header advert
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 96-B, Issue SUPP_10 July 2014 British Limb Reconstruction Society (BLRS)

T. Hester D. Bond S. Phillips

Gold standard for the management of non-union is open surgical debridement, stabilisation, and autologous bone grafting. LIPUS is becoming more popular, yet the evidence is still inconclusive. LIPUS involves the use of ultrasound at the fracture site with little risk to the patient.

The purpose of this study was to assess effectiveness and cost benefit of LIPUS in the management of non-unions post sustaining an open fracture.

We retrospectively reviewed 29 patients with open fractures with established non-union undergoing LIPUS since 2010 (4 females, mean age 48) range 3–27 months, mean 9 months, either post injury or last intervention. All were tertiary referrals, sustaining injuries to the following areas; Tibial 21, Femur 6, Humerus 2, Radius 1. Definitive fixation being; 9 TSF's, 11 IMN's, 9 plates. (undergoing a mean 2.4 procedures). Aside from sustaining an open fracture, 7 had risk factors for non-unions 5 smokers, 2 NSAID's. Failure of treatment was based on undertaking bone grafting.

In 28 patients (1 lost to follow up) union was achieved in 71% (mean 157 days). All were screened for infection, 4 had organisms on enrichment culture. 8 (5 Gustillo Anderson Grade 3A/B) injuries did not show evidence of callus formation, LIPUS was discontinued and grafting performed. Open fractures were graded as; 7 Grade 1, 4 Grade 2, 8 Grade 3A, 10 Grade 3B being received. Of these; 20 underwent primary closure, 6 free flaps and 3 SSG. The cost of LIPUS is approx £2500, compared bone grafting using autologous iliac crest graft with no medical comorbidities of £3715.

This case series further supports union rates after LIPUS. Cost and morbidity benefit of utilising LIPUS over opting for bone grafting initially is £1215 per patient. Whilst autologous bone grafting is currently the gold standard, it is not without morbidity. We achieved union rates of 71% despite a number of patients having recognised risk factors, showing that LIPUS is a useful resource in the management of non-union.


A. Hughes P. Soden A. Abdulkarim C. McMahon C. Hurson

Revision hip arthroplasty requires a comprehensive appreciation of abnormal bony anatomy. Advances in radiology and manufacturing technology have made three-dimensional representation of actual osseous anatomy obtainable. These models provide a visual and tactile reproduction of the bony abnormality in question.

Life size three dimensional models were manufactured from CT scans of two patients. The first had multiple previous hip arthroplasties and bilateral hip infections. There was a pelvic discontinuity on the right and a severe postero-superior deficiency on the left. The second patient had a first stage revision for infection and recurrent dislocations. Specific metal reduction protocols were used to reduce artefact. The dicom images were imported into Mimics, medical imaging processing software. The models were manufactured using the rapid prototyping process, Selective Laser Sintering (SLS).

The models allowed accurate templating using the actual prosthesis templates prior to surgery. Acetabular cup size, augment and buttress sizes, as well as cage dimensions were selected, adjusted and re-sterilised in advance. This reduced operative time, blood loss and improved surgical decision making. Screw trajectory simulation was also carried out on the models, thus reducing the chance of neurovascular injury.

With 3D printing technology, complex pelvic deformities can be better evaluated and can be treated with improved precision. The life size models allow accurate surgical simulation, thus improving anatomical appreciation and pre-operative planning. The accuracy and cost-effectiveness of the technique were impressive and its use should prove invaluable as a tool to aid clinical practice.


W. Harrison B. Narayan

Definitions and perceptions of good and poor outcome vary between patients and surgeons, and perceived inadequate outcome can lead to litigation. We investigated outcomes of litigation claims relating to non-union and deformity following lower limb long bone fractures from 1995 to 2010.

The database of all 10456 claims related to Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgery was obtained from the NHS Litigation Authority. Data was searched for “deformity, non-union and mal-union”, excluding spine, arthroplasty, foot and upper limb surgery. The type of complaint, whether defended or not, and costs was analysed.

241 claims met our criteria, 204 of which were closed, and 37 unsettled. Deformity/mal-union constituted 97, and non-union 143. Coronal/sagittal deformity cost £4.2 million, mean £45,487 (60% received compensation). Rotational mal-unions cost £1.6 million, mean £114,263 (87% received compensation). Non-union cost £5.3 million, mean £75,866 (60% received compensation).

Mean legal fees for coronal/sagittal deformity was £18,772, rotational deformity £37,384, and non-union £24,680. The total cost of litigation was £12.2 million, with a mean of £59,597 per settled claim. The mean pay-out for all confirmed negligence/liability was £56,046 (£1,300–£500,000, median £21,500) per case.

Non-union is an accepted complication following fracture surgery. However, this does not mitigate against non-union being seen as representing a poor standard of care. While it is unclear whether the payouts reflect a defensive culture or were due to avoidable errors, and notwithstanding the limitations of the database, we argue that failure of the index surgery should prompt a referral to a specialist centre.

The cosmetic appearances of rotational malalignment results in higher compensation, reinforcing outward perception of outcome as being more important than harmful effects.

We also note that the database sometimes contained conflicting and incomplete data, and make a case for standardisation of this component of the outcome process to allow for learning and reflection.


O. Carmody M. Kennedy

Note: No previous similar study to this has been carried out in the Republic of Ireland, to our knowledge. Ankle fractures are the most common lower limb fracture in all age groups in Ireland. Approximately 43% of all ankle fractures will require operative fixation.1 82% of all operative ankle procedures in Ireland are carried out on patients between 18–65 years old.

We felt it was imperative to study the incidence within various age groups, the associated length of hospital stay and to offer suggestions in reducing this length-of-stay.

