Unstable chest wall injuries have high rates of mortality and morbidity. These injuries can lead to respiratory dysfunction, and are associated with high rates of pneumonia, sepsis, prolonged ICU stays, and increased health care costs. Numerous studies have demonstrated improved outcomes with surgical fixation compared to non-operative treatment. However, an adequately powered multi-centre randomized controlled study using modern fixation techniques has been lacking.

We present a multi-centred, prospective, randomized controlled trial comparing surgical fixation of acute, unstable chest wall injuries with the current standard of non-operative management. Patients aged 16–85 with a flail chest (3 or more consecutive, segmental, displaced rib fractures), or severe deformity of the chest wall, were recruited from multiple trauma centers across North America. Exclusion criteria included: severe pulmonary contusion, severe head trauma, randomization>72 hours from injury, inability to perform surgical fixation within 96 hours from injury (in those randomized to surgery), fractures of the floating ribs, or fractures adjacent to the spine not amendable to surgical fixation. Patients were seen in follow-up for one year. The primary outcome was days free from mechanical ventilation in the first 28 days following injury. Secondary outcomes were days in ICU, rates of pneumonia, sepsis, need for tracheostomy, mortality, general health outcomes, pulmonary function testing, and other complications of treatment. A sample size of 206 was required to detect a difference of 2 ventilator-free days between the two groups, using a 2-tailed alpha error of 0.05 and a power of 0.80.

A total of 207 patients were recruited from 15 sites across Canada and USA, from 2011–2018. Ninety-nine patients were randomized to non-operative treatment, and 108 were randomized to surgical fixation. Overall, the mean age was 53 years, and 75% of patients were male, with 25% females. The commonest mechanisms of injury were: motor vehicle collisions (34%), falls (20%), motorcycle collisions (14%), and pedestrian injuries (11%). The mean injury severity score (ISS) at admission was 26, and patients had a mean of 10 rib fractures. Eighty-nine percent of patients had pneumothorax, 76% had haemothorax, and 54% had pulmonary contusion. There were no differences between the two groups in terms of demographics. The final results will be available and presented at the COA meeting in Halifax.

This is the largest randomized controlled trial to date, comparing surgical fixation to non-operative treatment of unstable chest wall and flail chest injuries. The results of this study will shed light on the best treatment options for patients with such injuries, help understand outcomes, and guide treatment. The final results will be available and presented at the COA meeting in Halifax.

Proximal humerus fractures are a common fragility fracture in older adults. A variety of treatment options exist, yet longer term outcomes of newer surgical treatments have not been extensively researched. Additionally, intermediate term outcomes following both surgical and non-surgical initial treatment of these injuries have not been evaluated at a population level. The purpose of this study was to utilise administrative data from Ontario, Canada to evaluate intermediate term outcomes following initial treatment of proximal humerus fractures.

We used data from the Canadian Institute for Health Information to identify all patients aged 50 and older who presented to an ambulatory care facility with a “main diagnosis” of proximal humerus fracture from April 1, 2004 to March 31, 2013. Intervention codes from the Discharge Abstract Database were used to categorise patients into fixation, replacement, reduction or non-surgically treated groups. We used intervention codes to identify instances of complication-related operations following initial treatment (including fixation, replacement, hardware removal, rotator cuff repair and irrigation and debridement [I&D]) at one year post initial treatment.

The majority of patients (28,369, 86.6%, 95% confidence interval [95% CI] 86.2–87.0%) were initially treated non-surgically, while 2835 (8.7%, 95% CI 8.4–9.0%) underwent initial fixation, 1280 (3.9%, 95% CI 3.7–4.1%) received primary joint replacement, and 276 (0.8%, 95% CI 0.8–1.0%) were initially treated with a reduction procedure. In the year following the initial treatment period, 127 (0.4%, 95%CI 0.4–0.5%) non-surgically treated patients underwent a replacement surgery, 292 (1.0%, 95%CI 0.9–1.2%) underwent fixation, and 12 (0.04%, 95% CI 0.02–0.07%) underwent a reduction procedure. Of the 2835 patients who received initial fixation, 57 (2.0%, 95% CI 1.6–2.6%) returned for a shoulder replacement, 80 received secondary fixation (2.8%, 95% CI 2.3–3.5%), 57 (2.0%, 95%CI 1.6–2.6%) underwent rotator cuff repair, 300 (10.6%, 95% CI 9.5–11.8%) had their implants removed, and 16 (0.6%, 95% CI 0.4–0.9%) returned for I&D. Of the 1280 patients who underwent initial replacement surgeries, 30 (2.3%, 95% CI 1.7–3.3%) returned for a secondary replacement, nine (0.7%, 95% CI 0.4–1.3%) underwent rotator cuff repair, and seven (0.6%, 95% CI 0.3–1.1%) had their implant removed. In the group who received initial reduction, eight (2.9%, 95% CI 1.5–5.6%) underwent a fixation procedure, six (2.2%, 95% CI 1.0–4.7%) received replacement surgeries, and five (1.8%, 95% CI 0.8–4.2%) each received rotator cuff repair and I&D in the year following initial treatment.

