Abstract
In the setting of traumatic elbow injuries involving coronoid fractures, the relative size of the coronoid fragment has been shown to relate to the stability of the joint. Currently, the challenge lies in accurately classifying the amount of bone loss in coronoid fractures. In comminuted fractures, bone loss is difficult to measure with plain radiographs or computed tomography. The purpose of this study is to describe a novel radiographic measure, the Coronoid Opening Angle (COA), on lateral elbow radiographs. We demonstrate the relationship of the COA to coronoid height and describe how this measure can be used to estimate bone loss and potentially predict elbow instability following coronoid fracture.
Radiographs were drawn from a regional database in a consecutive fashion. Candidate radiographs were excluded on the basis of radiographic evidence of degenerative changes, previous surgery or injury, bony deformity, and inadequate lateral view of the elbow. The COA was measured as the angle between the long axis of the ulna at the level of the trochlear notch, and the tip of coronoid, from a common origin at the posterior cortex of the olecranon. Images were reviewed by a fellowship trained upper extremity surgeon, an upper extremity fellow, and a junior resident. Normal COA, coronoid height, and calculated COA at varying amounts of bone loss were calculated by three reviewers. A sensitivity analysis was performed to determine how the COA can most effectively predict bone loss at varying coronoid heights. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was calculated for 39 subjects.
Seventy-two subjects were included for analysis (M=40, F=32). The normal coronoid opening angle is 33.19 degrees [32.2 – 34.2]. Coronoid height is 18.8 mm [18.1 – 19.6]. Extrapolating this baseline data, the COA at 20%, 33%, and 50% of coronoid bone loss was calculated to be 27.5, 23.5, and 18 degrees, respectively. ICC was found to be 0.90 or higher. Cutoff values were determined to maximize the sensitivity of the COA. A cutoff value of 21 degrees has a 92% sensitivity in detecting a minimum of 50% bone loss. The COA with similar sensitivity in predicting 20% and 33% bone loss are 32 and 27 degrees.
The coronoid opening angle is a novel technique that can be used on a lateral elbow radiograph to predict the minimum coronoid bone loss. This can be used to guide clinical decision making and potentially predict instability. Future research will aim to validate this tool in the clinical setting in predicting instability.
