Abstract

Abstract

Abstract

There is a lack of evidence as to the best way to deliver rehabilitation following TKA. Previous work has suggested that postoperative physiotherapy applied to all patients is not effective at improving one-year post-surgical outcomes. The aim of this study was to target physiotherapy to those at risk of poor outcome following TKA, and to determine if a therapist-led intervention offered superior results compared to a home-exercise based protocol in this ‘at risk’ group.

The Targeted Rehabilitation to Improve Outcomes (TRIO) study was a prospective randomised controlled trial run at 15-centres in the UK. Patients were identified as ‘potential poor outcome’ based on an Oxford Knee Score (OKS) classification at 6-weeks post-surgery and randomised to either therapist-led or home-exercise based protocols. Patients were reviewed by a physiotherapist and commenced 18-exercise sessions over 6-weeks. The therapist-led group undertook a progressive functional protocol (modified weekly in 1-1 contact sessions) in contrast to the static home-exercise based regime. Evaluation took place following rehabilitation intervention, then at 6-months and 1-year post-surgery. Primary outcome was comparative group OKS at 1-year. Secondary outcomes included, ‘worst’ and ‘average’ pain scores, OXS and EQ-5D, and satisfaction questionnaire. Health economic (cost-utility) analysis was undertaken from NHS perspective up to 1-year post-surgery. Incremental cost per Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) were calculated from intervention costs, patient reported primary and secondary care usage, and EQ-5D data.

4264 patients were screened, 1296 were eligible, 334 patients were randomised, 8 were lost to follow-up, therapy compliance was >85%. Clinically meaningful improvement in OKS (between baseline and 1-year) was seen in both arms (p < 0 .001). Between group difference in 1-year OKS was 1.91 (95%CI, −0.17–3.99) points favouring the therapist-led arm (p=0.07). Incorporating all time point data, between group difference in OKS was 2.25 points (95%CI, 0.61–3.90, p=0.008). Small, non-significant reductions (< 5 %) in both worst and average pain scores were observed favouring the therapist-led group. Enhanced satisfaction with pain relief (OR 1.65, p < 0 .02), ability to perform daily functional tasks (OR 1.66, p < 0 .02), and perform heavy functional tasks (OR 1.6, p=0.04) was reported in the therapist-led group. There was a small non-significant difference of 0.02 points (95%CI −0.02–0.06) between groups in EQ-5D, resulting in a £12,125 cost per QALY of delivering the therapist led intervention with a 57% chance of being cost-effective at the standard UK policy threshold of £20,000 per QALY.

TRIO is the largest randomised trial of physiotherapy following TKA, and the first to target rehabilitation to patients at risk of poor outcomes. Both therapist-led and home-exercise based rehabilitation groups made clinically meaningful improvements in outcome by 1-year. We observed a modest difference in OKS in favour of therapist-led rehabilitation compared to the home-exercises which was not statistically significant. The relatively tight confidence intervals suggests that any difference which might exist is too small to be clinically relevant. Patient satisfaction with outcome was however higher in those that received greater physiotherapist contact. While cost per QALY estimates were below UK policy threshold, this result is uncertain and insufficient to make accept-decline recommendations.

Aims

To assess how the cost-effectiveness of total hip arthroplasty (THA) and total knee arthroplasty (TKA) varies with age, sex, and preoperative Oxford Hip or Knee Score (OHS/OKS); and to identify the patient groups for whom THA/TKA is cost-effective.

Background

This article reviews four commonly used approaches to assess patient responsiveness to a treatment or therapy [Return To Normal (RTN), Minimal Important Difference (MID), Minimal Clinically Important Difference (MCID), OMERACT-OARSI (OO)], and demonstrates how each of the methods can be formulated in a multi-level modelling (MLM) framework.

Introduction

Knee arthroplasty is an effective intervention for painful arthritis when conservative measures have failed. Despite recent advances in component design and implantation techniques, a significant proportion of patients experience problems relating to the patella-femoral joint (PFJ).

Detailed knowledge of the shape and orientation of the normal and replaced femoral trochlea groove is critical when considering potential causes of anterior knee pain. Furthermore, to date it has proved difficult to establish a diagnosis due to shortcomings in current imaging techniques for obtaining satisfactory coronal plane motion data of the patella in the replaced knee.

The aim of this study was to correlate the trochlea shape of normal and replaced knees with corresponding coronal plane PFJ kinematic data.

The Swansea Morriston Achilles Rupture Treatment (SMART) programme was introduced in 2008. This paper summarises the outcome of this programme. Patients with a rupture of the Achilles tendon treated in our unit follow a comprehensive management protocol that includes a dedicated Achilles clinic, ultrasound examination, the use of functional orthoses, early weight-bearing, an accelerated exercise regime and guidelines for return to work and sport. The choice of conservative or surgical treatment was based on ultrasound findings.

The rate of re-rupture, the outcome using the Achilles Tendon Total Rupture Score (ATRS) and the Achilles Tendon Repair Score, (AS), and the complications were recorded. An elementary cost analysis was also performed.

Between 2008 and 2014 a total of 273 patients presented with an acute rupture 211 of whom were managed conservatively and 62 had surgical repair. There were three re-ruptures (1.1%). There were 215 men and 58 women with a mean age of 46.5 years (20 to 86). Functional outcome was satisfactory. Mean ATRS and AS at four months was 53.0 (sd 14), 64.9 (sd 15) (n = 135), six months 67.8 (sd 16), 73.8 (sd 15) (n = 103) and nine months (72.4; sd 14) 72.3 (sd 13) (n = 43). The programme realised estimated cost savings exceeding £91 000 per annum.

The SMART programme resulted in a low rate of re-rupture, a satisfactory outcome, a reduced rate of surgical intervention and a reduction in healthcare costs.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2015; 97-B:510–15.

Introduction:

Historically the incidence of Achilles re-ruptures has been described as around 5% after surgical repair and up to 21% after conservative management. In 2008 we commenced a dedicated Achilles tendon rupture clinic for both conservative and surgically managed patients using new standardised operating procedures (SOP). We have evaluated the impact of this new service, particularly with regard to re-rupture rate.

Previous attempts to measure coronal plane patellofemoral kinematics following knee replacement have suffered from methodological drawbacks; the patella being obscured by the components, metal artefact and technical inaccuracies. The aim of this study was to assess whether there was any significant difference in the patellofemoral kinematics between normal, TKR and PFJR patients using the validated MAUS™ technique (combining motion analysis with ultrasound).

60 patients were recruited into three groups; normal healthy volunteers (Normal), TKR, and PFJR patients. The MAUS technique incorporates a 12 camera analysis system (providing gross alignment data for tibial and femoral segments) and an ultrasound probe (providing coordinates of bony landmarks on patella femur and tibia) during a squat exercise. 6 DOF kinematics were described between 0 and 90° flexion. The validated accuracy of the MAUS technique registering the ultrasound images within the motion capture system is 1.84 mm (2 × SD).

Movements of the Normal group were significantly different from the TKR group (p=0.03) and the PFJR group (p<0.01), whilst there was no significant difference between the TKR and PFJR groups (p=0.27).

Our data suggest that many aspects of patellofemoral kinematics are absent following TKR and PFJR, which could be addressed in future designs of knee TKR and PFJR.

Objectives

This study examines variations in knee arthroplasty patient reported outcome measures according to patient age.

Introduction

Chronic mid body Achilles tendinopathy is a common problem. There is no consensus on treatment. The aim of this review was to assess the effectiveness of physiotherapy interventions (non surgical and non pharmacological) for this condition.

Introduction

There is uncertainty about the relationship between improvement in range of motion (ROM) and functional outcome or patient satisfaction after total hip arthroplasty (THA). Using data from a prospective multi-centre study we investigated this relationship.

We examined data from a large prospectively collected dataset which followed up patients after Exeter total hip replacement (THR) - the Exeter Primary Outcome Study. We studied 78 patients who had total hip replacement for osteoarthritis on a morphologically normal hip, and in whom the other hip was also morphologically normal for comparison. All selected patients had complete patient outcome data at 1 and 5 years, and x-rays at 1 year were available.

We measured accuracy of reconstruction on AP Pelvis radiographs. The parameters measured were difference in height of lesser trochanter from horizontal pelvic line (LLD); length from ASIS to greater trochanter (indicating abductor length, AL); length from symphysis to centre of femoral head (SFH); length from centre of head to axis of femur (offset). We examined clinical outcomes including gain of Oxford Hip Score (DOHS) at 1 and 5 years, absolute OHS at 1 and 5 years, and absolute SF-36 Physical Functioning and Role Physical scores at 1 and 5 years.

Examining the ratios of AL, SFH, Offset, Offset to SFH ratio and LLD between side of THR and unaffected side all showed marked variation. Thus the ratio of SFH varied from 0.85 to 1.11. For further analysis we divided the patients into 3 groups on the basis of variability of the ratio from 1; we examined whether the clinical scores above varied between these 3 groups. 1 way ANOVA demonstrated no significant difference for any of the clinical outcomes for any of the 5 grouped x-ray variables.

Accuracy of reconstruction has been shown to affect the risk of dislocation after THR. Our results indicate that clinical outcomes of total hip replacement appear resilient to some degree of surgical inaccuracy. Future trials of navigation should be designed to demonstrate not only improved accuracy but also improved clinical outcome.

Background

Despite interest, the current rate of day-case anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) in the UK remains low. Although specialised care pathways with standard operating procedures (SOPs) have been effective in reducing length of stay following some surgical procedures, this has not been previously reported for ACLR. We evaluate the effectiveness of SOPs for establishing day-case ACLR in a specialist unit.

Aims

Interest in soft tissue Radiostereometric Analysis (RSA) is rising. Previous authors have tried, with varying levels of success, to use this technique to analyse the intra-substance portion of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) graft constructs. These methods were either prone to large amounts of marker migration, deemed unsuitable for in-vivo use or, where alternative markers such as stainless steel sutures were used, lost the inherent accuracy that made RSA an attractive tool in the first place. We describe a modification of tantalum marker balls that allows for a new method of secure fixation to soft tissue in order to accurately analyse stretch, displacement and, potentially, dynamic movement using RSA.

Introduction

Osteoarthritis (OA) of the hip is an important cause of pain and morbidity. The mechanisms and pathogenesis of OA'sdevelopment remain unknown. Minor acetabular dysplasia and subtle variations in proximal femoral morphology are increasingly being recognized as factors that potentially compromise the joint biomechanically and lead to OA. Previous studies have shown that risk of hip OA increased as the femoral head to femoral neck ratio (HNR) decreased. Previous work has described the evolutionary change in inferior femoral neck trabecular density and geometry associated with upright stance, but no study has highlighted the evolutionary change in HNR. The aim of this study was to examine evolutionary evidence that the hominin bipedal stance has lead to alterations in HNR that would predispose humans to hip OA.

Introduction

Malalignment of some designs of stem is associated with an increased risk of aseptic loosening and revision. We investigated whether the alignment of the cemented polished, double-taper design adversely affected outcome, in a multicentre prospective study.

Introduction

The options for the treatment of the young active patient with unicompartmental symptomatic osteoarthritis and pre-existing Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) deficiency are limited. Patients with ACL deficiency and end-stage medial compartment osteoarthritis are usually young and active. The Oxford Unicompartmental Knee Replacement (UKA) is a well established treatment option in the management of symptomatic end-stage medial compartmental osteoarthritis, but a functionally intact ACL is a pre-requisite for its satisfactory outcome. If absent, high failure rates have been reported, primarily due to tibial loosening. Previously, we have reported results on a consecutive series of 15 such patients in whom the ACL was reconstructed and patients underwent a staged or simultaneous UKA. The aim of the current study is to provide an update on the clinical and radiological outcomes of a large, consecutive cohort of patients with ACL reconstruction and UKA for the treatment of end-stage medial compartment osteoarthritis and to evaluate, particularly, the outcome of those patients under 50.

Introduction

Acetabular cup lucency predicts cup survival. The relationship of subchondral plate removal and cup survival is unclear. Using data from a prospective study conducted between January 1999 and January 2002 we investigated the role of subchondral plate removal in cemented acetabular cup survival at five years.

INTRODUCTION

The introduction of hard-on-hard bearings and the consequences of increased wear due to edge-loading have renewed interest in the importance of acetabular component orientation for implant survival and functional outcome following hip arthroplasty. Some studies have shown increased dislocation risk when the cup is mal-oriented which has led to the identification of a safe-zone1. The aims of this prospective, multi-centered study of primary total hip arthroplasty (THA) were to: 1. Identify factors that influence cup orientation and 2. Describe the effect of cup orientation on clinical outcome.

A femoral head/neck ratio (HNR) of less than 1.27 is associated with an increased risk of arthritis. The aim of this study was to establish whether there is evolutionary evidence that the homonin, bipedal stance has led to alterations in HNR that predispose humans to osteoarthritis (OA).

Specimens provided by The Natural History Museums of London, Oxford and the Department of Zoology, University of Oxford were grouped according to gait pattern, HAKF (Hip and knee flexed), Arboreal (ability to stand with hip and knee joints extended) and homonin/bi-pedal. Specimens included those from Devonion, Triassic, Jurrasic, Cretaceous, Miocene, Paleolithic, Pleistocene periods to modern day. Three-dimensional skeletal geometries were segmented using CT images and HNR measurements were taken from coronal views. These were compared with the HNR of 119 asymptomatic human volunteers and 210 patients that had a hip joint replacement for primary OA.

Species of the HAKF group had the smallest HNR (1.10, SD:0.09). Species of the Arboreal group had significantly higher HNR (1.63, SD:0.15) in comparison to the Bipedal group (1.41, SD:0.04) (p=0.006), Human (1.33, SD:0.08) and the OA group (1.3, SD:0.09).

The range of movement associated with arboreal habitat caused an associated change in HNR. This study would suggest that the HNR peaked in the Miocene period with species that ambulated on both ground and trees. More recent homonin gait appears to have developed a smaller HNR and humans have the smallest amongst their close ancestors. Evolutionary theory would suggest that modern environmental pressures might pre-dispose future hominin evolution to OA, secondary to a further reduction in HNR.

INTRODUCTION

Establishing a full-thickness cartilage in the lateral compartment and functionally intact ACL is vital before proceeding with unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR). The aim of this study is to assess whether MRI is a useful adjunct in predicting suitability for UKR, as compared to standard and stress radiographs.

Purpose

Late stage medial unicompartmental osteoarthritic disease of the knee can be treated by either Total Knee Replacement (TKR) or Unicompartmental Replacement (UKR). As a precursor to the TOPKAT study this work tested the postulate that individual surgeons show high variation in the choice of treatment for individual patients.

