header advert
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 97-B, Issue SUPP_4 May 2015 Scottish Committee for Orthopaedics and Trauma (SCOT)

E.K. Davidson T.O. White A.C. Hall

Articular cartilage has very poor repair potential, however it has an extraordinary capacity to withstand physiological mechanical loads in an intact joint. The nature and extent of chondrocyte death in articular cartilage following many forms of injury (trephine, scalpel, osteotome, sutures and drilling) has been characterised, but the ability to bear mechanical injury from iatrogenic surgical interventions is still unknown.

A standard arthroscopic probe was moved at varying physiological pressures along the articular cartilage of joint before staining with fluorescent dyes to allow live/dead cell imaging using laser confocal scanning microscopy and imaging software, Image J. Bovine metatarsal phalangeal joints and fresh human cadaveric femoral condyles were used.

The probe caused statistically significant chondrocyte death in bovine cartilage (p=0.02). Mild pressure 5% cell death, moderate (standard arthroscopic technique pressure) 22% and severe pressure 38%. A similar result was seen in human tissue with 24% cell death at moderate pressure compared to a control (p=0.0699).

The widely assumed benign arthroscopic probe produces significant cell death in articular cartilage when used at standard operating pressures.


A.D. Duckworth J.G. Jefferies N.D. Clement T.O. White

The aim of this study was to document the outcome following either early or delayed fixation for complex (AO-OTA type 43.C) fractures of the tibial plafond. From our trauma database we identified all patients who sustained a complex intra-articular fracture of the distal tibia over an 11-year period. Demographic data, fracture classification, management, complications and subsequent surgeries were recorded. The primary outcome measure was the development of early complications following surgery. The secondary outcome measure was the long-term patient reported outcome.

There were 102 type C pilon fractures in 99 patients with a mean age of 42yrs (16–86) and 75.5% (n=77) were male. 73 (71.6%) patients underwent primary open reduction internal fixation (ORIF), with 20 (19.6%) undergoing primary external fixation with delayed ORIF. 34 complications were recorded in 28 (27.5%) patients. There were 18 (17.6%) infections, with a deep wound infection in 9 (8.8%) patients and a superficial wound infection in 9 (8.8%). Risk factors for developing infection were multiple co-morbidities (p=0.008), an open fracture (p=0.008), and primary external fixation with delayed ORIF (p=0.023). At a mean of 6 years (0.3–13; n=53) post injury the mean FAOS score was 76.2 (0–100), the mean FADI score was 75.7 (0–100), and 72% (n=38) of patients were satisfied.

This is the largest series in the literature documenting the outcome following fixation for type C tibial pilon fractures. Despite the severity of these injuries, we have demonstrated a satisfactory outcome using primary early fixation in the vast majority of cases.


ST Goudie D Gamble A Duckworth S Molyneux

An increasing number of distal humeral fractures are presenting as fragility fractures in low demand elderly patients. The optimal management of these injuries remains controversial. The primary aim of this study was to document the short and long term outcomes of these fractures treated with primary nonsurgical intervention. All patients were identified from a prospective trauma database from 1995 to 2010. All conservatively managed, isolated fractures of the distal humerus (OTA Type A,B,C) were included. Prospective long term follow up was collected by telephone interview. Demographic data, fracture classification, management protocol, subsequent surgeries, complications, range of motion, function and patient reported outcomes were recorded. The primary short-term outcome measure was the Broberg and Morrey Elbow Score. The primary long-term outcome measure was the DASH score.

Sixty-two patients were included. Mean age 76 (range, 11–96). Low-energy injuries were seen in 97% (59/61) of patients and ≥1 co-morbidities in 50% (27/54). At a mean of 3.7 months (range, 1–14) mean Broberg and Morrey score was 86 (range, 52–100); 70% (28/40) achieving excellent or good short-term outcome. Long-term follow-up was available in 17% (n=11) patients, with 75% (48/64) deceased. At a mean of 7 years (range, 4–17) mean DASH was 23.6 (range, 0.8–45.8), mean Oxford Elbow Score was 42 (range, 32–48). Overall patient satisfaction was 100% (n=11). One patient subsequently underwent open reduction internal fixation for malunion. We have reported satisfactory short-term and longer-term outcomes following the nonsurgical management of isolated distal humerus fractures in older lower demand patients.


