Purpose: Revision patellofemoral arthroplasty (PFA) is a relatively uncommon procedure, with no published reviews identified in the literature. Revision PFAs performed at our institution were reviewed to determine the reasons for PFA failure, the technical ease of revision and to document patient-reported outcomes after revision.

Methods: A prospective review of a cohort of 411 Avon PFA patients identified 31 subsequent revision knee procedures in 27 patients. Data was collected from the institution’s prospective data base, operative reports, X-rays and medical records. Post-operative knee scores (Oxford Knee Score, WOMAC Osteoarthritis Index, Bristol Knee Score) were available on 26 knees.

Results: The commonest reason for revision was progression of osteoarthritis (18 cases) followed by undetermined pain (7 cases). Patients with undetermined pain were found to be revised sooner than patients with disease progression (33 months vs 63 months) and also reported poorer outcome scores at 2 years post revision than the disease progression group.

Only two trochlea components were loose at the time of revision and one patella had a large amount of macroscopic wear. All other components were found to be well fixed with minimal wear at the time of revision. There were no difficulties in removing either component. No cases required augments or stemmed femoral components due to bone loss.

Patients undergoing revision surgery did report improvement in their post revision outcome scores compared with their pre-operative scores. The average Oxford Knee Score improved from 17 to 23, Bristol Knee Pain Scores improved from 11 to 20 and Bristol Knee Functional Scores improved from 15 to 16. These results are poorer than those recorded by the overall cohort of primary PFA.

Conclusion: PFA is easy to revise to a primary total knee. Results of revision knees are improved from pre-operative scores but not as good as expected.

Objective: To review the results of the Avon patellofemoral arthroplasty at 5 to 8 years.

Methods: The Avon patellofemoral arthroplasty was introduced in clinical practice in September 1996. We present a prospective cohort review of all patients treated in the first three years. Patients were evaluated using the Bristol knee score (BSK), the Melbourne patella score (MPS) and the Oxford knee score (OKS).

Results: 109 patellofemoral arthroplasties were performed in 92 patients between September 1996 and November 1999. The median age was 68 years (range 46 to 86 years). Nine patients (12 knees) died and two patients (two knees) were unfit for follow-up. Ten knees in 9 patients were lost to follow-up giving a follow-up rate of 89%. The mean period of follow-up was 5.6 years.

The median pain score rose from 15/40 pre-operatively to 40 points at eight years. The median (MPS) rose from 10/30 points pre-operatively to 25 points at eight years. The median (OKS) rose from 18/48 pre-operatively to 38 at eight years. 87% of knees had mild or no pain at eight years. There were no cases of failure of the prosthesis itself. All 15 revisions resulted from progression of arthrititis in the tibio-femoral joint. The five-year survival rate for all causes with 86 cases at risk was 96%.

Conclusions: The results show that this type of arthroplasty can give predictable pain relief and excellent functional improvement in patients with isolated patello-femoral arthritis. Disease progression is the main reason for revision to total knee replacement and great care is required in assessing the indications for this procedure.

Purpose of Study: Fixed bearing unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) has become popular since several series have shown good 10 year survivorship and excellent function. However little is known about survival during the second decade.

Method: From the Bristol database of over 4000 knee replacements 203 St. George Sled UKR’s which had already survived 10 years were identified. The mean age at surgery was 67 years (48–85), with 64% being female. This cohort has been further reviewed at an average of 14.8 years (10–30) from surgery to determine survivor-ship and function.

Results: Survivorship during the second decade was 87.5%. 58 patients (69 knees) had deceased with implant in situ, only 2 after revision. A further 15 UKR’s have been revised at an average of 13 years post op; 7 for progression of disease, 4 for tibial loosening, 3 for polyethylene wear, 2 for femoral component fracture and 2 for infection.

99 knees were followed for 15 years and 21 knees for 20 years. The average Bristol knee score of the surviving knees fell from 86 to 79 during the second decade.

A previous study showed an 89% 10 year survivor-ship and this is now extended to 82% at 15 years and 76.5% at 20 years.

