We propose a grading system for contrast free MRI images of tennis elbow and evaluate the inter and intra observer variability of their interpretation.

Methods: Three senior orthopaedic surgeons were asked to blindly grade 0.2T dedicated extremity contrast free MRI images of elbows of patients who presented with varying degrees of symptomatic tennis elbow.

Our proposed grading system of 1 to 5 based on the pattern around the common extensor tendon was used.

Images of the symptomatic and contralateral non symptomatic elbows were graded blindly twice with an interval of 1 month by each surgeon.

Each surgeon graded 176 MRI images twice.

The grades were subsequently grouped into (I) grades 1 to 2 and (II) grades 3 to 5

Results: With regards to the intra observer agreement, consultant A showed 90.1% agreement, consultant B showed 90.6% agreement and consultant C 96.0% agreement. The mean intra observer agreement rate was 92.2%.

The inter observer agreement between consultant A and B was 82.46%, between A and C 67.1% and between B and C 80.1%.

It was also noted that there were systematic differences to the inter observer variability. Consultant A graded the images 3 to 5 on both occasions 52.9% of the time, consultant B graded 3 to 5 on both occasions 37.8% of the time and consultant C graded 3 to 5 on both occasions 23.3% of the time.

Conclusion: The intra observer agreement rate is high. There is however a greater inter observer variation but this variation is consistent. We suggest that the inter observer differences can be improved by (1) reducing the grades to positive or negative and (2) by group reeducation of the observers.

Introduction: Darrach’s procedure is indicated for conditions were the distal radio-ulnar joint movement is painful or restricted. The procedure may be indicated at the time of wrist arthrodesis. Darrach’s procedure is not without complications and revision surgery may be indicated.

Aims: To determine the success rate following wrist arthrodesis and whether Darrach’s procedure correlates to revision surgery.

Methods: A retrospective case note review was performed of a consecutive series of patients who underwent wrist arthrodesis between 1991 and 2002 at our institution; performed by a single surgeon.

Results: 73 patients underwent wrist arthrodesis. 39 were female and 34 male. The indications for wrist arthrodesis were rheumatoid disease, osteoarthritis, carpal instability and failed wrist arthroplasty. Successful arthrodesis was achieved in 82% (60/73) of patients, where revision arthrodesis was defined as the end point. 25% (18/73) patients underwent Darrach’s procedure at the time of their primary arthrodesis. 25% (15/60) of the patients whose primary arthrodesis was successful underwent concomitant Darrach’s procedure. 23% (3/13) of patients who underwent revision arthrodesis had undergone concomitant Darrach’s procedure during their primary arthrodesis. 77% (10/13) patients who underwent revision arthrodesis did not undergo Darrach’s procedure at the time of their primary arthrodesis. Of these 10 patients, 3 (30%) of them underwent concomitant Darrach’s procedure during revision arthrodesis.

Conclusion: Wrist arthrodesis in our institution is comparable with that of published literature. The incidence of Darrach’s procedure at the time of primary wrist arthrodesis is 25%. There is a small increase to 30% in the number of patients who require Darrach’s procedure at the time of revision arthrodesis, which is not statistically significant.

Introduction. There has been a recent major increase in the use of unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) but few studies exist comparing its long term efficiency with total knee replacement (TKR)

Method. Ethical approval was obtained.

Between 1989 and 1992 a randomised prospective study was undertaken in which 102 cases adjudged suitable for UKR were allocated to receive either a St Georg Sled UKR or a Kinematic Modular TKR. Both cohorts had a median age of 68 and a similar sex distribution and preoperative knee score. Regular follow up has been maintained. As reported the early results favoured UKR. All cases have now been assessed after a minimum of 10 years using modified WOMAC, Oxford and Bristol Knee Scores (BKS) as well as radiographs.

Results. 28 cases had died with their knees known to be intact, 2 cases were untraceable. 33 knees in each group were reviewed. 3 in each group had been revised, no impending failures were identified on the radiographs.

