header advert
The Bone & Joint Journal Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from The Bone & Joint Journal

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Volume 65-B, Issue 4 August 1983

Closed meniscectomy Pages 373 - 374
Access Required

Tourniquet paralysis Pages 374 - 375
Access Required

Ultra-clean air Pages 375 - 377
Access Required

RJ Tregonning

A review is presented of early results of a consecutive series of 45 bucket-handle or flap tears of a meniscus treated by closed partial meniscectomy over a two-year period. The mean operating time was 45 minutes. All patients were treated in hospital and 39 of 41 assessable patients were discharged within 24 hours of operation. The mean time to return to work was 12.9 days. One patient later required arthrotomy to excise a residual nubbin of meniscal tissue which had been incompletely removed and caused pain. At follow-up at a mean of eight months after operation only one patient had temporary mechanical symptoms not explained by further injury or degenerative change. Seven patients who had undergone previous open meniscectomy reported improvement after closed meniscectomy in relation to both pain and disability. It is concluded that closed partial meniscectomy for these common meniscal tears is successful in the early relief of symptoms if all unstable fragments are excised. The technique is difficult to learn but is associated with rapid rehabilitation and a high rate of acceptance by the patient.


DT Shakespeare HS Rigby

A retrospective series of 272 operatively proven bucket-handle tears of the meniscus has been studied to define the natural history of the tear and to assess the accuracy of arthrography as a diagnostic technique. A simple twist, or a sporting injury accounted for most tears in the 196 patients on whom information was sufficient to allow analysis. There was, however, either no known trauma or merely a history of crouching in 20 per cent of patients. These were distributed evenly throughout the age range. Most of the 272 patients presented either with a locked knee (43 per cent) or with a history of locking (37 per cent). Fifty per cent of those with a previous history of locking but who were clinically unlocked at the time of operation, had displaced bucket-handle tears, indicating that unlocking of the knee joint frequently represents anterior extension of the tear, rather than relocation of the displaced fragment of meniscus. Significant meniscal tears were identified in 77 per cent of the 187 arthogram reports that were studied. Most errors in diagnosis seemed to occur when the separated fragment was hidden in the intercondylar notch and the peripheral rim was misinterpreted as an intact meniscus.


FW Paterson EL Trickey

A group of 40 patients with unstable knees due to a combination of a meniscal tear with a rupture of the anterior cruciate ligament was studied to assess the effects of treatment by meniscectomy alone. The results were assessed both subjectively and objectively, but emphasis was placed on the symptoms rather than the physical signs of instability. Meniscectomy alone cured the symptoms of instability in 22 of the patients and a further eight required no further surgical treatment; bucket-handle tears were associated with a good result and posterior-horn tears with a poor result. The remaining 10 patients later underwent an additional procedure to reconstruct the ligament because of persisting symptoms. It was concluded that in patients with this combined lesion the torn meniscus should be dealt with first. In young patients with a posterior-horn tear it would be justifiable to perform a ligamentous reconstruction at the same time as the meniscectomy.


C Gerber P Matter

Sixty-five knees were subjected to a kinematic analysis using the instant-centre technique in order to determine the effect of deficiency of the anterior cruciate ligament on the biomechanics of active movement in the knee. The instant-centre pathway in acute ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament was found to have a specific abnormality. This corresponded with a positive pivot-shift sign, but was present even when that sign was not clinically detectable. Primary repair using a transosseous wire suture did not usually abolish the biomechanical abnormality. The data provide a possible explanation for the doubtful prognosis of primary repair of this ligament and encourage clinical and biomechanical evaluation of alternative procedures such as primary augmented repair.