Conclusion: Satisfactory survival of fixed bearing UKR can be achieved in the second decade suggesting that the indications for mobile bearings require careful definition since there is a higher incidence of complications in many people’s hands.

Aims: determine functional outcome of revision Avon patellofemoral replacements (PFR), converted from primary Lubinus PFR.

Materials and Methods:

Prospective review of 11 knees (8 patients, 6 female).

Average age at primary PFR – 64 years

Indication – isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis (11), patellofemoral instability (3)

9 knees (7 patients) temporarily improved.

Revision Avon PFR at average 83 months after primary procedure.

Indication – polyethylene wear

polyethylene synovitis

femoral component malposition

At review:

average 61 months after revision

age – 70 years 10 months.

fixed flexion contracture 1.7°

maximum flexion 111°.

Bristol knee score improved from average of 54.5 to 77.2. Pain score component averaged 25, functional component averaged 16.9. No malalignment or instability.

Average American Knee Society Score 132.8

Bartlett patellar score 19.8

Three patients (4 knees) had medical problems contributing to their functional incapacity.

No radiological complications except minor polyethylene wear on lateral facet of one patella. Progression to tibiofemoral osteoarthritis (Ahlburgh grade 1) in 3 knees.

Discussion: Primary Lubinus PFR temporarily improved 82% of knees. Maltracking/polyethylene wear was usual cause for failure. Revision to Avon PFR resulted in substantial improvement of pain and function.

Conclusion: revision Avon PFR can provide a suitable alternative to revision to total knee replacement.

Purpose A new design of patello-femoral arthroplasty has been used to treat patients under 55 years suffering severe symptoms from chondral and early arthritic disease of the patello-femoral joint.

Materials and Methods and Results Fifty-two patello-femoral arthroplasties were performed in 45 patients under the age of fifty-five years when other treatments had failed. The average age was 48 years (range 36–54 years). Thirty-seven cases had undergone previous surgery for a variety of conditions, and the causes of the disorders were analysed. Results were assessed using pain scores and Bartlett’s and Oxford functional scores. 35 cases were reviewed at 8 months and 22 cases at two years. The median pain score improved from 10/40 points to 35 at two years. The Bartlett score increased from 10/30 points to 27 and the Oxford score from 19/48 points to 35 at two years. The range of movement increased from 114° to 121°. There have been no cases of deep infection, loosening, wear or instability. Disease progression, a potential risk has occurred in one case.

Conclusions This prosthesis offers a solution in younger patients with disabling symptoms of isolated early patello-femoral disease who have not responded to conservative surgical management.

Isolated patellofemoral arthritis occurs in up to 10% of patients suffering osteoarthritis of the knee. Previous reports of several different patellofemoral designs have given indifferent results. The Lubinus prosthesis has been shown to have a 50% failure rate at eight years in a study of 76 cases. The main reasons for failure were mal-alignment, wear, impingement and disease progression. As a result of these studies, a new prosthesis was designed to solve some of these problems.

The Avon patellofemoral arthroplasty was first implanted in September 1996. The cases have been entered into a prospective review with evaluations at eight months, two years and five years. The outcome was assessed using pain scores, Bartlett’s patella score and the Oxford knee score. To date, 186 knees have been treated; over 100 knees have been reviewed at two years and 20 knees at five years. The main pain score improved from a pre-operative level of 13.5 points out of 40 to 33.5 points at two years and 36 at five years. The mean pre-operative movement was 109° and this increased to 120° at five years. The Bartlett patella score improved from a pre-operative level of 10.5 points out of 30 pre-operatively to 23 points at two years and 25 at five years. The Oxford knee score was 20 points out of 48 pre-operatively and this improved to 35 points at two years and 40 points at five years. One patient developed subluxation, which required distal soft tissue realignment. No other patient has developed problems with alignment or wear. Ten knees have developed evidence of disease progression usually in the medial compartment of which six have required revision to a total knee replacement.

The results to date suggest that this improved design has all but eliminated the previous problems of malalignment and early wear. The functional results are as good or better than those of a total knee replacement. There is a low complication rate and an excellent range of movement. Disease progression remains a potential problem. This type of prosthesis offers a reasonable alternative to total knee replacement in this small group of patients with isolated, early patellofemoral disease.