At 10 years the UKR group had better Oxford and WOMAC scores as well as significantly more excellent results (19:14) and fewer fair and poor results on the BKS. Both groups averaged over 105′ of flexion but 61% of the UKR and only 15% of the TKR group had 120′ or more of flexion.

Conclusion. The faster rehabilitation and better early results with UKR are maintained for 10 years with few failures occurring. The average BKS of the UKR group only fell from 91 to 88 between 5 and 10 years suggesting minimal evidence of functional deterioration in either the prosthesis or the remainder of the joint.

Introduction and Aims: There has recently been an increase in the use of uni-compartmental knee replacement (UKR), but there are few studies comparing its long-term efficacy and survival with total knee replacement (TKR). We reported the five-year results of a randomised trial which showed that uni-compartmental replacement had a faster rehabilitation and better functional results than total replacement. We now report the 10-year results.

Method: After obtaining ethical approval, between 1989 and 1992, 102 cases judged suitable for UKR were randomly allocated to receive either a St Georg Sled UKR or a Kinematic Modular TKR. Both cohorts had a median age of 68 and a similar sex distribution and pre-operative knee scores. Regular follow-up has been maintained. All cases have now been assessed after a minimum of 10 years using modified the WOMAC, Pain, Oxford and Bristol Knee (BSK) scoring systems as well as radiographs.

Results: At 10 years, 29 cases had died with their knees known to be intact, two totals cases were untraceable. Thirty-two uni`s, and 34 totals were available for review. Three uni`s (6%) and two totals (4%) had been revised; there was one impending total failure on the radiographs.

The UKR group had better scores with Oxford: 38 v 34 /48 and WOMAC: 17 v 21 /60 and more excellent results (19 v 14) and fewer fair and poor results on the BKS (4 v 6). The range of movement improved in UKA`s from 107 degrees to 117 degrees, whereas the range decreased in TRK`s from 107 degrees to 104 degrees. Sixty-one percent of the UKR and only 16% of the TKR group had more than 120 degrees of flexion.

Conclusion: The St Georg Uni-compartmental arthroplasty continues to function well at 10 years, with better functional scores and a better range of movement than the Kinematic Total arthroplasty. There were similar failures in both groups.

Traditionally midshaft clavicle fractures have been treated conservatively. It is recognized that displaced and shortened fractures may be better treated operatively. In particular, patients with greater than 20 mm of shortening and 100 percent displacement have a symptomatic non union rate of 30 percent. The standard technique used previously has been via plate fixation with LC-DCP or DCP. However in the last 5 years intramedullary fixation has been popularized. “Rockwood intramedulary clavicular pin” remedies the past treatment issues including poor blood supply, painful prominent hardware and stress raiser related to removal of metal work.

Aim: The aim of this study was to assess the functional outcome following intramedullary fixation of clavicle using Rockwood pin.

Method: We retrospectively evaluated 17 patients with displaced and shortened mid-shaft clavicular fractures who underwent intramedullary pinning using Rock-wood pins. Each patient was assessed using the ASES, Constant and SF36 scoring system. A physical examination was performed and individual radiographs were assessed to determine union.

Results: The mean age of the patients was 28 (range 15–56). All patients went into union within 2 to 4 months. They had a shorter stay in hospital, earlier mobilization and no scar related paraesthesia. The average ASES score 98.2 (range 92–100) and constant 95.3 (range 89–100).

Summary: Displaced and shortened mid clavicular fractures require operative fixation. Plates and screws on the clavicle requires significant soft tissue stripping leading to compromised blood supply to the bone and multiple bi-cortical screws act as stress raisers. Previous intra-medullary devices presented with the problem of pin migration. Rockwood pins are designed with a differential pitch which leads to compression at the fracture site and prevent pin migration. From this study we now recommend the use of the Rockwood Pin for the management of displaced mid-shaft clavicle fractures.

Aim: To assess the functional outcome following internal fixation with the PHILOS® plating system for displaced proximal humeral fractures by using the ASES and Constant scoring system.

Background: Controversy exists with regards to the management of displaced proximal humeral fractures and many methods of treatment have been proposed over the years. In particular, the role of surgery has not been clearly defined. The current trend is toward limited dissection of the soft tissues with the use of minimal amounts of hardware to gain stability.