Purpose

To examine the clinical characteristics of patients undergoing knee arthroplasty with a pre-operative Oxford Knee Score >34 (‘good’/‘excellent’), and assess the appropriateness of surgical intervention for this group.

Purpose

The Oxford Knee Score (OKS) is a validated and widely used PROM that has been successfully used in assessing the outcome of knee arthroplasty (KA). It has been adopted as the nationally agreed outcome measure for this procedure and is now routinely collected. Increasingly, it is being used on an individual patient basis as a pre-operative measure of osteoarthritis and the need for joint replacement, despite not being validated for this use. The aim of this paper is to present evidence that challenges this new role for the OKS.

Purpose

The purpose was to determine if the use of cold irrigation fluid in routine knee arthroscopy leads to a reduction in post operative pain.

Introduction

Anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee (anteromedial gonarthrosis-AMG) is a common form of knee arthritis. In a clinical setting, knee arthritis has always been assessed by plain radiography in conjunction with pain and function assessments. Whilst this is useful for surgical decision making in bone on bone arthritis, plain radiography gives no insight to the earlier stages of disease. In a recent study 82% of patients with painful arthritis had only partial thickness joint space loss on plain radiography. These patients are managed with various surgical treatments; injection, arthroscopy, osteotomy and arthroplasty with varying results. We believe these varying results are in part due to these patients being at different stages of disease, which will respond differently to different treatments. However radiography cannot delineate these stages. We describe the Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) findings of this partial thickness AMG as a way of understanding these earlier stages of the disease.

Introduction

Preoperative psychological distress has been reported to predict poor outcome and patient dissatisfaction after total hip replacement (THR). We investigated this relationship in a prospective multi-centre study between January 1999 and January 2002.

Introduction

Anteromedial gonarthrosis is a common well described pattern of knee osteoarthritis with cartilage wear beginning in the anteromedial quadrant of the medial tibial plateau in the presence of an intact and functioning ACL. It is well known that mechanical factors such as limb alignment and meniscal integrity affect the progression of arthritis and there is some evidence that the morphology of the tibial plateau may be a risk factor in the development of this disease. The extension facet angle is the angle of the downslope of the anterior portion of the medial tibial plateau joint surface in relation to the middle portion on a sagittal view. If this is an important factor in the development of AMG there may be potential for disease modifying intervention.

This study investigates if there is a significant difference in this angle as measured on MRI between a study cohort with early AMG (partial thickness cartilage damage and intact ACL) and a comparator control cohort of patients (no cartilage damage and ACL rupture).

The heat produced by drills, saws and PMMA cement in the handling of bone can cause thermal necrosis. Thermal necrosis could be a factor in the formation of a fibrous tissue membrane and impaired bony ingrowth into porous prostheses. This has been proposed to lead to non-union of osteotomies and fractures, the failure of the bone-cement interface and the failure of resurfacing arthroplasty.

We compared three proprietary blades (the De Soutter, the Stryker Dual Cut and the Stryker Precision) in an in-vitro setting with porcine tibiae, using thermocouples embedded in the bone below the cutting surface to measure the increases in bone temperature.

There was a significant (p=0.001) difference in the change in temperature (δT) between the blade types. The mean increase in temperature was highest for the De Soutter, 2.84°C (SD: 1.83°C, range 0.48°C to 9.30°C); mean δT was 1.81°C (SD: 1.00°C, range 0.18°C to 4.85°C) for the Precision and 1.68°C (SD: 0.95°C, range 0.24°C to 5.67°C). Performing paired tests, there was no significant difference in δT between the Precision and Dual Cut blades (p=0.340), but both these blades had significantly (p=0.003 for Precision vs De Soutter, p<0.001 for Dual Cut vs De Soutter) lower values for δT than the Dual Cut.

Introduction

Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) accounts for 84% of all knee replacement surgery in the UK (NJR 2009) despite published epidemiological data showing that single compartment disease is most prevalent. We investigated this incompatibility further by describing the compartmental pattern and stage of cartilage loss of all patients with osteoarthritis (OA) presenting to a specialist knee clinic over one year.

Introduction

The results of the mobile bearing Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) in the lateral compartment have been disappointing with a five year survival of 82%. Therefore, it is recommended that mobile bearings should not be used for lateral UKR. This low survivorship is primarily due to high dislocation rate, all occurring in the first year. A detailed analysis of the causes of bearing dislocation confirmed the elevated lateral tibial joint line to be a contributory factor. A new surgical technique was therefore introduced in which care was taken neither to remove too much bone from distal femur nor to over tighten the knee and thus ensure that the tibial joint line was not elevated. Other modifications to the technique were also introduced including use of a domed tibial component.

We obtained information from the Elective Orthopaedic Centre on 1523 patients with baseline and six-month Oxford hip scores (OHS) after undergoing primary hip replacement (THR) and 1784 patients with Oxford knee scores (OKS) for primary knee replacement (TKR) who completed a six-month satisfaction questionnaire.

Receiver operating characteristic curves identified an absolute change in OHS of 14 points or more as the point that discriminates best between patients’ satisfaction levels and an 11-point change for the OKS. Satisfaction is highest (97.6%) in patients with an absolute change in OHS of 14 points or more, compared with lower levels of satisfaction (81.8%) below this threshold. Similarly, an 11-point absolute change in OKS was associated with 95.4% satisfaction compared with 76.5% below this threshold. For the six-month OHS a score of 35 points or more distinguished patients with the highest satisfaction level, and for the six-month OKS 30 points or more identified the highest level of satisfaction. The thresholds varied according to patients’ pre-operative score, where those with severe pre-operative pain/function required a lower six-month score to achieve the highest levels of satisfaction.

Our data suggest that the choice of a six-month follow-up to assess patient-reported outcomes of THR/TKR is acceptable. The thresholds help to differentiate between patients with different levels of satisfaction, but external validation will be required prior to general implementation in clinical practice.

Purpose of Study

To assess the incidence of radiolucency in cemented and cementless Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement at two years.

This study aims to investigate femoral blood flow during Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing (MMHR) by monitoring oxygen concentration during the operative procedure.

Patients undergoing MMHR using the posterior approach were evaluated. Following division of fascia lata, a calibrated gas-measuring electrode was inserted into the femoral neck, aiming for the supero-lateral quadrant of the head. Baseline oxygen concentration levels were detected after electrode insertion 2-3cm below the femoral head surface and all intra-operative measures were referenced against these. Oxygen levels were continuously monitored throughout the operation. Data from ten patients are presented.

Oxygen concentration dropped most noticeably during the surgical approach and was reduced by 62% (Std.dev +/-26%) following dislocation and capsulectomy. Insertion of implants resulted in a further oxygenation decrease by 18% (Std.dev +/-28%). The last obtained measure before wound closure detected 22% (Std.dev +/-31%) of initial baseline oxygen levels. Variation between subjects was observed and three patients demonstrated a limited recovery of oxygen levels during implant insertion and hip relocation.

Intra-operative measurement of oxygen concentration in blood perfusing the femoral head is feasible. Results in ten patients undergoing MMHR showed a dramatic effect on the oxygenation in the femoral head during surgical approach and implant fixation. This may increase the risk of avascular necrosis and subsequent femoral neck fracture. Future experiments will determine if less invasive procedures or specific positioning of the limb can protect the blood supply to femoral neck and head.

We obtained pre-operative and six-month post-operative Oxford hip (OHS) and knee scores (OKS) for 1523 patients who underwent total hip replacement and 1784 patients who underwent total knee replacement. They all also completed a six-month satisfaction question.

Scatter plots showed no relationship between pre-operative Oxford scores and six-month satisfaction scores. Spearman’s rank correlation coefficients were -0.04 (95% confidence interval (CI) -0.09 to 0.01) between OHS and satisfaction and 0.04 (95% CI -0.01 to 0.08) between OKS and satisfaction. A receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was used to identify a cut-off point for the pre-operative OHS/OKS that identifies whether or not a patient is satisfied with surgery. We obtained an area under the ROC curve of 0.51 (95% CI 0.45 to 0.56) for hip replacement and 0.56 (95% CI 0.51 to 0.60) for knee replacement, indicating that pre-operative Oxford scores have no predictive accuracy in distinguishing satisfied from dissatisfied patients.

In the NHS widespread attempts are being made to use patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) data for the purpose of prioritising patients for surgery. Oxford hip and knee scores have no predictive accuracy in relation to post-operative patient satisfaction. This evidence does not support their current use in prioritising access to care.

Introduction: Pseudotumours (soft-tissue masses relating to the hip joint) following metal-on-metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty (MoMHRA) have been associated with elevated serum and hip aspirate metal ion levels, suggesting that pseudotumours occur when there is increased wear. This study aimed to quantify in vivo wear of implants revised for pseudotumours and a control group of implants revised for other reasons of failure.

Methods: A total of 30 contemporary MoMHRA implants in two groups were investigated in this Institutional Review Board approved study:

8 MoMHRA implants revised due to pseudotumour;

The linear wear of retrieved implants was measured using a Taylor-Hobson Roundness machine. The average linear wear rate was defined as the maximum linear wear depth divided by the duration of the implant in vivo.

Results: In comparison with the non-pseudotumour implant group, the pseudotumour implant group was associated with:

significantly higher median linear wear rate of the femoral component: 8.1um/year (range 2.75–25.4um/year) vs. 1.79um/year (range 0.82–4.15um/year), p=0.002; and

Similarly, differences were also measured in absolute wear values. The median absolute linear wear was significantly higher in the pseudotumour implant group:

21.05um (range 2.74–164.80um) vs. 4.44um (range 1.50–8.80um) for the femoral component, p=0.005; and

Wear on the acetabular cup components in the pseudotumour group always involved the edge, indicating edge-loading of the bearing. In contrast, edge-loading was observed in only one acetabular component in the non-pseudotumour group of implants. The deepest wear was observed well within the bearing surface for the rest of the non-pseudotumour group. The difference in the incidence of edge-loading between the two groups was statistically significant (Fisher’s exact test, p=0.03).

Discussion: Significantly greater linear wear rates of the MoMHRA implants revised due to pseudotumour support the in vivo elevated metal ion concentrations in patients with pseudotumours. This study provides the first direct evidence to confirm that pseudotumour is associated with increased wear at the MoM articulation. Furthermore, edge-loading with the loss of fluid film lubrication may be the dominant wear generation mechanism in patients with pseudotumour.

Introduction: Anteromedial gonarthrosis is a common well described pattern of knee osteoarthritis with cartilage wear beginning in the anteromedial quadrant of the medial tibial plateau in the presence of an intact and functioning ACL. It is well known that mechanical factors such as limb alignment and meniscal integrity affect the progression of arthritis and there is some evidence that the morphology of the tibial plateau may be a risk factor in the development of this disease. The extension facet angle is the angle of the downslope of the anterior portion of the medial tibial plateau joint surface in relation to the middle portion on a sagittal view. If this is an important factor in the development of AMG there may be potential for disease modifying intervention.

This study investigates if there is a significant difference in this angle as measured on MRI between a study cohort with early AMG (partial thickness cartilage damage and intact ACL) and a comparator control cohort of patients (no cartilage damage and ACL rupture).

Methods: 3 Tesla MRI scans of 99 patients; 54 with partial thickness cartilage damage and 44 comparitors with no cartilage damage (acute ACL rupture) were assessed. The extension facet angle was measured (Osirix v3.6) using a validated technique on two consecutive MRI T2 sagittal slices orientated at the mid-coronal point of the medial femoral condyle. (InterClass Correlation 0.95, IntraClass Correlation 0.97, within subject variation of 1.1° and coefficiant of variation 10.7%). The mean of the two extension angle values was used. The results were tabulated and analysed (R v2.9.1).

Results: Of the 99 knees, 38 were female and 61 male; 44 left knees and 55 right. The mean extension facet angle for the partial thickness group was 12.7° (SD 3.35) and for the comparator group 8.7° (SD 3.09). There was a significant difference between these 2 groups (Mann Whitney U, p< 0.001). Although there were significantly more men than women in the comparator group, stratification analysis showed that there was no effect of gender on the mean extension facet angle.

Discussion: There is a significance difference in the extension facet angle between patients with AMG with only partial thickness cartilage loss and a comparator group. This has not been shown in a study group of this size before. Since none of the subjects had full thickness cartilage loss it is unlikely that this difference is due to bone attrition changing the angle as part of the disease process but this is an important area for further study. We believe that a higher medial tibial extension facet angle alters the mechanics within the medial compartment, placing these patients at higher risk of developing AMG. This may present an opportunity for risk factor modification, for example osteotomy.

The results of mobile bearing Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) in the lateral compartment have been disappointing (five-year survival: 82%). Therefore, it is recommended that mobile bearings should not be used for lateral UKR. This low survivorship is primarily due to a high dislocation rate. A detailed analysis confirmed the elevated lateral tibial joint line to be a contributory factor to bearing dislocation. A new surgical technique was therefore introduced in which care was taken neither to remove too much bone from the distal femur nor to over tighten the knee and therefore ensure that the tibial joint line was not elevated. Other modifications included use of a domed tibial component.

The aim of this study is to compare the outcome of these iterations: the original series (series I), those with improved surgical technique (series II) and the domed tibial component (series III). The primary outcome measure was bearing dislocation at one year. One year was chosen as all the dislocations in the first series occurred within a year. In the original series (n=53), implanted using a standard open approach, there were six dislocations in the first year, the average flexion 110°, and 95% had no/mild pain on activity. In the second series (n=65), there were 3 dislocations, the average flexion was 117°, and 80% had no/mild pain on activity.

In the third series with the modified technique and a convex domed tibial plateau, there was one dislocation, average flexion was 125° and 94% had no/mild pain on activity. At four years the cumulative primary dislocation rates were 10%, 5% and 0% respectively, and were significantly different (p=0.04).

The improved surgical technique and implant design has reduced dislocation rate to an acceptable level so a mobile bearing can now be recommended for lateral UKR.

Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis (RSA) can predict long-term outcome of prostheses by measuring migration over time. The Exeter femoral stem is a double-tapered highly polished implant and has been shown to subside within the cement mantle in 2 year RSA studies. It has a proven track record in terms of long-term survivorship and low revision rates. Several studies have demonstrated excellent clinical outcomes following its implantation but this is the first study to assess stem migration at 10 years, using RSA.

This is a single-centre study involving 20 patients (mean age: 63 years, SD=7) undergoing primary total hip replacement for degenerative osteoarthritis using the lateral (Hardinge) approach. RSA radiographs were taken with the patient bearing full weight post-operatively, at 3, 6, 12 months and at 2, 5 and 10 years follow-up. The three-dimensional migration of the Exeter femoral stem was determined.

