header advert
The Bone & Joint Journal Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from The Bone & Joint Journal

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Volume 66-B, Issue 2 March 1984

Access Required

Fractures of the hand Pages 159 - 167
Access Required

JP McElwaine J Colville

A study of excision arthroplasty (Girdlestone's pseudarthrosis) for infected total hip replacements is presented. Twenty-two patients were reviewed with a minimum follow-up of one year. Reduction in pain was significant but the functional results were poor. Factors contributing to poor function were old age, poor medical condition and arthritis of the contralateral hip; these were in addition to the gross instability resulting from the pseudarthrosis. The patients were easily fatigued and dependent on external supports; calipers were found to be unacceptable. The symptoms after excision arthroplasty are compared with those before the original hip replacement.


RL Leyshon JP Matthews

Nine cases of acetabular erosion following insertion of the Monk "hard top" hip prosthesis for subcapital fractures are presented. All of these patients had significant symptoms and represented 5% of the total group. In our experience acetabular erosion has proved to be a significant complication of the Monk "hard top" prosthesis.


H Wahlig E Dingeldein HW Buchholz M Buchholz F Bachmann

A randomised, double-blind study was performed in two groups of 15 patients undergoing total hip replacements, using antibiotic-loaded acrylic cement containing 0.5 g and 1.0 g gentamicin base respectively per 40 g pack of powdered polymer. Postoperatively, the gentamicin levels in the blood, in the urine and in the wound drainage fluid were measured. In both groups of patients, the serum gentamicin concentrations were low whereas the wound drainage fluid contained highly effective antibacterial concentrations. Serum, urine and wound secretion levels showed approximately two-fold higher concentrations in the group of patients receiving the higher gentamicin load.


RW Nutton RG Checketts

A series of 167 patients with Charnley-type total hip replacements were studied retrospectively to determine the incidence of trochanteric non-union, the degree of postoperative trochanteric displacement, and the relation between these two complications. The power in the hip abductor muscles, measured with a load-cell device, was significantly reduced if the trochanteric fragment had displaced proximally by more than 3 cm; 12% of those studied fell into this group and, as a consequence, had a poorer result. It was concluded that displacement of the trochanter was of greater importance than bony union in determining function in the replaced hip. Because these unwanted problems may compromise an otherwise successful operation, it is suggested tentatively that trochanteric osteotomy should be abandoned except for difficult primary operations or for revision procedures.


Y Mirovsky A Axer D Hendel

The residual shortening of the affected limbs in 55 patients treated by subtrochanteric varus derotation osteotomy was compared with that in 71 patients treated with weight-relieving calipers. When last examined, 43 of the former group and 47 of the latter had reached complete or near-complete skeletal maturity. The average follow-up was 9.1 years in the osteotomised patients and 5.25 years in the conservatively treated group. The average residual shortening (0.9 cm) was identical in both groups. In most patients the initial shortening caused by the osteotomy gradually corrected as, over a period of several years, the postosteotomy angle gradually became less varus. Any residual shortening depended principally on the severity of inhibition of endochondral ossification at the proximal femoral growth plate. Less residual shortening was seen in children who were under seven years of age at the onset of symptoms (under eight at operation) in whom the open-wedge technique of osteotomy was employed and who had good anatomical results.


P Hamberg J Gillquist J Lysholm

Arthroscopy is now well established as a method of diagnosing meniscal lesions, and its advantages have been pointed out in several reports. Arthroscopic surgery, however, is difficult to master, so that for meniscectomy open methods remain commoner. By taking advantage of the new instruments and equipment developed for arthroscopic operations, a modified technique of open meniscectomy, designed to improve the postoperative course, has been developed. In a prospective randomised study, the results after this modified open meniscectomy were comparable with those obtained after arthroscopic operation and were significantly better than those after conventional meniscectomy. The best results of all, however, were those after partial arthroscopic meniscectomy.


