header advert
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 95-B, Issue SUPP_12 March 2013 British Orthopaedic Trainees Association (BOTA)

A.D. Leeper P.T. Brandon A.V.M Morgan S. Cutts A.M.M. Cohen

Fascia iliaca compartment block (FIB), performed in the Emergency Department (A&E) in patients presenting with femoral neck fracture, has gained increasing recognition as an adjunctive analgesic. The purpose of this study was to investigate whether FIB significantly reduced the requirement for systemic opiates in the pre-operative setting. Analgesia requirements for all patients admitted with fractured neck of femur to one unit over a four month period were gathered prospectively. 33% patients had received FIB at diagnosis in ED, dependant on the expertise of the attending physician. Morphine requirements on arrival on the ward between groups were analysed. Over a four month period 144 patients were admitted with fractured neck of femur. Over this time period, introduction of an informal educational programme in A&E increased the incidence of FIB provision at diagnosis and reduced the average amount of morphine administered. Administration of FIB reduced the average morphine requirement in A&E by 56%, when compared with those who received systemic analgesia alone (CI 0.4–3.5, p=0.014). No adverse effects were reported with FIB. Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block is a safe and effective method of providing analgesia to patients with fractured neck of femur and reduces morphine requirement.


A. Hexter A. Panagiotidou J. Singh J. Skinner A. Hart

The articulating surface replacement (ASR) XL stemmed total hip replacement and ASR resurfacing hip systems were recalled by DePuy due to a high prevalence of early failure. The ASR XL has a greater failure rate than the ASR resurfacing, which has been increasingly attributed to wear and corrosion at the taper interface between the female taper surface of the femoral head and the male taper (trunnion) of the femoral stem. The aim of this study was to quantify the prevalence and severity of taper corrosion in retrieved ASR XL hip components.

A peer-reviewed subjective corrosion scoring system was used to quantify corrosion in a consecutive series of the 50 ASR XL hip components (head components – n=44; femoral stems – n=6) at our retrieval centre. Bearing surface wear (femoral head and acetabular cup combined) was quantified and a value of <5 microns was defined as low-wearing. Subsequent profilometry analysis was undertaken in the low-wearing hips to quantify material loss from the taper interface.

90% of components showed evidence of corrosion, with at least moderate corrosion observed in 58%. There were 17 low-wearing hips which had a median material loss from the taper interface of 3.51mm3 (range: 0.612–9.443). The median linear depth of material loss was 33μm (range: 8.5–78.0). No relationship was observed between taper corrosion and serum cobalt (r=0.204, p=0.2712) or chromium (r=0.146, p=0.432) metal ions.

Wear and material loss from metal-on-metal (MoM) hips is associated with pseudotumour formation and adverse soft-tissue reactions. We have shown that taper corrosion is extremely common in failed ASR XL hips and that wear occurs in the same degree of magnitude as at the bearing surface also occurs at the taper interface. Therefore our findings support the emerging concept of ‘taper failure’, whereby the taper is the predominate reason for failure of MoM hips. Future work must determine the relative contributions of the bearing surface and the taper interface to serum cobalt and chromium metal ion levels.


A. Hexter A. Panagiotidou J. Singh J. Skinner A. Hart

Corrosion at the taper interface between the femoral head and the femoral stem is well described in metal-on-polyethylene (MoP) hips but previously was undetermined in large diameter head metal-on-metal (LHMoM) hips. The high failure rate of the articulating surface replacement (ASR) XL hip system has been partly attributed to susceptibility to corrosive damage at the taper interface. It was not known if other hip manufacturers are liable to taper corrosion. Therefore the aim of this study was to quantify the prevalence and severity of taper corrosion in LHMoM hips and compare corrosion across five different current generation manufacturers.

Taper corrosion was analysed in a consecutive series of the five most common hip types at our retrieval centre: ASR XL, DePuy (n=49); Birmingham hip resurfacing, Smith & Nephew (n=33), Durom, Zimmer (n=31), M2a Magnum, Biomet (n=14) and Cormet, Stryker (n=10). A four-scale peer-reviewed qualitative corrosion scoring system was used to quantify corrosion (none, mild, moderate and severe).

Evidence of corrosion was observed in 86% of components, with at least moderate corrosion observed in 61%. No difference in corrosion was observed between the ASR XL and the other manufacturers (p=0.202). There was still no difference seen when all manufacturers were compared individually (p=0.363). A positive correlation was observed between corrosion and femoral head diameter (r=0.224, p=0.021). However no relationship was observed with implantation time (r=0.163, p=0.118).

Our study indicates that taper corrosion is common in LHMoM hips and affects all hip types equally. The clinical significance of this finding is that all hip types will be susceptible to the complications of corrosion, such as third body wear and osteolysis. Furthermore recent reports indicate that corrosive debris released from the taper interface may play a role in the formation of pseudotumours and adverse soft-tissue reactions. We found that larger femoral head sizes showed greater corrosion, which suggests that high torque increases fretting corrosion of the taper interface. Future work must determine the optimum femoral head size and investigate the chemical composition of the corrosive debris.


A. Hexter A. Panagiotidou J. Singh J. Skinner A. Hart

In metal-on-metal (MoM) total hip arthroplasty, the taper interface is where the femoral head (female taper surface) attaches to the trunnion (male taper) of the femoral stem. Corrosion is well reported in metal-on-polyethylene hips but little is known about taper corrosion in MoM devices. The aim of this study was to quantify corrosion in modern-generation stemmed MoM hip systems and gain insight into the nature of the underlying corrosive attack.

Taper corrosion was quantified in 161 failed MoM components (head components n=128; femoral stem n=33) from nine hip types with the use of a qualitative subjective scoring system. An unanticipated finding on preliminary inspection of the hips was a region on the female taper surface that contained ridges that directly corresponded with the ridged microthread on the trunnion. The ridges were not present on unimplanted (control) female taper surfaces and therefore a novel four-scale subjective scoring system was devised to quantify the prevalence and severity of this ‘imprinting’ phenomenon.

Evidence of corrosion was observed in 81% (131/161) of components, with at least moderate corrosion observed in 58% (94/161). Corrosion was greater on the female taper surface than on the male taper (p=0.034) and the two scores were associated (r=0.784, p=0.001). Imprinting affected all manufacturers and was observed in 64% (82/128) of head components. The corrosion and imprinting scores were strongly correlated (r=0.694, p=0.001). Corrosion was largely confined to the area of the female taper interface where imprinting had occurred i.e. the region that had been in contact with the trunnion microthread. Scanning electron microscopy showed evidence of fretting corrosion and substantial mechanical wear within the ridged region on the female taper surface.

Our study indicates that MoM hips are susceptible to taper corrosion. We believe it occurs by a process of “mechanically-assisted crevice corrosion,” involving the following sequence of events: joint fluid enters the taper junction as a result of pumping of fluid along the machined microthread of the trunnion. This results in galvanic corrosion of the anodic surface (the cobalt-chromium femoral head or taper sleeve). The pattern of corrosion of the head taper is determined by the surface profile of the screw thread of the trunnion, thus leaving an imprinted appearance. Historically the ridged microthread was introduced to trunnions to minimise the risk of burst fracture of ceramic heads. However this study indicates that the ridges are detrimental in MoM hips by causing extensive mechanical wear. Thus the possibility that cobalt-chrome and ceramic femoral head components require different trunnion designs needs urgent investigation.


R. Gogna D. Armstrong M. Espag

Distal radius fractures are very common and they often require surgical intervention to prevent long-term complications. We noticed that several patients were being managed non-operatively for prolonged periods of time, when ultimately surgical fixation was inevitable. Delayed fixation of these injuries results in prolonged immobilisation, repeat fracture clinic attendances, callous formation, poor soft tissues, stiffness and union. Our aim was to analyse the time to fixation of distal radius fractures at our hospital using a standard volar locking plate. Between December 2010 and September 2011, our study population included all patients who underwent surgical fixation for a distal radius fracture at Royal Derby Hospital. All fractures were fixed using a volar locking plate. Data collected included date of injury, fracture clinic attendances, date listed for surgery and date of surgery. There were 100 patients who underwent surgical fixation, with a mean age of 63.6 years (17 to 91). The mean date from injury to fixation was 7.7 days (range 0 to 23). 82% of fractures were operated on within 14 days, and 98% were fixed within 21 days. We accept that our study does have some limitations; this includes patients who are unwilling to accept surgery at their initial consultation. Distal radius fractures have a strong tendency to revert back to their original configuration; hence we suggest that a decision to operate should ideally be made at the one-week fracture clinic appointment. This avoids the difficulties and complications associated with delayed surgical intervention. Stability, displacement, reduction and patient factors should all be taken into account.


R.J. Mills A.J.M.D. Andrade

In January 2012, the Department of Health reportedly claimed that data demonstrated ‘half of knee surgery does not substantially change the outcome for patients: their mobility is not improved that much, nor their pain’. Furthermore, in recent years knee replacement surgery has been described as a procedure of limited clinical value (PLCV) by commissioning bodies nationwide. This study aimed to establish whether patients in Reading were satisfied with their surgery at five years and whether there was an objective improvement in their pain and function following surgery.

Five-year data was retrospectively reviewed from 130 knee replacements performed between January 2004 and July 2005. Patient details, intra-operative data and patient reported outcome measures (PROMs) were downloaded from our OrthoWave database. The Oxford Knee Score was completed pre-operatively, at six months and then yearly to five years, measuring pain and function specific to the knee operated on. In addition, patients were asked directly whether they felt satisfied with their joint replacement surgery.