The majority of proximal humerus fractures in patients 50 and older in Ontario, Canada are treated non-surgically. Complication-related operations in the year following initial non-operative treatment are relatively low. The most commonly observed procedure following initial fixation surgery is hardware removal.

Proximal femur fractures are increasing in prevalence, with femoral neck (FN) and intertrochanteric (IT) fractures representing the majority of these injuries. The salvage procedure for failed open reduction internal fixation (ORIF) is often a conversion to total hip arthroplasty (THA). The use of THA for failed ORIF improves pain and function, however the procedure is more challenging. The aim of this study was to investigate the clinical and radiographic outcomes in patients who have undergone THA after ORIF.

This retrospective case-control study compared patients who underwent THA after failed ORIF to a matched cohort undergoing primary THA for non-traumatic osteoarthritis. From 2004 to 2014, 40 patients were identified. The matched cohort was matched for date of operation, age, gender, and type of implant. Preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative data were collected and statistical analysis was performed.

The cohort of patients with a salvage THA included 18 male and 22 female patients with a mean age of 73 years and mean follow up of 3.1 years. Those with failed fixation included 12 IT fractures and 28 FN fractures. The mean time between ORIF and THA was 2.1 years for IT fractures and 8.5 years for FN fractures (p=0.03). The failed fixation group had longer procedures, greater drop in hemoglobin, and greater blood transfusion rate (p<0.05). There was one revision and one dislocation in the failed fixation group with no revisions or dislocations in the primary THA group. Length of admission, medical complications, and functional outcome as assessed with a standardised hip score and were found not to be statistically different between the groups.

Salvage THA for failed initial fixation of proximal femur fractures yields comparable clinical results to primary THA with an increased operative time, blood loss, and blood transfusion rate.

Introduction:

One method of femoral head preservation following avascular necrosis (AVN) is core decompression and Tantalum Rod insertion. There is, however, a published failure rate of up to 32% at 4 years. The purpose of the present study was to document the clinical and radiological outcome following Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) subsequent to failed Tantalum Rod insertion.

Introduction: Surgical fixation of intra-articular distal femoral fractures has been associated with nonunion & varus collapse. The soft tissuestripping associated with this fracture andthe surgical exposure have been factors associated with delayed union & infection. The limited soft tissue exposure has been lauded the as a solution to this fracture. However, it has occurred with the new fixation as well.(Locked Plate)

Aims: This study is an attempt to look at the fixation. Does the LISS system improve the results of this difficult fracture? Is there truly a difference in the outcome of this fracture utilizing the Locked plate system or is the percieved difference due to the surgical mini invasive approach.

Patients & Methods: One hunderd & forty patients were screened, only 53 were randomized and fixed in six academic centers over 5 years. All C3 fractures were excluded as they were felt not to be treatable by the DCS device, but they were treated appropiately. 35 females and 18 males were included in the study and randomized appropiatley.

Results: Fifty-three patients were randomized, 28 had the LISS implant and 25 had the DCS utilized. There were 3 nonunions in the LISS group plus two patients with early loss of reduction that required reoperation in the early post operative period. One patient developed arthrofibrosis requiring arthroscopic release and subsequently the implant failed necessitating refixation. In the DCS group, only one nonunion reported & required second surgery. This translated to a reoperation rate of 21% in the LISS group compared to 4% with DCS.

Conclusion: This prospective randomized multicentre trial showed a difference when comparing the LISS to the DCS in the supracondylar distal femur fractures.

Purpose: To conduct a study to identify differences in complication rates and outcomes between previously recognized sub-groups commonly treated for limb length discrepancies (LLD).

Method: Forty-two males and 13 females were treated for LLD at two level-one trauma centres. Mean LLD was 4.4 cm (range 1.8 to 18cm). There were 44 femoral segments (in 41 patients) and 14 tibia segments lengthened. Forty were post-traumatic, and 18 congenital/ developmental. Objective data regarding complications, length achieved, and lengthening duration was collected from patient records. Two groups were compared for differences: Developmental (congenital and developmental etiology combined; LLD occurred prior to skeletal maturity and treatment involved creating new length) versus post-traumatic (restoration of previously existing length), and tibia versus femoral lengthening.

