A damaged vertebral body can exhibit accelerated ‘creep’ under constant load, leading to progressive vertebral deformity. However, the risk of this happening is not easy to predict in clinical practice. The present cadaveric study aimed to identify morphometric measurements in a damaged vertebral body that can predict a susceptibility to accelerated creep. Mechanical testing of 28 human spinal motion segments (three vertebrae and intervening soft tissues) showed how the rate of creep of a damaged vertebral body increases with increasing “damage intensity” in its trabecular bone. Damage intensity was calculated from vertebral body residual strain following initial compressive overload. The calculations used additional data from 27 small samples of vertebral trabecular bone, which examined the relationship between trabecular bone damage intensity and residual strain.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
The study aim was to simulate oblique spinous process abutment (SPA) in cadaveric spines and determine how this affects coupled motion in the coronal plane. L4-S1 spinal segments from thirteen cadavers were loaded on a materials testing machine in pure compression at 1kN for 10 minutes. Reflective markers on the vertebral bodies were used to assess coronal motion using a motion analysis system. Oblique SPA was simulated by attaching moulded oblique aluminium strips to the L4 and L5 spinous processes. In each specimen, both a right- and left-sided SPA was simulated, in random order, and compression at 1kN was again applied. All tests were then repeated after endplate fracture. Coronal plane motion at baseline was compared with values following simulated SPA using Mann Whitney U-tests. Pre-fracture, SPA increased coronal motion by 0.28° and 0.34° on right and left sides respectively, compared to baseline, only the former was significant (P=0.03). Post-fracture, SPA decreased coronal motion by 0.36° and 0.46° on right and left sides respectively, only the latter was significant (P=0.03). Simulated oblique SPA in the intact spine initiated an increase in coronal motion during pure axial loading. These findings provide limited evidence that oblique SPA may be causative in DLS.
To determine if patients with coronal plane deformity in the lumbar spine have a higher grade of lumbar spine subtype compared to controls. This was a retrospective case/control study based on a review of radiological investigations in 250 patients aged over 40 years who had standing plain film lumbar radiographs with hips present. Measurements of lumbar coronal plane angle, lumbar lordosis, sacral slope, pelvic tilt and pelvic incidence were obtained. “Cases” with degenerative scoliosis (n=125) were defined as patients with a lumbar coronal plane angle of >10°. Lumbar spine subtype was categorised (1–4) using the Roussouly classification. Lumbar spine subtype was dichotomised into low (type 1,2) or high (type 3,4). Prevalence of lumbar spine subtype in cases versus controls was compared using the Chi squared test. Pelvic incidence was compared using an unpaired T-test. Predictors of lumbar coronal plane angle were identified using stepwise multiple regression. Significance was accepted at P<0.05.Aim:
Method:
Herniated disc tissue removed at surgery is mostly nucleus pulposus, with varying proportions of annulus fibrosus, cartilage endplate, and bone. Herniated nucleus swells and loses proteoglycans, and herniated annulus is invaded by blood vessels and inflammatory cells. However, little is known about the significance of endplate cartilage and bone within a herniation. Herniated tissue was removed surgically from 21 patients (10 with sciatica, 11 without). 5-μm sections were examined using H&E, Toluidine blue, Giemsa, and Masson-trichrome stains. Each tissue type in each specimen was scored for tears/fissures, neovascularisation, proteoglycan loss, cell clustering, and inflammatory cell invasion. Proportions of each tissue type were quantified using image analysis software.Introduction
Methods