The mean Oxford Hip Score at 10 years was 43.4 (SD=4.6) and there were no revisions. The stems subsided and rotated internally during a 10-year period. The mean migrations of the head and tip of the femoral stem in all three anatomic directions (antero-posterior, medio-lateral & supero-distal) were 0.69 mm posterior, 0.04 mm lateral and 1.67 mm distal for the head and 0.20 mm anterior, 0.02 mm lateral and 1.23 mm distal for the tip. The total migration at 10 years was 1.81 mm for the head and 1.25 mm for the tip.

The Exeter femoral stem exhibits migration which is a complex combination of translation and rotation in three dimensions. Comparing our 10 year with our previous 2 year migration results, the Exeter stems show continued, but slow distal migration and internal rotation. The subsidence continues to compress the cement and bone-cement interface which maintains secure fixation in the long term.

About ten years ago we introduced sophisticated instrumentation and an increased range of component sizes for the Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) to facilitate a minimally invasive surgical (MIS) approach. The device is now routinely implanted through an incision from the medial pole of the patella to the tibial tuberosity. This has resulted in a more rapid recovery and an improved functional result. As the access to the knee is limited there is a concern that the long term results may be compromised. The aim of this study was to determine the 10 year survival.

A prospective follow up of all Phase 3 minimally invasive Oxford UKR implanted by two senior authors (DWM & CAFD) has been undertaken. So far 1015 UKRs have been implanted for anteromedial osteoarthritis. All patients received a cemented implant through a MIS approach and were followed up prospectively by an independent observer. The data was collected prospectively regarding pre-operative status, complications and clinical as well as functional outcome at predetermined intervals.

The average age of patients was 66.4 years (range: 33 – 88) with mean Oxford Knee Score 41 (SD: 7.9) at the time of last follow up, Knee Society Score (objective) of 84 (SD: 13) and Knee Society Score (functional) of 83 (SD: 21). At ten years the survival of this cohort is 96%. There were 22 revisions including 7 for progression of arthritis, 5 for infection, 5 for bearing dislocation, 4 for unexplained pain and one for rupture of ACL secondary to trauma.

We conclude that the Oxford Knee can be implanted reliably through a minimally invasive approach, giving excellent long term results.

Introduction: This study explores whether modern magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with improved cartilage sequencing is able to show a more detailed view of antero-medial osteoarthritis of the knee (AMOA) than previously, so enabling a radiographic description of this common phenotype of disease. Modern MRI technology allows us to visualize in great detail the structures and cartilage within the knee, providing a better understanding of the pathoanatomy of AMOA. This description of the end stage of disease is useful as a baseline when investigating the progression of arthritis through the knee. Preoperative assessment of patients and selection of intervention is very important and preoperative imaging forms an integral part of this. This will also be useful in preoperative assessment and surgical management of patients.

Methods: 50 patients with a radiographic diagnosis of anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee and had been listed for unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) had MRI as part of their pre-op workup. At operation all were deemed suitable for UKA using the current Oxford indications. The image sequences were coronal, axial and sagittal with a predetermined cartilage protocol. The state of the ACL, cartilage wear degree and location, presence and pattern of osteophytes, meniscal anatomy and subchondral high signal were assessed.

Results: All the ACLs were visualized and in continuity, however 40% showed intrasubstance high signal. 100% of medial compartments showed full thickness anteromedial loss with preservation of the posteromedial cartilage. When present, the meniscus was extruded in 75% of cases.

90% of lateral compartments were normal and none had full thickness cartilage loss. However 10% showed high signal in the tibial plateau. There was a highly reproducible pattern of osteophyte formation; 94% posteromedial and posterolateral aspect of medial femoral condyle; 90% medial tibial; 80% medial femoral and 84% lateral intercondylar notch.

Discussion: This study maps the pattern of anteromedial osteoarthritis using modern MRI techniques. This creates a baseline description of disease which is useful when investigating disease progression. This also has importance in determining preoperative indications (preservation of ACL and posteromedial cartilage); surgical technique (determine pattern of osteophytes requiring resection) and potentially important for long-term outcome (early lateral compartment changes).

Metal on Metal Hip Resurfacing Arthroplasty (MoMHRA) has gained popularity due to its perceived advantages of bone conservation and relative ease of revision to a conventional THR if it fails. Known MoMHRA-associated complications include femoral neck fracture, avascular necrosis/collapse of the femoral head/neck, aseptic loosening and soft tissue responses such as ALVAL and pseudotumours. This study’s aim was to assess the functional outcome of failed MoMHRA revised to THR and compare it with a matched cohort of primary THRs.

Method: We have revised 53 MoMHRA cases to THR; the reasons for revision were femoral neck fracture (Fracture Group, n=21), soft tissue reaction (Pseudotumour Group, n=16) and other causes (Other Group, n=16: loosening, AVN and infection). Average followup was 2.9 years. These MoMHRA revisions were compared with 103 matched controls from a primary THR cohort; matched for age, gender and length of followup. We compared, using the MannWhitney U test, operative time (OT, measured in minutes), and Oxford Hip Score (OHS) between the revised MoMHRA groups and their individual controls. We also compared, using the Kruskal Wallis test, UCLA Activity Score in the revised MoMHRA groups.

Results: There were no differences between the Fracture Group (mean OT 99.6, SD: 30.4; mean OHS 19.8, SD:9.2) and its controls (mean OT 95.9, SD: 31.8; mean OHS 17.3, SD: 7.5) nor between the Other Group (mean OT 129.4, SD: 36.7; mean OHS 22.2, SD: 9.4) and its controls (mean OT 104.4, SD: 39.2; mean OHS 20.3, SD: 10.1) in terms of OT and OHS. The Pseudotumour Group had significantly longer OT (mean 161.6, SD: 24.5, p< 0.001) and worse outcome (mean OHS 39.1, SD: 9.3, p< 0.001) than its controls (mean OT 113.1, SD: 51.7; mean OHS 20.0, SD: 9.2). In the Fracture Group, there were 3 infections requiring revisions. For the Pseudotumour Group, there were 3 recurrent dislocations, 1 femoral artery stenosis and 3 femoral nerve palsies. In the Other Group, there were 2 periprosthetic fractures. There was significant difference (p< 0.001) in UCLA scores between the MoMHRA groups. The Pseudotumour Group had the lowest mean UCLA score of 3.8 (SD: 1.89). The Fracture Group (mean: 7.0, S.D. 2.0) and the Other Group (mean: 6.7, S.D. 2.1) had similar UCLA scores.

Discussion: The results demonstrate that outcome after revision of MoMHRA is dependent upon the indication for revision. Patients revised for soft tissue reactions had significantly worse outcome. Patients with soft tissue reactions are more likely to experience complications and require further surgical intervention. The pseudotumour associated revisions were associated with a significantly prolonged OT. The overall complication rate for the study groups was quite high, with 11 (21%) revised MoMHRA cases experiencing a complication. The Pseudotumour Group had a higher complication rate (37%).

Introduction: Most unicompartmental knee replacements (UKRs) employ cement for fixation of the prosthetic components to the bone. The information in the literature about the relative merits of cemented and cementless UKR is contradictory, with some favouring cementless fixation while others favouring cemented fixation. There is concern about the radiolucency which frequently develops around the tibial component with cemented fixations. The exact cause of the occurrence of radiolucency is unknown but according to some, it may suggest suboptimal fixation.

Method: Following ethical approval, 62 patients with medial OA were randomised to receive either cemented (n=31) or cementless components (n=31). All patients underwent identical surgical procedure with either a cemented or cementless Oxford UKR. Patients were assessed clinically and radiologically. The x-rays were taken with an image intensifier (I.I.). The position of the I.I. was adjusted until it was perfectly aligned with the tibial bone-implant interface thereby allowing accurate assessment of presence and extent of the radiolucency.

Results: The patients in the two groups were well matched. There was no significant difference in the clinical scores between the two groups. The mean OKS for the cemented group was 40 (± 8.3) and 42 (± 4.6) for cementless group. Narrow radiolucent lines were seen at the bone-implant interfaces of 75% of the cemented tibial components; partial in 43% and complete in 32%. In the cementless implants, partial radiolucencies were seen in 7% and complete radiolucencies in none. The differences are statistically highly significant (p< 0.0001) and imply satisfactory bone ingrowth into the cementless implants.

Conclusions: The method of fixation influences the incidence of radiolucency. With identical designs, no patient with cementless components developed any complete radiolucency. The observation raises the question as to whether cementless rather than cemented components should be routinely used for UKR.

Patello-femoral instability (PFI) affects 40 individuals per 100,000 population and causes significant morbidity. The causes of patello-femoral instability are multi-factorial, and an isolated anatomical abnormality does not necessarily indicate instability. Patello-femoral subluxation ranges from 0% (stable patella tracking) to 100% (dislocation) and there is an established relationship between the amount of subluxation and anterior knee pain. Traditionally, magnetic resonance (MR) imaging and standard radiographs are used to guide the clinician towards a suitable corrective procedure for PFI. The multi-factorial nature of patello-femoral instability is not addressed with current imaging techniques. This study aims to address which anatomical variables assessed on MR images are most relevant to patello-femoral subluxation. This information will aid surgical decision making, particularly in selecting the most appropriate reconstructive surgery.

A retrospective analysis of MR studies of 60 patients with suspected patello-femoral instability was performed. All patients were graded for degree of subluxation using a dynamic MR scan.

The patient scans were assessed for the presence of a specific range of anatomical variables:

patella alta, (modified Insall-Salvatti)

The Wilk’s Lambda test for multi-variate analysis was used to establish whether any relationship was present between the degree of patello-femoral instability and bony or soft tissue anatomical variables. Non-parametric statistical tests were applied across the groups and within the groups to assess their relative significance.

The following variables showed a significant relationship with patellofemoral subluxation; distance of the VMO from the patella (< 0.001), TTD (< 0.001), patella engagement (0.001), sulcus angles (0.004) and patella alta (0.005).

This study agrees with previous work showing a significant correlation between subluxation and trochlea sulcus angle and TTD.

This is the first study to establish a significant correlation between patella engagement and radiological instability. The lower the percentage engagement of the patella in the trochlea, the greater the degree of patello-femoral instability. Patella engagement showed a more significant relationship with subluxation than patella alta.

We report a new method of predicting patello-femoral instability by measuring the overlap of the patella in the trochlea groove.

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to report the mid-term survival results of Oxford UKAs in patients of 50 years of age or less, using (1) revision surgery and (2) Oxford Knee Scores (OKS) as outcome measures.

Method: A literature review identified studies of Oxford mobile bearing UKAs containing individuals 1) 50 years old or less with 2) medial osteoarthritis and 3) 2 years or longer follow-up. Authors were approached to participate in a multi-centre survival analysis by submitting all their patients, 50 years of age or less, who received a medial UKA for osteoarthritis. Patients who had died, been lost to follow-up or who underwent revision were identified. OKS were established for all patients with surviving implants.

Results: Seven centres submitted 107 patients. The mean age was 47 years (range 32–50). The average follow-up was 4 years (range 1–25). Forty-seven patients had follow-up into their fifth year or longer. The cumulative 7-year survival using revision as the endpoint was 96% (CI 8). The mean post-operative OKS for surviving implants was 38 (CI 2) out of a possible 48.

Conclusion: While early survival rates and function are encouraging, long-term follow-up is required before concluding UKA is a viable treatment option in young patients with unicompartmental knee arthritis.

Introduction: Metal on metal Hip Resurfacing Arthroplasty (MoMHRA) has gained popularity due to its perceived advantages of bone conservation and relative ease of revision to a conventional THR if it fails. This retrospective study is aimed at assessing the functional outcome of failed MoMHRA revised to THR and comparing it with a matched cohort of primary THRs.

Method: Since 1999 we have revised 53 MoMHRA to THR. The reasons for revision were femoral neck fracture (Group A, n=21), pseudotumour (Group B, n=16) and other causes (Group C, n=16: loosening, avascular necrosis and infection). Average follow-up was 3 years months (1.2–7.3). These revisions were compared with 106 primary THRs which were age, gender and follow-up matched with the revision group in a ratio of 2:1.

Results: The mean Oxford Hip Score (OHS) was 20.1 (12–51) for group A, 39.1 (14– 56) for group B, 22.8 (12–39) for group C and 17.8 (12–45) for primary THR group. In group A, there were three infections requiring further revisions. In group B, there were three recurrent dislocations, three patients with femoral nerve palsy and one femoral artery stenosis. In group C, there were no complications. The differences in clinical and functional outcome between group B and the remaining groups as well as the difference in the outcome between group B and control group were statistically significant (p < 0.05).

Conclusions: THR for failed MoMHRA was associated with significantly more complications, operation time and need for blood transfusion for the pseudotumour group. In addition, the revisions secondary to pseudotumour also had significantly worse functional outcome when compared to other MoMHRA revisions or primary THR.

Introduction: We investigated the relationship between psychological distress and outcome after total hip replacement (THR) in the Exeter Primary Outcome Study (EPOS).

Materials & Methods: Data were collected from a number of centres across England between January 1999 and January 2002 for patients undergoing primary hip replacement using the cemented Exeter femoral component (Stryker). We recorded the Oxford Hip Score (OHS) for physical function and SF36 questionnaire for both physical and mental domain assessment annually for five years. We dichotomised the patients into the mentally distressed (MHS < 50) and the not mentally distressed (MHS ≥ 50) groups based on their pre-operative Mental Health Score (MHS) from the SF36 score.

Results: Complete data were available for 455 (407 not distressed and 48 distressed) patients. Pre-operative OHS and SF-36 score was significantly worse in the distressed group (both p< 0.001). Mean OHS improved from 43 to 20 at 1 year after surgery and remained the same thereafter in the non distressed group. In the mentally distressed group pre-operative mean OHS of 48 improved to 22 at 1 year after surgery. Maximum improvement in OHS occurred in the 1st yr after surgery. Mean MHS improved from 76 to 81 at 1 year after surgery and remained the same thereafter in the non distressed group. Mean MHS improved from 35 to 62 at 1 year after surgery, reaching 65 at 5 years after surgery in the mentally distressed group. The maximum improvement in MHS occurred in the 1st yr after surgery.

Conclusion: Pre-operative psychological distress did not compromise functional outcome after hip arthroplasty. There was a substantial improvement in mental distress in patients with mental distress prior to surgery. Both groups of patients experienced improvement in Oxford Hip Score, which was maximal by 1 year after surgery and was maintained over the 5 year follow up.

Purpose: This study was designed to establish the poly-ethylene wear rates in the Oxford medial unicompert-mental knee replacement.

Introduction: The Oxford meniscal bearing knee was introduced as a design to reduce polyethylene wear. There has been one previous retrieval study of the Oxford UKA, which reported very low wear rates in some specimens, but abnormal patterns of wear in others, including impingement. There has been no further investigation of these abnormal wear patterns.