MD Northmore-Ball DJ Dandy RW Jackson

The results of three different types of meniscectomy have been compared in 219 knees, 71 treated by arthroscopic partial meniscectomy, 45 treated by open partial meniscectomy, and 103 treated by open total meniscectomy, with a mean follow-up of 4.3 years. Knees which had undergone previous operations or had other simultaneous operative procedures or ligamentous damage were excluded. Knees with chondromalacia were included provided that this did not amount to frank osteoarthritis. Simple indicators were used for the rate of early recovery from the operation, and the Tapper and Hoover scale was used to record the symptomatic results in the longer term. It was found that knees treated by arthroscopic partial meniscectomy did considerably better than the others by all the criteria used. In most parts of the study there was a clear gradation between the results of the three types of treatment: arthroscopic techniques did better than open operations, and partial meniscectomy did better than total meniscectomy.


MA Freeman GW Bradley

Clinical experience of the ICLH method of resurfacing the hip now spans 10 years. The first 36 arthroplasties, performed between 1972 and 1974, have been previously reported. This review covers in detail 204 such arthroplasties performed between 1975 and 1979 using a standard operative technique and prosthesis; these hips were consecutive and entirely unselected. Follow-up averaged 3.2 years (range two to six years). Successful hips are comparable to hips successfully replaced with stemmed prostheses. The rates of perioperative complications and failure due to infection, ectopic ossification, fracture of the femoral neck, and dislocation are favourably comparable to rates reported for stemmed total hip arthroplasties. The rate of aseptic loosening (17 per cent) greatly exceeded that found for stemmed total hip arthroplasties. Errors of patient selection, operative technique and prosthetic design have been identified. It is concluded that, although resurfacing arthroplasty of the hip may be an appealing procedure with theoretical advantages in certain instances, patient selection is essential, operative technique is demanding and changes in the design of the prosthesis are required. The procedure is still in evolution and therefore it should not yet be generally employed.


VV Surin K Sundholm L Backman

The risk factors associated with 34 deep infections from a consecutive series of 803 total hip replacements have been analysed using standard actuarial methods. The follow-up ranged from 3 to 10 years. Absence of prophylactic antibiotics, complications after operation, discharging wounds, previous operations and remote infection were related to the development of deep periprosthetic infection. An early discharge from the wound with growth of micro-organisms, though superficial in appearance, proved to be associated with a high risk of developing late deep infection. The mechanisms associated with deep infection involved multiple interrelated risk factors. Multiple regression analysis of our data indicated that these risk factors, when acting together, potentiate their effect on the development of the deep infection.


Access Required

The results of treating 148 hips in 135 children (aged 7 to 16 at the onset of management) for Perthes' disease are analysed. Cases are classified according to the amount of epiphysial containment and the results assessed according to the degree of preserved sphericity. It is concluded that to obtain satisfactory results in this age group treatment should be prolonged until the restitution of the epiphysis so as to maintain the initially achieved containment throughout the reparative process. Containment should be secured initially as follows: by non-operative treatment, in children aged seven to nine years with contained and also with slightly subluxated epiphyses; by femoral osteotomy, in children aged seven to nine years with severely subluxated epiphyses and also in children aged 10 and more with slightly subluxated epiphyses; by Salter's osteotomy, in children aged 10 years and more with contained epiphyses; by Chiari's osteotomy, in all crushed but smooth epiphyses, and also in children aged 10 and more with severely subluxated epiphyses; and by cheilectomy, in all crushed and saddle-shaped epiphyses, but only during the regenerative stage of the disease.


J Vegter JA van den Broek

A diastasis between the femoral head and the acetabulum can be achieved for a short while by the application of manual traction on the lower extremity. The intra-articular low-pressure area can be visualised radiographically and is known as a "vacuum phenomenon". The resulting arthrogram clearly outlines the shape, thickness and extent of the cartilage. In the presence of an effusion the diastasis occurs without a vacuum phenomenon. This simple, non-invasive and inoffensive method of traction radiography will not only show abnormalities of the cartilage but also demonstrate the presence or absence of an effusion of the hip.


K Yong-Hing SP Tchang

The operative technique and result of treatment of traumatic radio-ulnar synostosis in two patients are described. In both, the treatment was excision of the cross-union and interposition of a free non-vascularised fat transplant. The functional result was excellent, and there was no evidence of regrowth of the synostosis at two and three years respectively.


