Introduction

To evaluate the clinical success and hip pain and function of patients with infected hip replacement treated by two-stage exchange using a temporary implant with high dose vancomycin added to the antibiotic cement at the first stage revision.

This study aimed to compare the early clinical results and stem subsidence between three consecutive series of revision hip replacement cases with femoral impaction bone grafting to evaluate the effects of developments in technique. In the original series 1 (n=23), bone graft was irradiated at 25kG. I n series 2 (n=12) non-irradiated double washed graft and long stems were used as required.

In series 3 (n=21) modular tamps were used. Sensitive radiographic analysis techniques, EBRA and RSA, were used to measure stem subsidence. Major stem re-revision was required in five hips in series one, one hip in series two and no hips in series three. Two periprosthetic fractures occurred in series one. There was a statistically significant reduction in stem subsidence at the cement-bone interface at 12 months between series one and series two and three (p<0.05). In series three there was negligible stem subsidence at the cement-bone interface.

Technique developments in femoral impaction grafting, including the use of modular tamps designed to simply the procedure, yields excellent early clinical and radiographic results. Using RSA, we have shown that the fixation of the stems in bone is comparable to that achieved in primary hip replacement.

Background: Good results have been reported for cemented femoral total hip arthroplasty in young patients from centres with expert surgeons but what is unknown are the results when surgeries are performed by a group of surgeons with varying experience in total hip replacement. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the outcome of primary total hip arthroplasty using a polished cemented polished collarless double tapered stem in young patients aged less than 55 years performed by a group of surgeons with varying experience in total hip replacement.

Methods: One hundred and ninety seven arthroplasties in 169 patients were performed between 1988 to 2005. The procedures were performed by surgeons with varying arthroplasty experience. Follow-up was 2 to 19 years (median 8 years). Clinical outcomes, radiographic evaluations and survivorship analyses were undertaken.

Results: Of the 197 femoral stems, eight were revised, but none for aseptic loosening. Four stems underwent cement within cement revision for recurrent dislocation, leg length discrepancy, infection and to assist cup revision. Two stems were revised for periprosthetic fractures. Two stems were revised for infection. No stems were classified as probably or possibly loose. Median stem within cement subsidence was 1.0mm. Two stems have more than 5mm vertical subsidence and in the absence of radiolucent lines or associated pain they were not considered loose. At long term follow-up the overall incidence of femoral osteolysis was 7% (n=13 hips). At latest patient follow-up the median Harris Hip and pain scores were respectively 81 (range 34 to 100) and 40 (range 10 to 44). Survivorship of the polished collarless double tapered stems at 13 years using the endpoint revision for aseptic loosening was 100% (worst case analysis 96.5%).

Conclusion: This study confirms that good results of cemented polished collarless double tapered stems in the younger patient can be achieved by a group of surgeons with varying experience in total hip replacement. The ability to perform a minor stem revision, cement within cement, for other reasons than aseptic loosening further strengthens the indications for these type of implants in young patients.

Introduction: In the past, surgeons have found impaction bone grafting technically difficult leading to its limited use. This paper reviews the long term results and developments in instrumentation and techniques aimed at simplifying femoral impaction grafting at revision hip replacement. The expanded indications for this procedure are reviewed and recent results of stem fixation using radiostereometric analysis (RSA) are reported.

Methods: The impaction bone grafting procedure, using a cemented collarless polished double taper stem, has been used in 66 hips (median patient age 63yrs) since 1993. The technique has undergone numerous developments. Modular tamps have been used in the last 29 hips and in the last seven hips, a pneumatic mechanical vibration device has been used in place of manual impaction. Stem subsidence at both the prosthesis-cement and cement-graft/bone interfaces was measured, more recently using radiostereometric analysis.

Results: There was a high early incidence of failure in the initial cases but there have been no further revisions for mechanical failure at up to 15 years. Technique developments have resulted in dramatic improvements in stem fixation achieved. In the modular tamp cases, the mean stem subsidence at the cement-bone interface at 12 months was 0.07mm (0 to 0.7mm) at 12 months. The stem subsidence in the hips where the mechanical vibration device was used was 0.05mm (0 to 0.06mm). Femoral impaction grafting offers special advantages in younger patients include standard femoral stem revision and at the second stage of two stage revision for infection.

Discussion and Conclusion: A stable cement-bone interface is achieved using advanced techniques of femoral impaction grafting that includes the use of modular impaction instruments. Early results of mechanical vibration impaction are encouraging. Femoral impaction grafting restores bone and new techniques simplify the femoral revision procedure.

