header advert
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 84-B, Issue SUPP_I March 2002

P.F.R.G. de Muelenaere

There is little in the recent literature about the place of low molecular weight heparin (LMWH) in routine lumbosacral surgery.

This study aimed to determine firstly the risk of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) if Clexane was not given preoperatively, and secondly the complications associated with the use of the drug.

In a prospective study undertaken from January 2001 to April 2001, 64 patients scheduled for routine lumbosacral surgery were entered. We excluded patients with a high risk of DVT. The mean age of patients was 51 years (16 to 75). Patients were randomly selected to receive Endoxaparin (Clexane) preoperatively the night before (38 patients in group 1) or Clexane postoperatively (26 patients in group

2). All patients were evaluated by Doppler sonography pre-operatively, four days postoperatively and at six weeks. Blood loss was monitored intra-operatively and postoperatively. Clexane was administered only for eight days. Posterior lumbosacral spinal procedures only were done on 44 patients, while seven had combined anterior-posterior surgery and 13 anterior procedures only.

Mean intra-operative and postoperative blood losses in group 1 were twice those in group 2, and patients in group 1 tended to bleed for longer. Two cases of partial thrombosis were seen, both group 1. In group 1 intraspinal haematoma formation was seen in four patients, two of whom required additional surgery.

LMWH should not be given preoperatively for routine spinal cases. In fact, it is contra-indicated.


D. Koekemoer P.W. Kruger Pretoria

A retrospective study was done on the outcome of supracondylar femoral fractures treated with retrograde or supracondylar intramedullary nails.

Between January 1998 and December 2000, 69 patients were treated with Russell Taylor nails, 30 at Kalafong Hospital and 39 at Pretoria Academic Hospital. Injuries had resulted from motor vehicle accidents in 27 patients, from falls in 32 and from gunshots in 10. There were 13 open fractures and 14 patients had multiple injuries, including three head injuries and two vascular injuries. Using the AO classification, 40 fractures were graded type A and 29 type C. The mean age of the 18 female and 51 males was 45 years (17 to 90). Senior registrars performed the surgery. In all cases, the knee was opened for the procedure. Four patients died from their injuries.

The mean time to union was 13 weeks. Four patients had poor range of motion. Complications included two cases of superficial sepsis and three of deep sepsis. There were two cases of delayed union and three of fixation failure. In one patient the fixation impinged on the patella.

We find this a good way of treating supracondylar femoral fractures.


V. Pointillart O. Gille F. Vardier M. Pedram Ph. Bacon

Purpose: Access to the cervicothoracic junction is difficult both via a posterior and via an anterior approach. Tumour localisations or more rarely trauma however require access. Using the posterior approach, anterior decompression is limited by the narrow access and the vulnerability of the cord. Anterior reconstruction is impossible. Using the pure anterior approach, fixation and decompression of the caudal component is limited. Preoperative MRI shows the respective position of the manubrium sternal and the diseased vertebra, allowing a clear surgical strategy. To avoid sternotomy or even partial cleidectomy, both causes of postoperative pain and complications, we developed a medial sternal resection maintaining the stability of the sternoclavicular joints and allowing spinal decompression by corporectomy to T3 and fixation to T4.

Material and methods: A left anterolateral cervical approach was used to avoid injury to the recurrent nerve. This is a classical cervical approach generally used for access to C7-T1. It is prolonged caudally a few centimetres on the mid line to reach the anterior aspect of the sternum. After section of the sternohyoid, sternothyroid and scapulohyoid muscles, the three upper centimetres of the sternum are resected with a microdrill over a width of two centimetres. This give direct access to the anterior walls of T3 and T4. The lower limit of the exposure is described by the aortic arch (except in patients with severe kyphosis). The left brachiocephalic venous trunk is the crucial element situated just horizontally behind the sternum and protected by fat and fibrous tissue. It is important to release this trunk precautiously because injury at this level is difficult to suture and would require ligature (this is still possible if necessary but would lead to oedema of the left arm by defective drainage). After releasing the vein, the resection of the posterior wall of the sternum is completed with a Kerrison gouge. This gives a U-shaped groove that does not destabilise the sternoclavicular articulations and allows retraction of the vessels to expose the vertebral bodies. Screw fixation of T4 is possible, generally with slightly descending screws. The classical closure method is used.

Results: We have operated 13 patients with tumours or fractures using this approach (five T4, seven T3, one T2). Corporectomy was performed above T4. This approach did not lead to any direct complications. Postoperative pain was considered to be less than with sternotomy or cleidectomy, approaches we have now abandoned. Use of the endoscope improves visibility but the incision cannot be smaller because of the axe required for screwing. The important features of this method are the correct analysis of the preoperative relation between the target vertebra and the manubrium sternal and the dissection of the left brachiocephalic venous trunk.


B. Theilliez M.H. Fessy J. Benjui-Hugues

Purpose: We report an retrospective analysis of 33 patients with neurological para-osteo-arthroplathy of the hip who underwent surgery between 1985 and 1999.

Material and methods: Forty-three hips were operated in 33 patients aged 14 to 50 years at the time of the accident. Twenty-two patients had head trauma, two had spinal cord injury and three both. The causal mechanism was: trauma 27 patients, rupture of an inta-cranial aneurysm in five patients, widespread burns one patient. Localisations were inferome-dial 14 patients, anterior 10 patients, posterior two patients, circumferential five patients. Surgical care included complete resection in 30 cases, resection of the head and neck in six, and implantation of a total hip arthroplasty in seven. There were several perioperative accidents: two vessel injuries, two persistent bleedings, one haematoma, eight superficial infections, six recurrences, one ankylosis and one death. Functional outcome was assessed on the basis of gain in amplitude of hip flexion.

Results: Analysis was possible for 37 of the 43 hips. Outcome was good in 18 (flexion gain greater than 90°), fair in nine (flexion gain from 60 to 90°), poor in ten (flexion gain less than 60°). Complete resection gave better results (61.5%). Total hip arthroplasty gave mediocre results. The best results were obtained with resection for the inferomedial and anterior localisations.

Discussion: The decision for surgery should be discussed in light of the objectives to be achieved. We present our surgical strategy as a function of the localisation. We advocate systematic verification of the vascularisation and prefer the obturator approach for inferomedial localisations. The risk of recurrence depends on the delay from the accident to surgery.

Conclusion: Based on this retrospective series, we prefer surgical resection after the first year. We emphasise the importance of peroperative verification of the vascularisation.


P. Fleming N. Bermingham M. Fehily R. Khan M. Yousef G. Fenelon J. O’Leary

Background: Non-union of fractures is a common problem faced by orthopaedic surgeons. Although the basic processes of fracture healing have been better elucidated in recent years, in terms of their cellular and molecular biology, the pathogenesis of fracture non-union remains poorly understood.

Aims: To examine the pattern of cytokine expression in established non-unions, in particular the inflammatory cytokines interleukin 1 and tumour necrosis factor alpha.

Materials and Methods: Tissue was taken from 7 non united fractures at the time of a surgical procedure aimed at effecting union. Part of the tissue was snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen, and a portion of the sample was processed for routine histology. Normal bone tissue was taken from the femoral shaft at the time of arthoplasty, to provide normal control tissue. Total RNA was extracted from the frozen tissue by means of a mortar and pestle and a modified phenol-chloroform extraction protocol. Cytokine expression patterns were examined using the Cytokine Gene Expression plate I (PE Biosystems) and analysed using the Sequence Detection Software and Microsoft Excel.

Results: A consistent pattern of cytokine expression was seen in all non-union tissue samples. There was marked suppression of interleukin 1 beta, interleukin 8, interleukin 10 and TNF-alpha when compared to resting bone. This environment is thus one where the stimulus for bone resorption is suppressed, with consequent loss of stimulation of bone formation (theory of “bone coupling”), directly and also possibly through interaction with prostaglandin production. In addition, collagen production is stimulated preferentially. These findings argue against the traditional definitions of fracture non-union, and suggest a possible adjunctive role for the administration of interleukins in the treatment of non-united fractures.


B.N. Perry B.G.P. Lindeque

The worldwide increase in the resistance of micro-organisms to antimicrobial drugs leads to an increase in morbidity, mortality and health care costs. It is important to identify the resistant organisms, to provide alternative antibiotic treatment protocols and to identify the high-risk infection areas.

We undertook a retrospective study of 693 musculoskeletal infections seen in the Musculoskeletal Tumour and Sepsis Unit of Pretoria Academic Hospital over five years, capturing data relating to the microscopy, culture and sensitivity to antimicrobial drugs of micro-organisms from tissue samples and pus swabs.

Most infections developed in patients aged 31 to 40 years. Sepsis most often occurred postoperatively. The next most common sepsis followed trauma. The femur was the most common site, followed by the tibia and the knee. In descending order, the most common organisms isolated were Staphylococcus aureus, Staphylococcus epidermidis, Pseudomonas sp., Escherichia coli, Enterobacter sp.

In the last two years there was an alarming increase in coagulase-negative staphylococci. All micro-organisms exhibited increased resistance to specific antimicrobial drugs over the five-year period.


O. Gille V. Pointillart J.M. Vital

Purpose: The long Arnold nerve can be compressed at several sites. We analysed retrospectively eight patients who underwent surgery for Arnold’s neuralgia between January 1998 and June 2000. The purpose of our analysis was to determine the results of the neurolysis technique.

Material and methods: There were seven women and one man, mean age 52 years. Pain had progressed for more than one year (mean 3.5 years) and all patients had participated in long rehabilitation programmes. All had had at least one radioguided posterior injection at the C1–C2 level. Bilateral neurolysis was performed for patients with bilateral pain. The same surgical technique was used for all patients: desinsertion of the inferior oblique muscle from the lateral aspect of C2 and neurolysis of the posterior branch of C2 to the lower border of the inferior oblique muscle. When needed because of major osteoarthritis, C1–C2 fusion was achieved by posterior lacing.

Results: There were no per or postoperative complications. Neuralgia improved in all patients (70/100 to 20/100 on visual analogue scale). Pain relief was considerable for one female patient who had associated C1–C2 osteoarthritis. One patient complained of posterior joint pain at last follow-up. an anatomic cause of the compression was identified in three cases: osteophyte on the posterior part of the C1-C2 articulation, hypertrophy of the periradicular venous plexus, and passage of the Arnold nerve within the inferior oblique muscle with compression in a fibromuscular sheath.

Discussion: Several methods have been proposed to relieve Arnold’s neuralgia. Rehabilitation exercises and injections should, in our opinion, be attempted first. The Sturniolo procedure (unique desinsertion of the inferior oblique muscle) would be insufficient. We prefer to associate neurolysis at the C2 level because of the frequently associated anatomic anomalies.

Conclusion: Different sites can be involved in the compression of the Arnold nerve, warranting associated neurolysis.


P. Rossouw

During the last four years the author has used extracorporeal shock wave therapy (ESWT) to treat tendonoses, including 82 cases of tennis elbow, 108 cases of plantar fasciitis and 42 cases of related conditions. Treatment is administered in the consulting room without analgesia. This paper discusses the protocol used in selected cases.

In 78% of cases, overall subjective and objective results were good to excellent, in 15% fair. In only 17% was the result poor, with no improvement. No cases of degeneration were encountered. There were few complications and these were minor. Because of the obvious clinical benefits in selected cases, this new modality of orthopaedic treatment is still being used daily after four years.


P.Y. Glas B. Seutin M.H. Fessy

Purpose: Among 80 surgical treatments for acetabular fracture, the Dana Mears approach was used in 15. The purpose of this study was to analyse functional and radiological outcome of these fractures at a mean follow-up of 41 months.

Material and methods: The AO classification was used for fractures of the acetabulum : 12 class B (80%) with five B1a2 five B2a1 and two B1a1, and three class C (20%). There was one deformed callus (B1a2) at 120 days Two patients had associated pelvic injuries, eight a hip dislocation, and two an initial sciatic palsy. There were also two osteochondral fractures of the femoral head. The Dana Mears approach was modified slightly in the anterior part passing in front of the tensor muscle to preserve innervation. The gluteal muscles were raised by trochanterotomy. The displacement, the head/ roof congruency and the head/acetabulum congruency were assessed according to the 1981 SOFCOT criteria on the initial x-rays (AP pelvis, oblique ala and obturator) and computed tomographies. The quality of the reduction was assessed with the Matta and Duquesnoy-Senegas criteria. Clinical results were assessed with the Postel Merle d’Aubigné (PMA) score.

Results: Radiographically, there was an anatomic reduction in 73.3% of the cases and perfect head/roof congruency in 80%. Functional outcome was excellent or good in 80% of the patients. Postoperative complications included 11 ossifications, and one transient sciatic paralysis. There was one late aseptic osteonecrosis of the femoral head.

Discussion: The functional prognosis of these fractures is significantly correlated with the quality of reduction (p < 0.05). The advantage of this approach is the direct access to the roof without disinsertion of the gluteal muscles from the iliac crest, allowing more rapid recovery (seven to eight months) of medius gluteus function. In principal drawback is the very high rate of ossifications (one patient required revision for arthrolysis).

Conclusion: The Dana Mears triradiate approach is an integral part of the surgical treatment of acetabular fractures, particularly for B1a2 and B2a1 fractures, but also for B1a1 transtectal fractures. Conversely, this approach is insufficient for reduction of type C fractures requiring and extensive access to the iliac wing and for surgery of deformed calluses where an endopelvic approach is indispensable to control the vessels.


J.V. Lunn P. Gallagher D. Boucher-Hayes P. Murray

Osteoarthritis of the hip exhibits progressive degeneration of articular cartilage frequently resulting in total hip arthroplasty (THA). Expression of cytokines such as tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) and interleukin 6 (IL6) is increased in the synovium and articular cartilage of these patients. Furthermore, these cytokines have been shown to have a negative regulatory effect on chondrocyte proliferation and articular cartilage metabolism. We investigated the frequency of a G/C polymorphism at position −174 of the promoter region of the IL-6 gene and a G/A polymorphism at position −308 of the TNF alpha gene, both of which cause increased expression of these cytokines. We observed that the G variant of the IL6 gene was significantly higher in patients who had undergone revision THA compared to controls (P=0.05). It was also elevated in primary THA patients compared to controls. The G/A polymorphism in TNF alpha was not significantly associated with THA; however, this may reflect the lower incidence of this polymorphism in the population. These results suggest that an alteration in cytokine expression produced by the IL6 −174G/C mutation may have a role in the aetiology of osteoarthritis and the outcome of total hip arthroplasty.


H. Mullett A. Laing W. Curtin

Introduction: Cement removal in revision total hip arthroplast;y can be technically challenging. Traditional methods can be associated with femoral fracture or uncontrolled cortical perforation and bone loss. A new technique has been developed tha.t permits segmental extraction of bone cement from the femoral canal. Fresh cement is introduced into the old cement mantle and a threaded rod is placed into the wet cement and held in place while the cement hardens. The thread-forming rod is then removed leaving a threaded channel in the cement. Extraction rods are then screwed 1.5 to 2.5 cm into the threaded channel. A slap hammer, which attaches to the opposite end of the extraction rod, is used to remove 1.5- to 2.5-cm segments of cement. The old cement – cancellous bone interface fails before the new-old cement interface and the old/new cement is removed in segments. This allows minimal removal of cancellous bone.

Patients and Methods: Patients who had contra-indications to segmental cement removal such a discontinuous cement mantle were excluded. Twenty-five consecutive cases of revision arthroplasty were entered into the study. The indications were for aseptic loosening in twenty-three cases and deep infection in two cases.

Results: In twenty-two cases the cement was removed completely. In five cases the cement was removed en-bloc in one single extraction rather then in segments. In two cases there was failure of the new cement to bond to the original cement and alternative methods were used. In a further case the cement was removed using a combination of segmental and conventional techniques. There were no cases of cortical perforations or perforaltions in this series. We have found it to be a reliable and safe method of cement removal. The cost of the system is offset by reduced operative time and blood loss.


G.Rh. Owen D.O. Meredith I. ap Gwynn R.G. Richards

A non-invasive technique for labelling S phase osteoblasts in vitro following immunolabelling of their focal adhesions is proposed. Quantification of cell adhesion area in the S phase (where the cells are most spread) of the cell cycle is then possible with a scanning electron microscope (SEM).

Primary calvarial osteoblasts (isolated by migration) were cultured on plastic and implant quality metal discs. S-phase cells were labelled by a pulse of 3H thymidine in the culture medium for 30 min. Cells were cultured for a further 2h in normal media before being processed for immunogold labelling of vinculin. Briefly, cells were permeabilised and fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde. Non specific binding sites were blocked for 30 min. Cells were incubated with mouse anti vinculin for 1h before rinsing and blocking with 5% goat serum for 30 min. Secondary incubation was with goat anti mouse 5nm gold conjugate for 2h. After rinsing, cells were permanently fixed with 2.5% glutaraldehyde. For SEM visualisation, the gold label was enhanced with gold enhance solutions. Postfixation and staining was performed with osmium tetroxide. Samples were dehydrated and critically point dried. The discs were carbon coated and covered with a thin layer of photographic emulsion in a dark room and left in a light tight box at 4°C for 7 days before developing the emulsion.

Backscattered electron imaging with the SEM revealed silver grains on the nuclei of S-phase cells, produced by the interaction of radioactive emissions, from the labelled DNA, and the photographic emulsion. Immunolabelled focal adhesions were also observed at higher magnifications on the same cells.

This combination of autoradiography and high resolution SEM removes cell cycle variability, which has been a problem with previous in vitro adhesion studies. This method will be applied to quantify osteoblast cell adhesion to various implant materials to evaluate cell/implant interactions.


A. Pagnotta N. Specchia A. Gigante A. Toesca

The changes occurring in ligamentum flavum in lumbar spine stenosis are a matter of long–standing controversy. More recently, some studies showed that the posterior spinal structures, including hypertrophied ligamentum flavum, play a major role in the pathogenesis of the lumbar stenosis.

To investigate the pathogenesis of the degenerative changes of the ligamentum flavum occurring in lumbar spine stenosis, yellow ligament cells from patients with lumbar spine stenosis were cultured for the first time and subjected to biochemical, histochemical and immunohistochemical study.

Samples of ligamentum flavum were collected from 4 patients undergoing surgery for lumbar stenosis (mean age 47.2 years). Cell cultures were obtained from each patient and maintained in Dulbecco’s modified essential medium-10% fetal calf serum. Cell characterization was histochemically (Gomori’s and von Kossa staining), immunohistochemically (anti-type I, -type II, -type III and -type X collagen, anti-S100 protein, anti-fibronectin, anti-osteonectin and anti-osteocalcin), biochemically (cAMP activity after human parathyroid hormone stimulation) assessed. Samples collected from 2 age-matched patients who underwent surgery for lumbar fractures were used as controls.

Stenotic ligamentum flavum cells expressed high levels of alkaline phosphatase activity and produced a mineralized matrix rich in type I, type III and type X collagen, fibronectin, osteonectin, and osteocalcin. Stimulation with parathyroid hormone increased intracellular cAMP concentration. These findings indicate that there was significant evidence of osteoblast-like activity in these cells. Staining for type II and type X collagen, and S-100 protein reflected the proliferation of hypertrophic chondrocyte-like cells, confirmed with the co-localization of alkaline phosphatase and collagen type II. Cultures from control patients showed nor hypertrophic chondrocytic nor osteoblastic features. Our data demonstrated the presence of hypertrophic chondrocytes with an osteoblast-like activity in human stenotic ligamentum flavum. The osteoblast-like activity could have a role in the pathophysiology of the heterotopic ossification of ligamentum flavum in lumbar spine stenosis.


A. Hersan L. Pidhorz

Purpose: Bilateral hip disease is a common finding. For patients in good general health the question is whether total hip arthroplasty should be performed on both sides during the same operation or whether a deferred strategy would be better. We compared 24 patients (48 hips) to determine the relative advantages of these two treatment strategies.

Material and methods: Two treatment groups were formed: the first group (group A) was a prospective series of 12 patients who underwent total hip arthroplasty for both hips during the same operation between January 1992 and September 1999; the second group (group B) was composed of 12 patients who had total hip arthroplasty for both hips implanted during two different operations separated by at least one year and chosen by random selection among patients operated during the same period as group A patients. Group A was composed of five women and seven men, mean age 48.4 years (23–67). Group B was composed of five women and seven men, mean age 60 years (50–75). Pressfit cups were used in both groups (except one in group A). The femoral stem was cemented in seven patients in group A and in five in group B. Peroperative data (transfusion, complications, anaesthesia agents, duration of anaesthesia and operation) and post-operative data (transfusions, blood loss, haemoglobin, temperature curve, hospital stay, drugs, early and late complications, radiologic findings) were studied. LWMH was given prophylactically and all patients had a duplex Doppler exploration before discharge. All patients were reviewed regularly: mean follow-up was 5.75 years (2–9) in group A and 6.42 years (2.33–8.5) in group B.

Results: We added the two hospitalisations for group B patients. Mean duration of the operation was 6h in group A and 4h22m in group B. Anaestheia lasted 7h in group A and 6h16min in group B. Blood transfusions amounted to 5.27 packed cell units and 3.09 fresh frozen plasma units in group A, 4.75 and 2.83 respectively in group B. Blood loss was 1439 cc in group A and 1642 cc in group B. Haemoglobin and temperature curves were similar between the two groups. There were two cases of postoperative phlebitis in group A and one revision procedure on day 9 for haematoma in group B. There were no cases of infection. Mean hospital stay was 14.66 days in group A and 22.5 days in group B. Radiographs did not show evidence of loosening.

Discussion: The results obtained in our two series are similar to other reports in the literature (Eggle 1996, Shih 1985). Per- and postoperative complications were not more frequent for one or two procedures. Hospitalisation stays were much shorter in group A patients, providing an important cost savings (34.8% for simultaneous implantations).

Conclusion: Bilateral total hip arthroplasty during a single operation offers an advantage in terms of hospital stay and overall cost. Comparison with two different operations shows that complications are not more frequent. Inversely, work stoppage is shorter, making this strategy particularly interesting for younger patients.


B.G.P. Lindeque

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the safety of liquid collagen and cross-linked collagen in treating bone defects.

In a prospective trial, the use of liquid collagen and a stiffer, slightly more rigid cross-linked collagen allograft was evaluated. Bone cavities resulting from curettage of cysts or tumours were filled with either liquid or cross-linked collagen. The collagen was extracted from donor allograft and mixed with minute particles of crushed cortical bone. Patients were monitored clinically, radiologically and haematologically for complications, including infection, rejection or allergic reactions.

There were five patients with osteoid osteoma, five with chondrosarcoma, two with bone cysts, five with osteitis and three with chondroblastoma. One patient each had enchondroma, ossifying fibroma, osteosarcoma, aneurysmal bone cyst, fibrous dysplasia, thickening of the tibial cortex, avascular necrosis, Ewing’s sarcoma, a luxstacortical ganglion and a tumour of the pubic symphysis. Eleven patients received liquid collagen and 32 cross-linked collagen. The use of liquid collagen was abandoned because it was too fluid to keep in the cavity. The cross-linked collagen, though more solid, could be introduced even through small holes in a bone or spinal cages. No allergic reactions occurred and the bone graft behaved similarly to a combination of allograft/autogenous graft.

Cross-linked collagen is as effective as any other allogenic bone product in bone cavities. In this series there were no complications attributable to the graft.


I Pallister

Background: Neutrophil (PMN) infiltration of the lung is characteristic of ARDS. Interleukin-8 (IL-8) plays a central role in the recruitment of PMN to the lung and their subsequent activation. This study examines PMN migratory activity in response to IL-8, over the first 24 hours of admissions following major trauma.

Methodology: Study Population: Adult blunt trauma victims with ISS> /=18

PMN Migraoty Activity: PMN were isolated from citrated blood at admission, 8 and 24 hours later. The number of PMN migrating across porous tissue culture inserts in response to defined concentrations of IL-8 (zero, 10, 30 & 100ng/ml) were quantitated by peroxidase assay.

Results: Significantly greater numbers of trauma patients PMN migrated to concentrations of IL-8 (30& 100ng/ml) at each time point, when compared to normal volunteers (Mann-Whitney-U Test p< 0.05). At admissions, and 8 hours later, PMN from those who later developed ARDS exhibit an enhanced migratory response to high concentrations of IL-8, in contrast to the noraml physiological attenuation of migration seen in both the remaining trauma patients (NAD) and normal volunteers (NLV).

Discussion: These data indicate that major trauma fundamentally alters the migratory capacity of circulating PMN. Within 2 hours of admission, PMN show a unique pattern of activation in those who later develop ARDS, possibly due to alteration in IL-8 receptor expression, affinity or downstream signalling. These findings suggest that limiting PMN sequestration in the lung may represent a novel therapeutic target.


A.H. Parbhoo S. Govender K.P.S. Kumar

Fractures and fracture dislocations involving the lower lumbar spine and lumbosacral junction are uncommon. These high velocity injuries are often associated with neurological deficit, incontinence and dural tears. The accepted treatment has been posterior stabilisation with fusion, but loss of reduction has often been reported.

We reviewed our experience over the past four years in the management of eight male patients, two of whom sustained injuries in motor vehicle accidents and two in falls from a height. Two patients had L5/S1 traumatic spondylo-listhesis with no neurological deficit. Of the six patients with fracture dislocations of L3/4, four had translation in the sagittal and coronal planes and incomplete neurological deficit. Associated injuries in four patients included an ankle fracture, multiple rib fractures, dislocation of knee and hip, and a fracture dislocation of the midfoot.

Following satisfactory reduction, seven patients were treated by posterior spinal fusion (PSF) with instrumentation. One patient had anterior decompression, strut-grafting and posterior instrumentation. Three patients had dural tears.

In three patients treated by single segment PSF, reduction was not maintained. The maintenance of alignment was attributed to stable facet joints in one patient, two-segment instrumentation in three, and anterior strut grafting in one. One patient developed postoperative wound sepsis, which settled after repeated debridement and antibiotic treatment. Symptoms of nerve root compression improved in two of the four patients with neurological deficit.

Posterior reduction and instrumentation alone did not maintain reduction in these severe injuries. Anterior column support and multisegmental instrumentation may be required where there is marked vertebral body compression and neurological deficit.


A.J. Farrin

Systematic reviews show beneficial effects of spinal manipulation, general exercise, and ‘active management’. A national randomised factorial trial in primary care (UK BEAM trial) was designed to evaluate the effectiveness of these treatments for back pain. We will present the characteristics of participants recruited into the trial and preliminary health outcomes at one and three months.

Back pain patients, recruited from over 150 UK practices, were randomised to receive GP management, exercise classes, manipulation (either in NHS or private premises) or both manipulation and exercise classes. At one, three and twelve months, participants completed postal questionnaires which included questions about general health, experience of back pain, beliefs about back pain, psychological profile, functional disability and costs to both the NHS and the participants themselves.

The trial recruited 1334 participants, of which 84% and 77% completed one and three month questionnaires respectively. At randomisation, the mean Roland Disability Questionnaire (RDQ) score was 9.0 points (sd=4.0). This improved to 6.8 points (sd=4.8) at one month and to 5.5 points (sd=5.0) at three months.

Preliminary blinded results show an improvement in RDQ scores across all participants. The primary analysis, available late in 2002, will estimate the main effects of exercise and manipulation, each compared to GP care.


P. Boisrenoult S. Bricteux P. Beaufils P. Hardy

Purpose of the study: We compared in vitro the efficacy of screw-plate fixation versus double screw fixation on a model of type 2 Schatzker fracture of the lateral tibial plateau.

Materials and methods: Ten screw-plate fixations using a lateral prebent plate and 10 double-screw fixations (6.5 mm screws) were made on 10 pairs of non-embalmed cadaver knees after simulation of type 2 Schatzker fractures. The strength of each fixation was tested with a compression device. Criteria indicating failure were displacements greater than 2 mm of one or more fracture lines. The force applied at rupture and the stiffness of each type of fixation were compared. Wilcoxon’s test was used for statistical analysis.

Results: Force at rupture and stiffness of the fixation were similar for the two types of fixation. There was no statistical difference (p > 0.05) between the screw-plate and the double-screw fixations.

Discussion: Our findings on a model of type 2 Schatzker fractures are in agreement with previous data obtained by other authors working on models of type 1 Schatsker fractures. The biomechanical stability of the double-screw fixation is as good as that obtained with screw-plate fixation for the treatment of fractures of the lateral tibial plateau.


A. Lespargot M. Robert N. Khouri

Purpose of the study: Equinus in patients with cerebral palsy results from at least two factors: excessive contracture of the triceps surae and muscle retraction. Tendon surgery and progressive lengthening techniques using plaster walking boots can provide variable improvement in retraction. We compared the effect of this technique when applied with or without prior 40°C warming in the same patients. We also assessed the efficacy of this treatment method in terms or degree of retraction, patient age, puberty maturity, and sex.

Materials and methods: This series included 70 muscles in 52 patients with cerebral palsy aged 2 years 11 months to 21 years (mean 8 years 3 months). Common features in these patients were: equinus mainly explained by triceps retraction, no history of prior surgery on the triceps tendon, knee flexion less than 15° in the upright position, easily reduced lateral deformation of the foot, absence of mediotarsal dislocation, triceps stretching could be achieved without triggering unacceptably intense contracture.

The retraction of the triceps surae was measured from the maximal passive dorsal flexion angle of the foot, before and after applying each stretching boot. The difference between these measurements gave the gain obtained with the plaster boot. Protocol R− (stretching with plaster boot) consisted in a series of slow stretchings for 10 minutes before making the boot which was worn 7 days. Recurrent retraction in these same patients warranted another treatment within a delay of 3 to 17 months (mean delay 8.7 months). The same treatment then followed protocol R+ where the stretching was preceded by immersion of the segment in a 40°C water bath for 10 minutes.

Results: Mean gain obtained with protocol R+ (warming) was 6.8° knee extended and 7.1° knee flexed. These differences were highly significant in both cases (p < 0.0001). We had no failures with protocol R+ while with protocol R− (stretching without warming) the gain was nil or less than 5° for 29 muscles knee extended and for 32 muscles, knee flexed. The gain was not related to age, sex or puberty maturity. It was not related to the angle of dorsal flexion of the foot prior to stretching.

Discussion: Our findings demonstrate that when the conditions allowing prolonged stretching of the triceps surae are present, prior warming at 40°C for 10 minutes leads to an improvement in muscle lengthening in all patients, even in those for whom prior treatment had been unsuccessful without warming. This observation would indicate that the mechanisms allowing greater lengthening are present in all patients with cerebral palsy but that they cannot be triggered due to abnormal muscle viscosity related to distal vasomotor disorders frequently observed in this condition. Further research is needed to detail this point.


F. Schernberg B. Nurbel A. Harisboure M. Lawane

Purpose: This retrospective analysis was performed to determine the long-term usefulness of carpectomy and to define prognostic factors.

Material and methods: Forty-four patients were operated. There mean age was 39.2 years, and mean follow-up was 17 years (10–35 years). Twenty-two patients had osteoarthritis, one STT, thirteen SNAC-wrist, two SLAC-wrist, and three radiocarpal osteoarthritis. The wrists were free of degenerative lesions in 22 cases: eight Kienböck disease, five longstanding perilunar dislocations, six fracture sequelae, and one rheumatoid polyarthritis. Seventeen patients had had several procedures before the present operation. The dorsal approach was used for all patients except five. Complementary styloidectomy was associated in two cases. clinical and radiological outcome was assessed at one, five and fifteen years. Factors predictie of outcome were analysed with the Student test and the Man and Whitney test.

Results: The pain score (Cooney scale 1 to 4) was 3.19 preoperatively and 1.56, 1.88 and < 2 at one, five and fifteen years respectively. Flexion amplitude improved from 44° preoperatively to 61°, 68° and 62° at one, five and fifteen years respectively. Mean grip force, compared with the other wrist was 57.5%, 75% and 64% at one, five and fifteen years. Radiographically, at fifteen years 80% of the patients had a centred capitatum on the AP view of the lunar facet. On the lateral view, 56% of the patients exhibited anterior translation of the apitatum and 37% were centred. There was a degradation of the radiocapitum space requiring revision for arthrodesis in five cases.

Discussion, conclusion: This study confirms the long-term preservation of outcome after proximal carpectomy: 89% of the patients were satisfied at fifteen years. These findings also indicate that reconstruction of recent trauma (fracture-dislocation) produces variable results. For patients with grade II or II osteoarthritis (SNAC or SLAC-wrist) carpectomy should be reserved for selected patients with occupational or sports activities not requiring grip force. For grade III wrists, carpectomy can be proposed for elderly patients with limited activity. Grade IV is a contraindication for carpectomy. We do not recommend this procedure for patients with rheumatoid arthritis or Kienböck disease.


V. Pruès-Latour M. Papaloïzos

Purpose of the study: We report a case of complete unilateral absence of the radial artery in the forearm and reviewed the pertinent literature.

Case report: An 18-year-old girl was admitted for multiple fractures after a car accident. She presented with a comminuted fracture of the left distal humerus, an open grade I fracture according to the Gustilo classification involving the right ulna and radius, a mediodiaphyseal fracture of the right femur and an open grade II fracture of the proximal and distal left tibia. After open reduction and internal fixation of the bones of the right forearm, she presented transient ischemia of her right hand, the radial pulse not being detectable at the end of surgery. An arteriography showed a complete absence of the right radial artery, which was thought to be caused by arterial thrombosis. Surgical exploration evidenced the complete absence of the radial artery.

Discussion: Absence of the radial artery is observed in radial preaxial hemimelia, in specific genetic and chromosomal disorders (Fanconi’s anemia, Holt-Oram syndrome) and in association with other malformations. Unilateral absence of the radial artery has been described in association with other vascular abnormalities such as a larger anterior interosseous artery or the presence of a medial artery. Our case presented an isolated anatomical variation of the radial artery. This vascular anomaly was asymptomatic and discovered fortuitously. The incidence of this anatomic anomaly may be underestimated in the general population.


M. Lukhele

The success of lumbar spine fusion depends on good patient selection and bone grafting technique. Instrumentation of the fusion, now popular, improves fusion rates, eliminates the need for postoperative braces and allows early mobilisation. However, the stress shielding caused by rigid internal fixation is thought to lead to osteopoenia and degeneration of adjacent segments. Theatre times, intra-operative complications and costs are increased when pedicle screw fixation is added.

This is a report of a pilot study of eight patients who had one-level fusion and unilateral instrumentation between 1998 and 2000. Theatre time, fusion rate and functional outcomes were evaluated. The minimum follow-up time was eight months. Fusion was achieved in all patients and there was no metal failure. One patient continued to have back and leg pain in spite of a solid fusion.

Although this is a small study undertaken over a short period, the results suggest that unilateral pedicle screw fixation can be safely undertaken.


Ph. Piriou F. Sagnet Ch. Garreau de Loubresse Th. Judet

Purpose: We report our experience with acetabular reconstruction using cyropreserved bone bank hemipevli without a scaffold and total hip arthroplasty for major acetabular defects. Between 1985 and 1999, among 262 acetabular reconstructions requiring massive allografts using cryopre-served bone, 20 cases were performed with hemipelvi.

Material and methods: Mean age of the population was 56 years. The acetabulum had been operated on a mean three times. The 20 defects corresponded to Paprosky grade IIIB or SOFCOT grade IV bone loss. Clinical and radiological review of the 20 hips was made at a mean five years after treatment. None of the patients was lost to follow-up. The overall Postel Merle d’Aubigné (PMA) score at last follow-up was 17 for preoperatively scores at D2, M4 and S3 respectively. The acetabular defects were major and poorly described by the conventional systems. For example, the mean height of the bony defects was about 10 cm measured from the base of the radiographic U and the superolateral rim of the remaining roof.

Results: Globally, 13 patients had not required a reoperation at last follow-up. We had one postoperative death and two early displacements as well as two infections including one haematogenous infection. The Oakeschott criteria were used to analyse the review radiographs. Aseptic lysis of the graft was observed in five cases (generally around the 13th postoperative month) that required revision; a bone graft and a supporting ring were used in all cases because more bone stock was available than for the first revision. Among the 13 cases that did not require a new procedure, there were two with an ascended graft displacing the centre of rotation about 10 mm, followed by radiographic stability. The overall functional score for these 13 hemipelvi at last follow-up was 17 demonstrating the superior functional result compared with arthroplastic resection, the only alternative for such important loss of bone stock. It is not possible to implant a large non-cemented socket in these cases. Radiographic fusion was achieved, documented in 13 cases by the development of bony bridges or disappearance of the interface with oriented lines of force. Early graft resorption does not appear to occur when a metallic scaffold is associated (Garbuz).

Discussion: In all, 19 hips still had their total arthroplasty at last follow-up (one patient with failure preferred trocahntero-iliac coaptation.

Conclusion: Due to the inefficacy of alternative methods, this mode of restoration for major bone loss of the acetabular region (which facilitates secondary revision) appears to provide satisfactory results since the probability of preserving the prosthesis at a mean five years was slightly greater than 3/5. A stronger metallic scaffold may be the solution for the future.


E.H.W. Erken

We looked at the outcome of management of 16 patients (19 limb segments) with congenital fibular hemimelia treated in our unit over a 24-year period from 1978 to 2001. Eight boys and eight girls, all with associated musculoskeletal abnormalities in the lower limbs, were presented for management at or before the age of six months.

On four patients no surgery was performed. In the other 12, orthopaedic management was completed during the skeletal growth period. Primary amputations (one below-knee, one Syme and one Boyd) were performed on three patients and prostheses fitted in early childhood. Three patients with bilateral fibular hemimelia were treated initially with a Gruca ankle reconstruction procedure. Using the Ilizarov technique, we performed tibial lengthening procedures on nine patients.

At the latest follow-up, the three patients who had amputations were functioning well and had no complications. The nine patients in whom tibial lengthening was the main reconstructive procedure suffered numerous complications and all needed further corrective surgery or footwear alterations. None required or requested late amputation because of poor function or cosmesis. Analysing results by parameters such as restriction of activity, pain, complication rate, treatment costs, hospital and clinic visits, periods of absence from school, and patient satisfaction, we found notably better results among patients who underwent early primary amputation than among those who underwent tibial lengthening.

This needs to be kept in mind when advising parents of the most appropriate course of management of their child’s disorder.


S. Gaynor P. Murray M. O’Brien

Injury to the infrapatellar branch of the saphenous nerve has been reported as a complication of arthroscopic examination and surgery of the knee. This can result in altered sensation on the anterolateral aspect of the knee, reflex sympathetic dystrophy and, occasionally, severe deafferentation pain. The aim of this cadaveric study was to delineate the course of the infrapatellar branch as it passes across the anterior aspect of the knee and identify potential safe areas for blind puncture at arthroscopy. The risk of damage to the nerve branch from the various open incisions used for orthopaedic surgery of the knee is also discussed.

The distribution of the infrapatellar branch was studied in both lower limbers of eleven cadavers (22 specimens). Two patterns of nerve distribution could be described in relation to its path across the proximal margin of the tibia. In 28% of examined cadavers, the infrapatellar branch of the saphenous nerve traverses the patellar tendon and runs laterally without ever crossing over the tibia. In the remaining 72% the infrapatellar branch crossed the proximal margin of the tibia prior to crossing the patellar tendon. Using the interior pole of the patella as a landmark, our results indicated that blind puncture is safe within an approximate wedge-shaped area ranging from 10mm inferior and 30mm medial to the inferior pole up to a level 10mm superior and 50mm medial to the inferior pole of the patella. The incidence of injury to this nerve can be reduced by clarifying the distribution of the infrapatellar nerve branch in relation to palpable landmarks.


J. Rezzouk J. Fabre H.H. Vital B. Beuquet A. Duraudeau

Purpose: We have sometimes observed paralysis of the long portion of the triceps in patients operated after traumatic damage to the axillary nerve. In anatomy textbooks, the motor branch of the long portion of the triceps arises from the radial nerve within the triceps. We studied the position of the motor branch of the long portion of the triceps in order to better detail its origin.

Material and methods: Group I: this group included nine patients with trauma-induced lesions of the axillary nerve associated with clinical involvement of the long portion of the triceps. Group II: this group was composed of 20 cadaver specimens of the secondary posterior trunks. Group III: fif-teen approaches to the subclavian plexus with dissection of the secondary posterior trunk. Lesions to the axillary nerve were retrieved from the operation reports in group I. The origin of the motor branch of the long portion of the triceps was identified in group II. The same origin was identified by neurostimulation in group III.

Results: In group I there were six lesions of the axillary nerve situated a mean 10 mm from the division of the secondary posterior trunk and three lesions of the secondary posterior trunk. There were four type IV lesions and five type V lesions. In group II, the motor branch of the long portion of the triceps arose a mean 6 mm from the division of the secondary posterior trunk in 13 cases, at the division in five cases, and 10 mm downstream in two cases, but never from the radial nerve. In group III, the branch of long portion of the triceps arose a men 4.5 mm from the division of the secondary posterior trunk in 11 cases, and at the division in four cases, but never from the radial nerve.

Discussion: In patients with trauma to the axillary nerve with paralysis of the long portion of the triceps, lesions to the axillary nerve occur proximally and are severe. In our study, the motor branch of the long portion of the triceps always arose from the axillary nerve or the secondary posterior branch. This shows that paralysis of the long portion of the triceps is a sign of poor prognosis in patients with traumatic lesions to the axillary nerve. This association is for us an element in favour of a proximal and serious lesion to the axillary nerve.

Conclusion: Involvement of the long portion of the triceps must be searched for in patients with traumatic lesions to the axillary nerve. Paralysis of the long portion of the triceps is a sign of a serious lesion requiring early surgical repair before two months.


A. Durandeau J.M. Cognet Th. Fabre B. Benquet J. Bouchain

Purpose: Radial paralysis is a major complication of humeral shaft fractures. In most cases, the paralysis is regressive but in certain patients surgical repair is required to achieve full neurological recovery. We reviewed retrospectively our patients to determine the causes of non-recovery and evaluate the efficacy of different treatments.

Material and methods: Thirty patients were operated between 1990 and 1997 for radial nerve paralysis that was observed immediately after trauma or developed secondarily. Mean follow-up after surgery was 6.3 years. There were 22 men and 8 women, 16 right side and 14 left side. Mean delay from injury to surgery was four months (0–730 days). Elements that could be involved in radial paralysis were noted: type of fracture, level of the fracture, treatment, approach, material used. There were ten cases with non-union. Neurological recovery at three years was assessed with muscle tests and with the Alnot criteria. An electrical recording was also made in certain patients. Surgery involved neurolysis in 23 cases, nerve grafts in five and tendon transfers in two.

Results: Outcome was very good and good in 22 patients, good in one and could not be evaluated in one (tendon transfer). There were three failures (two neurolysis and one graft) and two patients were lost to follow-up. After neurolysis, mean delay to recovery was seven months; it was 15 months after nerve grafts. Recovery always occurred proximally to distally.

Discussion: Radial paralysis after femoral shaft fracture regresses spontaneously in 76% to 89% of the cases, depending on the series. There is a predominance in the 20 to 30 year age range. Several factors could be involved in radial paralysis (fracture of the distal third of the humerus, spiral fracture, plate fixation, nonunion). The anterolateral approach allows a better exposure of the nerve. Unlike other authors, we do no advocate exploration of the injured nerve during surgical treatment of the fracture because it is most difficult to determine the potential for recovery of a continuous nerve.

Conclusion: The risk of radial nerve paralysis is greatest for spiral fracture of the distal third of the humerus. In such cases, it may be useful to explore the nerve during the primary procedure and insert a plate. For other cases, we prefer to wait for spontaneous nerve recovery. If reinnervation is not observed at 100 days, we undertake exploration.


D. Molé E. Villanueva O. Roche F. Sirveaux

Purpose: Infection is a serious complication of total knee arthroplasty. Surgical strategies based on removal-reinsertion of the prosthesis in two times with antibiotic therapy has proven its efficacy. The use of a spacer between the two operations has been proposed to facilitate reimplantation. Since 1993, we have used this two-time procedure with an articulated spacer in an attempt to optimise functional outcome yet maintain anti-infection efficacy. We report our experience.

Material and methods: This retrospective series included 28 patients, 21 women (75%) and seven men (25%) who underwent surgery between December 1993 and February 2000.Mean age of the patients at revision was 67 years (18–83). Medical and surgical risk factors for infection were present in 64% and 54% of the cases respectively. Delay between prosthesis surgery and onset of the first signs of infection was 29 months (four days–222 months). A single-germ infection was involved in 18 cases (64%) and a multiple-germ infection in nine (36%). The infection was acute in 32% of the cases and chronic in 68%. There were eight fistulae (28%). Bacteriology reported staphylococcal infection in 25 cases (including 13 S. epidermidis), streptococcal infections in five, anaerobic germs in seven (corynebacterium in five) and Gram-negative germ (pseudomonas) in one. Delay between diagnosis of infection and insertion of the articulated spacer was 11 months (four days–62 months). The first operation consisted in removal of the prosthesis, wide excision of the synovial and infected tissues and insertion of the two articulated pieces, modelled with antibiotic-impregnated cement. Weight-bearing was authorised with crutches and an articulated brace. Rehabilitation exercises were performed to maintain joint amplitude. The prosthesis was reimplanted three months later (1.5–7 months). All prostheses were reimplanted with cement: two prostheses with posterior preservation, 20 posterior stabilised prostheses, and six hinge prostheses. The patients were given antibiotics for eleven months (1–25 months). The IKS score was used to assess functional outcome. Cure of infection was assessed on clinical, biological and radiographic findings.

Results: All patients were seen at a mean follow-up of 35 months (8–78). Follow-up was greater than 24 months in 68% of the patients. We had three cases (11%) of recurrent infection: one acute infection and two septic loosenings. At reimplantation, we had complications in seven patients (25%) ten of whom required revision surgery, six for mechanical complications (three dislocations, three aseptic loosenings). Mean IKS score was 136 points (50–190) with 79 points (30–100) for the knee and 67 points (20–90) for function. Mean flexion amplitude was 94° (45–115°).

Discussion, conclusion: With this method, joint mobility can be maintained between the two operations, greatly improving patient comfort. The mid-term results in terms of infection cure have been satisfactory (89% cure). Nevertheless, the final functional result can be disappointing, due to the persistence of pain (low-grade infection, difficult implant fixation…). The removal-reinsertion strategy using a single operation would in our opinion still have its indications.


F.A. Weber R.J.L. Stein P.F.B. von Bormann

Between 1997 and 2000, internal arthrodiastasis procedures (endo-apparatus), using an internal skeletal distraction device, were performed on 33 young patients who had reached the point of total hip arthroplasty or arthrodesis.

The mean age of the 20 males and 13 females was 19 years (range 11 to 51 years). We removed 19 implants, eight after completion of treatment or because they had outlived their usefulness, and 11 because no improvement in the hip disorder had been achieved.

Good results were achieved in two thirds of the patients, including patients suffering from avascular necrosis of the femoral head, old Perthes’ disease and contained hip dysplasia with joint space narrowing and pain. Chondrolysis and stiffness of the hip appear to be contraindications for this type of treatment. The three post-traumatic hip disorders were probably also not ideal cases.

In young patients, the results of total hip arthroplasty after trauma are poor, and the indications for internal arthrodiastasis should be redefined.


S. Morris L. Rynne S. Kelly H. Mullett A. Laing Feeney J. Corbett J. McCabe

The effects of infection following implantation of an orthopaedic prosthesis are devastating. The prevention of perioperative contamination is therfore of the utmost importance in arthroplasty. We undertook a prospective study to assess bacterial contamination in elective arthroplasty surgery. Splash bowls containing sterile saline are used to store and clean instruments used during the course of a procedure. The incidence of bacterial proliferation in splash bowls was examined as a marker of intra-operative contamination. A 100mL aliquot of fluid was removed from the splash basin at the end of the procedure and passed through a grid membrane using a vacuum pump. The membrane filter was then plated on chocolate agar and colony counts recorded at 24 and 48 hours. Organisms were identified by standard techniques. Demographic data, and perioperative data including the duration and type of procedure, the number of scrubbed and other personnel in theatre and the type of skin preparation and gowns used were also noted. A total of 43 cases were examined. 14 samples yielded positive cultures. Staphylcoccus was the most commonly cultured organism (9 cases). Four patients grew Pseudomonas species. Five patients grew other Gram-negative organisms including Neisseria and bacillus subspecies. Five patients grew multiple organisms. Mean duration of follow up was 8.4 months (range 6 – 18 months). None of the patients with contaminated samples developed any clinical signs of infection in the perioperative period; nor was there clinical or radiological evidence of infection or loosening on subsequent follow up. Despite the use of a laminar airflow system in all cases, in excess of 30% of cases were contaminated. This study underlines the importance of adhering to rigorous protocol in theatre including minimising theatre traffic and the use of antibiotic prophylaxis.


M. Oleksak M.A. Hashmi M. Saleh

We reviewed 351 cases of nonunion treated between 1987 and 2000. The principles of management included restoration of alignment, stabilisation and stimulation. More recently we used distraction and bone transport, bifocal techniques, single stage lengthening and correction of soft tissue contractures.

The ununited fractures resulted from trauma in 319 cases and in 32 were the sequelae of planned surgery. There were 159 atrophic, 89 hypertrophic and 103 infected nonunions. Nonunion occurred in the tibia in 162 patients, in the femur in 51 and in the upper limbs and other smaller bones in the rest.

At the time of this review, nine patients had abandoned treatment and 25 fractures remained ununited. Amputation had been performed on 20 patients, two at the request of patients with intractable pain, 14 following infection and four because of atrophy. Union was achieved in 297 cases (85%), including 90% of the atrophic, 89% of the hypertrophic and 73% of the infected nonunions. We found no statistically significant difference between the results of patients who smoked and non-smokers, but patients who smoked heavily healed more slowly.


PH. Adam L. Beguin M.H. Fessy

Purpose: The anatomy of the endosteal canal of the proximal femur varies greatly in the general population. This variability can compromise total hip arthroplasty when a femoral stem is inserted without cement. While the secondary fixation of the implant is dependent on several parameters, the predominant factor is the primary stability and the large contact between the bone and the treatment surface of the apposed prosthesis. These two conditions, necessary but insufficient to guarantee an excellent clinical result, are obtained if there is a correct bone-implant morphology match. We analysed the morphology of the endosteal canal of the proximal femur to determine whether there is a standard anatomic conformation justifying the use of line prostheses.

Material and methods: We examined 30 femurs harvested from 30 individuals in a consecutive series in our anatomy laboratory. We made 12 scanner slices parallel to the knee joint line starting 1 cm above the apex of the lesser trochanter going up to 11 cm above the lesser trochanter. For each slice, we assimilated the canal to an ellipsoid surface to characterise its barycentre, the angle of the greater axis relative to the reference plane of the posterior condyles, and its dimensions defined with length (greater axis), and width (perpendicular to the greater axis).

Results: For each femur, the AP projections of the barycentres fell on a straight line (anatomic axis) and the lateral projections on a parabole. Helitorsion, i.e. the difference in the torsion angles between the first slice and the last slice was constant (57±8.5°). The dimensions were recorded for each slice.

Discussion: This method can be criticised. We were able to confirm the tridimensional data reported by Noble and confirmed the notion of a somatotype. We defined the normal (statistical) equation of the endosteal canal for the proximal end of the femur (barycentre, dimensions).

Conclusion: The anatomy of the endosteal canal of the upper extremity of the femur is not variable but standardised. It is thus possible to adapt the bone to the prosthesis.


D. Dejour V. Correa E. Locatelli T. Tavernier

Purpose: There is some controversy over the most appropriate management of knee dislocation. Following the 1995 SOFCOT symposium, the most promising results appeared to be obtained with emergency treatment using a synthetic reinforcement. The purpose of this prospective work was to validate this conclusion.

Material and methods: Between November 1994 and October 1998, 17 patients admitted for emergency care of a knee dislocation were included in this prospective study. Ten were men, mean age was 29 years (17–48). A complete work-up was acquired: plain radiographs with stress views, MRI in 14 patients. The central pivot was torn in all cases. Tears involved the lateral ligaments in eleven cases, the medial ligaments in six and the patellar tendon in one. There were no vessel lesions. One patient had popliteal sciatic nerve paralysis. Emergency surgery was performed to staple or suture the peripheral tissues and suture the posterior cruciate ligament plus a synthetic reinforcement (Ligastric); the anterior cruciate ligament was not repaired. Immediate rehabilitation started with mobilisation 0°/60°up to day 21 then with 0°/90° up to day 60. The lower limb was immobilised in an extension brace and weight-bearing was encouraged starting on day 60.

Results: All patients were reviewed at consultation with stress radiographs. Mean follow-up was three years (two to six years). The IKDC score was recorded. Four patients had arthrolysis, one had an isolated reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament, one had an ablation of the synthetic ligament and repair of the anterior cruciate ligament. The 70° posterior drawer was 18° preoperatively and 9 mm at last follow-up (21–0 mm). The greatest laxity corresponded to a patient who had had ablation of the synthetic ligament. The Pudda index was 6 mm, mean mobility was 0/130°, and two patients had asymmetric 10° recurvtum. Subjective outcome was very satisfactory for seven patients, satisfactory for nine and disappointing for one.

Conclusion: The objective result can still be improved by correcting the posterior laxity. Not repairing the anterior cruciate ligament immediately does not worsen prognosis. There were no complications related to the synthetic ligament. This therapeutic attitude can be proposed for major knee trauma.


G.M. Siboto S.J.L. Roche

We treated 133 traumatic posterior dislocations surgically between July 1994 and March 2001. In 16 patients, labral tears had occurred.

Operating on posterior hip dislocations, initially we fixated the posterior wall with screws and/or buttress plate, depending on the size of the fragment, and did suture the torn labrum, relying rather on the buttress plate or intact posterior wall for stability.

We began repairing the torn labrum when we realised that any small fragments still attached to the labrum simply pull out from under the buttress plate, allowing the hip to redislocate. Once the wall has been reconstructed, interrupted sutures are passed through the labrum, with the hip internally rotated to prevent shortening of the capsule when sutures are tied. A one-third tubular plate is placed over the sutures lying on the posterior wall and fixed with screws. The sutures are then tied individually over the plate. Postoperatively the patient is kept in bed for six weeks, with the hip abducted and knee extended.

Seven patients in whom the labrum was not repaired experienced redislocation. We performed second operations on two of them, repositioning the plates and reconstructing the posterior wall, but redislocation again occurred. The redislocated femoral heads were damaged because they rubbed against the plate and screws. In the other nine patients, we sutured the labrum, and in a 3 month to 2.5 year follow-up, no redislocation has occurred. .

Labral repair restores stability, and tying interrupted sutures over a buttress plate is an easy and effective method of repair.


V. Desnoyers J.-L. Charissoux F. Aribit J.-P. Arnaud

We report a case of an aneurysmal cyst localized in the patella of a 37-year-old man. The lesion was secondary to a chondroblastoma at six years follow-up after initial curettage and bone graft. It were no recurrence. Treatment of aneurysmal cysts depends on the degree of articular involvement. We made a detailed study of 11 cases of this rare localization of aneurysmal cysts reported in the literature.


M. Mariba M. Lukhele E. Mzuza

Tuberculosis of the spine is very common and it is important to do confirmatory testing.

This retrospective study involved 40 patients in whom tuberculosis of the spine was diagnosed after clinical examination and investigations. All underwent decompression of the spine for neurological fallout. Intra-operatively, histological tissue, MCS and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) were assessed. PCR was positive in only 50% of the patients, but was complementary to histology and MCS.


Th. Dubert S.-A. Malikov A. Dinh D.-D. Kupatadze Ch. Oberlin J.-Y. Alnot B.-B. Nabokov

Purpose of the study: Proximal replantation is a technically feasible but life-threatening procedure. Indications must be restricted to patients in good condition with a good functional prognosis. The goal of replantation must be focused not only on reimplanting the amputated limb but also on achieving a good functional outcome. For the lower limb, simple terminalization remains the best choice in many cases. When a proximal amputation is not suitable for replantation, the main aim of the surgical procedure must be to reconstruct a stump long enough to permit fitting a prosthesis preserving the function of the adjacent joint. If the proximal stump beyond the last joint is very short, it may be possible to restore some length by partial replantation of spared tissues from the amputated part. We present here the results we obtained following this policy.

Materials and methods: This series included 16 cases of partial replantations, 14 involving the lower limb and 2 the upper limb. All were osteocutaneous microsurgical transfers. For the lower limb, all transfers recovered protective sensitivity following tibial nerve repair. The functional calcaeoplantar unit was used in 13 cases. The transfer of this specialized weight bearing tissue provided a stable distal surface making higher support unnecessary. In one case, we raised a 13-cm vascularized tibial segment covered with foot skin for additional length. For the upper limb, the osteocutaneous transfer, based on the radial artery, was not reinnervated, but this lack of sensitivity did not impair prosthesis fitting.

Results: One vascular failure was finally amputated. This was the only unsuccessful result. For all other patients, the surgical procedure facilitated prosthesis fitting and preserved the proximal joint function despite an initially very proximal amputation.

Discussion: The advantages of partial replantation are obvious compared with simple terminalization or secondary reconstruction. There is no secondary donor site and, because there is no major muscle mass in the distal fragment, the overall risk is very low compared with the risk of total proximal leg replantation.


P. Violas R. Kohler E. Mascard G. Bollini C. Kalifa J. Dubousset

Purpose of the study: Advances in chemotherapy protocols over the last 20 years have considerably improved the prognosis and functional outcome in patients with osteogenic sarcoma. We report here the results of a cooperative study conducted under the auspices of the French Society of Pediatric Oncology (SFOP). Twenty-nine oncology centers participated in this retrospective national multicentric study.

Materials and methods: The study included 15 .3 patients with osteogenic sarcoma of the limb who were treated by the OS87 protocol with conservative surgery between 1987 and 1994. The OS87 protocol consisted in conservative or nonconservative surgery combined with pre- and postoperative chemotherapy. The following inclusion criteria were used: age under 20 years, tumor localization in a limb (pelvis and spine excluded), no metastasis at diagnosis, biopsy proven osteogenic sarcoma.

Results: Mean age at diagnosis was 13 years. The knee localization predominated (80 p. 100). 82.5 p. 100 of the patients had grade IIB disease (Enneking classification). For the 187 patients included in the protocol surgery was nonconservative in 20 p. 100 of the cases and conservative in 80 p. 100. The choice of the surgical technique (arthroplasty, allograft, autograft, resection without reconstruction) depended on the patient’s age and school situation. Data analyzed here concerned only those patients who had conservative treatment. Mean follow-up was 64 months. The actuarial survival curve plateaued at 71 p. 100 at more than 6 years. Early and late complications were numerous and variable (mechanical, infectious, local recurrence). Secondary amputation was required in 10 p. 100 of the patients. The overall functional outcome of the preserved limbs was nevertheless good with rapid restoration of self-sufficiency despite major surgery and a high number of reoperations (about 65 p. 100 of cases).

Discussion: In light of the frequency and the seriousness of the complications, these results are modest. Patients and family should be advised of the risk, particularly the risk of secondary amputation which may be required early due to contaminated excision or at mid term due to major non-cancerological complications. As survival has been improved, functional capacity must be preserved for several years. This orients surgery towards more “biological” reconstruction which can provide greater longevity than arthroplasty.


F. Duparc R. Putz C. Michot J.M. Muller P. Fréger

Purpose: A fibrous element between the radial capitulum and the fovea is classically described; it is often called a synovial fringe. The term “meniscus” has been proposed to designate a truly rigid peripheral structure partially inter-postioned between the joint surfaces and susceptible of producing joint disease by internal disregulation of repeated pronation supination movements. This led us to study the anatomic and histological properties of this intra-articular structure.

Material and methods: Fifty adult cadaver shoulders were dissected. The en bloc resection included the capsule of the humeroradial joint and the entire annular ligament. We searched for a fibrous structure, noting its soft or rigid aspect, its position relative to the five-part segmentation of the capsuloligament resection, and its size and thickness. Vertical sections were made for the histology study to determine the organized connective tissue or synovial nature of the structure.

Results: An intra-articular element was visible in 43 cases, two structures were observed in two cases, on the deep aspect of the junction between the capsule and the annular ligament. The main positions observed were: circular (n=3), lateral and posterior (n = 11), posterior (n = 10). The anterior (n = 4), or lateral (n = 5) positions were rare. Mean length was 21.4 mm (9–51), mean width between the capsular attachment and the free edge was 2.9 mm (1–10), maxiam mean thickness was 1.7 mm (1–4 mm). The histology report showed two types of structures: a rigid structure with an oriented fibrous armature that had a triangular peripheral base continuous with the superior border of the annular ligament and covered with synovial on both sides of the free edge; a soft flexible structure formed uniquely by two layers of synovial and a more or less villous free edge. Fibrochondroid structures of the meniscal type were not observed. Small nerve fibers were demonstrated in some cases.

Discussion: Certain lateral epiconylalgias of the elbow would suggest involvement of the humeroradial joint, possibly related to injury of the humeoradial “mensiscus”. This study points out the frequency of this synovial or fiborsynovial fringe of variable dimensionts interpose between the radial capitulum and fovea. The structure has a more or less marked connective armature, basically in the lateral and posterior portion, and correctly cannot be termed a “meniscus”. This structure might be involved in inflammatory and painful syndromes observed in epicondylalgias of the humeroradial joint.


Ph. Gicquel B. De Billy Cl. Karger M.-C. Maximin J.-M. Clavert

We present an original method for the treatment of neglected Monteggia fractures using the Ilizarov technique. This method allows reduction without accessing the radial head by progressive ulnar lengthening after proximal subperiosteal osteotomy of the ulnar bone. We used this method in a six and a half year old girl and achieved excellent radiographical and functional results with normal joint amplitudes. In our opinion, the quality of the outcome is related to the progressiveness of the bone lengthening enabled by this technique which allows restoration of the ulnar length, preservation of the axes of both forearm bones, and controlled reduction of the radial head.


R. Ling

Fundamental engineering considerations indicate that micro-movement of the components of any hip arthroplasty is inevitable: stress cannot exist without strain and vice versa. Micromovement can be classified either as inducible recoverable movement that takes place between the weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing phases of each stride, or as non-recoverable displacement between successive loading cycles.

Radiostereometric analysis is now sufficiently advanced to clarify migration and its significance, and is beginning to throw light on the extent and significance of recoverable cyclical micromovement. We discuss the value of radiostereometric analysis in identifying, early in their in-service life, implants that are likely to loosen.


C. Charausset P. Landreau L. Bellaiche P. Mas

Purpose: Arthroscopic reinsinsertion of rotator cuff tears is an alternative to surgical treatment, but there is some question as to the reliability of this technique. The purpose of this work was to assess healing with arthroscan, MRI or ultrasonography after arthroscopic reinsertion of the supraspinatus.

Material: There were 48 supraspinatus resections in 47 patients (27 men and 20 women), mean age 56 years (range 34–76 years). Thirty patients were active workers (109 manual labourers), seven were sedentary workers, and ten were retired. Mean initial Constant score was 40.56 (range 13–67). Arthroscan or MRI identified 48 full thickness tears of the supraspinatus (41 distal and seven intermediate tears, associated with twenty cleavages of the subspinatus, six cases of biceps tendonitis, and four lesions involving the upper third of the subscapularis.

Methods: All patients underwent totally arthroscopic reinsertion of the supraspinatus. One tenotomy of the long biceps and three reinsertions of the upper third of the subscapularis were also performed. All patients were immobilised for six weeks. Passive rehabilitation was started immediately and active work was allowed after six weeks.

Results: For this consecutive series of 48 supraspinatus reinsertions with a minimum 12 months follow-up, the Constant score at last follow-up was 76.77 (range 39–99). Arthroscan (n=40), ultrasonography (n=3) and MRI (n=1) were performed at six months to search for leakage and assess healing at the trochiter and cartilage level, aspect of the inferior aspect of the tendon and muscle degeneration. No leakage was observed in 37 cases, the tendon had a normal aspect in 15, with fringes in four cases, and in 12 cases there was a point leakage. Full thickness tear was found in seven cases. Clinical outcome was not correlated with operative technique or preoperative imaging.

Discussion: These results in a preliminary series suggest that arthroscopic reinsertion of suprasinatus tears with little retraction is a reliable alternative to surgical reinsertion. The deltoid insertions are not disrupted and adherence phenomena and morbidity are reduced. Arthroscopy also allows complete exploration of the glenohumeral joint. Longer follow-up will be needed to determine the long-term outcome.


D. Goutallier S. Van Driessche J. Allain JM Postel

Leakage after simple suture repair of rotator cuff tears depends on the overall preoperative fatty degeneration index (FDI) of the muscles and preoperative fatty degeneration (FD) of the infraspinatus. When the FDI is = 2, cuff leakage is always observed after repair. The risk of recurrent tears of the supraspinus is high if the FD of the infraspinatus is > 1. However if the FDI is very low or nil, the rate of recurrent tears is 15%. These tears can be explained by tension on sutures in macroscopically and histologically abnormal tendons.

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine whether repair of rotator cuff tears using sutures without tension after removal of abnormal tendon stumps, a technique requiring tendon plasty, can improve the leakage rate.

Material and methods: Total repair of 24 rotator cuff tears was performed without tension on the sutures after resection of at least one centimetre of the supraspinatus tendon stump. This consecutive series was studied prospectively. The tears involved the supraspinatus and the infraspinatus in ten cases, all three tendons in 13 cases and only the supraspinatus in one case. Mean preoperative FDI was 1.18 (0.5–2.16); pre-operative FD of the infraspinatus was a mean 1.19 (0–2). The supraspinatus stump was resected from the trochiter in 14 cases, on the apex of the head of the humerus in seven and facing the glenoid cavity in three. Repair required translation advancement of the supraspinatus in 24 cases, translation advancement of the infraspinatus in six (associated with a rhomboid flap) and a trapezeal flap in three cases. Postoperative leakage was assessed with arthroscan (n=23) and ultrasonography (n=1) at one year.

Results: No leakage was observed in 20 of the 24 cuffs (83%). Recurrent tear of the supraspinatus was observed in three cases and in the supraspinatus and infraspinatus in one case each. The FDI of cuffs with recurrent tears (1.31) was not significantly greater than the FDI of cuffs without leakage (1.15) (p = 0.085). Preoperative FD of the infraspinatus of cuffs with recurrent tears (1.5) was significantly higher than that for cuffs without leakage (1.12) (p = 0.16). For the supraspinatus and the subscapularis, there was no significant difference between preoperative fatty degeneration of cuffs with recurrent tears and cuffs without leakage. The number of repaired tendons had a statistically significant effect (p = 0.012) on postoperative leakage: 23% of the recurrent tears after repair of three tendons showed no leakage compared with 9% after repair of one or two tendons (there was no significant difference for preoperative FDI, p = 0.33).

Discussion: Resection of macroscopically abnormal tendon stumps which requires tendinomuscular plasty, gives better anatomic results than simple suture. For an equivalent FDI, this allows fewer cases of leakage (83% without leakage compared with 50% after simple suture). Results were also better for an equivalent number of tendons repaired: 77% and 50% for three tendons and 91% and 55% for two tendons respectively).

Conclusion: Despite the almost constant need for plasty, rotator cuff repair using sutures without tension after resection of macroscopically abnormal tendon stumps gives, for an equivalent preoperative degree of fatty degeneration and an equivalent number of tendon repairs, better anatomic results than simple suture.


K. Matougui J.L. Leat F. Chalençon J.L. Besse M. Bourahoua T. de Polignac A. Godenèche F. Cladière B. Moyen

Purpose: There are three main causes of failure after valgisation osteotomy of the tibia requiring repeated osteotomies: insufficient valgus, excessive valgus, or loss of the valisation correction after a variable delay. The purpose of this study was to evaluate outcome after repeated oseotomies performed in relatively young patients or too active to propose arthroplasty. The technical problems were different for each aetiology.

Material and methods: The series included 47 knees operated on between 1974 and 1998 after a first osteotomy performed at a mean age of 46 years. Mean delay between the two operations was five years (1 to 12). A medial closure osteotomy had been performed at the first operation in 34 cases and a lateral opening osteotomy in 13. For the 19 knees with valgus, the second osteotomy was a medial closure in 14 and a lateral opening in five. A repeat valgisation was performed in 28 cases, 18 by lateral closure, one by medial opening and nine by curviplanar osteotomy. The IKS score was determined to assess function. The femoraotibial axes (HKA angle) were determined on full stance views. The Ahl-back osteoarthritis grading was used. For 17 patients who had undergone operations in other institutions, exact measurements were not always available concerning the preoperative status and the initial correction.

Results: The overall IKS score for function improved in 87% of the cases with a mean follow-up of five years. The IKS knee score improved from 73 to 89 points and the IKS function score from 65 to 81 points. For the 19 over-corrections, the mean HKA angle was changed from 190° to 184°. For the 28 under-corrections, the mean HKA angle was changed from 173° to 182°. The tibial tilt remained unchanged at 7° as did lateral gapping at 3°. Delay to consolidation was a mean 96 days.

Discussion: Revision osteotomies performed for correction defects should be distinguished. For these procedures, it would be logical to expect a good result if a 3 to 5 degree valgus is achieved. Revisions after a long period (33 cases) are different; required for wear, these cases correspond to progressive loss of the initial osteotomy effect. These patients are often candidates for prosthesis if seen after 70 years. Good results can however be obtained with a second osteotomy irrespective of the initial technique. We prefer reoperating with medial opening after initial lateral closure.


J.B. Stiehl

This paper reviews the causes of chronic instability after total hip arthroplasty (THA).

The overall reported incidence varies from 0.5% to 9.5%. At 2% to 6%, the incidence following primary THA is higher with a posterior approach than with an anterior approach (0.5% to 3%). The incidence is reported to be as high as 22% after revision THA and 50% after extensile triradiate approach for pelvic discontinuity.

Inadequate soft tissue lengthening, damaged abductors and nonunion of trochanteric osteotomy are known to predispose patients to chronic instability after THA. Elderly women are particularly susceptible. Poor patient compliance is also a cause.

Surgical technique is also a factor. The lateral decubitus position often causes flattening of the lumbar lordosis, leading to potential cup retroversion. Over 90% of all dislocations are posterior, and disruption of external rotators and capsular damage should be repaired if possible. The optimal implant position appears to be 40° TO 45° of abduction, 15° to 20° of femoral anteversion, and 20° to 30° of cup flexion. Elevation of the hip centre weakens abductor pull, causing instability. Because a reduced femoral offset causes potential instability, this should be measured preoperatively to make sure that the stem can provide adequate offset. It may be necessary to add a thicker liner to increase the offset.

Prosthetic factors which play a role in chronic instability include the use of smaller femoral heads, thick necked stems and heads with skirts. A larger femoral head increases stability simply by increasing the radian about the hip centre, increasing the potential range of motion. Extended posterior wall-adds improve the range of motion, and consequently the stability. However, there are fears that their use may increase the incidence of impingement and/or lead to increased wear. Skirted femoral heads impinge on the liner, limiting movement, and their use should be avoided in most cases of instability.

Femoral stem offset relates to the neck shaft angle and the effective hip centre/shaft axis length or offset. It is easier to increase offset with lower neck shaft angle than to lengthen the leg. Because a bell curve is used in the design of femoral stems, many prosthetic systems lack adequate offset, especially when larger stems (48 mm to 52 mm) are used.

In earlier prosthetic designs, bulk was added to the necks to eliminate stem breakage. In certain stems, the way in which dimensions were scaled meant the neck dimensions of larger prostheses were disproportionately big. We stopped using Depuy Stability stems sizes 16 mm and 18 mm because of this. Thornberry et al have shown that a circulotrapezoidal neck design is the best shape and leads to the least impingement. They have also shown that increasing the width of the chamfer of the acetabular liner rim improves the range of motion.

In treating early instability (occurring less than 30 days postoperatively) most authors recommend bracing for six to eight weeks and warning patients severely about the long-term potential of redislocation. In cases of chronic instability (occurring more than 30 days postoperatively) all potential problems must be explored: these include soft tissue laxity, cup retroversion, inadequate offset, surgical approach, etc. In managing multiple dislocation, the use of extended immobilisation is less desirable although patients who have undergone revision have been subjected to a great deal of soft tissue dissection and potentially should be braced for up to 12 months. If the cause is correctable-malpositioning, soft tissue laxity or bony impingement – treatment is likely to be successful in 85% of cases. However, if the implants are in good position, the ‘bloodless revision’ (Fehring) has less than 50% chance of succeeding. The implication is that an extended posterior wall liner, longer modular femoral head, and soft tissue reconstruction are not going to work in the majority of cases.

Designed by Noiles, the J& J SROM constrained acetabular liner uses a polyethylene capture mechanism that is secured by two additional screws. The pullout strength of this device is 1 350 N but torque required (lever-out strength) diminishes to 17.3 N.m for a 28-mm head. With a 32 mm head, 105° of flexion was obtained (while the normal hip needs up to 113° for usual flexion). Following up 21 patients with this implant for over two years, Anderson et al found redislocation in 29%. The only causative factor identified was an abduction angle of more than 70°. However, there were no cases of implant loosening of this device. Prevention of loosening was one of the design goals in using a ‘softer’ locking mechanism. Dislodgement of the liner requires immediate re-operation.

The Osteonics constrained liner cup has a dual socket. The inner socket has a polished chrome surface manufactured fit to the outer socket. It fits a 22 mm or 28 mm head, and has a locking ring identical to the bipolar implant that holds the head in place. The implant can be snap-fitted into a 52-mm or larger Osteonics cup. This liner can also be cemented into another metal-backed liner. Goetz et al evaluated 56 cases, in 10 of which this implant had been cemented and in 46 lock-fitted in appropriately matched metal shells. In one case, the cemented constrained liner had separated from the metal shell. None of the constrained liners had separated from the metal shells, but one shell had loosened.

There are many similar constrained acetabular liners. The choice is between a ‘locked’ liner that can never separate and a ‘softer’ lock that may protect fixation of the cup.


B.M. Boszczyk A.A. Boszczyk A. Korge W. Boos R. Putz J. R. Ralphs M. Benjamin S. Milz

Hypertrophy of lumbar articular facets and dorsal joint capsule are well documented in degenerative instability, the molecular changes occurring in the extracellular matrix (ECM) are however unknown.

The L4/L5 posterior articular complex was removed from seven individuals undergoing fusion for degenerative instability. After methanol fixation and decalcification in EDTA, specimens were cryosectioned at 12 μm and immunolabelled with monoclonal antibodies for collagen types I, II, III, V and VI; chondroitin-4 and 6 sulphates; dermatan and keratan sulphate; versican, tenascin, aggrecan and link-protein. Antibody binding was detected using the Vectastain ABC ‘Elite’ kit. Labelling patterns were compared to corresponding healthy specimens examined previously.

In comparison, the degenerative capsule was more dense and hypertrophied and the enthesis more fibrocartilaginous, with immunolabelling extensive for collagen type II, chondroitin–6-sulfate, chondroitin-4-sulfate, aggrecan and link-protein. The articular surface showed extensive evidence of degeneration, while the thickened capsular entheses encircled the articular facets dorsally. Bony spurs capped with regions of cartilaginous metaplasia were prominent in this region, the ECM labelling strongly for type II collagen and chondroitin-6-sulfate.

The hypertrophy of lumbar facet joints subject to instability of the functional spinal unit therefore appears to be due to proliferation of the capsular enthesis rather than the actual articular facet. In view of the physiological function of the dorsal joint capsule as a wrap-around ligament in assisting the limitation of axial rotation, the molecular changes found in degenerative instability suggest rotational instability, such as results from degenerative disc disease, to be a decisive factor in the development of spondylarthropathy. It is furthermore probable, that the pronounced sagittal joint orientation in degenerative instability is the result of reactive joint changes rather than a predisposing factor of instability.


L. Beguin Ph. Adam F. Farizon M. H. Fessy

Purpose: Dislocation of total hip arthoplasties is a sad reality. The incidence of this complication is estimated from 0.6 to 8%. Dislocation can be a single event that never recurs, but half of all dislocations will reoccur again. We analysed outcome after treating chronically unstable total hip arthroplasties using a double-mobility cup.

Material and methods: Between 1990 and 2000, we treated 42 cases of recurrent dislocation of total hip arthroplasties. Five were immediate, 33 early, and four late; five dislocations on the average. The prosthesis was implanted via the posterolateral approach for 36 patients. Thirteen patients treated in our unit had already had surgical treatment for chronic instability: 1 trochanteoplasty, 8 bone blocks, 5 restraining cups. A standing AP view of the pelvis was obtained in all patients before surgery to analyse shortening (gluteus medius insufficiency), cup tilt and anteversion, and stem lateralisation. Likewise a CT scan was performed systematically to analyse stem and cup anteversion. No position anomaly was found in 17 patients; at least one anomaly was found in the others. All patients were reoperated via the posterolateral approach. A double-mobility cup was implanted systematically without changing the stem.

Results: Among the 42 patients, we had two with recurrent dislocation, one in a neurologic patient and one in a patient with major anomalies in the position of the femoral component that was not changed. The incidence of recurrent dislocation was thus 4.75%.

Discussion: The therapeutic method used here can be compared with other solutions (trochanteroplasty, anti-dislocation crescent, antidislocation bone block, bipolar replacement). The double-mobility cup is particularly interesting for high-risk patients: neck fracture, tumour surgery, neurological disease, antecedent non-prosthetic surgery (dearthrodesis prosthesis). We advocate revision surgery after three dislocations.

Conclusion: The double-mobility cup appears to be a valid therapeutic option, both for the treatment and prevention of chronic instability of total hip arthroplasty.


O. Roche F. Sirveaux E. Meuly X. Leseur D. Molé

Purpose: Arthroscopic arthroplasty for painful shoulder is not always successful. Repeated arthroscopy is sometimes discussed for patients with recurrent pain. The purpose of this work was to determine the technique and identify indications.

Material and methods: We conducted a retrospective analysis of 24 patients (13 men, 11 women), mean age 52 years, who underwent repeated arthroscopy after failure within 31 months of arthroscopic acromioplasty with no other intervention. Three groups were formed: group 1 (7 patients): subacromial impingement due to tendinitis with intact supraspinatus; group 2 (11 patients): subacromial impingement secondary to cuff tear; group 3 (6 patients): calcified tendinopathy. In group 1, the acromion was type 1 in three cases, type 2 in three and type 3 in one; repeated arthroscopy included complementary acromioplasty. In group 2, all patients had complementary acromioplasty; six of them with biceps tenotomy. In group 3, the remaining calcification was removed in all patients and complementary acromioplasty in three.

Results: Mean follow-up was 21 months. In group 1, outcome was satisfactory in three patients (43%), irrespective of the acromial morphology. In group 2, outcome was satisfactory in six patients (55%), including five with acromioplasty with tenotomy and only one with complementary acromioplasty alone. In group 3, outcome was satisfactory in five patients (83%); one failure was attributed to remaining calcification; acromioplasty did not influence outcome.

Discussion, conclusion: The acromion should not be considered as the principal cause of failure after first acromioplasty. In this series, only 33% of the patients who had complementary acromioplasty had a good outcome at last follow-up. Biceps tenotomy in patients with rotator cuff tears and removal of the calcium deposit in patients with calcified tenopathies should be considered first.


P. Guigui L. Cardinne L. Rillardon T. Morais A. Vuillemin A. Deburge

Purpose of the study: The principal objective of this prospective continuous observation study was to determine the incidence of perioperative and early postoperative complications secondary to surgical treatment of lumbar stenosis. Secondary objectives were to describe these complications and try to identify favouring factors.

Material and methods: All patients without major spinal deviation who underwent surgery for lumbar spine stenosis in our unit from January 1998 to January 2000 were included in the study. Minimal follow-up had to be six months. The series thus included 306 patients. Three categories of preoperative parameters were recorded: comorbid fractures, type of stenosis operated, type of surgery (simple release, release plus fusion, etc). In order to obtain an exhaustive data set, all complications were recorded on observation charts during hospitalisation and at follow-up visits at three, six and twelve months postoperatively. Complications were divided into four major categories: major complications, early or late infections, early or late mechanical disorders, neurological complications including meningeal disease and neurological disorders secondary to surgery. Data were explored with univariate analysis to determine the overall incidence of complications and the specific incidence for each category of complications and multivariate analysis with logistic regression to determine factor favouring development of complications.

Results: Overall incidence of complications secondary to surgery was 26.5%. Incidence of general, infectious, neurological and mechanical complications were 13, 4.5, 2.6, and 2% respectively. Incidence of complications considered to be serious and/or requiring reoperation was 12%. Factors influencing the development of complications were comorbidity, body mass index, duration of the operation, and reoperation.

Discussion and conclusion: The rate of complications reported in the literature have been very variable and have been established from retrospective reviews making comparison with our findings rather difficult. Our work pointed out the role of certain favouring factors which could be usefully examined in a larger series.


J-P. Steib A. Mourad

Purpose of the study: Surgery for lumbar canal stenosis is classically an intracanalar procedure with the risk of injury of the dura mater or nerve roots or of postoperative haematoma with secondary sequelae. Extracanalar surgery could be useful for the treatment of lumbar canal stenosis in older patients.

Material and methods: The Farcy procedure is based on the observation that the root is compressed in the recessus by the tip of the upper facet. The foramen is too small. The tip can be cut with a chisel along a horizontal line plumb with the pedicle landmark on the upper border of the lateral mass. The tip of the facet and its osteophyte can be removed laterally to medially with a curette and separated from the capsule and the yellow ligament without exposing the root. Release of the foramen is verified with an elevator. From August 1999 to July 2000, 15 patients (ten women and five men) underwent the Farcy procedure in association with fusion-osteosynthesis. Mean age was 60.4 years (55–71). The patients had suffered a mean 8.5 years (1–30). All had lumbalgia. Radiculalgia involved one root in seven patients, two in four and three in four. The Beaujon score was 6.73 (0–14) before surgery. The procedure was performed at one level in five patients, at two in four, at three in four and at four in two. Laminectomy was associated in two patients early in our experience.

Results: Postoperative Beaujon score was 15.2 (9–12) with cure of lumbalgia in eleven patients and cure of radiculalgia in ten patients. five patients had a 100% relative gain and only four had a gain of less than 50%. There were two failures explained by a history of stroke in two women (67 and 71 years). The only complications were one haematoma that was reoperated and one superficial infection.

Discussion: These results are comparable with those obtained with intracanalar surgery. The procedure is equally effective and is more rapid without the risk of the classical complications. The one extradural haematoma observed was related to laminectomy which later was noted to be unnecessary.

Conclusion: The Farcy procedure is a useful technique for the treatment of lumbar spine stenosis. Further experience is needed to determine whether this extracanalar technique should replace classical techniques with the risk of complications related to exposure of the canal.


S.K. Magabotha R. Lekalakala I. Rogan

Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is done primarily for pain relief, and function improves when there is less pain. Greater understanding of the biomechanical functioning of the knee has led to an improvement in prosthetic implants. Surgical technique, which plays an important role in the overall outcome of TKA, has also improved over the years. Simultaneous bilateral total knee arthroplasty (SBTKA) is one of the latest techniques employed by arthroplasty surgeons. SBTKA has advantages and disadvantages, and there are clearly diverse reactions to it from surgeons treating patients with bilateral osteoarthritis.

We reviewed 87 patients who underwent SBTKA and compared complications, costs and functional results with those of patients who underwent staged TKA. The same surgeon performed all the operations. There was strict adherence to a consistent preoperative, intraoperative and postoperative protocol.

Our results showed that the complications of SBTKA are not significantly different from of staged TKA. SBTKA is definitely more cost-effective, and rehabilitation and function were the same as in patients who had a staged procedure.


J.N. Goubier O. Silbermann-Hoffman M. Tubiana C. Ober

Purpose: Desmoid tumours are uncommon in the axillary region. We report the clinical course in seven patients operated for desmoid tumours of the axillary region.

Material and methods: Our series included two women and five men. Mean age was 52 years (39–60). One tumour was in the trapesium, two were in the retroplexic, two in the axillary fossa, one in the deltoid and one in the upper part of the arm. Biopsy and magnetic resonance imaging were obtained in all patients. Surgical margins were in healthy tissue in five cases; resection was limited to intratumoural tissue in one. The axillary nerve had to be sacrificed in two patients, the spinal nerve in one and the medial nerve in one. Chemotherapy was given to one patient prior to surgery.

Results: Mean follow-up was 51 months (23.2–162.1). Five patients experienced at least one relapse requiring one or two complementary procedures. Among the relapse cases, one patient required resection of the median nerve with bypass of the humeral artery. No amputations were necessary and the brachial plexus was not sacrificed. Four patients were given one to five adjuvant chemotherapy courses. Two were given radiotherapy. Shoulder motion was preserved in two patients, moderately reduced in five. Elbow and finger mobility was compromised due to the medial epicondylar site of the tumour in one patient whose median nerve had to be sacrificed.

Discussion: Even though the surgical margins were in healthy tissue, the risk of relapse was high in our patients as in other series reported in the literature. The course does however stabilise after several episodes of recurrence, an observation reported in the literature and confirmed in our patients. In case of brachial plexus involvement, several authors advocate preservation of upper limb function despite incomplete tumour resection, proposing postoperative radiotherapy.

Conclusion: Desmoid tumours of the axillary region seriously compromise upper limb function. Surgical resection should be as complete as possible but without sacrificing upper limb function.


M.T. Mariba M. Lukhele

Sciwora lesions are common in children but rare in adults. In adults, they are often associated with spondylosis, and minor trauma may result in paralysis of varying degrees.

In our unit we conducted a retrospective analysis of adult patients with spinal cord injuries. Only two had Sciwora lesions. One lesion was in the thoracic spine and the other in the lumbar spine. The thoracic lesion led to complete paraplegia, with intrinsic cord damage. It was treated conservatively and the patient did not recover. The lumbar lesion was incomplete, with traumatic disc prolapse that recovered after discectomy.

Management of Sciwora lesions of the thoracic and lumbar spine depends on MRI findings.


C.J. Olivier M.A. de Beer N.G.J. Maritz

We evaluated the effectiveness of arthroscopic repair in patients with shoulder instability owing to a bony fragment as part of the Bankart lesion, using spiked Suretacs, sutures and anchors.

Over a two-year period, we followed up 23 of 25 consecutive cases, all with a bony fragment as part of the Bankart lesion. The mean age of patients, all of whom were male, was 21 years (17 to 35). Almost all injuries were sustained playing sports. Patients were clinically evaluated at six weeks and 20 weeks postoperatively and interviewed telephonically.

Full arthroscopic examination was performed in a lateral decubitus position. The affected capsular structures and labrum, with its attached bony fragment, were fully mobilised. The bony fragment was always attached to the capsular structures, with labral ring intact. We used a spiked Suretac anchor to reattach the bony fragment to its original anatomical position, and Mitek anchors and no. 1 Ticron sutures for individual reattachment of the capsule and ligaments. Postoperatively patients were immobilised in a shoulder sling for six weeks. Early restricted active and passive movements were advised. Patients routinely received postoperative physical and biokinetic rehabilitation. The mean follow up period was 16 months (5 to 29). There was no redislocation or subjective instability.

This technique yields excellent results, but because it is technically difficult should be used only by experienced shoulder arthroscopists with thorough knowledge of pathological shoulder anatomy.


M.S. Barrow E.H.W. Erken A. Schepers

A nine-year-old girl presented with a four-year history of progressive bowing of the left tibia. She had been seen in our clinic three and four years earlier, when no treatment was advised. She had been complaining of mild pain in the left leg for one month but was otherwise not very perturbed about her deformed leg.

Examination showed bowing of the left tibia, no leg length discrepancy, no limp, and a normal left knee and ankle. Radiological examination showed features of osteo-fibrous dysplasia of the left tibia, with eccentric expansion of the cortex, intracortical osteolysis, marginal sclerosis encroaching on the medulla and diffuse lesional calcification. No other bones were involved.

Because of the progressive bowing of the tibia and the mild pain, the recommended loose observation of the patient was abandoned. Daily treatment with 30 mg IVI pamidronate for three days resolved the pain. One month after the latest presentation the lesion was biopsied. Histological examination confirmed the diagnosis of osteofibrous dysplasia of the tibia. There was no evidence of adamantinoma.

The literature on this rare bone lesion in childhood supports the use of open biopsy if the deformity becomes painful, the bowing is progressive and the patient presents after the age of nine years. Important differential diagnoses include fibrous dysplasia and adamantinoma.


M.N. Rasool

The treatment of large bony defects following osteomyelitis and trauma with skin damage is challenging. This paper reports the results of fibular transplant for tibial defects.

Between 1990 and 2000, five children aged four to nine years were treated. Four had pyogenic osteomyelitis and one a compound fracture with bone loss. All had large wounds on the medial aspect of the tibia. Before reconstruction, conservative treatment lasted five to six months. Sequestrectomy and debridement were performed before fibular transfer.

At surgery the fibula was divided below the physis and transferred to the remaining tibia, deep to the tibialis anterior muscle belly. In two cases the fibula was fixed to the lateral aspect of the tibia with screws, and in three into the metaphysis with K-wires. Bone graft was packed around the transfer. Immobilised in a cast for four to six months, the leg was later protected with a calliper.

Follow-up ranged from 9 months to 10 years. All children are ambulant, four with callipers and one independently. The latter shows evidence of tibialisation of the fibula. Follow-up continues and the remaining four transfers show solid union and signs of fibular hypertrophy.

Osteomyelitis remains a crippling condition that results in bone defects. Fibular transfer is a salvage procedure and an alternative to ablation in cases of severe bone loss with infection and scarring. It should be reserved for difficult cases with extensive defects where conventional bone grafting is not possible.


G.G.A. Cappaert C.J. Grobbelaar

At the same time as the LCS knee, the ARD knee was developed. We aimed to assess whether over a 10 to 15-year period the SS 86 rotational platform knee system stood the test of time.

In a retrospective study, we followed up 250 patient, assessing patient satisfaction, range of motion and radiological appearance. Patient satisfaction was high and range of motion and radiological appearances very good.


J.F. de Beer K. van Rooyen R. Harvie J. Lotz

We discuss aspects of glenohumeral instability and rotator cuff tears in a clinically orientated approach, presenting a new way of quantifying structural bone loss from the anterior glenoid and defining the Glenoid Index as an indicator of the appropriate surgical approach to address anterior instability.

Repair of the rotator cuff depends on viable and functional muscular tissue. We discuss the potential for repair of the supraspinatus tendon in relation to the tangent sign, fat infiltration and retraction. Comparing MRI and arthroscopic findings, we highlight pitfalls in the diagnosis and repair of the subscapularis tendon.


A.A. Papadopoulos D.R. van der Jagt A. Schepers

Between January 1990 and October 2000, 108 total hip arthroplasties using a cemented polished titanium stem and a cemented ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWP) cup were performed at our hospital. Because during routine follow-up visits we noted instances of resorption of the calcar, we decided to assess whether this was a problem. We were able to assess 85 of the original 108 hips.

Calcar resorption was observed in 43 hips. The extent of calcar resorption varied from 1 mm to over 15 mm. In one patient a biopsy showed typical polyethylene granuloma.

Because there is a risk of long-term failure, we concluded that it is inadvisable to use a cemented polished titanium stem when UHMWP is one of the bearing surfaces.


J.F. de Beer K. van Rooyen R. Harvie

Painful conditions of the acromioclavicular (AC) joint are common in South Africa, particularly among sportsmen. These conditions are often treated by open excision of the distal end of the clavicle, but an arthroscopic procedure offers many advantages.

From February 1994 to February 2000, we performed 138 procedures. The mean age of patients ({71% men and 29% women) was 29 years (19 to 53). In cases of rotator cuff impingement, arthroscopic acromioplasty was followed by clavicular excision via the subacromial route. With a normal acromion and rotator cuff the AC joint was approached through two superior AC portals, avoiding removal of the AC ligaments. In all cases a standard 3.5-mm arthroscope was placed in one portal for viewing and the mechanical shaver inserted through the other. About 7 mm to 8mm of bone was removed from the clavicle. Patients were in hospital for about a day and 87% were discharged the same day.

The mean follow-up time was 34 months (2 months to 4 years). Patient satisfaction was high in 32%, fair in 60% and poor in 8%. Most patients (92%) returned to all previous sports and activities.

We concluded that the arthroscopic Mumford procedure is at least as successful as its open equivalent. It can be done as an outpatient procedure and permits a rapid return to activities. Cosmesis is excellent and stability of the AC joint is preserved.


J.F. de Beer K. van Rooyen R. Harvie D.F. du Toit C. Muller J. Matthysen

The rotator cuff is sited on the anatomical neck of the humerus and is formed by the insertion of the supraspinatus (SP), infraspinatus (IS), teres minor (TM) and subscapularis. All play a vital role in the movement of the glenohumeral joint, and the anatomy is of critical importance in arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. We undertook an osteological and gross anatomical dissection study of the insertion mechanism of these tendons, in particular the SP .

The SP inserts by a triple or quadruple mechanism. The ‘heel’ (medial) and capsule fuse, inserting into the anatomical neck proximal to the anterior facet of the greater humeral tubercle. The ‘foot arch’ inserts as a strong, flat, fibrous tendon into the facet. This area is cuboidal, rectangular, or ellipsoid, and measures 36 mm2 to 64 mm2. In about 5%, the insertion is fleshy (pitted), rendering it weaker than a tendinous attachment. The ‘toe’ lips over the edge of the facet laterally and fuses with the periosteum, fibres of the inter-transverse ligament and the IS. A proximal ‘hood’ of about 4 mm stretches down inferiorly and fuses with the periosteum of the humeral shaft. The subacromial or subdeltoid synovial bursa are sited laterally.

The IS and TM insert into the middle and posterior facets (225 mm and 36 mm2) at respective angles of 80° and 115°. The inferior portion of the TM facet is not fused with the shoulder capsule. The subscapularis inserts broadly into the lesser tubercle, and the superior fibres fuse with the shoulder capsule and intertransverse ligament. The insertion of the subscapularis does not contribute directly to the formation of the ‘hood’, which belongs exclusively to the SP, IP and TM.

This study confirms the complexity of the SP insertion and suggests that an unfavourable attachment or biomechanical anatomical malalignment may lead to eventual tendon/cuff degeneration.


D. Blaha

Calcium sulphate is now a proven adjunct to the replenishment of bone stock in joint replacement surgery. Alone and as a composite, it has been used successfully for many years in both dental and orthopaedic applications. OsteoSet (Wright Medical Technology), a processed, purified material, has been used as a bone void filler in 51 revision total hip arthroplasty (THA) procedures.

Follow-up of these cases ranges from 3 to 48 months. Radiographs show that the calcium sulphate has disappeared in all cases. In all but three patients, all of whom had failure of the acetabular component or infection, the calcium sulphate has been replaced with what appears to be trabeculated cancellous bone. Clinical results for cases that did not have mechanical failure or infection are indistinguishable from any revision THA in which the acetabular component is well fixed.

Implantation of the calcium sulphate pellets calls for preparation of a well vascularised bed. The pellets are placed in such a way that load is not transferred to them from the implanted acetabular component. Rather, the load should be transferred from the acetabular component directly to host bone. Postoperatively, load bearing is limited for at least eight weeks and for longer of the quality of the supporting bone is poor.


I.D. Learmonth

Periprosthetic fractures may occur intraoperatively or postoperatively. The incidence of is approximately 0.6% in primary and 2.4% in revision total hip arthroplasty. Predisposing factors include stress risers, osteolysis, osteopoenia, singly or in combination. Focusing on postoperative fractures, this paper provides a management algorithm.

If the fracture is stable, conservative treatment is appropriate. If the fracture is not stable, one needs to determine whether the prosthesis is loose or not. If the prosthesis is loose, further management will depend on the quality of the bone stock. Good bone stock will allow revision with a long stem or impaction grafting, while poor bone stock will require extensive allografting. Similarly, the adequacy of the bone stock determines the management regime if the pros-thesis is not loose. In the presence of good bone stock, it is usually possible to carry out open reduction and internal fixation. Poor bone stock requires bicortical onlay allografting.

From 1994 to 1998 36 periprosthetic fractures, 14 with stable implants and 22 with unstable, were treated. The stable implants were treated with Dall Miles plates, fixed with cables and crimp-sleeves, bicortical screws distal to the fracture and unicortical screws proximally. The fracture united in 11 hips, two of which subsequently required prosthetic revision for femoral loosening. In one hip the fixation failed with fracture of the cables. Despite other adverse reports, this type of system is recommended for fixation of periprosthetic fractures where the prosthesis is stable.

The 22 periprosthetic fractures with unstable implants were treated using the Bicontact long stem revision implant. Two distal interlocking screws provided early rotational and axial stability, and 14 patients had additional allografting.

Radiological evidence of fracture healing was apparent in all cases. One prosthesis subsided by more than 5 mm with fracture of the interlocking screws. Cementless long stem revision is the treatment of choice for periprosthetic fractures associated with a loose implant.

To ensure successful outcome it is necessary to determine the extent of the fracture, to assess fracture stability and to appreciate the available and appropriate treatment options. It is necessary to ‘be prepared’: these are challenging problems and the final decision often hinges on intraoperative findings.


S. Brijlall

Supracondylar femoral fractures challenge even the most experienced trauma surgeon. Fracture comminution often extends into the articular surface, increasing the risk of joint stiffness and post-traumatic arthritis. This is a preliminary prospective report of 42 supracondylar femoral nailing procedures performed on 41 patients between July 2000 and March 2001.

The mean age of the 21 women and 20 men was 62 years. Five fractures were compound. Classified according to AO classification, there were 28 type-AIII fractures, 10 type-AII, two type-CIII and two type-CII. In all cases a percutaneous surgical technique was used and a 13-mm x 250-mm supracondylar nail inserted. The mean operative time was 70 minutes. Mean follow-up was four months (2 to 10). There were no deep or superficial infections and no implant failures. Twenty fractures healed with no shortening within four months. The mean flexion arc was 105° (5° to 130°). Eight patients with osteoporosis had 1 cm to 2 cm of shortening, which did not affect functional outcome. Of the 20 patients whose fractures united, 17 had no pain and three had mild anterior knee pain. A single patient had 8° of valgus angulation at the fracture site.

This study shows that supracondylar femoral nailing provides improved fracture stabilisation both in elderly patients with osteoporotic metaphyseal bone and in younger patients with extensively comminuted fractures. Percutaneous techniques eliminate the need for extensive surgical dissection, shorten operation times and reduce blood loss.


Full Access
David Jones Jens Struckmeier J. Tenbosch Everett Smith

There is great confusion in the literature on mechano-transduction in osteoblasts. This is partly due to the use of hyper and hypophysiological systems for applying forces to cells. We only find evidence for the role of ion channels at hyper-physiological levels of strain. The cells are far more sensitive to tension than compression indicating that structures within the cell are decisive in determining response and that there is no tensegrity within the cell. Single cell mechanical measurements using an adapted atomic force microscope built in our lab, also does not show any evidence for a tensegrity structure. Analysis of the dimension of stretch and the amount of force needed to activate cells indicates that stretch activated ion channels are not involved as the force required is extremely high in relation to the activation energy of an ion channel. The force required to activate at the mechanosensing system is more in line with the forces generated inside a cell by the actin-myosin structure of several hundred thousand piconewtons.

We find no evidence for any other pathway than a PLC-PKC-Calcium pathway involved in any of the signal transduction pathways, but other pathways are involved in hyperphysiological stretch. One of these induces ICAM-1 and thus can induce inflammatory pathways through cell-cell binding of macrophages and other cells.

Due to the very high energies involved in activating the mechano-transduction pathways we do not see any graviception mechanism of single cells. Indeed many microgravitx flights of 25 seconds duration and a flight of 6 minutes did not show any effect in intracellular calcium. The cellular response to microgravity, if it is not an artefact, is not related to mechanosensing.

This work was supported by the German Space Agency (DLR)


G. Cappaert C.J. Grobbelaar

In the past, many high tibial osteotomies were done to relieve symptoms of osteoarthritis. These osteotomies have largely been replaced by total knee arthroplasty (TKA).

This paper presents the long-term results of 270 osteotomies followed up for 10 years and discusses the complications involved in subsequent conversion to TKA.


Florian Mertens Kai Koller Ullrich Boudriot Marita Kratz Eckhardt Bröckmann David Jones Everett Smith

Using the trabecular bone bioreactor (ZETOS) developed in our laboratories we have investigated the formation of bone using the fluorescent bone seeking markers calcein and alizarin red. And the association of bone formation with the increase in stiffness with mechanical loading.

10 mm diameter bone cores 5 mm thick were obtained from the distal radius /ulna of cows obtained at the slaughter house. by precision cutting with diamond saws and keyhole cutters (our pattern) in sterile 7–10°C phosphate buffered saline (PBS) and cultured in a variation of DMEM containing fructose HI GEM.

Results: Loading the bone 30x 4,000μ per day resulted in an increase of stiffness of 35%, by day 30 while the non loaded controls decreased in stiffness. Calcein was added at day 27 to the circulating medium for 4 hours and then fresh medium was circulated. On day 30 alazarin red was circulated through the trabecular bone. The bones were subsequently fixed and embedded in resin and sectioned by classical histological techniques. The difference in distance between the two dyes indicated the amount of bone formation. The mechanically loaded bones showed significant evidence of formation and also significant numbers of active osteoclasts indicating high bone turnover. No evidence of necrosis or cartilage formation was found. Formation in unloaded bones was much reduced and on many areas no active osteoblasts could be observed. This is the first demonstration of bone formation ex vivo after 30 days of culture.

We gratefully acknowledge support by the German Arthrose Foundation (DAH) and the AO in Davos, CH. DJ is a recipient of a Fork award from the AO


D. Dejour V. Correa E. Locatelli T. Tavernier

Purpose: Radiologists describe cysts of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) as a cystic formation of the cruciate tentorium. The estimated prevalence is 0.2 to 1.3% of patients explored by magnetic resonance imaging. The purpose of this study was to better define the clinical symptoms involved by comparing clinical, radiological and pathological findings.

Material and methods: Between February 1996 and April 2000, nine men underwent surgery of the anterior cruciate ligament for cysts. Mean age at surgery was 43 years (26) 54). None of the patients had a history of trauma and one patient had undergone medial meniscectomy 12 months earlier due to meniscosis. Pain had been present for six months to seven years and progressed slowly. It was very specifically related to hyperflexion. Five patients exhibited a moderate effusion and five had a painful joint line. The Lachmann was stiff. Single leg stance plain x-rays were normal. Magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated a poorly delimited heterogeneous destructured aspect of the ACL in seven patients. The suggested diagnosis was “partial tear of the ACL or old tear of the ACL”. A perfectly circumscribed cyst was revealed by the MRI in two cases, lying behind the ACL in the tentorium of the notch. The posterior cruciate ligament had a normal aspect in all cases.

Results: All patients underwent arthroscopy. The ACL was deorganised, widened and yellow in eight, with a yellow circumscribed nodule on the posterior aspect in one. An impingement between the ACL and the tentorium of the notch was observed in one case. Total synovectomy of the ACL sheath removing part of the ligamentous fibres was performed in eight cases. An isolated cyst was removed in one. Plasty of the notch was performed in one. Pathology reported degenerative dystrophic lesions in eight cases and haemopigmented villonodulary synovitis in one. All patients were reviewed at a mean follow-up of 14 months (8–48). Pain at hyperflexion had completely subsided and there was no hydrarthrosis. The Lachmann was stiff and symmetrical.

Conclusion: The term ACL cyst is probably inappropriate because we were unable to find true cystic formations but rather a spontaneous degenerative process. Synovectomy of the sheath gave good clinical results. MRI findings can be a diagnostic pitfall: a destructured aspect of the ACL without a context of trauma should suggest spontaneous degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament.


M. Chaker P. Chambat

Purpose: The purpose of our study was to evaluate, in a context of laxity, the incidence of meniscal lesions and their treatment on the osteoarthritic evolution after more than ten years. In 1986 and 1987, we operated 230 knees with tears of the anterior cruciate ligament using a patellar graft. Among these knees, 184 (80%) were reviewed clinically and radiographically for this study.

Material and methods: Ninety patients (49%) had healthy menisci at the operation and did not have a secondary meniscal procedure; 94 patients (51%) had a meniscal procedure before, during or after the plasty. Among these, 13 (14%) had had an earlier meniscectomy, 18 (19%) had had meniscectomy at the time of the plasty (two revisions), 35 (37%) had had sutures (five secondary failures), ten (11%) had had a long injury left in place (four revisons), and 18 (19%) with normal knees at the time of the plasty had a secondary meniscectomy.