MA Smith GF Savidge EJ Fountain

Six patients with severe haemophilic arthropathy of the elbow have been treated by limited excision arthroplasty using a sheet of silicone rubber as an interposition membrane. There were no complications. The symptoms and signs before and after operation have been assessed using the grading system advocated recently by the World Federation of Haemophilia. In all cases there was relief of pain and increased movement. Moreover, the subsequent incidence of spontaneous haemorrhage into the elbow has been reduced with considerable cost benefit.


Access Required
K Aho K Sainio M Kianta E Varpanen

We describe a 31-year-old man in whom a paresis and sensory defect of the left arm developed after amputation of the index finger. The operation was performed in a bloodless field, using a pneumatic tourniquet. The sensory defect resolved in two months and the paresis in five and a half months. We consider that direct pressure produced by the tourniquet caused the nerve lesion. It is probable that the tourniquet was inflated to a pressure of 500 millimetres of mercury instead of the intended 250 millimetres of mercury because of a faulty gauge. In order to avoid this rare complication, it is advisable to check the tourniquet gauge each time before use.


Synovial chondromatosis is a rare metaplastic condition affecting major synovial joints. It is extremely rare in childhood. The two children reported here are believed to be the youngest patients with this condition affecting the knee to have been described in the literature.


Access Required
JP Levai HC McLeod MA Freeman

The results of resurfacing or not resurfacing the articular cartilage of the patella were reviewed in 71 knees--47 with rheumatoid arthritis and 24 with osteoarthritis--which had been replaced with the ICLH prosthesis. Two rheumatoid and osteoporotic patellae developed transverse fractures with separation and were excluded from the review. The results showed that resurfacing the patella greatly reduced peripatellar pain with no counter-balancing disadvantage.


RG Burwell NJ James F Johnson JK Webb YG Wilson

This paper reports a new method for expressing numerically asymmetry of the contour of the back in a forward-bending position. Information is given at three spinal levels (T8, T12 and L3) for 636 schoolchildren aged 8 to 15 years. Rib-hump and lumbar-hump scores were standardised to create trunk asymmetry scores (TASs) making comparison possible between children of different age, size and sex. Two groups of children were defined: those with clinically straight spines (585 children); and those with clinical evidence of lateral spinal curves (51 children). In the children with clinically straight spines the main findings were: about 1:4 had objectively detectable rib and lumbar humps; female-to-male ratios were 1.2:1 for the thoracic region and 1.4:1 for the lumbar region; right humps were about 10 times more common than left; TASs in the boys and girls at each spinal level had normal distributions about means to the right of zero (where zero represents perfect symmetry); at T8 and T12, a wider scatter of TASs in girls than in boys; at L3, larger TASs in girls than in boys; a relation between shortening of one lower limb and a contralateral hump on the back; and no relation to age (except at L3), stature (corrected for age) or handedness. The findings are discussed in relation to possible causes of back contour asymmetry, early diagnosis of scoliosis by screening, sexual dimorphism and significance for the pathogenesis of idiopathic scoliosis. Ten children with clinically straight spines and larger TASs, and 42 out of 51 children with clinical evidence of lateral spinal curves in the forward-bending position attended for radiographic examination. Twelve children had "scoliosis curves" of 11 degrees or more as defined by the Scoliosis Research Society. The results are reported in relation to TASs, spinal curve angle (Cobb) and vertebral rotation.