While computed tomography (CT) provides an accurate measure of osteolysis volume, it would be advantageous in general clinical practice if plain radiographs could be used to monitor osteolysis. This study determined the ability of plain radiographs to detect the presence of and determine the progression in size of osteolytic lesions around cementless acetabular components.

Nineteen acetabular components were diagnosed with osteolysis using a high-resolution multi-slice CT scanner with metal artefact suppression. Mean duration since arthroplasty was 14 years (range 10–15 years) at initial CT. Repeat CT scans were undertaken over a five year period to determine osteolysis progression. On anteroposterior pelvis (AP) radiographs and oblique radiographs of the acetabulum seen on the rolled lateral hip view, which were taken at the same time as the CT scans, area of osteolysis was measured manually correcting for magnification.

Osteolysis was detected on the AP radiographs in 8 of 19 hips (42%), on the oblique radiographs in 6 of 19 hips (32%) and on the combined AP and oblique radiographs in 8 of 19 hips (42%). Throughout the study period, osteolysis was detected on 31 of 76 AP radiographs (41%) and 22 of 75 oblique radiographs (29%). Osteolysis was more likely to be detected on plain radiographs if the lesion volume was greater than 10cm3 in size (p=0.005). On CT, osteolysis progressed by more than 1cm3/yr in 10 of 19 hips (55%). In these ten hips, osteolysis progression was detected on AP radiographs in six hips and on oblique radiographs in three hips. No correlation was found between osteolysis progression measured by CT and that measured on AP (r2=0.16, p=0.37) or oblique (r2=0.37, p=0.15) or AP and oblique radiographs (r2=0.34, p=0.17).

Plain radiographs are poor in monitoring progression in size of periacetabular osteolytic lesions. Plain radiographs may detect lesions more than 10cm3 in size, but are unreliable.

Differentially loaded radiostereometric analysis (DLRSA) uses RSA whilst simultaneously applying load to the bones under investigation. This technique allows measurement of interfragmentary translations and rotations under measured amounts of weight bearing. The aim of this paper was to measure the mechanical stiffness of distal femoral fractures during healing.

Six patients with a 33A2, 33A3, 33B2 and 33C2 fracture were treated with open reduction, internal fixation using a long bridging plate. All patients had a DLRSA examination at 6, 12, 18 and 26 weeks postoperatively. Each DLRSA examination consisted of RSA radiographs taken without load (pre-load), under different increments of load, and finally, without load (post-load). The direction and magnitude of the interfragmentary displacements in six degrees of freedom were recorded at each examination.

DLRSA examinations were able to monitor the inter-fragmentary displacements of the distal femoral fragment relative to the femoral shaft. The interfragmentary displacement recorded, progressively increased as more load was applied in all patients, at all follow-up time points. The two dimensional (2D) translations under maximum tolerated load, progressively decreased over time in three patients. The 2D translations recorded under 60 kg of load at 26 weeks for these patients was 0.18, 0.21 and 0.27mm. The 2D translations of two patients did not decrease progressively between 6 and 18 weeks but did decrease at 26 weeks to 0.47 and 0.75mm. One patient recorded 2D translations of 4.11, 3.48 and 4.53mm under 30kg at 12, 18 and 26 weeks respectively. In the majority of examinations, post-load radiographs enabled the interfragmentary displacements under load to be identified as elastic in nature.

The DLRSA stiffness data confirmed that at 26 weeks three patients had united; two were delayed but improving; and one was a clear non-union without progression. DLRSA examinations may be used as a clinical research tool. to monitor in vivo the stiffness of healing femoral fractures fixed with “relative stability”.

Computed tomography (CT) provides a sensitive and accurate measure of periacetabular osteolytic lesion volume, however, there may remain a role for plain radiographs in monitoring osteolysis. This study aimed to compare CT and plain radiographs for determining the progression in size of osteolytic lesions around cementless acetabular components.

A high-resolution multi-slice CT scanner with metal artefact suppression was used to determine the volume and progression of osteolysis around 19 cementless Harris Galante-1 and PCA acetabular components. The mean duration since arthroplasty was 14 years (range 10–15 years) at initial CT. Repeat scans of the hip were undertaken over a five year period to determine the progression in size of osteolytic lesions over time. A second blinded observer manually measured the area of osteolytic lesions off anteroposterior pelvis radiographs and oblique radiographs of the acetabulum that were taken at the same time as the CT scan.

