Abstract
Introduction
Large diameter metal-on-metal hip arthroplasty (LDMMTHA) provides benefits of reduced dislocation rates and low wear. The use of modular systems allows better restoration of hip biomechanics. There have been reports of modular LDMMTHAs with tapered sleeves generating excessively high metal ions, due to possible mismatch between the titanium stem and the cobalt-chrome sleeve and the dual Morse tapers involved. We evaluated metal ion levels in LDMMTHA patients with and without a cobalt-chrome (CoCr) tapered sleeve.
Methods
A cross-sectional series of 91 patients with proximal porous titanium alloy stem LDMMTHA with identical design CoCr bearings, attending a 1 to 2-year review were assessed with routine clinical and radiographic examinations, hip scores and metal ion analysis. Of these 65 had a single Morse taper between monoblock CoCr heads and the stems. Twentysix had a tapered cobalt-chrome sleeve in addition, with the resultant dual taper. Mean bearing diameter was 46 mm in both groups and mean age was 58 years in the monoblocks and 66 years in the tapered sleeve group.
Results
Mean Oxford Hip score is worse in the tapered group (14.7) than in the monoblocks (12.6). All patients had well-functioning hips clinically and radiologically. Median blood cobalt and chromium are higher in the tapered sleeve (2.3μg/L and 1.8 μg/L) compared to the monoblocks (1.8 μg/L and 1.1 μg/L). Urine cobalt and chromium levels in the tapered sleeve (13.8 μg/24 hr and 5.3 μg/24 hr) also are higher than those in the monoblocks (12.2 μg/24 hr and 4.5 μg/24 hr respectively).
Discussion and Conclusion
The limitation of this study is that it is a cross-sectional study. The results indicate that the use of a tapered sleeve in total hip arthroplasty does lead elevation of cobalt and chromium levels and the difference is statistically significant. However these levels are not as high as the levels reported with some other hip systems which have been withdrawn and the clinical significance of the elevated levels in the present study is unknown.
