The aim of our study was to compare the incidence of post-operative anterior knee discomfort after anterograde tibial nailing by suprapatellar and infrapatellar approaches. 95 subjects presenting with a tibial fracture requiring an intramedullary nail were randomised to treatment using a suprapatellar (SP) or infrapatellar (IP) approach. Anterior knee discomfort was assessed at 4 months, 6 months and 1 year post operatively using the Aberdeen Weightbearing Test-Knee (AWT-K), knee specific patient reported outcome measures and the VAS pain score. The AWT-K is an objective measure which uses weight transmitted through the knee when kneeling as a surrogate for anterior knee discomfort. 53 patients were randomised to an SP approach and 42 to an IP approach. AWT-K results showed a greater mean proportion of weight transmitted through the injured leg compared to the uninjured leg when kneeling in the SP group compared to the IP group at all time points at all follow-up visits. This reached significance at 4 months for all time points except 30 seconds. It also reached significance at 6 months at 0 seconds and 1 year at 60 seconds. We conclude that the SP approach for anterograde tibial nailing reduces anterior knee discomfort post operatively compared to the IP approach.
Pelvic ring fractures usually result from significant trauma, frequently requiring operative stabilisation. The use of an anterior internal fixator (INFIX) is a new technique. This temporary construct is quick and easy to apply using pre-existing spinal implants. No reports of functional outcomes or compartive studies with existing surgical techniques exist in indexed literature. We present a prospective comparative case matched series of 21 patients treated with pelvic INFIX. 1:1 matching was achieved to a cohort of patients treated with open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) based on fracture pattern. All patients with rotationally and/or vertically unstable pelvic ring fractures treated within our level 1 trauma centre were considered for inclusion. Patients were prospectively followed up with health outcome measures (SF-36, EQ-5D) and joint specific outcome scores (Oxford and Harris hip scores). No statistically significant differences in age (mean 42v38 p=0.3143), length of stay, or operative time were seen. The ISS was significantly higher in the INFIX group (32v22 p=0.0019). Mean INFIX removal was at 14 weeks. Baseline responses were obtained on admission where feasible. Although there was no significant difference between the treatment groups, the ORIF group showed a significantly greater deterioration from the baseline than the INFIX group, suggesting INFIX better maintains pre-injury function. 29% of patients experienced LCNT palsy whilst the INFIX was in situ. 6 patients in the INFIX group experienced some form of metal work failure (3 required surgical removal), compared with 7 ORIF patients (4 required removal). Pelvic INFIX achieves bony stabilisation of unstable pelvic fractures, and should be considered for rotational or vertically unstable fractures requiring operative intervention. Despite higher ISS scores, INFIX patients performance in joint specific and global health functioning scores was not significantly different from ORIF patients. We do not use INFIX for pelvic fractures with symphyseal disruption.Results
Conclusions
This study demonstrates the utility of a modified postero-medial surgical approach to the knee in treating a series of patients with complex tibial plateau injuries with associated postero-medial shear fractures. Postero-medial shear fractures are under-appreciated and their clinical relevance have recently been characterised. Less invasive surgery and indirect reduction techniques are inadequate for treating these postero-medial coronal plane fractures. The approach includes an inverted ‘L’ shaped incision and reflection of the medial head of gastrocnemius, while protecting the neurovascular structures. This is a more extensile exposure than described by Trickey (1968). Our case series includes 8 females and 8 males. The average age is 53.1 years. The mechanism of injury included 7 RTAs, 5 fall from height, 1 industrial accident and 3 valgus injuries. All patients' schatzker grade 4, or above, fractures with a posteromedial split depression. Two were open, two had vascular compromise and one had neurological injury.Hypothesis
Methods
Patients presenting with a fractured neck of femur are a fragile group with multiple co-morbidities who are at risk of post-operative complications. As many as 52% of patients are reported to suffer a urinary tract infection post hip fracture surgery. There are little data surrounding the effects of post-operative urinary tract infections on mortality and deep prosthetic infection. We prospectively investigated the impact of post-operative urinary tract infection (UTI) in 9168 patients admitted to our institution with a diagnosis of proximal femoral fracture over an eleven year period in a prospective population study. We examined the effects of post operative UTI on the incidence of deep infection, survivorship and length of stay. Post-operative UTI occurred in 6.1% (n=561) and deep infection in 0.89% (n=82). Deep infection was significantly more common in patients complicated with a UTI (3.2% vs 0.74% p< 0.001) with a relative risk of 3.7:1. In 58% of patients the same organisms was cultured in the urine and hip samples. A postoperative UTI did not adversely effect 90 day survival, however was associated with an increased length of stay (ROC analysis AUC=0.79). Delays to surgery and age were not predictive of a post operative UTI. Recognition of the risks posed by post operative UTI, the risk factors for development of infection and early treatment is essential to reduce the risks of increased subsequent periprosthetic infection.