Disc degeneration is often scored using macroscopic and microscopic scoring systems. Although reproducible, these scores may not accurately reflect declining function in a degenerated disc. Accordingly, we compared macroscopic and microscopic degeneration scores with measurements of disc function. Thirteen cadaveric motion segments (62–93 yrs) were compressed to 1kN while a pressure-transducer was pulled across the mid-sagittal diameter of the disc. Resulting stress profiles indicated intradiscal pressure (IDP), and maximum stress in the anterior (MaxStress_Ant) and posterior (MaxStress_Post) annulus. Macroscopic Introduction
Methods
Physical disruption of the extracellular matrix influences the mechanical and chemical environment of intervertebral disc cells. We hypothesise that this can explain degenerative changes such as focal proteoglycan loss, impaired cell-matrix binding, cell clustering, and increased activity of matrix-degrading enzymes. Disc tissue samples were removed surgically from 11 patients (aged 34–75 yrs) who had a painful but non-herniated disc. Each sample was divided into a pair of specimens (approximately 5mm3), which were cultured at 37°C under 5% CO2. One of each pair was allowed to swell, while the other was restrained by a perspex ring. Live-cell imaging was performed with a wide field microscope for 36 hrs. Specimens were then sectioned at 5 and 30 μm for histology and immunofluorescence using a confocal microscope. Antibodies were used to recognise free integrin receptor α5β1, matrix metalloprotease MMP-1, and denatured collagen types I-III. Proteoglycan content of the medium, analysed using the colorimetric DMMB assay, was used to assess tissue swelling and GAG loss. Constrained/unconstrained results were compared using matched-pair t-tests.Introduction
Methods
Decreasing endplate porosity has been proposed as a risk factor for intervertebral disc degeneration, because it interferes with disc metabolite transport. However, endplate porosity has recently been shown to Nineteen cadaver motion segments (61–98 yrs) were compressed to 1kN while a pressure-transducer was pulled across the mid-sagittal diameter of the disc. Stress profiles indicated nucleus (intradiscal) pressure (IDP) and maximum stress in the anterior and posterior annulus. Subsequently, micro-CT was used to evaluate endplate porosity along the antero-posterior diameter of the adjacent endplates. Data were analysed using ANOVA and linear regression.Introduction
Methods
Dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) is the gold standard for assessing bone mineral density (BMD) and fracture risk in vivo. However, it has limitations in the spine because vertebrae show marked regional variations in BMD that are difficult to detect clinically. This study investigated whether micro-CT can provide improved estimates of BMD that better predict vertebral strength. Ten cadaveric vertebral bodies (mean age: 83.7 +/− 10.8 yrs) were scanned using lateral-projection DEXA and Micro-CT. Standardised protocols were used to determine BMD of the whole vertebral body and of anterior/posterior and superior/inferior regions. Vertebral body volume was assessed by water displacement after which specimens were compressed to failure to determine their compressive strength. Specimens were then ashed to determine their bone mineral content (BMC). Parameters were compared using ANOVA and linear regression.Introduction
Methods
The belief that an intervertebral disc must degenerate
before it can herniate has clinical and medicolegal significance,
but lacks scientific validity. We hypothesised that tissue changes
in herniated discs differ from those in discs that degenerate without
herniation. Tissues were obtained at surgery from 21 herniated discs
and 11 non-herniated discs of similar degeneration as assessed by
the Pfirrmann grade. Thin sections were graded histologically, and
certain features were quantified using immunofluorescence combined
with confocal microscopy and image analysis. Herniated and degenerated
tissues were compared separately for each tissue type: nucleus, inner
annulus and outer annulus. Herniated tissues showed significantly greater proteoglycan loss
(outer annulus), neovascularisation (annulus), innervation (annulus),
cellularity/inflammation (annulus) and expression of matrix-degrading
enzymes (inner annulus) than degenerated discs. No significant differences
were seen in the nucleus tissue from herniated and degenerated discs.
Degenerative changes start in the nucleus, so it seems unlikely
that advanced degeneration caused herniation in 21 of these 32 discs.