The National Hospital Inpatient Enquiry system (data collection accuracy 95.9%–98.2%), ICD-coding and data from the Central Statistics Office were analysed.2

14,903 ankle fractures underwent ORIF between 2002–09 (average 1,928/year). While there was a statistical increase in ORIF's in the over 65 group, there was no overall increase in the incidence of surgical procedures.

The average length-of-stay in 2002 was 4.8 days, but had significantly dropped to 4.0 days by 2009. This was most marked in the over 65's where it decreased from 10.5 to 7.7 days.

The annual incidence of ankle fractures requiring operative intervention in Ireland was 44.43 per 100,000 persons.

This study highlights many issues, namely:

While there is a significant decrease in length-of-stay to 4 days, we feel this figure could be significantly reduced further.

While the incidence of ankle fractures in the over-65 group remained stable, surprisingly there was a statistically significant increase in the number of operative procedures within this age group.


J.E. Tomlinson O.G. Evans R. Townsend M. Vincent E.J. Mills J.C. McGregor-Riley M.G. Dennison S.L. Royston

The purpose of the study was to retrospectively assess the patients treated to date with the vac ulta system using a technique of antibiotic instillation.

The vac ulta system is licensed for use with anti-septic instillation fluid but we have now treated a number of patients with antibiotic instillation under the guidance of the microbiology department. All patients being treated with the vac ulta system were included in the study. There were no exclusions. Pathology treated, infecting organism, antibiotic used and length of treatment were all recorded. Any antibiotic related complications were noted. Treatment was judged successful with resolution of presenting symptoms, normalization of inflammatory markers and three negative foam cultures.

There were 21 patients included in the study. There were 13 male and 8 female patients. Length of treatment ranged from 1 week to 10 weeks with a mean of 4.2 weeks. Follow up ranged from 1 month to 42 months with a mean follow up of 17.9 months

The most common pathogen was Staph. Aureus(11 cases). Enterobacter, ESBL, Strep. Milleri, MRSA and Citrobacter were also treated. Antibiotics instilled included flucloxacillin, meropenem, gentamicin, vancomycin, meropenem and teicoplanin. There were no antibiotic reactions/allergies. Pathologies treated included osteomyelitis, two stage amputations for infection, infected non-union and infected metalwork. Infection recurred in 2 of 21 patients (10%), with one recurring at 18 months and one at 2 years.

The 90% treatment success rate is highly encouraging in this notoriously difficult group of patients to treat. In this series vac instill was an effective treatment of infection and allows antibiotic treatment to be targeted to the infected tissues. There were no adverse reactions seen.

Larger series with longer follow up are no needed but we believe this technique is safe, successful and easily administered can be cautiously adopted on a wider basis.


M. Fernandez P. Makrides J. McArthur M. Venus J. Young J. Skillman M. Wyse M. Costa

We sought to evaluate the impact of a dedicated weekly ortho-plastics operating list on our ability to provide definitive soft tissue cover of open lower limb fractures within 72 hours.

We reviewed all open lower limb fractures at our centre before and after the introduction of an ortho-plastics list to determine whether definitive soft tissue coverage was achieved within 72 hours.

There were 23 open lower limb fractures at our centre in 2012 before the introduction of the ortho-plastics operating list of which only 7 (30%) had definitive soft tissue coverage within 72 hours. We hypothesised that the main reason for this was not patient or injury related factors but rather the logistical difficulties of coordinating theatre time on a routine trauma list with senior orthopaedic and plastic surgeon availability. To test this hypothesis we re-audited our time to soft tissue cover six months after the introduction of the ortho-plastics list and 70% of cases achieved coverage within 72 hours.

Achieving definitive soft tissue coverage of open lower limb fractures within 72 hours of injury is a challenge. A dedicated weekly ortho-plastics operating list significantly improves our ability to deliver this service.


M. Bansal S. Shetty S. Phillips A.F.G. Groom

The purpose of this study is to describe the use of the PHILOS plate (Synthes) in reverse configuration to treat complex distal humeral non-unions.

Non-union is a frequent complication of distal humeral fracture. It is a challenging problem due to the complex anatomy of the distal humerus, small distal fragment heavily loaded by the forearm acting as a long lever arm with powerful forces increasing the chances of displacement. Rigid fixation and stability with a device of high “pull-out” strength is required. The PHILOS plate has been used in reverse configuration to achieve good fixation while allowing central posterior placement of the implant.

11 patients with established non-union of distal humeral fractures were included in this study. No patient in whom this implant was used has been excluded. Initial fixation was revised using the PHILOS plate in reverse configuration and good fixation was achieved. Bone graft substitutes were used in all cases. Patients were followed to bony union, and functional recovery.

All fractures united. One required revision of plate due to fatigue failure. Average time to union was 8 months with excellent restoration of elbow function.

A reversed PHILOS plate provides an excellent method of fixation in distal humeral non-union, often complicated by distorted anatomy and previous surgical intervention. It has a high “pull-out” strength and may be placed in the centre of the posterior humerus, allowing proximal extension of the fixation as far as is required. It provides secure distal fixation without impinging on the olecranon fossa. It is more versatile and easier to use than available pre contoured plating systems.


O. Carmody E. Sheehan R. McGrath P. Keeling

An interesting case with excellent accompanying images, highlighting the significance of tourniquets in controlling exsanguination, whilst also raising the issue of amputation versus reconstruction in severely injured limbs.