Methods: We performed a retrospective analysis of 30 consecutive patients treated surgically with the PHILOS ® plate for a displaced proximal humeral fracture between February 2002 and October 2003. Patients were assessed clinically and radio graphically at an average follow-up time of 9 months. Functional outcome was determined utilising the American Shoulder and Elbow Society score (ASES) and Constant Murley score. The injury was classified using Neer’s 4 part classification.

Results: Average age of the patients was 58 years (19 to 92). There were 6 two part, 14 three part and 10 four part fractures. All the fractures were radio graphically united by 10 weeks. The average overall ASES score is 66.5%. The average overall Constant score is 55%. The average external rotation at 90 of abduction for the ages 15–55 was 55°–64° and the ages 56–95 was 25°–34°. The average forward elevation for the ages 15–55 was 85°–95° and the ages 76–95 was 55°–64°. The most difficult movement for the older subgroup of patients was internal rotation which was up to the sacrum.

Conclusion: Our results show that good fracture stability and functional outcome can be obtained from the use of the PHILOS® plate. Early mobilisation of the shoulder can be achieved without compromising fracture union. We would recommend the use of the PHILOS® plate for the management of displaced fractures of the proximal humerus.

Aim: To evaluate the functional outcome of patients following intra-osseous suturing for repair of distal biceps tendon ruptures, using the Mayo scoring system. Subsequent analysis of mRNA expression; in the ruptured biceps tendons was performed.

Methods: We operated on 8 patients who had ruptured their biceps tendon. The average ages of the patients were 36 (Range 22–50). The technique involved using intrasosseous suturing via a single anterior skin crease incision. The functional outcome of these patients was scored by using the Mayo elbow performance score. The average follow-up was 7 months. (Range 5–8 months). The tendons were processed for RNA isolation and reverse -transcription – polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR).

Results: The average subjective assessment (pain and function) of these patients was 63/70 (Range 57–68). The average objective assessment (motion and stability) was 24/30 (Range 22–27). The overall average was 87/100. None of the patients had any complications postoperatively. Our results showed that in the samples of ruptured biceps tendon there was mRNA expression of ECM structural components, especially aggrecan and the small proteoglycans biglycan and decorin. Interestingly, these samples also showed a high expression for the enzymes commonly involved in articular cartilage degradation and turnover, the aggrecanases (ADAMTS-4 and ADAMTS-5) and the matrix metalloproteinases (MMP-3 and MMP-13).

Conclusion: We demonstrated that intrasosseous suturing via a single anterior incision, in-patients with ruptured biceps tendons could provide a good functional outcome. This technique should therefore be considered as one of the surgical options in the management of this condition. We know clinically that patients can rupture their biceps tendon either due to trauma if not due to degenerative conditions. In our study we wanted to know if the subset of patients how ruptured their tendons traumatically had any pre-existing degenerative conditions leading on to the rupture compared to the normal subjects. Interestingly our study has shown that there is mRNA expression of degradative enzymes (aggrecanases and MMPs) in the samples of ruptured biceps tendon. Furthermore, our samples also showed mRNA expression for factors involved in the inflammatory response. In conclusion, mRNA expression of the factors involved in degradation and inflammation may suggest a phenotype that predisposes the biceps tendon to rupture, although further studies are required in order to investigate this.

Aim: To study mRNA expression in ruptured biceps tendon.

Methods: Our study was carried out in the University College of Medicine. We took the biceps tendon of 5 patients who had traumatic ruptures. The age of the patients ranged from 35–53. The tendons were processed for RNA isolation and reverse-transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) carried out in order to investigate the mRNA gene expression in ruptured biceps tendon of extra cellular matrix (ECM) components (e.g. proteoglycans and collagens); ECM degradative components (e.g. aggrecanases and MMPs); inflammatory components (e.g. cytokines and cyclooxygenases); and factors involved in the apoptotic response.