Methods: Forty-seven bearings were retrieved from patients who had received a medial Oxford UKA for anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee, none of which had previously been studied. Mean time to revision was 8.4 years (SD 4.1) and 20 had been implanted for over 10 years. The macroscopic pattern of polyethylene wear and the linear penetration (dial gauge measurement) was recorded for each bearing.

Results: The mean linear penetration rate (LPR) was 0.07mm/year. The patterns of wear fell into 4 categories, each with a different LPR; 1) No abnormal macroscopic appearance, n=16 (LPR = 0.01mm/year), 2) Abnormal macroscopic wear with extra-articular impingement, n=16 (LPR = 0.05mm/year), 3) Abnormal macroscopic wear with intra-articular impingement, n=6 (LPR = 0.10mm/year), 4) Abnormal macroscopic wear with impingement and signs of incongruous articulation, n=9 (LPR = 0.14mm/year). The differences in LPR were statistically significant (p< 0.05).

Conclusion: The results show that very low polyethylene wear rates are possible if the device functions normally. However if the bearing displays abnormal function (extra-articular, intra-articular impingement or incongruous articulation) wear rates increase significantly.

Introduction: Despite the satisfactory short-term implant survivorship of MoM hip resurfacing arthroplasty, symptomatic abnormal periprosthetic soft-tissue masses relating to the hip joint, ‘pseudotumours’, are being increasingly reported. These were found be locally destructive, requiring revision surgery in 75% of patients. Asymptomatic pseudotumours have not been previously investigated.

Methods: The aims were: (1) to investigate the prevalence of asymptomatic pseudotumours; and (2) to investigate their potential association with the level of metal ions. A total of 160 hips in 123 patients with a mean age 56 years (range 33–73) were evaluated at a mean follow-up of 61 months (range 13–88). Radiographs and OHS were assessed. Patients with a cystic or solid mass detected on the ultrasound/MRI had an aspiration or biopsy performed. Cobalt and chromium levels were analysed using Inductively-Coupled Plasma Spectrometer.

Results: Pseudotumours were found in 6 patients (5F: 1M). In 80% of bilateral cases, it was found in both sides. Histological examination showed extensive necrosis and diffuse lymphocyte infiltration. The presence of pseudotumour was associated with higher serum cobalt (9.2 μg/L vs. 1.9μg/L, p< 0.001) and chromium levels (12.0μg/L vs. 2.1μg/L, p< 0.001); higher hip aspirate cobalt (1182 μg/L vs. 86.2μg/L, p=0.003) and chromium levels (883μg/L vs. 114.8μg/L, p=0.006); and with inferior OHS (23 vs. 14 p=0.08).

Discussion: The prevalence of asymptomatic pseudotumour (5%) was higher than previously reported for the symptomatic pseudotumours (1%). There was a sixfold elevation of serum and a twelve-fold elevation of hip aspirate levels of cobalt and chromium in patients with pseudotumours. This suggests that pseudotumours may be a biological consequence of the large amount of metal debris generated in vivo. The association between pseudotumour and elevated metal ion levels might theoretically be explained by either systemic hypersensitivity responses to metal ions or local cytotoxic effects due to a high level of metal ions.

Introduction: This study explores whether modern magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with improved cartilage sequencing is able to show a more detailed view of anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee (AMOA). Preoperative assessment of patients and selection of intervention is very important and preoperative imaging forms an integral part of this. Modern MRI technology may allow us to visualize in great detail the structures and cartilage within the knee, providing a better understanding of the pathoanatomy of AMOA. This will be useful in preoperative assessment and surgical management of patients.

Methods: 50 patients with a radiographic diagnosis of anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee and had been listed for unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) had MRI as part of their pre-op workup. At operation all were deemed suitable for UKA using the current Oxford indications. The image sequences were coronal, axial and sagittal with a predetermined cartilage protocol. The state of the ACL, cartilage wear location and pattern, presence of osteophytes and subchondral high signal were assessed.

Results: All the ACLs were visualized and in continuity, however 40% showed intrasubstance high signal.

100% of medial compartments showed full thickness anteromedial loss with preservation of the posteromedial cartilage. When present, the meniscus was extruded in 96% of cases.

Discussion: This study maps the pattern of anteromedial osteoarthritis using modern MRI techniques. This has importance in determining preoperative indications (preservation of ACL and posteromedial cartilage); surgical technique (determine pattern of osteophytes requiring resection) and potentially important for long-term outcome (early lateral compartment changes).

Introduction: Although resurfacing hip replacements are widely used there are few little independent outcome data to support this. The aim of this study was to report the 5 year clinical outcome and 7 year survival of an independent series.

Method: 610 Birmingham hip resurfacings were implanted in 532 patients with an average age of 51.8 years (range 16.5–81.6 years) and were followed for between 2 to 8 years; 120 of this series had minimum five year follow-up. Two patients were lost. There were 23 revisions, giving an overall survival of 95% (95% CI 85–99%) at seven years. Fractured neck of femur (n=13) was the most common reason for revision, followed by aseptic loosening (n=4). There were also 3 patients who had failures that were possibly related to metal debris. At a minimum of 5 year follow-up 93% had excellent or good outcome according to the Harris Hip Score. The mean Oxford Hip Score was 16.1 points (SD 7.7) and the mean UCLA activity score was 6.6 points (SD 1.9). There were no patients with definite evidence of radiographic loosening or greater than 10% of neck narrowing.

Discussion: The results demonstrate that with the Birmingham Hip Resurfacing, implanted using the extended posterior approach, the five year survival is similar or better to the reported survival rates for cemented and hybrid THR’s in young patients.

Conclusions: Considering these patients are young and active these results are good and support the use of resurfacing. However, further study is needed to address the early failures; particularly those related to fracture and metal debris.

Statement of purpose: The aim of this study is to evaluate different designs of unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) by comparing the peak von Mises and contact stresses in polyethylene (PE) bearings over a step-up activity.

Summary of Methods: A validated finite element (FE) model was used in this study. Three UKR designs were modelled: a spherical femoral component with a spherical PE bearing (fully-congruent), a poly-radial femoral component with a concave PE bearing (semi-congruent), and a spherical femoral component with a flat bearing (non-congruent).

Kinematic data from in-vivo fluoroscopy measurements during a step-up activity was used to determine the relative tibial-femoral position as a function of knee flexion angle for each model. Medial and lateral force distribution was adapted from loads measured in-vivo with an instrumented implant during a step-up activity. The affect that varying the bearing thickness has on the stresses in the bearing was investigated. In addition, varus-valgus mal-alignment was investigated by rotating the femoral component through 10 degrees.

Summary of Results: Only the fully congruent bearing experienced peak von Mises and contact stresses below the PE lower fatigue limit (17MPa) for the step-up activity (fully congruent PE peak contact stress, 5MPa). The highest PE contact stresses were observed for the semi-congruent and non-congruent designs, which experienced approximately 3 times the PE lower fatigue limit. Peak PE von Mises stresses for the semi-congruent and non-congruent designs were similar, peaking at approximately 25MPa. Peak PE von Mises stresses were ameliorated with increased bearing thickness. Varus-valgus mal-alignment had little effect on the peak stresses in the three UKR designs.

Statement of Conclusions: Fully congruent articulating surfaces significantly reduce the peak contact stresses and von Mises stresses in the bearing. The FE model demonstrates that fully congruent bearings as thin as 2.5mm can be used without increasing the contact stresses significantly. Fully congruent designs can use thinner bearings and enable greater bone preservation.

Introduction: The results of the mobile bearing Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) in the lateral compartment have been disappointing with a five year survival of 82%. Therefore, it is recommended that mobile bearings should not be used for lateral UKR. This low survivorship is primarily due to high dislocation rate, all occurring in the first year. A detailed analysis of the causes of bearing dislocation confirmed the elevated lateral tibial joint line to be a contributory factor. A new surgical technique was therefore introduced in which care was taken neither to remove too much bone from the distal femur nor to over tighten the knee and therefore ensure that the tibial joint line was not elevated. Other modifications to the technique were also introduced including use of a domed tibial component.

Aim: The aim of this study is to compare the outcome of these iterations: the original series [series I], Series II with improved surgical technique and the domed tibial component [Series III].

Method: The primary assessment of outcome was bearing dislocation at one year. One year was chosen as all the dislocations in the first series occurred within a year. In series I, there were 53 knees, in series II 65 knees and in series III 60 knees, all with a minimum of one year follow up.

Results: In series I, there were 6 bearing dislocations (11%) and the average range of movement (ROM) was 110°. In the second series, there were 2 dislocations (3%) and the average ROM was 118°. In the third series, there were no primary dislocations and the average ROM was 125°.

Conclusions: The improved surgical technique and implant design has reduced the dislocation rate to an acceptable level so a mobile bearing can now be recommended for lateral UKR.

Statement of purpose: Finite element (FE) models of bone can be used to evaluate new and modified knee replacements. Validation of FE models is seldom used, and the quantification of modelling parameters has a considerable effect on the results obtained. The aim of this study is to develop a FE model of a cadaveric tibia and validate it against a comprehensive set of experiments.

Summary of Methods: Seventeen tri-axial rosettes were attached to a cleaned, fresh frozen cadaveric human tibia and the tibia was subjected to 13 loading conditions. Deflection and strain data were used for comparison with the FE model. A geometric model was created on the basis of computed tomography (CT) scans. The CT data was used to map 600 orthotropic material properties to the tibia. All experiments were simulated on the FE model. Measured principal strains were compared to their corresponding FE values using regression analysis. The validated tibia model was reduced in size (75mm to the proximal) and then re-modelled to represent only the proximal tibia. This re-modelled tibia was validated against the reduced size FE model. Virtual surgery was performed on the validated proximal model to implant a UKR.

Summary of Results: For the whole tibia model, the regression line for all axial loads combined had a slope of 0.999, an intercept of −6.24 micro-strain, and an R2 value of 0.962. The root mean square error as a percentage was 5%. For the proximal tibia model, correlation coefficients of 0.989 and 0.976 were obtained for the maximum and minimum principal strains respectively.

Statement of Conclusions: An FE model of an implanted proximal tibia has been validated against experimental data. This model is able to accurately predict the deflection and stresses in a replaced knee joint to obtain clinically relevant information. This will provide a virtual model of unicompartmental arthroplasty, where variables such as fixation method and bearing mechanics can be assessed.

Introduction: Treatment options for the young active patient with isolated symptomatic medial compartment OA and pre-existing ACL deficiency are limited. Implant longevity and activity levels may preclude TKA, whilst HTO and unicompartmentasl knee arythroplasty (UKA) are unreliable due to ligamentous instability. UKAs tend to fail because of wear or tibial loosening resulting from eccentric loading. Combined UKA and ACL reconstruction may therefore be a solution.

Method: Fifteen patients with combined ACL reconstruction and Oxford UKA (ACLR group), were matched (age, gender and follow-up period) with 15 patients with Oxford UKA with intact ACL (ACLI group). Prospectively collected clinical and x-ray data from the last follow-up (minimum 3 years, range: 3 – 5) were compared. Ten patients from each group also underwent in-vivo kinematic assessment using a standardised protocol.

Results: At the last follow-up, the clinical outcome for the two groups were similar. One ACLR patient needed revision due to infection. Radiological assessment did not show any significant difference between relative component positions and none of the patients had pathological radiolucencies suggestive of component loosening. Kinematic assessment showed posterior placement of the femur on tibia in extension for the ACLR group, which corrected with further flexion.

Conclusions: The short-term clinical results of combined ACL reconstruction and UKA are excellent. Lack of pathological radiolucencies and near normal knee kinematics suggest that early tibial loosening due to eccentric loading is unlikely.

Aim: The aim of this study was to asses the accuracy of skyline radiographs in the assessment of the patellofemoral joint, when compared to open intraoperative assessment.

Methods: Eighty nine patients undergoing knee replacement surgery were included in the study. Skyline radiographs were obtained preoperatively. These radiographs were assessed and graded by an experienced musculoskeletal radiologist using the Altman and Ahlbäck classifications. The grades were calculated for both the medial and lateral facets of the PFJ. Intraoperative assessment of the Patellofemoral joint was undertaken at the time of surgery. The damage was graded using the modified Collins classification (0: Normal, 1: Superficial damage, 2: Partial thickness cartilage loss, 3: Focal Full thickness cartilage loss < 2cm2, 4: Extensive full thickness cartilage loss < 2cm2). Data was obtained for the Medial Facet, Lateral Facet and Trochlea.

Results: Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient between the radiographic and macroscopic changes within the lateral PFJ were poor with both the Altman 0.22 (p=0.0350) and Ahlbäck 0.24 (p=0.018). The correlation of the medial PFJ was slightly better with a coefficient for Altman 0.42 (P< 0.0001) and Ahlbäck 0.34 (P> 0.001).

Conclusion: In conclusion skyline radiographs provide a poor to moderate preoperative assessment of the degree of osteoarthritis within the patella-femoral joint. This has significant implications for establishing radiographic criteria for planning patella-femoral joint replacement.

Purpose: The aim of this study is to compare the long-term survival results of TKA in patients under the age of 60, using

revision surgery and

Method: From our knee database we identified a cohort of 60 total knee replacements that had been performed over 15 years previously. We identified those who had died, those who had been revised and established the Oxford Knee Score (OKS) for all those still surviving.

Results Using the following endpoint criteria the cumulative 15-year survival was (A) revision surgery alone = 78% (CI 12), (B) revision surgery or an OKS less than or equal to 24 (50% of total OKS) = 63% (CI 13), and (C) revision surgery or moderate pain = 48% (CI 14).

Conclusion The functional survival of TKA in patients under the age of 60 decreases in the second decade following implantation with a significant number of prostheses failing the patient due to knee pain

Introduction: The information in the literature about the relative merits of cemented and cementless unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) is contradictory, with some favouring cementless fixation while others favouring cemented fixation. Cemented fixations give good survivorship but there is concern about the radiolucency which frequently develops around the tibial component. The exact cause of the occurrence of radiolucency is unknown but according to some, it may suggest suboptimal fixation.

Method: Sixty-two knees (31 in each group) were randomised to receive either cemented or cementless UKR components. The components were similar except that the cementless had a porous titanium and hydroxyappatite (HA) coating. Patients were prospectively assessed by an independent observer pre-operatively and annually thereafter. The clinical assessment included Oxford Knee Score, Knee Society Scores and Tegner activity score. Fluoroscopically aligned radiographs were assessed for thickness and extent of radiolucency under the tibial implant.

