The benefits of combining enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) interventions with an outpatient THA/TKA program are uncertain. The primary objective was to compare adverse event rate and secondly to compare pain management, functional recovery, PROMs and patients' satisfaction. We conducted an ambidirectional single subject cohort study on 48 consecutive patients who experienced both a standard-inpatient and an ERAS-outpatient THA/TKA (contralaterally). We compared complications according to Clavien-Dindo scale and Comprehensive Complications Index (CCI), and unplanned episodes of care. Postoperative pain assessed with a numeric rating scale, opioid consumption in morphine milligram equivalents, functional recovery, patient-reported outcome measures (WOMAC, KOOS, HOOS, Forgotten Joint Score and Patient Joint Perception) and patients' satisfaction were also evaluated.INTRODUCTION
METHODS
Mechanical alignment (MA) techniques for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) may introduce significant anatomic modifications, as it is known that few patients have neutral femoral, tibial or overall lower limb mechanical axes. A total of 1000 knee CT-Scans were analyzed from a database of patients undergoing TKA. MA tibial and femoral bone resections were simulated. Femoral rotation was aligned with either the trans-epicondylar axis (TEA) or with 3° of external rotation to the posterior condyles (PC). Medial-lateral (DML) and flexion-extension (DFE) gap differences were calculated. Extension space ML imbalances (3mm) occurred in 25% of varus and 54% of valgus knees and significant imbalances (5mm) were present in up to 8% of varus and 19% of valgus knees. For the flexion space DML, higher imbalance rates were created by the TEA technique (p < 0 .001). In valgus knees, TEA resulted in a DML in flexion of 5 mm in 42%, compared to 7% for PC. In varus knees both techniques performed better. When all the differences between DML and DFE are considered together, using TEA there were 18% of valgus knees and 49% of varus knees with < 3 mm imbalances throughout, and using PC 32% of valgus knees and 64% of varus knees. Significant anatomic modifications with related ML or FE gap imbalances are created using MA for TKA. Using MA techniques, PC creates less imbalances than TEA. Some of these imbalances may not be correctable by the surgeon and may explain post-operative TKA instability. Current imaging technology could predict preoperatively these intrinsic imitations of MA. Other alignment techniques that better reproduce knee anatomies should be explored.
Assessing patients' functional outcomes following total hip arthroplasty with traditional scoring systems is limited by their ceiling effects. The Forgotten Joint Score (FJS) has been suggested as a more discriminating option. The actual score in the FJS which constitutes a “forgotten joint”, however, has not been defined. The emerging concept of joint perception led to the development of the Patient's Joint Perception question (PJP) to assess the patient's opinion of their prosthetic joint. Two hundred fifty-seven THAs were assessed at a mean of 68 months follow-up (range 57–79). Outcomes included the WOMAC, FJS and the PJP. Correlation of the scores as well as the ceiling effects were analysed The mean FJS was 88.5 (range 27.1–100). PJP was correlated with the FJS and WOMAC (Spearman's rho: −0.510 and 0.465 respectively). Fifty-two percent of the patients felt their hip as a natural joint (FJS CI 95% 93.3–96), 24.1% as an artificial joint with no restriction (FJS CI 95% 83.1–90.5), and 23.3% as an artificial joint with minor restrictions (FJS CI 95% 73.8–82.2). Only 0.8% had major restrictions and none reported a non-functional joint. The ceiling effect was high with both the WOMAC and FJS, with 27.2% and 31.9%. In addition, 28.6% of the patients had a WOMAC >10 and 23.4% a FJS of < 9 0 while reporting having a natural hip. Furthermore, 21.5% with a perfect WOMAC or 21.9% with a perfect FJS, reported having an artificial joint with or without limitation. A forgotten hip perception corresponds to a FJS >93. In 20–30% of the cases, the WOMAC and FJS failed to identify the forgotten joint, or reached the maximum score when the patients did not feel their hip was natural. The PJP is a simple and reliable tool that enables identification of patients that feel their hip is natural.
For many years, achieving a neutral coronal Hip-Knee-Ankle angle (HKA) measured on radiographs has been considered a factor of success for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Lower limb HKA is influenced by the acquisition conditions, and static HKA (sHKA) may not be representative of the dynamic loading that occurs during gait. The primary aim of the study was to see if the sHKA is predictive of the dynamic HKA (dHKA). A secondary aim was to document to what degree the dHKA changes throughout gait. We analysed the 3-D knee kinematics during gait of a cohort of 90 healthy individuals (165 knees) with the KneeKG™ system. dHKA was calculated and compared with sHKA values. Knees were considered “Stable” if the dHKA remained positive or negative – i.e. in valgus or varus – for greater than 95% of the corresponding phase and “Changer” otherwise. Patient characteristics of the Stable and Changer knees were compared to find contributing factors. The dHKA absolute variation during gait was 10.9±5.3° [2 .4° – 28.3°] for the whole cohort. The variation was greater for the varus knees (10.3±4.8° [2.4° – 26.3°]), than for the valgus knees (12.8±6.1° [2.9° – 28.3°], p=0.008). We found a low to moderate correlation (r = 0.266 to 0.553, p < 0 .001) between sHKA and the dHKA values for varus knees and no correlation valgus knees. Twenty two percent (36/165) of the knees demonstrated a switch in the dHKA (Changer). Proportion of Changer knees was 15% for varus sHKA versus 39% for valgus sHKA (p < 0.001). Lower limb radiographic measures of coronal alignment have limited value for predicting dynamic measures of alignment during gait.