Results: Our results showed that in the samples of ruptured biceps tendon there was a good mRNA expression of ECM structural components, especially aggrecan and the small proteoglycans biglycan and decorin. Interestingly, these samples also showed a high expression for the enzymes commonly involved in articular cartilage degradation and turnover, the aggrecanases (ADAMTS-4 and –5) and the matrix metalloproteinases (MMP-3 and –13). As has been recently reported for Achilles tendon rupture (Cetti et al, 2003), an inflammatory reaction was also observed in these ruptured bicep tendons with expression of the inflammatory cytokines IL-1α and TNFα and the enzyme cyclooxygenase-2.

Conclusion: We know clinically that patients can rupture their biceps tendon either due to trauma if not due to degenerative conditions. In our study we wanted to know if the subset of patients who ruptured their tendons traumatically had any pre-existing degenerative conditions leading on to the rupture compared to the normal subjects. Interestingly our study has shown that there is mRNA expression of degradative enzymes (aggrecanases and MMPs) in the samples of ruptured biceps tendon. Whether these mRNA levels equate to increased enzyme activity of these molecules warrants further investigation. Furthermore, our samples also showed mRNA expression for factors involved in the inflammatory response. In conclusion, mRNA expression of the factors involved in degradation and inflammation may suggest a phenotype that predisposes the bicep tendon to rupture, although further studies are required in order to investigate this further.

Introduction: Lateral uni-compartmental knee replacement (UKR) is seldom indicated and remains controversial. It has been considered a technically challenging operation with variable success. Aim: The aim of this paper is to assess the results of unicompartmental knee replacement using a þxed noncongruous prosthesis. Methods: Eighty-eight knees in 79 patients with lateral unicompartmental osteoarthritis treated with a þxed bearing, non-congruous, fully unconstrained prosthesis. (St Georg Sled UKR) over a period of 21 years by different consultants and there trainees. Surgical approach and rehabilitation protocol varied over this period but there was no change in the surgical indications. Results: At a mean follow up of 9 years (range 2 to 21 years). Fifteen knees had revision surgery (9 for progression of arthritis and 6 for component loosening, 4 for implant breakage and 4 for more than one reason). Six patients complained of moderate or severe pain at þnal follow up. Only þve knees were lost to follow up in the 21-year period. Survivorship analysis was performed on the group using revision for any cause as the end point. At ten years the cumulative survival rate was 83% and at 15 years, when ten knees were still at risk, the cumulative survival rate was 74%. Conclusion: Based on our clinical results and survival rate the St Georg Sled UKR can be considered a suitable treatment for isolated lateral compartment osteoarthritis.

Introduction: The realisation that the medical and lateral menisci of the knee have important load-bearing and stability functions has stimulated orthopaedic surgeons to aim for preservation rather than excision if at all possible. The absence of meniscal tissue has been shown to increase load through the articular cartilage and ultimately accelerate the process of osteoarthritic degeneration. A major limitation is the relative avascularity of a large portion of the normal meniscus. McAndrews and Arnoczky reported in 1996 that repair of the white-white and even red-white zone remains a challenge. Monobutyrin is an angiogenic factor that has been used in the stimulation of healing burns and we hypothesized that it may have a positive effect on the healing meniscus.

The aim of the study was to determine the effects of 0 Ticron suture soaked in polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) on the histological and mechanical properties of healing meniscal tears in the red-white zone in an established animal model.

Methods: A bilateral medical meniscal incision model was used in 21 adult sheep.

Results: We confirmed that the PHB had no deleterious effects on the mechanical properties of the suture prior to commencing the surgery. Mechanical testing of the menisci at the set time-points demonstrated a significantly stronger repair in the PHB-soaked group. Macroscopic appearances were graded and found to be improved with PHB soaked sutures. On histological examination there were features suggestive of a more intense healing response including angiogenesis.

Conclusions: We have concluded that the use of butyric acid has no deleterious effects on the mechanical properties of the suture used and has positive effects on meniscal healing. We recommend further examination of this exciting development.

To determine whether the Dynamic Condylar Screw, DCS, is suitable in treating pathological subtrochanteric fractures of the femur and the incidence of failure with this device.