Results: At one year there were no differences in the clinical outcome between the groups and there were no loose components. No radiolucencies thicker than 1mm were seen. At one year none of the cementless tibias and 30% of the cemented tibias had complete radiolucencies. One out of 31 cementless (3%) and 12 out of 31 cemented (39%) had partial radiolucencies. This difference between these two groups was high significant (p< 0 0001).

Conclusions: This study clearly demonstrates that the incidence of radiolucency beneath the tibial component is influenced by component design and method of fixation. With identical designs of tibial component none of the cementless components developed complete radiolucences whereas 30% of the cemented components did. We conclude that HA achieves better bone integration than cement.

Introduction: Avascular necrosis of the femoral head after resurfacing hip replacement is an important complication which may lead to fracture or failure. We compared the changes in femoral head oxygenation resulting from the anterolateral approach to those resulting from the posterior approach.

Methods: In 22 patients undergoing hip resurfacing surgery, a calibrated gas-sensitive electrode was inserted supero-laterally in the femoral head via the femoral neck following division of the fascia lata. Inter-operative X-ray confirmed correct electrode placement. Baseline oxygen concentration levels were recorded immediately after electrode insertion. All results were expressed relative to this baseline, which was considered as 100% relative oxygen concentration. Oxygen levels were monitored continuously throughout the operation. 10 patients underwent surgery through the posterior approach, 12 patients through the antero-lateral approach.

Results: During the operation patterns were similar for both groups, except following joint relocation and soft tissue reconstruction; oxygen concentration recovered significantly in the anterolateral group only. The posterior approach resulted in significantly lower (p< 0.01) oxygen concentration at the end of the procedure (22%, SD 31) than the antero-lateral approach (123%, SD 99).

Discussion and Conclusion: The anterolateral approach disrupts the femoral head blood supply significantly less than the posterior approach in patients undergoing resurfacing. The incidence of complications related to avascular necrosis might be decreased by adopting blood supply conserving surgical approaches.

Introduction: Treatment options for the young active patient with isolated symptomatic medial compartment osteoarthritis and pre-existing anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency are limited. Implant longevity and activity levels may preclude total knee arthroplasty (TKA), whilst high tibial osteotomy HTO and unicompartmental arthroplasty (UKA) are unreliable due to ligamentous instability. UKA’s tend to fail because of wear or tibial loosening resulting from eccentric loading. Combined UKA and ACL reconstruction may therefore be a solution.

Method: Fifteen patients with combined ACL reconstruction and Oxford UKA (ACLR group), were matched (age, gender and follow-up period) with 15 patients with Oxford UKA with intact ACL (ACLI group). Prospectively collected clinical and x-ray data from the last follow-up (minimum 3 years, range: 3–5) were compared. Ten patients from each group also underwent in-vivo kinematic assessment using a standardised protocol.

Results: At the last follow-up, the clinical outcome for the two groups were similar (ACLR: OKS 46, KSS (objective): 99, ACLI: OKS 43, KSS (objective): 94). One ACLR patient needed revision due to infection. Radiological assessment did not show any significant difference between relative component positions and none of the patients had pathological radiolucencies suggestive of component loosening. Kinematic assessment showed posterior placement of the femur on tibia in extension for the ACLR group, which corrected with further flexion.

Conclusions: The short-term clinical results of combined ACL reconstruction and UKA are excellent. Lack of pathological radiolucencies and near normal knee kinematics suggest that early tibial loosening due to eccentric loading is unlikely. Similarly, wear is unlikely to be a problem because of the wear resistance of mobile bearing devices.

Introduction: The Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) use in the lateral compartment has been associated with a reduced flexion range and increased medial compartment pain than seen with its medial counterpart due to, in part, the inadequacy of a flat tibial tray replacing the domed anatomy of the lateral tibia. A new design incorporating a domed tibial component and a biconcave meniscal bearing has been developed to overcome these problems.

This study reports a clinical comparison of new and old establishing whether this modified implant has maintained the established normal kinematic profile of the Oxford UKR.

Method: Patients undergoing lateral UKR for OA were recruited for the study. Fifty one patients who underwent UKR with the domed design were compared to 60 patients who had lateral UKR with a flat inferior bearing surface. Kinematic evaluation was performed on 3 equal subgroups (n = 20); Group 1-Normal volunteer knees, Group 2-Flat Oxford Lateral UKR’s and Group 3-Domed Oxford Lateral UKR’s. The sagittal plane kinematics of each knee was assessed using videofluoroscopic analysis whilst performing a step up and deep knee bend activity. The fluoroscopic images were recorded digitally, corrected for distortion using a global correction method and analysed using specially developed software to identify the anatomical landmarks needed to determine the Patella Tendon Angle (PTA) (the angle the patella tendon and the tibial axis).

Knee kinematics were assessed by analysing the movement of the femur relative to the tibia using the PTA.

Results: PTA/KFA values, for both devices, from extension to flexion did not show any significant difference in PTA values in comparison to the normals as measured by a 3-way ANOVA. The Domed implant achieved higher maximal active flexion during the lunge exercise than those with a flat implant. Only 33% of the flat UKR’s achieved KFA of 130° or more under load whilst performing a lunge, compared with 75% of domed UKR’s and 90% of normal knees. No flat UKR achieved a KFA of 140° or more, yet 50% of all domed UKR’s did, as did 60% of all normal knees.

Conclusions: There was no significant difference in sagittal plane kinematics of the domed and flat Oxford UKR’s. Both designs had favorable kinematic profiles closely resembling that of the normal knee, suggesting normal function of the cruciate mechanism. The domed knees had a greater range of motion under load compared to the flats, approaching levels seen with the normal knee, suggesting that limited flexion for the flat plateau results from over tightening in high flexion and that this is corrected with the domed plateau. Problems with the second generation of lateral Oxford UKA have been rectified by a new bi-concave bearing without losing bearing stability and normal kinematics.

Introduction: Interest in hip resurfacing has recently been renewed by the introduction of metal-on-metal designs; it is being increasingly used for young patients, with over 30,000 implanted worldwide. The 5 year clinical results appear promising, but there are no long term data available. Radiostereometry (RSA) measures of implant migration have been able to predict implant failure; specifically large and continuous migration predicts aseptic loosening. We present the results of a five year RSA study examining the migration of the Birmingham Hip Resurfacing (BHR).

Methods: Twenty-four subjects with primary OA were implanted with the BHR device and with bone markers for RSA. RSA measurements were taken at 3, 6, 12, 24 and 60 months. The migration of the head and the tip of femoral component were measured in 3D.

Results: Preliminary analysis showed that the total 3D migration of the head and tip over five years was 0.32mm and 0.23mm respectively.

Discussion: A distal migration of more than 0.4mm over 2 years increases the likelihood of failure in conventional stems. The total migration of the BHR was approximately 0.3mm over a five year period, significantly less than cemented THR devices. The device is stable and this is promising for long-term survival.

Background: The Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) use in the lateral compartment has been associated with a reduced flexion range, increased medial compartment pain and a higher dislocation rate than seen with its medial counterpart due to the inadequacy of a flat tibial tray replacing the domed anatomy of the lateral tibia. A new design incorporating a domed tibial component and a biconcave meniscal bearing has been developed to overcome these problems. This current study was designed to establish whether this modi-fied ‘domed’ implant has maintained the established normal kinematic profile of the Oxford UKR.

Methods: The study population consisted of 60 participants from three equal groups; Group 1- Normal volunteer knees (n = 20), Group 2 – Flat Oxford Lateral UKR’s (n = 20) and Group 3 – Domed Oxford Lateral UKR’s (n = 20). The sagittal plane kinematics of each involved knee was assessed continuously using videofluoroscopic analysis. A standardised protocol of step-up and deep lunge was used to assess loadbearing range of motion during which the patella tendon angle (PTA) was measured as a function of the knee flexion angle (KFA).

Results: PTA/KFA values compared at 10 degree KFA increments from maximal extension to maximal flexion for all 3 groups did not demonstrate any statistically significant difference in PTA values between any group as measured by a 3-way ANOVA. The Domed implant achieved higher maximal active flexion during the lunge exercise than those with a Flat implant. Only 33% of the Flat UKR’s achieved KFA of 130 degrees or more under load whilst performing a lunge, compared with 75% of domed UKR’s and 90% of normal knees. No Flat UKR achieved a KFA of 140 degrees or more, yet 50% of all domed UKR’s did, as also did 60% of all normal knees.

Conclusions: There is no significant difference in the sagittal plane kinematics of the domed and flat Oxford UKR’s. Both implant designs have a favourable kinematic profile closely resembling the normal knee. The domed knees though do have a greater range of motion under load as compared to the flats, approaching levels seen with the normal knee.

There has been controversy about the practice of mixing femoral and acetabular implants from different manufacturers in total hip replacement (THR). We studied the clinical outcomes of over 1500 patients in the Exeter Primary Outcomes Study (EPOS) who underwent primary THR with a cemented Exeter stem (Stryker) but with various acetabular components. This was a prospective non-randomised multicentre study. Patient reported hip scores (Oxford Hip Score (OHS)) were measured before operation and at 1 and 2 years post operatively. The choice of acetabular implant was at the surgeons’ discretion. 982 patients had reached four year follow up. Six types of acetabular component were examined (Exeter, Exeter Contemporary, Duraloc (all Stryker), Charnley (DePuy), Cenator (Corin), and Trilogy (Zimmer)).

Patients who received a Charnley cup were found to have worse pre-operative status (significantly higher OHS) than those receiving other cups (especially those receiving Exeter cups) (p< 0.01). Post operatively, this difference continued, with the absolute OHS value remaining greater (i.e. worse clinical result) for the Charnley cup at 1, 2, 3 and 4 years. The association of poor pre-op status with worse post-op result was anticipated. However, when the clinical benefit of surgery (i.e. the improvement in OHS between pre-op and post-op) was assessed, there was no significant difference between the various implants at 1, 2, 3 and 4 years.

These results demonstrate that initial clinical benefit of surgery does not differ between patients receiving acetabular implants from varying manufacturers when the Exeter stem is used. These patients will be followed further to determine whether such “mixing and matching” results in differences in longer term outcomes.

The optimal surgical approach for total hip replacement (THR) remains controversial. We report the clinical outcomes of over 1000 patients in the Exeter primary outcomes study (epos) who underwent primary THR with a cemented Exeter stem (Stryker) but with various acetabular components. This was a prospective non randomised multi centre study. Patient reported hip scores (oxford hip score (OHS)) were measured before operation and at 3 months (n= 1312), 1 (n=1276), 2 (n= 1225), 3 (n=1205) and 4 (n=975) years post operatively. Physician reported scores (Merle d’Aubigne / Postel, MDAP) were measured before operation and at 12 months. All of the operations were carried out using either the anterolateral (Hardinge or modification) or posterior approach.

The posterior approach gave better absolute OHS scores at 3 months and 1 year compared with the anterolateral approach. The improvement in OHS between the pre-op and relevant post-op score was better for the posterior than the Hardinge approach, and this extended to 4 years (all p< 0.05). Early dislocation rates were low in both groups. There was significantly more likely to be heterotopic ossification in the Hardinge group, while stem alignment into varus was more common in the posterior approach group. There was no significant difference between the two approaches as measured using the MDAP score at pre-op or at 12 months after surgery.

These results demonstrate that initial patient perceived clinical benefit of surgery is greater using a posterior than with an anterolateral approach. This should be considered when assessing the best approach for a particular patient. The current results emphasise the value of using patient based outcome measures, as the MDAP score did not detect a difference in outcomes between the two groups.

There has been controversy about whether limb length discrepancy (LLD) affects outcome after total hip replacement (THR). We examined input variables and outcomes of over 1200 patients who received primary THR with the Exeter stem and a variety of acetabular components in the Exeter Primary Outcomes Study. This was a non randomized prospective multi centre study.

We examined whether specific groups of patients or surgeons were more likely to have LLD at one year after surgery. Data for leg length measured on clinical assessment were available for 1207 patients at 1 year. 237 patients were recorded as having a leg length difference of 1 cm or more, and 73 a difference of 2 cm or more. 138 were longer on the operated side and 99 were shorter. The likelihood of having LLD of 2 cm or more was not significantly affected by the grade of surgeon (consultant or trainee), BMI, age of patient, position of patient during surgery or surgical approach, or the use of regional or general anaesthetic.

We examined the effect of LLD on outcomes at 3 months and 1,2,3 and 4 years. Patients with LLD > 1cm had significantly worse Oxford Hip Scores (OHS) at 1, 2, 3 and 4 years (p< 0.01), with the OHS generally being an average 2 points worse in those with LLD. The most consistent difference between those with and without LLD was a patient reported limp on the Oxford Hip Questionnaire.

We conclude that LLD is a common problem after THR and that all patient groups may be affected. It is associated with a significantly worse functional outcome as measured by a validated hip score. Systematic adoption of accurate intra-operative measures of leg length might pay dividends in minimizing this complication.

There is concern that patients undergoing total hip replacement by trainee surgeons may do worse than those operated on by consultants. We examined the clinical outcomes of over patients in the Exeter Primary Outcomes Study who underwent primary THR with a cemented Exeter stem (Stryker) with various acetabular components. Over 1400 patients entered the prospective non-randomised multi centre study. Patient reported hip scores (Oxford Hip Score (OHS)) were measured pre operation and at 3 months, 1,2,3 and 4 years post operatively.

The number of patients assessed at 4 years was 982. Trainees operated on patients with worse pre-operative OHS (p< 0.05; t test)) and on significantly less patients under 60 years (p< 0.05 chi square). There was no significant difference in the improvement in OHS (i.e. pre-op OHS – post-op OHS) at any post-operative time point between consultants and trainees. However, patients operated upon by consultants had consistently better postoperative absolute OHS scores (p< 0.05 at 3 months and 1, 2, 3 and 4 years; t test). Complications were low in both groups. Operations performed by trainees lasted longer (mean of 104 vs. 85 minutes). There was also no difference in OHS scores of patients operated by trainees whether they were assisted by an SHO (n=132) or by a consultant (n=249).

In this large cohort of patients there was no difference in the improvement in OHS between patients operated by registrars and consultants. The difference in the absolute OHS values is likely explained by the difference in pre-operative status. We conclude that THRs performed by consultants and by trainees under appropriate supervision give similar initial clinical results. Given current changes to shorten surgical training, it is important that outcomes of THRs performed by future trainees are reviewed to ensure that outcomes are maintained.

The long-term survival of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) has been well established; however, functional outcome remains inconsistent. More normal postoperative TKA kinematics have been shown to produce better knee function. Improved kinematics can be obtained by using implants with optimised surface geometry. Hence a TKA with an appropriate surface geometryis likely to provide superior long-term functional outcome. The Advance-Medial Pivot TKA (Wright Medical) is a fixed bearing prosthesis with a conforming medial compartment and a non-conforming (flat on flat) lateral compartment. This surface geometry is designed with the intention of replicating the normal knee motion of sliding or pivoting medially and rolling back laterally.