The sample population consisted of 52 males and 78 females, with a mean age of 70 and mean body mass index of 30.2. Twenty-three of the patients had undergone uni-compartmental surgery (either Oxford or St George), with the remainder having either PFC or Scorpio total knee replacements. The mean pre-operative Oxford Knee Score was 20.4. The mean improvement in scores at six months was 14.77 (95% confidence interval 13.25–16.28, p<0.0001) and 17.23 at five years (95% confidence interval 15.66–18.79, p<0.0001). On direct questioning, 85.6% of patients were satisfied with their knee replacement, 3.4% were dissatisfied and 10.9% remained unsure. Reasons identified for dissatisfaction included chronic pain syndromes and the need for early revision surgery.

Patient reported outcome measures are increasingly being used to justify outcomes of surgery and the Oxford Knee Score is particularly helpful as it relates function and pain to the knee operated on, whilst attempting to minimise the effect of confounding co-pathology. This five-year data suggests that the majority of patients are satisfied with their knee surgery. A significant improvement in pain and function is evident at six months post-operatively and continues to be demonstrable at five years, supporting the British Orthopaedic Association's strong rebuttal of the recent negative press regarding knee surgery.


H.K. Ribee J. Kozdryk S. Quraishi M. Waites

Depression and anxiety are widely prevalent amongst patients suffering from chronic diseases including osteoarthritis. National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines recommend vigilance and routine screening in such chronic disease patients, and a recent King's Fund report found depression causes considerable expense to the NHS, with £1 for every £8 spent on chronic disease spent on patients mental health, costing between £8-13 billion annually. Depression increases length of hospital stay, and poorer clinical outcomes: depressed patients are 3.5 x as likely to die after suffering from myocardial infarction. Despite this, depression screening is not performed widely pre operatively. To see if there is a basis to recommend routine pre operative depression screening in hip and knee arthroplasty patients, we asked all patients attending Joint School to complete a Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). This is a well-validated tool for assessing the presence and degree (either mild, moderate or severe if present) of anxiety and depression, using fourteen questions, and providing a score out of 21 for each. We then correlated these results to pre operative Oxford Knee and Oxford Hip Scores to see if there was any relationship between the extent of impact of disease and any mood disorder present. 190 patients completed the questionnaire pre operatively. Of those, 82 (43%) scored as anxious. 73 (38%) scored as depressed. 47 (25%) scored as both. Overall 107 (56%) were either anxious, depressed or both. The median anxiety score was 7, with 44 (54%) scoring 8–10 (mild), 35 (43%) 11–15 (moderate) and 3 (4%) 16+ (severe). The median depression score was 6, with 53 (73%) scoring 8–10 (mild), 19 (26%) 11–15 (moderate) and 1 (1%) 16+ (severe). In order to look for an association between the severity of depression or anxiety and Oxford Scores, we grouped the Oxford Scores according to the patient's score on the HADS, and performed analysis of variance (ANOVA) to look for a significant difference between the Oxford Scores in the groups. There was no significant link between increase in Oxford Score and anxiety score (p=0.173314) but there was between Oxford Score and depression score (p=0.001377). There was equally no correlation between scores in patients classified simply as anxious or not anxious (p=0.14918) but a significant difference in Oxford Score was present between patients designated as depressed or not depressed (p=0.000297). We thus conclude depression and anxiety are very common amongst pre operative arthroplasty patients and thus assessment for this should be considered routinely preoperatively. In addition, there is a link between severity of osteoarthritis and severity of depression with increasing depression score associated with increasing Oxford Score. This makes further work to assess the reasons for this link imperative: does increasing severity of osteoarthritis result in increasing severity of depression, or does depression cause patients to feel the effects of their disease more keenly, and thus score higher on Oxford Scores? If this is the case, would patients treated for depression find the effect of their joint problems severe enough to warrant undertaking arthroplasty surgery?


J. Velpula P. Gajula M. Thibbaiah R. Ferandez A. Anand A. Pimpalnerkar

Treatments of Chronic Acromioclavicular joint dislocation are controversial. Many procedures have been described in the past for the management of them. Treatment modalities have changed with increasing understanding of the nature of the problem, patient expectations and the biomechanics of the joint

To assess the functional outcome of the chronic AC joint dislocations treated by modified Weaver-Dunn procedure combined with Acromioclavicular joint augmentation.

We treated 54 patients with chronic AC joint dislocation by modified Weaver-Dunn procedure with additional AC joint augmentation. We used tight rope system in 20 patients, Mersilene tape in 22 patients and no 5 Ethibond in 12 patients.

This Study was done between Jan 2003 to Jan2012. Mean follow up was 20 months, mean age of the patients was 35, and male to female distribution was 48:6. We assessed them clinically and radio logically during their follow up. All patients were back to their occupation. 80% are back to their pre injury sporting activity level. The mean Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score was 10.2 points. One patient had a failure of augmentation device.

Our study shows that chronic symptomatic AC joint dislocations, (Rockwood types III to V,) Managed with modified modified Weaver-Dunn procedure with augmentation are showing good short term results. Significant improvement in the patient satisfaction, early return to work and radiological appearance


R. Gogna

Intra-operative fluoroscopic screening is common practice in trauma surgery, as an operative guide and to assess the final fixation. However, often patients return to the ward and are sent for a further ‘check x-ray’ in the subsequent post-operative period.

Our aims were to evaluate the use of post-op ‘check x-rays’ in our hospital, and determine whether they had any influence on the management or outcomes for our trauma patients. Between December 2010 and June 2011, our study population included all patients who had intra-operative fluoroscopic images for trauma fixation surgery at Grantham and District Hospital. We then reviewed whether they had an additional x-ray taken in the post-operative period. Finally we assessed their subsequent fracture clinic follow-up images to determine whether there were any complications that had arisen. There were 108 patients who had intra-operative films, with a mean age of 59.7 years (17 to 98). Of these, 44% of patients had an additional x-ray in the post-operative period. There was a wide variability in practice between the various types of fixations (e.g. Hip, Humerus, Ankle, etc). At follow-up, all x-rays were satisfactory and there were no complications. The post-operative x-ray did not alter the management or outcome for any of our patients. There is no need for a ‘routine post-op check x-ray’ for patients who have had an adequate intra-operative film. Subjecting patients to additional x-rays causes them discomfort, delayed discharged, increased radiation exposure and has significant financial implications. Other similar studies support our results, and a post-operative film should only be requested if clinically indicated or in exceptional circumstances.


S.H. Vun S.A. Aitken M.M. McQueen C.M. Court-Brown

There are limited recent epidemiological data pertaining to the patterns of skeletal injury around the knee joint in adult patients. Data on fractures of the distal femur, proximal tibia and patella have been individually reported. We aimed to describe the collective epidemiological characteristics of all fractures around the knee.

We conducted a retrospective analysis of a prospectively collected fracture database from an institution serving 545,000 adults. The demographic and injury details for all patients suffering fractures of the distal femur, proximal tibia and patella were analysed. Fractures were classified according to the AO (distal femur, patella) and Schatzker (proximal tibia) systems.

A total of 173 fractures occurred in 170 patients (60% women), representing 6.7% of all lower limb fractures. There were 36 distal femoral fractures, 82 proximal tibial fractures (metaphyseal, plateau or bony avulsions) and 55 patella fractures.

Each fracture type displayed distinct epidemiological characteristics. Injuries of the distal femur occurred in older women. A proportion of tibial plateau fractures occurred in young men following high-energy trauma, but a greater number were encountered by older men and women following low-energy injury. The majority of fractures around the knee were caused by a simple fall from standing, followed by road traffic accidents, and falls from height.

When compared with historical data from our unit, the incidence of fractures around the knee has increased. The median age of affected patients has also risen, and this is particularly true for fractures of the distal femur and tibial plateau.

The epidemiological characteristics of fractures around the knee joint in our adult population are presented. Low-energy trauma in the elderly is likely to constitute an increasing proportion of knee injuries in the future, and this has implications for the provision of trauma services in our region.


S.H. Vun S.A. Aitken M.M. McQueen C.M. Court-Brown

A number of studies have described the epidemiological characteristics of clavicle fractures, including two previous reports from our institution. The Robinson classification system was described in 1998, after the analysis of 1,000 clavicle fractures. We aim to provide a contemporary analysis and compare current clavicle fracture patterns of our adult population with historical reports.

A retrospective analysis of a prospectively collected fracture database from an institution serving 598,000 was conducted. Demographic data were recorded prospectively for each patient with an acute clavicle fractures including age, gender, mode of injury, fracture classification, and the presence of associated skeletal injuries. Fractures were classified according to the Robinson system.

A total of 312 clavicle fractures were identified, occurring with an incidence of 55.9/100,000/yr (CI 49.8–62.5) and following a bimodal male and unimodal older female distribution. Sporting activity and a simple fall from standing caused the majority of injuries. More than half of simple fall fractures affected the lateral clavicle. The incidence of clavicle fractures has risen over a twenty year period, and a greater proportion of older adults are now affected. Overall, type II midshaft fractures remain the most common, but comparison of this series with historical data reveals that the epidemiology of clavicle fractures is changing.

We have identified an increase in the average patient age and overall incidence of clavicle fractures in our adult population. The incidence, relative frequency, and average patient age of type III lateral one-fifth fractures have increased. This epidemiological trend has implications for the future management of clavicle fractures in our region.


Q.O. Tang Z.M. Silk N. Hope J.S. Ha R.S. Ahluwalia A.M. Williams C.E.R. Gibbons J.S. Church

To date, there are no clear guidelines from the National Institute of Clinical Excellence or the British Orthopaedic Association regarding the use of Autologous Blood Transfusion (ABT) drains after elective primary Total Knee Replacement (TKR). There is little evidence to comparing specifically the use of ABT drains versus no drain. The majority of local practice is based on current evidence and personal surgical experience.

We aim to assess whether the use of ABT drains effects the haemoglobin level at day 1 post-operation and thus alter the requirement for allogenic blood transfusion. In addition we aim to establish whether ABT drains reduce post-operative infection risk and length of hospital stay.

