Abstract
Prophylactic antibiotics administered prior to joint arthroplasty have become standard practice. Due to concern over the risk that 2nd generation cephalosporins posed to the elderly, as regards clostridium difficile associated infections the antimicrobial management team in our unit changed the protocol for prophylactic antibiotics. As of 1st September 2009, flucloxacillin and gentamicin were preferred over cefuroxime as the first choice of prophylactic antibiotic. However, it was noted that postoperatively patients were experiencing a decrease in renal function.
One hundred patients who underwent a total hip replacement following the policy change were randomly selected from the departmental joint arthroplasty database. This group was age and sex matched to 100 patients undergoing their surgery prior to the change. Data was collected on renal function, length of stay, antibiotic and age. Any change in renal function was categorised using the RIFLE criteria.
Exclusion secondary to variations from protocol or treatment for femoral neck fractures resulted in a total number of 156 patients with 78 in each arm. The average age for both groups was 64 years. Non-parametric analysis of preoperative and postoperative serum creatinine concentrations and Glomerular Filtration Rate (GFR) demonstrated a significant difference between the two groups, showing that GFR decreased (p=0.041) and serum creatinine concentration increased (p=0.037) in the cohort receiving gentamicin. Classing the impaired renal function as: risk, injury or failure (RIFLE criteria) demonstrated a statistically significant difference for any criterion positive (p=0.016) but no significant difference for the specific RIFLE groups (p=0.068).
Acknowledging the small numbers and potential confounders for renal impairment, this study was able to show a difference in renal function for patients receiving gentamicin over cefuroxime as prophylaxis for joint arthroplasty.
