Abstract
Introduction
A correct balancing of the knee following TKA surgery is believed to minimize instability and improve patient satisfaction. In that respect, trial components containing force sensors can be used. These force sensors provide insight in the medial/lateral force ratio as well as absolute contact forces. Although this method finds clinical application already, the target values for both the force magnitude and ratio under surgical conditions remain uncertain.
Methods
A total of eight non-arthritic cadaveric knees have been tested mimicking surgical conditions. Therefore, the specimens are mounted in a custom knee simulator (Verstraete et al., 2015). This simulator allows to test full lower limb specimens, providing kinematic freedom throughout the range of motion. Knee flexion is obtained by lifting the femur (thigh pull). Knee kinematics are simultaneously recorded by means of a navigation system and based on the mechanical axis of the femur and tibia.
In addition, the load transferred through the medial and lateral compartment of the knee is monitored. Therefore, a 2.4 mm thick sawing blade is used to machine a slot in the tibia perpendicular to the mechanical axis, at the location of the tibial cut in TKA surgery. A complete disconnection was thereby assured between the tibial plateau and the distal tibia. To fill the created gap, custom 3D printed shims were inserted (Fig. 1). Through their specific geometry, these shims create a load deviation between two pressure pads (Tekscan type 4011 sensor) seated on the medial and lateral side. Following the insertion of the shims, the knee was closed before performing the kinematic and kinetic tests.
Results
Seven specimens showed a limited varus throughout the range of motion (ranging from 1° to 7° varus). The other knee was in valgus (4° valgus). Amongst varus knees, the results were very consistent, indicating high loads in full extension that rapidly decrease. Subsequently, the loads on the lateral side vanish. This leads to consistently high compartmental load ratios (medial load / total load) in flexion (Fig. 3).
Discussion
In full extension the screw-home mechanism results in increased loads, both medially and laterally. Upon flexion, the lateral loads disappear. This is attributed to slackening of the lateral collateral ligament, in turn linked to the femoral rollback and slope of the lateral compartment. The isometry of the medial collateral ligament contributes on the other hand to the near-constant load in the medial compartment. The above particularly applies for varus knees. The single valgus knee tested indicated a higher load transmission by the lateral compartment, potentially attributed to a contracture of the lateral structures.
With respect to TKA surgery, these findings are particularly relevant when considering anatomically designed implants. For those implants, this study concludes that a tighter medial compartment reflects that of healthy varus knees. Be aware however that in full extension, higher and up to equal loads can be acceptable for the medial and lateral compartment.
For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly (see Info & Metrics tab above).