It was hypothesised that preserving a layer of gliding tissue, the parietal layer of the ulnar bursa, between the contents of the carpal tunnel and the soft tissues incised during carpal tunnel surgery might reduce scar pain and improve grip strength and function following open carpal tunnel decompression. Patients consented to randomisation to treatment with either preservation of the parietal layer of the ulnar bursa beneath the flexor retinaculum at the time of open carpal tunnel decompression (57 patients) or division of this gliding layer as part of a standard open carpal tunnel decompression (61 patients). Grip strength was measured, scar pain was rated and the validated Patient Evaluation Measure questionnaire was used to assess symptoms and disability pre-operatively and at eight to nine weeks following surgery in seventy-seven women and thirty-four men; the remaining seven patients were lost to follow-up.Background
Methods
Scaphoid fracture malunion with flexion and shortening results in the ‘humpback deformity’. This is thought to be associated with poor clinical results when assessed with the lateral intra-scaphoid angle and the Green and O'Brien wrist evaluation scale. This method of deformity measurement is now considered unreliable and the functional score has not been validated in the setting of scaphoid fractures. To assess the outcome of scaphoid malunion at one year using the height to length ratio, a reliable measure of deformity, and the Patient Evaluation Measure (PEM), a functional assessment validated specifically for scaphoid fracture outcome.Background
Aims & objectives
Comminuted subtrochanteric fractures pose a clinical challenge; locking plate technology has been theorized to offer treatment advantages. A comminuted subtrochanteric femoral fracture model was created with a 2 cm gap below the lesser trochanter in fifteen matched pairs of human cadaveric femora confirmed to be non-osteoporotic. The femora were randomized to treatment with a trochanteric femoral nail (TFN), proximal femoral locking plate (PFLP), or 95° angled blade plate (ABP). Each was tested under incrementally increasing cyclic load up to 90,000 cycles to simulate progressive weight bearing during three months. The TFN was the strongest implant: it withstood significantly more cycles, failed at a significantly higher force, and withstood a significantly greater load than either plate (p<
0.001). Varus collapse was significantly lower in the TFN construct (p<
0.0001). Mode of failure differed among implants, with damage to the femoral head through implant cut-out in five of ten blade plate specimens and two of ten nail specimens, whereas no damage to the femoral head bone was observed in any of the PFLP specimens. The TFN was biomechanically stronger than the PFLP and this may have clinical relevance during the slow healing of subtrochanteric femoral fractures. The PFLP was biomechanically equivalent to the ABP but failure occurred without significant damage to the femoral head, suggesting that although biomechanically equivalent, the PFLP might have clinically relevant advantages in its mode of failure over the ABP.
We aim to assess the AP distance and teardrop angles in a cohort of normal wrists and to assess their possible use as prognostic indicators in fractures of the distal radius. Two hundred standardised PA and lateral wrist radiographs from uninjured wrists and 95 patients with fractures of the distal radius were assessed and anatomic parameters measured, including the Teardrop angle and AP distance. Clinical assessment at a mean of 6 years post fracture included an assessment of grip strength and range of motion along with the DASH score. The mean teardrop angle in 200 normal wrists was 68 degrees (95%CI:67–69 degrees) and did not differ significantly between sexes (p=0.148). The average teardrop angle at presentation in 95 fractures of the distal radius was 47 degrees (95%CI:41–50 degrees), improving significantly to 58 degrees (95%CI:56–61 degrees, p<
0.0001) post-reduction, and this improvement was maintained at 56 degrees (95%CI:54–59 degrees) at union. The final position was significantly better than at presentation (p<
0.0001). Loss of teardrop angle between the fractured and uninjured wrist was significantly related to reduced grip strength (p=0.04) and worse DASH score (p=0.03). The mean AP distance in 200 normal wrists was 19.6mm (95%CI:19.4–19.9mm) in males and 17.6mm (95%CI:17.2–18.0mm) in females, which is significantly different (p<
0.0001). The mean AP Distance at presentation in 95 fractures of the distal radius was 21.0mm (95%CI:20.4–21.7mm), which improved significantly to 19.6 (95%CI:19.1–20.2mm, p<
0.0001), but subsequently worsened to 20.8mm (95%CI:20.2–20.4mm) at union. This is not significantly better than at presentation (p=0.397). An increase in AP distance in the fractured wrist correlated to loss of range of motion (p<
0.01). The value of these parameters is that they offer quite detailed assessment of the articular surface of the distal radius in the absence of more detailed imaging. They appear to be of prognostic value.
Current design guidelines for the front end of motor vehicles aim to reduce tibial fractures but this may be at the expense of an increased risk of injury to the knee itself . The purpose of this study was to describe the type of knee injuries and group characteristics of those sustaining them with a view to initiating a more detailed research project in injuries to the lower limb. The medical records of all patients aged 16 years and over presenting to the Accident &
Emergency (A&
E) Department at University Hospital Nottingham with a knee injury sustained in a road traffic accident between April 1992 and December 1998 were identified and reviewed. In a total of 374 patients, 178 sustained significant knee injuries, requiring admission to hospital. 78% of these sustained a fracture, with fracture of the tibial plateau being most common. 22% of patients sustained ligamentous injury. Almost 50% of patients received operative treatment during the first month after injury. Current legislation may be responsible for placing pedestrians at more risk from knee injuries. An understanding of the mechanism of knee injury compared with tibial fracture is important and recommendations for prevention of injury can then be instituted.
