of the patients and in 30 of the femoral heads. There was no difference between the high migration index group and the low migration index group. In two cases progressive posterior dislocation continued following the operation, attributed to incomplete correction of the posterior acetabulum. One patient had an intra-operative fracture of the femoral neck. The results were similar in the more severe and less severe groups.

Conclusions: Hip reconstruction has favorable results in all types of CP. We found no difference between the group with high migration index and the low migration index concerning complications and outcome. A high migration index should not be considered as reason not to reconstruct the hip joint. The only contraindication for this procedure is osteoarthritic changes of the hip joint.


M. Eidelman N. Hos V. Bialik A. Katzman

Introduction: The standard treatment of displaced supracondylar fractures of the distal humerus in children is closed reduction and pin fixation, but the optimal pin configuration is controversial. Crossed-pin fixation of the humerus is mechanically more stable than any other kind of pin configuration, but this fixation may cause iatrogenic ulnar nerve injury. Many authors recommended fixation from the lateral side in order to eliminate this complication. Since 1999, we have been using a 3-pinfixation technique with insertion of the first two pins with the elbow in full flexion, followed by insertion of the third wire through the medial side with the elbow in full extension. We call this the “flexion-extension cross-pinning technique”.

Method: This is a retrospective review of 64 displaced supracondylar fractures fixed by flexion-extension cross pinning.

Results: Eleven children had Gartland type 2 fractures and 53 children had Gartland type 3 fractures. There was no iatrogenic ulnar neve palsy. Loss of reduction in two children was related to technical errors. One patient had superficial pin tract infection.

Conclusion: We feel that this technique and pins configuration is safe and easy to learn. It has become the standard method of fixation of displaced supracondylar fractures in our institution.


M. Yaniv E. Segev S. Wientroub E. Ezra

Background: Congenital dislocation of the patella can cause significant functional disability and is often associated with limb deformity in childhood. Two types or clinical manifestations of this condition have been previously described, namely the fixed lateral dislocation and the habitual or obligatory dislocation of the patella. Few surgical procedures have been suggested for the treatment of the complex condition.

Objective: We reviewed our surgical approach in ten knees (seven children) with both types of patellar dislocation, and evaluated the clinical and functional outcomes.

Methods: All our patients underwent an extensive sub-periosteal mobilization of the extensor mechanism from the lateral side of the thigh combined anteriorly with plication of the medial patellar retinaculum. This procedure was supplemented by medialization of half of patellar tendon in the skeletally immature patients, and by tibial tuberosity transfer that was performed in one skeletally mature patient.

Results: In six children, patellar dislocation was a part of a diagnosed syndrome, namely Down (3 patients), Larsen (1 patient), Rubinstein-Taybi (1 patient) and fibular hemimelia (1 patient). Six knees had fixed type and four (all Down syndrome) had obligatory type of patellar dislocation. Average age at surgery was 9.5 years (range 3.5–14) and the mean follow-up period was 19 months (range 7–33). There was no recurrence during the follow-up period. Two children with Down syndrome, who had flexion contraction and were non-ambulatory, began to walk three months and five months after the surgery. A significant resolution of the valgus deformities was obtained in the operated knees. Two complications were recorded, an undisplaced supracondylar fracture following removal of plastic cast and transitory peroneal nerve palsy.

Conclusions: Abnormal anatomical muscular and bony changes, soft tissue structural changes and limb alignment contribute to patellar dislocation and to subsequent clinical deterioration and deformity progression. Our surgical intervention aimed to realign the extensor mechanism and was effective in treating both types of congenital dislocation of the patella. Based on our experience, the long-standing habitual dislocation is accompanied by changes in the extensor mechanism of the knee that are similar to those occurring in the fixed patellar dislocation and therefore should be addressed surgically in a similar manner.


E. Mercado E. Cohen N. Alkrinawi D. Atar

Introduction: Fracture of the lateral condyle of distal humerus in the pediatric population is a common problem. In children less than 13 year the distal humerus is only partially ossified and it is sometimes impossible to assess whether a fracture extends to the articular surface of distal humerus and whether or not there is a step off. Classic recommendations were to perform an open reduction in order to ensure perfect reduction. There are sporadic reports on use of arthrography or MRI studies

Aim of the Study: Retrospective study- intended to evaluate the clinical and radiographic outcome in children in whom the articular surface of distal humerus was evaluated by arthrography . Uppon arthrography results undisplaced fractures were percutaneously pinned and displaced fractures underwent formal open reduction and internal fixation.

Patients and Methods: 11 children mean age 7.8 (1.5–15) were enrolled in the study. Inclusion criteria was a fracture of lateral condyle of humerus suspected to be type II according to Jakob (the fracture is complete but is not diplaced out of the elbow joint). The mean follow up was 2.4y (13m-5.2y). Range of motion. Carrying angle were and neurovascular status were noted and compared with controlateral elbow. Actual X-rays were reviewed.

Results: The patient sample represent around 8% of the whole number of children treated in our Institution during 2000–2005. In 7 patients we were able to avoid open reduction and still to achieve excellent results. In 4 cases that were finally managed by open reduction the intraoperative findings fitted the arthrographic findings.

In Conclusion: Arthrography may prevent unnecessary open reductions for lateral condyle fractures in children.