The Oxford Knee Score (OKS) is a validated and widely used PROM that has been successfully used in assessing the outcome of knee arthroplasty (KA). It has been adopted as the nationally agreed outcome measure for this procedure and is now routinely collected. Increasingly, it is being used on an individual patient basis as a pre-operative measure of osteoarthritis and the need for joint replacement, despite not being validated for this use. The aim of this paper is to present evidence that challenges this new role for the OKS. We have analysed pre-operative and post-operative OKS data from 3 large cohorts all undergoing KA, totalling over 3000 patients. In addition we have correlated the OKS to patient satisfaction scores. We have validated our findings using data published from the UK NJR.Purpose
Method
Stem geometry is known to influence the outcome in THA; however it is unknown whether the material properties, stiffness in particular can influence the stem stability and outcome. The aim of this study was to measure the influence of stem material properties on micromotion and migration using Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis (RSA) system. 41 patients were implanted with a collarless polished tapered (CPT) femoral stem (Zimmer, Warsaw, Indiana), which was made of either cobalt-chromium (CoCr) (n=21) or stainless steel (n=20). RSA was used to measure dynamically inducible micromotion (DIMM: difference in stem position in going from double-leg stance (DLS) to single leg stance (SLS)), prosthesis bending (difference in the head-tip distance when going from DLS to SLS), and mean migration of the head, tip and the cement restrictor. DIMM and bending were measured at 3 months, migration at 6, 12 and 24 months. All analyses were carried out using SPSS for windows (v.15.0.0, Chicago. IL, USA). Results were reported as mean ± 95% confidence interval (CI) and regarded as significant when p < 0.05. Preliminary analysis showed that total head DIMM was significantly (p = 0.02) greater for CoCr (0.97mm ± 0.6mm) than stainless steel (0.27mm ± 0.6mm). The mean stem bending for CoCr was 0.08mm (± 0.06mm) and for stainless steel 0.15mm (± 0.06mm) (p =0.77). Both implants heads migrated posteriorly, medially and distally. The mean subsidence for the cobalt-chromium and stainless steel stems was 1.02mm (± 0.19mm) (p < 0.001) and 1.12mm (± 0.34mm) (p=0.001) (p= 0.07) at 24 months. It was interesting to note that the dynamically induced micromotion was greater for the stiffer stem, however there were no differences in terms of overall migration, indicating that survival (in terms of loosening) should be the similar for both steel and CoCr versions of this implant.
Primary mechanical stability is important with uncemented THR because early migration is reduced, leading to more rapid osseointegration between the implant and bone. Such primary mechanical stability is provided by the design features of the device. The aim of this study was to compare the migration patterns of two uncemented hip stems, the Furlong Active and the Furlong HAC stem; the study was designed as a randomised control trial. The implants were the Furlong HAC, which is an established implant with good long term results, and the Furlong Active, which is a modified version of the Furlong HAC designed to minimise stress concentrations between the implant and bone, and thus to improve fixation. The migration of 43 uncemented femoral components for total hip replacement was measured in a randomised control trial using Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis (RSA) over two years. Twenty-three Furlong HAC and twenty Furlong Active stems were implanted into 43 patients. RSA examinations were carried out post-operatively, and at six months, 12 months and 24 months post-operatively. The patients stood in-front of a purpose made calibration frame which contained accurately positioned radio-opaque markers. From the obtained images, the 3-D positions of the prosthesis and the host bone were reconstructed. Geometrical algorithms were used to identify the components of the implant. These algorithms allowed the femoral component to be studied without the need to attach markers to the prosthesis. The migration was calculated relative to the femoral coordinate system representing the anterior-posterior (A-P), medial-lateral (M-L) and proximal-distal (P-D) directions respectively. Distal migration was termed subsidence.Introduction
Materials and methods
Preoperative psychological distress has been reported to predict poor outcome and patient dissatisfaction after total hip replacement (THR). We investigated this relationship in a prospective multi-centre study between January 1999 and January 2002. We recorded the Oxford Hip Score (OHS) and SF36 score preoperatively and up to five years after surgery and a global satisfaction questionnaire at five year follow up for 1039 patients. We dichotomised the patients into the mentally distressed (Mental Health Scale score - MHS <50) and the not mentally distressed (MHS (50) groups based on their pre-operative MHS of the SF36. 776 (677 not distressed and 99 distressed) out of 1039 patients were followed up at 5 years.Introduction
Methods
Anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee (anteromedial gonarthrosis-AMG) is a common form of knee arthritis. In a clinical setting, knee arthritis has always been assessed by plain radiography in conjunction with pain and function assessments. Whilst this is useful for surgical decision making in bone on bone arthritis, plain radiography gives no insight to the earlier stages of disease. In a recent study 82% of patients with painful arthritis had only partial thickness joint space loss on plain radiography. These patients are managed with various surgical treatments; injection, arthroscopy, osteotomy and arthroplasty with varying results. We believe these varying results are in part due to these patients being at different stages of disease, which will respond differently to different treatments. However radiography cannot delineate these stages. We describe the Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) findings of this partial thickness AMG as a way of understanding these earlier stages of the disease. 46 subjects with symptomatic partial thickness AMG underwent MRI assessment with dedicated 3 Tesla sequences. All joint compartments were scored for both partial and full thickness cartilage lesions, osteophytes and bone marrow lesions (BML). Both menisci were assessed for extrusion and tear. Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) integrity was also assessed. Osteophytes were graded on a four point scale in the intercondylar notch and the lateral margins of the joint compartments. Scoring was performed by a consultant radiologist and clinical research fellow using a validated MRI atlas with consensus reached for disagreements. The results were tabulated and relationships of the interval data assessed with linear by linear Chi2 test and Pearson's Correlation.Introduction
Method
Unicompartmental Knee Replacement (UKR) is an appealing alternative to Total Knee Replacement (TKR) when the patient has isolated compartment osteoarthritis (OA). A common observation post-operatively is radiolucency between the tibial tray wall and the bone. In addition, some patients complain of persistent pain following implantation with a UKR; this may be related to elevated bone strains in the tibia. The aim of this study was to investigate the mechanical environment of the tibia bone adjacent to the tray wall, following UKR, to determine whether this region of bone resorbs, and how altering the mechanical environment affects tibia strains. A finite element (FE) model of a cadaver tibia implanted with an Oxford UKR was used in this study, based on a validated model. A single static load, measured in-vivo during a step-up activity was used. There was a 1 mm layer of cement surrounding the keel in the cemented UKR, and the cement filled the cement pocket. In accordance with the operating procedure, no cement was used between the tray wall and bone. For the cementless UKR a layer of titanium filled the cement pocket. An intact tibia was used to compare to the cemented and cementless UKR implanted tibiae. The tibia was sectioned by the tray wall, defining the radiolucency zone (parallel to the vertical tray wall, 2 mm wide with a volume of 782.5 mm3), corresponding to the region on screened x-rays where radiolucencies are observed. Contact mechanics algorithms were used between all contacting surfaces; bonded contact was also introduced between the tray wall and adjacent bone, simulating a mechanical tie between them. Strain energy density (SED), was compared between the intact and implanted tibia for the radiolucency zone. Equivalent strains were compared on the proximal tibia between the intact and implanted tibia models. Forty patients (20 cemented, 20 cementless) who had undergone UKR were randomly selected from a database, and assessed for radiolucency.Introduction
Materials and methods
Anteromedial gonarthrosis is a common well described pattern of knee osteoarthritis with cartilage wear beginning in the anteromedial quadrant of the medial tibial plateau in the presence of an intact and functioning ACL. It is well known that mechanical factors such as limb alignment and meniscal integrity affect the progression of arthritis and there is some evidence that the morphology of the tibial plateau may be a risk factor in the development of this disease. The extension facet angle is the angle of the downslope of the anterior portion of the medial tibial plateau joint surface in relation to the middle portion on a sagittal view. If this is an important factor in the development of AMG there may be potential for disease modifying intervention. This study investigates if there is a significant difference in this angle as measured on MRI between a study cohort with early AMG (partial thickness cartilage damage and intact ACL) and a comparator control cohort of patients (no cartilage damage and ACL rupture). 3 Tesla MRI scans of 99 patients; 54 with partial thickness cartilage damage and 44 comparitors with no cartilage damage (acute ACL rupture) were assessed. The extension facet angle was measured (Osirix v3.6) using a validated technique on two consecutive MRI T2 sagittal slices orientated at the mid-coronal point of the medial femoral condyle. (InterClass Correlation 0.95, IntraClass Correlation 0.97, within subject variation of 1.1° and coefficient of variation 10.7%). The mean of the two extension angle values was used. The results were tabulated and analysed (R v2.9.1).Introduction