Mechanical alignment (MA) techniques for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) introduces significant anatomic modifications and secondary ligament imbalances. A restricted kinematic alignment (rKA) protocol was proposed to minimise these issues and improve TKA clinical results. A total of 1000 knee CT-Scans were analyzed from a database of patients undergoing TKA. rKA tibial and femoral bone resections were simulated. rKA is defined by the following criteria: Independent tibial and femoral cuts within ± 5° of the bone neutral mechanical axis and, a resulting HKA within ± 3° of neutral. Medial-lateral (ΔML) and flexion-extension (ΔFE) gap differences were calculated and compared with MA results. With the MA technique, femoral rotation was aligned with either the trans-epicondylar axis (TEA) or with 3° of external rotation to the posterior condyles (PC). Extension space ML imbalances (>/=3mm) occurred in 33% of TKA with MA technique versus 8% of the knees with rKA (p /=5mm) were present in up to 11% of MA knees versus 1% rKA (p < 0 .001). Using the MA technique, for the flexion space ΔML, higher imbalance rates were created by the TEA technique (p < 0 .001). rKA again performed better than both MA techniques using TEA of 3 degrees PC techniques (p < 0 .001). When all the differences between ΔML and ΔFE are considered together: using TEA there were 40.8% of the knees with < 3 mm imbalances throughout, using PC this was 55.3% and using rKA it was 91.5% of the knees (p < 0 .001). Significantly less anatomic modifications with related ML or FE gap imbalances are created using rKA versus MA for TKA. Using rKA may help the surgeon to balance a TKA, whilst keeping the alignment within a safe range.
Achieving a neutral static Hip-Knee-Ankle angle (sHKA) measured on radiographs has been considered a factor of success for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, recent studies have shown that sHKA seems to have no effect on TKA survivorship. sHKA is not representative of the dynamic loading occurring during gait, unlike the dynamic HKA (dHKA). The primary objective was to see if the sHKA is predictive of the dynamic HKA (dHKA). A secondary objective was to document to what degree the dHKA changes during gait.Background
Research question
In recent years, there has been a shift toward outpatient and short-stay protocols for patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty (THA) and total knee arthroplasty (TKA). We developed a peri-operative THA and TKA short stay protocol following the Enhance Recovery After Surgery principles (ERAS), aiming at both optimizing patients’ outcomes and reducing the hospital length of stay. The objective of this study was to evaluate the implementation of our ERAS short-stay protocol. We hypothesized that our ERAS THA and TKA short-stay protocol would result in a lower complication rate, shorter hospital length of stay and reduced direct health care costs compared to our standard procedure. We compared the complications rated according to Clavien-Dindo scale, hospital length of stay and costs of the episode of care between a prospective cohort of 120 ERAS short-stay THA or TKA and a matched historical control group of 150 THA or TKA.INTRODUCTION
METHODS
Mechanical alignment (MA) techniques for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) introduce significant anatomic modifications and secondary ligament imbalances. A restricted kinematic alignment (rKA) protocol was proposed to minimize these issues and improve TKA clinical results. rKA tibial and femoral bone resections were simulated on 1000 knee CT-Scans from a database of patients undergoing TKA. rKA is defined by the following criteria: Independent tibial and femoral cuts within ± 5° of the bone neutral mechanical axis and; a resulting HKA within ±3° of neutral. Medial-lateral (ΔML) and flexion-extension (ΔFE) gap differences were calculated and compared with measured resection MA results.Background
Method
Assessing patients’ functional outcomes following total knee arthroplasty (TKA) with traditional scoring systems is limited by their ceiling effects. The Forgotten Joint Score (FJS) has been suggested as a more discriminating option. The actual score in the FJS which constitutes a “forgotten joint,” however, has not been defined. The emerging concept of joint perception led to the development of the Patient's Joint Perception question (PJP) to assess the patient's opinion of their prosthetic joint. 101 TKA were assessed at a mean of 41 months of follow-up (range 29=51). Outcomes included the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), FJS, and PJP. Correlation of the scores as well as the ceiling effects were analyzed.Background