Access Required
JV Fowles CL Olweny E Katongole-Mbidde A Lukanga-Ndawula R Owor

Of 290 Ugandan children and adolescents with proven Burkitt's lymphoma 11 had lesions in the long bones or the pelvis. These started in the medulla as small osteolytic foci which coalesced and penetrated the cortex causing subperiosteal new bone formation in layers or spicules, and giving rise to large soft-tissue masses. Common sites were the femoral and tibial diaphyses and the metaphyses around the knee. Five were in the epiphyses. Other sites were the pelvis, humerus and ulna. One patient had a lymphomatous synovial effusion of the knee. In the lower limbs the lesions were often bilateral and symmetrical. Five patients had pathological fractures. Radiologically the lesions mimicked Ewing's sarcoma, osteosarcoma, osteomyelitis, acute leukaemia, syphilis and yaws, but clinically they were relatively painless, an important differential diagnostic feature. In the five patients with sustained remissions after chemotherapy the lesions and fractures healed well and the growth plates were undamaged.



Access Required
DJ Ross PA Dieppe I Watt JH Newman

Five elderly patients with chronic pyrophosphate arthropathy developed stress fractures of the tibia. All patients had deformed, painful knees with the result that their increasing symptoms were not readily attributed to a stress fracture. Such a possibility should be considered in patients with chronic pyrophosphate arthropathy since early recognition makes management of the stress fracture easier.


AR Raji RE Bowden

Apart from preliminary notices of present work, previous reports of experimental and clinical trials of the effects of a high-peak pulsed electromagnetic field (PEMF) on degeneration and regeneration of peripheral nerves lacked statistical analysis. Therefore, we designed experiments with standardised operative, histological, cytological and morphometric techniques to assess the effect of PEMF on lesions of the common peroneal nerves in paired male rats matched for age, environmental conditions and level and type of lesion. One of two types of lesion was induced in the left common peroneal nerve: in 12 pairs of rats the nerve was crushed just above the knee and in the remaining 12 pairs the nerve was cut and immediately sutured at the same level. The right common peroneal nerve of each rat served as a control. Animals received 15 minutes of PEMF produced by a Diapulse machine or sham treatment daily for periods ranging from three and a half days to eight weeks after injury. Healthy nerves were unaffected, but after damage there were statistically significant differences between PEMF treated and sham treated rats. PEMF accelerated the recovery of injured limbs and the degeneration, regeneration and maturation of myelinated axons; epineural, perineural and intraneural fibrosis was reduced; and the luminal cross-sectional area of intraneural vessels increased after both types of lesion. Findings are discussed and the need for clinical trials is stressed.


K Brown P Marie T Lyszakowski R Daniel R Cruess

The proximal fibular epiphysis was transferred in young puppies using microvascular techniques. The study demonstrated, as have previous investigators, that free epiphysial transfer without vascular anastomosis results in death of the chondrocytes of the growth plate. Histologically, the chondrocytes do not take up labelled proline, indicating diminished metabolic activity; do not take up radioactive thymidine, indicating that they are not dividing; and there is eventual disruption of the normal histological picture. In contrast, where the microvascular anastomoses re-established the blood supply to the growth plate, the epiphyses demonstrated normal histological appearance, uptake of radioactive proline and thymidine and continued to grow but at a slightly diminished rate. It is concluded that continued growth can occur after free vascularised epiphysial transfer in the dog.


W Whyte PV Bailey DL Hamblen WD Fisher IG Kelly

A comparison was made in a laminar-flow operating room between total-body exhaust gowns and a clothing system made from Fabric 450. This disposable clothing was found to be much more comfortable and convenient than the total-body exhaust gowns. The average airborne bacterial counts obtained during total hip replacement operations from each of the clothing systems were identical when the downflow method of ventilation was used (0.7 per cubic metre) and no significant difference could be demonstrated when the crossflow system was used (2.2 per cubic metre with the total-body exhaust gowns and 3.1 per cubic metre with the disposable clothing). Tests in a dispersal chamber were carried out to find the effectiveness of each item of the disposable clothing in reducing bacterial dispersion. These tests demonstrated the relative ineffectiveness of wearing a surgical gown as compared with wearing the complete system. It was confirmed bacteriologically that the downflow system of ventilation was more efficient than the crossflow type; the importance of this observation with respect to clothing and sepsis is discussed in this paper.