Results: We compared the radiological results in these different populations (osteoarthritis with remodelling compared with normal images). There was a significant difference between the population with normal knee images and the population with meniscal lesions irrespective of the time of treatment (prior meniscectomy, concomitant meniscectomy and plasty, healthy menisci at the time of plasty but secondary meniscectomy). There was no significant difference between the knees with normal menisci and those with sutured menisci.

Conclusion: Saving the meniscus has a major effect on the radiological evolution of the knee. Thus isolated meniscectomy should not be performed for laxity in young patients; meniscal lesions should be sutured at the time of ligamentoplasty.


I.D. Learmonth

Because there are a number of complicating factors, total hip arthroplasty (THA) performed following acetabular fractures has a less favourable prognosis than when done for primary degenerative arthritis. Patients who have had ace-tabular fracture and present for consideration of THA need careful clinical and radiological assessment. Investigation should include AP and lateral radiographs, 45° inlet/outlet views, obturator and iliac obliques, Judet views and CT scan, with or without 3D reconstruction. There are various classifications defining whether the bone deficiency is contained or uncontained and the extent of the structural defect. Treatment options include autograft, allograft together with mesh, screws, plates, rings, cages, etc.

It is probably preferable to undertake THA sooner (as soon as there is radiological evidence of incongruent articular surfaces) rather than later, as this reduces the delay between fracture and recovery from THA, and any inadequate reduction can be minimised or corrected. The surgical approach must allow adequate access for the intended reconstruction. Small contained or uncontained defects can be treated with cemented or cementless implants and limited grafting. Large defects require structural reinforcement, bone grafting, a retaining cage and, unless a custom-made implant is used, cemented fixation.

Potential problems at the time of surgery include sciatic nerve injury (beware the ‘double crush syndrome’) obstructive hardware, heterotopic ossification, avascular necrosis of the acetabulum and occult infection. Patients who are elderly or who present with markedly impacted fracture, extensive abrasion or fracture of the femoral head, displaced femoral neck fracture, and extensive acetabular comminution in the presence of osteopoenic bone, may warrant acute management with THA.

Early experience of THA in the treatment of selected acute fractures is encouraging. However, the clinical results of THA after fractures of the acetabulum are often disappointing, and there is no current evidence that open reduction and internal fixation improves the success of the subsequent THA.

THA following acetabular fractures is a challenging procedure with a high complication rate. Appropriate investigation and preoperative planning reduces the risk of complications.


K. Synnott A. Kenkinson M. Walsh T. O’Brien

Introduction: Gait initiation is a sequence of stereotypical postural shifts culminating in a forward step. Muscular and gravitational forces interact leading to appropriate dynamic conditions that allow progression. This requires a complicated system of neural and muscular control. Derangement of ground reaction forces during gait initiation may be a more specific indicator of neuromuscular disease than steady state gait.

Little work has been done on gait initiation in children and there is no published data on gait initiation with cerebral palsy. The aim of this study was to examine the ground reaction forces and centre of pressure in normal children during gait initiation, to compare these to similar values in hemiplegic children and to try to identify differences between the two which may be diagnostic for hemiplegia.

Patients and methods: Five normal and five hemiplegic children were studied. Kinematic and dynamic data were collected using a CodaTM motion analysis system and KestlerTM force plate. All subjects stood with one foot on and one foot off the force plate and walked off upon hearing an audible cue. Tests were repeated measuring right and left, normal and hemiplegic legs as both stance and swing legs. Ground reaction forces in the X,Y and Z axes, centre of pressure and kinematic data were collected and studied.

Results: 1) Normal children. In the vertical direction for the stance leg there is an initial fall in GRF, followed by a bimodal peak in GRF. In the fore-aft direction the GRF is initially directed backwards and subsequently has a bimodal forward force.

Medio-laterally the stance GRF tending to adduct falls initially and subsequently rises with a bimodal peak. The forces in the swing leg reciprocate these forces.

2) Hemiplegic children. The overall pattern seen when the normal leg is the stance leg are similar to those in normal children with certain specific variations in force development and magnitude. When the hemiplegic leg is the stance leg the overall patterns are again similar but considerably less smooth with characteristic changes indicative of neuro-muscular disturbance. The initial “adjusting” forces tend to be larger indicating the greater force required for control.

Discussion: The pattern and relative magnitude of forces measured for normal children are identical to those previously reported for adults. This validates our study design and indicates that central programming for gait initiation develops early in life. It is therefore an early developmental skill and may be used as a diagnostic test in childhood. Significant variations are seen in cerebral palsy. Knowledge of these specific changes may allow earlier and more accurate diagnosis of cerebral palsy in children under investigation for movement disorders. Normal GRF patterns during gait initiations may provide early reassurance for parents of children suspected of having cerebral palsy.


J Gallagher P. Tierney P. Murray M. O’Brien

Introduction: The infrapatellar fat pad was first described in 1904 by Albert Hoffa. Sometimes disregarded, it is apparent that the infrapatellar fat pad is of importance to knee joint function as fat at this site is only lost in severely emaciated individuals. Also, recent MRI studies have described various pathological changes affecting the fat pad. This study examined the anatomy of the infrapatellar fat pad in relation to knee symptoms and surgical approaches.

Materials and Methods: 8 preserved knees were dissected via semicircular parapatellar incisions extending from the tibial tubercle to the superior patellar border and including the quadriceps muscle 13 cm above the superior border of the patella. The synovial membrane of the joint and the ligamentum mucosum were divided and the tibial tubercle was then excised. The resultant tissue complex was removed and the fat pad dissected away from surrounding structures. The appearance, volume and presence of any clefts in the pad were recorded. The cadaveric dissections were then compared to direct observation of the fat pad during total knee replacement, during arthroscopy and on MR imaging.

Results: The infrapatellar fat pad was found to be present in all cases. It had a consistent shape consisting of a central mass with medial and lateral extensions. The ligamentum mucosum was attached to the intercondylar notch of the femur in all cases and measured an average of 15.7mm at its base. A horizontal cleft was found in 6 cases and a vertical cleft was found in 7 cases. Both have been previously noted. A tag extended superiorly from the posterior aspect of the fat pad in 7 cases. The volume of the fat pad had quite a large range among individual cadavers (average volume was 24 ml, range: 12–36ml). The intra-individual variation was smaller with an average difference of 4ml (range:2.7ml) between knees.

Discussion: The infrapatellar fat pad has been implicated in a wide variety of conditions affecting the knee joint. It has been shown to be involved in arthofibrosis of the knee following surgery, patellar tendonitis, formation of intra-articular fibrous bands, and a site of an ossifying chondroma. It seems that fat pad pathology is usually secondary to other knee joint pathology and primary involvement is rare. The presence of clefts in the fat pad is of importance as a distended cleft may mimic an abnormality and an abnormality in the cleft may be overlooked on imaging of the knee joint. The appearance of the fat pad on direct visualisation in the living person presented a fat pad with a more globular appearance than that seen in the cadaver. The clefts were clearly visualised on MRI.

Conclusion: The infrapatellar fat pad is a structure that is consistently present in the knee joint. It consists of a central body with medial and lateral and medical extensions. It usually contains a vertical cleft located superiorly and a horizontal cleft located inferiorly as well as a tag of fat extending superiorly, which forms the roof of the vertical cleft. The infrapatellar fat pad is attached to the intercondylar notch of the femur by the ligamentum mucosum and is firmly anchored to the patella by dense fibrous tissue.


R. Ling

The Exeter totally collarless, double-tapered femoral component was developed in 1969 jointly at the School of Engineering at the University of Exeter and the old Princess Elizabeth Orthopaedic Hospital. At the time, in common with a number of implants in contemporary use, the new Exeter stem was manufactured from the rather ductile stainless steel EN58J. The original version of the Exeter stem had a polished surface. This feature was not part of the original design specification, but was demanded by the current British standard governing the use of EN58J in orthopaedic implants. At that time, no thought was given to the possibility that the surface finish of the stem might influence outcome.

Used from 1970 to 1975, the original stems rarely came to need replacement because of loosening. The major complication was the incidence of stem fracture, first seen in 1973, which has reached 4% over a 25 to 30 year follow-up. A stronger stem was introduced at the beginning of 1976. This was manufactured from 316L. As there was no standard demanding a polished surface, this stem was manufactured with a surface two orders of magnitude rougher than the surface of the original polished Exeter stems. While the introduction of this stem almost completely solved the problem of stem fracture, with it appeared notable problems of femoral endosteal bone lysis and aseptic stem loosening, hardly seen with the original polished stems. The study of retrieved prostheses showed the matt surface stem to be prone to abrasive wear against the inside of the cement mantle, and that this phenomenon could lead both directly and indirectly to stem loosening.

Unfortunately, a decade passed before the polished stem was re-introduced in 1986. A monobloc version was used until the beginning of 1988, when the modular Exeter Universal stem was introduced. With both the monobloc and modular versions of the polished Exeter stem, both aseptic loosening and localised endosteal bone lysis have become rare.

Further retrieval studies have shown that in polished and matt Exeter stems the wear processes between stem and cement are fundamentally different. This difference may explain the substantial clinical difference in outcome between these two types of stem. These considerations lead to the view that abrasive stem wear in matt stems is probably a major cause of failure, and more important than failure of cement.


C. court E. Fadel G. Missenard J.Y. Nordin P. Dartevelle

Purpose: En bloc resection can be proposed for lung cancer involving the apex with invasion of the ribs or the transverse process using a transcervical anterior approach. Cancers invading the intervertebral foramen cannot be resected via this approach despite the classical indication for surgical resection. We report results of a novel surgical technique allowing cancerological resection of these tumours.

Material and methods: Fifteen patients with the same grade of cancer were operated using the same surgical technique. The first operative time included: superior lobectomy via anterior cervicothoracic access (without removal of the lobe), dissection of the subclavian vessels and the brachial plexus, section of the ribs and the T1 root, spinal exposure from C6 to T5, hemi-disectomy C7-T1 and discectomy at the level below the invaded foramen, medial vertebral groove, closure. The second operative time included: posterior access, extended instrumentation of the spine, hemi-laminectomy C7 extended as needed, section of the roots (depending on the level of the resection) within the canal, oblique posterior vertebral osteotomy along the medial border of the pedicle terminating in the anterior groove. Finally en bloc ablation via the posterior access of the surgical piece including the lung, the ribs and the hemi-vertebrae.

Results: Three- and four-level hemivertebrectomy was performed in eleven and three patients respectively. One patient had two hemivertebrectomies associated with one vertebrectomy. There were six resections (with repair) of the subclavian vessels for tumour invasion. Peroperative mortality was zero. Mean blood loss was 3000 ml. There were no neurological complications. There were eight postoperative complications: pneumonia five patients, cerebrospinal fluid fistula one patient, skin dehiscence one patient, haemorrhage one patient requiring reoperation. All patients were given postoperative radiotherapy. Three- and five-year survival was 36% and 27% respectively. Among the nine deaths, three had local relapse and six had general relapse.

Discussion: This techniques enables resection of tumours considered to be inextirpable using other techniques. Survival was the same as for tumours of the apex without invasion of the foramen and better than without surgery. This major surgery requires a well-trained multidisciplinary team (thoracic and vascular surgeons, spinal surgeon, anaesthesiologists, intensive care specialists). Contraindications for this type of surgery are invasion of the spinal canal, the brachial plexus and the vertebral body as well as the presence of a spinal artery entering the foramen to be resected.


G. Missenard E. Mascard C. Court

Purpose: Use of massive allografts for reconstruction of major bone stock defects remains a controversial issue. We reviewed our experience to compare results with other methods, particularly free vascularised bone transfer reconstructions.

Material and method: Between 1983 and 1995, 36 patients (15 men and 21 women) underwent cancerological resection of a long bone shaft for primary malignant tumour. Mean age was 19 years (8–84). The tumour was a high-grade sarcoma in 26 cases, low grade sarcoma in eight and adamantinoma in two. Mean length of resection was 19 cm (14–34). Cryopreserved allografts were used in 24 cases, gamma irradiated allografts in 12. Various osteosynthesis procedures were used, generally combining an axial assembly with a single or dual epiphyseal construct. Localisations were: femur 24, tibia ten and humerus four. All patients were reviewed at a minimum follow-up of five years (range 5–16 years, mean 8 years). Functional outcome was assessed with the Enneking criteria. Bone healing at junctions was considered to be achieved when there was no clinical expression and radiographic images remained unchanged for two years.

Results: All immediate complications were infections (one femur four tibias) and required partial or total ablation of the allograft in four cases and amputation in one (tibia). The predominant late complications were late consolidation (n=13) and stress fracture of the allograft (n=6). Six patients died before bone healing and were not retained for analysis. Among the 28 patients retained for analysis (eight excluded: six deaths, one amputation, one total ablation of the allograft), only ten achieved bone healing after one procedure. The other eighteen required on the average four reoperations to achieve consolidation (3–11 procedures for osteosynthesis and new allograft material). All patients had achieved bone healing at last follow-up. Functional outcome was excellent for femurs, good for tibias, and fair for humeri due to the impact on shoulder function. There was no significant difference in consolidation with cryopreserved and irradiated bone material but two irradiated grafts could not be used correctly because they were to friable.

Discussion: These more or less satisfactory results must be examined in light of the context. Cancerologicl resection (periosteum + soft tissue), generally combined with adjuvant treatment (chemotherapy for 24 patients and radiotherapy for three), places the patient in conditions highly unfavourable for bone healing. Use of allografts alone, combined with approximate fixation procedures early in our experience, demonstrated the limitations of the technique (only two primary consolidations among 18 patients). However, when the allograft was combined with axial fixation and immediate allograft or allograft after adjuvant treatment, primary consolidation was achieved in 80% of the cases (eight out of ten). All patients who achieved long-term remission conserved a functional limb with relatively preserved bone stock.

Conclusion: Despite controversial results, massive allograft reconstructions can provide a useful alternative to fill major bone stock defects of the femur or humerus. For the tibia the risk of infections may require further discussion before determining the best approach. These results should be compared with those in a homogeneous series of patients treated with a vascularised free bone transfer, but to our knowledge no such series is available in the literature.


N.G.J. Maritz P.J. Oosthuizen

Because there is little in the literature about specific presentation and examination methods for acromioclavicular (AC) joint pathology, we aimed to define and identify the most reliable tests.

We identified and examined 30 patients with probable AC joint pathology. We then excluded eight patients who experienced no pain relief after local Lignocaine infiltration, and examined 22 patients, two of whom had bilateral shoulder problems.

There were 15 complaints of AC joint pain, 13 of anterior pain, five of posterior pain and five of lateral pain. Pain radiated anteriorly in 14 patients, posteriorly in two, laterally in three and to the cervical region in three. Pain increased with weight-bearing in 18 shoulders, on elevation in five, on activities of daily living in six, at night or on being lain on in 11, and on reaching across the body in three. Clinical examination revealed swelling in seven shoulders and AC joint prominence in seven. There was local tenderness in 21 shoulders and there were crepitations in four. The forced cross-body test produced pain in 22 shoulders. In 22 shoulders, elevation was less than 60°. Jobe’s test was positive in 20, the Speed’s test in 19, O’Brien’s test in 15, the compression test in 15, the distraction test in 13. A painful arc was present to 160° in 13 shoulders. There was neck tenderness in 13 patients. Associated conditions included two cases of shoulder arthritis, six of impingement, two rotator cuff tears, two cases of biceps tendinitis and two of cervical pathology. Radiological changes were evident in 19 AC joints, 13 shoulder joints and 11 cervical spines. On ultrasonography, pathology was resent in 10 of 15 cases.

The most common symptoms were pain with weight-bearing, elevation and lying on shoulder. Anterior and posterior pain was the most common. The most common clinical findings were local tenderness, pain on elevation and the forced cross-body test, positive Jobe’s and Speed’s tests. Because no test is 100% accurate, the whole clinical presentation must be taken into account. Local infiltration of the AC joint is extremely helpful.


P.A. Daussin M. Chammas F. Bacou B. Coulet C. Lazergues Y. Alleiu

Purpose: Recovery of muscle function after nerve repair remains incomplete despite progress in microsurgical techniques. Potential for muscle recovery could be greatly improved. The purpose of our study was to demonstrate the functional impact of exogenous satellite cells in degenerated muscles.

Material and methods: We used the anterior tibialis muscle (Ta) in rabbits (n=24) as our experimental model. Muscle degeneration was created by bilateral injections of cardio-toxin into the Ta. Five days later, the left Ta was injected with autologous satellite cells (SC) at multiple points. The same volume of culture medium was injected into the right Ta. Two months later, maximal isometric muscle force and stress resistance of the Ta was measured. Histoimmuno-chemical labellings were made.

Results: The volume of cardiotoxin injected created two categories of muscles: recovery of former function was not possible with low dose cardiotoxin injections. Maximal isometric muscle force was less than 35% of the control. Transfer of SC restored nearly normal muscle force. Resistance to stress followed the same pattern. Recovery of maximal muscle force was possible with high-dose cardiotoxin injections. Resistance to stress was greater than the control (+ 35%). Transfer of SC did not modify results.

The weight of the Ta increased for both cardiotoxin doses. There was an increase in the size of the fibres with or without SC transfer.

Discussion: Injection of cardiotoxin induced muscle degeneration. With greater muscle degeneration, regeneration of muscle capacity was greater. Transfer of SC improved the functional result when muscle degeneration was incomplete. Improved resistance to stress after injection of high-dose cardiotoxin could result from changes in muscle myosin and fibrillary structure.

Conclusion: Further studies are needed before clinical application to better understand the underlying mechanisms operating with satellite cell injections. Many applications could be proposed, particularly for surgical nerve repair, ischaemic heart failure, and myopathy.


J. Walters G. Grobler B. Heywood I.D. Learmonth

We reviewed the outcome of prosthesis-to-bone fixation of the rough titanium femoral stem of an Ultraloc prosthesis (Zimmer, USA).

Between 1989 and 1991, 41 of 55 patients were traced for long-term review at a mean of 107 months (55 to 139). The primary pathology was avascular necrosis in 18 patients, osteoarthritis in 16, ankylosing spondylitis in two and Perthes’ disease in one, and there were two cases each of trauma and dysplasia. There was an equal number of men and women, whose mean age at operation was 47 years (24 to 66).

Radiological assessment of the stems revealed well-fixed stems in 40 patients (97.6%). In 20 stems small granulomata due to polyethylene wear were found in Gruen zones 1 and 7, and in one stem in zones 1, 6 and 7. Only one stem required revision for loosening (done at 59 months), but cups (48.8%) were loose. Three patients required revision owing to polyethylene wear and one for sepsis. In all four cases, removal of the stem was extremely difficult. The remaining 16 hips await revision.

Although the results obtained using an Ultraloc prosthesis are poor, from the point of view of fixation the stem has functioned successfully. However, the formation of granulomata causes cup loosening.


Full Access
S. Dix-Peek E.B. Hoffman B.C. Vrettos

We retrospectively reviewed 10 children treated for tuberculosis of the elbow over a 21-year period from 1979 to 1999.

The mean age at diagnosis was 5.5 years (1 to 11). The median duration of symptoms was 10 weeks (l week to 18 months). The patients presented mainly with swelling of the elbow joint due to synovitis. Radiological appearances of the elbow at presentation were assessed according to Kerri and Martini’s classification. One elbow was stage I (osteopoenia), eight were stage II (osteopoenia and erosions) and one stage III (joint space narrowing).

Open biopsy was performed on all patients. There was positive histology (caseating granuloma) and/or positive culture in eight patients. Of the two patients with non-specific histology and negative culture, one was found on chest radiograph to have tuberculosis involvement and the other healed on anti-tuberculosis therapy. All patients were treated with rifampicin, isoniazide and pyrazinamide for nine months. No synovectomy was done. Postoperatively all patients were immobilised in a backslab and then actively mobilised.

At a mean follow-up of three years (1 to 10), patients were assessed according to a modification of Kerri and Martini’s classification. Seven of the eight stage-I or stage-II patients had an excellent result (full range of movement) or good result (loss of less than 30% of range of movement). One stage-II patient had a fair result (loss of range of movement of 30% to 50%). The stage-III patient had a poor result (loss of more than 50% of range of movement).

We concluded that elbows with stage-I and stage-II disease (synovitis) have a good outcome. Anti-tuberculosis chemotherapy is effective in the treatment of stage-I and stage II disease. Synovectomy is unnecessary.


S.R.S. Bibby M.S. Razaq D.A. Jones J.P.G. Urban

Intervertebral disc cells exsist in a precarious nutritional environment. Local concentrations depend on both nutritional supply and demand. Little is known about the metabolism of disc cells; existing data focuses on intact tissue, where the local metabolic environment is unknown. We have thus developed a closed chamber to study the metabolism of isolated cells under controlled conditions.

Bovine disc cells were isolated from coccygeal discs and transferred to the sealed chamber, in which embedded electrodes measured pH, pO2 and glucose concentration, and a port allowed sampling and addition of metabolic reagents. Metabolic rates were assessed from concentration changes. Cell viability was assessed and intracellular ATP measured at completion of each experiment.

Under standard conditions, metabolic rates were similar to those measured in tissue, with a glucose:lactic acid ratio of approximately one to two. We have also examined the effect of extracellular pH on nucleus pulposus cell metabolism. Between pH 7.4–6.8, metabolism is insensitive to extracellular pH, and lactic acid production agrees with the literature 1, 2. Below pH 6.8, lactic acid production fell linearly with decreased pH. At pH 6.4, lactic acid production had fallen by 60%, and intracellular ATP by 80%.

These results show a fall in lactic acid production with extracellular acidification, which in vivo arises mainly from lactic acid produced by the cells. This may be protective. However the decrease in metabolism, and hence loss of ATP, may have a detrimental effect on the cells. There is thus a complex interplay between different components of the nutritional environment. Investigating these in combination should give valuable information about disc cell metabolism, as changes in cells metabolism can affect nutrient availability and hence cellular activity and viability.


R.O. Evans L. Lough Srot R R Bindra

Horse riding is a common pursuit and is more dangerous than believed. Most injuries of the hand and wrist are caused by falls, as in other sports. However, exclusive to riding are injuries sustained whilst leading a horse. Avulsion injuries are well recognised but little has been reported on phalangeal fractures in this situation.

We report on seven cases that required hospitalisation in our hand unit, for injuries from horses over a two year period. Six of these patients sustained multi-fragmented spiral periarticular fractures involving the middle and proximal phalanx and one a horse bit.

We will discuss in detail the mechanism of their injuries, the surgery undertaken, their post-operative rehabilitation and overall outcome. Furthermore we review the recommended horse handling technique and contrast it with the mechanism of injury in our cases.

In our experience the fractures seen were unstable, comminuted and needed internal fixation. One patient developed a delayed union and three post-operative stiffness. Our results suggest that fractures whilst leading horses are more complex than recognised, usually need surgery and often have a relatively poor outcome. All of these cases were largely preventable and could be attributed to incorrect horse leading technique.


A.C. Breen J.M. Muggleton M. Kondracki J. Wright A. Morris

This study compared the effect of manipulation with a period of normal activity on the range of intervertebral sidebending.

Thirty asymptomatic male volunteers were randomised to treatment or control groups. All were subjected to low-dose X-ray screening through 80° of passive lumbar spine side-bending. Motion sequences were digitised at a 5Hz sampling rate. The treatment group (n=16) had rotary manipulation to each lumbar linkage, followed by normal activity. The control group (n=14) had normal activity only. Both groups were then re-screened. Each vertebral pair was tracked and intervertebral rotation throughout the motion measured. Three subjects were analysed 10 times for reliability and all intervertebral motion was tracked twice.

Twenty-one manipulated linkages and 10 controls met the reliability criteria. For non-manipulated segments the mean range at first screening was 14.2° (SD 1.39) and manipulated segments 12.8° (SD 3.81). The range of the non-manipulated segments increased by +0.9o and the manipulated segments by +0.4°.

The change in manipulated segments was negligible and similar to controls, although the instrument can be sufficiently reliable to measure a 2° difference. The technique is sufficiently robust to determine if spinal manipulation changes these ranges in selected patients.


T.W. Munting E.B. Hoffman C.J. Hastings

In order to assess the incidence of avascular necrosis (AVN) following septic arthritis of the hip in children, we retrospectively reviewed the outcome of 227 hips with septic arthritis treated over an 18-year period. The mean age at presentation of the 221 patients, six of who had bilateral conditions, was 5.6 years (5 months to 14 years).

All patients underwent open arthrotomy and pus was found at surgery. Patients were treated with cloxacillin and patients aged six months to two years also received ampicillin. Staphylococcus areus was cultured in 51% of hips, Haemophilus influenzae in 9%, Streptococcus pneumoniae in 4% and Streptococcus pyogenes in 6%. The remaining 30% had no growth. Septicaemia was present in 20 patients at presentation.

AVN developed in 24 hips (10.5%), and chondrolysis in five (2.2%). Of the hips with AVN, seven were septicaemic. The most important factor in the development of AVN was a delay of five or more days from onset of symptoms to surgery. The risk of AVN with five days’ delay was 50% and increased exponentially with a longer delay. Septicaemia did not constitute a risk per se, but did contribute to a delay in diagnosis of hip involvement. The total head was involved in 14 of the 24 hips with AVN, while 10 had partial head involvement, with a better long-term outcome.


A. Veihelmann A. Hofbauer F. Krombach H.J. Refior K. Messmer

Nitric oxide (NO) production by the inducible NO synthase (iNOS) and enhanced emigration of leukocytes into synovial tissue are suggested to play a crucial role in mediating chronic joint inflammation such as rheumatoid arthritis. The effects of iNOS inhibition in experimental arthritis are dicussed controversally. The aim of our study was to analyze the synovial microcirculation and leukocyte endothelial cell interactions in iNOS-deficient mice with antigen-induced arthritis (AiA) in vivo. 14 homocygote iNOS-deficient (iNOS KO C57BL6/J x 129SvEv; Merck & Co., Rahway, NJ, USA) and 14 iNOS-positive (C57BL6/J x 129SvEv) mice were used for our study. The patella tendon was resected, which allows for visualization of the intraarticular synovial tissue of the knee joint using intravital fluorescence microscopy. Animals were allocated into four groups (iNOS +/+, iNOS +/+ with AiA, iNOS −/− and iNOS −/− with AiA) (n=7 each group). On day 8 after arthritis induction, functional capillary density (FCD), fraction of rolling leukocytes, and the number of adherent leukocytes were quantitatively analyzed in synovial postcapillary venules. Histologic sections were performed to assess leukocyte infiltration of the synovium.

FCD or leukocyte-endothelial cell interaction were not altered in healthy iNOS-deficient mice in comparison to iNOS +/+ animals. However, in iNOS-deficient animals with AiA there was a significant increase in the fraction of rolling (0,510,05) and in the number of adherent leukocytes (729126 mm-2) in comparison to wild type mice with AiA (0,330,07 and 565110 mm-2) (MWSEM, p < 0,05). Histologic sections revealed increased leukocyte infiltration in iNOS-deficient animals with AiA compared to iNOS +/+ arthritic animals.

In our study, there was an enhanced leukocyte accumulation and extravasation in iNOS-deficient mice with antigen-induced arthritis in comparison to iNOS-positive animals with arthritis. Thus, the induction of iNOS appears as critical protective response to AiA possibly by reducing leukocyte adhesion and infiltration.


A. Veihelmann G. Szczesny H.J. Refior K. Messmer

Edema and infection represent serious complications of blunt extremity trauma. It is important to differentiate between pathophysiological changes within tissues proximal and within distal to the site of trauma. The aim was to investigate the effects of soft tissue trauma on the microcirculation of the mouse lower limb. Endothelial leakage and leukocyte accumulation proximal and distal to the site of trauma were studied using intravital fluorescence microscopy.

Low-energy trauma to the lower limb was defined in previous experiments as a trauma transferring 50% of the energy required to produce tibial fracture. The trauma was inflicted under general anesthesia by an accelerator, hitting the mid-section of the calf in a perpendicular direction. 5, 90, and 180 minutes after trauma, the following microcirculatory parameters were measured: diameter of arterioles, venules, functional capillary density (FCD), extravasation of FITC-dextrane, and leukocyte-endothelial cell-interactions. Two groups (control and trauma) were studied proximal to, distal to and at the site of trauma. Skin, subcutaneous tissue and muscle were investigated individually in the trauma and the control groups (each group n=7).

At the site of trauma, distinct extravasation and edema formation in all tissues was observed. In subcutaneous and muscle tissue, microvascular thrombosis as well as edema were detected proximal and distal to the trauma. FCD was reduced in muscle and fat tissue. The numbers of rolling and adherent leukocytes were enhanced 5 minutes after trauma and throughout the observational period.

Our results demonstrate endothelial leakage and extravasation early after low-energy soft tissue trauma in all soft tissues proximal and distal to the site of trauma. In addition, we found high accumulation of leukocytes in all locations, especially in soft tissues. The model presented is ideally suited for the in vivo investigation of new therapeutic strategies for edema and thrombosis prevention in animals with soft tissue trauma.


Full Access
S. Dix-Peek C.J. Hastings E.B. Hoffman L.D. Lee

To assess the role of pelvic osteotomy during the closure of bladder and cloacal exstrophy, we retrospectively reviewed 10 patients treated from 1990 to 1999.

Six patients had cloacal exstrophy and four had bladder exstrophy. Two patients had no primary osteotomy. Two had posterior, two anterior pubic and two midiliac oblique osteotomies. Osteotomies were performed at a median age of 5.3 weeks.

The mean follow-up time was five years (2 to 11). We assessed facilitation of closure, reconstitution of pelvic anatomy, maintenance of interpubic distance (IPD), urinary continence and gait.

All osteotomies facilitated soft tissue closure at the time of surgery. Subjectively, the best restoration of pelvic anatomy was with a midiliac oblique osteotomy. In all patients, IPD increased progressively with increasing age (mean pre-operatively 3.3 cm, postoperatively 1.9 cm and 5.0 cm at follow-up).

The results of soft tissue surgery to provide continence and maintain abdominal wall closure were poor. All procedures to address incontinence failed and there was a 100% dehiscence/sepsis rate. Although half the children had increased external rotation of the hip at review, only one child had an externally rotated joint. .


K.J. Mulhall P. Kelly W.A. Curtin H.F. Given

The current long term results of total joint arthroplasty are limited by mechanical wear of the implants with an associated immune mediated bone lysis with subsequent loosening and eventual failure. It has been demonstrated that the osteolysis seen in cases of aseptic loosening is mediated by the immune system, particularly, both directly and indirectly, by activated macrophages. Macrophages indirectly cause osteolysis through release of the osteoclast activating cytokines: TNFα, IL-1 and PGE2 and also directly resorb bone in small amounts when activated by wear particles.

We wished to determine if macrophage activation and the release of osteolytic cytokines in response to orthopaedic wear debris could be suppressed pharmacologically, with the use of anti-inflammatory and anti oxidant agents.

We utilised established cell culture models of both peripherally derived monocyte/macrophages and lymphocyte enriched co-cultures and examined the effects of polymethylmethacrylate particles alone on the cells in culture. The effects of anti-inflammatory and anti-oxidant agents (dexamethasone, diclofenac and n-acetyl cysteine) in varying concentrations were then examined using ELISA of cytokine release and electron microscopy to examine ultra structural responses.

Cell viability was also measured in cultures over 24 hour periods (at 6, 12 and 24 hours) using Trypan blue exclusion and Coulter counter, while cell type and morphology were determined cytologically, including α-naphthyl acetate esterase cytochemical identification and electron microscopy. The use of N-acetyl cysteine was associated with very significant suppression of TNFα, IL-1β and PGE2 in both macrophage and lymphocyte enriched co-culture with no effect on cell viability. While diclofenac was also associated with significant decreases in cytokine expression it was associated with a decrease in cell viability that approached significance. Dexamethasone did not have a reliable effect on these cytokines. Ultra-structural electron microscopic examination of the cells also demonstrated signs of definite down-regulation of cytoplasmic and nuclear activation.

We have demonstrated, therefore, that novel anti-oxidant therapies and possibly other immune modulating drugs can eliminate the activation of macrophages in response to peri-prosthetic wear particles without any associated decrease in cell viability and thus may provide a means of reducing the incidence of loosening and failure of total joint arthroplasty.


R. McKeown A. Cosgrove R. Baker

Over a 4 year period 27 children with cerebral palsy underwent proximal femoral derotation osteotomy resulting in a total of 42 operations performed. Each of these children had pre operative gait analysis performed followed by derotation osteotomy. The degree of derotation varied individually and was judged to be correct when the foot lay in a neutral position. Gait analysis was not repeated until 1 year after surgery to allow for complete bony union, recovery of the soft tissues and general patient rehabilitation. Pre-operative and post-operative data were compared to give a quantitative analysis of the actual derotation obtained.

The mean age at the time of operation was 9.7 years (range 4.5–14.5 years). The male : female ration was 6 : 5. the mean amount of femoral derotation achieved was 26.25 degrees (minimum 7 degrees, maximum 66 degrees). The goal of the operation was to correct internal rotation and achieve a hip in a neutral position throughout the majority of the gait cycle. The average hip rotation in a normal able-bodied person is 1.72 degrees of external rotation. 84% achieved more than 75% derotation to neutral. The remainder were considered operational failures.

These results quantitatively demonstrate that proximal femoral derotation osteotomy is a successful operation in cerebral palsy to correct intoeing.


F.T. Welsch J.A. Martin A.A. Kurth N.N.P. Tran R.A. Brand

Chondrocyte sensitivity to strain depends on signal transduction pathways which include integrin-dependent increases in intracellular calcium. Human articular chondrocytes were cultured as monolayers in silicone dishes. After loading the cells with the calcium-fluorescent dye Fluo-3/AM the dishes were mounted in a 4-point bending apparatus and then fixed to a laser scanning confocal microscope. Biaxial substrate strain (15 000e) was applied to the silicone dish via a hand operated cam rotated at ~60 RPM (1 Hz) for 10 or for 50 cycles. Changes in intracellular calcium in single cells were determined by measuring the mean pixel values in the basal and stimulated images taken at different time points. The data reported for 50 cycle treatments represent 49 single cells of six independent cell isolations. The data for 10 cycle strain treatment are from a single experimental setup.

Increases in intracellular calcium were consistently observed in chondrocytes exposed to 15 000me for 50 cycles in a range from 1.3- to 4.0-fold with an average of 2.3-fold (SD=0.79). Few cells responded before 30 minutes but most of the responses occurred 30–60 minutes after strain. Consistent intracellular Ca++-increases were also seen after 10 strain cycles, however responses were detected within 5 minutes post-strain. The relative increase (2.7-fold ± 1.7) was similar in magnitude to 50 cycle responses.

Intracellular Ca++-fluxes in chondrocytes and other cells occur by at least two different mechanisms: through stretch-activated channels in the plasma membrane permit immediate Ca++-influx during strain application or by Ca++-efflux from intracellular compartments stimulated by slower acting second messengers. Our results suggest that the early response to 10 strain cycles is due to Ca++-influx via membrane channels while the later response to 50 cycles is due to Ca++-efflux from intracellular compartments, probably mediated by cytokines released in response to an initial Ca++-influx from the medium.


Full Access
A.R. Meir D.A. Jones D.S. McNally J.P.G. Urban J.C.T. Fairbank

Scoliosis is a disease characterised by vertebral rotation, lateral curvature and changes in sagittal profile. The role of mechanical forces in producing this deformity is not clear. It is thought that abnormal loading deforms the disc, which becomes permanently wedged. Modelling and in vitro studies suggest that such deformations should increase intradiscal pressure. Intradiscal pressure has been measured previously in a variety of clinical environments. The aim of this study is to measure pressure profiles across scoliotic discs to provide further information on the role of mechanical forces in scoliosis.

Pressure readings were obtained in consented patients with ethical approval using a needle-mounted sterilised pressure transducer (Gaeltec, Dunvegan, Isle of Skye) calibrated as described previously. The transducer needle was introduced into the disc of an anaesthetised patient during routine anterior scoliosis surgery and pressure profiles measured. Signals were collected, amplified and analysed using Power-lab and a laptop computer.

Pressure profiles across 10 human scoliotic discs from 3 patients have been measured to date. Pressures varied from 0.1 to 1.2 MPa.

Annular pressures showed high pressure, non-isotropic regions on the concave but not convex side of these discs.

Nuclear pressures recorded from the discs of these scoliotic patients were higher than those recorded previously in non-scoliotic recumbent individuals.


M. Mulier

We want to prove that you cannot make a good fitting stem of a THP before surgery because the resulting shape of the femoral cavity is set after all the tools have been introduced in the femur.

We are fully aware that fit and fill alone is not enough to obtain good fixation therefor all the investigated implants were plasma spray coated with HA.

We’ve investigated two groups of patients:

Pre-operative group: custommade implant based on CT scans and manufactured before surgery The proximal part was size for size and coated with HA; the distal part is cylindrical (44 cases, followup from 1.6 years to 5.2 years)

Per-operative group: custommade implants based on a mould of the femoral cavity in the proximal femur and manufactured during surgery. The prosthesis was size for size and the HA coating was applied on the proximal 1/3 of the implant. (13 cases, with a minimum followup 1 year).

The coating specifications for both groups were exactly the same.We’ve compared the Harris hip score for both groups and we’ve performed a radiolographical analysis.

Of the pre- operative group 6 protheses had to be revised.This results in a revision rate of 25 % which is not acceptable.In the peroperative group however, no revisions have been performed.

Radiografically the per-operative group showed much better results than then the pre-operative group.

The obtained results suggest that it is not only important to have a good bone growth initiator such as HA but the implant needs to be in close contact with the bone.This confirms the limited gap bridging capacity of HA which has been reported by several authors in the past. A close fit can only be obtained by designing and manufacturing the implant during surgery based on the actual size of the femoral cavity.


L.J. de Lange

In total hip arthroplasty (THA), it is preferable that patients have an ideal preoperative Body Mass Index (within 20% of the normal). The purpose of this study is to determine whether patients maintain their preoperative reduced weight after THA and whether the effort of encouragement and cost of a dietician to lose weight preoperatively is worthwhile.

Conducted over five years, this study included 100 patients with a mean age of 62.5 years (34 to 83). Preoperative and postoperative weights were obtained from clinical records.

There was a postoperative weight increase in 51% of patients and a decrease in postoperative weight in 46%. Pre-operative weight was maintained in 3%.


W.E.B. Johnson S.M. Eisenstein S. Roberts

Mature human intervertebral disc cells have generally been described as being either fibroblast-like or chondrocyte-like; i.e. appearing either elongated and bipolar or rounded/oval. Fibroblast-like cells are observed within the outer regions of the anulus fibrosus whilst chondrocyte-like cells are found in the more central regions of the disc. However, a few reports have noted that in some circumstances disc cells appear to extend more elaborate cytoplasmic processes into their surrounding extracellular matrix. In this study, we have examined healthy and pathological human intervertebral discs for the presence of the cytoskeletal elements, F-actin and vimentin.

Tissues examined included discs of no known pathology, discs with spondylolithesis, scoliosis specimens taken from the convex and concave sides, and degenerated discs. F-actin was not readily observed within discs cells but was a marked feature of vascular tissue within the disc and occasionally seen in infiltrating cells. Vimentin was more readily seen within cells of the inner anulus fibrosus and nucleus pulposus. In general, disc cell morphology was fibrocyte or chondrocyte-like; however, in spondylolisthetic discs, cells with numerous cytoplasmic projections were frequently observed.

The differential morphologies and cytoskeletal composition observed in disc cells may be indicative of variations in mechanical strains and/or pathologies, or indeed of cell function.


M Pritchard B.H. Roberts R.R. Bindra

The ‘Pi’ plate is an anatomical titanium plate recently introduced for the internal fixation of comminuted intra-articular distal radius fractures. We report our experience with this implant in a prospective series of twelve patients with an average age of thirty six years (range, 26–52 years).

A dorsal approach with release of the EPL tendon and extra-compartmental exposure of the radius between the second and fourth extensor compartments was employed in all cases. Iliac bone graft and a styloid K-wire were used to augment the plate fixation. Post-operatively, active mobilisation was started after wound healing. Wrist motion and grip strength measurements were made at six weeks, three months and six months by the therapist. At six months, patients recovered an average of 85% of range of movement compared with the opposite wrist, except for palmar flexion (65%). No loss of reduction was observed on follow-up radiographs. Complications were compartment syndrome, intraoperative EPL rupture and two cases of extensor tendonitis requiring implant removal.

The ‘Pi’ plate affords rigid fixation of distal radius fractures permitting early rehabilitation. It is however a demanding technique that is not without complications.


S. Bartys A.K. Burton P.J. Watson I. Wright C. Mackay C.J. Main

Traditional biomedical/ergonomic occupational interventions to reduce work loss show limited success. Attention is now focussing on tackling the psychosocial factors that influence occupational back pain.

A workforce survey of Glaxo Smith Kline (reported to the Society last year) established that clinical and occupational psychosocial factors (yellow & blue flags) act independently and may represent obstacles to recovery. Consequently, a nurse-led intervention was devised. Occupational nurses at two manufacturing sites were trained to identify both clinical and occupational psychosocial factors, and address them using a basic ‘counselling’ technique that reinforces evidence-based messages and advice, along with availability of modified work. The program should ideally be implemented within the first days of absence, with ‘case-management’ by the nurse for a further 4 weeks. Control sites simply offer ‘usual management’. Outcomes at 12-month follow-up are rates for work loss/work retention.

The target for contacting the worker (3 days) was achieved at one site, but not the other (mean 12 days), thus exerting a differential delay in delivering the intervention. The lack of early identification at the second site was due to local reporting/recording mechanisms. This study reveals a third class of obstacles to recovery – black flags – company policies/procedures that can impede occupational rehabilitation programs.


Full Access
E.B. Hoffman J. Allin J.A.B. Campbell F.M. Leisegang

We retrospectively reviewed 52 children treated for tuberculosis of the knee in the 21-year period 1979 to 1999.

The mean age at which the condition was diagnosed was 5.3 years (8 months to 13 years). The median duration of symptoms was four weeks (1 month to 3 years). All patients presented with swelling, mainly owing to synovitis. Pain was a symptom in only two thirds of patients.

Using Kerri and Martini’s classification of radiological appearances, 33 knees were stage I (osteopoenia), 15 stage II (osteopoenia with erosions), two stage III (joint space narrowing) and two stage IV (joint space narrowing with anatomical disorganisation). All knees had either positive histology (caseating granuloma) and/or a positive culture for tuberculosis.

Treatment was with rifampicin, isoniazide and pyrazinamide for nine months. No synovectomy was done. Of the 48 knees with stage-I and stage-II disease, 22 were immobilised for at least three months and 26 actively mobilised.

At a mean follow-up of five years (2 to 16 years), the results were classified according to Wilkinson. All stage-I and stage-II knees had an excellent result (full range of motion) or good result (more than 90° of flexion). Stage-III and stage-IV knees had a fair result (less than 30°of flexion) or poor result (ankylosis). In stage-I and stage-II knees, immobilisation did not affect outcome.

In the same period, 25 knees with a non-specific histology and negative culture presented the problem of the differential diagnosis between tuberculosis and particular juvenile rheumatoid arthritis (JRA). Of these 17 were subsequently diagnosed as JRA. A histological study assessed the value of synovial lining (SLC) hyperplasia. The sensitivity of SLC hyperplasia for JRA was only 53%. Synovial biopsies from 10 joints with tuberculosis (positive histology or culture) were subjected to the polymerase chain reaction test. The sensitivity was only 40% for tuberculosis.


G. Pierrard C. Hulet D. Schiltz D. Souquet B. Locker C. Vielpeau

Purpose: The MacIntosch method for reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament using a free intra-articular plasty with an extra-articular reinforcement was the classical treatment during the eighties for chronic anterior laxity. In 1992, we reported our short-term resuls in 180 cases. The purpose of this report is to analyse the results in 112 of these 180 cases with a mean follow-up of 14 years.

Material and methods: One hundred twelve knees operated between 1982 and 1987 were included in this study. There were 82 men (73.2%) and 30 women (26.8%), mean age 24.9±5.8 years. Mean follow-up was 165.3 ± 25.9 months. Mean delay from accident to repair was 30.9 months (3–144) and meniscectomy was performed in 88% of the cases, mainly for contact pivot sports (85%). All patients had an overt laxity (advanced in 73.2% or isolated in 26.9%). The MacIntosh plasty performed by arthrotomy used a patellar tendon with a quadriceps tendon band prolongation. Arthros-copy was performed prior to surgery in all cases. If the transplant was implanted over the top, the radiographic analysis of the tunnel position was only made for the tibia. An independent examiner reviewed all the patients clinically and radiographically using the IKDC criteria with instrumental KT 1000 measurements.

Results: Sports activities were resumed in 78% of the cases with a trend towards pivot sports without contact practised in an amateur setting. Subjectively, 69.6% of the patients were very satisfied and 25% were satisfied. The click was abolished in 83% of the cases, was minimal in 15% and overt in 2%. The medial meniscus was intact in 40% of the cases with only 10 secondary meniscal tears 14 years later. The residual manual maximal traction differential at KT 1000 was 1 ± 1.225 mm and the mean compliance was 1.69 ± 1 mm. The overall IKDC score was: 31% A, 47/6% B, 19.1% C, 1.9% D. X-rays were normal in 17%, showed remodelling in 55.4%, and joint narrowing < 50% in 23.8% and > 50% in 3.8%. For patients with an intact medial meniscus, joint narrowing was observed in 5.5% compared with 24% after resection of the medial meniscus. There were two repeat tears in this series compared with 22 tears of the contra-lateral anterior cruciate ligament. The unsatisfactory results (22%) were related to anatomic failure (two cases) and functional problems (18 cases, defective mobility and pain). The prognostic factors were age at time of operation and preservation of the medial meniscus.

Conclusions: This study confirms the persistently good clinical and functional results 14 years after plasty using the patellar tendon associated with lateral reinforcement. Ligament stabilisation was satisfactory but it must be recalled that at 14 years, the functional needs were different for these knees. The radiological course was more worrisome with joint narrowing in 27.6% of the cases.


R.A. Brooks M. Rushton J.A.W. Wimhurst N. Rushton

This study investigated the effects of wear particles, produced from a number of implant materials, at the bone-implant interface using a small animal model.

Particles were prepared from metal, ceramic and polymer replacement joint components or implant grade stock by grinding the materials against a diamond embedded grinding pad. The mean diameter of the particles ranged from 1.5mm to 3.2mm. Sterilised particles were suspended in sterile saline containing 2% v/v male Sprague-Dawley serum at a concentration of 109 particles per ml.

Seventy-two male Sprague-Dawley rats were assigned to twelve groups of six animals. A ceramic pin was inserted into the right tibia of each animal. Six groups were assigned a particle type with one group acting as vehicle control. 100ml of particle suspension or vehicle was injected into each knee joint at 8, 10 and 12 weeks following implantation and the animals were killed 2 weeks later. Of the remaining five groups, four were assigned a particle type and one was the vehicle control. These animals were injected with 100ml of particle suspension or vehicle at 20, 22 and 24 weeks following pin implantation and were killed 2 weeks later. The tibia and femora were removed, disarticulated and processed for histology. The total gap between pin and bone, including fibrous tissue, was measured.

Specimens showed no signs of infection either clinically or in the histopathology. All materials tested produced lesions at the bone-implant interface. A significant difference was seen between metal injected vs. vehicle control animals and aluminium oxide injected vs. vehicle controls. Particles of stainless steel produced the greatest response and this finding may have implications for the use of metal on metal articulations aimed at eliminating polyethylene wear.


D. Chaveaux A. Morchikh V. Ouillac N. Barthe V. Langlois J.L. Honton

Purpose: With appropriate software, dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) provides a means of measuring periprosthetic bone mineral density (BMD) reliably and reproducibly in a single plane. The current method has been improved since the first reports by MacCarthy in 1991.

Material and methods: Since 1992, two series of total hip arthroplasty femoral prostheses using a ceramic-polyethylene cup with a TA6V4 stem were implanted with cement (group A 25 SAS crystal anatomic stems, 22.2 head) or without cement (group B, 27 Euroform stems with hydroxyapatite surfacing on the upper 2/5, 28 head). The patients were followed prospectively with DEXA to measure BMD in the seven Gruen zones immediately after surgery, at six and twelve months, then every year to last follow-up. Mean follow-up was 74 months (36–166). A visual analogue scale was used for subjective assessment of pain. The clinical Harris score and radiological findings were also recorded.

Results: At last follow-up none of the prostheses had required revision surgery. The Harris score was greater than 90 for both groups (mean 91.4 and 95.4 for groups A and B respectively). Radiologically, there were no progressive lucent lines in the two groups but there were three stable lines (zone V, VII, VII, II) without clinical expression in group A and two (zone II, I) with persistent thigh pain in group B. Two migrations of less than 3 mm were also found in group A and four of more than 3 mm in group B. For the two groups, DEXA showed a diffuse reduction in BMD during the first six months that was statistically significant only for zones I and VII for the Euroform implant and for zone VII for the SAS Crystal implant. There was also a significant difference between the two prostheses for zone I. Modifications were not significant at three years and a last follow-up for the distal regions (II, II, V, VI). For group A (SAS Crystal), the reduction was 5.8% at three years and 5.7% at last follow-up for zone I and 18% at three years and 19% at last follow-up for zone VII. For group B, the reduction was 12.6 at three years and 11.4% at last follow-up for zone I and 17.4% at three years and 21.3% at last follow-up for zone VII.

Discussion: The correlations showed that variations in BMD were independent of the initial bone mineral content, patient age or sex, and were not significantly different between the two cemented or non-cemented implants. Patients with painful thighs (two in group A and six in group B) had a different pattern of BMD over time, showing less pronounced reduction in the proximal zones I and VII and marked bone resorption in zones III and V, an expression of different stress transmission.

Conclusion: This study provided the longest longitudinal radiological and clinical follow-up reported in the literature which, despite the bias introduced by the different types of implants, shows the reliability and reproducibility of DEXA of periprosthetic bone mineral density used to assess implant tolerance and quality of cementing.


M.A. Hartzband

Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty has been in use since the 1970s. In spite of early enthusiasm, the procedure soon fell into disfavour, particularly in the USA. Early failures were a result of improper indication, poor technique and in some cases and poor prosthetic design.

A new instrument system for use with the MG unicompartmental knee arthroplasty has been designed, with guides for accurate and reproducible alignment, sizing and resection. Potential benefits include early mobilisation, rapid rehabilitation, improved range of motion and shortened hospital stay.

This paper briefly reviews the literature and discusses indications and surgical techniques.


J. Allain S. Van Driessche T. Odent D. goutallier

Purpose of the study: Surgical treatment of degenerative spondylolisthesis generally requires spinal fusion. Arthrodesis can be achieved via an anterior or posterior approach. Over the last ten years, minimally invasive methods have been developed to limit operative trauma secondary to the anterior approach. There have however been few studies comparing outcome after this new technique with classical open surgery. The aim of this work was to compare spinal fusion achieved with a cage implanted retroperitoneoscopically with conventional screw-plate fixation using open lombotomy.

Material and methods: Sixty two patients with degenerative spondylolisthesis (L3-L4, L4-L5, L5-S1) were reviewed: 39 had had conventional spinal fusion (group 1) and 23 had undergone a minimally invasive procedure (group 2). Clinical (Beaujon score) and radiographic assessment was recorded at last follow-up. All patients in group 1 were operated on by the same surgeon via lombotomy (L3-L4 or L4-L5 fusion) or subumbilical laparotomy (L5-S1 fusion). An intersomatic graft was combined with screw-plate fixation in all cases. Patients in group 2 were also operated on by the same surgeon (different from group 1) who used a retroperitoneoscopic approach (L3-L4 or L4-L5 fusion). An intersomatic cage was filled with cancelous bone and screwed into the intersomatic space.

Results: Mean follow-up was four years in group 1 and two years in group 2. Mean Beaujon score improved from 8 to 17 in group 1 and from 9 to 16.5 in group 2. All patients achieved bone healing at last follow-up without secondary displacement or disassembly of the osteosynthesis. There were no neurological complications and no infections of the operative site. One patient in group 2 developed a vascular complication requiring conversion to classical lombotomy. Blood loss was 1100 ml in group 1 and 200 ml in group 2.

Conclusion: Anterior fusion with implantation of an intersomatic cage via retroperitoneoscopic access is a reliable and effective method for the treatment of degenerative spondylolisthesis. It reduced postoperative morbidity but must obviously comply with classical indications for lumbar fusion.


P. Guigui L. Rillardon A. Blamoutier P. Heissler A. Veil Picard A. Deburge

Purpose of the study: The principal aim of this prospective multicentric observational study was to validate an self-administered questionnaire for evaluation of functional outcome after surgical treatment of lumbar stenosis. The questionnaire was associated with an index of neurological impairment in order to account for objective neurological injury and an index exploring patient satisfaction after treatment for lumbalgia, radiculalgia and gait disorders.

Material and methods: The structure of the questionnaire was examined to determine whether the three dimensions of the evaluation scale were pertinent, to establish reproducibility (intra-observer variability), to study sensitivity to change, and finally to examine the items in the questionnaire and their capacity for effective measurement using the Cronbach alpha coefficient and principal components analysis. Reproducibility was tested on 49 patients who filled out the self-administered questionnaire twice, 15 days apart. The intra-class coefficients of correlation were calculated. Sensitivity was tested by correlating the variations of the scores obtained pre- and postoperatively with the index of satisfaction and by calculating mean standardised responses. The questionnaire items were validated by correlating the scores obtained using the questionnaire with scores obtained with three other self-administered questionnaires: SF36, EIFFEL2 and GHQ28.

Results: One hundred four patients were included in this study, 96 were seen at follow-up visits six and twelve months after surgery. Principal component analysis demonstrated the pertinence of the three dimensions in the evaluation scale. The overall Cronback alpha was 0.86. The overall intra-class coefficient of correlation was 0.95, varying from 0.86 to 0.97 for the dimensions studied. There was a good correlation (0.82) between the scores obtained and index of satisfaction. All mean standardised responses were greater than A1, indicating good sensitivity to change. There was a good correlation between the evaluated score and the EIFFEL2 self-administered questionnaire and the following dimensions of the SF36: physical activity, physical pain, vitality and limitation due to physical pain.

Discussion and conclusion: Using a simple self-administered questionnaire (eight questions), an index of satisfaction (four questions) and an objective score of neurological disorders allowed reliable, sensitive and reproducible assessment of the changes in the functional impairment caused by lumbar stenosis before and after surgical treatment.


A. Szabo I. Rogan

We review our first 100 LCS rotating platform total knee arthroplasty (TKA) procedures. Done between July 1993 and December 1996, they are currently at four to seven year follow-up.

The sample includes 100 TKAs done in 88 patients as unilateral or bilateral procedures. At operation the mean age of patients, 51% of whom were female and 49% male, was 67 years (47 to 84). The right side was replaced in 54% of cases and the left in 46%. Preoperative diagnoses included degenerative and post-traumatic osteoarthritis in 95 knees and rheumatoid arthritis in five.

Two assessments are currently being carried out. They include the American Knee Society Clinical Rating Score, functional ability and radiographic evaluation of knee alignment and radiolucencies. Mean clinical and functional Knee Society ratings were 38 and 57 (sum 95 points) preoperatively and 88 and 84 (sum 172 points) postoperatively. Radiographs showed valgus alignment in 90 rays and varus alignment (1° to 7°) in 10. Limited areas of radiolucency were seen around three tibial components. Two cases have required revision, one for septic loosening and one to correct recurrent varus deformity.


C. Hauke A. Kaelin P. Hoffmeyer

Purpose: The Less Invasive Stabilisation System (LISS) for fixation of the proximal femur is an automatic preformed fixator with three sizes. The self-perforating self-threading screws are locked into the plate fixator providing angular stability. Unlike conventional implants, the LISS plate is not applied directly to the bone, avoiding friction forces and periosteal damage. Precise adaptation of the implant to the form of the bone is not necessary. The system can also be easily and rapidly used as a “gliding” plate. After reduction via a proximal incision, the plate-fixator is inserted between the anterior tibial muscle and the periosteum and fixed with monocortical screws inserted percutaneously.

Material and methods: Between January 1999 and August 2000, we treated 18 multiple trauma patients with fractures of the proximal femur in 17 patients (nine men and eight women) using the LISS in a prospective multicentric study. Mean age was 50 years (20–89), median, 43 years). The AO classification of the fractures was four type A, four type B, and 13 type C. There were 14 open fractures. We used the LISS in one patient to stabilise a valgus osteotomy. One patient had a 41-C2.3 (Schatzker type VI) fracture with a compartment syndrome. Bone allographs were used in two cases. Clinical and radiographic follow-up data was collected at 6, 12, 24 and 48 weeks.

Results: Two foreign subjects with 41-A3 and 41-B1 fractures were lost to follow-up. For the other patients, bone healing was achieved between six and twelve weeks. Mean follow-up was ten months (three to twenty months). We had one complication, the compartment syndrome mentioned above, which healed without sequelae after fasciotomy and secondary thin skin graft. Joint motion was symmetrical and pain free in all patients three months after surgery. There were no nerve or vessel lesions secondary to epiperiosteal displacement of the fixator, and no case of infection or loosening. We did however observe secondary loss of reduction with development of minimal varus in three patients with complex fractures.

Conclusions: These preliminary results with the LISS demonstrate its usefulness as an alternative to conventional fixation systems. It is undoubtedly a most useful method for intra-articular and metaphyseal fractures with diaphyseal fracture lines and for fractures with two levels. Complications appear to depend on the type of fracture and the quality of the reduction, as with other types of fixators.


J-L. Husson S. Blond Ph. Dam Hieu Y. Lazorthes J.P. Nguyen F. Lapierre B. Laugner M.C. Djian F. Bellow

Purpose: Since the introduction of spinal cord stimulation for the treatment of chronic neuropathies (Shealy, 1967), further development has identified indications. The objective of this prospective multicentric protocol was to quantify clinical and economical results in a homogeneous group of rigorously selected patients.

Material and methods: In 1999, nine university hospital centres recruited 43 patients (22 men, 21 women, mean age 50.8 years) with chronic postoperative neuropathic sciataligia insufficiently controlled by antiseizure and antidepressor (tricyclic) drugs. There were 34 unilateral cases and nine bilateral cases and 60% of the patients also had lombalgia. Diagnosis was established on the basis of history taking, clinical signs, and anatomic and electrophysiological findings. Indications for spinal cord stimulation were determined in a pluridisciplinary context including a psychological evaluation. A temporary test was made before implanting the programmable neurostimulator (Itrel®II or Itrel®3, Medtonic) in order to check that the induced paresthesia involved the painful territory. Included patients were assessed before implantation then at six (39 patients), 12 (30 patients) and 24 months after institution of the stimulation. At each follow-up visit, the clinical effect was assessed with validated pain scales (visual analogue scale, McGill Pain score, Oswestry incapacity score). Economical data were obtained from the medical file, patient interviews, and a specific therapeutic follow-up chart. Preliminary results (mean follow-up 10 months) are presented.

Results: Clinical scores improved 40 to 50% one year after implantation of the neurostimulator. There was significant relief of sciatalgia: on the visual analogue scale the mean pain score (7.8/10 before implantation) was 2.7/10 (p < 0.05) and 3.6/10 (p < 0.05) at six and 12 months after implantation. Drug prescriptions (antiseizure, antidepressors) were reduced by 70%. Residual treatments were prescribed for lumbalgia which was relieved little by stimulation. Annual expenditures (drugs + visits + non-drug treatments) was reduced by 1578 euros per patient (mean). Hospitalisation rate fell from 26% to 10% and the rate of resumed occupational activities was 11%

Discussion: Assessment of 24 patients after implantation of a neurostimulator will complete these early results.


J. C. Bel J. Garret K. Elkholti B. Guigal G. Herzberg

Purpose: Good functional results for unstable fractures of the pelvis require reduction and fixation of the posterior lesions. “Open” techniques are highly invasive and sacroiliac screwing is insufficient alone. We evaluated results with a strategy based on minimally invasive complete reduction and osteosynthesis allowing early mobilisation.

Material and methods: The series included 19 men and two women, mean age 30 years (17–60) operated on between 1998 and 2000. Nineteen patients had multiple injuries. The AO classification was A5 C (12 CI unilateral, 3 (2 C2, 1C3) bilateral) and 6B (4 B1, 3 B2). The patients were operated on in the supine position with traction on the lower limb to reduce the hemipelvis ascension. Displaced anterior fractures were reduced and stabilised with a pubic plate or with an anterior external fixator. The posterior fractures were fixed with a percutaneosus canulated cancellous screw measuring 7.3 mm in diameter inserted transacrally into the S1 body to reach the opposite sacroiliac joint under fluoroscopic monitoring. The radiographic results were analysed by measuring the vertical ascension of the hemipelvis at the foot of the sacroiliac and clinical results with the Majeed score.

Results: The patients were operated on day four 0–8) after trauma. Anatomic reduction was achieved in 19 cases, with a gap of 5 mm in two cases. Thirteen anterior fixations (eleven plates, two external fixators) and 21 transacral screw fixations were used to stabilise the pelvi. There were no notable complications. One patient died early from multiple injuries. All were followed for one year after the accident and no secondary dismanteling has been observed. The final mean Majeed score was 95/100.

Discussion: Reduction is best if achieved early. With the transacral screw fixation, it is achieved in the supine position which is technically difficult due to the known anatomic variability of the sacrum. It also allows simultaneous treatment of C13 and C23 comminutive fractures. Anterior fixation is complete.

Conclusions: Percutaneous transacral screw fixation and anterior osteosynthesis is a minimaly invasive technique providing reproducible and reliable results for maintaining reduction in a large number of unstable fractures of the pelvic ring. These fixations allow the upright position and mobilisation early. The good anatomic result is maintained leading to a better functional result which should be validated in a longer series.


Full Access
P. Moroney T. McCarthy J. O’Byrne W. Quinlan

This study examines patient characteristics, indications for conversion, surgical and anaesthetic technique, peri-operative management and complications of surgery in this small and challenging group of patients. In the six years from 1994 to 1999, 33 conversion arthroplasties were performed for failed femoral hemiarthroplasty. The average age at conversion surgery was 75.5 years (range 65–90). The female to male ratio was 6:1. Primary hemiarthroplasties comprised 24 Austin-Moore, 6 Thompson & 3 Bipolar prostheses. The average interval from primary to conversion surgery was 50 months (6 months to 17 years). The average age at primary surgery was 71.2 years (62–88) – AMP:71.4 years, Thompson’s: 74.2 years, Bipolar: 63.5 years. All hemiarthroplasties were performed for fractured femoral necks. 62% of patients came from the Eastern Health Board area, while 38% were tertiary are referrals from other Health Boards. The average length of stay was 17.5 days (3–24). Indications for conversion included gross loosening/acetabular erosion in 9 cases, suspected infection in 4 cases and abscess/septicaemia in 1 case. All but 3 patients had significant pain (night pain etc.) and/or severely impaired mobility.

We also looked at anaesthetic and analgesic practice, surgical technique and prostheses used.

Post-operatively, mean total blood loss was 1430 ml (420–2280) with an average of 1.4 units of blood transfused (0–5). Intraoperative complications included acetabular & femoral perforation, periprosthetic fracture and cement reactions. Complications post-op (in hospital) included cardiac arrhythmia’s, cerebrovascular accidents, pulmonary embolus, myocardial infarct, respiratory & urinary tract infections, constipation, nausea & vomiting.

The elderly nature of these patients and the physiological stress of what is major surgery allied with multiple co-morbidities make their care especially challenging. A conversion arthroplasty is a procedure with a significant risk of considerable morbidity. Primary total hip replacement or bipolar hemiarthroplasty are options which, therefore, should be seriously considered in the case of fractured femoral necks to minimise the need for further surgery in the future, with all its attendant risks.


P. Makan

The posterior ligament complex (PLC) in the cervical spine comprises the posterior longitudinal ligament, ligamentum flavum and ligamentum nuchae, the latter homologous with the supraspinous and interspinous ligaments at other levels of the spine. In determining instability, evaluation of the PLC is an essential part of the assessment of cervical spine injuries. Disruption of the PLC occurs following flexion injuries, both in compression and in distraction, and following extension injuries with compression. PLC disruption, diagnosed when clinical examination reveals localised posterior spinal tenderness and/or a widened interspinous gap, is confirmed on standard and dynamic flexion-extension radiographs and MRI.

This paper is a retrospective review of 162 patients treated for cervical injuries between 1997 and 2001. There were 83 (51%) distraction flexion, 37 (23%) compression flexion, 18 (11%) compression extension, 17 (10%) vertical compression, six (4%) distraction extension and one (1%) lateral flexion injuries. In 79 patients with pure ligamentous instability, an interspinous stabilisation procedure was performed, using a titanium cable. When associated fractures occurred with PLC disruption, neurologically intact patients were managed conservatively with traction followed by a spinal brace. Patients with a neurological deficit underwent surgery. Using delayed dynamic flexion-extension views and MRI, PLC disruption was diagnosed late in nine flexion distraction injuries without facet dislocation. At follow-up, flexion-extension views showed that all PLC disruptions with associated fractures had stabilised. There were two broken cables in patients who underwent surgery.

Patients with cervical instability following trauma may be treated non-operatively when there are associated fractures, while patients with pure ligamentous instability should undergo fusion. Further, to exclude occult PLC disruption, all cervical injuries should be reviewed on flexion-extension views once the paraspinal muscle spasm has settled.


M. Naidu

Thoracic spine fractures and fracture dislocations often lead to neurological deficit, and associated injuries to morbidity and mortality.

An audit conducted between January 1999 and December 2000 evaluated the outcome of 63 patients with fractures and fracture dislocations of the thoracic spine. The mean age of patients, 41 of whom were male, was 30 years. In 45 patients the injury was sustained in a motor vehicle accident, and 23 patients had associated injuries. We used the Margel radiological classification. There were 37 fracture dislocations and 23 pure fractures. Twenty patients had a type-A injury (flexion), of which 19 were type AIII (burst). There were 40 patients with a type-B injury, 35 of which were type BI (flexion distraction), and three type BIII (flexion and axial loading). In three patients there was a type-C injury (rotational). There was total neurological deficit in 39 patients, 10 with type-A, 26 with type-B and three with type-C injuries. Fifteen patients had partial neurological deficit and nine were neurologically intact.

Posterior spinal fusion and bone graft was performed on 43 patients, anterior decompression and bone graft without instrumentation on seven, and combined anterior and posterior surgery on one. The remaining 12 were treated conservatively with orthoses. The neurological status of eight patients improved by a single grade following surgery and the neurological status of two following conservative treatment. Of the 54 patients with neurological deficit, 52 were wheelchair-bound. The poor neurological outcome was comparable to that in other studies.


C. Jeanrot T.-S. Vinh P. Anract G. de Pinieux M. Ouaknine M. Forest B. Tomeno

Purpose of the study: Chordoma is a malignant neoplasm believed to arise from notochord remnants. It accounts for approximately 3 to 4 p. 100 of primary bone tumors and is localized along the axial skeleton, 50 p. 100 being sacrococcygeal. Clinical, radiographical and histological findings have been well established since the first description by Ribbert in 1894. Sacral chordomas are however difficult to manage and remain a challenge for surgeons and radiotherapists alike. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the long-term results of surgical treatment and patterns of failure in patients treated for chordoma of the sacrum in our department.

Materials and methods: This retrospective study included 11 cases of sacral chordomas treated from 1973 to 1998. Patient age ranged from 36 to 77 years (mean 59 years). Six patients were female and five male. The initial treatment was surgery in all cases including intralesional removal in two cases, marginal resection in seven and complete en bloc resection in two.

Results: Median follow-up was 6 years (1 month to 14 years). Tumoral recurrences were observed in nine cases 5 months to 8 years after treatment. In two cases, recurrence was observed 8 years after radical sacrectomy. Treatment of recurrences was partial surgical removal with radiotherapy (40 to 70 Grays). Three patients developed metastases in lungs, liver and bone, respectively. Seven patients died, two from metastatic disease. The 5-year overall survival was 64 p. 100 but only 18 p. 100 of the patients survived 10 years. Average disease-free survival was 18 p. 100 at 5 years and 0 p. 100 at 10 years.

Discussion: Chordoma is a slow-growing tumor allowing survival for several years despite recurrent disease. However, only 10 to 20 p. 100 of the patients survive free of disease at 5 years. Recurrences are frequent (45 to 80 p. 100) and often multiple. Chordoma inevitably recurs and eventually leads to death after intralesional removal or marginal resection. Radical surgery should be attempted whenever technically feasible. When performed early, particularly for smaller lesions, it offers the best chance for cure. However, tumoral recurrence can occur postoperatively despite a macroscopically complete resection. Because radiation therapy seems to be more successful in controlling microscopic disease, it should be considered as a pre- or postoperative adjuvant to a macroscopically complete resection.


P.M. Kelly O. McCormack K.J. Mulhall M.M. Stephens

The intermetatarsal angle is widely used to determine whether a basal or distal metatarsal osteotomy should be used to correct a hallux valgus deformity. We have noticed that the point of intersection of the long axes of the first and second metatarsals on standard pre-operative weight-bearing AP radiographs consistently predicts the type of osteotomy required.

A basal osteotomy is generally recommended if the inter-metatarsal angle is ≥14°, whereas a distal osteotomy is usually sufficient if the angle is less than 14°.

Sixty standardised pre-operative AP weight bearing in-patients undergoing hallux valgus correction were included in our study. The intermetatarsal angle was measured in a standard fashion. The point of intersection in the foot was recorded in terms of the distance from the talonavicular joint.

Using a Pearson’s Correlation coefficient, our study revealed that an intermetatarsal angle of 14° or more consistently intersected either within the talar head or distal to thetalonavicular joint. We propose that this as an accurate and simple method of pre-operatively determining the choice of metatarsal osteotomy.


A. Mungherera

Dislocations of the thoracolumbar spine, which account for 11% of injuries in the T10 to L2 region, follow a high-energy, flexion-distraction force. In this region, there is a transition from a fixed kyphosis to a mobile lordosis, an absence of costotransverse ligaments and a change of facet alignment from a coronal to a sagittal plane.

In 1999, we treated 12 male and nine female patients with dislocations of the thoracolumbar spine. Their mean age was 30 years. Sixteen patients had been involved in motor vehicle collisions, four had fallen from a height and one had been assaulted with an iron bar. There were 14 Frankel grade-A injuries, one Frankel grade-C, two Frankel grade-D and four Frankel grade-E injuries. The site of injury was T12/L1 in 14 patients, L1/L2 in four, T11/T12 level in four and T10/T11 in one. Associated injuries included electrical burns and a fractured femur. None of the patients sustained visceral injuries. All patients were stabilised with transpedicular fixation. No disc sequestration was found.

Following surgery, one of the 14 Frankel grade-A patients improved to Frankel grade C but 13 made no neurological recovery. The four patients graded Frankel E did not deteriorate. The remaining three patients with partial neurological deficit made a complete recovery. Postoperative sepsis resolved in one patient following debridement and antibiotic therapy.

The thoracolumbar junction is anatomically and biomechanically predisposed to traumatic dislocation. The poor neurological outcome with dislocations at T11/T12 and T12/L1 may be attributed to cord injury, but injuries distal to this level have a better prognosis owing to cauda equina involvement.


P. Mansat S. Head M. Rongières Y. Bellumore P. Bonnevialle M. Mansat

Purpose: We report our experience with 23 Coonrad-Morrey total elbow prostheses.

Material and methods: Between July 1997 and February 2001, we implanted 34 Coonrad-Morrey total elbow pros-theses in 33 patients. Twenty-three patients (23 implants) were reviewed at a mean 24 months follow-up, maximum 40 months. There were three men and 20 women, mean age 62 years (42–69). Twelve patients had rheumatoid polyarthritis, the principal indication. There were also four recent fractures of the distal humerus, two nonunions, and one patient with post-traumatic osteoarthritis. One patient had sequelar osteoarthritis since childhood. Finally three revisions were performed for loosening of a GUEPAR prosthesis in two cases and a GSBIII prosthesis in one. Results were assessed with the Mayo Clinic score. We searched for lucent lines around the implants, polyethylene wear, and incorporation of the bone graft behind the anterior wing of the implant on plain radiographs.

Results: At last follow-up, the mean Mayo Clinic score had improved from 25 to 89 points (70–100). Before surgery, 17 patients had severe pain. At last follow-up, eight patients had occasional pain. Extension was improved by 10°, flexion by 27° giving a postoperative amplitude of 29° to 132°. Prona-tion supination progressed by 37° giving a rotation amplitude of 127°. The function score improved from 4 to 21 points. Sixteen of the 23 patients had normal elbow function. Outcome was excellent in 13 patients, good in eight, and fair in two. There were no lucent lines visible on the radiographs. There was no sign of polyethylene wear. The bon graft was incorporated behind the implant in 20 cases and was not visible in three. Complications included one peroperative fracture, one cutaneous dehiscence, one post-operative fracture of the olecranon due to a fall, and persistent ulnar paresthesia in four patients requiring secondary neurolysis in one.

Discussion, conclusion: The Coonrad-Morrey semi-constrained prosthesis provides a response to a large range of situations. The dominant indication is rheumatoid polyarthritis, but trauma patients can benefit from this reliable therapeutic solution giving a satisfactory rate of success. A satisfactory functional amplitude is generally achieved with this implant and the elbow is generally pain free.


F. Pfeffer J. Paucht L. Galois R. Traversari D. Mainard J.P. Delagoutte

Purpose: Traffic accidents and high level falls are the principal causes of femur trauma. Fractures generally involve the shaft but the proximal or distal metaphyseal zones may also be involved. Skin opening, vascular injury or associated lesions in multiple injury patients are all reasons for emergency treatment with an external fixator.

Material and methods: We report a retrospective series of 23 cases who were treated with this technique between 1996 and 2000. There were 15 men and seven women, mean age 36 years (17–92) who were traffic accident victims in 17 cases. Fourteen had multiple injuries. The mean Index Severity Score was 28 points. Fractures were located in shaft in 16 cases, the proximal metaphysis in three, and in the supra and intercondylar zone in nine. The Chauchoix and Duparc classification was grade 2 in eight cases, and grade 3 in three cases. The fixation was installed with two or three pins in the lateral position; The knee was bridged in cases with an associated injury to the proximal tibia (floating knee) (two cases) or severe injury to the knee ligaments. Patients were reviewed clinically and radiographically. Bone healing was considered to be achieved when full weight bearing was possible without osteosynthesis contention.

Results: Twenty patients were reviewed. Mean follow-up was 20 months (7–42). Bone healing was achieved in 100% of the cases with a mean delay of 9.4 months (4–32). In three patients 13%) a complementary procedure (cancellous graft or bone marrow graft) was needed to achieve healing, the delay in these patients was 22 months compared with 7.5 months without secondary procedures. One patient developed a callus with a > 10° deviation of the AP view and five permanent flexion greater than 10°. Supra and intercondylar fractures healed at a mean 6.6 months in five cases with a deformed callus. The force moment related to excessive spread of the fixator pins (greater than 20 cm) was not a factor of poor final radiological outcome. Mean knee flexion was greater than 100° in only three cases. These amplitudes were not obtained until the fixator pins were removed. No releasing procedures were needed. Three mobilisations under general anaesthesia were needed.

Discussion: External fixation allows stable and dynamic osteosynthesis of femoral shaft fractures. It is indicated when centromedulary nailling is impossible or for patients with an excessively high risk of infection. The insertion of the pins must be rigorously control (perpendicular to the diaphysis, bicortical insertion, far enough apart). Supra and intracondylar fractures remain difficult to stabilise with external fixations and internal plate fixation may be discussed in grade 2 open fractures. These can give poor functional results despite rapid consolidation. An immediate corticocancellous graft may be indicated when metaphyseal comminution requires stabilisation, mainly on the medial aspect to avoid varisation.

Conclusion: External fixation is an interesting solution for safe fixation of open shaft fractures (grade 2 and 3) or fractures associated with vascular and nerve injury. It would be more indicated for shaft fractures than for supracondylar fractures which are difficult to stabilise, particularly in case of major comminution.


M.R. Underwood

There is a desire to reduce the economic burden of low back pain. This in is part because of the 226% increase in invalidity benefits paid out for spinal disorders in the ten years to 1994/5. This paper examines the effect of the change from Invalidity Benefit to Incapacity Benefit in 1995, and considers the utility of these figures as a means of assessing changing patterns of back pain disability.

Data were obtained from the DSS on how benefit data were collected and numbers of days of Invalidity/Incapacity Benefits that were paid from 1983/4 to 1998/9. The data suggest that since 1995 that the rate of spinal disability has fallen and has now been stable at 90 million days per year for four years. The headline Incapacity Benefit figures have a very loose relationship with health impact of low back pain. Around 30,000 people per year make the transition to claiming long term Incapacity Benefit from claiming short term Incapacity Benefit.

Incapacity Benefit figures are of little utility in assessing changes in low back pain disability. Numbers making the transition to Long Term Incapacity Benefit may be a more useful indicator.


E. Coetzee

Evaluating the effectiveness of conservative treatment of odontoid fractures, from 1997 to 1999 we reviewed 22 cases.

All were treated first in halo traction and subsequently by halo thoracic brace immobilisation. We used Anderson and D’Alonzo’s classification of types I to III. The mean follow-up time was seven months. Initial displacement was measured radiologically and union was evaluated.

In type-II fractures, the incidence of pseudarthrosis was 40%. Fractures with more than 5 mm of initial displacement and more than 10° angulation all went on to nonunion, suggesting that type-II fractures should be treated by internal fixation.


V. Katz S. Loy J.Y. Alnot

Purpose: Trauma to the radial collateral ligaments requires the same attention as trauma to the ulnar ligaments. Damage is uncommon due to the particular anatomic position, but nevertheless a distinct clinical entity.

Material and methods: We report a retrospective analysis of 14 patients, eight who underwent emergency surgery and six with trauma sequelae. Mean follow-up was 22 months and mean age 37 years. Among the recent lesions, the pain score (scale from 1 to 5) was 4.5) and the instability score (scale from 1 to 3) was 3. Palmar subdislocation was 4.8 mm and laxity was 16.7°. Among the old lesions (> 1 month) the corresponding data were pain 3.3, instability 2.5, palmar sub-dislocation 4.2 mm, laxity 19.1°. Two patients had signs of osteoarthritis. At surgery, the phalanx and metacarpus were equally injured. Associated lesions (capsule, short abductor) were present in 78% of the patient. The radial collateral ligaments and the soft tissue were reinserted or retightened in all cases. One patients required arthrodesis due to cartilage damage.

Results: Among the recent injuries, 71% reached a good subjective result: amplitude loss (flexion/extension) was 17°, force was 75% and laxity was 5°. Two patients had palmar subdisloction. Among the older lesions, a good subjective result was achieved in 66%: loss of amplitude case 32°, force was 69% and laxity was 8°. Palmar subdislocation was 2 mm on the average. We had two cases of persistent dysaesthesia.

Discussion: Radial injury appears to be falsely benign because the Stener lesion is not found on this side of the metacarpophalange. The importance of the injury in these traumas is related to the vulnerability of the dorsal region of the medial collateral ligament and is probably the cause of poor outcome after surgery for older lesions with palmar dislocation which is difficult to correct. We advocate emergency surgery for a wide range of indications. We always operate major radial laxity (> 35°) or laxity associated with palmar subdislocation. For other cases, we use the anterior forced drawer view to disclose potential associated dorsal injury.


J.F. Kouvalchouk Ph. Collin A.R. Haddoun

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to: 1) analyse sequelae after fracture of the lateral process of the talus (deformed callus or nonunion) in six patients included five who were operated, the impact on the talocrural and subtalar joint, and treatments that can be proposed and expected results; 2) emphasise the fact that this lesion is not often recognised in its initial stage, leading to late diagnosis despite the better results obtained with early treatment.

Material and methods: Six patients were seen at consultation at the sequelar stage. There were six men, mean age 40 year (20–60); three were high-level athletes. The injury was cause by fall from a high level, two accidents leading to multiple injuries with an unanalysable mechanism, and ankle “sprain” in one patient. Delay to therapeutic management was four months to ten years (mean two years). Pain and joint stiffeness involving the talocrural joints and/or subtalar joints were the predominant signs. The deformed calluses involved the subtalar joint in five cases with one case of nonunion. Five of the patients had been treated surgically: four resections, one screw fixation of the nonunion, and one patient desired surgery. In all the operated cases, pain had disappeared almost entirely but the amplitude of the joints was not totally recovered.

Discussion: Two aspects are particularly important. first fractures of the lateral process of the talus must be considered globally. Frequency has been estimated at 1% of all ankle trauma, certainly an underestimation since these fractures often go unrecognised in the early stages and are too often confused with ankle sprains. Incidence is also increasing with the practise of snow boarding where this injury occurs in 15% of all ankle traumas. The injury results from distraction via the talocalaneal ligaments in an inversion trauma or by compression during dorsiflexion and pronation. Clinical diagnosis is difficult and plain x-rays poorly visualise the lesion, irrespective of the anatomic type (MacCrory classification). CT scan is required to obtain an exact analysis of the fracture and its displacement, necessary for correct treatment: simple immobilisation if there is no displacement or resection of the fragment or osteosynthesis depending on the size of the fragment. Secondly, the pathology of this injury is important to recall: deformed callus or nonunion. The volume of the lesion and its site explain the observed impact, but in all cases, the injury involves the talocruaral joint (painful impingement of the fibular ligament) and talar disorganisation (pain, stiffness or osteoarthritis at the later stages). Depending on the case, treatment consists in excision of the deformed callus, fixation of the nonunion and, for cases seen late, subtalar arthrodesis. An improvment in pain can be achieved but there is almost always loss of joint amplitude.

Conclusion: Whatever treatment is used, the results at the sequelar stage are never excellent. Only early diagnosis with a rigorous clinical examination and adapted imaging (CT scan) can lead to coherent early treatment which provides the best result.


E. Charrière S. Terrazzoni C. Pittet J. Lemaître P. Mordasini M. Dutoit P. Zysset

Two calcium phosphate cements, brushite and hydroxyapatite, have been recently developed as bone substitution materials. The brushite cement is biocompatible, resorbable, osteoconductive and injectable since it hardens in physiological conditions. In contrast, hydroxyapatite is less resorbable and is not injectable. However, hydroxyapatite presents a higher strength, which may open the perspective of use in weight-bearing regions of the skeleton subjected to multi-axial stresses. The purpose of this work is a full characterization of the multiaxial elastic and failure behaviour of these two cements in a moist environment.

The brushite cement was prepared by mixing three phosphate powders in presence of water. A mixture of monetite and calcite powders in presence of water was used to obtain hydroxyapatite self-setting cement. Cylindrical, hollow specimens (Øext=18mm, Øint=14mm, L=40mm) were manufactured to apply uniaxial and torsional deformations. The specimens were cast with a custom mould, avoiding any machining, and thus, residual stresses. Scanning electron microscopy and x-ray diffraction were used to examine the cement microstructures and to determine their final material phases. An MTS axial-torsional machine was used for all mechanical tests. Compression, tension and torsion tests were performed each on five brushite and five hydroxyapatite specimens under moist conditions. Uniaxial and biaxial extensometers were used to measure the elastic moduli and the Poisson ratio.

The brushite cement exhibited failure properties comparable or below those of average human cancellous bone and confirmed its indication as a bone filling material (Brushite failure strength : 1.3±0.3 MPa in tension, 2.9±0.4 MPa in shear and 10.7±2.0 MPa in compression). The hydroxyapatite cement had an order of magnitude larger compressive strength (75±4.2 MPa), comparable tensile (3.5±0.9 MPa) and shear (4.8±0.3 MPa) strengths as average human cancellous bone. As expected, the latter cement seems to be more compatible with a multiaxial weight-bearing function in bone substitution.


J-L. Bernard I. Fahed J-P. Mortier

Purpose: All displacements can be described with x, y, z coordinates. We propose an anterior view of the first metatarsal associated with a peroperative test to determine the precise position in the frontal plane, both statically and dynamically. Lateral release is an important step in surgical treatment of hallux valgus. Both the extent of release and the potential benefit of no release must be carefully evaluated. We propose a view allowing an assessment of the metatarsophalangeal reducibility.

Material and method: Peroperative test. This test explores cuneometatarsal laxity. We conducted a prospective study in 100 cases. A 12/100 pin was used to immobilise the first cuneiform and a 20/100 pin was placed in the base of the first metatarsal. A third distal pin in the neck was used to pivot the bone on its axis. A small protractor was used to measure the angle by projection with ±2.5° precision.

Modified Guntz view. This is a weight-bearing anterior view of the first metatarsal. The cassette is positioned posteriorly. The patient stands with the heal raised 40 mm on a 20mmx20mm plexiglass bar. The metatarsal diaphysis must appear perfectly vertical. An isosceles triangle is constructed on the articular facets; the base of the triangle is perfectly horizontal and defines the pronation-supination angle. We made 100 measurements and checked correlation with the peroperative test.

Reduction view. A Zimmer brace was used to reduce the varus metatarsus and adduct the toe. The metatarsophalangeal angle and the position of the sesamoids were used to assess reducibility.

Results: Pronation and/or pronation instability was = 10° in 96% of the patients. The reduction view enabled classifiation by three grades of reducibility.

Discussion: Our contribution is determining for correction of displacements taking into account the frontal plane. No other study has shown so clearly the existence of metatarsal pronation. We also confirmed the presence of a large proportion of cuneometatarsal instability. The extent of lateral release or the potential benefit of no release can now be assessed.

Conclusion: A certain number of failures have undoubtedly been related to neglect of the parameters studied here. It is indispensable to explore the frontal plane and the dynamic parameters before establishing indications for new flat-oblique metatarsal osteotomies using conventional or minimally invasive techniques.


R.J. Ramlakan

Lisfranc injuries make up 0.2% of all fractures. With or without midfoot injuries, treatment requires early accurate diagnosis, anatomical reduction and stable internal fixation. Some surgeons prefer K-wire fixation, while others rely on rigid screw fixation, especially of the medial column. To assess the radiological and functional outcome of K-wire fixation of Lisfranc injuries, we carried out a prospective study between January 1999 and December 2000.

The ages of our 15 male and four female patients ranged from 15 to 47 years. Using the Quenu and Kuss system to classify injuries, we treated five isolated, nine homolateral and five divergent injuries. In eight patients there were associated midfoot injuries, and four had compound fractures. We treated 11 fractures with closed reduction and K-wires. Open reduction with K-wire fixation was carried out on eight fractures, including the four compound fractures, within 19 days of admission. All patients were kept non-weight-bearing in a short backslab, and the wires removed at six weeks. Follow-up times ranged from 4 to 19 months.

To assess functional outcome we used the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society’s midfoot scoring system, which has a maximum score of 100. The mean score of our patients was 70 (52 to 85). Mild or occasional foot pain and slight gait abnormality resulted in limitation of recreational activities. At three months, 15 patients were fully weight-bearing. A single case of superficial sepsis resolved, and there were no cases of implant failure or loss of reduction.

K-wire fixation following anatomical reduction is a satisfactory option for the treatment of tarsometatarsal injuries, especially when severe injuries involve the midfoot. The technique is minimally invasive and the K-wires are easily inserted and removed.


O. Jardé E. Vimont A. Gabrion F. Tran Van

Purpose: We report a series of 52 chronic Achilles tendinopathies. Surgical treatments included peritendon dissection, release of the fasia cruris, limited blunt combing of the tendon, and resection of nodules, calcifications and cysts as needed.

Material and methods: Mean duration of disease before treatment was 18 months. Twenty-six patients had sports activities. There were 12 bilateral cases. Pain was present in all cases. Ultrasonography was used to establish the PUDDU classification: paratendinitis 21, tendinitis 22, paratendinitis with tendinitis 9. All patients were reviewed at two years. Clinical criteria were used to assess outcome.

Results: Mean follow-up was five years six months. Complete pain relief was achieved in 29 cases. Motion was normal in 48 with recovery of former sports level in 29. Overall outcome was very good in 29, good in 14, fair in six and poor in three.

Discussion: The mean age of patients with poor outcome was relatively high. All the poor results were correlated with amyotrophy. The presence of a foot deformity did not appear to have an unfavourable effect on outcome. Infitration of the Achilles tendon should be avoided. Avoiding immobilisation appears to prevent tibiotalar stiffness. Ultrasonography can distinguish paratendinitis, tendinitis and paratendinitis with tendinitis but MRI offers very precise images of the lesions.

Conclusion: Surgical treatment of chronic Achiles tendinopathy can be proposed after failure of medical treatment. Outcome is better in younger subjects who participate in sports activities and who have paratendinitis.


C F Kellett A Short A Price P Kyberd D Murray

Introduction: Polyethylene wear can be an important cause of knee replacement failure.

Method: Six TKRs in young, active patients with excellent Oxford Knee Scores and Knee Society Scores, mean 76 months post knee replacement and 5 control patients, 2 weeks post TKR, were selected. Each patient had weight bearing stereo radiographs of at 0, 15, 30, 45 and 60 degrees of flexion while standing in a calibration grid. These x-rays were analysed using our Radio Stereometric Analysis (RSA) system. The three-dimensional shape of the TKR (manufacturer’s computer aided design model) was matched to the TKR silhouette on the calibrated stereo radiographs for each angle of flexion. The relative positions of the femoral and tibial components in space were then determined and the linear and volumetric penetration was calculated using Matlab software.

Results: The accuracy of the system was found to be 0.3mm (CAD model tolerance 0.25mm). The mean linear wear in the control patients was 0.02mm (range −0.19 to +0.23mm). Average linear penetration in the study group was found to be 0.6 mm at 6 years, giving an overall linear wear rate of 0.1mm/year. Average penetration volume at 76 months was 399mm3. The average volumetric wear rate was 63mm3/year.

Conclusion: It is possible to measure volumetric wear in vivo using RSA. Volumetric wear rate was found to be 63mm3 per year. Studies on retrieved normally functioning hip replacements have shown volumetric wear rates of 35mm3 per year. However, clinical outcomes of knee replacements are comparable to those of hip replacements, suggesting that the knee has a more effective mechanism for dealing with polyethylene wear particles.

*Oxford Hip and Knee Group: P McLardy-Smith, C Dodd, D Murray & R Gundle


R. Krauspe K.M. Wess P. Raab U. Stahl D. Ronneberger P.P. Fietzek

The objective of our research is to elucidate the pathogenesis of soft-tissue contracture. Here we present a comparison of collagens isolated from deltoid ligament of 23 clubfeet classified according to the Dimeglio-classification and of 14 matched controls of normal feet.

Collagens were isolated by acetic acid extraction and by limited pepsin-solubilisation and analysed by SDS-PAGE. Ligaments and solubilised collagens were analysed for their extent of hydroxylation of prolyl- and lysyl-residues, their content of galactosyl-hydroxylysine and glucosyl-galacto-syl-hydroxylysine and their content of lysyl-oxidase dependent cross-links histidinohydroxylysino-norleucine (HHL), hydroxylysylpyridinoline (HP) and lysylpyridinoline (LP). Analysis were carried out using an amino acid analyser (Bio-chrom 20, Amersham Pharmacia Biotech) and a reverse-phase HPLC system (Gynkothek).

Percentage of collagen of total protein decreases in club-foot as compared to controls. SDS-PAGE of solubilised collagens shows a high content of type I, less of type III and small amounts of type V collagen in both groups. The extent of hydroxylation of proline appears to be very similar, whereas the degree of hydroxylation of lysine follows the Dimeglio-classification. In addition, glycosylation of hydroxylysine increases parallelly to the classification. However, the increase is found solely in the amount of disac-charides. Total content of HHL, the most important collagen cross-link in soft tissues, was increased significantly in club-feet as compared to controls. HP, the hard tissue specific collagen cross-link was increased slightly in clubfeet. Levels of LP were too low to detect differences precisely.

The data presented show distinct differences in the post-translational modifications of collagen (hydroxylation of lysyl-residues, glycosylation and lysyl-oxidase dependent cross-links) isolated from congenital idiopathic clubfeet and from controls.


J.J. van Niekerk

We retrospectively reviewed 100 consecutive cases of foot trauma, sometimes accompanied by other injuries, in people who had instituted legal proceedings to recoup losses after motor vehicle accidents. To keep matters in their correct perspective, it must be noted that claims on a contingency basis were not acceptable at the time of this review.

We excluded from the study patients with only minor foot injuries and significant other injuries. There was significant foot trauma in 14% of the reviewed motor vehicle accident cases, and 75% of patients had significant other injuries. Of patients who had suffered only foot trauma, 32% were male and 68% female. Their mean age was 36 years and the review was conducted a mean of 28 months after injury. Of those who suffered multiple injuries, 65% were male and 35% female. Their mean age was 34 years and the review conducted a mean of 21 months after injury. Combining the effects of patients’ other injuries but reviewing foot injuries separately, we assessed the long-term impact of the injuries as minimal, slight, moderate, severe or very severe. Nearly 50% of the foot injuries had a severe or very severe long-term impact, involving loss of amenities of life and the ability to earn a living. In 44% of the multiple trauma cases, the foot injury alone would cause significant loss of income. In about 30% of these cases the other injuries would have a similarly negative effect. We estimated that 60% of foot injures and 40% of other injuries would later come to need surgical treatment.

When we assessed the quality of care the patients received, we found that 50% of those with only foot injuries and 40% of those with foot and other injuries had not been given optimal treatment for their foot injuries. In 15% of cases the other injuries could have received better treatment.

Our review showed that foot injuries sustained in motor vehicle accidents can have serious long-term effects. However, because they are not life-threatening, at the time of the accident foot injuries receive suboptimal treatment. In multiple trauma patients, foot injuries should not be overlooked. Optimal treatment will improve the final outcome and enjoyment of life of motor vehicle accident victims.


O. Tschopp G. Carmona A. Kaelin

Purpose: We reviewed major amputations of the lower limbs in geriatric patients.

Material and method: This retrospective study was conducted in patient treated between January 1990 and December 1999. A total of 265 amputations in 209 patients, including 24 revisions and 32 bilateral amputations, were included in the study. Inclusion criteria were the major nature of the amputation requiring prosthetic fitting and patient age (greater than 65 years).

Results: The incidence of amputation in our geriatric population was 4 per 10 000. Mean age at amputation was 78 ± 7.5 years. Mean follow-up was 27.8 months. Tibial amputations predominated (123/264, 46.4%). Aetiology factors were basically diabetes mellitus (99/209, 47.4%), and atherosclerosis (85/209, 40.7%). Overall survival at one year was 61.7%, 47.9% at two years and 13.7% at ten years. Survival was better for tibial amputations (p = 0.023). Analysis of 12 comorbiditties revealed that amputated patients had significantly higher mortality when they also had heart failure (p = 0.001), dialysis (p = 0.001), rhythm disorders (p = 0.003), dementia (p = 0.008). Rhythm disorders (p = 0.01) and dementia (p = à.02) usually predicted a femoral level of amputation. The number of surgical revisions required for amputation at a higher level was 9.1% (24/265). Amputations of the contralateral limb were required in 34/209 patients (16.3%) after a mean delay of 19.7 months. Half of our patients were fitted with a prosthesis (53.6%, 112/209).

Discussion: We did not find any predominant aetiological factors by level of amputation. Statistical analysis demonstrated that survival depended on the low level of the amputation. Preservation of the knee was an important factor not only for rehabilitation but also for mortality. Survival after femoral amputation and after desarticulation of the knee was the same. Prosthesis fitting was difficult at the femoral level. Mortality depends on four basic comorbidities, heart failure, dialysis, rhythm disorders and dementia. Addition of comorbidities for a given patient has a significant effect and is not compatible with survival greater than five years.


G. Piétu M. Cappelli D. Waast C. Guilleux

Purpose: Retrograde nailing is emerging among methods proposed or stabilisation of femoral fractures above total knee arthroplasties (TKA).

Material and methods. Between June 1994 and may 2000, 12 fractures above TKA were treated by retrograde nailing. These fractures occurred 43 months (4–51) after implantation of the TKA in three men and women aged 74 years (43–88). The fracture was situated just above the prosthetic trochlea in ten, and distant from the implant in two. The posterior cruciate ligament was preserved in six TKA and six were posterior stabilised prostheses. Indications for arthroplasty were degenerative joint disease in nine and rheumatoid polyarthritis in three. Four patients had proximal implants (one fixation and three prostheses). A percutaneous approach was used except for three cases in order protect the tibial component. Closed reduction was achieved, but required an open reduction for completion in two cases. the nail was advanced just to the trochlea in patients with a preserved posterior cruciate ligament and beyond the posterior stabilisation cage for the posterior stabilised implants. The knee was mobilised immediately after surgery and total weight-bearing was encouraged four to six weeks later.

Results: There was one error in the proximal aiming, one metastatic infection from a leg ulcer at three months and one tibial loosening in a polyarthritic woman 66 months after arthroplasty, i.e. 51 months after the fracture. Bone healing was achieved at two to four months. Frontal deviation was less than 5°. Recurvatum was less than 5° in eight cases, between 5° and 10° in two cases and between 10° and 20° in two others. At mean follow-up of 23 months (3–60), maximal moss of mobility was 10°. There was not worsening of pain.

Discussion: Retrograde nailing leads to bone healing with satisfactory frontal alignment and minimal loss of mobility. The approach uses the initial incision, facilitating complementary procedures or revision if needed. The main problem is controlling recurvatum, even though at the follow-up reported there was no clinical impact or loosening. The limitations of this method are well defined: free medullary canal, sufficient knee flexion, compatible femoral component. The tibial obstacle in posterior stabilised implants is less well known; It should be protected during the nailing if it is high. The polyethylene insert may have to be removed temporarily in certain cases.

Conclusion: The two principal problems with retrograde nailing are recognising implants compatible with this technique and controlling recurvatum. Results are acceptable with a minimally invasive technique.


M.M. Murray J. McColm J. Hood S. Bell D. Pratt C.G. Greenough

The aim of this study was to compare implementation of RCGP guidelines in patients in Primary Care with acute low back pain between GP and Nurse Practitioner. This report presents preliminary results.

The intention was to recruit 200 patients presenting to GP with new episode of back pain. 50% randomised to NP care, 50% to GP care. Outcome measured by documentation audit and patient feedback. Individuals complete a questionnaire which includes a Low Back Outcome Score (LBOS) at 14 weeks, 6,12 and 24 months. All patients in NP arm given back book and advised against bed rest.

Initial Findings: (n = 145): The LBOS score was identical (30) for the 73 patients randomised to nurse practitioner care and the 72 with routine GP care. There were no significant differences between the scores at 14 weeks and 6 months, with an increase in LBOS to 45–49, but numbers dropping to 28 in the NP group and 26 in the GP group.

Process audit at 14 weeks: Only 10 of NP patients were not given the back book compared with 74% for GP care. 13% of NP patients were prescribed bed rest against 18 for GP care.

Initial results suggest no significant difference in outcome between GP and Nurse Practitioner patients. Of interest is that 10% and 13% of patients failed to recall important features of management. This implies that audit of healthcare processes by patient questionnaire may be unsatisfactory.


C.J. Grobbelaar G.G.A. Cappaert

Thromboembolism is a potentially fatal complication of total joint replacement. Some surgeons follow a ‘prophylaxis without compromise’ policy, while others, who realise that there are risks attached to the use of prophylactic drugs, go to the opposite extreme and administer no prophylaxis and no anti-thrombotic drugs, even for pulmonary embolism.

We believe the results of surveillance should determine the administration of anticoagulation therapy. In over 1 500 patients, anticoagulants have been administered only when clinically indicated and after positive Duplex diagnosis. Death due to pulmonary embolism has occurred in only two patients in six years, a reduction from 1.0% to less than 0.05%.

Our treatment protocol divides our patients into high and low risk cases. The results of Doppler and blood tests dictate the method and extent of prophylaxis for high-risk cases, and the therapeutic handling of positive clot formation in the low-risk population.


Full Access
G.E. Bartlett T. Gunendran G.C. Bannister

General Practitioner (GP) attendances for non-specific disease increase after life events. Whiplash injury has the effect of a life event in some people.

The aim of this study was to compare GP attendance rates in the year before and after whiplash injury to establish their rate and cause.

Ninety-eight subjects (62 women and 36 men) with whiplash injuries examined for medicolegal reports, with complete GP records for a year before and after injury.

The number of attendances and the reason for attendance. Consultations after the accident were subdivided into those for neck pain and for other reasons.

Subjects were reviewed more than one year after injury. All described neck pain 11% mild, 62% moderate and 27% severe. GP attendance rates before the accident were within the normal range but increased after (p=0.0001) because of neck pain symptoms. There was no association between attendance rates before and after injury but consultations for neck pain rose in proportion to severity of symptoms (p = 0.0015). Attendances unrelated to neck symptoms fell after injury (p = 0.002).

GP attendances for non-specific disorders increase after life events, but not after whiplash injury as patients focus on their neck symptoms.


P. Gleyze H. Thomazeau P.-H. Flurin L. Lafosse D.F. Gazielly M. Allard

Purpose of the study: The aim of this study was to evaluate the anatomical and technical limits of endoscopic rotator cuff repair. Anatomical results were also compared with functional assessment of the shoulder.

Material and methods: A multicentric serie of 87 patients presenting a full thickness rotator cuff tear repaired endoscopically was retrospectively reviewed at 25.4 months (mean) post surgery. Limits of the surgical technique were studied in correlation with functional results and anatomic radiographic evaluation (arthroscans in 93 p. 100).

Results: Anatomical repair (normal thickness and no contrast in the subacromial space on arthroscan) was achieved in 83 p. 100 of the rotator cuffs with limited damage to the frontal part of the supra spinatus tendon. This percentage fell to 57.8 p. 100 in case of posterior extension of the tear to the supra spinatus tendon and further dropped to 40.8 p. 100 in case of retraction to the apex of the humeral head. Functional outcome evaluated with the Constant score was strongly related to the radiographic cuff condition (p < 0.05). For distal and anterior tears of the supra spinatus tendon, the Constant score at revision was 89.8 points in cases with anatomic repair at revision. This score fell to 75 when the rotator cuff tear was evidenced radiographically (p < 0.0001). For tears involving the entire supra spinatus tendon repaired by arthroscopy, the functional difference at revision was 8 points on the Constant scale. Objective and subjective analysis of the surgical procedure identified significant peroperative elements predictive of clinical and anatomical outcome (difficult reduction, p < 0.05; subjective degree of solidity, p < 0.0001; anatomical aspect of the repaired cuff, p < 0.05).

Discussion: A comparison of our findings with data on equivalent lesions reported in the literature suggests that endoscopic surgery for rotator cuff tears offers both functional and anatomic results equivalent to those achieved with conventional open surgery. This assumes that the surgical procedure is carried out by surgeons experienced in shoulder arthroscopy who can precisely gauge the posterior/anterior extension of the tears and the limits of the surgical technique.


A.H. McGregor S.P.F. Hughes

The majority of studies investigating the outcome of lumbar decompression surgery have been retrospective in nature and have not used validated measures of outcome. The aim of this study was to prospectively investigate the short and long term outcome of lumbar decompression surgery in terms of function, disability, general health and psychological well being.

Eighty-four patients undergoing lumbar spinal stenosis surgery were recruited into this study. Patients were assessed using validated measures of outcome pre-operatively, and at 6 weeks, 6 months and one year post-operatively.

A significant reduction in pain (p< 0.001) was observed at the 6 week post-operative stage, this did not change at the subsequent assessment stages. Only some of the SF~36 categories were sensitive to change. The sub-categories that were sensitive to change were; physical function (p< 0.05); bodily pain (p< 0.001); and social function (p< 0.05). Improvements were observed in these categories at the 6 week and 6 month reviews. A gradual reduction in the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) was observed with time, with changes principally being observed between the 6 week and 6 month review, and 6 week and one year review stages (p< 0.05). Minimal changes were observed in the psychological assessments with time. The outcome of surgery could not be predicted reliably from psychological, functional or pain measures.

Lumbar decompression surgery leads to a reduction in pain and some improvements in function.


J.Y. Lazennec A. Madi Ch. Pompee J.P. Boutrand G. Mazmanian G. Saillant

Purpose: The aim of this work was to evaluate the short- and long-term biocompatibility, tolerance and tissue response after implantation of an intersomatic bioresorbabled lumbar cage (Phusiline®).

