header advert
The Bone & Joint Journal Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from The Bone & Joint Journal

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Volume 67-B, Issue 5 November 1985

Access Required

G Bonney JP Williams

We report 16 cases in which the upper cervical spine was approached through the mouth for operative decompression and stabilisation, with or without removal of diseased tissues. The indications are discussed and the technique is described. Results are compared with those of other reported series. We believe that this operation has a place in the treatment of certain conditions affecting the upper part of the cervical spine and the foramen magnum, with or without involvement of the medulla and spinal cord.


A Muirhead AN Conner

Abnormalities of lung function in 92 children with idiopathic or congenital scoliosis are described. The changes are restrictive in type with reduction in vital capacity and total lung capacity but normal residual volume. In children whose curves had an early onset, the amount by which vital capacity was reduced depended on the severity of the deformity; in those whose curves began in adolescence this severity had little or no effect on vital capacity. Most adolescents with idiopathic curves had normal or near normal lung volumes and measurement of vital capacity proved to be a reliable screening test. We therefore advocate a simple approach to the pre-operative pulmonary investigation of scoliotic patients; only a few require full spirometry.


C Gerber F Terrier R Ganz

Symptomatic impingement of the rotator cuff between the humeral head and the coracoid process has been studied and three varieties recognised: idiopathic, iatrogenic and traumatic. In all three the clinical findings consisted of pain in front of the shoulder, referred to the upper arm and forearm, and especially felt during forward flexion and medial rotation; the pain could be reproduced by medial rotation with the arm in 90 degrees of abduction, or by adduction with the shoulder flexed to 90 degrees. Patients were relieved of their symptoms by restoring adequate subcoracoid clearance.


RH Hawkins RJ Hawkins

We report a retrospective study of 46 patients with continuing difficulties after anterior reconstruction of a shoulder for instability. In 31 patients instability was still present; in 12 of these, posterior or multidirectional instability had not been recognised and a further 11 had an uncorrected anatomical defect. In 20 patients with significant pain there was often more than one cause: impingement syndrome was seen in nine, osteoarthritis in seven, implant irritation in four and instability alone in two. A disabling medial rotation contracture was seen in 10 patients, four of whom had painful osteoarthritis. We conclude that recurrence of symptoms may imply that the direction of the instability was not recognised, that an anterior repair should not be too tight, and that pain after successful stabilisation is often due to impingement.


JW Pritchett

Ten patients with humeral shaft fractures and no clinical or radiographic signs of healing after at least six weeks' immobilisation were treated by flexible intramedullary nailing using a closed retrograde technique. Bone grafting was not performed, and active movement was encouraged after operation. Nine fractures healed; the mean time to union was 10.5 weeks (range 6 to 22 weeks). One patient needed compression plating and bone grafting at 22 weeks, and another required re-operation for distal migration of the rods. There were no infections, nerve palsies or other complications. Stiffness of the shoulder which had developed during early treatment improved after operation.


VP Kumar P Balasubramaniam

The role of atmospheric pressure in providing static stability of the shoulder was studied experimentally in 24 cadaveric shoulders. Atmospheric air was allowed to enter the joint after puncturing the capsule. Three types of experiment were performed: in the first, the capsule was punctured after sequential division of the muscles; in the second, atmospheric air was let in by percutaneous puncture of of the capsule without dividing the muscles; and in the third, air was first let into the joint by percutaneous puncture of the capsule and then the muscles of the shoulder were divided. It was found that the intact shoulder subluxated after percutaneous puncture even without division of the overlying muscles or the capsule. Our findings suggest that negative pressure and muscle tone are the main static stabilisers of the shoulder, rather than the joint capsule.


M Garcia-Elias JM Salo

A patient with a fractured coracoid process in association with a dislocation of the shoulder is reported. The fracture was not recognised initially, and early mobilisation was encouraged; the widely separated fracture did not heal and a painful pseudarthrosis developed. We believe that this association may not be as rare as generally supposed, and emphasise the importance of careful clinical examination in patients with shoulder dislocation. If a coracoid fracture is suspected, lateral or oblique radiographs should be taken to confirm the diagnosis. A further radiograph after reduction is a useful precaution.