The aim of this study was to report our experience of patellofemoral arthroplasty in isolated osteoarthrosis.

Material and Methods: The Lubinus Patellofemoral Arthroplasty was performed between 1989 and 1995 in 76 knees. The Avon Patella Femoral Arthroplasty was used from 1996 to 2001 in 187 knees. The average age of the patients was 65.5 years (range 36–87) with a male to female ratio of 1: 5. All the patients have been prospectively reviewed with standard radiographs, the Bristol Knee Score, and more recently Bartlett and Oxford scores.

Results: Patients with the Lubinus prosthesis were followed for an average of 7.4 years (range 5–10 years). Eleven patients (14 knees) have died and the remaining 62 knees have a 100% follow-up. The cumulative revision rate was 28% (21 out of 76). Survivorship at 8 years was 65% (Cl 49 to 77) for revision and 48% (Cl 36 to 59) for revision plus moderate pain. The two main complications were Maltracking 32% and progressive tibio-femoral arthritis in 9%.

The Avon Arthroplasty with improved design features for better tracking and congruity was introduced in 1996 and 187 have now been inserted in 147 patients. One hundred and nine knees have been followed for 8 months and 82 have completed the 2 year follow-up. Two patients have undergone revision to a TKR 97.5% (survivorship 2 out of 82). Three patients have had a unicompartmental arthroplasty added for disease progression. There have been no cases of patella maltracking or subliaxation.

Four year survivorship for moderate pain and revision is 96% (79 out of 82). Functional scores compared favourably with parallel series of total knee replacements.

Conclusion: The medium-term results of the Lubinus Patello Femoral Arthroplasty are unsatisfactory. We suggest the use of this prosthesis should be discontinued. The Avon Arthroplasty has improved results in the short-term.

The aim of this study was to assess the value of plain AP and lateral radiographs in determining ACL condition in medial unicompartmental osteoarthritis.

Background: A functioning ACL has been shown to be important in the success of certain unicompartmental knee replacements. White (2001) has shown MRI to be too sensitive in this age group of patients. Keyes (1992) suggested that stress radiographs were necessary to accurately assess ACL integrity.

Method: One hundred and twenty-six patients undergoing knee arthroplasty for medial osteoarthritis, had their ACL’s graded as Normal, Frayed or Absent intra-operatively. Standard pre-operative AP and lateral standing radiographs were graded by the Ahlback system. On the lateral view, the plateau was divided into 5 zones from anterior to posterior. The zone, in which the point of deepest wear occurred, was recorded.

Results: There was a significant difference between the occurrence of deepest wear in the anterior three zones versus the posterior two zones for ACL normal and absent knees (² = 46.85, P< 0.001). There was a significant difference between the occurrence of normal and absent ACL’s in Ahlback grades ≤3 versus ≥4 (² = 53.8, P< 0.001). There was a moderately strong correlation between both zone of deepest wear on lateral radiograph and Ahlback grade with ACL condition (Spearman’s rho = 0.62 and 0.69 respectively). The Positive Predictive Values for the ACL being normal are 64% for Ahlback grades 3 or less and 67% for Zone of deepest wear in the anterior 3 zones. The Positive Predictive Values for the ACL being intact (but not necessarily normal) are 95% for Ahlback grade 3 or less; 91% for Zone of deepest wear in the anterior 3 zones; and 97% if these criteria are combined.

Combining Ahlback grade ≤3 with wear in the anterior 3 zones also gave a Negative Predictive Value of 92% for the ACL not being normal.

Conclusion: There is a “watershed” in ACL condition between Ahlback grade 3 and 4. Prostheses requiring Normal or Intact ACL’s should only be performed if Ahlback grade is ≤3. Standard radiographs can reliably predict ACL condition with high Positive and Negative predictive values.

The aim of this study was to assess the distribution of wear down to bone in lateral compartment osteoarthritis and to analyse the effect of ACL condition and Ahlbach grading on this distribution.