Material and methods: Eighteen sheep were operated on in 1999; three animals were sacrificed for study at three, six, nine and twelve months after implantation. The cage was placed between two lumbar vertebrae and filled and covered with cancellous bone. Cerebrospinal fluid, lateroaortic lymph nodes, liver, spleen and kidney samples were taken after sacrifice. The spinal segment from L1 to S1 was removed with the surrounding ligaments and muscles for radiography, MRI, and CT scan. Histology sections were stained with Paragon. The pathology examination included: bone and cell density, degree of tissue differentiation in contact with the implant, remodeling and consolidation of the fusion, implant resorption and associated reactions. An epifluorescence study was performed to assess bone apposition. Reaction of tissue in contact with the implant or far from the implant (laterovertebral muscles, paravetebral lymph nodes, liver, kidney, spleen) were qualified histologically.

Results: At three months, there was no evidence of implant resorption; there was active formation of new bone around the implant. Implant resorption and osteointegration had started at six months and bone remodeling around the implant was increased. There were signs of bone fusion within and around the cage. Spondylodesis was effective at nine months with bone apposition. Implant resorption continued. Spondylodesis was confirmed. After nine and twelve months implantation, there was no sign of local or general intolerance. Degradation of the implants was visible after one month and appeared to be most marked at 12 months. Approximately 30% of the initial surfaced area of the implants had been resorbed at 12 months.

Conclusion: One year after implantation, the implant had not induced any sign of local intolerance (no sign of inflammation, necrosis, osteolysis). Fusion occurred within and around the case. This study will be pursued (two groups of three animals will be sacrificed at 24 and 36 months) and should confirm the long-term effectiveness of this technique.


J. Street C. Power A. Wakai J.H. Wang A. McGuinness H.P. Redmond

Background: Low molecular weight heparins (LMWH) are of undoubted efficacy as thromboprophylaxis in orthopaedic surgical practice. However, prolonged dosage inhibits bone nodule formation in vitro and we have previously reported that daily dosing significantly delays fracture healing. To further investigate these phenomena we hypothesised that LMWH’s would reduce osteoblast survival and thus bone formation by inducing programmed cell death (apoptosis).

Methods: Primary human osteoblasts were isolated from femoral heads excised during hip arthoplasty and cultured to passage 3–5. These were examined for VEGF receptor expression using a biotinylated binding assay on flow cytometry. Osteoblasts were grown to confluence and then incubated for 24 hours in control medium or medium treated with enoxaparin (200 – 2X10(−4) IU/mL) or combination of enoxaparin (200 – 2X10 (−4) IU/mL) and VEGF (1ng/ml). Apoptosis was determined by measuring cytosolic histone-associated DNA fragmentation using an enzyme linked immunosorbant assay. Results were confirmed by DNA fragmentation analysis on agarose gel electrophoresis. Cell functional viability was measured by a tetrazolium bioreduction colorimetric assay.

Results: Data is expressed as percentage of control apoptosis or viability, illustrates mean ± s.e.m. and n=4 experiments in each case. ANOVA was employed for statistical analysis; *versus control, #versus enoxaparin treated; p< 0.05 was considered significant.

Conclusions: Therapeutic doses of LMWH attenuate osteo-blast survival by inducing significant apoptosis. This effect is partly abrogated by VEGF, which independently enhances osteoblast viability, thus delaying spontaneous and enoxaparin induced apoptosis. These findings may explain the bone resorptive effects of prolonged LMWH therapy and suggest a potential therapeutic role for VEGF in conditions of delayed bone formation.


F.-H. Dujardin N. Mazirt A.-C. Tobenas F. Duparc J.-M. Thomine

Purpose of the study: The aim of this work was to assess results after treatment by nailing of nonunion of the humeral shaft. In particular, we focused on consolidation and factors predictive of failure.

Material and method: A prospective study was conducted in 13 consecutive patients presenting aseptic nonunion of the humeral diaphysis. There were five cases after orthopedic treatment and eight cases after internal fixation. Two patients had iterative nonunions. Locked nailing was performed with three successive types of nails: the Seidel nail in four cases, the Russel Taylor nail in seven, and the ACE nail in two. Anterograde nailing was used for the first three cases and retrograde nailing for the others. All patients were followed regularly in our department. Last follow-up was one to seven years after nailing.

Results: Five nonunions (38%) did not consolidate after locked nailing. Consolidation was achieved in the other patients after four to 18 months. The anatomic result was good in these patients. Between the success and failure groups, there was no significant difference in age, gender, type of fracture, first intention treatment, delay from fracture to nailing, type or diameter of the nail, surgical access or not to the fracture site during nailing, or duration of complementary fixation. Anterograde nail insertion, used in our first three patients in this series, appeared to affect shoulder function. The retrograde route was used in other patients and did not appear to have any impact on the elbow itself or the elbow region.

Discussion: This clinical study was unable to identify clinical factors explaining failures but did provide several arguments suggesting that defective primary stability of the initial fixation could be incriminated in the failures.

Conclusion: Centromedullary locked nailing is a simple technique with potential for resolving difficult problems of nonunion. Good functional outcome can be obtained when consolidation is achieved. Rather than abandoning this technique, it would be advisable to conduct further research to determine what factors are determinant in its failures.


N. Mazirt A.-C. Tobenas X. Roussignol F. Duparc F.-H. Dujardin

Purpose of the study: A clinical trial on the treatment of humeral shaft nonunions with locked nailing evidenced 5 failures among 13 cases. The circumstances leading to the nonunion, the patient’s condition, and the nailing method were not found to have a predominant effect explaining this outcome. Inversely, clinical data suggested that abnormal mobility of the nonunion appeared to result from play in the assembly. To check this hypothesis, we measured primary stability in three nailing models using cadaver bones.

Materials and methods: Three nailing models, Seidel (S), Russel-Taylor (RT) and ACE were tested, each on 5 cadaver specimens. A 1 cm segmental resection was made in the mid third of the humerus to simulate an unstable nonunion. The nailing was performed in accordance with the instructions furnished by the manufacturers. The nailed specimens were placed in a testing device which alternatively applied a rotation force around the longitudinal axis (± 0.5 Nm), an axial compression-traction force (± 20 N) and a transverse shear force applied at the level of the osteotomy (± 20 N).

Results: This study demonstrated an instability of the three nails when submitted to a rotation force or a shear force: 14 to 28° and 1.6 to 3.4 mm respectively for the RT nail; 8 to 20° and 1 to 3 mm for the S nail; 5 to 15° and 1.7 to 3.2 mm for the ACE nail. The ACE nail appeared to be more stable when submitted to compression-traction force; the S nail accepted a 0.05 to 0.65 mm play which reached 9.7 mm for the RT nail. This instability appeared to result from play in the locking systems.

Discussion: These findings would demonstrate that these nailing systems cannot, in themselves, provide satisfactory primary stability. The experimentally evidenced instability would contribute, probably in association with locally unfavorable physiological or biological conditions, to the failure rate observed when nailing is used alone.

Conclusion: The locking system for tested nails would have to be modified to eliminate play in the assembly before continuing their use for the treatment nonunion of the humeral shaft.


L. Sedel

Severe acetabular fractures are difficult to treat. Complications include blood loss, neural damage, long operating times, and a high risk of sepsis and failure. Even when the fracture is ideally stabilised, there is a major risk of secondary osteoarthritis. This can be related to bone necrosis, cartilage surface damage, bone loss.

However, even in young patients modern surgical techniques, including use of an alumina-against-alumina bearing, may facilitate long-term survival without limitation of activity.

Functionally, the results of secondary procedures after failed osteosynthesis are statistically worse than after primary total hip arthroplasty (THA). The surgery is difficult because of material retrieval difficulties, nerve dissection, bone reconstruction and remaining muscular dysfunction.

We reviewed the results of 80 THA procedures done between 1980 and 1998 to treat 58 acetabular fractures. The mean age of our 57 patients (39 men and 18 women) was 50 years (21 to 80). The mean delay between fracture and THA was 10 years in 22 patients who had undergone osteosynthesis and six years in 35 patients who had been treated conservatively. The mean follow-up period was 5,5 years (6 months to 20 years).

There were eight instances of socket loosening, two of which were septic and six aseptic. Two of these patients had screw-in prostheses and six had cemented. There were 19 sciatic palsies, 13 of which developed after trauma, four after osteosynthesis and two after THA. There were three cases of gluteus medius palsy. In two of four cases of sepsis that occurred after osteosynthesis, sepsis recurred after THA, and in one patient sepsis developed after THA.

In this limited series, patients who underwent THA after osteosynthesis did not have as good an outcome as those in whom initial orthopaedic treatment was followed some weeks later by THA. We believe many poor results could have been avoided with better primary surgery. Functional results are likely to be better, and the incidence of complications lower, if primary THA is performed in conjunction with acetabular reconstruction. Of course, for treatment of simple acetabular fracture involving major displacement of the posterior wall, one column osteosynthesis is still recommended.


S. Aravindan J. Kennedy A.J. McGuinness

High complication rates and technical difficulties of intra-medullary fixation in children with osteogenesis imperfecta has prompted the modification of existing rod systems. The Sheffield telescoping intramedullary rod has T-piece which is permanently fixed and is expanded to reduce metaphyseal migration. This study analyses the outcome of this rod system over an 11-year period.

32 rods were inserted in the lower limbs of 11 children with osteogenesis imperfecta. All children had multiple fractures of the bones before rod insertion.24 rods were inserted into femur, of which 3 were exchange procedures for complications. 8 rods were inserted into tibia. 4 children had intramedullary rodding of all the 4 lower limb bones. The outcome was measured in terms of mobility status, incidence of refractures and rod related complications. Complications encountered include 2-rod migrations, one instance each of broken rod, bent rod and valgus drift in the tibia.There was no instance of epiphyseal damage or growth arrest.

Our series demonstrates that there is significant reduction in refractures and improvement in the mobility status in children with osteogenesis imperfecta following intramedullary fixation. The frequent complication of T-piece separation and the need for reoperation has been overcome with Sheffield modification of rod design. Though the incidence of rod related complications remain high, our study concludes that Sheffield rod system compares favourably with the existing intramedullary devices for osteogenesis imperfecta in the literature.


J.N. de Beer

We have long suspected that patients treated at our institution have narrower femoral canals than the literature suggests. This has implications when it comes to nail size and the question of using reamed or unreamed nails. Using CT analysis, we studied the morphology of the femoral isthmus.

We prospectively evaluated 30 men with a mean age of 26 years (20 to 35). Patients with previous femoral fractures were excluded from the study. A scanogram determined the level of the isthmus and axial cuts at this level accurately revealed canal size and shape.

We found a canal size of less than 12 mm in 62%. In a third of these, canal size was less than 11 mm. Axial cuts showed three types of femoral canals: 14 patients had thick femoral cortices and a narrow canal, seven had thin cortices and a wider canal, and nine had an oval canal, with the larger diameter in the sagittal plane.

If one adheres to the principle of reaming until cortical clutter is heard, the recommended 12-mm or 13-mm reamed femoral nail is not suitable for the majority of non-Caucasian men in our population. Larger nails may cause such complications as delayed union, nonunion and fracture. Smaller nails of 10-mm and 11-mm diameter result in satisfactory clinical and radiological outcomes.


G.G.A. Cappaert C.J. Grobbelaar

In a retrospective study, we examine the occurrence and management of sepsis in total knee arthroplasty. Histological examination and MCS play important roles.


G.G.A. Cappaert C.J. Grobbelaar

In the past many high tibial osteotomies were done to relieve symptoms of osteoarthritis. Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) has largely taken the place of these osteotomies.

Aiming to evaluate the long-term results of these osteotomies and assess the complications involved on conversion to TKA, we followed up 207 patients over a 10-year period.


P. Hernigou G. Tararis M. Ma

Purpose: The position of the patella after implantation of a total knee arthroplasty is generally determined by static measurements on the femoropatellar 30° flexion view or on a computed tomography (CT) scan in full extension. We studied the kinetics of the patellar implant between 0° and 90° on dynamic CT scans to determine the influence of torsion of the femoral and tibial components on the patellar course.

Material and methods: Twenty patients with titanium total knee arthroplasties implanted in 1991 and 1992 underwent a dynamic CT study preoperatively and during the year following prosthesis implantation. An Imatron machine was used to obtain dynamic slices during knee flexion from 0° to 90°. The patient was installed in the prone position. Slice thickness was 8 mm for images centred on the lower end of the femur. Ten 50 ms images were obtained during flexion from 0° to 90°. The technique used preoperatively and postoperatively enabled study of transversal translation and tilt of the patella.

Results: The orientation of the patellar transversal bony axis remained closely parallel to the flexion axis of the knee (i.e. the epicondylar axis) both preoperatively and postoperatively, irrespective of the orientation of the femoral and tibial components. Between 0° and 90° flexion, the prosthetic patella exhibited a translation movement laterally to medially during the first degrees of flexion then medially to laterally during the last degrees of flexion. The transversal displacement of the patellar insert was less pronounced when the femoral component was placed in external rotation from the epicondylar axis. For femoral implants in internal rotation (mean 5°), the translation of the patellar insert was a mean 1.5 mm between extension and flexion. This translation was only a mean 1 cm for implants in external rotation (mean 5°). Contact between the patellar prosthetic component and the femoral prosthetic component were more harmonious when the femoral implant was placed in external rotation. Torsion of the tibial implant did not appear to have an impact on the transversal course of the patella in this series.

Discussion, conclusion: Rotation of the femoral component influenced the relationship between the patella and the femoral component in flexion-extension movements. However, torsion of the femoral component had little effect on the position of the patella itself. The patellar remained schematically parallel to the epicondylar axis, maintaining an orientation close to that observed preoperatively. The torsion of the femoral implant is the element that modifies its position under the patella and by consequence the relations between the patella and the femoral trochleae. These modifications are more pronounced when the knee is in extension than when the knee is in 90° flexion, excepting for the lift-off phenomenon observed at 90° flexion which is related to the trapezoidal femorotibial resection spaces.


F. Delepine G. Delepine N. Delepine

Purpose: Several studies have been conducted to search for factors affecting the prognosis of osteosarcoma. In this work, we attempted to assess the prognostic value of the biopsy technique and initial management on long-term prognosis of localised osteosarcoma of the limbs.

Material and methods: The series included 139 patients (88 males and 51 females, aged 4 to 58 years) with high-grade malignant osteosarcoma of the lower limbs treated or followed by our team between 1984 and 1998. Seventy-eight patients were referred to our unit for biopsy performed by a team surgeon after careful search for local extension and conception of the future extratumour en bloc resection. The 84 other patients were referred to our team after biopsy or after induction chemotherapy. There was no statistical significant difference between the two groups for known prognostic factors (localisation, tumour size, gender). All patients were given pre- and postoperative chemotherapy using the protocols generally applied at the time of their treatment. Three referred patients had already undergone amputation. All others were treated with conservative surgery even in case of fracture, very large tumour or young age. Patients were followed by their surgeon and chemotherapist independently with regular visits every three months for two years then every six months for two years and every year thereafter. Median follow-up was ten years (2.5–16.5 years).

Results: There were 12 local relapses (9%). Two were complications observed among the 75 patients followed from the start in our unit and ten were among the 84 secondary referral patients. Relapse-free survival reached 54% (46/84) in the referral patients compared with 73% (40/55) for the patients initially treated in our unit. For patients treated initially in our unit after 1986, the relapse-free survival rate reached 93%. Multivariate analysis demonstrated that the difference was significant (p < 0.02).

Conclusion: Initial management by an experimented team is a major prognosis factor for long-term survival and for risk of local recurrence in patients with high-grade malignant osteosarcoma of the limbs first seen without metastasis. When the diagnosis of osteosarcoma cannot be ruled out, these patients should be referred to a team specialised in malignant bone tumours before biopsy.


F. Bonnel P. Faline Ch. Assi F. Canovas Ch. Bonnel

Purpose: The purpose of this work was to evaluate function of 256 total knee arthroplasties (TKA) (Wallaby) with preservation of the posterior cruciate ligament and to compare the femorotibial angle obtained postoperatively.

Material and methods: This prospective study included 256 consecutive TKA (cemented Wallaby 1) in 249 patients (mean age 68 years) with osteoarthritis (n=249) or rheumatoid polyarthritis (n=7). Pre- and postoperative clinical findings (HKS score, flexion, extension, laxity, walking distance, use of crutches) and AP full leg views with 20° loaded lateral views pre- and postoperatively (mechanical femoral, mechanical tibial, and femorotibial angles, tibial slope, patellar height, anterior tibial translation) were recorded.

Results: The 256 TKA were reviewed at a mean 3-year follow-up. Flexion amplitude was the evaluation criterion. Mean preoperative flexion was 109° (40–130°) with mean persistent flexion of 5° (0°–40°). Mean postoperative flexion was 98° (30–130°) with no persistent flexion. The mean preoperative femorotibial angle was 181.8° (160–201°) and was 180.4° (172–195°) postoperatively. The mean preperative mechanical femoral angle was 88° (82–96°) and 89.8° (80–96°) postoperatively. Mean mechanical tibial angle was 93° (85–104°) and 90.4° (84–86°) postoperatively.

Discussion: For certain authors, the only parameter predictive of postoperative flexion after gliding TKA with preservation of the posterior cruciate ligament is preoperative flexion. The statistical analysis of our series showed that correction of the femorotibial malalignement in the frontal plane was not correlated with postoperative knee function and precisely with postoperative flexion. Postoperative flexion was correlated with preoperative flexion. Our results on postoperative flexion of TKA related to preoperative flexion are in agreement with earlier analyses reported in the literature that do not find any absolute correlation with a neutral femorotibial angle in the frontal plane.

Conclusion: The quality of the functional outcome after total knee arthroplasty cannot be predicted solely on the correction of the initial deformity.


M. Lukhele M.T. Mariba

Fractures of the thoracolumbar spine are now so common that most orthopaedic surgeons are likely to have to handle one. It is important that we have common terms of reference when we assess, manage and discuss outcomes of these injuries.

The authors plan to assess the intra-observer and inter-observer interpretation of six plain radiographs of thoraco-lumbar fractures. Volunteer orthopaedic surgeons attending the SAOA Congress will be asked to classify the six radiographs twice, on different days, and the radiographic labelling will be changed. Participants will be given the Margel and Dennis classifications for reference. Participants’ names will not be required, only their year of qualification and exposure to spinal surgery.

The results will be analysed statistically and communicated to the orthopaedic community in due course.


R. Hammami G. Asencio R. Bertin P. Kouyoumdjian B. Megy S. Hacini

Purpose: We report our experience with 10 cases of osteotomy performed at the same time as total hip arthroplasty.

Material and methods: This series included ten knees in ten patients, mean age 63 years. The knees were divided into two groups: five with tibial deviations in one or two planes (three callus deformities, one congenital varus, and one coxalgia sequela) and six mono- or biplanar femoral deviations (three callus deformities, two congenital valgus, and one coxalgia sequela). The principal extra-articular deviation was greater than 10° in all cases. A total knee arthroplasty preserved the posterior cruciate ligament in nine cases with a non-cemented femoral stem implant and cemented tibial implant with or with out a stem. The tibial osteotomies were all in the proximal metaphysis. The femoral osteotomy was in the distal metaphysis in four cases, subtro-chanteric with derotation in one and in the diaphysis with derotation in one. The correction osteotomy was performed before the prosthesis bone cut. Complementary osteosynthesis was used in all cases.

Results: Minimal follow-up was 12 months with a mean of 19.6 months. Bone healing was achieved in all cases. Complete weight bearing was achieved at a mean 2.5 months. The mean postoperative HSS score was 76. Results were excellent in four knees, good in four, fair in one and poor in one. Mean joint amplitude was 105°. Radiographically, complete tibial correction was obtained for three knees (two biplanar corrections); for two knees the biplanar correction was incomplete in one plane. Among the four biplanar femoral deviations, complete correction was achieved in three and incomplete frontal correction in one, with two varus overcorrections in the frontal plane on the single plane deviations.

Discussion: We used this method to avoid intra-articular correction of extra-articular deviations, a source of complications.

Conclusion: Combining osteotomy with total knee arthroplasty during the same operation for patients with major axial deviation and degenerative joint disease provides satisfactory results in 80% of the cases.


P. Mary A. Logeart C. Blancot A. Mennir

Purpose: Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMP) are fragile products that must be protected from degradation and released progressively to achieve maximal efficacy. Release of quantities to the order of 10μg are required at ectopic sites in the rat; in humans 50 mg is required to induce new bone formation. Use of high-dose BMP is costly and the risk of overestimulating mesenchymatous cells remains to be determined. Functional dextranes, or DMCBSU, are inert biological derivatives with random substitution of carboxymethyl, benzylamide and sulfonate units. The affinity of these products for other growth factors led us to propose their use as specific carriers of BMP extracted from bovin bone.

Material and methods: Three different gels (CMDB2, OM27, LS8) and the native dextranes from which they are derived (T40, T500) were tested by to determine their capacity to adsorb and release BMP. Uptake and releasing kinetics were studied by fluorimetry using fluoresceine-labelled BMP. CMDB2 and its native dextrane T500, OM27 and LS8 and their native dextrane TT40, and collagen sponge (control) were implanted in the paravertebral grooves of the rat after impregnating the products with different concentrations of BMP (5 μg, 500 ng, 50 ng, 5 ng). The animals were sacrificed at six weeks. The presence of bone tissue was determined by microradiography and histomorphometry.

Results: The more porous gels (OM27 and LS8) adsorbed the greatest quantities of BMP (96.6 and 95.7 ng/ml respectively). Implantation of BMP associated with certain DMBCSU enabled elaboration of bony tissue in an ectopic site for quantities of BMP starting from 50 ng. This bony tissue formation was obtained for collagen sponge controls with doses 100-fold higher (5 μg). Bony tissue obtained with the BMP:DMCBSU combination was endochondral bone presenting cartilaginous lines, followed by mature bony tissue.

Conclusion: This preliminary study demonstrates that by choosing the right specific carrier for bone growth factors, it is possible to considerably reduce the minimal dose required to induce formation of new bone at an ectopic site. Implantations in bone defects of a critical size are under investigation to validate these results in a model closer to the clinical situation.


Ph. Massin B. Flautre P. Hardouin

Purpose: The purpose of this work was to demonstrate the presence of polyethylene particles at the fixation interfaces of the femoral and acetabular components of non-dislocated cemented hip prostheses that had functioned in vivo for several years.

Material and methods: Three femoral components and two acetabular cups were recovered in two patients who died from an intercurrent cause. The first patient, an 85-year-old woman, had had a hip prosthesis for eight years. There was no radiological sign of displacement nor cup wear (stainless steel /polyethylene cup). For this same patient, the other hip had be revised for acetabular loosening three months prior to death. The femoral component was not loosened; it had been removed with its cement then reimplanted within the same cement sheath that was not removed. The cement/bone interface was thus preserved at eight years. In the second patient, a woman aged 88 years, the delay was nine years. This patient had no radiographic sign of loosening. The polyethylene acetabular insert exhibited 1 mm linear wear. This was a ceramic /polyethylene cup. The specimens were prepared by decalcification and defatting then fixation in buffered formol (pH 7.2) before embedding in polymethyl-metacrylate. After hardening, a diamond-tipped diatome to obtain transverse section of the femur at four levels: lesser trochanter, 2 cm below the lesser trochanter, 1 cm above the tip of the stem, 1 cm below the distal tip of the stem. After polishing, the 50 μ thick sections were stained with Picrofuschin von Jienson. The polyethylene acetabular cups were prepared likewise. Polyethylene particles were counted under polarised optic microscope at each cement /implant and cement /bone interface using an image analyser (Histolab, microvision instruments, Evry, France).

Results: There was no evidence of a fibrous membrane between the bone and the cement. A 10 to 20 mm space was sometimes observed at the metal /cement interface. Polyethylene particles measuring 3 to 10 μm were found at both cement /bone and metal /cement interfaces, including at the distal femur level. Particles were observed in the cement at several sites.

Conclusion: Large-sized polyethylene particles migrate around non-displaced cemented implants, partidularly between bone lines, and can follow the cement poriosity.


X. Cassagnaud C. Maynou H. Mestdagh

Purpose: We analysed outcome of 106 Latarjet-Patte procedures at 7.5 years mean follow-up. Computed tomography of 80 bone blocks provided further details.

Material and methods: One hundred two patients (106 bone blocks), mean age 34 years, were reviewed at a mean 7.5 years follow-up. The sex ratio was 5/1 M/F. The accident had occurred at a mean age of 22 years, by trauma in 87% of the cases, generally involving the dominant limb. Eighty-seven patients practised sports, a high-risk sport in 48% of the cases. Clinical outcome was assessed with the Duplay and Row score, radiographs and a bilateral computed tomography scan in 80 cases.

Results: Postoperative morbidity was 12% and only required revision surgery in 2.8% of the cases. Posterior pain required screw ablation in 6% of the cases. Global outcome was excellent or good in 66% of the patients and 60% of the patients who practised sports were able to resume their activities at the same level. Painless shoulders were achieved for 70% of the patients. There was one post-traumatic recurrence and residual apprehension in 13% of the cases. Grade 3 or 3 osteoarthritis was present in 15% of the cases with a clear narrowing of the joint space in 3.5%. The CT scans were less favourable, showing global or posterior joint space narrowing in 17.5% of the cases. Monocortical screwing led to nonunion in 7%. Advanced osteolysis led to pain with alteration of the functional score.

Discussion: Postoperative complications deteriorated the global result. Overly long malleolar screws led to posterior pain with fatty degeneration of the infraspinatus. Osteoarthritis and “inverted L” subscapularis were the main factors related to loss of rotation. Persistent apprehension was not related to technical error, but to exaggerated anteversion of the humeral cap, basically due to the presence of a notch. Revision scans clearly contributed to the evaluation of the bone block and its position. It allowed a more objective assessment of the osteoarthritis, showing that plain radiographs underestimated both incidence and gravity related to delay after surgery, patient age and the overhanging property of the joint stop.

Conclusion: The Latarjet-Patte procedure has given satisfactory results that can be improved with rigorous technique. Computed tomography provides a more objective analysis of the results.


W.E.B. Johnson B. Caterson S.M. Eisenstein D.L. Hynds D.M. Snow S. Roberts

Although an increased and deeper innervation of painful and degenerate intervertebral discs (IVDs) has been reported, the mechanisms that regulate nerve growth into the IVD are largely unknown. In other tissues, proteoglycans have been found to act as nerve guidance molecules that, generally speaking, inhibit nerve growth. As disc degeneration is characterised by a loss of proteoglycans, we assessed the effects of IVD proteoglycans on nerve growth and guidance.

Using in vitro assays of nerve growth, we found that human disc proteoglycans inhibited nerve attachment, neurite extension and induced sensory growth cone turning in a dose-dependent manner. Digestions with chondroitinase ABC or keratinase abrogated these inhibitory effects. Proteoglycans of the anulus fibrosus were more inhibitory than those from the nucleus pulposus.

Disc proteoglycans inhibit nerve growth and this inhibitory activity may dependent on proteoglycan glycosylation and/or sulfation. A loss of proteoglycans from degenerative discs may therefore predispose the discs to nerve invasion.


Full Access
A. Evans

One million patients with head injuries present to UK hospitals each year. A significant proportion of these patients have ongoing problems and a large number remain disabled at one year. The management of these patients has recently been criticised by a Royal College of Surgeons Working Party Report (published in June 1999). Several recommendations for the care of head injured patients were made.

We have undertaken a study to examine the way these cases are currently dealt with in Welsh hospitals. A large proportion (75%) of these patients in Wales are cared for by non-neurosurgical consultants with the orthopaedic speciality receiving referrals in most hospitals (55%). A questionnaire was sent to these non-neurological consultants looking after head injuries with specific questions on the current care of these patients and for their opinion on the current system.

We have received an excellent response rate (99%) with the results showing that the Working Party recommendation have not been translated into a change in clinical practice. Our study indicates several shortcomings in the current care of these patients in Wales. It also demonstrates that the almost unanimous (98%) view amongst the consultants that responded is that there is a genuine need for change if we are to offer these patients the best care and rehabilitation in the 21st Century.


T.D.M. McClune A.K. Burton G. Waddell

A review of scientific literature on whiplash associated disorders was conducted to inform appropriate messages for an evidenced based patient educational booklet, “The Whiplash Book.” The booklet is being developed for use as both a clinical tool and general health intervention.

A systematic literature search was conducted, using MEDLINE and psychINFO, together with hand searches, reference tracking, and the Internet. The Quebec Task Force report and the British Columbia Whiplash Initiative were taken as the starting point. The new evidence covered the period May 1994 through March 2001 (147 articles). All relevant articles were included, with a particular focus on management and treatment of whiplash associated disorders. The quantity, consistency and relevance of all retrieved articles was evaluated, and rated as *** for consistent findings in multiple reports, ** for consensus based on balance of various findings, or * for limited information (single report).

The main messages from the literature suggest: physical serious injury is rare, reassurance about good prognosis is important, over-medication is detrimental, fastest recovery occurs with early return to normal pre-accident activities, self-exercise/manual therapy and positive attitudes/beliefs are helpful to regain activities levels, collars/rest and negative attitudes/beliefs delay recovery and contribute to chronicity.


R Kulkarni S Roy K Lyons R. Williams C Williams

Introduction: The natural history of bone bruises of the knee and their clinical significance remains unclear with only a few short term studies in the literature.

Aim: This study was designed to try and elucidate the long term outcome of bone bruises of the knee following trauma.

Materials and Methods: 60 patients with bone bruises identified in their knees by MRI scans following trauma were included in the study. All patients were reviewed in a research clinic with a minimum 5 year follow up. A detailed history including mechanism of injury, persistent symptoms and functional status was obtained. Clinical examination to identify intra-articular pathology was then undertaken. All patients had a repeat MRI scan of the knee. The relationship between the injury and the bone bruise, the effect of treatment if any and the long term outcome of such lesions was studied.

Results: 80% of the patients had a twisting injury with our without a hyperextension of valgus/varus force. 58% of our series had ACL injuries and 68% of the bone bruises were in the medial condyle. 72% of the patients did not return to their pre-accident status and had continuing symptoms although the majority of them did not have signs of clinical instability. There was MRI evidence of lasting sequelae of bone bruises in the majority of patients. Detailed results will be discussed.

Conclusions: bone bruises identified on MRI following trauma to the knee are significant lesions with the potential for long term sequelae.


N. Specchia A. Pagnotta F. Greco

The material most widely used in orthopaedics is hydroxyapatite (HA), anyway many differences are still present between synthetic HA and biological HA. The aim of this study was to compare adhesion, proliferation and differentiation of human osteoblast-like cells on hydroxyapatite discs with different porosity and on plastic cultures.

Human osteoblast-like cells were isolated from 4 young patients (mean age 24.5 years old), treated with collagenase and maintained in Dulbecco’s modified essential medium-10% fetal calf serum. Cells were plated on hydroxyapatite discs with 3 different porosities (35%, 35–55% e 55%) and on plastic cultures used as control. The proliferation was determined by the MTT colorimetric method, and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity was measured by a spettrophotometric method. Type I collagen and osteonectin production were demonstrated with fluorescence microscopy and osteoblast adhesion was studied by scanning electron microscopic (SEM) analysis. Results were analysed by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA).

Osteoblast proliferation on HA was three- to six-fold lower then on plastic. At 28 days, 2141 (± 350) cells/well grew on the most porous disks, with highly significant differences from controls. The ALP production was 2–3 fold lower on HA than on plastic. In the most porous disks, the mean ALP activity was of 2.95 (± 0.07) UI/well after 28 days, higher than in the other two groups. The type-I collagen and the osteonectin fluorescence reaction evidenced a cytoplasmic and a matrix labeling on HA at different porosities. SEM analysis showed osteoblasts with a flattened morphology and only few of them were metabolic active.

At 21 and 28 days, proliferation rate and ALP activity on the three HA cultures were significantly different (p< 0.05). A decrease in cell population and increased ALP activity were observed on the most porous material, and high proliferation and poor differentiation rates on the less porous disks.


J.M. TeKoppele J. DeGroot N. Verzijl J.W.J. Bijlsma F.P.J.G. Lafeber

Osteoarthritis (OA) is one of the most prevalent diseases of the elderly, affecting greater than 50% of the population over 60 years of age. Many factors are implicated in the development of OA but currently no mechanism has been described that provides an explanation for age as the major risk factor for OA. The present studies were designed to investigate the hypothesis that age-related accumulation of advanced glycation endproducts (AGEs) provides a molecular mechanism that explains (at least in part) the age-related increase in the incidence of OA.

To gain insight in the diversity of AGEs present in articular cartilage, several AGE measures were determined in a wide age-range of normal human articular cartilage samples: all demonstrated increased AGE levels with increasing age. The level of these AGEs was high in cartilage compared to other tissues such as skin, which is mainly caused by the very low turnover of the cartilage matrix proteins. The t1/2 of collagen in articular cartilage is ~117 years (compared to t1/2 of skin collagen of ~15 years).

Accumulation of AGEs in cartilage affected biomechanical, biochemical and cellular characteristics of the tissue. At the biomechanical level, increased AGE levels were accompanied by increased stiffness and brittleness, indicating that AGE accumulation leads to increased susceptibility of articular cartilage to mechanical damage. On the cellular level, accumulation of AGEs decreased the synthesis and degradation (= turnover) of the cartilage matrix. Such decreased cartilage turnover is likely to result in decreased repair capacity of the tissue.

In combination, the AGE-related increase in tissue brittleness and decrease in extracellular matrix turnover, results in articular cartilage that is more prone to damage. This concept, that AGE accumulation predisposes to the development of OA was tested in the canine anterior cruciate ligament transection (ACLT) model for osteoarthritis. Selectively enhancing AGE levels in articular cartilage of young animals (in the absence of other age-related changes) resulted in more severe OA.

Altogether, AGE accumulation in articular cartilage presents a molecular mechanism by which ageing predisposes to the development of OA, and it provides new possibilities for prevention and/or therapy via the inhibition and/or reversal of cartilage AGE formation.


E.H.W. Erken M.S. Barrow A.A. Aden

In this outcome-based study, we reviewed the results of the modified Woodward procedure performed on 10 patients over the last 15 years in our unit. The indication for surgery was a unilateral Sprengel’s deformity, Cavendish grade II or III, in children aged 3 to 6 years. Follow-up times ranged from 1 to 15 years. The patients were assessed according to patient and relatives’ satisfaction, cosmesis and functional results.

The modified Woodward procedure entailed a midline longitudinal incision over the spinous processes from C1 to T8. The origins of the trapezius and rhomboids were released from the spinous processes, the scapula lowered and derotated, the superomedial portion of the scapula resected and the trapezius and rhomboids reattached two vertebral levels lower. The clavicle was not osteotomised in any patient. A Velpeau sling was used for four weeks, after which physiotherapy was started.

There were no brachial plexus complications. There were two cases of winging of the scapulae. One patient had a cosmetically ugly scar. Our results showed a cosmetic improvement by an average of one grade and a mean functional improvement of 30° of abduction and flexion. Those patients where an omovertebral body was found and resected had the best cosmetic and functional results. All the patients were satisfied with their operations.

We feel that the pessimism regarding surgical results is unwarranted.


M.N. Rasool

Which of several osteotomies described for approximation of the pubic bones in wide congenital diastasis of the pelvis best facilitates closure is controversial. This paper describes the benefits of the horizontal innominate osteotomy in approximation of the pubic bones when there is wide congenital diastasis.

Between 1994 and 2000, 11 children, ranging in age from one week to eight years, were treated by horizontal innominate osteotomies. Six children had exstrophy of the bladder. There were ischiophagus tetrapus twins and cases of duplication of the genitalia and sacral teratoma. The follow-up time ranged from six months to six years.

General surgical procedures were followed by bilateral innominate osteotomies to facilitate approximation of the pubic bones for bladder, genitalia and anterior abdominal wall repair. The ilium was exposed subperiosteally with the patient supine. A Salter-type osteotomy was performed, dividing the innominate bone from the sciatic notch to just above the anterior inferior iliac spine. The distal fragments were rotated medially, the pubic bones approximated in the midline, and the surgical soft tissue procedures completed. Postoperatively, children were maintained in gallows traction for two weeks and immobilised in plaster for four further weeks.

All osteotomies healed well. Abdominal wound infections occurred in two children, resulting in separation of the pubis. One child had repeat osteotomies one year later and healed well. Abdominal wall hernia occurred in one child. The gap between the pubic bones in the remaining patients ranged from 1cm to- 5 cm. Internal rotation of the hip improved in all patients.

Horizontal iliac osteotomies enable complex pelvic malformations to be corrected without turning the patient. The approximation of the pubis relieves the tension for reconstruction of the bladder, urethra, genitalia and anterior abdominal wall. The procedure is quick and permits single stage closure.


F. Villermaux

Ceramic-ceramic (C-C) bearings have 20 years clinical experience with alumina ceramics. This system is re-emerging because of its demonstrated excellent wear performance compared to metal-PE or ceramic-PE. However, alumina ceramic imposes a design limitation to reduce breakage risk: most of the implanted C-C systems present a head larger than 28 mm. Zirconia ceramic is three-times more mechanically resistant and has proven its efficiency in ceramic-PE couple. As a result, a new C-C bearing with zirconia head has been studied. Excellent wear performance of the zirconia-alumina (Z-A) combination system has already widely been proven through multilaboratory experiments on a hip simulator. The mechanical aspect is investigated here to analyse the benefit of a zirconia head in a C-C system. This aspect has been first studied by Finite Element Analysis (FEA) and then validated by experimental testing.

The first series of tests on the 28mm system confirmed the FEA predictions: the breakage loads were correctly estimated for each assembly, showing that FEA is an effective tool to predict breakage load and location. The second series of tests were performed on 22.22mm systems. FEA predicted that the Z-A system should pass the 46 kN contrary to the A-A system. Breakage of the A-A system is expected to be in the head.

In conclusion, Z-A combination offers higher mechanical security for the existing C-C designs but above all, larger design choice than A-A system. Considering that wear performances are equivalent, the Z-A system can be thought as the logical evolution of A-A system.


P.F. Heini

Osteoporosis and osteoporotic fractures represent a growing medical and socioeconomic problem and the spine is the most common site for this kind of fracture. Back pain is the leading symptom with progressive loss of stature and restricted physical activity as a consequence. Vertebroplasty – percutaneous cement reinforcement of osteoporotic vertebrae - represents a new treatment alternative.

During a three year period, 512 vertebrae in 180 patients were reinforced for osteoporotic fractures with low viscosity PMMA. One to eight levels were treated per time, and 8ml (2–18ml) of PMMA per vertebra were injected. The patients’ pain (VAS) was prospectively monitored before surgery, one day, 3 months and one and two years postoperatively. Furthermore, X-rays were analysed 3, 12 and 24 months postoperatively.

One out of 180 patients suffered from an L2 root irritation due to cement leakage that subsided after steroid infiltration. 52 patients with 144 levels treated and a minimal follow up of two years showed a significant (p< 0.02) and lasting pain reduction from 7.7 to 2.8 points at two years. 6 patients were treated a 2nd time for a new fracture. The reinforced vertebrae remained stable without further sintering.

Vertebroplasty is efficient for the treatment of osteoporotic vertebral fractures. The injection technique used is safe, easy and fast. An unsolved problem remains the question about the importance of prophylactic reinforcement of non-fractured vertebrae.


N. Deblock C. Vivas B. Coulet M. Chammer Y. Allieu

Purpose: We evaluated submuscular anterior transposition of the ulnar nerve at the elbow with lengthening of the medial epicondylars as described by Dellon in patients with ulnar nerf deficiency due to compression.

Material and methods: A consecutive series of 30 submuscular tranpositions of the ulnar nerve in 28 patients were performed between 1994 and 1998. Four patients had had a prior procedure (two simple neurolyses, two subcutaneous transpositions). Mean age was 52 years. Preoperative EMB confirmed the diagnosis of ulnar compression at the elbow. All patients has sensorial and/or motor deficits. Postoperative immobilisation was maintained for 15 to 20 days.

Results: The patients were reviewed at a mean follow-up of four years two months. There were no cases of paraesthesia. Improved sensorial function was observed in 71% of the cases (normalisation in 50%) with improvement in the Foment sign and grip in 81.5% (normalisation in 48%). Mean elbow extension was −5°, and flexion was 135°. There was not limitation on wrist amplitudes. The thumb finger force on the operated side was 78% to 94% that measured on the healthy side and was a function of the MacGowan grade. The palm-finger force was 80% to 95% of the healthy side. There has been no recurrence at last follow-up.

Conclusion: Submuscular transposition using the Dellon technique in 30 cases of ulnar nerve compression at the elbow in patients with ulnar deficiency provided satisfactory sensorial and motor recovery. The usefulness of lengthening the medial epicondyls lies in removing the tension on the ulnar nerve and the little effect on elbow and wrist mobility. Submuscular transposition is the technique of choice for repeated neurolysis.


A. Godenèche J.C. Rollier F. Cladière K. Maatougui J.L. Lerat B. Moyen

Purpose: Several techniques have been described for the treatment of unstable fractures of the upper humerus. None appear to be appropriate for subtuberosity fractures, associated or not with a fracture of the trochiter or impacted valgus cephalotuberosity fractures, allowing a stable fixation with anatomic reduction while preserving blood supply to the bone fragments. For the last year, we have studied prospectively a percutaneous minimally invasive technique for this type of fracture. Our preliminary results are analysed here.

Material and methods: We used this technique for 12 patients aged 30 to 87 years with five displaced subtuberosity fractures, six subtuberosity fractures with a trochiter fracture and one impacted valgus cephalotuberosity fracture. Excepting the cephalotuberosity fracture, the joint fragment of the head was reduced by external manipulation under image amplifier guidance. Fixation was achieved with two 25/10 threaded pins inserted percutaneously in retrograde fashio from the anterolateral cortical to the humeral shaft. For eight cases, a third pin was inserted percutaneously from the trochiter to the medial cortical of the humerus. When percutaneous reduction of the trochiter was impossible (three cases) and for the cephalotuberosity fracture, we used a minimal transdeltoid lateral incision to reduce the trochiter and achieve reduction.

Results: Reduction was very satisfactory in all cases. There was one superficial infection that required pin withdrawal at three weeks leading to the only secondary displacement that was minimal and tolerable. We removed the pins after a mean two months. There were no nonunions. Seven patients have a follow-up greater than six months and exhibited a Constant score of 87% (71% to 100%).

Discussion: This techniques has provided very satisfactory results for rapid and stable fixation of the cephalic fragment without loss of blood supply and with a material easy to remove.

Conclusion: These early results are very encouraging and incite us to pursue this technique and analyse long-term results.


R. Volpi E. Dehoux B. Llagonne Ph. Segal

Purpose: The rate of failure knee arthrodesis can be high when performed after an infectious complication of a total knee arthroplasty. We evaluated, in 14 patients at a mean 19 months (3–44 months) follow-up, a technique for knee arthrodesis using a custom-made endomedullary implant.

Material and methods: Mean age of these eight women and six men was 68 years. There were 11 patients with an infected prosthesis, one with post-trauma arthritis, one with aseptic loosening of a hinge prosthesis, and one with pseudarthrodesis. For the 12 patients with ongoing infection, surgery was performed in two times with insertion of a spacer (with antibiotics) between the operations. Mean delay between the two operations was 18 weeks. The surgical procedure was associated with a two-drug antibiotic regimen given for a mean three months after arthrodesis. All arthrodeses were stabilised with a custom-made femora-tibial implant with reaming and fixation with two screws. A graft was always used, composed of the reaming products and powder bone substitute in seven cases, reaming products alone in three, and bone-bank heads in four.

Results: Morbitiy: There was one misalignment of the tibial insertion that was not revised. One skin cover problem was treated with a vastus medius flap. One nonunion evolved favourably after a new graft. There were two recurrent infections: chronic fistulae that were controlled by local care and adapted antibiotic therapy. Weight-bearing was started during the first postoperative week in 13 patients. Bone healing (assessed radiographically with resolution of pain) was achieved at a mean three months (2–6 months) in 13 cases. At last follow-up all patients had achieved a satisfactory level of independence.

Discussion: According to the literature, intramedullary devices are superior for consolidating knee arthrodeses, with a lower rate of complications. Use of custom-made endo-medullary implants facilitates the operation and assures better stabilisation of the arthrodesis, allowing rapid weight-bearing. The infection must be controlled before using these implants. The results in our patients are in agreement with the most recent series reported (Barry, Stephen, Kuoan).

Conclusion: In our hands, this type of implant provides an effective means of attaining bony fusion, including in patients who require arthrodesis for an infected prosthesis.


P. Pollintine S.J. Garbutt J. Tobias D. McNally G. Wakley P. Dolan M.A. Adams

Osteoporotic vertebral fractures are normally attributed to weakening of the vertebral body. However, the compressive strength of the spine also depends on the manner in which the intervertebral disc presses on the vertebral body, and on load-bearing by the neural arch. We present preliminary results from a large-scale investigation into the relative importance of these three influences on vertebral compressive strength.

Lumbar motion segments from elderly cadavers were subjected to 1.5 kN of compressive loading while the distribution of compressive stress was measured along the antero-posterior diameter of the intervertebral disc, using a miniature pressure-transducer. The overall compressive force on the disc, obtained by integrating the stress profile ( 1), was subtracted from the 1.5 kN applied load to give the force resisted by the neural arch. Stress profilometry was performed with each motion segment positioned to simulate the erect standing posture, and a forward stooping posture. Vertebral strength was measured by compressing the motion segments to failure in the forward stooping posture. In life, the spine is usually compressed most severely in this posture.

A univariate analysis of results from the first 9 motion segments (aged 72–92 yrs) showed that vertebral strength increased from 2.0 kN to 4.6 kN as the compressive force resisted by the neural arch in erect postures decreased from 1.1 kN to 0.4 kN (r2 = 0.42, p = 0.05). Updated results from this on-going study will be presented at the meeting.

Preliminary results suggest that habitual load-bearing by the neural arch in erect postures can lead to progressive weakening of the vertebral body, which is effectively “stress-shielded” by the neural arch. This weakening is exposed when the spine is loaded severely in a forward stooped posture, when it has a reduced compressive strength. This mechanism could explain some features of osteoporotic vertebral fractures in old people.


H. Mullett J. King D. Fitzpatrick K. O’Rourke

Introduction: Occipito-cervical fusion has evolved from the used of simple onlay bone grafts to the use of sophisticated modular implants. Initial stiffness prevents micromotion and allows a higher fusion rate.

Methods: A composite occipito-cervical model (OCM) was developed and validated using data obtained from cadaveric specimens. A jig was designed to pot the OCM, which allowed the application of independent moment forces to simulate flexion, extension, lateral flexion and rotation. The following implants were used 1 ) Grob plate with C1/C2 transarticular screw fixation.2) Grob Plate without C1/C2 transarticular screw fixation.3) Cervifix rod system 4) A Ransford loop system 5.) Olerud plate fixation. A three dimensional ultrasonic motion analysis system (Zebris Inc.) was used to record motion at three positions: 1)C0 2) C2 3) C4.A separate OCM was used for each instrumentation system.

Results: The Grob plate with C1/C2 transarticular fixation was found to confer the greatest initial stiffness. The Ransford loop construct was found to confer the least initial stiffness. Plate fixation offered greater stability then rod or loop constructs. We found the three dimensional motion analysis system to be ideal for displacement analysis in complex spinal instrumentation constructs.


M. Pfeiffer A. Wilke W. Goetz F. Chaparro E. Coetzee P. Griss

Anatomisches Institut der Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Germany

Biomedical Research Centre, Dept. of Orthopaedic Surgery, Academic Hospital, Pretoria, South Africa

To date, no animal model for disc degeneration has gained much acceptance, mostly due to the fact that most animals are quadrupeds and thus lack basic biomechanical characteristics of human spines. An adequate model would be of invaluable interest for degeneration related research.

In a standardized series of animal experiments in 18 adult Minipigs and 20 adult Cercopithecus aethiops monkeys all animals obtained nucleotomy in one lumbar FSU from a ret-roperitoneal approach and were sacrificed at last 24 weeks afterwards. The Minipigs were x-rayed at time of sacrifice, the monkeys prior to operation and at termination of the experiment. Vice versa, the Minipigs obtained intradiscal pressure recordings at these occasions. The Minipig spines were formol fixed whereas the monkey spines were harvested after perfusion with PBS, fresh frozen, and obtained CT and MRI scans prior to thawing, fixation and comprehensive histological evaluation.

The lumbar FSU of Minipig and Cercopithecus mainly consists of the same elements as in man. There are certain differences concerning the porcine endplates which ossify as an epiphyseal-like formation with ossification starting in its center, different from the so-called “Randleiste”. Whereas the operative procedure in the Minipigs came in handy, in the Cercopithecus monkey it proved to be demanding, though feasible, due to relatively wide transverse processes and thick psoas muscle structures. The psoas could not be easily detached and needed to be split instead, thus directly exposing the segment nerves. The histological, standard radiological, CT, MRI, and mechanical observations were very similar to those which can be made during the natural aging process of the disc in man.

Both animal models are recommendable for further research: Cercopithecus FSUs are more difficult to expose. Logistic reasons may favour Minipigs in Europe. In case of fusion related experiments the use of primates yet seems inevitable.


A. Nehme J.L. Tricoire Ph. Chiron J. Puget

Purpose: Bone remodelling and osteolysis around total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a highly debated subject in the medical literature. Such bone behaviour is poorly understood around femoral stems used in revision THA. The main problem is to obtain an objective assessment of bone remodelling and bone reconstruction over time, reconstruction techniques being very variable. Conventional radiology is insufficient, but dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) provides a means of following changes in the bone around first intention femoral stems.

Material and methods: We studied bone behaviour around revision femoral stems using the non-cemented “P.P. system”. This type of femoral stem is implanted after trochanter osteotomy to facilitate access and stimulate reconstruction. The series included 31 patients who underwent revision total hip arthroplasty. Follow-up examinations included standard radiographs and DEXA of the operated hips, the contralateral hip and the lumbar spine. Periprosthetic zones defined by Grüen were compared with the same zones in the contra-lateral femur. Mean follow-up was six years.

Results: The standard radiographs did not demonstrate any significant change in periprosthetic cortical thickness. The DEXA demonstrated a significant an average 19.97% reduction in bone density in zones 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6. There was no significant difference in zone 7 and an increase in zone 1 (torchanter osteotomy). These figures are to be compared with the variable thickness observed for first intention pros-theses even shortly after implantation.

Discussion: Our results are the first to our knowledge demonstrating the behaviour of bone around revision femoral stems.

Conclusion: Digastric trochanterotomy appears to be an effective means of stimulating reconstruction of the proximal femur. At equivalent follow-up, the quadrangular section of the revision P.P. stem is more favourable in terms of bone loss compared with first intention stems.


A. Langston R. Kulkarni H. Richards E.M. Downes

We report on four cases in which the diagnosis of compartment syndrome was delayed by the administration of patient controlled opiate analgesia ( PCA ) following intramedullary nailing of tibial shaft fractures. We believe that this poses a diagnostic problem and can lead to lasting sequelae as decompression is delayed. We present the 4 cases and a review of the literature. We recommend that the use of PCA in patients with intramedullary nailing following tibial shaft fractures be discontinued or used in conjunction with continuous intracompartmental pressure monitoring.


K.J. Tayton J. Bradley D. Forrest

The purpose of this study: is to test the hypothesis that there is little or no stress shielding afforded by a carbon composite femoral hip prosthesis when implanted in the human subject, and to investigate the possibility that a hydroxyapatite coating would prevent loosening.

The need for this development: is that loosening remains a problem for young patients who need a long term, reliable fixation of hip replacements, and it appears that if a solution exists to this problem then it probably lies away from the traditional cemented metal varieties.

One of the causes of loosening is stress shielding caused by rigid metal implants and a carbon composite femoral stem has been developed to overcome this. Paradoxically, flexible stems result in increased micro-motion at the prosthetic-bone interface and as a result they tend to loosen more frequently than metal ones. To overcome this, the carbon stem has been coated on its proximal third with hydroxyapatite, in order to get a secure fixation to the upper femur, but left bare distally to minimise weight transfer within the lower shaft.

The Study: 50 patients have entered the trial to date, and the detailed results of the first 35, which have been followed up for an average of 4 years will be presented. Stress shielding by the prosthesis was assessed, clinically, radiologically, and by dexa-scanning (usinga Hologic scanner with metal exclusion software). Two dexa-scan studies were carried out on each patient, at 1 and 2 years post operatively, and the bone mineral density of the implanted bone was compared with that of the normal contralateral side, using the Gruen zones as the basis of comparison. These results were compared with published figures for metal stems, and also with a small series of our own metal stems.

Results: 13 males and 22 females entered the trial, with an average age of 61.

Bone density around the carbon composite hip was found to increase by an average of 2% between the measurements carried out at 1 and 2 years post-op.

In the contralateral hip, bone density remained unchanged over the period.

Bone density around comparable metal stems reduced by an average of 3% in our cases, but losses over 20% are quoted by others especially for zones 1& 7.

Follow up is very short for responsible prognosis to be offered regarding loosening, but to date the function of the hips remains good.

Conclusion: it appears that this prosthesis is fulfilling the predictions made for it, and although there is a spread of responses to it, the average patient is showing a steady increase in periprosthetic bone mineral density and is

Clinically asymptomatic. Progress to a wider trial can now be recommended.


P. Valenti P. Sauzières D. Bouttens C. Nerot

Purpose: Revision of a humeral prosthesis or a total shoulder arthroplasty is a difficult therapeutic challenge. The purpose of this work was to report our experience in a retrospective series of 19 inverted Grammont prostheses implanted during revision procedures.

Material and methods: The series included 11 women and eight men, mean age 66.8 years (45–84). Nine patients had already undergone at least two procedures before the revision of their prosthesis. There were 19 revisions of humeral prostheses and four revision total shoulder arthroplasties. Causes leading to revision of the humeral prostheses were: infection one patient, secondary cuff tears six patients, anterosuperior dislocation of the prosthesis five patients, and stiff and painful shoulders three patients. For the total shoulder arthroplasties, three required revision for a loosened glenoid implant and two for secondary cuff tears with ascension of the humeral head. The same access was used as for the first procedure in most of the cases (deltopectoral or anterolateral approach). The rotator cuff was torn and retracted, or fibrous and non-functional. Ablation of the humeral implant and the cement led to fracture (error or infection) in six cases requiring cerclage for fixation. A complementary bone graft was needed in three cases at the glenoid level in three and at the humeral level in three others.

Results: The Constant score at mean follow-up of 36.4 months (12–60) was 55.07 (44–87) a clear improvement over the initial 13.87 (6–39) before revision. The score was less favourable for patients with several operations before revision. Mean anterior elevation was 29.33° (20–100) pre-operatievely and reached 118.67° (90–160) postoperatively. The pain score was 3/15 preoperatively and13.66/15 postoperatively.

Discussion: Other alternatives may be indicated in salvage situations with an unreparable cuff and a pseudo-paralytic shoulder: rectus or deltoid flaps, reconstruction of the acro-miocoracoid arch and glenohumeral arthrodesis.

Conclusion: The inverted Grammont prosthesis appears to be a useful salvage technique, particularly when the acro-miocoracoid arch is destroyed and the cuff is unreparable. The best chances of success are observed for revision of hemiarthroplasties of a pseudo-paralytic shoulder with complete passive mobility and an anterosuperior dislocation of the humeral prosthesis head.


A.R. Meir S. Kobyashi J.C.T. Fairbank J.P.G. Urban

Glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) govern the osmotic environment of cartilaginous tissues and hence determine their ability to resist the large compressive forces encountered during normal activity. In degeneration GAGs are lost and there is now much interest in biological repair processes where cells from cartilaginous tissues synthesise replacement GAGs and other matrix components in situ. In addition, cells can be grown in tissue engineered constructs. Unfortunately, GAG synthesis is slow.

The aim of this study was to determine whether GAG accumulation could be hastened by increasing cell density in a construct using articular cartilage and intervertebral disc cells cultured in alginate beads.

Bovine chondrocytes and intervertebral disc cells were placed in alginate bead suspension at varying cell densities. GAG synthesis rates, total GAG accumulation and lactate production rates were determined by standard methods. The cell viability profile across intact beads was determined using fluorescent probes.

Increasing cell density causes a reduction in lactate production and sulphate incorporation per million live cells. At greater than 20 million cells per ml, cell death is increased compared with lower densities. GAG produced per bead is not increased in proportion to increasing cell density.

These results show that there is a limit to the rate at which matrix per volume of tissue can be produced and accumulated. At high cell densities cellular activity is limited by toxicity arising from low pH and hypoxia.


Everett Smith David Jones Eckhardt Bröckmann

One of the mechanisms which controls bone growth, repair remodeling and absorption is mechanical loading. There exists no long-term in vitro model to study bone cells together with their matrix, nor a model that can apply quantitative mechanical forces of physiological amplitudes and frequencies. The analysis of the mechanical properties of bone (Young’s modulus and visco-elastic moduli) on small pieces of bone is also difficult with present devices. We have built a device that can maintain full viability and physiological response of bone for a period of several weeks and integrates all three functions.

10mm diameter bone cores 5 mm thick were obtained from the trabecular bone of the distal ulna of a 24 months old cow by precision cutting with diamond saws and keyhole cutters (our pattern) in sterile 7–10°C phosphate buffered saline (PBS) and cultured in a variation of DMEM containing fructose HI GEM.

Results: The results of these studies have shown that perfusion of trabecular bone can maintain all cells and maintain bone structure for at least 72 days. In conventional methods for bone organ cultures, small bones, such as rat calvaria, quickly start to resorb bone and degenerate. In our perfusion system we see no evidence of change.. Initial experiments have indicated that there are 2 visco-elastic moduli of bone with different time constants, that the elastic modulus of trabecular bone varies is site dependant and that loading to 0.4% compression raises prostaglandin E2 and insulin-like growth factor 1 within a few hours. Mechanical stiffness of bone is increased by 35% when loaded for 20 days at 4,000μ, and decreases by 25% when not loaded. PTH at 10-10M increases stiffness over the load effect and 10-6M PTH decreases stiffness even in the presence of loading. Active osteoclasts are seen during the whole culture period indicating that the stem cells are present and functional.

We gratefully acknowledge support by the German Arthrose Foundation (DAH) and the AO in Davos, CH.


J. N. Argenson J.M. Aubaniac E. Northcut R. Komistek D. Dennis

Purpose: Cinematic studies after total knee arthroplasty without an anterior cruciate ligament demonstrate abnormal behaviour compared with the normal knee. The purpose of this cinematic analysis was to examine the knee behaviour after implantation of single-compartment prostheses with an intact anterior cruciate ligament.

Material and methods: The femorotibial contact points were analysed by videofluoroscopy in 20 patients executing a complete weight-bearing extension to flexion movement. These patients had medial (n=16) or lateral (n=4) single-compartment implants. The clinical result in all patients was considered to be very good with a mean HSS score of 97.9 points at a mean 56 months postoperatively. The femorotibial contact points were determined using an automatic computerised adaptation-modelling system. An anterior contact on the medial tibial line in the sagittal plane was positive and a posterior contact was negative. The rotation axis in the craniopodal direction was measured between the anteroposterior longitudinal axis of the femoral component and the fixed axis of the tibial component.

Results: The mean position of the contact point for medial single-compartment prostheses was −90.8 mm in complete extension, −1.4 mm at 30° flexion, −2.4 mm at 60°, and −1.7 mm at 90°. Mean position of the contact point for lateral single-compartment prostheses was −4.0 mm at complete extension, −7.9 mm at 30° flexion, −5.7 mm at 60° and −5/7 mm at 90°. Seven patients with a medial implant and two patients with a lateral implant exhibited paradoxical anterior translation of the femur during flexion. On the average, patients with a medial implant had normal 3.3° axial rotation at 90°; axial rotation was 11.2° for patients with a lateral implant.

Discussion and conclusion: Cinematic analysis of the normal knee has demonstrated anterior femorotibial contact in extension and 14.2 mm posterior rolling of the femoral component during flexion. After total knee arthroplasty without preservation of the anterior cruciate ligament, the rolling movement is limited or absent and a paradoxical anterior translation can be observed. In the present study, the first reported on single-compartment implants, demonstrates that movement is similar to that in the normal knee but with major interindividual variability. A posterior contact at extension and a paradoxical anterior translation can also be observed. This suggests progressive development of anterior cruciate ligament laxity over time, which can at least in part explain the premature polyethylene wear observed after implantation of single-compartment knee implants.


T. Hayward P. Dolan

During forward bending activities, the collagenous tissues of the spine are protected from injury by reflex contractions of the back muscles which prevent excessive spinal flexion. Animal experiments have shown that this reflex response is diminished when spinal ligaments are subjected to creep ( 1). This study examined the effects of creep on the latency and amplitude of reflex activation of the back muscles in living people.

Ten healthy volunteers (4M/6F) consented to participate in the study. Subjects underwent two flexion treatments: i) prolonged sitting in a low chair for 2 hours, ii) 100 toe-touching exercises, each on a separate day. Before and after each treatment, subjects performed a standardised forward bending task during which simultaneous measurements were made of lumbar flexion, using the 3-Space Fastrak, and surface EMG activity of the erector spinae muscles at T10 and L3 ( 2). The latency of the reflex response was measured by recording the amount of lumbar flexion that occurred prior to the onset of muscle activation at each site. The amplitude of the reflex was measured by determining the peak EMG activity during the bending task. Each subject’s range of lumbar flexion was also measured independently before and after each treatment to determine the extent of any creep.

Both treatments caused creep, as indicated by a significant increase in the range of lumbar flexion. The treatments also brought about a significant delay in the reflex activation of the back muscles in the standardised bending task: after prolonged sitting, lumbar flexion during the bending task increased by 9.2 ± 7.4° and 5.7 ± 4.6° before the onset of EMG activity at T10 and L3 respectively; following the toe-touches, the equivalent increases in lumbar flexion were 5.4 ± 3.9° and 3.1 ± 4.4°. The amplitude of the reflex response was unchanged following prolonged sitting, but after the toe-touches, a 50% increase in peak EMG activity was observed at L3.

Creep in spinal tissues as a result of prolonged or repetitive flexion was associated with delayed reflex activation of the back muscles. There was no associated reduction in the amplitude of the reflex. The increase in peak EMG activity following the toe touches may reflect increased activation as a result of muscle fatigue. These results suggest that creep in spinal tissues may allow increased lumbar flexion and hence increased bending stresses to be applied to the intervertebral disc.


J-Y. Jenny P. Kehr

Purpose: The quality of implantation of single-compartment knee prostheses is a recognised prognostic factor. Acceptable reproducibility can be achieved with traditional instrumentations, although the rate of error can be significant. Computer-assisted implantation might improve results. Most of the currently proposed techniques require supplementary preoperative imaging or implantation of metallic material for guidance. The Orthopilot® system is a purely peroperative system and could thus provide better cost-effectiveness.

Material and methods: We implanted 30 single-compartment knee prostheses using the Orthopilot® computerised system (Aesculap, Chaumont, Group A) and compared the radiographic quality of the implant on telemetric AP and lateral views with those from a control group of 30 single-compartment prostheses implanted with a traditional instrumentation with a femoral centromedullary aiming device (group B). All patients underwent surgery for primary degeneration and were operated on by the same surgeon using the same implant (Search®, Aesculap, Chaumont). The control group was selected among a consecutive series of 250 implants to match the study group for age, gender, importance of the degeneration and frontal femorotibial mechanical angle.

Results: The mechanical femorotibial angle was within desired limits (177±3°) in 26 patients in group A and in 20 patients in group B. Frontal orientation of the femoral component was within desired limits (90±2°) in 27 patients in group A and in 19 in group B (p< 0.05). Frontal orientation of the tibial piece was within desired limits (90±2°) in 27 patients in group A and in 19 patients in group B (p < 0.02). The original level of the joint line was reconstructed with a 2 mm margin in 30 patients in group A and in 24 patients in group B (p < 0.05). Eighteen patients in group A and four patients in group B had optimal implantation for all criteria studied (p < 0.001). There were no system-related complications.

Discussion, conclusion: Computer-assisted implantation is more reliable and more reproducible than traditional instrumentation for the implantation of a single-compartment knee prosthesis. Follow-up results with these prostheses may be better. Systematic preoperative imaging, or preoperative implantation of metallic guide pins is not necessary with this system. The system appears to offer a better cost-effectiveness.


K. Crossman A. Al-Omar J.A. Oldham R.G. Cooper

Paraspinal muscle dysfunction is associated with chronic low back pain (CLBP) in prospective studies, some authors suggesting a primary role for muscle in CLBP development. To investigate this possibility, we compared paraspinal muscle electromyographic (EMG) fatigue characteristics with fibre-type composition in ambulant, male CLBP patients and male controls of similar age.

Thirty-five patients with Chronic Pain Grades of III (a high level of residual function, despite pain, negated the effects of disuse atrophy), and 32 controls were studied. Paraspinal surface EMG signals were recorded from the T10/11 and L4/5 regions bilaterally during standard isometric endurance tests. The rate of fatigue-induced median frequency (MF) decline was calculated from the power spectrum. Percutaneous paraspinal muscle biopsies permitted the determination of muscle fibre-type characteristics.

MF decline, mean fibre size and relative area occupied by fibre types did not differ significantly between groups.

The paraspinal muscles of ambulant CLBP patients demonstrate no excessive fatigability, when assessed by EMG, nor a relative paucity in the area occupied by either fibre type. Patients developing CLBP do not demonstrate an adverse paraspinal muscle fibre-type composition.


D. Blaha

For many years, it has been taught that the human knee is a ‘hinge’ joint and that the motion of the knee is controlled by a ‘four-bar link’. This classic view of the motions of the knee suggests that there is a prescribed path for the knee as it proceeds from extension to flexion and flexion to extension. This prescribed motion includes ‘rollback’, a term used for the progressive posterior displacement of the femur on the tibia as the knee moves from extension to flexion,

Most of the total knee prostheses available today have been designed to permit the movements that are required by this model of knee motion. The design features necessary to permit this motion are a lack of constraint between the tibial and femoral components, and a ‘J’ curve of the posterior part of the femoral component such that the radius of curvature is smaller on the posterior portion of the component than on the distal part.

Studies of the anatomy of the knee date back to the 1800s, before radiological studies were possible. Radiological evidence does not support the four-bar link and rollback theories or indicate that a ‘J’ curve is necessary. Rather, radiographs suggest that the knee is more of a ball-in-socket joint on the medial side with little or no rollback in normal function. Three-dimensional studies of the moving human knee both in vitro and in vivo also demonstrated that the knee joint moves as a ball-in-socket joint on the medial side, and that the lateral side displaces posteriorly or anteriorly as necessary to accommodate the rotational position of the tibia relative to the femur.

These kinematic findings have led to the design of a pros-thesis that mimics the normal knee. The femoral prosthesis has a single radius of curvature to each condyle both in the sagittal and coronal planes. The mating tibial component has an exactly conforming geometry on the medial side leading to ball-in-socket type of kinematics. The lateral side of the tibial component allows anterior or posterior displacement of the femur, mining the normal changes that take place with internal and external rotation.

Initial clinical results total knee arthroplasty procedures performed with this prosthesis are just passing the three-year follow-up interval. There have been no reports of catastrophic problems, and surgeons have been pleased with the stability, the rapidity with which function is regained, and the excellent range of motion following arthroplasty. Patients who have a more traditional total knee arthroplasty in one knee and the medial pivot prosthesis in the other prefer the medial pivot because of the feeling of stability.


G.G.A. Cappaert C.J. Grobbelaar

At the same time as the LCS knee, the ARD knee was developed. We aimed to assess whether over a 10 to 15-year period the SS 86 rotational platform knee system stood the test of time.

In a retrospective study, we followed up 250 patient, assessing patient satisfaction, range of motion and radiological appearance. Patient satisfaction was high and range of motion and radiological appearances very good.


A. Deburge L. Rillardon P. Guigui

Purpose of the study: Discal herniation is an exceptional cause of lumbar canal stenosis. When surgery for this disorder was first performed in the sixties, discectomy was not exceptional because discal protrusions were frequent. It was rather rapidly observed however that these protrusions were actually osteoarthitic discal rims that do not cause root compression. Discectomy was thus almost completely abandoned for lumbar stenosis surgery. Consequently, the development of true discal herniation after surgery for lumbar canal stenosis is highly exceptional. To our knowledge, this situation has not been reported in the literature. Among several hundred procedures for decompression of the lumbar canal practised in our unit over the last thirty years, we have observed seven cases.

Material and methods: The patients were aged 43 to 74 years at the time of reoperation (mean 61 years). The stenosis was at the L4-L5 level in all patients and extended to L3-L4 in three and to L5-S1 in two and was bilateral in one patient. The L4-L5 disk had been removed at the prior surgery in three patients. Delay to recurrent pain was variable, from six months to eleven years. The sciatic pain was associated with motor disorders in one patient. Discal herniation was observed at the L4-L5 level in all patients and was often voluminous, excluded in three patients. Reossification was present in one patient but did not have a compressive effect. Treatment after recurrence was chemonucleolysis in three patients, with two successes and one failure. Surgical treatment by discal excision was used in four cases associated with instrumented fusion in one patient.

Results: The patients were reviewed at one to ten years after the second operation. Nucleolysis was successful in two and a failure in one. The patient with failure of nucleolysis was treated by a new decompression with fusion and achieved an excellent result at ten years. Pain relief was achieved after surgery in all patients though only partial in one.

Discussion and conclusion: Discal herniation is rare in elderly subjects and can cause problems late after surgical decompression of lumbar canal stenosis. It is important to search for discal herniation which is not always easy to confirm radiologically due to postoperative remodeling. Chemonucleolysis is an effective and economical solution when the disk has not been resected during the first procedure. When an operation is necessary, spinal fusion is not useful except in case of associated instability.


F. Pfeffer S. Trétou D. Bensoussan R. Traversari L. Galois D. Mainard J.P. Delagoutte

Purpose: Local factors such as poor vascular supply, open fracture, or infection can affect the potential for bone formation after fracture, arthrodesis or distraction. The fundamental principal for the treatment of late healing or nonunion is to supplement the local supply of the elements necessary for bone maturation. Centrifuged bone marrow is known to have a osteogenic effect in the treatment of femoral head necrosis or as a complement to conventional grafts. We examined the effect of bone marrow grafts used with conventional grafts.

Material and methods: This retrospective analysis included 14 cases where centrifuged bone marrow graft was used as complementary treatment for post-traumatic nonunion (10 cases), distraction callus (three cases) or late healing after arthrodesis (one case). Bone marrow (300 ml) was harvested from the posterior iliac crest then centrifuged to isolate the maximum number of nucleated cells and stem cells. The centrifugate (60–80 ml) was injected into the fracture site with a trocar during the same operative time. Cell concentrations (total nucleated cells, stem cells (CFU-GM), fibroblastic colonies) were noted. Patients were followed at regular visits. Bone healing was considered to be acquired when weight-bearing was possible without fixation or immobilisation.

Results: Definitive bone healing was achieved rapidly in two cases. Two patients required a conventional graft of a nonunion to achieve consolidation. For six patients, consolidation could not be achieved (three nonunions and three distraction calluses). Final outcome was good or very good in 57% of the cases. Mean delay to bone healing was 6.5 months. The infectious context had no effect on the method. The mean number of nucleated cells injected was 3.9•109 cells in successful cases and 2.8•109 cells in unsuccessful cases. These concentrations affected outcome.

Discussion: This technique for stimulating bone maturation by supplying bone generating cells is indicated for late healing or recent nonunion. It is less effective for distraction calluses or for very old nonunions. Morbidity and iatrogenic effects are minimal. A rigorous harvesting method is required since the result is highly dependent on the cell concentrations and the number of injected cells. Bone marrow injections after centrifugation should be greater than 85 ml and have a cell concentration around 45•106 cells/ml. The method is less successful for old injuries and in patients with arteritis.

Conclusion: Bone marrow grafts are indicated for the treatment of late healing or recent nonunion. Morbidity is low but a rigorous harvesting method is required. The method should be implemented shortly after the fracture without waiting for potential signs of nonunion.


G. Lorton F. Laude J.Y Leznnec G. Saillant

Purpose: External fixators are widely used for limb lengthening procedures. More recently the femoral nail has been introduced combining the advantages of progressive lengthening obtained with external fixation and of the percutaneous approach of internal fixation. This retrospective analysis of 14 patients treated with the progressive femur lengthening nail (ECMP) Albizzia®, was conducted to analyse results in terms of limb length correction, bone healing and complications.

Material and methods: The fourteen patients, nine men and five women, mean age 27.3 years had leg length discrepancies = 20 cm. All were treated with the ECMAP nail (Albizzia®)in January or February 2000. There were nine right legs and five left legs. The patients had discrepancy subsequent to trauma (64.3%), hip dysplasia (21.4%) or neurological (7.15%) or infantile (7.15%) conditions. Mean leg length discrepancy was 41.5mm (20–150 mm); 57.1% of the patients wore a raised heal and 14.2% used crutches. The nail was inserted with reaming and locked on both ends. The corticotomy was made with an endomedullary saw in a closed procedure for 78.5% of the patients and with an open procedure for 21.5%. Angular correction was associated in 32.7% of the cases. Outcome was analysed on the basis of operative time, blood loss, rhythm and amount of limb lengthening, delay to healing and complications.

Results: Mean follow-up was 25 months. Mean operative time was 2 hr 28 min. The lengthening procedure began 4.1 days after nailing with, on the average, 20 ratchet clicks per day. Mean duration of the lengthening procedure was 32.5 days. Mean lengthening was 32.15 mm, i.e. 0.99 mm/day. Ten patients had a general anaesthesia at least twice to manipulate the nail ratchet. There were five cases with mechanical complications and one case of regressive nerve injury. There were no infections, no cases of joint stiffness and no axis defects. Bone healing was achieved a mean 2.7 days. There was one nonunion. Mean haemoglobin loss was four points, three patients required transfusion. Limb length was equivalent in six patients, with < 5 mm discrepancy in three, 6–10 mm discrepancy in one, 11 mm discrepancy in two and 64 mm discrepancy in one. One lengthening procedure had to be interrupted before term.

Discussion: ECMAP is unable to avoid the complications inherent in lengthening procedures but does offer undeniable advantages over external fixation. The risk of infection is very low and skin scars are minimal. Patient comfort is greatly improved (elimination of the cumbersome external fixator). Delay to bone healing is satisfactory and axial rotation defects can easily be corrected. This technique appears to be an excellent means for lengthening the femur in trauma patients.


A.A. van Zyl R. Denkema D. van der Jagt

We present five case studies of a new technique for the treatment of distal femur fractures after total knee arthroplasty. This type of fracture is rare, but when it occurs can present a dilemma as to the correct treatment. If the prosthesis is loose, the logical treatment is revision surgery with the use of long stem stabilisation. If the prostheses are firmly fixed, the best method of treatment is difficult to determine. Intramedullary fixation is a well-known modality, but proper fixation distal to the fracture can be problematic in very distal fractures.

We performed intramedullary fixation of these fractures, using standard retrograde condylar locking nails inserted through the notch of the femoral prostheses. The problem of distal fixation was solved by fixating the nail to the femoral prostheses with a plate that fitted into the notch of the pros-theses and was securely fixed to the nail with a custom-made screw. This not only gave alignment stability but also aided in compression of the fracture. A locking screw distal to the fracture line was inserted in some patients to aid fixation. but could not be placed in others owing to the distal position of the fracture. Autograft was used in most cases to aid fracture healing. Postoperatively the leg was immobilised in a cast for six weeks.

This method of fixation of the nail to the prostheses has not been described in the literature to date. We believe that this technique offers a new modality in treating these complex fractures, providing adequate fixation, alignment and compression stability.


C. Boeri J-Y. Jenny P. Kehr

Purpose: The biepicondylar axis of the femur is considered by many authors as a reliable reference axis for flexion-extension of the knee and to establish desirable orientation of the femoral component of a total knee arthroplasty. We studied the reproducibility of axis measurments made using an automatic digital acquisition system (OrthoPilot®, Aesculap, Chaumont, France). The system localises anatomic points in space from information obtained with a palpation probe carrying an infrared diode.

Material and methods: A consecutive series of 20 total knee arthroplasties (Search®, Aesculap, Chaumont, France) implanted by two senior surgeons on the same surgical team were studied. The mechanical axis of the femur was calculated prior to the study using kinematic acquisition of the position of the centres of rotation of the hip and the knee. The frontal reference plane was then defined from the most posterior point on the femoral condyles palpated with the probe as the plane containing the mechanical axis of the femur and parallel to the posterior bicondylar line. The apex of the two femoral epicondyles was obtained by direct palpation with the probe. A second plane passing through the apex of the epicondyles and parallel to the mechanical axis of the femur was thus defined. Three acquisitions were made for the same patient by each of the two surgeons without changing the posterior bicondylar reference plane. The angle between the frontal plane of reference and the biepicondylar plane was calculated directly by the software for each acquisition. The variability of the three measurements taken by each operator and between the two operators was studied with the Wilcoxon test for paired series and with Spearman’s coefficient of correlation.

Results: Mean intraobserver variability for the orientation of the biepicondylar axis was 4° for the two operators, with a maximum of 11° for the first operator and 9° for the second, the directions being random. The mean interobserver variability for this orientation was 4° with a maximum of 14°, again at random. All differences were statistically significant.

Discussion, conclusion: Measurements of the biepicondylar axis exhibit high intra- and interobserver variability, probably due to the anatomic conditions; the apex of the epicondyles is a blunt surface difficult to identify with precision. Use of this axis to determine the rotation of the femoral component of a total knee arthroplasty is thus an element of wide variability with measurement inaccuracy of a mean ± 5° but with a maximum that can reach 10°. The question remains to determine whether this uncertainty is tolerable or whether more precision is required.


A.D. Barrow P.I. Webster S.L. Biddulph

Treating 10 consecutive patients requiring wrist arthrodesis, we assessed the effectiveness of a titanium plate specifically designed by Hill Hastings for wrist arthrodesis. It appeared to call for little or no postoperative casting and to promise an early return to functionality.

We secured the plate to the third metacarpal and the radius and used autologous bone graft taken from their iliac crest. Length of time immobilisation, time to union, overall functional results and patient satisfaction were recorded.

In all 10 patients clinical and radiological union occurred in 8 to 12 weeks. Four patients had no postoperative immobilisation and six had a Litecast. Correctly applied, the pre-contured plate produced a consistently satisfactory position of fusion. One patient had a small area of wound skin necrosis in a pre-existing transverse scar over the dorsum of the wrist, but this healed.

The carpometacarpal joint is included in this fusion, which requires a longer longitudinal incision than some other wrist fusion techniques. However, patient satisfaction was high.


M.A. de Beer

In shoulder arthroplasty the glenoid component remains a problem. Hemi-arthroplasty requires less theatre time and gives rise to fewer complications. The question is whether the results of hemi-arthroplasty are inferior to those of total shoulder arthroplasty.

We assessed 189 patients who since July 1994 had undergone hemi-arthroplasty or total shoulder arthroplasty, excluding patients who suffered fractures, malunion or nonunion. In 77 patients (41%) the glenoid was replaced. The mean age of patients was 62 years. All humeral and glenoid components were cemented. Preoperative and postoperative assessments included pain (visual analogue scale), muscle strength, range of motion, functional activities and Constant shoulder scores.

At this early stage, total shoulder arthroplasty appears to give slightly better functional results than hemi-arthroplasty. However, there were five (6.5%) complications associated with the glenoid components, including glenoid component fracture, loosening and migration. Hemi-arthroplasty eliminates concerns about glenoid wear and glenoid complications, and we believe total shoulder arthroplasty should be reserved for specific problems.


A.D. Barrow B.H. Barrow P.I. Webster

Acromioclavicular (AC) joint dislocations and fractures of the distal clavicle present challenging problems for the treating surgeon. We treated eight patients using a hook-shaped plate fixed to the distal clavicle and ‘hooked’ under the posterior acromion.

In five patients the injury was a fractured distal clavicle and in three an AC joint dislocation. We analysed the time taken to achieve a functional capacity. The eventual functional result was indexed from the time of fracture union or complete stabilisation of the dislocations.

All five fractures went on to anatomical union. The three dislocations were all stabilised with no instability or sub-luxation. Two patients complained of impingement symptoms and decreased overhead functional capacity. After the implant was removed, both patients regained a full range of pain-free movement.

This is a small study with limited follow-up. However, the results suggest that this new implant provides an acceptable alternative in the management of distal clavicle fractures and AC joint dislocations. The complication of impingement can be treated by removal of the implant after union or stabilisation has been achieved.


A.D. Barrow M.J. Radziejowski

Radial and/or ulnar fractures caused by gunshots are common in our society. These fractures are often very comminuted, and surgical exposure of the fracture site may deprive previously viable bone fragments of a blood supply. We looked at a minimally invasive method of plating these fractures.

Two surgeons performed a percutaneous plating procedure on six consecutive patients with a diaphyseal gunshot of the radius and/or ulna. This type of fixation acts as an internal form of ‘external fixator’.

When this paper was prepared, five of the six patients had gone on to complete clinical and radiological union and the sixth was still under follow-up. The mean time to full union was 12 weeks. Mean pronation was 60° (20° to 80°) and mean supination 50° (10° to 70°). In all patients, full elbow and wrist movement was preserved. To date we have had no complications of nerve injury, sepsis or radioulnar synostosis.

This is a very limited series of patients, but it seems this method of treating gunshot injuries of forearm bones produces good results. The long-term effect on wrist function is difficult to predict.


Ph. Massin E. Astouin F. lavast

Purpose: The combined effects of metaphyseal filling and implant surface (smooth or rough) on stress applied to the cement was studied using finite element analysis.

Material and methods: The cement-metal interface was modelised in stable then unstable situations at different degrees of metaphyseal filling. For each case, stress applied to the cement sheath and femoral corticals were tested as were rotation displacements of certain nodes chosen at critical sites in the proximal part of the stem and the bone. A first model produced a 3D representation of the femur exposed to physiological weight-bearing. The second mode represented a femoral metaphysis with the cement sheath exposed to rotation forces, critical for femoral prosthesis stability.

Results: With implants with a rough surface (cement adherence), bone stress increased with decreasing implant size and was basically concentrated in the distal part of the bone (diaphysis). On the contrary, for polished surface implants, bone stress increased with the size of the implant and was basically concentrated in the proximal part of the bone (metaphysis). Stress in the cement sheath was lower for rough surface implants. With the smooth implant, they were greatest in the metaphyseal part of the cement sheath, especially with prosthetic configurations we the most filling. When a rotation force was applied to the implant, shear forces in the cement were greater with a rough than a smooth surface implant. Compression forces in the proximal and anterior part of the cement sheath increased with the size of the implant. Proximal discontinuity of the cement sheath did not produce deleterious mechanical effects. The smooth surface implants produced higher compression forces than rough surface implants in the proximal part of the cement sheath. In addition, with smooth surface implants, traction stress was zero in the proximal part of the cement sheath.

Discussion: Use of smooth surface implants with optimal metaphyseal filling increases the rotational stability and allows a better fixation of the femoral stem in total hip arthroplasty, with a more physiological transmission of the stress forces to the proximal part of the bone. It produces greater compression force on the cement but less traction stress.


P.F.R.G. de Muelenaere

In 2000 the Ulrich ALIF cage for lumbar surgery was introduced. We evaluated the effectiveness and safety of this new implant device by determining fusion rate, cost and complications.

Twenty patients undergoing anterior spinal surgery for failed posterior fusions were offered the option of receiving the implant device and entered into this prospective study. In all patients, the approach was either anterior retroperitoneal or left lateral retroperitoneal. The procedures were done under C-arm control. The mean operating time was 80 minutes. Blood loss was less than 400 ml. Mobilised the day after surgery, all patients used a soft lumbosacral brace for at least six weeks. Follow-up radiographs were taken on the third postoperative day and at six and 12 weeks.

The large bone graft surface of the cage allows excellent bone grafting and radiological visualisation. We encountered no complications related to the cage. One case of anterior subluxation of 1 cm occurred when a patient stumbled on the third day after surgery.


J.E. Viljoen

Using a biodegradable implant (Suretac), the author performed arthroscopic shoulder surgery for superior labral detachments, anterior to posterior (SLAP) on 40 patients from January 1994 to January 1999. This study evaluated the short and long-term outcome.

The mean age of the patients, 29 of whom participated in competitive overhead sporting activities, was 32 years. There were 34 patients with SLAP 2 lesions, three with SLAP 3 lesions and three with SLAP 4 lesions. The follow-up period ranged from 4 to 60 months. All patients were evaluated at four months and then again at 24 to 60 months, using the modified UCLA scoring system.

Results were good to excellent four months postoperatively in 85%. Reviewed at two years and longer, 95% of patients had good to excellent results, with 83% of sportsmen resuming their previous overhead sporting activities.


J-L. Besse M. Maestro E. Berthonnaud J. Dimnet J.L. Lerat B. Moyen

Purpose: Plantar pressure sores can lead to metatarsalgia depending on the patient’s activity level and age and on the status of the muscle-tendon system and the morphology of the forefoot. In 1995, Tanaka and Maestro attempted to quantify the relative lengths of the metatarsals. The purpose of this work was to check the results reported by Maestro and to try to define a morphotype classification of the metatarsals.

Material and methods: We analysed two series of normal feet: no apparent deformation, no callosity, no pain, no history of trauma or surgery. Fifty “normal” feet were selected among the personnel of the orthopaedics unit. Mean age of the 25 subjects was 30.3 ± 9.6 years, 44% were women. This series was compared with 34 “normal” feet reported by Maestro (age 55.2 ± 17.2 years, 62% women) used to define criteria for geometric progression (1995). A standing dorso-plantar radiograph was obtained with the same protocol for all patients. All radiographs were digitalized with a Vidar VXR-12 plus, then analysed by two observers with the semi-automatic FootLog measurements. The following measurements were recorded: SM4-M4 (distance between the line passing through the centre of the lateral sesmoid and perpendicular to the foot axis and the centre of the M4 head), M1 = d1 – d2 (length of the M1/SM4 head – length of the M2/SM4 head), Maestro criteria 1 = d2 – d3, Maestro 2 = d3 – d4, and Maestro 3 = d4 – d5.

Results: An SM4 line passing through the mid third of the M4 head (+2mm proximally / centre M4 head / −4 mm distally) as normal. The notion of row 2 geometric progression was conserved by tolerating 20% variation (Maestro 1 ± 1 mm, Maestro 2 ± 1mm, Maestro 3 ± 2 mm). Feet were classed in four metatarsal morphology types with subgroups: normal feet (line SM4 passing through the mid third of the M4 head – geometric progression) – long M23 (SM4 line centred on the mid third of M4 – but alteration of the geometric progression) with four subgroups (long M2, long M3, long M2-3, long M23 long 2) – M4M5 hypoplasia (distal SM4 line / at mid third of M4) with four subgroups (by geometric progression: long M2, long M23, long M23 long M2) – others (long M1: M1 > 3.3 mm causing distalization of SM4).

Discussion, conclusion: FootLog enables rapid radiographic measurements with excellent precision and intraobserver (variations from 0.1 to 0.2 mm and 0.1 to 0.5°) and interobserver (variations from 0.1 to 0.5 mm and 0.1 to 1°) reproducibility. In the two series of clinically “normal” feet, the measured parameters were strictly comparable. Radiologically, 31% were “normal”, and the others (30% long M23 – 37% M4M5 hypoplasia – 2% others) could be considered as predisposed to potential forefoot disorders. Finally only 48% of the subjects had the same morphotype for both feet. This study adds further precision to earlier qualitative evaluations of the forefoot architecture.


B.M.P. Silveira

Fractures of the femoral neck in the elderly are associated with significant morbidity and mortality. In the UK, patients with these fractures occupy 20% of orthopaedic beds.

Between September 1999 and August 2000 a prospective study was conducted to evaluate the outcome in 36 patients, 24 of them women, with femoral neck fractures treated by uncemented Thompson’s hemi-arthroplasty. The mean age of patients was 71.6 years. All patients had sustained a Garden type-III or IV fracture, and 89% were due to low velocity trauma. Associated conditions were hypertension (66%), diabetes mellitus (27%), dementia (22%), ischaemic heart diseases (16%), cerebrovascular accident (16%), asthma (16%), alcoholism, epilepsy and malignancies (5% each). Before the injury, 55% of patients walked normally, while 19% had a limp and 28% were using a walking aid. At the time of injury 67% were living with family, 22% independently and 11% in a nursing home.

Surgery was performed under spinal anaesthetic at a mean of 12.5 days (3 to 30) after injury. None of the patients received prophylactic treatment for deep vein thrombosis. Postoperative mobilisation was commenced at 48 hours, and patients were discharged a mean of 5.5 days (2 to 28) postoperatively to nursing homes (27.5%), family (27.5%) or independent living (16.5%). In the first month after surgery 27.5% of patients died. At six months 14% of patients had normal mobility, while 25% had a limp, 30% used a walking aid and 3% were wheelchair-bound.

The overall results in this study are comparable with those in the literature. The delay in surgery did not affect morbidity or mortality.


L.S. Barouk P. Rippstein E. Toullec

Purpose: Results of basal metatarsal osteotomy are generally unpredictable. We studied the very oblique BRT osteotomy with preservation of the proximal hinge and fixation using a threaded-head screw. We now use this technique as a routine procedure.

Material: From 1999 to 2000, 125 metatarsal osteotomies were performed on 93 feet in 77 patients (mean age 55 years). Indications were metatarsalgia alone in 34 feet, associated with another osteotomy for 21 feet, iatrogenic for 18 feet, and anterior pes cavus for 20 feet.

Method: The incision was dorsal (3 medial metatarsals) or medial for M1 or lateral for M5. The osteotomy was very oblique (60°), with removal of a thin wedge (max 3 mm) except for M1 or in case of pes cavus. The proximoplantar hinge was carefully preserved. The osteotomy was limited to the strict clinical needs and determined on the false lateral view. All patients were reviewed at six months and one year after surgery (mean follow-up 11 months).

Results: The fixation was solid allowing weight bearing at 15 days. Metatarso-phalangeal motion was preserved. There was no secondary displacement but there were three cases with a ruptured hinge due to an insufficiently oblique osteotomy. At last follow-up there has been no transfer to neighbouring rows. For the pes cavus cases, the M1 osteotomy was associated with osteotomy of one or several lateral metatarsals in 13/20 feet in order to further raise the first metatarsal without risk of transfer metatarsalgia.

Discussion: The BRT osteotomy provides an unprecedented reliability for proximal osteotomy with elevation of the metatarsus. It is highly dependent however on clinical assessment, as for any basal osteotomy, although the false lateral view is quite useful. Excessive dorsal elevation must be avoided; secondary elevation is avoided due to the absence of secondary displacement. This osteotomy can be performed easily on all five metatarsals for pes cavus. It is often associated with distal treatment of claw toes. Its association with calcaneum osteotomy is useful for extra-articular treatment of pes cavus to preserve long-term function.

Conclusion: For the two indications metatarsalgia and pes cavus, the BRT osteotomy with elevation of the base is easy to perform, prevents secondary displacement, is precise, and preserves joint function. Precision depends almost totally on clinical evaluation. Results have been very encouraging. Finally, this osteotomy, which involves elevation of the base alone, is complementary to the Weil osteotomy which has specific indications for longitudinal harmonisation of the metatarsus.


J.P. Clarac T. Fabre A. Fassier

Purpose: Using the transfemoral approach for a locked resurfaced implant without cement appears to be an interesting solution for reconstruction after loss of bone stock.

Material and methods: We report a multicentric consecutive series of a homogeneous group of 94 revision femoral implants in 26 women and 68 men, mean age 67 years (38–88). Mean follow-up was 19 months (12–38 months). All the patients were operated via the transfemoral approach which allowed removal of the implant, insertion of a new locked stem without cement and stabilisation of the femoral fragment in close contact with the implant. The cause of the revision was loosening of the femoral component in 83% of the cases in association with important loss of femoral bone. In addition, this technique was applied for stem fracture (6.5%), prosthesis fracture (5.5%), or another cause (3.5%). The loosened stem had been cemented in 87% of the cases; a first stem in 68% and a second one in 27%.

Clinically, the patients were assessed with the Postel Merle d’Aubigné (PMA) and Harris scores using the SOFCOT and Picault-Vives scores. We also assessed healing of the femoral fragment, the stability of the implant, and the bone response around the implant. Preoperative PMA and Harris scores were 8.5 (1–17) and 38 (5–86) respectively. In 91% of the cases, bone construction was important radiographically. The locked stem without cement was short in 32% of the cases, and long in 68%.

Results: At last follow-up the PMA and Harris scores were 15 (9–18) and 78 (37–99) respectively. The femoral fragment healed in 93% of the cases at one year. In 72%, bone reconstruction was significant. Two patients died. Four others required revision of the femoral implant.

Discussion: The advantages of this technique compared with other solutions is discussed. The main points of the operation are recalled. The causes of failure are analysed.

Conclusion: The transfemoral approach allows reconstruction of the bone defect. The primary stability allowed by locking gives time for osteointegration of the implant. These preliminary results confirm that secondary stability of the implant is achieved. In case osteointegration does not occur, a less aggressive surgical solution could be discussed.


A. Rochwerger G. Curvale A. Sbihi P.O. Pinelli P. Groulier

Purpose: In reports of arthrodesis of the metatarso-phalangeal joint of the great toe, differences in fusion rates have generally been determined as a function of the osteosynthe-sis material used. We studied the incidence of the type of avivement used in a group of patients fused with the same material.

Material and methods: We reviewed at six years 110 patients who underwent metatarso-phalangeal arthrodesis between 1988 and 1999. Two-thirds of the patients (77 patients) had had a simple avivement with osteosynthesis with a proximo-distal axial screw and pin. The same osteosynthesis was also performed in 33 patients who had joint resection between two parallel saw lines. Bone healing was studied on the loaded AP views.

Results: Fusion was obtained in 78% of the cases in the first group (simple avivement) and in 97% of the second within two to six months. The difference was significant, favouring parallel saw lines.

Discussion: The patients in the two groups had comparable indications for arthrodesis: advanced hallux valgus, osteoarthritis, recurrent hallux valgus after surgical treatment, inflammation. Non-fusion of metatarso-phalangeal arthrodesis of the great toe is usually well tolerated. The difference in the rate of non-fusion could be related to better stability obtained between the two parallel saw lines and to potentially more extensive vascular injury with conventional manual or motorised avivement.

Conclusion: If compatible with the anatomic characteristics of the foot, we recommend avivement by joint resection between two parallel saw lines for metatarso-phalangeal arthrodesis.


C. Erggelet A. Baltes

New cellular-based operation techniques like autologous chondrocyte transplantation (ACT) are performed more frequently for the treatment of full thickness cartilage defects. Non-steroid antiinflammatory drugs (NSIAD) are used universally after joint operations. Adverse effects of NSIAD on hyaline cartilage are discussed. Possible alterations regarding proliferation and vitality of transplanted chondrocytes after administration of NSAID are studied.

Twenty two specimen of human cartilage were harvested during joint operations (trauma, arthroplasty). The chondrocytes were encymatically (collagenase 0.2%/Biochrom) isolated After cryoconservation as used for ACT the cells were cultivated using standard medium (HAM’s F12, FCS 10%, Pen/Strep 1%, MEM-Vit 1%). Ibuprofen (Imbun/Merckle Germany) was added to the cultures analogous to the therapeutical synovial concentration (10μg/ml). Corresponding cultures in standard medium served as controls.

After 5 and 10 days the cells were trypsinized, counted in a Neubauer chamber and the vitality was tested with trypan blue staining. After 5 and 10 days the cultures showed an significant (p< 0.005) increase of cells from 0.25x106 to 0.51x106 resp.0.83x106 with Ibuprofen and 0.42x106 resp 0.67x106 in the controls. The vitality changed minorly from 96.0% after 5 days to 96.6% after 10 days in the Ibuprofen group and 94.1% to 96.3% in the controls. Age and gender of the donors as well as location of the harvesting site had no significant impact on proliferation rate and vitality of the chondrocytes.

The proliferation rate of human chondrocytes in monolayer culture increased significantly under the influence of Ibuprofen. The vitality of the cells was not affected by Ibuprofen. The results of various studies indicating an adverse effect of NSAID on hyaline cartilage and chondrocytes might be based on different substances in higher concentrations or animal models with unknown comparability to humans. Ongoing studies will focus on the influence of NSIAD on matrix synthesis of human chondrocytes.


J.Y. Lazennec V. Gleizes J. Poupon G. Saillant

Purpose: A significant increase in serum cobalt level has been reported after metal-on-metal total hip arthroplasty with wide individual variability related to activity level, mechanical conditions of the implant, and urinary elimination of cobalt. We studied serum cobalt levels over time to further analyse these factors.

Material and methods: The Metazul® prosthesis was implanted in 119 patients (72 men and 47 women, 12 bilateral implantations) (131 implants). We selected 50 patients (27 men and 23 women, mean age 53 years) who had two blood samples after the procedure allowing an assessment of the serum cobalt kinetics. Other chromium-cobalt implants, vitamin B12 intake, renal failure, or haematological disorders were recorded. An activity questionnaire was filled out by the patients at the time of the blood sample. Samples were drawn with a special kit to avoid metal contamination. The detection limit was 1 nmol/L (0.06 μg/L) with direct electrothermic atomic spectrometric absorption.

Results: In the overall series, serum cobalt level was 44 nmol/L for a physiological level in a control population of 4.28 nmol/L. The difference was significant (p < 0.0001) between the levels observed before surgery and after 18 months implantation. There was no significant correlation with the indication for arthroplasty, presence of dislocation or subdislocation, functional outcome or radiographic findings. Activity level the week before sampling did not influence the results. For the 50 cases evaluated longitudinally, four groups of patients could be identified. The first group (29 patients) had a serum cobalt level below 50 nmol/L over the entire study period. The second group (nine patients) had a level greater than 50 nmol/L followed by a decline ending with a final level below 50 nmol/L. In the third group (six patients) serum cobalt was greater than 50 nmol/L with no trend to a decline. In the fourth group (six patients) the cobalt levels were very high (greater than 150 nmol/L).

Discussion: The six patients in the fourth group were very particular. There were three patients with secondary bilateral implants with a late peak in serum cobalt, one with an impingement on the acetabular rim, one with renal failure, and one who had a very high level of physical activity. The first group had what appears to be a favourable course, similar to the second group where a stabilisation phenomenon could be operating. An explanation in the third group is difficult but could involve a third segment abrasion phenomenon.

Conclusion: Longitudinal analysis of serum cobalt levels provides more information than point measures in patients with metal-on-metal arthroplasties. Intercurrent mechanical phenomena can be detected; unexpected behaviour of the metal-on-metal junction can be suspected in certain patients.


M. Tlale

We analysed the functional outcome of 27 humeral shaft fractures treated non-operatively in our unit between 1999 and 2000.

The mean age of the 20 men and seven women was 37.9 years (20 to 65). Ten fractures occurred in motor vehicle accidents, eight in falls and three in assaults. The remaining six were gunshot injuries. There were 18 closed fractures and nine grade-I compound fractures. Nine fractures were oblique, eight transverse, eight comminuted and two spiral. There was radial nerve palsy in 12 patients, and one poly-trauma patient had a concomitant brachial artery injury. All patients were treated initially by closed reduction and U-slab immobilisation.

Radiological union was achieved in 12 patients (44.4%) at a mean of 11 weeks. Fixation by compression plating was necessary in 51.9%, treating delayed union in eight patients, radial nerve palsy in three, nonunion in one, a brachial plexus injury in one and polytrauma in one. One patient (3,7%) developed a pseudarthrosis and refused surgery.

We assessed pain, range of movement of adjacent joints, ability to perform activities of daily living and work. In patients treated by U-slab immobilisation, the mean time to full functional recovery was 18 weeks. Those who underwent surgery achieved full functional recovery a mean of eight weeks later.

Transverse and short oblique fractures are prone to delayed union and we recommend they be treated by primary internal fixation.


E. Dehoux C. Mensa B. Llagonne M. Raguet A. Pierson J.P. Leblanc P. Segal

Purpose: We were confronted with four cases of major loosening with migration of the metal-backed implant and acetabular osteolysis at seven years follow-up. We thus conducted a retrospective clinical and radiological analysis of our 192 prosthesis of this type implanted in 1993.

Material and methods: The clinical results were analysed using the Postel Merle d’Aubigné score (PMA). Radiographic wear was measured on the AP views without loading according to the Charnley method. Osteolysis was determined on the AP view using the De Lee and Charnley criteria. Certain files also had a scintigraphy or a CT scan performed to search for bone lysis. Osteolysis and femoral loosening were studied on the AP and lateral views. In agreement with the literature, wear of 0.1 mm/year was considered normal for these cemented prostheses and 0.15 mm/year for metal-backed cups.

Results: For the femoral component, there were two cases of loosening with massive osteolysis with a sanded titanium inserted with cement. None of the patients, with a cemented or non-cemented prosthesis underwent revision for pain. At the acetabular level, there were no failures for primary instability. Wear was normal (mean 0.08) in 89 cases (46.5%) and excessive (mean 0.26) in 103 cases (53.5%). Significant factors for wear were: patient age, gender, and level of activity. Factors without a significant influence were: size of the acetabular cup, type of bead, patient overweight. Osteolysis was the consequence of abnormal wear since in 42% of the abnormal wear cases showed osteolysis compared with 20% when wear was less than 0.15. The same observations were made for the clinical impact as 15.5% of the worn cups were symptomatic (PMA < 4) and 18 of the 103 patients (17.5%) underwent or will undergo revision.

Conclusion: Metal-backed cups present excessive wear at mid term causing early failure by osteolysis and implant migration. There are two options: remove the polyethylene sing a new metal-on-metal combination or a ceramic-ceramic combination, or returning to the metal-polyethylene combination with a cemented cup.


J. Bellemans

Today several therapeutic options exist for the management of early degenerative lesions in the knee. These include marrow stimulation techniques (abrasion arthroplasty, sub-chondral drilling, microfracturing), periosteal and perichondral graft interposition, the implantation of synthetic matrices (collagen, carbon fibres, or glycosaminoglycan gel), autologous chondrocyte transplantation, osteochondral mosaic autografts or allografts, or simple arthroscopic lavage and debridement.

It appears that some of these techniques are moderately successful in the short-term, especially in younger patients with relatively recent localised chondral lesions or erosion, and in joints with normal stability and alignment. In these optimal conditions, it is possible to achieve repair in 70% of the diseased area. However, the cartilage remains substandard, with a one-third decrease in stiffness and increased tissue permeability.

In the early degenerative knee, conservative treatment options include unloader bracing and the use of chondroprotective agents. Unloader braces have been shown to improve the disease-specific quality of life and the functional status of patients with varus osteoarthritis in prospective randomised clinical trials. However, patients often find braces uncomfortable and of doubtful effectiveness.

Current information about the use of chondroprotective agents in the treatment of osteoarthritis suggests that intra-articular hyaluronic acid improves lubrication in the joint and helps to decrease swelling and inflammation. Used as dietary supplements, oral glucosamine and chondroitin sulphate appear to work synergistically together to cause a net increase in the amount of healthy articular cartilage, hereby slowing the progression of osteoarthritis. Convenient and safe, these intra-articular and oral chondroprotective agents present an exciting new approach in the treatment of early degenerative knee lesions.


C. Knop U. Lange L. Bastian M. Blauth

The new distractable titanium implant (Synex) is designated for replacement of the vertebral body following fracture, posttraumatic kyphosis or tumor.

Synex was compared with the “Harms” cage (MOSS, 22x28 mm, stabilising ring) in two test series.

Test A: Measurement of the compressive strength of the vertebral body end-plate in uniaxial loading via both implants; Test B: Analysis of the bisegmental stability after corpectomy, replacement of L1 and stabilisation.

Materials and methods: In testseries A human vertebral specimens (L1) were matched according to bone mineral density (BMD). They were axially loaded (v=5mm/min) to failure via Synex (n=6) or MOSS (n=6) in an electrohydraulic testing device with load-displacement recording.

In test series B the bisegmental motion (T12-L2) of 12 spinal specimens were tested in a 3D loading simulator with moments of 0–7.5 Nm for the six directions. After testing the intact spine, we replaced L1 and stabilised with Fixateur interne (USS) or Ventrofix (VFix). Analysis of the range of motion (ROM), elastic zone (EZ) and neutral zone (NZ) for five conditions: 1) Intact specimen, 2) USS+Synex, 3) USS+MOSS, 4) VFix+Synex, 5) VFix+MOSS (randomized order).