Access Required
M Letts R Locht J Wiens

Thirty-three Monteggia fracture-dislocations occurring in patients aged 2 to 15 years were reviewed. A follow-up of 2 to 7 years in 25 patients revealed that 88% had good to excellent results and 12% had results which were fair or poor. Closed reduction was successful in 24 of 28 cases and appeared to be very effective. Open reduction was required only for older children or when treatment was begun late. A mild hyperextension deformity at the elbow noted on follow-up of patients with anterior dislocation of the radial head seemed to support the theory that the injury is caused by hyperextension. A new classification of Monteggia fracture-dislocations in children is proposed.


Access Required
JJ Wiley JP Galey

Forty-six children with Monteggia fracture-dislocations have been studied. The circumstances of the accident could rarely be recalled so that the mechanism of injury remains unclear. The study did, however, confirm the importance of conservative management of the injury in children; unlike the adult variety, this gave very satisfactory results. Our review also supports the classification into three basic types of Monteggia lesion according to the direction of displacement of the dislocated radial head. For simplicity, all other types, variations or equivalents can be regarded as belonging to these basic patterns; in particular we include those controversial cases in which the radiohumeral dislocation is combined with a fractured olecranon.


C Milgrom M Giladi M Stein H Kashtan JY Margulies R Chisin R Steinberg Z Aharonson

In a prospective study of 295 male Israeli military recruits a 31% incidence of stress fractures was found. Eighty per cent of the fractures were in the tibial or femoral shaft, while only 8% occurred in the tarsus and metatarsus. Sixty-nine per cent of the femoral stress fractures were asymptomatic, but only 8% of those in the tibia. Even asymptomatic stress fractures do, however, need to be treated. Possible explanations for the unusually high incidence of stress fractures in this study are discussed.


BM Wroblewski P Shelley

A method of performing a biplanar intracapsular trochanteric osteotomy with a Gigli saw was designed and tested prospectively in 431 cases of Charnley low friction arthroplasty. Three methods of trochanteric reattachment were tested, and a double cross-over wire with a compression spring was best; this method was successful in 222 out of 226 patients (98.2%), of which half were revision operations. Adduction seemed to be the main movement leading to trochanteric detachment.


Access Required
P Hardcastle S Nade

Trendelenburg's test of function of the hip joint was first reported before radiology was available. At least four methods of performing it have since been described in the literature. We examined 50 normal subjects and 103 people with disorders affecting either the spine or the hip, in order to determine the different responses that occurred when they were asked to stand on one leg. This has enabled us to define a standard method of performing the Trendelenburg test, and to interpret the test as a method of assessing hip abductor function. The major pitfalls that result in misinterpretation, or false-positive responses, are pain, lack of cooperation from the patient, and impingement between the rib cage and the iliac crest. False-negative responses result from the patient using muscles above and below the pelvis, and from leaning beyond the hip on the standing side.


Access Required
MK Seth JK Khurana

Ten patients with 13 ankylosed elbows after burns are described. Six elbows, fixed in nearly full extension, had almost total functional disability; the other seven had varying amounts of deformity. In five of the 13 elbows there was a continuous bony mass with loss of the joint space; these were treated by a modified excision arthroplasty which restored good movement and useful function, though there was some lateral laxity. Six elbows had a posterior bony block; this was excised, which restored a useful arc of movement. The literature on bony ankylosis after burns is reviewed and the management of these cases in a developing country is described.


DJ Gates M Alms MM Cruz

Hinged casts and roller traction were used in two developing countries to treat fractured femora, most of which were due to road traffic accidents or civil violence. This method of treatment, developed by Neufeld, is particularly useful in the Third World because it uses local materials, adapted in a hospital workshop, and circumvents the difficulties and complications of standard traction and of operative treatment. The results are reported from 11 patients treated in Uganda in 1979 and from 110 treated in the Dominican Republic in 1981 and 1982. All but one fracture united without complication or significant shortening after a brief period in hospital. The method was easily taught to hospital staff and is strongly recommended.


BM Wroblewski

Twenty-two high-density polyethylene sockets from Charnley low-friction arthroplasties have been studied. Acrylic casts and shadowgraph techniques were used to measure both the real and radiographic rates of wear; these rates showed a significant correlation. In the sagittal plane, nine of the sockets had worn lateral to a line drawn vertically from the centre of curvature of the socket, 12 had worn medial to that line and only one was worn exactly in the line. In the coronal plane, nine sockets had worn in front of a similar vertical line, two behind that line and 11 had worn exactly in the line. Evidence of impingement of the neck of the stem onto the rim of the socket was found in 14 patients; this is considered to be one of the causes of socket loosening. The obvious solution is to reduce the diameter of the neck of the stem from 12.5 mm to 10 mm; provided that it is made of cold-formed, high nitrogen-content stainless steel, this narrower neck is strong enough not to fracture.