Results: A mean of 4.4 cm of length was achieved over a mean duration of 83 days, for a mean lengthening index of 18.9 days/cm. Superficial pin tract infections were the most common complication, occurring in 33 segments (56%). Deep infection occurred in six segments (10%). Three of these six had a history of open fracture, and a fourth had a history of infection during initial fracture management. All were successfully treated with irrigation and debridement, and exchange nailing. The developmental group had significantly greater incidence of flexion contracture (13% versus 78%, p< 0.001), and surgical correction for a contracture deformity (5% versus 61%, p< 0.001). The post-traumatic group had a significantly higher rate of painful hardware requiring removal following successful treatment of their LLD (45% versus 16%, p=0.04). Tibia segments had a significantly greater lengthening index (29 d/cm versus 18 d/cm, p=0.03).

Conclusion: Limb lengthening is an involved process with potential for serious complications. Patients who had limb-lengthening for congenital/ developmental discrepancies had a higher rate of adjacent joint contrac-ture and subsequent requirement for surgical release. Patients with post-traumatic lengthening had a higher rate of hardware removal, and the lengthening index was greater for tibiae than femora. Deep infection remains a significant concern. This study provides information for physicians and patients on the rate and type of complications that can be expected both overall, and within specific LLD treatment groups.

Purpose: In a prospective randomized clinical trial, we have previously reported the “limb-specific” results comparing operative (plate fixation) versus non-operative (sling) treatment for completely displaced fractures of the shaft of the clavicle. We also sought to determine the effect that a fracture of the shaft of the clavicle had on general health status, as measured by the SF-36 General Health Status instrument. We then evaluated the effects of different treatment methods (operative versus non-operative), on general health scores.

Materials: We performed a multi-center, randomized clinical trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of completely displaced clavicular shaft fractures in 111 patients. In addition to radiographic, surgeon-based, and limb-specific data we prospectively gathered SF-36 questionnaires at baseline, and at 6 weeks and 3, 6, 12, and 24 months post-injury.

Results: Both groups had SF-36 scores equivalent to or slightly superior to population norms at baseline. A clavicular shaft fracture had a significant negative effect on SF-36 scores (especially the physical components) in both groups at 6 weeks (p< 0.01) and 3 months (p> < 0.01). There was a statistically greater decrease in Physical Component Scores (PCS) in the non-operative group compared to the operative group (P> < 0.05). At 6 months, scores had returned to pre-operative levels in the operative group, but remained significantly decreased in the non-operative group (p=0.04). This difference persisted at the one and two year points.

Conclusions: A displaced fracture of the clavicular shaft has a clinically significant negative effect on general health status scores. This effect can be mitigated by primary operative fixation, which restores scores to normal levels by six months post-injury. Patients treated non-operatively for a displaced fracture of the shaft of the clavicle demonstrated lower PCS scores at two years post-injury.

The purpose of this study was to evaluate functional outcome following supracondylar femur fractures using patient-based outcome measures.

Patients having sustained supracondylar femur fractures between 1990 and 2004 were identified from the fracture databases of two level-one trauma centres. Three patient-based outcome measures, the Short Form-36 (SF-36) Version two, the Short Musculoskeletal Functional Scale (SMFA), and the Lower Extremity Functional Scale (LEFS) were used to evaluate functional outcome. Each patient’s medical record was also reviewed to obtain information regarding potential predictors of outcome, including age, gender, fracture type (AO classification), presence of comorbidities, smoking status, open vs. closed fracture, and occurrence of complications. Univariate and multivariate models were then used to identify significant predictors of outcome, as reflected in the SMFA bother and dysfunction scores.

Sixty-one patients (thirty-five males and twenty-six females) with an average age (at time of injury) of 53 ± 18 years consented to participate. The average length of follow-up was 64 ± 34 months from the time of injury. Mean SF-36 V2 scores were lower than Canadian population norms indicating decreased function or greater pain, while mean SMFA scores were higher than published population norms indicating greater impairment and bother. The mean LEFS score was 40.78 ± 15.90 out of a maximum score of eighty. At the univariate level, the presence of complications was a significant predictor of both the SMFA bother (p=0.002) and dysfunction scores (p=0.015), while positive smoking status was a significant predictor of the bother score (p=0.002). Based on a multivariate linear regression model, the presence of complications (p=0.013) and positive smoking status (p=0.011) were both significant predictors of a higher SMFA bother score. In the multivariate model for SMFA dysfunction score, the presence of complications (p=0.014) and the presence of comorbidities (p=0.017) were significant predictors of a higher score.

