THE SAFETY AND COSTS OF ACHILLES TENDON SURGERY: COMPARING PATIENTS ENROLLED IN A RANDOMISED CLINICAL TRIAL TO THOSE OUTSIDE OF THE TRIAL

Abstract

The current standard of care in Calgary, Alberta for management of a ruptured Achilles tendon is surgical repair, typically performed following admission to hospital. The primary objective of this study was to compare the costs of hospital treatment and complications associated with the surgical repair of Achilles tendon ruptures between two groups of patients: Group One = patients enrolled in the randomised clinical trial (RCT) Multicentre Achilles Tendon Treatment Study (MATTS), Group Two = all other non-study patients.

This observational cohort study analyzed all patients surgically treated for Achilles tendon ruptures at Calgary area hospitals over a three-year period (October 2002–September 2005). Inclusion criteria: age eighteen to seventy years, acute rupture.

A total of two hundred and eighty-two patients met the inclusion criteria; thirty-three patients were included in Group One, two hundred and forty-nine patients in Group Two. In Group One, twenty-seven patients (82%) were treated as outpatients, five patients (15%) were ADOP-24hr, and one patient (3%) was admitted. In Group Two, twenty-seven patients (11%) were treated as outpatients, ninety-five patients (38%) were ADOP-24hr, and one hundred and twenty-seven patients (51%) were admitted. The total costs for patients treated as outpatients and requiring overnight stays in Group One were $18,408 and $7,419, respectively. In Group Two, the total cost for outpatients was $18,071 compared to $379,496 for non-study patients requiring overnight stay. If all overnight patients in each group were treated as outpatients, the total savings would be $235,545. There were no serious complications in Group One. In Group Two, complications included two cases of pulmonary embolus, and one case of compartment syndrome requiring readmission. All complications resolved.

Surgical treatment of Achilles tendon rupture can be performed safely and at less cost on an outpatient basis. Participation in this RCT has allowed us to recommend a change in the standard of care in Calgary.