MR Karpinski H Piggott

Fifteen patients with identical symptoms of pain and tenderness at the tip of the greater trochanter are reviewed. Diagnosis by the referring doctor was usually osteoarthritis of the hip or sciatica, but localised tenderness and pain on resisted abduction were the only clinical signs. Radiographs were usually normal. Most cases were relieved by one or more local steroid injections. This disorder has much in common with tennis elbow, golfer's elbow, coccydynia and policeman's heel. We suggest that all these conditions may be traction syndromes.


Access Required
MA Freeman RA Sudlow MW Casewell SS Radcliff

A review of patients with an infected resurfacing prosthesis is presented. Eight patients with a loose infected prosthesis were treated by a one-stage exchange arthroplasty; six others with a well-fixed infected prosthesis were treated by drainage and antibiotics. All eight treated by exchange arthroplasty remained free of infection as did five of those treated by drainage. In four of these last five patients, the prosthesis was inserted without cement; the possible role of polymethylmethacrylate in the persistence of infection is discussed.


Full thickness samples of articular cartilage were removed from areas of chondromalacia on the medial and "odd" facets of the patellae of 21 adults and examined by histology, autoradiography and electron microscopy. Surface fibrillation, loss of superficial matrix staining and reduced 35SO4 labelling was seen, with little change in the deep zone. Ten cases showed "fibrous metaplasia" of the superficial cartilage with definite evidence of cell division and apparent smoothing of the surface. Scattered chondrocyte replication appeared to occur in the surrounding intact cartilage. The findings suggest that early lesions in chondromalacia patellae may heal either by cartilage or fibrous metaplasia and that this may account for the resolution of clinical symptoms.


M Tew W Waugh IW Forster

Many knee replacement prostheses, embodying various principles of design, are now available and there is need for a method by which valid comparisons of results can be made. An important criterion of success is durability, so the length of time the prostheses have been in situ must be taken into account. Such a method is proposed here and is applied to the results of 673 knee replacements, of nine different types, implanted at the same hospital between 1970 and 1983. A prosthesis was considered to have failed if it had been removed or persistently caused severe pain. Two types of prosthesis were found to be significantly less successful than the other seven, between which none consistently showed significant superiority. Results for the seven types were similar despite the facts that they had been used for knees with different degrees of damage, some as secondary implants, and that they were of different design and at different stages of technical development. The more recently introduced types of prosthesis, designed to have theoretical advantages, were found in practice to be no more successful than the models they superseded.


SN Bell PE Campbell WG Cole MB Menelaus

We present three cases of a previously undescribed condition characterised by unilateral tibia vara associated with an area of focal fibrocartilaginous dysplasia in the medial aspect of the proximal tibia. The three children affected were aged 9, 15 and 27 months respectively. Two required tibial osteotomy, but in one the deformity resolved without treatment. The pathogenesis of the focal lesion remains conjectural; the most likely explanation is that the mesenchymal anlage of the tibial metaphysis has, for unknown reasons, developed abnormally at the insertion of the pes anserinus.


BG Bolton-Maggs RA Sudlow MA Freeman

We report a retrospective study of 62 total ankle arthroplasties performed between 1972 and 1981. Forty-one of these have been reviewed clinically after an average follow-up of five and a half years; only 13 can be described as satisfactory. The complications encountered in all 62 arthroplasties are detailed, the most significant being superficial wound healing problems, talar collapse, and loosening of the components; 13 prosthetic joints have already been removed and arthrodesis attempted. The management of the complications is discussed. In view of the high complication rate and the generally poor long-term clinical results, we recommend arthrodesis as the treatment of choice for the painful stiff arthritic ankle, regardless of the underlying pathological process.


PM Hutchins BK Foster DC Paterson EA Cole

One-hundred and seventy patients with 252 club feet treated by early posterior release were reviewed after a follow-up averaging 15 years 10 months. The feet were assessed both functionally and clinically and the results related to any bony deformity found radiographically; a satisfactory result was obtained in 81%. Lateral tibial torsion was examined and found to be less than in a normal population. The relationship between primary bone deformity and eventual functional result was examined, and a classification of talar dome deformity introduced. The range of ankle movement was a major factor in determining the functional result, and this in turn was influenced by the degree of talar dome flattening. It is suggested that the primary bone deformity present at birth dictates the eventual result of treatment.