Methods
The results of the mobile bearing Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) in the lateral compartment have been disappointing with a five year survival of 82%. Therefore, it is recommended that mobile bearings should not be used for lateral UKR. This low survivorship is primarily due to high dislocation rate, all occurring in the first year. A detailed analysis of the causes of bearing dislocation confirmed the elevated lateral tibial joint line to be a contributory factor. A new surgical technique was therefore introduced in which care was taken neither to remove too much bone from distal femur nor to over tighten the knee and thus ensure that the tibial joint line was not elevated. Other modifications to the technique were also introduced including use of a domed tibial component. The aim of this study is to compare the outcome of these iterations: the original series [series I], Series II with improved surgical technique and the domed tibial component [Series III].Introduction
Aim
Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) accounts for 84% of all knee replacement surgery in the UK (NJR 2009) despite published epidemiological data showing that single compartment disease is most prevalent. We investigated this incompatibility further by describing the compartmental pattern and stage of cartilage loss of all patients with osteoarthritis (OA) presenting to a specialist knee clinic over one year. All new primary referrals in a calendar year by local General Practitioners to knee clinic at a United Kingdom Hospital were assessed. Tertiary referrals and second opinions were excluded. The final diagnosis after all imaging was recorded and tabulated. The standing AP, lateral and skyline radiographs of all cases of arthritis were scored to assess the pattern of disease.Introduction
Methods
We obtained information from the Elective Orthopaedic
Centre on 1523 patients with baseline and six-month Oxford hip scores
(OHS) after undergoing primary hip replacement (THR) and 1784 patients
with Oxford knee scores (OKS) for primary knee replacement (TKR)
who completed a six-month satisfaction questionnaire. Receiver operating characteristic curves identified an absolute
change in OHS of 14 points or more as the point that discriminates
best between patients’ satisfaction levels and an 11-point change
for the OKS. Satisfaction is highest (97.6%) in patients with an
absolute change in OHS of 14 points or more, compared with lower
levels of satisfaction (81.8%) below this threshold. Similarly,
an 11-point absolute change in OKS was associated with 95.4% satisfaction
compared with 76.5% below this threshold. For the six-month OHS
a score of 35 points or more distinguished patients with the highest
satisfaction level, and for the six-month OKS 30 points or more identified
the highest level of satisfaction. The thresholds varied according
to patients’ pre-operative score, where those with severe pre-operative
pain/function required a lower six-month score to achieve the highest
levels of satisfaction. Our data suggest that the choice of a six-month follow-up to
assess patient-reported outcomes of THR/TKR is acceptable. The thresholds
help to differentiate between patients with different levels of
satisfaction, but external validation will be required prior to
general implementation in clinical practice.
To investigate the linear penetration rate of the polyethylene bearing in unicompartmental knee arthroplasty at twenty years. The Phase 1 Oxford medial UKR was introduced in 1978 as a design against wear, with a fully congruous articulation. In 1987 the Phase 2 implant was introduced with new instrumentation and changes to the bearing shape. We have previously shown a linear penetration rate (LPR) of 0.02 mm/year at ten years in Phase 2, but that higher penetration rates can be seen with impingement. The aim of this study was to determine the 20 year in-vivo LPR of the Oxford UKR, using Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis (RSA).Purpose of study
Introduction
Obesity has been considered a relative contra-indication in unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) due to fear of high wear rates, loosening and tibial collapse. The aim of this study was to investigate the impact of high body mass index (BMI) on ten-year survivorship and five-year functional outcome after Oxford UKA, a fully congruous mobile bearing design with large contact area and low wear rate. This prospective study examines a consecutive series of 595 knees (mean age 66 years, range: 33-88) undergoing Oxford UKA with a minimum 5-year follow-up. Patients were divided into three groups; Group I (Normal body weight), BMI <25 (n=171), Group II (overweight), BMI 25- 30 (n=264), and Group III (Obese), BMI ≥30 (n=160). The survivorship and functional outcome (as assessed by change in Oxford Knee Score [DeltaOKS]) and Knee Society Score (KSS) for all three groups were compared.Introduction
Methods