Nineteen sequential and unselected patients with twenty femurs with pathological subtrochanteric fractures, or impending fractures, were identified, which had been treated with DCS. Mean age was seventy. Follow up was until functional union (minimum follow up 18 months) or until death. Primary tumour was identified in seventeen of the nineteen cases.

Grade of surgeon was recorded as was the use of adjunctive measures at the time of surgery (PMMA). Subsequent failure, cause and need for revision was noted.

Operative morbidity was low and initial pain relief good in all cases. Two fractures went on to unite. Eight original implants survived until the patient died (mean survival time 24 days). Ten implants failed (50%). Failure resulted from fracture through the DCS plate in eight cases and cut out of the screw in the other two. Of these, five patients (6 femurs) went on to further operative procedures. The others were either deemed unfit (3 cases) or refused further surgery (1 case).

In the light of newer intramedullary techniques we feel the DCS should be used with caution in this type of fracture. DCS in this fracture is associated with a high degree of failure.

Surgeons often protect Tendon-bone reconstructions such as rotator cuff repairs by off loading them. We investigated the effect of limb position and boundary conditions in an in-vitro rabbit patella tendon-bone repair model. Patella tendons were repaired back to the tibia in eight hindlimb cadavers with 2 mitek anchors(Mitek, Westwood, MA) and 3-0 Ethibond (Ethicon, Sommerville, NJ) using two techniques, one involving simple sutures and the other involving crossing over between the sutures. A loading mechanism through the patella tendon was constructed using static weights over a pulley mechanism. The contact area and force at the PT-bone interface were measured using a TekScan pressure sensor (6911, TekScan, South Boston, MA). The contact footprint (area and normal force) was acquired under four configurations: (1) knee full extension with interface unloaded, (2) knee 45° flexion with interface unloaded, (3) knee full flexion with interface loaded by limb weight alone, (4) tendon loaded with limb weight and 20N force applied through tendon loading mechanism. The contact area force footprint changed substantially between the different suture techniques and loading configurations. Crossing over of sutures appears to provide an increased and more evenly distributed force across the tendon-bone interface. Repair off-loading was accompanied by a decrease in the contact footprint force and pressure. The force in both suture techniques increased with increasing flexion angle and was substantially increased by both bearing the weight of the dependent limb and by an axial load in the patellar tendon. Off loading a repair may not provide optimal environment for healing.

In Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) and Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) the total blood loss is composed of ‘visible’ blood loss from the surgical field and wound drainage, and blood loss into the tissues which is ‘hidden’. Blood management should be aimed at addressing the total blood loss.

56 TKAs and 46 THAs were prospectively studied. TKAs were performed with tourniquet. After tourniquet release, all drained blood was salvaged and significant volumes reinfused. No reinfusion was used for THAs.

The true total blood loss was calculated in the following way:

Patient Blood Volume (PBV) is: [1]

PBV = k1 x height3 + k2 x weight + k3

Therefore patient total Red Blood Cell volume (RBCv) is:

RBCv = PBV x Hct. (where Hct is Haematocrit)

Total RBCv loss = PBV x (Hct preop – Hct postop) + ml RBC transfused

The result is reconverted to Whole Blood volume.

Hidden Loss = Total Loss – Visible Loss.

In TKA, the mean total true blood loss was 1474ml. The mean hidden loss was 735ml. Therefore hidden loss is 50% of the total loss and the total true loss following TKA is twice the visible volume. In THA, the mean total true blood loss was 1629ml. The mean hidden loss was 343ml.

Thus hidden loss in THA is much smaller. (21%) Total loss is 1.3 times the visible loss. In the TKA group, comparing patients with large losses receiving reinfusion and those with small losses not receiving reinfusion, the proportion of total true loss which was hidden was the same, at 50%.

Patients with Body Mass Index (BMI) > 30 were compared with those with a BMI < 30 and no correlation was found between BMI and Hidden Loss.