The suppression of the immediate postmeniscectomy synovial reaction by a potent prostaglandin inhibitor (flurbiprofen 400 mg daily) resulted in significantly less knee pain and swelling in 50 patients compared to 50 age-matched controls taking a simple analgesic (paracetamol 4 g daily) (P less than 0.001), thus enhancing recovery by three to four weeks. In the patients undergoing partial meniscectomy knee function was restored by 27 days, a figure comparable with endoscopic methods.


RL Leyshon GM Channon DH Jenkins ZA Ralis

Sixty-three knees with chronic ligamentous instability treated with flexible carbon fibre are reviewed. Assessment was by pre-operative and postoperative grading of function in work and sport, together with a subjective evaluation of the result based on stability. Fifteen knees had collateral repairs, seven had cruciate repairs and 41 had combined collateral and cruciate repairs. Overall, 71% of knees showed improvement in function and 67% had good or excellent results subjectively. Clinical examination did not correlate well with the patient's evaluation of the result. Nineteen unselected cases with intra-articular (cruciate) carbon fibre had arthroscopies. Infiltration of collagen tissues into the cruciate replacement was a slower process than at the extra-articular (collateral) site. There was no clinical or macroscopic evidence of synovitis but microscopically there was evidence of synovial irritation.


Access Required
Y Mirovsky N Halperin D Hendel

Disruption of the major ligaments of the knee was seen in six young men, five parachutists and a house painter, after what we have termed abduction-traction injury. This unusual complaint results from the application of a sudden block to the ankle while falling head first, leading to traction and abduction of the knee. All the patients underwent operations, generally with unsatisfactory results. At operation tears of the anterior cruciate ligament, medial collateral ligament and posterior oblique ligament were seen in each case; in four patients the posterior capsule and in three the posterior cruciate ligament also were torn. In one patient the lateral collateral ligament was torn and the lateral meniscotibial ligament was avulsed. The compression component is absent in this type of injury and consequently the menisci and the osteochondral surfaces of the tibia and femur remained intact in each case.


CB Howard I Winston W Bell I Mackie DH Jenkins

Ruptures of the calcaneal tendon which present late may be repaired using carbon fibre to induce a neotendon. The operative technique is described and the results of five cases reviewed. The average muscle power obtained was 88% of normal, and the thickness of the neotendon was 148% of that of the normal side. It would appear that this tendon formation in man is comparable to that previously described in sheep.


GA Evans P Hardcastle AD Frenyo

One hundred patients with acute ruptures of the lateral ligaments of the ankle were randomly allocated either to conservative treatment in a plaster cast or to operative repair. With the aid of stress tenography, the extent of the injury was established. There were 30 patients with isolated anterior talofibular ruptures and 20 with additional calcaneofibular ligament ruptures in each treatment group. Operative repair was associated with a higher incidence of complications in the first weeks, and slightly delayed the patients' return to work. At an independent two-year review there was no evidence that operative repair offered improved symptomatic or functional benefit.


Access Required
B Helal M Greiss

A review is presented of 508 feet in 310 patients after telescoping osteotomy of the lesser metatarsals for metatarsalgia. The patients were predominantly female (80%), with a mean age of 55 years; the range of follow-up was 1 to 12 years. In 22% of the patients the metatarsalgia was associated with rheumatoid arthritis. Improvements in assessment and modifications in technique are reported and the management of complications is discussed. The results show that telescoping osteotomy for established cases of pressure metatarsalgia is a simple and reliable operation. Permanent relief of symptoms can be expected in over 80% of patients.


MF Macnicol S Voutsinas

The accessory navicular is occasionally the source of pain and local tenderness over the instep. If conservative measures fail, surgical treatment may be required and the results of 62 operations to one or both feet in 47 patients are reported. Twenty-six patients were treated by the Kidner operation, in which the main insertion of the tibialis posterior is re-routed; in the remaining 21 the ossicle was merely excised. Excision was as effective as the Kidner technique, provided that the medial surface of the main navicular bone was contoured to prevent any residual prominence. Both procedures were successful in relieving symptoms in the majority of cases and failures resulted from errors in the selection of patients or in the surgical technique. Correction of any associated flat foot was secondary to growth and maturation of the foot rather than to the operation; hence the Kidner procedure does not confer any particular advantages over simple excision.


