Clavicular hook plates have been used over the last decade in the treatment of lateral clavicular fractures with good rates of union reported throughout the literature. Fewer studies have reported the functional outcome of these patients and some have reported potential soft tissue damage post plate removal. We aimed to review the functional outcomes alongside union rates in patients treated with hook plates for lateral clavicular fractures. In this retrospective case series, 21 patients with traumatic lateral third clavicular fractures were included. 15 had Neer type II fractures, 4 Neer type III fractures, 1 patient had a Neer type I fracture and 1 radiograph was not able to be classified. All patients were treated with clavicular hook plates at the same district general hospital by five experienced surgeons between March 2010 and February 2015 adhering to the same surgical protocol. All patients had standard physiotherapy and post operative follow up. Plates were removed when radiological union was achieved in all but one patient who had the plate removed before union was achieved due to prolonged non-union. Patients were followed up post plate removal and evaluated clinically using the Oxford Shoulder Score. Their post plate radiographs were assessed by an independent radiologist and bony union documented. 21 patients were included. Mean age was 40 (range 14–63) with a male:female ratio of 17:4. Mean follow up was 5 months post injury (1–26 months). The hook plate remained in situ for a mean time of 4.3 months (2–16 months). One patient developed a post-operative wound infection treated with antibiotics, 2 patients developed adhesive capsulitis, one patient had not achieved bony union prior to hook plate removal at 16 months, however did achieve union 2 months post plate removal, two patients required revision plating. All patients achieved bony union eventually with good alignment and no displacement of the acromioclavicular joint seen on the most recent post operative radiographs. Post plate removal Oxford Shoulder Scores indicated good shoulder function with a mean score of 41.5 (maximum score possible 48 and the range of scores for our cohort was 30–47). Our data would support the use of hook plates in the treatment of lateral clavicular fractures. All patients achieved union eventually with good alignment and this was reflected in the good functional outcome scores. This study is limited in its small cohort and short-term follow up. More research is required to examine the long term consequences of hook plate surgery in a larger patient population.
Distal radius and ulna fractures are a common paediatric injury. Displaced or angulated fractures require manipulation under anaesthetic (MUA) with or without Kirchner (K) wire fixation to improve alignment and avoid malunion. After treatment a proportion redisplace requiring further surgical management. This study aimed to investigate whether the risk of redisplacement could be reduced by introducing surgical treatment guidelines to ascertain whether MUA alone or the addition of K wire fixation was required. A cohort of 51 paediatric forearm fractures managed either with an MUA alone or MUA and K wire fixation was analysed to determine fracture redisplacement rates and factors which predisposed to displacement. Guidelines for optimal management were developed based on these findings and published literature and implemented for the management of 36 further children. A 16% post-operative redisplacement rate was observed within the first cohort. Redisplacement was predicted if an ‘optimal reduction’ of less than 5° of angulation and/or 10% of translation was not achieved and no K wire fixation utilised. Adoption of the new guidelines resulted in a significantly reduced redisplacement rate of 6%. Implementation of departmental guidelines have reduced redisplacement rates of children's forearm fractures at Great Western Hospital.
Cementless surface replacement arthroplasty (CSRA) is an established treatment for glenohumeral osteoarthritis. Few studies however, evaluate its role in cuff tear arthopathy. The purpose of this study is to compare the outcomes of CSRA for both glenohumeral osteoarthritis and cuff tear arthopathy. 42 CSRA with the Mark IV Copeland prosthesis were performed for glenohumeral osteoarthritis (n=21) or cuff tear arthopathy (n=21). Patients were assessed with Oxford and Constant scores, patient satisfaction, range of motion and radiologically with plain radiographs. Mean follow-up and age was 5.2 years and 74 years in both groups. Functional outcomes were significantly higher in OA compared with CTA with OSS improving from 18 to 37.5 and 15 to 26 in both groups respectively. Forward flexion improved from 60° to 126° and 42° to 74° in both groups. Three patients in the CTA group had a deficient subscapularis tendon, two of whom dislocated anteriorly. Humeral head resurfacing arthroplasty is a viable treatment option for glenohumeral osteoarthritis. In patients with CTA, functional gains are limited. We suggest CSRA should be considered in low demand patients where pain is the primary problem. Caution should be taken in patients with a deficient subscapularis due to the high risk of dislocation.