Results: With Synex, significantly higher compression forces were recorded at 1–2 mm deformation. Ultimate compression force (Fmax) was higher (3396 N vs. 2719 N) and the distance until point of failure (Dmax) was significantly less using Synex. A significant correlation (R=0.89) between Fmax and BMD was found.

Significantly higher stability was noted with USS+Synex for extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation. No differences between Synex and MOSS were observed in combination with VFix. The combined instrumentation (USS) was superior to the anterior one (VFix).

The possibility of secondary dislocation, loss of correction, or posttraumatic kyphosis can be decreased using Synex for replacement of the vertebral body, compared with MOSS. A combined anterior-posterior stabilisation provides higher biomechanical stability compared with an anterior construct.


E. Hohmann P. Brucker A.B. Imhoff

Large osteochondral defects are difficult to treat, but several treatment options are available. The posterior condyle transfer salvage technique described by Wagner in 1964 and Imhoff in 1990 has been developed further, and is now used for coverage of large osteochondral defects in the load-bearing zone. The new technique is called MEGA-OATS.

From July 1999, 17 patients of mean age 39 years (16 to 6) were treated by MEGA-OATS. Two patients additionally underwent high tibial osteotomy and two bone grafting, using bone harvested from the proximal tibia. The mean follow-up was 12 months. The technique calls for excision of the posterior femoral condyle, which is placed in a specially designed work station. A MEGA-OATS cylinder of diameter 20 mm to 35 mm is prepared and, using the press-fit technique, grafted into the prepared defect zone.

The Lysholm score increased postoperatively from 63 (49 to 71) to 81 (72 to 85). Three months postoperatively control MRI showed incorporation of all cylinders. Between six and 12 weeks postoperatively, patients attained a full range of motion and became fully weight-bearing. To date no postoperative complications or meniscal lesions of the posterior horn have been observed.

MEGA-OATS achieves a congruent reconstruction of the articular surface in the load-bearing zone of the femoral condyle. We consider it a good alternative in the treatment of large osteochondral defects of the femoral condyle in young patients.


M. Lecuit P. Boisrenoult P. Beaufils

Purpose: Indications for tibiotalar arthrodesis persist in patients with septic or inflammatory joint disease. Arthroscopic arthrodesis can be used to limit immediate postoperative morbidity. This technique has been used in our unit since 1994. The purpose of this work was to assess long-term outcome and specific complications.

Material and methods: All patients who underwent arthroscopic tibiotalar arthrodesis since 1994 (16 patients) were reviewed by an independent observer. There were nine women and seven men, mean age 56 years (37–81). The cause of the tibiotalar disease was post-traumatic degeneration in 12 cases, primary osteoarthritis in two and rheumatoid polyarthritis in two. The ankle was centred preoperatively in all cases. Osteosynthesis was achieved with screw fixation in 14 cases and with an external fixator in two. Mean follow-up was 43.4 months (6–80 months). Outcome was assessed on the basis of delay to fusion, presence of residual pain, and complications induced by the technique.

Results: Mean hospital stay was five days (3–11 days). There was no infectious or cutaneous complication. Three patients had a sensorial deficit in the territory of the superficial fibular nerve. Fusion was obtained in all patients. Mean delay to fusion was 3.4 months (range 2–7.5 months). All patients except one who had a painful fibulotalar non-union could walk without pain after fusion had been achieved.

Discussion: Arthroscopic tibiotalar arthrodesisis a reliable procedure for the treatment of destroyed joints after centring the ankle. We were satisfied with the results of percutaneous screw fixation. Delay to fusion was comparable with delays observed after open procedures and complication rate was lower.

Conclusion: Since the postoperative morbidity is low and long-term results are equivalent, we propose arthroscopic arthrodesis for the treatment of tibiotalar destruction.


R.B. Snowdowne W.J. Kok

Regardless of the method used, open ankle arthrodesis is known to have a high rate of nonunion, reported to range from 4% to 25%. Salvage of failed ankle fusion is thus a relatively common procedure. Further, in cases of bone loss after distal tibial trauma, necrosis of the talus, Charcot joints and severe deformities of the ankle, there are known to be increased incidences of delayed union and nonunion.

Since 1997, 25 salvage ankle arthrodesis procedures have been performed, using a retrograde interlocking intramedullary nail as fixation. In this paper we discuss the indications, surgical techniques and results.

At a mean of nine weeks postoperatively, union was achieved in all cases. Complications included one case of late sepsis, which presented four years after surgery. During the operation one tibial fracture occurred. One distal screw backed out. The fixation was removed from three patients, one for late sepsis, one for septic nonunion, and the patient in whom the tibia fractured.


G. Hooper P. Armour J. Scott

We compared function in two groups of high demand patients who had undergone total knee arthroplasty (TKA), one group using a posterior cruciate sacrificing (PCS) prosthesis and the other a posterior cruciate retaining (PCR) prosthesis of similar design.

Patients were eligible for the study if surgery had been performed more than two years ago and they were under 65 years of age and had no coexisting morbidity that markedly decreased their physical activities. One surgeon operated on 28 patients in group A (20 TKAs), routinely retaining the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL). A second surgery operated on 19 patients in group B (25 TKAs) and routinely sacrificed the PCL. A mobile bearing prosthesis of similar design was used in each group. Patients were independently selected and assessed using a questionnaire specifically developed to assess higher levels of activity not usually assessed by other knee scores. Patients in the two groups were matched in terms of age, range of motion and follow-up

The gross activity score was 3.36 in group A and 3.12 in group B. The combined walking, running and stair-climbing score was in group A (7.68) than in group B (6.64). Patients in group B had decreased anterior knee pain and perceived their TKA closer to a normal knee (2.00 compared to 2.32).

We conclude that retaining the PCL in TKA results in better patient function without obvious complications.


B. Essadki C. Dumontier A. Sautet A. Apoil

Purpose of the study: Sports activities requiring antepulsion, adduction and medial rotation can favor the development of posterior instability of the shoulder. Conservative treatment is indicated, but many techniques have been proposed in case of failure. All do not allow recovery of the same sports level. We report our experience with six cases of posterior shoulder instability treated with a Gosset posterior bone block.

Material and methods: We retrospectively reviewed cases treated between 1974 and 1995. Six athletes, aged 17 to 34 years (mean 25 years) underwent posterior bone block surgery using the Gosset procedure on their dominant shoulder. Three of the patients had experienced involuntary dislocation and three others involuntary and voluntary dislocation. One patient had a multidirectional hyperlaxity. Five patients had participated in rehabilitation programs for at least five months. Two patients had undergone unsuccessful bone block surgery in another unit.

Results: Stability and pain relief were achieved in all cases. Three patients recovered complete mobility. In the three others, mean limitation of mobility for the different sectors was 15°. There has been no sign of osteoarthrosis at three years follow-up. All patients have resumed their sports activities, three at the same level.

Discussion: In our experience, most surgical techniques proposed for the treatment of posterior shoulder instability are unsuccessful. The Gosset iliac bone block prolongs the articular surface. After consolidation, it allows sports activities requiring shoulder force and provides satisfactory mobility.


M. Kassab C. Samaha G. Saillant

Purpose: Nonunion of the tibia is a therapeutic challenge requiring a good understanding of bone healing, bone substance loss and skin trophicity disorders. The fibula pro tibia Huntington procedure consists in transposing the homolateral fibula onto the injured tibia. This allows bridging the bone defect, realignement and stabilisation of the nonunion segment.

Material and methods: This retrospective series included eleven patients (ten men and one woman), mean age 32 years (16–62). The cause of the injury was a traffic accident in six cases, defenestration in one, adamatinoma in one and osteomyelitis in one. The skin was broken in nine patients with septic nonunion in seven. Mean follow-up was 13 years (1–21).

Results: Mean delay to healing was 10.5 months (8.5 for post-traumatic nonunions) and was achieved in eight cases. A higher tibial nonunion persisted after resection of an adamantinoma measuring 22 cm and two patients had to be amputated in a context of acute suppuration. Walking without crutches was possible for eight patients whose tibia had healed and the mean pain score was 2 / 10.

Discussion: Several solutions can be proposed for patients with a tibial nonunion. The inter-tibiofibular graft requires a large bone graft in patients who have already had several operations. Th Papineau method only provides cancellous bone which is mechanically weak. The Ilizarov method can allow bone transfer and dynamisation of the nonunion with compression distraction. Microanastomosis transfers using a free fibula require a trained team with the risk of potential infection of the anastomoses in these infected patients. The Huntington method has the advantage of providing osteosynthesis without the inconvenients of inert material. The fibular acts like a biological plate with good vascularisation and stability to realign and lengthen the tibial segment.

Conclusion: This surgical technique is a supplementary therapeutic means for treating (septic) nonunion of the tibia. It is easy to perform and may be the last salvage method. The advantages are: a solid compact graft fixed in the mechanical axis of the tibia, possibility of bridging bone loss of more than 28 cm, short operative time without risk of complications related to graft harvesting, shorter hospital stay.


R.A. Wilson A.G. Bailie M. McAnespie A. Dolan T.R.O. Beringer J. Elliott I. Steele Dr. Marsh

Objective: To assess the factors which result in increased mortality following a femoral neck fracture.

Design: Patients were sequentially recruited on admission to the fracture units and followed up at 2 weeks, 3 months, 6 months and 1 year.

Setting: The fracture units of two major Belfast teaching hospitals, The Royal Victoria and Belfast City Hospital (which have since amalgamated)

Subjects: All patients over the age of 65 years between 27th October 1997 and 30th November 1998 and who were admitted to the fracture units within 28 days of having sustained a fracture.

Outcome measures: Patients were assessed by: Barthel score, mental score, home circumstances. Mobility and mortality

Results: 748 patients (male/female 153/595). Mean age 82.1 years ± s.d. 7.4 years.

The overall 1-year mortality was 31.4% (235/748) and the sex distribution (male 73/153 [47.7%] female 162/595 [27.2%]).

27/748 patients who did not undergo surgical intervention had a 1-year mortality of 85.2%.

Factors which were associated with an increased 1 year mortality were: male sex (p< 0.0005), High ASA score (p< 0.0005), low Barthel score (p< 0.0005), poor mental score (p< 0.0005), decreased mobility (p< 0.0005), increased dependency in home circumstances (p< 0.0005), increased age (p< 0.0005), increased delay to surgery (p< 0.0005) and living alone (p< 0.0005).

Marital status, fracture type and type of operative intervention had no statistical effect on mortality.

Using logistic regression male sex, high ASA score, increased age, increased delay to surgery and poor mental score all remained independently associated with an increased mortality at 1 year.

Conclusion: The majority of factors which are associated with increased mortality following a femoral neck fracture are outside our control, namely age, sex and mental score. It should however be possible to reduce surgical delay and improve the patients pre-operative medical status (ASA score). A balance has to be struck between optimisation of the patient and delaying surgery unduly. The optimal timing of surgery requires further investigation.


L. Obert V. Grelet L. Jeunet A. Polette Y. Tropet P. Garuio

Purpose: Fractures o the distal radius remain a problem difficult to resolve. A post-operative displacement is observed in about half the cases. The displacement is generally a secondary shortening with mis- or unrecognized metaphyseal comminution. In the United State, autologous bone graft is widely used, which, like bone substitutes also used in France, allows appropriate filling of the metaphyseal comminution which always remains open after pin withdrawal. We present a prospective series of 30 patients with a fracture of the distal radius treated by pin or plate fixation in combination with Norian to fill the substance loss subsequent to metaphyseal comminution.

Material and methods: Thirty patients were treated between November 1998 and March 1999 for fracture of the distal radius with posterior displacement. The inclusion criterion was comminution > 2 according to the Laulan classification. All were treated by osteosynthesis with plate or pin fixation and insertion of Norian. There were 26 women and 4 men. Twenty-two patients had an articular fracture. Plate fixation was used in ten patients and pin fixation in 19.

The fracture involved the dominant side in 21 cases. The fracture was closed in all cases. Norian was injected after osteosynthesis following the recommendations of the manufacturer (impaction of the cavity rims created by the comminution, no motion for 10 min after injection). All patients were reviewed at 1, 3 and 6 months and at last follow-up. The flexion-extension and pronation-supination amplitudes were measured, as was the muscle force.

Results: All patients were reviewed with a minimum follow-up of at least 2 years. Mean age was 65 years (545–82). All fractures had consolidated. There were three defective calluses in patients aged over 80 years with osteoporosis; the clinical outcome was better than the radiological image. Three patients developed reflex dystrophy. Mean amplitudes were: flexion 43.6°, extension 52.3°, pronation 63°, supination 70°. The mean wrist force was 52 kpa. No complications related to Norian were observed. Two biopsies were made and showed, in one case at six months, early signs of osteointegration. The product disappeared progressively after 2 years but not in all patients. The immediate postoperative ulnar variance was unchanged at last follow-up. In seven patients the ulnar variance was modified with impaction of the fracture line but with no effect on pronation-supination.

Discussion: Metaphyseal comminution after fracture of the distal radius is a classical observation. It may be located posteriorly or anteriorly and leads to secondary impaction before or after pin withdrawal. To avoid this problem, and the inversion of the ulnar variance, the bone defect must be filed at the initial surgical procedure. Solutions include bone grafts (autograft, allograft, xenograft) and injection of methylmethacrylate. Bone substitutes can now be used to fill the gap without the theoretical or real risk of bacterial contamination. The first studies in animal models were published in 1995. Kopylov and Jupiter demonstrated the contribution of Norian for fractures of the lower end of the radius to avoid impaction and improve pronation-supination.

Conclusion: Metaphyseal comminution of fractures of the distal radius is a real problem. If the gap is not filled during the initial surgical treatment, impaction with inversion of the ulnar variance can lead to pronation-supination insufficiency. Norian SRS can be used to fill the bone defect producing mechanical results as good as or better than compression cancellous grafts. The produce is resorbed slowly and is easy to use. Its high cost is undoubtedly an inconvenience limiting its use to “young” patients with fractures of the distal radius. After 70 years, the absence of a strong correlation between the radiological and clinical result suggests a less “aggressive” therapeutic approach.


L.A. Gòmez Navalòn J.A. Salido Valle A. Lòpez Alonso

Purpose of the study: The aim of this work was to determine whether erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), C-reactive protein (CRP) and alpha-1-antitrypsin (A1AT) levels are correlated significantly with early postoperative infectious complications after hip prosthetic surgery.

Materials and methods: This prospective study was conducted on 100 total hip replacements performed between 1994 and 1995. ESR, CRP and A1AT were obtained before surgery then at 1, 2 and 6 weeks after surgery.

Results: Seven bacteriologically proven cases of infection were reported. Infection was considered to be superficial if it did not extend deeper than the muscles fascia. There was a strong statistical correlation between A1AT level and infection for all postoperative times (p < 0.0001). A1AT was highly sensitive (87.5 p. 100) and specific (85.8 p. 100) for infection compared with ESR (sensibility 70 p. 100 and specificity 65.9 p. 100) and CRP (sensitivity 63.6 p. 100 and specificity 80.1 p. 100).

Discussion and conclusion: In our hands, A1AT can be a most useful diagnostic tool for infection after prosthesis hip surgery. Although not totally specific, it is highly sensitive for infection compared with other tools such as ESR and CRP more frequently used. These findings suggest an avenue of research on the role of A1AT in infectious complications after prosthetic joint surgery.


Full Access
J. Kerner

We have developed an inexpensive way of dealing with fractures in a theatre without radiological facilities.

In 28 patients over the last four and a half years, we combined the use of commercially available metal fixators, the efficacy of which is well known, with the use of newly-developed JK-2000 plastic external fixators. First, we stabilised the fracture with the metal fixator. Next, we took an early postoperative radiograph and made whatever manual correction was necessary, stabilising the position with plastic holding bars. Several hours later the metal frame was removed.

We have experienced loss neither of proper alignment nor of expensive external fixators. We recommend this economical method for use in African hospitals with no intra-operative radiological facilities and limited financial resources.


O. Charrois L. Kerboull L. Vastel J.-P. Courpied M. Kerboull

Purpose of the study: Extensive loss of femoral bone subsequent to implant loosening raises an unsolved problem. The purpose of this work was to examine mid-term results of 18 iterative total hip arthroplasties with femoral reconstruction using massive allografts performed between 1986 and 1997.

Materials and methods: Using the Vives classification, the femoral bone lesions were grade 3 (n = 2) and grade 4 (n = 16). The reconstruction was achieved with radiated massive allografts measuring 11 to 35 cm implanted in a split host femur. Charnley-Kerboull implants with a long stem were cemented in the reconstructed femurs.

Results: Mean follow-up was 4 years 10 months (range 2 to 9 years). Nine complications in 7 hips were observed: 6 trochanter nonunions, two recurrent prosthesis dislocations and 1 femoral fracture. At last follow-up, the functional result was excellent or very good in 12 hips (Merle d’Aubigné classification). A stable fixation persisted for 15 implants and 3 had loosened. Graft-host femur consolidation was achieved in all cases except 1. There were 3 cases with extensive resorption of the graft including 2 associated with loosening of the femoral component.

Discussion: Reconstruction of the femur after extensive bone loss using a massive allograft appears to be a useful method for restoring bone tissue and providing immediate mechanical support for the femur.


C. Delaunay

Purpose of the study: Long-term outcome of Charnley low-friction arthroplasty in young active patients is impaired worldwide due to wear of the polyethylene (PE) component and osteolysis. In the late eighties, reports of possible low wear with some former metal on metal total hip arthroplasties led to the reintroduction of metallic bearings. The aims of this work were to examine the rationale for using metal on metal bearings in primary total hip arthroplasty (THA) and report preliminary results obtained with cementless Metasul™-Alloclassic™ hips.

Materials and methods: From January 1994 to March 1997, 64 cementless primary Alloclassic-THA (grit-blasted titanium SL stems and CSF treaded cups) with 28 mm Metasul bearings were performed. Mean age at surgery was 60 years (range, 36–73). Diagnoses were usual, mainly primary osteoarthrosis in 70 p. 100 of the hips. Two bearing surfaces were exchanged for late dislocation at 2.6 and 2.9 years. Thus, 62 hips in 58 active patients (4 bilateral) were reviewed after a minimum 2-year follow-up (mean 3.2 years, range 24–66 months).

Results: Clinical results according to the Merle d’Aubigne and Charnley rating system were graded excellent or good in all 62 hips. Radiologically, calcar, atrophy and spot welds were noted in 93 p. 100 and 82 p. 100 of hips respectively. Proximal reactive and lucent lines and mild proximal stress shielding were observed in 8 p. 100 and 4.8 p. 100 of hips respectively. No osteolysis granuloma has thus far been observed in the vicinity of any component. Cobalt blood level remained normal, except in 6 cases due to occupational exposure (n = 1), possible impingement (n = 1) or an unknown cause (n = 4). All elevated cobalt levels (range 7 to 25 mg/l) were nevertheless far below the toxic limit.

Discussion: Dislocation may be due either to the posterolateral surgical approach and/or early impingement with the first Metasul bearing design (head sleeve). Metasul acetabular component fixation is not restricted to only cementless metal-backing, unlike alumina-ceramic cups. The concern about the toxicity of metallic wear debris dissemination and the hematocarcinogenic risk must be taken into consideration as for any metallic THA. Follow-up is too short for the new polys for significant comparisons.

Conclusion: Metal on metal tribology is well known in vitro and Metasul™ bearings have functioned in vivo for 12 years (120 000 Metasul hips worldwide) as was expected from laboratory tests. Obviously, this friction couple is not the unique answer to PE-wear and THA longevity, but, in light of current data, appears as a trustworthy solution available today.


S.R. Kearns D. Moneley C. Condron P. Murray C. Kelly

Matsen in 1975 described Compartment Syndrome (CS) as a condition in which the circulation and function of tissues within a closed space are compromised by increased pressure within that space. Raised intra-compartmental pressures result in progressive venous obstruction, capillary stagnation and microvascular hypoxia.

N-acetyl cysteine (NAC) is an anti-oxidant used clinically to reduce liver injury following paracetamol overdose. NAC has been shown previously to reduce lung injury following exposure to endotoxin. Our aim was to evaluate the efficacy of n-acetyl cysteine in the prevention of CS induced acute muscle injury.

Sprague-Dawley rats (n=6/group) were randomised into Control, CS and CS pre-treated with N-Acetyl Cysteine (0.5g/kg i.p. 1 hr prior to induction). Cremasteric muscle was isolated on its neuro-vascular pedicle and CS injury was induced by placing the muscle in a specially designed pressure chamber. Arterial blood pressure was measured via a cannula placed in the carotid artery. To induce compartment syndrome chamber pressure was maintained at diastolic-10 mm Hg. After three hours pressure was released stimulating surgical fasciotomy. One hour after decompression muscle function was assessed by electrical field stimulation: peak twitch (PTV) and maximum tetanus (MTV) values were recorded. Tissue oedema was assessed by wet to dry ratio (WDR).

Compartment Syndrome (CS) resulted in a significant decrease in muscle function (PTV, MTV). CS also resulted in a significant increase in tissue oedema (WDR). Pre-Treatment with N-Acetyl Cysteine attenuated CS injury as assessed by these parameters. These data show that administration of the anti-oxidant N-Acetyl Cysteine results in significant attenuation of the muscle injury and oedema caused by Compartment Syndrome.

This work was supported by a grant from the Cappagh Trust.


C.K. Connolly G.R. Dickson G. Li R. Marsh

NSAID’s cycle-oxygenase (COX) inhibitory characteristics are either non-specific, COX-1 preferential or recently COX-2 preferential. NSAID’s have been widely reported to delay fracture repair however the mechanism of this affect remains unclear.

Left femoral osteotomies were performed in 54 male 3 month old CFLP mice immobilised with uniplanar external fixators. 27 externally fixated mice received 4mg/kg meloxicam,b.d., from the day of surgery, by gavage. The control group received the carrier alone. 18 mice had external fixators applied to intact femurs and received no meloxicam as a sham control. Individual mouse movement, was quantified each day by autocounters using an infrared beam motion detection system. Plasma was obtained by right ventricular aspiration under anaesthesia on days 2,4,8 and 16-post surgery.

A validated bioassay and a slot blotting immunoassay were employed to determine the plasma concentration of 11-6 and relative TNF-α levels to normal mouse serum.

TNF-α levels peaked at day 4 and were suppressed by COX-2 inhibition. Both the control and treatment groups had higher levels of TNF-α than the non-fractured controls. The plasma concentration of 11-6 was elevated by COX-2 inhibition at all time points. The levels of TNF-α and 11-6 correlated in fracture control and treatment groups (Spearman’s 0.039 and 0.002 respectively). The 11-6 plasma concentration correlated to the animal motion in the treatment group alone (Spearman’s 0.017).

As it has been shown that TNF-α induces 11-6 production and that this inhibits TNF-α production a possible model for these interaction is shown below.


P.F. Carton I. Sharif

Introduction: Many patients admitted to acute fracture units with femoral neck fractures are frail and elderly, dehydrated and malnourished, often with associated medical conditions. Surgery may be delayed for investigation, prolonged management and inadequate review of their medical problems, leading to clinical deterioration with poor outcome. Local anaesthetic techniques have been described for intracapsular fractures. We describe a technique effective for the treatment of the more difficult extracapsular type.

Aims: To provide a safe and effective technique using local anaesthetic and sedation, for the insertion of a dynamic hip screw in high risk elderly patients with extracapsular femoral neck fractures.

Method: Fifty elderly patients who sustained an inter-trochanteric fracture of their femoral neck underwent dynamic hip screw insertion under local anaesthetic and sedation. These patients were medically assessed following admission, all were ASA grade 4, had an additional medical condition (recent MI, CVA, chest infection, aortic stenosis) and were deemed unfit for either general or spinal anaesthesia. All patients not fit for traditional anaesthetic methods were assessed for their suitability for operation under LA, consented and placed on the next available theatre list.

A femoral nerve block was performed, with the aid of a nerve stimulator for accurate location, in the anaesthetic room; skin and periosteal infiltration was performed using a 22g spinal needle, with caution to include the distribution of the lateral cutaneous nerve. The patient was then placed on the fracture table and mild sedation (Ketamine, Diazemul, 02/N20) was administered, titrated against the patients requirements. The fracture was reduced using traction and internal rotation, and the DHS inserted.

Local Anaesthetic: Infiltration; * 20mls O.25% marcaine/1 in 200,000 adrenaline diluted to 40mls with sterile water. (30mls used with 10mls reserved) * 20mls 1% lidocaine diluted in 40mls of sterile water. (10mls used for skin). Local Anaesthetic femoral nerve block; * 10mls 0.25% plain marcaine

The combined amount of local anaesthetic used is well below safe limits recommended by the World Federation of Societies of Anaesthesiologists.

Conclusion: This technique is a safe, simple and effective method of allowing high risk, medically unfit patients to undergo surgery. It reduces operative bleeding and postoperative analgesia requirements, no peri-operative deaths occurred and one patient had evidence of post operative tachycardia that settled within 12 hours.


I.C. Kurta P.J. Richards M. Dove A.A. Rahmatall J. Dove G. MacKenzie

The aim of this study was to assess the accuracy of pedicle screw placement comparing Computer Assisted Orthopaedic Surgery equipment with conventional fluoroscopic technique.

Twelve porcine cervical spines were scanned pre-operatively by computer tomography for 3D reconstruction (1 mm slice thickness, 1mm increment and 1 mm pitch).

Computerised randomisation divided the specimens between surgeons of different experience, and the two pedicles of each vertebral level between the two surgical techniques. Stainless steel screws (6.5 diameter, spongiosa) were inserted. Post-operatively, fluoroscopic imaging was used for accuracy assessment by two independent observers, and findings were compared to macroscopic dissection of the spinal segments.

Of 96 pedicles in 12 porcine specimens, 78 received a pedicle screw, 18 screw placements were abandoned, 38 (39.6%) were satisfactorily placed (19 in each, p> 0.05). 40 screws were misplaced, 18 (45%) with the NAVITRAK system vs. 22 (55%) with the conventional technique. These single factor results (all non-significant), were corroborated using a linear logistic regression model. Some heterogeneity in performance was detected between surgeons, independently of the type of technique used.

Computer assisted surgery is an aiming device and is not advantageous over conventional methods in spines with high bone density.


S.R. Kearns D. Moneley P. Murray C. Kelly D.J. Bouchier-Hayes

Following ischaemia-reperfusion (I-R) tissues undergo a neutrophil mediated oxidant injury. Vitamin C is a water-soluble endogenous anti-oxidant, which has been shown in previous studies to abrogate neutrophil mediated endothelial injury. Our aim was to evaluate Vitamin C supplementation in the prevention of I-R induced acute muscle injury.

Sprague-Dawley rats (n-6/group) were randomised into control, I-R and I-R pretreated with Vitamin C (3.3g over 5 days). Cremasteric muscle was isolated on its neuro-vascular pedicle and I-R injury induced by clamping the pedicle for 3 hours, the tissue was subsequently reperfused for 60 minutes. Following reperfusion muscle function was assessed by electrical field stimulation: peak twitch (PTV), maximum tetanus (MTV) and fatigability values were recorded. Tissue neutrophil infiltration was assessed by tissue myeloperoxidase (MPO) activity and tissue oedema by wet:dry ratio (WDR).

Ischaemia-reperfusion (I-R) resulted in a significant decrease in muscle function (PTV< MTV) there was no difference in fatigability values between groups. I-R also resulted in a significant increase in neutrophil infiltration (MPO) and tissue oedema (WDR). Pre-treatment with Vitamin C attenuated I-R injury as assessed by these parameters. This data suggests that oral Vitamin C reduce I-R induced acute muscle injury, possibly by attenuating neutrophil mediated tissue injury.


I. Hovorka A. Benchikh C. Rzafindratsiva C. Argenson

Purpose: As proposed by Marnay, posterior fixation of the spine with self-stabilising forceps facilitates the operative procedure. These forceps enable lamolaminal, pediculolaminal, or pediculotransverse fixations. We developed a method for posterior fixation of the spine where a self-stabilising forceps links the lateral forceps hook to a medial hook allowing a bilateral hold on the segment for better fixation and correction. The aim of this work was to evaluate the contribution of the self-stabilising forceps compared with standard hooks during reduction movements.

Material and methods: Pull-out tests were conducted on five different holds using a supratransversal hook, a sublaminal hook, a pediculotransversal forceps, and a pediculolaminal forceps (Spine-Evolution), and a bipediculolaminal hook mounted on two vertebrae (Sofamor-Danek). The tests were performed on anatomic specimens. The test procedure was a reduction of a kyphosis of the upper part to the tested segment. Fourteen measurements were made for each implant.

Results: Pull-out force (N) was (mean, range): supratrans-versal hook (24, 8-40) < pediculotransvers forceps (154, 80-280) < supralaminal hook (360, 120–560) < pediculolam-inal forceps (491, 440–550) < bipediculolaminal forceps on two vertebrae (711, 400–800). The differences were significant.

Discussion: These results must be considered under the experimental conditions. Fixation with a supratransversal hook did not produce a reliable hold. The pediculotransversal forceps failed in one case due to fracture of a weak transversal mass. The supralaminal hook exhibited more consistent pull-out resistance. In most of the cases, pull-out occurred by fracture of the posterior arch. The bilateral self-stabilising forceps demonstrated the greatest pull-out resistance. During the five tests made with this forceps, the test was limited by the weakness of the osteosynthesis rods used so the maximal resistance to pull-out could not be measured (> 800 N).

Conclusion: The self-stabilising pediculolaminal forceps provides greater pull-out resistance than hooks alone. The self-stabilizing bipediculolaminal forceps allows a new surgical strategy for segmentary fixation with promising potential.


K. El-Ebed H. Mullett C. Prasad M. O’Sullivan

Introduction: Compartment syndrome is a well recognised complication of tibial diaphyseal fractures. The sequelae of late treatment can be devastating to both patient and surgeon. The aim of this study was to identify the incident, outcome and possible risk factors of compartment syndrome treated in a regional trauma unit.

Patients and Methods: A total of six hundred and twenty three tibial diaphyseal fractures were managed over a four year period (1995–1999). Two hundred and forty three of these were treated using a reamed intramedullary nail. One hundred and ninety four of these were closed and forty nine were open. AO radiological classification and Tscherne soft tissue classification were used to grade severity of injury. The mechanism of injury was recorded for all tibial fractures. Patients who were diagnosed with compartment syndrome were clinically and radiologically evaluated.

Results: Compartment syndrome was diagnosed in seventeen cases with an average follow up of twenty eight months (range 8–48 months). This represented a rate of compartment syndrome of 2.7% of all tibial fractures but 6.9% of cases treated with a reamed tibial nail. The average age of patients was twenty four years (range 18–42 years). Fractures were closed in twelve cases and open in 5. Results in this group were good in ten cases, fair in four cases and poor in three cases (Edwards Classification). Six patients developed complications following fasciotomy including drop foot, equinus contracture, muscle weakness and MRSA infection. In patients with complications, the interval between onset of symptoms and decompression was greater than ten hours. All patients who developed compartment syndrome had been treated using a reamed intramedullary nail.

Discussion: There was a statistically significant association between the use of intramedullary reaming and development of compartment syndrome (p< .05). We recognised a hitherto undescribed trend of compartment syndrome following reamed intramedullary nailing of tibial fractures sustained during sport activity. This may relate to higher initial compartment pressure in this group at the time of fracture. Increased awareness may avoid the consequences of late treatment of compartment syndrome.


P. E. Beaulé DB. Griffin J.M. Matta

Purpose: Diverse extended approaches have been described for the treatment of complex acetabular fractues. Little data is however available concerning the results, morbidity, and complications of acetabular fractures treated with this approach. The purpose of this work was to assess outcome in procedures performed by a single operator using the extended iliofemoral approach as described by Letournel for the treatment of acetabular fractures.

Material and methods: The database of the senior author included 833 acetabular fractures, 156 of which were operated via the extended iliofemoral approach in 109 patients who had a minimal two years follow-up. The series included 69 women and 40 men, mean age 34 years (11–93). Fracture type was: BC 64; TR+PW 15; T 12; ACH: 3; PW: 2; AC: 2. Delay before surgery was less than 21 days for 76 patients, between 21 days and three months for 22 and greater than three months for 11. There was a femoral head injury in 21% of the cases and 6% had had an earlier operation.

Results: At mean follow-up of 5.4 years (2–12), all fractures had healed. Reduction was anatomic in 69% of the cases, imperfect in 13ù and fair (interfragment gap > 3 mm) in 18%. The mean Postel Merle d’Aubigné score was 15 (5–18) with 63% excellent or good results. Complications were observed in 9% of the cases: seven infections, two serous discharges, and one necrosis of the scar borders. Ectopic ossifications were noted in 56% of the patients, 16% required surgical resection. Total arthroplasty was performed for 7% of the patients, arthrodesis for 4% and haematoma evacuation for 8%. The arthroplasty was revised two years after recurrent dislocation in one patient.

Discussion: This work allows us to conclude that the extended iliofemoral approach is safe and effective for the treatment of complex acetabular fractures. The percentage of excellent and good results is closely related to the quality of the reduction, and can be considered satisfactory known that the extended iliofemoral approach is used for more complex fractures less susceptible of healing. We recommend this approach for experimented operators well trained in the use of the iliofemoral approach.


P. Papin T. Steffen R. Reindle A. Olah T. Arvite T. Stoll M Bohner M. Aebi

Purpose: A preliminary biomechanical test conducted on cadaver specimens validated a new technique for vertebral bone harvesting for anterior intervertebral grafting of the lumbar spine. A cylinder of autologous bone harvested from a neighboring vertebra was used for the intervertebralimplant. The harvesting site was filled with a bone substitute. The biomechanical tests confirmed good restoration of the vertebral body structure. An in vivo study was conducted in the baboon. A block of tricalcium-phosphate (beta-TCP) impregnated with transforming growth factor beta3 (TGF-beta3) was used to fill the bone gap. The purpose of the present study was: 1) to assess the efficacy of this in vivo technique on a primate model, 2) to validate the surgical technique.

Material and methods: The retroperitoneal approach was used to operate nine baboons. Eighteen bone cylinders were harvested. The harvesting hole was left empty or filled with a 15 mm diameter beta-TCP cylinder, or with a beta-TCP cylinder impregnated with TGR-beta3. Control scans were obtained at three and six months postoperatively. The baboons were sacrificed at 6 months and the vertebral bodies were removed for histology study.

Results: There was no evidence of fracture or loss of vertebral body height. The harvesting holes left empty did not fill, while osteointegration and substantial resorption of the bone substitute was observed in the two other groups. In the group with beta-TCP impregnated with TGF-beta3 the resorption of the cylinder was more complete and signs of prevertebral neoformation of subperiosteal bone, not observed in the beta-TCP group, was observed. There was no neoformation of bone in the spinal canal or in the foramens. The scans showed progressive resorption starting three months postoperatively in the beta-TCP group impregnated with TGF-beta3.

Conclusion: The beta-TCP block used is a very good bone substitute for the primate spine. TGF-beta3 accelerates bone resorption and induces neoformation of subperiosteal bone. The new surgical technique for local harvesting of vertebral bone was validated.


J. Tonetti A. Eid T. Marinez F. Jourdel Ph. De Mourgues S. Plaweski Ph. Merloz

Purpose: We present a prospective review of 30 unstable pelvic ring fractures treated with iliosacral screw fixation under fluoroscopic guidance with or without anterior osteo-synthesis.

Material and methods: Thirty patients were included between January 1997 and June 2000. They were all treated in an emergency setting by traction with or without a pelvic clamp. Osteosynthesis was deferred for a mean eight days. Percutaneous iliosacral screw fixation was used in all patients associated with symphsis osteosynthesis in eight. The radioscopic technique used three views: inlet, outlet and lateral. There were three Tile B fractures, 26 Tile C fractures and one sacral fracture. The ISS was 30.8/75. Eleven patients experienced haemorrhagic shock, 16 had injuries to the lower limbs, four had surgical urological injuries, and seven had emergency arterography. A neurology examination and CT scan were obtained pre- and postoperatively. Clinical assessment used a visual analogue scale, the Majeed score, and the WHO score. Peroperative radiation was quantified in minutes, Kvots and mA.

Results: Fifty-one screws were implanted, 24 patients with two screws. There were 12 outside the bone and seven potentially iatrogenic lesions among the 18 neurological lesions observed. Mean radiatio was 1.03 min per patient and 0.6 min per screw. Mean follow-up was 24 months (9–50). Clinically the mean scores were: Majeed 8.5/100, WHO 0.7/3, visual analogue scale 3.2/10). Twenty patients suffered pain related to associated injuries. There were three dismantelings including one requiring revision surgery. Deformed callus was: anterior vertical translation 2.9 mm, posterior vertical translation 4.5 mm and horizontal anterior translation 3 mm. There was one complication for the symphysis fixation.

Discussion: These results are comparable to those reported in the literature. Complications are less frequent with this method. External reduction is good when achieved early. This series represents a learning curve where the 12 screws in extraosseous positions occurred during our first 16 cases. Implanting two screws per articulation increases the risk of extraosseous screws. Screw insertion is safer with the lateral view.

Conclusion: This series demonstrates that iliosacral percutaneous screw fixation is a valid method for the treatment of severe fractures of the pelvic ring. The rigorous method required is emphasised.


M. de Butet C.J. Huet F. Vandewalle J.L. Robert I. Migeon

Purpose: Is prevention of postoperative venous thrombosis using low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH) sufficient in orthopaedic and traumatology units?

Material and methods: Between 1995 and 2000, all patients undergoing orthopaedic or traumatology procedures involving the lower limb underwent a venous control the sixth day after surgery: RPO with phlebography if positive until September 1996 then duplex Doppler of the lower limbs. In all 755 patients, mean age 68 years (34–90), undergoing planned orthopaedic procedures (341 THA, 135 TKA, 111 tibial osteotomies, 66 single compartment prostheses, cruciate surgery) or procedures for trauma (56 femoral neck, trochanter, bimalleolar, etc.) were included.

Results: A total of 118 cases of deep vein thrombosis were discovered giving an incidence of 16%. The deep vein thrombosis was in the sural territory in 95 cases (posterior tibial, fibular, vastus and/or anterior tibial) but there were also 13 cases of proximal thrombosis in the iliofemoral or femoral localisations. The large majority of the cases were homolateral to the surgical side, eight were found in the other limb. In this series, the venous risk differed from one surgical procedure to another (for the same operator): 11% for THA, 22% for TKA (without tourniquet) and 17 to 12.5% for tibial osteotomies with tourniquet (valgisation and transposition of the anterior tuberosity), 13.5 % for single compartment prostheses with tourniquet. Our oldest patient was 90 years old and was treated by intermediary arthroplasty for a cervical fracture. The youngest were 34 years old for anterior cruciate ligament surgery or valgisation osteotomy and 38 and 39 years for THA subsequent to advanced necrosis. Finally, there was no statistical difference by sex.

Conclusion: Systematic use of duplex Doppler examination of both limbs postoperatively revealed a large number of deep vein thrombosis patients despite systematic use of LMWH which certainly modified their clinical presentation. These patients were then given adapted treatment which led to regression of the complications: postphlebitis syndrome and pulmonary embolism with the risk of medicolegal complications.


E. Buchanan

Acute recurrent LBP is prevalent within western society and is recognised as a predictor of chronic LBP related disability. Despite this, predictors of disability, in subjects with acute recurrent LBP, have not yet been explored. This study aimed to examine the association between variables of pain, psychology and disability, in acute recurrent LBP, and establish which of these measures best predicts LBP related disability.

The study was of prospective design employing regression analysis. A battery of questionnaires and a series of functional tests were obtained from 47 subjects, with acute recurrent LBP, at assessment and on conclusion of treatment. Measures of pain (VAS), psychology (CSQ, TSK, MSPQ, ZDS) and disability (step ups, stand ups, walking test, RMDQ) were employed. The criterion measure for resultant disability was the Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire.

The characteristics of the sample were found to typify that of an acute, rather than chronic, LBP population. Pain was found to correlate with all other variables and a relationship was demonstrated between subjective disability and psychological variables. The relationship between psychological variables and objective disability however, was less clear. Forty four percent of the residual disability was explained by initial scores of the Visual Analogue Pain Scale, the Modified Somatic Perceptions Questionnaire and the Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire. Fifty six percent of the resultant disability remains unexplained by the variables explored in this study.

It was concluded that subjects at risk of chronic LBP related disability might be identified at assessment by the initial levels of , anxiety and subjective disability.


K. Mulhall A. Ahmed A. McKeown E. Masterson

Although there have been many studies of the epidemiology of hip fractures in the older population, including the assessment of bone density and the predictive value of a Cole’s fracture in particular for later hip fracture, there has not previously been an analysis of combined presentation of hip and upper limb fractures. We performed this study to examine the incidence and risk factors of such combined injuries and to assess the impact these have on rehabilitation and subsequent treatment in order to formulate a possible clinical pathway or treatment protocol for such patients.

The study was performed retrospectively, with all patients admitted over 3 years with fractured neck of femur being reviewed. Of the 681 patients admitted over this period of time (324 intracapsular and 357 extracapsular fractured necks of femur), 22 were found to have a contemporaneous fracture of the upper limb. The associated upper limb fractures were distal radius (n=11), olecranon (n=5) and neck of humerus (n=6), with the same ratio of intracapsular to extra-capsular fractures as the whole group. The female to male ratio in both isolated hip and combined fracture groups was the same at 3:1. The mean patient age was 77.6 years for isolated hip fractures and 78.4 for the combined group. The usual mechanism of injury in both groups was a fall onto the side, but patients in the combined group also typically described having the arm outstretched for protection. The mean total length of stay in hospital for isolated hip fracture was 10.9 days and for combined fractures was 23.2 days (p< 0.05, ANOVA). Exact details were not retrievable from the nursing homes taking some of these patients, but from the data obtained there was a trend apparent for more of the combined group to require such care and for longer. In summary, it is obvious that patients sustaining combined upper limb and hip fractures can become a significant burden on already busy hospital services. These patients therefore require an even more concerted effort at rehabilitation than those patients with isolated hip fractures. We therefore now recommend the use of a specific clinical pathway or protocol including early fixation, immediate co-ordinated multidisciplinary team involvement and rehabilitation, with everyone involved with the treatment of these patients, doctors, physiotherapists, occupational therapists and others, being aware of these extra requirements. Issues for further analysis in these patients include assessing the contribution of bone density to such double fractures, the associated risk of further fractures and therefore whether such patients require further treatment or protective measures.


Full Access
E.L. Burger

Chondrosarcoma of the spine is a rare condition. In a 45-year follow-up study in one institution, only 21 cases were recorded.

We report on three cases, one a secondary chondrosarcoma and two primary tumours. Two presented with hyper-calcaemic renal calculi following massive bone destruction, and one, which we observed for four years, was a repeat chondrosarcoma. Adjuvant therapy has no role in treatment of these tumours, for which the only curative measure is radical surgery. We performed anteroposterior resection and spinal reconstruction on all three patients.

CT scan shows that all three have been tumour-free for the past 30 months. All three are neurologically intact. Because of pulmonary complications, two have required extended hospitalisation.

In the literature, a five-year survival rate is reported in 50% of cases. Good surgical planning and execution are vital in dealing with chondrosarcoma of the spine.


E. Lesprit B. Boutard D. Chauveaux

Purpose: We report a retrospective analysis of 20 patients with complex fracture of the distal radius treated in an emergency setting with an external fixation and complementary osteosynthesis.

Material and methods: These 20 patients, mean age 43 years, fifteen men and five women were treated between January 1998 and November 2000. The dominant limb was involved in 16 cases. There were ten manual labourers and four patients who had regular sports activities. The surgical procedure included manual reduction then application of an external fixator (Orthofix). The second time was for insertion of an anterior plate in nine cases. For seven patients, pinning was associated with the plate. Only eleven patients were treated with external fixation and pinning alone. Mean hospitalisation was ten days. Active rehabilitation of the fingers included daily exercises. All external fixators had been removed on day 45.

Results: Mean follow-up was 22 months. Clinically, mean outcome was: palmar flexion 40°, dorsal flexion 36°, radial inclination 12°, ulnar inclination 15°, pronation 75°, supination 62°. Force was often less than 20% of the contra-lateral side. Radiologically, mean results were: on the AP view radial tilt 23°, radioulnar distance +1 mm, mean radial; and on the lateral view, radial tilt −1.4°. Bone healing was achieved on day 45. Two patients developed severe reflex dystrophy. There were no infectious or skin complications. Two patients developed a carpal tunnel syndrome. The plate was removed in two cases. Two patients developed palmar dysaethesia. Two patients had a complementary procedure on the distal radioulnar joint due to defective supination. Eleven patients resumed their occupational activities at a mean six months.

Discussion: The purpose of this analysis was to determine, retrospectively, the role of external fixation of the wrist associated with complementary osteosynthesis in patients with complex fractures of the distal radius. These extra- and intra-articular fractures are difficult to treat and require minute analysis. Outcome in our patients indicated that this analysis is often incomplete before treatment. We had four patients with a stair-step joint surface due to defective primary reduction. The radius was usually well reduced in the frontal plane but the sagittal plane was rarely corrected. The radioulnar distance evolved unfavourably in eight patients reaching > +2mm. Our poorest results were in cases with external fixation and pinning. The best results were obtained with combined treatment using a plate, pins and the external fixator.

Conclusion: We advocate a very careful and rigorous analysis of the fracture, in agreement with the SOFCOT 2000 symposium concerning complex fractures, and prefer a triple surgical procedure using a plate, pins and the external fixator.


M. Oleksak M. Saleh

The Orthofix acute correction template has been developed for multiplanar deformity corrections, with or without lengthening, using a monolateral external fixation system such as the limb reconstruction system (LRS). Pin placement is achieved by marrying the template onto the particular deformity in the frontal, sagittal and rotational planes, so that after the osteotomy the pins can be rearranged by manipulating the fragments to permit application of the standard Orthofix fixation system. The options of compression, dynamisation or lengthening through the osteotomy sites remain available should they be required in the reconstructive procedure.

We have found the template useful in correcting multiplanar deformities intra-operatively. This is followed by internal fixation and removal of the external fixator at the end of the procedure. Internal fixation of diaphyseal and metaphyseal osteotomies is achieved with intramedullary nailing and blade fixation respectively.

This technique simplifies complex procedures, following careful planning by accurate pin placement. The fragments are compressed before definitive internal fixation. The correct mechanical axis is checked radiologically before stable fixation.


R. Cattaneo G. Guerreshi P. Poli A. Manzotti M.A. Catagni

Purpose: Severe open fractures of the forearm, particularly with bone loss, are particularly difficult to treat. Internal fixation is dangerous and cannot achieve restituitio ad inte-grum. The purpose of our clinical study was to present the method we use that has provided satisfactory results.

Material and method. Over an 18-year period starting in 1981, we have used external fixation of forearm fractures for only five cases, all men, aged 23–65 years. Three were work accident victims, one was a traffic accident victim and the last was an explosion victim. During this same period a total of 181 forearm fractures treated surgically in our unit with the AO method. The five men were treated in an emergency setting within three hours after the accident. The procedure included: 1) debridement to remove damaged soft tissue and minute bone fragments; 2) reduction with a 1.8 endomedullary Kirschner pin (bridging the bone loss); 3) application of a three-ring external fixation plus a 5/8 ring at the elbow to allow complete elbow fixation; 4) proximal osteotomy of the ulna and distal osteotomy of the radius for internal lengthening (0.5 mm per day) designed to achieve bone regeneration known to be slow in the forearm.

Results: In four out of five cases, we obtained bone reconstruction and bone healing within a delay of 176 to 248 days. In one patient, after 125 days, and after filling the bone loss, we converted to internal fixation with a plate and bone grafts to achieve cure 159 days later.

Discussion: Our experience is limited but does include very severe cases where septic complications were avoided and bone loss of 5 to 8 cm was resolved. Internal fixation with intermediary bone grafts would be imprudent in our opinion due to the risk of complication. The shorter limb on which we apply the Ilizarov device favours cure of the soft tissue damage.

Conclusion: The severe open fractures of the forearm, especially in cases with bone loos, can be resolved with external fixation using the Ilizarov method, avoiding the serious complications of necrosis and infection often encountered in these cases.


M. Witt R. Claus Ch. Burstein O. Anders

The aim of the study was to look at the concentrations of pro-inflammatory cytokines and soluble cell surface receptors including tissue factor (TF) in the drainage fluid and in the serum after retransfusion. TF is a membranous glycoprotein from the surface of fibroblasts or smooth muscle cells of vessels that functions as a receptor for the coagulation factor VII/VIIa (Kobayashi 1998)

ELISAs were used in twelfve patients to measure the concentrations of interleukins (IL-1β, IL-2, IL-6, IL-8), tumor necrosis factor-a as well as of soluble cell surface receptors (sIL-2Ra, sHLA-DR) and of TF.

All pro-inflammatory cytokines were released into the drainage fluid at increasing concentrations, IL-6 and IL-8 thereby exceeding postoperative systemic blood levels by 200-fold or 80-fold, respectively. Reinfusion of the collected shed blood led to a further increase in both the IL-6 and IL-8 serum concentrations, which were found to be elevated already postoperatively. sHLA-DR was found in an about 100-fold excess vs. serum. The concentration of TF in the drainage fluid was five times higher (158±71 pg/ml) than in serum. There was no increase of the serum of sHLA-DR or TF levels following the retransfusion.

IL-6 and IL-8 seem to be responsible for potential febrile reactions. The 100-fold elevated concentration of sHLA-DR in shed blood could therefore represent a physiological tissue level. The high TF-levels in the shed blood could be related to a local tissue damage. Dilution effects of fluid retransfused may be responsible for minor or no changes of cytokines, soluble cell surface receptors and TF in the circulation


M. Holmes P. Basu D. Pratt C.G. Greenough

The aim of this study was to test the effectiveness of a nurse practitioner-led clinic for managing the pre and postoperative care of patients undergoing lumbar spine surgery, against traditional clinic treatment.

Ninety patients were randomised- 46 (Group 1) attended a nurse practitioner run pre-operative class and post-operative follow-up clinic and 44 (Group 2) were seen by the surgeon before and after the operation. All patients completed the Low Back Outcome Score, MSPQ and Zung score, pre-operatively and at six months post-op.

There were 46 male and 44 female patients, and mean age was 45.4 years (range 20–77). The two groups were demographically similar (p = 0.418). The mean pre-op outcome score was 23.49 in group 1 and 17.41 in group 2 (p = 0.038) and the mean post-op scores were 44.67 and 35.38 for group 1 and 2 respectively (p = 0.021). Intra-group comparison showed an improvement in post-op outcome score for all patients (p = 0.001), but those in group 1 were significantly more satisfied (p = 0.008). Four theatre slots were lost in group 2 but none in group 1.

A nurse practitioner-led pre-op counselling and post-op follow-up is more effective than the traditional clinic attendance for patients undergoing lumbar spine surgery and prevented waste of theatre time.


G. Zanoli R. Padua E. Romanini

There is no consensus regarding the best method of assessing outcomes after total knee arthroplasty. There are now many questionnaires in the literature, well constructed and validated in the original language. Dawson’s questionnaire (1998) is designed as a 12-item self-administered instrument, and has undergone a complete validation procedure in its original English version.

Aim of this paper is to present the procedure of cultural adaptation and some data from the validation process of the Italian version of the questionnaire.

Two independent translations into Italian and back-translations into English were obtained, from specialised and general translators. The material was then evaluated in a multidisciplinary panel including elderly patients. A provisional version was obtained and tested in a pilot study. Results and comments were reviewed within the panel again which came up with the final version.

The questionnaire was administered to 100 patients scheduled for knee replacement. Other outcomes collected included a general health questionnaire, in its validated Italian version (SF-36), and several objective and radiographic parameters.

The burden on the patient and comprehension’s difficulties were registered. Validation included the assessment of internal consistency, construct and content validity. Correlation between different parameters were investigated. Test-retest reliability was assessed on 20 patients. Comparisons with the data presented in the original paper were performed.

The questionnaires were accepted favourably by the patients, even though the combination with the SF-36 increased the amount of time required for completion. Some difficulties were registered with the comprehension of the answering method, as well as of the meaning of single items. Results of the validation process were substantially equivalent to those of the original paper.


K.S. Moffatt L.C. Roberts

Low back pain has been described as a 20th century health care enigma. Increasingly, adolescents report back discomfort at an earlier age. In a cross-sectional study amongst a Danish population of 29,424 twins, Leboeuf-Yde reported a rapid increase in back pain prevalence after the age of 12. The link between childhood and adult back pain however, remains controversial.

In 1997 the NBPA School Bag Survey reported that 80% of school children carry ‘too much weight’ in ‘poorly designed’ school bags, resulting in postural stress. In response, BackCare (formerly NBPA) designed an ergonomic school bag. This study was undertaken to establish 16-year-olds’ views on the comfort and usability of the ergonomic bag in comparison to their usual school bag.

Thirty students, aged 16 years, were recruited from three local sixth form colleges. Each student used the ergonomic bag for one week. They evaluated the comfort and usability of both the ergonomic bag and their usual school bag using self-report questionnaires.

Seventy percent of the students reported back pain within the last 12 months. Ratings for the comfort of the ergonomic bag were compared with those for their usual school bag using the Wilcoxon test. There were statistically significant differences between the bags for comfort at the shoulders (p = 0.001) and all regions of the spine: neck (p = 0.000); upper back (p = 0.008); lower back (p = 0.001), with the ergonomic bag more comfortable than the students’ own. No significant differences were found between the bags for comfort in the arms, hands or legs.

Despite this improvement in spinal comfort, only 13% of students said they would use the ergonomic bag in preference to their usual bag. This was due to practical aspects such as its appearance and perceived lack of security for valuable items, such as ‘money and mobile phones’.

In this population of 16-year-olds, cosmetic and practical aspects of a school bag were more important than comfort. If such bags are to be accepted, manufacturers must create a fusion between ergonomics and fashion.


C.K. Connolly G.R. Dickson D.R. Marsh

Hypothesis: Early initiation of COX-2 inhibition is more detrimental to fracture healing than later, irrespective of the analgesia-permitted biomechanical stimulation of the fracture by movement.

Model: A validated externally fixated murine femoral fracture model.

Intervention: Left femoral osteotomies, immobilised with sagittal uniplanar external fixators. Treated mice received 4mg/kg meloxicam from the day of surgery, day 4 or day 8 post op until sacrifice, by gavage. Control mice received carrier alone.

Outcome Measurements: Mouse movement was quantified each day until sacrifice. Fracture geometry was determined from post-sacrifice orthogonal x-rays. Animals were sacrificed on day 4,8,16 and 24. Blind computer aided histomorphometric analysis was performed, on six coronal sections per specimen, determining the medial, intramedullary and lateral areas of total callus, mesenchymal tissue, cartilage and new bone.

Results: No difference existed between the treated groups and control fracture fragments overlap or alignment nor in post-operative movement. Meloxicam treated groups showed decreased callus areas on day 4, 8, and 16, although it was noted that callus remodelling had commenced after day 16 in the control specimens only. New bone areas were reduced in all treated groups at all time points examined relative to the controls with the reduction being proportional to duration of COX-2 inhibition. Mesenchymal tissue differentiation was maximally affected in the earliest treatment group.

On day 24, day 0 treated specimens demonstrated significantly more mesenchymal tissue. No correlation was demonstrated between post-operative motion and callus area or new bone area. The care of cartilage present however, was significantly correlated to the amount of post-operative movement in all groups.

Conclusions: COX-2 inhibition inhibits new bone formation in proportion to the proximity of its commencement the fractures occurrence, irrespective of fracture stimulation by motion. Cartilage production in the healing fracture is not altered by COX-2 inhibition but is proportional to fracture stimulation by motion.


P. Bonnevialle C. Cauhepe F. Alqoh Y. Bellumore M. Rongières M. Mansat

Purpose of the study: A retrospective series of 40 patients who underwent simultaneous intramedullary nailings for bilateral femoral shaft fractures was analyzed. The aim of our study was to verify that simultaneous nailing without reaming does not increased risk of fat embolism and to assess clinical and radiological outcome.

Material and method: This series included 27 men and 13 women, mean age 27.8 years, who underwent first intention intramedullary nailing between 1986 and February 1999. Thirty-two patients had multiple fractures. Mean ISS was 23 (range 9 to 59). Among the 80 femoral shaft fractures, 15 were open fractures, 3 were associated with sciatic paralysis, and 4 were complicated by an interruption of the femoral vessels. The AO classification was: type A = 44; type B = 25; type C = 11. Mean delay to simultaneous centromedullary nailing was 3.8 days: surgery was performed on the day of arrival for 25 patients. General anesthesia was used in all cases with respiratory assistance (FIO2 = 50 to 100 p. 100). Mean nail diameter was 11.6 (range 10–14). Gurd criteria and PaO2 were followed to assess pulmonary function. Clinical and radiological outcome was assessed using the modified Thorensen criteria.

Results: Preoperatively, PaO2 was < 87 mmHg in 8 patients. Four of these patients showed a discrete drop off and three improved well above the normal level. Only one patient experienced an important decrease but did not develop respiratory distress. Among the 32 patients with a normal level preoperatively, PaO2 remained in the normal range in 18, fell to a limit level but below 87 mmHg in 4, and showed a substantial drop off of 46 to 172 mmHg in 10. Two of these 10 patients developed respiratory distress due to fat embolism which was fatal in one case. One other patient died in the immediate postoperative period of an undetermined cause. All of the other patients recovered normal gas levels within a few hours or days. There were four cases of phlebitis, including one with pulmonary embolism, one case of respiratory distress by pulmonary superinfection, and one case of septicemia. Both femoral fracture sites became infected in one patient. Malunion occurred in two cases. Two vascular repairs of the femoropopliteal axis were unsuccessful, leading to above knee amputations. Thirty-four patients have been examined after a minimal 12 months follow-up (mean 30 months). Outcome was excellent for 48 femurs, good for 10 and fair for 10.

Discussion: This continuous series of simultaneous bilateral femoral shaft intramedullary nailings appears to be the only such report to date. The clinical and radiological outcomes were comparable with those achieved in one-side femoral fractures. The risk of fat embolism is inevitable after long bone fractures. Many factors favoring the risk are recognized, the most important being delay to fixation. Reaming creates excessive pressure in the medullary canal and could thus contribute to the risk. The presence of an associated chest trauma is not a formal contraindication if effective hematosis is preserved as evidenced by the blood gases.

Conclusion: Simultaneous nailing of bilateral femoral shaft fractures can be performed if blood gases remain acceptable and minimal reaming is used.


A. Ritchie

Many designs of hip prostheses are available. The rationale for their design is as varied as their shape.

However, the clinical results of these products are in many ways comparable, with similar survivorship at 10 and 15 years. This leads to the question, ‘Does design matter?’.

Looking at such variables as instrument design, cement, surgical technique, and variations that occur naturally among patients, this paper explores this question.


E. Lesprit J-C. Le Huec M. Desperiez

Purpose: We conducted a prospective preliminary study of ten cases of surgical repair of massive rotator cuff tears using a free quadriceps bone-tendon transplant. All procedures were performed between May 1998 and May 2000.

Material and methods: The series included seven men and three women (mean age 51 years 9 months). The dominant limb was involved in nine cases. Six of the patients were working. Mean duration of symptoms was 15 months (6–36 months). Mean preoperative Constant score was 49.1/100 points. The three most frequent signs were daily pain, limited amplitude, and loss of force. A MRI was obtained in nine cases and an arthroscan in one. There was a full-thickness tear of the rotator cuff with proximal retraction in eight cases and intermediary retraction in two. Fatty degneration (Goutallier-Bernageau) was basically grade II for the supraspinatus, and grade III for the infraspinatus. At MRI the tear measured more than 16 cm2. Acromioplasty was performed in all cases, tenotomy and long-biceps tenodesis in seven. Sutures were made with Mersuture n° 2 using the Mason-Allen technique along the tear contour. The superficial portion of the quatriceps tendon was harvested via a longitudinal prepatellar incision. The quadriceps tendon was harvested with the trapezoidal patellar bony attachement. The free quadriceps tendon flap was sutured to the borders of the cuff and a bony tunnel was made to impact the bony attachment. Postoperative immobilisation was achieved with an abduction sling and a removable flexion brace for the knee. All patients participated in the centre’s rehabilitation programme and were reviewed at consultation. An MRI was obtained for five patients with the longest follow-up.

Results: Mean follow-up was 18 months. Mean Constant score at last follow-up was greater than 70 points. Mean force was less than 5 kg. The MRI obtained in five cases demonstrated a normal tendon with no signs of necrosis. There was one tear of the quadriceps tendon at the knee. This patient experienced persistent fatigability at 12 months.

Discussion: Treatment of full-thickness tears of the rotator cuff remains problematic, particularly in young active patients. Acromioplasty and bursectomy only provide pain relief. There is an ascension of the humeral head with an excentrated scapula. Classical transosseous reinsertion is not possible when there is major retraction. Certain teams advance the supraspinatus and the infraspinatus. Deltoid flaps only provide pain relief by their interposition in the subacromial space. Tendon transfer using the rectus is highly invasive and difficult to perform. The quadriceps tendon transplant is resistant and integrates perfectly in this reconstruction.

Conclusion: Repair of massive full-thickness rotator cuff tears in young patients with limited fatty degeneration remains a difficult challenge. For these patients, we propose repair using a free quadriceps bone-tendon transplant.


K. Bernsmann U. Langlotz B. Ansari

The correct placement of the acetabular cup is the most challenging part within hip arthroplasty. For fulfilling the biomechanical requirements the three-dimensional position of the acetabular cup must be exactly adapted to the patient’s anatomy. The amount of acetabular cup malpositioning is still too high. CAS (Computer Assisted Surgery) in hip arthroplasty offers the opportunity to have an online feed-back concerning the exact 3-D position of the cup, the surgical tools, and the patient’s pelvis. Preoperatively the surgeon plans and records with the system’s software the optimum cup position, and size. Within the operation theatre optoelectronic tools serve to the CAS-system for tracking. By using these data, the CAS-system delivers real-time optical information about the 3-D position of the patient’s pelvis, the orientation of the surgical instruments (reamer, cup positioner), and the acetabular component. This allows the surgeon to navigate by these tools and to find the exact inclination, ante-version, and depth of the cup.

From Mars until December 1999, we could perform 80 CAS-system assisted cup placements. All 80 patients (80 hips) were operated on because of severe osteoarthritis. All operations were performed by one surgeon (KB). The average increase of the operation time was 20 minutes resulting an average of 70 minutes. The average loss of blood was 630 ml. No perioperative specific complications did occur. The therapeutic regimen had not to be changed in any case. There were no cases of early hip dislocation. Other early postoperative complications did not occur either.

By postoperative CT scans we could evaluate the accuracy of the computer assisted cup placement. The deviation of the postoperative cup position from the preoperative planing was each 3–5° in average. This method is a reliable support for the surgeon to be able to implant the acetabular cup exactly in the planned position.


T. Ala Eddine F. Rémy C. Chantelot F. Giraud M. Migaud A. Duquennoy

Purpose: The purpose of this prospective work was to determine: 1) the frequency of iliopsoas conflicts with prosthetic acetabular material in patients with a painful total hip arthroplasty, and 2) to determine the diagnostic features of this conflict and the results of an adapted therapeutic approach.

Material and methods: This prospective study was conducted between 1988 and 2000 in 206 painful total hip arthroplasties. Nine patients (4.%), mean age 50 years (38–65) had a highly suggestive clinical presentation (eight press-fit cups without cement, one metal-backed cemented cup). Mean delay to onset after implantation of the total hip arthroplasty was 7.3 months (1–48). The predominant clinical sign was groin pain triggered by active flexion of the hip with pain from 3° to 70°. For these nine patients, there was no sign of loosening and puncture had ruled out infection. The diagnosis was confirmed by sedation of the pain after extra-articular infiltration in contact with the anterior acetabular rim (rim overhang in six out of nine cases) under computed tomographic guidance.

Results: Therapeutic infiltration (xylocaine-slow release corticosteroids) under computed tomographic guidance provided complete sedation in four out of nine cases and partial sedation in one. Four patients experienced recurrence leading to terminal tenotomy of the iliopsoas which provided complete sedation in three and partial sedation in one. In all, seven of the nine patients achieved complete pain relief (four after infiltration including one recurrent case, and three after tenotomy). Physical examination at last follow-up did not disclose any loss of flexion amplitude of the thigh.

Discussion and conclusion: The delay to symptom onset was variable, but a symptom-free interval was always observed after implantation of the total hip arthroplasty. An anatomic factor (anterior cup rim) was not indispensable for diagnosis as it was confirmed in one of three cases with a positive infiltration test without rim overhang. The infiltration test was essential to confirm diagnosis and constituted the first therapeutic attempt which allowed complete cure in four of the nine patients. Tenotomy, indicated in case of recurrence, achieved complete cure in three of the four cases. The cup does not have to be changed necessarily to treat iliopsoas conflicts since infiltration or simple tenotomy provided complete cure in seven out of nine cases.


L. Blaise J.D. Webb B. Cales

The current choice of materials for the knee prosthesis is limited to metals for the femoral component and UHMWPE for the tibial bearing surface. The clinical experience in the hip surgery showed the great advantage of using ceramic heads regarding the reduction of polyethylene wear debris, especially zirconia. The first implantations of an alumina knee prosthesis in the 80ies confirmed the expected wear reduction but remained isolated because of the poor mechanical properties of alumina. The aim of this study was to evaluate the mechanical safety of a zirconia knee femoral component, with the help of Finite Element Analysis (FEA) and experimental burst testing.

A 3D FEA model reproduced the Cemented Foundation Total Knee System (Encore Orthopedics) with a zirconia femoral component. Flexion was reproduced up to 100° under a 7 kN load. When the flexion angle increases, the maximum tensile stress in zirconia moves from the base of the fixation pegs to the posterior end. The stress value remains around 40 MPa, which must be compared with the flexural strength of zirconia (> 1300 MPa). Concerning the UHMWPE tibial insert, the stress levels observed are equivalent to current metal-UHMWPE knees.

Rupture tests were also defined in order to evaluate the burst strength of the ceramic part. In the first testing configuration the maximum load occurs at the inner chamfers and the mean burst strength of the ceramic implants is 34.8 kN (±6.8). In the second rupture test, the parts broke at 13.0 kN (±2.0). Both types and levels of rupture were confirmed by FEA simulation.

In conclusion the FEA showed that regular physiological conditions are secure for the zirconia component. Experimental burst loads show a safety factor of 2 or more in comparison with the maximal load in the body.


O. Roche O. Gosselin F. Sirveaux D. Molé

Purpose: Arthroscopic treatment of calcified tendinopathy is classically performed in two times: exploration of the glenohumeral joint followed by subacromial arthroscopy to evacuate the calcification. In our experience, glenohumeral arthroscopy has only exceptionally provided a diagnostic element. In addition, the principal complication of this procedure is retractile capsulitis which may be a secondary effect of glenohumeral aggression. We conducted a retrospective analysis to assess the effect of systematic exploration of the glenohumeral joint.

Material and methods: Two homogeneous groups of patients were identified. Group 1 included 32 patients who had had glenohumeral arthroscopy then resection of the calcifications using a bursoscope. Group 2 included 32 patients whose treatment was limited to subacromial arthroscopy for resection. The preoperative Constant score (52 in group 1 and 54 in group 2), disease duration (34 and 40 months respectively), and localisation of the calcification were comparable for the two groups. Acromioplasty was not performed in these patients. All were reviewed at minimal follow-up of 6 months for assessment of the Constant score and a radiography study.

Results: At last follow-up the mean Constant score was 70 in group 1; calcifications had disappeared in 84% of the cases and delay to recovery (total pain relief and return to work) was 11 months. There were 4 cases of postoperative capsulitis (12.5%). The mean Constant score was 79 in group 2; calcifications had disappeared in 78% of the cases and delay to recovery was 6.5 weeks (p = 0.0001). There was one case of retractile capsulitis (3%). In group 1, glenohu-meral arthroscopy did not lead to the discovery of specific elements except in two cases where it identified partial tear of the deep aspect of the supraspinatus. Acromioplasty was never performed.

Discussion-Conclusion: Systematic glenohumeral arthros-copy is not warranted in patients undergoing treatment for calcified tendinopathy. The fact that glenohumeral exploration did not disclose any particular element and had no effect on healing and capsulitis rates favours the use of a subacromial approach alone.


M.A. Hartzband

This paper reviews the potential advantages and disadvantages of minimal incision total hip arthroplasty (THA).

A ‘mini-incision’ approach has been developed, with incision size decreasing to 7.5 mm to 8.5 mm over the past four years. This allows for adequate exposure and proper component positioning, and consistently good results have been achieved in over 400 patients.

Using a posterior approach, an oblique skin incision is made. The approach permits insertion of acetabular fixation screws, and the technique can be used for both cemented and non-cemented implants. New retractors have been developed to protect the proximal angle of the incision and elevate the femur for femoral preparation, and a new acetabular inserter developed to protect the distal pole of the incision.

Results have been excellent. There have been no dislocations and no cases of sciatic nerve palsy. The mean length of hospital stay is three days and mean operative time (skin to skin) 44.9 minutes.


F. Giraud C. Chantelot T. Ala Eddine H. Migaud C. Fontaine A. Duquennoy

Purpose: The aim of this study was to follow a prospective cohort of young subjects with total hip arthroplasties (THA) in order to determine 1) how they complied with instructions concerning the surveillance of their implant, and 2) determine factors affecting non-compliance and the potential consequences in terms of wear.

Material and methods: We implanted fifty Harris I cups with the ABG I stem in 15 young men and 24 young women (11 bilateral implantations) between 1991 and 1995. These patients were a non-consecutive prospective series of patients under 60 years of age (mean age at implantation was 38 ± 11 years, range 15–58 years). The ABG I stem was implanted when the femoral canal was cylindrical, other implants were chosen for other morphologies. 28-mm femoral heads were used in 38 cases (30 zircone, 8 chromium-cobalt, polyethylene thickness 8.6 mm, range 8.3–12.4). The patients were informed of the need for regular surveillance with controls at two months, and one year and then every two years. We re-evaluated all the patients again in 2000. Radiographic wear was assessed according to Livermore using a numeric table (OrthoGraphics).

Results: At mean follow-up of 72 ± 14 months (5–9 years), 20 of the 39 patients (25/50 implants) had not attended the intermediary consultations, but all were seen again for the systematic review made in 2000. There was no particular factor related to non-attendance other than male gender (p = 0.04). Wear was rather severe. Mean values were: linear wear 1.32 mm, 0.23 mm/an. Thirty-seven percent of the patients who had severe annual linear wear (> 0.2 mm) had not attended consultations, all were asymptomatic. The 28 mm head produced more volumetric wear than the 22 mm heads (p = 0.008). There was no other factor correlated with severity of wear (age, sex, activity, polyethylene thickness). This systematic revision led to: three replacements due to excessive wear > 2 mm and replacements planned for three others with > 2 mm wear. These six patients were asymptomatic and three of the six had never attended the planned visits.

Conclusion: Despite our recommendations, half of the patients did not comply with the planned surveillance protocol. Non-compliance being inevitable, we recommend regular systematic recalls to detect severe wear early, even in asymptomatic patients. In addition, our study demonstrated that zircone heads contribute little and confirmed the interest of 22 mm heads to limit wear phenomena.


L. Sedel

Alumina-on-alumina bearings in total hip arthroplasty (THA) were introduced about 30 years ago. Theoretically, their excellent tribological properties and low debris generation provide a solution to osteolysis. The 24-year experience of the Paris group suggests that osteolysis is no longer a problem. Any need for revision was related to mechanical failure rather than to debris, except in a few cases in which a pros-thesis that had been loose for many years resulting in metal-on-ceramic impingement.

Cemented socket and screw-in ring metal-backed alumina yielded poor results. The recent improvements in alumina quality and in ceramic fixation, using cementless fully coated hydroxyapatite material, may provide a solution in active young patients. Preliminary results of the first 100 THA procedures using a cementless stem and socket and 32-mm alumina head, and alumina liner secured with a Morse taper, are very encouraging. One socket required revision because of poor initial surgery in a severe acetabular fracture. Patients ranged in age from 14 to 71 years (median 45 years).


S.A. Clarke R.A. Brooks J.L. Hobby J.A. Wimhurst B.J. Myer S. Shore N. Rushton

This study investigated the relationship between histological, clinical and radiological features of aseptically loose total joint replacements (TJRs) and synovial fluid levels of interleukin (IL)-1b, IL-6, IL-8 and IL-10.

Tissue and synovial fluid samples were retrieved from patients undergoing primary (hip; n=15: knee; n=13), or revision of aseptically loose TJRs (hip; n=14: knee; n=9). The presence of inflammatory cells, blood vessels and wear debris in the tissue were assessed on a relative scale. Revision TJRs were assessed for sepsis, migration of the implant, gross loosening and the degree of radiolucency. Cytokine levels in the synovial fluid samples were determined by ELISA.

All cytokines were increased in synovial fluid from revision TJRs compared to primary replacements, as were the degree of macrophage and giant cell infiltration (p< 0.01). There was a significant positive correlation between the presence of macrophages and giant cells with the levels of IL-1b, IL-8 and IL-10 (p< 0.05) but not IL-6.

The amount of wear debris was related to the presence of macrophages and giant cells (p< 0.01) but not to any of the cytokines.

There were no relationships between any of the clinical parameters and the presence of wear debris or the levels of any cytokine with the exception of IL-6 and gross loosening (p< 0.01). Similarly there were no differences between hips and knees for any of the parameters except IL-6, for which higher levels were found in hips (p< 0.05).

The results suggest that macrophages and giant cells are responsible for the majority of IL-1b, IL-8 and IL-10 production but another cell type is contributing to IL-6 production. Furthermore, IL-6 does not fit the pattern of the other cytokines as it is upregulated in hip joints compared to knees and correlates with the presence of gross loosening. This may suggest a unique role for IL-6 that requires further investigation.


M. Schramm S. Krummbein H. Kraus R. P. Pitto

This is a biomechanical study measuring the maximum pull-out strength of implants inserted into vertebral bodies of the calf spine. The objective is to investigate the influence of different anchoring systems.

The following implants were used: Zielke USIS (Ulrich, Ulm), Kaneda KASS (DePuy, Sulzbach). Universal Spine System (USS, Synthes, Umkirch) and Hollow Modular Anchorage (HMA) system (Aesculap, Tuttlingen). We selected nine groups with seven vertebrae equal in mean sizes and Bone Mineral Density (BMD) for each system. Vertebral body and implant were connected to both ends of a servohydraulic testing machine. Distraction was applied until failure and the maximum axial pullout force was recorded.

No significant correlation of BMD and pullout strength appeared. The student t-test showed significant higher stability for USS with pullout resistant nut (4.0 kN) and KASS (two-screws, 4.2 kN) compared to all other systems (p < 0.025). The mode of failure was a burst fracture in these vertebrae and shearing in all other systems. Bicortical screws of USS (3.2 kN) showed stronger hold than single bicortical KASS (2.5 kN) and HMA 12 mm (2.6 kN). Zielke (2.1 kN) was equal to monocortical KASS (one screw 2.1 kN) and superior to monocortical USS (1.6 kN). All those provided less stability than HMA 14 mm (2.4 kN).

For in-vitro testing with calf spines the influence of BMD seems to be less important than that of implant design. Maximum strength of Kaneda KASS depends on angulation of screws. Stability of USS implants can be increased by use of pullout resistant nuts. Of all monocortical implants only HMA presents pullout resistant strength comparable to bicortical screws. In-vivo use of monocortical anchorage bears the lowest risk of vascular injury, because the far cortex remains intact.


P. Surer

Purpose: The purpose of this work was to determine the feasibility of using the Surfix anchored hip socket for revision arthroplasty after dysplasia or dislocation.

Material and methods: The series included 45 total hip arthroplasties revised between 1991 and 1995 in 42 patients. Four patients (five hips) had died before five years (at 2, 3, 3, 4 and 4 years) and two others were lost to follow-up (at 1 and 1 year). Thirty-six patients (38 hips) were retained for analysis. There were eight men and 28 women, mean age 60 years (24–74). Mean follow-up was 6.5 years (5–9). There were 20 high or intermediary malformations, 13 severe dysplasias, and five minor dysplasias; 34% had been operated on earlier. The acetabulum was gouged out to the paleoac-etabulum in all cases except one. Primary stability of the acetabulum was achieved with a Surfix anchor. With this anchorage system, the screw that crosses the acetabulum and is screwed into the bone is fixed to the prosthetic socket via a counter-sink placed in the head of the transverse screw. A femur head was used to reconstruct the acetabulum: the entire head was used in two cases, small cubes cut out of the head in 24, and ground head material in 12. The reconstruction bone was driven into the defect between the iliac wing and the implant after its fixation to solidarise the anchorage screws.

Results: There were two cases of regressive sciatic palsy. One case of progressive migration was observed after reconstruction in a patient with a high dislocation who underwent revision at two years for a new Surfix acetabulum. The final result was good but this case was withdrawn from the analysis. Clinical outcome for the 37 remaining patients were: pain 5.9 (35X6 – 2X5), motion 5.8 (33X6 – 3X5 – 1X4), walking 5.6 (26X6 – 10X5 – 1X4). Radiographically, the reconstruction of the bony acetabulum was good with rehabilitation and neocorticalisationof the graft material. There were modifications of the bony condensations and corticalisation around the screws. There were no displacements of the prosthetic socket and no cases with lucent lines.

Discussion: Independent acetabular screws cannot participate in resistance against compression. They become functional and effective when they are solidarised to the socket. They can be anchored in the bony columns allowing very good primary fixation.

Conclusion: The clinical and radiological results confirm the usefulness of the Surfix socket anchor when there is no bony support for the prosthetic socket.


O. Boubriak J.P.G. Urban

The aim of this study was to measure diffusion coefficients of solutes through the disc in relation to molecular weight.

The intervertebral disc is avascular thus nutrients and other factors from the blood supply are transported into the intervertebral disc by diffusive and convective flow. For small solutes such as lactate and glucose and oxygen, diffusion appears to predominate however convection may aid transport of larger molecules such as growth factors.

At present there however, there is virtually no information on diffusion of solutes of different molecular weights through the disc; this information is necessary for assessing and modelling transport pathways.

Diffusion coefficients were measured in nucleus and annulus sections of bovine intervertebral discs by a novel method which prevented tissue swelling and proteoglycan loss. Briefly strips of fluorescent or radiolabelled solute-saturated filter-paper were placed adjacent to the disc and the resulting concentration gradients measured at appropriate times. Solute sizes from 0.01 to 70 kDa were investigated. All results are reported as mean + s.e.m (n=6).

Diffusion coefficients (D) fell steeply with increase in molecular weight following a log-log relationship as predicted by theory. For small solutes (lactate) D for the outer annulus was 3.4 ± 1.1.10−6 cm2/sec while for 70 kDa dextran, D was 1.4 ± 0.6.10−7. There was no significant difference between values of D for nucleus and outer annulus for any solute.

Diffusion coefficients through the disc follow relationships seen in other cartilages and are dependant on tissue properties and molecular weight. The similarities between values for nucleus and outer annulus demonstrate the conflicting roles of proteoglycan and water contents in governing diffusion through the matrix with D decreasing both with increase in proteoglycan and decrease in water content.


Y. Gleizes L. Bernard B. Pron F. Signoret J.M. Feron J.L. Gaillard

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine the usefulness of systematic bacteriological culture of drainage fluid after aseptic orthopaedic surgery in identifying infection early. There is much controversy over this point in the literature. In addition, the public health cost (approximately 30 euros per culture) must be considered in terms of effectivenes.

Material and methods: A prospective study was conducted in a single orthopaedic surgery department over a one-year period (1999) including all patients undergoing class I surgery (aseptic orthopaedic and traumatologic surgery). The population included 843 patients (52% men, 48% women, mean age 49 years, age range 15–98 years) who underwent 880 aseptic orthopaedic surgery procedures (osteosynthesis 60%, arthroplasty 30%, others 10%). One or several bacteriological cultures on early drainage fluid were performed (n=2434). The results of these cultures were analysed to determine their contribution to early detection of infection and rapid institution of adapted treatment (medical treatment with antibiotics or medical and surgical (revision) treatment).

Results: The bacteriological cultures were negative in 830 patients (98.5%) and positive in 13 (1.5%). A deep infection developed in 21 patients including 3 patients who had a positive drainage fluid culture and 18 who had a negative culture. In addition, ten patients had false positive cultures subsequent to extraneous contamination. The sensitivity, specificity and positive and negative predictive values were 14%, 98%, 23% and 98% respectively.

Discussion, conclusion: Drainage is a common procedure after orthopaedic surgery. The objective is to limit the risk of haematoma formation, but paradoxically with an increased risk of infection by retrograde contamination. The observed sensitivity and predictive values of drainage fluid cultures would suggest this is not a reliable method for detecting infection early, especially since the presence of a drain increases the risk of infection. In the final analysis, we do not recommend systematic culture of drainage fluid after aseptic orthopaedic surgery.


H. Richards A. Fitzgerald D.H.A. Jones

In the reconstruction of the exstrophy/epispadias complex pelvic osteotomy has a role in helping the urologist close the anterior defect thereby improving appearance and helping to achieve continence. In the neonate and infant, we have traditionally used an oblique osteotomy coupled with plastering of the legs until the osteotomy shows signs of healing. Plastering has significant disadvantages in respect of nursing care. We have therefore looked to external fixation in this age group.

In the past year we have used the A.O. wrist fixator to stabilise the osteotomised pelvis of ten babies with bladder exstrophy ranging in age from neonates to two years. All have achieved soft tissue closure with improved appearance. However, because of the foreshortened anterior pelvis in the exstrophy patients, it is not possible to reconstruct to normality. The results to date are promising and the patients remain under follow up.


M.N. Rasool

Congenital vertical talus is a rare deformity. Many different surgical procedures have been described, and there is debate about whether the correction should be done in one or two stages. We review the results of single stage surgical correction of congenital vertical talus.

Between 1992 and 2000, five boys and seven girls were treated, ranging in age from eight months to two years. In six children both feet were involved, so there was a total of 18 feet. One child had spina bifida, four had arthrogryposis multiplex congenita and three had syndromes and chromosomal abnormalities. Four cases were idiopathic.

Dorsolateral and medial incisions were used. Through the dorsolateral the sinus tarsus, calcaneocuboid and talonavicular joints were released and the extensors lengthened. Through the medial incision the navicula was reduced onto the talus, the tibialis posterior and talonavicular capsule were reefed and the tendo Achillis lengthened. The talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints were pinned. The tibialis anterior was re-routed through the talar neck. Plasters were changed after two weeks and serial plasters were applied for four to six months.

Follow-up ranged from one to seven years. Results were assessed clinically and radiologically, using the Adelaar 10 point scoring system. There were no wound complications or cases of avascular necrosis of the talus. Further surgery was required to correct cavus in two feet, to correct forefoot abduction in two, and to correct hindfoot valgus in one. Results were rated good in 12 feet and fair in six. Radiologically there was notable improvement in the anteroposterior and lateral talocalcaneal and tarso-first metatarsal angles. All patients were ambulant at last follow-up.

In treating congenital vertical talus, good clinical and radiological results can be obtained with single stage correction of the hindfoot and midfoot deformities.


D. Murphy P. Kenny D. Bennett D.P. Moore

In 1993 a specialist limb length discrepancy and deformity clinic was established at Our Lady’s Hospital for Sick Children. Since then, the senior author has performed 193 lower limb lengthenings. Of these, there were 50 paediatric cases who had 74 segments lengthened using the Ilizarov method of distraction osteogenesis. A retrospective study of data and radiographic review of these children was performed. In particular, the grade of severity of deformity and complications encountered whilst lengthening were documented.

Complications were defined as any unwanted event and graded as minor or major with the major complications being further classed as serious or severe. Each patients deformity was classified using the Dahl Deformity Severity Scale which grades deformity according to percentage length discrepancy.

There were 26 females and 24 males in the study population, their average age being 13.1 years (range 2.8–18 years). 65% of the lengthenings had a congenital aetiology for the deformity. The mean hospital stay was 7 days and the average length achieved was 4.9cm. There were 79 minor complications and 48 major complications. The overall complication rate (total complications divided by the number of segments lengthened) was 1.74%.

This study shows how the Deformity Severity Scale may be used as a prognostic indicator to identify limb deformity at high risk of lengthening complication. It may also be used to determine the relative complication risk for each patient according to his or her percentage limb length discrepancy.


M. Fehily P. Fleming M. Yousef R. Khan K. Mohoklar D. Borton

Open reduction and internal fixation is the treatment of choice for patients with displaced fractures of the lateral and medial malleoli. Ideally, operative treatment restores sufficient stability to allow full mobility at the ankle joint. However, because of the necessity to protect the ankle from weight-bearing and other forces, we routinely immobilise the ankle in a below-knee cast because of our concerns about patient compliance. We carried out a prospective study to assess patient compliance with instructions on non-weight bearing following ORIF of ankle fractures.

All 30 patients at our hospital who were treated for an ankle fracture over a 14 month period were included in our study. 22 of these underwent ORIF. A below knee cast was applied in all cases, and patients were instructed not to put any weight on the injured limb. A pressure sensitive film (Fuji Prescale Film, Sensor Products Inc., NJ, USA) was incorporated into the cast beneath the heel pad. Patients were informed that this was being done to measure the pressure within the cast, for the purposes of a trial. The cast was changed (including the pressure sensitive film) at two-week intervals over a six week period, providing three separate measurements of pressure on the heel. The sole of the cast was also examined, to complement the findings on the pressure film. At each visit, the patients level of pain was assessed using a visual analogue score, and the wound (if present) was examined.

There was a remarkable variation in the amount of weight bearing performed by the patients in this study, but several trends could be observed. In most cases, patient compliance was greatest in the first four weeks following cast application, but patients tended to put significant weight on the limb in the 4–6 week period. Female patients tended to comply better than males. Patients with a history of alcohol or drug abuse complied poorly. Compliance was lower in those individuals with lower pain scores. Of interest, the degree of weight bearing did not significantly affect the radiological or clinical outcome at the 6-week mark in any case. We conclude that patient compliance with non-weight bearing is generally poor, although the effect of this poor compliance on the long-term outcome requires further study.


D.J. White C.G. Greenough

Recently a great amount of research has been conducted into fatigability of paraspinal muscles in relation to Lower Back Pain (LBP). Additionally relationships have been observed between a general level of “fitness” and LBP. This research project aimed to evaluate the influence of aerobic fitness and health on lower back muscle function as measured by Electromyographic (EMG) spectral parameters.

Participants undertake a series of psychometric tests, anthropometric data collection, EMG spectral analysis of the paraspinal muscles at lumbar and thoracic regions, and an aerobic fitness test. The EMG test involves a 30-sec isometric pull against a load normalised for weight. The spectral half-width, initial median frequency and median frequency slope are calculated. Participants are given biofeedback and exercise advice.

Participants in this study were of above average fitness level compared to normative data. Other anthropometric data were similar to previous work conducted within this department. Preliminary regression analysis results have revealed no relationships between aerobic fitness level and EMG parameters, a finding that is counter to current beliefs on LBP and fitness, however it was observed that age did significantly influence lumbar spectral variable values (p = .002). A similar psychological profile was observed for all fitness levels.


P.J.E. Holt P. Cashman A.M.J. Bull A.H. McGregor

Low back pain (LBP) is a common problem in rowers of all levels. Few studies have looked at the relationship between rowing technique, the forces generated during the rowing stroke and the kinematics of spinal motion. Of particular concern with respect to spinal injury and damage are the effects of fatigue during long rowing sessions.

A technique has been developed using an electromagnetic motion system and strain gauge instrumented load cell to measure spinal and pelvic motion and force generated at the oar during rowing on an exercise rowing ergometer. Using this technique 13 elite national and international oarsmen (mean age 22.43 ± 0.02 years) from local top squad rowing teams were investigated. The test protocol comprised of a one hour rowing piece. During this session rowing stroke profiles were quantified in terms of lumbopelvic kinematics and stroke force profiles. These profiles were sampled at the start of the session and quarterly intervals during the hour piece.

From this data we were able to quantify the motion of the lumbar spine and pelvis during rowing and relate this to the stroke force profile. The stroke profiles over the one hour piece were then compared to examine the effects of fatigue. This revealed marked changes and increases in the amount of spinal motion during the hour piece suggesting that to maintain stroke force profiles athletes were utilising greater ranges of spinal motion. The relevance of this with regard to low back pain however, requires further investigation.


Full Access
H.J.S. Colyn R.G. Molteno E.M. Mennen

Between September 1997 and April 2000 hip arthrodesis was performed on six patients, using a modification of the techniques described by F.R. Thompson. The ages of patients ranged from 11 to 13 years, and indications included trauma (one patient) post-septic arthritis (two patients) and tuberculosis of the hip joint (three patients).

The subtrochanteric osteotomy was performed as a coronal chevron, differing from previously described techniques. Patients were immobilised in a spica in a functional position of 20° flexion and the zero position (1° abduction per year of growth left) for six weeks postoperatively. The follow-up period ranged from 16 to 40 months.

Union was achieved within six weeks. All patients achieved a pain-free gait, with minimal signs of disability.

We believe that hip arthrodesis is an acceptable way of treating children with destroyed joints and intractable pain. The modification we used prevents displacement of the sub-trochanteric osteotomy but allows correct positioning of the limb.


M. Larrouy L. D. Duranthon E. Vandenbussche B. Augereau

Purpose: Fractures of the upper humerus are frequent in elderly persons. While 80% are generally treated orthopaedically, about 20% are complex complicating treatment. Osteosythesis has given disappointing results due to the poor bone quality. Simple humeral arthroplsaty with simple tuberosity fixation could be a solution.

Material and method: Between 1993 and 1998, 50 patients, 39 women and 11 men, mean age 74.5 years (51–90) were treated for cephalotuberosity fractures with cemented humeral arthroplasty. The dominant side was involved in 80% of the cases; there were 39 fractures with four fragments in the Neer classification with seven associated with anterior dislocation, eleven with three fragments including two associated with anterior dislocation. Three patients had a neurological complication: elongation of the brachial plexus in one and irritation of the ulnar nerve in two. Mean delay to surgery was 2.4 days. Thirty-seven patients were operated via the superolateral approach, 13 via the deltopectoral approach. A total of 37 Neer prostheses were implanted and 13 Guepar prostheses. Three patients had a full thickness cuff tear, sutured in the same operative time. The glenoid cavity was healthy in all cases. the upper limb was immobilised elbow against thorax using an abduction brace for 2& days. Active rehabilitation exercises began during the sixth week.

Results: Mean follow-up was 2.5 years. Twelve patients had died, four were lost to follow-up and six could not be examined due to an alteration of their cognitive functions. The analysis thus concerned 28 patients. The mean absolute Constant score at last follow-up was 47 points, with a weighted score of 70 points. Outcome was good in nine cases, fair in eight, and poor in eleven. 86% of the shoulders were pain free. Overall active mobility was: antepulsion 80.5°, abduction 77°, external rotation 20°; 18 patients had internal rotation at L5or more. Radiographically, there was a tuberosity lysis in eight patients and a defective trochiter callus in nine. No changes in the humeral component cementing were observed. The trochiter lever arm was 28 cm, 92.7% of the offset measured on the healthy side. The distance between the apex of the head and the trochiter was 10 mm on the average. Glenoid wear was noted in ten cases. There was no evidence of periprosthetic ossification. Mean ES was 9.9 mm.

Discussion: Pain relief was good. Amplitudes were correlated with age, the quality of the tuberosity fixation, and the duration of rehabilitation (> 1 year). An associated dislocation did not appear to have a deleterious effect. The approach used or offset did not appear to affect results.

Conclusion: Our patients achieved good pain relief but lost a certain degree of mobility, similar to findings reported in the literature. The main prognostic factors are the quality of the tuberosity reconstruction and patient compliance to rehabilitation.


J. McKenna M. Walsh A. Jenkinson P. Hewart T. O’Brien

Patients with hemiplegic cerebral palsy walk with a well recognised characteristic gait pattern. They also commonly have a significant leg length discrepancy which is less well appreciated. The typical equinus gait in these patients is assumed to be an integral part of the disease process of spasticity and a tendency to develop joint contractures. However an alternative explanation for the presence of an equinus deformity may be that it is a response to the development of a significant leg length discrepancy in these patients. The development of such an equinus deformity would have the effect of functionally lengthening the short hemiplegic leg. We set up a study to examine the correlation between leg length discrepancy and equinus deformity. We reviewed the gait analyses and clinical examinations of 183 patients with hemiplegic cerebral palsy. While 22% had no significant leg length discrepancy, 65% had a measured discrepancy of greater than 1cm. There was a linear correlation between age and limb length discrepancy. We also found that there was a linear relationship between leg length discrepancy and ankle equinus at the point of ground contact. We propose that the equinus deformity seen in the hemiplegic cerebral palsy patient is multifactorial and is related not only to the disease state but also to the presence of leg length discrepancy. The equinus deformity functionally lengthens the short hemiplegic leg. Indeed it may represent an attempt by these patients to functionally equalise their leg lengths. This factor must be taken into account when considering correction of an equinus deformity in patients with hemiplegic cerebral palsy in order to avoid either recurrence of the deformity or the production of functionally unequal leg lengths. We have also highlighted the presence of significant shortening of the hemiplegic leg in these patients.


M. Shah H. Mullett M. O’Sullivan

Introduction: Thromboembolic complications are common in both elective and trauma orthopaedic practice. Despite the many studies reported in the literature, there remain a number of unanswered questions regarding the use of thrombophylaxis. The aim of this study was to establish the current practice amongst Irish consultant orthopaedic surgeons regarding thromboprophylaxis.

Materials and Methods: A detailed confidential written questionaire was sent to all consultant orthopaedic surgeons in the republic of Ireland. Surgeons were asked to indicate the type of mechanical and chemothromboprophylaxis in the setting of total hip arthroplasty, knee arthroplasty and hip fracture. They were also questioned regarding 1) time of commencement of therapy 2) duration of therapy 3) method of diagnosis of DVT 4) Estimated incidence of mortality from pulmonary embolism in the last five years 5) Whether there was established protocol for DVT prophylaxis in their unit. 6) Reason for not using chemothromboprophylaxis if not used and 7) whether their method of treatment was influenced by anaesthetic concerns.

Results: The response rate was seventy percent. Over ninetyfive percent of surgeons used a combination of physical and chemical modalities. There was a wide variation between type of therapy, commencement time and duration of prophylaxis. There was a higher rate of intervention and duration of therapy in elective practice. A unit policy regarding thromboprophylaxis existed in a majority of hospitals (54.7%). Forty-seven per cent of respondents felt that there had been no post-operative mortality in their practice in the previous five years from pulmonary embolism. Twenty-six percent of respondents felt that anaesthetists influenced the type of prophylaxis used. The results of this survey shows that venous thromboembolism is regarded as a significant complication of orthopaedic surgery and that most orthopaedic surgeons take active steps to try and prevent its occurrence. There was a higher rate of intervention in this groug of surgeons compared to previous surveys of British orthopaedic surgeons. This may reflect a higher standard of care or a concern regarding the high rate of litigation in the republic of Ireland. However there is no consensus as to the optimum therapy which reflects the conflicting evidence available in the many publications on this subject.


M. Thomas P. Williams K. Lyons S. Hemmadi D. O’Doherty

In the last six months 6 cases of subacute epiphyseal osteomyelitis have presented to the Paediatric Orthopaedic Department at the University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff. We present a clinical review of these cases illustrating the salient points in their varied presentation and management, together with the results of a retrospective analysis of the incidence of this rare condition. We ask “is there an increasing incidence of this rare condition or have we become increasingly aware of this potential diagnosis in children?”


H. Moussa P. Boutin J. Daussange M.E. Bolanderr L. Sedel

Purpose: The purpose of this retrospective study was to assess long-term clinical and radiological outcome in a continuous series of alumine-alumine total hip arthroplasties.

Material and methods: This series included 118 total hip arthroplasties performed in 106 patients (70 men and 36 women), mean age 62.2 ± 11.9 years (32–89). Primary degenerative hip disease was the main aetiology. All the arthroplasties were performed by the same operator. In all cases, the femoral piece was a titanium alloy with a Morse cone for fixation of the femoral head; an “all alumine” cup was used for all. The implants were fixed with cement for 85 hips, without cemented for 29, and with a hybrid technique for four. The Merle d’Aubigné score was used to assess clinical outcome. Classical landmarks on the AP pelvis views were used to assess implant migration. Cup wear was measured using the Livermore method. Actuarial survival curves were plotted.

Results: At mean follow-up of 20 years, 45 patients (51 hips) were still living and had not required revision. Twenty-five patients (25 hips) had undergone revision for replacement of the acetabular component and/or the femoral component. Twenty-seven patients (30 hips) had died and nine patients (12 hips) were lost to follow-up. The mean functional score was 16.2 ± 1.8 at last follow-up. Cumulated survival at 20 years was 85.6% (95%CI 72.2–99.0) for cups without cement compared with 61.2% (95%CI 46.8–75.6) for stems without cement (log rank test p = 0.0162). Cumulated survival at 20 years was 84.9% (95%CI 71.1–98.8) for stems without cement compared with 87.3% (95%CI 77.4–97.1) for cemented stems (log rank, p < 0.05). Wear was unmeasurable. Osteolytic lesions required reconstruction with an allograft in three of the 25 revisions. There were no cases with fracture of the alumine head or cup.

Discussion: The limited number of cases with osteolysis at 20 years is probably related to minimal wear of the prosthetic components. Fixation of alumine cups could still be improved.


R.J.L. Stein F.A. Weber

Using the EOL cup, we performed 15 operations between December 1999 and January 2001. Most of them were salvage procedures after recurrent dislocation of total hip arthroplasty and subsequent revision surgery. The six men and nine women (mean age 63 years) had experienced a total of 42 dislocations and 16 previous revision procedures. The mean follow-up was 10 months. No redislocation has occurred.

We believe the EOL cup is an alternative salvage solution for problem cases.


C. Hulet D.E. Hurwitz T.P. Andriacchi J.O. Galante C. Vielpeau

Purpose of the study: This prospective study was conducted to analyze the mechanisms of gait compensation in patients with painful hip and to search for correlations with preoperative clinical and radiographic findings.

Material and methods: Optoelectronic and multicomponent force-plate datas were used to calculate joint motion, moments and intersegmental forces for 26 patients with unilateral hip pain and 20 normal age and sex-matched patients. Height was similar in the two groups but mean weight in the study group (83 kg) was greater than in the controls (68 kg). The preoperative Harris score was 53 in the study group and 16 patients had a permanent flexion contracture of the knee (mean 15°, range 5–30°). Radiographically, there were 22 cases of osteoarthritis hip disease and 4 cases of necrosis.

Results: Gait analysis showed a significant 0.66 ± 0.06 m (12 p. 100) reduction in step length. Patients who had severe hip pain walked with a decreased dynamic range of motion (18 ± 5°, p < 0.0001) with a curve reversal as they extended the hip. They also reduced dynamic range of motion of the knee and ankle. Patients who presented a reversal in their dynamic hip range of motion had a greater passive flexion contracture and a greater loss in range of motion during gait than those with a smooth regular pattern (p < 0.0001). Patients with hip pain walked with significantly decreased external extension, adduction, and internal and external rotation moments (p < 0.0001). They also unloaded the ipsilateral knee and ankle. The decreased hip extension moment was significantly correlated with an increased level of pain (p < 0.0001). There was no correlation with radiological findings.

Discussion: Reversal of dynamic hip range of motion was interpreted as a mechanism to increase effective hip extension during stance phase through increased anterior pelvic tilt and lumbar lordosis.

Conclusion: Patients with painful hip walked with a manner that was asymmetric. These gait modifications were related to hip limitation in passive motion and pain. Patients with flexion contracture adopted a compensatory gait mechanism. This study confirms relation between hip pain and forces across the hip joint.


G. Delepine F. Delepine N. Delepine

Purpose: Between January 1975 and December 2000, 498 cases of sarcoma of limb bones were treated by our multi-disciplinary team. Mean patient age was 27.1 years. Mean tumour size was 13.1 cm. Histology revealed osteosarcoma (n= 231), chondrosarcoma (n=118), Ewing sarcoma (n=104), MFH (n= 25), fibrosarcoma (n=12) and diverse tumours (n=8). The most frequent localisations were: femur (n=203), pelvis (n=98), tibia (n=86), humerus (n=60). Metastasis was present in 64 cases when first seen by our team. The histological resection was wide in 295 cases, marginal in 185 and contaminated in 18. Adjuvant treatment was adapted to patient age, histology and tumour localisation. Postoperative radiotherapy (34 to 50 Gy) was given for certain adults with osteosarcoma or Ewing tumours who had little histological response to preoperative chemotherapy or who had a marginal or contaminated resection.

Results: Median follow-up was 12 years. Two hundred fifty-two patients were living and disease free, eight were still under treatment, and 238 had died of their disease or treatment complications. There were 35 cases of local relapse, most of them (n=26) in referred patients, particularly after insufficiently effective chemotherapy. Complications were mainly deep infections (n=42). Secondary amputation was required for 24 patients (5%). Functional outcome at last follow-up was excellent in 52% of the patients, good in 35%, fair in 7% and unsatisfactory in 6%. Outcome depended basically on tumour size and localisation and deteriorated with infectious complications and radiotherapy.

Conclusion: 1. In our series, conservative surgery was performed in 95% of the cases, even for large tumours with fractures or for young children. 2. Functional outcome was better after conservative surgery: more than 85% excellent or good function. 3. Risk of local relapse was 2% for patients seen for initial diagnosis of high-grade malignant sarcoma. For patients with low-grade malignant tumours, or those who could not be given effective chemotherapy, the risk of local relapse was higher. 4. Radiotherapy improved local control for Ewing sarcomas and mesenchymatous chondro-sarcomas but its effect could not be assessed for the other tumours. As most of the secondary amputations and most of the poor functional results were observed in patients given complementary radiotherapy, this therapeutic modality, should, in our opinion, be avoided. 5. Preoperative chemotherapy being potentially dangerous for poor responders when the preoperative phase is continued too long, we advocate one month of preoperative chemotherapy for osteosarcoma and six weeks for Ewing sarcoma. This should be sufficient to allow conservative surgery (reduced tumour size) and chemotherapy (precise dose and protocols).


A. Ackermann

The peroneal nerve, important for normal gait, follows a precarious route around the lateral side of the knee.

Except after major knee trauma, the peroneal nerve seldom malfunctions. Only rarely does it undergo spontaneous compression. Treatment varies.


K. Kastanos C. Anderson

Shoulder movements from neutral into flexion, extension, abduction, adduction and external rotation are easily measured with a goniometer. In the neutral position, the glenohumeral ligaments, which act as the reins of the joint, limit movement and are symmetrically relaxed. The torso obstructs internal rotation with the arm adducted at the side and the full range of movement cannot be attained.

The torso is cleared when the shoulder is abducted, usually to 90°. However, this degree of abduction places the shoulder within the painful arc of impingement and may influence the degree of internal rotation. Further, owing to shoulder joint stiffness, some patients may not be able to abduct the shoulder to 90°. Because of these problems, it has become internationally accepted to measure internal rotation in the near-neutral position by determining the vertebral level behind the back to which the thumb can reach.

We assessed 200 symptomatic and asymptomatic shoulders to determine the correlation between the ‘hand behind back’ and angular measurements of internal rotation at 90° or 30° of abduction.


E.E.G. Lautenbach

Health fund providers often require objective motivation for surgery, and patients often try to pressurise surgeons into operating. The author developed a scoring system to weigh up objectively the indications and contraindications for and urgency of joint replacement.

A considerably expanded Harris Hip Score and American Knee Society ratings are used. Rather than using a subjective adjective to evaluate pain, it is objectively evaluated by type and frequency of analgesic. The totality of the patient’s condition is considered in assessing functional ability, particularly with regard to other affected joints and the patient’s ability to perform normal activities of daily living. Taken into account is how much walking, climbing and stair-climbing a patient’s work demands and whether getting to work requires a long walk or use of public transport. The functional demands of daily home life are assessed, and also how much assistance is available to the patient.

By adding the American scores to the additional scores for pain and functional ability, and then subtracting that total from the functional demand, one arrives at a score for the degree of compromise. The scoring includes a prediction of the risk of morbidity and mortality. When this risk is balanced by the degree of compromise, one arrives at a score for contraindication. Put another way, pain + functional ability - functional demand =compromise, and compromise x risk of mortality and morbidity =100.


