PAPER 056: RCT OF A POROUS METAL TIBIAL MONOBLOCK TKA COMPONENT USING RSA – 2-YEAR RESULTS

Abstract

Purpose: Porous metal technology may have significant impacts on implant fixation and long-term survival due to their high co-efficient of friction and similarity to trabecular bone in morphology and mechanical behaviour. While promising, the in vivo mechanical behaviour and micromotion at the interface has not previously been reported on. We report on the 2-year results of an RCT using radiosterometric analysis (RSA) to asses a porous metal (PM) monoblock tibial component.

Method: Patients undergoing TKA were randomized to receive a either the PM (n=34) or the cemented tibial component (n=33). A standardized protocol was used for intra and post-operative factors. RSA exams were obtained postoperatively within 4 days of surgery and at 6, 12 and 24 months. One patient was excluded due to an intraoperative complication, and four others were lost to follow-up due to poor bead visibility or morbidity. Standard subjective outcome measures were applied.

Results: There were no revisions in either group. The PM group exhibited two distinct migration patterns. One group stabilized immediately with similar migration to the cemented cases (0.38 vs. 0.46 p=0.4). A subset of 6 PM cases demonstrated significantly higher initial migration (mean=2.01mm, p< 0.01) but appeared stable at 2 years. In addition, 3 of the 6 high migration cases manifested independent bead subsidence. This was determined to be due to PM plate deformation. Two cemented cases were considered at risk for early failure due to aseptic loosening because of RSA migration pattern. There were no differences between groups in the subjective health outcome measures.

Conclusion: A subset of PM components demonstrated high early migration followed by stabilization. It appears that some of these PM components deformed under load, most often in the posteromedial corner, perhaps as a result of malalignment or ligament imbalance. The implications of this finding are yet to be determined.