Comparing SF-36 and SMFA scores with published population norms, supracondylar femur fractures were associated with residual impact. Based on our analysis, smoking, the presence of medical comorbidities at the time of fracture, and the occurrence of complications following fracture repair were the main predictors of poorer patient outcomes following supracondylar femur fracture.

Bone transport/limb lengthening with circular external fixation has been associated with a prolonged period of time in the frame and a significant major complication rate following frame removal. We examined the results of bone transport in fifty-one limbs using the “monorail” technique and found a dramatically improved lengthening index (24.5 days/cm. – time in frame /cm. of length gained) and an absence of refracture or angulatory deformity following fixator removal. This technique is our treatment of choice for limb lengthening/bone transport.

We sought to determine patient oriented outcome and complication rates following b one transport using an external fixator placed over an intramedullary nail (the “monorail” technique).

Bone transport using the monorail technique is associated with a dramatically improved lengthening index and a lower major complication rate than traditional ring fixator methods. Patient satisfaction with the procedure was high.

Our study confirms the significant advantages of the monorail technique for bone transport/limb lengthening. The time in the fixator is dramatically reduced, and complications associated with earlier techniques such as angulatory deformity or refracture were not seen.

We identified forty-nine patients (fifty-one limbs) who had undergone bone transport using the monorail technique (external fixator placed over an intramedullary nail). There were thirty-five men and fourteen women with a mean age of thirty-five years (range 17–50). Pre-operative diagnoses included post traumatic length discrepancy/bone defect (forty-one), congenital short stature (six) and other (four). All patients had a unilateral fixator placed over an implanted intramedullary nail. Once length correction was achieved, the fixator was removed and the nail “locked”. The mean amount of lengthening was 5.5 cm. (range 2 – 18 cm.). The lengthening index was 24.5 days /cm. (duration of external fixation/cm. bone length gained), with a range from ten to fifty days /cm. There were nineteen complications (thirty-seven percent): nine premature consolidations, four infected pin sites, two hardware failures, two osteomyelitis, one DVT, one nonunion. There were no refractures, angulatory deformities or cases of intramedullary sepsis.

When deciding on treatment for displaced mid-shaft clavicle fractures, patients often inquire if repair of (potential) nonunion results in outcome similar to acute fixation. We used objective muscle strength testing and patient-oriented outcome measures to examine this question. Late reconstruction of nonunion following displaced mid-shaft fractures of the clavicle results in restoration of objective muscle strength similar to that seen with immediate fixation. However, there was a significant loss in muscle endurance as well as a trend towards a decrease in outcome scores (DASH, Constant) following late reconstruction. This information is useful in surgical decision making and in counseling patients.

Using objectively measured strength and patient-oriented health-status instruments, we sought to determine if delay in repair of displaced, mid-shaft clavicle fractures negatively affected shoulder strength or outcome.

Late reconstruction of clavicle nonunion results in restoration of objective muscle strength similar to that seen with immediate fracture fixation, but there was a significant loss in muscle endurance as well as a trend towards a decrease in outcome scores (DASH, Constant).

All patients had sustained completely displaced, closed, isolated mid-shaft clavicle fractures. Fifteen patients had immediate plate fixation (mean 0.6 months post-fracture) and fifteen had plate fixation for non-union (mean fifty-eight months post-fracture). Objective muscle strength testing on the BTE was done a mean of twenty-nine months post-fixation (normal contralateral limb as control). There were no significant differences between acute fixation and delayed reconstruction groups with regards to strength of shoulder flexion (acute = 92.4%, delayed = 89.4%, p=0.56), shoulder abduction (acute = 98.8%, delayed = 96.7, p=0.75), external rotation (acute = 98.4%, delayed = 91.9%, p=0.29), or internal rotation (acute = 96.3%, delayed = 97.4%, p=0.87). However, there was a trend for improved Constant scores (acute = 94.5, delayed = 90, p=0.09) and the DASH scores (acute = 3.4, delayed = 9.0, p=0.09) in the acute fixation group. We found a significant decrease in muscle endurance with regards to shoulder flexion (acute = 107.0%, delayed = 71.1%, p=0.007) and a trend towards weaker shoulder abduction (acute = 103.1%, delayed = 88.7 %).

