Abstract
Background
This is an epidemiological study of patients with middle third clavicle fractures presenting to a tertiary hospital. The data is used to formulate a classification system for middle third clavicle fractures based on fracture configuration and displacement.
Description of methods
Patients presenting primarily to a referral hospital with middle third clavicle fractures were identified using the PACS radiology system. The radiographs were reviewed to determine the fracture type, displacement, shortening and amount of comminution. The clinical notes of each patient were reviewed to determine the mechanism of injury, soft tissue status, neurovascular status and treatment rendered. A novel classification system was developed to describe the different fracture configurations seen in the group. The interobserver and intraobserver correlation of the classification system as well as the ability of the classification system to predict treatment were tested.
Summary of results
Three hundred and three patients were included in the review, 223 males and 80 females. Middle third clavicle fractures were displaced in 69% of cases. Displaced fractures tend to have a significant amount of displacement and shortening in most cases with averages of 19.64mm (Std Dev. 6.901) and 19.15mm (Std Dev. 9.616) respectively. Acceptable interobserver and intraobserver correlation levels were shown for the proposed classification system.
Conclusion
The epidemiology of middle third clavicle fractures found in the population studied differs substantially from first world populations. It underlines the high level of road traffic accidents and interpersonal violence seen in South Africa. Surgeons treating clavicle fractures are still divided on the indications for surgery with little correlation found between the fracture type and displacement on radiographs and the type of treatment rendered. The classification system provides guidelines to treating surgeons to the correct treatment modality.
MULTIPLE DISCLOSURES