Methods
Mechanical alignment in TKA introduces significant anatomic modifications for many individuals, which may result in unequal medial-lateral or flexion-extension bone resections. The objective of this study was to calculate bone resection thicknesses and resulting gap sizes, simulating a measured resection mechanical alignment technique for TKA. Measured resection mechanical alignment bone resections were simulated on 1000 consecutive lower limb CT-Scans from patients undergoing TKA. Bone resections were simulated to reproduce the following measured resection mechanical alignment surgical technique. The distal femoral and proximal tibial cuts were perpendicular to the mechanical axis, setting the resection depth at 8mm from the most distal femoral condyle and from the most proximal tibial plateau (Figure 1). If the resection of the contralateral side was <0mm, the resection level was increased such that the minimum resection was 0mm. An 8mm resection thickness was based on an implant size of 10mm (bone +2mm of cartilage). Femoral rotation was aligned with either the trans-epicondylar axis or with 3 degrees of external rotation to the posterior condyles. After simulation of the bone cuts, media-lateral gap difference and flexion-extension gaps difference were calculated. The gap sizes were calculated as the sum of the femoral and tibial bone resections, with a target bone resection of 16mm (+ cartilage corresponding to the implant thickness).INTRODUCTION
METHODS
This study reports the mid-term results of total hip arthroplasty (THA) performed using a monoblock acetabular component with a large-diameter head (LDH) ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC) bearing. Of the 276 hips (246 patients) included in this study, 264 (96%) were reviewed at a mean of 67 months (48 to 79) postoperatively. Procedures were performed with a mini posterior approach. Clinical and radiological outcomes were recorded at regular intervals. A noise assessment questionnaire was completed at last follow-up.Aims
Patients and Methods
The mechanical alignment (MA) for Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) with neutral alignment goal has had good overall long-term outcomes. In spite of improvements in implant designs and surgical tools aiming for better accuracy and reproducibility of surgical technique, functional outcomes of MA TKA have remained insufficient. Therefore, alternative, more anatomicaloptions restoring part (adjusted MA (aMA) and adjusted kinematic alignment (aKA) techniques) or the entire constitutional frontal deformity (unicompartment knee arthroplasty (UKA) and kinematic alignment (KA) techniques) have been developed, with promising results. The kinematic alignment for TKA is a new and attractive surgical technique enabling a patient specific treatment. The growing evidence of the kinematic alignment mid-term effectiveness, safety and potential short falls are discussed in this paper. The current review describes the rationale and the evidence behind different surgical options for knee replacement, including current concepts in alignment in TKA. We also introduce two new classification systems for “implant alignments options” (Figure 1) and “osteoarthritic knees” (Figure 2) that would help surgeons to select the best surgical option for each patient. This would also be valuable for comparison between techniques in future research.
The mechanical alignment (MA) for Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) with neutral alignment goal has had good overall long-term outcomes. In spite of improvements in implant designs and surgical tools aiming for better accuracy and reproducibility of surgical technique, functional outcomes of MA TKA have remained insufficient. Therefore, alternative, more anatomical options restoring part (adjusted MA (aMA) and adjusted kinematic alignment (aKA) techniques) or the entire constitutional frontal deformity (unicompartment knee arthroplasty (UKA) and kinematic alignment (KA) techniques) have been developed, with promising results. The kinematic alignment for TKA is a new and attractive surgical technique enabling a patient specific treatment. The growing evidence of the kinematic alignment mid-term effectiveness, safety and potential short falls are discussed in this paper. The current review describes the rationale and the evidence behind different surgical options for knee replacement, including current concepts in alignment in TKA. We also introduce two new classification systems for “implant alignments options” and “osteoarthritic knees” that would help surgeons to select the best surgical option for each patient. This would also be valuable for comparison between techniques in future research.
