Abstract
Introduction
Some patients complain ingrown pain or discomfort after implanting Co-Cr conventional endprosthesis of the hip. Some of this complaint may be attributable for effect on cartilage metabolism. It have been reported that ceramic is bioinert for biological tissue. On the other hand, metal including cobalt-chrome (Co-Cr) have some detrimental effect on biological tissue. However, there is no report concerning acetabular cartilage metabolism after hip endprosthesis implantation.
In the present study, we hypothesized that ceramic head have small detrimental effect on cartilage cell metabolism. Specific aim of the study is to compare the protein level of inflammation related cytokines, amount of hyaluronic acid (HA) in culture media, and cartilage mRNA expression in organ culture model of hip end prosthesis implanted using ceramic head and Co-Cr head.
Materials and Methods
Six acetabulum of 3 matured crossbred pig (average weight: 36 +/− 3.6kg) was retrieved. Animal experiment was performed under the rules of ethical committee of animal experiment. Average diameter of pig acetabulum was 26.3 +/− 0.6 mm. Just after sacrifice, mechanical loading using Instron testing machine with 26mm diameter of Co-Cr in right hip and Ceramic heads in left hip was performed in culture media. Ten thousand cycles of cyclic compression and rotation load (1.5kN to 0.15kN of compression and 12 degrees of rotation) to cartilage was applied at 1Hz (Figure 1).
Culture media was analyzed for protein levels of inflammation related cytokines and amount of HA. Relative quantitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) from acetabular cartilage was performed as previously reported using specific primer sets for type II collagen, aggrecan, TNF-alpha, Interleukine-1 and 6, and MMP-1, 3, 13.
Results
IL-1 beta protein level from culture media was significantly higher in Co-Cr than that in Ceramic (155+/−25.2 pg/ml vs. 86.3+/−9.6 pg/ml respectively). MMP-3 protein level had tendency to be higher in culture media from Co-Cr than that from Ceramic (16.3+/−10.6 ng/ml vs. 10.0+/−0.1 ng/ml respectively, p<0.05), however there was no significant difference. There were no significant differences of protein levels from culture media in MMP-1, IL-1a, and TNF between two groups.
Amount of HA from culture media of Co-Cr group was significantly higher than that from Ceramic group (337+/−38.4 mg/ml versus 257+/−11.1 mg/ml respectively, p<0.05).
Type II collagen mRNA expression was 3 times higher in Ceramic group than that in Co-Cr group. IL-1 beta mRNA expression was 4 times higher in Co-Cr group than that in Ceramic group. Other gene expression had no significant differences.
Discussion
The present study showed that Co-Cr affects cartilage metabolism than Ceramic. Co-Cr group had higher protein level and mRNA expression of inflammation related cytokine, IL-1 beta, and higher HA. Concerning the mRNA expression from cartilage, type II collagen was significantly higher in Ceramic group.
It has been reported that HA level is high in osteoarthritic joint. These report and our results showed that ceramic head have small detrimental effect on cartilage cell metabolism.
There are limitations of the present study. Firstly, the sample size is small. Secondly, we did not evaluate synovial membrane metabolism.
