To assess the survivorship of unicompartmental replacements (UKR) revised to UKR. Background: Partial revision of UKR, or revision to a further UKR is a rarely performed procedure with some data from the Australian registry suggesting that results are not good, with early revision being required. All revision procedures from initial UKR are prospectively followed and scored as part of our department's knee database. We analysed the 37 cases in our database that showed revision of UKR to UKR. These included cases in the following categories: a) Mobile bearing revised to mobile bearing (n=8) b) Mobile bearing revised to fixed bearing (n=20) c) Fixed bearing revised to fixed bearing (n=9)Aim
Method
The gold standard for measuring knee alignment is the lower limb mechanical axis. This is traditionally assessed by weight-bearing full length lower limb X-rays (LLX). CT scanograms (CTS) are however, becoming increasingly popular in view of lower radiation exposure, speed and supine positioning. We assessed the correlation and reproducibility of knee joint coronal alignment using these two imaging modalities. LLX and CTS images were obtained in 24 knees with degenerate joint disease or failed TKR. Hip to ankle mechanical alignment were measured using the PACS software. Coronal knee alignment was assessed from the centre of the knee, measuring the valgus/varus angle relative to the mechanical axis. Measurements were made by two orthopaedic surgeons (Research Fellow and Consultant) on two separate occasions. The mean alignment angles measured by observers 1 and 2 on CTS were 180.29° (SD 6.04) and 180.71° (SD 6.13) respectively, while on LLX were 181.04° (SD7.58) and 181.04° (SD 7.72). The measurements between the two observers were highly correlated for both the CTS (r = 0.97, p < 0.001) and the LLX (r = 0.99, p < 0.001). The angles measured on CTS and LLX were highly correlated (r = 0.826, p < 0.001) with high degree of internal consistency (ICC = 0.804). Malalignment of greater than 5° was seen in 19% of the CTS and 35% of the LLX. There was good correlation between CT scanogram and weight-bearing X-ray measurements in normally-aligned knees. However, as expected, in the malaligned lower limb, the influence of weight-bearing is critical which demonstrates the significance of weight-bearing X-rays.
Patello-femoral arthritis can result in a considerable thinning of the patella. The restoration of an adequate patella thickness is key to the successful outcome of knee arthroplasty. The objectives were (1) to establish a reproducible patella width:thickness index including chondral surface and (2) to investigate whether there is a difference between bone alone and bone/chondral construct thickness as shown by MRI. Forty three MRI scans of young adults, mean age 27 (range 17–38), 34 male and 9 female, were studied. Exclusion criteria included degenerative joint disease, patello-femoral pathology or age under 16/over 40 (102 patients). The bony and chondral thickness of the patella and its width were measured. Inter/intra observer variability was calculated and correlation analysis performed. We found a strong correlation between patella plus cartilage thickness and width (Pearson 0.75, P < 0.001). The mean width:thickness ratio was 1.8 (SD 0.10, 95% CI 1.77–1.83). Without cartilage the ratio was 2.16 (SD 0.15, 95% CI 2.11–2.21), correlation was moderate (Pearson 0.68, P < 0.001). The average patella cartilage thickness was 4.1mm (SD 1.1, 95% CI 3.8–4.5). The narrow confidence intervals for the ratio of patella width:thickness suggest that patella width can be used as a guide to accurate restoration of patella thickness during total knee or patella-femoral replacement. We would recommend a ratio of 1.8:1.
Patients with severe knee instability remain a surgical challenge. Furthermore, in the presence of extensive bone loss, constrained condylar implants may be unsuitable. Hinged knee replacements have served an important role in the management of such complex knee pathologies. A combined prospective and retrospective study of 138 consecutive hinge knee arthroplasties (42 primary and 96 revisions) of 8 different models performed in our institution between 2004 and 2010 at a mean follow up of 4.2years. Outcomes were reviewed and knee scores preoperatively and postoperatively at 1, 2 and 5 years using the American knee scoring system. The mean preoperative American knee score of 31 improved to 87 postoperatively. Complication rate was 19%, 15% of which required re-revisions for: loosening (4%), Infection (4%), periprosthetic fracture (3%), Implant fracture (2%), Component disassembly (1%) and dislocation (1%). Overall implant failure rate was 9% and implant survivorship was greater than 80% at 4 years. In our study, hinge prostheses provided good stability and symptom relief with a lower complication rate compared to some previous studies. In addition, we believe hinge prostheses can also serve as reasonable alternatives to amputation and arthrodesis in many complex knees cases.
