25–40% of unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) revisions are performed for unexplained pain possibly secondary to elevated proximal tibial bone strain. This study investigates the effect of tibial component metal backing and polyethylene thickness on cancellous bone strain in a finite element model (FEM) of a cemented fixed bearing medial UKR, validated using previously published acoustic emission data (AE).

FEMs of composite tibiae implanted with an all-polyethylene tibial component (AP) and a metal backed one (MB) were created. Polyethylene of thickness 6–10mm in 2mm increments was loaded to a medial load of 2500N. The volume of cancellous bone exposed to <−3000 (pathological overloading) and <−7000 (failure limit) minimum principal (compressive) microstrain (µ∊) and >3000 and >7000 maximum principal (tensile) microstrain was measured.

Linear regression analysis showed good correlation between measured AE hits and volume of cancellous bone elements with compressive strain <−3000µ∊: correlation coefficients (R= 0.947, R2 = 0.847), standard error of the estimate (12.6 AE hits) and percentage error (12.5%) (p<0.001). AP implants displayed greater cancellous bone strains than MB implants for all strain variables at all loads. Patterns of strain differed between implants: MB concentrations at the lateral edge; AP concentrations at the keel, peg and at the region of load application. AP implants had 2.2 (10mm) to 3.2 (6mm) times the volume of cancellous bone compressively strained <−7000µ∊ than the MB implants. Altering MB polyethylene insert thickness had no effect. We advocate using caution with all-polyethylene UKR implants especially in large or active patients where loads are higher.

Joint registries report that 25–40% of UKR revisions are performed for pain. Proximal tibial strain and microdamage are possible causes of this “unexplained” pain. The aim of this study was to examine the effect of UKR implant design and material on proximal tibial cortical strain and cancellous microdamage.

Composite Sawbone tibias were implanted with cemented UKR components: 5 fixed bearing all-polyethylene (FB-AP), 5 fixed bearing metal backed (FB-MB), and 5 mobile bearing metal backed implants (MB-MB). Five intact tibias were used as controls. Tibias were loaded in 500N increments to 2500N. Cortical surface strain was measured using digital image correlation (DIC). Cancellous microdamage was measured using acoustic emission (AE), a technique which detects elastic waves produced by the rapid release of energy during microdamage events.

DIC showed significant differences in anteromedial cortical strain between implants at 1500N and 2500N in the proximal 10mm only (p<0.001) with strain shielding in metal backed implants. AE showed significant differences in cancellous microdamage (AE hits), between implants at all loads (p=0.001). FB-AP implants displayed significantly more hits at all loads than both controls and metal backed implants (p<0.001). FB-AP implants also differed significantly by displaying AE hits on unloading (p=0.01), reflecting a lack of implant stiffness. Compared to controls, the FB-AP implant displayed 15x the total AE hits, the FB-MB 6x and the MB-MB 2.7x. All-polyethylene medial UKR implants are associated with greater cancellous bone microdamage than metal backed implants even at low loads.

Introduction

Iatrogenic proximal femur hoop-stress fracture is a recognised complication of uncemented hip arthroplasty. It has a reported incidence of two to three percent and increases patient morbidity. We describe a novel technology that predicts fracture in real-time by less than one minute.