Abstract
Introduction
Hip stem taper wear and corrosion is a multifactorial process involving mechanical, chemical and biological damage modes. For the most cases it seems likely that the mechanically driven fretting wear is accompanied by other damage modes like pitting corrosion, galvanic corrosion or metal transfer. Recent retrieval studies have reported that the taper surface topography may affect taper damage resulting from fretting and corrosion [1]. Therefore, the current study aimed to examine effects of different taper topography parameters and material combinations on taper mechanics and results regarding wear and corrosion have been investigated.
Materials and Methods
Combined experimental and numerical studies were conducted using titanium, cobalt-chromium and stainless steel generic tapers (Figure1). Uniaxial tensile tests were performed to determine the mechanical properties of the materials examined. For the taper studies macro-geometry of ceramic ball heads (BIOLOX®delta) and tapers were characterized using a coordinate measuring machine, and assembly experiments according to ISO7206-10 were conducted up to 4kN. Before and after loading, taper subsidence was quantified by assembly height measurements. Taper micro-geometry, taper surface deformation, and contact area were determined by profilometry. Initial numerical studies determined coefficients of friction for the three material combinations. Macro- and micro-geometries of the tapers were modelled, and taper subsidence and assembly load served as boundary conditions. Further studies used simplified models to examine effects of varying profile depths and angular gaps on surface deformation, taper subsidence, contact area, engagement length and pull-off force.
Results
Largest coefficient of friction and pull-off forces were calculated for steel (µ=0.32), cobalt-chromium revealed the lowest with µ=0.18. Titanium showed largest deformations and taper subsidence throughout all calculations (Figure2, Figure3). Taper subsidence, engagement length and deformations increased with increasing profile depth while contact area decreased. Pull-off forces were almost constant for different profile depths while they increased for increasing angular gaps. Taper subsidence and deformations also increased with increasing angular gap while engagement length decreased and contact area almost remained constant.
Discussion
In order to decrease wear and corrosion micromotions should be minimized. Therefore, smaller angular gaps and smaller profile depths seems to be beneficial since deformation and taper subsidence are reduced. Literature data confirmed the results for different angular gaps showing that a larger angular gap is associated with larger amounts of micromotion and wear [2, 3]. Additionally, larger angular gaps and larger profile depths result in larger plastic deformation facilitating subsurface crack initiation and propagation. A large angular gap may also facilitate particle release [4]. Larger pull-off forces can indicate larger resistance against micromotion. Therefore, steel may tend to later develop fretting-corrosion in situ. However, among the metals examined steel also showed the largest equivalent plastic strain. This study is limited to pairings involving ceramic heads. These can help mitigating fretting corrosion resulting from micromotion between ball head and cobalt-chromium or titanium alloy tapers [5]. However, future studies will include other ball head materials. In conclusion, this study showed that taper surface topography affects taper mechanics and is important in terms of wear and corrosion.