Funding: Mr. Potter was supported by a St. Michael’s Hospital Summer Student Scholarship

Using patient-oriented outcome measures, we examined twenty-six patients following surgical repair of clavicular nonunion. Patient satisfaction was high, and there was only a minor degree of residual disability (mean DASH score 14.5, SF-36 scores within normal range). Time from injury to surgical repair did not influence results.

Using modern, patient-oriented limb-specific outcome measures, we sought to determine the effect of time to repair on patient satisfaction following surgical fixation of nonunion of the clavicular shaft.

As measured by the DASH and SF-36, patient satisfaction was high following clavicular nonunion repair with only minor degrees of residual disability. Time to repair did not have a significant effect on outcome.

Previous reports of clavicular nonunion repair have concentrated on radiographic or surgeon-based criteria. Our study shows that successful clavicular nonunion repair effectively restores upper extremity function and general health status to near-normal levels.

We identified twenty-six patients who had undergone open reduction, internal fixation of a nonunion of the clavicular shaft. There were sixteen men and ten women, with a mean age of forty-four years (range thirty to seventy-one years). The mean duration of nonunion was 1.9 years with a range from four months to thirty-one years. All patients underwent fixation with a plate, and 73% of patients also underwent iliac crest bone grafting. Two nonunions required revision surgery for healing: twenty-four healed after the index procedure. We assessed patient outcome using standard history and physical, radiographs, and the DASH and SF-36 outcome instruments. The mean DASH score (0 = perfect, 100 = complete disability, “normal” = 10) was 14.5 (range 0 to 58), indicating good restoration of upper extremity function with mild residual disability. SF-36 scores were within the normal range. There was no significant difference in DASH or SF-36 scores between those fixed “early” (< six months) and those repaired “late” (> six months), p=0.30, p=0.78, respectively.

Using patient-oriented outcome measures, we examined twenty-six patients following surgical repair of clavicular nonunion. Patient satisfaction was high, and there was only a minor degree of residual disability (mean DASH score 14.5, SF-36 scores within normal range). Time from injury to surgical repair did not influence results.

We evaluated the clinical, radiographic, and functional outcome of uncemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) following vascularized fibular grafting for avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head. A group of twenty-two patients who had been converted from a vascularized fibular graft to THA was compared to a similar group of twenty-two patients who had received a THA with no prior graft. The graft group was found to have worse outcomes than the control group as measured by SF-36, and WOMAC scores, as well as a hip score.

These results show that vascularized fibular grafting complicates future THA.

The Purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical, radiographic, and functional outcome of uncemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) following vascularized fibular grafting for avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head. These results indicate that functional and clinical outcome following post-graft THA is worse than outcome following THA performed as a primary intervention.

Judicious use of the vascularized fibular graft procedure is critical in order to minimize the number of graft failures and avoid the negative outcomes associated with THA after failed vascularized fibular grafting.

Twenty-six hips in twenty-two patients who had a THA following a failed vascularized fibular graft were compared to a group of twenty-three hips in twenty-two age and sex-matched patients who had received a THA with no prior graft (combined mean age: 39.0 yrs). Primary outcome measures included the SF-36 (patient-based general health assessment – total score and physical sub-component) and WOMAC (patient-based arthritis specific score) scores at matched follow up times (mean: 6.2years, range: two to fourteen years). An objective hip score was also used, as were several radiographic variables. The post-graft group had lower SF-36 final scores (p< 0.006), lower SF-36: physical function scores (p< 0.001), and lower WOMAC scores (p< 0.045) than the control group. Post-graft THA was complicated by longer operative time (p< 0.025) and greater subsidence of the femoral prosthesis (p< 0.004) compared to controls. Additionally, the post-graft group had worse hip score values (p< 0.05) than controls.

Vascularized fibular grafting is a commonly used procedure to cure or delay progression of AVN in the hip. Currently this procedure is used for young (< 40 years) patients with hip AVN who are in an early, pre-collapse stage of the disease. Although the efficacy of vascularized fibular grafting has been proven, up to 29% of grafts fail at five years and need to be converted to THA (Urbaniak et al., 1995). This study shows that THA after failed vascularized fibular grafting has a worse outcome than THA as a primary intervention. Therefore judicious use of the graft procedure is critical in order to minimize the number of graft failures and avoid the negative outcomes associated with it.

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine how the “ideal” tibial nail insertion point varies with tibial rotation and to determine what radiographic landmarks can be used to identify the most suitable rotational view for insertion of a tibial intramedullary nail.

