Outcome measures used were post operative mortality, Post operative improvement in Frankel score, level of pain perception, level of mobility and ability to perform activities of daily living.
The possibility that AIS aetiology involves undetected neuromuscular dysfunction is considered likely by several workers [1,2]. Yet in the extensive neuroscience research of idiopathic scoliosis certain neurodevelopmental concepts have been neglected. These include [3]:
a CNS body schema (“body in the brain”) for posture and movement control generated during development and growth by establishing a long-lasting memory, and pruning of cortical synapses at puberty. During normal development the CNS has to adapt to the rapidly growing skeleton of adolescence, and in AIS to developing spinal asymmetry from whatever cause. Examination of publications relating to the CNS body schema, parietal lobe and temporo-parietal junction [4,5] led us to a new concept: namely, that a delay in maturation of the CNS body schema during adolescence with an early AIS deformity at a time of rapid spinal growth results in the CNS attempting to balance the deformity in a trunk that is larger than the information on personal space (self) already established in the brain by that time of development. It is postulated that this CNS maturational delay allows scoliosis curve progression to occur – unless the delay is temporary when curve progression would cease. The maturational delay may be primary in the brain or secondary to impaired sensory input from end-organs [6], nerve fibre tracts [2,7,8] or central processing [9,10]. The motor component of the concept could be evaluated using transcranial magnetic stimulation [11].
In subjects with lumbar, thoracolumbar or pelvic tilt scoliosis no pattern of structural leg length inequality has been reported [1]. Forty-seven girls of 108 consecutive adolescent patients referred from routine scoliosis school screening during 1996–1999 had lower spinal scoliosis – lumbar (LS) 17, or thoracolumbar (TLS) 30 (mean Cobb angle 16 degrees, range 4–38 degrees, mean age 14.8 years, left curves 25). The controls were 280 normal girls (11–18 years, mean age 13.4 years). Anthropometric measurements were made of total leg lengths (LL), tibiae (TL) and feet (FL) by one observer (RGB) and asymmetries calculated for LL, TL and FL, as absolutes and percentage asymmetries of right/left lengths. There are no detectable changes of absolute asymmetries with age for LL, TL or FL in scoliotic or normal girls. Asymmetries are found in scoliotic girls compared with normals with relative lengthening on the right for each of LL (0.95%) and TL (0.99%) (each p<
0.001), but not FL (0.38%).
In schoolchildren screened for scoliosis about 40% have minor, non-progressive, lumbar scolioses secondary to pelvic tilt with leg-length and/or sacral inequality [1] not reported with preoperative thoracic curves [2]. Forty-nine of 108 consecutive adolescent patients referred from routine scoliosis school screening during 1996–1999 had lower spinal scoliosis with measurable radiological sacral alar and hip tilt angles – lumbar scoliosis 18, thoracolumbar scoliosis 31 (girls 41, boys 8, mean Cobb angle 16 degrees, range 4–38 degrees). In standing full spine antero-posterior radiographs measurements were made of Cobb angle and pelvic asymmetries as sacral alar and iliac heights (left minus right). From anthropometric measurements derivatives were calculated as ilio-femoral length (total leg length minus tibial length) and several length asymmetries, namely: ilio-femoral length asymmetry, total leg length inequality and tibial length asymmetry (all left minus right). Ilio-femoral length asymmetry correlates significantly with sacral alar height asymmetry (girls negatively r= − 0.456, p=0.002, boys positively r=0.726 p=0.041) but not iliac height asymmetry (girls p=0.201) from which three types are identified. Total leg length inequality but not tibial length asymmetry in the girls is associated with sacral alar height asymmetry (r= − 0.367 p=0.017 &
r=0.039 p=0.807 respectively). Interpretation is complicated by total leg lengths each including some ilium in which there is asymmetry [3]. But lack of association between ilio-femoral length asymmetry and iliac height asymmetry suggests that the femoral component is more important than iliac component in determining the associations between sacral alar height asymmetry and each of ilio-femoral length asymmetry and total leg length inequality.
Sacral alar height asymmetry and leg length asymmetries. The evidence suggests that sacral alar height asymmetry is not secondary to the leg length inequalities at least in most girls (negative correlations) and is more likely to result from primary skeletal changes in femur(s) and sacrum. Sacral alar height asymmetry and Cobb angle. Scoliosis progression and iliac height asymmetry [3] appear to need factors additional to those that determine ilio-femoral length asymmetry – for in the girls Cobb angle is associated with both sacral alar height asymmetry and iliac height asymmetry (each p<
0.001) but not with either ilio-femoral length asymmetry (p=0.249) or total leg length inequality (p=0.650). The additional factors may be biomechanical [4], and/or biological in the trunk [5] and central nervous system [6].