A 39 year old male motorcyclist was BIBA to the Midland Regional Hospital in Tullamore, following a head-on collision with a bus at high velocity. On arrival, he was assessed via ATLS guidelines; A- intubated, B- respiratory rate 32, C - heart rate 140bpm, blood-pressure 55/15 and D- GCS 7/15. Injuries included partial traumatic amputation of the right lower limb with clearly visible posterior femoral condyles, a heavily comminuted distal tibial fracture and almost complete avulsion of the skin and fat at the popliteal fossa. Obvious massive blood loss at the scene had been tempered by a passer-by who applied a beach towel as a makeshift tourniquet. CT Brain demonstrated extra-dural and subarachnoid haemorrhages with gross midline shift. Unfortunately, the neurosurgical team in Beaumont concluded that surgical intervention would be inappropriate. However, his kidneys had not sustained ATN and were made available for donation.

Two vital surgical issues were featured in this case. Firstly, it highlighted the importance of tourniquets in controlling exsanguination in a trauma situation1. Secondly, it raised the critical issue of amputation versus reconstruction in severely injured limbs2,3.

Without prompt placement of a make-shift tourniquet by a passer-by, this patient would have almost certainly died at the scene of the accident. Two kidneys were successfully donated as a result.

The importance of appropriate tourniquet use cannot be overstated. This case highlights its potential life or limb-saving capabilities in emergency trauma situations. It also raises the critical issue of amputation versus reconstruction in acute emergency situations.


B.J. O'Neill C.M. Fox A.P. Molloy D.P. Moore

The purpose of this study was to review the outcomes and complications of all circular external fixators (frames) used for the management of acute lower limb trauma in our institution over a twenty year period.

We retrospectively reviewed a prospectively compiled database of all frames applied in our institution and identified all frames which were applied for acute lower limb trauma. We identified 68 fractures in 63 patients. There were 11 femoral fractures and 57 tibial fractures. All fractures were classified using the AO Classification system, and most fractures were Type C fractures. We used an Ilizarov frame in 53 patients and a Taylor Spatial Frame in 15 patients. The mean time in frame was 365 days for a femoral fracture and 230 days for a tibial fracture. There were five tibial non-unions giving an overall union rate of 93%. Factors associated with non-union included high energy trauma and cigarette smoking.

The vast majority of lower limb fractures can be treated using ‘conventional’ methods. Complex fractures which are not amenable to open reduction and internal fixation or cast immobilisation can be treated in a frame with excellent results. The paucity of published reports regarding the use of frames for complex trauma reflects the under-utilisation of the technique.


A.J. Keightley S.Z. Nawaz D.S. Elliott A. Khaleel

The purpose of this study was to review the long term functional results of patients undergoing treatment for high energy tibial plateau fractures.

Between January 1994 and June 2013 our unit managed 105 high energy tibial plateau fractures (Schatzker IV-VI) with an Ilizarov frame. All cases were treated via ligamentotaxis and percutaneous fine wire fixation or with a limited open reduction of the joint surface. A retrospective analysis of all patients that have undergone Ilizarov fixation of a tibial plateau fracture was performed with radiological and clinical functional outcome measurements.

We analysed 105 patients with a mean follow up of 93.5 months (range 5–200). The patient group had an average age of 49 years (range 15–87) with 62 patients being male. Fracture pattern was analysed with Schatzker's classification showing 18 type IV, 10 type V and 77 type VI tibial plateau fractures. All fractures had an average time to union of 145 days. Patients had and average range of movement of 117 degrees.

Patients undergoing Ilizarov treatment for high energy tibial plateau fractures achieve successful results long term. Definitive treatment should be decided with respect to fracture pattern and the soft tissue envelope. The management aim should be to achieve anatomical reduction and stable fixation to enable early mobilization. Our study confirms the good functional outcomes and low morbidity that can be achieved in high energy fractures treated with Ilizarov fixation.


W. Harrison B. Narayan

Claims for clinical negligence are increasing annually. Limb reconstructive surgery recognises ‘problems, obstacles, and complications’ as part of the treatment process, but this does not prevent a claim for an alleged poor result or a complication.

We analysed claims for clinical negligence in the National Health Service in England and Wales for issues following limb reconstructive surgery.

A database of all 10,456 claims related to Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgery from 1995–2010 was obtained from the NHS Litigation Authority. A Search Function for keywords “Ilizarov, limb reconstruction, external fixation, and pin-site” was used for subset analysis. Data was analysed for type of complaint, whether defended or not, and for costs.

52 claims fitted our filters - 48 were closed, and 4 ongoing. The claims included damage to local structures (n=3), missed compartment syndrome (n=2), premature frame removal (n=5), infection (n=13), wrong-site-surgery (n=1), poor outcome (n=16) and technical error (n=10). Seven patients underwent amputation. The total cost of litigation was £4,444,344, with a mean of £90,700 per settled claim. 40% were successfully defended, with defence cost of £15,322. The mean pay-out for confirmed negligence/liability was £90,056 (£1,500-£419,999, median £45,000) per case.

We believe this is the first study looking at complications following limb reconstruction from this perspective.

Analysis reveals a spectrum of claims for negligence. Perceived technical errors and poor outcome predominate. Whilst the limitations of the database preclude against identification of whether the procedures were carried out in specialist units, claims for technical errors are a cause for concern. These will be discussed in detail. Outcomes following limb reconstruction are difficult to quantify, and the settling of claims for a perceived poor outcome makes the case for pre-operative counselling and the need for robust outcome measures in our specialty.


P. Fenton A. Hughes D. Howard R. Atkins M. Jackson S. Mitchell J. Livingstone

Percutaneous grafting of non-union using bone marrow concentrates has shown promising results, we present our experience and outcomes following the use of microdrilling and marrowstim in long bone non-unions.

We retrospectively reviewed all patients undergoing a marrowstim procedure for non-union in 2011–12. Casenotes and radiographs were reviewed for all. Details of injury, previous surgery and non-union interventions together with additional procedures performed after marrowstim were recorded for all patients. The time to clinical and radiological union were noted.