Methods: Twelve cadaveric lower limb specimens with intact soft tissues around the knee and ankle joints were used. A 2.0mm Kirschner wire was placed in the center of the anatomic safe zone and centered on the tibial shaft. The leg was rotated and imaged using a fluoroscopic C-arm until the K-wire was positioned just medial to the lateral tibial spine (defined as the neutral anteroposterior radiograph). The leg was then fixed and radiographs were taken in 5 degree increments by rotating the fluoroscope internally and externally (in total, a 50 degree arc). Following this a second K-wire was placed in 5 mm increments both medially and laterally and the fluoroscope rotated until this second K-wire was positioned just medial to the lateral tibial spine. Radiographs were digitized for measurements.

Results: Given the presence of a 30 degree rotational arc through which the radiograph appeared anteroposterior, it was possible to improperly translate the start point up to 15 mm. Relative external rotation of the image used for nail placement led to a medial insertion site when using the lateral tibial spine as the landmark. A line drawn at the lateral edge of the tibial plateau to bisect the fibula head correlated with an entry point that was central or up to 5 mm lateral to the ideal entry point. The use of a fibula head bisector line avoided a medial insertion point.

Conclusions: Rotation of the tibia may result in up to 15 mm of translation of the start point that may be unrecognized. Relative external rotation of the film used for nail placement leads to medial insertion sites when using the lateral tibial spine as a landmark. The fibula head bisector line can be used to avoid choosing external rotation views and thus avoid medial insertion points.

The purpose of this study was to investigate the use of early post-operative bone scintigraphy to predict surgical outcome following vascularized fibular grafting (VFG) for osteonecrosis of the hip. Bone scans from one hundred and four hips (Steinberg stage I–IV) treated with VFG between 1994 and 2000 were retrospectively reviewed. Bone scan scores were significantly lower in the failed group (n=31) compared to the successful group (n=73), p=0.03. Logistic regression demonstrated that a higher bone scan score was associated with success, p=0.028, with an odds ratio of 3.08 (1.13–8.40).

The purpose of this study was to investigate the use of bone scintigraphy to predict surgical outcome following vascularized fibular grafting (VFG) for osteonecrosis of the hip.

Subjects with a higher bone scan score post-operatively had a three-fold higher chance of success than subjects with the lowest score.

These results suggest that having a well perfused and viable graft in the early post-operative period improves the chances of a successful result.

Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography images from one hundred and four hips (Steinberg I–IV) treated with VFG between 1994 and 2000 were retrospectively reviewed. Each scan was divided into three regions, the greater trochanter, neck, and head. The intensity at the graft in each region (axially and coronally) was compared to the intensity at the ipsilateral proximal femoral diaph-ysis and assigned a score: less than diaphysis (one), equal to (two), and greater than (three). Cumulative scores were obtained for each subject. Intraobserver variability was 0.93. Surgical failure was defined as conversion to or on the waiting list for total hip arthroplasty.

Thirty percent of hips failed treatment (n=31, mean survival 34.9 months, range 5–98), while 70% were successful (n=73, mean follow-up 56.6 months, range 22–100). Bone scan scores were significantly lower in the failed group (mean 7.1, range 6–12) compared to the successful group (mean 8.5, range 6–18), p=0.03. Positive skewness (+1.7) was demonstrated as 64% of hips had a score of six while 36% had a score > 6 (range 8–18). Logistic regression demonstrated that a bone scan score > 6 was associated with success, p=0.028, with an odds ratio of 3.08 (1.13–8.40).

The purpose of this study was to investigate patient-based functional outcome and objectively measure strength following plate fixation of fractures of both bones of the forearm. Twenty-five subjects were clinically and radiographically reviewed. Strength of elbow flexion, extension, supination, pronation, wrist flex-ion, extension and grip were significantly reduced in the injured arm. (p< 0.01, range 62%–84% of normal). Mean (+/− SE) DASH score was 19.5 +/− 4.0 and eighty-eight percent (22/25) scored good to excellent on the Gartland-Werley scale (mean 4.04 +/− 0.91). No statistical difference in mean maximal radial bow (MRB) or location of MRB between injured and non-injured arm was found.

The purpose of this study was to investigate functional outcome and objectively measure strength following plate fixation of fractures of both bones of the forearm (BBOF).

Anatomic reduction was associated with good to excellent functional outcome. However strength of the elbow, forearm, wrist and grip were significantly reduced in the injured arm.

Despite good to excellent functional outcome following this injury, significant reduction in strength of the upper extremity should be expected, and thus is an area for potential improvement in post-operative care.