Joint Replacement Surgery involves a ‘hidden’ blood loss which is not revealed and cannot be measured or reinfused in practice, but which should be taken into account when planning blood loss management. In TKA it is substantial. In THA it is much smaller and probably not of as much clinical concern. Hidden loss is no greater in the Obese patient.

Objective: To report the survivorship rate and clinical outcome of a large series of lateral unicompartmental replacements.

Method: 88 lateral St Georg Sled LTKRS were performed between 1978 and 1999. Clinical and radiological data was prospectively recorded at regular follow up and only 5 knees were lost during the 22 year period.

Results: 15 knees were revised after an average of 8 years. (eight for progressive arthritis, six for loosening and four for femoral fracture) 29 patients (30 knees) died during the course of the study. At final follow up (average 9 years) 50 of the 63 remaining knees were rated as good or excellent, nine as fair and nine poor. The mean range of flexion was 110°.

At 10 years the cumulative survival rate was 83% and at 15 years 78% (10 knees at risk). The “worst case scenario” where knees with pain or lost to follow up are added to revisions shows a 10 year survivorship of 74%.

Conclusion: Although the results are not as good as medial UKR. These clinical outcomes suggest that the conservative surgical procedure of lateral UKR with the fixed bearing St George Sled prosthesis can give acceptable results in the uncommon situation of severely symptomatic isolated lateral tibio femoral arthritis.

Horse riding is a common pursuit and is more dangerous than believed. Most injuries of the hand and wrist are caused by falls, as in other sports. However, exclusive to riding are injuries sustained whilst leading a horse. Avulsion injuries are well recognised but little has been reported on phalangeal fractures in this situation.

We report on seven cases that required hospitalisation in our hand unit, for injuries from horses over a two year period. Six of these patients sustained multi-fragmented spiral periarticular fractures involving the middle and proximal phalanx and one a horse bit.

We will discuss in detail the mechanism of their injuries, the surgery undertaken, their post-operative rehabilitation and overall outcome. Furthermore we review the recommended horse handling technique and contrast it with the mechanism of injury in our cases.

In our experience the fractures seen were unstable, comminuted and needed internal fixation. One patient developed a delayed union and three post-operative stiffness. Our results suggest that fractures whilst leading horses are more complex than recognised, usually need surgery and often have a relatively poor outcome. All of these cases were largely preventable and could be attributed to incorrect horse leading technique.

Previous clinical studies have studied tibiofibular torsion by measuring the angular difference between a proximal (often bicondylar) plane and a distal bimalleolar plane. We measured the angular difference between the proximal and distal posterior tibial planes as defined by ultrasound scans. We found no significant torsional difference between the right and left tibiae of 87 normal children, nor between their different age groups. The mean external torsion of 58 legs with congenital talipes equinovarus was 18 degrees; significantly less than the mean 40 degrees in the normal children and 27 degrees in the clinically normal legs of the 22 patients with unilateral congenital talipes equinovarus. We did not confirm the previously reported increase in external torsion with increasing age. The relative internal tibial torsion we have demonstrated in patients with congenital talipes equinovarus must be differentiated from the posterior displacement of the distal fibula observed by others and which may result from manipulative treatment. The relative internal tibial torsion we found in the clinically normal legs of children with congenital talipes equinovarus is further evidence that in this condition the pathology is not confined to the clinically affected foot.

The parameters of cellular proliferation and growth in the growth plates of immature rats were measured after unilateral tibial osteotomy and used to calculate growth rates. Distal osteotomy of one tibia was followed by a bilateral increase in the calculated growth rate of the distal growth plates. However, the ipsilateral distal growth plate grew faster than the contralateral between 12 and 18 days after operation, which appeared to be related to increased cell proliferation and height. Proximal osteotomy led to an increase in growth rates proximally which was more marked on the contralateral side. The lesser response of the ipsilateral growth plate may have been due to local impairment of blood supply, or to greater local release of metabolites after bony damage. Distal tibial osteotomy gave similar results to circumferential release of the distal tibial periosteum. Proximal osteotomy, however, produced a relative impairment of growth on the operated side. This may be of importance in the correction of childhood deformities associated with inequality of leg length.