Forty-two patients undergoing elective primary TKR in West London between September 2011 and December 2011 were evaluated pre- and post-operatively. Patient records were scrutinised. The patient population was divided into those who received no drain post-operatively and those with an ABT drain where fluid was suctioned out of the knee in a closed system, filtered in a separate compartment and re-transfused into the patient.

Twenty-six patients had ABT drains and 4 (15.4%) required an allogenic blood transfusion post-operatively. Sixteen patients received no drain and 5 (31.3%) required allogenic blood. There was no statistical difference between these two groups (p=0.22). There was no statistical difference (p=0.75) in the average day 1 haemoglobin drop between the ABT drain and no drain groups with haemoglobin drops of 2.80 and 2.91 respectively. There was no statistical difference in the length of hospital stay between the 2 groups (p=0.35). There was no statistical difference (p=0.26) in infection rates between the 2 groups (2 in ABT drains Vs. 0 in no drains). Of the 2 patients who experienced complications one had cellulitis and the other had an infected haematoma, which was subsequently washed out.

The results identify little benefit in using ABT drains to reduce the requirement for allogenic blood transfusion in the post-operative period following TKR. However, due to small patient numbers transfusion rates of 31.3% in the ABT drain group Vs. 15.4% in the no drain group cannot be ignored. Therefore further studies including larger patient numbers with power calculations are required before a true observation can be identified.


J.C.K. Wong Y. Khan S.A. Sidhom S. Halder

The last decade has seen a rise in the use of the gamma nail for managing inter-trochanteric and subtrochanteric hip fractures. Patients with multiple co-morbidities are under high anaesthetic risk of mortality and are usually not suitable for general or regional anaesthesia. However, there can be a strong case for fixing these fractures despite these risks. Apart from aiming to return patients to their pre-morbid mobility, other advantages include pain relief and reducing the complications of being bed bound (e.g. pressure ulcers, psychosocial factors). While operative use of local anaesthesia and sedation has been documented for insertion of extra-medullary femoral implants such as the sliding hip screw, currently no literature is present for the insertion of the gamma nail.

We studied intra-operative and post-operative outcomes of three patients aged between 64 and 83 with right inter-trochanteric hip fractures and American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) scores of 4 or more. Consent for each case was obtained after discussion with the patient and family, or conducted with the patient's best interests in mind. All patients received a short unlocked gamma nail, and were operated on within 24 hours of admission. Each patient underwent local injections of Bupivacaine or Lignocaine or both, with Epinephrine, and with one patient receiving nerve block of the fascia iliaca. Each patient received a combination of sedatives under the discretion of the anaesthetist including Midazolam, Ketamine, Propofol, Fentanyl, and/or Haloperidol. Operating time ranged from 30–90 minutes. Patients were managed post-operatively with analgesia based on the WHO pain ladder and physiotherapy.

Our results showed no intra-operative complications in any of the cases. All patients noted improvement in their pain and comfort post-operatively without complications of the operation site. Two patients achieved their pre-morbid level of mobility after undergoing physiotherapy and were subsequently discharged from the orthopaedic team. One patient with ongoing pre-operative medical complications died 5 days after the operation.

This study provides a glimpse into the use of local anaesthetic and sedation on high operative risk patients, and this may be a viable alternative to extra-medullary implants or non-operation. Further research is needed to quantify the risks and benefits of operating within this patient group.


L. Murphy S. McKenna D. Shirley

The 2011 National Hip Fracture Database (NHFD) Report has shown our institute has the fewest number of patients meeting the 36-hour target to theatre in the UK (9%) but well above the national average for review by geriatrician (42.5%) at 76%. We believe our timely medical input means patients' are more physiologically normalised prior to surgery. We aimed to review our postoperative results to see if our patients had significantly different morbidity and mortality compared to the rest of the UK.

We reviewed 152 patients between the period September 2009 and September 2010. All of the patients were prospectively identified and their information was added to our hip fracture database. Using the auditing software we reviewed the patients' outcomes and compared them to national averages using figures from the NHFD.

Of the 152 patients identified 13% met the 36-hour target. The average time to theatre for the study group was 89 hours. 83% of the group had a pre-operative assessment by a geriatrician. The primary reason for surgical delay was a lack of space on a theatre list (61.2%) followed by being medical unfit (16.4%). The average length of acute hospital stay was 16.4 days matching the national average while 30 Day mortality at 7.9% was (0.5%) lower than NHFD figures.

We continue to try and improve our time to surgery for hip fracture patients and accept this is mostly related to limited theatre access. Deficient resources due to Northern Ireland's exclusion from the best practice tariff means we are unable to compete with the top performing units in the NHFD. While it makes humanitarian sense to expedite surgery, evidence used to determine the 36-hour target is quoted as “low quality” or “very low quality”. Our data shows no significant difference in outcomes compared to national figures.


H. Noureddine G. Roberts

Following the recommendation of NICE guidelines (CG124) we have recently started using cemented smooth tapered stem hemiarthroplasty as our standard management of intra-capsular neck of femur fractures. Prior to publication of the above guidelines the standard implant utilised was Thompson Hemiarthroplasty prosthesis. The cost implications of this change have not been fully appreciated and the benefit of these changes in ASA grade 3–4 patients has not previously been analysed.

We identified a cohort of 89 patients admitted with displaced intra-capsular neck of femur fracture with an ASA grade 3–4. These underwent hip hemiarthroplaties at our centre over a period of 12 months (before and after guideline implementation). Data regarding in-hospital mortality, dislocation, reoperation and place of discharge were retrospectively collected and analysed.

Our cohort included 46 patients who underwent a Thompsons Hemiarthroplasty, 30 patients who had a cemented smooth tapered stem hemiarthroplasty and 13 patients who had an Austin-moore Hemiarthroplasty.

In-patient mortality rates were highest in the Austin-moore group, followed by the Thompsons group compared to none in the smooth tapered stem group. However, this was not statistically significant. One patient in the Thompsons group and one patient in the smooth tapered group had multiple dislocations and re-operations, compared with none in the Austin-moore group. In terms of percentage of patients who were discharged home from hospital the smooth tapered stem group had a percentage that was more than twice that of the Thompson's which was in turn higher than that found in the Austin-moore group.

In conclusion, our data suggests that in patients with an ASA grade of 3–4 there is no significant benefit from using cemented smooth tapper stems when performing a Hip Hemiarthroplasty compared with a well performed Thompsons and that the cost savings of this is significant. We accept that our current numbers are relatively small and further work is needed.


L. Athanatos N. Nixon G. Holmes L. James A. Bass

Flexible flat foot is considered one of the commonest normal variants in children's orthopaedic practice. The weightbearing foot is usually regarded as flexible on the basis of results from clinical and radiographic examination as well as measured foot-ground pressure pattern.

Our aim was to compare the pedobarographic and radiographic findings of normal arched and symptomatic flexible flat feet and investigate if there were sensitive markers that could be used in selecting patients for surgical correction.

We retrospectively collected data from eighteen patients (ten to sixteen year old). Our control group consisted of ten patients (twenty feet) with normal arched feet and the study group of eight patients (fifteen feet) with symptomatic flat feet who were awaiting surgical correction.

The mean and standard deviations of three radiographic markers (Calcaneal pitch, Naviculocuboid overlap and lateral Talo-1st metatarsal angle) in addition to foot pressures measured at the hindfoot, medial/lateral/total midfoot (MMF, LMF, TMF), forefoot and the percentage of weight going through the MMF over the TMF (medial midfoot ratio (MMFR) during the mid-stance gait phase are reported. In addition, the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value of the pedobarographic parameters were estimated.

There was a significant difference in the Naviculocuboid overlap (P<0.001 T test) and Calcaneal pitch (P<0.05 T test) between both groups. The flat feet group had significantly higher MMF, LMF, TMF and MMFR (P < 0.001 Mann-Whitney). LMF had the highest sensitivity and negative predictive value (94%) whereas MMF, TMF and MMFR had the highest specificity and positive predictive value (100%).

Compared to our control group, patients with symptomatic flexible flat feet had significantly higher pressures distributed in the midfoot, in particular in the medial midfoot. Pedobarography appears to be a sensitive and specific tool that can be used, in conjunction with clinical and radiographic findings, in diagnosing flat feet.

Our study suggests that pedobarography could be used to measure the degree of deformity before and after surgical intervention.


J. Singh L. Jeyaseelan M. Sicuri M. Fox M. Sinisi

Sciatic nerve injury remains a significant and devastating complication of total hip arthroplasty. Incidence as quoted in the literature ranges from 0.08% in primary joint replacement to 7.5% in revision arthroplasty. While as urgent exploration is recommended for nerve palsies associated with pain, management of sciatic nerve palsy with little or no pain is still controversial. In light of this, many patients with persistent palsies are often not referred to our specialist centre until after 6 months post-injury. The aim of this study was to review the outcomes of surgical intervention in patients presenting with sciatic nerve palsy more than 6 months after total hip arthroplasty.

This retrospective cohort study identified 35 patients who underwent exploration and neurolysis of the affected sciatic nerve. All patients had documented follow-up at 1, 3, 6, 12 and 18 months to assess sensory and motor recovery. Patients were scored for sensory and motor function in the tibia and common personal nerve divisions, pre and post-operatively. The scoring system devised by Kline et al (1995) was used. Pre-operative electrophysiology was also reviewed.

We found a statistically significant functional recovery following neurolysis of the sciatic nerve (p<0.01). A statistically significant relationship was also found between time to neurolysis and recovery of tibial nerve function (p = 0.02), such that greater delay to neurolysis was associated with poorer recovery. There was no significant relationship between time to neurolysis and recovery of common peroneal nerve function (p = 0.28).

Our results indicate that the neurolysis of the sciatic nerve, six months or more post injury is associated with functional recovery. We feel that without surgical exploration this clinical improvement would not have occurred. Therefore, we believe that neurolysis plays a vital role at any stage of sciatic nerve injury. However, early presentation to a specialist unit is associated with better outcomes.