In treating open long bone fractures our current policy includes early administration of intravenous antibiotics and surgery on a scheduled trauma list. We have reviewed our infection rates 6 years following the initiation of this policy. 220 fractures were studied. Our records included time of administration of antibiotics, time to theatre and seniority of surgeon. We identified cases of superficial or deep infection. Surgical debridement occurred within 6 hours of injury in 45% of cases and after 6 hours in 55%. Overall infection rates were 11% and 15.7% respectively. Intravenous antibiotics were administered within 3 hours of injury in 80% of cases and after 3 hours in 20% of cases. Overall infection rates were 14% and 12.5% respectively. Infection rates where the most senior surgeon present was a consultant were 9.5% compared to 16% with the consultant absent. Our results suggest that the change in policy may have contributed to an improvement of the deep infection rate to 4.3% from the previous figure of 8.5%, although this decrease was not statistically significant. Time to theatre has not adversely affected the infection rate, and presence of a senior surgeon may have improved infection rates, although both trends were not statistically significant.
Manipulation under anaesthetic (MUA) is an established treatment for frozen shoulder. Frozen shoulder may coexist with other shoulder conditions, whose treatment may differ from MUA. One such condition is calcific tendonitis. Only one study to date documents treatment of patients with frozen shoulder and concurrent calcific tendinitis. The objective was to demonstrate that MUA and injection is a satisfactory treatment for concurrent diagnosis of frozen shoulder and calcific tendinitis. Patients with a clinical diagnosis of frozen shoulder and radiological evidence of calcific tendinitis were prospectively recruited from Jan 1999 – Jan 2009. Treatment by MUA and injection was performed. Clinical examination, Oxford Shoulder Scores and need for further treatment were used as outcome measures. Fourteen patients (median age 53.5 years) were identified with frozen shoulder and concurrent calcific tendinitis. Significant improvement in both Oxford Shoulder Score and range of movement was achieved following MUA (P values < 0.001). Two patients required further treatment (not for calcific tendinitis). This improvement was maintained in the long term (median 107 wks). It is our belief that MUA and injection is a safe and effective treatment, addressing the frozen shoulder with MUA takes priority, and as such frozen shoulder “trumps” other pathologies occurring simultaneously.
Manipulation under anaesthetic (MUA) for the treatment of frozen shoulder is well established and effective however timing of surgery remains controversial. Intervention before 9 months has previously been shown to be associated with improved outcome. We test this theory by measuring Oxford Shoulder Score (OSS), re-MUA and subsequent surgery rate. A retrospective review of a prospectively collected, single surgeon, consecutive patient series revealed 244 primary frozen shoulders treated by MUA within 4 weeks of presentation. The mean duration of antecedent symptoms was 28 weeks (95% CI 4-44 weeks) and time to follow up was 26 days (95% CI 11-41 days). The mean OSS improved by 16 points (2-tailed t test p< 0.001) with a mean follow up OSS of 43 (95% CI 38-48). 195 shoulders were manipulated before 38 weeks (9 months) and had the same mean change in OSS (16) as the 49 shoulders manipulated after 38 weeks. 48 shoulders, including 15 diabetic shoulders required further MUA. 8 shoulders had subsequent surgery. These events were also independent of antecedent symptom duration. Early MUA does not appear to produce improved outcomes when compared to later intervention but we note does result in an earlier return to function.
In suspected scaphoid fracture the initial scaphoid series plain radiographs are 84-94% sensitive for scaphoid fractures. Patients are immobilised awaiting diagnosis. Unnecessary lengthy immobilisation leads to lost productivity and may leave the wrist stiff. Early accurate diagnosis would improve patient management. Although Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) has come to be regarded as the gold standard in identifying occult scaphoid injury, recent evidence suggests Computer Tomography (CT) to be more accurate in identifying scaphoid cortical fracture. Additionally CT and USS are frequently a more available resource than MRI. We hypothesised that 16 slice CT is superior to high spatial resolution Ultrasonography (USS) in the diagnosis of radiograph negative suspected cortical scaphoid fracture and that a 5 point clinical examination will help to identify patients most likely to have sustained a fracture within this group. 100 patients with two negative scaphoid series and at least two out of five established clinical signs of scaphoid injury (anatomical snuffbox tenderness (AST), scaphoid tubercle tenderness (STT), effusion, pain on circumduction and pain on axial loading) were prospectively investigated with CT and USS. MRI was arranged for patient with persistent symptoms but negative CT/USS.Background
Methods
To determine whether a delay of greater than 6 hrs from injury to initial surgical debridement and the timing of antibiotic administration affect infection rates in open long-bone fractures in a typical district general hospital in the UK. In a prospective study, 248 consecutive open long-bone fractures (248 patients) were recruited over a 10-year period between 1996 and 2005. The data were collected in weekly audit meetings. Patients were followed until clinical or radiological union occurred or until a secondary procedure for non-union or infection was performed. The timing of the injury, initial surgical debridement, timing of antibiotic administration, and definitive procedures were all recorded. We also recorded the bone involved and the Gustillo and Anderson (GA) score. Patients who died within 3 months from the injury or who were transferred for definitive treatment were excluded.Aims
Methods