S.B. Roberts N. Beattie N.D. McNiven C.M. Robinson

The natural history of primary anterior glenohumeral dislocation in adolescent patients remains unclear and no consensus exists for management of these patients. The study objectives were to report the natural history following primary anterior glenohumeral joint dislocation in adolescent patients and to identify risk factors for repeat dislocation.

We reviewed prospectively-collected clinical and radiological data of 133 adolescent patients (mean age 16.3 years (range 13–18); 115 male patients (86.5%)) diagnosed with primary anterior glenohumeral joint dislocation and managed nonoperatively from 1996 to 2008 at our institution (mean follow-up 95.2 months (range 1–215)).

During follow-up, 102 (absolute incidence of 76.7%) patients experienced repeat dislocation. Median time interval between primary and repeat dislocation was 10 months (CI: 7.4 – 12.6). On survival analysis, 59% (CI: 51.2 – 66.8%) of patients remained stable one year following initial injury, 38% (CI: 30.2 – 45.8%) after two years, 21% (CI: 13.2- 28.8%) after five years, and 7% (CI: 1.1–12.9%) after 10 years. Neither age nor gender significantly predicted repeat dislocation during follow-up.

In conclusion, adolescent patients with primary anterior glenohumeral joint dislocations have a high rate of repeat dislocation, which usually occurs within two years of initial injury, and these patients should be considered early for operative stabilisation.


S.D. Middleton N. McNiven E.J. Griffin R.E. Anakwe C.W. Oliver

We define the long-term outcomes and rates of further operative intervention following displaced Bennett's fractures treated with Kirschner (K)-wire fixation.

We prospectively identified patients who were treated for displaced Bennett's fractures over a 13 year period between 1996 and 2009. Electronic records for these patients were examined and patients were invited to complete a Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) questionnaire in addition to a patient satisfaction questionnaire.

We identified 143 patients with displaced Bennett's fractures treated with K-wire fixation and followed them up at a mean of 13 years. The mean patient age at the time of injury was 33.2 years. At the time of follow up, 11 patients had died and 1 had developed dementia and was unable to respond. 9 patients had no contact details. This left 122 patients available for recruitment. Of these, 60 did not respond leaving a study group of 62 patients. Patients reported excellent functional outcomes and high levels of satisfaction at follow up. Mean satisfaction was 89% and the mean DASH score was 3.2. The infection rate was 3%. None of the 122 patients had undergone salvage procedures and none of the responders had changed occupation or sporting activities.

Long-term patient reported outcomes following displaced Bennett's are excellent. Fusion surgery or trapeziectomy was not undertaken for any patient in this series nor did this injury result in sporting or occupational changes. The rate of infection is low and similar to the literature for other surgical procedures with percutaneous K-wires.


S.A. Aitken P.J. Jenkins L.A. Rymaszewski

The management of distal humeral fractures in low-demand patients with osteoporotic bone remains controversial. Total elbow arthroplasty (TEA) has been recommended for cases where achieving stable ORIF can be difficult. The ‘bag of bones’ technique, (early movement with fragments accepted in their displaced position), is now rarely considered as it is commonly believed to confer a poor functional result. The aim of this study was to present the short- and medium-term functional outcomes following the primary conservative treatment of distal humeral fractures in elderly and low-demand patients.

We carried out a retrospective case note and radiograph review of all patients (n=40) aged 50 years or more, with distal humeral fractures treated conservatively at our institution over a six-year period. Short-term function was assessed using the Broberg and Morrey (B&M) score. Medium term function was assessed by telephone interview (n=20) using the Oxford Elbow Score (OES), QuickDASH and a pain questionnaire.

The mean post-injury B&M score improved from 42 points at 6 weeks to 67 points by 3 months. By four years, surviving patients had a mean OES of 30 points, a mean QuickDASH of 38 points, and 95% reported a functional range of elbow flexion. Those with fracture non-union experienced greater pain on repetitive elbow activities, but no difference in rest pain, compared with patients whose fractures had united. The cumulative 1-year rate of fracture union was 53%, while the 5-year mortality approached 40%.

Conservative management of distal humeral fractures confers a reasonable functional result to the patient whilst avoiding the substantial surgical risks associated with primary ORIF or TEA.


