Abstract
Introduction
Open hip debridement surgery has been used for treatment of femoral acetabular impingement pain for over ten years in our unit. While literature has reported promising short-term outcomes, longer term outcomes are more sparsely reported.
Patients/Materials & Methods
Patients who had undergone this surgery were identified on our database. Electronic, radiographic and paper records were reviewed. Demographic data, radiological and operative findings were recorded. Patients underwent ten-year review with standardised AP hip radiographs, questionnaire, non-arthritic hip (NAHS), Oxford hip (OHS) and SF-12 scores
Results
A total of 1626 operations were identified of which 183 had reached the tenth anniversary of their surgery. There were 91 females and 92 males. The average age was 39. Kaplan-Meier analysis indicated an overall 78% survival at ten years. However, once the learning curve was accounted for, by excluding the first year's cohort of patients, the survival rate was 84% at 10 years. Those who underwent hip arthroplasty were older at initial surgery and had a higher Tonnis grade than those who survived. The majority failed within the first 2 years. Labral repair, restoration of a normal centre edge angle and adequate CAM correction were associated with better survival. In those whose hip survived, the average NAHS and OHS were 87 and 39 respectively. 15% required further non-arthroplasty surgery (scope/revision) and 51% underwent trochanteric screw removal. 89% of survivors deemed their surgery to have been worthwhile at ten year follow up.
Discussion
These results represent the first cohorts of our patients to reach ten year follow up. The results represent a learning curve in patient selection. It is unsurprising that those with more arthritic change were more likely to fail.
Conclusion
In patients with clearly defined CAM impingement without joint space narrowing and where successful resection of the CAM and restoration of a normal centre edge angle can be achieved open hip debridement remains an operation with worthwhile outcomes at ten years.