J.F. de Beer K. van Rooyen R. Harvie

The capsular shift procedure is done to treat instability due to ligamentous laxity. Usually there is no traumatic avulsion of the labroligamentous tissues.

In surgical repair the anterior labrum is separated from the glenoid. The labrum and attached ligaments are shifted superiorly and attached with bone anchors to the decorticated glenoid. The labrum and ligaments are rolled into a soft tissue ‘bumper’ (we refer to this as labroplasty). Arthroscopic rotator interval plication is added to the procedure.

For six months to six years we followed up 67 patients treated between 1994 and 2000. There were two cases of recurrent subluxation (3%). Patient satisfaction was high.


M.E. Carides

We reviewed 14 patients who underwent thumb lengthening over a four-year-period. Lengthening was performed for terminal deficiency in nine patients and for segmental bone loss in five.

The callotasis method was used in eight patients and the Matev method in six. In all patients, the Orthofix mini-external fixator was used as the distracting device.

Final gains in length ranged from 22 mm to 36 mm. The mean fixator application time was 89 days (68 to115). Complications included one malunion, one over-lengthening, two pin migrations through bone and four cases of pin-tract sepsis. There were no skin or neurovascular complications.

These techniques are safe and provide useful alternatives to other methods of thumb reconstruction.


P.F.R.G. de Muelenaere

The problems arising at the levels above or below a previous successful fusion are well known. The aim of this study was to determine the incidence of junctional disk degeneration and/or stenosis and to attempt to establish preventative measures.

Between July 1993 and December 2000, a single surgeon performed lumbosacral fusions on 938 patients. The primary fusion was subsequently extended in 26 men and 16 women (2.8%). The mean age of patients at the time of the second fusion was 52 years. The mean time from the primary to a second procedure was three years. Initial data showed that seven patients had mild to moderate degeneration of the disc and/or facet joints above the level of intended fusion. No other risk factors were identified.

At 2.8%, it would appear that extension of a fusion is necessary less often than anticipated. The need for extension may have been prevented in seven patients had the primary fusion been extended.


P. Rossouw

This paper introduces a relatively new treatment of pes planus.

Over three years we have treated 21 patients with idiopathic or acquired pes planus by inserting a cylindrical polyethylene prosthesis in the subtalar sinus tarsi to limit subtalar movements. After a two to four-week period in postoperative surgical plaster, patients become fully weight-bearing, with immediate correction of alignment of the pes planus.

The polyethylene has excellent wear properties and we have encountered no wear or particular reactions. We have had no bone resorption or infections, and few and minor complications. Correction of the deformity is maintained even after removal of the prosthesis.

The advantages of immediate correction of the deformity and early full weight-bearing make this simple and effective procedure an attractive alternative to conservative treatment, osteotomy and subtalar fusion in selected cases.


P. Bonnevialle F. Alqoh P. Mansat Y. Bellumore F. Accadbled

Purpose: Reaming is classically contraindicated for open leg fractures. For certain authors, reaming can favour bone healing without increasing the risk of infection (Court-Brown JBJS 90B and 91B, Wiss Coor 95). The aim of this retrospective analysis of patients treated in a single centre was to validate these notions and determine the role of locked centromedullary nailing (LN) with reaming for the treatment of open leg fractures.

Material and methods: Between 1989 and June 2000, 141 open leg fractures were fixed with locked centromedullary nailing without reaming in 103 men and 38 women, mean age 34 years, who were mainly accident victims (2-wheel vehicles 43%, 4-wheel vehicles 22%). Multiple trauma was present in 18.7% of the cases and multiple fractures in 28%. Skin wounds were (Gustilo classification): type I 81 (57%), type II 38 (27%), type IIIA 14, and type IIIB 8. There was a simple fracture in 50% of the cases, a wedge fracture in 32%, and comminution in 18% with bifocal fractures in 10 cases. Osteosynthesis was performed within a mean 5.5 hours (2–18) and deferred in six cases. The Grosse and Kempf nail was used in all cases with reaming (man 11). Static locking was used in 88% of the cases. type I, II and IIA skin wounds were sutured after debridement. Three aponeurotomies were performed as preventive measures. Type IIIB wounds were treated by early plasty. A brief antibiotic prophylaxis was given in all cases.

Results: There was one aggravation of the comminution, two dismantelings subsequent to unauthorised weight-bearing, three compartment syndromes and one lateral sciatic popliteal paralysis. Two patients died from their multiple injuries. Four patients developed infection: two healed without removing the nail, one was amputated (free flap failure). One patient consulted another unit. Ten patients who were not residents of our area were lost to follow-up. Dynamisation was performed in 31 patients (25.6%) at a mean 4.4 months. Four patients with delayed healing cured after a new nailing with secondary reaming. Delay to bone healing was related to the type of fracture (p < 0.01): 4.2 months for type A (AO classification), 5.2 months for type B and 5.9 months for type C. Bone healing was correlated with Gustilo type (p < 0.05): 4.5 months for types I, 4.6 months for type II, 5.8 months for types III. Six patients developed nonunion: four were revised with success after a new nailing and secondary reaming (two lost to follow-up). Delayed healing and non-union were related to type of fracture (A = 3.8%, B = 15.6%, C = 18%) and soft tissue damage (Gustilo I: 4.1%; II: 10.7%; III: 15.8%).

Discussion conclusion: Locked centromedullary nailing with reaming is appropriate when the skin wound is minimal; dynamisation and/or replacement of the nail with secondary reaming should be discussed early in case of delayed healing.


M.A. Hartzband

The debate about retaining or sacrificing the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) in total knee arthroplasty continues. Benefits of PCL retention cited by researchers include increased flexion, improved posterior rollback, improved quadriceps function, decreased post-tibial subluxation and reduced interface stress. On the other hand, other researchers contend that sacrificing the PCL affords latitude for correction of fixed deformity, improves exposure, ligament balancing, flexion and stability.

This paper reports on a bilateral knee study that is currently in progress and involves three separate sites/investigators. It describes Knee Society scores, range of motion and intra-operative metrics for 100 patients followed up for one to four years.


D. Brinkert J. Gaudias C. Boeri J.Y. Jenny

Purpose: Treatment of infection in patients with an unstable bone is based on removal of implants, bone resection, reconstruction, and external fixation. We report a retrospective series of 11 patients who developed post-traumatic osteitis of the tibia on an unstable bone who were treated by removal of all implants, cleaning, antibiotics, and internal fixation using a centromedullary locked nail.

Material and methods: The series included seven men and four women, mean age 32.4 years (16–56). Initially, there were two closed fractures and nine open fractures (Gustilo II: 4, IIIA: 1; IIIB: 4) treated by external fixation in six cases, centromedullary locked nailing in four and plate fixation in one. Bacteriology results were available for all deep surgical samples. The initial implants were removed in all cases, followed by debridement sparing soft tissue, and reaming of the bone. Adapted antibiotics were prolonged for three months. Refixation using a centromedullary locked nail was performed at the first revision time in two cases and later after cleaning in nine (mean delay 28 days, range 2–53 days). Two cases required a flap for cover.

Results: There were two failures: one due to recurrent infection with a different germ, the other due to necrosis of a latissimus dorsi flap followed by amputation. There were nine successes with bone healing in all cases (first intention in eight and after complementary bone graft in one) and no recurrent infection at the current mean follow-up of 2.6 years.

Discussion: These eleven cases have a common feature of no extensive bone necrosis or major bone defect. Bone resection was basically related to reaming with a minimalistic approach for soft tissue debridement. Reliable bacteriological examinations, effective antibiotic therapy, and prolonged and rapid skin cover are essential elements for success.

Conclusion: This experience is limited but does demonstrate that locked centromedullary nailing can be successful for the treatment of long bone infections on unstable bones, considering that this could be the ideal fixation method.


G. Cappaert

Discussion about the use of posterior stabilised or posterior retaining knee prostheses is likely to continue, although there seems to be an international trend towards posterior-sacrificing prosthesis. The remaining controversy hinges on whether stability in flexion is important, whether it is the condylar or epicondylar axis that is important, and whether platform orientation important.

This paper discusses the importance of stability. It suggests that neither the epicondylar nor the condylar axis can be used as absolutes, and that platform orientation plays an important role with rotational platform knee systems.


Ph. Chiron Ch. Besombes G. Biordano Ch. Csimma A. Valentin

Purpose: We studied the effect of rhBMP-2 in patients with open leg fractures to determine the impact on the number of revision procedures and on late bone healing or nonunion.

Material and method: Four hundred fifty patients with an open tibial shaft fracture that could be treated with a stratified nail (Gustilo-Anderson) were included in the study. Patients were randomly assigned to three treatment arms: control, with rhBMP-2 0.75 mg/ml, and with rhBMP-2 1.5 mg/ml. The proteins were carried on a biodegradable collagen sponge. The rhBMP impregnated sponge was placed on the wound in contact with the fracture after reduction and nailing. A dynamic or locked nail was used, with or without reaming.

Results: Follow-up data were available for 93% of the patients at 12 months after nailing. Compared with the control group, the number of reoperations for delayed healing was lower in the rhBMP-2 groups (p = 0.0017). Results were better in the 1.5 mg/ml group (−44%, RR=0.56, 95CI = 0.40-0.78, p=0.0005). The number of major reoperations (bone grafts new nailing) was considerably reduced (−49%, p = 0.0264). Between the 10th and 52nd week, the proportion of patients with a healed bone was significantly higher in the 1.5 mg/ml group than in the control group. At six months, 58% of the patients treated with 1.5 mg/ml had healed, compared with only 38% in the control group. Mean delay to healing was significantly lower in the 1.5 mg/ml group compared with controls (Kaplan Meier, p=0.022) and mean delay to healing in 50% of the patients was 145 days, compared with 184 days. Rate of infection was similar in the three groups, but there were significantly fewer infections in the 1.5 mg/ml group patients with a grade 3 fracture than in controls (p=0.0219). There was also a lower rate of fixation material failure in the 1.5 mg/ml group (p=0.0174). Anti rhBMP-2 antibodies (< 6%) or anti-collagen bovine antibodies (< 20%) were observed without presence of anti-human collagen antibodies and without any clinical expression or apparent effect on the clinical outcome.

Conclusion: At the dose of 1.5 mg/ml, rhBMP-2 associated with centromedullary nailing significantly improved outcome, with fewer reoperations for late healing and fewer major reoperations. Fracture healing was accelerated and rate of infection was lower in patients with the most severe fractures.


Full Access
G. Hooper

A patient’s response to knee assessment questionnaires is often subjective and linked to age and cultural expectations.

In New Zealand 150 people, split into three groups of ages 20 to 40 years, 40 to 60 years and over 60 years, were given three commonly used knee assessment questionnaires. All were examined objectively to determine that their knees were normal. Scores in these groups were compared to similar groups of Canadian subjects and the results analysed.

The results show significant differences in expectations between the age groups. Older people were reluctant to score maximum points for their normal knees. The Hospital for Special Surgery’s knee score gave the lowest results, followed by the Knee Society score. In the over-60-year group there was a significant difference between scores in New Zealand and Canada, with Canadians tending to score higher in all scores.

These findings have implications when it comes to comparing results of total knee arthroplasty in different countries and age groups. This study has been expanded to include other countries in an attempt to find a mathematical formula that will make future comparisons more relevant.


D. Gastambide P-L. Peyrou

Purpose: Since 1990, we have used specific material, presented to us by T. Tajima (Japan) during his visit in 1989 for percutaneous surgical cervical discectomy. French material was developed in 1992. The purpose of this work is to present our experience with this technique over the last ten years.

Material and methods: Indications were cervicobrachial neuralgia unresponsive to medical care and secondary to MRI or CT documented cervical disc herniation. We used the right anterolateral approach guided with the image amplifier for patients under local anaesthesia and neuroleptanalgesia ou general anaesthesia. A guide wire was positioned in the centre of the anterior aspect of the disc to insert a 2.5 mm working tube in the middle of the disc. A special trephin with an inverted inside thread induced an aspiration effect when turned into the disc, in line with the posterior wall of the vertebra. This enabled removal of several “carrots” measuring 1 to 2 cm long of discal or even disco-osteophytic material. The removal of the posterior third of the disc and the herniation was completed with a fine disc forceps.

Results: There were 85 procedures in 82 patients, mean age 42 years (35 women, 47 men): 57 at one level, mainly C5C6, 27 at two levels simultaneously, and one at three levels during the same operation. Mean follow-up for the 80 results known was 15 months (3–90 months). There were nine failures (two required conventional surgical fusion), 14 fair results, and 57 good results, giving a total of 88.75% good and fair results. Unlike percutaneous surgical lumbar discectomy, where good results at three months may deteriorate at two years, good results at three months after percutaneous cervical discectomy remained good at two years.

Discussion: This technique provides results as good as chemonucleolysis. An advantage of the technique that allergy or disco-osteophytic protrusions are not contraindications. We did not have any infection or injury to neighbouring tissue.

Conclusion: When rigorous operative procedures are used in this area with potential risk, percutaneous surgical cervical discectomy can be a useful routine therapeutic tool.


Full Access
G.G.A. Cappaert C.J. Grobbelaar

We give the preliminary results of 22 consecutive shoulder replacements done over a two-year period using a locally-produced prosthesis. Most of the replacements were done for traumatic reasons.


F. Delepine G. Delepine

Purpose: Benign giant-cell tumours of the lower radius constitute a therapeutic challenge. Curettage with bone graft is generally used, but in this localisation recurrence varies from 25% to 80% requiring repeated surgery with a high risk of losing function.

Material and methods: Eight patients (five men and three women), aged 27 to 59 years were treated by our team between 1972 and 1994. Primary care was given in our unit for six of them and two others were referred for secondary surgery after recurrence. Radiographically, five of the tumours were aggressive (two had already led to fracture) and three were progressing. Three patients were treated first by curettage and bone graft to fill the gap. For the five other patients treatment included enucleation, curretage, and cement filling followed by osteosynthesis and immediate mobilisation. All patients were followed regularly at visits every three months for two years then every six months for two more years and every year thereafter. Median follow-up was 15 years (six–25 years).

Results: There were 12 recurrences (including four in soft tissue) in five patients (three patients initially treated with bone filling and two others among the five treated with cement filling). Recurrence was noted six to 30 months after surgery. Two patients initially treated with bone filling later had an arthrodesis that was filled with cement. Patients whose gap had been filled with cement and who had recurrence were treated again with cement filling. At last follow-up, all patients were in remission but two of them had lost wrist mobility. According to the function criteria established by the European Society for Bone Tumours, the final functional result was excellent in five, good in two and fair in one. Patients treated with cement filling had wrist mobility comparable to the healthy side and did not exhibit any radiographic alteration of the joint line.

Conclusion: The risk of relapse is high after treatment of benign giant-cell tumours of the lower radius. Filling the gap with cement does not avoid the risk of relapse but can be repeated without major inconvenience as long as autologous bone does not have to be harvested and immediate mobilisation is possible. The long-term functional outcome is the best argument favouring cement filling for benign giant-cell tumours of the lower radius, even in case of voluminous, aggressive tumours leading to fracture or relapse.


G. Chick J.-Y. Alnot O. Silbermann-Hoffman

Solitary tumors of the peripheral nerves are uncommon and found to be benign in 90 p. 100 of the cases. They develop from the elements constituting the nerve and are generally schwannomas (80 p. 100). Other tumors are much more exceptional and exhibit wide histological variability.

The diagnosis of a tumor of the peripheral nerve must be envisaged for all cases with tumefaction or pain on the path of a nerve exacerbated at percussion. Magnetic resonance imaging is the preferred exploration technique, particularly useful in case of a deep tumor.

Preservation of nerve continuity is the underlying goal of the therapeutic strategy, irrespective of the type of tumor. Extricable tumors are to be distinguished from inextricable tumors. Extricable tumors (schwannomas, intranervous lipomas) displace nerve fiber bundles without penetrating into the bundle itself and can thus be resected without interrupting nerve continuity. Prognosis is excellent if no recurrence or degeneration occurs. In case of persistent symptoms, a new exploration may be required to search for other localized tumor(s) unperceived at the first procedure. Inextricable tumors (solitary neurofibromas, hemangiomas of the Schwann sheath, neurofibrolipomas) infiltrate the structural elements of the nerve fibers making complete excision impossible without altering the nerve fibers. Epineurotomy (associated with an interfascicular biopsy for pathology examination) allows decompression and can often provide symptom relief although moderate paresthesia may persist. Patients must be informed of this possibility prior to surgery. Any recent and rapidly evolving modification in the clinical findings is suggestive of recurrence and should be followed by revision exploration. Malignant degeneration has not been observed in solitary tumors to our knowledge. Our own experience with 51 cases is generally in agreement with reports in the literature.


M.A. Hartzband

A multicentre prospective study in the USA involves more than 75 investigators who have enrolled over 1 800 cases over nearly four years.

In a subset of this group, the performance of a tapered, cementless, porous stem is being evaluated. One surgeon has used this stem in 301 hips in 282 patients, of whom 141 are at one-year follow-up and 51 at two-year follow-up. An optional large proximal body stem was often used to optimise proximal femoral fill.

Clinical and radiological examinations were carried out immediately after surgery and at 6, 12 and 24 months, and demographic, Health Status (SF-12), and Harris Hip Score (HSS) data noted. From a preoperative mean of 41, the HSS improved to 88 and 92 at one-year and two-year follow-ups respectively. No progressive radiolucency, implant migration, gross loosening, osteolysis or polyethylene wear has been observed.


R.J. Bader G. Willmann

Limitations of the range of motion (ROM) of total hip prostheses lead to impingement causing dislocation and material failure. Due to wear, the femoral head penetrates polyethylene (PE)-sockets by about 0,1 mm/year (ceramic on PE) and 0,2–0,6 mm/year (metal on PE). Wear rate increases with steep acetabular cup position. In contrast to polyethylene, wear of alumina-ceramic cups appears to be independent from inclination angle and is only about 0,001 mm/year. Wear and design features may restrict the artificial joint mobility. The purpose of this study is to determine the effects of head penetration on ROM in relation to different cup positions.

Computer simulation was carried out with a three-dimensional CAD-program. 3-D models of modular cup, spherical head, and stem with cylindrical neck and 12/14 taper were generated. The femoral head was shifted 0, 1, 2, and 5 mm towards the pole of the cup. According to mean direction of penetration measured in retrieved PE-sockets, femoral head was also moved 0, 1, 2, and 5 mm in vertical direction. The joint motions were measured at different cup positions.

The study demonstrates that ROM is clearly reduced by increasing head penetration. After 2 mm penetration, e.g. maximum flexion is reduced by approx. 15° at 45° cup inclination. Restriction of flexion is more pronounced in the vertical penetration path. If the socket is placed in more horizontal position, less ROM of flexion, extension and abduction is observed. With steeper cup positions ROM of flexion increases but, as well as risk of dislocation, wear and penetration rate of PE sockets increase.

Modern hip prostheses should provide sufficient joint movements, precise implant positioning and low wear bearing couples avoiding penetration of femoral head. Additionally, design aspects like liner geometry, head-neck ratio have to be considered preventing impingement, dislocation or early failure by aseptic loosening.


C.J. Grobbelaar

Evaluating 30 years of total hip arthroplasty, we analyse the factors that determine longevity in terms of implant, design, materials, instrumentation and operative technique.

Simple implant design is important. Cups should be thick-walled and cemented. Particularly when cross-linked polyethylene is used, the size of the head bears little relation to the prevention of wear, but using too small a head seriously impairs stability. Improved cement and cementing techniques now facilitate exact placement. Traction instrumentation controls leg length equalisation and periarticular tissue tension, and further enhances stability.


A. Beck P. Augat G. Krischak F. Gebhard L. Kinzl L. Claes

In vitro experiments have shown, that stabilisation of the fibula in complete fractures of the lower leg give more stability compared to a single stabilisation of the tibia. However it is not known how this biomechanical conditions influence the bone healing process. To investigate the effect of fibula stability in tibia fracture healing tibial osteotomies in rats with and without fibula fractures were compared.

Male wistar rats (n=18) were operated by a transverse osteotomy of the proximal tibia of the left leg. Fracture was stabilised by intramedullary nailing. In 8 cases an additional closed fibula fracture was performed. The healing period was 21 days.

Each whole leg was examined by x-ray. After explantation of the tibia and removing of the nail and the fibula, the tibia was examined by CT-Scan, three-point-bending and histological evaluation.

Animals, who had a fibula fracture along with the tibia fracture presented with delayed healing. Density in CT-scan was 30% lower (p=0,0002) in animals with a fibula fracture (405mg/ccm, SD:64) compared to those without a fibula fracture (mean=577mg/ccm, SD:17). In three point bending the bending stiffness was 79% lower (p=0,0006) in animals with a fibula fracture (mean=252Nmm/mm, SD:118) compared to animals without a fibula fracture (mean=1219Nmm/mm, SD:478). The breaking force was 59% lower (p=0,0004) in animals with a fibula fracture (mean=17,5N, SD:6) compared to animals without a fibula fracture (mean=42,4N, SD:14).

Complete fractures of the lower leg healed considerably worse than solitary fractures of the tibia. We conclude that the missing of rotational stability of our k-wire fixation of the tibia with a unfixed fibula fracture is one of the reasons for the delay in fracture repair. The results support the in vitro findings of the biomechanical importance of the fibula for the stability of tibia fractures.


J. B. Queinnec O. Roche F. Sirveaux D. Molé

Purpose: Does the postoperative abduction brace facilitate healing after rotator cuff repair? We have answered this question empirically using, since 1995, a premodelled abduction brace for four weeks for all patients, together with early passive rehabilitation. The purpose of this work was to assess the efficacy of this brace and compare outcome with that in patients treated in 1994–1995 with and without the brace.

Material and methods: This retrospective analysis was conducted in 72 patients, mean age 58 years. Contant functional score and imaging of the tendon healing (arthroscan 56%, MRI 44%) were used as assessment criteria. Four homogeneous groups were identified: Group 1 (40 patients, mean age 55 years) was composed of patients with a distal tear of the supraspinatus; twenty patients in this group were treated with a “elbow-to-body” sling (group 1a) and twenty others with the abduction brace (group 1b); Group 2 (32 patients, mean age 60 years) was composed of patients with an intermediary tear of the supraspinatus, partially extending anteriorly or posteriorly, fifteen patients in this group were treated with a “elbow-to-body” sling (group 2a) and seventeen others with the abduction brace (group 2b).

Results: Mean follow-up was 49 months. The weighted Constant score improved from 57.3% to 89.1%. Imaging demonstrated recurrent tears in 25 patients (35%). In group 1 (distal tear of the supraspinatus), the weighted Constant score at last follow-up was 89% (93% in group 1a and 86% in group 1b). There were eight recurrent tears (20%), (25% in group 1a and 15% in group 1b). Use of the abduction brace (group 1a) had no effect. In group 2 (intermediat tear of the supraspinatus), weighted Constant score was 88% (82% in group 2a and 94% in group 2b). There were seventeen recurrent tears (53%) (71% in group 2a and 41% in group 2b). At last follow-up, there was no significant difference for functional score or tear recurrence.

Discussion and conclusion: These findings suggest the postoperative abduction brace is not beneficial after repair of non-retracted distal cuff tears. On the contrary, for intermediate tears, it allows a clear improvement in the final Constant score and a lower rate of recurrent tears. This study provides information useful for choosing the postoperative management of patients undergoing repair of rotator cuff tears.


R. Golele E.J. Raubenheimer D. Potgieter

We aimed to assess static and dynamic bone changes in patients with rickets.

Transcortical iliac crest biopsies of 40 hospitalised children with rickets were taken after administration of two cycles of tetracycline 10 days apart to label new bone formation. Histomorphometric analysis was performed on appropriately stained undecalcified sections. Static and dynamic bone changes measured included the volume of bone and osteoid, trabecular and cortical bone dimensions and resorptive and mineralisation activities. We compared the results with normal values and noted the nature of the mineralisation fronts.

Trabecular osteoid volumes of 31 (78%) patients were above the normal range of 1.9% (±. 0.4%). Nine patients (22%) had atrophic osteoid. Of these, five patients were over the age of 20 years and therefore regarded as having osteomalacia and excluded from the series. Of the remaining four patients, one had renal disease, two had rickets associated with kwashiorkor-marasmus syndrome, and in one no cause could be found.

Tetracycline labelling was found more sensitive than subjective evaluation of the mineralisation fronts. Despite a balanced hospital diet, a bone formation rate of zero was found in three patients, indicating a need for vitamin D and mineral supplementation. In seven cases, decreased mineralisation lag times indicated a response to the balanced diet.

This study shows that histological analysis of labelled bone biopsies is helpful not only diagnostically but also in assessing response to management of deficiency states in children.


E.E.G. Lautenbach

Health fund providers often require objective motivation for surgery, and patients often try to pressurise surgeons into operating. The author developed a scoring system to weigh up objectively the indications and contra-indications for and urgency of joint replacement.

A considerably expanded Harris Hip Score and American Knee Society ratings are used. Rather than using a subjective adjective to evaluate pain, it is objectively evaluated by type and frequency of analgesic. The totality of the patient’s condition is considered in assessing functional ability, particularly with regard to other affected joints and the patient’s ability to perform normal activities of daily living. Taken into account is how much walking, climbing and stair-climbing a patient’s work demands and whether getting to work requires a long walk or use of public transport. The functional demands of daily home life are assessed, and also how much assistance is available to the patient.

By adding the American scores to the additional scores for pain and functional ability, and then subtracting that total from the functional demand, one arrives at a score for the degree of compromise. The scoring includes a prediction of the risk of morbidity and mortality. When this risk is balanced by the degree of compromise, one arrives at a score for contra-indication. Put another way, pain + functional ability – functional demand = compromise, and compromise x risk of mortality and morbidity = contraindication.


A. Baburam

Reports on bleeding tendencies in osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) are rare in the literature. Abnormalities are attributed to a defect in the vessel wall.

In a prospective study of 36 patients with known OI, we used the thrombo-elastogram (TEG) to survey haemostatic competence. TEG, which can indicate the nature of a haemostatic defect within an hour, provides a graphic representation of clotting. The study was conducted from July 2000 to April 2001. The ages of the 18 male and 18 female patients ranged from 9 months to 21 years (mean 10.7 years). Three had type-I OI, 27 type-III and six type-IV. Blood specimens were taken according to a TEG protocol and, to correlate with other bleeding tests, specimens were analysed for platelet count, prothrombin time (PT) and partial thromboplastin time (PTT).

Platelet counts were normal in all patients. PT and PTT were normal in all but one patient. When TEG results were compared with standard values, 30 patients had normal results, four had increased coagulation and two had a decreased coagulable state directly attributed to platelet defects.

Haemostatic defects in OI may be due to platelet function abnormalities. TEG, an inexpensive, simple, sensitive and reliable screening instrument, should be used before surgery to identify bleeding tendencies in OI patients.


I.C. Kurta P.J. Richards M. Dove A.A. Rahmatall J. Dove G. MacKenzie

The aim of this study was to assess the accuracy of pedicle screw placement using NAVITRAK, a system of Computer Assisted Orthopaedic Surgery and conventional fluoroscopic technique.

Twelve porcine lumbar spines were scanned pre-operatively by computer tomography for 3-D reconstruction ( 1 mm slice thickness, 1mm increment and 2.5 mm pitch ).

Computer randomisation divided the specimens between surgeons of different experience, and the two pedicles of each vertebral level between the two surgical techniques. Stainless steel screws (6.5 spongiosa) were inserted.

Post-operatively, fluoroscopic- and CT imaging were blindly assessed for accuracy by two independent observers, and compared to macroscopic dissection of the spinal segments.

Of 168 pedicles in 12 porcine specimens, 166 received a pedicle screw. Two pedicle screw placements were abandoned. Sixyty-one screws (73%) were placed satisfactorily with the CAOS system, 56 (67.5%) in the conventional group.

In 26 pedicles the screws were placed unsatisfactorily (12 pedicles (46.2%) with the NAVITRAK system and 14 pedicles (53.8%) with the conventional technique.

The NAVITRAK system in combination with stainless steel screws showed a difference of 5.5% in misplacement in favour for the computer assisted technique.


G. Zanoli R. Johnsson G. Gunnarsson B. Strömqvist

Aim of many surgical operations on the spine is very often to achieve a solid fusion between two or more vertebrae (arthrodesis). Describing lumbar spine mobility radiographically has been determined to be very imprecise with measurement errors of three to six mm in the sagittal plane. Using roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis (RSA) it is possible to perform clinical kinematic lumbar studies with high accuracy. Many experimental studies have presented basic data on the stabilising implant effect in human cadaver lumbar spines, but no study compared the in vivo stabilising effect in different types of implant.

The RSA was performed in a radiographic set-up with two 40° angulated roentgen tubes with simultaneous exposures. A combined reference plate and calibration device with 0.8 mm tantalum balls at known positions was situated between the patient and the uniplanar film cassette, enabling simultaneous calibration and patient examination. At each RSA the patients were examined in supine and erect positions without corset. The translatory movements, induced by the change in position, of the 0.8 mm tantalum balls implanted into the fused vertebrae were calculated by computed data processing. These translations visualised the movements of the most proximal vertebra of the fusion in relation to the most distal.

The present study has demonstrated the in vivo stability of lumbar fusion augmented with transpedicular screws to be adequate. Sagittal translation seems to be easier to elicit than movements along the other three-dimensional axes. A widely decompressed and destabilised vertebra without screw fixation increases the risk for persisting intervertebral translations. The RSA technique described seems to be a good way for comparing the in vivo behaviour of different implant systems


G.C. O’Toole T. Abuzakuk P. Murray

Previous reports have indicated that elderly patients suffer more operative complications than younger patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty (THR)

We reviewed 46 consecutive patients over 85 years of age at the time of THR. All patients were at least 3 years post-op at the time of review. Pre and post operative D’Aubigne-Postel Hip Scores were assigned. Length of stay, transfusion rates, intra-operative blood loss and patient satisfaction were also noted. Statistical comparisons were mode with a control group of patients, average age 66.3 years.

The average age at the time of operation was 86.6 (range 85–92) years. The average follow up was 52.8 (range 38–86) months. The average hospital stay was 21.1 (range 12–40, median 18) days. Pre-operative D’Aubigne-Postel Score averaged 8.4 (range 1–14) points, post-operative D’Aubigne-Postel Score averaged 13.1 (range 9–18) points. Subjective satisfaction was high. There were no operative complications and no dislocations during the follow up period. There were no deaths within one year of surgery. Four of the 45 patients died during the 3 year follow up period.

When compared to the control group, patients over the age of 85 years had an increased intra-operative blood loss, p< 0.001, they also had an increased blood transfusion at rate, p=0.0005. Patients over the age of 85 remained in hospital longer, p=0.0002. Comparing D’Aubigne-Postel Score, patients over the age of 85 years benefited as much as the control group, p=0.0001.

We conclude that THR is the over 85 years old patients is a safe procedure and yields good functional results.


J.N. Argenson X. Flecher E. Ryembault J.M. Aubaniac

Purpose: Implantation of a prosthesis on a remodelled femur can cause technical difficulties affecting the outcome of the arthroplasty. We performed a tridimensional study of the femoral anatomy before prosthesis implantation for sequelar congenital hip dislocation.

Material and method: The series included 312 hips in 262 patients. The same radiography and computed tomography work-up was perfomred in all patients. There were 288 women and 84 men, men age 56 years. Mean weight was 66 kg and mean height was 163 cm. The crowe classification was 195 dysplasia, 123 dislocations (41% class I, 27% class II, 13% class III, 19% class IV). Telemetric measurements were: femoral isthma, the centre of the lesser trochanter, limb length discrepancy, the cephalo-cervico-diaphyseal angle. Computed tomographic measurements were: anterio-posterior and mediolateral dimensions and femur funneling, helitorsion between the bichondylar plane and the upper femur, anteroposterior diameter of the acetabulum.

Results: The mean mediolateral and anteroposterior diameters of the femoral canal at the isthma were 9.8 and 13.1 cm respectively in dysplasia and 9.3 and 12.6 cm, 9.4 and 12.7, and 9.7 and 13.6 cm in I, II, and III–IV congenital dislocations respectively. The femoral funneling index varied from 1.9 to 7.6 in dysplasia and from 2.6 to 7.9, 2.1 to 8.4 and 2.1 to 8.7 in I, II, and III–IV congenital dislocations respectively. The mean cephalo-cervico-diaphyseal angle was 129.3°, 131.9°, 136.8°, and 127.4° respectively. Maximal leg length discrepancy was 45, 57, 71, and 82 cm respectively. Mean helitorsion was 22.9° (1°–52°), 36.4° (8°–86°), 43.2° (2°–82°- and 38.4° (6°–68°) respectively. The mean anteroposterior diameter of the acetabulum was 52, 51.2, 53.1; and 49.6 cm respectively.

Discussion and conclusion: The dysplastic or dislocated femur is narrower than the normal femur with wide variations in funneling and cephalo-cervico-diphyseal angle. The mean difference in leg length increases gradually with helitorsion but with wide individual variability, irrespective of the grade. These tridimensional anatomic data can be useful for predicting difficulties in prosthetic treatment of these patients.


H. Hamcha J. Fenerean P. Pries

Purpose: The purpose of this experimental study was to compare fixation with hooks and screws inserted posteriorly. A digitalized analysis using finite element analysis was applied.

Material and methods: We used seven human thoracic spines for this experimental study. We identified 49 pairs of two vertebrae. Traction was applied to rupture, the maximal force at rupture measured with an Instron. Fixations were made with four pedicle screws and two pediculolaminar clamps. For the digitalized study, the modellised vertebra was composed of 63000 nodes and 14000 elements. Calculations were made in the elastic domain using the finite elements abacus method.

Results: Traction on the peidculolaminar clamp produced a fracture at the base of the pedicles in all cases. When screw fixation was used, there was a medial fissuration of the base of the pedicle. For hooks, pull-out force was 1108±510 Newtons. It was 820±418 Newtons for the 4-mm diameter screws and 1395±425 Newtons for the 5-mm screws. T5–T6 and T7–T8 assemblies ruptured more easily. The screw model demonstrated a concentration of the stress forces at the medial level of the pedicle, inside the spinal canal. Use of a long screw did not reduce stress significantly. The hook model demonstrated maximal stress force at the lower level of the pedicles.

Discussion and conclusion: From a mechanical point of view, screw fixation is best, but this type of fixation did not fulfil all expectations. The results showed that the force for 4-mm screws is 23% weaker than for hooks and that 5-mm screws only provide a 12% better force than hooks. There are two mechanisms for pull-out, stripping of the bone threads, or rupture of the pedicles. The bone thread strips when the screw threads do not penetrate the cortical bone sufficiently because the screw is too small. On the contrary, larger screws risk injuring the pedicle. Pedicle rupture is observed for much higher stress force and constitutes the upper limit of resistance. This leads us to hypothesise that in most cases, screw pull-out occurs by bone thread stripping. Screws are less effective if they cannot be correctly anchored in the cortical, probably the cause of their relative weakness. The screw diameter should be chosen to adapt to the diameter of each pedicle. Stress forces would be transmitted better from the screw to the pedicle. The vertebrae are exposed to greater stress forces with hooks. The digitalised study confirmed that use of long screws crossing the entire vertebra did not provide a sufficient diminution of stress on the pedicles to justify their use.


G. Giordano M. Mouzins J.L. Tricoire Ph. Chiron B. Malavaud J. Puget

Purpose: Van Den Bosch reported diminished quality of sexual intercourse in 40% of the patients victims of pelvic fractures. Using the Rosen self-administered questionnaire, five aspects of sexual activity were analysed: erectile function and orgasm, sexual desire, satisfaction with sexual intercourse and overall satisfaction. This retrospective series included patients with pelvic ring fractures in 1999.

Material and methods: The situation of 46 patients, aged 30 to 70 years was assessed with the International Index of Erectile Function self-administered questionnaire and a questionnaire concerning the patient’s status. The radiographic analysis included the Tyle classification. Associated injury to the membranous urethra were noted. Students t test was used to compare the IIEF scores in the study population and in a control population constituted for validation of the questionnaire.

Results: Forty-six patients responded (60.1%). None of the patients complained of disorders before the accident. Thirty-seven patients had sexual activities during the four weeks before responding including 11 (29.7%) with variable degrees of dyserection. Pubic dysfunction was the only factor associated with impaired sexual activity, leading to lower satisfaction and erectile function. There was no relationship between the five IIEF items and age, duration of follow-up, Tyle classification, branch fractures.

Discussion: This study is the first using the IIEF score to ascertain the degree of male sexual dysfunction after pelvic fractures. This self-administered questionnaire provides a tool adapted to the patient’s needs. Compared with the control group, we noted a prevalence of erectile dysfunction to the order of 30% with a significant diminution of overall satisfaction (p < 0.05). There was no significant correlation between male sexual sequelae, type of fracture and the notion of urethra injury. Pubic dysjunction is regularly correlated with decreased erectile function and overall satisfaction, probably in relation with injury to the cavernous bodies. Impaired sexual function, found long after the trauma (mean follow-up 26.8 years) suggests a permanent injury.

Conclusion: The IIEF self-administered questionnaire is interesting for young male patients victims of pelvic trauma, particularly in case of pubic dysjunction. Used during rehabilitation, it can identify patients with sexual sequelae (erectile function) in an overall medical and medicolegal management scheme.


J. Langa

The Orthopaedic National Programme aims to co-ordinate the provision of efficient orthopaedic and trauma service to central, provincial and rural hospitals. The country is divided into southern, central and northern regions, each with a central hospital with orthopaedic surgeons. The 1 500-bed Central Hospital in Maputo is the national referral centre and the teaching hospital for Eduardo Mondlane University. The orthopaedic department has 200 beds and 12 orthopaedic surgeons. In each provincial hospital an orthopaedic surgeon provides specialist care and supports and supervises the surgical paramedical staff at district and rural hospitals.

The referring hospitals have been equipped to provide conservative treatment. The types of fractures that should be treated surgically have been clearly defined. In some rural hospitals with surgical facilities, there are well-trained surgical paramedics, but where possible patients are treated conservatively. We guarantee the supply of equipment and material and provide regular refresher training.

In Mozambique fractures constitute more than 70% of the orthopaedic pathology. In adults the most common are fractures of the femur, tibia, forearm and arm. In children under 16 years, 60% of hospital admissions are for trauma, usually sustained in falls from trees or vehicle accidents. Infections account for 30% of admissions, and other causes for the remainder. In contrast with developed countries, we have few patients with fractures due to osteoporosis.


Ch. Trojani S. Piche P. Eude C. Avidor S. June C. Argenson F. de Peretti

Purpose: We report the operative technique and preliminary results for percutaneous osteosynthesis in the supine position with computed tomography guidance for acetabular fractures without joint displacement.

Material and methods: This prospective study conducted in a single unit included a consecutive non-randomised series of 55 patients who underwent surgery for an unstable pelvic injury between June 1996 and December 2000 under computed tomography guidance. In ten cases, the radiographic and computed tomographic analysis demonstrated a coronal fracture of one of the columns without joint displacement accessible for anteroposterior screw fixation. There were eight men and two women, mean age 35 years.

Surgery: the ten patients were operated on in the supine position, in the scanner room under the same aseptic conditions as in the operation room. The reference computed tomography slice was the Corse slice. The femoral vasculo-nervous bundle was identified. A threaded guide wire was inserted perpendicuallary to the fracture line, anteriorly to posteriorly (Cap Corse technique). A perforated screw with a 7.3 mm diameter was used to fix the fracture. Minimal post-surgical surveillance was 48 hours. Weight bearing was not authorised for six weeks to three months. Al patients were followed prospectively, and mean follow-up ws 16 months (12–36).

Results: Traction was lifted immediately after surgery in all cases. All the patients got up the day after surgery. Mean hospital stay was less than five days postoperatively in all cases. There were no complications (vascular, neurologic, infectious) and no secondary displacement. At last follow-up, he Postel Merle d’Aubigné score was 18 for eight patients, 16 for one and 14 for one. Two patients showed radiographic signs of degenerative hip disease.

Discussion: This percutaneous osteosynthesis method using computed tomographic guidance is reliable (100% well positioned screws) and avoids the need for traction in bed. Morbidity is low (no complications). Even though these eight patients did not present clinical and radiographic signs of osteoarthritis, this technique did not avoid the risk of degenerative hip disease in two patients.

Conclusion: An alternative to traction, percutaneous osteo-synthesis with computed tomographic guidance performed in the supine position for acetabular fractures is a cost-effective procedure.


E. Schnaid C. Schnitzler M.B.E. Sweet

We studied the histomorphometry of the trabecular bone of 19 black men and 15 black women over the age of 60 years who had sustained fractured neck of femur (FNF) as a result of minor trauma. The findings were correlated with indicators of iron overload (ferritin and vitamin C).

A striking feature was the presence of iron granules in the bone marrow of 16 of the men and nine of the women, together with fibrosis. Present in large numbers, the granules were quantitated. There were significantly more iron granules in the men than in the women (p =0.05). Ferritin levels were higher in those patients with large numbers of granules than in those with few or no granules. There was no clear correlation with the indicators, bone formation or resorption.

We concluded that iron overload is a strong aetiological factor in black male FNF patients. In postmenopausal female FNF patients, the possible aetiological role of iron overload is complicated by hormone deficiency.


M.B.E. Sweet A. Biscardi E. Schnaid A. Schepers A. Coelho

Among elderly Caucasians, fractures of the femoral neck are a common cause of disability. Intertrochanteric and intra-capsular fractures occur equally often, and both are about three times more common in women than in men. Risk factors include neurological impairment, malnutrition, impaired vision, malignancy and decreased activity.

We found that in black South Africans femoral neck fractures occur equally often in men and in women. Intracapsular fractures are comparatively rare, occurring in one of every eight female patients and one of every 3.5 male patients. Further, we found that in both black men and black women the femoral neck was consistently and significantly shorter than in whites.

These results suggest that a short femoral neck may offer protection not only against intracapsular fracture, but also possibly against fracture of the femoral neck in general. In addition, greater cortical thickness in black people probably offers further protection.


P. Kouyoumdjian G. Asencio V. Leclerc R. Hammami B. Megy R. Bertin H. Triki

Purpose: This prospective study was conducted to evaluate correction of post-traumatic deformity of the thoracolumbar and lumbar spine at consolidation after posterior instrumentation associated with transpedicular graft.

Material and method: The analysis began in 1998 and included 11 patients (mean age 37 years, age range 19–62 years) with lumbar (two L2) or thoracolumbar (four T12 and five L1) fractures. The Magerl classification was A1=2, A2=3, mixed=3. Inclusion criteria were: age < 65 years, regional kyphosis > 10°), intact pedicles, relative gain on local and/or regional kyphosis peroperatively > 70% after correction for reduction-distraction. Posterior instrumentation used the V-V assembly in two cases and 2VV-1VC assembly in nine. Evaluation criteria were, postoperatively and at consolidation: local kyphosis, corrected regional kyphosis, Cobb angle in the frontal plane. Autologous graft tissue harvested from the iliac crest was introduced via the right and left pedicle into the damaged vertebra using an adapted funnel after raising the vertebral plate with a spatula.

Results: Mean follow-up was 11 months (range 8–18). Associated procedures were laminectomy in three cases and posterior graft in two. Preoperatively local kyphosis was 19° (12° to 37°) and regional kyphosis was 17° (10° to 35°). Postoperatively, local and regional kyphosis were 4.5° (0–11°) and −2° (−10 to 5°) giving a mean relative gain of 80% (SD = 0.1). Mean relative gain at consolidation was 75% (SD = 0.2 for local kyphosis and 86% for regional kyphosis. The correction was statistically significant. There was no significant difference between the correction postoperatively and at consolidation.

Discussion: Transpedicular grafting associated with posterior instrumentation can avoid anterior access in a certain number of cases. Indications are fractures in patients under 65 years of age with a regional kyphosis > 10° and an important anterior defect after reduction (> 40% reduction in height). All patients achieved bone healing without significant loss of correction. The limitations of this technique include the requirement for intact pedicles, a posterior wall displacement of less than 60% and a peroperative relative gain greater than 70% for the local and/or regional kyphosis. An anterior approach must be associated in other cases.

Conclusion: Transpedicular grafting is a simple technique allowing true reconstruction of the vertebral body. It can avoid a certain number of supplementary anterior approaches.


E. Dehoux Ph. Trouchard C. Mensa Ph. Segal

Purpose of the study: Cases of serious trauma to the cervical spine requiring surgical management in older subjects goes in hand with the general trend towards a more active elderly population. We analyzed retrospectively our experience with 28 patients cared for in our unit from 1990 to 1999.

Patients and methods: Mean age of these 11 women and 17 men was 73 years (range 65–93). High-energy trauma was the cause of the cervical injury in 12 patients (42%). The others were victims of falls in their homes. This later cause explains the long delay to care (21 days on the average with a range from zero days to six months). The six patients who had injuries to the upper cervical spine had fractures of the odontoid process secondary to a fall. The mobile segment of the spine was involved in most of the injuries involving the lower cervical spine (eleven severe sprains and six dislocations) resulting from high-energy trauma in half of the cases. These injuries occurred above an osteoarthritic block. Half of the patients had neurological complications: eleven immediate, three late. The Franckel classification was: A=2, C=4, D=7. The same repair technique was used for the upper an lower cervical spine. Five of the six fractures of the odontoid process were fixed with a Bölher screw, and one with posterior fusion. An anterior graft with plate fixation was used 18 times for the lower spine. Roy Camille posterior fixation was used four times because of the irreducible nature of the fracture or because of the need for posterior fusion.

Results: Morbidity was high. Seven patients (25%) had serious cardiorespiratory complications leading to death in five patients. All these patients had neurological sequelae (Franckel A and C). For the other patients, the postoperative period was uneventful and similar to that observed in younger patients (immobilization, neurological recovery, consolidation).

Discussion: The high frequency of upper cervical spine trauma observed in our series is also reported in the literature. It increases with age. The frequency of neurological involvement was identical to that observed by Roth and Spivak. Prognosis was poor in case of neurological involvement. The appropriateness of surgery in Franckel A patients may be questionable. Surgery cannot avoid the risk of mortality in these patients but it can enable mobilisation and nursing care, avoiding the need for a halo jacket.

Conclusion: Spinal trauma in the elderly can be managed similarly to that in young adults, at least in cases without major neurological involvement.


C. Court H. Sari-Ali J.Y Nordin

Purpose: Rotation dislocation of C1-C2 subsequent to trauma is not often described in adults. The clinical, radiological and computed tomographic diagnostic criteria are not well known and can lead to false positive diagnosis. The Fielding classification was described for children. We report five cases of traumatic rotation dislocation of C1-C2 in adults and propose computed tomographic criteria for diagnosis. The Fielding classification is discussed.

Material and methods: In two cases, the diagnosis was suggested by the clinical presentation and the plain x-rays. In three cases, it was revealed by the systematic CT performed in multiple trauma patients. In three cases, MRI enabled visualisation of ligament tears (transverse ligament, alaire ligament). Finally, the C1-C2 relations in neutral position and in rotation were studied on the CT scans in the study patients and in ten healthy subjects to establish diagnostic criteria. The patients were treated with cervical traction until reduction was achieved (checked with CT) then with an “Indian”collar for 45 days. One patient did not wear the collar and experienced a recurrent dislocation.

Results and discussion: In patients who can be examined, the diagnosis is suggested by suboccipital pain, slight rotation inclination of the head to the contralateral side, impossibility of turning the head to the opposite side beyond the mid line. The open-mouth x-ray can be a source of false positive diagnosis but can be suggestive. The CT scan must be performed under precise conditions: patient positioned without rotation or inclination of the head (false positive); superposition of the two slices passing through the C1 and C2 faces (unilateral loss of congruency); sagittal reconstruction. In case of doubt, homo and contralateral rotation slices can provide more sensitive images. The five dislocations were uin-lateral (Fielding type II) with posterior displacement in two cases, a finding not described in this classification. In addition, type I could be a variant of the normal (as seen in control scans). Treatment in the early phase is conservative with reduction by simple cervical traction (verification on CT), followed by complementary immobilisation until ligament healing.

Conclusion: The diagnosis of traumatic rotation dislocation of C1-C2 in adults is based on CT evidence. Certain injuries should be added to complete the Fielding classification. When recognised early, this rotation dislocations can be treated conservatively.


M.A. Pinnington C.F. Dowrick E. Thornton

The aim of this study was to develop a qualitative health diary with predictive validity on outcome in patients with new episodes of low back pain.

Diaries have been used as a tangible record of everyday process. In the medical setting, diaries have been used to help patients document symptoms and feelings. As a qualitative tool, health diaries exhibit many of the advantages of in-depth interviews, in that they yield a personal account of illness. far richer than by quantitative techniques. The importance of predicting outcome of LBP in the early stages is well documented, given its prevalence and drain on health-care resources. The condition lends itself well therefore to a diary study.

New episodes of low back pain consulting their GP in three general practices completed a 7 day free-text health diary and a series of validated questionnaires, designed to measure function (RMDQ), anxiety/depression (HAD) and general demographics. Questionnaires were repeated at 2 and 6 weeks. Patient outcome was then categorised into one of 3 groups: fully-recovered, partly-recovered, or not-recovered based on RMDQ scores. Diary entries are now being analysed thematically using well-established methods of qualitative thematic analysis to search for predictive validity of diary data.

At 6 weeks, 47 patients had fully recovered, 26 had partly recovered and 12 had not recovered. Preliminary coding of diary entries has identified the emergence of 11 primary themes. Physical/pain, employment, reflection, emotional, functional, coping, temporality, expectations, social, rolelduties, medication. Findings to date suggest that patients who don’t recover at six weeks make reference to far more emotional and negative physical/coping/functional discourse in their diaries than those patients who recover partly or fully.

There is evidence of the emergence of themes common to patients who have not recovered at 6 weeks and who may be at greatest risk of chronicity. If further qualitative analysis confirms this trend, the free-text health diary may prove to be an easily administered, cost-effective and valid predictor of outcome in the very early stages of an episode of LBP.


C. McMahon J. Funk J. Crandall L. Tourret C. Bass

Axial loading of the foot/ankle complex is an important injury mechanism in vehicular trauma, responsible for severe injuries such as calcaneus, talus and tibial pilon fractures. Axial loading may be applied to the leg externally, by the toepan and/or pedals, as well as internally by active muscle tension applied through the Achilles tendon during pre-impact bracing. In order to evaluate the effect of active muscle tension on the injury-tolerance of the foot/ankle complex, axial impact tests were performed on isolated lower legs, with and without experimentally stimulated muscle tension applied through the Achilles’ tendon. Acoustic emission was used to determine the exact time of fracture during the tests. The primary fracture mode was calcaneal fracture in both groups, but tibial pilon fractures occurred more frequently with the addition of Achilles tension. A linear regression model was developed that describes the expected axial loading injury tolerance of the foot/ankle complex in terms of specimen age, gender, mass and level of Achilles tension.


Y. Allieu B Coulet M. Chammas O. Delatre H. Tournebise F. Omanna

Purpose: Reactivation of upper limb function in high-tetraplegia patients requires two successive procedures: restoration of elbow extension, then construction of the key grip. Performing both procedures during the same operative time can reduce the operative time. We compared this combined technique with the classical programme, particular for patients requiring transfer of the brachioradialis to construct the key grip.

Material and methods: The study series included 16 upper limbs in 15 tetraplegic patients. Two distinct operative programmes were used. Group A (nine limbs): transfer of the posterior deltoid to the triceps and active key grip by transfer of the brachioradialis on the flexor pollicis longus. According to the Giens classification there were three group 2, five group 3 and one group 4. Group B (seven limbs): transfer of the biceps on the triceps and passive tenodesis key grip. The Giens classification was five group 2 and two group 3. Five of these limbs exhibited supination attitude of the forearm that was treated initially with isolated osteotomy of the radius. Mean follow-up was ten months. A control group underwent the same surgical programmes but with two distinct operative times.

Results: Mean hospital stay was shortened compared with the control group 4.1±0.8 months versus 10±1.0 months). Elbow extension force according to the BMRC scale was 3.8±0.6 in Group A versus 3.5 for the control group and 3.2±0.5 for Group B compared with 2.8 for the control group. Mean active key grip force was 1.8±0.9 kg for Group A versus 1.9 for controls and 0.9±0.6 kg for the passive key grips in Group B versus 0.9 for controls. Functional independence improved postoperatively, the QIF improved from 40.0±18.0 to 55.2±17.0.

Discussion: This work demonstrated that a single operation shortens hospital stay without affecting the final outcome and that the brachioradial can be transferred on the flexor pollicis longus for reactivation of elbow extension. In our experience, only 46% of the tetraplegic patients starting a functional surgery programme benefit from reactivation of the elbow and hand. Procedures performed during a single operation allow a more systematic approach.


CH. Chantelot T. Aihonnou G. Robert G. Gueguen H. Migaud C. Fontaine

Purpose: The few reports of long-term outcome of Kien-böck disease are helpful in establishing therapeutic indications.

Material and methods: Between 1970 and 1995, radius shortening procedures were performed in 44 patients. Among these 31 patients (eight women and 23 men), mean age 32 years (18–48) at surgery, with 33 operated wrists (18 right, 11 left, 2 bilateral, 19 dominant hands) were reviewed clinically (25 patients by an independent observer, three by their family physician) and radiologically (26 patients) or responded to a phone interview (five patients) at a mean 12 years follow-up (4–19 years). Four patients had died, nine were lost to follow-up. Before surgery the pain was intense (Michon scale): 32 grade I, one grade II. According to Lichtman, there were three grade I, seven grade II, eighteen grade IIIa and five grade IIIb. There was one case of haematoma and one reflex dystrophy, five late consolidations and five nonunions (three diaphyseal out of eight and two metaphyseal out of 25).

Results: The Michon pain score was variable, 11 grade IV, six grade III, nine grade II, but also seven grade I and four secondary arthrodeses. Postoperative amplitudes ere: flexion 50°, extension 53°, abduction 20°, adduction 29°, pronation 83°, supination 74°. Mean amplitudes increased for flexion (+12°), extension (+13°), abduction (+6°), and adduction (+11°), but decreased for pronation (−3°) and supination (−13°). The postoperative wrist fore (Jamar) was 32 kg (80° of other side). Eighteen patients were able to resume an occupational activity, requiring equivalent (14 patients, including 12 manual labourers) or greater (two patients) wrist force. At last follow-up the Lichtman classification was one grade I, four grade II, eight grade III1, three grade IIIb, and seven grade IV. The pre- to postoperative radiography comparison (26 wrists) showed two improvements, seven stabilisations, 14 aggravations, and three arthrodeses. There were also three cases of ulnocarpal impingement (one reoperated). Discussion: the factors predictive of good outcome were minimally advanced disease (Lichtman), little reduction in lunatum height (Stahl), absence of carpal collapse (McMurtry), absence of complication.

Conclusion: Shortening of the radius is an excellent procedure to Lichtman grade IIIa. Results are less satisfactory for grade IIIb but still acceptable compared with resections of the first row or intracarpal arthrodesis. To avoid the risk of ulnocarpal impingement, it would be preferable to reorient the glenoid or shorten the capitatum rather than shorten the radius in patients with a normal radioulnar index.


K.P. Thosago D.E. Lekalakala

Segmental fractures of the femoral neck and shaft present a treatment challenge. A diagnostic difficulty sometimes arises because the classical signs present in an isolated fractured neck of femur are masked by the associated femoral shaft fracture. Especially where there is no preoperative pelvic radiograph, the femoral neck fracture may present as an incidental finding at the time the shaft fracture is treated. Because much of the impact at the time of injury is taken up by the femoral shaft, the fracture of the femoral neck is often undisplaced.

Between January 1995 and April 2001, we treated 36 patients with ipsilateral femoral neck and shaft fractures at GaRankuwa Hospital. Within 24 to 48 hours of injury, eight patients were treated with AO screws and DCP, two with DHS and DCP, 13 with Recon nails and 13 with UFN and Miss-a-nail. In four months 28 patients went on to uneventful union. Complications included two cases of implant failure, two of avascular necrosis, two of failed reduction of femoral neck fracture, one of sepsis and one of nonunion of the femoral shaft. The complications, especially implant failure and failed reduction, occurred mainly in patients who were operated on at night and by junior members of staff.


P. Buma R. Stoop P. van der Kraan C. Billinghurst A. Hollander R. Poole W. van den Berg

Collagen type type II destruction was studied after induction of experimental OA by ACL-transection in the rat. Damage was investigated by analysis of type II collagen neoepitope expression. Cleavage of type II collagen by collagenases (MMP’s) was detected by the Col2-3/4C-short antibody and collagen denaturation by Col2-3/4m. Rats were sacrificed after 2, 7, 14, 28 and 70 days. Immunostaining was performed using the Col2-3/4C (Collagenase-cleavage site) or the Col2-3/4m antibody (denatured type II collagen).

The first changes after the ACL-transsection were chondrocyte death at the margins of the articular cartilage of both tibia and femur. At day seven a pannus-like tissue protruded from the synovial tissue over the dead cartilage. Underneath the pannus-like tissue a marked staining for the collagenase-cleavage site was observed. The dead cartilage was replaced by fibrocartilage within 4 weeks after which the staining for the collagenase cleavage neoepitope had completely disappeared.

In contrast with the peripheral cartilage, in the central part of the medial tibia and femur dead chondrocytes were found on week 2 until the last time point examined, which was not replaced by fibrocartilage in this timespan. In these areas, loss of proteoglycans, fibrillation of superficial cartilage and staining for denatured type II collagen was found. Both cartilage damage and staining for denatured collagen increased with time. Only light collagenase cleavage site staining was observed on all time points in this central location.

OA in rats after ACL-transsection can be divided in two stages. An early phase lasting about 4 weeks, in which chondrocyte remodelling of the dead cartilage follows death at the cartilage margins. In this phase marked degradation of type II collagen by collagenases occurs. The second phase, characterised by cartilage damage in the central tibia and femur, shows increased staining for denatured type II collagen but little staining for the collagenase cleavage neoepitope.


Full Access
S.S. Golele R.G. Golele

Between 1993 and 2000 we conducted a prospective study of 50 patients presenting late with ankle fractures. They all had with persistent pain, swelling, ankle deformity and difficulty with walking. Reasons for presenting late included fracture blisters, under-treatment, refusal of surgery and neglect. The mean age of patients was 44.1 years (20 to 82). The mean delay between injury and treatment was 18.4 weeks (4 to 64).

All patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation. Operations were more demanding when done after 24 weeks or in cases of Weber C fractures. Anatomical reduction was achieved in 88% of cases and clinical and radiological deformity corrected in all. All fractures went on to union and patients attained satisfactory motion. There were improvements in pain, swelling and walking. Three cases of deep sepsis were treated with debridement and antibiotics. Ankylosis developed in two patients and arthritis in seven.

The encouraging results suggest that symptomatic, malunited and displaced intra-articular ankle fractures should be treated surgically, even when presented late.


B. Ferré S. Barouk J-L. Besse O. Jarde M. Maestro B. Valtin

Purpose: The growing use of foot surgery includes many innovating techniques which require adequate evaluation. To facilitate evaluation, the Association Française de Chirurgie du Pied (AFCP) elaborated a computer program for acquisition of clinical and radiological data on foot surgery. The data collected were centralised and analysed to assess surgical procedures.

Material and methods: Clinically. Signs of forefoot disorders were reviewed and classed by surgeons with extensive experience in forefoot surgery. Signs were classed by topic then formulated for the computer display to facilitate input during consultations. A system of profiles was designed to limit the data input filed and shorten input time. The program includes an automatic calculation of the Kitaoka forefoot score.

Radiologically: The system includes a tool for analysing radiographs using a vectorial drawing software integrated in the database. This system uses remarkable landmarks chosen by clicking on the radiographs: angles and lengths for preoperative planning are calculated automatically. These values are automatically integrated into the database and can be retrieved for file studies.

Operation report: Procedures performed on the forefoot are presented in picture form with clinical data. A profiles system is used to choose the items for input and reduce entry time.

Printout: Printouts can be made to include in the patient’s files.

Exploitation: Data can be exported for processing with another programme. This function was tested with a dissertation written on Weil osteotomies.

Conclusion: This freely distributed software is a first step toward a computer evaluation system for foot surgery. Our hope is that sufficient data can be collected to validate the reliability of our surgical techniques.


Full Access
M.A. Hanna

In this review of a limited series of 24 hip replacements done over a six-year period is reviewed, the rationale and theoretical motivation are discussed and the results reported.

The mean follow-up is 30 months (10 to 66). There were twice as many male as female patients. Their mean age was 46.8 years. Results were scored on a Charnley/D’Aubigne system.

There were technical difficulties but they were not insurmountable. Disciplined preoperative planning is required.

The results are promising but some questions remain about long-term effects of metal debris and long-term prosthetic survival.


A. Dambreville J. G. Rolland

Purpose: Although hip prosthesis heads made of titanium are no longer implanted to our knowledge, it is important to officially record the failures related to their use. Device monitoring experts can only prove the hazard resulting from these implants if results of human clinical series have clearly described the inconveniences. We found a rich body of literature dating from the end of the eighties that concluded that the rate of wear with the polyethylene lined titanium implants was very low but have found no paper describing the problems related to its use. We report this work to fill the gap.

Material and methods: This prospective study included a consecutive series of the first 100 total hip prostheses using the ion-implanted titanium 22.2 mm head (NITRU-VID) implanted between January 30, 1990 and June 19, 1991. There were 45 men and 55 women, 55 right hips and 45 left hips implanted for primary degenerative disease in 92, dysplasia in two and congenital dislocation in six. Mean age at implantation was 60 years (28–82). The same operative technique was used for all patients using the same Atlas-PSM implant. Eleven patients died and six were lost to follow-up. Thus 83 ere retained for analysis with the Postel-Merle-d’Aubigné (PMA) score on the AP and lateral views of the hip. Kaplan-Meier survival curves were established.

Results: Eleven patients underwent revision surgery for different causes, metallosis in seven. The delay to revision for metallosis was eight years in two, nine years in one and ten years in four. These cases of metallosis were expressed clinically by moderate pain and minimal radiographic signs: bone defect in the greater trochanter in seven, acetabular lines in three. Four cups loosened, none of the femur components. The diagnosis of metallosis was made at revision in five cases, and on the basis of hip biopsy in two. Metallosis was intense with black coloration of all the tissues. Pathology confirmed the diagnosis; the head were depolished with wear of the upper pole and loss of spherical shape as verified in the laboratory. The 10-year survival was 91.33%. For the 72 patients who did not have revision surgery, only nine still had moderate pain and four limped. There were eleven cases with trochanteric defects in zone 3 requiring close follow-up as this can be an early sign of metallosis.

Discussion: This study proves that despite the ion-implantation, the heads wear and lead to metallosis. No metallosis was observed when using the same implants with different heads at a maximal follow-up of 14 years. In an earlier study on the first 100 implants of this type, the 10-year survival was 98.7%. The drop in the 10-year survival from 98.7 to 91.33% can only be explained by the ion-implanted titanium heads.

Conclusions: Ion-implanted titanium heads wear and lead to metallosis. Their use is formally contraindicated. Hip biopsy can provide early diagnosis of metallosis.


A. Ritchie

Osteolysis caused by polyethylene wear particles leads to loosening or bone destruction.

Attempts to minimise wear rely largely on selection of the most suitable materials for the purpose. This is typically stainless steel, cobalt chromium or ceramic for the femoral head and primarily polyethylene on the acetabular side. However, there is increased use of both ceramic-on-ceramic and metal-on-metal articulations, particularly in younger patients, and of cross-linked polyethylene in the hip articulation.

Emphasising material selection and development, this paper discusses possible future technical direction of the hip articulation.


C. Gatzka U. Knothe G. Reilly P. Niederer M.L. Knothe Tate

The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of cement-free implant fixation on microperfusion in the vicinity of the bone-implant interface and to elucidate the effects of mechanical loading on interstitial fluid flow.

Experiments were conducted on both forelimbs of sheep (n=8, age: 4–7 years) using an ex vivo model. Immediately after euthanasia, forelimbs were amputated and a system of perfusion with Procion red (0,08 %) as flow indicator was established. In one group (4 animals), an prosthesis was inserted into the reamed intramedullary cavity of the metacarpus. In a second group (4 animals) no implant was inserted. For each pair, one limb (chosen randomly) was subjected to cyclic loading. Loading was applied at a rate of 1 Hz for 5 minutes. Infusion lasted 5 minutes in all limbs. After the experiment histological cross sections were taken and analysed for the amount of tracer present. Twelve regions were marked on the slide prior to examination and acquired under fluorescence mode. The average pixel intensity of each field of view, was measured using ‘Scion Image’ software.

The mean (± standard deviation) of the 12 readings (pixel intensities) for each group were as follows: Non-implanted group, loaded: 83.31 (± 13.56); Non-implanted group, unloaded 80.80 (± 9.22); Implanted group, loaded: 71.86 (± 19.28); Implanted group, unloaded 66.79 (± 15.52). Anova analysis showed the effect of loading not to be significant statistically (p = 0.082) but the effect of implant to be highly significant (p0.0001).

Implant fixation and mechanical loading affect both microperfusion and interstitial fluid flow modulated mass transport in bony tissue surrounding implants. It appears that the presence of an implant per se reduces perfusion as well as fluid flow in the vicinity of the bone-implant interface. Within subchondral bone loading does not have a significant effect on transport of small molecular weight tracers.


E. Hohmann P. B. Schöttle A.B. Imhoff

Osteochondral autologous transplantation (OATS) is a new technique for the treatment of osteochondral defects.

In a prospective randomised study, between November 1996 and June 2000 we used the OATS technique to treat 136 patients (90 male, 46 female) with a mean osteochondral defect of 3.3 cm2. The defect was in the medial femoral condyle in 54 cases, the lateral femoral condyle in nine, the patella in 15, the trochlea in six, the tibial plateau in one, the talus in 29, the tibial plafond in two, the capitellum in four. There were 16 other locations. The procedure was performed either open or arthroscopically. A mean of 2.2 cylinders was transplanted. At the same time, we treated malalignment by high tibial osteotomy (HTO) in 20 patients, and instability by anterior (ACL) or posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) reconstruction in 16. Five patients required reconstruction of both ACL and PCL.

The Lysholm score in the lower limbs increased from a preoperative mean of 58.3 (20 to 77) to a mean of 90.2 (70 to 100). Treatment by OATS alone increased the score from 62.9 to 91.6. The combination of OATS and HTO increased the score from 65.2 to 91.6. With additional ACL/PCL reconstruction, the score increased from 49.9 to 82.6. The combination of OATS, HTO and ACL/PCL reconstruction increased the Lysholm score from 55.5 to 85.5. Control postoperative MRI with IV contrast (Gd-DTPA) showed incorporation of all but one cylinder. Complications included one case of arthrofibrosis and sinking of one cylinder. One patient developed regional pain syndrome and three had pain at the malleolar osteotomy site, resolved by screw removal. For four weeks after the operation, 10% of patients complained of pain at the donor side in the lateral femoral condyle. There were no complications related to OATS performed in the upper limbs, and control MRI three months postoperatively showed incorporation of all cylinders.

The results are encouraging, and give rise to the hope that this cost-effective and safe new treatment for limited osteochondral defects may delay or even prevent the onset of osteoarthritis.


A.C. Masquelet B. Bajer Th. Bégué

Purpose: Demonstrate the importance of surgical repair of soft tissue damage in an orthopaedic surgery unit.

Material and methods: This retrospective study included 455 patients who underwent soft tissue flap surgery between April 1980 and April 2000. There were a total of 556 flaps, hand and finger flaps were excluded from the analysis. Overall results concerning the general treatment for the underlying conditions was not analysed. There were 132 women and 313 men, mean age 42 years. Among these patients 276 (60%) were referred from other hospitals for secondary care. Most of the tissue damage (373 patients among the 455) concerned the lower limb. The soft tissue loss was part of a bone and joint problem in most cases, including: septic nonunion and osteitis (189 patients), trauma and complications after planned orthopaedic surgery (74 patients), grade IIB or IIIC open fractures according to the Gustilo classification (66 patients). There were a total of 485 pediculated or fasciocutaneous muscle flaps and 71 free flaps.

Results: Flap survival rate was 90.32%. The result was total necrosis of the flap in 9.68%. The rate of failure was 30% for free flaps and 5% for pediculated flaps.

Discussion: This study demonstrated the usefulness of surgical care of soft tissue damage in an orthopaedic surgery unit, particularly for trauma and infection patients. The large number of pediculated flaps is an expression of the reliability of this technique easily applied in a polyvalent orthopaedics traumatology unit. The high rate of failure for free flaps is related to the inherent risk of secondary repair and the inflammatory or infected nature of the soft tissues and also the difficulty encountered in controlling this type of surgery under such conditions. The data reported here allow individual analysis by type of pathology.

Conclusion: Overall management of bone and joint disease patients requires proper skill in soft tissue repair.


D. Guinard Y. Tourné J. Csal D. Corcella F. Moutet

Purpose: As suggested by MacCraw in 1979, the digitorum brevis extensor island flap provides an excellent local cover for small sized tissue losses of the foot and ankle. Despite its advantages, this alternative is not widely used. We report our experience in 11 cases.

Material and methods: Eleven patients underwent reconstruction procedures using the digitorum brevis extensor island flap. There were nine men and two women, mean age 45 years (36–58). The reconstruction was required for post-traumatic infection sequelae of the ankle for four cases, resection of local malignant lesions of the dorsal foot in three, metatasophalangeal involvement of the great toe (septic arthritis and deep electric burn) for two, and finally fistulised chronic osteitis of the base of the fifth metatarus for one patient with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. For eight patients, the flap was harvested from the anteior tibial pedicle and for three, the retrograde flow was fed by the pedious artery to treat metatasophalangeal lesions of the great toe and the base of the fifth metatarsus.

Results: Healing was achieved in all cases with definitive cure of the infectious problem. Subjectively, all patients had a good functional and cosmetic outcome when the flap was harvested on a proximal pedicle. For the single patient with a distal pediculated flap, there as a moderate problem with toe flexion due to adherences. None of the patients developed secondary trophicity problems.

Discussion: The digitorum brevis extensor island flap is a reliable reconstruction option to be discussed as an alternative for distant or free flaps. The pedious muscle flap is easy to harvest and is close to the recipient site limiting functional sequelae. Depending on the pivot point, the pedicle is positioned proximally or distally, the rotation arc being sufficient to reach the ankle or the foot. In addition, this is the only simple local flap, particularly for covering metatasophalangeal joints.

Conclusion: This very useful method merits reconsideration in comparison with other technical solutions for the treatment of small-sized skin loss (20 cm2) or for cure of local infectious lesions of the ankle, the foot and the forefoot.


S. Pretorius D. Newton

Treated conservatively, hyperextension injuries of the cervical spine have a poor outcome, but surgical treatment does not yet provide a realistic alternative. This study was prompted by the lack of classifications of cervical spondylosis and outcome studies of hyperextension in the literature, and the absence of a user-friendly neurological score.

The retrospective study included 60 patients admitted over the last 12 years with hyperextension injuries and varying degrees of neurological deficit. The mean age of patients was 52 years and most had radiological evidence of cervical spondylosis. None had any neurological deficit before the accident. Injuries were sustained in falls in 56%, in motor vehicle accidents in 34%, in assaults in 8% and in sports injuries in 2%. The neurological deficits varied: 11% had complete lesions, 33% central cord syndrome, 18% motor complete-sensory incomplete, 33% motor incomplete-sensory incomplete. The nervous system was normal in 2%. The posterior columns were often involved, with loss of pro-prioception. In the majority of cases conservative treatment consisted of six weeks of light traction in gentle flexion, followed by mobilisation in an ABCO brace for six weeks.

The results showed that the mean Asia score gain for the group treated conservatively was 23, for the surgically stabilised group 3 and the surgically- decompressed group 55. There was a 16% mortality rate. The mean time for rehabilitation was 5.5 months. Both the final outcome and the time to rehabilitation were extremely variable.

We present a classification of cervical spondylosis and ways of measuring congenital and acquired spinal cord narrowing. We combine the Asia and Frankel scoring systems to give a user-friendly guide.


K. Srikumar B. Anto D. Cogley D.R. Redmond

Percutaneous fixation of syndesmosis is an accepted treatment of isolated Weber C fractures of the ankle. However, the status of syndesmosis after removal of the screws has never been studied to our knowledge. We studied eight patients for any residual diastasis and its clinical significance. CT scan was used to study the residual diastasis of syndesmosis after the removal of screws by comparing with the normal side. Patients were clinically assessed using Maryland and International Foot Scoring systems. The talocrural angles were measured and were compared with the normal side.

Ten patients of isolated Weber C fractures were treated with percutaneous application of syndesmotic position scres from November ’97 to July ’99. Eight were available for follow up and two were lost to follow up. The average follow up was 427.9 days (14.26 months) with a range 167–744 days. There were 7 males and 3 females. The average age was 32.2 years (range 17–66). Left side was involved in 6 cases and right side in 4. The scres were removed after an average period of 78.3 days (11.8 weeks) with a range of 45–189 days.

All patients were found to be having diastasis ranging from 1 mm to 3 mm with an average of 2.06 mm. The Maryland score ranged from 76 to 100 with an average of 90. The international score ranged from 78 to 100 with an average of 87.62. The diastasis roughly paralleled with the Foot scores.

All patients who had percutaneous fixation of syndesmosis had residual diastasis following removal of the screws and this may be clinically significant.


A. McClelland Subramanyan D. Connolly D. Beverland

Introduction: There is increasing awareness and concern among the medical profession, general public and media about the various complications of homologous blood transfusion.

Primary arthroplasty of either the hip or knee has an estimated total bleeding of 1.51 (Lotke et al 1991), commonly resulting in transfusion. In knee arthroplasty, performed with the use of a tourniquet, almost all the bleeding occurs postoperatively. Several studies have shown that salvage of blood after the operation and reinfusion can reduce the need for homologous transfusion (Majkowski RS et al, Newman JH et al).

We studied prospectively 100 consecutive patients for knee replacement to compare post-operative transfusion requirements in blood salvage and reinfusion group and a no drain technique.

Methods: After written consent 100 consecutive patients for knee replacement surgery were randomly allocated by computer generated numbers to either the no drain group (n=50) or the reinfusion group (n=50). The patients were anaesthetised as deemed appropriate by their anaesthetist. All the patients were operated on using a tourniquet. At the end of surgery the wound was closed with or without a deep drain. The drain was attached to the Constavac CBC II closed suction system. Preoperative haemoglobin and haematocrit values were recorded. Homologous blood was transfused to the patients as per the standard protocol depending on the haematocrit and or haemoglobin at 4 & 8 hours post-operatively, as well as days 1,2 & 3. In the reinfusion group blood collected in the reservoir was transferred to the blood bag and reinfused at 5 hours or 500 mls depending which was earlier. At 8 hours the reservoir blood was collected and reinfused, no more blood was reinfused as per the manufacturer recommendations. Cardiovascular stability was assessed by hourly blood pressure and heart rate during the first 24 hours and twice daily thereafter. Blood loss was assesses by measuring the drain loss, assessing the wound ooze serial haematocrits and total transfusion requirements.

Results: 50 patients were completed in each group. The mean preoperative haemoglobin in the drain group was 12.8 g/dl and in the no drain group it was 12.9 g/dl. No difference in predisposing factors for bleeding was recorded in the two groups. The mean volume of blood collected in the drain group was 1008mls and the mean volume of autologous transfused was 864 mls. 14% of patients in both groups had no requirement for homologous blood. There was no significant difference in the homologous blood transfusion in the two groups over the study period (up to day 3 post op), the no drain group requiring and average of 2.1 units of packed cells the reinfusion group requiring an average of 1.8 units of packed cells in total. The homologous blood requirements in the drain group was significantly reduced on day 2 in comparison to the no drain group, but as noted there was no overall reduction in homologous requirements. Cardiovascularly 16% of patients with a drain had at least one episode of hypotension (Bp < 90 systolic) compared with 20% of patients in the no drain group. The group without a drain had a significant increase in wound ooze (70% compared with 44%)

Conclusion: Post-operative blood salvaging and autologous transfusion following primary knee replacement under tourniquet in this study did not significantly reduce the patient’s requirement for homologous blood transfusion in the first 3 days post operatively. There was a significant increase in wound ooze in the no drain group but as shown this has not result in an increase in cardiovascular instability or an increase in transfusion requirements.


F. Chalençon D. Pâris J.L. Maatougui J.L. Besse B. Lerat B. Moyen

Purpose: We reviewed retrospectively 40 ligamentoplasties of the anterior cruciate ligament in patients who had undergone several prior reconstructions (1 to 6). The initial operation had used a synthetic ligament in 13 cases, patellar tendon in 23 and divers implants in four.

Material and methods: Forty patients, 12 women and 28 men, with recurrent ligament tears where reoperated by the same surgeon. Mean age was 28.5 years (16–51). Mean follow-up after the last operation was 27 months. All patients were reviewed (history, physical examinatin and KT 1000); 20 of them responded to a self-administered questionnaire using the IKDC chart later after the clinical review, and 23 of the 40 had radiographs to measure laxity. Arthroscopic reconstruction was used in 33 cases. A surgical procedure was necessary on a peripheral ligament in six cases and osteotomy for tibial valgisation in one. Reconstruction was achieved with the quadriceps tendon in 11 cases, the patellar tendon in 18, the hamstrings in eight and Mac in Jones in three. The IKDC score was used for clinical assessment with manual arthrometric measurement of laxity. Radiographs were obtained to measure the anterior drawer of the medial and lateral compartments of both knees for right-left and pre-postoperative comparisons.

Results: The initial handicap was marked (IKDC: 18 D, 21 C, 1 B). Reconstruction was good or very good in 72.5% of the knees (IKCD: 2 A, 27 B, 10 C, 1 D). Self-evaluation revealed 25% painful knees for intense activities. Laxity was improved with a mean differential gain of 5.35 mm of the maximal pre- and postoperative KT 100 (7.24 versus 1.89). Among the 24 knees with radiographic assessment, the mean differential preoperative was 9.14 mm preoperatively and 4.69 mm at last follow-up giving a gain of 4.45 mm. One athlete was able to resume sports activities at the same or higher level and others at a lower level.

Discussion, conclusion: This study confirms that the results obtained after revision repair are less satisfactory than after primary repair. This homogeneous (one operator) and large series with a sufficient follow-up can be compared with the rare published series. Each ligament reconstruction is specific and warrants a specific surgical approach adapted to each individual case.


S. Govender

Atlanto-axial rotatory fixation (AARF) is uncommon and is usually associated with a history of trauma to the neck or an upper respiratory tract infection. In patients who present early, correction of the deformity with traction and orthoses has been reported.

Owing to failure of reduction, patients presenting late (more than a month after the condition developed) have been treated with an in situ C1/C2 fusion. Follow-up of in situ fusions has shown both progression of the deformity and correction through compensatory mechanisms.

Over a five-year period seven AARF patients (16%), ranging in age from 5 to 11 years, presented more than three months after injury. All patients had a ‘cock robin’ posture and were neurologically intact. In three patients the injury was sustained in a fall from a tree and in four it was due to a motor vehicle accident. Two patients sustained additional fractures.

All patients had CT scans. In four patients MR scans and MR angiography were used to evaluate the pathology in the atlanto-axial complex, including the vertebral artery, and revealed soft-tissue interposition in the atlanto-axial joint and atlantodental interval. There was thrombosis of the vertebral artery in two patients. Clinical and radiological correction of the deformity was achieved with transoral release and skull traction, followed by fusion.

While in previous studies there has been speculation on the causes of failure of closed reduction, MRI and the transoral procedure identified the pathology in this uncommon condition.


S. Morris T. McCarthy M. Neligan M. Timlin P. Gargan P. Murray J. O’Byrne W. Quinlan

Introduction: Since the introduction of joint arthroplasty major advances including the introduction of laminar airflow, have been made in reducing infection to current rates of 1 to 2%. Nonetheless infection remains a devastating complication, with major implications in terms of patient suffering, duration of hospital stay and financial burden. We undertook a study to examine the incidence of bacterial wound contamination occurring in the intra-operative period.

Materials and Methods: All patients admitted to our unit for elective hip and knee arthroplasty were entered into the study. On arrival in theatre a skin swab was taken. The patient was then prepared and draped in the anaesthetic room before final draping by the surgical team in the operating theatre. All procedures were performed in theatres equipped with laminar airflow, and all surgical personnel wore isolator suits. During the course of the procedure swabs were taken from the anterior aspect of the femur at 30-minute intervals. In addition the skin and inside blades and the suction tip were harvested at the end of the procedure. All samples were then sent for culture. Patient data including age, comorbid conditions and history of previous surgery were noted on a standardised pro forma. In addition, operative data including duration of the procedure, operating surgeon and type of drape and skin preparation used were noted.

Results: 65 patients have been examined to date. An incidence of contamination of 14% has been noted (9 patients) with the skin blade and suction tip being the most common source of contaminating organisms. Staphylococcus epidermis was cultured in 5 cases, with Gram negative organisms being cultured in the remaining samples. In all 9 cases only small numbers of organisms were identified. None of the patients with positive cultures developed clinical signs of deep or superficial wound sepsis, and all had an uncomplicated postoperative course.

Conclusions: While low levels of contamination are unavoidable in theatre, it is important that strict discipline be maintained in order to minimise this risk. In particular, careful attention to patient skin preparation, the use of prophylactic antibiotics and minimising use of the suction tubing help decrease contamination rates.


O. Jardé E. Havet P. Mertl M. de Lestang

Purpose: We reviewed 30 cases of osteochondrial lesions of the astragalus dome treated surgically.

Material and methods: Among the 30 patients, 17 practised sports and 24 had a history of trauma. Delay to surgery was ten months. All patients were treated by curettage using perforations according to Pridie. There were 11 direct approaches, 13 malleolar osteotomies and six arthroscopies. Cancellous grafts completed the treatment in six cases.

Results: Mean follow-up was three years seven months (minimum two years). All the patients had an arthroscan at last follow-up. The postoperative results were assessed according to clinical and arthroscan criteria.

Discusion: We emphasise the importance of the Fracture Osteonecrosis Geode (FOG) classification system and the subsequent pathophyisiological and prognostic conclusions. The Berndt and Harty classifications should be abandoned. Only symptomatic lesions should be treated. Surgical treatment (arthroscopy or direct access with cancellous graft) is required for efficacy at this stage. Surgical treatments provides very good results in 75% of the cases with pain relief and improved walking distance. We advocate arthroscopic perforation curettage for localised necrosis. In case of major substance loss, cancellous grfat requires a direct access.


D. Gihr A. Babinet J.Y. Pierga G. de Pinieux Ph. Antract P. Pouillart M. Forest B. Tomeno

Purpose: The prognosis is dramatic in patients with malignant Schwannoma. These tumours appear to progress invariably irrespective of the complementary treatment given. In order to determine whether this clinical impression is founded, we reviewed retrospectively patients cared for conjointly by the Cochin Hospital and the Curie Institute since 1956.

Material and methods: This series included 32 patients (17 men and 15 women) including seven who had a Recklinghausen neurofibromatosis (three men and four women). The logrank test was used to compare the actuarial survival curves and determine prognostic factors and potential benefit of chemotherapy and radiotherapy protocols.

Results: Mean age at diagnosis was 42.1 years (11.8–78.9). Ten percent of the schwannomas were grade I, 25% grade II and 65% grade III. All patients except two underwent surgery. The resection was considered wide in three cases, marginal in 17, contaminated in seven and non-classifiable in three. There were 14 cases of local recurrence within a mean delay of 12 months (1–66 months). Twelve patients developed secondary local relapse within a mean delay of 36 months (0–169 months). Different neoadjuvant or adjuvant treatments were administered, including chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Twenty-four patients died with a median survival of 25 months. The survival curves showed that complementary treatments did not significantly improve survival. The only factor with prognostic value was the histological grade and the quality of the resection.

Discussion: Our findings are in general agreement with data in the literature demonstrating the lack of efficacy of complementary treatments in patients with malignant schwannomas. Inversely Recklinghausen disease did not appear to modify prognosis in our patients.


Ch. Assi A. Faline F. Canovas F. Bonnel

Purpose: A pre- and postoperative radiographic analysis of 50 total knee arthroplasties (TKA) was performed to determine the femorotibial correction angle and the tibial and femoral mechanical angles obtained as a function of the initial bony deformity. The preoperative angle beyond which correction was not achieved was determined.

Material and methods: This prospective single-centre study included 50 TKA (25 men and 25 women), mean age 69.1 years (range 53–83). Degenerative disease involved the right knee in 21 cases and the left knee in 29. A Wallaby I TKA (semi-restrained with preservation of the posterior cruciate ligament) was implanted in all cases. Three angles were calculated on the AP loaded knee: AFT (femorotibial angle), AFM (femoral mechanical angle), ATM (tibial mechanical angle). For each angle, statistic analysis was performed on four groups of patients: group I: overall population, group II: patients with normal axis (178°< AFT< 182°; 88°< AFM< 92°; 88)< ATM< 92°), group III: patients with varus (AFT> 182°; AFM> 92°; ATM> 92°), and group IV: patients with valus (AFT< 178°; AFM< 88°; ATM< 88°). Non-parametric tests (Spearman rank test and MacNemar symmetry test) were performed on SAS software for statistical analysis with p< 0.05 considered as significant.

Results: Pre- and postoperative AFT showed: significant improvement of the mean (> 3.44° in group I, > 6.87° in group III, and > 6.12° in group IV). There was no significant difference in group II. Pre- and postoperative AFM showed: constant but non-significant improvement in groups I and III (> 3°) and constant and significant improvement in groups III and IV (> 2.5°). Pre- and postoperative ATM showed: significant improvement in groups I and III (> 3°), constant but non-significant improvement in group IV (n=4). There was no group II. An ATM > 94° was the threshold angle beyond which correction was not obtained.

Discussion: Taken together, the results of this study confirm the reliability of the Wallaby I instrumentation for achieving a correct postoperative mechanical axis. These results are comparable with data in the literature (with or without preservation of the posterior cruciate ligament). However, the correction of the bony deformity obtained depended uniquely on the initial deformity of the tibia. Extreme deformity of the tibia should be corrected with osteotomy or with a more restrained prosthesis.


Ph. Segal E. Dehoux C. Mensa

Purpose: For many years, single-compartment knee inserts have been one of our most frequent operative indications, but the uncertain nature of the results and early deterioration have led us to revisit the failure cases and modalities for total knee arthroplasty.

Material and methods: From 1994 to 2001, we reoperated 33 single-compartment knee inserts (28 medial and five lateral inserts). Mean delay from initial implantation was 4.3 years (range nine months to ten years). Clinical and radiological assessment was done with the IKS score. Peroperative exploration searched for the underlying cause.

Results: All single-compartment inserts were replaced with a total knee arthroplasty. The mean HSS improved from 42.8±15 to 83.6±18% good and very good results. The causes of failure were loosening in 22 cases including four cases of implant fracture or displacement. We had three stress fractures of the tibial plateau. The revision procedure required compensation blocks for the tibia in two cases, and a bone graft in four. Finally, a tibial stem extension was needed in nine cases. There were two mechanical complications after revision, one recurrent stiff knee and one recurrent dislocation of a posterior stabilised prosthesis.

Discussion: Ligament tension and balance both in extension and flexion remains an important problem in revision procedures on single-compartment inserts. The difficulty in setting the femoral rotation is well known due to the loss of posterior condyle tissue. Tibial stem extensions can be useful, particularly if a graft of the medial compartment is used. Use of adapted instrumentation facilitates revision of these single-compartment knee inserts and may provide further confidence in first intention total knee arthroplasty.


T.A. Wallny D. Schulze Bertelsbeck R.L. Schild I. Theuerkauf

Two dimensional ultrasound of the shoulder joint has become a well established diagnostic tool. Difficult interpretation of ultrasonographic findings, however, suggests that ultrasound appears not to be an always reliable method, especially in partial thickness tears. The present study was performed to determine whether the use of three dimensional (3D) sonography further increases the diagnostic yield of ultrasound.

On a total of 22 externally intact appearing rotator cuffs of cadaveric shoulder joints 7 full thickness and 15 partial thickness incisions were carried out on the M. supraspinatus, subscapularis and infraspinatus tendon. The specimens included the humeral head, the glenoid, the joint capsule and periarticular tendons.

Ultrasound was performed on the shoulder specimens in a water basin with a 8.5 MHz curved array transducer (Combison 530D, Kretztechnik, Zipf, Austria).

With three dimensional ultrasound rotator cuff lesions were more often correctly diagnosed (sensitivity of 77 %) than with conventional 2D sonography (sensitivity of 64 %). Specificity was 85 % and 69 %, respectively. In partial thickness tears in particular, 3D imaging was the superior method reaching a sensitivity and specifity of 73% and 77%, respectively compared to 53% and 61%, respectively with 2D ultrasound.

The use of three dimensional ultrasound appears to have a higher diagnostic yield in partial thickness tears. One advantage is that the examiner must not move the transducer to obtain other planes. Changes in echogenicity can be observed in the complete volume and in any plane. In the diagnosis of partial tears these changes enabled the examiner to distinguish intact from ruptured tissue.


R. Kulkarni C.A. Bourgeault N. Greer D.A. Loch J.E. Bechtold R.F. Kyle R.B. Gustilo

Aim: The objective of this study was to compare the initial stability of an uncemented curved long stem femoral component (ABR, Zimmer, Warsaw Indiana) implanted using conventional broaching to an uncemented ABR implanted as a revision using morselized compacted allograft to fill a circumferential proximal bone defect.

Materials and Methods: Primary: Eight fresh frozen human femurs were implanted with correctly sized ABR stems without cement using standard surgical instruments and 1mm distal overreaming. The implant was loaded cyclically at 3 hz on a MTS servohdraulic materials test frame in a direction representing the peak force of the stance phase of the gait (2.5 X body weight). A 3-dimensional motion measurement device with six linear variable transformers measure the relative motion between the bone and the prosthesis with an accuracy of 0.5μm. The contruct was loaded in ten cycle increments until the component was seated and then recoverable motion was recorded over a further ten loading cycles. Revision: In the revision case bone loss was modelled by removing all the cancellous bone from the proximal femur with 1mm distal overreaming. Morselized bone graft was impacted into the defect using specially prepared smooth tamps shaped to the geometry of the ABR stem. The original prosthesis was then reimplanted without the use of cement. The seating and testing cycles were repeated. Primary and revision vectors were compared using a paired students t – test.

Results: There was no statistically significant difference in the magnitude of the resultant vector of the 3 translational components of the micro motion between the two methods of implantation (p=0.19).

Conclusions: Initial stability of a cementless femoral implant is a requirement for bone ingrowth. The use of compacted morsellized allograft in a revision Total Hip Arthroplasty with a proximal circumferential defect can provide a stable bed for the implantation of an uncemented femoral component. The revised implant using the compacted allograft method was initially as stable as the primary implantation.

This technique would be particularly applicable when the surgeon would like to avoid the use of cement in a revision setting. The use of this method for uncemented revision Total Hip Arthroplasty should be studied further in a clinical setting before it is advocated for widespread use.


P.F.B. von Bormann

Jimmy Craig had many talents and virtues.

A keen sportsman, he played rugby for his school and university and in his younger days was an amateur boxer of note. Directly from medical school he joined the Medical Corps of the South African Forces fighting in the Western desert, and then went up the boot of Italy. On his return to Johannesburg, his home town, he developed expertise in cerebral palsy treatment and surgery.

From about 1970 until the year before his death in 1992, he regularly visited Ikhwezi Lokusa School for the Orthopaedically Handicapped, just outside Umtata, once or twice a year. His visits lasted a week at a time.

In those years he assessed approximately 1 500 children and operated on about 600. For the first 15 years, the operations were almost exclusively soft tissue surgery: tendon lengthening, tendon transfers and clubfoot releases. As the facilities in Umtata were upgraded, he performed an increasing amount of bone surgery. The operations he did were mainly on the lower limbs. They included lengthening of the triceps surae at the level of the gastrocnemius, lengthening of the tendo Achillis, release of hamstrings and hip adductors, recession of iliopsoas recession at the hips and Souter slides. On the upper limbs he fairly regularly performed surgical release of the first web space and release of flexor carpi ulnaris.

He closely supervised the postoperative care provided by the school, which always had at least one expert Bobarth trained physiotherapist in residence.


E. Hazotte H. Coudane P. Metais J. Leroux A. Blum

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the diagnosis of medial and lateral meniscal injury in operated and non-operated knees.

Material and methods: This prospective longitudinal study was conducted between January 1st 1995 and December 31st 1997. Each patient had a physical examination, a standard radiography study, and an MRI and an arthroscopy. The MRI was performed with two machines running at 1.5 Tesla and 0.5 Tesla. Spin-echo T2 slices were obtained in the saggital plane, and spin-echo fat saturation slices in the frontal and axial planes. Arthroscopy was performed and/or controlled by the same operator.

Results: The protocol included 132 patients. Ten patients (ten knees) had another arthroscopy after arthroscopic meniscectomy. Mean time between the physical examination and MRI was 57 days, it was 69 days between MRI and arthroscopy. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value and precision were, respectively, 94.8%, 61.%, 86.7%, 81.5% and 85.6% for the medial meniscus and 73%, 93.3%, 76% 93.5% and 90.1% for the lateral meniscus.

Discussion: Arthroscopy remains the gold standard for prospective comparative studies (Reigher 1986, Jackson 1988, Kelly 1991). MRI is the examination of choice for the diagnosis of meniscal injury in non-operated knees (Polly 1988). Most false positives concern injuries located on the posterior part of the medial meniscus. For radiologists (Mink 1988), these false negatives would result from poor analysis by the arthroscopic surgeon (Quinn 1991). Arthroscopists point out that radiologists overestimate injuries of the posterior segment (Barronian 1989, Fischer 1991, Spiers 1994). These false negatives involve the lateral meniscus (Cheung 1997). Our study corroborates the results reported in the literature. For repeated arthroscopies, no conclusion can be drawn from the interval of confidence observed in a population of ten knees. Nevertheless, in these knees, the MRI provided a good means of identifying recurrent lesions of both the medial and lateral menisci.

Conclusion: The physical examination provide a strong clue to meniscal injury in non-operated knees, so it is not necessary to perform an MRI before arthroscopy In all other cases, particularly there is recurrence, MRI can identify injury to the medial or lateral menisci with good sensitivity and specificity. In most cases, if the MRI is negative, it is not necessary to perform arthroscopy to search for a meniscal injury.


V Mishra U. Umedi P. Durkin D.R. Marsh

Objectives: (i) To compare and correlate outcome in Sanders Type 2 Os Calcis fractures using two disease-specific scores (Kerr-Atkin score & American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle society score) and a general quality of life score (short form 36 health status questionnaire). (ii) To compare results of operative with non operative treatment, in this group of patients.

Design: Retrospective study using a combination of case notes, plain x-rays and CT scan films review along with current clinical assessment.

Patients: 30 patients with 32 fractures of Os Calcis (Sanders type 2) were identified. These patients were treated during 1994–1997 with mean follow up of 40 months.

Intervention: 16 patients were treated by open reduction and internal fixation using a lateral approach. The remaining 14 patients were managed non operatively. Treatment modality was decided by consultant preference.

Outcome measurements: Kerr-Atkin score, AOFAS score, SF36.

Results: We found an extremely significant correlation (p,.001, Spearman) between the two disease specific scores. AOFAS score showed a stronger correlation with physical component summary score (PCS) of the SF36 than the Kerr-Atkin score.

The age of the patient had little impact on the Kerr-Atkins score but a large effect on PCS. Conversely the pre-op Bohlers angle, a measure of fracture severity, had a large effect on the Kerr-Atkins score but little impact on the PCS. The AOFAS was responsive to both these predictors: 41% of the variance in AOFAS score was explained by Bohlers angle and the age of the patient.

We did not find any significant difference in outcome between operative and non-operatively treated patients.

Conclusion: The AOFAS score was found superior in assessment of outcome for Sanders type 2 fractures, though the Kerr-Atkin score also performed well.

This study does not demonstrate any significant advantage of operative treatment in Sanders type 2 fractures of the Os Calcis.


C. Baertich L. Fourcade G. Cochu C. Malat J-L? Cherissoun J-P. Arnaud

Purpose: We report a retrospective series of 28 patients with trauma-induced dislocation of the knee. The purpose of our study was to evaluated long-term outcome after orthopaedic as well as surgical management of these injured knees and to propose a therapeutic attitude best adapted to the initial situation.

Material and methods: The series included 28 patients, including one who had a bilateral dislocation. There were four women and 24 men, mean age 35.3 years at the time of the accident (17–69). Mean follow-up was 10.8 years. Nineteen knees were treated orthopaedically after reduction, surgery was used for ten patients. Five patients underwent an initial operation (during the first week following the accident), five had a secondary operation one to eight years after the accident. Mobility and laxity were assessed clinically. The Lysholm-Tegner and the Meyers scores were used to assess function. Radiological results were assessed with the Ahlback classification and the IKDC score to judge potential progression to single-or triple compartment osteoarthritis.

Results: Clinically, mean amplitude was 105° flexion and −2° extension. Four knees were stiff with flexion = 80°. There was a persistent anterior drawer sign for all knees except four. Medial laxity (valgus) was often important (83% of the patients). Functionally, the mean Lysholm score was 80.5 (17–100). The mean pre and post-trauma Tegner score was 5.1/3. The Meyes classification showed 15 good and excellent results and eight fair and six poor results. Radiographically, more than half the patients had no sign of degenerative joint disease and only four knees has signs of true three-compartment osteoarthritis according to the Ahlback classification. Separate analysis of patients treated orthopaedically and surgically showed that good results with orthopaedic treatment concerned patients with an anterior or posterior dislocation with predominantly anterior laxity. The fair and poor results concerned six of the eight patients with initially multidimensional laxity, particularly postero-lateral laxity that persisted at last follow-up. Surgical treatment gave good results mainly when given early (four very good results out of five knees).

Discussion: Recent work has demonstrated very satisfactory results for femorotibal stability after ligament reconstruction, usually with allografts. Our good functional results, comparable with earlier series, and the encouraging radiographic results have led us to chose orthopaedic treatment for selected patients (correct preservation of the posterolateral plane, particularly in case of dislocation with hyperextension corresponding to grade II in the Schenck classification), and on the contrary, to prefer early surgical treatment for the posterolateral plane.

Conclusion: Management of injury to knee ligaments after femorotibial dislocations should be guided by a precise examination of the initial laxities conducted under general anaesthesia. If the posteriolateral plane is satisfactory, orthopaedic treatment followed by active rehabilitation can provide good functional and radiographic results.


G.M. Siboto S.J.L. Roche

This paper highlights the fact that full length labral tears are a cause of instability in posterior fracture-dislocations of the hip.

From July 1994 to March 2001, 133 consecutive posterior fracture-dislocations of the hip were surgically treated. On admission, all patients were initially subjected to closed reduction, and in some cases skeletal or skin traction was applied. Pelvic radiographs were taken to confirm relocation, and CT done to look for intra-articular bone fragments. Intra-operative findings and surgical technique were recorded.

Redislocation occurred in eight patients, whose surgical notes were reviewed to determine the cause. Despite 9 kg of skeletal traction, one patients’s hip redislocated the day after closed reduction. In the other seven, redislocation occurred postoperatively. The time to redislocation varied from one day to 16 weeks, and because redislocation was sometimes painless, not all patients reported it immediately.

Two patients, whose radiographs showed very small fragments at the superior-posterior position, would normally have been treated conservatively. On one, surgery was performed because the fragment was lodged at the weight-bearing area of the joint. The hip of the other redislocated on skeletal traction the day after closed reduction. At surgery, it was noted that both patients had extensive soft tissue stripping and full length tears of the labrum. The other six patients had clear posterior wall fractures requiring surgical reconstruction. The fragments were often attached to the capsule but were too small to fix with screws, so buttress plating was used alone.

Full-length labral tears in posterior dislocations of the hip cause instability, and failure to address this adequately at surgery may result in redislocation.


T. Martinez S. Blendea C. Hubesson J. Tonetti A. Eid S. Plaweski P. Merloz

Purpose: The purpose of this work was to compare the precision and reliability of screw fixation using two different guiding systems. The first system was based on computed tomography (CT) imaging and the second on digitalized fluoroscopic imaging.

Material and methods: Between 1998 and 2000, 88 patients underwent spinal fixation for diverse disease states (idiopathic scoliosis in 43, and fracture, spondylolisthesis or instability in 45). Pedicular screws (n = 223) were inserted in levels T4 to S1. The passive CT navigation system was used for 73 patients (177 pedicular screws) and the fluoroscopic navigation system for 15 (46 pedicular screws). An independent observer identified the position of the pedicular screws on the postoperative CT.

Results: Among the 73 patients who underwent a CT-guided procedure (177 pedicular screws) the rate of incorrect screw position was 6.2% (11/117) with = 2 mm penetration of the cortical. Among the 15 patients who underwent a fluoroscopy-guided procedure (46 pedicular screws), the rate of incorrect screw position was 17% (8/46) again with = 2 mm penetration of the cortical. For scoliosis patients, the rate of erroneous screw insertion was 6% for CT navigation and 28% for fluoroscopic navigation. For fractures and degenerative instability, the rates were 6% and 11% respectively.

Discussion: The passive nature of the two navigation systems used do not induce any peroperative constraint on the surgeon. With the CT system, landmarks have to be collected peroperatively on the posterior arch of the operated vertebra, a step that is not needed for the fluoroscopic system. The two techniques appear to be reliable for insertion of pedicular screws. We did not have any neurological disorders in this series. It can be recalled that the conventional method produces a 15 to 40% rate of erroneous insertion. The CT system provides better results for all types of diseases; the improvement is about 6%.

Conclusion: With CT-navigation, a large portion of the per-operative radiographs are no longer necessary. Operative time is slightly longer than for the classical procedure due to the collection of the 3D information, particularly important for scoliosis. With the fluoroscopy system, no special preoperative imaging is required. Two or three peroperative radiographs are sufficient, limiting irradiation during insertion of the pedicular screws. The fluoroscopic system does not however provide 3D images.


D. Chapnikoff A. Besson C. Chantelot C. Fontaine H. Migaud A. Duquennoy

Purpose of the study: There are few reports onlong-term outcome after Bankart procedure. The purpose of this study was to determine the rate of recurrent dislocation, the clinical results and the incidence of glenohumeral osteoarthritis after a minimum 10-year follow-up.

Material and methods: Ninety-seven Bankart procedures were performed in 97 patients between 1972 and 1986 for treatment of anterior shoulder instability with recurrent dislocations. We retrospectively reviewed 74 patients and obtained 64 complete radioclinical evaluations for an average follow-up of 16 years. Clinical evaluation was based on the G. Walch and the Duplay group score but for easier comparisons, we also calculated the Rowe et al. score. Radiographical evaluation was established on the Samilson and Prieto classification but real glenohumeral osteoarthritis with joint narrowing was noted independently as grade four. We also studied the contralateral shoulder.

Results: At last follow-up, 7 shoulders (9.5%) had recurrent dislocation, but two of them occurred subsequent to severe trauma over 18 months. Most patients (95%) were satisfied or very satisfied. Six patients (8.1%) had persistent apprehension but in some it was not due to anterior apprehension. According to the Duplay score (or the Rowe score), 25 shoulders (44.6%) had an excellent result (35/61.4%) 16 (28.6%) a good result (7/12.3%), 11 (19.7%) a fair result (11.19.3) and 4 (5.4%) a poor result (4/7%). Operated shoulders were pain free for 75% and painful for forced movements only for 25%. External rotation at 90° of abduction was reduced by 8.7 ± 15.7°. There was no limitation of internal rotation. Patients returned to preoperative sports activities at the same level for 70.9% and at a lower level for 12.7%. According to the Samilson classification, 7 (13%) of the shoulders had grade 2 and 2 (3.7%) had grade 3 glenohumeral osteoarthritis. We found 4 cases (7.4%) of real glenohumeral osteoarthritis (grade four) and 2 of these patients had contralateral osteoarthritis of a non unstable shoulder. There was no perioperative complication.

Discussion: In our hands the Bankart procedure is appeared as a safe procedure with a low rate of glenohumeral osteoarthritis and a high rate of patient satisfaction.