Management of pseudotumours associated with MoM THA can be difficult and complications are frequent. The functional outcome of patients after revision surgery may be suboptimal. The objective of this study was to assess our experience with revisions of failed MoM THA due to pseudotumours. 78 hips were diagnosed with pseudotumours in 70 patients following metal-on-metal hip replacements. Of these, 68 MoM THA were revised in 62 patients. Pre operative symptoms, radiographic analysis, metal ion levels, MRI results, intra-operative findings, WOMAC scores, the satisfaction level and the complication rate were recorded. Five patients had a resurfacing arthroplasty as their primary implants while the remaining 63 hips in 57 patients had MoM THA of different brands. The average time between the primary and revision surgery was 69 months (range 15–120). The average age at revision was 59 years (43–87). The mean follow-up was 24 months (range 2–73). 36 patients had minimal one year follow-up. Most lesions consisted of cystic changes and solid lesions were observed in 19 patients. In 57 hips, the pseudotumours were located posteriorly or postero-laterally around the greater trochanter. Intra operatively, muscle necrosis was observed in 15(22%) patients. Most THA cases demonstrated wear and corrosion at the head neck junction of the femoral implants. Thirty-five patients (44.9%) had greater than 50 degrees of cup abduction, including 10 patients (12.8%) with an abduction angle greater than 60 degrees. The average pre operative and postoperative Co ion levels were 27.46 ug/L (range 0.36–145.6) and 2.46 (range 0.4–12.48), respectively. Post revision, a total of 10 hips (14.7%) sustained a dislocation, with seven (10.3%) of them experiencing recurrent dislocations. In 8/10 hips, the femoral head size was 36mm or greater. Revision for dislocation occurred in seven(10.3%) patients. Three(4.4%) deep and one(1.47%) superficial infections occurred and deep infections were re-operated. One(1.47%) fracture of the greater trochanter and one (1.47%) psoas tendinitis did not need revision. Therefore, a total of 10 patients (14.7%) were reoperated. 6 revisions for instability were performed in the first 34 patients, while 1 were done in the last 34 patients. At one year post revision surgery, the mean WOMAC score was 19.68 (range 0–48). In comparison, the mean WOMAC score of the same patients one year after their primary surgery was 8.1 (0–63). Patient satisfaction level of patients one year post revision surgery was 7.61 (range 5–10) compared to 4.15 (range 0–7) pre-revision one. The complication rate after revision of pseudotumours is high. Most re revisions occurred secondary to instability despite the use of larger femoral heads. The functional outcome at one year post revision seems to be lower than that seen after primary THA but similar to other revisions in the literature. Experience in the management of these patients may reduce the complication rate.
Modifying Knee anatomy during mechanical Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) may impact ligament balance, patellar tracking and quadriceps function. Although well fixed, patients may report high levels (20%) of dissatisfaction. One theory is that putting the knee in neutral mechanical alignment may be responsible for these unsatisfactory results. Kinematic TKA has gained interest in recent years; it aims to resurface the knee joint and preservation of natural femoral flexion axis about which the tibia and patella articulate, recreating the native knee without the need for soft tissue relaease. That's being said, it remains the question of whether all patients are suitable for kinematic alignment. Some patients' anatomy may be inherently biomechanically inferior and recreating native anatomy in these patients may result in early implant failure. The senior author (PAV) has been performing Kinematic TKA since 2011, and has developed an algorithm in order to better predict which patient may benefit from this technique. Lower limb CT scans from 4884 consecutive patients scheduled for TKA arthroplasty were analysed. These exams were performed for patient-specific instrumentation production (My Knee®, Medacta, Switzerland). Multiple anatomical landmarks used to create accurate CT-based preoperative planning and determine the mechanical axis of bone for the femur and tibia and overall Hip-knee-Ankle (HKA). We wanted to test the safe range for kinematic TKA for the planned distal resection of the femur and tibia. Safe range algorithm was defined as the combination of the following criteria: – Independent tibial and femoral cuts within ± 5° of the bone neutral mechanical axis and HKA within ± 3°. The purpose of this study is to verify the applicability of the proposed safe range algorithm on a large sample of individual scheduled for TKA. The preoperative tibial mechanical angle average 2.9 degrees in varus, femoral mechanical angle averaged 2.7 degrees in valgus and overall HKA averaged of 0.1 in varus. There were 2475 (51%) knees out of 4884, with femur and tibia mechanical axis within ±5° and HKA within ±3° without need for bony corrections. After applying the algorithm, a total of 4062 cases (83%) were successfully been evaluated using the proposed protocol to reach a safe range of HKA ±3° with minimal correction. The remaining 822 cases (17%) could not be managed by the proposed algorithm because of their unusual anatomies and were dealt with individually. In this study, we tested a proposed algorithm to perform kinematic alignment TKA avoiding preservation/restoration of some extreme anatomies that might not be suitable for TKA long-term survivorship. A total of 4062 cases (83%) were successfully eligible for our proposed safe range algorithm for kinematic TKA. In conclusion, kinematically aligned TKA may be a promising option to improve normal knee function restoration and patient satisfaction. Until we have valuable data confirming the compatibility of all patients' pre arthritic anatomies with TKA long-term survivorship, we believe that kinematically alignment should be performed within some limits. Further studies with Radiostereometry or longer follow up might help determine if all patients' anatomies are suitable for Kinematic TKA.