S. Gupta D. Cafferky F. Cowie P. Riches I. Anthony A. Mahendra

Extracorporeal irradiation and re-implantation of a bone segment is a technique employed in bone sarcoma surgery for limb salvage in the setting of reasonable bone stock. There is neither consensus nor rationale given for the dosage of irradiation used in previous studies, with values of up to 300Gy applied. We investigated the influence of extracorporeal irradiation on the elastic and viscoelastic properties of bone. Bone specimens were extracted from mature cattle and subdivided into thirteen groups; twelve groups exposed to increasing levels of irradiation and a control group. The specimens, once irradiated, underwent mechanical testing in saline at 37°C.

Mechanical properties were calculated by experimental means which included Young's Modulus, Poisson's Ratio, Dissipation Factor, Storage Modulus, Loss Modulus and Dynamic Modulus. These were all obtained for comparison of the irradiated specimens to the control group.

We found there to be a statistically significant increase in Poisson's ratio after increasing irradiation doses up to 300Gy were applied. However, there was negligible change in all other mechanical properties of bone that were assessed. Therefore, we conclude that the overall mechanical effect of high levels of extracorporeal irradiation (300Gy) is minute, and can be administered to reduce the risk of malignancy recurrence.


STJ Tsang LA Mills J Frantzias J Baren JF Keating AH Simpson

The aim of this study was to identify risk factors for failure of exchange nailing for femoral diaphyseal fracture non-unions. The study cohort comprised 40 patients with femoral diaphyseal non-unions treated by exchange nailing. The main outcome measures were union, number of secondary fixation procedures required to achieve union and time to union. Univariate analysis and multiple regression were used to identify risk factors for failure to achieve union.

The mean age of the patients at exchange nail surgery was 37 years. The median time to exchange nailing from primary fixation was 8.4 months. Multiple causes for non-union were found in 14 (35.0%) cases, with infection present in 12 (30.0%) patients. Further exchange procedures were required in nine (22.5%) cases, one patient (2.5%) required the use of another fixation modality, to achieve union. Union was ultimately achieved in 35 (94.5%) patients. The median time to union was 9.4 months after the exchange nail procedure. Univariate analysis confirmed that cigarette smoking and infection were predictive of failure (p<0.05). Multi-regression analysis found that Gustilo-Anderson grade, presence of dead bone or a gap and infection were predictive of exchange nail failure (p <0.05).

Exchange nailing is an effective treatment for aseptic femoral diaphyseal fracture non-union. Patients with infection required more than one procedure. Smoking, infection and the presence of dead-bone or a gap at the fracture site were associated with an increased risk of further fixation surgery.


A. Faulkner M. Reidy G. Scicluna A. Baird K. Prentice J. Coward A. Wang A. Davis J. Joss

Blood tests including liver function tests (LFTs), C-reactive protein (CRP), coagulation screens and international normalising ratios (INR) are frequently requested investigations that complement the surgical and anaesthetic pre-operative assessment of patients. The paucity of guidance available for blood requesting in acute trauma and orthopaedic admissions can lead to inappropriate requesting practices and over investigation. Unnecessary tests place an economic burden on a hospital and repeated venepuncture is unpleasant for patients.

We audited blood requesting practices and with multidisciplinary input developed guidelines to improve practice which were subsequently implemented.

Admissions over a period of one month to Ninewells Hospital and Perth Royal Infirmary were audited retrospectively. The frequency and clinical indications for LFTs, coagulation screens/INR and CRP for the duration of the patient's admission were recorded. Re-audit was carried out for one month after the introduction of the guidelines.

216 patients were included in January and 236 patients in September 2014. Total no. of LFTs requested: January 895, September 336 (−62.5%). Total no of coagulation screens/INR requested: January 307, September 210 (−31.6%). Total number of CRPs requested: January 894, September 317 (−64.5%). No. of blood requests per patient: January (M=4.81, SD 4.75), September (M=3.60, SD = 4.70). A significant decrease was observed in admission requesting and subsequent monitoring (p<0.01) for LFTs, coagulation screens/INR, CRP when the guidance was introduced.