We identified 32 patients, in sixteen the tibia was involved in 15 the femur and in one the humerus. Ten of the 32 had undergone intervention for non-union prior to marrowstim including 4 exchange nailings, 2 nail dynamisations, 3 caption graftings, 2 compression in circular frame and 1 revision of internal fixation. Three underwent adjunctive procedures at the time of marroswstim. In 18 further procedures were required following marrowstim. In 4 this involved frame adjustment, 5 underwent exchange nailing, 4 revision internal fixation, 2 additional marrowstim, 2 autologous bone grafting and 3 a course of exogen treatment.

In total 27 achieved radiological and clinical union at a mean of 9.6 months, of these ten achieved union without requiring additional intervention following marrowstim, at a mean of 5.4 months. There were no complications relating to marrowstim harvest or application.

Marrowstim appears to be a safe and relatively cheap addition to the armamentarium for treatment of non-union. However many patients require further procedures in addition to marrowstim to achieve union. Furthermore given the range of procedures this cohort of patients have undergone before and after marrowstim intervention it is difficult to draw conclusions regarding it efficacy.


I.S. Grewal A. Borbora N. Giotakis S. Nayagam S. Vinjamuri B. Narayan

The purpose of this study was to investigate the usefulness of PET-CT in the diagnosis and treatment of long bone infections following trauma.

All patients referred to the limb reconstruction service for management of non-unions were treated by the same protocol. PET-CT with FDG was performed in all patients to assess if the non-union site was infected and if so, the extent of the infection. Those requiring operative management were treated in a 2-stage manner. Initially with debridement based on PET-CT; sampling for microbiology and histology; and then Teicoplanin and Ciprofloxacin. If samples were positive then the patients were treated for a total of 6 weeks with antibiotics based on microbiology advice before undergoing definitive fixation. The sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV were then calculated for PET-CTs ability to predict presence of infection using extended cultures and histology as the gold standard.

38 consecutive patients underwent surgery, 24 male and 14 female. 24 were deemed infected on extended culture or histology. PET-CT was anecdotally found to be extremely useful at determining the extent of infection to plan debridement.

PPV 0.83

NPV 0.89

Sensitivity 0.96

Specificity 0.61

As well as providing unique ability to demarcate areas of bony infection in the presence of metalwork, the ability to detect or exclude infection was exceptional.

This is a test, however, which is operator dependent and requires a skilled Nuclear Radiology Consultant to accurately interpret images. In our relatively small pilot study the accuracy improved noticeably over one year.

PET-CT has potential to be a powerful tool in the diagnosis and treatment of long bone infection following trauma and certainly warrants further investigation.


B.J. O'Neill O.C. Breathnach D.P. Moore

The purpose of this study was to review the outcomes and complications of all circular external fixators (frames) used for the management of sterile and infected fracture non-unions in the lower limb in our institution over a twenty year period.

We retrospectively reviewed a prospectively compiled database of all frames applied in our institution and identified all frames which were applied for acute lower limb trauma. We identified 76 non-unions in 76 patients. There were 22 femoral non-unions and 54 tibial non-unions. Five femoral non-unions and 12 tibial non-unions were confirmed infected. The mean time in frame was 281 days for a sterile non-union and 457 days for an infected non-union. There was a union rate of 87% for sterile non-unions and 71% of infected non-unions at cessation of treatment. Factors associated with persistent non-union included cigarette smoking, soft tissue complications, and excessive pin-site toilet by the patient.

Lower-limb fracture non-unions can be extremely difficult to treat. The patients included in our study had previously undergone more traditional treatments in an attempt to establish union. The results presented demonstrate that circular frames are an excellent treatment modality in non-unions resistant to other forms of treatment. We would recommend this as a first line treatment for patients at higher risk of developing fracture non-union.


E.G Tierney C. M Curtin S.A. Cryan G.P. Duffy F.J. O'Brien

Gene-activated scaffolds have shown potential in localised gene delivery resulting in bone tissue regeneration. In this study, the ability of two gene delivery vectors, polyethyleneimine (PEI) and nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA), to act as carriers for the delivery of therapeutic genes when combined with our collagen-nHA (coll-nHA) scaffolds to produce gene-activated scaffolds [1, 2], was determined. In addition, coll-nHA-dual gene scaffolds containing both an angiogenic gene and an osteogenic gene were assessed for bone healing in an in vivo Wistar rat calvarial defect model. When cells were applied to the coll-nHA scaffolds under osteogenic conditions in vitro, the dual scaffolds exhibited significantly superior osteogenic potential when analysed using microCT, calcium quantification and histology compared to single-gene scaffolds and gene-free controls. When the dual scaffolds were assessed in vivo, the nHA dual scaffold outperformed all other groups as early as 4 weeks post-implantation as determined using X-ray, microCT, quantification of new bone volume, histology and vessel formation. This research has demonstrated the potential of using novel coll-nHA scaffolds for therapeutic gene therapy while also being capable of simultaneously delivering numerous genes. This study underlines the effect of specifically tailoring gene-activated scaffolds for bone regeneration applications.


L. Tang W. Harrison N. Holt B. Narayan S. Nayagam N. Giotakis

Calcium sulphate (CaSO4) is a recognised form of delivery of antibiotic for the treatment of bone infection. Complications inherent in the rapid reabsorption are well recognised (predominantly that of wound breakdown and leakage). There is little data on the frequency of these complications. The purpose of this study was to quantify the incidence of wound leakage from CaSO4 and the service impact in orthopaedic surgery.

Infective limb reconstruction cases managed with gentamicin impregnated CaSO4 between 2004–2012 were identified. Co-morbidities and factors influencing wound leakage were recorded. Medical and wound care notes were analysed. Episodes of delayed discharge and unscheduled clinic attendance due to wound leakage were recorded.

