Abstract
Introduction and Objective
Scaphoid waist fractures (SWF) are notable in upper limb trauma and predominantly occur in young men. Morbidities associated with SWF include fracture non-union, premature arthritis and humpback deformity. Delayed treatment and non-adherence to fracture immobilisation increases likelihood of these complications. There is evidence that men engage in negative health behaviours such as delayed help-seeking. The Scaphoid Waist Internal Fixation for Fractures Trial (SWIFFT) conducted interviews in individuals who had sustained a SWF. Although SWIFFT showed multiple social determinants for the overall injury and healing experience, a key factor this novel study considers is age and sex. This study aimed to analyse interview data from young male participants in SWIFFT to help distinguish the experience of SWF in young men, through exploring the influence of masculinity.
Materials and Methods
A purposive sample of 12 young male participants were selected from SWIFFT. These participants were enrolled from a possibility of 13 different centres across Britain. There were 17 semi-structured interviews produced from these participants, and this was thought to be sufficient for data saturation. These interviews were evaluated through deductive thematic analysis with an open-coding approach, with respondents’ experiences being compared against themes documented in men's health literature. The “Braun and Clarke (2006) Six Phases of Thematic Analysis” methodology was adopted to perform this.
Results
There were three thematic models developed in the data set, which then were further divided into subthemes. Model 1: Negative Health Behaviour Prior to Treatment, model 2: Feeling Frail and model 3: Need for Speed. Model 1 corroborated that participants were inclined to sustain the injury as a result of risk-taking and would subsequently hesitate to seek treatment. Model 2 indicated that as a result of the injury, respondents were unable to engage in physical activities and activities of daily living. Respondents exercised caution to varying extents after sustaining a SWF. Model 3 highlighted that interviewees were prone to non-adherence with fracture immobilisation and in hindsight resumed employment prematurely.
Conclusions
The findings of this study demonstrate that masculinity is significantly influential on the experience of SWF in young men. This was indicated through the results of thematic analysis strongly corresponding with behaviours established in men's health literature. Educational interventions could be of value in addressing behaviours observed in this population group, such as delayed help-seeking and non-compliance with fracture immobilisation. Further work in patient education and concordance with treatment after sustaining a SWF may be beneficial to longer term outcomes. In turn, this may reduce complications associated with SWF in young men.