Aim: To investigate the sagittal plane kinematics of Advanced Medial Pivot Knee and compare with those of “flat on flat” fixed bearing TKA and normal knees

18 patients who had undergone primary TKA for osteoarthritis were recruited at an average of 18 months post operation. These patients performed flexion and extension exercises against gravity and a step up exercise. Video fluoroscopy of these activities was used to obtain the patellar tendon angle (PTA). This is a previously validated method for assessing sagittal plane kinematics of a knee joint. The kinematic profile of the Advance Medial Pivot Knee was compared to the profile of 14 normal knees and 30 flat on flat, fixed bearing TKA’s.

The sagittal plane kinematics of the Advance TKA differed from the normal knees. However, similarly to normal knees, a linear relationship was observed between PTA and knee flexion angle throughout knee flexion range. The kinematics of the Medial Pivot Knee were similar to normal when the knee was in a highly flexed position.

Functional plane kinematics of the Advance Medial Pivot TKA appear to meet the design criteria in that a linear relationship between PTA and flexion angle is maintained. Further work is required to establish if these improved sagittal plane kinematics translate into improved functional outcome.

Medial unicompartmental replacement (UKR) has been shown to have superior functional results to total knee replacement (TKR) in appropriately selected patients, and this has been associated with a resurgence of interest in the procedure. This may relate to evidence showing that the kinematic profile of UKR is similar to the normal knee, in comparison to TKR, which has abnormal kinematics. Concerns remain over the survivorship of UKR and work has suggested the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) may become dysfunctional over time. Cruciate mechanism dysfunction would produce poor kinematics and instability providing a potential mechanism of failure for the UKR.

Aim: To test the hypothesis that the sagittal plane kinematics (and cruciate mechanism) of a fixed bearing medial UKR deteriorate over time (short to long term).

A cross sectional study was designed in which 24 patients who had undergone successful UKR were recruited and divided into early (2–5 years) and late (> 9 years) groups according to time since surgery. Patients performed flexion/extension against gravity, and a step up. Video fluoroscopy of these activities was used to obtain the Patellar Tendon Angle (PTA), the angle between the long axis of the tibia and the patella tendon, as a function of knee flexion. This is a previously validated method of assessing sagittal plane kinematics of a knee joint.

This work suggests the sagittal plane kinematics of a fixed bearing UKR is maintained in the long term. There is no evidence that the cruciate mechanism has failed at ten years. However, increased tibial bearing conformity from ‘dishing’, and adequate muscle control, cannot be ruled out as possible mechanisms for the satisfactory kinematics observed in the long term for this UKA.

The indications for unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) remain controversial; in particular the threshold of disease in the patellofemoral compartment is debated. Whilst some authorities ignore the condition of the patellofemoral joint, others consider pre-existing patellofemoral osteoarthritis (PFOA) a contra-indication to UKA. The aim of this study was to determine the influence of PFOA on the outcome of medial UKA.

This prospective study involved one hundred consecutive patients who had undergone cemented medial Oxford UKA (phase 3), via a minimally invasive approach, at least one year previously. Patients were divided into two groups according to the presence or absence of full thickness cartilage loss (FTCL) on the patella or trochlea at operation. A pre-operative skyline radiograph was graded using the Altman score, by an independent Musculoskeletal Radiologist. Outcome was evaluated with the Knee Society Score (AKSS) and the Oxford Knee Score (OKS, maximum 48). Groups were compared for differences in knee score and Altman grade using a one way ANOVA. Repeat analysis was performed using the presence of anterior knee pain (AKP) as the group defining variable.

There were 28 patients with FTCL, and both groups were well matched for age, gender and activity levels. Analysis showed no significant difference in post operative knee scores between groups with either the presence of FTCL or the presence of AKP pre-operatively as a factor. There was no significant difference in Altman grade between groups.

Intra-operative evidence of PFOA in patients with medial compartment osteoarthritis does not prejudice the outcome of UKA. Even the inclusion of patients with symptomatic AKP, without necessarily having PFOA, does not affect the outcome after UKA. These short results are encouraging, but longer follow up is required.

Functional outcome after patellofemoral joint replacement (PFA) for osteoarthritis remains inconsistent. It is believed that functional outcome for joint replacement is dependent upon postoperative joint kinematics. Minimal disruption of the native joint, as in PFA, should produce more normal kinematics and improved outcome. No previous studies have examined joint kinematics after isolated PFA.

Aim: To investigate the sagittal plane kinematics of patellofemoral replacement and compare with the normal knee.

Twelve patients who had undergone successful PFA at least two years previously were recruited. Patients performed flexion/extension against gravity, and a step up. Video fluoroscopy of these activities was used to obtain the Patellar Tendon Angle (PTA), the angle between the long axis of the tibia and the patella tendon, as a function of knee flexion. This is a previously validated method of assessing sagittal plane kinematics of a knee joint. The kinematic profile of the PFA joints was compared to the profiles for fourteen normal knees.

Overall, the kinematic plot obtained for PFA reflected similar trends to that for normal knees; but the PTA was slightly but significantly increased throughout the entire range of flexion (two degrees). This is equivalent to an average displacement of the lower pole of the patella of 1.5mm.

Sagittal plane knee kinematics after PFA are much more normal than after TKR and this should give improved functional outcome. The observed increase in PTA through range may result from increased patella thickness or a shallow trochlear groove and may influence patellofemoral contact forces.

Oxford Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is now performed using a minimally invasive surgical (MIS) technique. Although early results are encouraging, the studies assessing outcome could be criticised for the restricted number of patients and limited follow-up. Aim of this study was to assess clinical outcome and prosthetic survival rate inpatients with minimally invasive Oxford medial UKA.

This prospective study assessed 500 consecutive patients, who underwent cemented Oxford UKA for medial OA using MIS technique. Patients were assessed using objective and functional Knee Society Score (KSS).

This study has confirmed preliminary findings that Oxford UKA using a minimally invasive approach is safe, reliable and effective.

Proprioception protects joints against injurious movements and is critical for joint stability maintenance under dynamic conditions. Knee replacement effect on proprioception in general remains elusive. This study aimed to evaluate the changes in proprioceptive performance after knee replacement; comparing Total (TKA) to Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty (UKA).

Thirty-four patients with osteoarthritis were recruited; 15 patients underwent TKA using the AGC prosthesis and 19patients underwent UKA using the Oxford prosthesis. Both cruciate ligaments were preserved in the UKA group, while only the PCL was preserved in TKA patients. Patients’ age was similar in both groups.> Joint Position Sense (JPS) and postural sway were used as measures of proprioception. Both groups were assessed pre- and 6 months post-operatively in both limbs. JPS was measured as the error in actively and passively reproducing five randomly ordered knee flexion angles between 30 and 70°using an isokinetic dynamometer. Postural sway (area and path) was measured during single leg stance using a Balance Performance Monitor. Functional outcome was assessed using the Oxford Knee Score (OKS).

Pre-operatively, no differences in JPS or sway were found between limbs in either group. No differences existed between the two groups. Post-operatively, both groups had significant improvement of JPS in the operated limb (UKA mean4.64°, SD1.44° and TKA mean5.18°, SD1.35°). No changes in JPS were seen in the control side. A significant improvement (P< 0.0001) in sway area and path was found in the UKA group only in both limbs. No significant changes in sway occurred in either limb of TKA patients. The OKS improved from 21.4 to 35.5 for TKA patients and from 23.9 to 38for UKA patients.

Both UKA and TKA improve proprioception as assessed by JPS. However, UKA alone improves postural sway in both limbs. This may impart explain why UKA patients function better than TKA patients

Introduction: The factors causing chronic instability, a common sequela of ankle inversion sprains are unclear, despite wide investigation. However, few studies have examined potential factors during the injuring movement. We therefore measured the ability of dancers to control ankle movement during quiet stance and after a perturbation into inversion in a group with chronic instability (N=16) and healthy controls (N=26).

Methods: Control of ankle movement was determined by the magnitude of lateral oscillation at the ankle, measured by a 3SPACE Fastrak. The oscillation was measured during single leg stance (baseline oscillation) for two foot positions, flat and demi-pointe. In both positions, the time taken to return to the baseline oscillation after an inversion perturbation (perturbation time) of 15° for the flat foot and 7.5° for the demi-pointe position was also determined.

Results: The baseline oscillation was significantly smaller (P< 0.005) on the demi-pointe for the sprained group (2.5 ± 0.5 mm) than for controls (4.0 ± 2.3 mm). In addition, the perturbation time for the flat foot was significantly longer (P< 0.05) for the sprained group (2.2 ± 0.4 sec) than for controls (1.8 ± 0.5 sec). However, there was a higher (P< 0.05) failure rate among the sprained group for both the perturbation test with the foot flat and for baseline oscillation on the demi-pointe than among the controls.

Conclusions: Our findings demonstrate altered sensorimotor control in chronically unstable ankles. Those sprainers who successfully completed the tasks “braced” the ankle, allowing a small range of oscillation. The increased perturbation time in the sprained group may reflect a deficit in either detection of inversion movements, peroneal muscle response, or both.

Introduction: Numerous studies in the orthopaedic literature have reported changes in knee kinematics following rupture of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL). Gait analysis is currently the preferred method for studying these in vivo kinematics. The accuracy of this method of analysis remains limited due to errors related to skin movement artefact. Most studies have therefore been limited to analysing subjects performing simple tasks such as straight-line walking, since results become increasingly inaccurate as the subject moves faster. Standard skin marker formats allow measurements of knee flexion angle and varus/valgus angles to be recorded relatively accurately during such tasks. Accurate measurements of rotations and translations at the knee joint, however, are not possible with these set-ups.

Aim: To produce a new method for interpretation of kinematic data from gait analysis, to allow accurate measurement of 3-D displacements at the knee joint during dynamic activity.

Method: We employed two different sets of skin markers in an attempt to increase the accuracy of our data, by diminishing the effects of skin movement. The Kabada¹ marker set was used with retroreflective spheres of 14.5mm diameter. This marker set was used to establish 3-D femoral and tibial co-ordinate systems. We then established a femoral and tibial co-ordinate centre within the distal femur and proximal tibia respectively. A second set of markers was used similar to the “point-cluster” method described by Andriacchi et al². This involved groups of eight smaller spheres (9.5mm diameter) placed in a non-uniform distribution on each of the thigh and shank segments. The positions of all these remaining markers, relative to the co-ordinate centres were then established. 15 subjects were then recorded while performing a series of running and cutting tasks. For each trial that was then analysed, we used all visible markers to optimize the recorded position of the tibial and femoral co-ordinate centres, using a method similar to that described by Soderkvist³. The displacements of these co-ordinate centres were then used to calculate the 3-D tibio-femoral kinematics. Reliability and repeatability tests suggest that this method produces results accurate to 3–4mm.

Conclusion: We believe we have developed a practical and accurate method to analyse 3-D joint kinematics from gait laboratory data.

Introduction: Knee joint arthroplasty (total or unicompartmental) is the standard operative treatment for osteoarthritis (OA). Survival rate is good for both types but functional outcome is different. The function of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is substantially better than that of total knee arthroplasty (TKA). As function can be strongly influenced by proprioceptive ability, it is possible that improved outcome seen in patients with UKA results from retaining proprioceptive function associated with the cruciate ligaments. This prospective longitudinal study aimed to evaluate the change in proprioceptive performance after knee replacement; comparing TKA to UKA.

Methods and Materials: Two groups of patients with OA as diagnosed clinically and by X-ray were recruited. Group 1 consisted of 15 patients (mean age 65.8 years range 57–72 years, 10 females and 5 males) listed for TKA with the AGC prosthesis (Biomet, UK). Group 2 consisted of 19 patients (mean age 65.5 years range 52–75 years; 9 females and 10 males) listed for UKA with the Oxford UKA (Biomet, UK) for medial compartment OA. The ACL and PCL were present and preserved in all patients in Group 2, while only the PCL was preserved in Group 1 patients. Joint Position Sense (JPS) and postural sway were used as measures of proprioception performance. Both groups were assessed pre-and 6 months post-operatively in both limbs. JPS was measured using a dynamometer (KinCom, Chatanooga Ltd) as the error in actively and passively reproducing five randomly ordered knee flexion angles (30°, 40°, 50°, 60° and 70°). Postural sway (area, path and velocity) was measured during single leg stance using a Balance Performance Monitor (SMS Medical) for 30 seconds interval. Functional outcome was assessed using the Oxford Knee Score (OKS).

Results: Pre-operatively, no differences in JPS or sway were found between limbs in either group. No differences existed between the two groups. Post-operatively, both groups had significant improvement of JPS in the operated limb only (Mean ± standard deviation for UKA 4.64±1.44° and for TKA 5.18±1.35°). No changes in JPS were seen in the control side. An improvement in sway was found in the UKA group only. UKA patients showed significant improvement in both sway area and path (p< .0001) for both limbs post-operatively. No significant post-operative changes in sway occurred in either limb of TKA patients. The OKS improved postoperatively in both groups, rising from 21.4 to 35.5 for TKA patients and from 23.9 to 38 for UKA patients.

Conclusion: Interestingly, joint position sense improved for both groups but did not seem to show any difference between UKA and TKA. Postural sway was influenced by joint replacement type. Ligament retention may contribute to improved global postural control seen after unicompartmental knee arthroplasty and may explain the higher level of function seen in these patients.

Purpose This study aims to investigate blood flow in the femoral head during Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing (MMHR) through the posterior approach by monitoring oxygen concentration during the operative procedure.

Methods Following division of fascia lata, a calibrated gas-measuring electrode was inserted into the femoral neck, aiming for the anterolateral quadrant of the head. Baseline oxygen concentration levels were detected after electrode insertion 2–3cm below the femoral head surface and all intra-operative measures were referenced against these. Oxygen levels were continuously monitored throughout the operation. Results of measurements from ten patients are presented.

Results Oxygen concentration was reduced during the surgical approach and average oxygen concentration following dislocation and circumferential capsulotomy dropped to 43% of baseline (Std.dev +/−37%), this was a highly significant reduction (p< 0.005). Insertion of implants resulted in a further significant drop in oxygen concentration (p< 0.02) to 16% of baseline (Std. dev +/−27%). Oxygen concentration rose slightly after relocation of the resurfaced joint and reconstruction of posterior soft tissues, reaching 22% (Std.dev +/−31%) of initial baseline oxygen levels. Considerable variation between subjects was observed. Three subjects had no remaining oxygen concentration at the end of surgery.