80 patients (18 female, 62 male), with a mean age of 45 years (18–80 years, median 46 years) underwent 84 procedures utilising CaSO4. 47 were in the tibia, 14 in the femur, 10 in the humerus. A mean of 36 mL (4–150 mL, median 22 ml, unknown in 18 cases) was used.

31 cases (37%) had post-operative wound leakage, the majority from the tibia(55%) and femur(25%). 21 cases (25%) leaked within the first week. Each 10 ml rise in CaSO4 volume lead to a 50% rise in leakage incidence. Leak duration ranged from 4 days–10 months. The majority leaked between 1–4 months before ceasing spontaneously and without specific treatment.

14 cases (17%) required a cumulative 32 unscheduled clinic appointments for leakage. Further surgery was required for infection in 7 cases (8.3%). Delayed discharge was not clearly attributable to CaSO4. The mode of skin closure and cultured organism did not affect leakage.

CaSO4 has unpredictable leakage, but is present in 1/3 of patients. Volume of CaSO4 impacts on leakage. Leakage usually self-resolves and does not clearly impact on final outcomes. The cost impact of ongoing wound care and additional clinic appointments may be substantial.


E.M. Thompson A. Matisko T.M. McFadden J.P. Gleeson G. Duffy D.J. Kelly F.J. O'Brien

Autogenous bone grafting limitations have motivated the development of Tissue-Engineered (TE) biomaterials that offer an alternative as bone void fillers. However, the lack of a blood supply within implanted constructs may result in avascular necrosis and construct failure1. The aim of this project was to investigate the potential of novel TE constructs to promote vascularisation and bone defect repair using two distinct approaches. In Study 1, we investigated the potential of a mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) and endothelial cell (EC) co-culture to stimulate pre-vascularisation of biomaterials prior to in vivo implantation2. In Study 2, we investigated the potential of TE hypertrophic cartilage to promote the release of angiogenic factors such as VEGF, vascular invasion and subsequent endochondral bone formation in an in vivo model.

Collagen-only (Coll), collagen-glycosaminoglycan (CG) and collagen-hydroxyapatite (CHA) scaffolds were fabricated by freeze-drying3, seeded with cells and implanted into critical-sized calvarial and femoral defects in immunocompetent rats. In Study 1, Coll and CG scaffolds were initially seeded with ECs, allowed to form capillary-like networks before the delayed addition of MSCs and continued culture prior to calvarial implantation. In Study 2, CG and CHA scaffolds were seeded with MSCs and cultured under chondrogenic and subsequent hypertrophic conditions to form a cartilage pre-cursor prior to calvarial and femoral implantation in vivo.

MicroCT and histomorphometry quantification demonstrated the ability of both systems to support increased bone formation compared to controls. Moreover, the greatest levels of bone formation were observed in the CG groups, notably in those containing cartilage tissue (Study 2). Assessment of the immune response suggests the addition of MSCs promotes the polarisation of macrophages away from inflammation (M1) towards a pro-remodelling phenotype (M2).

We have developed distinct collagen-based systems that promote vascularisation and ultimately enhance bone formation, confirming their potential as advanced strategies for bone repair applications.


A. Sinha D. Selvan A. Sinha L.A. James

We present our experience of using tension band plates to achieve guided growth in children for correction of calcaneus deformity of the ankle.

11 consecutive patients (13 ankles) fulfilled the inclusion criteria over a 4-year period. All underwent surgical treatment using a flexible two hole plate and screws on the posterior aspect of distal tibial physis. Measurements were done on preoperative, intraoperative screening and 1-year post operative plain AP and lateral ankle radiographs. The anterior distal tibia angle (ADTA), lateral distal tibial angle (LDTA) and screw divergence angle (angle subtended by lines passing through the long axis of the screws) were used to assess the deformity correction. A 2 tailed student t-test was carried out on the initial and 1-year post-op measurements to determine statistical significance with a p value <0.05 considered as significant

There were 10 residual clubfoot deformities, 2 post-traumatic deformities and 1 spinal tumor causing deformity. The average age of the patients was 10 years 5 months (range 4 to 13 years). There were 9 males and 2 females. The ADTA showed a statistically significant change with a p value of 0.0008 with a mean correction of 8.6 degrees (range of 2.3 to 15.6 degrees). The SDA demonstrated a mean correction of 15.4 degrees (range 0.3 to 41.8 degrees), p=0.002. The LDTA did not change significantly (p= 0.08), thus confirming no coincidental coronal plane deformity had occurred. 5 ankles required revision of fixation due to metalwork reaching its maximum limit of divergence at an average of 1 year. 2 ankles had screw pulled out due to osteolysis around the screw. There were no cases of infection.

We report satisfactory short-term results of correction of calcaneus deformity using a flexible tension band plate and screws system.


F. Matcham L. Rayner S. Shetty M. Bansal D. Bond S. Phillips A. Simpson M. Hotopf A.F.G. Groom

The purpose of this study was to identify the prevalence of common mental disorders in patients undergoing complex limb reconstruction.

Patients undergoing limb reconstruction are vulnerable to mental health problem as they must adapt to significant and prolonged physical disability. Treatment emphasis has been on restoration and rehabilitation of physical health with little or no attention given to spectrum of psychological consequences. IMPARTS (Integrating Mental and Physical healthcare: Research, Training and Services) is a King's Health Partners initiative aiming to develop informatics to improve detection and management of common mental disorders in medical settings. IMPARTS screening in the King's College Hospital limb reconstruction clinic commenced in April 2012.

Outpatients attending between April 2012 and November 2013 were screened prior to their appointment. Patients were screened for symptoms of depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), alcohol dependence and drug use.