N. Willcox I.C. Kurta M. Dove A.A. Rahmatall J. Dove G. MacKenzie

The aim of this study was to demonstrate a correlation between FASTRAK readings of spinal movement and established disability scores in-patients undergoing litigation.

A retrospective, blind study was conducted on patients who had been evaluated clinically between January 1994-October 1998. Statistical regression analysis between evaluated Oswestry Disability Score (ODS) and MSPQ/Zung questionnaires and the mean ROM was obtained. 49 patients with soft tissue injuries of the cervical (n = 14) and lumbar (n = 34) spine were assessed. All of them were undergoing litigation.

A standardised Fastrak trace measuring flexion, extension, right and left bending and rotation of the cervical and lumbar spine was recorded. An ODS and MSPQ/Zung questionnaire was filled in under the supervision of a senior physiotherapist.

There was no correlation between the ODS and MSPQ/Zung and mean ROM for the cervical spine. In the lumbar spine, flexion and ODS correlated statistically significantly (p< 0.01) and right rotation with the combined MSPQ/Zung score (p< 0.014).

This preliminary study is encouraging in that it demonstrates a direct correlation between FASTRAK measurements and recognised disability scores in the lumbar spine. Further analysis of non- litigation cohorts will contribute to establish these correlations.


N.A. Ramaniraka L.R. Rakotomanana P.J. Rubin P.-F. Leyvraz

Purpose of the study: After total hip replacement, the initial stability of the cementless femoral stem is a prerequisite for ensuring bone ingrowth and therefore long term fixation of the stem. For custom made implants, long term success of the replacement has been associated with reconstruction of the offset, antero/retro version of the neck orientation and its varus/valgus orientation angle. The goals of this study were to analyze the effects of the extra-medullary parameters on the stability of a noncemented stem after a total hip replacement, and to evaluate the change of stress transfer.

Material and methods: The geometry of a femur was reconstructed from CT-scanner data to obtain a three-dimensional model with distribution of bone density. The intra-medullary shape of the stem was based on the CT-scanner. Seven extra-medullary stem designs were compared: 1) Anatomical case based on the reconstruction of the femoral head position from the CT data; 2) Retroverted case of − 15° with respect to the anatomical reconstruction; 3) Anteverted case with an excessive anteversion angle of + 15° with respect to the anatomical case; 4) Medial case: shortened femoral neck length (− 10 mm) inducing a medial shift of the femoral head offset; 5) Lateral case: elongated femoral neck length (+ 10 mm) inducing lateral shift of the femoral head offset 6) Varus case with CCD angle 127°; 7) Valgus case with CCD angle 143°. The plasma sprayed stem surface was modeled with a frictional contact between bone and implant (friction coefficient: 0.6). The loading condition corresponding to the single limb stance phase during the gait cycle was used for all cases. Applied loads included major muscular forces (gluteus maximus, gluteus medius, psoas).

Results: Micromotions (debonding and slipping) of the stems relative to the femur and interfacial stresses (pressure and friction) were different according to the extra-medullary parameters. However, the locations of peak stresses and micromotions were not modified. The highest micromotions and stresses corresponded to the lateral situation and to the anteverted case (micro-slipping and pressure were increased up to 35 p.100). High peak pressure was observed for all designs, ranging from anatomical case (34 MPa) to anteverted case (44 MPa). The peak stresses and micromotions were minimal for the anatomical case. The maximal micro-debonding was not significantly modified by the extra-medullary design of the femoral stem.

Discussion: The extra-medullary stem design has been shown to affect the primary stability of implant and the stress transfer after THR. Most interfacial regions present small micro-slipping which normally allows the occurrence of bone ingrowth. The anatomical design presents the lowest micromotions and the lowest interfacial stresses. The worst cases correspond to the anteverted and lateralized cases. Probably, the anteverted situation involves higher torsion torque, which in turn may induce high torsion shear micro-motions and higher stress at the interface. Moreover, the lever arm of the weight bearing force on the femoral head is augmented for the augmented neck length situation. This increases the bending moment, and therefore may increase the stresses as well as the stem shear micromotions. In summary, the present results could be taken as biomechanical arguments for the requirement of anatomical reconstruction of not only the intra-medullary shape but also the extra-medullary parameters (reconstruction of the normal hip biomechanics).


C. Nich H. Hamadouche L. Vaste J.P. Courpied M. Mathieu

Purpose: Revision total knee arthroplasty (RTKA) is particularly difficult and results more variable than primary total knee arthroplasty due to the added problem of bone loss. Massive bone allografts have been proposed to restore bone stock and mechanical conditions as close to the physiological situation as possible. The purpose of this retrospective analysis was to assess clinical and radiological results after knee reconstruction with massive allografts in patients undergoing revision total knee arthroplasty.

Materials and method: This series included 14 patients who underwent a revision procedure between February 1990 and August 1998 for RTKA with segmentary bone loss and bone defects. This group included seven patients with mechanical failure and seven others with septic loosening. Reconstruction was achieved with a massive allograft sealed around a long stem cemented implant. The composite assembly was impacted into the patient’s bony segment. The allografts were used to reconstruct the distal femur in nine cases, the proximal tibia in one, and both in the others. The IKS score and radiographic homogenisation of the host-graft junction were assessment criteria.

Results: Mean follow-up was 50 months (24–110). Mean IKS score was significantly improved from 43 (11–70) pre-operatively to 75 (40–100) at last follow-up (Wilcoxon test, p = 0.002). At last follow-up, the flexion-extension amplitude was 91±10°. Radiographic integration of the allografts was achieved in 14 out of 18 grafts. Three allografts were resorbed leading to fracture with subsequent implant failure and a new revision in two. There were no infections.

Discussion and conclusion: Bone grafts may be a solution to the difficult problem of bone loss during RTKA. Massive grafts combined with long stem implants have given encouraging early and mid-term results. The duration of these results is under evaluation.


Ph. Sauzieères Ph. Valenti R. Costa N. Lefevre V. Dumaine J. Cosquer

Purpose: The hand-to-forehead test is a new subjective and objective test for anterior shoulder instability. This test is performed preoperatively under general anaesthesia and involves a quantifiable patient-controlled apprehension test and an objective quantitative test of anterior stability.

Material and methods: Between January 1998 and April 2000, 135 patients (97 men and 38 women), mean age 25 years, age range 16–40 years, candidates for surgery for anterior instability of the shoulder (115 Latarget, 14 Bankart, 6 capsular shift) were tested. A control group of 300 candidates free of any shoulder disorder for other surgery were also tested.

Results: the Apprehension test was positive in 95 of the operated patients and negative in 40. Mean angle was 160° (90–180°). The test was always negative in patients with an underlying hyperlaxity (18 patients). The test was positive in 20 controls and negative in 270. Test sensitivity was 72%, specificity 92.5%, positive predictive value 42%, (prevalence 1.5%) and negative predictive value 86%. Reproducibility was 80%. The objective test was positive in 125 of the operated patients and negative in 10. The value was 2++ in 55% of the cases. In the control group, the objective test was positive in 28 and negative in 272. The sensitivity of the objective test was 95%, specificity 90%, positive predictive value 55% and negative predictive value 95%. Reproducibility was 92%.

Discussion: The purpose of the hand-to-forehead test is to express the instability as perceived by the patient and to exteriorise anterior laxity without reproducing true anterior displacement. Excepting cases with underlying hyperlaxity, this test does not appear to be inflenced by different injuries subsequent to recurrent anterior dislocation. (no significant difference between glenoid bone lesions, Broca lesions or Malgaigne notches).

Conclusion: This new test provides a reliable objective assessment of anterior instability of the shoulder using a quantifiable combination of classical apprehension and laxity tests. It is a supplementary diagnostic tool for difficult cases and a useful aid for pre- and postoperative evaluation of these patients.


P. Simon C. Delloye F. Bressier C. Nyssen-Behets X. Banse S.R. Babin D. Schmitt

Purpose: Only very partial integration of massive allografts is generally achieved, affecting bone-graft junctions and the peripheral cortical. In clinical practice, this is not a major problem for massive reconstructions with a sleeve prosthesis but can be a handicap for junctional grafts or osteoarticular grafts where weak recolonisation can be a source of complications.

Material and methods: Extraperiosteal resection measuring 5 cm in length was made in the mid shaft region and bridged by a cyropreserved non-irradiated allograft before stabilisation with a static locked nail. Three groups of ten sheep were studied. The first group received a simple allograft without perforation; the allograft was perforated in the second group (1.1 mm drill bit); and the perforations in the allograft in the third group were lined with decalcified bone powder with assumed potential for inducing bone growth. The implantation was studied after a delay of six months. There were three infections so the analysis was made on 27 grafts. Plain x-rays (consolidation of the graft-bone junctions), histomorphometrics (porosity, new peripheral and endomedullary bone deposit, cortical thickness), and bone density were studied.

Results: Rate of bone-graft consolidation was not significantly different in the three groups. The callus was more endosteal in groups 2 and 3 (p< 0.02) and endomedullary bone deposit was greater (p=0.0001) than in group 1 without perforation. There was approximately three times more bone deposit in the perforated allografts than in the non-perforated allografts; Adjunction of demineralised bone around the perforated grafts did not lead to any significant difference compared with the perforated allografts (group 2).

Discussion: Significantly more bone deposit observed with perforated allografts should lead to better biomechanical behaviour. This is being tested in further work.

Conclusion: Perforations induce a significant increase in new bone deposit in massive cortical allografts, remodelling is much more active and extensive than with non-perforated allografts. It would be logical to propose perforated allografts for junctional or osteochondral massive cortical grafts.


R. Kulkarni A. Rogers E.M. Downes

Introduction: The search for a gold standard uncemented hip prosthesis with long term results matching cemented Charnley implants continues. It has been suggested that biological fixation would reduce the incidence of aseptic loosening caused by cement and polyethylene particles. The ABG (Howmedica) is a titanium alloy stem with an anatomic design and a modular head option of vitallium or ceramic. The cup is hemispherical and is fully coated with hydroxyapatite while the stem is proximally coated for metaphyseal fixation. We present a prospective series of 100 Consecutive patients with an immediate term follow up.

Methods: 100 patients who had an ABG prosthesis inserted between 1991 & 1996 were included in the study. All patients were operated upon by the senior author or under his direct supervision. Patients underwent a preoperative assessment including a detailed history, measurement of range of motion, Postel Merle D’Aubigne scoring and ADL assessment. Clinical and radiological review was Conducted at 3 months, 6 months, 1 year and then at yearly intervals. At each visit Patients were questioned regarding the presence of any thigh pain and Complications. All patients were clinically evaluated, Postel Merle D’Aubigne Score was obtained and ADL status assessed. AP and lateral radiographs were Taken and studied. Polyethylene wear was measured by using the Livermore Method. The Kaplan- Meier method was used to explore the survival pattern of the implants.

Results: The mean age of the patients was 52 years (range 23–72). Follow up ranged from 3 To 8 years (mean 5 years ). The mean preoperative Postel Merle D’Aubigne score Was 7 ( range 0–14) and mean score at final follow-up was 17.7(range 15–18).

Only 4 patients complained of thigh pain and most had dramatic and lasting improvement of the ADL status. Complications included 3 dislocations and 2 Superficial infections. Non progressive lucencies were noted in 6 stems and 2 cups. No stems were loose and one patient had a loose cup and is awaiting surgery. A high rate of superior polethylene wear of 0.2mm/year was identified in a Number of patients yet the survivorship was 99% after an average 5 year follow up.

Conclusion: Our results demonstrate the efficacy and excellent medium term outcome of the ABG prosthesis. A higher rate of complications in the first 2 years reiterates the lesson that every surgeon has to complete a learning curve before being technically comfortable with a new prosthesis. Of concern was the high rate of superior polyethylene wear although this did not effect the survivorship.


E. Fourati J-S. Coste C. Trojani P. Boileau

Purpose: Neer modified the Bankart operation, adding a reinforcement crossing the capsule anteriorly on the humeral side. The purpose of this study was to report results after more than two years.

Material and methods: Between 1991 and 1998, 77 patients underwent surgery for traumatic anteroinferior instability. Clinical and radiological outcome was reviewed in 64 of this patients by an observer different from the operator at a mean follow-up of 45 months (24–120 months). Patients with a unique anterior reinforcement were excluded from the analysis. The patients were generally young (mean 27 years) with sports activities (89%). Recurrent dislocation was observed in 39 patients, subdislocation in seven and painful and unstable shoulders in seven. Ten patients had an associated hyperlaxity, defined by elbow-to-body external rotation greater than 85%, according to the SOFCOT criteria. Three patients had had a prior procedure for a coracoid bone block.

Results: According to the Duplay score: outcome was excellent in 27 cases, good in 22, fair in nine and poor in six. Mean delay to return to former occupational activity was four months; it was seven months for sports activity. The deficit in external rotation was 3.4° on the average. Ten patients had persistent apprehension. Recurrence was observed in seven patients (11%) a mean 25 months after the operation (seven days to six years) as dislocation in two and subdislocation in five and due to trauma in five cases. Young age, hyperlaxity, high-risk sports, an important humeral notch, major capsular distension, and a high number of dislocations or subdislocations were the factors associated with recurrence. According to the Samilson criteria, pre-osteoarthritic lesions of the gleno-humeral joint were present in two cases preoperatively (one grade I and one grade II) and in eight cases postoperatively (four grade I, three grade II, and one grade III).

Discussion, conclusion: The Bankart operation as modified by Neer does not produce a stiff joint as is thought by many, probably due to the upper-lower capsular retention rather than lateral-medial retention. Nevertheless, the stability results are less satisfactory than generally reported for coracoid stop procedures.


G.P. Grobler B. Bernstein

The good results of the Charnley stem are well documented. Modifications to the stem design need to be evaluated clinically in order to assess possible risks and benefits.

We assessed the results of the first 100 consecutive Elite Plus arthroplasties performed at one centre. At a minimum of five years postoperatively, patients were recalled for clinical and radiological assessment. Postoperative radiographs were graded A to D and compared to final radiographs.

Overall results were good, with 97% of the stems still functioning well clinically and radiologically. The three failures, all of which occurred at the bone cement interface in young patients, showed early signs of radiological debonding. In the rest of the patients there was good fixation, with no evidence of subsistence or loosening.

The Elite Plus stem modifications to the Charnley stem appear to yield good results at five years. It is postulated that the canal should not be power-reamed because, by eliminating good cancellous bone and polishing the cortex, this may contribute to failure at the bone-cement interface. We will undertake further follow-up to evaluate longer term results.


P. Gaudin Ph. Hardy J-L. Blin

Purpose: The risk of recurrence would be greater after arthroscopic treatment of shoulder instability compared with open repair. We wanted to find what effect bone lesions and more particularly posterosuperior notch in the humerus have on outcome after arthroscopic management of shoulder instability.

Material and methods: We made a retrospective analysis of 60 patients who underwent an arthroscopic procedure between February 1993 and December 1998. Mean age was 28 years three months. All patients in this series had a bony notch measured on the preoperative scan. Six measurements were made to determine the volume of the notch approximated to the half volume of a revolution ellipse. The ratio of this volume to total volume of the humeral head (approximated as a sphere) was also calculated. The glenoid cavities were classed in four groups: normal, abrasion, fracture, amputation. Operative result was assessed with the Duplay score at a mean follow-up of 42.7 months.

Results: Outcome was excellent in 24 patients, good in 14, fair in seven, poor in five including four related to recurrent instability, and a failure in ten requiring reoperation. The rate of recurrence with reoperation was 16.6%. Notch volumes varied from 0 to 4792 mm3 (mean 1019±1253). The notch/ head ratio ranged from 0 to 10.5% (mean = 2.28±2.63). Only 12 patients (20%) did not have a bony notch; 11 of them had an excellent or good result. Mean volume of the notch in patients with excellent, good, or fair outcome (group A) was 639.72 mm3. Mean volume of the notch in the failure cases (group B) was 2158.11 mm3. Glenoid cavity classes in group A were 17 normal, 20 abrasion, 8 fracture, 0 amputation. In group B the classes were 2 normal, 9 abrasion, 2 fracture, 2 amputation. The volume of the notch was significantly correlated with outcome (Spierman test). There was no significant correlation for the glenoid cavity.

Discussion: Despite the absence of a significant correlation with the glenoid cavity classes, the presence of a glenoid lesions in cases with a bony notch smaller than 500 mm3 had an important impact in three out of the four failures (two amputations and one fracture). Considering a threshold value of 1000 mm3, the rate of failure was 7.7% irrespective of the glenoid lesions and 52.5% if glenoid amputations and fractures were excluded.

Conclusion: It would appear that arthroscopic treatment should be reserved for patients with a small humeral notch (< 1000 mm3). Glenoid lesions should also be quantified in patients with small notches.


M. Hamadouche F. Madi L. Kerboull J.P. Courpied M. Kerboull

Purpose: New surfaces have been developed to reduce polyethylene wear. The zircone ceramic surface appears to have a theoretical advantage due to its interesting tribologic properties. The purpose of this prospective study was to assess clinical and radiological outcome at a minimal two years follow-up in a consecutive series of total hip arthroplasties using the polyethylene zircone junction.

Material and methods: La series included 56 total hip arthroplasties performed in 49 patients (30 women and 19 men), mean age 52.2 ± 12 years (25–76). Primary degenerative hip disease was the aetiology in 43% of the cases, dysplasia in 27%. The femoral component was made of 316L steel with a 11°25 Morse cone for 27 hips and a 5°40 cone for 29 hips. The femoral head measured 22.2 mm and was made of polycrystaline zircone ceramic stabilised in the tragonal form with yttrium (Y-TZP). All the arthroplasties were performed via transtrochanteric access using cemented Charnley-Kerboull implants. Clinical outcome was assessed with the Merle-d’Aubigné score. Classical landmarks on the AP pelvis views were used to assess implant migration. Cup wear was measured using the Livermore method. Actuarial survival curves were plotted.

Results: Mean follow-up was 32 months (24–48). None of the patients were lost to follow-up. The mean functional score at last follow-up was 17.8±0.2 (16–18) versus 12.2±2.6 before arthroplasty (Student t test for paired variables, p < 0.0001). No cases of migration of the femoral or acetabular component were observed. Acetabular wear was always less than the precision of the measurement method. Osteolytic lesions were however observed as endosteal defects in the Merkel region measuring less than 1 cm2, observed in 18 out of the 56 hips (32%). These osteolytic lesions generally appeared between the first and second year and did not appear to progress.

Discussion: Osteolysis in the Merkel region appeared early for one third of the hips, despite the absence of cup polyethylene wear. It would be reasonable to be prudent when using zirone ceramic heads. We are continuing our close follow-up of this group of patients. In addition, measurements of wear and migration are being made using the EBRA method.


A.A. Gadgil S.M. Eisenstein

Purpose of the study: To study clinical, radiological and pathological features of this rare condition and to observe the effect of surgery on the relief of presenting symptoms.

Materials, Methods and Results: between February 1989 to May 1999, more than 200 spinal operations were carried out at Oswestry, amongst which we found 11 patients with 13 symptomatic lumbar synovial cysts. Nine patients were female and 2 were male. Among the symptoms produced, sciatica was present in 10 out of 11 patients, neurologic claudication was present in 6 patients and only one patient had neurologic deficit. All the patients suffered with back pain, which was either of facetal origin or mechanical back pain.

Radiological investigations revealed that all patients had evidence of facet arthrosis. Seven patients had degenerative spondylolisthesis. Degenerative disc disease was also seen in 7 patients.

The contents of the cysts varied from serous fluid to chalky white material to gelatinous grey material. One cyst contained calcium pyrophosphate crystals. Another cyst contained hydroxyapatite crystals. Seven cysts which contained deposition of bone debris in the cyst wall also revealed an (giant cell and macrophage) inflammatory reaction to this bone debris. In all patients complete resolution of sciatica, neurologic claudication and neurologic deficit was observed after surgery. However, after a minimum follow up of two years the back pain persisted in all but one patient.

Conclusion: Lumbar synovial cyst is a rare condition, more common in females, elderly, and occurs most commonly in association with degenerative disease of the spine, although it can also be caused by other conditions like trauma, or rheumatoid arthritis. When they cause compression of the dura or nerve roots, they present with symptoms like sciatica and neurologic claudication, which resolve promptly after surgery. However, patients also have a long history of back pain from the associated degenerative spinal disease which usually does not resolve unless it is addressed separately and patients need to be warned regarding this.


S. Audebert C. Maynou E. Petroff H. Mestdagh

Purpose: The purpose of this work was to study the biomechanical properties of mobile cup shoulder prostheses and factors affecting their kinetics.

Material and methods: Bipolar shoulder prostheses were implanted in 39 patients with degenerative shoulders and a destroyed cuff. Radiocinematic recordings of anterior elevation and active rotation were made at a mean 32 months follow-up (13 months–550 months).

Results: Three types of biomechanical behaviour were observed for elevation movements. “Normal” behaviour was observed in 17 prostheses with preservation of the scapulohumeral rhythm and chronological participation of the three articular interfaces [intraprosthetic (head/cup), extra-prosthetic (cup/glenoid), scapulothoracic]. Mean anterior elevation was 114.7° for these shoulders. A “paradoxical” behaviour was observed in ten prostheses. Anterior elevation depended entirely on the scapulorthoracic joint, and was limited on the average to 42.5°. An “intermediate” behaviour was observed in 12 prostheses with inversion of the scapulohumearl rhythm. The glenohumeral mobility was decreased due to the absence of extraprosthetic mobility (eight cases) or intraprosthetic mobility (four cases). Mean anterior elevation in these shoulders was 80.83°. When the elevation behaviour was “normal”, the Constant score at last follow-up was significantly better compared with “intermediate” (p = 0.008) or “paradoxical” (p = 0.0001) behaviour.

Three types of biomechanical behaviour were also observed for rotation movements: a “chronological “ behaviour was observed for 15 prostheses, via extraprosthetic mobility in all. Mean external rotation was 37.33° and mean internal rotation was 6.53 points. An “anarchic” behaviour was observed in 16 prostheses with a random proportion of intra- and extraprosthetic mobility. Mean external rotation was 8.75° and mean internal rotation was 4.25 points. For shoulders with “chronological” or “anarchic” behaviour, the mean external rotation (p = 0.002) and the mean internal rotation (0.04) were statistically better than shoulders with “truncated” behaviour.

Discussion: An atrophic deltoid, mediocre joint congruency, and early-stage excentred scapular degeneration with preserved glenoid bone stock are factors favouring “paradoxical” elevation. Deltoid atrophy alone favours “truncated” rotation. This study was helpful in identifying conditions most appropriate for implanting this type of prosthesis and factors predicting postoperative outcome.


L. Pidhorz Ph. Ridereau Ch. Cadu

Purpose: Removing cement for revision total hip arthroplasty is always a challenge. The OSCAR device (Orthosonics Ltd UK) provides an elegant solution. We conducted a prospective study of ultrasound ablation using this device in 19 patients undergoing revision total hip arthroplasty to assess feasibility.

Material and methods: Between March 1999 and January 2001, 17 patients, ten women and seven men underwent revision of their femoral component for aseptic loosening (14 cases) or infection (five cases). The Vives criteria as modified by SOFCOT were six grade 1, six grade 2, five grade 3 and two grade 4. The femoral stem removed had a standard length in 17 cases and measured 250 mm in one. The cement obturated the femur in one case with a proximal misinsertion. On the average, the terminal plug went 40 mm beyond the tip of the stem. Trochanterotomy was used ten times and anterior approach in nine. Two ultrasound probes were used: scraper probes that removed cement from the walls and a perforating probe when needed to remove the terminal plug. We recorded the time needed to remove all the cement, the ease or difficulty of the process, the presence of misinserted cement, need for other methods (new window, femorotomy), duration of the hospital stay, and delay to weight-bearing with crutches. The quality of the cementing and presence of cement overflow were determined on plain radiographs. All patients were reviewed for this work.

Results: It took less than 60 min to remove the cement in 14 cases and from 60 to 90 min for four cases; the cement could not be totally removed in one case. There was one fracture (grade 4 during a third revision operation). The end plug was removed under good conditions in 14 cases. The femoral stem could be recemented in nine cases using a longer stem in five. Cementing was satisfactory in 12 cases. Deferred surgery was required for the five cases with infection; in two cases the cement persisted at the second operation requiring a new ablation process. There were no cases of misinsertion. Mean hospital stay was 10.1 days and weight-bearing was authorised on the third day for patients without infection. At a mean follow-up of 8.5 months, there have been no cases of revision, fracture or stem migration.

Discussion: The rate of total hip arthroplasty revision is an estimated 10%. The risk of an incident during cement ablation is an estimated 18% to 28%. Advantages of the ultrasound technique include: shorter operative time, simple material, less danger for weak bone as noted in our patients, absence of the need for complementary fixation, shorter hospital stay, and lower cost. Histology studies have demonstrated the absence of deleterious effects of ultrasound ablation explaining the good quality of recementing (12 cases).

Conclusion: Ultrasound ablation of femoral cement is effective for aseptic revision. In case of infection, the presence of persistent cement might be related to recurrent infection.


N. Schütze A. Lechner J. Müller J. Eulert F. Jakob

The human cystein-rich protein 61 (hCYR61) belongs to an emerging family of genes which modulate growth and differentiation. Previously, hCYR61 was identified by us as a fast and transiently 1,25(OH)2-vitamin D3 responsive gene product in human osteoblasts by differential display PCR. Here, we further studied the role of the protein in human osteoblasts.

Using the human hFOB cell line hCYR61 mRNA was analysed by northern hybridisation. Protein levels were detected using western blotting. Intracellular localisation of the hCYR61 protein was determined using the expression as a fusion protein with green fluorescent protein. Immunohistology was performed in hFOB cells as well as primary human osteoblasts and human bone samples.

From northern analyses the hCYR61 mRNA was regulated by 1,25(OH)2-vitamin D3 as well as the growth factors TNFa, EGF, bFGF and IL1b 5-10-fold within 1 hour in the hFOB cell line. Here we show that the same factors markedly upregulated the hCYR61 protein within 24 to 48 hours in hFOB cells as has been analysed by western blotting. From cellular supernatants a highly upregulation of the hCYR61 protein by the growth factors was observed. A full length hCYR61 protein fused to the green fluorescent protein localised to the Golgi-apparatus. From immunohistology proliferating hFOB cells and primary osteoblasts express significant hCYR61 protein, whereas differentiated osteoblasts display a marked downregulation of hCYR61. In human bone high levels of hCYR61 were observed at the human growth plate as well as on surfaces of mineralised structures.

In summary, hCYR61 in human bone represents an immediate early regulated gene. The secreted protein plays a role as an extracellular matrix signaling protein which could play an important role in cell-cell communication within the bone microenvironment. The high expression level and regulation patterns observed in our studies suggest an important role in situations of bone repair and remodeling.


F.M. Bischof D. Basu J.M. Pettifor

The purpose of this study was to determine factors contributing to the high incidence of fractures in patients with spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy in residential care, and to assess the effect of vitamin D therapy.

Over a period of four years, 20 patients in a cohort of 88 had sustained 56 long bone fractures. We compared them to an age-matched group from the same cohort with no history of fractures. The mobility of patients, who spent their time indoors, was severely restricted in both groups.

There was radiological and biochemical evidence of rickets and osteomalacia in both groups, but the disease was more severe in the fracture group. There was a significant relationship between the number of fractures and the use of anticonvulsant therapy.

Administration of vitamin D (5 000 IU per day) to both the fracture and control group over three months resulted in a marked increase in mean serum calcium (p =0.01), and a dramatic decrease (p < 0.003) in mean alkaline phosphatase to a level just above normal. All non-ambulatory residents with cerebral palsy now receive a maintenance dose of 50 000 IU of calciferol a month. No further fractures have occurred since vitamin D administration.

We recommend vitamin D supplementation for all non-ambulatory children with cerebral palsy in residential care who do not get regular exposure to sunlight.


S Kutty D. Mulqueen J.P. McCabe W.A. Curtin

We evaluated 100 patients in two separate groups of 50 patients for Limb Length Discrepancy after Charnley Total Hip Arthroplasty. The study was a retrospective analysis of the group considered. Group 1 included 50 consecutive patients with unilateral disease who underwent total hip arthroplasty between June 98 – June 99 without intraoperative measurement. Group II included 50 patients with unilateral disease who underwent total hip arthroplasty between June 98 – July 99 with pre-operative templating and intraoperative measurements.

Evaluation was undertaken with radiographs using the method of Williamson and Reckling. Two independent observers evaluated pre-operative radiographs and postoperative radiographs taken at a mean of 3 months (6 weeks – 6 months). The inter-oberserver variation was found in 9 preoperative radiographs and 15 postoperative radiographs in the 100 patients (p< 0.6). The mean age of the patients in Group I was 71 years and 4 months (52–83 years) with 24 males and 26 females. The mean age of patients in group II was 69 years and 7 months (41–82 years) with 25 males and 25 females. 23 patients (46%) in group I had a discrepancy of which 19 patients (38%) had a mean increase of o.4cm (0.1–0.8cm) and 4 patients (8%) had a mean decrease in length of 0.325cm (0.2–1.1cm). In group II 14 patients (28%) had a discrepancy with 9 patients (18%) had an mean increase of 0.41cm(0.1–1cm) and a mean decrease of 0.3cm(0.1–0.6cm).

The discrepancy found in our series of 100 patients in minimal. The discrepancy can be minimised to a further extend with pre operative templating and intraoperative measurements (p< 0.04). Our study supports the adoption of this to prevent limb length discrepancy after total hip arthroplasty.


R. Badet K. Bouatour T. Aït Si Selmi H. Dejour Ph. Neyret

Purpose: Implantation of a single-compartment lateral prosthesis can be proposed to patients with primary or secondary osteoarthritis uniquely involving the lateral femorotibial compartment. Many surgeons hesitate to use this procedure which does not have a particularly good reputation. We report a series analysed retrospectively to determine the impact of aetiology, operative findings, and pre- and post-operative radiographic findings on final outcome. We searched for the ‘ideal’ indication and specific technical difficulties encountered.

Material and methods: The review included 81 single-compartment medial implants (complete pre- and postoperative radiological and clinical data were available for 87% of the files, all were reviewed). Minimum follow-up was two years (mean 6.5 years). Clinical assessment was based on the IKS score and radiological analysis included a complete series (AP, lateral, axial, full knee, preoperative stress views).

Results: Mean IKS score was clearly improved from 49/100 preoperatively to 90.2/100 postoperatively. Severe pain was noted in 12% of the patients preoperatively versus 1.2% postoperatively. Sixty-three percent of the patients had completely forgotten their knee. Mean amplitude was 0.5–123°. Clinical lateral laxity was less than 5° in 93% of the patients and the knee was stable in the sagittal plane in 96.5%. Mean function score improved from 59/100 preoperatively to 73.3/100 postoperatively, limited basically by going up and down stairs (normal values in 36% of the patients). Walking distance was greater than 1 km in 68% of the patients (29% preoperatively). In the frontal plane, the mean mechanical femorotibial angle was 183.31 ± 3.01° (189.9 ± 5° preoperatively) with a mean mechanical femoral angle of 91.06 ± 3.01 (and a mean mechanical tibial angle of 90.6 ± 1°. Implant survival at five years was 97.15% and 93.33% at ten years (three loosenings and one metallosis).

Discussion: At last follow-up, the final result was significantly affected by diverse factors: osteoarthritis status at surgery (p < 0.02), patient age (p < 0.01), raising the anterior tibial tuberosity (p < 0.01), initial aetiology. The results were compared with data in the literature and discussed by type of indication and therapeutic options for lateral femoral osteoarthritis. The problem of indications in case of tibial plateau fractures and lateral meniscectomy is discussed.

Conclusion: These clinical and radiological results show that the lateral single-compartment prosthesis is a safe and reliable procedure for the treatment of primary or secondary osteoarthritis of the lateral femorotibial compartment.


J.M. Segonds J.Y. Alnot H. Asfazadourian

Purpose: The serratus anterior, innervated by the Charles Bell nerve, contributes to dynamic abduction and elevation of the shoulder by stabilising the scapula on the thorax. Abduction and elevation beyond 90° or movement of the spinal border of the scapula is impossible in case of serratus anterior paralysis.

Material and methods: This series included 16 patients with traumatic damage to the Charles Bell nerve leading to unique paralysis of the serratus anterior. Mean age of the patients at diagnosis was 27.5 years. Nine patients underwent scapulothoracic arthrodesis or scapulopexia and seven patients were not operated due to spontaneous total or partial recovery.

Results: Initial elevation in the non operated group was 125°. At five years elevation was 145°, Constant score was 85, and shoulder abduction force was 12 kg (83% of the contralateral force). Final outcome was very good in four patients, good in one, fair in one and poor in one (the fair and poor outcomes involved severe pain for one and major loss of force for the other). Preoperative elevation in the operated group was 95°, reaching 104° at last follow-up. At four years, elevation was 104°, Constant score was 75, and shoulder abduction force was 9 kg (72% of the contralateral force). One case of infection required revision and healed satisfactorily. Outcome was very good in six patients and good in three.

Discussion: Several types of treatment can be proposed: non-surgical care, muscle transfer basically with the pectoralis major, and scapulothoracic arthrodesis. The principal series reported in the literature on scapulothoracic arthrodesis concern patients with fascioscapulohumeral dystrophy and are not comparable with our series. It would be possible to compare our patients with series of post-trauma paralysis using muscle transfer which have given good results for mobility but limited improvement in global muscle force. In our patients, scapulothoracic arthrodesis gave good results in terms of muscle force, pain and overall shoulder function; mobility was fixed by the position of the scapula in the arthrodesis. We advocate this method for the treatment of serratus anterior paralysis mainly in manual labourers.


E. Tanck G.H. Van Lenthe R.J. Wubbels T. Hara R. Huiskes

Mechanical loading is important for the maintenance of the skeleton. In this study we addressed the following question. What is the influence of long-term exposure to 2.5 g on bone architecture in male rats? We expect that bone density will increase.

For the experiments we used a total of 14 Long Evans rats. Two experiments were performed in which the rats were exposed to 2.5 g for a period between 33 and 44 weeks. In the first experiment we analyzed the 3D trabecular structure in the femoral head, and in the second one the structure in the proximal tibia (metaphysis) was analyzed using micro-computer-tomography.

Rats exposed to 2.5 g had between 6% and 29% less total body weight than controls. Changes in anisotropy, which is a measure for trabecular alignment, were negligible. In the femoral head, the bone volume fraction (BV/TV) was similar for rats exposed to 2.5 g and controls. The diameters of the femoral head and neck in rats exposed to hypergravity were smaller than in controls, but not significantly. In the tibia, the BV/TV was lower for rats exposed to 2.5 g than for control rats (p< 0.05), whereas the size of the tibial plateau was larger in the exposed rats (p< 0.05).

These preliminary results were in contrast to our expectation. When exposed to 2.5 g, the trabecular architecture in the femoral head hardly changed, and in the tibia the BV/TV decreased. The tibial plateau was however larger. Adaptation to hypergravity conditions might be more at the global, cortical level than at the trabecular level. Alternatively, it is possible that the activity of rats exposed to hypergravity was less compared to controls. This would result in decreased dynamic stimulation of the bone so that the BV/TV still may satisfy the mechanical demands of rats exposed to hyper-gravity.


C. Maynou X. Cassagnaud S. Elise H. Mestdagh

Purpose: We examined the long-term effect of the Latarjet-Patte procedure on subscapularis function and trophicity.

Material and methods: The series included 102 patients (106 shoulders) reviewed at a mean follow-up of 7.5 years. The subscapularis was opened by dissection along the direction of the fibres in 27 shoulders (group I) and via inverted-L tenotomy in 69 (group II). Duplay and Rowe scores were used to assess clinical outcome. Subscapularis function was measured with the hand-back distance and the Gerber lift-off test in comparison with a control group composed of healthy subjects in order to account for limb dominance. Computed tomography was used to measure fatty degeneration and muscle atrophy.

Results: The Duplay and Rowe scores gave 76.4% and 87.7% satisfactory results. The Duplay score was 89.9/100 in group I and 82.1 in group II (p = 0.02). The hand-back distance and muscle force as judged by the lift-off test were statistically different between the dominant and non-dominant sides (p = 0.001). Loss of muscle force was greater for dominant sides in the operated shoulders. The mobility score, the lift-off test, and the hand-back distance were significantly altered in group II patients. Fatty degeneration of the sub-scapularis was greater on the operated side (0.76 vs 0.054) (p = 0.001). It increased with age at surgery and at review (p = 0.0001), for dominant shoulders in group II (1.18 vs 0.12). It affected the Duplay score (p = 0.006), the hand-back distance, and the lift-off test (p = 0.01). Fatty degeneration was greater than 2 in 66% of the shoulders with a poor outcome and persistent apprehension in 35.3%. Subscapular atrophy was greater on the operated side (0.91 vs 1.17) (p = 0.0001) and was statistically correlated with fatty degeneration, the Duplay score, the lift-off test, and the hand-back distance. It was greater in group II (0.71) than in group I (0.2).

Discussion: Recovery of muscle force is better for dominant shoulders. Muscle trophicity and function are influenced by subscapular tenotomy that leads to significant loss of internal rotation force, atrophy, and fatty degeneration affecting final long-term outcome.

Conclusion: We recommend discission of the subscapularis for coracoid bone block procedures.


M.W. Solomons M. Cvitanich

Humeral shaft fractures, which make up about 3% of all fractures, can often be managed non-operatively, with outcomes ranging from good to excellent. Conservative management techniques include the hanging arm cast, U-slab coaptation splintage, thoracobrachial immobilisation, shoulder spica cast, skeletal traction and functional bracing. The outcomes of functional bracing and U-slab coaptation splint-age have been shown to be equally good, but Sarmiento et al reported that patients found functional bracing more acceptable. We compared the costs in time and money.

The U-slab coaptation splint is bulky and not uncommonly the slab slips or loosens, requiring repeated reapplication. We looked retrospectively at the frequency of U-slab reapplication in our outpatient setting, and multiplied the frequency of reapplication by the cost per unit and time per unit, comparing these parameters with those for functional braces.

Our study showed that in monetary terms U-slab coaptation was cheaper than functional bracing, but highlighted the hidden cost in terms of application time, additional imaging and rehabilitative physiotherapy. Functional bracing has the added advantages of single application, increased patient comfort and hygiene, more rapid rehabilitation of shoulder and elbow movements and ease of access for soft tissue dressing.


J.B. Stiehl

This report reviews the long-term results of treating acetabula with unusually severe problems, such as pelvic discontinuity or major column loss after failed total hip arthroplasty (THA) and reconstruction problems.

Loss of acetabular bone stock results from removal of bone during the original procedure, prosthetic failure, and osteolysis. In massive structural failure, the acetabular rim, quadrilateral plate, and associated columns become deficient. At worst, this may be combined with pelvic discontinuity and disruption of the ilium and ischium. Prosthetic protrusio may result from fixation loss and be associated with scarring of the femoral vessels, femoral nerve, ureter and bowel. A variety of implants has been used to in ace-tabular reconstruction. The results are often poor because of insufficient bone stock to support the implant.

In a consecutive series of 251 THA revisions done between 1988 and 1996, 17 patients were treated for major pelvic column loss, pelvic discontinuity or both.

In five patients, a posterolateral approach without trochanteric osteotomy was used. The extensile triradiate approach with ilioinguinal extension was used in 12 patients in whom severe prosthetic protrusio increased the risk of intrapelvic iatrogenic injury. A long anterior column pelvic plate was applied. A posteriorly placed AO 4.5-mm pelvic reconstruction plate with 10 to 12 holes was used in nine cases of pelvic discontinuity and in five cases of posterior column bone loss. This plate extended from the most inferior extent of the ischium across the wall of the posterior column to a point high on the ilium. Anterior column fixation was done in eight of nine cases of pelvic discontinuity and all three cases of anterior column deficiency. This called for an 8 to 12-hole 3.5-mm AO pelvic reconstruction plate that extended from the pubic symphysis across the pelvic rim. This spanned the anterior column defect, ranging from 4 cm to 8 cm, to the medial wall of the ilium.

Bulk allograft was used in 16 of the 17 patients. The patient in whom allograft was not used had pelvic discontinuity following pelvic irradiation. Whole pelvic acetabular transplants were used in seven with severe bone loss or following resection for chondrosarcoma and the other for pigmented or villonodular synovitis. Posterior segmental acetabular allograft was used in two cases of posterior column absence. Femoral heads were used in two posterior column defects, three pelvic discontinuities with anterior column defect, and two anterior column defects. Acetabular components were cemented in six of seven whole bulk ace-tabular transplants, six of nine pelvic discontinuities and two anterior column defects.

Cemented implants were classified as loose if there was a complete radiolucent line at the bone cement interface, measurable component migration or measurable change in position. Uncemented acetabular components were considered loose if component migration had occurred or screws had broken. Pelvic plates were considered loose if there was measurable migration or change in plate position or if fixation screws had backed out or broken.

Radiographic union was considered present when bridging callus or trabecular bone was visible across the discontinuity site. Junctional healing was considered probable when radiographs did not show obvious signs of failure. Grafts were considered unhealed if there was obvious displacement, bone gaps or hardware breakage.

Seven of the nine patients with pelvic discontinuity had late evidence of healing of the fracture and allograft consolidation. One underwent removal of the graft at three weeks after developing acute postoperative infection: early junctional healing of a whole bulk acetabular allograft required an osteotomy to break up the interface. Another patient, who underwent removal of the graft and implant at three months for chronic infection, had consolidation of a whole bulk ace-tabular allograft. One patient underwent revision of a pressfitted acetabular component at 60 months, and the pelvic discontinuity was solidly united. In a fourth patient, explored at 124 months for loosening of a cemented cup, there was near complete dissolution of the graft posterior acetabular wall and a loose posterior pelvic plate. In a patient with pelvic discontinuity after radiation therapy for uterine carcinoma, satisfactory healing of the pelvic discontinuity was confirmed at 32 months, when excisional arthroplasty for late chronic infection followed urinary sepsis.

Seven patients had major column loss with severe cavitary defects. Consolidation of the allograft was noted in all seven within the first 12 months of follow-up.

Revision (47%) was required for infection in three patients, implant loosening in four, and recurrent implant dislocation in one. The four loose cups were revised to a cemented all-polyethylene component. All four implants had been placed on less than 50% host bone. None of the four has required subsequent revision.

Dislocation postoperatively occurred in eight patients. In six, the extensile triradiate approach had been used. This approach led to dislocation in 50%. The main reasons for using the extensile triradiate approach were to avoid catastrophic injuries by direct exposure of vital structures and to allow stable anterior column plate fixation. In that no neurovascular injuries occurred and stable durable allograft consolidation and healing of pelvic discontinuity took place, these goals were largely met.

Three patients developed late sciatic palsy. In one, plaster immobilisation had possibly caused direct pressure over the fibular head and led to chronic peroneal palsy. The other two underwent additional exploration of the sciatic nerve for late entrapment caused by migration of screws from the posterior column plate. Two patients developed bladder infections postoperatively. Another developed superficial phlebitis of the lower leg.

Acetabular revision for loosening was necessary in three of seven cementless implants, while only two of 10 cemented implants failed. The acetabular component should be cemented into the allograft when more than 50% of the prosthetic interface is non-viable.

Virtually all graft material, including dense cortical grafts, may ultimately fail if used for implant fixation. Patients should be told about the inevitable risks. However, techniques used led to stable healing of the pelvic discontinuity in most cases. Long pelvic plates that securely stabilise the pelvis and allografts carefully opposed to host bone may explain the relative success in this series.


L. Tristan J. Laulan Y. Kerjean E. Fassio P. Burdin

Purpose: Serratus anterior palsy is usually part of a Parsonnage and Turner syndrome. When occurring alone, it may be secondary to compression of the long thoracic nerve. The anatomic point of contact has been described at the level of the second rib. We report our experience with a musculofascial serratus anterior flap showing that the crossing point of the long thoracic nerve and the thoracic branch of the thoracodorsal artery, the serratus anterior fascia could also be a potential point of compression.

Material and method: We cared for two patients with complete and isolated palsy of the serratus anterior. In the first patient, the paralysis developed over one year and in the second had started three months before treatment. In both patients, the preoperative electromyogram showed an absence of serratus anterior activity. We therefore performed exoneurolysis of the long thoracic nerve in both cases. At surgery, the nerve was clearly compressed at the point where the long thoracic nerve crossed the thoracic branch of the thoracodorsal artery.

Results: The first patient recovered normal muscle activity one year after surgery. Complete recovery was achieved in the second patient at three months.

Discussion: These two cases would support the hypothesis that the long thoracic nerve can become compressed within the serratus anterior fascia. In all cases with serratus anterior palsy secondary to suspected mechanical compression, we propose exoneurolysis of the long thoracic nerve.


J. Caton Z. Merabet P. Reynaud P.J. Ternamian

Purpose: Since 1962, when Sir John Charnley implanted the first total arthroplasty, long-term studies have demonstrated the excellent survival of these implants with greater than 85% survival at 25 years (John Older, Mike Wroblewski, ACORA group in 1995). Polyethylene wear is the main obstacle to long-term survival of the Charnley total hip arthroplasty. New friction surfaces have been proposed to reduce wear, notable the ceramic/ceramic junction proposed by Pierre Boutin since 1970 with the ceramic/polyethylene derivative. The alumine ceramic head cannot be greater than 22.225 cm due to the risk of fracture, leading to the zircone head. D. Goutallier and his school recently demonstrated (1999) that the use of zircone can increase wear with early development of osteolysis and acetabular loosening. For this reason, we compared wear between two series of prostheses using the 22.2 zircone/polyethylene combination versus the metal/polyethylene combination.

Material and methods: Two series of 37 patients were compared for wear. The first series included 41 hips with a zircone/polyethelene combination using a 22.2 cm head. The second series of 38 hips used a metal/polyethylene combination and 22.2 cm heads. The femoral components were the same in the two series with an 8/10 Morse cone. Mean follow-up in the two series was 38 months. All patients underwent surgery in 1997 for the zircone/polyethylene implants and in 1995 for the metal/polyethylene implants. Mean age in the zircone/polyethylene series was 58 years and in the metal/polyethylene series 66. The Postel Merle d’Aubigné (PMA) score at review was 16.6 for the zircone/polyethylene series and 17.7 for the metal/polyethylene series. Manual measurements of wear were made using the Livermore method with determination of the centre of the head according to Cherrot and Kerboull, doubled with computer-assisted interobserver radiological measurements.

Results: At three years, 31.5% of the metal/polyethylene implants were devoid of any signs of wear compared with 29.2% in the zircone/polyethylene implants. Mean wear was 0.19 per year for the metal/polyethylene implants versus 0.12 per year for the zircone/polyethylene implants. Overall wear on the AP view at last follow-up was 0.62 mm for the metal/polyethylene implants and 0.40 mm for the zircone/polyethylene implants at three years. This difference was significant p < à.005).

Discussion: We did not find any greater wear with the zircone/polyethylene combination compared with metal/polyethylene as was also demonstrated by D. Goutallier. M. Wroblewski (2000) demonstrated in a study with 10 years follow-up that wear was twice as great the first two years with a 22.225 diameter head using the alumine ceramic/polyethylene combination (0.1 mm per year), then stabilised. This was probably due to a stabilisation period. We are probably currently in this stabilisation period with the zircone/polyethylene implants.


M. Ding I. Hvid

Structure model type and trabecular thickness are important characteristics in describing cancellous bone architecture. It has been qualitatively observed that a radical change of trabeculae from plate-like to rod-like occurs in aging, bone remodeling, and osteoporosis. Thickness of trabeculae has traditionally been measured using model-based histomorphometric methods on two-dimensional (2-D) sections. However, no quantitative study has been published based on three-dimensional (3-D) methods on the age-related changes in structure model type and trabecular thickness for human peripheral (tibial) cancellous bone.

In this study, 160 human proximal tibial cancellous bone specimens from 40 normal donors, aged 16 to 85 years, were collected. These specimens were micro-CT scanned, then the micro-CT images were segmented using optimal thresholds. From accurate 3-D data sets, structure model type and trabecular thickness were quantified by means of novel 3-D methods. Structure model type was assessed by calculating the structure model index (SMI). The SMI was quantified based on a differential analysis of the triangulated bone surface of a structure. This technique allowed quantification of structure model type, such as plate, rod objects or mixture of plates or rods. Trabecular thickness was calculated directly from 3-D images, which is especially important for an a priori unknown or changing structure. Furthermore, 2-D trabecular thickness was also calculated based on the plate model.

Our results showed that structure model type changed towards more rod-like in the elderly, and that trabecular thickness declined significantly with age. These changes become significant after 80 years of age for human tibial cancellous bone, whereas both properties seem to remain relatively unchanged between 20 and 80 years. Although a fairly close relationship was seen between 3-D trabecular thickness and 2-D trabecular thickness, real 3-D trabecular thickness was significantly underestimated using 2-D method.


S. van der Donk P. Buma R. Straathof D. Versleyen T.J.J.H. Slooff B.W. Schreurs

It has been generally accepted that dynamic mechanical load is important for normal bone physiology, remodeling and fracture healing. Impacted morsellized grafts can be seen as healing of many small fractured bone parts, involving bone remodelling, apposition and formation of new bone. Therefore load may be stimulative for the incorporation of this type of graft.

In a pilot study we observed a positive effect of load on the density of incorporated bone after 12 weeks. Based on these results we hypothesised that physiological loading has a stimulatory effect on the early stage of bone graft incorporation. To test this idea we implanted fresh frozen allograft bone chips in 12 goats and loaded these grafts with the newly developed subcutaneous pressure implant ( Lamerigts et al., Biomaterials2000; 21: 741–7). The goats were divided in two groups: non-loaded and loaded. The loaded group was subjected to a loading regime of 3 MPa for 5 days/week (1 Hz, one hour/day). After 5 weeks the bone mineral density was measured with quantitative CT scanning, followed by routine histology and histomorphometry.

Bone mineral density was not affected by load. Histology revealed microscopic evidence of normal bone graft incorporation as seen in previous studies. The amount of active incorporating bone was higher under load (p< 0.05).

The formation of a new bony structure was not affected by load in this early stage of bone graft incorporation. However, load resulted in a more active graft incorporation after 5 weeks. The difference between the loaded and non-loaded group might be partially obscured by a low level of physiological loading in the non-loaded group induced by the daily activity of the animals.


Full Access
P. O’Grady J. O’Byrne T. O’Brien* J. Fitzpatrick W. Watson

Aseptic loosening has become the single most important long-term complication of total joint replacements. The pathophysiology of this loosening is multifactorial in origin ranging from mechanical wear, poor surgical technique, thermal damage and the inflammatory response to particulate wear debris. Cytokines are released in response to macrophage activation by particulate wear debris (PWD), the resultant inflammatory cascade stimulates osteoclastic resorption of bone. The failure of remodelling and repair mechanisms may be as a result of Osteonecrosis from cement (PMMA).

Hypothesis: That PMMA increases Osteoblast susceptibility to necrosis and apoptosis following inflammatory challenge.

Materials and Methods: Osteoblast cell cultures were grown on PMMA cement plates and assessed for apoptosis and necrosis by PI exclusion staining, morphological changes on light and electron microscopy and flow cytometry.

Results: PMMA induced osteonecrosis is highest at 1 hour (34.45) in comparison to control levels (4.55). There is no significant change in Apoptosis at 24 hours. Culture of the Osteoblasts on cement and delayed stimulation with TNF-α causes increased Apoptosis and Necrosis.

Conclusion: PMMA cement causes Osteoblast necrosis in the early stages of polymerisation, after 24 hours there is little increase in apoptosis/necrosis. However Osteoblasts that grow in contact with cement are more susceptible to apoptosis and necrosis following TNFα challenge. This may prove to be an important step in the pathogenesis of Aseptic loosening.


M. Chaker P. Chambat

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to compare, at ten years follow-up, the clinical and radiological results obtained in two series of patients who underwent patellar tendon ligmentoplasty for anterior cruciate ligament tears. One series was operated in an acute setting (before 45 days) and the other for chronic lesions.

Material and methods: In 1986 and 1987, we performed patellar ligamentoplasty for anterior cruciate ligament tears in 230 knees. Mean delay to surgery was ten days for 77 knees (53 reviewed with clinical and radiological evaluation and 12 with questionnaires, i.e. 84%). For 153 knees surgery was performed for chronic lesions (107 reviewed with clinical and radiological evaluation and 12 with questionnaires, i.e. 77%). The IKDC chart was used to assess outcome with KT 2000 measurements on the loaded images.

Results: There was a significant difference between the two series for: overt meniscal tears at the time of surgery (58% in the chronic series and 11% in the acute series, p < < 1%); osteoarthritic (26% chronic versus 6% acute, p < 1%); overall IKDC score (96% for acute versus 84% for chronic, p < 3%). The same was true for subjective assessment (normal for 95% of the acute knees versus 65% for the chronic knees) and for rate of recurrent tears (2% for acute and 9% for chronic). There was no significant difference between the series for clinical signs (pain, swelling, apprehension), mean residual laxity as measured by KT 2000, although it was greater for the chronic knees (+2.6%) than for the acute knees (+2.3%). Permanent flexion was not significantly different between the series (31% for chronic and 28% for acute) although the reason was different since for the chronic series, subsequent meniscectomy was necessary.

Conclusion: Patellar ligamentoplasty performed in an acute setting provides better clinical and radiological outcome. It stabilises the knee better before possible development of a meniscal lesion that may precipitate osteoarthritis.


S. Jambou C. Hulet D. Schiltz D. Souquet B. Locker C. Vielpeau

Purpose: Arthroscopic reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) with a free patellar tendon graft is a classical method for the treatment of anterior knee laxity. The purpose of this study was to analyse clinical and radiological outcome in 218 cases at five years and to search for prognostic factors.

Material and methods: Between 1993 and 1994, arthroscopic repair of the ACL was performed in 218 knees with two independent tunnels using a free patellar graft. This prospective study included 177 knees reviewed at a mean 67±7 months follow-up using the IKDC criteria and instrumental manual KT-1000 laxity measurements. The series included 67.4% men and 32.6% women, mean age 26.7 years (14–59). Delay from the accident to surgery was a mean 22.3 months (1–228 months). Two medial, 15 lateral and five medial and lateral meniscectomies had been performed before the operation studied. The position of the tunnels was studied using the Aglietti method. Differences were considered significant at p < 0.05.

Results: Sports activities could be resumed in 87% of the cases at the same level for 62% with a mean delay of 12 months. Subjectively, the patients were satisfied or very satisfied in 86% of the cases. Symptom score was A in 50%, B in 38%, C in 8.3% and D in 3.7%. Maximal manual residual differential measured with KT-100 was 0.75 ± 2.3 mm with an abolished click in 82% of the cases and a glide in 12%. Sceondary medial meniscectomy was performed in 19 cases. At last follow-up the meniscal material was intact in 127 cases (60%). Overall IKDC score for the 177 cases reviewed was: A 57%, B 24%, C 9%, D 9%. Radiographically, the knee was normal in 66.6% of the cases, remodelled in 29.6%, and exhibited joint space narrowing less than 50% in 13.4% and overall osteoarthritis in 0.6%. The Aglietti lateral score as 25.5±7% for the tibia and 66.3±7.2% for the femur. During follow-up, there were 13 cases of recurrent tears related to repeated sports trauma or poor femoral position. During this same period, there were 20 tears of the contralateral ACL. Functional outcome was correlated with the presence of a medial meniscus, the length of delay from accident to surgery, and the presence of radiological evidence of residual laxity.

Conclusion: This study demonstrated that chronic anterior laxity of the knee, treated with a free patellar tendon graft implanted arthroscopically provides good restoration of the knee in 82% of the cases with little residual laxity. Joint space narrowing was found in 1% of the cases and was strongly correlated with the status of the medial meniscus that should be preserved. The number of recurrent tears was equivalent to the number of contralateral tears observed during the same period.


S. Plaweski T. Martinez C. Schuster P. Merloz

Purpose: This prospective comparative study examined the two-year results of two femoral fixation method for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) repair using the four-part hamstring technique. A consecutive series of 60 patients with the same tear criteria involving the ACL alone were randomly assigned to the two treatment arms. Femoral fixation was achieved by mixed corticocancellous transfixation or by interference screw fixation.

Material and methods: The series included two cohorts of 30 patients each. We excluded patients with a history of ligament or bone surgery and those with associated lesions of the peripheral ligaments. Complementary lateral reinforcement was not performed in either group. The interference screw fixation group had 20 men and 10 women, mean age 29 years (14–48), 18 right side. The blind femoral tunnel was drilled arthroscopically. The transfixation group included 19 men and 11 women, mean age 26 years (16–40), 17 right side. The blind femoral tunnel was drilled via a transtibial approach using the Rosenberg aiming procedure. In both cohorts, tibial fixation of the transplant was achieved with a resorbable polylactic screw measuring at least the diameter of the tibial tunnel. Statistical analysis of results (Statview 4.5) was based on the clinical IKDC score, thigh volume, and level of sports activity. Telos at 15 and 20 kg was used to measure laxity.

Results: Mean delay to review was 24 months (22–26). The two cohorts were comparable preoperatively (laxity, sports level, meniscal or cartilage lesions). There was no statistical difference for joint amplitudes, joint instability, or level of sports activity at last follow-up. The telos differential laxity at 15 kg was statistically lower in the interference screw fixation group (mean 1.1 mm) than in the transfixation group (mean 1.4 mm) (p < 0.01). There were no complications in either group, particularly no cyclope syndrome. Radiographically, there was no statistical difference for the position of the tibial tunnel. The femoral tunnel was however different: the Aglietti index was 0.57 for transfixation and 0.62 for interference screw fixation (p < 0.01).

Discussion: This prospective study demonstrated the good mid-term anatomic results after 4-part hamstring plasty of the ACL for both types of femoral fixation (transfixation or interference screw fixation). The position of the femoral tunnel appeared to be better with interference screw fixation, with a statistical correlation with better anatomic results (telos). This suggests that the transtibial femoral aiming procedure does not necessarily produce a totally satisfactory isometric alignment.


L. Bastian U. Lange C. Knop M. Zdichavsky M. Oeser M. Blauth

The biomechanical effects on facet joints after posterior fusion remain unclear and seem to be responsible for accelerated degeneration. The following biomechanical study was performed to investigate the effects on the pressure and mobility of neighbouring unfused segments after double level T12-L2 posterior stabilization.

The experimental study was performed on eighteen fresh, human, cadaveric thoracolumbal spine specimens. The specimens were cleaned and dissected from muscles and fat with care to preserve bone-ligament units intact. In a specially constructed testing machine the data of the segmental pressure and mobility of adjacent segments above and below the fusion were measured before and after double level T12-L2 posterior stabilization with an internal fixator (Universal Spine System) in flexion, extension, lateral bending, and rotation. For measuring the mobility a motion tracker (3Space Fastrak) and for direct evaluation of the pressure a quartz miniature force transducer was used. Also the bone mineral density of the specimens were measured and showed normal values.

In flexion and extension Range of Motion (ROM) of the segment above the double level T12-L2 posterior fusion was significantly increased (p< 0,05). In the adjacent segment below the fusion there was no significant increased mobility after fusion for each moment was applied. The pressure did not show any significant difference, but after posterior fusion in flexion and extension the pressure below the posterior fusion (L2/L3) was decreased and above the fusion (T11/T12) increased.

There is evidence that the adjacent segment above a double-level T12-L2 posterior fusion becomes more mobile and leads possibly to an accelerated degeneration in the facet joints due to increased stress at this point. Also the posterior fusion seems to change the load distribution in the facets of adjacent segments. These results could be responsible for symptoms like low back pain after spinal surgery.


C. Trojan K. Benchik El Fegoun J.S. Coste P. Boileau

Purpose: Cyclope syndrome is described in the literature as a postoperative complication of arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) grafts, leading to permanent flexion. The discovery of this syndrome in ten patients before reconstruction of the ACL led us to revisit the pathophysiology.

Material and methods: Among 250 candidates for ACL grafts, ten presented a positive but dull Lachman-Trillat sign with permanent flexion greater than 10°. The rotation click was negative in two and dull in eight. KT 200 measured differential laxity greater than 4 mm in all. Nine patients were reviewed at consultation, one patient had recently undergone another operation. Clinical and radiographic findings recorded in the patient’s files and operation reports were reviewed by two observers different from the operator.

Results: Arthroscopy revealed a partial tear of the ACL in three cases, a scarred ACL nourished by the PCL in five and a full thickness tear of the ACL in two. There was a fibrous barbell nodule inserted on the tibia in all cases, a characteristic feature of cyclope syndrome. The nodule was interposed between the femur and tibia at extension and was resected in all cases. Pathology reported a ligamentoid structure undergoing fibrous organisation. At last follow-up, greater than two years for nine patients, the IKDC rating was A for six patients and B for three patients. None of the patients had a defective extension differential.

Discussion: Persistent flexion preoperatively in a patient with a torn anterior cruciate ligament suggests possible presence of a ligamento-fibrous nodule interposing between the femur and tibia at extension. This nodule can go unnoticed at arthroscopy but appears to be unmasked in the Cabott position after partial resection of the subpatellar fat. It is particularly important to look for this nodule when the stump of the torn ACL is not found and the patient has experienced a recent sprain. Since we started looking for this nodule in all cases with resection, we have no longer encountered postoperative cyclope syndrome.

Conclusion: This group of arguments strongly suggests that the conditions necessary for the constitution of cyclope syndrome are probably present before reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament.


R. Ling

Localised femoral endosteal bone lysis at or distal to the level of the lesser trochanter can occur soon after cemented hip arthroplasty or as long as 15 years later in a hip that has otherwise functioned perfectly well. The first important question about these lesions is why they occur, and the second, why they occur where they do. Particulate debris, particularly from wear of ultra-high molecular weight poly-ethylene, is commonly regarded as the cause, but changes in hydrostatic pressure may play a more important role than previously thought.

Because the femur bows anteriorly and posteriorly, deficiencies in the cement mantle are particularly likely to occur in relation to the interior aspect of the stem at the level of the lesser trochanter and in relation to the tip of the stem posteriorly.

We suggest that localised lytic lesions occur at the sites of defects in the cement mantle. There is evidence that with pressure changes, joint fluid and whatever particles it contains come into contact with the endosteal surface of the femur at the sites of these mantle defects. Such lesions occur only rarely when polished stems are used. With matt stems, abrasive wear enlarges the internal dimension of the cement mantle, increasing the size of the fluid conduit between stem and cement. Matt surfaced stems retrieved from patients with localised lysis show evidence of both abrasive wear and slurry wear, ‘wear caused by hard particles carried in fluid’. The nature of the changes due to slurry wear shows that the flow of fluid along these stems is from distal to proximal. As the stem becomes increasingly unstable inside the cement mantle owing to wear, the hydrostatic effects on increased stem movement become magnified and may on their own produce bone lysis.


Full Access
E.J. Smith

Following total hip arthroplasty, leg-lengthening disability is not uncommon, and it remains an important problem for patients.

This paper discusses methods of equalising limb lengths and reviews results achieved at the Avon Orthopaedic Centre in Bristol.


N. Bonin T Aït Si Selmi† H. Dejour P. Neyret

Purpose: We studied the subjective, functional and radiographic results after anterior cruciate ligament repair using the mid-third of the patellar tendon, combined with tibial osteotomy for valgisation during the same operative time.

Material and methods: Between 1983 and 1999, this procedure was performed in 66 knees. We studied 47 knees presenting a remodelled medial compartment or medial fem-orotibial narrowing greater than 50% (preosteoarthritis), excluding three AFTI, 11 lateral decoaptations, and 5 knees with excessive genu varum. We reviewed 34 knees (72.3%) in 32 patients with a mean follow-up of 10.5 years (1–16 years) using the IKDC ratings. A complete series of x-rays were obtained in 33 patients including a comparative single-leg stance view and full leg views. Mean age at surgery was 32 years (18–49); delay from accident to operation was eight years (0.5–33). There was at least one antecedent operation in 24 knee (22 medial menisci). Fourteen knees presented a remodelled medial femorotibial compartment (grade B) and 19 had a medial joint space narrowing > 50% (grade C). The lateral femorotibial compartment was remodelled in four cases (12M%).

Results: At last follow-up, 93% of the patients were satisfied or very satisfied. The mean subjective score including symptoms, function and level of activity was 78.4 (46–96.6). Intense sports activities (ski, tennis) were practised by 46% of the patients. Clinically, five knees were considered normal (A), fifteen nearly normal (B), twelve abnormal (C) and two very abnormal (D). These results were correlated with pre- and postoperative anterior translation of the tibia on single leg stance. Radiologically, among the 1′ knees with a remodelled medial femorotibial component (grade B), three progressed to grade C; among the 19 knees in grade C, two progressed to grade D (narrowing > 50%). Axial correction was significantly greater for grade B knees at review. For the lateral femorotibial compartment, 22 showed remodelling and two narrowing less than 50%. There was no correlation with axial correction. Changes in tibial tilt were studied.

Discussion, conclusion: At ten years, the combined ACL reconstruction, tibial osteotomy for valgisation, led to stabilisation of the osteoarthritic condition and most often led to a stable and satisfactory knee.


S. W. J. Becker I. Hovorka K. Röhl C. Argenson

Recent developments focus on a minimal-invasive approach to the thoracic spine with thoracoscopy. Very often it is necessary to collapse the lung in order to expose the thoracic spine. This technique cannot be used on patients with reduced pulmonary capacity or pleural adhesions. We are trying to use a semi- open technique to combine the advantages of open and thoracoscopic surgery.

The semi-open technique requires a 5 cm incision over the 10th rib with or without partial removal of the rib and retropleural approach to the thoracolumbar spine. From this incision a retropleural insertion of the thoracoscope using an additional incision 2 ribs above the original incision can be performed if necessary. The vertebra and surrounding tissues are visualised by thoracoscope, all further necessary interventions as well as diaphragm splitting can be performed via the main approach. After trial operations on cadavers we performed a spondylodesis on 22 patients with fractures of the lower thoracic and upper lumbar spine using a semi-open technique.

With the above described incision we were able to expose all vertebrae from Th11 to L2 and to perform a splitting of the diaphragm. Two cases needed an intraoperative and one case a postoperative pleural drainage. The maximum blood loss was 200 ml, maximum operation time 180 min. No complications such as infections or malunion occurred during follow-up.

We conclude that the semi-open technique is combining the advantage of open and thoracoscopic surgery avoiding a collapse of the lung and reducing the number of pleural drainages. All levels of the thoracolumbar spine can be reached and a safe spondylodesis with minimal blood loss can be performed. However this technique is requiring a learning curve and should be preceded by animal or cadaver trial operations.


C.J. Grobbelaar

This paper examines research over three decades.

Special mention is given to material research and basic implant design. In South Africa there were unique opportunities to conduct engineering and biological research on materials, close examining the interface – the key to total joint replacement success. It seems there is now more clarity on the longevity of implants and on how to avoid certain pitfalls.


J-P. Mortier J-L. Bernard I. Fahed

Purpose: We present a new basilar osteotomy we have called TRADE. This osteotomy uses a single flat-oblique cut to achieve lateral basimetatarsal translation with lowering and derotation.

Material: The ATLAS system was used. This system includes a four point axial staple for the phalanx and a staple plate for the metatarsus. The staple plaque was designed around the tibial osteotomy plates. It is composed of a straight plate screwed to the diaphysis. It carries two spikes at variable angles that penetrate the epiphysis perpendicularly. The desired angle is measured peroperatively and the plate is bent appropriately using a graduated template. Application of the staple plate then imposes the exact correction.

Method: We tested the basal osteotomy on five anatomic hallux valgus specimens, including one fresh specimen. We also reviewed 125 files of patients who underwent double flat-oblique osteotomy fixed with the system. Each type of hallux valgus was defined pre- and postoperatively, clinically and radiologically: four views, three to determine the orientation of the deformity in the three planes and a fourth one to assess reducibility. The operative technique involved four times. The first was often not necessary: lateral release, depending on the degree of retraction on the reduction view. The second time, the medial chevron osteotomy of the first phalanx, was almost always needed. The third time was the basimetatarsal ostetomy; the flat-oblique direction was determined from an abacus taking into account three variables: varus, rotation, lowering. The fourth time, exostosectomy with capsule retention, was not always needed. The patients experienced little pain postoperatively when the procedure was limited to the two osteotomies without affecting the soft tissues. For the 125 cases, intermetatarsal deviation was improved from 18°67 to 6°86, metatarsophalangeal angle from 33°59 to 11° and pronation from 13°42 to 0°72.

Conclusion: The TRADE osteotomy allows correction in all three planes. Correction is particularly precise in the frontal plane where the risk of undercorrection and recurrence is high. The procedure can be modulated according to the radiological presentation and can be limited to two osteotomies using short skin incisions without opening the joint.


J.B. Stiehl

Chronic ligament insufficiency in total knee arthroplasty is associated with extension/flexion imbalance, late rupture of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), excessive joint line elevation and PCL insufficiency.

To solve the ligament balance problem, designated anatomical ‘cookbook’ bone cuts are used. Cutting ligaments affects flexion and extension gaps differently, and saving the PCL makes flexion gap adjustment difficult.

In ligamentous releases, the extension gap is affected by release of pes tendons, semimembranosus, iliotibial tract, biceps tendon, gastrocnemius tendon, and popliteus. Extension and flexion gaps are affected by release of the medial and lateral capsular ligaments, superficial medial collateral ligament, and lateral collateral ligament. The 50% rule states that flexion increases 50% more than extension with release.

Revision of all implants is usually needed. A liner exchange seldom works. Flexion/extension balance remains the critical problem. Modular revision implants are critical for correction of the gaps.


J. Bellemans

Many surgeons consider revision total knee arthroplasty (TKA) a difficult procedure, calling for flexibility and improvisation.

However, revision TKA can be broken into a number of consecutive steps that need to be performed. Setting up a reproducible and stepwise approach is mandatory for the surgeon who performs this procedure more or less regularly.

At our institution, we have followed a five-step protocol in performing 166 revision TKA procedures. Its relatively strict guidelines leave little room for intraoperative improvisation. Our protocol covers exposition, implant extraction, implant selection, bone preparation and dealing with bony defects.

There has been acceptable ‘on the table’ reconstruction in all cases.


A. Pierre C. Hulet S. Jambou D. Schiltz B. Locker C. Vielpeau

Purpose: Tibiotalar arthrodesis is a classical procedure for the treatment of painful deformation-destruction of the tibiotalar joint. The purpose of this retrospective study was to determine prognostic factors and tolerance to tibiotalar arthrodesis observed in 68 procedures performed with two different techniques (47 surgical fusions (Group 1), and 21 arthroscopic fusions (Group 2)).

Material and methods: Between 1985 and 1999, 68 patients, mean age 51 years (22–88) underwent 55 arthrodesis procedures (47 post-traumatic, 2 paralytic, 6 rheumatoid polyarthritis, 4 sequelae of septic arthritis). All patients had major functional impairment. The tibiotalar joint was stiff in all cases and mean motion was 20 ± 15°. The subtalar facet was nearly normal in 33 cases, altered in six and had already fused in nine. The mediotarsal facet was altered in 12 cases, six had already had a double arthrodesis, and was normal in 50. On the preoperative Méary view, there was a normal axis in 13 patients, valgus in 28 and varus in 24. According to the Duquennoy radiographic criteria, there was subtalar involvement in 32 cases and mediotarsal involvement in 19. Tibiotalar arthrodeses procedures were performed arthroscopically after 1993 for cases with little axial deformation. Open surgery was used for all other cases (43 Méary technique). A plaster cast was used in all cases. All patients were reviewed using the Duguennoy score and two radiographic views: lateral weight-bearing view for the sagittal plane position (tibiopedious angle) and the Méary view for the frontal plane.

Results: At a mean follow-up of four years, fusion rate was 82% (group 1 83%, group 2 81%). Mean delay to fusion was 3.2 ± 1 month irrespective of the causal disease or surgical technique. Functional outcome was very good in 28%, good in 34.5%, fair in 34.5% and poor in 3% and did not depend on the surgical technique. The subtalar was painful with zero motion in 18 cases (26.5%), generally associated with residual equine. The mediotarsal was stiff in 17 cases and very painful in four. In the frontal plane, 16 ankles were correctly axed, 27 were in valgus (mean 5.6°) and 20 in varus (mean 7.6°) with no difference between the two groups. In the sagittal plane, four ankles were in talus, nine in neutral position, and 49 had a residual equine, including 32 > 5°. In most cases, fair or poor outcome was related to subtalar pain. More than 50% of the patients with equine fusion greater than 5° had subtalar pain.

Conclusion: For the same deformity, arthroscopic arthrodesis can shorten hospital stay and improve the rate and degree of trophic disorders. Arthroscopic tibiotalar arthrodesis is an elegant technique that we use for centred ankles or for patients with risk factors, particularly skin conditions. The rate of fusion with the arthroscopic approach is not however better than with open surgery. Precise clinical and radiological assessment of the subtalar facet as well as the position of the fusion in the sagittal plane at 90° without equine deviation are important prognostic factors observed in this series.


H. Bensafi E. Bonnet B Chaminade J.L. Tricoire J. Puget

Purpose: Prevention of post-trauma infections is basically aimed at streptococcal, staphylococcal and anaerobic germs. An increasing number of open fractures are however contaminated with Bacillus cereus leading to a multidisciplinary discussion involving infectious disease specialists, orthopaedic surgeons, and bacteriologists concerning the appropriate management. Bacillus is an ubiquitous genus of sporulated telluric Gram positive germs found in soil and plants. B. cereus can lead to local wound infection. This environmental (including hospital) bacterium is often a temporary host of the skin flora and its isolation can be taken as a simple contamination with no therapeutic consequence. B. cereus is sensitive to fluoroquinolones.

Material and methods: Between August 1995 and December 2000, B. cereus was isolated in 41 patients from surgical specimens taken from deep muscle and bone tissues. Ordinary medium was used for culture. Genomic analysis was used to type the Bacillus. Statistical analysis was conducted in cooperation with the epidemiology unit.

Results: In our unit, isolation of B. cereus was significantly associated with severe open leg fractures (Gustilo grades IIA and IIIB) with soil contamination. Samples were taken due to fever, wound discharge, elevation of C reactive protein despite antibiotic prophylaxis beyond 48 hours using the standard protocol of aminopenicillin + betalactamase inhibitor, constantly inactive against B. cereus. The strains identified presented different genomic types ruling out nosocomial contramination. One amputation, one chronic osteitis and one anteriolateral leg compartment necrosis resulted from B. cereus infection in this series.

Conclusion: Arguments developed here allow us to recall the importance of careful surgical debridement of open fractures and to emphasise the requirement for bacteriological samples and appropriate antibiotic therapy for 48 hours, combining, in agreement with the 1998 Consensus Conference, aminopenicillin + betalactamase inhibitor and gentamycin which is active against B. cereus. Severe open leg fractures which follow an unfavourable course should suggest possible B. cereus infection requiring early antibiotic therapy using a regimen with good bone diffusion including a fluoroquinolone which is always active against B. cereus.


T. Trichard F. Rémy H. Migaud A. Besson C. Feugas A. Duquennoy

Purpose: The aims of this work were to assess very long-term outcome and to assess functional course of talocrural arthrodesis as well as to determine the clinical and radiological impact on adjacent joints.

Material and method: Fifty-two talocrural arthrodeses performed in 52 patients between 1963 and 1981 served as the reference population for this study. Clinical and radiological assessment of this series of patients was conducted in 1983, then again in 1999. Twenty-five talocrural arthrodeses in 25 patients were reviewed at a mean 23 years (19 to 36 years) (six patients were lost to follow-up, 20 had died, one had had leg amputation. The arthrodesis had been performed for advanced degenerative joint disease or to correct for post-traumatic deformity, or in two cases, for neurological varus equinus. Functional outcome was evaluated on the Duquennoy and Stahl score (100 points) that was also used for the intermediary assessment. Radiographic assessment included the position of the arthrodesis, the status of the adjacent joints (subtalar and mediotarsal), and residual motion of the forefoot.

Results: At 23 years follow-up, 13 patients (52%) had good (five patients) or very good (eight patients) function and 12 (48%) had fair function, according to the 100 point scale. There were no patients with poor function. Patients without intercurrent conditions (neurological or heart disease, obesity) had good or very good function in 80% of the cases. Patients were very satisfied in 48% of the cases, having “forgotten” their ankle. At the seven-year follow-up analysis, 15 patients (60%) had a very good (ten patients) or good (five patients) result, seven had a fair result, and three had a poor result. Comparing the 7-year and 23-year assessments did not disclose any significant degradation of the result (p = 0.07). Intercurrent conditions explained the two functional degradations, but there were also three functional improvements over the same period. Talocrural arthrodesis induced stiffness in the subtalar joint in all cases, associated with severe osteoarthritis with little clinical expression. There was a slow degradation of the mediotarsal joint but hypermobility useful for good function was maintained in 45% of the cases (mean 24°). Fair results were related to development of subtalar osteoarthritis, malposition of the arthrodesis in the frontal plane (rear foot varus) and presence of intercurrent conditions (cardiovascular, neurological disease).

Conclusion: Talocrural arthrodesis is a safe and reliable procedure for the treatment of destroyed joints. This palliative surgery can restore satisfactory function which persists in the long term.


V. Gleizes A. Vuagnas N Granier J. Salamon C. Vaylet P. Alberin E.P. Denormand F. Signoret J.M. Feron A. Lottue P. Granier D. Peyramond J. Breux J.E. Bru L. Arieux G. Potel M. Dueng C. Perronne

Purpose: The diagnosis of chronic bone and joint infections, particularly in patients with implants, can be a difficult task. Among the clinical and laboratory tests proposed for the diagnosis of infection, 99mTc HMPOA labelled leukocyte scintigraphy is one of the least invasive examinations available. We evaluated its efficacy in terms of reliability.

Material and methods: Ninety patients with suspected bone and joint infections were included in this study: 53% men and 47% women. Mean age was 56.6 years and 80% had osteosynthesis implants. Mean duration of clinical signs before scintigraphy was 6.5 months. The suspected site was the hip in 49%, the knee in 28% and another in 23%. Physical examination (local aspect, temperature) and laboratory tests (differential count, platelets, CRP, ESR) as well as standard radiographs were performed in addition to labelled scintigraphy. These patients were operated and bone samples were taken for bacteriology studies to confirm or infirm the presence of infection. In this series, 73% of the patients were found to have a real infection (73% staphylococcal, 17% multiple germs, 20% other).

Results: The following variables were included in the multivariate analysis: fever, standard radiographs, polynuclear neutrophil count, CRP, ESR, leukocyte-labelled scintigraphy. Sensitivity (Se), specificity (Sp), and odds ratio (OR) were determined. The multivariate analysis showed: fever (Se=0.48; Sp=0.59; OR=1.3); abnormal radiograph (Se=0.71; Sp=0.62; OR=4; p=0.02); polynuclear neutrophil count (OR=1; p=0.19); CRP (OR=1.02; p=0.06); ESR (OR=1.03; p=0.04); leukocyte-labelled scintigraphy (Se=0.71; Sp=0.82; OR=11.6; p< 0.001).

Discussion and conclusion: These findings demonstrate the efficacy of 99mTc HMPOA-labelled leukocyte scintigraphy in terms of reliability for the diagnosis of chronic bone infection compared with other clinical (fever), laboratory (ESR, CRP), and radiographic indicators.


J-A. Epinette

Purpose: Despite excellent histological and biomechanical results proving the real efficacy of “biological” implant-bone fixation, use of hydroxyapatite surfacing, widely used for hip implants, remains largely unemployed for knee prostheses. We analysed our ten years experience with hydroxyapatite coated knee implants in a prospective study of 384 cases.

Material and methods: Among the 384 prostheses, 361 were primary implantations, and 331 (92%) were still “in place” after ten years experience. Nineteen patients had died and only one (0.3%) was lost to follow-up; three patients were excluded from the analysis due to other major handicaps. There were five revision procedures including three (0.8%) related to deep infection and two (0.6%) to failure with loosening and pain. Mean age of the patients was 70.4 years (40–89). Indications were basically degenerative disease (91%), inflammatory rheumatoid disease (6.9%) and necrosis (1.7%).

Results: Mean IKS score at five years minimal follow-up for primary surgery patients was 95.4 and 84.2 points for the overall knee score and the functional score respectively, giving 81.1% and 73.1% good and excellent results for the knee and functional score.

Discussion: These clinical results compare well with the best studies reported on total knee arthroplasty with or without cement. Radiographically, we did not have any cases with evidence of an implant-bone interface problem, for femoral or tibial components with the exception of two knees (0.55%) with severe osteolysis and loosening leading to revision surgery. In addition, hydroxyapatite demonstrated its capacity to progressively fill bone-implant gaps over time, confirming the experimental work by Søballe. Cumulative survival was 96.6±0.0688% and 97.37 ± 0.0324% taking ablation and prosthesis-related failure as the endpoint respectively.

Conclusion: These results allow renewed confidence in hydroxyapatite as a prosthesis fixation mode, for the knee as well as for the hip.


P. Rossouw

Increasingly often diagnosed by sophisticated investigation, rotator cuff disease may be treated conservatively or surgically. Surgical options are decompression alone, decompression and debridement, partial rotator cuff repair, full reconstruction, tendon transfer and prosthetic replacement.

Emphasising the quality of the repair rather than the classification of the injury, this paper details the criteria used in reaching a decision about the type of surgical treatment. Clinical, radiological, ultrasonographic and arthroscopic findings are used. The prognosis is directly related to the repair.


M. Kassab Ph. Antract A. Babinet G. de Pinieux B. Tomeno

Purpose: We report oncological and functional outcome after ten pelvis reconstructions using the Puget technique.

Material and methods: Ten patients (six men and four women), mean age 50 years (37–71) with malignant bone tumours, generally a chondrosarcoma, were included in this series. The tumour involved zone II in five patients, zones II and III in the other five. Resection was followed by reconstruction using the superior portion of the homolateral femur and a cemented total hip arthroplasty. Mean resection was 13 cm (7–23). Mean operative time was 386 min and mean blood loss was 5490 ml. The resection was wide in seven patients, marginal in two and resection margins were contaminated in one. The patients were reviewed at three, six and twelve months then each year. The function score (Enneking) was recorded for all patients. Living patients also filled out a TESS quality of life questionnaire.

Results: At mean follow-up of 22 months (7–42), four patients were living and disease free and two patients were living with recurrent disease. Three patients had died from their disease and one from pulmonary embolism. Postoperative complications were: one dislocation, one phlebitis, one reflex dystrophy, one injury to the internal genital nerve, two infections and one necrosis of the scar tissue. Bone healing was obtained at a mean five months. The mean Enneking function score was 68% and the mean TESS score was 75%.

Discussion: The high proportion of deaths is related to the severe prognosis of these pelvic tumours. This reconstruction technique described by Puget, provides an interesting alternative to other reconstruction methods for the acetabular region. The autogenous graft combined with a standard total hip arthroplasty makes this a rather easy to perform and low-cost procedure.

Conclusion: Functional outcome has been, in our experience, better than with arthrodesis, acetabular prosthesis, or saddle prosthesis and massive allograft of the pelvis.


O. Vinardi Ph. Soubrane M. Ghréa J. Honiger A. Apoil A. Sautet

Purpose: Filling bone defects is a major challenge in orthopaedic surgery. One of the therapeutical alternatives to combined autologous bone grafts and bone substitutes is to use a biomaterial carrying bone stem cells. The purpose of this study was to test a hybrid biomaterial in a major bone loss model in the rabbit.

Material and methods: The study material was the AN 69 hydrogel (Hospal). Twenty-four rabbits were divided into four identical groups of six individuals. Each animal underwent a unilateral resection measuring 2 cm in the mid third of the cubitus: group 1 simple resection; group 2 resection and centromedullary pin; group 3 resection, centromedullary pin and biomaterial; group 4 resection, centromedullary pin, biomaterial with bone marrow stem cells. Animal were sacrificed at six weeks. A radiograph was obtained immediately after surgery and at sacrifice. The study parameters were: new bone formation, bone healing, bone remodelling. Each criteria was assessed with a mean score (Werntz score). A pathology examination was performed in all cases to study new bone formation, polylmere degradation and inflammation.

Results: The overall radiographic score was group 1 = 2, group 2 = 8, group 3 = 24, group 4 = 42 for a maximum 62 points. Histologically, there was nonunion after simple pinning with formation of a defective callus. The nonunion persisted after pinning and hydrogel without cell seeding. New bone formation was moderate and predominated on the borders of the bone resection. After pinning associated with cell seeded hydrogel, an osteogenic lamina arose from the hydrogel network. This osteogenesis was continuous with osteogenesis originating from the bone section cut.

Discussion: These findings demonstrate that associated a hydrogel with bone stem cells can produce more significant bone formation than in controls, confirming the animal model. Treatment of major bone loss and aseptic osteonecrosis after curettage could be proposed with this new biomaterial combining a hydrogel and CD34+ stem cells in humans.


J.F. de Beer K. van Rooyen R. Harvie D.F. du Toit C. Muller J. Matthysen

The acromion is a bony process that juts out from the lateral end of the scapular spine. It is continuous with the blade and the spinous process. The process is rectangular, and carries a facet for the clavicle. Inferiorly is sited the subacromial bursa. Inferior encroachment or displacement of the acromion can result in impingement.

The aim of this osteological study was to assess the presence of acromial displacement and variations predisposing to compaction of the subacromial space. Using the method described by Morrison and Bigliana, we assessed the scapulae of 128 men and women ranging from 35 to 92 years of age. We found a flat acromion in 30%, no hook in 48%, a small hook in 18% and a large hook in 4%. The presence of a hook was associated with a subacromial facet and a large hook with glenoid erosion.

This study confirms the presence of four types of acromion.


J.M.P. Sparkes J.H. Healey M. Burt P. Boland

Aim: To investigate the possibility of using polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) bone cement as a delivery vehicle for anti-tumour chemotherapy.

Methods: Doxorubicin was incorporated into PMMA pellets and incubated in physiological medium at 37°C. Release of Doxorubicin from the pellets continued for eight weeks as demonstrated by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC).

Doxorubicin-containing pellets were incubated with sarcoma cultures at 37°C for 24 hours. A significantly higher cell death rate(as measured by flow cytometry) was seen in the plates exposed to Doxorubicin compared to those exposed only to plain PMMA, indicating that the Doxorubicin released from the cement pellets retained its cytotoxic capability.

PMMA-Doxorubicin cement pellets were implanted in rat tibiae and the animals killed at intervals over three weeks. HPLC analysis showed that this technique produced high concentrations of Doxorubicin adjacent to the implant but negligible systemic levels(heart, kidney, lung, liver).

Four groups of rats had sarcomas established in their tibiae and then treated either by excision of tumour and Doxorubicin/PMMA implantation, excision and plain PMMA implantation, excision only or no treatment. The animals were then observed for tumour regrowth. A survival advantage was demonstrated for those animals treated by tumour excision and Doxorubicin/PMMA implantation.

Conclusion: These experiments demonstrate that PMMA is an effective medium for the delivery of cytotoxic chemotherapy. This method has scope for early translation to the human situation.


O. Fernez-Bertrand G. Saillant E. Rolland

Purpose: This work was not designed to re-examine the different surgical techniques and their indications, but to verify the long-term stability of outcome in patients having undergone the same surgical technique performed by the same surgeon (82% of the cases). The purpose of this work was to assess elbow function at more than ten years after surgery in a series of 28 elbows with a mean follow-up of 13 years.

Material and method: Between 1985 and 1990, 31 patients underwent elbow surgery in our unit for epicondylitis after failure of well-conducted medical treatment. No selection was made, all operated patients were included in the analysis. Twenty-five patients (28 elbows) could be re-evaluated. All patients included in the analysis responded to a phone interview and completed a questionnaire at a mean 13 years follow-up. The surgical technique was the same in all cases: systematic complete dissection of the common epicondyle muscles, with very superficial partial epicondylectomy with a chisel was needed.

Results: All patients in the series were reviewed at three and nine months after surgery then were included in this study at ten to fifteen years. At last follow-up, outcome was excellent in 21 elbows, good in five, and acceptable in two. There were no elbows with a poor outcome (based on the roles and Maudsley classification).

Discussion: For some, surgical treatment with muscular release would hinder muscle force and increase the risk of destabilised elbow (the epicondylar muscles being considered to actively stabilise the joint). The present analysis was unable to identify any signs suggestive of sequelae related to instability nor patient complaints related to decreased muscle force.

Conclusion: It would appear that the good results remain stable in the long term. The only case exhibiting a worse situation was in a patient with predictable problems due to cartilage injury. The good initial results were definitive, inciting us to propose this surgical procedure for patients who do not respond to medical treatment. This procedure allows renewed sports activities at the former level in the great majority of the cases after a simple standardised intervention.


J. Hadjokowicz F. Duteille P. Pasquier F. Dap G. Dautel

Purpose: The antecubital flap described in 1983 by Lamberti and Cormak fed by the first proximal collateral of the radial artery is not widely used. We propose a clinical series of seven patients where this flap was used to demonstrate its interest for elbow substance loss.

Material and method: Our series included seven patients operated on between 1998 and 2000. There were six men and one woman, mean age 33.5 years (2′–53). Tissue loss ranged form 20 to 90cm2. Tissue harvesting ranged from 20 to 108 cm2. For four cases the tissue loss was limited to the olecranon and the epitrochlear area in a traffic accident victim. In all cases bone exposure required coverage. The lateral cutaneous nerve of the forearm was harvested in all cases with the flap to provide adequate sensitivity. Mean operative time was 1 h 15 min.

Results: All flaps survived. Elbow amplitudes remained normal. Sensorial disorders resulting form the lateral cutaneous nerve removal from the forearm were considered insignificant by all patients. The patients found the scar to be satisfactory.

Discussion: There have been few reports on the usefulness of this flap. Our clinical experience suggests the antecubital flap is a reliable flap which is easy and rapid to perform.


O. Jarde E. Havet P. Mertl Z. Laya F. Tran Van P. Vives

Purpose of the study: We reviewed a series of 52 cases of chronic Achilles tendinopathy treated surgically by release of the fascia cruris, resection of peritendon, longitudinal incision of the tendon and occasional excision of intratendinous lesions.

Materials and methods: The mean course prior to surgery was about 18 months. Twenty-six patients practiced sports. Complaints were bilateral in 12 cases. Pain was always present. Ultrasound exploration evidenced paratendinitis (n = 21), tendinosis (n = 22) and paratendinitis with tendinosis (n = 9) (Puddu classification). Patients were reviewed after a minimal 2-year follow-up. Results were assessed on the basis of clinical findings.

Results: Mean follow-up was 5 years 6 months. Twenty-nine patients were free of pain. The range of motion was normal in 48 cases and 29 patients resumed sports activities at the same level as prior to surgery. Outcome was very good in 29 patients, good in 14 average in 6 and poor in 3.

Discussion: Stiffness of the tibio-tarsal joint can be avoided by proper mobilization. Outcome appears to be better in middle-aged patients. Poor outcome is closely related to amyotrphy. The presence of a foot deformity does not appear to have an unfavorable influence on outcome. The Achilles tendon must not be infiltrated. Ultrasound is highly contributive, but MRI provides a more accurate analysis.

Conclusion: Surgical treatment of chronic Achilles tendinopathies can be proposed when conservative treatment has been unsuccessful. Outcome is better in young active patients and in cases where paratendinitis predominates.


N.S. Thompson P.C. Nolan J.W. Calderwood

Introduction: Intramedullary fixation is a recognised method of fracture fixation in fifth metacarpal fractures. We describe a new technique for fixation of fractures of the middle three metacarpals.

Patients and Methods: We reviewed a single surgeon’s series of 16 male patients (mean age 27.9 years, range 18–46) with 20 displaced transverse midshaft fractures of the 2nd, 3rd and 4th metacarpals treated by antegrade intramedullary Kirschner wiring. Work related and domestic accidents constituted the mode of injury in 8 patients and in the remaining 8 as a result of an assault, fall or road traffic accident. Twelve patients were in employment at the time of injury including four heavy manual labourers.

A single pre-bent 1.6 millimetre Kirschner wire was inserted into the medullary canal through a drill hole in the metacarpal base and passed across the reduced fracture into the metacarpal head. The proximal end of the wire remained protruding percutaneously. Following stabilisation of the fracture, early mobilisation was commenced.

Results: All of the study group had satisfactory clinical and radiological outcomes. All of the fractures united clinically and radiologically. There was one case of delayed union, with union at 35 weeks. In the remaining patients fracture union had occurred radiologically at an average of 5.4 weeks (range 4–12 weeks). Radiologically there was a mean angular deformity of 4.05° (range 0–11°) in the coronal plane and 0.75° (range 0–9°) in the sagittal plane. Postoperatively 2 patients developed a pin tract infection requiring treatment with antibiotics and early removal of the K-wire. All patients on questioning by telephone questionnaire were satisfied with their resulting hand function and appearance. All patients had returned to normal activities of daily living by 8 weeks. Of those patients in employment all had returned to work by 6 weeks (mean 3.3. weeks).

Conclusion: Antegrade intramedullary single K wiring is a useful technique for managing unstable midshaft metacarpal fractures producing excellent clinical and radiological results.


B. Chaminade S. Zographos G. Uthéza

Purpose of the study: In accordance with the conclusions established at the SOFCOT symposium in 1988, we propose surgical treatment of displaced fractures of the calcaneus with screw fixation after reduction. We developed an original classification system of 3D computed tomography images which allows a precise description of the fractures and guides joint and calcaneal body reconstructions. The purpose of this work was to provide a precise analysis of operated fractures in order to identify prognostic factors and validate use of exclusive screw fixation for calcaneal fractures.

Materials and methods: This series included 60 operated articular fractures of the calcaneus. The Uthéza classification was: 12 vertical, 7 horizontal with 1 fracture line, 3 horizontal with 2 fracture lines, 23 mixed with 1 fracture line and 15 mixed with 2 fracture lines. 3D computed tomography evidenced the fundamental fracture lines and their anterior extension. Fixation was achieved with one screw inserted in a transverse position under the posterior facet and one oblique screw from the greater tuberosity to the sustentaculum tali.

The medial and lateral Böhler angles were measured on plain x-rays. The analysis included search for a double line on the posterior talocalcaneal facet, secondary body displacement, the position of the oblique screw and the degree of posttraumatic subtalar wear. The clinical criteria established in the 1988 SOFCOT guidelines were recorded. Analysis of variance, Pearson and Spearman coefficients, and RIDITS analysis (the most powerful method available for evidencing a relationship between two qualitative variables one of which is ordinal) were used to search for prognostic elements and correlations.

Results: No severe complications were encountered with the wide lateral access. A negative medial Böhler angle was significantly correlated with an additionnal posterior facet line. A mean 80 p. 100 reduction in the lowering of the medial part of the posterior facet and an 87 p. 100 reduction in lateral pivoting were achieved irrespective of the type of fracture. Minimal secondary body displacements were significantly related to anchorage of the oblique screw outside the sustentaculum tali. Functional outcome was satisfactory (very good + good + average) in 75 p. 100 of the cases and physical outcome in 50 p. 100 (very good + good) irrespective of the type of fracture. Outcome was significantly correlated with reduction in the Böhler angle, double lines on the posterior facet, secondary displacement and osteoarthritis.

Discussion: The 3D analysis of posterior facet fractures using our classification was useful in guiding reconstruction with correction of the medial lowering and the lateral pivoting. A negative medial Böhler angle was a factor of poor prognosis: more posterior facet lines, joint wear and deterioration of the functional and physical outcome. Good outcome required good reduction of the Böhler angle and good anchorage of the oblique screw in the sustentaculum tali. Good subtalar mobility was associated with pain relief. Uniform anatomic and pathologic classifications and precise analysis criteria are needed for pertinent comparison between series and proper definition for indications for first-line reconstruction-arthrodesis.

Conclusion: Measurement of the medial Böhler angle improves the sensitivity of revision criteria for articular fractures of the calcaneus. Screw fixation has proven its reliability.


P. Cronier A. Talha L. Hubert Ph. Massin J.L. Toulemonde

Purpose: We wanted to ascertain whether the advantages of functional treatment on trophicity could be combined with the advantages of surgical treatment on anatomic results in patients with displaced calcaneal join fractures.

Material and methods: Using the AO 3.5 reconstruction plates with specific stereotypic modelling we were able to obtain solid fixation in almost all cases of calcaneal joint fractures using a rigorous technique and following precise principles, notably the direction of the screw into the sustentaculum tali.As the osteosynthesis is very stable, we postulate that partial and progressive early weight bearing would be acceptable as long as pain was under a threshold level used as sign of micromobility. The first cases were very favourable so we extended this method, using it as a routine procedure for all cases (excepting those with an associated injury excluding weight bearing). Among 122 fractures operated with this method, 118 were reviewed.

Results: According to the Duparc classification, we treated one type 2, 34 type 3, 76 type 4 and seven type 5 fractures. Weight bearing was initiated on the average at 14 days, with a median of seven days. The Boehler angle improved from 0° preoperatively to 22° postoperatively. We did not have any cases of secondary displacement greater than 2°. The functional outcome was, according to the SOFCOT criteria: very good 34.5%, good 41.4%, fair 9.5% and poor 0%. Physical results (SOFCOT criteria) were: very good 17.2%, good 54.3%, fair 26.7%, poor 1.7%. Anatomic results according to AFC criteria were: very good and good 69%, fair 25.9%, poor 5.1%.

Discussion: These result demonstrate that a rigorous therapeutic management scheme can combine the advantages of functional and surgical treatment of displaced calcaneal joint fractures. Early weight-bearing below the pain threshold was effective since all our bilateral cases could be discharged after walking a few steps. Recovery was more rapid when weight bearing was late. Crutches could be abandoned at two months on the average.

Conclusion: We believe that solid osteosynthesis is possible in almost all cases of displaced calcaneal fractures with joint involvement if a rigorous technique is used. Progressive early weight bearing below the pain threshold is a significant adjuvant factor favouring rapid and quality outcome.


I. Hovorka A. Damotte H. Arcamone C. Argenson P. Boileau

Purpose: The advent of lapaoscopic disectomy has made it possible to cure discal herniation with minimal trauma and no limitations on indications. We have adopted the technique described by J. Destandau since June 1998. The purpose of this work was to report our early results.

Material and methods: Forty patients were included in a period from June 1998 to August 2000. There were 24 men and 16 women, mean age 43 years (24–78). Eleven patients had an associated stenosis of the spinal canal. Accelerated rehabilitation was employed. Sitting and driving were allowed early.

Results: Mean follow-up was 13 months (2–27 months). Mean operative time was 63 minutes (30–150 min). Mean hospital stay was 3.92 days (2–10). There were 29 patients without stenosis of the lumbar canal. In this subgroup, outcome was excellent in 69%, good in 21% (six patients), fair in 3% (one patient), and poor in 7% (two patients). For the PROLO score, three patients were who were retreated were not included in the analysis. Outcome was excellent in 73% (19 patients), good in 12% (three patients), fair in 12% (three patients, and poor in 4% (one patient). In patients with lumbar canal stenosis, (eleven patients), three were reoperated for wider decompression; there was no haematoma. One patient was reoperated for deep infection. For the other patients the WADDELL score was excellent in five and good; in two the PROLO score was excellent in six and poor in one.

Discussion: The technique favoured a narrow approach. Shorter exposure preserved the anatomy, but for the three patients with an associated stenosis, reoperation was necessary for decompression. For the cases without complications, we noticed that recovery was very rapid, a finding which is exceptional with the conventional technique.

Conclusion: Our early experience with this technique has demonstrated that laparoscopic discectomy is feasible and safe. An associated stenosis is a limitation; we recommend systematic decompression in association with the discectomy.


J.E. Viljoen S.A. Osman

Two surgeons performed arthroscopic subacromial decompression (ASD) on 302 shoulders between January 1995 and January 1999. The mean age of patients was 49.6 years (28 to 81). The mean follow-up period was 36 months (4 to 62).

Evaluated using the modified UCLA scoring system, 91% of patients had a good to excellent result at short-term follow-up. However, patients reviewed for two years or longer showed a 98% successful outcome. The commonest delay in improvement was stiffness, with six patients requiring surgical intervention. Early mobilisation with posterior capsular stretching is recommended. Careful clinical assessment of patients with chronic rotator cuff impingement and accurate identification of arthroscopic impingement signs ensures a successful outcome. Our study confirms other reports that ASD leads to good results in carefully selected patients.


J. Afriat G. Guegnon

Purpose: Kinematics of the total knee arthroplasty plateau has been widely studied. Many methods can be used: opto-electronic captors, electromagnetic knee device, radiography, repositioning with the CAO model. We report a simple method based on calculating the position of two radio-opaque markers and the contours of the prosthetic components.

Material and methods: Twenty patients with a unilateral mobile plateau total knee arthroplasty were studied. An image amplifier linked to a digital recorder (frequency 25 Hz), CAO models of the implant, and adapted software (Matlab) were used. Each patient performed a series of movements, standing up from the sitting position, within the fluoroscopic field. Each sequence was digitalized. Kinematic images were sampled at 6 Hz. Different parameters were measured on each sampled image: position of two radio-opaque markers included in the polyethylene insert and characteristic dimensions of the prosthesis components. These 2D recordings were used to deduct the relative 3D position of each of the prosthetic components. Laws of analytic geometry and functional analysis were used to resolve the triangular matrices needed to transform the 2D measures into 3D values. Angular and linear positions of the prosthetic components were established for different times t. Reconcatenation by time produced an kinematic analysis of the pros-thesis behaviour.

Results: This method allowed us to establish the kinematics of the total knee arthroplasty mobile plateau with a precision of 0.2 mm and 0.4°. The proposed analysis method is reliable and precise. It is less costly in development time than methods based on automatic repositioning of 3D models of the implant on fluoroscopic images.

Conclusion: The measurement method proposed requires radio-opaque markers positioned in orthogonal directions so they are visible during movements. Although we used a semi-automatic calculation protocol, totally automatic systems can be applied to process fluoroscopic images.


Y. Julien E. Baulot G. Sys L. Dewilde P. Trouilloud

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to analyse results of the inverted shoulder prosthesis (Grammont Delta III prosthesis) for surgical treatment of malignant tumours of the upper portion of the humerus in twelve patients.

Material and methods: Twelve patients were treated in two centres (six patients each). There were five women and seven men, mean age 51 years (34–69). Seven had a primary tumour and five had a unique secondary tumour. All tumours were implanted after Malawer I resection (IA four case and IB two cases), with an autologous bone graft using resected irradiated bone. All resections were wide as needed for healthy margins. Resection extended to the lower fourth of the humerus in four cases, to between the lower fourth and third in six cases and to the upper third or less in two cases. Ten patients were reviewed at a mean follow-up of 22 months (7–60) to assess clinical function (Constant score) and radiographic results. Two patients with a unique secondary tumour died within the six months following surgery due to progression of the primary tumour.

Results: The mean Constant score was 58.75 (30–81.1). Weighted for age and gender, the result was 70.3% (32.6–82). Five sedentary patients were able to resume their former activities (1/2). Radiographically, there were two resorptions of the autograft, two glenoid lucent lines that did not progress, four notches in the column, and three Sneppen 1 calcifications. Mechanically, there were no prosthesis dislocations in patients whose resection extended to the lower fourth of the humerus, four dislocations in the one-fourth one-third group (2/6) and two dislocation in the upper group (2/2).

Discussion, conclusion: Functional and radiographic outcome after anatomic prosthesis implantation for surgical treatment of malignant tumours of the upper portion of the humerus was directly related to the status of the rotator cuff. The Grammont Delta III inverted prosthesis provided satisfactory functional and radiographic results in this indication after Malawer I resection, irrespective of the rotator cuff sacrifice. The risk of prosthesis instability appeared to be related to the extent of the humeral resection required for cancerological cure. For patients who undergo resection of one third or more of the humerus, muscle plasty should be associated.


V. Mandalia T. Thomas

The aim of this study was to evaluate the analgesic effect of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL) in patients with refractory tennis elbow, golfer’s elbow and plantar fasciitis.

Patients with tennis elbow (34), golfer’s elbow (11) and plantar fasciitis lesions (14) who had not responded to a minimum of six months’ conservative treatment were included in this three-year study of ESWL. Patients who were pregnant or had neurological problems, coagulation disorder and tumour in the area of treatment were excluded. Patients received 2 000 shock waves of 0.04 to 0.12 mj/mnf three times at monthly intervals. Patients were followed up for a minimum of six months and maximum of 36 months. The effectiveness of ESWL was assessed in terms of improvement in duration and severity of pain, functional disability, complication of treatment and recurrence. Good or excellent results were achieved in 67.65% of patients with tennis elbow, 45.45% with golfer’s elbow and 71.42% with plantar fasciitis.

