Abstract
Introduction
Periprosthetic joint infection (PJI) can be difficult to diagnose. A variety of techniques have been described. The efficacy of the alpha-defensin laboratory test was examined and compared with other established modalities in the diagnostic workup of ‘real world’ arthroplasty patients.
Methods
This was a retrospective review of 210 episodes (86 hips, 124 Knees) in 172 patients at one centre, and included samples from acute admissions, elective aspirations, and planned revisions. MSIS (musculoskeletal infection society) major and minor criteria were used for diagnosing PJI.
Each patient was investigated using a standardised protocol with inflammatory markers, synovial fluid analysis for white cell count (SWCC) and polymorphonuclear leukoctyes percentage (PMN %), and synovial fluid/tissue culture. Synovial fluid was also tested for alpha-defensin.
Results
Fifty-two (24.8%) episodes were defined as ‘PJI’ using MSIS criteria, and 158 ‘non-PJI’. Alpha-defensin had 71.2% (95% CI 56.9–82.9) sensitivity and 94.3% (89.5–97.4) specificity. The positive predictive value was 80.4% (68.1–88.8) with negative predictive value of 90.9% (6.6–93.9).
Thirty-seven (of 52 PJI episodes) were ‘culture positive’ (identical microorganism on ≥2 samples). Eighty (of 158 non-PJI) satisfied none of the major or minor MSIS criteria, and none of these patients subsequently had a PJI. In this sub-set of 117, alpha-defensin had 64.9% (47.5–79.8) sensitivity and 98.7% (92.9–99.9) specificity, whilst the sensitivities of CRP (>20), SWCC (>3000) and PMN (>80%) were 94.6% (81.8–99.3), 86.5% (71.2–95.5) and 83.8% (68.0–93.8) respectively.
There were 93 episodes where at least 1 minor criterion was satisfied and/or a sinus was present, but were not ‘culture positive’. In these, alpha-defensin had 85.7% (57.2–98.2) sensitivity and 88.4% (78.4–94.9) specificity.
Discussion and conclusion
The alpha-defensin laboratory test has a lower sensitivity than previously reported, limiting its use for diagnosing PJI. SWCC and PMN % have similar sensitivity and are cheaper. We no use the alpha-defensin test.