In total, 298 individual patients were screened. The prevalence of depression was found to be 21.8%, with 6.4% experiencing suicidal thoughts. Probable anxiety disorder was identified in 20.7% of patients. Symptoms of PTSD were reported by 29.2%, with 9.0% reporting severe symptoms. Probable alcohol dependence was identified in 2.7% of patients, and 3.0% screened positive for drug misuse.

The consequences of undergoing limb reconstruction stretch beyond the physical problem to mental well-being, rendering patients vulnerable to mental health problems and substance misuse. Early detection and management of such problems may have a significant effect on physical treatment outcome and rehabilitation to productive social life. There is urgent need to integrate mental health care as part of early management of severely injured patients.


T. Jennison M. McNally R. Giordmaina

The aim of this study was to assess the incidence of fibula non-union in patients undergoing distraction osteogenesis, and the incidence of symptoms following this.

A consecutive series of 58 patients undergoing distraction osteogenesis at a tertiary centre under a single surgeon were included. Data was collected prospectively. Plain radiographs were reviewed retrospectively by a blinded reviewer. Union was defined as the presence of bridging callous on two views.

There were 58 distraction procedures performed. The mean age was 37.2 years (range 16.0 to 80.6). There were 36 males and 22 females. The mean follow-up was 23.4 months (4–70 months)

9 (15.5%) went onto non-union at frame removal. 3 (33.3%) of the 9 fibulas that did not unite developed symptoms. 2 (66.7%) of these required surgery in the form of fibula plating. Both of these patient's symptoms resolved following surgery. 3 (33.3%) of the 9 non-united fibulas also had tibial non-union compared to 1 of the 49 where the fibula united.

There was no association between location of fibula osteotomy and development of non-union. 35 fibula osteotomies were performed in the third quarter.

Of the fibulas that united, the mean fibula lengthening was 9.25 mm (range 1.2–27.8 mm). In the fibulas that went onto non-union the mean lengthening was 23.66 mm (range 5.1–51.5 mm) (P = 0.004).

54 (93.1%) of the tibias united following osteotomy and distraction, whilst 4 (6.9%) went onto non-union requiring operative treatment. Of the 4 tibias that did not unite, 3 (75%) also had fibula non-union (P = 0.01).

Fibula non-union is a relatively common complication following osteotomy in distraction osteogenesis. The length of fibula distraction and tibia non-union are significant risk factors for the development of a fibula non-union. We recommend surgical intervention for those patients who have symptomatic fibula non-unions.


S.J. Robinson A.J. Highcock G. Cleary L.A. James

The purpose of this study is to assess the improvement in pain and function of the ankle when arthrodiastasis is used for end stage juvenile idiopathic arthritis [JIA] in the paediatric population.

All patients treated with ankle arthrodiastasis, 2009–2013 were studied. Clinical, radiological and survivorship data were examined. The Oxford Ankle Foot Questionnaire for Children (OxAFQ-C) and Parents (OxAFQ-P), along with the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) Clinical rating system for Ankle-Hindfoot were recorded pre-operatively and at 6 months.

Eight patients (9 ankles) with severe tibiotalar JIA, refractory to medical management were treated. Average age at surgery was 14.5 years (range 8–19). Average length of arthrodiastasis was 3.5 months. Length of follow-up averaged 13 months (range 5–28 months).

All scores showed an improvement at 6 months. OxAFQ-C scores (out of 60) improved on average from 23 to 43. OxAFQ-P scores also improved from19 to 39. The largest improvement was found for the physical subsection. AOFAS Ankle-Hindfoot score (out of 100) averaged 34 pre-op and 74 at 6 months. Pain scored out of 10 decreased from an average of 7.4 to 4.3 at 6 months. All patients and parents were satisfied with the surgery and would have the procedure performed again.

Radiological studies demonstrated cartilage regeneration, joint restoration and deformity correction with arthrodiastasis. Survivorship was good (75%) at 36 months, but 2 patients (3 ankles) had subsequent surgery in the adult sector for progression of disease despite initial improvement following arthrodiastasis.

This case series demonstrates the efficacy of ankle arthrodiastasis as a surgical option in severe end-stage ankle inflammatory arthritis in paediatric patients in the short to midterm. It improved functional scores and pain scores which should delay the need for more radical joint fusion or replacement procedures in this challenging surgical condition.


I. Ibrahim A. Timms M. Chasseaud D. Goodier P. Calder

Pin site care in external fixation remains a major challenge. The ideal dressing regime still remains controversial as does the type of dressing. We present an audit following the use of a sponge compression dressing in comparison to previously used sterile gauze.

All pins and wires were inserted using a standardised technique. Dressings were applied during surgery to prevent haematoma formation.

The new sponge dressing was applied to the wire or half-pin sites and compressed to the skin by either pierced tubing over the wire or clips at the end of the procedure. Dressings were changed weekly unless the pin sites were discharging serous fluid or frankly infected, when they were changed as required.

The pin sites were evaluated for evidence of infection or irritation using the good, bad or ugly grading system. Each evaluation was performed by two of the authors on two separate occasions to assess the inter- and intra-observer error. The results were compared to those previously reported using sterile gauze as the pin site dressing.

1035 pin sites were assessed. 985 pin sites were graded as “good” (95.2%), 49 “bad” (4.7%) and 1 “ugly”. The kappa values demonstrated excellent inter- and intra-observer correlation, 0.892 and 0.905 respectively.

The previous study using gauze reported 600 pin sites with 514 graded “good” (85.7%), 80 “bad” (13.3%) and 6 “ugly” (1%).

The use of compression sponge dressing appears to reduce the rate of pin site irritation and infection. Further anecdotal evidence by patients who have undergone surgical treatment using both techniques demonstrated a preference for the sponge dressings due to ease of dressing change and general comfort once applied. We therefore would recommend this type of dressing in the use of external fixation.