Conclusion Intra-operative measurement of oxygen concentration in blood perfusing the femoral head is feasible. During MMHR there is a dramatic decrease in femoral oxygenation during surgical approach and implant fixation. This may increase the risk of avascular necrosis and subsequent femoral neck fracture. Future experiments will determine if less invasive procedures or a different approach can protect the blood supply to femoral neck and head.

Aims: The purpose of this study is to determine the causes of failed medial Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) and assess the outcome after revision surgery.

Materials And Methods: From 1993 to 2003, sixty-nine Oxford UKA (58 patients) were revised to a total knee replacements (TKR) at this centre. The type of implant used at revision surgery, pre- and post-revision American Knee Society (AKS) and Tegner scores were analyzed retrospectively.

Results: The patient’s mean age at the time of UKA was 64.5 years (range: 50–79). The average pre-revision scores were as follows: AKS-Objective score was 41.2 (± 10.4), the AKS-functional score was 56.8 (±10.0) and the average Tegner score was 1.5 (±0.6). The mean follow-up period was 38.3 (range: 12–107) months. The common causes of failure were: lateral compartment osteoarthritis (34.0%), component loosening (30.4%) and early or late infection requiring two-stage revision surgery (14.3%). The majority were revised using a standard primary TKR implant and only six (9%) requiring augmentation stems. Patellar resurfacing was performed in 25% of cases. The mean polyethylene liner width of the revision TKR was 13.4mm (±3.7). The average post-revision scores were: AKS-Objective score 77.4 (±13.1), the AKS-functional AKS score 70 (±21.1) and the average Tegner score of 2.2 (±0.8). Three knees needed rerevision for infection of the revised implant.

Conclusions: Lateral compartment osteoarthritis was the commonest indication for revision surgery for a failed medial Oxford UKA. Revision of a UKA is technically easier and the results are superior to the published results of revision of a primary TKR. In more than 90% cases, no augmentation or stemmed implants were necessary.

Introduction: The incidence of femoral neck fracture is approximately 2% after resurfacing hip replacement. Avascular necrosis is thought to be a contributory factor. The aim of this study was to investigate oxygen concentration in the femoral head during metal-on-metal hip resurfacing (MMHR).

Materials and Methods: In ten patients, following division of the fascia lata, a calibrated gas-measuring electrode was inserted into the supero-lateral quadrant of the femoral head via the femoral neck. Xsrays confirmed placement of the electrode 2-3 cms below the femoral head surface. Baseline oxygen concentration levels were recorded immediately upon electrode insertion and used as a reference for all intra-operative measures. Oxygen levels were monitored continuously throughout the operation.

Results: Oxygen concentration was reduced during the surgical approach and average oxygen concentration following dislocation and circumferential capsulotomy dropped significantly (p< 0.005) to 38% of baseline (SD=26%). Insertion of implants resulted in a further significant drop in oxygen concentration (p< 0.04) to 21% of baseline (SD=28%). Oxygen concentration rose slightly, but not significantly after relocation of the resurfaced joint and reconstruction of posterior soft tissues, reaching 22% of initial baseline oxygen levels. Considerable variation between subjects was observed.

Discussion: Intra-operative measurement of oxygen concentration in blood perfusing the femoral head is possible. During MMHR there is a dramatic decrease in femoral head oxygenation during surgical approach and implant fixation. This may increase the risk of avascular necrosis and subsequent femoral neck fracture. Future experiments will determine if a different surgical approach can protect the blood supply to the femoral head and neck. Measurements of femoral head oxygenation during metal-on-metal hip resurfacing demonstrated a significant concentration decrease during surgical approach and implant fixation.

Introduction: The indications for medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) remain controversial; in particular, those relating to the state of the patello-femoral joint (PFJ). Some authorities consider the presence of anterior knee pain (AKP) and/or full thickness cartilage loss (FTCL) to be a contraindication. The aim of this study was to determine the influence of patello-femoral problems on the outcome of medial UKA.

Materials and Methods: This prospective study involved one hundred knees with cemented medial Oxford UKA (phase 3), via a minimally invasive approach. Pre-operatively presence or absence of AKP was noted. The cartilage status of medial and lateral patello-femoral joint was grade and recorded intra-operatively. Outcome was evaluated at one-year with the Knee Society Score and the Oxford Knee Score (OKS).

Results: 54% of patients had pre-operative AKP. The clinical outcome at one year was not dependent on the presence or absence of pre-operative AKP [OKS: 40.2 (± 8.2) for patients without pre-op. AKP and OKS: 40.8 ((± 6.8) for patients with pre-operative AKP]. 35% of patients had FTCL seen at operation in the PFJ. The outcome at one year was independent of the state of the medial and/or lateral PFJ [OKS = 40.7 (± 7) with normal or partial thickness cartilage loss and OKS = 39.8 (± 7) with full thickness cartilage loss in PFJ]

Conclusions: These short-term results suggest that for the Oxford UKA the presence of anterior knee pain or full thickness cartilage damage in patello-femoral joint should not be considered to be a contraindication.

Introduction Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing (MMHR) has been established as a successful alternative to Total Hip Replacement (THR). However, several series report a 2 % incidence of early femoral neck fractures. Avascular necrosis (AVN) was considered to be responsible for the majority of observed fractures, raising concerns about the femoral head blood supply during MMHR. This study aims to further understand the mechanisms of femoral blood flow restriction by monitoring gas levels (O2) during the operative procedure.

Methods Patients undergoing MMHR using the posterior approach were evaluated. Following division of fascia lata, a guide wire was introduced up the femoral neck, aiming for the anterosuperior quadrant of the head. It was then removed. A calibrated gas-measuring electrode was inserted in the created bone channel. X-ray confirmation was obtained to ensure that the active measurement area of the electrode was 2–3cm below the femoral surface. O2 and N2O levels were then continuously monitored throughout the operation.

Results A preliminary analysis of four patients is presented: Stable N2O- measurements throughout the procedure confirmed valid electrode measurements. Baseline oxygen concentration levels of 40%– 60% were detected before division of short rotators. After hip dislocation oxygen concentration dropped in all patients to levels ranging between 0% and 5%. Oxygen concentration was found to remain depressed at these levels throughout the entire operation in three patients. Recovery of O2 concentration to baseline levels was observed in one patient 15 minutes after dislocation.

Discussion In three patients the extended posterior approach and joint dislocation had a dramatic effect on the perfusion in the femoral head. These patients have a high risk for development of AVN and potential femoral neck fracture. Whilst the results require further verification, subsequent experiments will determine if less invasive procedures or specific positioning of the limb can protect the femoral blood supply.

Introduction: The Charnley Elite femoral component was first introduced in 1992 as a new design variant of the original Charnley femoral component (De Puy, Leeds, UK) with modified neck and stem geometry. The original component had undergone few changes in nearly forty years and has excellent long-term results.

Early migration of the new stem design was determined by Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis (RSA). Rapid early migration of a component relative to the bone, measured by RSA, is predictive of subsequent aseptic loosening for a number of femoral stems. As there was rapid early migration and rotation of the Charnley Elite stem, we predicted that the long-term results would be poor. An outcome assessment is required as stems of this type are still being implanted.

Materials and method: One hundred Charnley Elite stems, implanted in our centre between 1994 and 1997 were included in a prospective, cross-sectional follow-up study. Outcome measures include validated clinical scores (Charnley hip score, Harris hip score and Oxford hip score) and radiological scores (Gruen classification) as well as revision rates over the past 10 years.

Results: The preliminary analysis results are given. The mean time to follow-up was 8.28 years. 20 patients have died due to causes unrelated to their operations. 10 patients had stem revisions: 9 for aseptic loosening and 1 for a peri-prosthetic fracture. This indicates a significant 10% failure rate of the prosthesis in less than 10 years.

Preliminary clinical scores in the patients who had not undergone any subsequent surgery were adequate (Oxford Hip Score mean average of 23.9).

Thirteen percent of radiographs analysed had evidence of loosening, giving an overall loosening rate of 14% at 8 years.

Discussion and conclusion: The clinical follow-up supports the RSA predictions of early failure of the Charnley Elite femoral stem.

Polyethylene particulate wear debris continues to be implicated in the aetiology of aseptic loosening following knee arthroplasty. The Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty employs a spherical femoral component and a fully congruous meniscal bearing to increase contact area and theoretically reduce the potential for polyethylene wear. This study measures the in vivo ten-year linear wear of the device, using a roentgenstereophotogrammetric technique.

In this in vivo study, seven medial Oxford unicompartmental prostheses, which had been implanted ten years previously were studied. Stereo pairs of radiographs were acquired for each patient and the films were analysed using a roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis calibration and a computer-aided design model silhouette-fitting technique. Penetration of the femoral component into the original volume of the bearing was our estimate of linear wear. In addition, eight control patients were examined less than three weeks post-insertion of an Oxford prosthesis, where no wear would be expected. The control group showed no measured wear and suggested a system accuracy of 0.1 mm. At ten years, the mean linear wear rate was 0.02 mm/year.

The results from this in vivo study confirm that the device has low ten-year linear wear in clinical practice. This may offer the device a survival advantage in the long term.

Introduction: Total knee replacement (TKR) is a common treatment for end stage osteoarthritis of knee. The best knee replacement is one in which the kinematics of the normal knee are reproduced. Amongst several factors affecting kinematics, variation in surface geometry and the retention/ sacrifice of the PCL are considered especially important. It is not known which of these two factors is most influential for establishing optimum joint kinematics after TKR.

Method: Four groups of patients who had undergone TKR at least one year previously were recruited. Two groups of patients had undergone replacement with a single axis design (Scorpio, Stryker Howmedica) in both PCL retaining (Scorpio CR, n=15) and PCL sacrificing (Scorpio CS, n=15) variants. The other two groups had undergone replacement with the traditional polyradial design prosthesis (Sigma, Depuy, Johnson & Johnson), again with both PCL retaining (Sigma CR, n=14) and PCL sacrificing (Sigma CS, n=13) variants. An in-vivo fluoroscopic analysis was carried out on all patients. Patients were asked to perform closed chain step up and open chain extension and flexion against gravity. The kinematic profile of each knee was obtained by measuring patella tendon angle (PTA) at specific angles of knee flexion (KFA) using an established fluoroscopic method. The data was also compared with the kinematic profile of normal knees. American Knee Society, Oxford and Patella Scores were recorded for all patients.

Results: All groups were comparable in terms of age and gender. In addition, no significant difference was found between groups in clinical outcome. PTA results for a step-up exercise are shown in the figure. A one way ANOVA between groups revealed that knee kinematics after total knee replacement is different to that for normal knees. No differences were found between groups when the data was analysed using CR/CS as the independent variable. The only differences between groups were found when surface geometry was used as the independent variable. It was shown that the kinematic profile of the single axis Scorpio design (in both CR & CS ) was closer to normal, especially near extension, than the traditional polyradial design (Sigma CR & CS).

Conclusions: Kinematics after a total knee replacement differ from that for a normal knee. Differences in surface design between knee replacements appear to have greater influence on kinematics than the presence or absence of the PCL.

Introduction and Aims: Since existing data relating to the kinematics of ACL-deficient knee joints relates mainly to walking, the kinematics during more dynamic activities remains unknown; therefore, the aim of this unique study was to describe in vivo ACL-deficient knee kinematics and muscle activity during running and cutting.

Method: Fifteen subjects with proven unilateral ACL rupture were measured performing running and cutting tasks prior to surgical reconstruction. Gait analysis was used to determine inter-limb differences in displacements at the knee joint during stance phase. Simultaneous EMG analysis was performed to give temporal measures of lower limb muscle activity.

Results: No significant inter-limb difference was seen for tibio-femoral translation in the sagittal or coronal planes during any part of stance phase. The ACLD limb showed a significantly reduced maximum knee flexion angle (40.4 vs. 44.0 degrees) compared to the ACL-intact (ACLI) limb (p=0.04). Internal tibial rotation was significantly greater (7.3 vs. 0.7 degrees) in the ACLD limb at toe-off (p=0.03). The quadriceps muscle group was found to be active for a significantly greater percentage of stance phase in the ACLD limb compared to the ACLI limb (p=0.001).

Conclusion: The ACL-deficient gait involves consistently greater knee extensor activity than ACL-intact gait during running, and as a consequence maximum knee flexion angle is reduced. These findings contrast with the description of ‘quadriceps-avoidance’ gait often described for ACL-deficient subjects. ACL-deficient gait also demonstrates increased rotational instability during terminal stance phase.

Introduction and Aims: Single compartmental replacement procedures are increasingly preferred over total knee replacement (TKR) for single compartment osteoarthritis of the knee joint. Theoretically, reduced disruption of the native joint should produce more normal kinematics. This study aimed to describe and compare the sagittal plane kinematics of four different, commonly used devices.

Method: Four groups of patients who had undergone successful single compartment replacement at least two years previously were recruited. Fifteen following Oxford medial UKA, 12 following medial St Georg Sled UKA, five following Oxford lateral UKA, and 12 following Avon PFJ replacement. Patients performed flexion/extension against gravity, and a step-up during video fluoroscopy. The Patellar Tendon Angle (PTA), the angle between the long axis of the tibia and the patella tendon, was obtained as a function of knee flexion. This relationship provides indication of sagittal movement between femur and tibia through range and has been validated as a reliable measure of joint kinematics.

Results: The kinematic profile for each group was compared to that of the profile for 12 normal and 30 TKR (AGC) knees. All three tibiofemoral devices produced knee kinematics similar to the normal knee. The PTA was found to have a linear relationship to flexion angle, decreasing with increasing knee flexion angle. No such linear relationship exists for the TKR joint, which display abnormal kinematics. The PF device also reflected similar trends to that for normal knees except that the PTA was moderately increased throughout the entire range of flexion (three degrees).

Conclusion: In contrast to TKR, all single compartmental knee replacements provided kinematics similar to the normal joint. The kinematic pattern of the PFJ replacement may be of most interest as the observed increase in PTA through range could influence patello-femoral contact forces

Introduction and Aims: Uni-compartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is appropriate for one in three osteoarthritic knees requiring replacement. An accelerated protocol enables patients undergoing UKA to be discharged within 24 hours of surgery. Before such an approach is universally accepted it must be safe, effective and economically viable. A study was performed to compare the new accelerated protocol with current standard care in a state healthcare system.

Method: A single blind RCT design was used. Patients eligible for UKA were screened for NSAID tolerance, social circumstances and geographical location before allocation to either an accelerated recovery group (Group A) or a standard non-accelerated group (Group S). The accelerated protocol included dedicated pain management and discharge support. Primary outcome was the Oxford Knee Assessment at six months post-operation, compared using independent t tests. Pain, range of movement and incidence of complications were also recorded by assessors blind to group allocation. Cost effectiveness was calculated in quality life adjusted years (QLAY) using the Euroqual instrument. The study power was sufficient to avoid type 2 errors. The study was supported by a NHS Regional R& D grant.

