Metal on metal hip resurfacing (MMHR) is a popular procedure for the treatment of osteoarthritis in young patients. Several centres have observed masses, arising from around these devices, we call these inflammatory pseudotumours. They are locally invasive and may cause massive soft tissue destruction. The aim of this study was to determine the incidence and risk factors for pseudotumours that are serious enough to require revision surgery. In out unit, 1,419 MMHRs were performed between June 1999 and November 2008. All revisions were identified, including all cases revised for pseudotumour. Pseudotumour diagnosis was made by histological examination of samples from revision. A Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was performed, Cox regression analysis was used to estimate the independent effects of different factors. The revision rate for pseudotumour increased with time and was 4% (95% CI: 2.2% to 5.8%) at eight years. Female gender was a strong risk factor: at eight years the revision rate for pseudotumours in men was 0.5% (95% CI 0% to 1.1%), in women over 40 it was 6% (95% CI 2.3% to 10.1%) and in women under 40 it was 25% (95% CI 7.3% to 42.9%) (p<
0.001). Other factors associated with an increase in revision rate were, small components (p=0.003) and dysplasia (p=0.019), whereas implant type was not (p=0.156). We recommend that resurfacings are undertaken with caution in women, especially those younger than 40 years of age, but they remain a good option in men. Further work is required to understand the patho-aetiology of pseudotumours so that this severe complication can be avoided.
For the whole cohort, there was no significant difference in ion levels (Cr: p=0.092. Co=0.075) between cups positioned within Z3 (n=58) versus those outside (n=46 mean). Male patients with cups within Z3 (n=27) had lower ion levels in comparison to those outside Z3, which were significantly lower for Co (p=0.049) but not Cr (p=0.084). Female patients had similar levels within and out of Z3 for both ions (Cr: p=0.83, Co: p=0.84). However, patients with cups within Z1 (n=13) had significantly lower Co (p=0.005) and Cr (p=0.001) than those outside Z1 (n=95). Interestingly, Co levels were significantly lower in Z1 (n=13) in comparison to Z2 (n=33) (p=0.048) but Cr levels were not different (p=0.06).
Although originally designed to aid the management of primary malignant bone tumours, the indications for modular endoprosthetic replacement (EPR) have expanded to include complex periprosthetic fractures and failed internal fixation. The incidence of these challenging cases is increasing with an aged population. We reviewed retrospectively our experience with the use of EPR in patients who had undergone limb salvage following complex trauma presentations. Between 2003 and 2008 twenty one patients underwent EPR following referral to the Oxford Sarcoma Service following lower limb trauma. The average age was 71 years (44–87). The average number of previous surgical procedures was 3 (range 0–11). The mean Harris Hip Score was 89.5 (range 64–85). The mean American Knee Society Score was 82 (range 62–100) and the mean functional score was 62 (range 30–75). Complications included two cases of deep infection; one resulted in a two stage revision procedure, while the other retained the EPR following a washout. EPR is an effective salvage procedure for failed trauma fixation and periprosthetic fractures. Immediate weight bearing and a good functional outcome can be expected in this difficult group of patients.
to determine the prevalence of asymptomatic pseudotumours after MoMHRA; and to measure Co and Cr ion levels as well as lymphocyte proliferation responses to Ni, Co and Cr (the principal elements in the CoCr alloy used in MoMHRA) in MoMHRA patients with and without asymptomatic pseudotumours.
Metal Ion Levels – The presence of pseudotumour was associated with significantly higher median serum cobalt levels (9.2mg/L vs. 1.9mg/L, p<
0.001), chromium levels (12.0mg/L vs. 2.1mg/L, p<
0.001), hip aspirate cobalt levels (1182 mg/L vs. 86.2mg/L, p=0.003), and aspirate chromium levels (883mg/L vs. 114.8mg/ L, p=0.006), as well as with inferior functional scores (OHS 41 vs. 47 p<
0.001). There was no significant difference in acetabular cup inclination angle (p=0.51). Lymphocyte Reactivity: A higher incidence and level of enhanced lymphocyte reactivity to Ni (p=0.001), but not to Co or Cr (the principal elements in the CoCr alloy used in metal-on-metal hip resurfacing implants), was found in patients with MoMHRA compared to the patients without MoM implants. However, lymphocyte reactivity to Co, Cr and Ni did not significantly differ in patients with pseudotumours compared to those patients without pseudotumours. Conclusion: The prevalence of asymptomatic pseudotumours in females was high, especially in females with bilateral MoMHRA implants (30%). The patients with ‘asymptomatic’ pseudotumours were in fact mildly symptomatic. Lymphocyte reactivity to Co, Cr and Ni did not differ in patients with pseudotumour compared to those patients without pseudotumours, suggesting that systemic hypersensitivity type IV reactions, mediated by lymphocyte reactivity to these metals, is not the dominant mechanism in pathogenesis of the soft tissue pseudotumours. Furthermore, pseudotumours were not detected in those patients who had normal levels of cobalt and chromium ions. This suggests that pseudotumours do not occur if MoM articulations are well functioning. Therefore, pseudotumours are likely to be a biological consequence of the large amount of metal debris generated in vivo due to excessive wear.
It is advised that lumps which are greater than 5cm should be referred to a sarcoma centre for management and that small lesions cause less harm with unplanned excision.