N. P. McGoldrick K. Olajide J. Noel P. Kiely D. Moore P. Kelly

Our aim was to use CT Scanogram to evaluate fibular growth, and thus calculate normal growth velocity, which may aid in determining the timing of epiphysiodesis.

Current understanding of normal lower limb growth and growth prediction originates in the work of Anderson et al published in the 1960s. There now exist several clinical and mathematical methods to aid in the treatment of leg length discrepancy, including the timing of epiphysiodesis. Early research in this area provided limited information on the growth of the fibula. It is now well recognized that abnormal growth of paired long bones may evolve into deformity of clinical significance. Existing work examining fibular growth used plain film radiography only. Computed Tomography (CT) scanogram is now the preferred method for evaluating leg length discrepancy in the paediatric population. We calculated fibular growth for 28 children (n = 28, 16 girls and 12 boys) presenting with leg length discrepancy to our unit. Mean age at presentation was 111.1 months (range 33 – 155 months). For inclusion, each child had to have at least five CT scanograms performed, at six monthly intervals. Fibular length was calculated digitally as the distance from the proximal edge of the proximal epiphysis to the most distal edge of the distal epiphysis. For calculation purposes, mean fibular length was determined from two measurements taken of the fibula. A graph for annual fibular growth was plotted and fibular growth velocity calculated.

CT Scanogram may be used to calculate normal fibular growth in children presenting with leg length discrepancy.


S Shetty M Bansal WDI Groom RK Varma AFG Groom

The purpose of this study is to describe the use of intramedullary distraction coupled with an additional osteotomy to achieve union with simultaneous deformity correction and lengthening in femoral non-union.

Femoral non-union is a difficult problem often associated with shortening, angulation, and mal-rotation. We report the use of an intramedullary distraction device, with additional osteotomy, to achieve union, restore femoral length and alignment. Simple distraction in femoral non-union is often ineffective, possibly because the non-union site is relatively avascular. Osteotomy is known to increase blood flow and, with lengthening, promote union through distraction histiogenesis.

7 patients with posttraumatic diaphyseal femoral non-union with shortening were studied. Pre-operative planning included long leg standing views, with CT to measure mal-rotation. 6 patients were treated with the Intramedullary Skeletal Kinetic Distractor (ISKD) with an osteotomy distant from non-union site within the parameters required for the device. One patient underwent distraction without osteotomy. Patients were followed to union. Complications and adjuvant interventions were recorded.

All 7 patients with femoral non-union treated with ISKD were included and followed up. Patients treated with osteotomy united at average of 9 months with satisfactory deformity correction and lengthening. However patient who underwent pure distraction failed to unite. Complications included failure to lengthen, requiring manipulation, and delayed consolidation of regenerate requiring bone graft. The procedure was well tolerated

The initial results of the management of femoral non-union with deformity by intramedullary distraction coupled with osteotomy are encouraging. Complications were minor and readily manageable. We believe there is an important role for this method in the management of femoral non-unions associated with deformity and length discrepancy.


S. Dorman R. Maheshwari H. George R. Davies L. James

We report our early experience with distracting external fixation used to offload the hip after avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head secondary to severe slipped upper femoral epiphysis (SUFE).

A case series of five patients treated in a tertiary centre is reported. Electronic case records and radiographs were reviewed. Data recorded included demographics, initial presentation, timing of head collapse, timing and duration of distraction and outcome including referral to adult arthoplasty services.

Mean age at presentation was 12 years (range 12–15). 4 were females. Initial treatment in 4 cases was a delayed cuneiform osteotomy and pinning, one patient underwent serendipitous reduction and percutaneous pinning. Mean duration to initial surgery was 10 days (range 5–16). All patients had femoral head collapse at a mean of 148 days from time of presentation. 2 patients required backing out of screws due to intra-articular protrusion. All patients underwent distraction at a mean 193 days from presentation. Average distraction achieved was 10 mm and duration of application was 125 days (range 91–139)

All patients experienced improvement or resolution of pain but persistence of poor function, characterised by fixed adduction and limb length discrepancy. 3 patients were referred to adult arthroplasty services.

This may be an effective treatment option for pain associated with AVN post SUFE. However, in our experience normal anatomy and function of the hip is not restored if performed after collapse of the femoral head. Consideration should be given to application of the distractor either at the time of initial fixation or prior to femoral head collapse. Authors believe that timing of the application of the distractor is critical for a successful outcome and recommend a prospective study with large numbers.


B.J. O'Neill N.G. Burke D.P. Moore P.M. Kelly

The purpose of this study was to review the outcomes of four children with genu valgum secondary to Hurler Syndrome treated with circular external fixators (frames) for angular correction.

We retrospectively reviewed the medical and radiographic records of four children with Hurler Syndrome and genu valgum treated with frames. Three children had simultaneous bilateral tibial corrections. The fourth child had unilateral femoral correction. The mean age of the children was 14 years at application of frame. Mean duration of frame was 113 days for the tibial frames, and the femoral frame remained in-situ for 150 days. Correction was assessed clinically, and radiologically with x-rays and CT scannograms, with excellent results in all four cases. The complexities of each individual case necessitated specific and individualised treatment for each child. Complications included further deformities arising in treated and un-treated long-bones both during and after application of frame.

Prior to the introduction of bone marrow transplantation, the average life expectancy of children with Hurler Syndrome was seven years. With bone marrow transplantation, affected children are now living much longer, and many develop characteristic long bone deformities in their lower limbs. These deformities are progressive and can be multifocal and polyostotic. Managament can be extremely challenging, and prior reports of management with hemiepiphysiodesis with staples and 8-plates have been mixed. We believe that this is the first series of circular frame lower limb reconstruction in children with Hurler Syndrome. The flexibility and adaptability of frames confers a unique advantage in the management of these complex deformities.