AI Lang-Stevenson WJ Sharrard

The results and complications of the use of Bailey-Dubow extensible rods in 28 lower limb bones of 10 patients suffering from osteogenesis imperfecta are reviewed. Twenty-eight operations were for the primary insertion of the rods into the femur or tibia; a further nine operations were needed for the treatment of complications. These complications included 10 instances of proximal migration of the distal end of the rod, one of incorrect placement in the proximal femur, four instances of loosening of a T-piece and three of infection about a rod, two of these being in one child. Most complications arose from technical faults at insertion. The details of technique which have evolved from experience are described. Only one fracture has occurred in a bone after correct placement of a rod. Of the 10 patients, seven of whom had never walked before, seven were able to walk and two others had achieved walking, but were under treatment for complications at the time of review. There was no evidence of damage to growth epiphyses. The greater technical complexity of insertion of Bailey-Dubow rods is well justified by the results obtained when they are correctly applied.


JL Pozo HA Crockard AO Ransford

Basilar impression is a well-recognised though rare complication of osteogenesis imperfecta. Three patients, all members of the same family, with advanced basilar impression complicating osteogenesis imperfecta tarda, are described. The clinical features in these cases illustrate the natural history of this condition: from asymptomatic ventricular dilatation, through the foramen magnum compression syndrome, to death from brain-stem compression. The radiological criteria on which the diagnosis is based, are defined. Review of the literature reveals only seven previously documented cases, all in patients with mild forms of osteogenesis imperfecta. The unusually low incidence of basilar impression in osteogenesis imperfecta and its apparent restriction to patients with mild forms of the disease is discussed. The examination of close relatives of patients with basilar impression and osteogenesis imperfecta is emphasised in order to anticipate the onset of severe neurological complications.


Access Required
SS Babhulkar WB Tayade SK Babhulkar

The familiar picture of spinal tuberculosis is one of destruction of adjacent vertebral bodies and of the intervening disc. There are, however, other patients without these radiographic changes and with no clinical deformity who present with symptoms and signs of compression of the spinal cord or cauda equina. These patients fall into two different groups: those with tuberculosis of the neural arch; and those with extra-osseous extradural tuberculosis. Both may require laminectomy, but whereas the first has bony involvement and a cold abscess, the second has neither.


LW Lowe AJ Miller RL Allum DW Higginson

This paper describes the development, operative technique and results of an unconstrained total elbow arthroplasty. Forty-seven elbow replacements were carried out in 44 patients between 1974 and 1982. There was a high rate of loosening in the early condylar replacements. The results in patients with post-traumatic arthritis were poor. The later design employs an ulnar stem, with a humeral stem if the distal humeral bone stock is poor. When used in carefully selected patients with rheumatoid arthritis, pain is reduced significantly, stability and movement are preserved and function is improved.


RK Soni ME Cavendish

Eighty elbows in 65 patients with an average age of 57 years have had two-part non-constrained Liverpool elbow arthroplasties performed since 1974. Fifty-five had rheumatoid arthritis, eight osteoarthritis or ankylosis secondary to injury, one osteochondritis dissecans and one pyknodysostosis. The average preoperative range of movement was 42 degrees to 112 degrees with 47 degrees of pronation and 42 degrees of supination. There was significant gain in the arc of movements at follow-up: 32 degrees in the extension-flexion range (average range 32 degrees to 134 degrees of flexion) and 42 degrees in forearm rotation (average pronation 69 degrees and supination 62 degrees). Before operation severe pain was the predominating symptom in 43 elbows (53.8%) but after replacement there was only moderate pain in five elbows (6.2%). The results were excellent in 42 (52.5%), good in 15 (18.7%), fair in 9 (11.3%) and unsatisfactory or poor in 14 (17.5%). Eight elbows required revision of the arthroplasty: three were post-traumatic, disorganised or osteoarthritic joints, three rheumatoid and both elbows in the patient with pyknodysostosis. Loosening of the prosthesis (particularly the humeral component) was the common factor necessitating revision. Of six rheumatoid elbows needing removal of the implant, four had deep infection, one had a dislodged humeral component as a result of injury and in one a divided olecranon had developed non-union. Rheumatoid elbows benefited more than post-traumatic arthritic elbows from the operation. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)