X.L. Griffin M. Chaudhry N. Parsons J. McArthur M.L. Costa

Autologous bone graft has been used in the treatment of complex bone defects for more than a century. Morbidity associated with the harvest of this bone graft has led orthopaedic surgeons to seek alternative therapies in the treatment of long bone non-unions.

The aim of this study was to determine whether the use of demineralised bone matrix as a bone healing adjunct improves clinical outcomes in adult patients with long bone non-union. A systematic search was carried out of the peer-reviewed English language literature to identify all relevant studies. The search strategy returned a total of 47 studies. Five of these studies were relevant to the research question. The studies were critically assessed and where appropriate combined in a meta-analysis.

4 non-comparative studies and one comparative study were reviewed. An overall estimate of the rate of union for the five studies was 86% (95%CI: 71–94%). The one comparative study demonstrated the relative risk (RR) of healing was not significantly better than in patients treated with autologous bone graft; RR=1.03 (95%CI 0.96–1.12).

There are limited data to support the use of demineralised bone matrix in the treatment of long bone non-union. Demineralised bone matrix is likely to be similarly effective to other treatments in the management of non-union. This study confirms the clinical and ethical requirements to proceed with a randomised controlled trial to test the effectiveness of this intervention.


R. Pagoti J. Dennison D. Beverland

Salvage Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) presents a viable solution following failed treatment of a hip fracture. Several studies have suggested higher complication rate including high dislocation rate associated with salvage THA. The present study evaluates the results and complications of hip arthroplasty performed as a salvage procedure after the failed treatment of a hip fracture and comparison made to Primary THA in osteoarthritis (OA). Between 1992 and 2007, 53 patients with a mean age of seventy years were treated with THA after the failed treatment of a hip fracture under the care of a single surgeon. The indication for conversion arthroplasty was Avascular necrosis head – 24(45.3%), screw cut out – 6 (11.3%), non-union – 2(3.8%), Displaced fracture – 2(3.8%), Secondary OA – 19 (35.8%). The implants retrieved were Cannulated screws – 3, Sliding plate and screw – 46, Spline plate – 2, Smith Petersons nail – 1, Martin Plate – 1. This group of patients were matched for age, sex, side, and ASA grading with a group of 59 patients who underwent THA for primary osteoarthritis (THA-OA group). Posterior approach was used in all cases. Four patients (7.5%) required grafting of cup and 21 patients (39.6%) required soft tissue release. The average blood loss was 555 ml, mean duration of surgery was 85.5 min, average inpatient stay was 6.7 days. Cemented THA was used in 43 patients and Cementless THA in 10 patients. At one year follow up there were no dislocations, one patient had an undisplaced femoral fracture treated in Spica. Three patients had broken screws; one patient with shortening > 1 inch. There was one revision for deep infection. The mean Harris Hip Score (HHS) improved from 28.4 to 82.5 at one year, while the Oxford Hip score (OHS) improved from 50.9 to 21.9 (Old system). When the scores were compared to the THA-OA group there was no difference in the oxford hip scores and the the mean one year HHS in the THA-OA group was slightly higher than the group with salvage THA, but the difference was not statistically significant. Hip arthroplasty is an effective salvage procedure in patients with prior surgery for hip fracture. Most patients have good pain relief and functional improvement. Despite the operative challenges, remarkably few serious orthopaedic complications were associated with this procedure in the present study.


A. Ghaffar B.A. Hickey R.P.O. Rice H.G. Davies

Approximately 20% of patients with ankle fracture sustain syndesmosis injury. This is most common in trans-syndesmotic (type B) and supra-syndesmotic (type C) fibula fractures. Intra-operative assessment of syndesmosis integrity is important because failure to treat these injuries can result in ankle instability and pain.

Our aim was to audit the documentation of intra-operative testing of syndesmosis during ankle fracture open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF). All patients who had ankle fracture ORIF between 1/1/2010 and 21/11/2011 were included. Pre-operative radiographs were reviewed and fractures were classified according to AO classification. Operation notes were reviewed for documentation of assessment of syndesmosis integrity.

153 patients, of mean age 50 years (15–93) were included. 60% (n=92) were female. In 78% of cases (n=119), an assessment of syndesmosis integrity was documented in the operation note. Of the patients with no documented syndesmosis assessment (n=35), the majority had type B fractures (n=34). One patient had a type C fracture.

We have shown that 22% of patients undergoing ankle ORIF for fracture do not have documented assessment of syndesmosis integrity. We suggest that all patients who have ankle ORIF should have intra-operative assessment and documentation of syndesmosis integrity so these injuries are identified and treated accordingly.


A. Miller B. Stew T. Moorhouse D. Owens H. Whittet

The anatomy of the prevertebral region of the neck is of vital importance to orthopaedic surgeons when managing cervical spine trauma. Lateral radiographs are used in the acute assessment of this area as they are readily available and cost effectiveness. Thickening of the retropharyngeal space on a radiograph may be highly suggestive of serious and life-threatening pathologies. Accurate interpretation of radiological evidence is essential to assist the clinician in diagnosis. Current guidelines for radiological measurement state that these prevertebral soft tissues should not exceed 5mm at the midvertebral level of C3 and 20mm at C7. A ratio between soft tissue measurements and the width of the corresponding vertebra has also been championed as this takes into account magnification errors and variation in patient body habitus. Soft tissue measurements greater than 30% of the upper cervical vertebral bodies and greater than 100% of the lower cervical vertebral bodies are considered to be abnormal. The aim of this study was to assess reliability of current radiological guidelines on soft tissue measurement. A review of 200 consecutive normal lateral soft tissue cervical spine radiographs was undertaken. Patients were included if they were immobilised for blunt trauma and were aged 18 or older. Each patient included had cervical pathology excluded by a combination of clinical examination, flexion-extension views, CT and or MRI. Exclusion criteria included those patients with pre-existing cervical or retropharyngeal pathology, those who had been intubated or had a nasogastric tube passed. Two reviewers independently assessed soft tissue and bony widths at C3 and C7 using the PACs Software. All measurements were taken at the mid vertebral level, not at the end plates to ensure any anterior osteophytes did not create a falsely wide measurement. Plane film radiographs of 107 males and 93 females were included with an average age of 53. At the C3 level, mean soft tissue widths were 4.7mm ± 0.84mm SD and ranged from 2.7 to 7.4mm. The mean soft tissue width at C7 was 14.4mm ± 2.8mm SD with a range of 7.1 to 21.0 mm. Our results show 21.5% (43/200) of the patients exceeded the 5mm upper limit and 20% (40/200) exceeded the soft tissue to vertebra ratio at C3. Only 1% (2/200) of patients exceeded the upper limit of 20mm at C7 and only 2% (4/200) exceeded the soft tissue to vertebra ratio. The C3 guideline for maximum soft tissue widths has a poor specificity (78.5%) and the soft tissue to vertebral ratio at this level may also lead to further unnecessary investigation, as it too has a specificity of only 80%. However, the guidelines for PVST measurements at C7 are much more reliable with a specificity of 99.5% for the absolute measurement and 99% for the soft tissue to vertebra ratio. The ratio measurement has not conferred any significant diagnostic benefit over the static measurement. Current guidelines overestimate injuries at the C3 level but seem appropriate at the C7 level. There is no major benefit to using a ratio measurement over an absolute value.


C.M. Jordan M.C. Quaye K. Madi Y-H. Hsu J. Tong A.J. Cossey

The treatment of acute full thickness chondral damage within the knee is a surgical challenge. Frequently used surgical techniques include chondroplasty, micro-fracture and chondrocyte implantation. These procedures give unpredictable functional outcomes and if the formation of neocartilage is achieved it is predominantly composed of type 1 collagen.

The TruFit osteochondral plug was designed to provide a scaffold for cell proliferation into full thickness chondral defects. It is a composite polymer composed of polylactide co-glycolide, calcium sulphate and poly-glycolide fibres. It is composed of 2 layers, one with a similar trabecular network to cancellous bone and a superficial layer designed to simulate articular lining.

The TruFit bone plug was analysed using micro-computed tomography. Its morphology characteristics, granulometry, mechanical performance and image guided failure were tested as well as numerical modelling to assess the permeability of TruFit.

Morphological parameters of the TruFit bone plug compared favourably with those of human tissue. Under load the scaffold exhibited shear bands throughout the composite leading to a failure mechanism similar to cancellous bone. Stress relaxation rates of the scaffolds were greatly decreased under wet conditions, likely due to plasticisation of the scaffold by water.

The biomechanical properties of the TruFit bone plugs are a cause for concern. The Scaffolds mechanical performance under load rapidly deteriorates in wet conditions at body temperature (the natural knee environment). This early failure will lead to defects in the articular surface where the plug has been inserted. Clinical data is sparse. This study correlates with work performed by Dockery et al & Spalding et al. These clinical studies have shown that the TruFit implant shows no evidence of bone ingrowth or osteoconductivity. It provides no subchondral support to neocartilage or tissue that was stimulated to form around the defects and surgical sites.