Large bearing surfaces are appealing in total hip arthroplasty (THA) as they may help create a greater range of impingement free motion and reduce the risk of dislocation. However, attempts to achieve this with a metal bearing surface have been blighted by adverse reactions to metal debris. Ceramic bearings have a good long-term track record in more conventional head sizes, and manufacturing techniques now permit the use of larger ceramic bearing surfaces using monoblock uncemented acetabular components. In this study, we are reviewing the early results of the Maxera® acetabular component (Zimmer, Indiana) at our institution. All data was collected prospectively. Maxera® acetabular component is a Titanium (Ti) shell with plasma sprayed Ti for the osteointegrative surface. Delta ceramic liner is inserted & locked into the cup shell by the manufacturer (non-modular). With the Maxera cup system, the bearing diameter is dictated by the acetabular component size. Acetabular components (AC) of 46 and 48 mm have a bearing diameter (BD) of 36 mm, AC of 50 and 52 mm: have a 40 mm BD, AC of 54 and 56 mm: have a BD of 44 mm and AC of 58–64: have a 48mm BD. Delta ceramic femoral head size of 44 and 48 mm have a modular Ti sleeve between the head and femoral stem trunnion. Femoral head sizes of 36 and 40 mm have no Ti sleeve. All THA had an uncemented femoral stem. Implants were inserted with a posterior approach. Patients were reviewed at 6 weeks, 6 months and then annually with radiographs. Clinical function was evaluated using WOMAC and UCLA scores along with joint perception questionnaires. Five hundred components have been implanted in 442 patients (250 women, 192 men) with a mean age of 55, (min 17, max 80) and a mean BMI of 26.9 (min 17.8, max 51). The mean acetabular size was 54 (min 46, max 64), leading to a mean femoral head size of 44. At a minimum of two years follow-up (mean 3.8 years): 5 patients have been revised, 4 secondary to undetected intraoperative fracture of the femur and only one due to early displacement of a Maxera® cup (0.2%). Five patients reported a mild squeaking; two reported clicking and one patient presented with a symptomatic heterotopic ossification. The WOMAC score improved significantly post-operatively, (57.4 compared to 4.4 post-operatively, p<0.001). The mean post-operative UCLA score was 6.9. Sixty percent (60.6%) of patients rated their joint perception as either “natural” or “artificial without limitation”. two patients (0.4%) suffered a dislocation after high velocity trauma without recurrence after closed reduction. No ceramic component fracture was recorded. This prospective study shows that this monoblock acetabular component provides an easy implantation with minimal complications. The ceramic bearing surface provides good clinical function and joint perception. Bearing surfaces of this design may provide an alternative to large head metal on metal (MoM) implants without the side effects of metal debris/ions.
This randomised trial evaluated the outcome of
a single design of unicompartmental arthroplasty of the knee (UKA) with
either a cemented all-polyethylene or a metal-backed modular tibial
component. A total of 63 knees in 45 patients (17 male, 28 female)
were included, 27 in the all-polyethylene group and 36 in the metal-backed
group. The mean age was 57.9 years (39.6 to 76.9). At a mean follow-up
of 6.4 years (5 to 9.9), 11 all-polyethylene components (41%) were
revised (at a mean of 5.8 years; 1.4 to 8.0) post-operatively and
two metal-backed components were revised (at one and five years).
One revision in both groups was for unexplained pain, one in the
metal-backed group was for progression of osteoarthritis. The others
in the all-polyethylene group were for aseptic loosening. The survivorship
at seven years calculated by the Kaplan–Meier method for the all-polyethylene
group was 56.5% (95% CI 31.9 to 75.2, number at risk 7) and for
the metal-backed group was 93.8% (95% CI 77.3 to 98.4, number at
risk 16) This difference was statistically significant (p <
0.001).
At the most recent follow-up, significantly better mean Western
Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index Scores were found
in the all-polyethylene group (13.4 This randomised study demonstrates that all-polyethylene components
in this design of fixed bearing UKA had unsatisfactory results with
significantly higher rates of failure before ten years compared
with the metal-back components. Cite this article:
A total of 219 hips in 192 patients aged between
18 and 65 years were randomised to 28-mm metal-on-metal uncemented
total hip replacements (THRs, 107 hips) or hybrid hip resurfacing
(HR, 112 hips). At a mean follow-up of eight years (6.6 to 9.3)
there was no significant difference between the THR and HR groups
regarding rate of revision (4.0% (4 of 99) Cite this article:
The purpose of the study was to determine the rate of conversion from RSA to THR in a number of Canadian centers performing resurfacings Retrospective review was undertaken in 12 Canadian Centers to determine the rate of revision and reason for conversion from RSA to THR. Averages and cross-tabulation with Chi-Squared analysis was performed. kaplan Meier survivorship was calculated.Purpose
Method
antero-lateral skin incision in TKA produces a lower rate of hypoesthesia compared to the medial parapatellar cutaneous approach, and reduced hypoesthesia is linked with less discomfort and possibly a better clinical outcome.
