The variation in surgical performance, both between
centres and individual surgeons, has recently been of significant
political, media and public interest. Within the United Kingdom, a
government agenda to increase accountability amongst surgeons has
led to the online publication of ‘surgeon-level’ data. Surgeons,
journalists and the public need to understand these data if they
are to be useful in driving up standards of surgical care. This
Editorial describes the use of Funnel Plots, which are the common
means by which such data are presented, and discusses how the plots
are generated. Cite this article:
Perthes’ disease is an osteonecrosis of the juvenile
hip, the aetiology of which is unknown. A number of comorbid associations
have been suggested that may offer insights into aetiology, yet
the strength and validity of these are unclear. This study explored
such associations through a case control study using the United
Kingdom General Practice Research database. Associations investigated
were those previously suggested within the literature. Perthes’ disease has a significant association with congenital
genitourinary and inguinal anomalies, suggesting that intra-uterine
factors may be critical to causation. Other comorbid associations
may offer insight to support or refute theories of pathogenesis.
Clinical prediction algorithms are used to differentiate
transient synovitis from septic arthritis. These algorithms typically
include the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), although in clinical practice
measurement of the C-reactive protein (CRP) has largely replaced
the ESR. We evaluated the use of CRP in a predictive algorithm. The records of 311 children with an effusion of the hip, which
was confirmed on ultrasound, were reviewed (mean age 5.3 years (0.2
to 15.1)). Of these, 269 resolved without intervention and without
long-term sequelae and were considered to have had transient synovitis.
The remaining 42 underwent arthrotomy because of suspicion of septic
arthritis. Infection was confirmed in 29 (18 had micro-organisms
isolated and 11 had a high synovial fluid white cell count). In
the remaining 13 no evidence of infection was found and they were
also considered to have had transient synovitis. In total 29 hips
were categorised as septic arthritis and 282 as transient synovitis.
The temperature, weight-bearing status, peripheral white blood cell
count and CRP was reviewed in each patient. A CRP >
20 mg/l was the strongest independent risk factor for
septic arthritis (odds ratio 81.9, p <
0.001). A multivariable
prediction model revealed that only two determinants (weight-bearing
status and CRP >
20 mg/l) were independent in differentiating septic
arthritis from transient synovitis. Individuals with neither predictor
had a <
1% probability of septic arthritis, but those with both
had a 74% probability of septic arthritis. A two-variable algorithm
can therefore quantify the risk of septic arthritis, and is an excellent
negative predictor.
The association between idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV) and developmental dysplasia of the hip is uncertain. We present an observational cohort study spanning 6.5 years of selective ultrasound screening of hips in clubfoot. From 119 babies with CTEV there were nine cases of hip dysplasia, in seven individuals. This suggests that 1 in 17 babies with CTEV will have underlying hip dysplasia. This study supports selective ultrasound screening of hips in infants with CTEV.