Abstract
Summary Statement
Magnesium has a number of qualities suitable for bioresorbable metallic implants. However, high corrosion rate and formation of hydrogen gas can compromise its performance. Combining magnesium with calcium phosphate improves magnesium's biocompatibility by decreasing gas formation and increasing bone remodeling.
Introduction
Clinical problems like risk of postoperative infection and increased incidence of pediatric trauma requiring surgical intervention raised the need for temporary orthopedic implants that would resorb after the bone healing is complete. This would decrease high costs associated with repeated surgeries, minimise recovery times, decrease the risk of postoperative infections, and thus promote higher quality of life to the patients. The specific requirement for orthopedic implants, aside from being bioresorbable, is the ability to bear high loads. Magnesium was suggested as a suitable material for these purposes because it is biocompatible; has excellent mechanical properties; is natural for human body, and seems to stimulate new bone formation. However, an important problem with magnesium is high corrosion rate with consistent hydrogen gas formation on contact with fluids. This in vivo study focuses on investigation of new magnesium-based implants specifically designed to minimise hydrogen gas formation.
Methods
Four types of degradable magnesium-based materials were tested for biocompatibility in this study: Magnesium-Hydroxyapatite implants (Mg-HA); Magnesium-Calcium Phosphate Cement (Mg-CPC); alloy of 96% Magnesium and 4% Yttrium (W4); and 99.95% pure magnesium which was a control group. Biomaterials were operated into 33 male New Zealand white rabbits. The animals were sacrificed after 6 and 12 weeks after which the samples were embedded into Epon, paraffin and Technovit resin. The staining was done with TRAP, hematoxylin eosin and toluidine blue. Additionally, TEM and immunohistochemical analysis were performed. The data was analysed both qualitatively and quantitatively by Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS, v18, SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL).
Results
Mg-CPC showed the best performance in this study. New bone formation was significantly more prevalent in Mg-CPC group while gas formation was significantly less comparing to the other materials. Mg-HA had the worst properties due to extremely fast degradation already at 6 weeks, the least amount of new bone formation, and the lowest amount of osteoclasts and multinucleated cells in the implantation site. Pure magnesium and W4 had similar properties: both were surrounded with corrosion layer, and the gas volumes were significantly higher in these two groups compared to other materials.
Discussion/Conclusion
New bone was seen forming either in direct contact to implants or around the gas bubbles. The later can be interpreted as body's reaction to protect from gas spreading. Mg-HA's degradation rate was far too fast and this is unacceptable for orthopedic fractures which often require several months to heal and that experience much load. Pure magnesium and W4 although maintained their integrity, were surrounded by corrosion layer and gas bubbles that were bigger in diameter than in the other groups. These findings could compromise implant stability. Mg-CPC was the most biocompatible; it showed significantly higher amount of osteoclasts which is a first sign of bone remodeling. It had also significantly less gas production than other groups. These results show that magnesium's biocompatibility could be improved by combining it with other suitable materials, such as calcium phosphate.