All 19 hips had CT detected osteolysis. Osteolysis was detected on one or both of the anteroposterior pelvis or oblique radiographs from at least one time point in eight of 19 hips (42%). Osteolysis was detected on 31 of 76 anteroposterior pelvis radiographs (41%) and on 22 of 75 oblique radiographs (29%) (p=0.140). Osteolysis was more likely to be detected on plain radiographs if the lesion volume was greater than 10cm3 in size compared to those 5–10cm3 and less than 5cm3 in size (p=0.009). In 10 of 19 hips (55%), CT determined that osteolytic lesions progressed in size by more than 1cm3/yr. The mean volume of osteolysis progression was 3.2cm3/yr (range 1.1–7.5cm3/yr). Progression in size of osteolytic lesions was significantly associated with hips with larger osteolytic lesions at the initial CT (p=0.0004). Radiographic measurements detected progression of osteolytic lesions in 5 of the 10 hips (50%) that progressed. No correlation was found between progression in size of osteolytic lesions as measured by CT and progression in size of osteolytic lesions as measured off the anteroposterior pelvis (r2 = 0.16, p=0.37), oblique (r2=0.37, p=0.15) and combined anteroposterior pelvis and oblique radiographs (r2=0.34, p=0.17).

Periacetabular osteolytic lesions are more likely to be detected on plain radiographs if they are more than 10cm3 in size. Plain radiographs may therefore provide some monitoring value as lesions more than 10cm3 are more likely to be progressive. However, plain radiographs should not be relied upon to monitor the progression of these lesions.

Differentially loaded radiostereometric analysis (DLRSA) uses RSA whilst simultaneously applying load to the bones under investigation. This technique allows measurement of interfragmentary translations and rotations under measured weight bearing and joint movement. We have recently introduced this technique to monitor tibial plateau fracture healing. This paper presents our preliminary results.

Twelve patients with a 41 B2, B3, C2, or C3 fracture were followed for a minimum of three months. RSA beads were inserted in the largest osteochondral fragment and the adjacent metaphysis. Knee flexion was restricted to 60° for 6 weeks. After partial weight bearing (20kg) between 2 and 6 weeks, patients progressed to full weight bearing. Follow up included clinical and radiological examinations and patient reported outcome scores (Lysholm, KOOS). DLRSA examinations included RSA radiographs in 60° flexion and under measured weight bearing. Significant interfragmentary displacement was defined as translations greater than 0.5mm and/or rotations greater than 1.5°.

There was no loss to follow-up. Longitudinal RSA follow-up: Follow-up RSA radiographs were compared to postoperative examinations. Osteochondral fragment depression was less than 0.5mm in seven patients and between 2 and 4mm in the remaining five patients. Significant interfragmentary displacement after three months was recorded in three patients. DLRSA flexion results: Under 60° of flexion, translations over 0.5mm were recorded in five patients (one postoperatively; one at 2 weeks; two at 6 weeks; and one postoperatively, at 2 weeks and at 3 months). Rotations over 1.5° were recorded in six patients (one postoperatively; two at 2 weeks; one at 6 weeks; one at 2 weeks, 3 months and 4.5 months; and one postoperatively, at 2 weeks, 3 months and 6 months). DLRSA weight bearing results: Under partial weight bearing at two weeks, two patients recorded significant translations, one involving a significant rotation. Under weight bearing as tolerated, three patients recorded significant translations (one at 6 weeks; and two at 18 weeks) and four patients recorded significant rotations (one at 6 weeks; one at 18 weeks; and two at 12 and 18 weeks). Patient Reported Outcomes: Both the Lysholm and KOOS scores improved between 6 weeks and 3 months. DLRSA provides new insight and perspective in tibial plateau fractures. Some fractures take more than three months to heal. Our current rehabilitation protocol was safe in most patients, however significant interfragmentary displacement was encountered in 17% at the 2 week followup, raising questions about the quality of the initial stability.

Irradiating allograft bone may compromise the mechanical stability of the prosthesis-bone construct, potentially having adverse effects on the outcome of femoral impaction grafting at revision hip replacement. This in vitro study aimed to determine the effect of irradiation of allograft bone used in femoral impaction grafting on initial prosthesis stability.

Morsellised ovine femoral head bone was irradiated at 0 kGy (control), 15 kGy and 60 kGy. For each group, six ovine femurs were implanted with a cemented polished double taper stem following femoral impaction bone grafting. Dynamic hip joint loading was applied to the femoral head using a servo-hydraulic materials testing machine. The primary outcome was stem micromotion. Tri-axial micromotion of the stem relative to the bone at two sites was measured using linear variable differential transformers and non-contact laser motion transducers. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS.