Twenty-five subjects (M/F 19/6, mean age 47.6 (range 20–71)) treated with plate fixation for fractures of BBOF were clinically and radiographically reviewed. Mean duration of follow-up was 5.7 years (range 2–13.4 y). Post-operative protocol included short-term immobilization followed by active-assisted ROM and strengthening starting between four and six weeks. Isometric muscle strength was objectively measured with the Baltimore Therapeutic Equipment work simulator (model WS-20). Strength of elbow flexion (72% of non-injured arm, p< 0.0001), elbow extension (84%, p=0.0004), forearm supination (75%, p=0.005), forearm pronation (69%, p< 0.0001), wrist flexion (81%, p=0.009), wrist extension (62%, p< 0.0001) and grip (70%, p< 0.0001) were all significantly reduced in the injured arm. Mean (+/− SE) DASH and Gartland-Werley scores were 19.5 +/− 4.0 (range 0–61) and 4.04 +/− 0.91 (range 0–15) respectively. Eighty-eight percent (22/25) scored good to excellent on the Gartland-Werley scale. No statistical difference in mean maximal radial bow (MRB) between injured and non-injured arm was found (mean +/− SE, 1.42 +/− 0.07 vs 1.58 +/− 0.05 respectively) or in location of MRB (61% vs 59%).

Fracture of the femoral head usually results from high-energy trauma, particularly motor vehicle accidents. These fractures are often associated with poor functional outcomes. SF-36 and MFA scores were obtained for twenty-five femoral head fractures. The mean SF-36 scores was 57.2 (22.6 to 82) and the mean MFA score was 37.6 (10–72). As expected the scores were negatively correlated (−0.587, p=0.005). The presence of an ipsilateral posterior acetabluar wall fracture negatively affected functional outcome. Fragment excision was associated with a higher functional outcome when compared to internal fixation. Posterior surgical approach resulted in higher scores than patients who underwent an anterior procedure.

Fracture of the femoral head is a rare but severe injury. The purpose of this study is to determine the functional outcome of and prognostic factors associated with femoral head fractures.

Acetabular wall fracture, surgical approach, and method of surgical treatment are prognostic factors of functional outcome as measured by the SF-36 and the MFA.

There is currently no consensus on the management of femoral head fractures and treatment practices have evolved on the basis of a limited series of studies. Functional outcome following femoral head fracture has been evaluated using Epstein’s criteria in several studies, however, only one study has been conducted using a validated outcome measure.

Twenty-five femoral head fractures in twenty-four patients were identified from the trauma and orthopaedic databases of two major trauma centres. The patient with bilateral femoral head fractures was not included in the analysis. After obtaining informed consent, the patients’ medical records were reviewed. Functional outcome was assessed using two validated, patient-based outcome measures, the Short Form (SF)-36 and the Musculoskeletal Functional Assessment instrument (MFA). The average age of the patients was 36.8 (std. dev. 11.1) and the mean length of follow-up was 41.4 months (minimum twelve months). Three factors were identified using non-parametric analysis that significantly affected the functional outcome scores:

The presence of an ipsilateral posterior acetabluar wall fracture negatively affected functional outcome (p=0.08).

5207 patients treated for a calcaneous fracture in Ontario between 1993–1999 were identified from population datasets and were reviewed to evaluate regional practice variation and complication rates for operatively and non-operatively managed calcaneous fractures. There was considerable geographic variation in treatment. Individuals in some parts of Ontario were almost eight times more likely to receive operative treatment than others. The majority of calcaneous fractures in Ontario are treated non-operatively, however the large observed practice variation suggests that there is disagreement among treating clinicians. Primary subtalar fusion has a high risk of post-operative infection and should therefore be considered very cautiously.

The purpose of this study was to evaluate regional practice variation and complication rates for operatively and non-operatively managed calcaneous fractures.

The majority of calcaneous fractures in Ontario are treated non-operatively, however the large observed practice variation suggests that there is disagreement among treating clinicians. Primary subtalar fusion has a high risk of post-operative infection and should therefore be considered very cautiously.

Given the observed regional variation in management of calcaneous fractures more work needs to be done to address this issue.

5207 fractures of the calcaneous in Ontario between 1993–1999were identified from population datasets. Regional variations in treatment and complication rates were computed. Multiple linear regression was used to identify factors associated with complications.