S.G.A. Naqvi S. Iqbal I. Braithwaite R. Banim T. Reynolds

Hip fractures accounts to about 86000 cases per annum in UK. AP and Lateral radiographs form an essential investigation in planning the management of these fractures. Recently it has been suggested that lateral view doesn't provide any additional information in majority of the cases. We looked retrospectively at 25 consecutive radiographs with intracapsular and extracapsular fracture neck of femur each presenting to our department between May 2010 and January 2011. These radiographs were put on the CD in 2 folders as AP and Lateral. It was reviewed by 2 Observers who suggested their preferred treatment. The results were compared for the intra observer agreement to assess the necessity of the lateral view of the radiographs. We also compared the treatment options with the gold standard and looked at the interobserver agreement. Of the 50 set of radiographs that were reviewed, Observer 1 had disagreed with himself on one occasion (98%agreement) compared to the Observer 2 who had two disagreements (96% agreement). When analyzing the intracapsular fractures, we found 100% agreement of OBSERVER 1 with himself when proposing treatment on AP and Lateral View. Whereas, OBSERVER 2 had only one disagreement. It gave us a Free marginal kappa value of more than 0.70 indicating excellent agreement. One difference doesn't have any statistical significance. In the extracapsular fractures, Kappa values ranged from 0.413 to 0.88. OBSERVER 1 did change his opinion after reviewing the lateral view but generally had good outcome (K=0.88). Whereas, the opinion of OBSERVER 2 was unaffected by the Lateral view. The X-ray diagnoses by OBSERVER 1 and OBSERVER 2 had only moderate agreement (K=0.52 (AP) and 0.57 (Lat). Comparing the observer opinion to the gold standard (operation performed) showed moderate agreement both on AP and Lateral view (OBSERVER 1 AP and Lat both K=0.64, OBSERVER 2 AP and Lat both K=0.41). The Lateral view failed to change the opinion of the observers (K > 0.7) but there was moderate to excellent agreement between the observers and observer vs operation (The Gold Standard) with kappa value of more than 0.52. We feel that the Lateral view doesn't make any difference in most of the cases as shown by a good intra-observer agreement. However, we cannot completely rule out their importance and they should be performed in occult fractures, pathological fractures, fractures extending into the shaft, young patients, and on the request of physician.


D. Hipps A. Holmes K. Sugden R. Refaie D. Dowen A. C. Gray

There were 70000 people admitted to hospital with fractured hips in 2007 and the incidence is rising by 2% each year. Hip fractures represent significant morbidity and mortality to patients and cost the NHS £1.8 billion annually.

In 2008 the British Orthopaedic Association Standards for Trauma (BOAST) issued a 14-point guideline to be followed for the management of hip fractures. The aim was to improve secondary prevention of osteoporosis, reduce the falls risk and further fractures. This aimed to provide better care to improve the outcomes for patients and reduce the burden of hip fractures on society.

The aim of the audit was to see if the BOAST guidelines are met before and after the transition to a level 1 MTC (Major Trauma Centre) and to measure any impact the change had.

Methods: Prospective data was collected for three months in 2010, 2011 and 2012. 94 case notes were reviewed and compared to the outcomes laid out in the BOAST guidelines to see if standards were met.

Overall adherence to the guideline's recommendations was high throughout the 3 sample months. For each of the 3 sample months 100% adherence was seen in all of the following criteria: further imaging if x-rays unclear, appropriate analgesia, pre-op assessment, seniority of surgeon, orthogeriatrician involvement, seniority of surgeons and submission to the National Hip Fracture Database. The main common area where adherence was less than 100% was with A and E breaches (i.e. greater than 4 hours referral to the ward).

Despite relocation and transition to a level 1 MTC, the management of fractured neck of femur patients compared to the BOAST guidelines remained of a high standard. Further improvements have also been made since moving to the new hospital site where shortcomings in management have been identified.

Improvements from year one to three include prophylactic antibiotics and warfarin reversal; there is now a new trust protocol in place for warfarin reversal in the case of hip fractures. Elsewhere adherence to the guidelines remains high across the sample months. Confirming that despite moving to a level 1 status the trauma team continues to be performing well and managing this group appropriately.

In January 2012 BOAST published a second version of the hip fracture guidelines: A and E breaches were removed from the guidelines. There have also been several new additions to the guidelines, which prompt a further re-audit in the future.


H.A. Wilson S. O'Leary

An important aspect of the governance of surgical services within a Healthcare Trust is the correct coding of elective procedures performed. Within the Trust, treatment codes are banded into specific healthcare resource groups (HRGs), which generate a predetermined income. Accurate coding and grouping of the treatments provided for patients is consequently vital to Trusts to ensure that they receive appropriate financial reward for the care provided, so ensuring they remain economically viable as a department.

We present a retrospective study investigating the accuracy of procedure coding, code allocation to HRGs, and the resultant cost consequences for all elective arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) repairs completed by one consultant over one financial year (01/01/2010-31/03/2011).

In this period a total of 55 ACL repairs were undertaken by the consultant. Data was available for 43 of these cases, all of which were repairs of traumatic ACL ruptures. The patients had an average age of 26.7 (17–55) years, all were ASA 1 and had no significant comorbidities. They were all booked for identical procedures, except one patient who required an allograft; 12 required meniscectomies. All 43 had an operation note completed by the operating consultant.

Within this trust patient and procedural codes were generated from electronic discharge letters (EDLs). We found that all 43 EDLs were completed accurately, contained full details of the procedures undertaken, and included relevant information such as complications, patient comorbidities, length of stay and the prescription of analgesics.

These 43 EDLs generated 15 different diagnostic codes and 10 different procedure codes, with a total of 35 different combinations of codes. These were then grouped into six different HRGs. These six HRGs generated income for the Trust, varying from £1880 to £3554 (mean £2670) for the procedures, with a total income of £114,823. We found that patient and procedure details, and the level of doctor completing the EDL did not significantly influence the HRG generated (P = 0.4)

Currently within the Trust, and nationally the HRG tariff for a routine ACL repair has not been agreed upon. The maximum possible tariff from an HRG for this procedure for a patient with no significant comorbidities is described as – ‘Reconstruction of intraarticular ligament – Major knee procedure for trauma’, generating an income of £5183 per case. Application of this tariff would have resulted in a total income of £222,869 for the 43 patients included in the present study a potential increase of earnings for the Trust of £108,046, for one elective procedure in one financial year.

The findings of this study reveal the potential for limitations in the governance of surgical services through inaccuracies in HRG coding, despite the availability of suitably detailed EDLs. It is suggested that Trusts should audit and, where indicated, ensure effective quality assurance of HRG coding in the interests of the governance of secondary care services.


J.E. Tomlinson R. Stevens G. Page P.G. Haslam

With the recent reductions in junior doctor hours levels of staffing have become ever more critical as clinical duties are covered with fewer junior doctors available on a daily basis. Trainees also have to meet specific requirements of the curriculum and thus need to be allocated to posts with suitable opportunities. There is little evidence available to account for the allocation of posts to individual trusts and departments with training post numbers seem driven by historical allocation, rather than based on trainee and local population needs.

‘SHO’ tier numbers were obtained for each orthopaedic department within the Yorkshire deanery through direct contact with the departments. Data was also obtained to establish the workload of these departments. Information was gathered from the national neck of femur database, hospital episode statistics, the national joint registry, the trauma audit and research network (TARN) and finally Dr Foster and the national census. The workload data was then analysed and compared to the staffing levels in each department.

Data was obtained for fourteen trusts across the Yorkshire Deanery. The percentage of SHO tier doctors in training posts ranged from 0 to 78% (mean 37%) across the trusts surveyed, with wide variation in make up of the SHO tier in each department.

Workload was standardised using the unit of cases/SHO/annum. The workload for neck of femur fractures ranged from 8 to 52 cases/SHO/annum (mean 36). General trauma admissions ranged from 199 to 383 cases/SHO/annum (mean 288). Elective arthroplasty admissions ranged from 11 to 174 (mean 70). Pearson correlation coefficients were 0.5 for elective arthroplasty and neck of femur admissions and 0.8 for trauma admissions.

There is wide variation in workload between trusts when standardised for the number of SHO's with weak to moderate correlations between the number of juniors and workload in each department. This wide variation will impact on patient care, but also the training opportunities available in different posts – where workload is higher it is likely there will be an increased need for ward based work away from clinics and theatre lists.

The introduction of the foundation programme and MMC has changed the structure of the SHO grade at a time when the EWTD introduction has also had a profound impact on working patterns and hours. At this time we believe there is a need for a review of trainee allocations nationally with comparison to workload in each trust, trainee logbook data and data on curriculum competencies met. With the proposed reductions in trainee numbers now is the time for a centrally led review of these posts via the Royal College, BOA and BOTA to ensure high quality training, maintain high standards of patient care and secure the future of the orthopaedic profession.


W. D. Harrison S. Johnson-Lynn D. Cloke J.J. Candal-Couto

Subacromial corticosteroid injections are a well-recognised management for chronic shoulder pain and are routinely used in general practice and musculoskeletal clinics. Mycobacterium tuberculosis (TB) of a joint is a rare presentation in the United Kingdom. International literature exists for cases of reactivated latent tuberculosis following intra-articular corticosteroid injections in a knee; however there are no reports of a primary presentation of undiagnosed TB in a joint following therapeutic corticosteroid injections.

A seventy-four year old lady presented with a one-year history of a painful shoulder, which clinically manifested as a rotator cuff tear with impingement syndrome. Following three subacromial depo-medrone injections, the patient developed a painless “cold” lump which was investigated as a suspicious, possibly metastatic lesion. This lump slowly developed a sinus and a subsequent MRI scan identified a large intra-articular abscess formation. The sinus then progressed to a large intra-articular 5×8 cm cavity with exposed bone (picture available). The patient had no diagnosis of TB but had pathogen exposure as a child via her parents.

The patient underwent three weeks of multiple débridement and intravenous amoxicillin/flucloxacillin to treat Staphylococcus aureus grown on an initial culture. Despite best efforts the wound further dehisced with a very painful and immobile shoulder. Given the poor response to penicillin and ongoing wound breakdown there was a suspicion of TB. After a further fortnight, Mycobacterium tuberculosis was eventually cultured and quadruple antimicrobial therapy commenced. Ongoing débridement of the rotator cuff and bone was required alongside two months of unremitting closed vacuum dressing. The wound remained persistently open and excision of the humeral head was necessary, followed by secondary wound closure. There were no extra-articular manifestations of TB in this patient. At present the shoulder is de-functioned, the wound healed and shoulder pain free.