On the contrary, specific changes in the annulus can be interpreted
as the consequences of herniation, when disruption allows local
swelling, proteoglycan loss, and the ingrowth of blood vessels,
nerves and inflammatory cells. In conclusion, it should not be assumed that degenerative changes
always precede disc herniation. Cite this article:
Discogenic pain is associated with ingrowth of blood vessels and nerves, but uncertainty over the extent of ingrowth is hindering development of appropriate treatments. We hypothesise that adult human annulus fibrosus is such a dense crosslinked tissue that ingrowth Disc tissue was examined from 61 patients (aged 37–75 yrs) undergoing surgery for disc herniation, degeneration or scoliosis. 5 µm sections were stained with H&E to identify structures and tissue types. 30 µm frozen sections were examined using confocal microscopy, following immunostaining for CD31 (an endothelial cell marker), PGP 9.5 and Substance P (general and nociceptive nerve markers, respectively). Fluorescent tags were attached to the antibodies. ‘Volocity’ software was used to calculate numbers and total cross-sectional area of labelled structures, and to measure their distance from the nearest free surface (disc periphery, or annulus fissure).Introduction
Methods
Senile kyphosis arises from anterior ‘wedge’ deformity of thoracolumbar vertebrae, often in the absence of trauma. It is difficult to reproduce these deformities in cadaveric spines, because a vertebral endplate usually fails first. We hypothesise that endplate fracture concentrates sufficient loading on to the anterior cortex that a wedge deformity develops subsequently under physiological repetitive loading. Thirty-four cadaveric thoracolumbar “motion segments,” aged 70–97 yrs, were overloaded in combined bending and compression. Physiologically-reasonable cyclic loading was then applied, at progressively higher loads, for up to 2 hrs. Before and after fracture, and again after cyclic loading the Introduction
Methods
Osteoporotic vertebral fractures can cause severe vertebral wedging and kyphotic deformity. This study tested the hypothesis that kyphoplasty restores vertebral height, shape and mechanical function to a greater extent than vertebroplasty following severe wedge fractures. Pairs of thoracolumbar “motion segments” from seventeen cadavers (70–97 yrs) were compressed to failure in moderate flexion and then cyclically loaded to create severe wedge deformity. One of each pair underwent vertebroplasty and the other kyphoplasty. Specimens were then creep loaded at 1.0kN for 1 hour. At each stage of the experiment the following parameters were measured: vertebral height and wedge angle from radiographs, motion segment compressive stiffness, and stress distributions within the intervertebral discs. The latter indicated intra-discal pressure (IDP) and neural arch load-bearing (FN).Introduction
Methods
Herniated disc tissue removed at surgery usually appears degenerated, and MRI often reveals degenerative changes in adjacent discs and vertebrae. This has fostered the belief that a disc Surgically-removed discs were examined using histology, immunohistochemistry and confocal microscopy. 21 samples of herniated tissues were compared with age-matched tissues excised from 11 patients whose discs had reached a similar Pfirrman grade of degeneration but without herniating. Degenerative changes were assessed separately in three tissue types (where present): nucleus, inner annulus, and outer annulus. Mann-Whitney U tests were used to compare ‘herniated’ vs ‘in-situ’ tissues.Introduction
Methods
Senile kyphosis arises from anterior ‘wedge’ deformity of thoracolumbar vertebrae, often in the absence of trauma. It is difficult to reproduce these deformities in cadaveric spines, because a vertebral endplate usually fails first. We hypothesise that endplate fracture concentrates sufficient loading on to the anterior cortex that a wedge deformity develops subsequently under physiological repetitive loading. Thirty-four cadaveric thoracolumbar “motion segments,” aged 70–97 yrs, were overloaded in combined bending and compression. Physiologically-reasonable cyclic loading was then applied, at progressively higher loads, for up to 2 hrs. Before and after fracture, and again after cyclic loading the distribution of compressive loading on the vertebral body was assessed from recordings of compressive stress along the sagittal mid-plane of the adjacent intervertebral disc. Vertebral deformity was assessed from radiographs at the beginning and end of testing.Introduction
Methods
Vertebroplasty helps to restore mechanical function to a fractured vertebra. We investigated how the Nine pairs of three-vertebra cadaver spine specimens (aged 67–90 yr) were compressed to induce fracture. One of each pair underwent vertebroplasty with PMMA, the other with a resin (Cortoss). Specimens were then creep-loaded at 1.0kN for 1hr. Before and after vertebroplasty, compressive stiffness was determined, and stress profilometry was performed by pulling a pressure-transducer through each disc whilst under 1.0kN load. Profiles indicated intradiscal pressure (IDP) and compressive load-bearing by the neural arch (FN) at both disc levels. Micro-CT was used to quantify cement fill in the anterior and posterior halves of each augmented vertebral body, and also in the region immediately adjacent to the fractured endplateIntroduction