B Ferris C Jones

Aspergillus infection of the spine is rare; for it to lead to paraplegia is still more rare. When this does occur it is usually treated by decompression and antifungal agents, but the results have usually been poor. We report two cases of successful conservative treatment of Aspergillus paraplegia in patients with chronic granulomatous disease.


SN Bell BJ Dooley BM O'Brien NF Bright

A cortical bone graft on a muscle pedicle was taken from the ulna and transferred to bridge a complete defect of the radius in 16 dogs. In 14 control dogs a free graft was used, that is, one without a muscle pedicle. Union in the group with pedicle grafts was far superior to that in the group with free grafts, mainly because in those with pedicle grafts there was good subperiosteal new bone formation from active viable periosteum. In six of the pedicle grafts the viability of some osteocytes was retained over a 12-week period and in five the graft was almost completely replaced by new bone.


D Amir P Mogle H Weinberg

A family of 114 people in six generations, of whom 45 were affected by multiple epiphysial dysplasia, was described in this Journal in May 1960. We have been able to review them again 23 years later, and also to report on the type and incidence of the disease in more children and in a further generation. The relative severity of the disease in different branches of the family has been unchanged through the generations. Patients who were previously hopelessly crippled can today be rehabilitated by total hip replacement. Genetic counselling and birth control have reduced the relative and absolute numbers of affected children; this is tending to make the disease self-limiting.


Y Hirasawa Y Katsumi T Tokioka

We have studied the restoration of sensation in 24 patients after operations involving the digital nerves of the thumb. These comprised 10 neurorrhaphies, two nerve graftings, five replantations, one toe-to-thumb transfer and six neurovascular island flaps. The average follow-up period was 46 months. Greater sensitivity was found in the moving two-point discrimination (2PD) test than in the static 2PD test. The results of the Semmes-Weinstein test showed good correlation with the static 2PD test. Porter's letter test showed correlations with both 2PD tests, and the pulp-writing test showed good correlation with the moving 2PD test. The neurorrhaphy cases had the best results using the static 2PD and Semmes-Weinstein test, and had good restoration of sensation; the replantation cases were next best. After neurovascular island flaps, patients exhibited hypersensitivity, double sensation and distorted images on the pulp-writing test. Using this same test the nerve grafting cases had distorted touch perception and perceived a straight line as a curve. The pulp-writing test, using moving touch, is one method of examining mechanoreceptors and shows to what extent the patient perceives what touches the finger pulp; it gives a better indication of higher functions than the 2PD test.


M Lehto VC Duance D Restall

The presence of the connective tissue components fibronectin and the different types of collagen was demonstrated by histological and immunohistological methods in the granulation and scar tissue of a healing injury in rat muscle. The effects of physical activity on granulation tissue production, scar formation and muscle regeneration at various stages of healing were studied. It was shown that immobilisation after injury accelerates granulation tissue production, but if continued too long, leads to contraction of the scar and to poor structural organisation of the components of regenerating muscle and scar tissue. However, a certain period of immobilisation, about five days for rat muscle, is required to allow newly-formed granulation tissue to cover the injured area and to have sufficient tensile strength to withstand subsequent mobilisation. This mobilisation, at the correct interval, seems essential for the quicker resorption of scar tissue and the better structural organisation of the muscle.


AA Amis Campbell JH Miller

The calcaneal tendons of rabbits were excised and either replaced with a carbon or polyester fibre implant, or left as controls. The strength of the neotendons and their mode of failure under tension were examined at intervals up to six months after operation. Return to near normal strength took six months to develop, suggesting that patients having ligament or tendon reconstructions should not resume normal activity for several months. Carbon fibre-based neotendons showed progressive elongation which, unless avoided by a sufficient period of immobilisation, would affect the functional result.


PM Hutchins MF Macnicol

Twenty young men with displaced fractures of one or more long bones in the lower limb, but with no evidence of cranial, thoracic or abdominal injury, were studied prospectively. Although all the patients became hypoxaemic, the six who developed signs of respiratory distress (Group 1) were found to have a significantly lower arterial oxygen tension and a significantly higher rate of urinary urea excretion than the remaining 14 patients whose pulmonary function appeared to be clinically normal (Group 2). Circulating fat macroglobules were identified in three cases, only one of whom was in Group 1, and hence the tests for fat embolism were not of prognostic value. Although an immunodeficient state is considered to contribute to the pulmonary insufficiency which occurs after major trauma, convincing evidence of a lymphocyte-suppressive agent was found in only one patient.