This unique case study highlights that intra-articular corticosteroid can precipitate the first presentation of Mycobacterium tuberculosis septic arthritis. The evolution of symptoms mimic many other shoulder complaints making confident diagnosis a challenge. The infective bone and joint destruction did not respond to the management described in the current literature. There remains a further management issues as to whether arthroplasty surgery can be offered to post-TB infected shoulder joints.

Taking a TB exposure history is indicated prior to local immunosuppressant injection, particularly in the older age group of western populations and ethnicities with known risk factors.


A. Young J. Ward C. Curwen

Enhanced recovery pathways (ERPs) utilise multimodal rehabilitation techniques to reduce post-operative pain and accelerate the rehabilitation process following surgery. Originally described following elective colonic surgery enhanced recovery pathways have gained increasing use following elective hip and knee joint replacement in recent years. Early studies have indicated that enhanced recovery pathways can reduce length of hospital stay, reduce complications and improve cost-effectiveness of joint replacement surgery. Despite this growing evidence base uptake has been slow in certain centres and many surgeons are yet to utilise enhanced recovery pathways in their practice. We look at the process and effects of implementing an enhanced recovery pathway following total hip replacement surgery at a district general hospital in the United Kingdom.

A retrospective study was initially undertaken over a four-month period to assess patient demographics, length of stay, time to physiotherapy and complication rates including re-admission within 28 days.

Based on national recommendations an enhanced recovery pathway protocol was then implemented for an elective total hip replacement list. Inclusion criteria were elective patients undergoing primary total hip replacement (THR) surgery. The pathway included pre-operative nutrition optimisation, 4mg ondansetron, 8mg dexamethasone and 1g tranexamic acid at induction and 150mL ropivacaine HCL 0.2%, 30mg ketorolac and adrenaline (RKA) mix infiltration to joint capsule, external rotators, gluteus tendon, iliotibial band, soft-tissues and skin around the hip joint. The patient was mobilised four-hours after surgery where possible and aimed to be discharged once mobile and pain was under control.

Following implementation a prospective study was undertaken to compare patient demographics, length of stay and complication rates including re-admission within 28 days.

34 patients met the inclusion criteria and were included in each group pre and post-enhanced recovery pathway. Following implementation of an enhanced recovery pathway mean length of stay decreased from 5.4 days to 3.5 days (CI 1.94, p < 0.0001). Sub-group analysis based on ASA grade revealed that this reduction in length of stay was most pronounced in ASA 1 patients with mean length of stay reduced from 5.0 days to 3.2 days (CI 1.83, p < 0.0001). There was no significant change in the number of complications or re-admission rates following enhanced recovery pathway.

The enhanced recovery pathway was quick and easy to implement with co-ordination between surgeons, anaesthetist, nursing staff and patients. This observational study of consecutive primary total hip replacement patients shows a substantial reduction in length of stay with no change in complication rates after the introduction of a multimodal enhanced recovery protocol. Both of these factors reduce hospital costs for elective THR patients and may improve patient experiences.


JJ George Malal A I W Mayne A M Noorani M Kent M Smith I Guisasola P Brownson

The aim of the study was to assess the medium term outcome for complex proximal humeral fractures treated with the long proximal humeral internal locking system (PHILOS) plate fixation.

All patients who had long PHILOS plate fixation of proximal humerus fractures with metaphyseal or diaphyseal extension over a three year period at our institution were included in the study. Patients had their case notes and radiographs reviewed. Patients were also contacted to assess functional outcome using the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain, DASH, Oxford shoulder score (OSS) and Stanmore Percentage of Normal Shoulder Assessment (SPONSA).

Out of an initial cohort of 34 patients, 1 died, 2 patients had unrelated illnesses resulting in them being unable to complete the assessment and 6 were lost to follow-up, leaving 25 patients (74%) for review. All patients had proximal humeral fractures with metaphyseal or diaphyseal extension requiring long plate osteosynthesis. One patient had the procedure for non union following initial treatment with an intra medullary nail and the rest were acute injuries. The patients were followed up after a mean of 27 months (range 11–60). The length of plate used varied from 5 to 12 holes for the shaft region.

There was 1 wound infection. 3 patients had non unions which required bone grafting and revision internal fixation. At final follow-up, mean pain was 3.6 (95% Confidence Interval 2.5–4.8) with only 4 patients having residual pain greater than 5 on the VAS scale. Mean DASH score was 41.2 (95% CI 32.0–50.4), mean OSS was 29.1 (95% CI 24.3–33.9) and mean SPONSA was 63.9% (95% CI 50.8–77.2)

The long PHILOS plate appears to represent a good treatment option for complex proximal humerus fractures with favourable medium term results and few complications.


JJ George Malal AM Noorani D Wharton M Kent M Smith I Guisasola P Brownson

The aim of the study was to assess the rate of greater tuberosity non union in reverse shoulder arthroplasty performed for proximal humerus fractures and to assess if union is related to type of fracture or the intraoperative reduction of the greater tuberosity.

All cases of reverse shoulder arthroplasty for proximal humerus fractures at our institution over a three year period were retrospectively reviewed from casenotes and radiologically and the position of the greater tuberosity was documented at immediate post op, 6 months and 12 months. Any malunion or non union were noted.

A total of 27 cases of reverse shoulder arthroplasty for proximal humeral fractures were identified. 4 cases did not have complete follow up xrays and were excluded from analysis. The average age at operation of the cohort of the 23 remaining patients was 79 years (range 70–91). The greater tuberosity was anatomically well positioned intraoperatively in 17 of the 23 cases.

At the end of 12 months there were 4 cases of tuberosity non union (17%), all except one occurring in poorly intraoperatively positioned greater tuberosity. 50% (3 out of 6) of greater tuberosities displaced further and remained ununited if the intraoperative position was poor. Only 6% (1 out of 17) greater tuberosities did not unite if the greater tuberosities was reduced anatomically. Intra operatively position of the greater tuberosity was strongly associated with their union (Fischer's exact test p<0.05). Union of greater tuberosity was not statistically associated with fracture pattern (Fischer's exact test p=0.48).

Our case series show a low rate of tuberosity malunion after reverse shoulder arthroplasty for proximal humerus fracture. Good positioning and fixation of the greater tuberosity intra operatively is a strong predictor of their uneventful union to shaft.


K. Mehta M. Shakeel JJ George Malal M. Waseem

The study was designed to look at canine related injuries presenting to the orthopaedic department at a small rural district general hospital and to assess their cost to the NHS.

A retrospective review of case notes and x-rays of all dog related injuries presenting to the orthopaedic services at our hospital over a one year period starting January 2011 was undertaken. The injuries involved and the treatment provided along with the direct financial cost of these services were calculated from trust tariffs.

Dog related injuries accounted for 84 out of a total of 48,405 patients presenting to the accident and emergency services over the index period. Of these, 29 required orthopaedic input with 57% of injuries resulting from trying to restrain a dog and the rest from being attacked by a dog. 14 patients were admitted to the wards with 11 among them requiring orthopaedic interventions ranging from wound wash outs and debridement to open reduction and internal fixation of fractures. These procedures cost £38,951 to the NHS. There were a total of 38 inpatient days involved costing another £9,196. A further 28 clinic visits were billed at £4,032. The total cost for the orthopaedic services provided was £52,179. There were no mortalities associated with these injuries over the time period.

Canine related injuries are costly and avoidable. General public awareness of the problem coupled with appropriate legislation and its strict enforcement may be necessary to protect people from our canine companions.


B. Rocos B.J.A. Lankester

The introduction of direct thrombin inhibitors in arthroplasty surgery has reignited the debate on the risk of wound complications when using chemical thromboprophylaxis. It has been suggested that direct thrombin inhibitors might lead to an increased risk of systemic and operative site bleeding and wound sepsis when compared to low molecular weight heparin.

In July 2009, departmental thromboprophylaxis policy for patients undergoing hip and knee replacement surgery (including revision) was changed from subcutaneous enoxaparin for the duration of inpatient stay to dabigatran for 10 days (knees) or 28 days (hips) unless contraindicated. In the 2 years prior to policy change, 1091 patients underwent hip or knee arthroplasty (Group A), with1150 patients undergoing the same procedures in the 2 years following July 2009 (Group B). A minority of patients were already on warfarin (2% in group 1, 3% in group 2).

This study presents a retrospective analysis of all patients who returned to theatre within 30 days of joint replacement surgery to assess whether the change in unit policy caused any discernible increase in bleeding-related complications.

In group A, 20/1091 patients (1.8%) returned to theatre within 30 days. 9 were for reasons unrelated to thromboprophylaxis (mainly dislocated hips), 4 for gastrointestinal bleeding and 7 for wound complications (haematoma, wound breakdown, or infection).

In group B, 22/1150 patients (1.9%) returned to theatre within 30 days. 13 were for unrelated reasons, 4 for gastrointestinal bleeding, and 5 for wound complications. One patient with a wound complication was on warfarin and therefore did not receive dabigatran.

The lower wound complication rate in group B was not statistically different.

This study, in a large heterogeneous group of patients, suggests that a change from enoxaparin to dabigatran does not increase the incidence of local or systemic complications of sufficient severity to warrant return to theatre.


Z. Gamie D. Shields J. Neale J. Claydon S. Hazarika A.C. Gray

Recent NICE guidelines suggest that Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) be offered to all patients with a displaced intracapsular neck of femur fracture who: are able to walk independently; not cognitively impaired and are medically fit for the anaesthesia and procedure. This is likely to have significant logistical implications for individual departments.

Data from the National Hip Fracture Database was analysed retrospectively between January 2009 and November 2011. The aim was to determine if patients with displaced intracapsular neck of femur fractures admitted to a single tertiary referral orthopaedic trauma unit received a THA if they met NICE criteria. Case notes were then reviewed to obtain outcome and complication rates after surgery.

