header advert
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 96-B, Issue SUPP_14 October 2014 Scottish Committee for Orthopaedics and Trauma (SCOT)

STJ Tsang LA Mills J Frantzias J Baren JF Keating AH Simpson

The aim of this study was to identify risk factors for failure of exchange nailing in tibial diaphyseal fracture non-unions. The cohort comprised 99 tibial diaphyseal fracture non-unions treated by exchange nailing. The mean age of the patients at exchange nail surgery was 36 years. The median time from primary fixation to exchange nailing was 6.4 months. The main outcome measures were union, number of secondary fixation procedures required to achieve union and time to union. Univariate analysis and multiple regression were used to identify risk factors for failure to achieve union.

Multiple causes for non-union were found in 31.3% cases, with infection present in 32.3%. Further exchange procedures were required in 35.4%, 7.1% required the use of other fixation modalities. Union was ultimately achieved in 97.8%. The median time to union was 8.7 months. Univariate analysis revealed that cigarette smoking, an atrophic pattern of non-union and infection were predictive for failure of exchange nailing (p<0.05). Multi-regression analysis found that only infection was statistically significantly predictive (p<0.05) of exchange nail failure.

Exchange nailing is an effective treatment for tibial diaphyseal non-unions even in the presence of infection. Smoking, atrophic pattern of non-union and infection are associated with an increased risk of further fixation surgery.


S. Johnson M. Jafri A. Jariwala G. Mcleod

Management of irreparable rotator cuff tears is challenging and controversial. Surgeons have been utilising biological tissue scaffolding to augment repairs, but there are concerns regarding viability and function. We wished to investigate this viability and clinical outcome in a small group of patients.

All procedures were performed by a single surgeon over a three-year period. Inclusion criteria were patients with large cuff tears and failure of non-operative treatment. Exclusion criteria were patients with glenohumeral arthritis and where cuff repair could not be successfully performed. Open rotator cuff repair followed by augmentation with Graft Jacket® Regenerative Tissue Matrix (Wright Medical) was performed in all patients. A structured cuff repair physiotherapy protocol was then followed. Follow-up was at six months and at minimum twenty-four months post-operatively where Constant scores (CS) and Oxford Shoulder scores (OSS) were noted and a repeat ultrasound performed.

Fourteen patients underwent the procedure. No patient was lost to follow-up. There were seven males and seven females with a mean age of 63 years (range 31–77). At minimum twenty-four month follow-up, thirteen patients had flexion and abduction above 90 degrees and symmetrical external rotation. Mean CS was 81 (range 70–91) and mean OSS was 46 (range 41–48). Shoulder ultrasound revealed an intact Graft Jacket® in all thirteen patients. The final patient had lower functional movement and lower CS (34) and OSS (25) and ultrasound identified a re-rupture.

This study indicates that augmentation of large rotator cuff repairs with biological tissue scaffolding is a viable option and has good functional results.


O. Bailey K Gronkowski W.J. Leach

The aim of this study was to determine if patient reported outcome scores for arthroscopic meniscectomy are adversely affected by the degree of knee osteoarthritis or patient body mass index (BMI).

All patients who underwent arthroscopic meniscectomy within the NHS in Scotland between 6th February and 29th April 2012 were audited as part of the Scottish Government Musculoskeletal Knee Arthroscopy Audit and were eligible for inclusion within this study. A total of 270 patients returned both their pre-operative and post-operative EuroQol 5Q5D5L descriptive questionnaire and Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcomes Scores. Patients were stratified according to BMI, degree of osteoarthritis, history of injury, and duration of knee symptoms.

Pre-operative to post-operative EuroQol index scores [0.642±0.253 to 0.735±0.277, median±SD] and Knee injury and Osteoarthrtis Outcome Scores [44.63±18.78 to 62.28±24.94, median±SD] improved across all patients (p<0.0001). This was irrespective of degree of BMI, history of injury, or duration of symptoms. There was no such improvement in patients with moderate to severe osteoarthritis. Those patients with a BMI >35 kg/m2 had lower post-operative scores than the pre-operative scores of those of BMI <30 kg/m2.

Arthroscopic meniscectomy is beneficial regardless of patient BMI, duration of symptoms, history of injury, or in the presence of mild arthritis.


P Hindle C West LC Biant B Péault

Perivascular stem cells (PSCs) from lipoaspirate demonstrate increased purity and immaturity with greater engraftment potential than standard mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs). MSCs from the infra-patellar fat pad (IFP) have previously demonstrated increased chondrogenic potential. This study investigated the availability and potential of PSCs harvested from the infra-patellar fat pad of the human knee for musculoskeletal regeneration.