The implementation of the bloods guidance resulted in a large reduction in admission requesting and subsequent monitoring without incident. The cost of investigation was significantly reduced, as were venepuncture rates.


C. Munro S.L. Barker

The upper age limit for Paediatric Orthopaedic referrals and admissions has recently been increased from 14 to 16 years. This has many benefits but will change the volume of cases as well as influencing both case mix and the resources required. We analysed the operations and admissions in our department for the year preceding and succeeding the change in age limit in order to evaluate the impact on the service. Our outcome measures were number of trauma and elective cases treated, time spent operating, case mix and cost to the service.

Admission and operative logs for the aforementioned years were analysed to obtain number of admissions, length of stay and operative intervention as well as time in theatre. National reference data from Information Services Division Scotland was used in order to get accurate costs for theatre time and inpatient stays in our hospital.

Results showed an increase in total number of cases from 438 per year to 499. Trauma cases increased from 133 (30.4%) to 202 (40.5%). Of these, 35 (17.3%) were over 14 years. The number of children over 14 years which had an operation, doubled from 51 to 102. Hours spent operating increased from 681.25 to 830.25. The percentage time operating on those aged over 14 increased from 13.2% to 23.8%. Theatre costs increased by £148005 (21.9%) to £822442.50.

The change in age limit has significantly increased case variety and numbers. This has significant financial implications and as such needs adequately resourced to ensure high quality clinical care.


ND Clement G Keenan D Marsh D Nayagam R Atkins AHRW Simpson

We conducted a multicentre two arm double blind randomised controlled trial to assess efficacy of pulsed ultrasound for accelerating the rate of bone healing. Sixty-two skeletally mature adults undergoing limb lengthening, of between 2.5cm to 10cm by distraction osteogenesis, at the proximal tibia using an Ilizarov frame were randomised to either an active or a placebo (control) ultrasound device.

Primary outcome measure was time ready for removal of frame after adjusting for distraction length (days/cm) for both intension to treat (ITT) and per protocol (PP) patients. The time at which the frame was removed was determined by the maturation of the regenerate bone. Secondary outcomes were return to weight bearing and covariates affecting time to frame removal.

The baseline characteristics of the two groups were well balanced, and 90% of patients were managed and followed up as PP. There was no difference in the time to frame removal between the two groups for the ITT (5.0days/cm, p=0.23) or the PP (10.1days/cm, p=0.054). There was no difference in return to weight bearing between the two groups, after adjusting for distraction length, for the ITT or PP patients (p>0.5). Smoking was the only covariate identified to increase the frame removal time (hazard ratio 0.46, 95% confidence interval 0.22 to 0.96; p=0.04).

This trial demonstrated no difference in bone healing between those who underwent pulsed ultrasound and those who did not. Smoking was observed to have a significant inhibitory effect on bone healing.


IR Murray WR Hardy CC West X Zhang AW James C Soo AHRW Simpson B Peault

Adipose tissue is an attractive source of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) as it is largely dispensable and readily accessible through minimally invasive procedures such as lipoaspiration. Until recently MSCs could only be isolated in a process involving ex-vivo culture. Pericytes (CD45−, CD146+, and CD34−) and adventitial cells (CD45−, CD146−, CD34+) represent two populations of MSCs (collectively termed perivascular stem cells or PSCs) that can be prospectively purified using fluorescence activated cell sorting (FACS). We performed FACS on lipoaspirate samples from n=129 donors to determine the frequency and yield of PSCs and to establish patient and processing factors that influence yield.

The mean number of stromal vascular fraction (SVF) cells from 100ml of lipoaspirate was 37.8×106. Within the SVF, mean cell viability was 82%, with 31.6% of cells being heamatopoietic (CD45+). Adventitial cells and pericytes represented 31.6% and 7.9% of SVF cells respectively. As such, 200ml of lipoaspirate would theoretically yield 24.5 million MSCs –a sufficient number to enable point-of-care delivery for use in several orthopaedic applications. The yield and prevalence of PSCs were minimally affected by donor age, sex and BMI. Storing lipoaspirate samples for up to 72 hours prior to processing had no significant deleterious effects on MSC yield or viability.

Our study confirms that pure populations of MSC-precursors (PSCs) can be prospectively isolated from adipose tissue, in sufficient quantities to negate the necessity for culture expansion while widening possible applications to include trauma, where a time delay between extraction and implantation excludes their use.


