Abstract
Purpose
Surgeons sometimes encounter moderate or severe varus deformed osteoarthritic cases in which medial substantial release including semimembranosus is compelled to appropriately balance soft tissues in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, medial stability after TKA is important for acquisition of proper knee kinematics to lead to medial pivot motion during knee flexion. The purpose of the present study is to prove the hypothesis that step by step medial release, especially semimembranosus release, reduces medial stability in cruciate-retaining (CR) total knee arthroplasty (TKA).
Methods
Twenty CR TKAs were performed in patients with moderate varus-type osteoarthritis (10° < varus deformity <20°) using the tibia first technique guided by a navigation system (Orthopilot). During the process of medial release, knee kinematics including tibial internal rotation and anterior translation during knee flexion were assessed using the navigation system at 3 points; (1) after anterior cruciate ligament resection (pre-release), (2) medial tibial and femoral osteophyte removal and release of minimum deep layer of medial collateral ligament (minimum release) and (3) release of semimembranosus (semimembranosus release). In addition, the kinematics after all prostheses implantation (semimembranosus release group) were assessed and compared with those assessed in another 20 patients in which only minimum release was performed (minimum release group).
Results
Kinematic pattern in step by step medial release exhibited external tibial rotation during mid-range of flexion and then shifted to internal tibial rotation toward to 120 degrees of knee flexion (Fig. A). During 60 to 120 degrees of flexion, semimembranosus release significantly reduced the amount of internal tibial rotation compared with pre-release (Fig. 1B). Tibial anterior translation showed no significant differences among each procedure. After all prostheses implanted, the amount of tibial internal rotation during 60 to 120 degrees of knee flexion was significantly maintained in minimum release compared with semimembranosus release group (Fig. 2).
Conclusions
Semimembranosus release reduces tibial internal rotation in CR TKA, suggesting that semimembranosus release should be avoided in case of moderate varus-type osteoarthritis for considering medial stability.