Methods
Risk factors for disc degeneration depend on how the condition is defined, i.e. on the specific disc degeneration “phenotype”. We present evidence that there are two major and largely-distinct types of disc degeneration. The relevant research literature was reviewed and re-interpreted.Introduction
Methods
Delamination of the annulus fibrosus is an early feature of disc degeneration, and it allows individual lamellae to collapse into the nucleus, or to bulge radially outwards. We 102 thoracolumbar motion segments (T8-9 to L5-S1) were dissected from 42 cadavers aged 19–92 yrs. Each specimen was subjected to 1 kN compression, while intradiscal compressive stresses were measured by pulling a pressure transducer along the disc's mid-sagittal diameter. Stress gradients were measured, in the anterior and posterior annulus, as the average rate of increase in compressive stress (MPa/mm) between the nucleus and the region of maximum stress in the annulus. Average nucleus pressure was also recorded. Disc degeneration was assessed macroscopically on a scale of 1–4.Introduction
Methods
Severe ‘discogenic’ back pain may be related to the ingrowth of nerves and blood vessels, although this is controversial. We hypothesise that ingrowth is greater in painful discs, and is facilitated in the region of annulus fissures. We compared tissue removed at surgery from 22 patients with discogenic back pain and/or sciatica, and from 16 young patients with scoliosis who served as controls. Wax-embedded specimens were sectioned at 7μm. Nerves and blood vessels were identified using histological stains, and antibodies to PGP 9.5 and CD31 respectively.Introduction
Methods
The feature of disc degeneration most closely associated with pain is a large fissure in the annulus fibrosus. Nerves and blood vessels are excluded from normal discs by high matrix stresses and by high proteoglycan (PG) content. However, they appear to grow into annulus fissures in surgically-removed degenerated discs. We hypothesize that anulus fissures provide a micro-environment that is mechanically and chemically conducive to the in-growth of nerves and blood vessels. 18 three-vertebra thoraco-lumbar spine specimens (T10/12 to L2/4) were obtained from 9 cadavers aged 68-92 yrs. All 36 discs were injected with Toluidine Blue so that leaking dye would indicate major fissures in the annulus. Specimens were then compressed at 1000 N while positioned in simulated flexed and extended postures, and the distribution of compressive stress within each disc was characterised by pulling a pressure transducer through it in various planes. After testing, discs were dissected and the morphology of fissures noted. Reductions in stress in the vicinity of fissures were compared with average pressure in the disc nucleus. Distributions of PGs and collagen were investigated in 16 surgically-removed discs by staining with Safranin O. Digital images were analysed in Matlab to obtain profiles of stain density in the vicinity of fissures.Introduction
Methods
Fracture of an osteoporotic vertebral body reduces vertebral stiffness and decompresses the nucleus in the adjacent intervertebral disc. This leads to high compressive stresses acting on the annulus and neural arch. Altered load-sharing at the fractured level may influence loading of neighbouring vertebrae, increasing the risk of a fracture ‘cascade’. Vertebroplasty has been shown to normalise load-bearing by fractured vertebrae but it may increase the risk of adjacent level fracture. The aim of this study was to determine the effects of fracture and subsequent vertebroplasty on the loading of neighbouring (non-augmented) vertebrae. Fourteen pairs of three-vertebra cadaver spine specimens (67-92 yr) were loaded to induce fracture. One of each pair underwent vertebroplasty with PMMA, the other with a resin (Cortoss). Specimens were then creep loaded at 1.0kN for 1hr. In 17 specimens where the upper or lower vertebra fractured, compressive stress distributions were measured in the disc between adjacent non-fractured vertebrae by pulling a pressure transducer through the disc whilst under 1.0kN load. These ‘stress profiles’ were obtained at each stage of the experiment (in flexion and extension) in order to quantify intradiscal pressure (IDP), the size of stress concentrations in the posterior annulus (SP) and compressive load-bearing by anterior (FA) and posterior (FP) halves of the vertebral body and by the neural arch (FN).Background
Methods
In the annulus fibrosus of degenerated intervertebral discs, disruption to inter-lamellar cross-ties appears to lead to delamination, and the development of anulus fissures. We hypothesise that such internal disruption is likely to be driven by high gradients of compressive stress (i.e. large differences in stress from the nucleus to the mid anulus). Eighty-nine thoracolumbar motion segements, from T7/8 to L4/5, were dissected from 38 cadavers aged 42-96 yrs. Each was subjected to 1 kN compressive loading, while intradiscal compressive stresses were measured by pulling a pressure transducer along the disc's mid-sagittal diameter. Measurements were repeated in flexed and extended postures. Stress gradients were measured, in the anterior and posterior anulus of each disc, as the average rate of increase in stress (MPa/mm) between the nucleus and the region of maximum compressive stress in the anulus. Average nucleus pressure (IDP) was also recorded.Background