A.K. Unnithan Y. Jabbar A. Khaleel

Shear plane non unions: biomechanical study and clinical application using an all wire Illizarov frame.

60 degree osteotomy of plastic tibiae were stabilised using four different Ilizarov frame configurations.

Models were loaded and shear displacement measured at the fracture site. The optimum frame design was identified and used in clinical practice.

The transfracture locked olive wire frame model offered the least displacement in the experimental model This frame model was used in two patients with shear plane non unions and both healed satisfactorily Both displacements had previously failed to unite with standard frame constructs.

Transfracture locked olive wire frame design is useful in the treatment of tibial non unions with shear plane.


N. Jacobs M. Sutherland D.A. Stubbs M.A. McNally

The purpose of this study is to provide a systematic review of the literature and assess outcome of our experience of Ilizarov Bone Transport in reconstruction for primary malignant tumours of bone (PMTB).

A systematic review of the literature for reported cases of primary reconstruction of PMTB using distraction osteogenesis was performed. All cases of distraction osteogenesis for primary reconstruction of PMTB in our institution were reviewed. Outcome was determined from retrospective review of case notes and radiology. Patients were contacted to define final status.

There are few cases of primary reconstruction of PMTB using Ilizarov method in the literature. Most reports relate to benign tumours or reconstruction of secondary deformities or non-union after tumour resection. At our institution we have treated 7 patients with bone defects resulting from excision of a PMTB. Mean age was 42.1 years (23–48). Tumours occurred in the tibia in 4 cases and the femur in 3 cases. Histologic diagnosis was chondrosarcoma in 3, malignant fibrous histiocytoma in 2, adamantinoma in 1 and malignant intraosseous nerve sheath tumour in 1.

All patients were assessed through the hospital sarcoma board and shown to have isolated bone lesions without metastases. Mean bone defect after resection was 13.1 cm (10–17). Mean frame time was 13.6 months (5–23). Mean follow-up was 46 months (15–137). Complications included pin infection, docking site non-union, premature fusion of corticotomy, soft tissue infection and minor varus deformity. There was one local recurrence of tumour at five months after resection, resulting in a through hip disarticulation. The other cases remain tumour-free with united, well-aligned bones and acceptable long-term function.

PMTB is rare and poses a major reconstructive dilemma. Distraction osteogenesis provides an effective method of biologic reconstruction in selected cases, and good outcomes can be achieved.


R.S. Pinto W. Harrison S. Huson K. Graham S. Nayagam

The purpose of this study is to report a unique overgrowth syndrome and discuss the insights into the complex orthopaedic management.

Written consent to report this case was granted. The patient's condition, wrongly diagnosed as Proteus syndrome, is characterised by a genetic mutation in PIK3CA, a critical regulator of cell growth. This lead to unregulated cellular division of fibroblasts isolated to the lower limbs. The legs weighed 117 kg, with a circumference of >110 cm. In addition to lower limb overgrowth, numerous musculoskeletal and organ pathologies have been encountered since birth requiring treatment from a wide variety of healthcare specialists and basic scientists. At 32 years, the patient developed septicaemia secondary to an infected foot ulcer. Amputation had been discussed in the elective setting, however the presence of sepsis expedited surgery. The above knee amputation took 9 hours and four assistants including a plastic surgeon. A difficult dissection revealed a deep subcutaneous fatty layer that integrated with deep muscle, massive hypertrophy of cutaneous nerves and the sciatic nerve and ossification within the distal quarter of the quadriceps muscles requiring osteotomy. The lower limb osteology was grossly aberrant. The size of the amputated limb did not permit use of a tourniquet and cell salvage reintroduced 10.5 litres of blood with a further 6 units of red cells intra-operatively. The leg stump successfully took to a split-skin graft. A unique phenomenon was witnessed post-operatively whereby the stump continued to grow due to upregulation of fibroblasts secondary to trauma. Targeted genetic therapies have been successfully developed to suppress this stump growth.

This unique and unclassified overgrowth syndrome was caused by a mutation in the PIK3CA gene. Orthopaedic management of the oversized limb was complex requiring multiple surgeons and prolonged general anesthetic. A multi-disciplinary approach to this condition is required for optimizing outcomes in these patients.


N.P. McGoldrick J.S. Butler S. Sheehan S. Dudeney G.C. O'Toole

The purpose of this study is to present a series of soft tissue sarcomas requiring complex vascular reconstructions, and to describe their management and outcomes.

Soft tissue sarcomas are rare mesodermal malignancies accounting for approximately 1% of all cancers diagnosed annually. Sarcomas involving the pelvis and extremities are of particular interest to the orthopaedic surgeon. Tumours that encase and invade large calibre vascular structures present a major surgical challenge in terms of safety of excision with acceptability of surgical margins. Technical advances in the fields of both orthopaedic and vascular surgery have resulted in a trend towards limb salvage with vascular reconstruction in preference to amputation. Limb-salvage surgery is now feasible due to the variety of reconstructive options available to the surgeon. Nevertheless, surgery with concomitant vascular reconstruction is associated with higher rates of complications including infection and amputation. We present a case series of soft tissue sarcomas with vascular compromise, requiring resection and vascular reconstruction. We treated four patients (n = 4, three females, and one male) with soft tissue masses, which were found to involve local vascular structures. Histology revealed leiomyosarcoma (n = 2) and alveolar soft part sarcomas (n = 2). Both synthetic graft and autogenous graft (long saphenous vein) techniques were utilised. Arterial reconstruction was undertaken in all cases. Venous reconstruction was performed in one case. One patient required graft thrombectomy at one month post-operatively for thrombosis.

We present a series of complex tumour cases with concomitant vascular reconstructions drawn from our institution's experience as a national tertiary referral sarcoma service.