Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction has become a standard procedure with a documented good and excellent outcome of 70–90%. Important variables of outcome after surgery consist of objective and subjective variables. It is important to examine the relationship between commonly used knee rating systems and functional tests to assess whether there is a correlation between rating systems and functional performance. The purpose of this study was to determine if a correlation exists between four commonly used knee rating systems (Lysholm, Tegner, IKDC, Noyes) and commonly performed dunctional tests: single and timed hop, vertical jump and isometric, isokinetic and eccentric muscle strength. 44 consecutive patients (31 males and 13 females) were selected (mean age 27.9 years). All subjects were tested prior and 12 month following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. The subjects completed the above knee rating scores. The patients were then evaluated performing the following tests: single leg hop for distance, timed hop and vertical jump. Muscle strength was assessed using a Biodex dynamometer. Isometric strength was examined at 30 and 60 degrees of flex-ion. Isokinetic testing (concentric and eccentric) was performed at 120 and 180 degrees/sec. Their results of functional testing were expressed as percentage of the contralateral non involved limb. A positive correlation was found between single leg hop, Lysholm (r=0.53, p<
0.05). IKDC (r=0.30, p<
00002) and Noyes score (r=0.45, p<
0.01). A positive correlation was found between vertical jump, Lysholm (r=0.21, p<
0002), IKDC (r=0.31, p<
0.0001) and Noyes score (r=0.31, p<
0.0001). There was no correlation between timed hop and knee scores. A negative correlation (r=0.25–0.46) was noted between eccentric peak extension torque at 120 degrees/sec and 180 degrees/sec (r=0.230.26). However it only reached significance (p<
0.04) between IKDC and eccentric torque at 120 degrees/sec and 180 degrees/sec (p<
0.01). In addition there was a moderate negative correlation (r=0.26, p<
0.0004)) between Lysholm score and eccentric peak torque at 180 degrees/sec. No correlations were found for isokinetic and isometric torque for the knee flexors. Knee rating systems seem to reflect functional capabilities and subjective satisfaction of patients prior and post ACL reconstruction. Isokinetic strength does not seem to be an important predictor of knee function.
Malpositioning of the acetabular cup component in total hip arthroplasty can result in increased wear, early nonseptic loosening and is the most common cause of dislocation. Previous research has defined a safe zone with an inclination of 40±10 degrees and anteversion of 15±10 degrees. The purpose of this study was to using CT based measurements. 32 patients receiving a primary hip replacement between June 2005 and December 2006 were enrolled in the study. Alignment of the implant is based on the acquisition of landmarks (ASIS and pubic tubercle) and placement of tracking pins into the ASIS. The target position for all patients was 45 degrees of inclination and 15 degrees of anteversion. The position was determined by postoperative Ct scans of the pelvis. This group was compared to a historical control group. Descriptive statistics revealed that the demographics of both groups were comparable. Mean cup placement in the navigation group was 46.6±5.9 deg of inclination and 18.8±5.6 deg of anteversion. Mean cup placement in the control group was 45.8±9.5 deg of inclination and 27.3±15.0 deg of anteversion. With navigation 73.7% resp 89.5% of cups were placed within the safe zone for inclination resp. anteversion whereas only 60.9% resp. 39% of cups were placed with freehand technqie. Taking both inclination and anteversion into consideration 68.4% of cups were placed in the safe zone with navigation. Only 25.7% were placed for both inclination and anteversion were placed into the safe zone. Computer navigation for total joint arthroplasty, if helpful to the surgeon, has to increase reliability of component placement and show a significant reduction in variation compared to freehand techniques. Our results demonstrate that imageless navigation is a reliable tool which significantly increases precision of acetabular cup placement. Further studies are needed to evaluate and further increase the accuracy of the system
Large osteochondral defects of the femoral condyle still pose a difficult problem to treat. A variety of options is available but most of result in replacement with inferior fibrous or hyaline-like cartilage in the load-bearing zone of the knee joint. We present the five year results of Mega-OATS. This technique utilizes the posterior femoral condyle for coverage of osteochondral defects and is called Mega-OATS. From July 1999, 33 patients of mean age 34.3 years (15–59) were treated with MEGA-OATS. Fifteen patients additionally underwent high tibial osteotomy and two bone grafting using bone harvested from the proximal tibia. The average defect size was 6.2±1.8 cm2. The mean follow up was 66.4±13.2 months. The technique calls for excision of the posterior femoral condyle which is placed in a specially designed work station. The Lysholm score increased post-operatively from 49.0±19.4 to 88.5±14.9 12 months post surgery to 85.5±16.0 five years post surgery. Three months post-operatively, patients attained a full range of motion and became fully weight-bearing. There was no difference in patients undergoing combined surgery with high tibial osteotomy and patients undergoing Mega OATS as a single procedure after five years. No post-operative meniscal lesions of the posterior horn have been observed. Mega-OATS achieves a congruent reconstruction of the articular surface in the load bearing zone of the femoral condyle. We consider it a good alternative and salvage procedure in the treatment of large osteochondral defects of the femoral condyle.
Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction has become a standard procedure with a documented good and excellent outcome of 70–90%. It has been demonstrated by previous research that all patients following surgery demonstrate a strength deficit of almost 20%. However it is not known whether these strength deficits have an influence on postoperative functionality. 52 consecutive patients (38 males and 14 females) were selected (mean age 27.9 years). All subjects were tested prior and 12 month following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Muscle strength was assessed using a Biodex dynamometer. Isometric strength was examined at 30 and 60 degrees of flexion. Isokinetic testing was performed at 180 degrees/sec and peak torque and symmetry indices were analysed. No correlations were found between the Cinncinnati Score and isokinetic peak torque for extension. A moderate significant (p=0.001–0.007) correlation (r=0.200.45) was found for peak flexion torque in ACL reconstructed patients. In ACL deficient patients symmetry indices (r=0.36–0.43, p=0.001–0.004) were moderately related to functionality for both flexion and extension. Quadriceps muscle strength does not seem to be an important predictor of knee function after ACL reconstruction. Flexors seem to be important to protect the graft from overload. In ACLD knees functionality is related to high symmetry indices suggesting similar strength is necessary to perceive knee function as near normal. This is possibly a normal neuromuscular adaptation caused by contralateral quadriceps avoidance.
Gait analysis is an important tool to measure function following total knee replacement. It is currently unknown whether there is a correlation between subjective and objective outcome variables. The purpose of this study was to analyse relationships between subjective outcome scores and kinematic and kinetic data. 25 consecutive patients (15 males, 10 females) were selected (mean age 68 years, BMI 31.8). All subjects were tested a minimum of 24 months following total knee replacement. SF12, Oxford knee score, knee society and KOOS scores were collected. Muscle strength was assessed using a Biodex dynamometer and symmetry indices were analysed. A timed up and go test and KT2000 measurements were performed. Strong correlations (r=0.52–0.74) were found between scoring systems (SF 12, Oxford knee score, knee society score, KOOS score) and the timed up and go test. Moderate correlations (r=0.27–0.35) were found between knee scores and KT2000 measurements. Only weak correlations (r=0.09–0.12) were found between knee scores and strength. None of the correlations reached statistical significance. Post hoc contrasts demonstrated adequate power (0.95) of the study. The finding of this study suggests that outcome scores and objective and functional tests following total knee arthroplasty measure different variables of outcome. Whilst objective tests and gait analysis provide an understanding of joint mechanics after surgery and can be used to calculate resultant forces and moments, patient perceived outcomes have no Significant correlation to knee biomechanics. This may be related to factors such as pain relief, improved quality of life and the ability to perform activities of daily life. In contrast modern implants may provide a satisfactory outcome resulting in high patient satisfaction. The results of this study underline the importance of using subjective patient outcome measures to follow up total knee replacement patients.