Methods
Vertebral osteoporotic fracture increases both elastic and time-dependent ('creep') deformations of the fractured vertebral body during subsequent loading. The accelerated rate of creep deformation is especially marked in central and anterior regions of the vertebral body where bone mineral density is lowest. In life, subsequent loading of damaged vertebrae may cause anterior wedging of the vertebral body which could contribute to the development of kyphotic deformity. The aim of this study was to determine whether gradual creep deformations of damaged vertebrae can be reduced by vertebroplasty. Fourteen pairs of spine specimens, each comprising three vertebrae and the intervening soft tissue, were obtained from cadavers aged 67-92 yr. Specimens were loaded in combined bending and compression until one of the vertebral bodies was damaged. Damaged vertebrae were then augmented so that one of each pair underwent vertebroplasty with polymethylmethacrylate cement, the other with a resin (Cortoss). A 1kN compressive force was applied for 1 hr before fracture, after fracture, and after vertebroplasty, while creep deformation was measured in anterior, middle and posterior regions of each vertebral body, using a MacReflex optical tracking system.Introduction
Methods
Osteoporotic vertebral deformities are conventionally attributed to fracture, although deformity is often insidious, and bone is known to “creep” under constant load. We hypothesise that deformity can arise from creep that is accelerated by minor injury. Thirty-nine thoracolumbar “motion segments” were tested from cadavers aged 42-92 yrs. Vertebral body BMD was measured using DXA. A 1.0 kN compressive force was applied for 30 mins, while the height of each vertebral body was measured using a MacReflex optical tracking system. After 30 mins recovery, one vertebral body from each specimen was subjected to controlled micro-damage (<5mm height loss) by compressive overload, and the creep test was repeated. Load-sharing between the vertebral body and neural arch was evaluated from stress measurements made by pulling a pressure transducer through the intervertebral disc. Creep was inversely proportional to BMD below a threshold BMD of 0.5 g/cm2 (R2=0.30, P<0.01) and did not recover substantially after unloading. Creep was greater in the anterior cortex compared to the posterior (p=0.01) so that anterior wedge deformity occurred. Vertebral micro-damage usually affected a single endplate, causing creep of that vertebra to increase in proportion to the severity of damage. Anterior wedging of vertebral bodies during creep increased by 0.10o (STD 0.20o) for intact vertebrae, and by 0.68o (STD 1.34o) for damaged vertebrae. Creep is substantial in elderly vertebrae with low BMD, and is accelerated by micro-damage. Preferential loss of trabeculae from the anterior vertebral body could explain greater anterior creep and vertebral wedging.
To investigate whether restoration of mechanical function and spinal load-sharing following vertebroplasty depends upon cement distribution. Fifteen pairs of cadaver motion segments (51-91 yr) were loaded to induce fracture. One from each pair underwent vertebroplasty with PMMA, the other with a resin (Cortoss). Various mechanical parameters were measured before and after vertebroplasty. Micro-CT was used to determine volumetric cement fill, and plane radiographs (sagittal, frontal, and axial) to determine areal fill, for the whole vertebral body and for several specific regions. Correlations between volumetric fill and areal fill for the whole vertebral body, and between regional volumetric fill and changes in mechanical parameters following vertebroplasty, were assessed using linear regression. For Cortoss, areal and volumetric fills were significantly correlated (R=0.58-0.84) but cement distribution had no significant effect on any mechanical parameters following vertebroplasty. For PMMA, areal fills showed no correlation with volumetric fill, suggesting a non-uniform distribution of cement that influenced mechanical outcome. Increased filling of the vertebral body adjacent to the disc was associated with increased intradiscal pressure (R=0.56, p<0.05) in flexed posture, and reduced neural arch load bearing (FN) in extended posture (R=0.76, p<0.01). Increased filling of the anterior vertebral body was associated with increased bending stiffness (R=0.55, p<0.05). Cortoss tends to spread evenly within the vertebral body, and its distribution has little influence on the mechanical outcome of vertebroplasty. PMMA spreads less evenly, and its mechanical benefits are increased when cement is concentrated in the anterior vertebral body and adjacent to the intervertebral disc.