ESWL seems a useful treatment option, as effective administered monthly as weekly. Its effectiveness in cases of golfer’s elbow in questionable.


B. Zniber P. Beaufils

Purpose: Re-establishment of correct patellofemoral kinetics is a major challenge in patients with major dislocation of the patella. Several factors affect the position of the patella, rotation of the prosthetic components, lateral section of the patella, and …perhaps…surgical access.

Material and methods: Between 1994 and 1999, 26 knees with major dislocation of the patella were treated by the same operator with total knee arthroplasty (TKA) using a Cedior (Sulzer) implant. The operative technique was the same for all patients with the exception of the surgical access. For group 1 knees (n=13) a medial access was used (medial parapellar approach, 2 lateral patellar sections). For group 2 knees (n=13) a lateral access was used (lateral parapatellar approach lifting the anterior tibial tendon and refixing it after the procedure with systematic lateral fixation of the patella). Patellar tilt and lateral displacement and the patellar index (PI) (distance using head of the fibula as the fixed point) were the main judgement criteria. Student’s t test was used for statistical analysis. The two groups were comparable for: preoperative axial deviation (176.8±6.45°), lateral displacement (8.65±3.74 mm), and PI (0.789±0.166), and postoperative position of the femorotibial implants.

Results: Patellar displacement persisted in one knee in group 1 requiring a new prosthesis. Anterior impaction of the tibial piece in one knee in group 2 did not require reoperation. Radiographically, lateral displacement was minimal in both groups (0.692 and 0 mm in groups 1 and 2) (p=0.17). Residual postoperative tilt was +3.8° in group 1 and −3.3° in group 2 (p=0.06). PI was 0.859 in group 1 and 0.956 in group 2 (p=0.24). In group 2, the postoperative PI (0.956±0.231) was not changed from the preoperative PI (0.831±0.152) an expression of the absence of ascension of the anterior tibial tendon (p =0.1).

Dicussion: Lateral displacement of the patella was entirely corrected in both groups. Unlike the lateral access, medial access, even with lateral section of the patella, did not correct for the tilt. Raising the anterior tibial tendon did not in our experience have any iatrogenic effect in itself. Irrespective of the femorotibial axis, lateral access for degenerative knees with major dislocation of the patella appears to be the best approach for implantation of total knee arthroplasty.


D. Conhyea T. O’Donnell F. Condon T. Shaju E. Masterson

Background: We have noticed while performing total hip arthroplasty, that during skin closure, the anterior edge of the wound tends to migrate proximally in relation to the posterior edge. This result is an inaccurate approximation of the wound, the so-called ‘dogs ear’. The aims of the study were to assess and quantify the degree of migration of the anterior edge relative to the posterior one using an invisible marker and to see whether marking the incision site prior to surgery improved skin closure.

Material and methods: We included forty patients undergoing primary hip arthroplasty in the study. Prior to surgery, the skin was marked with five lines perpendicular to the incision line with an invisible skin marker using the greater trochanter as reference point. The skin was then routinely prepared with betadine and a proprietary adhesive incision drape (Ioban 2) was applied to the incision site. The surgeon performed the operation routinely and intra-operatively, the subcutaneous fat content was measured at three set points and averaged. After the wound had been closed, an ultraviolet light source was used to highlight the invisible lines. The gap between the anterior and posterior edge was measured for each line. One set of patients had their incision site marked with a visible marker on the incision drape while the other set did not.

Results: There was a persistent proximal migration of the anterior edge in relation to the posterior edge. The proximal part of the incision site had a more marked skin migration compared to the distal wound. In the unmarked group, the proximal part of the anterior edge tended to migrate on average by 9.5 mm (from 30 mm to 5 mm) in respect to the posterior edge. In the marked group, this migration was reduced to an average of 1.6 mm (from 2 mm to 0 mm) and there was a statistical difference between the 2 groups with p< 0.0001 using the independent t-test as illustrated by the table. Of note, the degree of migration did not vary with the thickness of the fat content. Also, all the wounds healed with no signs of infection.

Conclusion: From this study, we have been able to quantify objectively the extent of migration of the anterior edge of the wound in a hip incision in relation to the posterior edge. Improved hip closure following total hip replacement was achieved after marking the skin prior to surgery. We therefore recommend marking the skin pre-operatively prior to hip incision in order to achieve accurate skin closure as part of the general principle of proper wound closure.


J.-N. Goubier C. Laporte G. Saillant

A 55-year-old man developed a pseudoaneurysm of the popliteal artery after tibial valgization osteotomy performed for degenerative genu varum. A tourniquet was used for the procedure. A wedge osteotomy was performed two centimeters under the joint line; the correction angle was ten degrees. Immediately after the end of the procedure, the distal pulses disappeared for ten minutes. Doppler exploration of the arterial network did not demonstrate any anomaly. Ten days postoperatively, the patient complained of sudden onset pain in the knee and tension in the popliteal fossa. Arteriography demonstrated a pseudo-aneurysm of the popliteal artery. The lesion caused an interruption of arterial flow and was successfully treated by emergency resection and suture.


Full Access
T. Odendaal

The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of various modes of treatment for low back disorders in terms of eventual physical impairment and disability.

Between 1998 and 2001 the author assessed for compensation purposes 135 adult men and women with low back disorders, following the bio-psychosocial approach described by Waddell. Grades of impairment and disability were compared in respect of various treatment categories, including non-surgical treatment, discectomy (single procedure), fusion (single procedure), single surgical procedure (any type), multiple surgical procedures (any type). The last category comprised patients with recognisable psychosocial features, regardless of treatment.

Mean results for the different categories show considerable variation between patients. Although the results are not mathematically pure, there are certain clear trends. Non-surgical treatment gives the lowest impairment on the Wad-dell scale. A single surgical procedure, regardless of type, results in 56% greater physical impairment than non-surgical treatment. With multiple surgical procedures, impairment increases in proportion to the number of procedures. Patients with recognisable psychosocial features show proportionately more inappropriate symptoms and signs, regardless of treatment. Patients’ subjective sense of disability and distress is usually higher than their objectively assessed physical impairment.


P.M. Kelly K.J. Mulhall W.G. Watson J.M. Fitzpatrick J. O’Byrne

Aseptic loosening is currently the leading cause of failure of total hip arthroplasty. The aetiology of periprosthetic bone resorption is currently under intense investigation. Wear particles are produced from the articulating surface of the femoral and acetabular components. These particles gain access to the bone-cement interface where they are phagocytosed by macrophages. Particle stimulated macrophages differentiate into bone resorping osteoclasts. This leads to periprosthetic bone resorption and subsequent implant loosening.

Nuclear factor kappa B (NFκB) is a transcription factor known to be activated by pathogenic stimuli in a variety of cells. The activation of NFkB would appear to be the primary event in the activation of particle stimulated macrophages in the periprosthetic membrane. NFκB subsequently causes a cascade of events leading to the release of bone resorbing cytokines, namely interleukin-6 (IL-6) and tumour necrosis factor α (TNFα).

The aim of our study was to ascertain if bone resorption could be prevented in vitro by the addition of PDTC, an NFkB inhibitor to particle stimulated macrophages.

Human monocytes were isolated and cultured from healthy volunteers. The monocyte/macrophage cell line was differentiated into osteoclasts by the addition of alumina particles and allowed to adhere onto bone slices. The NFkB inhibitor, PDTC, has added to the cultured osteoclasts. Bone resorption was analysed by counting the number of resorption pits in each bone slice.

The addition of PDTC to stimulated macrophages reduced the number of resorption pits by greater than 40% compared to control.

This is a unique and promising finding that may offer a future therapeutic strategy for the prevention of periprosthetic bone resorption and therefore aseptic loosening in total hip arthoplasty.


E. Coetzee A.P. Revelas

Reviewing 40 consecutive cases over a two-year period, we tested the efficacy of variable screw plate fixation postoperatively.

A Codman plate was used in all cases. We compared radiological preoperative measurements of the kyphotic angle and disc height with immediate postoperative measurements and measurements at a mean of eight months postoperatively. In no case was there an increase in kyphotic angle. Disc height remained within two mm of that shown on immediate postoperative radiographs.

We concluded that satisfactory results are obtained with variable screw plate fixation, with no compromised stability.


E.J. Smith

There has been an escalation in the number of revision total hip arthroplasty (THA) procedures. In the UK, revision operations now make up 15% of THA surgery. The use of bone graft in revision surgery is a major challenge. Prosthetic stability within the graft is essential for the process of new bone formation.

This presentation discusses the parameters that influence the stability of the composite construct, such as implant design, graft composition and impaction technique.


Vedova P Dalla K.J. Mulhall F Margheritini J Kennedy L. Romanini

Polyethylene wear in total hip arthroplasty Is associated with generation of particulate wear debris and component failure. Wear has both mechanical and biological consequences with one of the most important of these being the stimulation of immune medicated periprosthetic osteolysis in response to polyethylene particles. It has been shown that the amouont of wear debris generated correlates with the degree of osteolysis encountered. Unfortunately, the assessment of wear of components remains difficult and we wished to apply a new digitised technique of measuring wear using engineering computer softwear on a population of uncemented total hip replacement (THR) patients.

Forty patients having primary uncemented THR (ABG 1 prosthesis) for osteoarthritis were enrolled in the study. Seventeen had a 28mm femoral head implanted and 23 had a 32mm head. There were 28 females and 12 males concerned, all having standardised (120 cm hip to x-ray tube) ;weight bearing antero-posterior plain radiographs of the hip performed in the immediate post-operative period and again at a mean of 6 years post-operatively (range 54 – 96 months). The x-rays were then scanned to computer and analysed using Autocad software. The analysis essentially involved 4 steps, namely assessing sphericity of the cup, sphericity of the head, superimposition of the post-operative and 6 year radiographs an.d obtaining computer generated analysis of both the amount and direction of wear.

The results of our analysis demonstrated that there was an overall mean wear of 0.157mm per year (range 0.08 – 0.27mm). Of the 17 patients with a 28mm head the mean wear was 0.143mm per year, whereas the 32mm heads were associated with a mean wear rate of 0.188mm per year, with the difference reaching statistical significance (p=0.004). Analysis of the direction of wear demonstrated that as expected wear typically occurred in a superolateral direction with a mean vector of 9° lateral to the vertical axis of the hip.

These results primarily demonstrate the usefulness of appropriate computer software in determining wear of components in THR. This allows for assessment of rate and degree of wear which may be important in identifying patients at particular risk of developing significant osteolysis, loosening and ultimately component failure. The results are also consistent with previous reports of increased volumetric wear with large diameter heads and direction of wear in retrieval studies. It is therefore promising as an investigative tool for the in vivo assessment of inovations in THR design in the future.


P.M. Kelly D. Beregin U. Cunningham T. Higgins A.R. Poynton M.G. Walsh

Dysphagia is said to occur in 2% of patients immobilized in a Halo-Vest for the treatment of cervical injuries. This has been reported to lead to aspiration pneumonia which has a significant mortality rate in the elderly. In our experience dysphagia is a far greater problem than reported and is proportional to the degree of cervical spine extension.

The aim of our study was to ascertain the effect of cervical spine extension on swallowing in normal volunteers immobilized in a Halo- vest.

A halo vest was used to immobilize the cervical spine and to vary the degree of extension in ten volunteers. Videoflouroscopic studies were performed for each volunteer using three consistencies – liquid, paste and biscuit. The study was performed in neutral, 20° and 40° of extension. A subjective rating scale was completed by each volunteer. Videoflouroscopic study were blindly analysed by a radiologist and a speech and language therapist. Fourteen parameters were measured and recorded for each swallow.

Subjectively there was significantly increasing level of difficulty experienced for each swallow. At both degrees of extension there was a significant difference in oral transit time, piecemeal deglutition, Laryngeal penetration (a highly significant risk factor for aspiration), amount of residue occurring at the level of the valleculae and the number of successive clearance swallows compared to control.

In conclusion this study has clearly demonstrated significant impairment in deglutition following halo vest application. This impairment is directly related to the degree of neck extension. These findings should be taken into careful consideration when managing patients in cervical orthoses.


S.P. Kale L. Read S. Russell

With an alarming 10% increase in disability payments for backpain annually, the importance of early management of backpain within the first 6 weeks is paramount. The problems of a long and often agonising waiting time for a hospital consultation has been overcome by setting up of the Alexandra Hospital Backpain Assessment Clinic (ABPAC) with initial and immediate consultation by a trained clinical physiotherapist.

From the period March 1995 to March 1999 a total of 1881 patients werw reviewed by the ABPAC and an analysis of these cases is presented. 640/1881 (34%) patients were assessed, advised and discharged. 535/1881 (28%) patients were assessed, given supervised physiotherapy, advised and discharged. 169/1881 (16%) patients were assessed, investigated and discharged. In all 292/1881 (16%) patients needed actual review by consultant, out of which only 48 (2.5%) needed surgery. Only 63/1881 patients needed an MRI scan. There were only 2 patients who were found to have serious pathology in the form of spinal metastasis and only 5 were inappropriate because non-spinal pathology was picked up at initial assessment. There were no “missed” diagnosis.

Thus the clinic with its emphasis on examination and advice rather than “treatment” does not allow for repeated series of consultations nor the development of “regulars” who become dependent on the hospital for treatment, saving the NHS serious money and consultant time. This study proves that such a clinic apart from being safe, is also well accepted by patients and referring G.Ps alike. An outline of its working and the management algorithms is presented.


S.L. Evans D Bose L Jones R Pullin D.M. O’Doherty K.M. Holford P. Davies

Interbody fusion is increasingly widely used as a treatment for intervertebral disc disorders, but the biomechanics of the procedure are not well understood. The compressive loads through the spine are largely carried by the implant or bone graft, which typically rests on a relatively small area of the vertebral body. As the compressive strength of the bone is very low, subsidence of the implants into the vertebral bodies is a common clinical complication.

Previous biomechanical studies of spinal fusion have concentrated on the stiffness of the constructs, which is important in promoting fusion. Preliminary studies have shown that there are large differences in compressive strength between different implant systems, and gave an insight into the biomechanical factors that are important in determining the strength of spinal fusion constructs. This paper reports part of a larger on going study comparing anterior and posterior fusion systems, with various methods of fixation.

A major problem in interpreting the results of these tests is to distinguish between initial settling of the implants and the onset of failure to construct. We have developed a novel technique using acoustic emission monitoring to detect microcracking in the bones, which allows the onset of failure to be distinguished from initial bedding in of the implants.

Two implant systems were tested, the Syncage and the Contact fusion cage. The cages were implanted into porcine lumbar spines at L4-L5, and the implanted motion segment was then dissected out. Steel plates were mounted on each end using bone cement to ensure an even distribution of load through the vertebral body. The complete constructs were then loaded in compression, using acoustic emission sensors to detect microcracking in the bones. The load was cyclically increased in o.5kN steps until failure occurred.

The acoustic emission technique gave a sensitive indication of the onset of damage in the bones and allowed the initial settling of the implant under load to be identified. Using cyclic unloading and reloading, it was possible to accurately identify whether this damage had weakened the construct or increased its strength by redistributing stress concentrations. Initial results indicate that the Contact fusion cage fails at a much lower load than the Syncage in this model; this is ascribed to the very small contact areas between the cage and the vertebral body, which results in high compressive stresses in the bone. Under large compressive loads it appears that the constructs become unstable, and fail by buckling and plastic collapse of the vertebral bodies. Various failure models are therefore possible depending on which part of the vertebral body starts to collapse first.


J.A. Harty J.G. Kennedy K. Casey W. Quinlan

The longevity of total joint arthroplasty relies on articulating surfaces that are durable and produce little polyethylene debris and consequent osteolysis and loosening. In an effort to improve wear characteristics of the acetabular line, Hylamer (Du Pont Depuy Orthopaedics, Warsaw, Indiana) was produced as an alternative to ultra high molecular weight polyethylene. To date however reports using Hylamer with Cobalt chrome, stainless steel and alumina ceramic femoral heads have yielded results that have not reached the potential of initial in vitro trials. No study has examined the outcome following a Zirconia femoral head and a Hylamer acetabular shell. The tribological properties of Zirconia make it an ideal countersurface with low friction and long term durability. This study examines the outcome when these components were used in combination with a select cohort of patients and evaluates the benefit of their continued use.

From 1994 to 1997 fifty one patients had Hylamer cup with zirconia femoral head elite total joint arthroplasty performed. Forty-seven patients with fifty-eight arthroplasties were included in this study. All patients were less that fifty years with a male preponderance. There were eleven bilateral arthroplasties all of which had the second procedure at least two months from the index procedure. The principle diagnosis was osteoarthritis in forty-three hips with rheumatoid disease in twelve hips. The remaining two patients were operated on for end stage osteonecrosis.

The Elite total joint arthroplasty (DePuy, Warsaw in.) was used in all cases. The 22.225mm zirconia head was used exclusive in this study. The Hylamer shell used was a solid polyethylene block with a minimum depth of 6mm. Both the acetabular and femoral component were cemented with Palacos polymethylmethacrelate (Howmedica, Rutherford NJ) using third generation cementing techniques.

Patients were evaluated both clinically and radiographically three months and six months following surgery and thereafter at yearly intervals. Both the SF36 questionnaire and Mayo score were used to evaluate subjectively and objectively patient outcome. Regression analysis was used to determine if the age, sex and weight of the patient as well as the angle of inclination of the acetabular cup correlated with polyethylene wear and outcome. Kaplan Meir survival analysis was used to calculate the probability of survival of the original prosthesis.

There was no correlation between age, weight nor sex of the patient and outcome. The angle of inclination was correlated with a poorer ourcome but this did not reach statistical significance. The mean linear wear rate was 0.021mm year (range 0.011–0.055). Ten year survivalship analysis was calculated at 97%. SF 36 scores were standardised and the mean post operative score was 89 (range 62–97).

The results presented are significantly better than previously described in clinical trials using Hylamer liners. The reasons for this are multifactorial. This study used 22.225 mm heads in association with a solid cemented polyethylene acetabular block. Both have been associated with lower volumetric wear but neither have been used on previous studies of Hylamer. In addition the tribological properties of Hylamer may have been undermined in previous studies by poorly conforming countersurfaces using a different manufacturer for femoral and acetabular components. Finally the use of a second generation ceramic, zirconia with a Hylamer liner has produced medium term outcomes that confound previous reports and that exceed many published reports on traditional polyethylene liners.


P. J. Kiely C. Condron D. Monley P. Murray D. Bouchier-Hayes

Acute respiratory distress syndrome is a long established complication and continuing cause of significant morbidity and mortality in the multiply injured patient. Systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) is classically associated with acute pulmonary dysfunction. A variety of insults including trauma, sepsis, hypoxia, ischaemia reperfusion, can trigger systemic inflammatory response and acute lung injury. In models of sepsis, endotoxaemia and ischaemia-reperfusion, acute lung injury is characterised by widespread endothelial-neutrophil interaction and neutrophil activation.

Another associated finding in these models of injury, is evidence of induced diaphragm muscle dysfunction, by electrophysiological testing of muscle strips post injury.

An established model of incremental increasing skeletal trauma was employed. Adult male sprague dawley rats (mean weight 476grams, 370–520g) were randomised to control, single hindlimb fracture, bilateral hindlimb fracture and bilateral hind limb fracture + 20% haemorrhage.

Indices of acute lung injury studied 2 hours post injury were bronchalveolar lavage, cell counts, and protein assays. Pulmonary tissue myeloperoxidase activity was assayed as an indicator of neutrophil activation and pulmonary wet/dry weights were measured as a marker of pulmonary oedema.

Diaphragmatic electrophysiological testing was also performed 2 hours post injury. Freshly harvested diaphragmatic muscle strips had peak evoked muscle twitches measured, the maximal tetanic twitch and muscle strip fatigue times were also assessed.

Statistical analysis was performed by means of analysis of variance (ANOVA).

Results: The cohort of animals with the greatest injury severity manifested evidence of acute lung injury when compared with controls, this was associated with evidence of interstitial leucosequestration. This data suggests that neutrophils are involved in mediating an acute lung injury following musculoskeletal trauma.


A. Wakai J.T. Street J.H. Wang D.C. Winter R. O’Sullivan H.P. Redmond

Introduction: Limb reperfusion in patients following pneumatic tourniquet-controlled surgery is associated with nitric oxide (NO) generation. Meanwhile, NO mediates vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)-cytoprotection in myocardial ischaemia-reperfusion injury. In addition, VEGF is contributory in attenuating skeletal muscle ischaemia-reperfusion injury (SMRI). Whether this effect of VEGF is NO-mediated in SMRI is unknown. We investigate whether systemic nitric oxide production in tourniquet-induced SMRI is dependent on VEGF release.

Methods: Anaesthetised male C57BL/6 mice were randomised (n=10 per group) into two groups: time controls (no tourniquet) and test animals with bilateral hindlimb tourniquets (SMRI; 2 hours of ischaemia, 2 hours of reperfusion). Blood samples were collected in test animals prior to ischaemia and after 2 hours of reperfusion. In controls, blood samples were collected at the same corresponding time points. Serum VEGF, nitric oxide metabolites (nitrite and nitrate) and the proinflammatory cytokine tumour necrosis fractor (TNF)-α (an indicator of systemic inflammation) were determined. At the end of reperfusion, the lungs and muscle (right gastrocnemius) were harvested and tissue injury determined by measuring myeloperoxidase (MPO) activity, a marker of neutrophil infiltration. Data are presented as mean ± SEM and statistical comparison was performed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with significance attributed to P,0.05.

Results: In comparison to control animals, both the muscle (4.9±0.3 versus 4±0.03 units/g of wet tissue; P=0.02) and lung (16.7±1.9 versus 10.4±0.5; P=0.005) MPO activity at the end of reperfusion was significantly greater in test animals.

Conclusions: Our data demonstrates that SMRI results in local and systemic proinflammatory responses. In contrast to myocardial ischaemia-reperfusion injury, nitric oxide production in tourniquet-induced SMRI is VEGF-independent. Alternative mechanisms for nitric oxide production in tourniquet-controlled limb surgery requires further evaluation.


B. Mohan Prof. J.R. Nixon E. Doran A. Kumar

In Musgrave Park Hospital, Belfast, younger patients requiring THR were treated by custom-made titanium alloy femoral prosthesis. The identifit hips, which were used initially, were intraoperatively customised by preparing a silicon mould of the endosteal cavity and immediate computer assisted fabrication. The Xpress hips used measurements from preoperative marker x-rays allowing creation of templates and subsequent computer analysis to mill a stem prior to surgery.

7 identifit and 51 Xpress primary uncemented custom THRs were inserted in 50 patients between May 92 and June 96. The average age for the indentifit cases was 47 years (range 24–72) and the Xpress cases 39 years (range 23–51). The Xpress cases were followed up to an average of 47 months (range 12–74 months) and identifit cases to an average of 59 months (range 14–77 months). The indications for arthroplasty were osteoarthrosis in 15 hips, CDH in 14, dysplasia in 11, AVN in 4, rheumatoid arthritis in 3 and other diagnosis in 11. Clinical assessments were made using the Oxford score and the Modified Harris Hip score. The postoperative radiographs were evaluated for subsidence of the prosthesis; and adaptive osseous changes like osteolysis, hypertrophic cortical remodelling, sclerotic radiolucent line formation around the prosthesis and formation of a bone pedestal below the tip of the prosthesis.

The average post-op Oxford hip score for those patients not revised was 32.5 /60 (range 12–51).

16 of the 51 Xpress hips underwent revision and 2 were awaiting revision, which is a failure rate of 35.3%. Of the identifit hips 1 out of the 7 was revised (14.3%). Overall 32.8% was the rate of failure. The average duration from primary operation to revision was 47 months for Xpress hips and 90 months for the identifit hips. Of the Xpress hips, revision was done for acetabular component in 1, femoral component in 4, both components in 1, acetabular liner + femoral head in 1 and acetabular liner + femoral component in 9. The 1 revision in the identifit hip was for recurrent dislocation.

The reasons for revision in the Xpress hips were dislocation in 2 cases, loose femoral component in 13 cases and infection in 1.

Average subsidence of the femoral component was 6mm (range 0–25.9) and this did not have significant correlation with predicting outcome. Pedestal formation (intramedullary formation of bone beneath the tip of the femoral stem) was seen in 87%, sclerotic rediolucent lines were seen in 64%, osteolysis was found in 31% and hypertrophic cortical remodelling was seen in 31%. These also did not reach significance in predicting outcome.

Thus even though the idea of an uncemented custom THR is attractive, especially in the younger age group, the failure rate was found to be unacceptably high. On the basis of these data we have discontinued the use of this custom made non-porous uncemented femoral prosthesis.


G.C. O’Toole L. Grimes G. O’Hare M. Dolan D. Mulcahy

In Ireland and the United Kingdom, there were 22 deaths as a direct result of blood transfusion during the period October 1996 to September 1998. Added to this mortality, there were 366 cases of complications directly related to blood transfusion.

With the introduction of a Haemovigilance Nurse, changing surgical personnel and an increased public awareness of the potential hazards of transfusion, we were anxious to review whether transfusion rates have changed in our Regional Orthopaedic Centre for the period January 1999 to July 2000

All patients undergoing primary or revision arthroplasty in our Regional Orthopaedic Unit during the study period were retrospectively reviewed.

459 primary or revision arthroplasties were performed in the study period. Prior to the introduction of a haemovigilance Nurse, from the period January 1999 to October 1999, transfusion rates for primary arthroplasties averaged 1.41 units/patient with 74% of patients being transfused. After the introduction of a haemovigilance Nurse, from November 1999 to July 2000, transfusion rates for primary arthroplasties averaged 0.51 units/patient, with 31% of patients being transfused.

Prior to the introduction of a haemovigilance Nurse revision arthroplasties averaged 2.5 units/patient, with 100% of patients being transfused. After the introduction of the haemovigilance Nurse transfusion averaged 1.2 units/patient, with 62% of patients being transfused.

There was a statistically significant difference between transfusion rates prior to the introduction of a Haemovigilance Nurse and new surgical personnel and the period after their introduction (p< 0.005).

In the current climate post the Finlay Tribunal and the resultant increased public awareness, transfusing a patient without justifiable cause is no longer acceptable.

Patients in this unit are now transfused according to clinical needs and accurate measurement of intra-operative and post-operative blood loss, compared to their calculated maximum allowed blood loss (MABL). The changing transfusion rates seen in our Unit correspond to the introduction of a Haemovigilance Nurse and a change in surgical personnel. Our new transfusion protocol is working well without compromising patient care.


B. Al-Sayed A.R. Poynton C. Tansey P. Kelly M.G. Walsh J. O’Byrne

The management of type two odontoid peg fractures remains controversial. The policy in our unit is to initially manage all of these injuries non-operatively. Patients with displaced fractures (0.2mm translation, > 15° angulation) are placed in halo vests followed by fracture reduction under radiological control. Undisplaced or minimally displaced fractures are treated in either custom-made minerva orthoses or halo vests.

We report the results of 42 consecutive cases of type two odontoid peg fractures. There were 24 males and 18 females with a mean age of 53 (range 18–89) years. Twenty-one (50%) of patients were > 65 years of age. In 29 cases the fracture was undisplaced or minimally displaced and in the remaining 13 cases it was displaced (> 2mm translation, > 15° angulation) either posteriorly (extension-type)(6) or anteriorly (flexion type) (7). All displaced cases were treated in halo vests while the remainder were treated in minervas (14) or halo vests (15).

Loss of reduction occurred in nine cases necessitating adjustment in five and C1/2 posterior fusion in four. Of these cases five were displaced extension type-fractures, two required fusion. Pin site infection necessitated early removal of halo vest and conversion to minerva in three cases. In all of these cases fracture union was achieved.

Overall, union was achieved in 37 patients giving a non-union rate of 12%. The mean age of the five non-unions was 42 years with only one patient over 65 years of age. Four of these patients had C1/2 posterior fusions and the remaining patient refused surgery.

Of the 29 patients with displaced or minimally displaced fractures five (17%) required surgery for either non-union (3) or displacement (2), whereas three (23%) of the displaced group required surgery for non-union (1) or displacement (2). All of these were extension type fractures.

We conclude that a policy of non-operative management of these fractures resulted in union in a high proportion of patients of all age groups except for those with extension type fractures. This fracture pattern may warrant primary surgical intervention.


S. Byrne P. Connolly J.A. Harty P. Kenny F. McManus

Acute haematogenous osteomyelitis remains a significant cause of morbidity in the paediatric population. The clinical presentation has changed, however, over the last number of decades. The typical picture of established osteomyelitis is less commonly seen. Children more often present with a less fulminant picture.

The treatment of acute haematogenous osteomyelitis remains controversial. Antibiotic therapy, initially intravenous, then orally, is the gold standard. Hover, the role of surgery is unclear. Some centres, particularly in North America treat 25–40% of patients surgically.

We present our experience with acute haematogenous osteomyelitis in children over a three year period. The total number of patients was forty-five. The mean age was 6.1 (range 6 months to thirteen years). The most common isolated organism was Staphylococcus Aureus. The mode of treatment was intravenous antibiotics for two weeks, or until clinical, and laboratory evidence of improvement, and the oral antibiotics for six weeks. No patients required surgical interventioin. All patients made a satisfactory recovery.

We conclude that the treatment of acute haematogenous osteomyelitis in the paediatric population should consist of antibiotic therapy only, and that there is no place for surgery.


H. Mullett D. O’Connor M. Doyle* S. Kutty A. Laing M. O’Sullivan

Aim: A prospective randomised clinical trial was performed to evaluate two forms of immobilisation in the treatment of colles fractures not requiring manipulation.

Methods: Patients were randomised to either plaster cast (PC) or a removable splint: wrist splint (FWS) according to date of presentation. Patients who had associated injuries to the same upper limb, previous wrist fracture, and open fractures, below 20 years or impaired cognitive function were excluded. The hospital ethical committee approved the study and informed consent was obtained from patients. Patients were reviewed at one week, two weeks, six weeks and twelve weeks following enrolment into the trial. Radiographs were performed on the first four visits. Subjective data was obtained using a patient questionnaire. Levels of pain, comfort in cast, swelling and any modifications to the cast were documented. Was used at six and twelve weeks to assess Clinical assessment was performed by a qualified physiotherapist using the demerit score of Sarmiento which combines range of motion, grip strength and functional assessment.

Results: There were thirty-seven patients in the PC group and thirty-four in the FWS group. They were well matched in terms of age and sex distribution One patient in the PC group required manipulation under anaesthesia due to loss of position at one week. There was no statistical difference between either treatment method in radiological position. Nine patients in the PC group required change of cast due to loosening or discomfort. A further eight patients in the PC group required cast trimming. Visual analogue scores for pain and cast discomfort were lower in the FS group (p< 0.05). Grip strength compared to the opposite side was higher in the FS group (55.9% Vs 47.8% at week six, 71.8% Vs 65% at week twelve). Functional assessment demonstrated a higher score in the FS group at six weeks. However the difference did not reach statistical significance at repeat examination at twelve weeks.

Conclusion: In this study there was no difference in either method in maintaining fracture position. However there was greater patient satisfaction and earlier rehabilitation in those patients treated in a futura wrist splint. Patients treated in plaster cast required a greater use of plaster room resources. We feel that the use of a removable wrist splint in suitable patients with either undisplaced or minimally displaced distal radial fractures is validated by this study.


H.K. Sharma M. Bhat M. Laverick

We report the results of application of a strategy for deformity correction in hypophosphataemic rickets using careful preoperative planning, multiple osteotomies where appropriate and acute or gradual correction using internal or circular external fixation or a combination.

7 patients with 25 limb segments (14 femur and 11 Tibia) had deformity correction with either intramedullary nailing (10 Femur and 3 Tibia) or llizarov ring fixator (4 femur and 8 Tibia). The average age was 18 years (7–39 years), 5 were female and 2 male, had an average follow up of 36 months (10–77 months). All patients had adequate control of rickets pre operatively.

Clinical examination and analysis of pre and post-operative X-rays were carried out by an observer not involved in the surgical procedures. Standardised X-rays were analysed using the method of Paley and Tetsworth (Clin Orthop 280 48–71. 1992).

Satisfactory correction of deformity was achieved in both frontal and sagittal plane. There were total 8 episodes of soft tissue infection with no long-term consequence. Average ankle ROM was 7–44 and knee ROM was 0–128. There is no recurrence of the deformity.

All patients were happy with outcome and are prepared to undergo same treatment if required, even though some were restricted in terms of sport and leisure activities.

We conclude that satisfactory correction of deformity in VDRR can be achieved and maintained with nailing or llizarov fixator in short term with minimal complications, no recurrence and excellent outcome.


Full Access
R. Abel M. Dinkelacker R. Rupp H.J. Gerner

Instrumented gait analysis has evolved into a widely used tool to define and describe abnormalities of gait. It is used as a tool to enhance the performance in sports as well as to measure the effects of conservative or surgical treatment methods. Patients usually walk very slow during gait training, whereas normal data are obtained at regular walking velocity. This may lead to misinterpretations. The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of walking slow towards gait and to establish normal data for “walking slow” on a treadmill.

10 healthy volunteers with no known gait problem underwent training to accommodate to the conditions of treadmill walking. There were 5 females and 5 males. The mean age was 30 [range 22–56] years. Instrumented gait analysis was performed using a camera system (Motion Analysis Systems). Data obtained were processed by OrthotracTM and the proprietary software of our lab. During data acquisition participants were asked to walk at leisure velocity, then they were asked to slow down as much as possible.

The normal walking velocity of was 0,99 [range 0,78–1,16] m/s. When asked to walk as slow as possible the walking speed decreased to 0,29 [range 0,14–0,50] m/s. We noted a change in the ratio between swing and stance periods with less swing time, as well as a increase of double limb support time. Step length decreased. Changes in the pattern of motion included delayed and increased peak ankle dorsiflexion and decrease of ankle plantar flexion at initial contact. 3-D motion data for hip and knee also demonstrate noteworthy changes, generally resulting in a decrease of joint excursion.

Interpretation of gait data obtained from slow walking patients should consider the effects walking velocity. Locomotion therapy (e.g. for spinal cord injuries) should not force patients into motion patterns that are only found at faster walking velocities.


A. Beck P. Augat G. Krischak F. Gebhard L. Kinzl L. Claes

Non-steroidal anti-rheumatics (NSAR) are often used in patients with fractured bones for analgetic reasons. This animal experiment was performed to determine the influence of NSAR on the process of fracture healing. As an alternative central acting analgetic without peripheral effect Tramadol was included in this experiment.

Wistar rats were operated by a transverse osteotomy of the proximal tibia of the left leg, fracture was stabilized by intramedullary nailing (healing period 21 days). All therapeutics were applied orally, twice a day. The animals were divided in 4 groups, 10 rats each: Group 1 was treated with placebo, group2 with tramadol (20mg/kg bodyweight/day), group3 with Diclofenac-Colestyramin (5mg/kg/bw./day) over 7 days followed by 14 days placebo, group4 with Diclofenac-Colestyramin (5mg/kg/bw./day) over 21 days. On day 21 the rats were sacrificed and each leg was examined by x-ray, than the tibia was examined by CT-Scan, three-point-bending and histological evaluation.

There were no significant differences between group1 and 2 and between group3 and 4, respectively. Therefore the data of group1 and 2 as well as group3 and 4 are put together.

The results of CT and 3-point-bending showed, that rats treated by Diclofenac presented with delayed fracture healing compared to those treated by placebo or Tramadol. Bone density was 30% lower (p = 0,0001) in animals treated with Diclofenac (mean = 577mg/ccm, SD:53,1 in group1 and 2 vs. mean = 404,3mg/ccm, SD:27,3 in group3 and 4).

The breaking force was 45% (p = 0,0009) lower (mean = 42,4N, SD:14,2 vs. mean = 23,3N, SD:8,2) and the bending stiffness 56% (p = 0,0039) lower (mean = 1218,9Nmm/mm, SD:477,9 vs. mean = 532,6Nmm/mm, SD:389,9) in animals, treated with diclofenac. Diclofenacserumlevels on day 21 in rats with longtime diclofenac application (mean = 242ng/ml, SD:47,7) were comparable to those in humans.

Oral application of Diclofenac significantly delayed fracture healing in rats. This effect might be comparable to other NSAR and fracture healing in humans.


P. Buma J. Pieper T van Tienen JLC van Susante P.M. van der Kraan J.H. Veerkamp W.B. van den Berg R. Veth T.H. van Kuppevelt

Type I and II collagen-based scaffolds, with and without attached chondroitine sulphate (CS), were implanted without additional chondrocytes into full-thickness defects in the trochlea of young adult rabbits. We hypothesise that the chemical composition of the matrix will have a direct effect on the speed of repopulation and the phenotypic expression of the subchondral repair cells.

Evaluation of the repair process was performed with routine histology and with two quantitative histological grading systems, four and twelve weeks after implantation.

Four weeks after implantation, type I collagenous scaffolds were completely filled with a cartilage-like repair tissue. By contrast, type II collagenous scaffolds showed a superficial zone of cartilaginous tissue, and in many defects chondrocyte-like cells at the interface of the implant material with the subchondral bone. In collagen type II filled lesions larger areas of the scaffolds were completely devoid of repair tissue. Control defects showed a repair reaction that was very similar to that observed in defects filled with a type I scaffold.

After 12 weeks, the subchondral defect was largely replaced by bone and the differences between the scaffolds were less pronounced. The quantitative blind score of the sections confirmed that the scores of the control defect and of the collagen type I based scaffolds were slightly higher as compared to the type II based scaffolds. Irrespective of the type of scaffold, there was a trend that the scaffolds with CS scored slightly higher than those without CS.

We conclude that different types of scaffold induce different repair reactions. Collagen types I based scaffolds seem superior to guide progenitor cells from a subchondral origin into the defect. Repair cells in collagen type II based scaffolds seem to assume a chondrocyte-like phenotype, which could have a negative effect on the mobility of the repair cells.


M. Ding A. Odgaard I. Hvid

Osteoarthrosis (OA) stands alongside cancer and heart disease as one of the major causes of suffering and disability amongst the elderly. Changes related to OA occur in all elements of the joint, and there are indications that sub-chondral cancellous bone plays a primary role in the cartilage degeneration in OA. Most previous investigations have been focused on moderate and late OA, whereas little is known about the changes in cancellous bone microstructure in human early OA. This study quantified cancellous bone microstructure in early-stage OA using three-dimensional (3D) methods.

Subchondral cancellous bone specimens, produced from 10 human post-mortem early-stage osteoarthrotic (OA) proximal tibiae and 10 normal age- and gender-matched proximal tibiae, were allocated to 4 groups: medial OA, lateral control, normal medial control, and normal lateral control. OA initiates mostly at the medial condyle, and histological analysis was done to confirm this change. The cylindrical specimens were micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) scanned. From accurate 3D data sets, structural parameters were determined by means of true, unbiased and assumption-free 3D methods. The data were assessed statistically, and a p< 0.05 was considered significant.

Our data supported the hypothesis that significant microstructural changes – other than density changes – occur in early-stage OA cancellous bone. OA cancellous bone is markedly plate-like, less anisotropic, less interconnected, but lower in mechanical properties which suggests a disorganisation in the microstructure as OA initiation. Structure model type best explains the mechanical properties for the OA and the normal controls. However, the determination coefficients (R2) for the OA group are largely reduced. These results indicate significant property and quality deterioration in early-stage OA subchondral cancellous bone.


M. Haake A. Thon M. Bette

Extracorporal shock wave therapy (ESWT) seems to be a promising new tool for the treatment of chronic pain due to tendinopathies such as tennis elbow or a painful heel. Mechanisms of ESWT-induced analgesia are still unknown. One major system for controlling pain is the endogenous opioid system that could be the biochemical basis of the ESWT-effects.

The aim of the study was to investigate the possible influence of low energy ESWT on the endogenous opioid-system in the lumbar spinal cord of the rat.

Immunohistochemical analysis of the expression of opioids Met-Enkephalin (MRGL), and dynorphin (Dyn) were performed in rats treated either once with 1000 impulses or three times with 1000 impulses with two different energy flux densities each (0.04 and 0.11 mJ/mm2) at 4 or 72 h after ESWT.

No different immunoreactivity of MRGL and Dyn was seen after single ESWT treatment in comparison with the sham group. This result was not influenced by different energy flux doses or repetitive ESWT treatment. Met-Enk and Dyn expression was similar on ipsi- and contralateral side and was unchanged at later time points after ESWT treatment.

Low energy ESWT had no influence on the opioid-systems and therefore does not trigger this endogenous anti-nociceptive system under basal conditions. Furthermore these results show that low energy ESWT had no side effects on rat spinal cord (e.g. neuronal destruction or enhanced permeability of the blood brain barrier for leukocytes) even after the application of 3 x 1000 impulses with the energy flux density as high as 0.11 mJ/mm2. Although applications in orthopaedics have outnumbered those in urology, there is no firm evidence of efficacy of ESWT in orthopaedics from well-designed randomised clinical trials and the molecular mechanisms of the of the anti-nociceptive effect of ESWT are still unknown.


V. Jansson P. E. Müller

In an experimental study in rabbits, bone and cartilage regeneration could be achieved with a new class of resorbable bio-implants. These implants consist of an open porous structure made from polylacitdes and an open porous fleece made from polyglactin/polydioxanon. Both layers were not separated from each other, thus allowing mesenchymal cells to penetrate freely from bone into both the bone substitute and the cartilage substitute layer. It could be shown that ostochondral defects of 4mm diameter and 6mm depth in the condyle of the knee of rabbits healed by the process of mesenchymal cell differentiation into osteocytes and chondrocytes triggered by mechanical load induction only. Evaluation of the newly formed cartilage by light microscopy and immunohistology showed hyaline like features.

However, in many clinical cases chondral defects occur without substantial accompanying bone loss. In these situations, reconstruction of the cartilage defects only seems to be sufficient. However, fixation of such fleeces onto the bone is difficult. On one hand, adherence of the fleece to the underlying bone is crucial, on the other hand an open connection from the bone to the fleece must be accomplished in order to allow mesenchymal cells to penetrate the fleece. Therefor, any kind of glue fixation is not appropriate. To overcome this problem, a new fixation method was developed which allows a safe connection of the fleece onto the bone while providing an open contact of the fleece to the bone marrow for unhampered migration of mesenchymal cells.

The new “Cartilage patches” consist of a fleece (serving as the cartilage substitute layer) made from polyglactin/polydioxanon which had proven its applicability in the above mentioned experiments. Fixation of fleece was achieved by “darts” which were glued onto the fleece. The darts were made from polylacitdes, thus providing sufficient mechanical stability in the bone.

During operation, small holes are cut into the bone by a special instrument. The holes are located in such a way that the darts of the cartilage patch fit into them, such resulting in a stable fixation of the fleece onto the underlying bone. Blood containing mesenchymal cells from the bone marrow is able to flow from the holes into the fleece. In a biomechanical analysis the adherence of the cartilage patches were tested with respect to shear resistance and pull-out stabillity. The results of the tests show that the new cartilage patches withstand the mechanical stress exerted onto articular surfaces and can serve as a new class of cartilage substitute layers. In an animal experiment the applicability of the cartilage patches in reconstruction of cartilage defects in the knee joint of sheep will be proven.


M.M. Morlock R. Nassutt R. Janßen M. Honl G. Willmann

Ceramic-on-ceramic was shown to have advantageous tribologic properties (low wear and friction). For medical applications two ceramics, alumina and zircona, are available. This case study shows that the combination of different ceramics for hard-hard pairings can be critical.

A 57 year old patient received a total hip prosthesis (cementless stem with a ceramic head and a monolithic ceramic cup). Thirty-five months postoperatively the patient complained about squeaking noises during walking and stair climbing. Clinical diagnoses showed a good range of motion and no signs of loosening. Conventional rehabilitation did not improve the situation and 43 months after primary surgery the cup and the head had to be revised on the patients request. Intraoperatively no loosening indications were found. The explanted components were analysed using a 3D co-ordinate measuring machine.

The head and the cup were made of different ceramics. The zirconia (ZrO2) head occurred rather white whereas the alumina (Al2O3) cup was yellow-reddish. The inner articulating surface of the cup showed no decoloration or wear. The surface of the head contained mated areas with surface defects in equatorial regions (maximum wear depth 9μm).

The head and the cup were combined from different manufacturers. The distinct surface changes and wear marks of the zirconia head probably caused the squeaking noise after 3 years in situ. Zirconia for medical applications is generally Y-TZP ceramic. Pressure, heating, and water can cause severe surface embrittlement. Pre-damaging due to the manufacturing process or friction in the joint might be the mechanism leading to pre-mature wear and failure. Joint components from different manufacturers should only be implanted with proper official authorisation.


L.R. Rakotomanana A. Terrier P. F. Leyvraz J. Miyagaki H. Fujie K. Hayashi

Bone tissue is known to adapt to a stress change with some time delay. In vivo experimental studies were conducted for measuring the effects of mechanical loading on bone remodelling. In parallel, numerous models were developed for simulating the long-term bone response to various physical activities. However, most of models neglected the delay of bone response and they were not fully identified with corresponding experimental measurement. The purpose of this work was to develop a model describing the delay between stress change and cortical bone response.

A mathematical model was developed, accounting for the delays for bone response to stress. For in vivo experiment, 80 female Wistar rats (9-week old) were randomly divided into a running and a control group. First group regimen consisted of treadmill running program: 1 hr. per day, 6 days a week during first 15 weeks (treadmill speed 1.6 km/h). At week 15, the running group rats were returned to normal activity (sedentary state in cages), during last 15 weeks. Rats of the control group were subjected to normal activity for each period. At week 0, 3, 7, 15 (end of running period), 16, 18, 22 and 30 (end of experiment), 5 rats of each group were sacrificed for measuring the bone relative density via micro-hardness measurement on the left tibia (60 points per tibia).

Bone density of running group increased asymptotically during the first 15 weeks. An abrupt decrease of density occurred when rats returned to sedentary state at week 15. The densification rate is ten times lower than the rate whereas bone formation delay (13 days) is greater than bone resorption delay (1 day). These delays were related to the delays of bone cells activities with mineralisation process in reaction to physical activities.


R.G. Richards A. Persson B. Gasser R. Wieling

Movement between an implant surface and overlying soft tissue gives rise to fibrous capsule formation with a liquid filled void. Clinically, this situation is more prevalent with electropolished stainless steel (EPSS) implants compared to commercially pure titanium (CpTi) implants. We hypothesise this is mainly due to lack of microtopography on the EPSS.

Four experimental EPSS surfaces with varying microtopographies were selected by a combination of morphological analysis using the scanning electron microscope and quantitative roughness analysis using laser profilometry. Standard treated EPSS (ISO 5832/1) and CpTi (ISO 5832/2) surfaces were also used. The plates had only one screw hole at either end so that the interaction of the tissue with an intact surface could be evaluated. Six plates of each type were implanted on both the left and right tibia, randomly, of 18 white New Zealand rabbits under the muscle for 12 weeks.

After sacrifice samples underwent standard histological processing. Briefly, fixation, dehydration, embedding in methyl methacrylate, sectioning at 250μm slices (with implant), grinding to 50μm and staining with Giemsa. Digital images were taken with a light microscope and the size of thickening of connective tissue on the implant surface and the presence or absence of a liquid filled void was observed.

Results showed no voids present on the CpTi samples. The standard EPSS had 3/6 plates with a void. The experimental EPSS surfaces were in-between these results. There was no relationship between quantitative measurements of average roughness (Ra) and the presence or absence of a void. There was a relationship between lack of fine microroughness of a surface (as seen with the SEM) and the presence of a void. The size of capsular thickening was not related to the Ra of the surface. These results support that void formation is mainly due to lack of microtopography on the plates.


A.A.C. Reed C.J. Joyner H. Brownlow A.H.R.W. Simpson

During fracture repair, a number of growth factors and cytokines are present at elevated levels at the fracture site such as Transforming Growth Factor Beta (TGF-), Fibroblast Growth Factor (FGF) and Platelet Derived Growth Factor (PDGF). The aim of the study was to investigate the presence of these growth factors in healing fractures and fracture non-unions, in order to test the hypothesis that atrophic non-unions express a lower level of growth factors than hypertrophic non-unions and healing fractures.

Biopsies were taken from the fracture site of 23 patients (mean age 46) with uninfected non-unions, 12 patients with hypertrophic (mean 13.8 months after fracture) and 11 patients with atrophic (mean 16.5 months after fracture). A comparison group of biopsies from early fracture callus (one to four weeks after fracture) in five patients with healing fractures was also included. Five-micron paraffin sections were immunohistochemically stained for TGF-, FGF-II and PDGF. Growth factors were then assessed in six different cell types.

Fibroblasts, endothelial cells and macrophages were found to express TGF-, FGF-II and PDGF in all three-fracture groups. Osteoblasts, osteoclasts and chondrocytes were not present in the healing fracture group. The growth factor expression in osteoblasts, osteoclasts and chondrocytes in the non-union groups were found to be variable, however, the expression of these growth factors appeared to be less in the atrophic non-unions than hypertrophic non-unions.

The expression of these growth factors was found to be less in the atrophic non-union group than the hypertrophic non-union group in osteoblasts, osteoclasts and chondrocytes. These results may have relevance for new therapies that can be aimed at delivering growth factors to treat fracture non-unions. By further investigation of the differential expression of these growth factors it may be possible to determine which factors are likely to stimulate fracture healing.


C.H. Siebert C. Niedhart S. Koch D. Gottschalk

Although osteochondral grafting techniques have nearly been perfected, donor site morbidity still causes concern. A synthetic β-tricalcium phospate cement was used in the attempt to obtain a primary closure of such osteochondral defects, while supplying a scaffold for tissue ingrowth.

Twenty merino sheep underwent an osteochondral grafting procedure. The paste-like β-TCP cement was used to fill the ensuing cylindrical, full-thickness defect. Animals were sacrificed after 3 or 6 months.

The macroscopic observations revealed neither osteophytes nor synovial proliferation, while demonstrating coverage of the defect with cartilage-like tissue. After 6 months, all defects were covered with a ”neo-cartilage” and the congruity of the joint surface was restored in 6 of 10 animals. A surface depression was found in the remaining cases. A demarkation of the defect border at the interface with the original cartilage could only be seen in 2 instances. The x-rays of the retrieved distal femurs revealed only traces of the dense β-TCP particles. Microradiographs demonstrated the incorporation of the implant. Fluorescent staining showed continuous bone ingrowth. Histologically, masses of unabsorbed TCP were irregularly distributed through-out the defect. Newly formed bone had filled much of the defect. The histological evaluation confirmed that the surface of the cement was covered with a cartilage-like tissue.

This study showed, that the newly developed in-situ self-hardening resorbable β-tricalcium phosphate cement is easy to handle, hardens in a clinical-type setting, is bioactive and resorbable. Its osteoconductive effect lead to a restoration of biomechanically stable bone and allows for a normal remodeling process. Biomaterials made of β-TCP promise to play a role as a biodegradable scaffold, allowing osteo-blast ingrowth and cartilagenous resurfacing, while being fully resorbed during the process. The cement may also be used to deliver bioactive agents and cells for defect repair in the near future.


D. Scale K. Küspert M. Rauschmann W. Hauger L. Zichner

There are nearly no studies which describe the influence of the ileotibial tract (IT) on force distribution in the knee joint in a qunatitative manner. Therfore the aim of this work was to develop a complex 3-D computer model of the lower extremity, consisting of bones, joints and muscle models describing their dynamic behaviour including a special IT model. The computer model provided the possibility to simlate training of the muscular system.

Thus the computer model provided among others the possibility to simulate training of the lateral thigh muscles and vastus lateralis with the aim to tension the IT, with the option to calculate force distribution in the knee and compare it with the effect of a tibial osteotomy.

Patients with varus knees were examined. Kinematic data during walking together with forceplate and EMG data wer collected, before and after tibial osteotomy. The anatomy of the patients was recorded by MRI.

Gait and MRI data were the input in the new developed three dimensional computer model. The scaled geometrical data by Delp (1990) and the MRI data were combined to represent the individuals anatomy.

The model of the lower extremity included 43 muscles with origins/insertions and force-length properties described by Delp (1990). The muscle model was improved by including force-velocity properties and a new muscle tendon parameter (tendon stiffness). A functional scaling method was developed to fit the muscle models to individual anatomy. The IT complex was modelled as a coupled unit of IT, tensor fascia latae and gluteus maximus. Muscle and joint forces were determined using an optimization approach minimizing the cube of the sum of muscle forces divided by their upper bounds.

Simulated muscle training of the lateral thigh muscles and vastus lateralis led to an increased tensioning of the IT. As a result the lateral knee force raised considerably similar to the increase after osteotomy. However the decrease in the medial compartment was small and not comparable with the effect of a valgus osteotomy. Tensioning of the IT leads apparently to an overall larger resulting knee force stabilizing the joint, but is not able to reduce medial knee force to an extent that can avoid osteotomy.


C.B. Rieker S. Schaffner R. Schön R. Konrad

Aseptic loosening due to particle disease is one of the major problems for THA. Since simulator studies are expensive, there is a need for screening tests to evaluate different pairings. Recent publications have shown that multiaxial motions are important in reproducing appropriate wear behaviour. The objective of the study was to design a simple bidirectional pin-on-disc screening test with multidirectional motions allowing on-line dimensional wear measurements and to compare the measured in-vitro wear rate with the observed in-vivo wear rate.

The multidirectional motions were obtained by a rotating pin on a rotating disc. With one disc rotation, the pin rotates 4 times, which leads to 4 changes in the wear direction. The wear characteristics were: load 3.45 MPa, lubricant 33% calf serum – 67% Ringer’s solution, temperature 37°C. The wear rate was measured on-line by the dimensional change in the height of the pin and by the conventional gravimetric method.

Following results were obtained: Wear Coefficient [mm3/Nm]: 1.446 10-6 ± 0.447 10-6 [CoCrMo – UHMWPE] – 0.515 10-6 ± 0.136 10-6 [Al2O3- UHMWPE] /Linear Wear Rate [mm/106 cycles]: 0.132 ± 0.041 [CoCrMo – UHMWPE] – 0.047 ± 0.012 [Al2O3- UHMWPE] /Gravimetric Wear Rate [mg/106 cycles]: 2.104 ± 0.709 [CoCrMo – UHMWPE] – 0.769 ± 0.205 [Al2O3- UHMWPE].

This bi-directional screening test with shear motions has the following characteristics: Gives the three wear parameters /Shows s significant difference between the CoCrMo – UHMWPE and the Al203 – UHMWPE pairing /Demonstrates a relatively good agreement between the in-vivo and the in-vitro measurements.

This type of screening tests will provide some earlier information concerning the tribological behaviour of pairing for total hip joints.


C.H. Siebert D.C. Wirtz D. Gottschalk C. Niedhart

Among the wide variety of bone substitutes presently available, pure β-tricalcium phosphate ceramics have become available (Biosorb®; Aesculap, Tuttlingen). During the first 12 months of a prospective clinical trial, Biosorb® products were implanted in 21 patients. The ceramics were used in a variety of clinical settings, ranging from pelvic osteotomies in children (n=9), to filling of bone cysts or osseous defects (n=4), to dorsal spondylodesis (n=6), as well as for the grafting of pseudarthroses (n=2). Average follow-up period was 13 (6–18) months.

The β-TCP granules, when used as part of a composite graft in combination with autologous bone, were completely resorbed after an average period of 14 weeks, while the cubes required 12 to 15 months. The more massive wedges have shown only a decrease in size and radio density. Due to the ability of the cubes and wedges to bear loads of up to 30 MPa, they were successfully implanted during pelvic osteotomies to augment or completely replace the bicortical grafts. Complications or foreign body reactions were not noted. The osseointegration was found to be favorable for all forms.

In light of the problems associated with autologous and allogeneic grafts, the use of synthetic bone substitutes will continue to increase. The combination of complete resorption, lack of risk of infection, and load sharing ability make the β-tricalcium phosphate implants a valuable addition to the spectrum of bone replacement products presently available. Their use in pediatric orthopedics could help avoid donor site morbidity including contour changes or growth disturbances, while providing a more stable graft. During the first phase of a prospective clinical trial, we have come to the conclusion, that the β-tricalcium phosphate ceramics represent a real alternative to other bone substitutes.


E. Steinhauser W. Mittelmeier M. Ellenrieder J. Scholz H. Grundei R. Gradinger

For younger patients many surgeons recommend femoral neck endoprostheses as alternative to stemmed implants in THA. Due to metaphyseal anchorage several advantages are quoted, e.g. preservation of the femoral diaphysis for a revision implant. Determinant factor for long-term implant stability is the load transmission to the bone. Because so far only few information about the load transfer of femoral neck endoprostheses exist, a photoelastic analysis was performed. Aim of the study was the comparison of bony strain pattern before and after implantation of a femoral neck endoprosthesis.

‘Composite-femurs’ (Pacific Research Labs) were used due to of their mechanical characteristics close to human femurs but better reproducibility. Three femurs were coated with photoelastic material. The femurs were loaded prior and post implantation of a femoral neck endoprosthesis type Cigar (ESKA Implants). Test load consisted of the resulting hip joint force and muscle forces (abductors, tractus iliotibialis). Load was applied statically by a universal testing machine and additional weights. Bony strain was measured along the medial, ventral, lateral and dorsal cortex. Statistical analysis of the implant related strain alterations was based on a 99% confidence interval.

The unresected femurs showed an excellent match of bony strain patterns. Implantation of femoral neck endoprostheses caused highly significant strain changes at the trochanteric region. Greatest differences were observed at the lateral cortex. Above the implant’s traction screw former areas of tension changed to compression. Along the medial cortex below the resection plane strain reductions were measured but disappeared at the latest at 40 mm below. No significant changes in strain were detected at the ventral and dorsal cortex.

Implant related bony strain alterations were limited to the trochanteric region of the femur. A marked strain alteration at the lateral trochanteric aspect was measured. Whether this is of clinical importance can not be answered yet.


T.A. Wallny R.L. Schild R. Fimmers U.A. Wagner M.E. Hansmann

The vertebral canal reaches maturity early in life. The size of the lumbar spinal canal was evaluated to determine normal values for vertebral canal size.

For our prospective cross-sectional study 95 women with a singleton pregnancy between 16 and 41 weeks of gestation were recruited during their routine anomaly scan. After defining the region of interest on the 2D ultrasound image, volume scanning was performed and the rendered volume was displayed in three orthogonal planes on the screen. Area and volume of the vertebral canal in L1, L3 and L5 were calculated.

Area and volume of the vertebral canal showed a close correlation to gestational age. Advancing gestational age was characterised by a statistically significant increase in all volumetric and conventional 2D measurements. No major differences regarding area and volume measurements could be found between upper and lower spine.

Sonographic evaluation of the fetal spine plays an important role in obstetric anomaly scans. Prenatal diagnosis may also lead to interesting aspects concerning back pain in adults. A small vertebral canal is considered to be one of the causes for back pain in later life but these syndromes are multi-factorial. Since interpedicular diameter of the spinal canal at the level of L1-L4 at birth is approximately 70 % of the adult size, any kind of intrauterine growth impairment will affect further development. Further data will show if our normal values will have significance in the early detection of disorders of the vertebral canal.


P. Guigui P. Wodecki P. Bizot P. Lambert G. Chaumeil A. Deburge

Purpose of the study: Little is known about the impact of posterolateral arthrodesis on adjacent levels. In order to examine this question, we analyzed the radiological evolution of the lumbar spine in patients treated for lumbar stenosis, comparing cases where posterolateral arthrodesis was used with the other cases. Our aim was to determine whether the long-term radiographical modifications were affected by the arthrodesis.

Material and methods: Among our series of patients presenting with lumbar stenosis between 1984 and 1992, we retained two groups: patients in group 1 (n = 46) who underwent single-level decompressions at L4–L5 or L4–L5 and L5–S1 level; and patients in group II (n = 81) who underwent decompressions on the same levels associated with posterolateral arthrodesis extending from L4 to the sacrum with or without instrumentation. We compared the course of the two levels above the decompression (L2–L3 and L3–L4) between the two groups. We compared three radiological parameters: disc height, intervertabral slipping, and intersegmental mobility. We also examined the correlations between radiological modifications and functional outcome. Mean follow-up for these 127 patients was 9 years.

Results: The two groups were comparable for age, gender, follow-up, and presurgical functional score, disc height and intervertebral slipping at equivalent levels. At last follow-up, disc narrowing was observed at L2–L3 and L3–L4; it was significantly greater in the group with complementary arthrodesis. At L3–L4, intervertebral slipping also worsened more in the arthrodesis patients. Use of osteosynthesis significantly increased the risk of developing such radiological lesions. These lesions were associated, solely in the arthrodesis group, with poorer functional outcome.

Conclusion: Our findings allow the conclusion that, despite the effect of physiological aging, the observed long-term degenerative lesions in patients undergoing treatment of lumbar stenosis are related to the associated arthrodesis which increases their frequency and severity, deteriorating the functional outcome.


C. Cadilhac B. Fenoll A. Peretti J.-P. Padovani J.-C. Pouliquen P. Rigault

Purpose of the study: Congenital pseudarthrosis of the clavicle is rare, only 200 cases having been reported. Based on 25 personal cases and an overview of the literature, we try to explain the etiology of this condition and the different kinds of treatment.

Material and methods: A retrospective analysis was performed on twenty-five children (16 females, 9 males, mean age at the end of the follow up – 11.5 yrs) from three different centers. We assessed the outcome of surgical and nonsurgical procedures, based on pain, functional ability, cosmetic results, and x-ray examination.

Results: A family background was noted in three children. The lesion always involved the right side. Twenty patients presented a bump over the middle third of the clavicle, thirteen a foreshortened shoulder girdle, three complained of discomfort. In two cases, palpation of the clavicular area was painful. No neurovascular compressive syndrome was reported. None of the patients complained of a decrease in the range of motion or in the strength of the upper limb. X-rays showed a middle third defect. In five cases we found abnormal first ribs.

Seventeen patients underwent surgery, at a mean age of 6 years and 4 months. The procedure always included excision of the pseudarthrosis at both ends and internal fixation with a wire or a plate. In only eight cases a bone graft was used. Healing was achieved in fourteen patients. Three patients needed a second surgical procedure. In these 3 cases we had not used bone grafting. All patients had a normal range of shoulder motion, except a twelve year old girl who complained of discomfort of the right upper limb. The cosmetic result was good in eleven cases, one surgical wound was noted as hypertrophic, and one developed a keloid. An asymmetry of the trunk was still noted in seven cases. The x-rays showed symmetric clavicles in ten cases.

Eight patients were treated conservatively. All of them had a normal range of motion of the shoulder, six had a good cosmetic result and two cases a poor one.

Discussion

According to Alldred, the anomaly results from the failed coalescence of the two primary ossification centers of the clavicle. The overview of the literature and our findings (in one case) confirm that the cartilage which covers both ends of the bone is made of growth cartilage. However, the true mechanism of the nonunion is still unknown. The three familial cases of our work suggest a possible genetic transmission of the disease.

The diagnosis is based on the following criteria: right side lesion, found in infancy, without previous fracture, increasing size with growth, without major functional consequences, without neurofibromatosis or cleidocranial dysostosis symptom. X-rays or histologic examination will confirm the diagnosis showing the usual findings described above.

Complications of the pseudarthrosis of the clavicle are rare and late. Conservative management appears to give good results as seen with our eight patients. However surgical treatment ensures symmetrical shoulder girdles and good function with few complications. Therefore, we recommend performing an excision of the cartilaginous caps, followed by an iliac bone graft and an internal fixation with wire. Surgical management will be preferred in symptomatic patients, in the case of major or increasing deformity, or on parental request.


O. Jarde J.-L. Trinquier-Lautard F. Garate M. de Lestang P. Vives

Purpose of the study: We reviewed 30 cases of osteochondral lesions of the astragalar vault treated surgically.

Material and methods: Among the 30 patients, 17 participated in sports activities and 24 had a history of trauma. Mean delay to surgery was 10 months. Treatment included osteochonritis curettage and Pridie perforations. Direct access was used in 11 cases, malleolar osteotomy in 13 and arthroscopy in 6. Cancellous bone grafts were used in 6 cases.

Results: Mean follow-up was 3 years 7 months (minimum 2 years). All patients had an arthroscan at last follow-up. Evaluation of post-operative outcome was based on clinical assessment and arthroscan findings. Surgical treatment provided very good results in 75 p. 100 of cases with pain relief and improved walking distance.

Discussion: Our cases pointed out the important contribution of the FOG (Fracture Osteonecrosis Geode) classification to pathogenic and prognostic analysis. The Berndt and Harty classifications were not found to be useful.

Conclusion: In case of localized necrosis, we propose arthroscopic perforation curettage. In case of bone loss, a direct cancellous graft may be used.


M. Bonnin G. Deschamps P. Neyret P. Chambat

Purpose of the study: We reviewed 69 consecutive cases of total knee arthroplasty revisions to analyze the causes of failure.

Material and methods: Sixty-nine total knee arthroplasty revisions were required between 1990 and 1997 for non-septic failure. Five categories of failures were identified: 30 loosenings including 11 with an initial malposition (varus position of the tibial component in 8 cases), 14 laxities (medial in 5, lateral in 5 and anteroposterior in 4), 11 stiff knees with no other clinical or radiological anomaly, 6 patellar failures (2 dislocations, 2 cases of excessive wear, 2 painful knees with a Freeman prosthesis), and 8 cases of painful knees with no other detectable anomaly.

Results: A three-phase reconstruction procedure was used after removing the failing TKA:1) reconstruction of the tibia with replacement of lost bone, 2) reconstruction of the femur with balanced flexion determining the size of the implant, 3) balanced extension determining the distal/proximal position of the femoral component. A “simple” sliding prosthesis was used in 16 cases, a modular reconstruction prosthesis in 40 cases and a hinge prosthesis in 13 cases. Mean follow-up for functional and radiographic assessment after revision surgery was 37 months (59 cases) with a minimum follow-up of 1 year. The best outcome was observed in the “loosening”, “laxity”, and “stiffness” patients. Outcome was less favorable for the group “isolated pain” with IKS functional scores of 35.5 ± 16 and 52.5 ± 21.

Discussion: In 36 p. 100 of cases, TKA failure was related to a technical mistake (component malposition, poor ligament alignment). In 33 p. 100, failure was patient related (multiple procedures, congenital hip dysplasia, rheumatoid arthritis...). Outcome after revision TKA was less favorable than after primary TKA, particularly in case of painful knees with no other detectable anomaly.

Conclusion: Surgical revision of TKA must follow a rigorous procedure with a detailed preoperative work-up. The decision for revision must not be made unless a precise anomaly has been identified.


F. Vadier X. Courjaud V. Pointillart J.-M. Vital

Purpose of the study: We report a case of type 1 neurofibromatosis (von Recklinghausen’s disease) of the lower cervical spine in a 13-year-old girl.

Case report: There was no neurological deficit. Plain films showed dysplastic 82° kyphosis centered on the C4–C5 disc. Surgical treatment consisted in anterior multilevel interbody grafting and plate osteosynthesis combined with posterior arthrodesis. Good bone fusion was obtained with acceptable cervical mobility. The residual cervical kyphosis was 18°.

Discussion: An evaluation of the cervical spine should be proposed for patients with neurofibromatosis even if there is no thoracic scoliosis. Severe cervical deformities can lead to serious neurological complications. Circumferential arthrodesis appears to provide optimum results.


F. Bonnomet Y. Lefèbvre P. Clavert P. Gicquel P. Marcillou M. Katzner J.-F. Kempf

Purpose of the study: The aim of this work was to report our experience with arthroscopy for the treatment of acetabular labral lesions and identify prognostic factors determining mid- and long-term outcome.

Material and methods: Between August 1991 and December 1997, 12 patients (ten women, two men, mean age 39 years, age range 25–61 years) underwent arthroscopic treatment of an acetabular labrum lesion. All were reviewed at a mean 4 years follow-up (18 months-8 years). Half of the patients (n = 6) had a history of hip surgery: two femoral osteotomies and one acetabular bone block for congenital hip dislocation, two high-energy traumas and one traumatic dislocation. Clinical manifestations including pain (n = 12), a sensation of a snag (n = 10), or blockage (n = 8) had developed over a mean 15 months (2–24 months). Standard x-rays evidenced early signs of degenerative disease in four cases and acetabular dysplasia in four (5° < VCE < 18°), and were normal in four. Arthroscanography was performed in all cases and always evidenced a lesion of the anterior or anterosuperior part of the labrum, generally a fissuration (n = 7). The surgical procedure performed on an orthopedic table with traction on the limb lasted 45 to 75 min for regularization of the degenerated labrum in three patients, resection of the languette in six, the anse de seau in two or the labral notch in one. A short hospitalization (24 to 48 hours) was sufficient with immediate weight bearing with two canes. One patient developed sciatic paresia which regressed in 72 hours with vulvar edema due to excessive peroperative traction.

Results: Besides the labral lesion, the exploration also identified an associated chondral lesion in seven cases (acetabulum in two, femoral head in three, both in two) which had been suspected in six cases from preoperative imaging (osteoarthrosis in four, dysplasia in two) and which affected the final outcome. Four of these patients (osteoarthritis in two and dysplasia in two) worsened clinically and radiographically to the point where a total hip arthroplasty was required in three. Among the three other patients, two had residual pain (osteoarthritis in one and initial x-ray normal in one) with no radiographic deterioration and only one (osteoarthrtis) was totally relieved without any radiographic deterioration at six years follow-up. Among the five patients with no chondral lesions, three (with normal x-rays initially) were pain free at four years follow-up while the two others (dysplasia) had residual pain at two years follow-up with no sign of osteoarthrtis on the latest x-rays.

Discussion: Lesions of the acetabular labrum are uncommon but can be treated arthroscopically. Resection of the labral lesion is immediately effective but does not prevent long-term degradation of the joint if there is an associated chondral lesion.


A. Vidil B. Augereau

Purpose of the study: Old tears of the subscapular muscle situated in the glenoid area are not accessible to direct repair and require locoregional muscle plasty. The clavicular portion of the pectoralis major can be used for reconstruction. The purpose of this study was to describe the operative technique and examine short-term outcome.

Material and methods: Five patients, mean age 54 years (45–71 years) with an irreparable tear of the subscapularis in the glenoid area with fatty degeneration greater than grade two in the Goutallier classification were treated. Four had had previous surgery for acromioplasty associated with rotator cuff repair in two or implantation of a humeral prosthesis in one. The preoperative Constant score was 27.5 (mean, range = 8.5–54) due to invalidating pain, limited active mobility and reduced muscle force. Gerber’s lift-off test was positive for those patients for whom it could be performed. Plain x-rays evidenced anterior subdislocation of the humeral head in one case. Subscapular reconstruction was achieved using the entire clavicular portion of the pectoralis major which was dissected and sectioned at its distal insertion on the humerus then reinserted by transosseous suture onto the lesser tuberosity. The rehabilitation program started with active and passive mobility against gravity within a few days of surgery using biofeedback contraction of the muscle flap then active contractions two months postoperatively. Patients were reviewed at a mean 19 months (6–42 months) for clinical and radiological assessment.

Results: Four patients had a painless shoulder with a negative lift-off test. The gain in active mobility was predominantly achieved with anterior elevation and abduction. Muscle force was weak leading to a low overall Constant score at revision (mean = 50, range = 30–63). Radiographically, the humeral head was centered exactly as on the preoperative films. There were no cases with a new anterior subdislocation nor an aggravation of a former subdislocation. Functional outcome was better in cases with a unique tear of the subscapularis.

Discussion and conclusion: Open surgery is used for primary repair of recent tears of the subscapularis. This technique gives 80 p. 100 good and very good results. In case of symptomatic acromioclavicular osteoarthtisis, better long-term results can be obtained by using a tendodesis of the long biceps and resecting the lateral centimeter of the clavicle. In case of irreparable tears in the glenoid area, reconstruction by transfer of the clavicular portion of the pectoralis major can produce a stable painless shoulder with improved active moblity and normal clinical tests. This method provides anterior stability of the glenohumeral articulation and prevents any anterior subdislocation of the humeral head, thus protecting the joint from secondary degeneration.


F. Bonnel P. Baldet F. Canovas P. Faure Ph. Mouilleron

Purpose: Reports on the histological lesions observed in patients with degenerative disease of the shoulder have generally involved only a few cases. We conducted a prospective study in 662 shoulders operated on for impingement or rotator cuff tear.

Material: The cases analysed included 402 subacromial impingements and 260 rotator cuff tears.

Methods: Pathology specimens were obtained from the subacromiodeltoid bursa, the acromion, the acromio-coracoid ligament, the acromioclavicular joint, the borders of the rotator cuff tear, and the biceps tendon. There were 2573 pathology specimens.

Results: The pathology examination revealed degenerative lesions (fibrosis, oedema, calcifications, fissuration, atrophy, delamination, fatty infiltration, necrosis, chondroid metaplasia, fragmentation), or inflammation. The subacromiodeltoid bursa presented fibrosis lesions in 3 out of 4 cases (74%). Signs of inflammation were found in 21% of the cases, oedema in 9%, and no lesion in 15%. The acromiocoracoid ligament showed oedema in 35%, fissuration in 35%, delamination in 25%, fragmentation in 11%, atrophy in 8%, fatty infiltration in 6%, necrosis in 4%, hypervascularisation in 2%, chondroid metaplasia in 1%, and no lesion in 27%. For the acromion, degenerative lesions were present in 88%, impingement in 83%, cuff tears in 92%. Lesions of the cuff in patients with tears showed degeneration in 86% (fissuration 46%, necrosis 35%, fragmentation 30%, vascular penetration with chondroid metaplasia 17%, delamination 10%, haemorrhagic remodelling 4%, adipose degeneration 3%, atrophy 2%, oedema 42%, calcifications 30%, fibrosis 26%, inflammation 7%, and no lesion 1 case). The biceps tendon showed degenerative lesions (90%), inflammation 2 cases, no lesion 3 cases. The acromioclavian joint (67 cases) showed degenerative lesions in all cases. Rotator cuff tears showed inflammatory lesions 30%, and subacromial impingement 16%.

Discussion: The statistical analysis revealed a significant correlation between the presence of a normal subacromiodeltoid bursa and the type of pathology. There was a significant statistical relationship between the presence of inflammatory lesions and the type of pathology. There was no significant correlation with the pain score. There was a significant relationship between the presence of fibrosis of the acromiocoracoid ligament and the functional score at last follow-up. The presence of ligament fibrosis would be a sign of poor prognosis. This relationship was present irrespective of the pain, force and stability scores.

Conclusion: The acromiocoracoid ligament was not found to be particularly involved suggesting that the idea of impingement should be revisited. For cases with a tear, the presence of a acromiocoracoid ligament with no histological lesion confirms that tears are not always associated with an impingement. Among cuff tear or impingement cases, there was a number of acromions with no bone lesion. Inflammatory lesions were not frequent. Unravelling the pathology of the degenerative shoulder is a complex process making interpretation and correlation with clinical signs and proposed therapeutic protocols difficult.


J-F. Kempf V. Prues-Labour F. Bonnomet Y. Lefalne B. Schlemmer

Purpose: There is still debate on classification, pathogenesis, and treatment of partial non-full thickness tears of the rotator cuff. We assessed mid-term outcome after arthroscopic repair.

Material and methods: Between 1990 and 1998, 208 partial tears of the rotator cuffs were treated in our unit. Eighty patients were reviewed by an examiner different and independent from the surgery team. The review included a physical examination, Constant score and radiography. The series included 42 men and 38 women, mean age 52 years (23–73) who were seen at a mean follow-up of 59 months (17–118). We identified four groups: group 1 included lesions of the deep articular aspect of the supraspinatus: 34 cases; group 2 included tears of the superficial aspect: 27 cases; group 3 included tears involving both the deep and superficial aspect without full-thickness tear on the preoperative arthrogram; and group 4 included lesions involving a partial tear of the supraspinatus associated with another articular lesion. Acromioplasty was performed in all cases associated with section of the acromiocoracoid ligament.

Results: Absolute Constant score progressed from 53 points preoperatively to 80 points at last follow-up. Mean Constant score of the contralateral shoulder was 87 points. There was a significant difference between outcome in the first three groups where the mean age was 50 years and the fourth group (trauma context) where the mean age was 36 years. Constant score was 84.7, 92, 92, and 73 for groups 1, 2, 3 and 4 respectively. There was no statistically significant improvement compared with the preoperative Constant score (67 points). Radiographically, there was no change in the subacromial space. Superficial lesions were more frequently associated with type 3 acromial impingement.

Discussion: Globally, we observed a deterioration of outcome with time compared with the first review, with 76% satisfactory results at five years. The same outcome was obtained with superficial and deep lesions. We are in agreement with others that it is necessary to identify a subgroup of patients under 40 years of age with a partial tear of the rotator cuff in a trauma context. For these patients, arthroscopic acromioplasty is not a satisfactory therapeutic approach. The causal lesion (posterosuperior impingement, rim injury or instability) should be treated.


D. Saragaglia A. Huboud Peron H. Pichon C. Chaussard

Purpose: Several treatments can be proposed for calcified tenopathy of the rotator cuff. Corticosteroid infiltration, radioscopic trituration-aspiration, and arthroscopy are the most widely used modalities. Over the last decade, we have come to refer our cases of well-circumscribed calcified tenopathy easily accessible to radioscopy to our radiology colleagues since radioscopic treatment has appeared to be quite cost-effective. This trend has continued despite the new interest of the arthroscopists in this disease. We have nevertheless had a certain number of failures (25%) and at this time have decided to prefer arthroscopy. The purpose of this work was to present our results with arthroscopy used after failure of tirturation-aspiration or for patients with calcifications we considered to have contraindications for trituration-aspiration (poorly circumscribed chain of calcifications).

Material and methods: Between 1990 and 1997, we performed 28 arthroscopic procedures in 28 patients. There were 18 women and ten men, mean age 47.5 years (28–71 years). All suffered pain at night and painful blockage during certain motions, particularly anterolateal elevation and forced internal rotation. We did not use the preoperative Constant score because we considered that the pain always gives a false score in these patients, particularly for muscle force. Nevertheless, the mean pain score preoperatively was 4.5 (0–10), daily activity was 14 (8–18) and active motion was 32 (20–40). All calcifications were located in the supraspinatus and the anterior part of the infraspinatus. Acromial morphology was type III in seven cases. All the patients underwent arthroscopy with resection of the coracoacromial ligament and anterior acromioplasty without touching the residual calcification.

Results: All patients were reviewed by an independent surgeon different than the operator. Mean follow-up was 54 months (18–108 months). Subjectively, 89% of the patients were cured or improved, 11% were unchanged. Objectively, the Constant score weighted for age and sex was a mean 91.4% (50–100%) with a median 100%. We had 20 shoulders with excellent outcome (weighted Constant score 85–94%), two with fair outcome (65–84%), and three with poor outcome (< 65%), giving 82% satisfactory outcome. Muscle force was very satisfactory (mean 7.5%) and close to the contralateral shoulder (8.25 kg). Radiologically, 17 of the 29 shoulders were cleared of calcifications (61%).

Conclusion: Arthroscopic acromioplasty after failure of trituration-aspiration gives quite satisfactory results, including for calcifications we had considered to by “untriturables”.


T. Leemrijse B. Valtin

Purpose: We are often tempted to set aside (forget?) a certain number of cases we treated during our “learning curve”. We decided to review our first 56 cases of Scarf osteotomies five years after surgery. We detailed outcome, failures, and current modifications of the surgical technique.

Material and methods: End 1991 beginning 1992, we performed Scarf osteotomy on the first metatarsal in 56 feet for correction of hallux valgus in 33 patients aged 22 to 73 yeas (mean 49.7 years). Metatarso-phalangeal deviation of the first row was 20° to 70° (mean 38.5°) associated with metatarus varus from 12° to 24° (mean 16.6°). There were seven types of hallus valgus. Sesamoid deviation was classed in five categories. There were 20, 15 and 19 Greek, square and Egyptian feet respectively. Associated procedures included 26 osteotomies of the first phalanx of the great toe: twelve for angulation, ten for shortening, and six for angulation and shortening. For the other rows, there were five Gauthier osteotomies of the neck of the second metatarsal for overload syndrome of the second row and one Gauthier osteotomy of the second and third metatarsals for metatarso-phalangeal dislocation.

Results: The patient-assessed subjective result deteriorated with time: excellent 36 (64.2%), good 18 (32.1%), fair 2 (3.7%) at one year and excellent 32 (57.2%), good 15 (26.7%), fair 7 (12.5%), mediocre 1 (2.6%) at five years. Objective results for deformations were: postoperative metatarso-phalangeal angle of the first row 10° to 35° (mean 19°) and metatarsus varus 10° to 18° (mean 11.3°). The morphological result was practically acquired at one year, there was little further accentuation of the deformation with time. There was a clear improvement of the sesamoid position. These positive results cannot mask seven cases with angles of 30° and three with 35°. There was no case of hallux varus in this series. There were two “failures” requiring revision, one for recurrent and bothersome bone deformation and the other for metatarsalgia that developed only after correction of the hallux valgus.

Discussion, conclusion: This review disclosed two problems: insufficient correction and the development of postoperative metatarsalgia. The defective corrections were attributed to insufficient translation in the early cases and to the osteotomy which did not lower (or even raise) the metatarsal head. We have changed the osteotomy line in order to widen the translation surface and also to lower more the metatarsal head.


F. Canovas G. Poirée A. Faline C. Assi F. Dusserre

Purpose: Talonavicular arthritis, associated or not with rear foot deformity, is common in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. The work by Steinhauser and Gérard demonstrated the usefulness of talonavicular arthrodesis for the treatment of this rear foot disorder. The purpose of this study was to assess outcome after this surgical technique in patients with rheumatoid polyarthritis.

Material and methods: Between 1988 and 1998, 26 feet (24 men, 2 women, 17 right, 7 left) were operated by the same surgeon. Mean age of the patients at surgery was 51 years. Mean delay from disease onset to talonavicular arthrodesis was 13 years. Postoperative immobilisation lasted 45 days. Mean follow-up was five years (1–10).

Results: Patients were very satisfied or satisfied in 92.3% of the cases. Mean pre- and postoperative pain score was 8.14 and 1.77 respectively (p = 0.0001). Normal shoes could be worn by 37.5 and 66.7% of the patients pre- and postoperatively. Patient independence was significantly improved (p = 0.0001). The postoperative analysis of the plantar prints demonstrated pes planus and pes cavus. In 29.2 and 12.5%, the mean postoperative tibiocalcaneal angle was 0.78° with pes varus in eight cases (2°–10°). The mean Djean angle was 122.3° and 122.8° pre- and postoperatively (p = 0.24). Three talocrural joints (11.5%) that were intact preoperatively had degraded at last follow-up. The statistical analysis showed that clinical outcome was not affected by the postoperative aspect of the foot. There were three cases of tight non-union (11.5%) two of which were asymptomatic and two cases of infection (7.5%) requiring revision surgery. These complications led to two poor outcomes.

Discussion: The rate of non-union varies in published series from 3 to 37%. The rate observed in our series has led us to delay weight bearing. The residual varus found in eight feet, related to a shortened medial column, may warrant intertalonavicular grafting.

Conclusion: Talonavicular arthrodesis is a useful procedure despite a significant risk of complications.


S. Minaud V. Masselot B. Blanchet P.O. Pinelli S. Nazarian

Purpose of the study: Isthmic reconstruction has been proposed as an alternative to spinal fusion for the treament of symptomatic spondylolysis unresponsive to conservative treatment. The purpose of this work was to assess long-term outcome after isthmic reconstruction according to R. Louis.

Material and methods: Fifty-one patients were reviewed at four to 23 years. The sex ratio was 3F/1M; age range was 11 to 43 years. The surgical method included: 1) isthmic reconstruction using a graft followed by temporary screw-plate fixation; 2) ablation of implants, verification of the fusion and intervertebral mobility, arthrolysis as needed. Pain and resumption of occupational and sports activities were used to assess clinical outcome. Radiological criteria included linear and angular measurements in the sagittal plane, isthmic consolidation, slipping, disk height, intersegmentary angular mobility.

Results: Clinically, outcome was very good or good in 75% of the cases, fair in 21% and poor in 4%. For L5 reconstructions, outcome was very good or good in 83.5% and fair in 16.5%. Mean relative overall gain was 66%, reaching 72% for L5 reconstructions and only 31% for L3 or L4 reconstructions. Patients resumed their occupational activities in 92% of the cases. Most of those with sports activities resumed practice. Radiologically, fusion was achieved in 70% of the cases. The rate of consolidation was 80% for L5. Reduction in the immediately caudad and cephalad disk height was 33% for L5 reconstructions. Mobility was reduced 63% for the L5-S1 space and 50% for the L4-L5 space. Clinical outcome was correlated with isthmic consolidation. Residual mobility was inversely proportional to the duration of osteosynthesis.

Conclusion: Isthmic reconstruction using a graft and temporary ostheosynthesis is a surgical method providing very good anatomic isthmic consolidation. Despite the need for two operations and the relative stiffness of the immedicately caudad space, this procedure can provide good functional results and avoid the need a few years later for a more complex operation.


O. Mazel P. Antonietti R. Terracuor R. Trabelsi

Purpose of the study: Missing a cervical stenosis in patients with lumbar canal stenosis can lead to an inadequate surgical strategy and delay in treatment of overt cord compression.

Material and methods: Among 100 patients with lumbar canal stenosis, we identified patients with symptoms related to cervical stenosis. These four patients had to undergo surgical decompression of the cervical and lumbar spine to achieve full symptom relief. Careful analysis of the clinical expression is essential to identify cervical stenosis with few or no signs. Presence of gait disorders related to balance disorders, widening of the balance polygone, or use of a crutch, are suggestive of an associated lesion. MRI facilitates diagnosis of cervical compression. EMG and somesthetic evoked potentials are the gold standard examinations to confirm clinical and radiographic suspicion.

Results: Gait disorders, other than simple claudication and/or radiculalgia warranted MRI and electric explorations in these patients. In these four patients, compression of the posterior cord explained well the gait disorders via a deep sensorial mechanism.

Discussion: MRI evidence of cervical osteoarthritis is not sufficient to confirm the origin of the patient’s complaints. There must be a perfect correlation with the electrical results, particularly evoked potentials associated with MRI to confirm the organic origin of disorders resulting from cervical stenosis. Positive diagnosis of such an association requires a specific treatment algorithm as was used in three of our four patients. In the fourth case, the lumbar compression appeared to predominate over the cervical compression leading to decompression of the lumbar canal followed later by decompression of the cervical canal. Between the two procedures, the patient’s status had considerably declined. This strategy which had appeared adequate was thus found to be quite inadequate and even dangerous.

Conclusion: Presence of gait disorders other than simple claudication or single-level or multiple-level radiculalgia in patients with lumbar canal stenosis should lead to search for an associated cervical stenosis. The perfect correlation between the radiographic and electrical findings is indispensable to establish certain diagnosis. The cervical stenosis should be treated before the lumbar stenosis.


J. Afriat G. Guegnon

Purpose: In vivo analysis of the kinematics of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is of particular interest because it i) enables measurements of mobile plateau displacements by degree of freedom (rotation, anteroposterior translation, mediolateral motion); ii) provides crucial information concerning polyethylene wear and loosening.

Material and methods: Twenty patients with a mobile plateau TKA with posterior stabilisation were selected on the basis of three inclusion criteria: follow-up greater than six months, unilateral prosthesis, satisfactory clinical result (HKS = 80). The lateral view on the image amplifier was recorded using a digital recorder while the patient produced flexion-extension movements of the loaded knee in the sitting position. We determined the position of the mobile plateau relative to the tibial base and to the femoral piece throughout the flexion cycle using two radio-opaque markers included in the mobile plateau.

Results: Rotation of the mobile plateau-tibial base interface was observed for all 20 TKA. There was an external rotation from flexion to extension of 3° to 16° in all cases. there was also an anteroposterior translation for 18/20 TKA. For ten TKA this was an anterior translation from flexion to extension. For eight TKA, it was a posterior translation of the mobile plateau. The movement was minimal (mean 2 mm) in all cases.

Discussion: We compared these findings with data in the literature obtained with the same fluoroscopic method. The behaviour observed was intermediary to that for two versions of a reference TKA with a mobile plateau (two mobile menisci, rotating platform).

Conclusion: We demonstrated rotation and anteroposterior translation movements of the mobile plateau total knee arthroplasty studied. The mobile plateau was in a “floating” situation in 18/20 cases. This is theoretically favourable to the transmission of stress forces. An in vitro study using stress gauges to measure stress at interfaces should provide complementary information to this fluoroscopic study.


M. Bercovy E. Weber A. Duron

Purpose: The purpose of this work was to compare polyethylene (PE) wear between prostheses with similar function but different congruency of the femoral implant / PE insert and, as a corollary, the mobility of the plateau.

Material and methods: We studied two groups of knee prostheses: prostheses preserving both cruciate ligaments (n = 20), and stabilised prostheses without preservation of the cruciate ligaments (n = 20). Four representative samples of ten patients by type of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) were selected at random among a cohort of 105 patients operated on between 1994 and 1996 with a mean follow-up of five years. All patients were reviewed with AP and lateral radiographs, a view in the plateau plane, and goniometry. Using this random selection, patients in the two groups were comparable for operative age (69 years), diagnosis (degenerative disease), sex ratio, IKS score (> 80/100), and follow-up. The only difference between the two groups was the postoperative goniometry: 180±2° for fixed plateau; 178±3° for mobile plateau (p< 0.05).

Result: Penetration of the femur in the PE insert (U) (after correction for radiographic magnification) was: TKA two cruciates fixed plateau: U=3.5±1.5mm; TKA two cruciates mobile plateau: U=0±1mm (p< 0.001); TKA posterior stabilisation fixed plateau: U=2.5±1mm; TKA posterior stabilisation mobile plateau: U=0 mm (p< 0.001). A difference of more than 3° in the mechanical axis did not show detectable wear in the group of congruent prostheses while for fixed plateau prostheses, wear appeared when the mechanical axis was 180°.

Discussion: Few studies have compared PE wear of TKAs with identical form and function. The random selection allowed us to compare homogeneous groups of patients eliminating selection bias of the retrospective analysis and of the effect of patients lost to follow-up. The highly significant difference between the groups compared avoided potential ß risk. However the quality of the PE and its mode of sterilisation were not known with certainty for the tested implants.

Conclusion: This study demonstrates the importance of congruency as a factor reducing PE wear in TKA. This parameter is more favourable when the postoperative mechanical axis is perfectly corrected.


C. Lutz W. Van Hille J. Lano J.H. Jaegger

Purpose: We report aseptic complications observed in a retrospective series of 130 total knee arthroplasties using first generation Miller-Galante implants at 6.6 months mean follow-up.

Material and methods: Mean age of the patients at surgery was 65.4 years (35–82). One third of the patients was considered to be obese (BI > 30). The principal cause was primary degenerative joint disease (85%). Most of the implants were implanted without cement except for the first 9 prostheses (hybrid). Mean IKS score was 47.3 (12–70) preoperatively and 74.3 (30–99.5) postoperatively with 70% excellent or good results.

Results: The principal aseptic complications in this series were related to the patella (17%): loosening, fracture, dislocation, necrosis and metallosis. These complications were sometimes associated. Use of a metal-backed patellar insert was correlated with the development of certain patellar complications. The rate of aseptic loosening was 3.4% for the tibia, 1.7% for the femur. There was no statistically significant factor predictive of loosening (alignment, laxity, wear were not significant). Wear of the tibial component polyethylene predominated in the medial femorotibial compartment and was strongly correlated with varus and/or frontal laxity (p = 0.01). Images of bone rarefaction in the distal femur were observed in 61% of the cases. Their intensity was variable; stress shielding or osteolytic mechanisms appeared to be involved. Three revision procedures were required to treated clinically invalidating instability: one frontal laxity corrected by implantation of a thicker polyethylene tibial insert and two important sagittal laxities treated by posterior stabilised prostheses. Other aseptic complications were: stiffness requiring arthrolysis (n=1), unexplained painful prosthesis (n=1) and reflex dystrophy (n=1). These complications led to revision in 15% of the cases. Patient characteristics and mode of fixation were similar in patients with and without complications.

Discussion: These observations point out the multifactorial nature of failure of total knee arthroplasty, most often related to a complication of technical errors and implant properties. Nevertheless, patella-related complications was just one of the principal causes of the problems encountered with the Miller-Galante first-generation prosthesis, particularly the metal-backed insert, leading several teams to abandon this implant.


P.H. Flurin M. Allard V. Bousquet P. Colombet C. de Lavigne

Purpose: Outome after arthroscopic management of anterior instability of the shoulder has varied since the early series. The results proposed at the 1993 symposium of the French Society of Arthroscopy suggest we should be using this technique with prudence. We report here our experience with patients operated on between 1993 and 1997 who were selected on the basis of the 1993 conclusions that excluded patients with multiple recurrent instability and fractures of the anterior rim of the glenoid cavity.

Material and methods: Sixty-seven shoulders were operated on between 1993 and 1997. Mean follow-up for 58 of these shoulders (86%) was five years. These 58 patients constituted the study group. There were 31 men and 27 women, mean age 25 years, who had 30 recurrent shoulder dislocations, 12 shoulder subdislocations and 16 painful unstable shoulders. Forty-six percent of the patients participated in competition-level sports with forced shoulder movements in 39.6% of the cases. The surgical technique involved retightening the inferior glenohumeral ligament that was fixed with resorbable sutures. Immobilisation with elbow-to-body contention was strictly applied for three weeks at least followed by progressive rehabilitation exercises until renewed sports activities starting four months postoperatively.

Results: The mean overall Duplay score was 85.5 (sport 21/25; stability 18/25; mobility 24/25; pain 22/25). Outcome was good and very good in 82.7% of the patients, fair in 8.6%, and poor in 5 (recurrence). Subjectively, 55% of the patients were very satisfied, 27.5% were satisfied, 15.5% were disappointed and 1.7% were displeased. There were four complications (one infection cured with antibiotic therapy with a final score of 100 and three serious cases of capsulitis that recovered before one year). Gender, age, type and duration of instability, level of sports activity, and articular laxity appeared to affect outcome.

Discussion: The rate of failure (8.6%) is similar to that with open surgery (4.6% in the SOFCOT symposium 1999) and would be well below the rates observed in the 1993 arthroscopy series although the different patient selection does not allow valid comparison.

Conclusion: Arthroscopic stabilisation of the shoulder is a technically difficult procedure that has progressively shown its effectiveness after an appropriate learning curve and in carefully selected patients. Favourable elements include age over 20 years, competition level sports activity, recent instability, and absence of constitutional hyperlaxity.


S. Slimani H. Coudane D. Marçon E. Lesure

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to analyse total shoulder arthroplasty failures and the outcome after simple ablation of the prosthesis or revision with a Grammont inverted prosthesis.

Material and methods: This was a longitudianal prospective study of patients with a failed shoulder prosthesis who underwent either simple ablation of the prosthesis or revision athroplasty with an inverted Grammond prosthesis. Clinical (Constant score) and radiographic analysis was performed before revision and at last follow-up using identical criteria. The shoulder prosthesis was removed in case of failure due to infection. For all other causes of failure, an inverted Grammond prosthesis was implanted.

Results: The series included nine patients (eight women and one man) reoperated between January 1st 1995 and December 31st 1999. Mean follow-up was 47 months (12–108). Delay between the first procedure and revision surgery was 26 months (6–72). The cause of the failure of the first implant was: infection (four patients), dislocation (one patient), three-tendon rotator cuff tears (four cases). The overall Constant score before revision surgery was 18.5 (6–30). Mean Constant score at last follow-up was 40.1 (35–54). Mean gain in pain score was 9.4 points (0–15) and mean gain in hand position was 2.75 points (0–10).

Discussion: Complications after shoulder arthroplasty are not uncommon (14% according to Wirth, 1994) and treatment is difficult (Sperling 1999). Instability, rotator cuff tears, glenoid loosening, and infection are the most frequent causes of failure (Wirth 1994). The patients in this series had a very poor Constant score involving all the subscores, although deterioration of the pain score predominated. The gain, both with ablation and revision total shoulder arthroplasty, was greater than 25 points on the average. This gain was proportional to the initial score before revision and patients who had a revision total shoulder arthroplasty had a better gain (p < 0.001). Simple implant ablation did however improve the mean Constant score among patients with infection whose initial score was lower than the others (p < 0.001). the final outcome was moderate. The only patients who recovered muscle force were those who had a total revision prosthesis (p < 0.05).

Conclusion: Revision of a shoulder prosthesis gives disappointing results in terms of absolute outcome score, even though the gain over the initial functional situation is encouraging. Simple ablation of an implant is still indicated in certain patients, in particular those who have an initial Constant score under 20 points.


Ph. Cartier F. Laude

Purpose: We analysed complications observed after 1771 implantations of single-compartment knee prostheses performed since 1974.

Material and methods: Sterilised all polyethylene Marmor implants were used from 1974 to 1984. Metal-backed tibial implants with or without cement and condyle resurfacing were added after 1984.

Results: Mean survival of the 207 Marmor cemented prostheses implanted from 1974 to 1984 was 93% at 12 years. There were nine significant complications: seven loosenings, three with infection, and two deteriorations of the other compartment. There were five minor complications: two instabilities, one patellar and one anterior laxity; two stiff joints; one meniscal lesion in the other compartment and one hamstring tendinitis. A non-adjustable cobalt-chromium metal backed insert was added to the polyethylene lining in 1984. For the 790 implants using this prosthesis, 48 had to be revised (6%) four to eight years after implantation for polyethylene wear due to an insufficient thickness for size 7.5 mm and gamma sterilisation.

These observations led us to use, since 1991, two new polyethylene inserts sterilised with ethylene oxide: an adjustable titanium metal-back support with cement in 329 cases and without cement in 171 with hydroxyapatite surfacing, and a modified Marmor with complete thickness (min 9 mm) peripheral cortical support used in 274 cases. Fourteen revisions were required for: screwing problems in three cases early in our experience, three loosenings, three inappropriate indications, two patellar problems, one deterioration of the other compartment, one knee instability on an oblique plateau and unexplained residual knee pain. There was no evidence of significant polyethylene wear, even for the oldest cases in our series.

Conclusion: This long-term analysis of single-compartment knee prostheses has shown that at the tibial level the essential elements are the minimal thickness of the polyethylene, the type of sterilisation, and the type of metal back. Resurfaced condyles have demonstrated their superiority over those requiring a resection since only one femoral loosening was observed. Revision for total knee arthroplasty is not different from first intention replacements.


F. Rémy F. Gougeon T. Ala Eddine H. Migaud C. Fontaine A. Duquennoy

Purpose: A new radiographic classification of the femoral trochlea was proposed by David Dejour in 1998 to quantify the severity of bony dysplasia. The purpose of this work was to evaluate the reproducibility of this classification system and to determine its contribution to the identification of trochlea with a high-risk of femoropatellar instability.

Material and methods: Nine independent observers (one resident, four junior surgeons, four senior surgeons) with no knowledge of the patient’s history read 68 strict lateral views of knees with femoropatellar instability (53 objective instabilities (OI) and 15 potential instabilities (PI)). The classification system includes four types determined with three signs: crossing (defining the dysplasia and present in all four types), supratrochlear spike, double contour. The four types are: type A crossing alone, type B crossing and spike, type C crossing and double contour, type D crossing, spike and double contour. The kappa test was used to assess reproducibility and chi square test to analyse data by category.

Results: Twenty-one radiographs were excluded by one or several observers due to insufficient quality or the impossibility to identify the signs of the new classification. Interob-server reproducibility assess on 47 radiographs was fair (kappa = 0.48). The crossing sign was identified by the nine observers on the 47 radiographs. Reproducibility of identification of the spike was good (κ= 0.62), but was fair for the double contour (κ = 0.51). there was no difference in reproducibility by level of experience of the observers. The new classification system was not correlated with severity of femoropatellar instability: presence of spike 80% OI, absence of spike 67% OI; presence of double contour 74% OI, absence of double contour 75% OI.

Discussion, conclusion: This new classification system is more reproducibly than the former 3-type system proposed by Henri Dejour. The crossing sign and the spike are the most reproducible signs. There presence is however insufficient to quantify the dysplasia and predict the severity of the femoropatellar instability. A quantitative measure of the depth of the trochlea, which shows excellent reproducibility (interclass coefficient 0.65) could be added to better quantify the morphological anomaly and determine the most adapted treatment.


J.C. Le Huec E. Lesprite F. Touagliaro R. Hadidaner J. Magendie J.L. Husson

Purpose: Thoracoscopic spinal surgery may be less aggressive than classical open surgery. We relate our experience over the last five years, analysing complications observed.

Material and methods: Between 1995 and 2000, 68 patients underwent thoracoscopic spinal surgery. There were 34 men and 34 women, mean age 30.2 years (13–69). We analysed indications, preoperative anaesthesia parameters, peroperative and postoperative parameters and pulmonary, vascular, neurological and instrumental complications.

Results: Indications were: metastatic compression in three patients, disc herniation in eight with five calcified discs, fracture in 25, anterior release for scoliosis in 32 with inter-somatic graft in 20. Mean duration of the hospital stay was 19.6 days (7–48). There were three fractures with lung contusion that were excluded from the analysis although thoracoscopic surgery was possible. The analysis thus included 61 right and four left thoracoscopies. Four to nine trocars were used. There were three cases of intercostal nevralgia. Operation time depended on the underlying disease: 18 min for scoliosis, 2 hr 40 min for fractures, 4 hr 15 min for discal herniation (2 h 20–7 h 15). Blood loss was less than 200 cc for scoliosis, a mean 533 cc for fractures, and 800 cc for metastases. There were no pulmonary, vascular or instrumental complications. The image amplifier was used to monitor all osteosyntheses. We had one patient whose neurological situation worsened after resection of a transdural calcified thoracic herniation. Stay in the intensive care unit after surgery was 3.4 days, the drain was removed at 3.26 days and had collected 1240 cc. Postoperative paint was assessed for patients who had undergone thoracoscopy alone and who had no other disease (19 fractures and 8 herniation cases). level three antalgesics were required for 3.2 days. There were no vascular complications or signs of phlebitis. One residual atelectasia of the lower right lobe occurred in a female patient with major traumatic contusion, and pleural effusion was observed in three. One patient developed a contralateral pneumothorax that was punctured after release of major scoliosis (Cobe 92°). Residual pleural effusion after withdrawing the drain was aspirated at 48 hours. There were no infections.

Discussion: Thoracoscopy allowed the planned procedure in all patients. Blood loss was much lower than with classical open surgery. Pain was controlled better and the cosmetic effect was exceptional. Function was recovered rapidly by fracture patients. the quality of the anterior release for the scoliosis patients was equivalent to that obtained with classical techniques.

Conclusion: The complication rate was lower than that usually observed for similar procedures using classical techniques.


J. Delecrin D. Brossard M. Romih N. Passuti

Purpose: Indications for anterior release associated with posterior release for stiff idiopathic scoliosis in adults has varied from institution to institution. The traction view is taken as a useful tool to determine whether anterior release is necessary. The purpose of this study was to validate this hypothesis in a homogeneous group of patients with specifically defined idiopathic scoliosis and to determine predictive value of the traction view. Based on this prediction, we then compared postoperative frontal correction in patients with and without anterior release, performed thoracoscopically.

Material and methods: All patients had idiopathic thoracic scoliosis with a Cobb angle greater than 60° and less than 35% reduction on the standard traction view. Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation was used for release/posterior fusion procedures. A posterior approach was used alone in group 1 patients (n = 46). Group 2 patients (n = 10) underwent thoracoscopic first intention anterior release/fusion.

Results: The postoperative Cobb angle was strongly correlated with the preoperative angle on the traction view (r = 0.86, p < 0.001). The traction view predicted the postoperative Cobb angle actually achieved rather than the degree of correction of the Cobb angle. The severity of the curvature, 81.5° and 83.3° in groups 1 and 2 respectively, and reducibility on the traction view, 61.6° and 62.1° in groups 1 and 2 respectively, were not different. Likewise the postoperative angles were not significantly different between the two groups (47.4° and 45.4° respectively).

