Abstract
Purpose: The current concern to achieve 120° postoperative flexion in certain patients raises the problems of polyethylene wear, prosthesis stability, and surgical technique. The purpose of this clinical and radiographic comparative study was to analyse pertinent factors
Material and methods: We studied two groups of posterior stabilised total knee prostheses with mobile plateaux. In group A (23 knees), the plateau had rotatory and translation mobility. In group B (36 knees) the plateaux only had rotatory mobility and the posterior condyle was long. We studied clinical flexion before surgery and postoperatively at one year. The radiographic analysis included: mechanical axis, height of the articular space, patellar height, anteroposterior prosthetic surface. In both groups the patients had undergone medial parapatellar arthrotomy and had participated in the same rehabilitation programme.
Results: There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups for age, gender, weight, height, pre-operative diagnosis, or preoperative flexion (mean 120.8°, range 90–130° in group A and mean 120.7°, range 90–140° in group B). Mean postoperative flexion was 114.8° (50–140°) in group A and 130.4° (90–150°) in group B. The difference was statistically significant. There were two episodes of instability in group A and none in group B. There was no difference concerning the pre- or postoperative axis or patellar height. There was a difference in articular space height and anteroposterior prosthetic surface.
Discussion: The gain in flexion achieved in group B is related to the smaller anteroposterior prosthetic surface and the more systematic use of distractors to clear the posterior part of the knee. The design of the posterior condyle could also be involved, allowing better congruence beyond 120°. The difference in stability between the two groups could be related to a difference in the distance between the apex of the tibial attachment and the posterior stabilisation cam. This study demonstrated that increased flexion is possible after total knee arthroplasty in certain patients. It is related to surgical technique but also has direct implications for prosthesis design.
The abstracts were prepared by Docteur Jean Barthas. Correspondence should be addressed to him at Secrétariat de la Société S.O.F.C.O.T., 56 rue Boissonade, 75014 Paris.