Results: Forty-one patients (21 group A, 20 group S) were included. Groups had comparable age and patient profiles. Average discharge time was 37 hours (1.5 days) for group A and 114 hours (4.3 days) for group S. Pain on hospital discharge was similar for both groups. No significant difference was found between groups for pain or range of movement at any time, although patients in group S regained pre-operative flexion faster than group A. One major complication occurred in each group; one infection (group S) and one manipulation for poor movement (group A). The cost per QLAY for the new protocol was 59% of the standard care.

Conclusion: The new protocol allows for safe accelerated discharge from hospital after UKA. The approach is cost-effective and should help to increase the throughput of patients who require knee replacement.

Introduction and Aims: The purpose of this study was to analyse the results of a new intramedullary retrograde humeral nail used for fixation of difficult fractures of humerus.

Method: In Airedale NHS Trust and Calderdale hospitals, 282 patients were treated for displaced humeral fractures. The new nail called Halder Humeral Nail (HHN) was inserted from the olecranon roof proximally towards the head of humerus. It had a specialised locking system by opening of a trio wire at the proximal head of humerus and distally near the elbow the nail was locked with the help of a screw on a plate. Patients were mobilised immediately after surgery in a polysling.

Results: At six weeks, 95% of patients were pain free and could perform daily activities comfortably. Average post-operative Constance score was 74.7. Complications included proximal migration of the nail and the trio wire in seven cases; six patients had non-union and one patient had infection. Breakage of trio wire was seen in five cases. This resulted in modification of the nail by introducing an additional screw to lock at proximal humerus around the trio wires.

Conclusion: We concluded that stable internal fixation and a good fracture union could be achieved by this new HHN, especially in a displaced humeral fracture, even in poor quality bone with fracture at different level. Pain-free movements, and early recovery was possible without damaging the rotator cuff and risking the axillary nerve.

Introduction and Aims Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is appropriate for one in three osteoarthritic knees requiring replacement. An accelerated protocol enables patients undergoing UKA to be discharged within 24 hours of surgery. Before such an approach is universally accepted it must be safe, effective and economically viable. A study was performed to compare the new accelerated protocol with current standard care in a state healthcare system.

Method A single blind RCT design was used. Patients eligible for UKA were screened for NSAID tolerance, social circumstances and geographical location before allocation to either an accelerated recovery group (Group A) or a standard non accelerated group (Group S). The accelerated protocol included dedicated pain management and discharge support. Primary outcome was the Oxford Knee Assessment at 6 months post operation, compared using independent t tests. Pain, range of movement and incidence of complications were also recorded by assessors blind to group allocation. Cost effectiveness was calculated in quality life adjusted years (QLAY) using the Euroqual instrument. The study power was sufficient to avoid type 2 errors. The study was supported by a NHS Regional R& D grant.

Results Forty one patients (21 group A, 20 group S) were included. Groups had comparable age and patient profiles. Average discharge time was 37 hours (1.5 days) for group A and 114 hours (4.3 days) for group S. Pain on hospital discharge was similar for both groups. No significant difference was found between groups for pain or range of movement at any time, although patients in group S regained pre-operative flexion faster than group A. One major complication occurred in each group; one infection (group S) and one manipulation for poor movement (group A). The cost per QLAY for the new protocol was 59% of the standard care.

Conclusion The new protocol allows for safe accelerated discharge from hospital after UKA. The approach is cost effective and should help to increase the throughput of patients who require knee replacement.

Introduction: Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is an increasingly popular procedure for young osteoarthritic patients whose age and activity levels preclude the use of a total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, successful reconstruction using an unconstrained mobile bearing implant requires an intact and functioning ACL. Patients with isolated medial compartment OA and an absent ACL therefore provide a management dilemma for the treating surgeon. One option is to perform a combined ACL reconstruction and mobile bearing UKA. This paper presents early results of this new procedure using an Oxford UKA and ACL reconstruction using an autograft.

Materials and Methods: Eleven patients who underwent one or two-staged ACL reconstruction and Oxford UKA for treatment of symptomatic medial compartment OA were reviewed at one year after surgery. The combined procedure required specific precautions and considerations; care had to be taken to place the tibial tunnel as far laterally as possible to avoid impingement of the graft by the tibial implant. Also, the presence of a posteromedial, rather than an anteromedial cartilage defect has the potential to reduce accuracy for placement of the initial tibial cut.

Results: All patients were male with an average age of 49 years (range: 36 – 52) and mean follow up of 1.3 years. One patient needed revision to TKA due to infection. The objective and functional knee society scores improved pre to post operatively from 55 to 98, and 85 to 100, respectively.

Conclusions: ACL reconstruction and simultaneous or staged UKA is a viable treatment option for patients with symptomatic medial compartment arthritis in whom the ACL is absent. Early results of this technically demanding procedure are encouraging but longer follow-up is required.

Purpose of the study Function is strongly infl uenced by proprioceptive ability, this prospective longitudinal study aimed to evaluate the change in proprioceptive performance after knee replacement; comparing total to unicompartment replacement.

Methods and Results Two groups of patients with OA as diagnosed clinically and by X-ray were recruited. Group 1 consisted of 15 patients (mean age 65.8yrs range 57-72yrs, 10 females & 5 males) listed for Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) with the AGC (Biomet, UK). Group 2 consisted of 19 patients (mean age 65.5yrs range 52–75yrs; 9 females & 10 males) listed for Oxford Uni-compartmental Knee Arthroplasty (OUKA) for medial compartment OA. The ACL and PCL were present and preserved in all patients in Group 2, while only the PCL was preserved for Group 1 patients.

Joint Position Sense (JPS) & sway were used as measures of proprioception performance. Both groups were assessed pre- and 6 months post-op. JPS was measured using an isokinetic dynamometer (KinCom, Chatanooga Ltd) as the error in actively and passively reproducing fi ve randomly ordered knee fl exion angles (30°, 40°, 50°, 60° and 70°). Sway (area, path and velocity) was measured during single leg stance using a Balance Performance Monitor (SMS Medical) for 30-second interval. Functional outcome was assessed using the Oxford Knee Score (OKS).

Pre-operatively, no differences in JPS or sway were found between limbs in either group. No differences existed between the two groups.

Post-operatively, both groups had signifi cant improvement of JPS in the operated limb only (Mean ± standard deviation for UKA 4.64±1.44° and for TKA 5.18±1.35°). No changes in JPS were seen in the control side. Group 2 patients showed signifi cant improvement in both sway area and path (p< .0001) for both limbs post-operatively. No signifi cant post-operative changes in sway occurred in either limb of Group 1 patients.

The OKS improved post-operatively in both groups, rising from 21.4 to 35.5 for Group 1 patients and from 23.9 to 38 for Group 2 patients.

Conclusion Interestingly, joint position sense improved for both groups but did not seem to show any difference between UKA and TKA. Postural sway was infl uenced by joint replacement type. Ligament retention may contribute to improved global postural control seen after unicompartmental knee arthroplasty and may explain the higher level of function seen in these patients.

Introduction and Aims A randomised controlled trial (RCT) and a multi-centre unilateral cohort study were performed as part of the stepwise introduction of a new mobile bearing knee. The aim was to ensure that outcome for the new device was at least as good as that for an established fixed bearing device. This paper presents three year follow up of the published one year results. Instability and prevalence of “clicking” from the joint were examined in detail.

Method 1. A multi-centre RCT of patients undergoing bilateral knee replacement compared functional outcome between two different prostheses, the new mobile bearing device (TMK) and an established fixed bearing device (AGC). 2. A separate multi-centre cohort of 166 patients who had undergone a unilateral mobile bearing procedure at least six months previously was used to assess complication rate and corroborate any findings from the bilateral trial. Outcome measures included Oxford Knee Scores, American Knee Society ratings and complication rate.

Results The bilateral trial revealed no significant differences in outcome between the two devices. Revision rate for all (199) mobile bearing knees was less than 2%. The mean Oxford Knee Score for outcome for all mobile bearing knees was 37.1 ± 10.1. About 7% of patients reported instability. Clicking was more common in the TMK (48%) than in the AGC (30%) and was reported as a problem in 16% of TMK’s in the cohort study. However, clicking was unrelated to outcome score in both studies.

Conclusion At three years, the mobile bearing device was as good as the fixed bearing device. There was a relatively high prevalence of “clicking” in the TMK but the cause remains unclear. Furthermore, the symptom was not associated with poor functional outcome. The bilateral RCT and cohort study allows assessment of function and potential problems. It provides rigourous scientific justification for the introduction and early assessment of new implants.

There has been a rapid uptake in the use of Resurfacing Hip Replacement (RHR) in the United Kingdom, and its use is likely to accelerate both in Europe and the USA. The current level of use of RHR is not accurately known.

It was decided to audit the use of RHR amongst Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeons in the United Kingdom, and to identify the number of operations performed in the last twelve month period, and the specific training undertaken before offering this procedure.

A questionnaire was sent to 1600 Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeons with 894 responding.

19% had performed RHR in the previous year.

Excluding surgeons that do not perform Total Hip Replacement, 23.5% of surgeons had performed RHR.

29.5% of all orthopaedic surgeons had observed RHR surgery and 23% had been on an RHR course. 65% of all consultants who had attended a course were offering RHR surgery.

7.8% of those performing RHR had neither been on a course nor observed surgery.

There was no relationship between years in practice and RHR surgery.

There was a weak association with British Hip Society membership and with a previous fellowship in Hip Surgery.

Of those performing RHR, 72% perform less than 20 cases per year. The majority of surgeons perform 6-10 RHRs per year.

Although interest in RHR is increasing, it is currently performed by the minority of consultants. Given the steep learning curve, the lack of knowledge of long-term survival, and concerns regarding metal on metal bearing surfaces, RHR should be used by surgeons with a specialist interest in hip arthroplasty. We believe RHR should be used in accordance with the guidance given by the National Institute for Clinical Excellence.

Aim: To compare the kinematic profile of two types of TKRs – a single-axis design Vs a polyradial design, with that of the normal knee.

Methodology: An in-vivo fluoroscopic analysis was carried out as part of a four-armed prospective randomised trial comparing the clinical outcome of two commonly used types of TKRs each with posterior cruciate retaining -CR and sacrificing –CS models. The kinematic profile was obtained by measuring patella tendon angle at specific angles of knee flexion using an established fluoroscopic method whilst the patients performed close and open chain exercises. The data was compared with the kinematic profile of the normal knee.

Results: Fifty-five patients who had undergone TKR at least one year prior, were invited to take part in this ethically approved study. They were matched for age and gender and had a similar clinical outcome.

The kinematic profile of single axis design TKR was closer to normal especially near extension. During mid-flexion, abnormal anterior femoral translation was noticed with the polyradial design. No significant difference was noted between CR and CS designs.

Conclusions: Kinematics after a TKR differed from that of a normal knee. Reproducible differences were found between the two designs, which may predict mode of failure and longevity.

Introduction: Oxford Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is now performed using a minimally invasive surgical (MIS) technique. Although early results are encouraging, the studies assessing outcome could be criticised for the restricted number of patients and centres involved. A multi-centre follow-up of patients is required to confirm the preliminary findings.

Aim: To examine early clinical outcome in patients with minimally invasive Oxford medial UKA using a multi-centre, multi-surgeon design.

Materials and Methods: This prospective study was carried out in three centres with involvement of six surgeons. All patients undergoing cemented Oxford UKA for medial OA using MIS were included. 231 consecutive UKAs with a minimum follow up of 2 years (mean: 2.84) were assessed using objective and functional Knee Society Score (KSS).

Results: There were 108 females and 102 males (21-bilateral) with average age of 66.8 years (42 – 86). No significant difference was noted between various age groups or between different surgeons. Three knees were revised: one for infection, one for unexplained pain and one for bearing dislocation. Cumulative survival rate at 2 years was 98.6% with 93% patients having good or excellent KSS rating.

Conclusions: This multi-centre study has confirmed preliminary findings that Oxford UKA using a minimally invasive approach is safe and effective.

Aim: To study the sagittal plane kinematics of the Avon patello-femoral replacement (Stryker-Howmedica), PTA.

Introduction: Replacement of the patello-femoral joint for end stage osteoarthritis has previously been associated with inconsistent results. Retention of the cruciate ligaments is likely to be important in maintaining normal kinematics and hence improved functional outcome.

Methodology: Twelve patients who had undergone Avon PFR least two years previously were recruited following ethical approval. American Knee Society, Bristol and Oxford knee scores were obtained. Patients performed open chain flexion and extension against gravity, in addition to closed chain step up. Video fluoroscopy of these activities was used to obtain the Patellar Tendon Angle (PTA), which is the angle between the long axis of the tibia and the patella tendon, at specific angles of knee flexion. This is a previously validated method of assessing the kinematic profile of a knee joint. These measurements were used to determine the kinematic profile of each knee and they were then compared to a group of twelve normal knees.

Results: A one way ANOVA revealed no significant differences between the kinematic profile following Avon PFR and that of the normal knee. All patients had good or excellent knee scores.

Conclusion: The kinematic profile after Avon PFR is similar to that of the normal knee. In contrast all TKRs we have studied have abnormal kinematics, which are associated with abnormal patello-femoral joint loading. This suggests that isolated PFR should have a functional advantage over TKR.

Introduction: Lateral uni-compartmental knee replacement (UKR) is seldom indicated and remains controversial. It has been considered a technically challenging operation with variable success. Aim: The aim of this paper is to assess the results of unicompartmental knee replacement using a þxed noncongruous prosthesis. Methods: Eighty-eight knees in 79 patients with lateral unicompartmental osteoarthritis treated with a þxed bearing, non-congruous, fully unconstrained prosthesis. (St Georg Sled UKR) over a period of 21 years by different consultants and there trainees. Surgical approach and rehabilitation protocol varied over this period but there was no change in the surgical indications. Results: At a mean follow up of 9 years (range 2 to 21 years). Fifteen knees had revision surgery (9 for progression of arthritis and 6 for component loosening, 4 for implant breakage and 4 for more than one reason). Six patients complained of moderate or severe pain at þnal follow up. Only þve knees were lost to follow up in the 21-year period. Survivorship analysis was performed on the group using revision for any cause as the end point. At ten years the cumulative survival rate was 83% and at 15 years, when ten knees were still at risk, the cumulative survival rate was 74%. Conclusion: Based on our clinical results and survival rate the St Georg Sled UKR can be considered a suitable treatment for isolated lateral compartment osteoarthritis.