Compared to the control and 15 kGy groups, specimens in the 60 kGy group demonstrated statistically significant greater micromotion in the axial, antero-posterior and medio-lateral axes. A multi-factorial post-hoc power analysis based on the overall effect of group size indicated a power of 0.7. There was no difference in micromotion between the control and 15 kGy groups. The average micromotion in the axial axes was 63μm in the control and 59μm in the 15 kGy group.

The results of this study suggest that a maximum irradiation dose of 15 kGy may not affect initial prosthesis stability following femoral impaction grafting in this model and provide the basis for us to now proceed to in-vivo studies examining the effect of irradiated bone on implant stability over time.

Periprosthetic osteolysis is a serious medium to long-term complication of total hip arthroplasty. Interobserver reliability of detecting osteolysis around cementless ace-tabular components is reported to be poor using plain radiographs. Quantitative computed tomography (CT) provides sensitive and accurate measures of osteolytic lesion volume, however, there may remain a role for plain radiographs in monitoring progression of osteolysis. The aim of this study was to use quantitative CT to monitor the progression of osteolytic lesions around cementless acetabular components and to compare plain radiographs and CT in determining the progression of osteolysis.

A high-resolution multi-slice quantitative CT scanner with metal artefact suppression was used to determine the volume of osteolysis around 18 cementless acetabular components. The mean time since arthroplasty was 14 years (range 10–15 years) at the initial CT. Repeat scans of the hip were undertaken over a five-year period to determine progression of osteolysis with time. A second blinded observer examined anteroposterior and lateral plain radiographs taken at the same time as the CT scans and measured the location and area of osteolytic lesions.

CT measurements determined that in ten of 18 hips (56%), osteolytic lesions progressed by more than 1cm3/yr. Progression in size of osteolytic lesions was significantly associated with hips with larger osteolytic lesions at the initial CT (p=0.0005). The mean volume of osteolysis progression was 4.9cm3/year (range 2.8–7.5cm3/yr) for cases with osteolysis volumes greater than 10cm3 at the initial CT, and 0.7cm3/yr (range 0–2.3cm3/yr) for cases with osteolysis volumes smaller than or equal to 10cm3 at the initial CT (p=0.002). Importantly, the rate of osteolysis progression between CT scans varied greatly in some hips. In contrast, using plain radiograph assessment, progression in the area of osteolytic lesions was only detected in 10% of hips.

In conclusion, quantitative CT provides new insights into the natural history of periacetabular osteolysis. Total osteolysis volume greater than 10cm3 is associated with a high risk of progression and progress, on average, at a greater rate than those less than 10cm3. Plain radiographs, including a lateral view, are an unreliable clinical diagnostic tool to predict substantial progression of periacetabular osteolytic lesions.

Introduction and Aims: This paper presents a treatment plan for femoral stem revision that has been developed based on long-term studies of revision total hip replacement (THR) using cemented stems, cementless proximal fixation stems, cemented stems with impaction grafting and modular titanium long stems.

Method: The clinical and radiographic results of femoral stem revision were compared using the following techniques: 1) a standard or long cemented collarless double taper Exeter or CPT stems (CCDT stems) [n=190]; 2) a proximally porous coated mid to long cementless stem [n=56]; 3) two series of CCDT stems with impaction grafting n=34]; and 4) a modular grit-blasted titanium taper stem [n=13] used for severe cortical damage. Treatment decisions were made based on the age of the patient, the appearance of the pre-operative radiograph and the extent of bone deficiency at surgery. Follow-up was from 17 to two years.

Results: Only one hip was lost to follow-up. In the CCDT group, at a median follow-up of five years (range 2–17 years), two standard length stems and one long stem had been re-revised for loosening (1.5%) and seven stems had been re-revised for other reasons. Survivorship to re-revision for loosening at eight years was 95% (95%CI=85–100%) for both standard and long stems. There was a trend for better longer-term results for long stems. The extent of pre-operative bone loss did not influence results. For the cementless proximal fixation group, at a median follow-up of 10 years, re-revision of the stem for loosening occurred in 20%. Importantly, these poor results could have been predicted from short-term results. The initial series of femoral impaction grafting with CCDT stems and irradiated bone had a small incidence of stem loosening and periprosthetic fracture. The majority of stems subsided, but at a median follow-up of eight years there were no further re-revisions. In the second series, usually with non-irradiated allograft with mesh containment, there was minimal stem subsidence and no re-revision. The grit blasted titanium taper stem has dealt with periprosthetic fratures and severe proximal cortical loss, but with some cases of subsidence and femoral fracture.