We have updated our previous randomised controlled trial comparing release of chromium (Cr) and cobalt (Co) ions and included levels of titanium (Ti) ions. We have compared the findings from 28 mm metal-on-metal total hip replacement, performed using titanium CLS/Spotorno femoral components and titanium AlloFit acetabular components with Metasul bearings, with Durom hip resurfacing using a Metasul articulation or bearing and a titanium plasma-sprayed coating for fixation of the acetabular component. Although significantly higher blood ion levels of Cr and Co were observed at three months in the resurfaced group than in total hip replacement, no significant difference was found at two years post-operatively for Cr, 1.58 μg/L and 1.62 μg/L respectively (p = 0.819) and for Co, 0.67 μg/L and 0.94 μg/L respectively (p = 0.207). A steady state was reached at one year in the resurfaced group and after three months in the total hip replacement group. Interestingly, Ti, which is not part of the bearing surfaces with its release resulting from metal corrosion, had significantly elevated ion levels after implantation in both groups. The hip resurfacing group had significantly higher Ti levels than the total hip replacement group for all periods of follow-up. At two years the mean blood levels of Ti ions were 1.87 μg/L in hip resurfacing and and 1.30 μg/L in total hip replacement (p = 0.001). The study confirms even with different bearing diameters and clearances, hip replacement and 28 mm metal-on-metal total hip replacement produced similar Cr and Co metal ion levels in this randomised controlled trial study design, but apart from wear on bearing surfaces, passive corrosion of exposed metallic surfaces is a factor which influences ion concentrations. Ti plasma spray coating the acetabular components for hip resurfacing produces significantly higher release of Ti than Ti grit-blasted surfaces in total hip replacement.
Background: Leg length equality and femoral offset restoration are important parameters related to success of total hip arthroplasty (THA). However, it is not uncommon for errors to occur during surgery which can lead to less optimal functional result and potential source for litigation. Several techniques that are commonly used to assess leg length and femoral offset during THA include pre-operative templating, intra-operative measurements with a ruler using bony landmarks, assessing soft tissue tension and using measurement device with a reference pin in the iliac crest. We have previously reported on our precision to reconstruct the diseased hip with THA done without navigation. Post-operative radiographic analysis demonstrated that leg length was restored to within +/− 4mm of the contralateral side in only 60% of the patients with 4 patients needing a shoe lift. With regards to femoral offset reconstruction, it was increased by a mean of 5.1 mm and restored to within +/− 4mm of the normal contralateral side in only 25% of patients. Computer navigation has proven to be a more precise tool to achieve optimal positioning of THA implants and precise biomechanical reconstruction of the hip joint. However, performing complete THA using navigation is complex including the requirement to change the position of the patient during registration. A recent stand-alone CT-free hip navigation software from Orthosoft Inc allows navigation to be used for limb length and offset measurements during THA. We report our results from a preliminary study using this technique in 14 hips undergoing THA. In this technique, a tracker is placed over the iliac crest. There is no need to fix a tracker on the femur. Registration of the following are done: greater trochanter (using a screw), patella (using an ECG lead) and the plane of the operating table (using three points on the surface of the operating table in a triangular configuration). The centre of rotation of the hip is determined by either mapping the acetabulum or by using the appropriate sized calibrated reamer. With the definitive acetabular component in place, the new center of rotation is registered and the hip is reduced with trial femoral component. Re-registration of the new position of the greater trochanter and patella allows the computer to calculate the relative change in the limb length and offset compared to the pre-operative status. The differences in the pre-operative and post-operative limb length and offset were calculated using Imagika software and compared with the navigated values recorded by the computer. The mean absolute error for the relative change in the limb length as measured by the computer when compared to the radiographic measurement was 1.25 mm with a standard deviation of 1.77 mm. The mean absolute error for the relative change in the offset as measured by the computer when compared with the radiographic measurement was 2.96 mm with a standard deviation of 2.56 mm. The process of navigation was quick and on average adds 10 minutes to the operative time. Our preliminary study shows that the accuracy of the navigation software is very good in estimating the change in the limb length intra-operatively with a maximum error of 3 mm. The accuracy was also good in estimating the offset (3 mm or less except in one case where the error was 5 mm and this may be due to technical error in registration). This compares favorably with our own data on THA done without navigation. This easy to use navigation technique has the potential to decrease the magnitude of error in restoration of limb length and offset during THA. We thank Francois Paradois and Michael Lanigan from Orthosoft Inc. for their technical advice.
Hip Resurfacing (HR) is nowadays widely used as an alternative to Total Hip Replacement (THR), especially for the young and active patients. Because of the more physiological distribution of the load in the femur, this technique is particularly known to reduce bone loss due to stress shielding behaviour, a major problem encountered with THA. Different computational studies have analysed the performance of HR prostheses. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to apply a computational approach, in fact a bone remodelling analysis, in order to investigate its application to evaluate the bone structure changes postoperatively. A Finite Element model was developed of a femur with HR prosthesis. The model was reconstructed starting with the femur medical images, and then the prosthesis was positioned in the clinical implantation angle (5° valgus). A cement mantle thickness of 1mm was included. Then a Finite Element Analysis in combination with a bone remodelling model (bone material properties) was performed. The results obtained predict as there is a certain bone loss in the superolateral and inferior medial zone. Additional bone material apposition is locally found with the aim of fixing the implant stem on the medial side, but also a remarkable distal ingrowth around the stem tip. All these findings are in good qualitative agreement with clinical observations. We conclude that the numerical simulation used in this study is a useful tool in predicting bone remodelling inside a cemented HR prosthesis. This kind of methodologies will help on the design of devices, surgical techniques, etc.