Background: The distribution of medial compartment wear is now well described and shows posterior progression and increased area of wear with worsening AhIback grade and ACL condition (Porteous 2000). Harman (1998) described wear situated more posteriorly in the lateral compartment but did not show any change to this with altering ACL function, and did not assess the severity of the arthritis.

Method: Forty two tibial plateaus resected at total or unicompartmental replacement for lateral compartment osteoarthritis were analysed for the anterior and posterior extent of wear, as well as the point of deepest wear and the size of lesion. The plateau was divided into five zones from anterior to posterior. The ACL condition at surgery was graded as Normal, Frayed or Absent. Radiographs were classified by Ahlbach grade. Analysis using Mann-Whitney U-test, Fisher’s exact test and Spearman’s rank correlation were performed.

Results: The significant changes with increasing Ahlbach grade were that: the point of deepest wear moved posteriorly, the posterior extent of wear moved posteriorly and the size of the lesion increased. With ACL deterioration and rupture, the anterior extent of the wear moved forward and the size of lesion increased, but this did not occur through posterior migration of the posterior extent of the wear. There was a significant difference between the Ahlbach grade of ACL Normal and Absent knees.

Conclusion: In early disease, the wear is situated more posteriorly than in medial disease. The wear size increases with ACL insufficiency, but the further posterior progression of wear associated with posterior femoral subluxation seen in advanced disease seems to be more dependant on the loss of bone reflected in the Ahlbach grading.

Objective: To report the survivorship rate and clinical outcome of a large series of lateral unicompartmental replacements.

Method: 88 lateral St Georg Sled LTKRS were performed between 1978 and 1999. Clinical and radiological data was prospectively recorded at regular follow up and only 5 knees were lost during the 22 year period.

Results: 15 knees were revised after an average of 8 years. (eight for progressive arthritis, six for loosening and four for femoral fracture) 29 patients (30 knees) died during the course of the study. At final follow up (average 9 years) 50 of the 63 remaining knees were rated as good or excellent, nine as fair and nine poor. The mean range of flexion was 110°.

At 10 years the cumulative survival rate was 83% and at 15 years 78% (10 knees at risk). The “worst case scenario” where knees with pain or lost to follow up are added to revisions shows a 10 year survivorship of 74%.

Conclusion: Although the results are not as good as medial UKR. These clinical outcomes suggest that the conservative surgical procedure of lateral UKR with the fixed bearing St George Sled prosthesis can give acceptable results in the uncommon situation of severely symptomatic isolated lateral tibio femoral arthritis.

Purpose: To compare the ten-year survivorship results of an established total and medial compartment knee replacement performed in a single centre over an eighteen year period.

Method: Since 1978 knee replacements have been prospectively recorded in Bristol on a database. Regular clinical and radiological review has been undertaken every two or three years up to twenty years. 408 medial St Georg Unicompartmental replacements and 531 Kinematic total knee replacements have been subject to survivorship analysis using three failure end points. One - revision or removal of the implant. Two – revision or removal and moderate or severe pain. Three – the worst case including all patients lost to follow-up.

Results: The follow-up rate was 97% in both groups. 212 patients (562 knees) died and 31 patients (35 knees) were lost to follow-up. At ten years 25 medial Sled and 20 Kinematic knee arthroplasties had been revised. There was no significant difference (p > 0.05) in the number of good and excellent results. The mean range of movement at the last follow-up was 109 degrees for the medial Sled and 100 degrees for the Kinematic (p< 0.01). 94% of the medial Sled patients obtained a range of movement equal to or greater than 90 degrees whereas only 84% of Kinematic patients obtained this range (p < 0.05).

The ten-year survivorship figures were similar for both groups. Revision as the end point was 87.5% for the medial Sled and 89.6% for the Kinematic knees. When moderate and severe pain was considered in addition to revision ten-year survivorship was 79.4% in both groups. The worst case survivorship was also 74% in both groups.

Conclusion: The ten-year survivorship results of a fixed bearing, non-congruous, Unicompartmental arthroplasty are as good as those of a total knee replacement when performed in a single centre by two consultant surgeons and a variety of trainees. The advantages of a more rapid recovery and better quality result are offset by an easier though slightly higher revision rate.