Osteoporotic fracture reduces vertebral stiffness, and alters spinal load-sharing. Vertebroplasty partially reverses these changes at the fractured level, but is suspected to increase deformations and stress at adjacent levels. We examined this possibility. Twelve pairs of three-vertebra cadaver spine specimens (67-92 yr) were loaded to induce fracture. One of each pair underwent vertebroplasty with PMMA, the other with a resin (Cortoss). Specimens were then creep-loaded at 1.0kN for 1hr. In 15 specimens, either the uppermost or lowest vertebra was fractured, so that compressive stress distributions could be determined in the disc between adjacent non-fractured vertebrae. Stress was measured in flexion and extension, at each stage of the experiment, by pulling a pressure-transducer through the disc whilst under 1.0kN load. Stress profiles quantified intradiscal pressure (IDP), stress concentrations in the posterior annulus (SPP), and compressive load-bearing by the neural arch (FN). Elastic deformations in adjacent vertebrae were measured using a MacReflex tracking system during 1.0kN compressive ramp loading.Introduction
Methods
Vertebral osteoporotic fracture increases both elastic and time-dependent (‘creep’) deformations of the fractured vertebral body during subsequent loading. This is especially marked in central and anterior regions of the vertebral body, and could explain the development of kyphotic deformity in life. We hypothesise that vertebroplasty can reduce these creep deformations. Twelve Introduction
Methods
Fissures in the anulus fibrosus are common in disc degeneration, and are associated with discogenic pain. We hypothesise that anulus fissures are conducive to the ingrowth of blood vessels and nerves. To investigate the mechanical and chemical micro-environment of anulus fissures.Background
Purpose
stress distributions on fractured and adjacent vertebral bodies, load-sharing between the vertebral bodies and neural arch, and cement leakage.
These findings suggest that people with more severe fractures and low BMD may gain most mechanical benefit from vertebroplasty.
Stress concentration in the annulus was calculated by subtracting the nuclear pressure from the maximum stress in the annulus. Neural arch compressive load was obtained by subtracting the disc compressive force, calculated by integrating intradiscal stress over area, from the applied 1.5kN (
Pollintine P et al (2001). SBPR Annual Meeting, Bristol. Backcare Research Award 2002.
Numerous studies have examined the biomechanical properties of the vertebral body following PMMA cement augmentation for the treatment of osteoporotic vertebral body fractures. To date there is no published literature reporting the effects of Vertebroplasty on internal intervertebral disc biomechanics which in turn have been shown to reflect loading patterns of the vertebral column. To study effects of PMMA cement augmentation of vertebral body fractures on intervertebral disc biomechanics using stress prolifometry to assess differential anterior and posterior vertebral column loading. Eight cadaveric motion segments were individually loaded on a hydraulically powered materials testing machine under 1.5kN of axial compression. Following fracture induction the lower vertebral body underwent Vertebroplasty. Profiles of the vertically acting compressive stress were obtained by pulling a pressure sensitive transducer along the mid-sagittal diameter of the intervertebral disc. “Stress profile” measurements were obtained before fracture, following fracture, and after vertebro-plasty both in extension and flexion. Stress profiles were integrated over area to calculate the compressive force across the disc. The compressive load acting on the neural arch was calculated by subtracting the disc force from the applied 1.5kN load. In flexed postures posterior column loading increased from 17.1% to 42.2% following fracture (p<
0.01) and then decreased significantly from 42.2% to 23.68% following vertebroplasty (p<
0.03). There was no significant difference between pre-fracture and post-vertebroplasty status (p=0.11). In extended posture, fracture produced increased posterior column loading 72.9% vs 51.8% (p<
0.005) and following vertebroplasty there was no significant change (p=0.2). In moderate degrees of flexion, vertebroplasty produces normalisation of load bearing through the anterior vertebral column and hence offloads the posterior elements to a significant degree. This could be postulated, to partly account for the analgesic effect seen following vertebroplasty in the clinical setting.