J.A. Nicholson I. Ahmed A. Ning S. Wong J.F. Keating

This study reports on the natural history of acetabular fracture dislocations. We retrospectively reviewed patients who sustained an acetabular fracture associated with a posterior hip dislocation from a prospective database. Patient characteristics, complications and the requirement for further surgery were recorded. Patient outcomes were measured using the Oxford Hip score and Short Form SF-12 health survey.

A total of 99 patients were treated over a 24 year period. The mean age was 41 years. Open reduction and internal fixation was performed in the majority (n=87), 10 were managed conservatively following closed reduction and two underwent primary total hip replacement (THR). At a median follow up of 12.4 years (range 4–24 years) patient outcomes were available for 53 patients. 12 patients had died. 19 patients went onto have a THR as a secondary procedure, of which 11 had confirmed avascular necrosis. Median time to THR was 2 years (range 1–17 years). The mean Oxford hip score was 35 (range 2–48), SF-12 physical component score (PCS) was 40 and a third of the patients used a walking aid. In THR group the mean Oxford score was 32 (range 3–46), SF-12 PCS was 39 and almost all required a walking aid.

This is the first study to present the long term outcomes following an acetabular fracture dislocation. Our study suggests there is considerable disability in this group of patients and the requirement for subsequent THR has inferior patient reported outcomes.


K.E. Bugler T.O. White

Early weight-bearing of patients with ankle fractures is associated with good outcomes. There are a number of potential advantages to early mobilisation including reduced hospital stay and earlier return to work and regular daily activities. However, many surgeons have not incorporated this into their routine ankle fracture protocol, particularly for patients managed operatively; potentially due to concerns regarding loss of reduction. We hypothesised that ankle fractures managed fully weight-bearing would have good outcomes and a low rate of loss of reduction.

All ankle fractures presenting to our department over a 15-month period were studied prospectively. Patients were instructed to mobilise fully weight-bearing as able, either immediately postoperatively (for those fractures considered unstable that underwent operative intervention), or at the first fracture clinic review (if stable and managed conservatively). Only patients with syndesmotic injuries and those with neuropathy or psychiatric illness were excluded. The effectiveness of this management protocol was assessed by clinical and radiographic review following fracture union.

847 patients were included, of whom 25% were over the age of 65. 33% of fractures were unstable and therefore managed operatively, 66% were stable and therefore managed in casts or with functional bracing. In every case the radiographs showed maintenance of anatomical mortise and fracture reduction at the time of union, good patient reported outcomes were also recorded.

Early weight-bearing of patients with ankle fractures, whether managed conservatively or operatively, results in very low rates of loss of reduction and should be considered routine management for the majority of patients.


R Lawton B Clift

The posterior approach to the hip avoids violating abductors and has presumed functional advantages. The anterolateral approach risks abductor damage, but has reportedly lower dislocation rate.

To determine effects of surgical approach on function and dislocation after primary and revision THR 3274 primary THRs and 66 first time revision THRs were investigated from the arthroplasty database (2000–2008).

2682 (82%) primary THRs were via anterolateral approach, 592 (18%) by posterior. Post primary dislocation rate was 50/2682 (1.9%) for anterolateral and 26/592 (4.4%) for posterior. Posterior approach had significantly better Harris Hip Scores: 91 vs 88 (P = 0.000) and function: 40 vs 37 (P = 0.000). Of the 66 revisions THRs, 30 were anterolateral and 36 posterior. Dislocation rates were 2/30 (6.7%) and 4/36 (11.1%) respectively. There was no significant difference in Harris Hip Score or Harris Hip Function 1 year after revision based on revision surgery approach. However there was a significant difference in Harris Hip Function 1 year after revision based on the approach for primary surgery (Anterolateral 30 vs Posterior 37, P=0.008) and a similar trend in Harris Hip Score (Anterolateral 79 vs Posterior 85, P = 0.198) and patients who had posterior approach for both primary and revision had the best scores overall.

The clinical relevance of the modest, but statistically significant difference in Harris hip score after primary THR is unclear. That primary approach has an impact on function after revision suggests the posterior approach should be considered in younger patients likely to require revision in the future.