A953. CASE REPORT-EARLY FAILURE AFTER TOTAL KNEE ARTHROPLASTY WITH USE OF MINIMAL INCISION SUGERY

Abstract

Recently, many researches of minimal incision surgery (MIS) total knee arthroplasty (TKA) have been reported, however very few of these contain clinical results. Regardless of this, MIS TKA is widely promoted as an improvement over traditional TKA. Although traditional TKA allows for excellent visualization, component orientation, fixation, and has been associated with remarkable long-term implant survival, many patients expect an extremely small incision, minimal or no pain and discomfort associated with their surgery, and certainly no increase in the complication rate. While there is some evidence that short term benefits may occur, there is concern that there may be an increase in complications with the use of MIS technique. We report here cases that malalignments in early phase were occurred after MIS TKAs. A consecutive series of MIS TKA for varus osteoarthritis undertaken by 2 surgeons at 2 centers during 2-year priod (2006–2007) was reviewed. During this interval, 50 MIS TKAs were performed. The mean age was 75.6 years (range 54 to 88 years). Cases for post-operatively infection were excluded. There were 2 cases that early failures due to varus sinking of tibial component were confirmed in early phase (7 and 3 months after primary surgery). We analyzed data between early failed cases and non-failed cases. Patients with early failure were younger, which showed a trend toward significance (p=0.11; failed; 66.5, non-failed; 75.9 years). There was no difference in amount of both medial and lateral side of distal femoral cut between early failed cases and non-failed cases. Proximal tibial cut was significantly larger in early failed cases compared with non-failed cases (p=0.01; failed; 16.5±4.5, nonfailed; 11.4±6.6). There was no difference in Femorotibial angle (FTA) after surgery between them. Substantial backgrounds of occurring early failure after MIS TKA are not still clarified, however, very early failure were occurred in patients, who had significant large cut of proximal tibia, in our experienced cases. MIS TKA may lead to varus imbalance due to increased amount of bony cut and decreased medial soft tissue release. Henceforth, the high prevalence of MIS failures occurring in early phase is disturbing, because of limited working space and warrants further investigation.