Five hundred and forty-six patients were admitted with a displaced intracapsular neck of femur fracture over the described time period. Sixty-five patients met the NICE criteria to receive a THA (mean age 74 years, M:F = 16: 49); however, 21 patients had a THA. The other patients received either a cemented Thompson or bipolar hemiarthroplasty. Within the THA cohort there were no episodes of dislocation, venous thromboembolism, significant wound complications or infections that required further surgery. Within the hemiarthroplasty cohort there was 2 mortalities, 2 implant related infections, 1 dislocation and 2 required revision to a THA.

There is evidence to suggest better outcomes in this cohort of patients, in terms pain and function. There is also a forecasted cost saving for departments, largely due to the relative reduction in complications. However, there were many cases (44) in our department, which would have been eligible for a THA, according to the NICE guidelines, who received a hemiarthroplasty. This is likely a reflection of the increased technical demand, and larger logistical difficulties faced by the department. We did note more complications within the hemiarthroplasty group, however, the numbers are too small to address statistical significance, and a longer follow up would be needed to further evaluate this. There is a clear scope for optimisation and improvement of infrastructure to develop time and resources to cope with the increased demand for THA for displaced intracapsular neck of femur fractures, in order to closely adhere to the NICE guidelines.


GR. Phillips P. Lee A. Robertson K. Lyons MC. Forster

The TruFit® plug is a cylindrical scaffold designed to bridge defects in articular cartilages. It is a porous structure with interconnected pores, which gives it the capability of providing a framework for the ingrowth new tissue and remodelling to articular cartilage and bone.

The aim of this study was to assess the radiological incorporation of TruFit® Plugs using MRI. Between December 2007 & August 2009, 22 patients underwent treatment of a chondral or osteochondral lesion using one or more TruFit Plugs. At a minimum of 2 years, 10 patients (12 lesions) were MRI scanned and assessed with a modified MOCART Scoring system by an independent Consultant Musculoskeletal Radiologist. 8 patients were no longer contactable and 4 patients declined MRI as their knee was asymptomatic.

8 of 12 lesions showed congruent articular cartilage cover with a surface of a similar thickness and signal to the surrounding cartilage and reconstitution of the subchondral bone plate. 2 lesions had a thicker congruent articular surface with a similar signal to the surrounding articular cartilage without restoration of the subchondral bone plate. 2 lesions showed no graft incorporation at all and were filled with granulation tissue. Full incorporation of the bony portion of the plug had occurred in only 3 lesions with partial incorporation in 7 lesions. The remaining portion of these 7 lesions looked cystic on MRI.

The MRI appearances of the TruFit® Plug at 2 years are encouraging with the majority (83%) showing good restoration of the articular surface with tissue of similar thickness, congruity and signal as the surrounding articular cartilage. However complete incorporation of the TruFit® Plug is rare and cystic change is common. The significance of this cystic change is not clear.


J.A. Nicholson G. Waiter D. Lawrie G. Ashcroft

Dupuytrens disease is a fibrosing condition of the palmar aponeurosis and its extensions within the digits. Normal fascial fibres running longitudinally in the subcutaneous tissues of the palm become thickened and form the characteristic nodules and cords pathognomonic of Dupuytrens disease. A wide variety of surgical interventions exist, of these the partial fasciectomy remains the most conventional and widely used technique. Minimally invasive surgical treatments such as needle fasciotomy are, however, becoming increasingly popular. Dupuytrens disease remains a challenging condition to treat as recurrence is universally found with all surgical interventions. Although recurrence may be related to the severity of the disease, there are currently no research tools other than clinical examination to examine changes in the diseased tissue postoperatively and predict likelihood of long-term success.

Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) may be of value for the study of Dupuytren disease, at present its use has been greatly underexplored. We wished to carry out a pilot study in order to examine the possibility of using 3.0 Tesla MRI to study Dupuytren tissue and then furthermore to examine the potential changes post-operatively following percutaneous fasciotomy.

Five patients set to undergo percutaneous needle fasciotomy were recruited and consented for the study. All patients underwent MRI scanning of the affected hand pre-operatively and at two weeks post-operatively. Scanning was carried out in the 3.0 Tesla research MRI scanner at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. Patients were placed prone in the MRI scanner with the hand outstretched above the head in the so-called “Superman” position. A specially designed wrist and hand coil was used. Under the expertise of radiographers and physicists, image capture encompassed four novel scanning sequences in order to make a volumetric three-dimensional image sample of the affected hand. MIPAV software (Bethesda, Maryland) was used for image analysis.

Scanning revealed well defined anatomy. The Dupuytren cord arose from the palmar aponeurosis tissue which is deep to the palmar skin and subcutaneous tissue. It was distinctly different to deep structures such as the flexor tendons and intrinsic hand muscles which appeared with a uniform low and high signal respectively. The Dupuytren tissue had a heterogeneous signal on both T1 and T2 images. On T1 the tissue signal appeared high to intermediate, similar to that of bone and muscle, but low areas of signal were observed diffusely in an irregular fashion throughout. On T2 the tissue had a low signal throughout with some focal areas of high signal. Dupuytren tissue was mapped using MIPAV software for pre- and post-operative comparisons. Signal intensity, surface area and volume of the cords and fasciotomy sites were explored.

Our initial results suggest MRI can be used to study Dupuytren tissue. Such a research tool may be of use to study the natural history of Dupuytren disease and furthermore, the response to medical and surgical interventions.


A. Soni M. Shakokani I. Chambers

Cobalt-chrome alloys are widely used in dentistry and Orthopaedic implant industry. Vitallium is a similar alloy which contains 60% cobalt, 20% chromium, 5% molybdenum along with traces of other substances. It has been in use along with stainless steel for the last century because of its lightweight, favourable mechanical properties and resistance to corrosion. We present an unusual case of synovial cyst formation following Vitallium plating mimicking a sarcoma. To our knowledge, we are the first to report a delayed tissue reaction to Vitallium plating 40 years after its implantation.

A 78 yrs old man had a right femoral intertrochanteric fracture 40 years ago, which was fixed with a Vitallium nail plate. His postoperative recovery was uneventful and he regained full function of his leg. 3 years prior to excision, he presented with a painless swelling around his right upper thigh to our unit. Aspiration of the swelling and investigations were requested but patient was lost to follow up due to social reasons. Seven months prior to excision, he represented as the swelling had increased to the extent that it was involving the anterior and posterior aspect of the upper thigh with pressure necrosis of skin posteriorly. Examination revealed painless, transilluminable, fluctuant multilobular swelling over the right proximal femur overlying the healed surgical scar. Compression of the larger lobe in the buttock clearly forced fluid into the anterior compartment of the thigh where again swelling was extensive. Surprisingly he had full range of movements at the hip joint.

Radiograph of the hip showed a soft tissue swelling with a healed fracture and Vitallium implant insitu. Cytology was negative. MRI scan showed multiloculated cystic lesions extending anteriorly, laterally and posteriorly into the intermuscular and subcutaneous planes around the right proximal femur. Multiple small dependent foci likely representing debris or synovial proliferation was seen within loculations.

Excision of the cystic lesions with removal of metal work was performed. The old incision was reopened in the lateral position and a large cystic lesion with a thick capsule was dissected down to the metal work. The lesion was lying superficial to the vastus lateralis but was communicating with metal work. The metal work was removed with difficulty, no visible metallosis. A second cystic lesion was located more posteriorly but its neck was communicating with the thin hole into the first lesion. The lesion was excised completely.

Macroscopic examination showed two cysts 9×8×5.5cm and 20×10×7.5cm with a smooth external surface and the lumen appeared trabecular containing numerous loose (rice) bodies. Microscopy showed a dense fibrotic cyst wall with lumen with multiple small nodules containing organised fibrinous and eosinophilic material. Several foci of cellular debris including lymphocytes and macrophages were scattered in nodules best representing a synovial cyst with loose/rice bodies. No malignancy was seen.

We recommend early removal of metal work if it shows any signs of local reaction provided fracture is united. Be aware of large foreign body/ hypersensitivity reaction and incompatible equipment for removal.


S. Ul Islam W. Dandachli R. Richards M. Hall-Craggs J. Witt

The position of the pelvis has been shown to influence acetabular orientation. However there have been no studies quantifying that effect on the native acetabulum. Our aims were to investigate whether it is possible to quantify the relationship between pelvic tilt and acetabular orientation in native hips, and whether pelvic tilt affects acetabular cover of the femoral head.

Computerized tomography scans of 93 hips (36 normal, 31 dysplastic and 26 with acetabular retroversion) were analyzed. We used a CT technique that allows standardised three-dimensional (3D) analysis of acetabular inclination and anteversion and calculation of femoral head cover in relation to the anterior pelvic plane and at different degrees of forward and backward tilt. Acetabular anteversion, inclination and cover of the femoral head were measured at pelvic tilt angles ranging from −20° to 20° in relation to the anterior pelvic plane using 5° increments.

The effect of pelvic tilt on version was similar in the normal, dysplastic and retroverted groups, with a drop in anteversion ranging from 2.5° to 5° for every 5° of forward tilt. The effect on inclination was less marked and varied among the three groups. Pelvic tilt increased femoral head cover in both normal and dysplastic hips. The effect was less marked, and tended to be negligible at higher positive tilt angles, in the retroverted group.

This study has provided benchmark data on how pelvic tilt affects various acetabular parameters which in turn may be helpful in promoting greater understanding of acetabular abnormalities and how pelvic tilt affects the interpretation of pelvic radiographs.


M.L.T. Jayatilaka R. Macfarlane G. Allan M.R. Cope

The majority of orthopaedic surgeons routinely review their patients after six weeks, following surgery. During the first six weeks, orthopaedic surgeons are blissfully unaware of how frequently their patients seek medical attention related to problems with their arthroplasty. During this period of time, General Practitioners play a vital role in the care of the post-operative arthroplasty patient.

