To compare the long-term outcomes of fibular nailing and plate fixation for unstable ankle fractures in a cohort of patients under the age of 65 years.

Patients from a previously conducted randomized control trial comparing fibular nailing and plate fixation were contacted at a minimum of 10 years post intervention at a single study centre. Short term data were collected prospectively and long-term data were collected retrospectively using an electronic patient record software.

Ninety-nine patients from one trauma centre were included (48 fibular nails and 51 plate fixations). Groups were matched for gender (p = 0.579), age (p = 0.811), body mass index (BMI)(p = 0.925), smoking status (p = 0.209), alcohol status (p = 0.679) and injury type (p = 0.674). Radiographically at an average of 2 years post-injury, there was no statistically significant difference between groups for development of osteoarthritis (p = 0.851). Both groups had 1 tibio-talar fusion (2% of both groups) secondary to osteoarthritis with no statistically significant difference in overall re-operation rate between groups identified (p = 0.518,). Forty-five percent (n=42) of patients had so far returned patient reported outcome measures at a minimum of 10 years (Fibular nail n=19, plate fixation n=23). No significant difference was found between groups at 10 years for the Olerud and Molander Ankle Score (p = 0.990), the Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire (p = 0.288), Euroqol-5D Index (p = 0.828) and Euroqol-5D Visual Analogue Score (p = 0.769).

The current study illustrates no difference between fibular nail fixation and plate fixation at a long-term follow up of 10 years in patients under 65 years old, although the study is currently under powered.

Aims

The primary aim of this study was to assess whether patients waiting six months or more for a total hip (THA) or knee (KA) arthroplasty had a deterioration in their health-related quality of life (HRQoL). Secondary aims were to assess changes in frailty and the number of patients living in a state considered to be worse than death (WTD), and factors associated with changes in HRQoL and frailty.

The primary aim was to assess whether patients waiting 6-months or more for a total hip (THA) or knee (KA) arthroplasty had a deterioration in their health-related quality of life (HRQoL). Secondary aims were to assess change in level of frailty and the number living in a state worse than death (WTD).

Eight-six patients waiting for a primary TKA or KA for more than 6-months were selected at random from waiting lists in three centres. Patient demographics, waiting time, EuroQol 5-dimension (EQ-5D) and visual analogue scores (EQ-VAS), Rockwood clinical frailty score (CFS) and SF-36 subjective change in HRQoL were recorded at the time of and for a timepoint 6-months prior to assessment. The study was powered to the EQ-5D (primary measure of HRQoL).

There were 40 male and 46 female patients with a mean age of 68 (33 to 91) years; 65 patients were awaiting a THA and 21 a TKA. The mean waiting time was 372 (226 to 749) days. The EQ-5D index deteriorated by 0.222 (95%CI 0.164 to 0.280, p<0.001). The EQ-VAS also deteriorated by 10.8 (95%CI 7.5 to 14.0, p<0.001). CFS progressed from a median of 3 to 4 (p<0.001). The number of patients WTD increased from seven to 22 (p<0.001). Thirty-one(36%) patients felt their HRQoL was much worse and 28 (33%) felt it was somewhat worse.

Patients waiting more than 6-months had a clinically significant deterioration in their HRQoL and demonstrated increasing level of frailty with more than a quarter living in a health state WTD.