Non-operative treatment of lateral clavicle fractures presents a difficult problem. A high incidence of non-union, residual pain and shoulder girdle instability has been reported. A variety of fixation techniques have been described but the complication rates of these procedures can be high. This retrospective review describes the use of distal radius locking plates for fixation of lateral unstable clavicle fractures. From January 2006 until December 2007 23 patients (17 males, 5 females; mean age 31 yrs (12–70) presented to our service. 2 patients sustained type 1, 16 patients type 2, 2 patients type 4 and 3 patients type 5 fractures (Neer classification). Patients were reviewed clinically, radiographically and with Constant score assessment. Union was acchieved at a mean follow up of 7.2 weeks. The mean Constant score at 6 months was 84, the mean DASH score 27.7. The following complications were seen during the follow-up period: 1 superficial infection settling with oral antibiotics and 1 non-union in a type 5 fracture requiring bone grafting. Clavicle fractures of the lateral aspect are controversial. The mechanism of injury often results in ruptures of the adjacent coracoclavicular ligaments and create instability and increased motion between the proximal and distal fragment. The result of this series of cases are encouraging and we recommend the use of distal radius locking plates to treat unstable lateral clavicle fractures. However a larger study is needed to further evaluate mid- and long-term shoulder function.
High tibial osteotomies are commonly performed for varus/valgus malalignment of the knee. In the past we have been well aware that a high tibial osteotomy corrects the coronal plane but we did not consider changes of the tibial slope. Altering the slope has an impact on the in situ forces of the cruciate ligaments and influences the stability of the knee. The purpose of this study was to investigate the amount of alteration of the tibial slope by a closed wedge osteotomy. From January 2001 to September 2001 we reviewed retrospectively all Xrays of patients that underwent a high tibial osteotomy or were admitted for removal of hardware. 80 patients were included. 67 patients could be followed up. The slope on the preoperative xrays was 6,1 degrees (0–12). A closed wedge osteotomy decreased the slope by a mean of 4,88 degrees. A high tibial osteotomy of six degrees in the coronal plane decreased the slope by 4.29 degrees, a HTO of eight degrees decreased the slope by 7 degrees, a HTO of ten degrees by altered the slope by 4.75 and of twelve degrees by decreased the slope by 6.5 degrees. A closed wedge osteotomy decreases the tibial slope. It is the preferred technique when a combined procedure (HTO and ACL reconstruction) is planned. There is no correlation between the degree of correction of the coronal plane by a closed wedge high tibial osteotomy and changes of the tibial slope.
Osteochondral autologous transplantation (OATS) is a new technique for the treatment of osteochondral defects. In a prospective study between April 1996 und May 2001 we used the OATS technique to treat 201 patients (125 male, 76 female) with a mean osteochondral defect of 3,3 cm2. The defect was in the medial femoral condyle in 96 cases, the lateral femoral condyle in 16, the patella in 22, the trochlea in seven, the tibial plateau in one, the talus in 48, the tibial plafond in two and capitellum in four. There were 17 other locations. The procedure was performed either open or arthroscopically. A mean of 2,2 cylinders was transplanted. The Lysholm score in the lower limbs increased from a preoperative mean of 58,3 (20 to77) to a mean of 90,2 (70 to 100). Treatment by OATS alone increased the score from 65,2 to 91,6. With additional ACL/PCL reconstruction, the score increased from 49,9 to 82,6. The combination of OATS, HTO, ACL/PCL reconstruction increased the Lysholm score from 55,5 to 85,5. Ten per cent of patients complained of pain at the donor site in the lateral femoral condyle. There were no complications related to OATS performed in the upper limbs, and control MRI three months postoperatively showed incorporation of all cylinders. The results are encouraging, and give rise, to the hope that this cost-effective and safe treatment for limited osteochondral defects may delay or even prevent the onset of osteoarthritis.
Traumatic shoulder dislocations at young age result in a significant re-dislocation rate and lead to chronic instability. Conservative treatment fails in 25–96% of cases especially in young active patients. The accepted standard treatment is the classical open Bankart repair which almost always results in loss of motion. The development of new techniques and devices has lead to an increase in arthroscopic techniques for shoulder stabilisations. Between September 1996 and October 2000 262 arthroscopic shoulder stabilisations were performed by the senior author: 159 cases FASTak® titanium anchors, 26 Panalok® anchors and 57 cases Suretac® anchors were used. Minimum follow up was 12 months with a mean follow up of 24.9 months (12–50). Rowe score and a visual analogue scale was used to measure patient satisfaction. The Rowe score increased to 83,1 +/− 20,9. The visual analogue score demonstrated overall patient satisfaction. Complications included redislocations(4.7%) sub-luxations (6.3%) and ongoing instability (6.3%). Return to sports occurred in 89.1% of patients with 68.4% being able to return to their previous sports activity level. This study demonstrates that arthroscopic shoulder stabilisation is comparable to the gold standard open Bankart repair. It is associated with a high patient satisfaction, lower morbidity, faster return to the previous activity level, better range of motion and less postoperative pain. The disadvantage of the technique is a long learning curve and the potentially longer operating times.
