Abstract
Clinical and radiological results of total hip arthroplasty (THA) using proximally coated single wedge (PSW) cementless stems are generally excellent. The geometry of cementless stems and the morphology of proximal femurs (Dorr types) provide optimal fit for primary stability and secondary biologic fixation. Because the geometry of PSW shape is designed to be engaged at the metaphysis, cementless PSW stem is not traditionally recommended to Dorr type C femurs with concerns of inadequate implant-host bone contact and the risk of femoral fracture. Nevertheless, previous studies on PSW cementless stems have not examined long-term survivorship according to Dorr types of femur. Paucity of a long-term comparative study makes it difficult to know whether the PSW stem plays a role in Dorr type C femurs or not. We postulated that the PSW stem could achieve stable fixation without increased risk of femoral fracture even in Dorr type C femurs, and demonstrate acceptable long-term results. The aim of this study was to investigate differences of clinical and radiological outcomes of THA using PSW stem according to proximal femoral geometry (Dorr types) in more than a 10-year follow-up.
Three hundred and seven primary THA in 247 patients, which was performed with use of a single-designed PSW stem from 1997 to 2003 and was followed up for over 10 years, were included in this retrospective study. According to Dorr's criteria, 89 femora were classified as Type A, 156 as Type B, and 62 as Type C. The patients' mean age at operation was 43.2 years (range, 18.4 – 69.6 years). They were followed-up for an average of 13.2 years (the range, 10.0 – 17.3 years). All of the hips were evaluated clinically and radiologically with special attention to the occurrence of implant loosening and periprosthetic femoral fracture.
The mean preoperative Harris hip score (50.4±20.6 points) improved significantly to 95.6±9.0 points at the final follow-ups. The improvements were observed regardless of Dorr types (p<0.001 in all 3 groups). The incidence of thigh pain (p=0.704) was not significantly different among groups. Implant survivorship was 100% in all 3 groups. None of the stems were loosened or revised. No significant differences were observed in osteolysis (p=0.492), pedestal formation (p=0.323), or cortical hypertrophy (p=0.169) among the groups [Fig. 1]. Radiolucent lines less than 2mm in thickness in Gruen zone 4 were observed more in Dorr type C femora than in Dorr type A or B (p=0.003) [Fig. 2]. Spot weld (p<0.001) and stress shielding (p=0.010) of proximal femur were more pronounced in Dorr C type femora than in type A or B [Fig. 3]. The prevalence of intraoperative (p=0.550) or postoperative (p=0.600) femoral fractures were not significantly different among the groups.
From over a 10-year follow-up, the PSW stem provided excellent stem survivorship regardless of Dorr type with satisfactory outcomes. The remodeling process around the stem was more pronounced in Dorr type C femur. The present study shows that the PSW stem is a recommendable option for Dorr type C femur.
For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly (see Info & Metrics tab above).
