THORACOPLASTY IN ADOLESCENT IDIOPATHIC SCOLIOSIS: A CRITICAL APPRAISAL

Abstract

Thoracoplasty has been described as primarily a cosmetic resection of the rib hump. The purpose of our study was to investigate whether removal of a normal spine stabilizer affected the correction of the spine, particularly in the sagittal plane. Thirty-eight adolescent idiopathic scoliosis patients who underwent thoracoplasty were compared with eighteen controls in terms of maintenance of correction and patient satisfaction using the SRS questionnaire. Thoracoplasty had no effect on curve correction in the coronal plane. It did show a significant effect on sagittal plane correction of the thoracic hypokyphosis without any significant detractors in terms of patient outcome

To investigate whether thoracoplasty affected spinal correction. We also compared patient outcomes thoracoplasty patients and controls, as well as long-term curve maintenance.

Thoracoplasty did increase the correction of thoracic hypokyphosis, without any significant detractors in terms of patient outcome.

Current understanding of the scoliotic curve as a three dimensional helix has led to increased recognition of the importance of sagittal contour and balancing the spine’s reciprocal curves to avoid problems such as flat back syndrome. Correction of the scoliotic curve intraoperatively may require the removal of spine stabilizers such as the disc and annulus, posterior facet and capsule, and thoracic cage stabilizers such as the ribs.

Thirty-eight patients who had either concave para-median or convex Steel mid-rib thoracoplasty were reviewed and compared to eighteen controls. Prospective patient outcomes using the Scoliosis Research Society instrument with an average of > one year follow-up were available for thirty patients. Degree of curve settle and maintenance of correction was measured on follow-up radiographs.

Thoracoplasty had no effect on curve correction in the coronal plane. It did show a significant effect on sagittal plane correction of thoracic hypokyphosis. The paramedian group showed a mean increase of tweleve degrees, the Steel group 8.7 degrees, and, the control group 3.1 degrees. No significant difference between pain, satisfaction, function, and self-image was found. Long-term radiographic follow-up (average three years) showed a mean coronal curve settle of 4.6 degrees (thoracoplasty) versus 3.1 degrees (non-thoracoplasty), and an accompanying improvement in sagittal plane correction of 4.2 and 3.0 degrees, respectively.