There was considerable geographic variation in treatment. Individuals in some parts of Ontario were almost eight times more likely to receive operative treatment than others. General surgeons or general practitioners definitively treated 30% of patients (almost all closed). Overall rate of complications was low, however there was a 13.4 percent infection rate following immediate subtalar fusion. Infection was 5.3% following ORIF and 0.6% following closed treatment. Infection risk was increased in multiple trauma patients and those with open fractures. Subsequent subtalar fusion rates (within the study period) were higher in multiple trauma patients, but were not associated with treatment (open or closed). Amputation was 22.5 times more likely following open calcaneous fractures but the overall amputation rate was only 0.17%. No relationship between surgeon experience and the rate of complications following operative treatment was identified.

This study investigated the effect presence, method, and timing of fixation of femoral shaft fractures have on the morbidity and mortality of patients with pulmonary contusion.

In the multiply-injured patient with femoral shaft fractures, early (< 24 hours) fracture stabilization with closed, reamed, statically-locked intramedullary nailing has been shown to decrease morbidity and mortality. Controversy exists as to whether such treatment compromises the outcome in patients that have significant co-existing pulmonary injury. This study is the first to specifically investigate the sub-group of patients that have pulmonary contusion.

A retrospective review of patients presenting to a Level One trauma center from 1990 to 2002 with pulmonary contusion identified three hundred and twenty-two cases. Patient characteristics of age, sex, GCS, ISS, AIS, presence of femoral shaft fracture, method and timing of treatment of femoral shaft fracture, and presence of other pulmonary injuries were recorded, as were the outcomes of pulmonary complications (acute lung injury (ALI), ARDS, fat embolism syndrome, pulmonary embolism, and pneumonia), days on ventilatory support, days in the intensive care unit and ward, and death.

There were no significant differences in the patient characteristics between groups with and without femoral shaft fracture. Except for an increased likelihood of the femoral shaft fracture group having ALI (RR 1.11), there were no significant differences in outcomes between the femur fracture/non-femur fracture groups. As well, there were no significant differences in outcomes between the groups that had fracture fixation before or after twenty-four hours or had the fracture fixed with or without intramedullary nailing.

The presence, method, and timing of treatment of femoral shaft fractures do not increase the morbidity or mortality of trauma patients that have pulmonary contusion.

In five teaching hospitals, seventy-two patients with seventy-three bicondylar tibial plateau fractures were prospectively randomized by envelope to treatment either by AO methods (group A) or ring fixator methods (group B). Outcome measures included clinical and radiographic parameters, & HSS knee scores.

Results: Re-intervention was necessary within six months in ten group A & seven Group B patients. Forty-three procedures were performed (thirty-three Group A-ten Group B) I& D 12- 3: STSG 3-0: Quadricepsplasty 1-0; Manipulation 2–4; Muscle flap 2–0; Above knee amputation 1–0; Revision ORIF 5–1; Revision Rings 0–1; Bone graft 2–1; Bead pouch 3-0; Synovectomy 1-0; Sequestrectomy 1-0.

More patients had more septic and wound complications resulting in more need for re-intervention following ORIF.

Conclusion. For bi-condylar tibial plateau fractures (OTA 41.C) six-month HSS scores are significantly higher after treatment with Ring Fixator methods. Reintervention rates for deep sepsis/wound problems are higher with AO methods. Wound and infection complications occurring after AO treatment are more severe and require multiple procedures for control.

We have conducted a prospective randomized trial to determine the outcomes of treatment by

Open reduction and internal fixation or

We report our early findings on re-intervention rates for complications.

In five teaching hospitals, seventy-two patients with seventy-three bi-condylar tibial plateau fractures were prospectively randomized by envelope to treatment either by AO methods (group A) or ring fixator methods (group B). Outcome measures included clinical and radiographic parameters, & HSS knee scores. Randomization gave the following demographics

Re-intervention was necessary within six months in ten group A & seven Group B patients. Forty-three procedures were performed (thirty-three Group A-ten Group B) I& D 12- 3: STSG 3-0: Quadricepsplasty 1-0; Manipulation 2-4; Muscle flap 2-0; Above knee amputation 1-0; Revision ORIF 5-1; Revision Rings 0-1; Bone graft 2-1; Bead pouch 3-0; Synovectomy 1-0; Sequestrectomy 1-0.

More patients had more septic and wound complications resulting in more need for re-intervention following ORIF.

For bi-condylar tibial plateau fractures (OTA 41.C) six-month HSS scores are significantly higher after treatment with Ring Fixator methods. Reintervention rates for deep sepsis/wound problems are higher with AO methods. Wound and infection complications occurring after AO treatment are more severe and require multiple procedures for control.

Please contact author for pictures and/or diagrams.