Abstract
While knee osteoarthritis (OA) is now recognized as a complex disease affecting the whole joint, not just the cartilages, there remains a paucity of data regarding the interactions between knee components. One relationship of particular interest is between the spatial variations in cartilage thickness (CTh) and subchondral bone mineral density (BMD). Indeed, bone and cartilage are two mechanosensitive tissues that interact as a functional unit and there is evidence of a biomechanical coupling between both tissues. Particularly, a recent in vivo study has shown a positive relationship in non-OA knees with thicker cartilage where bone is denser, and an alteration of this relationship in OA knees. These observations support the concept of an osteochondral unit and warrant additional research to assess the influence of bone depth. Therefore, this study aimed to characterize the relationship between spatial variations in CTh and BMD measured at various depths below the bone surface.
CT-arthrography of 20 non-OA tibias and 20 severe medial-compartment OA tibias were segmented to build 3D mesh models of the bones and cartilages. Each individual tibia model was registered to a reference tibia, allowing to calculate BMD maps at 1, 3, 5 and 10mm below the bone-cartilage interface in the medial compartment. Pearson correlations between CTh maps and the four BMD maps were then calculated for each knee. Lastly, differences in correlation coefficients between successive bone layers were assessed using Wilcoxon signed-rank tests.
In both OA and non-OA tibias, the correlation coefficients were higher with the BMD measured in the 1mm layer, and followed a pattern of statistically significant decrease with bone layers of increasing depth (p < 0.021). In non-OA tibias, the median relationship was positive with a strong effect size in the 1, 3 and 5mm layers, while in OA tibias the median relationship was positive only in the 1mm layer and with a medium effect size. In the OA tibias, the median relationship was negative with a weak effect size in the 3 and 5mm layers, and it was negative with a medium effect size in the 10mm layer.
In conclusion, the results of the present study support the value of considering bone and cartilage as a unit, and more generally support OA pathophysiology models based on relationships among knee properties.