Tissue sections of IFP were stained with markers for PSCs, MSCs and endothelial cells to confirm their presence and location. Samples were obtained from patients undergoing TKR (n=13) or ACL reconstructions (n=10). Pericytes and adventitial cells made up 3.8% and 21.2% respectively of the stromal vascular fraction. The total number of pericytes and adventitial cells were 4.6±2.2×104 and 16.2±3.2×104 respectively. Cells were cultured both separately and combined. Cell identity was ascertained using fluorescence-activated cell sorting, immunocytochemistry and PCR. Cultured PSCs were differentiated using chondrogneic, osteogenic, adipogenic and myogenic medias. Differentiation was determined using Alcian Blue, Alizarin red, Oil Red O and myosin staining.

This study demonstrates that the IPFP is a viable source of PSCs that can be harvested either arthroscopically or through an arthrotomy by orthopaedic surgeons for cell-based musculoskeletal regeneration. Their potential now needs to be compared to conventional MSCs.


S Dalgleish DC Campbell JGB MacLean

The initial management of slipped upper femoral epiphysis (SUFE) can determine the occurrence of longterm disability due to complications. Previous surveys have concentrated on orthopaedic surgeons with a specialist paediatric interest. In many units in Scotland, the initial responsibility for management may be an admitting trauma surgeon with a different subspecialty interest.

All Orthopaedic surgeons in Scotland participating in acute admitting were invited to complete a web based survey to ascertain current practice in the initial management of adolescents presenting with SUFE.

92/144 (64%) of surgeons approached responded. When faced with a severe stable slip, 53% of respondents were happy to pin in situ, whilst 47% would refer either to a colleague or specialist paediatric unit. With an unstable slip of similar magnitude, 38% would self-treat, 18% refer to a colleague and 44% refer to a paediatric orthopaedic unit. Of those treating, 58% stated their treatment was selected irrespective of timing of presentation. 79% of respondents had treated 5 or less cases in the preceding 5 years with 7% more than 10 cases. Universal prophylactic pinning was supported in 29%, selective in 62% and never in 9%.

The responses obtained confirm the variance in management of SUFE that exists amidst acute admitting units in Scotland. Management of a stable slip is uncontroversial except possibly in severe cases. This contrasts with the acute unstable slip, in which various factors are thought to influence the outcome, such as instability and the issue of timing, which are not universally appreciated.


I.R.M. Bohler V. Velu Y. Husmi A. Campbell

This abstract is currently withdrawn to allow an independent review of findings to take place.


S.D. Middleton N. McNiven R.E. Anakwe P.J. Jenkins S.A. Aitken J.F. Keating M. Moran

We define the medium-term outcomes following total hip replacement (THR) for hip fracture. There is currently no information regarding longer term clinical and patient reported outcomes in this group of patients selected in accordance with national guidelines.

We prospectively identified patients who underwent THR for a displaced hip fracture over a three year period between 2007 and 2010. These patients were followed up at 5 years using the Oxford hip score, Short-form 12(SF-12) questionnaire and satisfaction questionnaire.

We identified 128 patients. Mean follow up was at 5.4 years with a mean age of 76.5 years. 21 patients (16%) had died, 12 patients (9%) had developed dementia and 3 patients had no contact details, leaving a study group of 92 patients. 74 patients(80%) responded. Patients reported excellent functional outcomes and satisfaction at 5 years (mean Oxford Hip Score 40.3; SF-12 Physical Health Composite Score 44.0; SF-12 Mental Health Composite Score 46.2; mean satisfaction 90%). The rates of dislocation (2%), deep infection (2%) and revision (3%) were comparable to those quoted for elective THR. When compared with 2 year follow up, there was no statistically significant change in outcome.

Medium-term outcomes for THR after hip fracture are excellent and the early proven benefits of this surgery are sustained. Mortality rates are equivalent to elective THR registry data and significantly lower than overall mortality rates following hip fracture. Our data validates the selection process detailed in national guidelines and confirms the low complication rate. THR is a safe and highly effective treatment for fit elderly patients with displaced hip fractures.


M. Halai A. Ker D. Nadeem T. Sjostrom B. Su M.J. Dalby R.M.D. Meek P.S. Young

In biomaterial engineering the surface of an implant can influence cell differentiation, adhesion and affinity towards the implant. Increased bone marrow derived mesenchymal stromal cell (BMSC) differentiation towards bone forming osteoblasts, on contact with an implant, can improve osteointegration. The process of micropatterning has been shown to improve osteointegration in polymers, but there are few reports surrounding ceramics.

The purpose of this study was to establish a co-culture of BMSCs with osteoclast progenitor cells and to observe the response to micropatterned zirconia toughened alumina (ZTA) ceramics with 30 µm diameter pits. The aim was to establish if the pits were specifically bioactive towards osteogenesis or were generally bioactive and would also stimulate osteoclastogenesis that could potentially lead to osteolysis.

We demonstrate specific bioactivity of micropits towards osteogenesis with more nodule formation and less osteoclastogenesis. This may have a role when designing ceramic orthopaedic implants.