The aim of our study was to compare the precision and effectiveness of a CT-free computer navigation system against conventional technique (using a standard mechanical jig) in a cohort of unselected consecutive series of hip resurfacings. One hundred and thirty nine consecutive Durom hip resurfacing procedures (51 navigated and 88 non-navigated) performed in 125 patients were analysed. All the procedures were done through a posterior approach by two surgeons and the study cohort include the hip resurfacings done during the transition phase of the surgeons’ adoption of navigation. There were no significant differences in the gender, age, height, weight, BMI, native neck-shaft angles, component sizes and blood loss between the two groups. There was a significant difference in the operative time between the two groups (111 minutes for the navigated group versus 105 minutes for the non-navigated group; p=0.048). There were 4 cases of notching in the non-navigated group and none in the navigated group. There were no other intra-operative technical problems in either of the groups nor were there any femoral neck fractures. No significant difference was found between the mean post-operative stem-shaft angles (138.5° for the navigated group versus 139.0° for the non navigated group, p=0.740). However there was a significant difference in the difference between the planned stem-shaft angle versus the post-operative stem-shaft angle (0.4° for the navigated group versus 2.1° for the non-navigated group; p=0.005). There was significantly more scatter in the difference between the post-operative stem-shaft angle and the planned stem-shaft angle in the non-navigated group (standard deviation = 3.6°) when compared with the navigated group (standard deviation = 0.9°; Levene’s test for equality of variances = p≤0.01). No case in the navigated group showed a post-operative stem-shaft angle of more than 5° deviation from the planned neck-shaft angle when compared to 33 cases (38%) in the non-navigated group (p≤0.001). While only 4 cases (8%) in the navigated group had a postoperative stem-shaft angle deviating more than 3° from the planned stem-shaft angle, this occurred in 50 cases (57%) in the non-navigated group (p≤0.001). Hip resurfacing is a technically demanding procedure with a steep learning curve. Varus placement of the femoral component and notching have been recognised as important factors associated with early failures following hip resurfacing. While conventional instruments allowed reasonable alignment of the femoral component, our study has shown that use of computer navigation allows more accurate placement of the femoral component even when the surgeons had a significant experience with conventional technique.
Heterotopic ossification (HO) occurs commonly after total hip arthroplasty (THA). Its severe form can result in impaired range of motion with reduced functional outcome. The rate and severity of HO after hip surface replacement arthroplasty (SRA) have never been well studied. Two hundred and ten hips were randomised to receive uncemented metal-on-metal THA or metal-on-metal SRA. Standard radiographs of the pelvis were assessed for HO by two reviewers at the latest follow-up (minimum of six months), using Brooker severity grading and Kjaersgaard-Andersen regional classification. The incidence of HO was 38.5% in the SRA group compared to 32.6% in the THA group (p=0.5). However, there was a significant difference in severity grades for the two groups (chi square, p=0.02). According to Brooker’s classification, nearly half of HO was of grade two in SRA and of grade one in THA. SRA was associated with significantly higher rates of severe HO (grades three and four) than THA (12.5% vs. 2.2%; p=0.009). Inter-rater agreement for Brooker grading was excellent (Cohen’s kappa, 0.88; p<
0.01). The incidence of HO after hip arthroplasty seems to be determined by patient-related factors. However, HO severity appears to be associated with local surgical factors and thereby SRA may result in more severe HO than THA. An extensive surgical approach, additional soft tissue release and the blunt damage occurring in gluteal muscles with SRA may signal the induction of more severe HO. Peri-operative deposition of bone debris derived from femoral head preparation may also play a role by transplanting osteoprogenitor cells. Surgeons must be aware of this risk of severe HO when offering SRA as an alternative treatment to younger patients. Routine prophylaxis with NSAIDs needs to be considered in these patients. A meticulous surgical technique to reduce muscle damage, pulsed lavage to clear bone debris, and debridement of necrotic tissue, may help to decrease the risk of severe HO in SRA.