Posttraumatic shoulder instability is a common problem in the field of sports medicine. Especially overhead athletes need intact stabilisers to meet the functional requirements. Open procedures often result in limitations of movement postoperatively. Arthroscopic techniques offer potential advantages such as better range of motion and shorter rehabilitation times. Between September 1996 and October 2000 159 arthroscopic shoulder stabilisations were performed with FASTak® anchors. The mean follow up was 24.9 months (12–50). Rowe score and a visual analogue scale were used to measure patient satisfaction. 72 patients (m=57, f=15)with a mean age of 27.6 years (17–65) were included and clinically examined. The Rowe score increased to 83.1 after primary stabilisation and 68.1 after revision procedures. The visual analogue score demonstrated overall patient satisfaction. 89.1% (n=64) of the patients could return to sports with 68,4% (n=49) being able to return to their previous sports activity level. Overhead athletes returned to sports in 89.4% of cases and 63.3% to their pre-injury level. In the non-overhead athletes 86% returned to sports with 60% to their pre-injury level. This study demonstrates that arthroscopic shoulder stabilisation with FASTak® anchors may be offered to the athlete regardless of the sports activity. It allows return to sports in a high percentage and does offer the potential advantages of a faster return to the previous activity level, better range of motion and less postoperative pain. Disadvantages of the technique is a long learning curve and should therefore only be performed by dedicated and experienced shoulder surgeons.
In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more of the authors has received, or is likely to receive direct material benefits.
It is suggested that there is a link between arch type of the foot and overuse injuries. The use of individual selected running shoes can reduce running injuries substantially. To select the correct shoe the runner needs to have appropriate knowledge of his own foot anatomy and biomechanics. A questionnaire was used to investigate the knowledge of the runner about his arch height and biomechanics of running. Clinical examination was performed by 5 orthopaedic surgeons and experienced orthopaedic technicians. Weight-bearing podograms were used to further define the deformity. We examined 92 volunteers with a mean age of 35.4 (12–63) years, a mean size of 176 cm (154–195) with a mean body weight of 70.38 kg (45–95). Eighteen out of 47 runners with a flatfoot deformity identified their deformity correctly. Twenty five out of 43 volunteers with a normal arch were correct in assessing their foot. Two runners with a cavus foot were correct in identifying their foot. Only 4 out of 38 runners that diagnosed themselves as being pronators have been found to be pronators. Four runners with a self-diagnosed non-pro-nating foot were classified as being pronators. Three runners that could not classify themselves were diagnosed as pronators. This study demonstrates the poor knowledge of foot deformities in the running community.
Large osteochondral defects are difficult to treat, but several treatment options are available. The posterior condyle transfer salvage technique described by Wagner in 1964 and Imhoff in 1990 has been developed further and is now used for coverage of large osteochondral defects in the load-bearing zone. The new technique is called MEGA-OATS. From July 1999, 25 patients of mean age 33.3 years (17 to 60) were treated with MEGA-OATS. Thirteen patients additionally underwent high tibial osteotomy and two bone grafting, using bone harvested from the proximal tibia. The mean follow up was 17.8 months. The technique calls for excision of the posterior femoral condyle which is placed in a specially designed work station. A MEGA-OATS cylinder of diameter 20 mm to 35 mm is prepared and, using the press-fit technique, grafted into the prepared defect zone. The Lysholm score increased postoperatively from 66.33 (49 to 71) to 87.8 (72 to 97). Three months postoperatively control MRI showed incorporation of all cylinders. Between six and 12 weeks postoperatively patients attained a full range of motion and became fully weight-bearing. To date one superficial infection resolving on oral antibiotics and two cases of arthrofibrosis four months postoperatively that required arthroscopic release were seen. No postoperative meniscal lesions of the posterior horn have been observed. MEGA-OATS achieves a congruent reconstruction of the articular surface in the load-bearing zone of the femoral condyle. We consider it a good alternative in the treatment of large osteochondral defects of the femoral condyle in young patients.