This aim of this study was to investigate apoptosis, reactive oxygen species (ROS), and their upstream markers in Anteromedial Gonarthrosis (AMG). Ten resection specimens, from patients undergoing unicompartmental knee replacement for AMG, and ten control specimens, collected from vascular disease patients undergoing above knee amputation, were used. Routine histology and immunohistochemical studies were conducted for Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL), Active Caspase 3, Cytochrome C, Active Bax, Bim, 3-Nitrotyrosine and Forkhead box O3A (FOXO 3A).Aim
Methods
To assess the incidence of radiolucency in cemented and cementless Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement at two years. Most unicompartmental knee replacements (UKRs) employ cement for fixation of the prosthetic components. The information in the literature about the relative merits of cemented and cementless UKR is contradictory, with some favouring cementless fixation and others favouring cemented fixation. In addition, there is concern about the radiolucency that frequently develops beneath the tibial component with cemented fixation. The exact cause of the occurrence of radiolucency is unknown but it has been hypothesised that it may suggest suboptimal fixation.Purpose of Study
Introduction
Kozinn and Scott have made recommendations about contra-indications for unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR). They suggest that patients younger than 60, weight > 82 kilograms, patients with exposed bone in patella-femoral compartment or patients who are physically active/perform heavy labour should not be offered a UKR. In addition, chondrocalcinosis is a contra-indication. These strict selection criteria are based on the experience with fixed bearing UKAs and are more intuitive than evidence based. The Oxford UKR has a fully congruous mobile bearing and has been shown to have minimal wear. Over the past 25 years, the Oxford Group has followed a standardised protocol for patient selection for UKR. We ignore patella-femoral joint pathology, chondrocalcinosis, patient's age, weight and activity level when deciding the suitability for UKR. Using the standardised indications, more than 1100 Oxford UKRs have been performed to date over the last 10 years. These patients are assessed pre-operatively and at regular intervals post-operatively in a dedicated research clinic. We present the results of these consecutive cases. Patients were classified into two groups: group I (satisfy Kozinn-Scott recommendations) and group II (outside recommendations).Introduction
Methods
In 12 patients, we measured the oxygen concentration in the femoral head-neck junction during hip resurfacing through the anterolateral approach. This was compared with previous measurements made for the posterior approach. For the anterolateral approach, the oxygen concentration was found to be highly dependent upon the position of the leg, which was adjusted during surgery to provide exposure to the acetabulum and femoral head. Gross external rotation of the hip gave a significant decrease in oxygenation of the femoral head. Straightening the limb led to recovery in oxygen concentration, indicating that the blood supply was maintained. The oxygen concentration at the end of the procedure was not significantly different from that at the start. The anterolateral approach appears to produce less disruption to the blood flow in the femoral head-neck junction than the posterior approach for patients undergoing hip resurfacing. This may be reflected subsequently in a lower incidence of fracture of the femoral neck and avascular necrosis.
This study aims to investigate femoral blood flow during Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing (MMHR) by monitoring oxygen concentration during the operative procedure. Patients undergoing MMHR using the posterior approach were evaluated. Following division of fascia lata, a calibrated gas-measuring electrode was inserted into the femoral neck, aiming for the supero-lateral quadrant of the head. Baseline oxygen concentration levels were detected after electrode insertion 2-3cm below the femoral head surface and all intra-operative measures were referenced against these. Oxygen levels were continuously monitored throughout the operation. Data from ten patients are presented. Oxygen concentration dropped most noticeably during the surgical approach and was reduced by 62% (Std.dev +/-26%) following dislocation and capsulectomy. Insertion of implants resulted in a further oxygenation decrease by 18% (Std.dev +/-28%). The last obtained measure before wound closure detected 22% (Std.dev +/-31%) of initial baseline oxygen levels. Variation between subjects was observed and three patients demonstrated a limited recovery of oxygen levels during implant insertion and hip relocation. Intra-operative measurement of oxygen concentration in blood perfusing the femoral head is feasible. Results in ten patients undergoing MMHR showed a dramatic effect on the oxygenation in the femoral head during surgical approach and implant fixation. This may increase the risk of avascular necrosis and subsequent femoral neck fracture. Future experiments will determine if less invasive procedures or specific positioning of the limb can protect the blood supply to femoral neck and head.