The aim of this study was to determine how frequently patients seek medical attention following primary joint replacement in this interim six-week period.

102 patients from a single practice who had undergone a primary hip or knee replacement from 2003 to 2011 were included and the notes of all these patients were analysed retrospectively. Within this group there were 33 men and 69 women. 45 (44.1%) patients sought medical attention during the 6-week period, which accounted for 69 GP led interventions. The maximum number of interventions was four and a minimum of zero. Of these, 45 patients (29.4%) were seen once, 9 (8.8%) were seen twice, 3 (2.9%) were seen three times and 3 (2.9%) were seen four times. The interventions were for the following reasons: 1(0.9%) for post operative anaemia, 5 (4.9%) for constipation, (1.9%) for post operative nausea, 8 (7.8%) for leg pain (1 scanned for DVT), 5 (4.9%) for leg swelling (2 scanned for DVT), 12 (11.7%) were administered antibiotics, of which 1 was for a chest infection (1 scanned for DVT), 7(6.8%) for a wound review (1 scanned for DVT) (2 patients were started on antibiotic) and 19.6% (20) patients were seen for post operative analgesia. In total, there were 5 (4.9%) patients scanned for DVT and all scans were negative.

GPs play a vital, often underestimated role in the post operative care of primary arthroplasty patients. The majority of interventions were required simply because of inadequate post-operative analgesia being given to patients upon discharge. This is an issue that the orthopaedic department can address, which will improve patient care and ease the burden on primary care. Patients still continue to see their GPs for suspected wound infections despite being instructed to contact the hospital. This issue needs to be addressed with further education, as any infection, even superficial, can have devastating consequences if it spreads to the prosthesis.


D.J. Westacott J. McArthur R.J. King P. Foguet

The orientation of the acetabular component in metal-on-metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty affects wear rate and hence failure. Correct assessment of acetabular orientation is key in assessing the painful hip resurfacing. This study aimed to establish if interpretation of pelvic radiographs with TraumaCad software can provide a reliable alternative to computed tomography (CT) in measuring the acetabular inclination and version.

TraumaCad was used to measure the acetabular orientation on AP pelvis radiographs of 14 painful hip resurfacings. Four orthopaedic surgeons performed each measurement twice. These were compared with measurements taken from CT reformats performed by an experienced musculoskeletal radiologist. The correlation between TraumaCad and CT was calculated, as was the intra- and inter-observer reliability of TraumaCad.

There is strong correlation between the two techniques for the measurement of inclination and version (p<0.001). Intra- and inter-observer reliability of TraumaCad measurements are good (p<0.001). Mean absolute error for measurement of inclination was 2.1°. TraumaCad underestimated version compared to CT in 93% of cases, by 12.6 degrees on average.

When assessing acetabular orientation in hip resurfacing, the orthopaedic surgeon may use TraumaCad in the knowledge that it correlates well with CT and has good intra- and inter-observer reliability but underestimates version by 12° on average. This underestimation may be contributed to by the natural divergence of the X-ray beam, the short arc of the ellipse left exposed by the large diameter head, and the non-hemispherical resurfacing cup.


S.J.W. Kent

Diagnosing musculoskeletal pathology from radiographs is an important skill in orthopaedics and emergency medicine. Knowing which fractures are more likely to be missed allows a high index of suspicion when looking at certain radiographs. Likewise, knowing which fractures will be rigorously followed up if they are missed helps to increase index of suspicion for those fractures. Therefore we used a prospectively gathered database of missed radiographic diagnoses to determine which injuries are missed most commonly and how these injuries are followed up.

Four hundred and thirty two missed radiographic diagnoses were recorded from a total of thirty seven thousand, two hundred and seventy nine radiographs (37,279) in an emergency medicine department over three years. The most common area in which fractures were missed was the foot (22%), followed by hand (19%) and wrist (15%). The most common diagnosis to be missed was fracture of a proximal phalanx, followed by fracture of a distal radius and fracture of a metatarsal. The hip, knee, cervical spine and wrist were the areas most likely to be followed up, each with 32–35% of missed diagnoses being followed up in this way. The areas most likely to be further imaged with CT or MRI were the knee and hip. Two of the missed fractured femurs were managed operatively.

Our results show that missed radiographic diagnosis are most commonly of the foot and hand, and that missed diagnosis of knee and femur fractures are followed up most rigorously. By showing which radiographs are most likely to contain missed fractures, and what these fractures are, we allow orthopaedic trainees to increase their level of diagnostic suspicion when reviewing these radiographs.


A. Zaghloul E. Griffiths C Lawrence P. Nicolai

To evaluate prospectively the mid-term results of the Zimmer Unicondylar Knee arthoplasty (UKA).

Between 2005 and 2012, 187 unicompartmental knee arthroplasties (UKA) were performed by a single surgeon using a fixed-bearing prosthesis (Zimmer). 37 cases were excluded as either were lost to follow-up or had less than six months follow-up. The study included 150 UKAs. Deformity, if present, was correctable. Patellofemoral joint (PFJ) disease was not considered as an absolute contraindication. The average patient age at the time of surgery was 66 years (range 42–88 years); 78 of which were male. Mean follow-up time was 3.6 years (range 7–81 months). Mean Body Mass Index (BMI) was 29 (range 21–41). Clinical and conventional radiological evaluations were carried out at six months, one, two and five years postoperatively.

147 cases were medial compartment replacement and three were lateral. 86 patients had grade III OA and 64 had grade IV (Kellgren and Lawrence). 113 patients had an element of PFJ disease. The mean Knee Society knee and function scores had an improvement from 55 and 54 points pre-operatively to 95 and 94 points respectively at time of most recent evaluation. The average flexion improved from 116 degrees pre-operatively to 127 degrees. Two cases were revised, one due to progression of osteoarthritis in the lateral compartment of the knee and the other was due to arthrofibrosis.

The Zimmer unicompartmental knee arthroplasty provided excellent pain relief and restoration of function in carefully selected patients. However, long-term studies are necessary to investigate the survival rate for this prothesis.


R. Subbu R. Nandra D. Patel J. McArthur P. Thompson

In August 2007 NICE issued its guidance for the treatment of patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA) with arthroscopic lavage. The recommendations stated that referral for arthroscopic lavage and debridement should not be offered as part of treatment for osteoarthritis, unless the person has osteoarthritis with a clear history of ‘mechanical locking’ (not gelling, giving way, or x-ray evidence of loose bodies). The aim of this study was to assess both the application of these guidelines over a four month period and whether this procedure had improved symptoms at first follow-up.

This was a retrospective review from August-December 2011. The total number of arthroscopies performed during this period was obtained from theatre records. Further data was obtained through the hospital's electronic database. The diagnosis of OA was made through the analysis of referral and clinic letters, plain radiographs, MRI reports and operation notes. Only those patients with persisting OA symptoms were included, those with OA and recent history of injury or trauma were excluded. During this time period, 222 knee arthroscopies were performed in total, 99 were identified with persistent OA symptoms.

Having identified these patients, referral letters were further analysed to identify the initial presenting symptom. Of the 99, 50 presented with pain, 28 presented with pain plus another symptom other than locking e.g. stiffness/swelling/giving-way, 21 presented with pain plus mechanical locking. According to current guidelines only these 21 patients should have been offered arthroscopic lavage as a form of treatment. In addition to these findings we identified what procedures had been carried out during arthroscopy for each symptom. Of those presenting with pain, 82% had a washout and debridement, 8% had washout, 4% had partial medial meniscectomy, 4% had lateral patellar release and 2% had partial lateral meniscectomy. Those with pain plus other symptoms not including locking, 82% had washout and debridement, 11% had partial medial meniscectomy, and 7% had a washout. Of those presenting with pain plus mechanical locking, 81% had washout and debridement and 19% had partial medial meniscectomy.

Following the procedure, we analysed the outcome of symptoms at first-follow up. The mean follow-up time was 8 weeks. Of those presenting with just pain, 44% showed improvement, 52% had no change/on-going symptoms, 2% were unknown. Of those with pain plus other symptoms other than locking, 57% showed improvement, 35% had no change/on-going symptoms, 8% unknown. Of those with pain plus mechanical locking, 80% showed improvement, 10% had no change/on-going symptoms, 10% unknown.

The results of this study support the current evidence that unless there are clear mechanical symptoms of locking, the use of arthroscopy in arthritic knee joints should be judicious and the reasons should be clearly documented.


W. El-nahas I. Nwachuku K. Khan J. Hodgkinson

Clinical success of total knee arthroplasty is correlated with correct orientation of the components. Controversy remains in the orthopaedic community as to whether the intramedullary or extramedullary tibial alignment guide is more accurate in the tibial cut.

Is there any difference between intramedullary and extramedullary jigs to achieve better accuracy of the tibial components in total knee replacements?

A retrospective study done on 100 patients during the time period 2007 to 2010. The 100 knee replacements were done by the same surgeon, where 50 patients had the intramedullary tibial alignment guide and the other 50 had the extramedullary one. The tibiofemoral angle was measured pre-operatively as well as post operatively, the tibial alignment angle was measured post operatively then the results were statistically analysed using the SPSS.

There was no significant difference between both groups regarding the tibial alignment angles. Both techniques proved accurate in producing an acceptable post operative tibial component alignment angle. We recommend orthopaedic surgeons choose either technique knowing that accuracy levels are similar.

The debate between intramedullary and extramedullary tibial cutting jigs/guides/ devices continues and most orthopaedic surgeons will use their preferred technique and will continue to achieve good post operative results as we have found in our centre. Our study is rare due to the fact we have a single surgeon performing both techniques, therefore controlling for any surgical experience or operating technique differences.