Of the hand patients 7 of the 10 patients had wide excision of the lesion with 3 an amputation. 5 of the cases were for inadequate previous excision (50%). 7 of the 17 in the foot and ankle group underwent amputation (41%) the rest wide excision. 29% of cases were for second time surgery due to inadequate previous excision.
Tribological studies of hip arthroplasty suggest that larger diameter metal-on-metal (MOM) articulations would produce less wear than smaller diameter articulations. Other advantages using these large femoral heads implants include better stability with lower dislocation rates and improved range of motion. The aim of the present study was to compare chromium (Cr), cobalt (Co) and titanium (Ti) ion concentrations up to 1-year after implantation of different large diameter MOM total hip arthroplasty (THA).
Statistical group comparison revealed significant difference for Cr (p=0.006), Co (p=0.047) and Ti (p=<
0.001). With Biomet implants presenting the best results for Cr and Co and Zimmer the highest Ti level.
Metal on Metal Hip Resurfacing Arthroplasty (MoMHRA) has gained popularity due to its perceived advantages of bone conservation and relative ease of revision to a conventional THR if it fails. Known MoMHRA-associated complications include femoral neck fracture, avascular necrosis/collapse of the femoral head/neck, aseptic loosening and soft tissue responses such as ALVAL and pseudotumours. This study’s aim was to assess the functional outcome of failed MoMHRA revised to THR and compare it with a matched cohort of primary THRs.
Pseudotumours are a rare complication of hip resurfacing. They are thought to be a response to metal debris which may be caused by edge loading due to poor orientation of the acetabular component. Our aim was to determine the optimal acetabular orientation to minimise the risk of pseudotumour formation. We matched 31 hip resurfacings revised for pseudotumour formation with 58 controls who had a satisfactory outcome from this procedure. The radiographic inclination and anteversion angles of the acetabular component were measured on anteroposterior radiographs of the pelvis using Einzel-Bild-Roentgen-Analyse software. The mean inclination angle (47°, 10° to 81°) and anteversion angle (14°, 4° to 34°) of the pseudotumour cases were the same (p = 0.8, p = 0.2) as the controls, 46° (29° to 60°) and 16° (4° to 30°) respectively, but the variation was greater. Assuming an accuracy of implantation of ± 10° about a target position, the optimal radiographic position was found to be approximately 45° of inclination and 20° of anteversion. The incidence of pseudotumours inside the zone was four times lower (p = 0.007) than outside the zone. In order to minimise the risk of pseudotumour formation we recommend that surgeons implant the acetabular component at an inclination of 45° (± 10) and anteversion of 20° (± 10) on post-operative radiographs. Because of differences between the radiographic and the operative angles, this may be best achieved by aiming for an inclination of 40° and an anteversion of 25°.
The treatment of acetabular metastases with total hip arthroplasty is technically challenging often with significant loss of structural continuity in the medial wall and roof of the acetabulum, as described by Harrington in 1981 as class III defects. Traditionally the acetabular component is stabilised with Harrington rods but the risk of post-operative complications, especially bleeding is significant. We performed 10 consecutive total hip arthroplasties in patients with metastases involving the acetabulum with Harrington class III defects. The first three patients had acetabular reconstruction with a Kerboull cage, (Stryker Howmedica.) The cage was secured using a combination of screw fixation to the ileum and PMMA cement filling voids behind the cage. A polyethylene acetabular cup is then cemented into the cage. There was concern about the superior fixation using this implant and so the remaining 7 patients were treated using the Graft Augmentation Prosthesis (GAP II), (Stryker How-medica.) This is a titanium reconstruction cage with two superior flanges allowing extensive screw fixation onto the ileum. Two patients had very large defects where there was not sufficient support to use this cage alone, so the technique was augmented with Harrington rods. No implants have failed to date. One patient, an 83 year old female, died 23 days post-operatively after suffering a stroke. Two patients died of their disease 95 and 115 days after surgery. The remaining patients continue to have good pain and mobility following surgery as demonstrated by the Oxford hip score. We conclude that in suitable patients with extensive metastatic involvement of the acetabulum, a flanged acetabular reconstruction cage prosthesis is much improved way of providing support for a total hip replacement. This procedure can greatly improve quality of life, and to date we have had no mechanical failures of fixation using this technique.
We report on a group of 20 metal-on-metal resurfaced hips (17 patients) presenting with a soft tissue mass associated with various symptoms. We describe these masses as pseudotumours. All patients underwent plain radiography and fuller investigation with CT, MRI and ultrasound. Where samples were available, histology was performed. All patients in this series were female. Presentation was variable; the most common symptom was pain or discomfort in the hip region. Other symptoms included spontaneous dislocation, nerve palsy, an enlarging mass or a rash. The common histological features were extensive necrosis and lymphocytic infiltration. Fourteen of the 20 cases (70%) have so far required revision to a conventional hip replacement and their symptoms have either settled completely or improved substantially since the revision surgery. Two of the three bilateral cases have asymptomatic pseudotumours on the opposite side. We estimate that about 1% of patients develop a pseudotumour in the first five postoperative years after a hip resurfacing. The cause of these pseudotumours is unknown and is probably multi-factorial, further work is required to define this; they may be manifestations of a metal sensitivity response. We are concerned that with time the incidence of these pseudotumours will increase.