Conclusion: Based on these results, our treatment plan for routine femoral revision in middle-aged and elderly patients without severe proximal deficiency is a polished CCDT long stem. In younger patients, impaction grafting is recommended, provided deficient bone is protected. Cementless modular stems are reserved for femurs with severe proximal cortical deficiency.

Introduction and Aims: The usefulness of bone graft substitutes and growth factors to promote bone graft incorporation and prosthesis fixation in hip replacement should be examined in a loaded model, as results from cortical defect models may not apply. This paper reviews the results of femoral impaction grafting using these materials in an ovine hip replacement model.

Method: At cemented hemiarthroplasty, sheep femurs were impacted with allograft bone (control group n=23) or with allograft mixed with: 1) corglaes bioglass (n=12); 2) a synthetic hydroxyapatite (HA) (n=6) or the bone morpohogenetic protein OP-1 (n=6) (study groups) and implanted with a cemented double taper femoral stem. Sheep were sacrificed at between six and 26 weeks. The primary outcome was femoral stem subsidence, as determined more recently by the development of clinical radiostereometric analysis (RSA) in this model. Femoral fixation, as assessed by ex-vivo mechanical testing, and bone graft incorporation, as assessed by histological review and histoquantitation, were also key outcomes.

Results: In the control groups, there was a consistent response with bone graft incorporation by new bone advancing proximal to distally in the femur and advancing from the endocortex towards the cement mantle. Mineralised bone apposition occurred by six weeks and this was preceeded by partial resorption of the graft. Complete graft incorporation, with subsequent remodelling of bone, was evident proximally by 26 weeks. Bone graft incorporation in femurs impacted with a 1:1 allograft: bioglass mix was minimal and there was often partial or complete resorption of the graft with replacement by fibrous tissue, resorption of endocortical bone and instability of the femoral prosthesis. Supplementation of allograft with OP-1 promotes initial graft resorption, thus hastening bone graft incorporation and remodelling but one case of stem subsidence, that may have been associated with early resorption seen in the OP-1 group, reinforces the need for further studies examining dose response. There was excellent incorporation of the allograft and HA, with new woven bone directly apposing the HA surface and integrated into the larger porous spaces of the HA. There was no adverse response to the HA and there was minimal to no subsidence of the stem at the cement-bone interface, as determined by RSA.

Conclusion: This model is extremely valuable for investigating new biological approaches to reconstruction of major bone deficiency at revision hip replacement and demonstrates clear differences between materials used to supplement allograft, with HA and OP-1 giving encouraging results. RSA is an essential outcomes tool for this model.

Introduction There are currently hundreds of total hip replacement (THR) prosthesis designs in use. In practice the decision to use a THR prosthesis should be based on published long-term outcomes. This study provides a critical analysis of the literature to determine what prostheses have successful published results.

Methods The Medline (Ovid) database was searched for English text publications on primary THR published between 1975 and 2002. The search produced 12219 publications with 1400 (11.5%) reporting an incidence of revision or survivorship. Criteria for potentially successful designs were applied to the percentage of hips unrevised or survivorship data. Success was defined as less than 1% revised for any cause or less than 0.5% revised due to aseptic loosening. Using reported loss to follow-up, worst case analysis was performed to divide successful prostheses into definitely (DS), probably (PB) or possibly successful (PS).

Results Only 404 (23%) of the 1404 publications reviewed were methodologically adequate. The cemented acetabular prostheses had 39 (26.5%) reports of success (46%DS, 26%PB, 28%PS) at greater than 10 years and 80 (54%) reports of failure. The cement-less acetabular prostheses had 12 (10%) reports of success (42%DS, 42%PB, 16%PS), and 55 (46%) reports of failure. For cemented femoral prostheses 50 (30%) (62%DS, 18%PB, 20%PS) reports were successful, and 86 (51%) were failures. For cementless femoral prostheses 16 (18%) (69%DS, 25%PB, 6%PS) reports were successful and 38 (42%) were failures. Nineteen different cemented acetabular designs, and 34 different cementless acetabular designs had reports of success. For the femoral prostheses there were 27 different cemented designs and 26 different uncemented designs with reports of success. Thirty-two (18.2%) prostheses designs had reports of both success and failure, 71 (40%) had reports of failure only and 73 (41.5%) had reports of success only. It was not possible to identify what design alterations, if any, were attributed to a prosthesis being classified as both a success and a failure, because the technical details of the prosthesis were often not reported.