A descriptive study of osteoporotic fractures and the evaluation of the relative risk of hip fracture following a minor fracture were done on 2.5 million individuals from 1980 to 1997. People aged forty-five years old and older have a risk for hip fracture after a minor fracture of 2.3–17.3 time the risk of people without previous fracture. Given the availability of pharmaceuticals that decrease the fracture risk dramatically within the first 18 months of therapy, the average four to six years time between minor and hip fracture represents a perfect window of opportunity for preventive treatment. Osteoporotic fractures, especially hip fractures, represent a major health problem in terms of morbidity, mortality and cost. Since the availability of new treatments for osteoporosis, a better understanding of the disease is needed to define the indications for treatment. A descriptive study of osteoporotic fractures and the evaluation of the relative risk of hip fracture following a minor fracture were done on a population aged fortyfive years old and older from 1980 to 1997 (2.5 million individuals). During the follow-up period, 220,120 fractures (hip, wrist, proximal humerus and ankle) were recorded. Wrist fractures were the most frequent (42.2%) followed by hip fractures (32.5%). Although the proportions of fracture sites were similar for both sexes, 75% of the fractures occurred in females. The mortality rate 1 year after a hip fracture is increased by 14–27% for men and 9–13% for women. Men and women aged fortyfive years old and older have a risk for hip fracture after a humerus or a wrist fracture of 2.3–17.3 time the risk of people without previous fracture. The average time between a wrist or humerus fracture and a hip fracture was four to six years. Wrist and humerus fractures represent a major risk for future hip fracture. Given the availability of pharmaceuticals that decrease the risk of hip fracture dramatically within the first eighteen months of therapy, the interval between minor and hip fracture represents a perfect window of opportunity for preventive treatment to decrease the risk of future hip fracture.
The dramatic improvement in clinical function after total hip arthroplasty (THA) has been well-documented. Gait studies, however, demonstrate abnormal gait pattern after THA. THA patients may complain of thigh pain, leg length inequality, instability and reduced range of motion. Surface replacement arthroplasty (SRA) has the benefit of restoring a more normal hip anatomy and biomechanics, which could improve clinical function and patient satisfaction after surgery. We compared the clinical function and patient satisfaction in a group of young patients randomized to receive SRA or THA. The results are presented and discussed. The dramatic improvement in clinical function after total hip arthroplasty (THA) has been well-documented. However gait studies demonstrate abnormal gait patterns after THA, and patients may complain of thigh pain, leg length inequality, instability and reduced range of motion. Surface replacement arthroplasty (SRA) has the benefit of restoring a more normal hip anatomy and biomechanics, which could improve clinical function and patient satisfaction after surgery. All patients eligible for the study were randomised to receive uncemented metal-metal THA or a hybrid metal-metal SRA. Clinical data were prospectively collected pre-operatively and at three, six and twelve months post-operatively. WOMAC score, SF-36, Merle D’Aubigné, and other clinical data, along with patient satisfaction, were compared. One hundred and fifty patients were randomized. Both groups demonstrated a very high satisfaction rate. Although there was a tendency for the SRA group to participate in more demanding activities at six months post-operatively, no difference was found in clinical function scores. Two isolated dislocations occurred in the THA group and none in the SRA group. There were no other significant complications in either group. The few short-term clinical data reported in the literature for new generation SRA implants demonstrate an excellent outcome comparable to THA. Despite enthusiasm about total hip resurfacing, no direct prospective comparative study with THA has been published in the literature. This study confirms the safety and benefits of metal-metal SRA of the hip in the early post-operative period. Funding: This research project was funded by Zimmer, Warsaw
One hundred and forty eight hybrid total hip arthroplasties in patients less than seventy years old were randomised to metal on polyethylene or alumina on alumina bearing surfaces. At two to seven years of follow-up, no significant difference was found on hip scores or survivorship of the implants. No specific complication associated to alumina components like fracture or malpositionning of the acetabular insert were observed. Alumina on alumina bearing surfaces give early clinical and radiological results similar to metal on polyethylene, suggesting that they have a potential to become good bearing surfaces in hip arthroplasty for young patients. The excellent results obtained with metal-polyethylene (M-P) bearing surfaces in total hip arthroplasty (THA) are still limited by the production of polyethylene wear debris, osteolysis and aseptic loosening. Because of it superior tribologic properties and bioinert composition, alumina-alumina (AL-AL) bearing surfaces are proposed to improve survival of THA but previously reported early complications prevented widespread use of alumina ceramic. This study compares early results and complication with Ceraver M-P and AL-AL THA. One hundred forty-eight Ceraver hybrid THA in patients less than seventy years old were randomised to M-P or AL-AL bearing surfaces. We present the clinical and radiological results for patients two to seven years after their surgery. No significant difference was found on W.O.M.A.C. and Merle D’Aubigné Postel scores. No specific complication associated with alumina components like fracture or malpositionning of the acetabular insert were observed in this study. Documented complications were: infection 4 AL-AL/2 M-P; dislocation 1 AL-AL/4 M-P; and heterotopic ossification 47% AL-AL/24% M-P. No aseptic loosening was observed. Ceraver AL-AL bearing surfaces give early clinical and radiological results similar to M-P. Our results are in accordance with studies suggesting that AL-AL have a potential to become good bearing surfaces in THA in the young patients.