Osteoporotic fractures are associated with bone loss following hormonal changes and reduced physical activity in middle age. But these systemic changes do not explain why the anterior vertebral body should be such a common site of fracture. We hypothesise that age-related degenerative changes in the intervertebral discs can lead to abnormal load-bearing by the anterior vertebral body. Cadaveric lumbar motion segments (mean age 50 ± 19 yrs, n = 33) were subjected to 2 kN of compressive loading while the distribution of compressive stress was measured along the antero-posterior diameter of the intervertebral disc, using a miniature pressure-transducer. “Stress profiles” were obtained with each motion segment positioned to simulate a) the erect standing posture, and b) a forward stooping posture. Stress measurements were effectively integrated over area in order to calculate the force acting on the anterior and posterior halves of the disc (
In motion segments with non-degenerated (grade 1) discs, less than 5% of the compressive force was resisted by the neural arch, and forces on the disc were distributed evenly in both postures. However, in the presence of severe disc degeneration, neural arch load-bearing increased to 40% in the erect posture, and the compressive force exerted by the disc on the vertebral body was concentrated anteriorly in flexion, and posteriorly in erect posture. In severely degenerated discs, the proportion of the 2 kN resisted by the anterior disc increased from 18% in the erect posture to 58% in the forward stooped posture. Disc degeneration causes the disc to lose height, so that in erect postures, substantial compressive force is transferred to the neural arch. In addition, the disc loses its ability to distribute stress evenly on the vertebral body, so that the anterior vertebral body is heavily loaded in flexion. These two effects combine to ensure that the anterior vertebral body is stress-shielded in erect postures, and yet severely loaded in flexed postures. This could explain why anterior vertebral body fractures are so common in elderly people with degenerated discs, and why forward bending movements often precipitate the injury.
Osteoporotic vertebral fractures are normally attributed to weakening of the vertebral body. However, the compressive strength of the spine also depends on the manner in which the intervertebral disc presses on the vertebral body, and on load-bearing by the neural arch. We present preliminary results from a large-scale investigation into the relative importance of these three influences on vertebral compressive strength. Lumbar motion segments from elderly cadavers were subjected to 1.5 kN of compressive loading while the distribution of compressive stress was measured along the antero-posterior diameter of the intervertebral disc, using a miniature pressure-transducer. The overall compressive force on the disc, obtained by integrating the stress profile (
A univariate analysis of results from the first 9 motion segments (aged 72–92 yrs) showed that vertebral strength increased from 2.0 kN to 4.6 kN as the compressive force resisted by the neural arch in erect postures decreased from 1.1 kN to 0.4 kN (r2 = 0.42, p = 0.05). Updated results from this on-going study will be presented at the meeting. Preliminary results suggest that habitual load-bearing by the neural arch in erect postures can lead to progressive weakening of the vertebral body, which is effectively “stress-shielded” by the neural arch. This weakening is exposed when the spine is loaded severely in a forward stooped posture, when it has a reduced compressive strength. This mechanism could explain some features of osteoporotic vertebral fractures in old people.