Patients with severe knee instability and extensive bone loss remain a surgical challenge. In such cases, regular knee implants and constrained condylar implants may not be suitable or have been attempted and failed. Hinged knee replacements have developed an important role in the management of such complex knee cases. They also have an increasingly important role in cases such as rheumatoid arthritis and other cases of severe joint destruction. We present a review of 138 consecutive hinge knee arthroplasties of 8 different Hinge models performed in our unit between 2004 and 2010. Combined prospective and retrospective study of 138 (42 primary and 96 revisions) consecutive cases of Hinge knee replacements at a mean follow up of 4.2 years. Outcomes were recorded and scored using the American knee score preoperatively, 1, 2 and 5 years. Complications, re-revisions, implant failures and survivorship were also assessed.Introduction
Method
Separation of the ACL into anteromedial (AM) and posterolateral (PL) fibre bundles has been widely accepted. The bundles act synergistically to restrain anterior laxity throughout knee flexion, with the PL bundle providing the more important restraint near extension and its obliquity better restraining tibial rotational laxity. 10% of ACL injuries involve isolated rupture to one of these bundles causing patients to present with instability symptoms or pain. As knowledge about the influence of the ACL bundles on knee kinematics has increased, isolated reconstruction of either PL or AM bundle has been advocated. However only one cohort study of 17 patients has been presented in the clinical literature. KOOS (Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score) and IKDC (International Knee Documentation Committee Form) scores at 1yr post op were obtained for 12 patients who had undergone isolated ACL augmentation between 2007 and 2009. These were compared with previously published outcome scores for standard ACL reconstruction procedures. In addition examination under anaesthesia (EUA) assessments were analysed to see if a pattern of laxity for isolated AM and PL rupture could be determined. There were 5 patients with isolated AM bundle rupture and 7 with isolated PL bundle rupture. EUA analysis demonstrated that patients with isolated PL bundle rupture had increased pivot shift and Lachman test laxity, whereas the AM bundle rupture group had increased laxity with the anterior drawer test. Compared to previously published IKDC scores, there were no difference between isolated bundle augmentation and standard ACL reconstruction. However the KOOS scores showed significantly increased Sports function scores which was significantly better in the isolated bundle augmentations (93/100 v's 74/100). Differences between isolated AM and PL bundle reconstructions were not distinguishable. Isolated ACL bundle tears make up a significant proportion ACL injuries. Although technically more difficult than standard ACL reconstruction, isolated bundle augmentation appears to result in improved sports function when compared to standard ACL reconstruction.
The legion knee revision system was designed as a follow and improvement to the Genesis II knee system- allowing for a surgeon directed femoral rotation as opposed to the in-built femoral rotation in the previous system. This is a prospective review of consecutive patients who underwent knee revision surgery using the legion knee system. Clinical and functional assessments were carried out preoperatively, one year and 2 years post op. Radiographic evaluation was done at 1 and 2years follow up. Standard knee scoring systems (American Knee Scores-AKS, and Oxford score were used for the clinical and functional evaluation of these patients. The WOMAC score was also used to assess for pain, stiffness and social function in these patients. The radiographic assessment included review of standing AP, lateral and skyline views. Figgie's method was used to measure the joint line reproduction. A difference of 5 mm (pre = op/post-op) was deemed satisfactory.Introduction
Methods
The aim of this study was to compare the short-term and mid-term outcome of lateral UKRs using a single prosthesis, the AMC Uniglide knee implant. Between 2003 and 2010, seventy lateral unicompartmental knee replacements (mean patient age 63.6±12.7 years) were performed at our unit for isolated lateral compartmental disease. Range of knee motion and functional outcome measures including the American Knee Society (AKSS), Oxford (OKS) and WOMAC scores were recorded from 19 knees at five years' post-operatively and compared to 35 knees at two-years and 53 knees at one-year post-op.Purpose
Methods
Kneeling ability is better in unicompartmental than total knee arthroplasty. There is also an impression that mobile bearing knees achieve better functional outcome than their fixed bearing cousins in unicompartmental and to a lesser extent total joint arthroplasty. In the UK, the market leading unicompartmental replacement is mobile bearing. To analyse kneeling ability after total and unicompartmental knee replacement using mobile and fixed bearing inserts.Introduction
Aim
The aim of this study was to study the short-term outcome of a contemporary modular revision knee system used in our centre for managing Knee revision arthroplasty Preoperative, one and two years follow up scores and radiographic analysis were recorded from 72 consecutive knee revision cases performed between 2006 and 2008. Outcome measures included the American Knee Society (AKSS), Oxford (OKS) and WOMAC scores and range of motion. The radiographic assessment included review of standing AP, lateral and skyline views. Figgie's method was used to measure the joint line reproduction. A difference of 5 mm (pre=op/post-op) was deemed satisfactory.PURPOSE