Discussion: The traction views were found to predict reduction of the thoracic curvature even for stiff scoliosis but with a wide error. The two groups were comparable since there was no difference in the mean degree of reducibility under traction. Consequently, anterior release did not appear to improve the postoperative correction in the frontal plane.

Conclusion: The traction view does not appear to be sufficiently discriminating to determine the usefulness of anterior release associated with posterior release for the treatment of stiff idiopathic thoracic scoliosis.


S. Lautman G. Faizon R. Roger Ph. Rosset

Purpose: Classifications of fractures of the thoracolumbar spine are theoretically designed to help make therapeutic decisions. Three classifications (J. Laulan, F. Denis, F. Magerl) were compared to assess reproducibility for use by a surgery team.

Material and methods: The classifications were described during a SOFCOT symposium in 1995. Four observers examined 60 files reading them twice at a 1 month interval. The files included plain radiographs (AP and lateral view) and a scanner series and were read in random order. Intra- and interobserver concordance were measured with the kappa method.

Results: Intra- and interobserver reproducibility was good for the classification proposed by F. Denis (kappa = 0.6229 and 0.0795) for classification groups but was weak for subgroups (kappa = 0.028 and 0.571). Reproducibility was moderate for the classification proposed by J. Laulin (interob-server kappa = 0.460, intraobserver kappa = 0.541). The Magerl classification produced low to negligible reproducibility for classification groups and subgroups (intra- and interobserver kappa = 0.138 to 0.0343).

Discussion: Because of its low to negligible reproducibility, the Magerl classification would be difficult to use in clinical practice to make coherent therapeutic decisions or for scientific research to analyze series of fractures treated using this classification. The reproducibility of the F. Denis classification was good for groups but low for subgroups that include fractures resulting from different mechanisms requiring radically different treatment strategies. This is a good classification system for descriptive work but can lead to treatments poorly adapted to the causal mechanism of the fracture. The reproducibility of the J. Laulan classification is moderate but each group in this classification corresponds to fractures caused by the same mechanism. Therapeutic indications determined with this system would be more coherent.


P. Mansat F. Alqoh M. Rongières Y. Bellumore P. Bonnevialle M. Mansat

Purpose: We report a series of 16 GUEPAR total elbow prostheses implanted in a single centre.

Material and methods: Between 1988 and 1996, sixteen GUEPAR prostheses were implanted in 13 patients (three bilateral implantations). There were 11 women and two men, mean age 61 years (51–81). Twelve patients (14 elbows) had rheumatoid polyarthritis and one patient (two elbows) had post-traumatic degenerative disease. The V transtricepital approach was used in 15 cases and the Bryan-Morrey approach in one. Postoperatively, the elbows were immobilised at 45° flexion for the normal period (18 days) followed by active mobilisation. Results were analysed with the Mayo Clinic score. The radiographs were examined in search for lucent lines and signs of loosening and prosthetic instability.

Results: At a mean follow-up of four years (2–12), the mean Mayo Clinic score had improved from 33 to 75 points (45–100). Eleven elbows were pain free at last follow-up. Extension and flexion progressed 22° giving a postoperative amplitude of 34° to 129°. Pronation supination progressed by 15° giving a 154° rotation amplitude. The function score improved from 6 to 18 points. Seven of the sixteen elbows achieved normal function. Outcome was excellent for seven elbows, good for one, fair for three and poor for five. In two elbows, instability required changing the ulnar implant. There were four implant loosenings that required revision at 24, 36 ,36 and 48 months after the initial implantation. The radiographic analysis demonstrated a complete lucent line around the humeral and ulnar implant in one case, around the ulnar implant in one case. There were two peroperative fractures of the humerus and on postoperative fracture due to a fall. Ulnar paresthesia was observed in two cases requiring secondary neurolysis in one. There were no infections or secondary injury to the triceps.

Discussion: The GUEPAR prosthesis is a non-constrained prosthesis essentially indicated for rheumatoid polyarthritis. If the intrinsic stability is lost, the implant is contraindicated if there is loss of bone stock or if the instability is major. In selected cases, a generally painless elbow with recovery of the functional amplitude can be achieved with this prosthesis. Nevertheless, the presence of four early loosenings in our series as well as two instabilities suggest this implant should be abandoned in favour of a semi-constrained implant.


Ch. Chantelot G. Robert T. Aihonou G. Strouck H. Migaud C. Fontaine

Purpose: The synovectomy-reaxation-stabilisation (SRS) procedure classically involves tenosynovectomy of the extensors, articulr synovectomy, partial deinnervation of the wrist, and tendon transfer. The purpose of this study was to: 1) evaluate functional and radiographic results, 2) search for possible correlations between results and the extent of articular synovectomy or type of tendon transfer.

Material and methods: Between 1984 and 1998, an SRS procedure was performed in 75 patients, 14 were excluded: seven had died, five were lost to folow-u and two had had wrist arthrodesis. A total of 73 wrists were analysed in 61 patients. Mean follow-up was 70 months and mean patient age was 53 years. Functional assessment was based on the Gschwend pain scale.

Results: Before surgery, 94% of the patients had grade III or IV pain. At last follow-up, 93% of them grade 0 or I. The gain in pain was greatest for patients with severe carpitis. At last follow-up, the wrist was stiff; stiffness basically involved flexion with 43° pre and 27° postoperatively, radial inclination 13° pre and 9° postoperatively, and pronation in patients with advanced Larsen grade preoperatively. Extension, ulnar inclination, and supination were improved 5° to 10°. Extension of the synovectomy to carpal joints had a stiffening effect. Before the operation, 25 wrists were in Larsen grades 0, 1 and 2 and 48 wrists were in Larsen grades 3 or 4. At last follow-up, there were nine wrists in Larsen grades 0, 1, or 2 and 64 in Larsen grades 3 or 4. Carpitis thus continued to evolve and the height of the carpus declined. Ulnar translation of the carpus progressed a mean 2 mm. Spontaneous radial inclination of the wrist was aggravated by a mean 3°. The frontal position of the wrist was better after transfer of the long radial extensor of the carpus on the short radial extensor of the carpus than for transfer on the ulnar extensor of the carpus or without transfer.

Discussion: Our pain results are in agreement with data in the literature but we did not observe preserved or improved mobility. Extended synovectomy appeared to have a stiffening effect. Progression of the ulnar translation of the carpus was less pronounced with simple resection of the head of the ulna. It was better to transfer the long radial extensor of the carpus on the short radial extensor of the carpus to correct for frontal deviation of the carpus.


C. Mathoulin G. Vandeputte M. Haerle P. Valenti A. Gilbert

Purpose: We report the long-term outcome after treatment of scaphoid nonunion using a graft harvested on the anterior aspect of the radius and vascularised with the anterior carpus artery.

Material and methods: We treated 72 patients, 11 women and 61 men. Mean age was 31.4 years (15–61) and mean delay from initial fracture of the scaphiod to treatment of nonunion was 22 months (4–120 months). Twenty-seven patients had had prior tratments (11 Mati-Russe, 16 screw fixations). Alnot classification was 40 grade 2A, 28 grade 2B and 4 grade 3A. the patients were generally treated as out-patients under locoregional anaesthesia. A single approach was needed. After reduction and fixation of the scaphoid, the graft was harvested from the anterior aspect of the radius and inserted in the bone gap, usually fixed with a temporary pin. A palmar brace was maintained until bone healing.

Results: Bone healing was achieved in 66 patients (91.6%). Mean delay to healing was 9.8 weeks (6–24). Pain relief was achieved in all patients; 59 were completely pain free. Mean flexion improved from 45° to 56° and mean extension from 54° to 65°. Muscle force improved from 50% to 90% of the healthy side. There were three cases of reflex dystrophy, two cases of styloid radial osteoarthritis and three cases of postoperative stiffness requiring secondary arthrolysis. Functional outcome was excellent in 46 patients, good in 13, fair in 9 and poor in 4.

Discussion: The vascularised graft advocated by Judet as early as 1964 has proven its efficacy for repeated nonunions of the scaphoid. In our series, there was a direct correlation between the grade of the nonunion and the final outcome, the best results being obtain for grade 2A.

Conclusion: Use of a bone graft vascularised with the anterior carpus artery only requires on approach, and provides a high rate of bone healing. We recommend this method for first line treatment of nonunion of the scaphoid.


A. Frank M. Ouaknine

Purpose: The difficulty of successive reconstructions of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) using an autologous graft depends on many factors. The choice of the new transplant is crucial. The purpose of this study was to assess outcome in 17 patients who underwent successive repairs of the ACL after failed patellar tendon graft where the same patellar ligament site was used to harvest the graft. This choice resulted from the width of the existing bone tunnels (irrespective of the type of screw used) that were often correctly positioned by contraindicated a relatively narrow transplant.

Material and method: The graft was obtained from the patellar ligament at the same site as used for the primary repair in 19 patients. The graft was medialised so half of the fibres were cicatricial and half were tendon with bone prolongations. Arthroscopy revealed a lesion of the distal portion of the transplant near the tibial inertion in nine cases, a proximal lesion in five cases and distension in five cases. Five patients had also had a contralateral plasty of the ACL. Mean age was 31 years. Symptoms included instability, alone or with pain. In 12 cases, partial meniscectomy was performed before or during the repeat plasty procedure. Minimum follow-up was one year for 17 patients with a mean of 21 months. IKCD and Lysholm-Tegner criteria were assessed. Laxity was measured at maximal manual traction using a KT 1000.

Results: Overall IKDC outcome was 2A, 10B, 4C, and 1D. Differential laxity at maximal manual traction, evaluated for the 12 patients with a healthy contralateral knee was 2.7 ± 1.3 mm (versus 1.7±1.9 mm in the control series). Mean pre-postoperative gain in the 17 patients was 5.4 ± 3 mm (versus 5.6 ± 2.4 mm in the control series). The predominant sign was residual pain (11/17). Pain was generally moderate and induced by exercise. Pain at the site of graft harvesting was frequent during the six months after surgery (11 cases) but rare after one year (2 cases).

Discussion: Due to the cartilage and meniscal history of this population of patients who had undergone several repairs of the ACL, the results were satisfactory and little different from those obtained with the same primary procedure in a control group. The residual laxity study showed that the mechanical quality of the transplant was good. Histology studies published on repeat patellar tendon harvesting have been discordant.

Conclusions: Repeat harvesting of the patellar tendon for ACL repair appears to be an excellent alternative since it is thicker than the primary transplant and thus fills the bone defects better than other transplants (particularly hamstring).


B. Schlatterer S. Jung F. Pereretti

Purpose: The prospective study conducted by an independent examiner included an overall series of 104 ligamento-plasties using the fascia lata (Jaeger procedure).

Material and methods: All procedures were performed by the same operator and outcome was assessed at least 12 months after operation (mean follow-up 27 months).

Results and discussion: The IKDC scores were comparable with other series using autotransplants: 39% A, 45% B, 12% C, 4% D. Mean residual laxity differential (KT 2000) was 1.92 mm (−2 to 6 mm) and showed the anatomic efficacy of this technique. Extra-articular reinforcement was determinant in supporting the intra-articular plasty, calibrated at 6 mm diameter, explaining the good score obtained for residual differential laxity in sub-extension: 54% A, 29%B, 3%C. Laxity measured between +2 and +3 mm in 14% of the patients who could not be classed in the IKDC A and B classes. Mixed plasty with the fascia lata neutralised rotation clicks in 90.4% of the cases. The lateral portion of the mixed plasty did not raise any problem for ligamentisation explaining its efficacy and low rate of rotation clicks at last follow-up.

All professional athletes in this series and all athletes participating in high-level competitions were able to resume their former sports activity at the same level; for the entire series 67% resumed their former sports activities at the same level. Thirty-eight competition level athletes (n=63, 60%) resumed competition after surgery, 24 (38%) practised leisure sports. The change to leisure sports in these 24 patients was related to the knee plasty in eight. Irreducible knee flexion (+5°) was related to reflex dystrophy in four patients. Eleven patients presented reflex dystrophy; two had mobilisation under general anaesthesia.

None of the patients had a painful harvesting site. Among the four cases with lateral decoaptation, two were related to poor dissection of the posterolateral angle without any pre-existing lesion of the peripheral formations.

Section of the lateral intermuscular partition allowed complete closure of the fascia lata in all the difficult cases. We had only one case of proximal muscular herniation at the harvesting site.


T. Ala Eddine C. Chantelot J. Beniluz F. Giraud H. Migaud A. Duquennoy

Purpose: Changes in the lever arm of the abductors is not always perfectly controlled during implantation of total hip arthroplasties. Its possible effect on the development of prothesis dislocation is not known. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the influence of the lever arm and its modifications on the development of prosthetic instability.

Material and methods: We analysed prospectively 73 total hip arthroplasties implanted via the posterolateral approach. The study group was composed of a consecutive series of 45 dislocated prostheses and a control group of 28 stable prostheses selected at random. The following measurements were made on the anteroposterior x-ray: 1) lever arm of the abductors, 2) femoral offset. These measures were compared with the healthy contralateral hip and when this hip was diseased or had a prosthesis, with the pre-implantation x-rays.

Results: None of the studied parameters was statistically different between the dislocated and stable prostheses. However, in the dislocated prostheses, the lever arm of the abductors before insertion of the prosthesis was shorter than in the control group (p = 0.04) suggesting the presence of a group of hips “at risk”. There was a correlation between the offset values and the lever arm values for the stable prostheses and for the healthy contralateral hips in both groups. Conversely, this balance was not found in the dislocated hips. The lever arm/offset ratio was calculated to determine if the ideal ratio influenced hip stability. This ratio was not directly related to the development of dislocation, but it was decreased for dislocated hips. This ratio was ideal for 75% of the stable prostheses and for only 53% of the dislocated prostheses.

Conclusions: We concluded that: 1) hips “at risk” of dislocation would have a shorter lever arm, 2) the lever arm or the femoral offset do not have a direct effect on dislocation, and 3) stable hip prostheses have a balance similar to that in healthy hips identified by a correlation between the lever arm and the femoral offset. We thus emphasise the importance of respecting these parameters although they are probably not the only factors influencing prosthesis stability. Allowable variations are small, demanding careful and precise operation planning.


PK Bazouk C. Maynou H. Mestdagh

Purpose: Use of nitrogen-ion implanted titanium heads appeared to us as an essential factor in the development of aseptic acetabular and femoral loosenings.

Material and methods: Our series included 62 implanted titanium heads reviewed at a mean follow-up of 84.4 months. Nine patients had died and one was lost to follow-up. The heads were combined with a titanium-sanded elastic pressfix cup in 40 cases, and with the same cup with hydroxyapatite surfacing in 12 cases. Titanium femoral stems were cemented in 16 cases and non-cemented in 36 with a titanium-sanded metaphyseal support.

Results: At mean follow-up of 84.4 months, there was a lucent line in three zones on the AP view, including 9 that were complete, in 11 cups. Acetabular osteolysis was observed around five cups and femoral osteolysis around eight stems. Mean wear was 0.18 mm per year. Considering the entire series (61 heads), there were 11 cups requiring revision for aseptic loosening at a mean 74.2 months; four stems (all without cement) that had to be replaced for aseptic loosening at 74.5 months. Polyethylene wear on the removed implants was more pronounced than for the non-revised implants (0.34 mm/year versus 0.14 mm/year, p < 0.05). Metallosis was associated in eight cases. Macroscopic analysis of the heads revealed evidence of delamination on the entire contact surface with the polyethylene. The femoral and acetabular implants did not appear to be the cause of these loosenings because associated with other types of heads (stainless steel, chromium-cobalt, alumine, zircone, niturate titanium) they did not lead to loosening except in one case (stainless steel head) out of 118.

Discussion: Titanium is known to be have poor friction properties. To improve performance, ionic implantation has been proposed. The layer of nitrogen ions projected onto the surface of the head only cover a thickness to the order of one micron. Once this protective film is rapidly dissipated by abrasion, the titanium comes in direct contact with the polyethylene, leading to important release of titanium and polyethylene particles that can cause osteolytis and aseptic loosening.

Conclusion: Close surveillance of patients with these heads is necessary to recognise wear early and propose synovectomy and head replacement in case of implant loosening.


H. de la Selle J. Leroux H. Coudane K. Polet GF. Girard A. Blum

Purpose: Despite the development of new imaging techniques (MRI, CT scan) longitudinal studies of total hip arthroplasty (THA) are still conducted with conventional radiographs. New techniques for conventional radiograpy such as luminous screens with memory raise the question of longitudinal study in patients with THA where the new screen-film might produce artefacts.

Material and method: This prospective study examined intermethod and interobserver agreement. Thirty-seven patients were included in the series from July 1st, 1998 and September 30, 1998. Each patient had a double radiography series: three plain films using the conventional technique (C) and three digitalized screen films (D). The C were taken with a 1/1 ratio on a Philips Diagnost 90 table and developed using the Kodak M6 method using a 36 x 43 cm cassette for the pelvic x-ray and a 24 x 30 cm cassette for the x-ray of the prosthetic hip. The D were made on the Philips Diagnost 90 table and developed with the Agfa ADC70 procedure on a memory screen with a 5 pl/mm spatial resolution for 36 x 43 cm for the pelvic x-ray and 28 x 35 for the prosthetic hip. The same operator performed the complete radiography series in the same patient (C and D). The images were read examining the cement/bone interfaces and the prosthesis/cement interfaces looking for the classical radio-lucent lines in the De Lee and Charnley sectors. The presence and the thickness of the radiolucent line were classed in three groups: no line, line less than 2 mm, line greater than 2 mm. For each patient, the films were placed in anonymous folders and two subgroups were selected at random for the readers (a radiologist and an orthopaedic surgeon) who did not read successively the same films for the same patient. The results were recorded with an Excel data sheet and the statistical analysis was done with the BMDP software.

Results: Thirty-seven patients were included (22 women and 15 men) with 40 THA. Mean age was 64 years (42–86). Mean follow-up of the THA was 25 months (2–248). Four patients had mechanical pain or deceased joint amplitude and 33 patients had no clinical sign. Only one lucent line was found measuring less than 2 mm in the 1st quadrant of the cup and the 3, 4, and 5 zones on the AP view and the 10, 11, 12 zones on the lateral view on the tail of the pros-thesis. In this study, the kappa value was less than 0.5 for the mean concordance according to the Landis and Koch classification. The Kappa was higher for the intermethod analysis irrespective of the reader, than for the interobserver analysis.

Discussion, conclusion: Independent readers of the two types of images (C and D) did not demonstrate any difference for cemented or noncemented prosthesis in a longitudinal study of THA. The reproducibility between the C and D techniques was small. However, our study only analysed a few of the numerous radiographic signs considered to favour loosening (stress shielding, lucent lines etc.…). However, the analysis of the Kappa results demonstrated mean concordance between the techniques better than mean concordance between observers.


C. Boeri J. Gaudia J.Y. Jenny

Purpose: Centromedullary nailing with reaming is a recognised treatment for open leg fractures with a well-measured risk of postoperative infection. The development nailing procedures without reaming might reduce this risk.

Material and methods: We performed a Medline search using the following key words: nailing, tibia, open fracture, infection. To be retained for analysis, articles had to evaluate infectious risk of nailing with or without reaming, in clinical trials or experimental studies, with precise diagnostic criteria. Clinical articles retained were classed in three categories by decreasing value of their methodology: prospective randomised comparative studies, case-control studies, comparative observation studies, simple observation studies. Only comparative experimental and prospective comparative randomised studies were considered to be pertinent.

Results: Five articles met the predefined quality inclusion criteria and were retained for analysis: three experimental studies and two clinical trials. The experimental studies by Melcher (1995 and 1996) demonstrated a significant increase in infection rate and bacterial counts after nailing with reaming; there were two confounding factors however, steel or titanium nail and full or hollow nail which also had a significant effect on the rate of infection. The experimental work by Curtis (1995) did not find any difference in incidence and severity of infection between nailings with and without reaming. The two prospective comparative randomised clinical trials by Keating (1007) and Finkemeier (2000) included a total of 132 cases. the risk of infection was 8% after nailing with reaming and 7% after nailing without reaming (NS). The relative risk of infection after nailing with reaming was 1.02-fol greater than that without reaming (NS).

Discussion, conclusion: There is experimental evidence that would tend to prove that the risk of infection is lower after nailing with reaming, but it is insufficient to explain the mechanism of this lower rate. Inversely, although the clinical observation series tend to confirm these results, the two methodologically valid prospective comparative randomised studies did not find any difference. To date, there is no objective evidence ruling out the usefulness of nailing with reaming because of higher infection risk in open leg fractures.


L. Bernard V. Gleizes J. El Haj B. Pron A Lotthéa F. Signoret Ph. Denormandie J.M. Feron C. Perronnec L.L. Gaillard

Purpose: Patients hospitalized for osteomyelitis due to multi-resistant strains are often given prolonged parenteral antibiotics. Ambulatory parenteral antibiotic therapy is an alternative allowing outpatient care. The purpose of this study is to assess tolerance, cost and efficacy of this type of treatment.

Material and methods: Thirty-nine patients followed for osteomyelitis were included in this study. These patients were given antibiotics in a continuous infusion using a portable diffuser connected to an implanted chamber. Mean duration of treatment was four months, range 1.5–12 months. The follow-up team included the primary care physician, an infectious diseases specialist, and a nurse with special training in prolonged ambulatory antibiotic treatments. Results of weekly blood tests were transmitted to the referral hospital physician. Adverse effects and cost of prolonged ambulatory antibiotic therapy were recorded. Cost included costs for nurses, physical therapists, and physicians as well as drugs, supplies and laboratory tests. The cost of hospitalisation was determined on the basis of the standard cost for one day of hospitalisation in France.

Results: There were three cases of thrombophlebitis and one case of allergic reaction, both required re-hospitalisation. Cure was achieved in 93% of the patients. Mean follow-up since cure with discontinuation of the antibiotics was 18 months (14–22). Home care was possible in 100% of the patients and 23% of the patients were able to resume their occupational activity; 25% resumed their schooling. Self-administered schemes were possible in 23% of the patients. Compared with conventional hospitalisation, ambulatory parenteral antibiotic therapy enabled a cost savings of 1352 euros per patient.

Discussion: These results demonstrate that ambulatory antibiotic therapy is a very good alternative to classical hospitalisation enabling low morbidity, early resumption of social activities without loss of efficacy.


Ph. Anract M. Ouaknine Ch. Charrousset A. Babinet C. Jeanrot B. Tomeno

Purpose: Primary bone tumours located in the upper limb are mainly found in the proximal portion of the humerus. Tumour resection raises difficult situations due to the sacrifice of the cuff tendons. We propose a decision making scheme for determining the best reconstruction strategy.

Material and methods: This retrospective analysis was based on 35 cases (19 massive prostheses, ten composite prostheses, three inverted prostheses and three composite arthrodeses). All the clinical and radiographic data were reviewed to examine function, active motion, pain, and use of the upper limb in everyday activities.

Results: Massive humeral prostheses provided a technically simple solution but produced mediocre functional results: painless shoulder without active motion, but preservation of elbow and forearm function. Composite humeral prostheses (prosthesis + allograft) did not, in our experience provide any gain in function compared with massive prostheses. Allografts were resorbed after four to five years. Composite arthrodesis with allograft and vascularised fibular graft provided a mobile shoulder with a useful amplitude and a pain free joint. Results persisted. The inverted Delta prostheses (Grammont) covered with allografts and with preservation of the rotator cuff tendons offered an interesting alternative with functional results superior to arthrodesis and similar to those with shoulder prostheses implanted for degenerative disease. The persistence of the glenoid anchorage remains uncertain.

Conclusions: We use the following scheme for reconstruction of the proximal humerus. Resection of the proximal humerus with preservation of the deltoid in patients in good general health: inverted composite prosthesis. Resection of the proximal humerus without preservation of the deltoid in patients in poor general health: composite arthrodesis. Resection of the proximal humerus in patients in very poor general health when complex surgery with long post-operative care is not possible: massive prosthesis.


G. des Guetz S. Piperno-Neumann P. Anract G. de Pinieux L. Ollivier M. Forest J.Y. Pierga B. Tomeno P. Pouillart

Purpose: This retrospective analysis was based on observations in 15 patients, seven men and eight women, mean age 48 years (19–72) treated between 1988 and 2000 at the Curie Institute. The tumour was located in limbs in eight patients (one humerus, two femurs, four tibias, one fibula), in the axial skeleton in five (four pelvi, one sacrum), and in the rib cage and the scapula in one each. Histology examination of the dedifferentiated component displayed fibrosacroma in six cases, HFM in two, rhabdomyosarcoma in two and leiomyosarcoma and osteosarcoma in one each. Six patients were given neoadjuvant and adjuvant chemotherapy of the osteosarcoma type and underwent conservative surgery of the affected limb in three out of four cases. Total histological necrosis was observed in three out of six cases. Six patients were given adjuvant treatment alone using an osteosarcoma protocol. Three unoperable patients were given palliative chemotherapy and radiotherapy.

Results: Nine patients died from their disease. The most frequent metastatic site was the lung; mean survival was 20 months. Six patients survived including five with no progression (1+, 5+, 6+, 7+, 12+ years). Three out of five had had preoperative chemotherapy with a complete histological response and two out of five had had osteosarcoma protocol adjuvant chemotherapy.

Conclusion: Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma is generally considered to have very poor prognosis and should lead to an adapted therapeutic strategy. In our series, the osteosarcoma protocol provided complete histological response in three out of six patients. Five patients had prolonged survival, all had been given an osteosarcoma type chemotherapy protocol.


O. Moulin Ph. Anract A. Babinet S. Piperno-Neumann G. de Guetz B. Tomeno

Purpose: We report cancerological and functional outcome in 41 patients who underwent interilioabdominal disarticulation for malignant tumours.

Material and methods: This retrospective series included 27 men and 14 women, mean age 49 years, most of whom underwent surgery for chondrosarcoma. In ten patients, the disarticulation followed a resection-reconstruction procedure. In five patients, it followed curettage or contaminated margin resection. For seven patients it was performed after radiotherapy alone. None of the patients had metastatic dissemination prior to surgery. The resection margins were in healthy tissue in 24 cases and contaminated in 17. Mean follow-up was 62 months.

Results: Twenty-eight patients died from their disease and one died from pulmonary embolism. At last follow-up, among the 13 living patients, five had local or general relapse. For the 17 patients who had contaminated resection margins, ten developed a recurrent tumour compared with five recurrent tumours among the 25 patients with resection margins in healthy tissue. Mean five-and ten-year survival rates were 30% and 25% respectively. Initial treatment, tumour size and tumour histology did not have any significant effect on prognosis. The only factor with a significant effect on survival was the quality of the resection margins. All patients were able to walk with two crutches.

Discussion: Interilioabdominal disarticulation is a very mutilating procedure. Since the development of conservative surgery of the pelvis, indications for interilioabdominal disarticulation are generally limited to very voluminous endopelvic tumours with vessel and nerve invasion. For local recurrence after surgical resection of the pelvis or proximal femur, especially in patients with infection or radiated tissue, interilioabdominal disarticulation may be the only solution providing satisfactory cancerological resection. Careful exploration of the locoregional and general extension is necessary before proposing this mutilating procedure, with its inherent psychological and functional impact, in order to properly select patients free of metastasis who could benefit from the cancerological resection provided by inter-ilioabdominal disarticulation.


A. Sautet O. Vinardi P. Soubrane M. Ghrea J. Honiger L. Humbert P de Saint-Maur F. Berenbaume A. Apoil

Purpose: Joint cartilage repair is one of the most widely studies aspects of orthopedic care. The tissue’s intrinsic capacity to repair degenerative, inflammatory or trauma-induce damage is low. The purpose of this study was to report early results obtained with an allograft using a hybrid biocartilage in the rabbit.

Material and methods: Chondrocytes obtained by successive enzymatic digestion of joint cartilage from the knee joint were implanted via medial arthrotomy into an osteo-cartilaginous knee defect measuring 4 cm in diameter and 3 mm in depth produced by trepanation of the tronchlea. Both knees were operated in six adult New Zealand rabbits. After eight weeks, the animals were assessed clinically then sacrificed. The femoral condyles were removed for histological study. All grafted joints were mobile and had normal function without risk of self-mutilation.

Results: The joint samples did not show any evidence of effusion. The implant site was still visible macroscopically and presented a cartilaginous surface continuous with the healthy cartilage. After HES staining, the distal pole of the implant was found to be colonised with young cartilage continuous with the trochlear cartilage. Enchondral ossification appeared to be present in the distal part of certain cartilaginous nodules with a bony lamina continuous with the adjacent subchondral bone. There was no evidence of an inflammatory reaction of the synovial and the patellar cartilage was normal.

Discussion: These preliminary results of a hybrid biocartilage graft combined with cartilage surface reconstruction and osteointegration of the deep implant without in vivo supply of growth factors are encouraging. The safety of the supporting material was demonstrated. We are currently working on developing an autograft from progenitor cells.


D. Van de Velde Ph. Deroche J. Tabutin

Purpose: We performed mechanical trials to quantify the contribution of locking to the stability of revision femoral implants. The implant tested was a revision prosthesis with anatomic metaphyseal contact locked with three distal bolts measuring 4.5 mm.

Material and methods: Twelve implants were impacted into composite saw bones with constant and known dimensions and mechanical properties. Three displacement sensors were used to measure micromovements between the prosthesis and the bone: three specially designed force sensors were inserted into the bolt holes to measure the force distributions for each hole. Measurements were made with an Instron. Compression cycles (780 1-Hz cycles, 100daN applied to the femoral head) and torsion cycles (780 1-Hz cycles, 4.5 Nm applied to the femoral head) were used to simulate loading and weight-bearing and to estimate the evolution of the system. Trials were conducted in two different configurations: stable metaphyseal prosthesis, unstable metaphyseal prosthesis (simulating surgical resection). These two configurations were tested with a locked and with a non-locked implant.

Results: Loading distribution between the bolts was variable and depended on the insertion conditions, implant/bolt tolerance, and the quality of the supporting bone. In the “stable” metaphyseal configuration, the bolts carried a large percentage of the compression force (up to 30%) despite the support provided by the metaphysis; when exposed to torsion stress, the metaphyseal form of the prosthesis carried the charge and avoided this phenomenon. Locking had only minimal effect on micromovements, the impaction and the form of the prosthesis maintaining its stability. For the “unstable” configuration, locking created a stable situation: micromovements were limited to those observed in the stable prosthesis (< 150 μm), compatible with bone regrowth. The bolts carried most of the charge (74.8 ±20%; 56.0±41.7%) during the compression and torsion tests. Loading created major stress within the bolts whose properties (strict diameter 4.5 mm, lateral threading) should be taken into consideration to avoid risk of rupture beyond the elastic limit of the material.

Discussion: These results can be reasonably extrapolated to surgical situations leading to the following conclusions: locking is useful and reliable after surgical resection, all the holes available should be used for locking, “rational” unlocking can be useful if “physiological” metaphyseal stress is desired.


L. Pidhorz Ph. Ridereau Ch. Cadu

Purpose: Loosening and wear of the polyethylene insert remains an important problem after ten years. The Harris-Galante 1 (HGP1) press fit titanium backed cup appears to provide an interesting alternative. We studied the clinical and radiological outcome of 191 total hip arthroplasties performed between June 1985 and June 1990.

Material and methods: This prospective continuous series included 174 patients (191 hips), 76 women and 98 men, mean age 62.1 years (19–83). The posterior approach was used in all cases for treatment of degenerative hip disease (80%) or osteonecrosis (14.6%). The polyethylene-metal cup was used with a 28mm head in 90.7% of the cases. The press-fit cup was fixed with three screws. At review, 39 patients had died (45 hips), 25 were contacted for a phone interview, and two were lost to follow-up; 119 patients were re-examined and had a standard radiography series at last follow-up. Mean follow-up was 11.9 years (10–15). The Postel Merle d’Aubigné (PMA) score and the Harris hip score (HHS) were used to assess outcome. Quality of bone fixation and cup migration were studied as were lucent lines classed according to De Lee. Wear was calculated using the Livermore method and osteolysis using the Mulroy method. Actuarial survival curves were plotted using reoperation as the end-point if the polyethylene insert was changed or revision if the cup was changed for any reason. Qualitative data were compared using chi square test.

Results: There was one death on day three and three dislocations including two requiring reoperation for an insert overhang. The PMA pain score improved from 2.58 to 5.5 and the overall PMA score from 10.5 to 16.2. the HHS improved from 53.5 to 87.2 points. A lucent line measuring < 1 mm was found in 12 cases; one was complete, nine were in a single zone. Osteolysis was found in 28 cases and was qualified as severe in four. Mean polyethylene wear was 0.1 mm (volume 65.5 mm3). There was no case with cup migration or cup tilt and none of the cups had to be changed. Five polyethylene inserts were changed due to wear at a mean 145 months. The actuarial survival curve taking into account the seven insert changes showed a mean 15-year survival of 96.7±3%.

Discussion: The Harris-Galante press-fit cup has exhibited good behaviour at a mean 11.9 years follow-up. Mean annual wear was = 0.1 mm in 42 patients; it was > 0.2 mm in 18 patients including five who required reoperation to change the insert at 145 months. Osteolysis was noted in 28 cases, an important problem.

Conclusion: With only two patients lost to follow-up at ten years, this prospective review demonstrates well that the press-fit cup is well tolerated which has suffered from comparison with cemented cups. Five worn inserts had to be changed, requiring a simple operation. There were four cases of severe osteolysis.


C. Vielpeau P. Bacon C. Huet Y. Acquitter D. Schiltz B. Locker

Purpose: After cementing, various changes are observed in femoral bone resulting from various factors (ageing process, stress forces, granuloma…). The purpose of this work was to examine the radiological expression of these changes a mean 12 years after prosthesis implantation.

Material and methods: Charnley-Kerboull total hip arthroplasty was performed in 304 patients (338 hips) between January 1st, 1984 and December 31st, 1986. Mean age of the population was 65.5 years. Most of the patients had degenerative hip disease (81.4%). Among these 304 patients, 108 had died and 56 were lost to follow-up, giving 174 patients retained for analysis at a maximum follow-up of 16 years (mean 12 years). Noble and Nordin scores were recorded before surgery and during follow-up as were the cortical and cement thicknesses in the seven zones described by Gruen.

Results: The actuarial curve, calculated for the 338 hips showed 95.1% survival at 12 years (taking into account all revisions irrespective of the cause). Femoral stem survival was 97.1±2% taking certain or probable loosening as the endpoint. Several categories or radiological changes were observed: – femoral defects (18%) correlated with cup wear; – progressive widening of the medullary canal without loosening and a mean femoral score moving from 55.7 to 52.16 (p< 0.01) especially in thin women and for wide-mouthed femurs; – cortical thickening near the tip (57%) more frequently for greater distal filling; – stress shielding especially in women (p< 0.001) with a low initial score for the femur (p< 0.0006) and with greater distal filling.

Conclusion: Like Kerboull, we tried to achieve primary stem stability before cementing. Cementing results were good (97% at 12 years), but detailed radiographic analysis demonstrated that cortical thinning remained in zone 7, especially when the primary stability was achieved in the distal portion of the femur (high preoperative Noble index). Variations in the metaphyseal-diaphyseal ratio require adaptating the form of the stem to be cemented in order to achieve better filling and avoid primary stability mainly in the distal portion.


L. El Ayoubi X. Roussignol A. Karmouta I. Auquit Aukbur P.Y. Milliez N. Biga

Purpose: The radial nerve raises several problems during plate fixation of the mid third of the humerus because of its particular anatomic position. Translocation of the radial nerve has been proposed to distend the nerve. There have been few studies studying the feasibility of translocation. The purpose of our work was to validate the translocation effect on nerve distension and the status of the translocated radial nerve branches.

Materials and methods: We report an anatomic study of six cases. These patients had recent communitive fractures of the mid third of the humerus with immediate radial paralysis in three cases. The anterolateral approach was used to expose the nerves that were found to be continuous. Nerve translocation then plate fixation were achieved without neurolysis. The anatomic study was conducted on 15 cadavers: the distance between the last branch for the triceps and the first epicondylar motor branch was calculated in three positions: D0: mean distance in the anatomic position of the nerve; D1: mean distance of the nerve in the anatomic position with the plate; D2: mean distance after anterior translocation of the nerve. We provoked shaft fractures in the mid and lower third of the humerus and evaluated the sensorial and motor branches after translocation.

Results: In this clinical series, translocation was easily achieved in all cases without stretching the sensorial or motor branches. The three radial paralyses recovered in six months. There was not postoperative paralysis for the other cases. For the anatomy study, mean measurements for D0, D1, and D2 were 112, 116 and 106 mm, for a 10 mm gain between D2 and D1. The sensorial branch was stretched making the technique difficult in one case.

Discussion: The results of these two studies confirm the effect of radial nerve distension that facilitates fixation. It frees the posterior aspect of the humerus allowing access in case of nonunion. However, the translocation should be done without neurolysis of the radial nerve and after informed consent from the patient.

Conclusion: Anteromedial translocation of the radial nerve appears to be useful for fractures of the humerus. The ideal indication is an oblique fracture of the mid or lower third of the humeral shaft with immediate radial palsy. A certain degree of comminution facilitates the translocation.


O. Charrois A. Kawahji M. Rhami J.P. Courpied

Purpose: Rapidly destructive degeneration of the hip joint is a condition whose relations with habitual degenerative hip disease are poorly understood. This uncommon condition is observed in 5 to 10% of patients with degenerative hips and almost always requires arthroplasty; The objectives of this retrospective study were to determine the distinctive radiological and clinical features of this condition and assess long-term outcome after total hip arthroplasty in these patients.

Material and methods: The study concerned 100 total hip arthroplasties performed between 1984 and 1088 in 67 men and 11 men, mean age 71 years with rapidly destructive degeneration of the hip joint. All arthroplasties were implanted via the transtrochanteric approach with cemented Charnley-Kerboul implants. Mean follow-up was seven years ten months.

Results: There were seven complications: two nonunions of the trochanter, three extensive periprosthetic ossifications, one recurrent case of dislocation, and one late infection by blood stream dissemination. At last follow-up, 95 hips exhibited excellent or very good function (Poste-Merle-d’Aubigné classification). Fixation was stable for 94 ace-tabular implants and 97 femoral implants. Six acetabular implants and three femoral implants had loosened. These femoral loosenings were always associated with acetabular loosening. Four hips required revision surgery: one for non-union of the trochanter, one for septic loosening, and two for asepctic loosening.

Discussion: This study confirmed the radiological definition and the clinical features of this condition and demonstrated the reliability of the pathology examination of the femoral head and the articular capsule. Among the different hypotheses put forward to explain this condition, we cannot retain the presence of joint over-use, or use of anti-inflammatory drugs, nor infirm a micro-crystalline or vascular origin. Nevertheless, the vascular phenomena observed in the femoral head are comparable to those observed in joint lesions subsequent to ischaemia. Total hip arthroplasty causes considerable blood loss, estimated at 2706 ml (haematocrit 35%), apparently much higher than during arthroplasties using an identical technique for patients with the usual form of degenerative hip disease. Excepting this fact, complications, clinical outcome and arthroplasty longevity were not different than those generally observed.


J.M. Segonds J.Y. Alnot

Purpose: Nonunion of the humeral shaft is an uncommon complication of diaphyseal fractures. The rate of nonunion reported in the literature is nevertheless very variable, ranging from 1 to 10%. There are many causal and favouring factors often related to a technical error or poor therapeutic indication. There are several ways to treat humeral shaft fractures (orthopaedic treatment, locked centromedullary nail, ascending pinning, plate fixation, external fixation). Rigorous technique and rigorous indications are the key to success.

Material and methods: We reviewed 35 patients with aseptic nonunion of the humeral shaft between 1995 and 2000. The nonunion resulted from imperfect initial treatment in 24. Mean age was 44 years; fracture of the mid third of the shaft was oblique or transverse in general; all types of initial treatments had been used but ascending pins predominated (16 cases). All patients were reoperated for external plate fixation with a cancellous or corticocancellous bone graft after identifying the radial nerve.

Results: All patients achieved consolidation within a mean delay of 15 weeks with good shoulder (mean elevation 135°) and elbow (mean 10–130°) amplitudes. There were two cases of transient radial paresis with spontaneous recovery. Only two patients experienced mild arm pain that did not required long-term antalgesic treatment. There were no injuries to the femorocutaneous nerve at the site of graft harvesting.

Discussion: Plate fixation for nonunion of the humerus is widely described in the literature. The main complications with this method include radial paralysis and infection. For this reason, several recent reports have advocated locked nailing or external fixation of the Ilizarov type. These methods are technically difficult and are not free of their own complications. We thus recommend screw plate fixation (eight cortical screws on either side of the nonunion) associated with cancellous bone grafts. The results in our series with almost no complications favour this option.


Ph. Hernigou D. Bachir F. Galacteros

Purpose: The gravity of osteonecrosis in patients with sickle cell anaemia is well known, but the spontaneous course of grade I and II necrosis is not. The first MRI studies performed in these patients were made in 1985. This study compared the spontaneous course in 45 cases of grade I and II necrosis diagnosed between 1985 and 1990 with that in 43 cases of hip necrosis with the same grades I and II diagnosed between 1990 and 1995 in adult patients with sickle cell anaemia treated by medullary drilling with autologous bone marrow grafts.

Material and methods: The 45 cases of necrosis followed were diagnosed between 1985 and 1990. These patients did not undergo conservative treatment until the sphericity of the femoral head was lost. They were followed clinically and radiographically up through 2000. The second group of 43 cases of hip necrosis were diagnosed between 1990 and 1995. These patients were treated by meduallary drilling with an autologous bone marrow graft. The bone marrow as harvested from the iliac crests, concentrated and reinjected in the osteonecrotic area. The patients were followed clinically and radiographically until 2000. All patients had an x-ray of the hip (AP and lateral views) at last follow-up. As the follow-up was different for the two groups, comparisons were made using the survival curves; all patients were followed for at least five years.

Results: In group I where the clinical course was spontaneous, the spherical shape of the head was lost in 100% of the patients at five years (30% at one year, 60% at two years and 100% at five years), leading to surgery for 80%, usually with prosthesis implantation. In group II where the patients were treated by drilling and autologous bone marrow transplantation, two patients (5%) lost femoral head sphericity at five years. Ten percent of the patients (4 patients) had lost the femoral head sphericity at the current mean follow-up of eight years (minimum five, maximum ten) and required reoperation for prosthesis implantation. MRI and CT imaging in the non-reoperated patients demonstrated a spherical head and remodelling or disappearance of the osteonecrosis at five years.

Discussion and conclusion: The spontaneous course of necrosis in adults with sickle cell anaemia is unfavourable after five years. This spontaneous course can be modified (at least the rate of progression) by drilling associated with autologous bone marrow transplantation, if it is performed early enough.


P. E. Beaulé F.J. Dory J. M. Matta

Purpose: A classification system for fractures is an important communication tool for surgeons allowing the development of management schemes as well as an estimation of the prognosis. The purpose of our work was to evaluate the inter- and intra-observer reproducibility of the Letournel classification system for acetabular fractures.

Material methods and results: Sixty-five x-rays (AP and Judet views) and computed tomography (CT) series were chosen at random from a data base containing 800 fractures. The distribution of the fracture types followed data in the literature. Three groups of observers were formed, each composed of three orthopaedic surgeons. Group 1 included surgeons who had studied with Letournel, group 2 surgeons specialised in acetabular fractures, and group 3 surgeons qualified for general traumatology surgery. The kappa coefficient was determined to assess agreement between observers. Each observer read the images twice without knowledge of the treatment. The observers first classed the fractures using the x-rays alone then with the x-rays in combination with the CT. Two sessions were organised, two months apart to avoid any possible memorisation. Reproducibility without then with CT for the first session were: group 1: 0.07 and 0.74; group 2: 0.71 and 0.69; group 3: 0.51 and 0.512. Results were similar in the second session. Intra-observer reproducibility without then with CT was: group 1: 0.80 and 0.83; group 2 0.80 and 0.80; group 3: 0.64 and 0.69. Among the six more experimented observers (groups 1 and 2), 100% agreement was found for 66% of the x-rays compared with 22% for the new observers.

Discussion and conclusion: The Letournel classification system using x-rays in combination or not with CT is reliable (kappa > 7) for properly trained surgeons with regular experience in treating acetabular fractures. The value of the CT in the assessment of acetabular fractures is well established for identifying detached elements and joint crush. Conversely, CT does not appear to be essential to class ace-tabular fractures. The Letournel classification can be used as a reliable tool for the description of acetabular fractures and taught to surgeons desiring to undertake regular treatment of these fractures.


J.L. Husson L. Montron J.L. Polard G. Saillant

Purpose: The purpose of this work was to determine the role of orthopaedic treatment as a function of initial criteria of instability and potential risk of secondary restabilisation after healing of the common anterior vertebal ligament in patients with bipediculated C2 fractures and to compare the results of surgical treatment using CE pediatric fixation of C1-C3 fractures associated with C1-C3 graft to those with C2-C3 arthrodesis using posterior screw plate fixation with a pedicular screw in C2.

Material and methods: This was a retrospective analysis conducted in patients treated over a ten year period. There were 57 patients treated by two different orthopaedic surgery teams. There were 33 women and 24 mean, mean age 37 years with a maximum follow-up of 12 months. Clinical and radiographic findings were the same before treatment and at last follow-up. The surgical indication was for rupture of the common posterior vertebral ligament as assessed differently by two different surgical teams.

Results: Orthopaedic treatment was given to 65% of the patients (72% and 62% for the two teams). Clinical outcome in these patients was good or excellent in 69% and 79% resepectively for the two teams. Surgical treatment was given in 35% of the cases. Cervical CD fixation produced 100% fair clinical results and 40% very good and good radiographic results with the other 60% being acceptable. For the C2-C3 plate with a pedicular screw in C2, the clinical outcome was good or very good in 53% with 34% fair and poor results and 73% good and very good and 27% poor radiographic results.

Discusssion: This work demonstrated that indications or orthopaedic treatment can be extended, following the work by Roy-Cammille on the instability of these lesions introducting thus the notion of spontaneous anterior restabilisation due to healing of the common anterior vertebral ligament. For the choice of the technique, arthrodesis by cervical CD fixation remains a safe and sure technique despite the logical loss of C2-C3 rotation. Plate screw fixation with a C2 pedicular screw is more attractive but remains technically difficult.


O. Jardé J. Vernois S. Massy J. Berthelet

Purpose: We report a series of 32 ankle fractures reviewed 15 years after osteosynthesis.

Material and methods: The series included 12 fibular fractures, 14 bimalleolar fractures, and six trimalleolar fractures. The Weber classification was: type A four, type B 18, type C ten. Postoperative radiograpphy demonstrated 28 anatomic reductions and four shortened fibulae (3 to 5 cm). The results were assessed using the Harper criteria with a Kitaoka radiographic series. The statistical analysis was done with chi square.

Results: At the review 15 years after osteosynthesis, 19 ankles were pain free. Normal mobility was noted in 22 cases, and an absence of oedema in 18. Thirty patients wore normal shoes. Walking was normal in 23 cases; the x-rays revealed tibiotalar narrowing in 12 cases, and lengthenings of the malleolus in 23. Ten cases of tibiotalar narrowings were associated with a long medial malleolus. The objective results were good in 23 cases, fair in eight and poor in one. At fifteen years follow-up, osteoarthritis had developed in 37% of the cases despite anatomic reconstruction in 28. The four fibular shortenings were associated with development of osteoarthritis. Ossification of the medial malleola corresponded to detachment of a non-medial sutured ligament. Ankle osteoarthritis, when present, was particularly well tolerated.

Discussion: The long-term results of osteosyntheis for malleolar fractures was good in this series. Success requires perfect restoration of the joint anatomy. Unlike other series reported in the literature, non-surgical treatment of the medial collateral ligament led to medial periarticular ossifications in the very long term and limited joint mobility. We propose surgical suture of the medial collateral ligament.


J.L. Mallet M. Garcia M. Chammas J.L. Roux

Purpose: Transfer of the vascularised fibula causes an imbalance in the lower limb due to the small calibre of the bone compared with the recipient bone (femur, tibia). “Femorisation” or “tibialisation” is slow, requiring prolonged protection with an orthesis. The doubled fibula or “shotgun” technique which maintains fibular periosteal vascularisation may overcome this inconvenience.

Material and methods: We report a series of eight free vascular shotgun fibular transfers at a mean four years follow-up (1–11). The recipient site was the lower limb in all patients who had undergone multiple operations, seven for chronic osteitis and one for chondrosarcome (five femoral supracondylar grafts, one knee arthrodesis, two metaphyseal tibial grafts). A cortico-cancellous autologous graft was associated during the same operation for six patients; Osteo-synthesis was achieved in seven cases with an external fixator and in one case with locked centromedullary nailing.

Results: The bone scintigraphy obtained in all cases at the third postoperative day showed intense uptake in the graft in six cases. We had seven cases of osteitis with no case of recurrent sepsis. Mean delay to bone healing assessed radiographically was 5.2 months. Hypertrophy of the fibula was noted at last follow-up in four cases. The external fixator was removed on the average at 6.8 months (5–9). Weight bearing was allowed in all cases with an adjustable protective orthesis. There was one fracture of the graft in a patient with a knee arthordesis which was treated with a corticocancellous autologous bone graft.

Conclusion: This series demonstrates the interest of doubling the free fibular transplant compared with other bone transfers to the lower limbs, improving the balance of the bone calibre and resistance. For patients with loss of supracondylar femoral bone, we describe a widened posterior access allowing the preparation of the recipient site with a single installation for the graft harvesting and fibular transfer.


PROTRUSIO ACETABULI Pages 71 - 71
Full Access
E.J. Smith

The aetiology of pelvic protrusion of the femoral head is discussed and the process classified. We provide a protocol for the management of protrusio acetabuli.


G.P. Grobler J. Walters I. Learmonth B. Bernstein A.W.B. Heywood

We evaluate the results of total hip arthroplasty using either a porous-coated or a hydroxyapatite (HA) coated femoral component.

For a prospective trial we selected a cohort of young patients with a mean age of 39 (19 to 56). They were randomly selected to have either a one-third porous-coated or one-third HA-coated uncemented femoral component. One of two experienced hip surgeons performed the operations. Within the constraints of pathology, the approach and surgical technique was the same in all the cases. Patients were followed-up clinically and radiologically for a mean period of 102 months (87 to 113).

To date there have been no revisions. All components have remained well fixed and there is no evidence of progressive subsidence.

We found no significant difference between porous-coated or HA-coated stems.


Full Access
I.D. Learmonth

Reports in the literature of the incidence of dislocation following primary total hip arthroplasty (THA) vary from 0.5% to 5%. Contributing factors include surgical approach, loss of the abductor mechanism, a decreased offset of the hip joint, malorientation of the components, specific design features of the components, soft tissue laxity and lack of patient compliance.

The increased rate of dislocation with a posterior approach has been dramatically reduced with an enhanced posterior soft tissue repair. Component features associated with an increased risk of dislocation include reduced head/neck offset, an asymmetrical cup and possibly the head size.

Component malorientation is probably the most important factor leading to recurrent dislocation. With the patient in a lateral position, there can be unpredictable variation in the position of the pelvis, and intraoperative movements aggravated this. Uncertainty about the position of the pelvis at the time of insertion of the acetabular component may lead to malpositioning.

The surgeon should attempt to ensure adequate repair of the posterior capsule and external rotators. It is important to reproduce the offset, insert the components with the correct orientation, avoid impingement, and ensure patient compliance in the early postoperative period.

Dislocations are considered early if they occur within three months of THA and late after three months, and management varies accordingly.

While every effort should be made to avoid dislocation following THA, there is no learning curve: reviewing a series of 10 400 THA procedures performed at the Mayo Clinic, Woo and Morrey (1982) reported that the dislocation rate remained between 2% and 3%.


R.J.L. Stein F.A. Weber

Using the EOL cup, 15 operations were performed between December 1999 and January 2001. Most of them were salvage procedures after recurrent dislocations of total hip replacement and their revisions. The six men and nine women (mean age 63 years) had experienced a total of 42 dislocations and 16 previous revision procedures. One patient had seven recorded dislocations, two cases each had three previous revisions, and three cases each had two previous revisions.

The mean follow-up was 10 months. No redislocations have occurred.

This cup presents an alternative salvage solution for problem cases.


A.A. van Zyl

Revision total hip arthroplasty (THA) may be indicated for reasons other than femoral loosening.

From 1991 to 1999, 190 revision THA procedures were performed. These included 39 cement-on-cement (20.5%), 68 bone impaction (35.8%), 31 long stem cemented (16.3%), 16 acetabulum only (8.4%), six by-pass prosthesis (3.2%), 20 short stem cemented (10.5%) and 10 miscellaneous revisions (5.3%).

The mean time from previous THA was 6.6 years (1 to 23). Of the cement-on-cement revisions 18 (46%) were done for acetabular loosening, 13 (33.5%) for chronic dislocation, seven (18%) for fracture of the femoral prosthesis and one (2.5%) for chondrolysis of the hemiprosthesis. At a mean short follow-up of three years (1 to 7), we have seen no loosening of the femoral prosthesis.

The absolute indication for this procedure is a Type-A cement mantle in Gruen zones 2 to 6. Cement-on-cement revision can be done only in selected cases, but when possible this technique saves time and money and reduces the perioperative risk.


J. Bellemans

Although most surgeons agree that the functional results obtained with modern total knee arthroplasty (TKA) are acceptable, it is clear that even with the most recent designs it is still impossible to duplicate the behaviour and functional performance of a normal knee.

Recent kinematic studies have shown that modern TKA designs consistently provoke aberrant kinematics, mainly owing to the absence of the anterior cruciate ligament and the inability to maintain a functional posterior cruciate ligament (PCL). With regard to roll-back, PS cam-post designs appear to perform better than PCL retaining knees, but only in deeper degrees of flexion, usually only beyond 90°.

Whether it is strictly necessary to try to obtain normal kinematics remains an open debate. Clearly, aberrant kinematics are the direct cause of the flexion limitation we see in many of our patients. Further, they probably contribute to many of the discomforts associated with modern TKA, such as difficulties descending stairs, rising from chairs, pivoting and thrusting. Improvements in current TKA designs should aim at introducing the concept of guided-motion (intrinsic mechanism) and at maintaining or restoring (extrinsic) determinants of kinematics, i.e. the cruciate ligaments, the joint configuration and the extra-articular structures.


Full Access
G. Hooper

Since its introduction in Christchurch in 1989, the mobile bearing LCS prosthesis has been used in over 3 500 total knee arthroplasty (TKA) procedures. The prosthesis is unique in that it has a mobile articulation not only at the tibiofemoral joint but also at the patellofemoral joint. The tibiofemoral articulation may be posterior cruciate retaining (meniscal bearings - MB) or sacrificing (rotating platform - RP).

Clinical and radiological assessment of 569 patients over three to nine years shows no significant difference between MB and RP groups with respect to Knee Society and New Jersey knees or the WOMAC functional score. In 93% of patients results were good or excellent. There were more early complications among MB patients, with five MB dislocations. However, four of these dislocations occurred in the early years this prosthesis and may reflect surgical inexperience. Clinical evidence of posterior cruciate laxity was present in 15% of the MB group, but there was no significant difference between knee scores of this group, the rest of the MB group, or the RP group.

When resurfaced patellae were compared to knees that were not resurfaced, there was no significant difference. Patellae with more than 4 mm of lateral subluxation were identified, but their knee scores were not significantly different.

The early to medium-term results of our continuing study of the LCS mobile bearing prosthesis are at least comparable to those of studies of fixed bearing prostheses. We continue to use this implant with confidence, but await long-term results.


A.D. Barrow M.J. Radziejowski P.I. Webster

Conservative treatment of the ‘boxer’s fracture’ gives acceptable functional results but often leaves the patient with a residual deformity.

Using a prograde intramedullary K-wire, we treated 23 consecutive patients with a fractured neck of the fifth metacarpal. Volar angulation exceeded 40°. A 1.6-mm pre-bent K-wire was inserted via the base of the fifth metacarpal in each case. Time to regaining full function, time to union and final functional and radiological outcome were recorded.

All 23 patients went on to full clinical and radiological union within six weeks. In 18 patients, the reduction was anatomical with no residual angulation. In five the residual angulation ranged from 5° to 15°, with a mean of 8°. There was a transient sensory neuropraxia in two patients.

This minimally invasive technique is a simple, cost-effective and reliable method of treating a ‘boxer’s fracture’ and ensures a rapid return to full function with little or no residual deformity.


J.E. Viljoen

From January 1995 to January 1999, the author performed arthroscopic subacromial decompression (ASD) on 220 patients.

The mean age of patients was 47.4 years (28 to 72). The follow-up period ranged from 4 to 60 months. The modified UCLA scoring system was used to evaluate patients at four months and again at 24 to 60 months. At short-term follow-up, 91% of patients achieved good to excellent results. However, patients reviewed for two years or longer showed a 98% successful outcome. Stiffness was commonly the last thing to improve, and three patients required surgical intervention.

Early mobilisation with posterior capsular stretching is recommended. Careful clinical assessment of patients with chronic rotator cuff impingement and accurate identification of arthroscopic impingement signs ensures a successful outcome. This study confirms other reports that ASD produces good results in carefully-selected patients.


F.A. Weber C.J. Grobbelaar T.A. du Plessis J.N. Cakic A. Spirakis G.G.A. Cappaert

Wear of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWP) acetabular cups is a well-known cause of osteolysis and loosening of the components. Improvement of the wear resistance of UHMWP could extend the clinical life of total hip arthroplasty (THA). Chemical cross-linking in acetylene with gamma radiation is a cheap and effective way of increasing wear resistance of UHMWP.

This study is a report on 263 patients (123 males and 140 females) on whom Dr Weber performed THA between 1977 and 1984, using the Pretoria (Grobbelaar) monobloc stainless steel hip with 30-mm metal head. There were 96 patients (107 prostheses) available for follow-up at a mean of 18.3 years, with 89 surviving prosthesis in 79 patients (83.2%).

We collected complete sets of radiographs of 54 patients (mean age 71.4 years) for a radiological survey in 1999. In 41 patients (76%) we found no wear. The mean age of these patients was 72 years. Wear was noted in the other 13 patients (24%), whose mean age was 75 years. The mean follow-up time was 16 years (8 to 23). The mean magnification in the radiological study was 18%. Mean wear for the total group was 1.29 mm and mean annual wear 0.17 mm.

A similar analysis performed on a group of 64 of Dr Grobbelaar’s patients at 15.5 year mean follow-up shows remarkable similarity, with mean wear of 0.172 mm for a group of 64 patients and annual wear 0.11 mm. Dr Oonishi of Japan, who has conducted the only other long-term follow-up, found similarly promising results.


Full Access
E.H.W. Erken

Twenty-five years ago, Prof. Peter H. Beighton, our association’s geneticist, presented a paper reminding us that more than 2 000 genetic diseases and disorders have been identified. Many of the conditions are apparently confined to one particular geographical locality or ethnic group. A large proportion of genetic diseases and disorders has skeletal manifestations.

The Little People of South Africa (Association of Persons with Restricted Growth) have needed advice about the management of orthopaedic complications such as spinal problems in achondroplasia, axial deviations of the lower limbs, and in particular the possibilities of limb lengthening in disproportionate skeletal dysplasias.

From the story of a young achondroplastic woman who suffered from low back pain and was offered an operation by a neurosurgeon, there stemmed a media-driven report on dwarfs in the Land of Legends near Tzaneen, an epidemiological field study on achondroplasia in the Northern Province, and a combined round table consultation between a team of orthopaedic surgeons and a pair of Pedi sangomas.

In the village was an index group of three Pedi women and one man who were diagnosed with probable acrome-somelic dysplasia (Grebe), a form of achondrogenesis. The oldest woman and the man were brother and sister, and the two younger women their daughters by spouses of normal stature. While their heads and faces were normal and their spines straight, their dysmorphic features included shortness of stature (mean height 94 cm), disproportionate limb length and ligamentous laxity. The little man’s late father was also a dwarf, as was one of his eight brothers: there were thus six dwarfs in a direct line in three generations. The dwarf man and woman were both sangomas, as their father had been.

None of them had low back pain, but they knew how to cure it.


F.D. van der Westhuizen H.J.S. Colyn R.G. Molteno

We studied the outcome of displaced supracondylar fractures in 98 children treated over three years to December 2000. In 74 patients fractures were treated by closed reduction and percutaneous K-wire fixation. Through a direct posterior approach, open reduction was obtained in the other 24. Postoperatively the elbow was immobilised in a posterior cast in 30° flexion for three to four weeks. The cast and K-wires were removed in the clinic and the elbow mobilised.

In patients treated by closed reduction, the mean range of movement (ROM) was 10° to 120° at the one-month follow-up. There was a cubitus varus deformity in four patients. One patient developed pintract infection. There were five neurological complications, of which only one (ulnar nerve) was surgical. The mean ROM of patients treated by open reduction was 15° to 110° at the one-month follow-up. Pre-operatively two patients in this group had a neurological deficit (one median and one radial nerve), which had improved at follow-up.

Treatment of supracondylar humeral fractures in children by closed reduction and percutaneous K-wires is safe and reliable. Where open reduction is necessary, a posterior approach is more acceptable cosmetically and does not lead to functional loss.


E. Schnaid A. Biscardi M.B.E. Sweet

We studied the bone density and bone mineral content of 14 men and 10 women over the age of 60 years who had sustained a femoral neck fracture as a result of minor trauma. They were matched for age and gender with controls from a peri-urban black population.

Among the men, the femoral T and Z scores were significantly lower in the patients than in the controls. There were no significant differences among the female patient and control groups. In the controls, the mean bone densities were lower than in hologic white controls. The differences were not age-related. The black female controls also had lower bone densities than hologic white controls. These densities fell rapidly after the age of 50 years and this was age-related. As measured by their T scores, most of the patients were at risk for fractures.


B.G.P. Lindeque H.M. Snyckers J.C. van Niekerk

The purpose of our study was to ascertain whether complete debridement and cancellous bone grafting prevents the progression of early (Ficat stages I to III) non-traumatic avascular necrosis of the femoral head.

Between 1995 and 2001 15 patients presented at the Pre-toria Academic Hospital with atraumatic avascular necrosis of the femoral head. The necrosis was staged according to the modified Ficat classification based on radiographs and on MRI and/or a bone scintigram: there were five Ficat stage-I, six stage-IIA, two stage-IIB and two stage-III hips. Postoperatively the diagnosis was confirmed histologically in all cases.

Using the Harris Hip Score (HHS), patients were clinically evaluated preoperatively and at each follow-up examination. The Ficat classification was also determined at each follow-up. A lateral approach with a trap door procedure was followed by debridement of the necrotic area and autogenous bone grafting. The mean follow-up period was 20 months, with the longest follow-up six years. There was no progression of disease in the five patients with Ficat stage-I hips, and there was a mean HHS improvement of 40 points. The six Ficat stage-IIA and two stage-IIB patients also had no progression of disease and exhibited 53 and 78 point respectively HHS improvements. Both Ficat stage-III patients progressed to total hip arthroplasties after a mean of 17 months.

We conclude that debridement and cancellous bone grafting is effective in treating patients with Ficat stage-I to IIB avascular necrosis.


R.N. Dunn M.A. Fazal M.A. Edgar

Aiming to evaluate the efficacy and safety of instrumentation using only segmental pedicle screw fixation, we undertook a prospective study of 17 patients with idiopathic scoliosis who underwent corrective surgery in 1998 and 1999.

A total of 170 pedicle screws was inserted, 119 in the thoracic spine and 51 in the lumbar, extending from T2 to L5. The Cobb angle was measured on an erect anteroposterior radiograph postoperatively and at 6 and 12-month follow-up. Pedicle screw placement was assessed on the radiographs, and where there was concern about screw position, CT scan was performed.

Of the 170 pedicle screws, three were malpositioned lateral to the pedicle and one medial to the pedicle. One pedicle fractured during screw insertion, and three screws partially pulled out on the convex side of the curve at T3 to T5. At six months the mean Cobb angle correction was 53.6%. There were no neurological complications. Two cases required subsequent trimming of rods.

We believe fixation using only segmental pedicle screws is a safe method of correcting idiopathic scholastic deformities, but retain some reservations about the pull-out strength of the uppermost screws in the thoracic spine.


M.J. Radziejowski T.F. Wisniewski

In a prospective study, we reviewed 23 proximal humeral fractures treated by AO/Synthes intramedullary nailing between January 1999 and December 2000.

According to Neer’s classification, there were 12 two-part fractures, eight three-part and three four-part fractures. There was anterior dislocation of the glenohumeral joint in four patients. The mean age of the 16 men and seven women was 49 years (26 to 71). More fractures occurred in patients over 55 years of age. Anteroposterior and trans-scapular radiographs were taken and CT routinely performed. Surgery was performed within 5 to 14 days of injury. In young patients with two-part fractures, we used percutaneous integrate nailing. Three and four-part fractures were reduced and fixed through a short anterolateral deltoid split approach. The nail was inserted without reaming. The fracture fragments were reduced around the exposed proximal part of the nail and reduction secured by insertion of locking screws and a tension wire band. Ruptures of the rotator cuff were repaired. The nail was locked distally in 16 fractures.

The arm was immobilised for two or three weeks but supervised shoulder movement started as early as four to five days postoperatively. All fractures healed within 12 weeks. Functional shoulder movement returned in all but two cases. In younger patients recovery was faster and a near-full range of abduction and flexion returned. No sepsis occurred. Postoperative backing-out of the nail and varus deformity of the humeral head occurred in two patients. Two patients required re-operation. Backing-out of proximal locking screws was observed but did not affect functional outcome.

This minimally-invasive method of fixation by intramedullary nail, locking screws and tension wire band through a short incision may be an alternative way of managing complex proximal humeral fractures.


E. Coetzee

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of hyaluronic acid on the stability of the functional spinal unit (FSU) after discectomy.

The study included 20 Cercopithecus monkeys. Through a left retroperitoneal approach, four FSUs were exposed and nucleotomy performed. On one level a simple nucleotomy was done, while hyaluronic acid was inserted into one space, hylaform into another, and hylaform and bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)-2 into the fourth. The specimens were evaluated radiologically and histologically at the University of Marburg, Germany.

The vertebral height of all segments remained mostly unchanged. Insertion of hylaform with BMP-2 led to ossification in 30%. There was no ossification after insertion of hyaluronic acid alone or in 10% of simple nucleotomies.

The insertion of hyaluronic acid shows a promising capability of preventing disc collapse after nucleotomy and may enhance the favourable outcome of minimally invasive procedures.


E.H.W. Erken N.C. Botoulas

We conducted a long-term follow-up study to determine the functional status and level of social integration of 67 children with myelomeningocele. All of them attended a Spinal Defect Clinic for at least four years between 1968 and 1979, and all attended a Rehabilitation School for at least four years, either as day scholars or as boarders. An analysis of their functional walking abilities was presented at the congress in 1979.

Hospital and school records were obtained, and patients were asked to complete a questionnaire about their marital status, children, employment and educational status. Further questions asked about change in ambulatory status, sphincter status, urinary tract problems, numbers and types of operations performed after 1979, and whether they were satisfied with the results.

We traced 55 of the 67. There had been 12 deaths, most as result of urosepsis. Many patients had moved from the area. Many were in homes or living secluded lives and unwilling to get involved. Many patients had undergone more surgery, particularly amputation of the feet or legs. After leaving the Rehabilitation School, many patients became wheelchair-bound: these were extremely unhappy and felt they had been misled by the promise that they would continue to walk. All were over-weight.

The 10 patients who had spinal surgery were delighted with the result. Many were happy with the medical management and education they had received in childhood, and felt privileged to have their support systems. Many were gainfully employed and married with children.

The long-term follow-up study revealed that in adulthood the order of priorities of these patients remained the same as in childhood and adolescence. Most important was communication, then activities of daily living. Transportation and ambulation were secondary issues.


T.F. Wisniewski M.J. Radziejowski

In a prospective study, we reviewed 52 metaphyseal fractures of the proximal tibia treated by percutaneous plating between January 1996 and October 2000. Owing to the proximity of the fractures to the joint, intramedullary nailing was not suitable.

The mean age of the patients, most of whom were men, was 41 years (16 to 82). Five fractures were open. There were 10 comminuted fractures extending into the diaphysis and five segmental fractures. The fractures were reduced and under the image intensifier percutaneously plated through a short approach proximal to the fracture. Fracture reduction was achieved either by manipulation and traction or by use of femoral distractor and reduction clamp. Synthes tibial head buttress plates and screws were used for stabilisation. On average, three proximal and distal screws were percutaneously inserted. Satisfactory fracture reduction was achieved in the anteroposterior plane in all fractures, but in the sagittal plane tilting of the proximal fragment was observed in five cases. There were no intra-operative neuro-vascular complications. Postoperatively the leg was immobilised in a brace for 6 to 12 weeks. At a mean of six to eight weeks, when radiological signs of healing were noted, weight-bearing was permitted. The mean time to union was 12 weeks (8 to 18). There were two cases of delayed union. No patient had functional restrictions, secondary displacement or failure of fixation. In four patients the proximal screws backed out, but this did not affect functional outcome. Late sepsis, which developed at the site of the distal screws in six patients, subsided after drainage of abscesses in two patients and removal of plate and screws in four.

Percutaneous plating may be used to manage proximal tibial fractures unsuited to intramedullary nailing.


S. Brijlall

Fractures of the distal humerus present a challenge. The fractures are often intra-articular and the bone osteoporotic. The elbow tolerates surgery and immobilisation poorly, and it is difficult to secure rigid fixation. Union must be achieved and elbow motion preserved. The results of fixation of fractures of the distal humerus are unpredictable. Fixation with two plates at 90° angles to one another has become the standard against which all other treatment is measured. Following up patients for a mean of 24 months, the author conducted a prospective study evaluating posterior plating of the two columns of the distal humerus with reconstruction plates and intercondylar fixation.

Between 1996 and 2000, 18 women and seven men with unilateral intra-articular fractures of the distal humerus were treated. Their mean age was 46 years (35 to 71). The fractures were classified according to the AO classification: there were 22 type-CII and three type-CIII. Four fractures were compound.

One of two posterior approaches was used, either through the triceps aponeurosis or using an olecranon osteotomy. Postoperative management included prophylactic intravenous antibiotics for 48 hours and a posterior splint for 7 to 10 days. Active movement commenced once sutures were removed, but patients avoided active or resisted extension for six weeks. The mean time to union was 16 weeks. Patients attained a mean range of elbow movement of 105° (35° to 135°). One patient developed superficial sepsis but recovered after treatment with antibiotics. One patient with a compound injury developed a deep infection, which required multiple debridements, gentamycin beads and bone grafting to achieve union. There were no implant failures or cases of nerve paralysis.

This study demonstrated no differences in functional outcome between triceps aponeurosis or olecranon osteotomy approach. Union and satisfactory functional results were achieved with posterior plating of the columns and intercondylar fixation.


Full Access
M. Oleksak M. Metcalfe M. Saleh

Hybrid fixation is now an established modality of treatment for articular fractures of the proximal and distal tibia. However, there is a lack of consensus over the management of non-articular metaphyseal fractures extending into the diaphysis. Despite sophisticated techniques, intramedullary nailing remains difficult and has relatively high rates of malunion and nonunion. Plate fixation may produce satisfactory results, but its use is limited where there is major extension into the diaphysis or where the soft tissues are compromised.

Since 1995, we have used hybrid external fixation in the treatment of such fractures in 24 male and 16 female patients of mean age 54 years (15 to 92). Mostly sustained in road traffic accidents, there were 26 closed and 14 open fractures, seven of which were Gustillo type IIIB. There were 26 distal tibial, seven proximal and seven tibial shaft fractures.

Metaphyseal fixation consisted of two rings with tension wires, diaphyseal fixation of screws. We used additional rings in segmental diaphyseal fractures or used olive compression wires across the fracture when additional stability was required. Hybrid fixation was the primary procedure in 25 patients and a secondary procedure, performed within eight weeks of injury, in 15. All patients went on to union in a mean of 45 weeks, but 10 required additional procedures such as bone-grafting, additional insertion of olive wire and soft-tissue procedures. Residual malunion in six patients required adjustment with frame fixation, with minimal clinical significance. We had three pin-tract infections and one deep infection, which resolved after sequestrectomy.

When choosing a fixation system, it must be taken into account that high-energy tibial fractures may be slow to unite and that deep infection is related to the degree of soft-tissue injury. We believe hybrid fixation is a safe and minimally invasive treatment option. Careful attention to reduction and soft-tissue management, followed by early functional rehabilitation, can reduce healing times.


H.H. Volkersz J.M. Eltringham R. Mulamba

Between 1997 and 2000, 25 Schatzker type-V and VI tibial plateau fractures were treated at our hospitals with the Ortho-fix ring fixator and followed up for between 10 months and four years. We chose this form of treatment for three reasons. First, because these are usually high-energy injuries, open reduction and internal fixation has to be done on admission or when the swelling has reduced, which can take up to three weeks. Secondly, internal fixation usually requires bone grafting at the same time. Thirdly, there is a high incidence of sepsis following conventional treatment with double plate and bone graft.

There were 20 closed or grade-I compound fractures and five grade-II compound fractures. The mean age of the 22 men and three women was 45.3 years (30 to 71). One patient had a head injury. There were ipsilateral femoral fractures in two patients, one of whom also had a comminuted distal radial fracture on the contralateral side, and one patient had a contralateral tibial plafond fracture. We routinely placed patients on a traction table and reduced the fracture, using Bohler’s method of traction and elastic bandaging. If necessary we made a limited incision and held the fragment with a large fragment screw under C-arm control. Using three or ideally four proximal wires, we made sure that the most proximal went through the fibular head. With local patients the frame was applied within 24 hours of admission. In patients who were referred from other parts of Africa, the frame was applied up to 10 days after the accident, irrespective of the amount of swelling. Continuous passive motion from 0° to 90° was started immediately postoperatively and maintained for a minimum of five days. Patients were then given crutches and mobilised touch weight-bearing in the frame. When the frame was removed, patients were fitted with a DonJoy hinged knee brace with no limitation of knee flexion or extension. All but two patients attained 90° of flexion within 10 days of application of the frame. Four patients failed to achieve full extension. Grade-I pin-tract sepsis developed in 12 patients and grade-II in four. All infections settled with treatment. One proximal wire needed to be resited. The mean time to removal of the frame was 4.5 months. No bone grafting was required.

We concluded that the amount of swelling is not a critical issue and that the ring fixator can be applied within 10 days of the injury. Probably because there was minimal interference with soft tissues, deep-seated sepsis did not occur. Even in osteoporotic bone, wire fixation gives excellent stability. There is still uncertainty about long-term follow-up, development of post-traumatic osteoarthritis and the possibility of sepsis if total knee arthroplasty is undertaken later.


TOTAL ANKLE REPLACEMENT Pages 88 - 88
Full Access
P. Rossouw

Total ankle replacement, a relatively controversial procedure, is technically demanding.

Over the past four years, the author has performed 52 total ankle replacements for osteoarthritis. Patients have attained a 30% to 70% increase in the range of movement. Results have been rated good to excellent in 90% of cases, although 20% of ankles took a year to settle. Immediate benefits were relief of pain and correction of deformity. The procedure required a shorter period of convalescence than arthrodesis, and the rate of morbidity was notably lower. Subsequent conversion to arthrodesis was performed in 3% of patients, and eight prostheses required revision.

The overall results prove this procedure superior to ankle arthrodesis. Once the surgical technique has been mastered, this procedure is likely to become the treatment of choice in arthritis of the ankle.


J.B. Craig

A 22-year-old man was admitted to hospital after being assaulted. He complained of a painful neck and upper limbs, with weakness and numbness of his upper limbs.

Initial treatment was skull traction for six weeks, during which the motor power in the upper limbs recovered. CT scan of the cervical spine showed a lytic expanding bone lesion in the atlas. At 10 weeks he was transferred to a Spinal Centre, walking normally, with good bladder and bowel control. He was complaining of intermittent occipital headaches and pain at the cervicothoracic junction. He was wearing a cervical orthosis. His neck movements were guarded and markedly restricted. No neurological deficit was detected. A right-sided brachiocephalic artery angiogram showed no abnormality. MR scan showed definite narrowing of the spinal canal at the C2 vertebral level and stress studies some vertebral instability at the atlanto-axial level. Under general anaesthetic a transoral biopsy, curettage, and bone grafting of the atlas was carried out. The biopsy material comprised white membranous-type material, which had the histological features of hydatid cysts. A posterior spinal fusion with instrumentation was performed over posterior vertebral arches Cl to C3. Postoperatively ultrasound of the abdomen and radiograph of the chest did not reveal any further evidence of hydatid disease. Treatment with albendazole was commenced. The diagnosis was not anticipated preoperatively.


Full Access
P.J. Erasmus

During knee arthroplasty operations, it appeared that different patterns of patellar degeneration occur. To confirm this, 123 patellae were evaluated in a prospective study. The patellae of patients who had undergone patellar surgery or osteotomy were excluded.

The femur was divided into three condyles and nine areas, and the patella into three facets and nine areas. Areas of grade-III or more degeneration on the patella and femoral condyle were recorded. In 74 knees (60%), the patellar degeneration was less than grade III. In 49 (40 %), the patellar degeneration was grade III or more. In these 49 knees, there were 122 lesions in the nine areas of the femur and 77 lesions in the nine areas of the patella. These lesions were analysed to determine the most common areas of femoral and patellar degeneration. Further analysis was undertaken to determine whether there was any pattern of degeneration between the patellar and femoral lesions.

The medial femoral condyle, central and central-medial patella had the highest incidence of degeneration. These probably represent areas of greatest load-bearing in the knee. The areas with least degeneration were in the lateral femur and the superior patella, probably the lowest load-bearing areas. It was noted that any pattern of patellar degeneration could occur with any pattern of femoral degeneration. Lateral and central patellar facet degeneration is a well-recognised clinical and radiological condition. Medial patellar facet degeneration was a common finding. The medial facet is especially loaded in the flexed knee. A fixed flexion contractor, common in medial compartment osteoarthritis, may partially explain the high incidence of medial facet degeneration in these patients. Medial patellar facet degeneration is not a well-recognised condition and in the literature is generally considered secondary to lateral release. In this series, patients with lateral releases were excluded.

Standard patellar skyline views show only the unloaded medial facet. Medial patellar facet degeneration is probably more common than is clinically recognised, and may account for unexplained anterior knee pain, especially in the flexed knee. In this situation, pain will be aggravated by a lateral retinacular release.


P.J. Erasmus

At present bone scan is the only objective indicator of homeostasis in the bone and adjacent joint. This prospective study of 19 consecutive osteotomies in 17 patients was undertaken to see whether homeostasis is achieved around the knee after high tibial osteotomy for medial compartment osteoarthritis.

All cases underwent preoperative clinical, radiological and bone scan evaluation. Clinical evaluation included an SF12 score. Radiographs included standard anteroposterior, lateral, intercondylar and skyline patellar views, as well as standing views for measuring the mechanical axis and calculating the degree of correction. The three-phase technecium-99 m scan included blood-flow, blood pool uptake and delayed static imaging. As part of the surgical procedure an arthroscopic examination was performed and the degree of degeneration in all three compartments of the knee were noted. An excision wedge osteotomy was performed, aiming to achieve a 3° mechanical valgus alignment. Tension wire fixation allowed immediate mobilisation. One year postoperatively the clinical examination, standing radiographs and bone scans were repeated and the results statistically analysed.

One year postoperatively the mean SF12 score had improved from a preoperative 13.6 to 21.2 and the mean mechanical alignment from 6.3° of varus (3° to 12°) to 2° of valgus (0° to 4°). The significant decrease in isotope uptake in the medial compartment correlated with the clinical improvement and improved alignment. There was a significant reciprocal change from high uptake in the medial compartment preoperatively to high uptake in the lateral compartment one year postoperatively.

Medial compartment homeostasis was achieved one year after tibial osteotomy, but homeostasis was not achieved in the whole joint. Although correction was so conservative that it resulted in a mean of only 2° of mechanical valgus alignment, the area of increased uptake shifted from medial to lateral compartment. It is probable that the preoperative varus alignment led to reduced load-bearing and disuse osteoporosis in the lateral compartment, and that the increased uptake represents metabolic response to greater load. Possibly lateral compartment homeostasis will be restored over time.

This study shows that even a mild realignment improves homeostasis in the medial compartment. With the development of biological resurfacing, the importance of osteotomy may increase.


Full Access
E. Hohmann J. Agneskirchner A.B. Imhoff

Knee trauma often causes meniscal injuries. Only 15% of all tears can be repaired. Partial or complete meniscectomy subsequently leads to an increased incidence of chondral damage and onset of early osteoarthritis. In Europe in 1999, 355 000 meniscal injuries were treated, 284 000 of which required partial or complete meniscectomy

As an alternative to allograft, the collagen meniscus implant (CMI®) can be used for reconstruction. A collagen matrix moulded in the form of a meniscus, this is trimmed to defect size and sutured into place arthroscopically. It then serves as a scaffold for cellular invasion. Indications are tears that require partial meniscectomy or an intact remnant stable meniscus. Cruciate ligament injuries, malalignment, osteoarthritis and stage-IV osteochondral defects are the principal contraindications.

Between July 1998 and March 2000, 10 patients received a CMI in our department. Additional pathologies (four anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries, four varus malalignments and five chondral defects) were treated simultaneously. The Lysholm score increased from 70 to 99 in patients treated with an additional high tibial osteotomy (HTO), from 58 to 91 in the group with ACL reconstruction, from 71 to 93 in patients with osteochondral autologous transplantation (OATS). The Lysholm score of the combined group (two patients with HTO and OATS, two with HTO and ACL reconstruction) improved from a preoperative 69 to 99 postoperatively.

CMI, a biocompatible resorbable implant, induces cellular ingrowth and arthroscopic implantation. However, there are still questions to be answered. Few cases have been reported and no long-term studies have yet been published. It is not yet known whether osteochondral defects, unstable joints or malignment are limitations of using the implants.


J.B. Craig

A 20-year-old man, known to have systemic lupus erythematosus, presented with a year-long history of thoracolumbar backache. He made intermittent use of simple analgesics, and had received steroid therapy over five years from the age of 13. Clinical examination revealed a mild right thoracic rib hump. Plain radiographs and CT scan showed a thoracic aortic aneurysm with an estimated 50% loss of the left anterolateral part of vertebral bodies T7, T8 and T9.

The patient required resection of the aneurysm and replacement graft. An orthopaedic opinion was requested about the possible need for simultaneous spinal stabilisation surgery. The vertebral bone loss was considered similar to the bone loss seen in bullet injuries of the spine, and therefore unlikely to result in spinal instability. This proved to be the case in follow-up radiological examination at 16 months.


J.E. Viljoen

Tears of the posterior horn of the menisci often call for arthroscopic surgery to the medial or lateral compartments of the knee. In osteoarthritis knees, or when there is anterior cruciate ligament deficiency or joint tightness, using conventional anterolateral and anteromedial portals can be difficult. This is so also in very large adult knees. There is a risk of iatrogenic damage to the articular surfaces and structures of the knee.

The establishment of an accessory medial and/or lateral portal for instrumentation makes it easy and safe to perform arthroscopic surgery to the posterior medial and/or lateral compartments. The author used this technique in 103 patients in whom access to the posterior compartments was problematic.

The simple but effective technique is particularly useful for the inexperienced surgeon or arthroscopist in training.


FLEXOR HALLUCIS LONGUS Pages 89 - 89
Full Access
A.M. Mullins

The flexor hallucis longus (FHL) muscle is attached to the middle two thirds of the posterior fibula and interosseus membrane. Its long muscle and tendon lie adjacent to the distal tibia. The fibular attachment carries a blood supply of importance when the ipsilateral fibula is used to graft defects in the tibial shaft. Fracture of the lower tibia and fibula can lead to selective traumatic contracture of the FHL, which in turn may cause a flexion contracture of the big and adjacent two toes. The cross connection of the FHL to the medial aspect of the flexor digitorum longus (FDL) in the mid-sole may result in clawing of the second and third toes. Lengthening of the tendon behind the lower tibia resolves the contracture.

Surgery which shortens the first ray, such as first metatarsal osteotomy or Keller’s procedure, slackens the pull of the FHL on the big toe, transferring it to the FDL via the cross connection. This in turn results in elevation of the big toe and usually in clawing of the second and third toes. The lesser toes supplied by the FHL can be identified by the extension tenodesis test. Distal tenotomies of the long flexor tendons to the second and third toes usually resolve the clawing and restore flexion of the big toe.

The FHL tendon passes through a strong flexor sheath at the level of the talus and calcaneus. In this tunnel attrition of the posterior aspect of the FHL tendon can occur, particularly in such people as ballerinas, in whom working on point causes kinking of the tendon where it enters the mouth of the tunnel. Crepitus can be felt behind the fully plantarflexed ankle with active movement of the big toe. Surgical release of the flexor sheath and repair of the tendon may be performed.


P. Rossouw

The author describes a new soft tissue reconstruction of hallux valgus.

This method reduces the intermetatarsal angle as well as the sesamoid metatarsal relationship. The procedure can be used in conjunction with various metatarsal osteotomies.


J.F. de Beer K. van Rooyen R. Harvey D.F. du Toit C. Muller J. Matthysen

The supraspinatus tendon (SP) often ruptures. Gray established that the tendinous insertion always attaches to the highest facet of the greater tubercle of the humerus. Our osteological study of 124 shoulders in men and women between the ages of 35 and 94 years refocuses on the humeral insertion of the SP in relation to infraspinatus (IS) and teres minor (TM).

We found type-I SFs (cubic) in 53 shoulders (43%) and type-II SFs (rectangular or oblong) in 21 (17%). Type-III (ellipsoid) SFs were present in 20 shoulders (16%) and type-IV (angulated or sloping) in 11 (9%). SFs were type V (with tuberosity) in 12 shoulders (10%) and type VI (pitted) in three (2%). The facet area of the SP, IP and TM varied from 49 mm, 225 mm and 36mm2. Of the three muscles, the IS facet was consistently the largest (p < 0.05) and shaped rectangularly.

The SP inserted in a cubic or rectangular facet format in 75% of people. SP facet-size may relate to tendon strength, degeneration and rupture. This information may contribute to the understanding of tears of the rotator cuff.


P.F.R.G. de Muelenaere

A report published in 1999 showed that whether stainless steel or titanium screws were used in spinal surgery made little difference to outcome. However, the smaller number of titanium group patients, who had a shorter follow-up period, skewed statistical analysis in the study. The present study re-evaluates the incidence of complications, especially the pseudarthrosis rate, in a series of patients who underwent lumbosacral fusion with a segmental spinal correction system fixation device.

Of over 1 100 patients who underwent surgery between July 1993 and December 2000, 846 could be followed up adequately. Stainless steel devices were used in 410 and titanium implants in 436. There were roughly equal numbers of male and female patients, and occupation and smoking profiles were similar.

The incidence of pseudarthrosis was equal and the incidence of screw breakage was less than 1% in both groups.


S. Roberts J. Menage E.H. Evans J.P.G. Urban A.J. Day S.M. Eisenstein

The aim of this study was to identify potential inflammatory mediators in herniated and non-herniated intervertebral disc. It has been suggested that inflammation of the nerve root is a pre-requisite for disc herniations to be symptomatic. What leads to this inflammation is a matter of conjecture; one possible cause may be inflammatory mediators released from the herniated disc tissue itself. In this study we have examined discs from individuals with and without disc herniations to determine if there is a different degree of occurrence.

Twenty two discs from 21 patients with disc herniation were examined together with four discs from patients with other disc disorders and five age-matched discs from individuals obtained at autopsy. Samples were studied for the presence of blood vessels and inflammatory cytokines: IL-1α and β, IL-6, INOS, MCP1, TNFα, TSG-6 and thromboxane.

Of the herniated discs 10 were protrusions, six extrusions and six sequestrations. There was less of all the cytokines in the non-herniated discs than found in the herniated, with very little immunostaining for iNOS or IL-1α in any samples. Staining was seen in all herniated samples for IL-1β, but in fewer for IL-six and MCP1 (86%), thromboxane (68%), TNFα (64%) and TSG-6 (59%). The presence of cytokines was strongly associated with the presence of blood vessels. Protruded discs had less TNFα and thromboxane than sequestrated or extruded discs.

Cytokines appear to play an active role in the aetiopathogenesis of disc herniations. Some may be involved in the stimulation of degradative enzymes and hence resorption of, for example, sequestrations, whereas others may be responsible for an inflammatory response in the surrounding tissues such as nerve roots.


A.H. McGregor S.P.F. Hughes

There is a paucity of information regarding patient rated expectations of surgery and measures of satisfaction with surgery in terms of specific outcome measures such as pain. The aim of this study was to investigate patient expectations of surgery and short and long term satisfaction with the outcome of decompressive surgery in terms of pain, function, disability, general health.

Eighty-four patients undergoing spinal stenosis surgery were recruited into this study. On recruitment into the study patients were also asked to rate their expectations of improved in pain, general health, function etc. In addition at each review stage patients were asked to rate their satisfaction in improvement of these key outcome measures.

These demonstrated that patients had very high expectations of recovery particularly in terms of pain and function and that patients were confident of achieving this recovery (76.8%) confident of a good result. Levels of satisfaction however, varied considerably. 41% of subjects were 50% satisfied with the outcome, whilst 30% were dissatisfied. Most patients felt that they had made the right decision to have surgery although the surgery had only achieved 43.4% ± 37.8 of the outcome they had expected.

Examination of patient’s expectations of and satisfaction with surgery revealed that frequently patients had unrealistic expectations of their surgery and as a consequence tended to have lower levels of satisfaction.


N.E. Foster M. Underwood T. Pincus A. Breen G. Harding S. Vogel

The traditional biomedical model of managing musculoskeletal problems, such as low back pain (LBP), tends to be pathology driven, in which the aim is to locate an objectively identified disturbance. Appropriate treatment is conceptualised as a physical intervention that will compensate for or correct the identified disturbance. There is growing appreciation of the need to consider other factors, e.g. the meaning of the problem to the patient and professional, his/her experiences, cognitions, motivations and preferences. Improving the understanding about the beliefs and expectations of patients and health professionals is fundamental, since a better understanding of these factors, and any mismatch between professionals and patients, will facilitate improved management.

A multidisciplinary group of researchers (chiropractor, GP, osteopath, physiotherapist, psychologist, sociologist) have developed a collaborative research programme to investigate the decision-making processes in the care of patients with musculoskeletal pain. The programme uses mixed methods, including systematic reviews, survey research, focus groups and semi-structured interviews with patients and practitioners.

Three studies have already started: patient and health professional beliefs and expectations for the causes and treatment of chronic musculoskeletal pain. 1) Funded by the ARC, the purpose is to develop an understanding of the relationships between the different, professional and lay, theoretical frameworks used to diagnose and treat chronic musculoskeletal pain, and how these affect care. 2) Clinicians cognitions in apparently ineffective treatment of low back pain: funded by the ESRC, the purpose is to identify the reasons clinicians continue to treat LBP in the absence of improvement. Research on risk factors for the transition from acute to chronic LBP has concentrated on patient characteristics (psychological and social). It is possible that clinicians’ behaviour, advice and even treatment contribute to maintaining the problem indirectly. 3) Overcoming barriers to evidence-based practice (EBP) in LBP management in the physical therapy professions; funded by the Department of Physiotherapy Studies, Keele University, this study aims to explore the perceptions of physiotherapists, chiropractors and osteopaths, about the opportunities and threats of taking an EBP approach to LBP management and identify methods by which implementation of evidence can be facilitated.

This collaboration is the first of its kind and was developed through shared interests in the decision-making processes in the healthcare of people with musculoskeletal pain. We are keen to share the ideas and work in progress with the wider musculoskeletal pain research community.


P. Pollintine P. Dolan J. Tobias M.A. Adams

Osteoporotic fractures are associated with bone loss following hormonal changes and reduced physical activity in middle age. But these systemic changes do not explain why the anterior vertebral body should be such a common site of fracture. We hypothesise that age-related degenerative changes in the intervertebral discs can lead to abnormal load-bearing by the anterior vertebral body.

Cadaveric lumbar motion segments (mean age 50 ± 19 yrs, n = 33) were subjected to 2 kN of compressive loading while the distribution of compressive stress was measured along the antero-posterior diameter of the intervertebral disc, using a miniature pressure-transducer. “Stress profiles” were obtained with each motion segment positioned to simulate a) the erect standing posture, and b) a forward stooping posture. Stress measurements were effectively integrated over area in order to calculate the force acting on the anterior and posterior halves of the disc ( 1). These two forces were subtracted from the applied 2 kN to determine the compressive force resisted by the neural arch. Discs were sectioned and their degree of disc degeneration assessed visually on a scale of 1–4.

In motion segments with non-degenerated (grade 1) discs, less than 5% of the compressive force was resisted by the neural arch, and forces on the disc were distributed evenly in both postures. However, in the presence of severe disc degeneration, neural arch load-bearing increased to 40% in the erect posture, and the compressive force exerted by the disc on the vertebral body was concentrated anteriorly in flexion, and posteriorly in erect posture. In severely degenerated discs, the proportion of the 2 kN resisted by the anterior disc increased from 18% in the erect posture to 58% in the forward stooped posture.

Disc degeneration causes the disc to lose height, so that in erect postures, substantial compressive force is transferred to the neural arch. In addition, the disc loses its ability to distribute stress evenly on the vertebral body, so that the anterior vertebral body is heavily loaded in flexion. These two effects combine to ensure that the anterior vertebral body is stress-shielded in erect postures, and yet severely loaded in flexed postures. This could explain why anterior vertebral body fractures are so common in elderly people with degenerated discs, and why forward bending movements often precipitate the injury.


K. Stevenson E.M. Hay

The aim of this study was to examine GP’s and PT’s views of a physiotherapy led acute low back pain service

Acute back pain sufferers develop chronic symptoms but early management may prevent chronicity ( 1). The Stafford-shire Acute Back Pain Service (StABS) is physiotherapy led and provides early triage and management.

GPs and PT’s eligible to use the service were sent a self-completed questionnaire. Response rate was 45% for GP’s and 69% for PT. Seventy-two percent of GP’s and 88% of PT’s were satisfied with the service. The majority of GP’s had copies of agreed guidelines (81%) and most were adhering to guidance on bedrest by not prescribing it (67%). Both professions found difficulty with patient expectations, demands for x-rays and treatment compliance.

The majority of GP’s and PT’s were satisfied with a physiotherapy led back pain service. The difficulties experienced by both groups will form the basis of a training package for both professions .


M.T.N. Knight A. Goswami

This study evaluates the results of Endoscopic Foraminoplasty on 30 consecutive patients followed for a minimum of 2 years.

The objective has been to assess the efficacy of endoscopic aware state pain source definition combined with endoscopic decompression of the foramen, mobilisation and neurolysis of the exiting and transiting nerves and ablation of osteophytes in patients with spondylolytic spondylolisthesis.

This prospective study involved Endoscopic Foraminoplasty performed on 16 males, and 14 females with an average age of 46 years (36–72 years). They were followed for an average period of 34 months (28–41 months).

One-hundred percent cohort integrity was maintained at the final follow up. Results were analysed using the percentage change in Oswestry Disability Index, and percentage change in visual analogue pain (VAP) scores. Using a percentage change in Oswestry Disability Index of 50 or more to determine good and excellent outcomes, 75% (22 out of 30) exceed this value with five (17%) having 100% benefit for the procedure.

These results indicate that Endoscopic Laser Foraminoplasty provides a minimalist means of exploring the extra-foraminal zone, the listhetic defect, the foramen and its contents, and the epidural space and performing decompression, discectomy, osteophytectomy, perineural neurolysis in patients with spondylolytic-spondylolisthes. Done in an aware state, it serves to identify and localise the source of pain generation.


M.R. Underwood

There is some evidence to suggest that, spinal manipulation, and general exercise may help patients with back pain.

We are conducting a randomised controlled trial to compare usual care in general practice for low back pain patients with exercise classes, a package of treatment by a manipulator, manipulation followed by exercise and to compare manipulation’s effect in private and NHS facilities.

Participants were recruited from 167 general practices belonging to the Medical Research Council General Practice Research Framework in 15 sites across the UK with a total registered population of 1,140,000 patients. A total of 1,334 correctly randomised participants have been recruited. Mean age of participants is 43 years, 55% are female and Mean Roland Morris score 8. Follow up rates at one and three months are 83% and 78% respectively. Follow up finishes in May 2002

It is possible to recruit large numbers of back pain patients for trials of physical therapy in primary care.


P. Croft

The intention is not to attempt a review of outcome instruments, but to select a few themes at random for debate and discussion.

Outcome measures have taken on two meanings: desirable results of interventions and methods of distinguishing subgroups. It is important to separate the two.

Instruments and measures which classify back pain into subgroups need, in clinical or public health terms, to identify characteristics of individual or groups which,. measure impact or severity, estimate prognosis or help to select treatment or guide prevention.

Measures of outcome need to identify characteristics relevant to the objective of the particular study. Such measures may or may not be immediately relevant to the wellbeing of the individual or the group.

To illustrate these rather abstract points, I will use the examples of muscle volume, anxiety about injury, and lifting heavy weights, and consider the concepts of impairment, disability and handicap.

There are now many multiple-item questionnaires covering general health status and different dimensions of health, including the specific impact of back pain on everyday activity. Change over time in scores derived from these are often validated by comparing one with another or with a simple question to the patients as to whether they feel better or not. There needs to be more justification and clarity concerning the added value of these complex questionnaires, since the logical question at the moment is why not simply rely on the patient to tell us whether they are better or not?

Interesting attempts to fill this gap between the “objective instrument” and the patient’s global well-being include the concept of clinically important change and the idea of measuring change in an item rated by the individual patient as the most urgent or desirable to improve. Both in the end depend though on that simple question of whether the patient feels better or not.

The difficulty with patient-centred outcome measures is that many of them imply a very narrow model of change. There are other perspectives to be considered.

Society-centred measures of desirable outcome – less work loss, fewer welfare payments, less health care use. These need not be seen as negative: they imply better rehabilitation, improved facilities, effective prevention. In effect though they are outcome measures for social change rather than targets for the individual back pain sufferer.

Redefining expectations. A big challenge for outcome research is how to incorporate the idea, long a part of therapist technique, that a patient’s expectations can be redefined and targets set which are achievable but which do not necessarily coincide with items on a disability scale. A crude example is the idea that someone’s measurable disability may continue but they are able to work more happily and productively.

Outcome measurement at the moment does not take into account the pattern of back pain over time. Epidemiological studies confirm that back pain for the individual is often a recurrent, intermittent affair, with little evidence that treatment dramatically alters long-term experience. Yet short-term benefits will add up over time in a recurrent condition. Rather than being pessimistic about lack of long-term change in some of our current outcome measures we should aim to measure reduction in the density of pain over time and measure changes in the adaptation of back pain sufferers to society and of society to back pain suffering.


D.J. White C.G. Greenough

Due to the disproportionate prevalence of Lower Back Pain (LBP) amongst the socially excluded a Health Action Zone (HAZ) funded population based research project was implemented to evaluate LBP, using EMG spectral analysis, physical fitness and health status amongst this cohort. A large representative sample (n = 300) was required, however the study has been confounded in obtaining its’ prospective sample due to recruitment problems.

Initial recruitment techniques utilised health promotion roadshows held in prominent public locations throughout Teesside and a large-scale media campaign. The ‘roadshows’ promote a positive message relating to LBP and the importance of exercise. Each person receives the opportunity to obtain unique individual information relating to back muscle function from EMG testing as a motivator to participate. Secondary recruitment took the form of purposive sampling amongst selected professional groups (teachers, police, prison officers), testing taking place in the workplace but employing the same research “message”.

The project had been unsuccessful in i) recruiting the general public within the public domain and ii) specifically recruiting the socially excluded. Population based research, especially that which intends to target difficult to access populations may encounter difficulties in recruitment. Why? Distrust and suspicion towards positions of “authority”, low perceived importance of research to this cohort, simple apathy? These reasons are anecdotal and we would be very interested in any ideas and welcome any input on this frustrating issue.


M. Knight A. Goswami A. Hothersall

Perceived knowledge suggests that patients with Failed Back Surgery and a poor psychological profile would respond poorly to surgical interventions. This comparative study was designed to identify if there was a significant difference in the outcome following endoscopic spinal intervention in patients with Failed Back Surgery when compared to those who had no previous interventions.

Between April 1997 and November 1998, 54 patients with failed open back surgery and 85 without previous interventions were included in the study, underwent aware state pain source identification and endoscopic foraminal interventions. Pre- and post-operative assessment at 2 years was made using the Distress and Risk Assessment Method (DRAM), Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) and a Visual Analogue Pain Scale (VAPS). A Mann-Whitney U and Wilcoxon-Signed Rank tests were performed.

Patients with failed back surgery demonstrated greater psychological distress, disability (p < 0.05) and pain pre-operatively than those who underwent primary endoscopic interventions. Post-operatively both groups demonstrated significant improvement and no difference was found in the Zung, DRAM, ODI and VAPS scores.

With aware state pain source identification, targeted minimal intervention and discrete tissue ablation patients with failed back surgery with associated depression can demonstrate favourable physical and psychometric outcomes.


M. Knight A. Goswami A. Hothersall

Introduction of new surgical intervention need assessment of the true results by eliminating cognitive dissonance and the placebo effect. Significant time must elapse since the procedure to derive conclusions. With the initial gratifying results of Endoscopic Foraminoplasty a retrospective analysis of the data was performed to identify if the outcome was accurate and not a placebo effect.

Early postoperative Data (6 weeks and 6 months) derived from questionnaires on 91 patients with Endoscopic Foraminoplasty (April 1997 and November 1998), which included the Oswestry Disability Scale and a Visual Analogue Pain Scale was compared with the data at 2 years (late). A t-test was used to assess the difference between the Oswestry Disability scores from the two questionnaires and a Wilcoxon Signed Rank test for the Visual Analogue Pain Scale.

No significant difference between the Visual Analogue Pain Scores at 6 weeks to 6 months and 2 years post-operation was noted. There was however, a marginal improvement (p= 0.05) in Oswestry Index over two years period.

The initial outcome of Endoscopic Laser Foraminoplasty was sustained or improved at the end of two years and was not a placebo effect.


A. Hothersall M.T.N. Knight A. Goswami

The view that patients low back pain presenting with ‘abnormal’ psychometric and poor DRAM scores predict an unsatisfactory surgical outcome is considered controversial. This prospective study was designed to identify if DRAM Scores (Scores of Distress Risk Assessment Method) is a predictive determinant or a reactive instrument in regard to the outcome of Endoscopic Foraminoplasty.

One hundred and eighty-five patients (86 males and 99 females) underwent an Endoscopic Laser Foraminoplasty between April 1997 and November 1998. Pre- and postoperative assessment at 2 years was made using the Oswestry Disability Scale, and the Visual Analogue Pain Scale and the DRAM scores. Patients were categorised by their pre-op DRAM score. A Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance and a regression analysis were performed.

There was significant improvement in disability and pain scores at two years. (p< 0.05). A significant difference in median DRAM between the preoperative and postoperative score at two years was noted. While the DRAM score predicted the patients’ disability and pain it failed to predict the change in outcome.

The DRAM score highlights individuals in distress who may need psychological support and physical treatment for optimum benefit from endoscopic spinal intervention and not be used to deny a surgical intervention.


I.T. Russell

There is limited evidence for the effects of ordering and length on responses to questionnaires used in the health field. Multiple outcome measures used in back pain studies have implications for respondent burden and response quality. This randomised study assessed the effect of questionnaire ordering and length on missing data and internal reliability for two health outcome measures.

Back pain patients were recruited from 26 UK practices in the UK BEAM feasibility study. Patients were randomised to receive a 27 page self-completed questionnaire with the Roland Disability Questionnaire (RDQ) at the front and SF-36 at the back of the questionnaire, or vice versa.

The mean number of missing items for the SF-36 was 0.07 (sd=0.68) and 0.56 (sd=2.73) at the front and back of the questionnaire; this difference was statistically significant (p< 0.05) for the general health perception scale. The internal consistency (Cronbach’s Alpha) of the RDQ was unaffected by questionnaire positioning; but was generally higher when the SF-36 (mean difference = 0.03) was at the start of the questionnaire and statistically significant for the vitality scale (p< 0.01).

The positioning of instruments affects patients’ responses. Researchers should consider the influence of questionnaire design. Primary measures should be positioned at the front of questionnaires.