Conclusions Only 22% of prostheses reported were successful at greater than 10 years. High loss to follow-up meant only 56% of the potentially successful prostheses were definitely successful. The reporting of prosthesis manufacturer and catalogue numbers, and the publication of good and poor results are recommended to better gauge the success of designs.

In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more of the authors is in receipt of a research grant from a non-commercial source.

Introduction This study reviews the mid to long term results of revision THR with cemented, collarless double-tapered (CCDT) stems.

Methods We prospectively studied 192 revisions, in 183 patients, of femoral stems using standard (42%) or long (58%) Exeter and CPT CCDT stems. Results were analysed according to the length of stem, extent of pre-operative deficiency (Paprosky I:II:IIIa:IIIb:IV = 4:20:44:20:12%) and intra-operative bone loss. Postoperative radiographs were independently analysed for loosening and stress shielding. Risk factors of poor outcome were examined by multivariate logistic regression. The median follow-up was six years (2 to 17 years) with 55 patients having died (28%) and no cases lost to follow-up.

Results There were four stem re-revisions for sepsis (2%), three for aseptic loosening (1.5%) and three for component malpositioning (1.5%). The survivorship to femoral re-revision for aseptic loosening at eight years was 95% (95%CI=90–100%) for standard and 95% (90 – 100%) for long stems (p=0.674). Migration was less than five millimetre in unrevised stems. Survivorship and outcomes was independent of the Paprosky grade. There was a trend for better longer-term results in hips with long stems. Major stress shielding was not seen and thigh pain was not a problem.

Conclusions CCDT long stems are suitable for most femoral revisions in patients without severe segmental deficiency.

In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more of the authors is in receipt of a research grant from a non-commercial source.

Introduction Early complications of revision total hip replacement (rTHR) with femoral impaction allografting have included stem subsidence and loosening. In this comparative study, the impact of new techniques, including the use of longer stems, non-irradiated washed allograft, larger bone chips and medial mesh, on early clinical and radiographic outcomes was examined.

Methods The initial series of rTHRs with femoral impaction allografting comprised 20 hips (19 patients, median age 68 years) with a median follow-up of eight years. In the current series where the new techniques were used, there are 11 hips (11 patients, median age 69 years) with a median follow-up of 1.5 years. Three surgeons at one hospital undertook all rTHRs using a polished cemented collarless double tapered stem. Patients were mobilised on day one with partial weight bearing for 12 weeks. The femoral deficiencies commonly comprised extensive cavitatory loss combined with segmental deficiencies. Regular clinical and radiographic assessment was undertaken.

Results In the initial series, there were three early rerevisions for subsidence and stem loosening and one rerevision for infection. Periprosthetic fracture occurred early in three hips. EBRA FCA was used to assess stem subsidence. By two to four years, nine femoral stems had subsided more than five millimetres. At mid-term follow-up of eight years there have been no further rerevisions. In comparison, there has been minimal stem subsidence in the current series, with no stems subsiding more than five millimetres. To-date there have been no periprosthetic fractures and no complications requiring re-revision.

Conclusions Prospective monitoring of rTHR is important to identify factors that may be associated with poor outcome. Current techniques of femoral impaction grafting at rTHR, that includes washing of allograft and the use of long length stems and proximal mesh support yield good early-term radiographic and clinical results.

Introduction Peri-acetabular osteolysis is a serious complication of total hip arthroplasty (THA). The aim of this study was to determine, using quantitative computed tomography (CT), the location, volume and rate of progression of peri-acetabular osteolytic lesions, and to determine the validity of this CT technique with intra-operative measurements.

Methods High-resolution spiral multislice CT scan (Somatom Volume Zoom, Siemens, Munich, Germany), with metal-artefact suppression protocol, was used to measure the volume of osteolytic lesions around 47 cementless THAs in 36 patients (median age 73 years, duration 14 years, range five to 24 years). In vitro validation was undertaken. CT scans were taken from the top of sacroiliac joint down to two centimetres below the end of the prosthesis. Reconstruction images were analysed by two different observers and progression of osteolysis with time was determined. In some patients, subsequently revised, in-vivo CT measurements were compared to intra-operative measurements. The rate of progression of osteolytic lesions was calculated. The technique was optimised and validated by extensive in-vitro studies, using bovine and human pelves.