METHODS
Body Mass Index (BMI) is used to quantify generalised obesity, but does not account for variations in soft tissue distribution. To define an index quantifying the knee soft tissue depth, utilising underlying bony anatomy, and compare with BMI as a measure of individual patient's knee soft tissue envelopes. We performed a practicality and reproducibility study to validate the Bristol Knee Index for future prospective use.Background
Aims
Assessing medium term outcome of medial Uni compartmental replacement and whether there is a difference in outcome between mobile and fixed bearing variants of the same prosthesis. Knee outcome was assessed in 150 patients (81 male, 69 females, mean age 67.0±10.4yrs) undergoing medial UKR knee (Uniglide, Corin Medical, UK) using either fixed or mobile bearing prosthesis between 2002-2007. All operations were performed by members of the Bristol knee group. All patients were scored using the American Knee Score (AKS), Oxford Knee Score (OKS), and WOMAC pre-operatively and at 2-year follow up. The mobile group (n=93) comprised 43 males and 50 females, aged 62.8±8.9yrs. The fixed bearing group (n=57) comprised 38 males and 19 females, aged 74±8.8yrs.Purpose of the study
Methods
There are a few papers in the literature to indicate the likely functional outcome of conservatively managed sportsmen in whom primary outcome cruciate ligament [ACL] healing occurs. We reviewed 298 sportsmen presenting with isolated ACL rupture that were conservatively managed with a rehabilitation programme, based on regaining proprioceptive and hamstring control, and aimed at achieving primary ACL healing. All were protected in a hinged brace. In 50 patients, the ACL was determined as having healed clinically; these patients underwent instrumented laximetry testing with KT 1000 arthrometry and were determined: IKDC A [Normal] or IKDC B [nearly normal]. An MRI was also performed which confirmed healing in 39 patients with ACL fibres parallel to Blumenstat's line. In 11 patients the ACL stump had healed to the PCL. The 50 patients were followed up for an average 16 months [range, 14 to 17 months]. 56% of patients suffered recurrent instability when they returned to their preinjury level of contact or pivoting sport. For competitive athletes, 76.5% suffered further instability on return to sport despite the four-month rehabilitation and independent arthrometry score or MRI findings. However, for occasional, recreational athletes only 7% suffered recurrent instability. This study suggests that a rehabilitation programme aimed at primary ACL healing affords satisfactory results for the occasional, recreational athlete but does not achieve the quality of restraint sufficient for contact or pivoting sports in competitive athletes. These patients suffer high levels of recurrent instability and are exposed to the risk of secondary chondral and meniscal injury.
Although good long term results for fixed bearing uni-compartmental knee replacements (UKRs) have been reported mobile bearings predominate in some parts of the world. Three prospective studies have been undertaken comparing the short and medium term outcomes of fixed and mobile UKRs.
A 5 year comparative cohort study of 47 Oxford mobile bearing and 57 St Georg Sled fixed bearing UKRs. A 2 year study of 50 fixed and 50 mobile bearing AMC Uniglide UKRs.(The implant system allows implantation of either a fixed or mobile tibial component with the same femoral component.) The 1 year results of a randomised controlled trial of 38 fixed and 33 mobile AMC Uniglide UKRs in patients under 70. In all groups the preoperative sex mix, average age and knee scores were extremely similar. All patients were assessed both pre and postoperatively by a research nurse and radiographs were taken; the results were entered on the Bristol Knee database.
Multiple problems were encountered, perhaps because of the introduction of MIS, but at 5 years 11 Oxford and 4 Sleds had failed. The major problem with the mobile bearing implant was instability though tibial fractures were also seen. Both groups had three cases of arthritic progression and loose cement was seen twice in the fixed bearing group. – Amongst the remaining patients the median scores for the Sled were better. Bristol Knee Score (Max 100) 95:90; Oxford (Max 48) 39:37; and reduced WOMAC (Best score 12) 18:24. 2 bearing exchanges and 3 revisions were needed in the mobile group with none in the fixed group. Again all scores were better for the fixed group. American Knee Score (AKS) (Max 200) 195:185; Oxford (Max48) 39:37; and reduced WOMAC (Max 12) 19:20. One fixed bearing implant had been revised but none in the mobile group, however 3 randomised to receive a mobile bearing had a fixed bearing inserted because the surgeon was unhappy about bearing stability; all three are doing well. All knee scores at one year show the fixed bearing implant to be performing better. AKS (Max 200) 194:173; Oxford (Max48) 39:33; and WOMAC(Max) 12 18:22.
On the tibia, the centre of the AM attachment was located 18 mm anterior to the Retro-eminence ridge (RER). The centre of the PL bundle lay 8.4 mm posterior to the centre of the AM bundle. These positions were at 35% and 52% along Amis and Jacob’s line
Electromagnetic Navigation is in its infancy, and the authors feel that surgical time and accuracy will improve with more frequent use and the development of increasingly more sophisticated software packages. Our study continues.