M.R. Simons D.A. Sewell S.A. Mehdi

Hallux valgus (HV) deformities have been well defined in the adult population. HV appears to be more prevalent in elderly and female populations and it is postulated that women's shoe wear contributes to its progression.

This study was a pilot to quantify the prevalence of foot deformities and foot pain in an adolescent population.

Our cohort consisted of 202 school children aged 11–17 recruited from two schools in Edinburgh. Foot health data was recorded via the Manchester Scale (MHVS) and the Oxford Ankle and Foot Questionnaire (OAFQ). Photographic assessment of all participants allowed MHVS to be calculated by two orthopaedic surgeons. The photographic assessment was then repeated by the same surgeon 12 months later to allow inter and intra observer reliability to be calculated.

Results showed that the prevalence of HV in our cohort was 32.7% and there was a female preponderance 56% to 44%. Other foot measurements revealed 48.5% had HV-interphalangeus, 25.7% had a low medial longitudinal arch and 22.3% had a valgus hindfoot angle. Significantly more females (18%) than males (5%) wore shoes narrower than their feet (p=0.003). OAFQ scores revealed that foot pain was more common in those with HV deformities although not statistically significant (75% to 68%, p=0.243). The prevalence of foot pain was negatively correlated with age (r=−0.175, p=0.14).

This study suggests that there is a significant prevalence of HV and foot pain amongst female adolescents. This will need to be confirmed by a population study based on power calculation informed by this pilot.


ST Goudie D Gamble J Reid A Duckworth S Molyneux

The primary aim of this study was to identify risk factors for developing neuritis and its impact on outcome following open reduction internal fixation (ORIF) of distal humerus fractures.

Patients were identified from a prospective trauma database (1995–2010). All fractures of the distal humerus (OA-OTA Type A, B, C) managed with ORIF were included. Prospective long-term follow up was collected by telephone. Demographic data, fracture classification, intraoperative details (time to surgery, tourniquet, approach, fixation technique, nerve transposition), subsequent surgeries, presence of postoperative nerve palsy, complications and range of motion were collected. The Broberg and Morrey Elbow Score and DASH score were used as functional outcome measures.

Eighty-two patients, mean age 50(range, 13–93) were included. 16% (13/82) developed post-operative ulnar neuritis, 7% (6/82) radial neuritis and 5% (4/82) longterm nonspecific dysaesthesia. Short-term (mean 10 months, range 1–120, collected in 82 patients) and long-term (mean 6 years, range 4–18, collected in 45%, 34/75, of living patients) was completed. In patients with nerve complication: average Broberg and Morrey score was 86 (76% good/excellent), average DASH was 24.7(range, 3.3–100) and Oxford Elbow Score was 39.5(range, 18–48). Compared to: 94 (96% good/excellent), 17.7(range, 0–73.3) and 43.8(range, 17–48) in patients without. Mean pain score was 3.7 in patients with nerve complication compared to 2 without. Nerve complications were seen with increased frequency in young, male patients with high energy and Type C injuries.

Nerve complication following ORIF of distal humerus fractures is relatively common. They have detrimental impact on functional outcome. Certain groups appear to be at increased risk.


A.G. Marsh O. Al Fakayh S. Patil

Ganz peri-acetabular osteotomy is commonly used to treat symptomatic hip dysplasia. It aims to increase the load bearing contact area of the hip to reduce the risk of subsequent osteoarthritis. In this study we assess the radiographic and clinical results of the procedure since its introduction to our unit.

All patients undergoing Ganz osteotomies at our unit were followed up prospectively. Data collected included patient demographics and pre- and post-operative functional scores (Harris and Non-arthritic hip scores). In addition, acetabular correction was evaluated on pre-and post-operative radiographs (using Centre-Edge angle and Tonnis angle). Complications were also noted.

Overall 50 procedures were performed between 2007 and 2013 with median follow-up of 3 years (1–7 years). The majority of patients (90%) were female. Average age at time of surgery was 32 years (17–39). There were significant improvements in pre- and post-operative median functional scores (Modified Harris Hip Score = 52 versus 63, p=0.001), Non-arthritic Hip Score = 49 versus 60, p=0.01). Median Centre Edge Angle improved from 15 degrees pre-operatively (range = 8–19 degrees) to 29 degrees post-operatively (22–36 degrees), p=0.02. Similarly, pre-operative Tonnis angle improved from 19 degrees (16–38) to 7 degrees (2–14), p=0.01. Four patients developed post-operative complications: 1 superficial wound infection, 1deep infection requiring hip washout and antibiotic treatment and 2 patients subsequently requiring total hip replacements.

We have shown that the Ganz peri-acetabular osteotomy can be effective for the treatment of painful hip dysplasia improving both functional and radiographic outcomes. However, patient selection is a key factor.