Abstract
Summary
Carriers for local delivery of stem cells into degenerative intervertebral discs need to be tested under physiological loading since stem cell viability, density and differentiation, as well as carrier stability are strongly affected by loading.
Introduction
The success of the local delivery of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) to degenerative discs relies on three main factors: (i) an appropriate delivery method, (ii) a suitable carrier, (iii) resistance to loading forces. Bioreactors allow the application of loading to whole intervertebral discs and represent a useful tool to screen the potential of new regenerative therapies. We have previously shown that hydrogel delivery through the endplate (EP) leaves the annulus fibrosus (AF) intact (as opposed to an approach through the AF). Furthermore, we have found that the physiological loading needs to be adapted for nucleotomised discs. In this study we compare the behaviour of two MSCs carriers under loading in a whole IVD bioreactor.
Materials & Methods
MSCs were isolated from human bone marrow after approval by the local ethical commission and written consent of the patient (age: 20–60 years). Whole IVDs were harvested from calf tails obtained from the local abattoir. Partial nucleotomies were achieved by mechanically removing the nucleus pulposus (NP) through the endplate. Firstly, hMSCs suspended in hyaluronan thermoreversible hydrogel2 (6×106 cells/ml) were supplied to the nucleotomised IVDs and the removed EP was re-inserted. Discs were either loaded for one week at 0.06 ± 0.02 MPa, 0.1 Hz, 4 hours/day (n=4) or kept unloaded in culture medium (control). Secondly, hMSCs suspended in fibrin (100 mg/ml fibrinogen and 500 IU/ml thrombin) were applied to IVDs as above described. Discs were kept unloaded in culture medium for one week and then loaded for two weeks at 0.06 ± 0.02 MPa, 0.1Hz, 3 hours/day (n=4) or kept unloaded (control). Analyses included histology, gene expression and cell viability.
Results
On the gene level, it was found that loading is required to induce aggrecan (a major component of the NP tissue) up-regulation in MSCs for both carriers. Aggrecan was up-reguled in MSCs already after one week of loading in the thermoreversible hyaluronan, but only after two weeks MSCs in fibrin. Additionally, the highest expression of keratin-19 (NP marker) was found in the loaded thermoreversible hyaluronan group. However, there was a high cell and material loss under loading in this group.
Fibrin was more stable in the chosen experimental conditions, as shown in the safranin O-Fast green staining of the IVD. Indeed, the NP cavity was still filled with fibrin gel after 2 weeks of loading. No significant cell loss or decrease in cell viability was found in the fibrin gel after 2 weeks of loading.
Discussion/Conclusion
The hyaluronan thermoreversible hydrogel is superior in promoting the differentiation of MSCs toward the disc phenotype, as attested by the aggrecan up-regulation. However, the fibrin gel has a better stability and is more effective at maintaining a high density of MSCs, even under loading. In conclusion, stem cell carriers need to be evaluated in a relevant setting, e.g. in an IVD under load.
The study was partially supported by a NASS Research grant.