Results The incidence of lesions located in each site was: the ilium, 65%; around fixation screws, 20%; in the anterior column, nine percent; and in the medial wall, six percent. Some lesions were shown to be relatively quiescent, while others were aggressively osteolytic. Intra and inter-observer error for the CT measurement technique was four percent and 2.8%, respectively. In vitro volumetric measurements of simulated bone defects adjacent to the acetabular component and fixation screw were accurate to within 96% and precise to 98%. In addition, preliminary data obtained intra-operatively indicate the accuracy of CT in identifying the sites of osteolysis.

Conclusions CT is thus a valid and reliable technique for investigating the natural history of osteolysis and the factors that may influence its progression. It will also enable assessment of non-surgical treatments of osteolysis.

In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more of the authors is in receipt of a research grant from a non-commercial source.

Introduction: Accelerated rehabilitation programs following ACL reconstruction require adequate fixation strength. Staple fixation of grafts outside the tibial tunnel has been shown to have fixation strength comparable to interference screws. The use of bioresorbable polymer implants has potentially significant advantages especially if revision is required. The purpose of this study was to evaluate a new bioresorbable fixation staple using an ovine model.

Materials and Methods: Forty-eight mature sheep underwent unilateral cranial cruciate ligament (CrCl) reconstruction. The reconstruction comprised a loop of superficial digital flexor tendon (autograft) joined to a prosthetic ligament (LK-15). Femoral fixation was by endobutton. Tibial fixation of the LK-15 was with either a new Poly-L-lactic acid (PLLA) staple (Zimmer Japan/Gunze Ltd.) or a Cobalt-chrome (CoCr) staple. Biomechanical and histological responses were evaluated at 0, 6, 12 and 24 weeks.

Results: At all times post-reconstruction there were no significant differences between staple types for construct strength or stiffness (p> 0.05). The staple was not the site of reconstruction failure, and there were no adverse tissue reactions, for either staple type. Fibrous tissue was more often found at the interface of the CoCr staple.

Conclusions: The PLLA staple performed biomechanically as well as the metal staple for tibial fixation of cruciate ligament reconstructions. There were no significant observable adverse histological responses over the time intervals examined.

The purpose of health outcomes monitoring is to assess the benefits and risks of health care processes, to enable benchmarking and to allow comparative studies of new technologies and variations in clinical practice. This paper critically reviews the discipline of health outcomes monitoring in joint replacement surgery. We reviewed over 250 papers published over the last 20 years in the major English speaking journals were reviewed. We conclude that there are considerable shortcomings of clinical studies which make it difficult to determine the results of different joint replacement designs. The shortcomings include inadequate study design and the lack of comparative data. Despite repeated calls for standardisation of outcome measures, this has yet to be achieved. Considerable resources are often invested in outcomes monitoring programs.It is therefore important that instruments are selected based on them meeting strict psychometric criteria, that adequate follow-up is achieved and that appropriate data analysis techniques are utilised, otherwise interpretation of results is difficult. We have found that patients’ reporting of symptoms and outcomes after hip arthroplasty were found to be consistent with those reported by their reviewing doctor. We therefore suggest that for uncomplicated joint arthroplasty cases, the marginal costs of their regular review in outpatients probably outweighs the marginal benefits and important resources and doctors time would be made available for other patient care activity if these patients were reviewed by patient self-administered questionnaires. Our studies have shown that SF-36 health survey and the WOMAC instruments are useful when administered by mailed survey, however, the cost-benefits of using these outcomes instruments is an important consideration. The lack of comparable outcomes data should encourage greater orthopaedic participation in multi-centre outcomes studies including randomised trials.

Reported rates of dislocation after primary and revision total hip replacement (THR) vary widely, whereas subluxation after THR is not commonly reported. Importantly, it is now recognised that reported dislocation rates are likely to be an underestimate of the true dislocation rate. The primary aim of this study was to develop and validate a Patient Hip Instability Questionnaire and subsequently to use this questionnaire to determine the incidence of dislocation, subluxation and symptoms due to hip instability following primary and revision THR. In addition the associated costs, morbidity, disability and effects on health-related quality of life were examined.

A retrospective review of dislocation rates from 1996 to 1998 identified problems in determining the true dislocation rate from standard hospital and database records. Therefore, a patient-completed Hip Instability Questionnaire was developed and validated to monitor dislocation and subluxation rates. This was then mailed to patients three and 12 months following primary or revision THR. All dislocations were then confirmed by telephone interview and radiographs. Telephone interviews and patient completion of the SF-36 questionnaire were used to assess morbidity, disability and quality of life. Costs of treating patients with hip dislocation were also determined.