Patterns of extra-spinal skeletal length asymmetry have been reported for upper limbs [1] and ribcage [2] of patients with upper spine adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. This paper reports a third pattern in the ilia. Seventy of 108 consecutive adolescent patients referred from routine scoliosis school screening during 1996–1999 had lower spine scoliosis – lumbar (LS), thoracolumbar (TLS), or pelvic tilt scoliosis (PTS). Radiologic bi-iliac and hip tilt angles were both measurable in 60 subjects: LS 18, TLS 31, and PTS 11 (girls 44, boys 16, mean age 14.6 years). Cobb angle (CA), apical vertebral rotation (AVR) and apical vertebral translation from the T1-S1 line (AVT) were measured on standing full spine radiographs (mean Cobb angle 14 degrees, range 4–38 degrees, 33 left, 27 right curves). Bi-iliac tilt angle (BITA) and hip tilt angle (HTA) were measured trigonometrically and iliac height asymmetry calculated as BITA minus HTA (corrected BITA=CBITA) and directly as iliac height asymmetry. Iliac height is relatively taller on the concavity of these curves (p<
0.001). CBITA is associated with Cobb angle, AVR and AVT (each p<
0.001).
In idiopathic scoliosis the detection of extra-spinal left-right skeletal length asymmetries in the upper limbs, ribs, ilia and lower limbs [1–7] begs the question: are these asymmetries unconnected with the pathogenesis, or are they an indicator of what may also be happening in immature vertebrae of the spine? The vertebrate body plan has mirror-image bilateral symmetries (mirror symmetrical, homologous morphologies) that are highly conserved culminating in the adult form [8]. The normal human body can be viewed as containing paired skeletal structures in the axial and appendicular skeleton as a) separate left and right paired forms (e.g. long limb bones, ribs, ilia), and b) united in paired forms (e.g. vertebrae, skull, mandible). Each of these separate and united pairs are mirror-image forms – enantiomorphs. In idiopathic scoliosis, genetic and epigenetic (environmental) mechanisms [9–11] may disturb the symmetry control of enantiomorphic immature bones [12–13] and, by creating left-right endochondral growth asymmetries, cause the extra-spinal bone length asymmetries, and within one or more vertebrae create growth conflict with distortion as deformities (= unsynchronised bone growth concept) [14].
High correlation was revealed between postoperative decompensation and derotation of lumbar apical vertebrae (P=0.62, p<
0.001) with a critical value of 40%. A 2x2 table showed that in patients with lumbar apical vertebral derotation of less than 40% specificity was 90% with regard to postoperative decompensation.
There was no relationship between repeatability and the measurement size.
Anterior instrumentation for thoracic AIS has advanced to a point where it can be widely adopted, particularly if the patient expresses concerns regarding the rib hump or is hypokyphotic.
Giant Cell Tumour of the Tendon Sheath is a benign tumour of synovial origin most frequently affecting the upper limb. Up to 11% exhibit radiographic evidence of cortical erosion and intra-osseous expansion. In the upper limb recurrence rates of between 10–50% following excision have been reported. However, GCT-TS is rarely described in the foot and ankle and its behaviour is ill understood. 17 cases of this rarely described tumour in the foot and ankle are presented, describing their clinical presentation, histopathology, treatment and outcome. Analysis of all cases of histopathologically proven GCT-TS of the foot and ankle from the Oxford Tumour Registry, was conducted between the periods of January 1984 to December 1999. 22 cases were identified of which 17 cases had adequate records to allow analysis of patient demographics, duration of symptoms, preoperative investigations, presumed diagnosis, precise site of origin, post operative complications and recurrence rates The mean age of presentation was 28 (8–53). 10 cases were female and 7 male. 76% cases occurred in the foot, all of which arose adjacent to the phalanges or heads of the metatarsals. 14% occurred in relation to the ankle or sub-talar joint. 82% presented with a painless swelling. The duration of symptoms ranged from 6 months to 8 years. Only one patient complained of sensory symptoms. Pre-operative investigations included radiographs in 64% with 3 cases having an additional MRI scan. The MRI scans of GCT-TS have characteristic changes on T1 and T2 images. The presumed preoperative diagnosis was incorrect in 82%. 36% of radiographs taken showed changes including cortical erosion and speckled calcification. A local excision was performed in 15 cases, an amputation in one and a wide local excision in one case only. There have been no recurrences during the follow up period of between 1–12 years. GCT-TS of foot and ankle is rare and is commonly misdiagnosed. Despite only a local excision being performed in more than 80% of this series there were no recurrences. Plain radiographs may show cortical erosion or speckled calcification in up to 36% and MRI is helpful in further defining the anatomy of the lesion, allowing planned excision and reducing the risk of recurrence.