During forward bending activities, the collagenous tissues of the spine are protected from injury by reflex contractions of the back muscles which prevent excessive spinal flexion. Animal experiments have shown that this reflex response is diminished when spinal ligaments are subjected to creep (
Ten healthy volunteers (4M/6F) consented to participate in the study. Subjects underwent two flexion treatments: i) prolonged sitting in a low chair for 2 hours, ii) 100 toe-touching exercises, each on a separate day. Before and after each treatment, subjects performed a standardised forward bending task during which simultaneous measurements were made of lumbar flexion, using the 3-Space Fastrak, and surface EMG activity of the erector spinae muscles at T10 and L3 (
Both treatments caused creep, as indicated by a significant increase in the range of lumbar flexion. The treatments also brought about a significant delay in the reflex activation of the back muscles in the standardised bending task: after prolonged sitting, lumbar flexion during the bending task increased by 9.2 ± 7.4° and 5.7 ± 4.6° before the onset of EMG activity at T10 and L3 respectively; following the toe-touches, the equivalent increases in lumbar flexion were 5.4 ± 3.9° and 3.1 ± 4.4°. The amplitude of the reflex response was unchanged following prolonged sitting, but after the toe-touches, a 50% increase in peak EMG activity was observed at L3. Creep in spinal tissues as a result of prolonged or repetitive flexion was associated with delayed reflex activation of the back muscles. There was no associated reduction in the amplitude of the reflex. The increase in peak EMG activity following the toe touches may reflect increased activation as a result of muscle fatigue. These results suggest that creep in spinal tissues may allow increased lumbar flexion and hence increased bending stresses to be applied to the intervertebral disc.
We investigated the distribution of compressive ‘stress’ within cadaver intervertebral discs, using a pressure transducer mounted in a 1.3 mm diameter needle. The needle was pulled along the midsagittal diameter of a lumbar disc with the face of the transducer either vertical or horizontal while the disc was subjected to a constant compressive force. The resulting ‘stress profiles’ were analysed in order to characterise the distribution of vertical and horizontal compressive stress within each disc. A total of 87 discs from subjects aged between 16 and 87 years was examined. Our results showed that age-related degenerative changes reduced the diameter of the central hydrostatic region of each disc (the ‘functional nucleus’) by approximately 50%, and the pressure within this region fell by 30%. The width of the functional annulus increased by 80% and the height of compressive ‘stress peaks’ within it by 160%. The effects of age and degeneration were greater at L4/L5 than at L2/L3, and the posterior annulus was affected more than the anterior. Age and degeneration were themselves closely related, but the stage of degeneration had the greater effect on stress distributions. We suggest that structural changes within the annulus and endplate lead to a transfer of load from the nucleus to the posterior annulus. High ‘stress’ concentrations within the annulus may cause pain, and lead to further disruption.
Diurnal changes in the loads acting on the spine affect the water content and height of the intervertebral discs. We have reviewed the effects of these changes on spinal mechanics, and their possible clinical significance. Cadaveric lumbar spines subjected to periods of creep loading show a disc height change similar to the physiological change. As a result intervertebral discs bulge more, become stiffer in compression and more flexible in bending. Disc tissue becomes more elastic as its water content falls, and its affinity for water increases. Disc prolapse becomes more difficult. The neural arch and associated ligaments resist an increasing proportion of the compressive and bending stresses acting on the spine. Observations on living people show that these changes are not fully compensated for by modified muscle activity. We conclude that different spinal structures are more heavily loaded at different times of the day. Therefore, the time of onset of symptoms and signs, and any diurnal variation in their severity, may help us understand more about the pathophysiology of low back pain and sciatica.
Cadaveric lumbar discs were injected with chymopapain and subjected to a series of mechanical tests over a period of up to 19 hours. Discs from the same spine injected with saline were used as controls. The results showed that chymopapain had no measurable effect on the mechanical properties of the disc apart from the increased height and stiffening caused by fluid injection. Another series of tests on isolated pieces of disc material showed that chymopapain could reduce the size of prolapsed nuclear material by 24% in one hour and by 80% in 48 hours. It is concluded that, in the short-term, chymopapain has a negligible effect on the mechanics of a disc but it can reduce the size of any prolapsed nuclear material with which it comes in contact.
One hundred and thirty-nine discs from cadaveric lumbar spines were injected with a mixture of radio-opaque fluid and dye. Discograms were taken and the discs were then sectioned in the sagittal plane. Examination of the sections revealed that injected fluid did not at first mix with the disc matrix but pushed it aside to form pools of injected fluid. The location of these pools, and hence the appearance of a discogram, depended on the stage of degeneration of the disc. It is concluded that useful clinical information can be obtained from discograms.