Simultaneous dislocation of the elbow and the proximal radio-ulnar joint is rare. Two children with this uncommon injury are reported. One child had a transverse divergent dislocation that was treated successfully by closed reduction. The other had a convergent dislocation (or translocation of the radius and ulna) which needed open reduction. Convergent dislocation is even rarer than transverse divergent dislocation, and this is believed to be the first time it has been reported.


NJ Goddard JA Fixsen

The use of a rotation osteotomy of the humerus in 10 patients with disabling loss of lateral rotation at the shoulder due to brachial plexus birth injuries is described. The operative technique and complications are discussed. Before operation only one patient was independent, but after operation nine of them were. Restoration of lateral rotation at the shoulder can improve the function, the appearance and the independence of these handicapped patients.


GD Sundararaj K Mani

Simultaneous paralysis of the ulnar, median and radial nerves is seen in about 1% of hands with nerve involvement in Hansen's disease. Forty such cases were treated between 1955 and 1976; 35 of these have been followed up. In two hands there was a high radial, median and ulnar palsy and these left no scope for reconstruction. The other 33 cases which underwent two-stage reconstructive surgery are presented here. The first stage consisted of restoring active extension of the wrist, fingers and thumb: for this purpose the ideal muscles for transfer are pronator teres, flexor carpi radialis and palmaris longus respectively, and muscle power exceeding Grade 3 (on the MRC classification) was achieved in 89%, 96%, and 100% of these individual transfers. Arthrodesis of the wrist is not recommended when suitable muscles are available for transfer. The second stage of reconstruction attempts to restore intrinsic function of the fingers and opposition of the thumb; the sublimis is ideal for both purposes and satisfactory restoration of function was achieved in 89% and 85% of cases respectively. Ten of the 18 hands in which all five tendons were transferred had good or excellent results.


Access Required
F Bertoni P Calderoni P Bacchini M Campanacci

The clinical and pathological features of six cases of desmoplastic fibroma of bone are presented. Desmoplastic fibroma is rarely seen as a primary tumour of bone; when it does occur the sites of predilection are the long bones, but other sites such as the scapula and os calcis can be involved. Radiographically the lesion tends to expand the bone from within; it is well-demarcated and lytic, often with a trabeculated soap-bubble appearance. The cellular structure and the morphological arrangement are similar to those of aggressive fibromatosis of soft tissues. Differential diagnosis from malignant spindle-cell lesions of bone is important because the treatment of choice for desmoplastic fibroma of bone is simply excision with a thin layer of healthy tissue.


A Uchida SM Nade ER McCartney W Ching

Ceramics have many properties which might make them suitable alternatives to bone grafts. This present study was done to find a suitable biodegradable porous ceramic for human bone replacement. Three different porous ceramics (calcium aluminate, calcium hydroxyapatite and tricalcium phosphate), with interlinked pores of two size ranges (150 to 210 micron), were implanted into the skulls of rats and rabbits for up to six months; the interaction with surrounding bone, which is virtually devoid of bone marrow, was then assessed. The ceramics caused no adverse biological response. Tissue ingrowth into pores throughout the implant was seen in all three types and in both pore sizes of ceramic, but the density of the penetrating tissue was far less for calcium aluminate than for calcium hydroxyapatite or tricalcium phosphate. For each type of ceramic, the soft-tissue ingrowth was more dense with the larger pore size, and with a longer period of implantation. Bone ingrowth was not usually seen within the pores of any ceramic. There were no differences in the histological findings between the rats and the rabbits. The results demonstrate that it is possible to produce ceramic materials with a porous structure which allows ingrowth of tissue and biological fluids.