Abstract
Introduction
Navigation in total hip arthroplasty (THA) has the goal to improve accuracy of cup orientation. Measurement of cup orientation on conventional pelvic radiographs is susceptible to error due to pelvic malpositioning during acquisition. A recently developed and validated software using a postoperative radiograph in combination with statistical shape modelling allows calculation of exact 3-dimensional cup orientation independent of pelvic malpositioning.
Objectives
We asked (1) what is the accuracy of computer-navigated cup orientation (inclination and anteversion) and (2) what is the percentage of outliers (>10° difference to aimed inclination and anteversion) using postoperative measurement of 3-dimensional cup orientation.
Methods
We performed a retrospective comparative study including a single surgeon series with 114 THAs (109 patients). Surgery was performed through the anterolateral approach with the patient in supine position. An image-free navigation system (PiGalileo, Smith & Nephew) with a passive digital reference base for the pelvic wing and one for the distal femur was used. The anterior pelvic plane (APP) was registered manually using a pointer and used as anatomical reference. After implantation of the press-fit cup (EP-Fit plus, Smith & Nephew) the final cup orientation (inclination and anteversion) was registered with the navigation system. Postoperative orientation was calculated using validated software to calculate 3-dimensional cup orientation. The postoperative anteroposterior pelvic radiograph in combination with a statistical model of the pelvis allowed calculation of inclination and anteversion referenced to the APP. The software was previously validated using CT measurements and revealed a mean accuracy of 0.4° for inclination 0.6° for anteversion with a maximum error of 3.3° and 3.6°, respectively. The mean postoperative inclination in the current series was 46° ± 4° (range, 35° – 60°) and the mean anteversion was 23° ± 6° (range, 11° – 37°). Accuracy was calculated as the absolute difference of the intraoperative registered cup orientation and the postoperative calculated orientation. An outlier was defined if cup orientation was outside a range of ±10° of inclination and/or anteversion.
Results
(1) The mean accuracy for inclination was 3 ± 3° (0 – 17°) and 6 ± 5° (0 – 22°) for anteversion. (2) Three out of 114 cups (3%) were outliers for inclination. An increased percentage of outliers was found for anteversion with 23 out of 114 cups (20%; p<0.001). In total, 25 cups (22%) were outliers (See Figure 1).
Conclusions
Previous studies evaluating accuracy of cup orientation were limited in numbers of hips due to the use of CT or used measurements on conventional postoperative radiographs which are prone to error due to pelvic malpositioning. Novel and validated software allows accurate and anatomically referenced measurement of postoperative cup orientation. This study is the single largest case series with 3-dimensional measurement of cup orientation for validation of navigated THA. Computer-assisted image-free navigation of cup orientation showed a high accuracy of cup orientation with 78% within a narrow range of ±10° of inclination and anteversion. Accuracy of cup inclination was increased compared to cup anteversion.
For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly (see Info & Metrics tab above).