The response rate to the mailed questionnaire was greater than 95%. The questionnaire was shown to be a valid measure of the true rate of dislocation following THR and confirmed the inaccuracies in previous methods of determining dislocation rate based on hospital and database records. Using this questionnaire, the rate of subluxation was higher than previously reported and the significant morbidity and health care costs associated with with this complication were identified.

The use of this questionnaire will allow better assessment of morbidity and costs due to complications following THR.

Introduction: New biological approaches to reconstruction of major bone deficiency such as the use of bone substitutes and growth factors are being developed. This paper reports on the adverse response to the Bioglass in comparison to allograft alone.

Aim: To compare the biological response to femoral impaction grafting and a cemented femoral stem when using allograft bone versus allograft bone plus a synthetic bone graft substitute, Bioactive glass.

Methods: Eighteen merino wethers underwent a left cemented hemi-arthroplasty and were randomised to have impaction allografting of the femur using either allograft alone (allograft group) or a 50:50 mix of allograft and Bioactive glass (Bioglass group). After sacrifice at 12 weeks, histological analysis of the femora at the levels of the proximal, mid and distal femoral stem and distal to the stem was undertaken.

Results: In the allograft group, there was a consistent response with bone graft incorporation being greatest in the proximal femur and occurring progressively less, more distally. Mineralised bone apposition in the graft occurred post-operatively after eight weeks. In contrast, in the Bioglass group, the response was inconsistent. Bone graft incorporation was either minimal, or there was partial or complete resorption of the bone graft with replacement by particulate-laden fibrous tissue and resorption of endocortical bone. Inflammation of the capsule tissue was noted in some cases.

Conclusion: In comparison to allograft alone, the use of Bioglass to supplement allograft for use in impaction grafting in ovine hip arthroplasty gave inferior results.

Aim: To compare the outcomes of cemented and uncemented primary total hip arthroplasty and to report the radiological features of 41 Exeter polished tapered stems which demonstrate good clinical scores at long-term review.

Methods: We set up a randomised trial, involving two surgeons, Twenty stems were modular and 21 were monoblock. The radiographic measurements, made using templates adjusted for magnification, included vertical subsidence of the stem, scoring of cement mantle thickness, analysis of the p-c and cement-bone (c-b) radiolucencies, and cement fracture in each of the Gruen zones on AP and lateral views.

Loosening was classified as possible if there was between 50 and 99 percent c-b radiolucency, probable when there was complete radiolucency, or definite when vertical subsidence was more than 5mm. The presence and type of radiological features analysed according to surgeon and whether a centraliser was utilised.

Results: There were no failures of the polished stems with 100% survival at 11 years. At the latest review, none of the polished cemented stems demonstrated definite or possible loosening. Osteolysis was found proximally in two cases and more distally in one case and each of these stems was implanted without a centraliser. Incomplete cement mantles and the presence of radiolucencies were more common around stems without centralisers, however the differences in results according to surgeon is a potential confounder and requires investigation in a larger series.

Conclusion: This study demonstrated excellent radiological results of the polished Exeter stem at mid to long-term follow-up.

There is a lack of properly undertaken comparative studies of total hip replacement (THR). A randomised trial was established to examine the hypothesis that there are no important differences in clinical outcome at 2 years and at long-term follow-up between cemented and uncemented primary THR in middle aged patients.Eighty-three patients with 90 osteoarthritic hips were randomised to a cemented Exeter THR involving a matte or polished tapered stem (n=47, median age 68yrs) or an uncemented PCA proximally porous-coated cobalt-chrome stem and porous coated press fit cup (n=43, median age 66yrs). Patients underwent immediate full weight bearing post-operatively. The follow-up period is 8 to 16 years. The median Harris hip scores for the cemented and uncemented groups respectively were 92 and 95 at 2 years and 89 and 96 at long-term follow-up. Four cemented hips have been revised for aseptic loosening. There have been no failures of the polished stems. An analysis of a larger series of matt versus polished cemented stems also found that the results of the polished stems were superior. Four uncemented hips have been revised, two more recently for acetabular wear and osteolysis. There was a high rate of radiographic demarcation of the cemented cups. There were no important differences in the clinical scores between cemented and uncemented THR. Some matte surfaced femoral stems failed and this trend was confirmed by analysis of a larger series. Osteolysis around the uncemented acetabular components is a concern. Importantly immediate weight bearing was associated with good results of uncemented stems.